1. Podcasts
  2. 48 Hours
  3. Ghosts of Mississippi
48 Hours

29 Oct 2026 · 38m · 18 chapters

In short

“Ghosts of Mississippi” follows the Columbus, Mississippi investigation into five elderly murders (1996–1998) and the town’s later FBI probe into police corruption that derailed the case.

Guest backgrounds

The transcript names no podcast guests; it includes interviewees and officials (e.g., police chief Donnie Freshour; prosecutor Dennis Harmon; profiler Cecil Wingo; serial-killer expert John Kelly; victims’ relatives like Grady Randall; salon owner Trish Shepard and artist Jane Harmon).

Key claims

Police suspected a serial killer who strangled and hogtied victims, turned on gas in their kitchens, and may have taunted investigators. Investigators later blamed botched early crime-scene work and limited resources. The FBI later found Freshour embezzled Crime Stoppers funds to pay a mistress, leading to his guilty plea and prison time.

Notable examples

Victims include Mac Fowler (stabbed), Lauren Wilbanks (strangled/stabbed 30+ times), Robert Hanna (beaten/strangled; house set on fire), Louise Randall (strangled; hogtied; gas turned on), and Betty Everett (strangled; hogtied; gas turned on).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:17

Southern Hospitality and Local Legends

Discover the eerie tales and ghost stories of Columbus, Mississippi.

“I think I'm fortunate to have grown up here just because of how nice everybody is.”
4:20

Unsolved Murders in Columbus

Exploring the alarming series of unsolved murders in a small town.

“I am just outraged that this could happen.”
6:40

Community Reactions and Fear

The impact of the murders on the local community and their responses.

“We're talking about the murders this morning.”
8:00

Police Investigation and Theories

Insights into the police investigation and theories about the killer.

“The pressure is on this man to solve these crimes.”
10:00

Profiling the Suspect

Understanding the profile of the potential serial killer and their motives.

“I think it's the person that's raised here.”
14:00

Analyzing the Murders

Explore the insights of serial killer profilers on murder cases.

“The police are upping the ante on the reward.”
18:08

A Town's Dark Secrets

Discussion on unresolved murder cases and unusual suicides in Columbus.

“There are a lot of very interesting suicides in this town.”
19:30

Murder and Controversy

The community's struggle with unresolved murders and their implications.

“It ain't something that started yesterday in this town.”
24:42

Police Chief's Scandal

Investigation into the police chief and its impact on the community.

“but there are some things you can't get away with.”
28:00

Embezzlement and Legal Consequences

Learn about the embezzlement case involving former police chief Donnie Freshour and the impact on the community.

“I was not under the impression at first that it was being illegally given to me, so to speak.”
Show all 18 chapters
29:48

The Ongoing Murder Investigation

Explore the ongoing investigation into a series of unsolved murders and community reactions.

“I got what I deserved to a certain degree.”
32:38

Community Concerns Over Unsolved Murders

Hear the frustrations of community members regarding the lack of progress on murder cases.

“Queen of the Rednecks for one more night.”
34:21

Leadership Changes in the Police Department

Discuss the changes in police leadership and their approach to solving the murders.

“But even Chief Freshour admits this investigation had problems from the start.”
36:22

New Theories on the Murder Cases

Examine the new theories proposed by the police regarding the connections between murders.

“and puts a patrol lieutenant in charge of the murder investigation.”
37:15

Grady Randall Under Scrutiny

Explore the investigation into Grady Randall, son of one of the victims, and the implications.

“The other three murders we tend to feel that were individuals.”
40:48

Reflections on the Past and Future

Reflect on the unresolved murders and the community's hope for justice.

“If there wasn't such thing as a ghost, I would think that you would find him here.”
42:00

Unresolved Murders and Community Concerns

Explore the ongoing investigation into serial killings and the impact on the community.

“The big story is the election of a new mayor, who says he'll make the stalled murder investigation a priority.”
43:01

Personal Stories of Fear and Vigilance

Hear personal accounts of how residents cope with fear and the threat of unresolved crimes.

“Does it bother anybody knowing that a killer or some killers could still be loose around here?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 48 Hours, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00A trucker merges onto the I-10 in New Orleans. He checks his mirrors. The lane is clear. And then, boom, impact. A pickup truck, seemingly out of nowhere, scrapes down the side of his 18-wheeler. Multiple passengers inside. One man flees the scene. And the driver of the pickup, he doesn't seem all that upset. It didn't feel like a regular accident. Because it wasn't. Across the city, truckers were getting sideswiped. all on the same stretch of the same freeway. And behind most of the cases was one personal injury lawyer, a Hollywood stuntwoman turned attorney named Vanessa Mota. This podcast is a story about fake accidents that led to real consequences and a scheme that ends in betrayal and murder.

0:51Listen to Over My Dead Body, Operation Sideswipe, wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Ever find yourself standing in front of your closet having a full-blown style spiral? You know the feeling. Staring at a rack of clothes wondering if wide-leg jeans are actually worth the hype. Whether an outfit is truly work-appropriate or why finding a pair of pants that fits properly feels like a full-time job. You do not have to navigate it alone anymore because Maurice's is essentially that stylish friend in your group chat who always knows what looks good on you.

1:34Way back in 1931, their founder chose to focus on real women living real lives rather than chasing fashion trends. And that care still shines through today. Whether you're running out the door for coffee, handling school pickup, or getting dressed for a Saturday night wedding, Maurice's delivers versatile, approachable style and inclusive sizing that fits you perfectly every single time. Plus, with over 800 stores nationwide and an incredible website, you can pop into any store for free, personalized fit advice and outfit inspiration from their in-store stylist without needing an appointment. Next time you need a second opinion, head to Maurice's and walk out feeling effortless, comfortable and completely confident.

2:16Use code 48HRS for an extra 10 % off your total purchase at maurices.com.

2:32We're in a little bitty town. Good morning, Saints. Good morning, Centers. I think I'm fortunate to have grown up here just because of how nice everybody is.

2:55And what you hear about southern hospitality is true, you know, it's still here, but... It's a nice place to live. There are a lot of nice people, but there are a lot of strange things that happen. The graveyard, Friendship Cemetery, is supposed to have a ghost.

3:12Harold Dow: Columbus, Mississippi is a town with a lot of ghosts. It's a lady in a poop skirt that walks around weeping. Some would even say an evil spirit hovers over the town. Seems like most of the ghosts around here are sad.

3:31Harold Dow: From the Civil War graveyard to the mansions and Main Street, it seems these days the dead are suddenly everywhere. Hello, you have reached the Columbus Lounge Homicide Task Force hotline. If you have any information regarding the homicide investigations, please leave a message after the beat. Good evening, everyone, and thanks for joining us tonight. For the third time in five weeks, another elderly Columbus woman found dead in her homes. It's our big story tonight. In this town of just 30 ,000, the most recent victim, 67-year-old Betty Everett, a town known as a nice place to retire. It's a place where you wouldn't think something like this would occur.

4:13Harold Dow: Since 1996, there have been five unsolved murders. Unthinkable. Four of the five were strangled. I am just outraged that this could happen. All were elderly victims who lived within a mile of each other. And when I looked in, she was laying right there by the bed. There were no signs of forced entry. There was no apparent motive. This is somebody that's sick. I mean, that's somebody that's cold and heartless. Police fear that this might be the work of a serial killer. Not knowing who they're going to get next and where they're going to come from is what scares the people. May, oh, Father, through your love and your grace, that fear would be removed and we could soon find our father those who have done the dastardly thing of murder within our community.

5:01I'm going to use some country boy logic here. Once you get a dog starting killing, eating chickens, you don't stop. There ain't been a reason for any of them to die the death they've died.

5:11Harold Dow: The hot topic at Trish Shepard's beauty shop lately, the murders. Because I do a lot of cops hair. I do a lot of the attorneys and their wives. Trish and her friends, Jane Harmon and Sammy Austin, knew almost all of the victims. The one was a hairdresser that worked as a volunteer, basically, at a nursing home. 68-year-old Betty Everett, a hairdresser. The other little lady was just a waitress. Louise Randall, frail but feisty, living alone. She was rowdy and fun. I mean, she was. She was rowdy. She'd tell you off if you told her she wasn't waiting your table right. She knew who came in because she had to unlock the latch on her door.

5:56And she would not unlock it unless she knew who was out there.

5:59Harold Dow: And then there was Lauren Wilbanks, 75, a decorator. That really upset me because he was a good person, and it was just a murder. They didn't take his diamonds. They didn't take any money from him. They just killed him. These are old people. They didn't do anything. They weren't a threat. There's a thread there somewhere. Also murdered, Robert Hanna, 61, a retired cafeteria worker, and 78-year-old Mac Fowler, a retired farmer who lived alone. Five unsolved murders, that's a lot. Wouldn't you agree? Yep. I bet there's more unsolved murders than that.

6:37FM 103.9 WACR. We're talking about the murders this morning. Let's go to our phone lines. This is Jean. Jean from Columbus, am I correct? Yes. Do you think anything like this would happen in the area of Columbus? Oh, absolutely not. When I was growing up, we never locked our doors. Our windows were open. I never thought a thing about it. This finger, put it down straight.

6:58Harold Dow: Ellen Smith is an unlikely marksman. Well, I think we're all a little nervous. Okay. How's that feel? Does it feel pretty good? Yeah. All of us over 60 anyway. Ellen lived near the two most recent victims. Don't they go out and leave my house unlocked unless I'm going to be right inside of that door? She's determined not to let anyone get the jump on her. Well, I think I told a policeman that I would be tempted to shoot at somebody's legs if they came in. And they said, don't shoot at the legs, shoot the kill. Take your hand down. Take your thumb off the hammer. It's okay. Just take your time.

7:39Missed it completely after all that work.

7:46This crime has really caused folks to think about walking like they used to. They're looking over their shoulder, which is real sad because one or two individuals has caused this whole town to change their lifestyle and that's not right.

8:02Harold Dow: The pressure is on this man to solve these crimes. Chief Donald Freshow. It's weighing on us, it sure is. You losing sleep? Sure, sure. I was up last night cruising the road, talking to people. You took around Lee Park near the auxiliary hut. What do we have? When we come back, the Columbus police hunt for a serial killer in their midst. I think it's somebody from in town. I think it's the person that was raised here. He does all the right things with all the right people. That's next. We can solve it. Why do you say you can solve it? Well, we could, but now whether or not we'd live to tell it is another story.

8:42There is a feeling like this is supposed to be Mayberry, a pretty little historic town where everything looks nice, but...

8:52Harold Dow: It's 6.30 in the evening and time to pay a visit to another sleepy southern town. They want to show them the Mayberry image. They ain't going to show them no murders. You got a prisoner? Yeah, I got four. Oh, I wish I could have been there. I wish I'd have had a crack at these babies. Lock them up, Barney. Everything always works out in Mayberry. Unfortunately, real life isn't as tidy. We got plenty of Barneys running around in Aunt Bea's, but no Sheriff Taylor. The police in Columbus, Mississippi are facing a killer. Five elderly people are dead. Hidden ring, 7 o 'clock. And the town has been turned upside down.

9:33Harold Dow: Dead eggs.

9:37I carry me a gun in my house all the time and carry me a hammer when I go outside to my car.

9:46Like me, I just carry my little 9mm and let him come back in my house. I'll take my amendment rights and just keep on going. Lacey! What are we going to do? Change your polish?

9:57Harold Dow: At Trish Shepherd's salon, there are rumors. I like that rat on you. I think it's somebody from in town. I think it's the person that's raised here. That's a pretty color red for you. That goes to church here. He does all the right things with all the right people. You don't really want to go poking your nose around. Her friends Jane Harmon and Sammy Austin are trading secrets. Some things seem to happen here that don't happen anywhere else. About the dark side of their sunny hometown. We hear things. I mean, everybody does. They're sisters, both artists, with a studio just above the police station.

10:31These things have been going on so long and nothing's been solved and maybe you think maybe there's someone who doesn't want anything to be solved.

10:39Harold Dow: Jane is married to Dennis Harmon, the Columbus prosecutor. There's no motive for this. There's no rhyme or reason for this. And if you don't know who to look for any rhyme or reason, it's much, much harder to find out who did it. At first, the killing seemed random. They began with Mac Fowler, the retired farmer. In July 1996, he was found stabbed in his home. Then, 16 months later, an acquaintance of Fowler's was murdered. Lauren Wilbanks, the decorator, was strangled and stabbed more than 30 times after a bloody struggle in his kitchen. I just hope there's not any more, because I know all the little old people are scared.

11:21Harold Dow: The cases attracted little attention at first, but then in the fall of 1998, there were three killings in five weeks. On November 13th, Robert Hanna was beaten and strangled to death. The gas in his kitchen was turned on and his house set afire. Police believed he'd been hogtied. Just one week later, Louise Randall was strangled and also hogtied. The gas in her kitchen was turned on too. This person's not going to stop. He's getting better or cleaner on his murders. One month later, the killer seemed to be mocking the town. The day before, we had a meeting in town, a public meeting, to let the public come in and voice their concerns and things.

12:06The next night, another body's found.

12:07Harold Dow: That was victim number five, Betty Everett. Local TV reporter Don Culpepper covered the murders. Police chief, the first thing he said to me that day is, we're being taunted, aren't we? And I thought, you know, you could be right. That shows that either it's a devil of a coincidence or this person's out there watching TV and kind of saying I'm one step ahead of the law enforcement. Betty Everett's crime scene was the most startling of all. She was found strangled and hogtied, exactly like Louise Randall. The gas was turned on in her home as well. These crimes that were committed, you have to have a taste for.

12:46Harold Dow: Since then, the focus has been on a potential serial killer. You're getting some kind of thrill out of killing these elderly people. Are you saying the motive is for some kind of thrill seeker? Yes. Police Chief Donnie Freshour is trying to figure out who would commit such crimes and why. First off, it's going to look like me or you. You know, we're not looking at a man with a mask and a hood sneaking around houses. What do we have? This individual could be professional. 1028, J1. Detective Selvane McQueen is tracking down every lead. You know, clean cut, driving a Jaguar or a Mercedes or a Corvette, you know, we really don't know.

13:30What y 'all doing? Just hanging out? Yeah.

13:32Harold Dow: And he's talking to everyone. Mr. Knight, Sergeant McQueen, how are you doing? You'll just take a look at these. Detective Gary Moore is feeling pretty overwhelmed. We've still got hundreds of leads and we're still trying to run down. Okay, that's who I was thinking. That's him. I got a call yesterday telling me about a man that has been abusing his elderly mother, who lives not just a few blocks from the last victim. The police are upping the ante on the reward. I don't know if you've got your hands on those. And they're bringing in two serial killer experts, John Kelly from New Jersey and Cecil Wingo from Texas.

14:12The big job here that I do is listening. listening to the officers talking to me or listening to what they've written down.

14:22Harold Dow: Wingo is a profiler. He's analyzing the murders and will issue a report that the police hope will direct them to the killer. The body has so many things to say, even its position. An autopsy could even tell me whether or not the killer was right or left-handed. Who will fit the profile? There was absolutely no reason for this person to kill my mother. Somebody else would like to know what Wingo will come up with. When she went to bed at night, this security door is always locked. And then she would shut this door, lock this. Grady Randall is the son of the fourth victim, Louise Randall, the retired waitress.

15:04She had just turned 80 years old. I can't imagine anybody wanting to harm someone like herself.

15:09Harold Dow: He was three hours away in Tennessee when he got the call. I started knocking on the door and there was no answer. Nancy Tate, a neighbor, had found his mother's body. Lines was closed. She usually opened them in the daytime. I started hitting on the windows. She was coming by to help Louise get to the doctor that morning. The screen door just opened. Okay, but it's normally locked, right? It's normally locked. Okay. What was the first thing you saw that told you something was wrong? The drawers were pulled out. The drawers were pulled out? You could tell these desk drawers right here had been gone through, and they had come in here and gone through my pack.

15:48Harold Dow: The killer left Randall's hunting gear carefully laid out on the bed. There is a possibility, due to how things were arranged, that person could have possibly been here when Nancy knocked on the door. This door was closed. As long as I've been coming to this house, I had never seen this door closed before. So I opened it and when I looked in, she was laying right there by the bed. Face down, with hands tied behind her, with an electrical cord which ran down her back and wrapped around her legs. I just kept saying, this is not happening. This is not happening. And you know, I can just visualize her lying there.

16:30I can't get it out of my mind. The police said that the only reason he killed her was simply because she knew who it was. Whoever did it knew what they were doing because the knots were just, that stays in my mind. It was just perfect.

16:47Harold Dow: You think you'll strike again, Grady? I couldn't imagine ever doing something like this, but I would think if I got away with it once, I'd be scared halfway to death to try to do it again. if I was stupid enough to do something like that, I know the fear of God would be placed in me with y 'all being here.

17:10Harold Dow: This is from Dr. Wingo, both of them. Back at the police station, the profiler's report has just come in. Let me see. It tells police to look for a methodical, organized person who can kill and leave no trace. He's saying that the guy's going to reside somewhere in this area. The killer must fit into the community because the victims have all let the murderer enter their homes. But the report doesn't give police a prime suspect. This is typical of a white male. And then a paragraph later, they say, don't exclude a black male. I don't think it's going to solve the case. Would you rather just get lucky?

17:51Oh, I'll take luck over skill anytime. Yes, sir.

17:55Harold Dow: The fact is, the Columbus Police Department hasn't had much luck when it comes to solving murder cases. I just think it is super weird that you don't solve a murder. Bizarre deaths have gone unsolved here for years. There are a lot of very interesting suicides in this town. Coming up... We see a lot of those. Getting away with murder in Columbus, Mississippi. There was a gentleman that committed suicide by table saw. That's creepy.

18:30You know that thing where you get an amazing pair of shoes at a really great price and want to tell everyone about it? Yeah, so do we. Here at Designer Shoe Warehouse, we'll give you something to brag about. Like the latest styles from brands you love. Or the trends everyone's obsessing over. Or shoes that make you feel like, well, you. So go ahead, show off a little. Find shoes that get you at prices that get your budget. Head to your DSW store or DSW.com today. DSW, let us surprise you. I'm pretty confident talking into a mic. Hey, I'm doing it right now. But home projects, I second guess everything.

19:09Is that noise normal? Is that water damage? Who do I even call? That's where Thumbtack comes in. Just upload a photo or voice note and it uses AI-powered search to match you with a right top-rated local pro. So instead of guessing, you get clarity and can hire with confidence. For your next home project, try Thumbtack. Hire the right pro today.

19:49It ain't something that started yesterday in this town. There's been murders going on for 20-something years that ain't none of them ever been solved.

19:57Harold Dow: Trish Shepard, the hairdresser, and her friend Jane Harmon, the artist, have been keeping tabs on the dead in Columbus, Mississippi. You'll see in the paper body found, exlocation, autopsy to be done, and you don't see anything else about it. We see a lot of those. Unidentified body found. That's creepy. The serial murders remain unsolved. Louise Randall, Betty Everett, Lauren Wilbanks, Robert Hanna, and Mac Fowler, all were killed in their homes. I don't think it's a serial killer. I don't really think it's that simple. It's never that simple here. Even City Prosecutor Dennis Harmon, Jane's husband, is not surprised that the police here are having a hard time cracking the five cases.

20:46Mercifully, we have no experience with a serial killer.

20:50Harold Dow: Harmon's relatively new to the job, but he can tell you Columbus has a long history of mysterious deaths that just don't add up. There are a lot of very interesting suicides in this town. Well, that's a good lead. There was one young man, there was a hole in the back of his head when they found him in water. The hole was ruled a crawfish hole and that somehow was a suicide in the water. Crawfish hole? Crawfish hole. Harmon wonders if some of the bodies that turn up around here in odd circumstances might in fact be victims of foul play. There was a gentleman that was ruled suicide by table saw.

21:26By table saw? Yeah, that he took a table saw and cut his hand off and then bled to death. But you've got to be kidding. No. I mean, I love the town other than the fact that there are crimes committed in a town this small, and then nobody can get to the bottom of it.

21:40Harold Dow: There are more murders per capita in Columbus, Mississippi, than there are in New York City, twice as many. In fact, while the police have been investigating the five serial killings, the murder of another woman has caused controversy in town. Her case was supposedly solved, but a lot of people think somebody got away with murder. Liz Dill vanished back in 1996. How old was she? About 30, 70. Yeah. 30-year-old woman. She had a child. She was at home, alone, and supposedly when her husband came home, she was not there. Dill's body was discovered three days after she disappeared. Two guys found her in a field nude.

22:24She was field dressed.

22:25Harold Dow: Now you say field dressed. For the folks in the city, what does that mean? I deer hunt. When you kill a deer, you take the deer's back legs and they'll tie a rope around there and they hang them like this. I wanted someone to pick this woman, go into her house, take her out of her house in the middle of the night, and kill her, and skin her, and rape her. Reporter Don Culpepper covered the case for TV station WCBI. Yeah, it stunned people. It should stun people in any city, but in a small town like this, yeah, that's a big, big thing. I mean, it was a Perry Mason episode. Everybody at the time was griping about the murders not being solved, so they jumped on this one and got them two people and made it look like that that was the end of the story.

23:08Harold Dow: Two men were arrested and convicted of the rape and murder of Liz Dill, but suspicions remained about who masterminded the crime. In two murder trials, one of the number one suspects was her husband. Had nothing to do with it. Never would. I wished it had been me. Would swap right now. Everybody thinks that the husband done it. According to court records, Brian Dill was seen with the killers on the night of the murder, But the two men convicted of the crime never implicated Dill in the killing. And the district attorney says there just wasn't enough evidence to make a case. Brian Dill is not under arrest.

23:46Brian Dill's a free man and never has been charged with a crime.

23:49Harold Dow: But when Brian Dill went to court to try to collect his wife's life insurance money, more than$200 ,000, the judge denied him the money saying, and I quote, Brian Ellis Dill caused the willful and intentional death of his wife. I mean, that was a stunning thing to have on a piece of paper from a judge to say, I'm not giving this man insurance money because I believe he was involved in his wife's murder.

24:18This is not the kind of town things like this are supposed to happen in. You know, I mean, five unsolved murders and possibility of men having their wives kidnapped and killed, tortured, raped, no one being arrested for any of these crimes.

24:33Harold Dow: So in a town like this, you can get away with murder? Pretty much, depending on who you are. A lot of people may think you can get away with murder in Columbus, but there are some things you can't get away with. Good evening. Tonight, an FBI investigation of the Columbus Police Department and its chief continues. What happened to Chief Donnie Freshour? He just got caught playing with the kitty. A bombshell drops on the police chief and the serial killer investigation. That's next.

25:29With five unsolved murders haunting their town, the police in Columbus, Mississippi already have their hands full. They still can't say for sure if they're dealing with a serial killer or cruel coincidence. They've made no arrests and there's little visible progress in the investigation, leading some people to wonder if the finest in small-town Columbus are up to the job. As Harold Dow picks up the story, an already complicated case is becoming even more muddled. And wait till you see who turns up on the wrong side of the tracks. All right, here we go from the National Weather Service. A picture-perfect day in Columbus, Mississippi.

26:14All right, let's go!

26:15Harold Dow: It would have been a perfect evening in Columbus, Mississippi. Police Chief Donnie Freshour's church softball team is about to come from behind to win a hard-fought game.

26:28Are they hot or are they hot? Thank you.

26:31Harold Dow: But Chief Freshour has hit a foul ball and he's under investigation. Some officers at the Columbus Police Department are under a cloud of suspicion. By the FBI. Files, records and Chief Freshour's computer hard drive have been seized by investigators. You know, like a kid. I don't mind getting accused of what I've done, but don't accuse me of what I didn't do. It's been seven months since the last murder here in Columbus, Mississippi. No killers have been caught. In fact, the only arrest that has made headlines here is, get this, the arrest of the police chief. Dead Freshour illegally funnel Crime Stopper tip money and possibly...

27:08...name Amy Morgan-Nabry. This will be a major shakeup.

27:11Harold Dow: Lies. Chief Donnie Freshour, what happened? You can have that one. He just got caught playing with the kitty. Okay.

27:35I feel that my civil rights were violated by the chief of police.

27:40Harold Dow: Amy Neighbors, mother of three, alleges she had a sexual relationship with Chief Freshour. He wanted me to have sex with him, wanted me to be his kept woman, whatever you want to say. And that he paid her with private funds donated to solving the five murders and other crimes. He gave me Crime Stopper money. I was not under the impression at first that it was being illegally given to me, so to speak. He claimed he was trying to help me out. Did he actually just put the money in your hand? A few times he did actually give me cash money, but other times he gave me a code, and he told me to go to the bank and give them the code and they would give me money.

28:21The federal crime was to embezzle that money.

28:25Harold Dow: Prosecutor Dennis Harmon was involved with the FBI investigation. Crime Stopper is a local organization. We collect money for tips for confidential sources, and he was rigging it so that it appeared that confidential sources were getting money from Crime Stoppers, when in fact it was a girlfriend. Did it happen more than once? Yes, sir. About three times. Three or four times. Was he in uniform? Did he have a police car? He did, uh... He did, uh... Yes, he did. We did ride in his police car. His official police car. She's well-known to the police. She's got several minor charges against her shopliftings, embezzlement, that sort of thing.

29:09Harold Dow: Pressured by the FBI, Amy Neighbors wore a wire. Facing that evidence, Freshour pled guilty to conspiracy and embezzlement. Does it look like he'll be doing time? My bet is, yeah. Former Columbus Police Chief Donald Freshour was sentenced to eight months in prison following his admission to embezzling funds from Crimestoppers. I'm totally behind my husband, my family's behind him, and our church is behind him. All of us knew Donnie. We were stunned and surprised and disgusted at what happened. I'll say I'm sorry until I'm going to give out. That's all I can do. I got what I deserved to a certain degree.

29:53Tell us what happened. What went wrong? Even though I had the stars on my shoulder of the chief of police, I'm still human. And I screwed up.

30:02Harold Dow: With Donnie Freshour gone, the murder investigation is back to square one. Five elderly people are dead, and their killer is still on the loose. If they really got the right person, I think it would just shock the town after that. But the police are about to pursue some unusual leads, and no one is above suspicion. That's next.

30:33True crime is full of unanswered questions, but earning your degree doesn't have to be a mystery. That's where Southern New Hampshire University comes in. SNHU offers more than 200 online degree programs with flexibility that puts you in the driver's seat and trusted support to keep you on track, even when life takes an unexpected turn. Find the answers you're searching for at snhu.edu slash 48 hours. Do you ever wish you could ask nosy questions about people's money? I have$729.71 in my bank account. We bought a$1.3 million house on a$350 ,000 income. On the podcast, What We Spend, we ask those questions.

31:17It's a show about money and all the feelings that come with spending it. I want to be the kind of person who can just take care of the people in my life. Listen to What We Spend, an Odyssey original, available now wherever you get your podcasts. A lot has changed since Bob's Discount Furniture opened its first store 35 years ago. Car phones have become cell phones, grunge band hits have become oldies, and you can order furniture online. But what hasn't changed is the way they do business, aka the Bob's way. Doing things the Bob's way means that when I shop at Bob's, I know I'll find the latest top-rated styles like the Aspen sofa for just$3.99, bedrooms with great features like storage and charging, consumer reports recommended mattresses, and real marble dining sets, all at 90s-era prices, with financing to fit any budget and lightning-fast shipping.

32:10Plus, Bob's still makes furniture shopping fun, with friendly associates and cafes full of free treats and ice cream. Want a seat for yourself? Stop into your local Bob's store or shopmybobs.com to celebrate 35 years of the best values in the furniture biz. only at Bob's Discount Furniture.

32:37I gotta get ready.

32:39Harold Dow: Trish Shepard is in a hurry. Where do we put that dress? Tonight will be a big night. This is my dress. Queen of the Rednecks for one more night. She's getting dolled up. We do this once a year. For a gathering, Mississippi style, of the fast and the powerful. I guess we're ready. Dirt Track Racing.

33:09I pass out the trophies here tonight.

33:20Harold Dow: But it seems like there is no finish line in sight for the five murder cases. I still just don't understand why they hadn't been solved. And there have been no arrests. It doesn't seem to the public eye that there's any effort being put into it. The race to catch the serial killer has spun out of control. In other cities, you pick the city, New York, Chicago, when there are five murders and law enforcement officials think it's a serial killer out there, you actually can see law enforcement shaking the bushes. I'd be scared of the body that would fall out of the bush around here. Trish Shepard, for one, blames the police department.

34:01We've got a corrupt police department, and you can't solve a murder if the department don't get straight.

34:07Harold Dow: We're all human. One person who won't solve the crime is former police chief Donnie Freshour. He's serving time in federal prison for embezzling Crimestoppers' money to give to his mistress. Not the murders, but the police chief's going to jail now. But even Chief Freshour admits this investigation had problems from the start. Do you think mistakes were made? Sure. A policeman is human. If you're human, you're going to make errors. Maybe we approached it with the idea that this is going to be another one of those. We get out, we get some leads, we run it down, and they'll be done by lunch. Freshour admits the crime scenes were trampled and tainted.

34:47If we were a little bit more careful at the crime scene, we possibly could have gleamed a little more evidence. Would you say the investigation was botched? Enough wasn't done early enough.

34:59Harold Dow: As city prosecutor, Dennis Harmon saw what was going on. Botched covers a multitude of evils. Specifically, there were not enough people out there. That was the biggest problem. Overtime was being limited. The number of detectives was being limited. Big city problems with the small town resources. What went wrong? We have a very good criminal out there for covering his tracks. The fact that the murders haven't been solved, who do you blame for that? Columbus Mayor George Wade is on the hot seat. It's difficult to blame any one single person or department. I think we all have to share that responsibility, and that's what we're doing.

35:42Harold Dow: But somebody's getting away with murder here. Oh, yes, but we haven't given up either.

35:51Harold Dow: So now there's a new chief to reckon with. The investigation's still ongoing. People are working on it around the clock. Billy Pickens was promoted to try to clean up the department. We did talk to a number of people in the community, and a number of them had told us that they had lost confidence in the police department. What's your response to that? hopefully that we can get back with the public, have it as much confidence in us as they once did. Chief Pickens thinks big changes are in order. He reassigns the chief homicide detective and puts a patrol lieutenant in charge of the murder investigation.

36:29Harold Dow: But folks aren't so sure that's going to help matters. Regular patrol people put in detective positions. What do you make of that? I don't understand that. There's a difference between a patrolman and a detective, I would think. We're still following up all leads, new leads and old leads. And the new chief has a new theory on how the murders are connected. We don't have a serial killer that's mad running around in Columbus. Chief Pickens believes only two of the five crime scenes are identical. So instead of just one killer, there are several. We have five murders, and at the present, time I feel like there's only two that's actually connected.

37:11Then the others would be the two ladies, Mrs. Everett and Mrs. Randall. The other three murders we tend to feel that were individuals. We do have a couple of suspects.

37:23Harold Dow: One person the police are looking at is Grady Randall. Remember him son of Louise Randall, one of the victims. That lady loved me more than life itself. Randall says the police told him that he seems to know too many details about the crime scene. The bathroom right here is where it supposedly took place. A crime scene he says he never saw because on the night of the murder, he was traveling in Tennessee on business. She looked in here and saw my mother lying right here on the floor between the bed and cedar chest, face down with hands tied behind her with an electrical cord which ran down her back and wrapped around her legs.

38:14Harold Dow: Randall says he has been questioned several times about his mother's murder. They've come to Memphis and they've talked to me. Of course, they took fingerprints. Wait a minute. Took your fingerprints? I'm not going to say it doesn't bother me at all that I'm not offended whatsoever. It does bother me. My mother and I were very close. But at the same time, I feel like they're doing their job. If it requires investigating me, hey, let's do it. Let's get past this and get down to brass tacks. Will the police find anything in their investigation of Grady Randall? Mama was just, she was the sweetest thing.

38:55Harold Dow: Are you optimistic that you will be able to bring someone to justice here in these murders? Very optimistic. Hopefully they won't pin it on the wrong person. I'd rather it remain unsolved.

39:15Let's be honest, everyone hates fees, right? That's where Chime comes in. Chime is completely changing the way that people manage their money. Unlike traditional banks that often pile on hidden charges, Chime offers fee-free banking with no overdraft fees, no monthly maintenance fees, and no minimum balance requirements. You actually get rewarded for everyday spending, earning 5 % cash back in a category of your choice, like gas or groceries, all while building your credit without a credit check. And SpotMe has your back with up to$200 in fee-free overdraft protection when life gets expensive.

39:53Join the millions who are already banking fee-free with America's number one choice for banking. Head to chime.com slash 48 hours. That is chime.com slash 48 hours. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card provided by Chime's bank partners. Qualifying direct deposits required. Terms and limits apply. Go to chime.com slash disclosures for details.

40:18Harold Dow: A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online. It's the difference between giving away those cookies you just made for free and running your cookie empire. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between having a movie reviewing hobby and a movie reviewing career. Squarespace, because no No matter what you're into, a website makes it real. Use offer code DIFFERENCE for 50 % off select plans. Terms and conditions apply.

40:57If there wasn't such thing as a ghost, I would think that you would find him here. It's spooky.

41:07That's supposed to be where the lady with the long flowing white gown walks. One lady told me that she was looking for her child.

41:15Harold Dow: In Columbus, Mississippi's oldest cemetery, the dead are said to walk. Miss Randall's out here. I think Miss Everett is. Maybe there's more to their death than meets the eye. Columbus's elderly victims may be dead and buried, But for Louise Randall, Betty Everett, Mac Fowler, Lauren Wilbanks, and Robert Hanna, the wait for justice could be eternal. I want people to realize that they are people, not just a name on a piece of paper. When Chief Billy Pickens first took office in 1999, he made some progress. Wherever there's something that we think is a lead, we're going to go. A year after we first brought you this report...

42:01Harold Dow: Good evening, everyone. The big story is the election of a new mayor, who says he'll make the stalled murder investigation a priority. Do you think you will be able to solve any of these murders? No one can say yes or no. I would like to say yes, but I'm going to say I hope we do. Since the last of the so-called serial killings back in 1998, there have been no more murders, which match the pattern. They've talked to me. Of course, they took fingerprints. Grady Randall, the son of victim Louise Randall, has been questioned several times, but he has never been charged with anything. Police chief Billy Pickens told 48 Hours, quote, Grady Randall was offered and took a polygraph test and passed.

42:49Harold Dow: He is not being looked at at this time as a strong suspect. And the former police chief, Donnie Freshour, has done his time in federal prison. Eight months. He's now working construction. Does it bother anybody knowing that a killer or some killers could still be loose around here? Well, yes, I think it does. But you can't live in fear all your life. Ellen Smith learned how to use a gun to protect herself. I guess I would have shot it if I'd had to. I'd probably been so scared I would have shot myself in the foot. She's still not taking any chances. Now, do you still keep your gun close by? Oh, yeah.

43:29Harold Dow: Under your pillow? Yeah. You still do? Uh-huh. I don't know if they'll ever be able to find him at this late date. Do you think they will ever solve these five murders? Not unless they bring in people from outside that don't care about a name or care about old politics and old money. Because it is going to be an in-town person. It ain't going to be some vagrant walking down the street. This town is really nice, but it's kind of like, which I don't know if you northerners have this, but in the south you do have little roaches and they're impossible to get rid of. And in the daytime it's fine. And you cut the lights off.

44:10Here they go.

44:14This is like Columbus. When you're here, it's very nice. But when you cut the lights out, things creep out. In 2017, police arrested David Murray, whose DNA sample was linked to the murder of Mac Fowler. Murray was hospitalized for mental evaluation. No evidence has been found connecting him to the other murders. Upgrade to a high-efficiency furnace just in time for winter. Right now at Four Seasons, replace your old furnace and AC and get up to$5 ,000 in rebates on a qualifying HVAC system. Plus, pay zero down and 0 % interest for 72 months. For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call for all the right reasons call 866-4-SEASONS for the proof credit rebates vary by system ends november 15th details at fourseasons heating cooling.com slash details it's the middle of the night you hear a sound you freeze but the real horror isn't outside the window it's on it the terrifying truth outdated broken blinds are exposing your private life to the street.

45:24Your beautiful home has become a crime scene of zero privacy. Take back complete control of your peaceful sanctuary. Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com.

From the publisher

Between 1996 and 1998, the small town of Columbus, Mississippi faced five unsolved murders of elderly residents. The victims were killed in their homes, and similarities among the crimes led investigators to suspect a possible serial killer. As fear spread throughout the community, police faced mounting pressure to identify the perpetrator, while residents questioned whether authorities were overlooking important evidence or protecting someone within the town. "48 Hours" correspondent Harold Dow reports. This classic "48 Hours" episode last aired on 7/16/2001. Watch all-new episodes of “48 Hours” on Saturdays and stream on demand on Paramount+.

More from 48 Hours

All episodes