1. Podcasts
  2. 48 Hours
  3. A Parent's Worst Nightmare
48 Hours

19 Jun 2025 · 45m · 20 chapters

Episode artwork

A Parent's Worst Nightmare

In short

The 1997 disappearance of five-month-old Sabrina Eisenberg from her crib in Valrico, Florida, and the ensuing decade-long fight over whether her parents were involved, including a months-long FBI-style wiretap, a federal indictment for conspiracy/lying, and later claims that the recordings were largely unintelligible and inadmissible.

Key claims

Steve and Marlene Eisenberg say Sabrina was taken by an intruder; police and prosecutors suspected the parents and allegedly tried to force a confession. The prosecution’s case relied on secret bug recordings, but experts and judges later said the tapes were largely unintelligible, with some statements false, leading to charges being dropped.

Notable examples

an open garage door; FBI wiretap/bugs for nearly three months; alleged “baby dead and buried” quotes; courtroom audio described as static/mumbling; a later Illinois adoption case where a child (“Paloma”) was DNA-tested and rejected as Sabrina.

Guests

Scott Middleton (former Tampa cop); Kathy Dotson (friend); TV reporter Bill McGinty; Graham Brink (St. Petersburg Times reporter); Barry Cohen (defense lawyer); John Fitzgibbons (former U.S. attorney); Mike Paris (wiretap/bud detection expert); Anthony Pelicano (audio expert mentioned); Stephen Koons (federal prosecutor mentioned); Jack Mitchell (audio expert for 48 Hours); Joe Mullins (forensic artist at National Center for Missing and Exploited Children).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:15

The Disappearance of Sabrina

Exploring the emotional turmoil of parents after their daughter goes missing.

“It's about a little girl that goes missing and I don't think anyone knows for sure what happened to her.”
1:09

Family Background and Happy Beginnings

A glimpse into the Eisenberg family's early happy life before tragedy struck.

“And we need her back in our family where she belongs.”
2:10

Life Changes and Realizations

How the Eisenbergs' life transformed after Sabrina's disappearance.

“We're very naive, young, happy-go-lucky.”
3:16

The Morning of the Incident

Detailing the harrowing morning when Sabrina was discovered missing.

“I have dreams often that she's coming home and that we're playing, and the dreams are as vivid as they're real.”
4:48

The Investigation Begins

The initial actions taken by police and media in the wake of the disappearance.

“Every night we kick myself, ourself, because we didn't use an alarm and we had one.”
7:14

Public Perception and Family Scrutiny

How the public began to view the Eisenbergs as suspects in the case.

“Sheriff's deputies began an extensive search in and around the Eisenberg home, but found nothing.”
8:11

Detectives' Growing Doubts

Descriptions of police suspicions regarding the Eisenbergs in Sabrina's case.

“First of all, you're in shock and my baby is gone.”
10:28

Shifting Focus of the Investigation

How the investigation evolved to look at various leads beyond the Eisenbergs.

“Any concerned parent they thought would have taken that call immediately.”
14:00

The Investigation Intensifies

Learn about the aggressive tactics used by police in the Eisenberg case.

“that even suggested that either one of them were responsible.”
16:42

The Grand Jury and Legal Advice

Understand the Eisenbergs' decision to invoke their Fifth Amendment rights.

“Every day for nearly three months, from 7 a.m.”
Show all 20 chapters
19:35

The Shocking FBI Raid

Explore the dramatic events of the FBI raid at the Eisenberg's home.

“sheriff's office was feeling the pressure and Barry Cohen knew it.”
23:02

Indictment and Legal Fallout

Examine the implications of the indictment against the Eisenbergs.

“It was like the scariest thing to have a gun pointed at you.”
26:19

Tapes and Courtroom Drama

Delve into the courtroom drama surrounding the secret tapes and their significance.

“or will they just add to the confusion already surrounding the case?”
28:01

The Courtroom Audio Evidence

Learn about the confusing audio evidence presented in court and its implications.

“And all we could hear in the courtroom that day was mumbling.”
30:05

Expert Analysis of the Tapes

Discover the experts' opinions on the audio tapes and their findings.

“This came as no surprise to the Eisenberg team.”
31:08

Misconduct and Inadmissible Evidence

Explore the issues of police misconduct and the implications for the case.

“Mitchell has analyzed hundreds of tapes during his career and is convinced that some of the most incriminating quotes may not even belong to the Eisenbergs.”
33:10

Aftermath of the Case Dismissal

Examine the responses and consequences following the case dismissal.

“For example, police told the judge that Merlene's 911 call was, quote, unemotional.”
34:36

Hope and Family Life Post-Case

Understand how the Eisenbergs cope with their loss and maintain hope.

“His supervisors refused to comment on the outcome, but he is still a federal prosecutor.”
36:53

Attempts to Locate Sabrina

Learn about the search for Sabrina and the hope for her return.

“Sabrina Eisenberg, who was abducted from a Florida home.”
38:57

The Ongoing Search and Call for Help

Hear about the efforts to find Sabrina and how the public can assist.

“Here in the Forensic Imaging Unit, the cases don't even come back here until they're at least two years old.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 48 Hours, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00.

0:15I don't think anyone has a conclusion to this story yet. It's about a little girl that goes missing and I don't think anyone knows for sure what happened to her. She had just started to crawl. She could not get out of the crib herself. Come on, oh, she's getting up. Here she goes. I mean, it's the most horrific thing you can imagine, looking into your child's crib and not seeing her there.

0:47Every night, we'd kick myself because we didn't use an alarm, and we had one every night. But I'm not going to dwell on it. If the Eisenbergs are telling the truth, you have to believe that someone walked into their house in the middle of the night to where baby Sabrina was sleeping, plucked her out of a crib, and vanished forever. And we need her back in our family where she belongs. And I know she's out there. I think that Steve and Marlene know more than what they're saying. Police are like, well, we believe you know where Sabrina is or what happened to her. All of a sudden, I hear, Marlene, come downstairs.

1:27And the next thing I know is there's a gun being pointed right at my face. Well, at some point, it became just like a soap opera. Where is your daughter? Not only has our daughter been taken from us, but they tried to destroy everything about our family. Can you tell us where Sabrina is? It hurts. She's seven years old, and she's not home yet. That kills me.

1:51Troy Roberts: Where's our baby?

2:06Happy Halloween. Happy Halloween. Hey, everybody. Happy Thanksgiving. Happy Thanksgiving. Yay. Marlene. Hmm. The young bride. Oh, Jesus. Happy birthday. I love you. Our life is like a fairy tale. We started off so happy. Say happy. Happy. New year. Monica, blow. Whoa. We're very naive, young, happy-go-lucky. And I don't think we're so naive anymore. And Sabrina's crawling, and she's almost five months old. I don't think we're so happy-go-lucky anymore.

2:43Troy Roberts: Marlene and Steve Eisenberg would be the first to tell you they're just a regular family. When you encounter a stranger or someone that doesn't know you very well and they ask you how many children you have, what do you say? Three. Because that's how many children I do have. But their youngest daughter, Sabrina, has not been seen or heard from for more than 10 years. Not since November 24th, 1997, when the five-month-old seemingly vanished. I believe she's just a beautiful young lady, seven years old. She's not a baby anymore. I have dreams often that she's coming home and that we're playing, and the dreams are as vivid as they're real.

3:24Have you been able to successfully rebuild your life?

3:34We are a happy family, but we will be an ecstatic family when we're all together. like we should be.

3:43Troy Roberts: Steve and Marlene Eisenberg's ordeal began here at their home in Valrico, Florida, just outside of Tampa. It was 6.30 in the morning and Marlene was beginning her day, rising early as usual before her husband and three children. Immediately, though, she sensed that something wasn't quite right, that something had gone terribly wrong. I remember just screaming. I opened up my gate, he's gone out of the crib. All right, ma 'am, need to calm down. Oh, God, my baby is gone! My baby is gone! It's something I really don't like to listen to because I can't... It just brings everything back. Marlene and Steve would like to forget everything about that awful night, especially the garage door that they admit to leaving open.

4:30I guess the garage is left open. The door was left open? I think the garage must have been left open.

4:36Troy Roberts: Would you have done anything differently about securing the house? Oh, for sure. My God. What would you have done differently? What we do now. I look at the doors every night and we make sure they're shut and locked and we turn the alarm on. Every night we kick myself, ourself, because we didn't use an alarm and we had one. Of course we would do things differently.

4:59Troy Roberts: But that night, with the door open, the Eisenbergs can only assume that someone crept quietly into the house and snatched Sabrina while they were sleeping. My baby's not in her crib. You know, where is she? All right, stay on the line. Do you have other kids in the house? She is. She is. It's just amazing. After Marlene called 911, Steve went next door to a neighbor. The doorbell rang that morning and your wife answered the door. Yes. What happened next? The first thing Steve had said to my wife was, she's missing. Scott Middleton is a former Tampa cop. At the time, he and his wife lived directly across the street.

5:43My wife had ran out the front door and Marlene was waving, just, you know, hey. What do you mean? Well, it was, you know, it wasn't the panic. You know, it was not a panic parent.

5:57Troy Roberts: Immediately, his police training kicked in. What was struck you as odd that morning? They're just, you know, and I'm a parent myself. There wasn't any emotion there to say, hey, my kids are gone. But this news video shows how distraught Marlene was. That November morning, Sabrina disappeared. I didn't understand anything that was going on. I mean, it was just all hysterics. And I called Marlene, and it was a miracle that she picked up, and she was a mess. Good friend Kathy Dotson heard the panic in Marlene's voice. She was crying, and I said, I just heard, is it true? I mean, I was just blown away, and she was like, yes, yeah, I gotta go, I gotta go.

6:40I mean, she was just a mess.

6:42Troy Roberts: Within minutes, deputies from the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Department descended on the Iceberg home. and the media was right behind them. This was a great story. Being a parent, I hate to say that anyone's missing child is a good story, but as time wore on, it became a very interesting story. TV reporter Bill McGinty covered the story for WTSP, the CBS affiliate in Tampa. This was the lead story in our newscast every day for months, because every day there was something new to tell. I got you. Sheriff's deputies began an extensive search in and around the Eisenberg home, but found nothing.

7:24There are mass witnesses at this point. We have no reason to believe that they're involved.

7:29Troy Roberts: Still, deputies were struck by the disheveled appearance of the Eisenberg home. To the cops, it spelled neglect. But to her friends, it was just the way Marlene was. She wasn't an immaculate housekeeper. Anybody would testify to that, that, you know, her house was a mess. By the end of that first horrible day... And I'm begging that person to please bring our baby back to us. Police encouraged the couple to go on TV and plead for their daughter's safe return. But to a curious public, the Eisenbergs seemed cold and aloof. Most people thought, at least the speculation on the street is, if my baby were taken, I'd be a lot more upset than that.

8:10Troy Roberts: Some people looking at that have said that you seemed strangely unemotional. First of all, you're in shock and my baby is gone. I have no idea where she is and I have to say something. We all miss her and love her very much and we need her to come home to us, please. You don't know what to say, you don't know how to react. There's not a book that you read on what to go through when you've had something horrible happen in your life. But like a lot of people, McGinty thought there was just something slightly off about their story. It's a little tough to swallow that somebody went in through a door and took a baby out of a crib right across the hallway from where they were sleeping.

8:53You drive into the neighborhood, there's one way in, one way out. They live on a cul-de-sac. There's a big wall around their neighborhood.

8:59Troy Roberts: Suspicion was growing around the Eisenbergs. Take this snippet of videotape. For a brief moment, less than a second really, Steve was recorded with a smile on his face. A lot of our behavior was what was dictated for us to do and be by the police. When we were leaving our house one day, they made a joke and we laughed. The focus of the story shifted from Sabrina Eisenberg, five months old, missing baby, to Marlene and Steve Eisenberg. Even Brownie, the family dog, came under scrutiny. Why had she not barked at the intruder? Brownie was a nut. Would Brownie bark at his own shadow? Yeah. Brownie was a dog that was full of all kinds of energy.

9:42Rambunctious dog? Laid back.

9:44Troy Roberts: Laid back? Laid back. Brownie did not bark. Nope. With the Eisenberg's permission, the FBI tapped their phone so that any call from a kidnapper could be traced. One of the first calls was from Steve's brother Dave, a lawyer. Well, what's going on down there? I mean, the detectives are doing their job. They're following every lead they have. When detectives listened in, they were amazed that Steve, supposedly awaiting a call from his child's kidnappers, never answers the call-waiting beep that kicks in. Every other phone call is the press. Right now, the detectives are in a meeting. To the police, this was proof the Eisenbergs knew much more about Sabrina's disappearance than they were letting on.

10:28Troy Roberts: Any concerned parent they thought would have taken that call immediately. Suspicious, the detectives confronted Marlene. We called them here to help us find her, or who took her, or where is she? And this person's sitting there telling me, you know, well, we think you know where Sabrina is and what happened.

11:0024 hours after Sabrina was reported missing, the Eisenbergs were frustrated with a police

11:08Troy Roberts: response. They chose to look for a body, not a baby. Any lead that was called in for a live baby at the airport, they didn't follow up on it. 911. A neighbor, a couple nights before Sabrina was taken from our house, a woman had her window of her baby's room broken into. A couple of nights before. 1533 hours. Are you telling me that the police never conducted an honest search? They tried to find a body. The investigators never really got past Mr. and Mrs. Eisenberg. Graham Brink, a reporter for the St. Petersburg Times, has written extensively about the case. Most people, I believe, would tell you that the community thought they had done it or that it was an accident and they were covering it up.

11:47Troy Roberts: You understand that the police had to investigate you? Oh, sure. Investigate us, but follow other leads. The statistics show that when a baby is abducted, there's only one chance in a thousand that someone other than a family member did it. Well, guess what? You're meeting number one. Right. There she goes to William's shoes. There's her big brother acting silly. Hi. Before Sabrina disappeared, life for the Eisenbergs largely revolved around their three children. Sabrina and her two older siblings, William, then nine, and Monica, five. You know, I love kids. I love my kids. I love my friends' kids.

12:26And now just tilt your head up and blow as hard as you can.

12:29Troy Roberts: Marlene even started her own business for kids, running a baby and toddler exercise program. Steve worked real estate in Tampa's blooming economy. We're just regular people. But ugly gossip was spreading. Tell me what kinds of things were you hearing? One of them may have been having an affair, that the baby may not have been Steve's biologically. The Eisenbergs, meanwhile, continued to cooperate with the investigation. Sheriff's detectives gave the couple lie detector tests and then reportedly leaked information that some of Marlene's answers were deceptive. The results of your first polygraph test, Marlene, was inconclusive.

13:09Troy Roberts: Correct. And you failed the second test. I was told I was inconclusive on the second test as well. Police said that you failed it. I was told by them that I was inconclusive.

13:21Troy Roberts: The investigation was now three days old, and at the advice of his brother, Steve got a lawyer. You guys should get an attorney, you know, because these people are, you know, they're out to get you. The Eisenbergs hired Barry Cohen, one of the most high-profile and combative lawyers in Florida. What kind of lawyer are you? Good lawyer. Damn good lawyer. Cohen says there's nothing that points to his client's guilt. There was no physical evidence. This entire investigation, the FBI, the Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office, did not produce one piece of physical evidence that even suggested that either one of them were responsible.

14:04Everybody's probably a suspect, and they've been asked the hard questions.

14:09Troy Roberts: Despite that, Cohen says sheriff's detectives had one mission, to prove the Eisenbergs were involved. When I saw the police were acting in bad faith and that they were destined to try to frame Marlene and Steve, that's where we stopped cooperating. The Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office refused to talk to us about the case, but reporter Bill McGinty says the cops definitely pursued other leads, even though the vast majority were from people who mistakenly thought they had spotted Sabrina. They were running two parallel investigations, one looking at the Eisenbergs and one looking into every other possibility.

14:45We went to the Eisenberg war room where they had volumes of information, places they'd been to, thousands of different leads.

14:54Troy Roberts: But there's no doubt the police felt stymied just when they thought they were on the verge of breaking the couple. We are not going to permit any further interviews. The case became very adversarial. Would you say that the Eisenbergs are cooperating in the search for Sabrina? Limited cooperation, very limited. It was Barry trying to defend his clients. as best he could against what he saw was a horde of investigators and prosecutors trying to bring them down. Why would innocent people need to hire a lawyer? Because the law enforcement officers were not trying to find the truth. Leads were pouring in, but the police clearly thought their best suspects were sitting right in this house.

15:39Troy Roberts: In a highly unusual move reserved largely for mob bosses and drug kingpins, Hillsborough County Sheriff detectives got a warrant allowing them to secretly plant small listing devices or bugs in the Eisenberg's kitchen and bedroom. Why did the police wiretap the home? I think they thought it was their last chance of getting the Eisenberg's. This would not be a good place for microphones. 48 Hours asked Mike Paris, a wiretap and bug detection expert, to come to the Eisenberg home to show us how the wiretapping operation worked. This is the actual bug? That's the microphone here, yes. It's quite sensitive to, it has the ability to pick up a whisper within probably about 30 or 40 feet.

16:24Troy Roberts: Parris explains that the bug is attached to a transmitter and then placed behind a wall jack to an existing telephone line. A sophisticated eavesdropper is going to want to be able to have access to wire like we have here. The sound then travels along outside phone lines to a nearby police station. And the sound quality? Excellent. Excellent. As long as it's applied correctly. Which is critical. That's correct. Every day for nearly three months, from 7 a.m. to midnight, sheriff's deputies listened and recorded thousands of private conversations going on in the Eisenberg home. They had a lot of pressure on them to make a case, so they figured if they're guilty, they'll probably talk about it.

17:07Troy Roberts: Sabrina had been gone for two months when a federal grand jury was convened to examine her disappearance. The Eisenbergs were asked to testify, but Cohen advised them to invoke their Fifth Amendment rights. He advised you not to testify before the grand jury looking into your daughter's disappearance. Why wouldn't you want to do that? We did what we felt was necessary at that time. You know how it looked though. Your daughter is missing and you two don't want to cooperate with the process. You don't want to testify before the grand jury. That's not true. We cooperated with the whole process. We cooperated 100%.

17:44You didn't testify before the grand jury. You know what? If you have any other grand jury questions, you can ask our attorneys.

17:50Troy Roberts: Why did you advise the Eisenbergs not to testify before the grand jury? I knew the reputation of Steve Kuntz. Stephen Kuntz was the lead federal prosecutor in the case and, to put it mildly, Cohen doesn't think much of him. He has no business in the system. If he worked for a corporation, they'd be sued for negligent hiring and or negligent retention successfully. Is that when things got really ugly? You know, things have been ugly for so long, we don't remember when they became ugly. As the grand jury heard testimony, social workers showed up at the Eisenbergs' front door to investigate whether the couple's older children, William and Monica, were being mistreated.

18:35Troy Roberts: So what did you make of this? Was this a strong-arm tactic? Totally. I think they wanted to scare us and let us think that they were taking away our children. They just wanted to know because they could talk to them all evening and the children would let them know that all we do is love them. It's just another effort on the part of the authorities here, in this case, to break these people. But their ordeal was only just beginning. It was like the scariest thing to have a gun pointed at you. I mean, he was literally aiming the gun right at my face.

19:20Troy Roberts: The swamps outside Tampa keep many secrets. Do they also hold the key to solving the mystery of what happened to Sabrina Eisenberg? Searchers seem to think so but after a year and a half without any answers the sheriff's office was feeling the pressure and Barry Cohen knew it. They were embarrassed they didn't want to have another Ramsey case on their hands out here where the investigators were made a fool out of. Like the Ramsey case detectives looking for Sabrina were convinced the parents were somehow involved. I think once law enforcement collectively decided that the Eisenbergs were responsible and guilty, then whatever it took to implicate and to charge them, then that was going to be done.

20:14Troy Roberts: John Fitzgibbons, a former U.S. attorney now in private practice in Tampa, says Barry Cohen... I don't care what they said. And his zeal to protect the Eisenbergs was aggravating investigators. Barry basically and repeatedly stabbed his finger in their eye throughout the case. We don't know if they've correctly written down what they've said. We don't know whether they've taken it out of context. We don't know whether they've confabulated the information. He mocked the investigation. He publicly challenged the investigation. They should be apologizing, not only to the Eisenbergs, but to all of the other law enforcement officers whose integrity they have undermined.

20:55Troy Roberts: Do you think that using kinder, gentler language and being more cooperative would have helped your clients more? Well, no, I don't think this case called for any euphemisms or any kinder language. This was a war. This was a war. You don't go into a war with a BB gun. The Eisenbergs, meanwhile, were trying to keep their hopes alive. We know we didn't harm her, and I can't believe anybody else would harm her. I believe that she was taken to be loved by someone. What I think about is, how can I bring my daughter home? And that's what's most important to me. By May 1999, the Eisenbergs were struggling financially.

21:37Troy Roberts: So they sold their house in Florida and moved back to Steve's childhood home in Bethesda, Maryland. I believe that the police are someone you're supposed to teach your kids to respect. And I could not do that living in Tampa. And just four months later, on September the 9th, they receive some unexpected visitors. I was packing because our family was going to Boston for Rosh Hashanah. Clothes on the bed and cars pulled up. and got a look and seeing people just walking around the driveway. I didn't understand who these people were, why they're all coming here. So I called Barry. I called my attorney.

22:26I'm literally on hold, you know, wanting to talk to somebody. It must have been a new secretary or something, and she didn't know where anybody was. They've broken into the house. All of a sudden I hear, Marlene, come downstairs. You need to come downstairs. And I come right here and the next thing I know is there's a gun being pointed right at my face. And he's just pointing a gun right at me. And I'm like, just in shock, just looking at them, what's going on? And he's like, put down the phone. And I was like, put down the gun. It was like the scariest thing to have a gun pointed at you. I mean, he was literally aiming the gun right at my face.

23:08Troy Roberts: The intruders tell Marlene who they are, the FBI. I said, did you find Sabrina? Where is she? And at that point, they said, we didn't find Sabrina. We believe that she's dead. And I said, no, I don't believe that. I'll never believe that. And they said, well, we're arresting you. At the same time, across town, agents are arresting Steve. They put me in a cell, strip-searched me. They did the fingerprints, the photos, and the whole time I'm just thinking you're making a huge mistake. You didn't look for our daughter, and you're making the biggest mistake right now. Prosecutors believe they have an airtight case because of the secret wire recordings.

23:55The indictment also charges the Eisenbergs, discussed on several occasions, that the baby was actually dead and what story they would tell authorities concerning the disappearance of the baby.

24:08Troy Roberts: They are later released on bail using Steve's father's home as collateral. Stephen, did you kill your daughter? Did you kill your daughter? No comment. The Eisenbergs are indicted not for murder, but for conspiracy and for lying to investigators. The charges, if proved, could send them to prison for up to 30 years. We'd like to give you a chance to respond to that indictment and say something on your behalf.

24:39Troy Roberts: The indictment was based on the police bugging operation that lasted nearly three months. More than 2 ,600 conversations were recorded between the Eisenbergs, in which police say they discussed killing their daughter. The indictment was horrific to read. And that they could even put a bug in our bedroom, especially the bedroom. It's just, you know, it's a sanctuary for a husband and wife. And it's scary to sit there and say, oh my God, you know, look what they're trying to do to us. Did you kill your daughter? Prosecutors said the Eisenbergs' taped conversations were devastating. Marlene reportedly said, the baby's dead and buried.

25:23Troy Roberts: It was found dead because you did it. The baby's dead no matter what you say. You just did it. Steve supposedly responded, we need to discuss the way that we can beat the charge. We will do what we have to do. I thought the government has a hell of a powerful case here. At the couple's bail hearing, a federal prosecutor tells a judge she had heard Steve Eisenberg on the tape say, I wish I hadn't harmed her. It was the cocaine. I'll do drug tests from now to eternity, and you'll never find any drugs in my system. I said, Steve, I said, look at the detail in this indictment. I never said anything that they say I said.

26:07Marlene never said anything that they say she said. And I said, Steve, I believe you. And then I went back and we finally got those tapes.

26:17Troy Roberts: But do the tapes contain a confession or will they just add to the confusion already surrounding the case?

26:38Troy Roberts: It had been more than two years since baby Sabrina vanished from her crib. Federal prosecutors were sure they had a case, not a murder case, but a case of conspiracy. They were determined to get a confession. I knew pretty shortly that it was going to get ugly. Barry Cohen, fellow prosecutor Stephen Koons, was overzealous. He's totally ambitious, he's totally irresponsible, and he believes in one thing, and that is getting a conviction and getting his name in the paper. In December of 2000, the Eisenbergs, the feds, and the secret tapes were about to have their day in court. The courtroom was packed, and everyone was there for one reason and one reason alone, to hear the bombshell recordings.

27:30When they told us these are the quotes, we have them on tape, everybody thought, oh, wow, gee whiz, they're dead in the water.

27:41Troy Roberts: These tapes were the backbone of the prosecution's entire case. But can you hear what's on them? Listen closely.

28:00I later described it as it's sounding like chickens squawking with a hurricane playing in the background.

28:11Static, a lot of TV, a lot of noise. And all we could hear in the courtroom that day was mumbling. And you could hear the hum of appliances and things like that.

28:21Troy Roberts: But the prosecution heard more than just noise. They believe they heard incriminating evidence.

28:38When it was played in open court, the judge looked over at the prosecutor and he had his glasses on the end of his nose. and that look was a glare. This is the best you got?

28:50Troy Roberts: Barry Cohen hired a former analyst from the FBI to listen to the tapes. He said, well, I'm going to call it the way I see it. I said, that's great. When he submitted his affidavit that he had listened to the tapes and the tapes did not match up with the words in the transcript, I thought that was the turning point of the case. Former prosecutor John Fitzgibbons. It was just astounding. There were sentences and paragraphs that didn't connect up. To combat Cohen's expert witness, Stephen Kuntz hired audio expert and private investigator to the stars, Anthony Pelicano, whose clients included Michael Jackson and Elizabeth Taylor.

29:28Troy Roberts: Pelicano had a reputation for resorting to violence to get his way. I learned that he bragged in articles that were written about him, about getting people to talk to him with a baseball bat and slicing people's faces. A real fair word would be that he was just a real scumbag. Anthony Pelicano later pled guilty in another case to possessing illegal explosives. Why would the government stoop to hiring Tony Pelicano when shortly after that he was indicted himself? And he served two and a half years in federal prison. It appeared that Pelicano and the prosecutors were the only ones in the courtroom who could hear the incriminating evidence.

30:12Troy Roberts: This came as no surprise to the Eisenberg team. One of their lawyers on their legal team sat back in his chair like this and just looked at the media and said, told you. I can't comprehend how someone with even a minimum amount of intelligence could come up with those phrases when listening to the tapes.

30:35This is the worst transcription I have ever seen.

30:43Troy Roberts: 48 Hours hired our own audio expert to listen to the tapes. Jack Mitchell has worked for the U.S. Department of Justice. This entire paragraph right here is nonsense. It's almost as if it were just simply made up. There is no evidence whatsoever on any of the recordings that I have examined that will implicate the Eisenbergs in the disappearance of baby Sabrina. None. Mitchell has analyzed hundreds of tapes during his career and is convinced that some of the most incriminating quotes may not even belong to the Eisenbergs. That means to me that it's possible that this whole matter of need to have you kill me all the way down through the baby's dead is a television program.

31:41See, we have a lot of interference here.

31:43Troy Roberts: Remember when bugging expert Mike Parris talked about the sensitivity of the microphones used to tape the Eisenbergs?

31:55Troy Roberts: Have you been able to understand any of this? No, this is very unusual. It sounds like they had some sort of technical problem with the application. The damning evidence was nowhere to be found.

32:13All lies, just all lies. We knew that there was nothing on those tapes. It just goes to show what a furtive imagination the police had.

32:24Troy Roberts: All of this was enough to make Barry Cohen suspect the worst. You believe that the Eisenbergs were framed. Yeah, don't you? Why would they want to frame the Eisenbergs? Why? They wanted to get a quick confession, clear this case, and look good. But the only problem was they didn't have any facts, so they had to make them. The prosecution's case against the couple began collapsing. Now it was the feds who had some tough questions to answer. Prosecutors told the judges that the bugging conformed with state and federal laws. Is that true? No. They were lies. They misled the judges to get permission to bug the house.

33:07Yeah, misled is a euphemism. They lied to the judge because they didn't have any evidence. 911. My baby's been kidnapped.

33:15Troy Roberts: For example, police told the judge that Merlene's 911 call was, quote, unemotional. My baby's gone. My baby's gone. My baby's gone. I think at the end of the day, the police crossed the line. And whether the Eisenbergs are guilty or innocent, they were victims of police misconduct here. In fact, two judges appointed to review the case found the Eisenberg tapes were, quote, largely unintelligible. They called some of the prosecution statements false and pure fiction. In a stunning blow to the prosecution, the recordings were ruled inadmissible. The case against Marlene and Steve Eisenberg is all but officially thrown out.

34:05One week later, all charges were dropped.

34:10Troy Roberts: Felt vindicated? It was a relief. Vindication? No. Relief? Yes. After our repeated calls to lead prosecutor Stephen Coons were not returned, we approached him for answers. And I would be interested in speaking to you about the prosecution of this case.

34:34Troy Roberts: Stephen Coons was temporarily demoted while he was investigated by the Department of Justice. His supervisors refused to comment on the outcome, but he is still a federal prosecutor.

34:55Troy Roberts: While it was a hollow victory for the Eisenbergs, today they hope a new clue will bring their daughter home. Putting all the pieces together to come up with an age-progressive image of what we feel Sabrina will look like.

35:20The old family secret recipe. Do you want a regular spoon or do you want to use that, Monica?

35:27Troy Roberts: Today, Steve and Marlene Eisenberg are settling into a normal family routine. Any chance you get the leg, huh? Caring for their children, William and Monica. You used to love that.

35:43But Sabrina is not forgotten. Come on, you pretty girl. Come on, pretty girl.

35:54Troy Roberts: They even keep a separate bedroom in their Maryland home, reserved for their missing daughter. We go to bed at night. We say goodnight to all our kids. We go downstairs, we kiss William, we kiss Monica, and we say goodnight, Sabrina. We walk by this room. Even buying her souvenirs from their vacations. When she comes home, this is her stuff, and her room, and her Beanie Babies, and she can play with them and do anything she wants with them. They believe their daughter is somewhere alive and well, and is being raised by a family who desperately wanted a child. Aren't these reminders painful, though?

36:29Troy Roberts: Don't you go into that room and want to cry? No. I go into that room and say, okay, when are you coming home? You know, you're going to love these things. When are you coming home? It hurts. She's seven years old and she's not home yet. That kills me.

36:48Troy Roberts: But Marlene has good reason to never give up hope. A possible break in the case of another missing child, Sabrina Eisenberg, who was abducted from a Florida home. It was May 2003 when a couple in Illinois began adoption proceedings on a six-year-old child who did not have a birth certificate. I thought she definitely looked like Sabrina as a baby. I mean, the pictures were very similar. Pontiac Police Chief Don Schlosser began an investigation. A woman whose identity no one knew handed the child over to a second party. A lot of people, including the Eisenbergs, believe the mystery behind Sabrina's disappearance was about to be solved.

37:32It gives us optimism that she's going to be coming back home to our family. It all just seemed like it was going to fit, that this could be really her. And, you know, we were just on pins and needles and on edge, just praying that it was going to be her.

37:44Troy Roberts: For two weeks, Steve and Marlene waited for the results of a DNA analysis. The Paloma's DNA did not match. It was very difficult and very emotional for all of us. Paloma's natural mother was a Mexican woman who abandoned her baby at a clinic on the Texas border. A nurse there gave the baby to her sister in Illinois. There was no malice in what she was doing. She simply went about the process in a wrong way. Eventually, the sister did adopt Paloma legally. Are you still angry? If they bring Sabrina home, I won't be angry. And I have to pray that they do the right thing, that they will look for her and bring her home.

38:37There's pictures with Monica holding Sabrina, William and Sabrina.

38:43Troy Roberts: Today, the Eisenbergs put their hope in those who stood by them. I'm a believer we're going to bring Sabrina home. The National Center for Missing Children. What day did she go missing? What is the child's race? Where she would go missing when she met online. The staff at the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children has been invaluable. Here in the Forensic Imaging Unit, the cases don't even come back here until they're at least two years old. Joe Mullins is a forensic artist at the center who creates age-progressed photos. He was abducted at 21 months? Yep. Of what children may look like years after they've gone missing.

39:17Troy Roberts: 21 years later, and this is how close we got. So this composite sketch led to his recovery? Yes, it did. It did. This technology has helped in the recovery of almost 800 children. There's a split screen of her brothers and sisters at about the same age as she would be today. Using facial features from Sabrina's older brother and sister, Mullins creates this image of what Sabrina might look like at age 7. I pray to God somebody can look at her and say, that's an Eisenberg. Do you really believe she'll come back to you? I believe it. I know you're only focused on finding your daughter. There will still be people out there that will look at the two of you and say, you know what?

39:59Troy Roberts: They got away with it. They got away with it. And when she comes home, everyone will know the truth. And what we ask is that you look to help bring her home so you can see the truth too.

40:16If you have any information about Sabrina Eisenberg, please call 1-800-THE-LOST.

From the publisher

In November 1997, Florida couple Marlene and Steve Aisenberg reported their five-month-old daughter Sabrina missing from her crib. The police began to search for the baby but soon became convinced that the couple knew more about their baby’s disappearance than they admitted. “48 Hours" Correspondent Troy Roberts reports. This classic "48 Hours" episode last aired on 2/9/2008. Watch all-new episodes of “48 Hours” on Saturdays, and stream on demand on Paramount+.

To learn more about listener data and our privacy practices visit: https://www.audacyinc.com/privacy-policy

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit https://podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from 48 Hours

All episodes