1. Podcasts
  2. 48 Hours
  3. Dangerous Games
48 Hours

22 Oct 2026 · 39m · 12 chapters

In short

2012 murder of 19-year-old Elizabeth “Lizzie” Marriott in New Hampshire, involving allegations of BDSM, rape, strangulation, and a cover-up; trial testimony centers on Kat McDonough’s shifting accounts and physical evidence. Guests/people featured: Catherine McDonough (Cat) and Seth Mazzalia are central; Catherine is described as Seth’s former girlfriend who says he became violent and controlling, and she later testifies for the prosecution via a plea deal. Lizzie’s parents, Melissa and Bob Marriott, and Lizzie’s friend Nate McNeil are interviewed. Reporter Rod Doherty and witness/editor Rod Doherty are referenced for coverage. Witnesses include Nate McNeil, Tony and Becky (Lizzie’s uncle/aunt), and Roberta Gerken and Paul Hickok.

Key claims

Prosecutors say Seth strangled Lizzie with gloves and a rope, raped her, then disposed of her body at Pierce Island; Cat helped hide evidence and later testified that Seth killed Lizzie. Defense claims Cat lied and caused Lizzie’s death during consensual sex gone wrong, with Seth only helping afterward.

Notable examples

Kat’s text messages about finding another partner; gloves/underwear with DNA; disposal items (suitcase, rope, clothing) thrown away; jury verdicts convicting Seth of first-degree murder by strangulation and rape.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:41

The Crime of Lizzie Marriott

Explore the tragic case of Lizzie Marriott and her murder.

“and Lizzie Marriott was the perfect victim for him.”
4:48

Lizzie's Last Days

Learn about Lizzie Marriott's life leading up to her disappearance.

“The cool blue of the New Hampshire seawater is as deep as Lizzie Marriott's love for the ocean.”
7:46

Investigative Breakthroughs

Follow the investigation into Lizzie's disappearance and the suspects.

“I said to Becky and then I said, friends, what friends are we talking about?”
14:50

Seth Mazzalia's Arrest and Background

Discover the events leading to Mazzalia's arrest and his past relationships.

“Mazzalia says after Lizzie died, he panicked and brought the body here to Pierce Island, where the Piscatica River meets the Atlantic Ocean.”
18:57

Cat McDonough's Testimony

Explore Cat's account of the night Lizzie died and the aftermath.

“Ten years later, Seth Mazzalia stands accused of killing Lizzie Marriott and his latest teenage lover is coming to his defense.”
21:47

Trial and Prosecution's Case

Understand the prosecution's case against Seth Mazzalia during the trial.

“Instead of a possible 21-year sentence, she'd get a maximum of three years.”
23:57

Details of the Night Lizzie Died

Listen to the harrowing details of Lizzie's last night and the courtroom reactions.

“that Lizzie's death was an accident was a lie, prosecutors say, to protect Mazzalia.”
28:01

Testimony and Disturbing Events

The trial reveals critical testimony about Lizzie's death and the actions of Kat and Seth.

“Do you swear or affirm that the testimony...”
31:28

Details of the Crime and Relationship Dynamics

Kat McDonough's involvement in Lizzie's murder and the underlying abusive relationship are examined.

“What would unfold that last night of her life and after her death was beyond belief.”
39:01

The Verdict and Aftermath

The jury's verdict on Seth Mazzalia and the impact of the trial on Lizzie's family are discussed.

“But not the way they do business, a.k.a.”
Show all 12 chapters
42:00

Sentencing and Mourning Lizzie

Hear the emotional impact on Lizzie's family after the killer's sentencing.

“And incredibly, Lizzie's parents say they have sympathy for Kat.”
45:06

Uncovering a Mother's Murder

Lauren Malloy discovers the truth about her mother's mysterious death.

“Until one day, she got a phone call that changed everything.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 48 Hours, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00True crime is full of unanswered questions, but earning your degree doesn't have to be a mystery. That's where Southern New Hampshire University comes in. SNHU offers more than 200 online degree programs with flexibility that puts you in the driver's seat and trusted support to keep you on track, even when life takes an unexpected turn. Find the answers you're searching for at snhu.edu slash 48 hours. You know how many people talk about a capsule wardrobe for clothes? Jenny Bird does that for jewelry. They've basically redefined how to accessorize by creating the ultimate jewelry capsule. Instead of a box full of random items saving themselves for special occasions, Jenny Bird makes elevated essential pieces, from earrings to necklaces, that you'll actually reach for every single day.

0:52And if you wake up early like me, you know how great it is to have anything that makes your morning routine easier. Jenny Bird can do just that because their pieces are so versatile that you can mix and match without overthinking your look. Every time you wear yours, be prepared for someone to ask where you got it. And you'll love that you're not constantly rebuying trendy accessories every season. These staples just work with everything in your closet. Getting dressed is just so much easier when your accessories are this seamless. Plus, Jenny Bird pieces look and feel more expensive than they are.

1:28Get a free gift with your first Jenny Bird order when you shop at Jenny-Bird.com.

1:40It was inevitable that Seth Mazzalia was going to kill. and Lizzie Marriott was the perfect victim for him. He attacked, he raped, and he murdered. This is his victim, 19-year-old Elizabeth Marriott.

2:06Lizzie was always happy, and she always found the best in everyone. She had such an aura about her. You know, people wanted to talk to her. Ladies and gentlemen, the state calls Catherine McDonough. It was clear that this trial was going to all be about Cat McDonough's testimony. Ms. McDonough, how do you know what Seth Mazzalia did to Elizabeth Marriott? I was there.

2:36Cat was always into strange things. She was always talking about her different personalities. She was dating an older guy, Seth Mazzalia. The relationship between Seth and Kat was going to be a dangerous problem.

2:59Seth was into the BDSM type thing. Did he and you engage in bondage, domination, master submissive? Yes. This case is not a romanticized, fictionalized novel you may have read. This was the exercise of power and control. Lizzie was attractive. She was what he had been looking for. The defendant in McDonough schemed about how they could exploit her sexually. Was that why you reached out to Lizzie Marriott and invited her to the apartment? Yes. Seth was hoping there would be some sort of sexual encounter And it all seemed to be going according to the defendant's sexual plot Until Lizzie said no He didn't like to be told though And what the master wanted, he got The defendant put on gloves and he grabbed a rope Ms.

4:05McDonough, who killed Elizabeth Marriott? Seth and Azalea But during the trial, I was surprised how many people thought she was lying. Ladies and gentlemen, Seth Mazzella did not cause Ms. Marriott's death. Pat McDonough is lying. The physical evidence shows what? Sex. There was sex. There were ropes. It was an accident.

4:33Troy Roberts: Did you think this was maybe a sexual encounter that went awry? and got too rough? Or was this murder? Murder.

4:45Troy Roberts: I'm Troy Roberts. Tonight on 48 Hours. Dangerous Games.

4:59Troy Roberts: The cool blue of the New Hampshire seawater is as deep as Lizzie Marriott's love for the ocean. But that same ocean would play a role in the tragedy that ended Lizzie's life. Lizzie was vivacious. She loved her friends. She loved the little critters around her. Lizzie's mother, Melissa Marriott. You know, you'd see her and she'd have a tortoise in her hand or a little turtle and, you know, be putting it back on the brook side of our road. And her father, Bob Marriott. She and I used to do just the silliest things together. just no rhyme or reason. In October 2012, Lizzie Marriott was 19 years old.

5:44Troy Roberts: She had just entered the University of New Hampshire as a sophomore. It has a wonderful marine biology program, and it's where she really wanted to go. And while attending UNH as a day student, Lizzie was living here with her uncle Tony and Aunt Becky. One of my favorite things was when she would come back, she'd scream, I'm home, and it really made us feel comfortable that she really felt like our home was also her home. Tuesday, October 9, 2012 started out like any other day. On Tuesday, she said going to a friend's house. Be home no later than 12. And that's the last thing we heard from her.

6:25Troy Roberts: Wednesday morning, Lizzie had not come back. And it made me nervous. I said, well, you know, teenage girl, she probably stayed late. Hey, can I crash at your house? But by Thursday, still no sign of Lizzie. Thursday morning. Thursday morning. There's no car. And she says, oh my God, Lizzie's not here. And that's, and then it was like sheer panic. Now something's really wrong. Hi, Tony, it's Bob. Have you heard from Lizzie? No, we were about to call you. That's when your heart goes in your throat. Oh, my God, you know, what's going on? What do you do when your child is missing? I didn't have a checklist that told me what to do.

7:13Troy Roberts: Lizzie's parents live a couple hours' drive away in Massachusetts. They immediately called police to report her missing. We worked the phones for, I don't know, two hours maybe, and finally just couldn't take it anymore and jumped in the car and drove. Let's call the FBI. Let's call the state police. I'm driving and she's calling the cell phone to call anyone we can think of. Lizzie's family realized they didn't know who she was seeing that Tuesday night. I said to Becky and then I said, friends, what friends are we talking about? Who's she going to see? We didn't even know. But investigators had an early break.

7:54Troy Roberts: Friends told him who Lizzie was supposed to see that night. Kat McDonough. I know Lizzie and Kat had met. I didn't know if they were anything more than work acquaintances at the time. Nate McNeil worked at a local Target store with both Lizzie and Kat. He was one of Lizzie's new friends in New Hampshire. When word got out that Lizzie was missing, Nate reached out to Kat. At that point, I actually texted Kat because I knew that they had plans Tuesday night. I asked, hey, did Lizzie ever come over your house? No one seems to know where she is. And she texted back, no, I didn't see her. She never came over.

8:34Troy Roberts: Nate had known Kat Madonna for years. She was my sister's friend from kindergarten. Investigators piecing together Lizzie's last known activities started looking at Kat. At the time, she was living with her boyfriend, Seth Mazelia. Reporter and editor Rod Doherty covered the story for the Foster's Daily Democrat. Kat McDonough was fairly well known in the community. She seemed to be a normal teenager. Seth and Kat met in the summer of 2011 through the local theater scene. When I met her, she was very young. She was 17. I'm sorry. That's all right. Don't worry about it. And she was a sweet girl.

9:13Kat McDonough and I am doing one of the Puck's monologues. And here we go.

9:19Troy Roberts: Richard DeMario offered Kat a part in a play he was directing in the fall of 2011. I've got a crow. I saw a young girl who was very interested in partaking in the production, who was reliable and helpful. But DeMario says Kat changed dramatically after she started dating Seth. All right. Seth Mazalia, 5, 1, 2, 3. Yeah, I'll do it. And Pyramus, you'll figure it out fast enough. Don't worry. I think it's just a good girl who got mixed up in a very bad situation. And the bad situation was going to get worse. Kat moved in with 29-year-old Seth Mazalia shortly after she turned 18, cutting off all contact with her family.

10:12We thought it was, you know, very sudden. and we all knew that her parents didn't really approve of it.

10:18Troy Roberts: Seth Mazzalia worked at a local electronics store, taught martial arts, and was a trained EMT. And our reporter is researching him. He's coming across his name on these sex and bondage sites. Reporters and police would discover Seth had a very dark side. Dust, dust, dust. And that seemed to be a big part of Seth Mazzalia's life. A dark side police learned that also involved Kat. She posted dark pictures of herself online using screen names like Vampirate Actress and Miss Scarlet. She had obviously developed this fetish that we learned about that had to do with ropes and bondage and submissiveness.

11:06Troy Roberts: Kat and Seth were advertising on fetish websites, looking to bring a third person into their relationship. But they didn't find Lizzie Marriott on those websites. All she was trying to do was make friends with people. Three days after Lizzie's disappearance, investigators were convinced Kat and Seth knew something. Police brought them in for questioning at the same time. They were placed in separate rooms. The local police and the attorney general and the state police were very active very fast. Kat told police the same thing she told Nate in that text. Lizzie never showed up. About two hours into the interview, Kat stopped answering questions.

11:47Troy Roberts: Police said she was free to go, but she waited there for Seth. That's when things started, like, blowing up. Seth Mazalia was telling a totally different story. He spoke to police for 11 hours. What he told them was shocking. Lizzie Marriott was at the apartment the night she went missing. He said there was sex. Something went wrong. And Lizzie died.

12:27Ever find yourself standing in front of your closet having a full-blown style spiral? You know the feeling. Staring at a rack of clothes, wondering if wide-legged jeans are actually worth the hype. Whether an outfit is truly work-appropriate. or why finding a pair of pants that fits properly feels like a full-time job. You do not have to navigate it alone anymore because Maurice's is essentially that stylish friend in your group chat who always knows what looks good on you. Way back in 1931, their founder chose to focus on real women living real lives rather than chasing fashion trends. And that care still shines through today.

13:04Whether you're running out the door for coffee, handling school pickup, or getting dressed for a Saturday night wedding. Maurice's delivers versatile, approachable style and inclusive sizing that fits you perfectly every single time. Plus, with over 800 stores nationwide and an incredible website, you can pop into any store for free, personalized fit advice and outfit inspiration from their in-store stylist without needing an appointment. Next time you need a second opinion, head to Maurice's and walk out feeling effortless, comfortable, and completely confident. Use code 48HRS for an extra 10 % off your total purchase at maurices.com.

13:42Let's be honest, everyone hates fees, right? That's where Chime comes in. Chime is completely changing the way that people manage their money. Unlike traditional banks that often pile on hidden charges, Chime offers fee-free banking with no overdraft fees, no monthly maintenance fees, and no minimum balance requirements. You actually get rewarded for everyday spending, earning 5 % cash back in a category of your choice, like gas or groceries, all while building your credit without a credit check. And SpotMe has your back with up to$200 in fee-free overdraft protection when life gets expensive.

14:20Join the millions who are already banking fee-free with America's number one choice for banking. Head to chime.com slash 48 hours. That is chime.com slash 48 hours. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card provided by Chime's bank partners. Qualifying direct deposits required. Terms and limits apply. Go to chime.com slash disclosures for details.

14:49Troy Roberts: With Seth Mazzalia's bombshell admission that Lizzie had died in the apartment he shared with Kat McDonough, police had questions. Was Kat involved? And where was Lizzie's body? Mazzalia says after Lizzie died, he panicked and brought the body here to Pierce Island, where the Piscatica River meets the Atlantic Ocean. The search started immediately. Live with the latest, Jim. Heavy police presence, and it certainly is being treated as a crime scene. We're talking about potentially devastating news. But there was no trace of Lizzie. In the early hours of Saturday morning, Seth Mazzalia was arrested and charged with the murder of Lizzie Marriott.

15:39Troy Roberts: 48 hours later, Mazzalia was arraigned.

15:47Troy Roberts: New Hampshire law enforcement broke the news to Lizzie's parents. I knew before I walked in. It was bad. And we went off into a separate room and were given the news that Lizzie was dead.

16:18After you hear those words, you're kind of numb.

16:25Troy Roberts: Mazzalia's interrogation is sealed, so we don't know all the details of what he told police. Most importantly, was Kat involved in Lizzie's death? She would remain free for now. Police found clues in the dumpster behind Seth and Kat's apartment building.

16:47Troy Roberts: Men's underwear, a pair of black gloves, and Lizzie's sweatshirt. Law enforcement continued to search the Piscataqua River for weeks, but they never found Lizzie's body. She's just out there someplace. They just threw her away in the ocean.

17:11I wish that she hadn't been there, But if it wasn't Lizzie Marriott, it would have been somebody else.

17:17Troy Roberts: One person who was not surprised when Seth Mazzella was arrested for Lizzie's murder was this woman. He fantasized about murder a lot when I was with him. Her name is Catherine, and she dated Seth when she was in high school and he was in college in upstate New York. She says she knows his dark side. Initially, he was, you know, the flowers. He was very caring. And when did that change? He's always been into the BDSM type thing. BDSM stands for bondage, dominance, and sadomasochism. And unlike the popular book series turned movie, Catherine says Seth became increasingly violent and sexually abusive.

18:01We were naked and fooling around, and he put his hand around my throat fully. I told him to stop, and he started doing it harder. It just completely freaked me out.

18:14Troy Roberts: She says he gradually took control of her life. It's this slow descent into lack of choices to the point where I can't leave. In 2002, the couple moved to New Hampshire, where Catherine says Seth was always trying to bring other women into their bed. And it was something that was a constant. There was always needing to have more than just me in the relationship. And explain to me why you didn't leave. Where would I have gone? I was 600 miles away from home and afraid to leave because if I left, he would kill me. And he would hunt me down and he would kill me. Catherine finally moved out and went into hiding.

19:00Troy Roberts: Ten years later, Seth Mazzalia stands accused of killing Lizzie Marriott and his latest teenage lover is coming to his defense. Two days after his arrest, very different-looking Cat meets with his lawyers to try and clear his name. Okay, and you're here on your own free will because you want to talk to me? Okay, perfect. Cat is videotaped reviewing her statement. She now admits that Lizzie did come over that night. She says Lizzie's death was an accident. Seth was like sitting and the two of us are kind of just goofing around. The night started with the three of them watching a movie and playing cards, which Kat says led to consensual group sex.

19:45It started going from silly to sexual. It started getting a little more intense.

19:50Troy Roberts: Kat says Lizzie agreed to be tied up with bondage ropes and even draws a diagram of the harness. I had tied harnesses on me before. It was the first time I'd ever tied harnesses on someone else. Kat demonstrates how she was positioned over Lizzie. How are you actually just... She gives exact details of what she said happened that night. She says Lizzie had a seizure, suffocated, and died as she was lying under her on the floor. And Lizzie's... On the ground. On the ground, between your legs. Mm-hmm. Okay. Kat seems strangely detached as she describes what she says were the last moments of Lizzie's life.

20:33It was too much to handle. I was freaking out. Okay.

20:38Troy Roberts: Lizzie's friend Nate says Kat's story is preposterous. It was extreme, and it didn't make sense. I couldn't see her just outright doing something like that, especially with Kat and some guy. She only went over a house once. And Nate knows Lizzie had a girlfriend, Brittany, and they were in a long-term committed relationship. She always talked about all the fun things they would do, and how much they really cared for each other. Lizzie's family also finds this story outrageous, and they can't understand why Cat is still not in jail. Cat's responsible. Cat's involved in this. You know, why isn't she arrested?

21:15Yeah, we got him behind bars. But what about her? Police have made a second arrest in the murder of 19-year-old Lizzie Marriott.

21:23Troy Roberts: Lizzie's family would wait two months before Cat was finally arrested, but not for murder. Kat McDonough was charged with three counts involving hindering an investigation in order to have no further contact with Seth Mazzella. She needs to rot in jail. Without Lizzie's body, it's a very tough case. Prosecutors need Kat's testimony, and they offered her a deal. Instead of a possible 21-year sentence, she'd get a maximum of three years.

22:05Troy Roberts: All rise, jury is entering. This is a case of deliberate rape, of deliberate, purposeful, and cold-blooded murder. In May 2014, two years after Lizzie Marriott died under mysterious circumstances, Seth Mazzella goes on trial for her murder. The defendant struck quick, and he struck without any mercy whatsoever. Prosecutor Peter Hinckley. This is his victim, 19-year-old Elizabeth Marion. When you have a kid, you spend a lot of time thinking, you know, what can I do for them? And when that child is murdered, the number of things you can do really evaporates. And supporting her in the trial was one of the last things I'll be able to do for her.

23:13After his rape and murder, the defendant conspired with Catherine McDonough to falsify evidence of his crimes.

23:21Troy Roberts: The prosecution's case will hinge on the testimony of Kat McDonough, testifying as part of her plea deal. She's about to tell yet another version of what happened that night. This is just the beginning where I've been able to open up and actually explain what really happened to her. Kat now says Lizzie was murdered right before her own eyes. Ms. McDonough, who killed Elizabeth Marriott? Seth Mazzalia. The prosecution says Mazzalia controlled Kat completely. The defendant ordered in McDonough was to obey without question. Kat's earlier story that Lizzie's death was an accident was a lie, prosecutors say, to protect Mazzalia.

24:02Troy Roberts: Did Lizzie die accidentally during some form of sexual activity gone bad that she agreed to? No. Given her history of lying, was it a gamble to put her on the stand? Absolutely. Attorney Andrew Katrupe represented Kat in her plea deal. Her testimony was critical. In my view, very much so. I think the government understood that there would be a decent chance that Mr. Mazzelli would not be convicted without her testimony. Do you swear or affirm that the testimony... The first two days of Kat McDonough being on the stand were raw. Reporter Rod Doherty. The stories of their relationship, the sexual activity that went on.

24:43Who introduced who to the use of ropes and sexual activity? He was the one who brought the ropes in. Did he and you engage in domination, master submissive? Yes. She descended into such a dark world. It's time I punished you, you filthy little whore.

25:02Troy Roberts: Prosecutors read from a text message Mazzelia sent six weeks before Lizzie's death, where he promises to punish Kat in explicit ways and commands her to find him another girl. You choose a friend. Any of yours will do. And you offer her to me. That I may do anything I wish with her while you watch. Ms. McDonough, did your efforts to locate another sexual partner for the defendant intensify when you received that text message? Yes. And was that why you reached out to Lizzie Marriott and invited her over to the apartment? Yes. October 9, 2012 The last night of Lizzie's life Texts show that she arrives at Seth and Kat's apartment At 8.51 p.m.

25:51And then we all started to talk about what we wanted to do

25:55Troy Roberts: They decided on a movie And at Kat's suggestion A game of strip poker Prosecutors believe Lizzie had no idea She was being set up for a sexual encounter We all sat down and began to play The lights were very dim. We were kind of just laughing. I ended up not wearing anything. She ended up in just her underwear. And that's when Kat says Seth made his move to initiate sex. Seth suggested that I should kiss Lizzie. She said that she wasn't comfortable with that and that she was in a committed relationship. Kat says Seth made still another suggestion. He asked her if he could have sex with me in the room.

26:42She said no, that she wasn't okay with it.

26:45Troy Roberts: Kat says she could tell that Seth was getting angry after being told no, not once, but twice. He didn't like to be told, though. Seth was sitting on the futon behind us, and that's when he did it. Kat says while she and Lizzie sat on the floor watching the movie, Seth quietly put on gloves and grabbed a rope. He moved up behind her and he pulled the rope over her neck and strangled her. She let out a quick noise and then she sort of stopped moving. And did these appear to be the gloves that the defendant wore when he strangled Lizzie with a rope? Yes. The testimony is devastating for Lizzie's parents.

27:40It's too much.

27:41Troy Roberts: So difficult. There were times when Melissa Marriott couldn't even be in the courtroom. She wasn't moving at all. She was completely limp. And then Kat says Seth did the unthinkable. He raped Lizzie. Did she appear conscious? No. Did you tell him to stop? No. Did you go or yell for help? No. Nothing. Kat did nothing to save Lizzie's life. You have disgust for the jurors. Take a moment.

28:24Judge, maybe we can take a break now.

28:30Do you swear or affirm that the testimony...

28:32Troy Roberts: Roberta Gerken, a friend of Mazalia's, testifies she got a strange call from Kat at 10.49 that night. Something was going on. They wanted my assistance, and they wanted me to come over there. Roberta Gerken and her boyfriend Paul Hickok arrive at the apartment a little after 11 p.m. As I'm walking in, there's a body on the floor. There's a body on the floor right next to the bed. Hickok testifies that Seth's explanation was vague. All he kept repeating was, he's gone too far this time. He's gone too far. Seth was sitting on the bed, basically where her head was. Kat was against the kitchen cabinets, almost in a fetal position.

29:14Troy Roberts: Not wanting to get involved, Roberta and Paul left the apartment and never called 911. They did say they urged Seth to call an ambulance. But Seth Mazelia had other ideas. Seth came over to me. I was still curled up. And he held out his arm to me and he said, come on, we're in this together. And together, Seth and Kat would descend down a dark and disturbing path.

29:51Fall is a vibe. So what's yours? Do you go wild? Or get a little nostalgic? Do you like to cozy up indoors? Or kick it outdoors? Whatever you fall for. Get shoes that get you. We've got the trend. You bring the vibes. DSW, let us surprise you. Do you have a dark curiosity? Heart Starts Pounding Horrors, Hauntings, and Mysteries is a weekly podcast hosted by me, Kaylin Moore. Each week, I'll take you on a dark journey through terrifying true urban legends, bizarre true crime cases, chilling tales of backwoods horror, and more. So if you're looking to join a passionate community of the darkly curious, check out Heart Starts Pounding on the free Odyssey app or wherever you get your podcasts.

30:44And remember, stay curious.

30:50It's the middle of the night. You hear a sound. You freeze. But the real horror isn't outside the window. It's on it. The terrifying truth? Outdated broken blinds are exposing your private life to the street. Your beautiful home has become a crime scene of zero privacy. Take back complete control of your peaceful sanctuary. Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com.

31:27Troy Roberts: Lizzie Marriott was the girl with the ready smile and the sweet sense of humor. What would unfold that last night of her life and after her death was beyond belief. It was late. It was very late. like around 1 a.m. Together, the defendant and McDonough located Lizzie's car. They took that car using back roads that avoided the tollboose.

31:59Troy Roberts: Kat says after Lizzie was murdered, she helped Seth put the body into Lizzie's car. They drove some 13 miles from their apartment to the New Hampshire coast. Kat says she and Seth parked at the end of Pierce Island and brought Lizzie's body wrapped in tarp and stuck into a suitcase up this path to this overlook above the river. They took Lizzie's body out of the suitcase. Who pushed Lizzie's body over the cliff at that point in time? Seth did.

32:37Troy Roberts: She says Lizzie's body tumbled down the cliff, but it was low tide, and Lizzie landed on the rock some 35 feet below. Seth told Kat to climb down and drag Lizzie's body into the water. He said he couldn't climb because he was too exhausted. So that's when I climbed down to her. He said to cover her with seaweed. So I covered her completely with seaweed, and I managed to push her into the water.

33:17It's so hard to envision that level of evilness and disregard for humanity.

33:27Troy Roberts: Kat says they spent the remaining hours of that night throwing away evidence that has never been recovered. The suitcase, most of Lizzie's clothing, and the rope she was strangled with. Finally, they left Lizzie's car in a dark parking lot at the University of New Hampshire and walked the six miles home.

33:52Troy Roberts: Kat's attorney, Andrew Kertrupi. She helped dispose of a body. She didn't call police. She didn't run away and try to get help. I can't defend that conduct at all. It's indefendable. I understand that she clearly believed that he would do the same to her. Joachim Barth is Seth Mazzella's defense attorney. Attorney Barth. Thank you, Your Honor. His strategy proved Kat McDonough killed Lizzie Marriott. Ladies and gentlemen, Seth Mazzella did not rape and he did not murder Liz Marriott. Kat McDonough caused her death. Barth argues that Kat's testimony is a lie. Seth was nothing more than a lovesick accomplice, and Kat was the aggressor that night.

34:40Troy Roberts: Barth admits Seth did help dispose of Lizzie's body. Although Kat caused Lizzie's death, Seth was in fact there. And so he did participate in the deeply flawed acts that followed the death. They say Kat is only now blaming Seth to save herself. Barth argues the story Kat tells in this video that Lizzie suffocated underneath her during sex is the real truth. The defense tries at every turn to paint Kat as a liar. Do you have the capacity to look these jurors in the eye and lie to them while you project meekness and submissiveness and remorse? I'm not lying to them. Well, I'm up here to explain everything that had happened truthfully to the point where I am admitting to awful things that I personally have done.

35:43I did lie a lot, but I don't want to anymore, and that's why I'm up here telling the truth.

35:51Troy Roberts: Letters shown in court prosecutors argue point to the reason Kat lied for Seth. They say she was his victim in a relationship where violence and abuse were masked under the guise of so-called kinky sex. In this letter, Seth writes, I will dominate you, brutally, without mercy. How often would the defendant be your dominant and you be his slave or submissive? All the time. Daily? Yes. Prosecutors argue this was Mazzalia's method of domination and control. Regardless of whether or not you were the defendant's slave or submissive, who always had the final say on matters? He did. At the time of Lizzie's death, prosecutors say, Kat was completely isolated, cut off from her family and friends by Mazzalia, and totally depended on him.

36:46I didn't want to lose him. He was the only person I had. I didn't have anywhere else I could go.

36:55Troy Roberts: To support their claim Kat was a victim, the prosecution calls Dr. Scott Hampton, an expert on abusive relationships. You can love someone and be scared of them simultaneously. Dr. Hampton says abusers gradually take control of a victim's entire life. This is what abusers count on. This is a very gradual increase of the manipulation, the control, and it usually just increases when they feel they need to. And Kat's attorney believes that's true. She did not do anything later on in the relationship that Seth did not want to have happen. Anything. Physical evidence would also be key to the prosecution's case.

37:36Troy Roberts: The underwear and the gloves, Kat says, Seth wore while strangling Lizzie Marion. And this was another item that you threw away in the dumpster behind Mill Street? Yes. And these are the items, the gloves that the defendant wore when he strangled Lizzie to death? Yes. Test results found Lizzie and Mazzalia's DNA on the underwear, which prosecutors say supports Kat's story of rape. But the defense contends the DNA proves nothing. The physical evidence shows what? Sex. Kat was on the stand for 10 days, but Seth Mazzalia did not testify. The jury will have to make the choice. Trust Kat, an admitted liar, or the silent Seth Mazzalia.

38:30A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online. It's the difference between giving away those cookies you just made for free and running your cookie empire. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between having a movie reviewing hobby and a movie reviewing career. Squarespace. Because no matter what you're into, a website makes it real. Use offer code DIFFERENCE for 50 % off select plans. Terms and conditions apply. A lot has changed since Bob's Discount Furniture opened its first store in 1991.

39:04But not the way they do business, a.k.a. the Bob's way. 35 years later, Bob's still carries today's latest trends at 90s-era prices. Like the Aspen Sofa for just$3.99 with over 2 ,000 five-star reviews. Plus, it comes in two sizes and is the same price no matter which you choose. So everyone gets a seat no matter how big your 90s grunge band is. So stop in and celebrate 35 years of top-rated styles only at Bob's Discount Furniture.

39:38All rise for the Honorable Court. Do you swear or affirm that the...

39:42Troy Roberts: 33 witnesses, five grueling weeks, and Lizzie Marriott's murder trial is finally drawing to a close. For Lizzie's parents, listening to the evidence has been unbearable. We were shell-shocked during the trial. Lizzie died twice a day every day. It was awful. In closing arguments, the defense argues Kat can't be trusted. What we have is Kat McDonough being the manipulator of facts lying to you from that witness stand. But Prosecutor Jeffrey Ward reminds the jury that Kat is not on trial. Seth Mazzella is. Send him the message that you've seen through the lies and know the truth about him, that he is a cold-blooded killer.

40:29Jurors, the case is yours to deliberate and decide.

40:34Troy Roberts: The first afternoon ends with no decision. By noon on the second day, a verdict. May be seated. Has the jury reached unanimous verdicts? Yes. I have never been that nervous in my life. Members of the jury will take your verdicts, Madam Clerk. We're all sitting on pins and needles. Jury's verdicts as follows on purposeful first-degree murder by strangulation. Guilty. Guilty. Mr. Mazzele, you are remanded into custody, sir. Guilty of first-degree murder by strangulation. Guilty of first-degree rape and murder. Guilty on two counts of conspiracy. Lizzie's father, who had not spoken publicly until now, breaks his silence.

41:24We are very grateful that the jury returned a guilty verdict for first-degree murder. The truth of what happened to Lizzie is horrendous. And every time it has been told, it has reinforced the despair that we feel.

41:47Troy Roberts: The Marriott's believe Lizzie's murder was the result of an abusive relationship that spiraled out of control. I don't think that Kat McDonough, in the absence of Seth Mazzalio, would have done the things that she did. And incredibly, Lizzie's parents say they have sympathy for Kat. You know, she was 19 and very young, and I think she felt like she had no place else to go. But the Marriott's main interest was making sure Lizzie's killer was held responsible. Seven weeks after the guilty verdict, Mazzalia is back in court for sentencing. You were the one who took her life from her and from us. You're a twisted individual who brought only darkness and pain in this world.

42:34Troy Roberts: At the hearing, Lizzie's family has the opportunity to speak. Mr. Mazzalia, I'm Melissa Marriott. I'm Lizzie's mother. I mislead every day. I wake up in the morning and she's gone. I go to bed at night and she's still gone. and all because a cowardly 30-year-old man could not deal with a confident young woman. Lizzie is gone. I still find that hard to comprehend. You murdered her over a year and a half ago and every day I wonder what you would have been doing. I call this dad's exhibit one. Look close and you can see a frog gently cupped in her hands. Why is Lizzie so happy? She is saving that frog.

43:23May I?

43:36Thank you. Attorney Davis, does he wish to speak? This is his opportunity.

43:40Troy Roberts: Remarkably, Seth Mazalia now has something to say. I did not rape and murder Elizabeth Marriott. I did play a part in covering up her death. For that, I am truly sorry. Judge Horan is unmoved. On charge ID 779, first-degree murder, you are sentenced to the New Hampshire State Prison for life and shall not be eligible for parole. Mazalia is led away to spend the rest of his life in prison.

44:13Troy Roberts: It's been two years since her daughter's murder, and Lizzie's mother is still not able to visit the place Lizzie loved so much. The ocean. I haven't been to the beach since she died. I can't go. I just see it and it's so overwhelming. With Lizzie's body lost to the sea, there is no grave. Her parents have created this simple memorial for her by a lake in the Massachusetts woods, where Lizzie's spirit can be free.

44:51Kat McDonough was released from prison in 2016.

45:00Lauren Malloy spent 30 years believing her mother died of natural causes. That's what everyone told her. That's what she believed. Until one day, she got a phone call that changed everything. A woman claiming to be her mom's best friend told Lauren that her mother was murdered and that no one had ever investigated it. So she did what the detectives wouldn't. She pulled the threads, knocked on doors, and confronted the contradictions. And what she found? It's worse than she imagined. Something happened to Lori Molloy. Someone killed her. And Lauren won't stop until she finds out who. The system may have given up on her mom, but family never will.

45:44Listen to My Mom's Murder wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all 10 episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts. Upgrade to a high-efficiency furnace just in time for winter. Right now at Four Seasons, replace your old furnace and AC and get up to$5 ,000 in rebates on a qualifying HVAC system. Plus, pay zero down and 0 % interest for 72 months. For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-FOURSEASONS. For the approved credit, rebates vary by system.

46:26Ends November 15th. Details at FourSeasonsHeatingCooling.com slash details.

From the publisher

In 2012, Lizzi Marriott was a 19-year-old New Hampshire student when she disappeared after visiting her co-worker, Kat McDonough, and Kat's boyfriend, Seth Mazzaglia, in their apartment. Kat initially claimed Lizzi's death was accidental, but later testified that Seth strangled Lizzi with a rope after she rejected his sexual advances. "48 Hours" correspondent Troy Roberts reports.

This classic "48 Hours" episode last aired on 9/19/2015. Watch all-new episodes of “48 Hours” on Saturdays and stream on demand on Paramount+.

More from 48 Hours

All episodes