1. Podcasts
  2. 48 Hours
  3. Murder at Mount Hood
48 Hours

16 Nov 2026 · 41m · 14 chapters

In short

The disappearance and murder of Susan Lane Fournier (“Phoenix”) in the Mount Hood area, Oregon, and the investigation leading to her husband Michael Fournier’s conviction.

Guest backgrounds

The episode includes community members and investigators, including Clackamas County Sheriff’s Deputy Aaron Clark; detectives Jim White and Alex Monarch; and community figures such as Sarah Caswell (Phoenix’s boss/friend), Kristen Prudence (meditation/sound bath leader), Carrie Gesh (hiker who spotted Phoenix’s truck), and James Evans (formed a search party). It also features Phoenix’s sons Jesse and Dakota and Michael Fournier.

Key claims

Phoenix vanished after last being seen/texted before work; her truck was found without her or her wolf-hybrid dogs. Investigators say Michael lied about hitchhiking, disposed of the dogs, and shot Phoenix three times. His motive was tied to divorce/property loss.

Notable examples

Phoenix’s truck spotted on East Salmon River Road; surveillance at Halsey Auto Parts showing the truck with dogs then without; Phoenix’s phone recovered from the Columbia River; dogs found with zip ties near the river; autopsy showing .22-caliber shots.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:25

Community Connections and Missing Person

Discussion of the close-knit community and the concern for Phoenix's disappearance.

“I think that Mount Hood draws a certain people here.”
4:11

Investigation Begins

Details about the investigation into Phoenix's disappearance and community reaction.

“A lot of the community members up there thought we were only running a search and rescue operation.”
7:10

Phoenix's Life and Background

Exploring Phoenix's life story, background, and relationships.

“She had two adult sons, Jesse and Dakota, who she had raised in California and Kansas with her former husband, Fred.”
9:26

Phoenix's Spiritual Journey

Description of Phoenix's spiritual practices and community involvement.

“that she felt that she had built herself up from the ashes.”
10:34

Discovery of the Truck

Details surrounding the discovery of Phoenix's truck and the implications.

“The crystals and just the way that energy works.”
14:56

Search and Rescue Operations

Details of the search and rescue efforts for the missing hiker and community reactions.

“So there's concern that she may have gone up one of these more challenging trails and that she might be out there injured.”
17:55

Michael's Alibi

Michael Fournier provides a questionable alibi following his wife's disappearance.

“Investigators had tried calling Michael but got no answer.”
20:15

Community Frustration and Investigative Secrets

The community's frustration over the investigation and authorities' covert actions.

“They continued searching at Salmon River Road, and the mountain community grew more frustrated.”
22:34

Tracking Phoenix's Phone

Detectives gather evidence through cell phone tracking and video footage.

“For all the right reasons, call 866-4-SEASONS.”
25:29

Confrontation with Michael

Jesse confronts Michael Fournier about his mother's disappearance.

“Detectives now knew Michael Fournier had not told the truth about hitchhiking that day.”
Show all 14 chapters
28:00

The Search for Phoenix

Learn about the community's efforts to search for Phoenix after her disappearance.

“Jesse says it was clear he wasn't going to get any answers from Michael.”
30:53

Discovery of the Body

Details emerge about the tragic discovery of Phoenix's body and subsequent investigations.

“For all the right reasons, call 866-4-SEASONS.”
37:56

Trial and Conviction

Follow the trial of Michael Fournier and the prosecution's case against him.

“Susan Lane was requesting the property that they lived on.”
42:04

Community's Response to Justice

Learn about the community's efforts to remember Phoenix and celebrate justice.

“Michael Fournier was found guilty of second-degree murder.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 48 Hours, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00It's the middle of the night. You hear a sound. You freeze. But the real horror isn't outside the window. It's on it. The terrifying truth? Outdated broken blinds are exposing your private life to the street. Your beautiful home has become a crime scene of zero privacy. Take back complete control of your peaceful sanctuary. Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com. There are a lot of reasons Chicago homeowners have chosen Four Seasons since 1971. An A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau.

0:39That's one. Two, BBB Torch Awards for Ethics. That's another. And service around the clock every day of the year. That's a big one. For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-4SEASONS.

1:15Welch's is fairly isolated. There really is only one way in and one way out. There's Highway 26. And as you go off the road, you only have to go a few minutes before you're suddenly in the woods. You're in the deep woods. I think that Mount Hood draws a certain people here. I think a lot of the people that live here, we have that common thread of being connected to nature. The beauty of the scenery around us calls to us. This mountain community is so special. How we have each other's back, we look out for each other. November 22nd, 2024, a community member called me concerned about Phoenix. 61-year-old Susan Lane Fournier, who goes by Phoenix, was last heard from on Friday.

2:09Phoenix was like a mother figure for me. Maternal, unconditional love, just so outgoing and authentic. She wasn't afraid to be herself. I think it's safe to say she is beloved by everybody up there. How did people know she was missing? She didn't go to work, which was very unusual for her. Nobody heard from her, and nobody could get a hold of her. I put out a Facebook message, if you see her truck, let us know, trying to find out where she went. And how quickly did word spread that she was missing? Right away. It was all over the place on social media. They're looking for her dogs. She had two beloved dogs.

2:50It would never leave her side. They were very, very protective of her. If you got between her and the dogs, they could be aggressive. They always stayed in the back of her truck. The next day, her truck was spotted along the East Salmon River Road. We found it, but there's no phoenix and no dogs. Search and rescue was up there almost immediately. All of a sudden, everybody was on scene. The search and rescue operation initially focused on the immediate area around that trailhead. and then worked outward. She is a hiker. We believe that she's up here with her dogs. There were news reports saying that they were looking for a missing hiker.

3:32I never thought she was a missing hiker. Where her truck was found was absolutely not a place she would have gone. She would have never taken her dogs there. We all knew that she wasn't there. They weren't listening to us, telling them she's not up there. At what point were you starting to get worried that she was a victim of foul play? I think right away. I knew that she was stressed out, but I didn't know exactly what was going on and how scared she was. If Phoenix is afraid of something, then that says a lot. I was just hoping that she wasn't left for dead somewhere while they're looking in the wrong place.

4:13A lot of the community members up there thought we were only running a search and rescue operation. And what are you going to tell them? Hey, we're running a criminal investigation. Please don't tell the prime suspect. Sheriff's office. Anybody home?

4:32Peter Van Sant reports murder at Mount Hood.

4:39Tucked in off the road to Mount Hood, the Hoodland Plaza Shopping Center serves as a gathering place for the people of Welch's, Oregon, where they sometimes get things that money just can't buy. It's kind of a community hub. If someone needed to vent or talk or need help, that's where they'd go. The plaza is home to Sarah Caswell's Pizza Shop and the neighboring Hoodland Bazaar, the whimsical gift shop where her friend Phoenix Lane worked. November 22nd, 2024, we showed up to work and she hadn't showed up. Phoenix was supposed to open the store at 11 that Friday morning. She hadn't put the signs out yet and I was like, that's crazy.

5:24She would never not show up. Phoenix's boss tried texting her, but she didn't respond. Sarah became so concerned she did something unusual. She reached out for help. Up here we don't have a lot of law enforcement. Even if you call them and you need them it can take up to two hours because the county is so big. So a lot of the times when we have to deal with things up here we take it on as mountain justice. What the community calls mountain justice is a kind of self-reliance, lending a hand when a neighbor is in trouble. It's a very tight-knit community. They definitely tend to take care of their own problems.

6:05Sarah called Aaron Clark, a Clackamas County Sheriff's Deputy who often patrols the Mount Hood region. He wasn't working in the area that day and suggested that Phoenix's boss called the Sheriff's Office to request a welfare check. My employee did not show up to work today, you know, unexpectedly. And we were worried about her well-being. Two deputies arrived at Phoenix's home that night. The lights were on and the door was unlocked. Sheriff's office! Anybody inside? No people so far. But there was no sign of 61-year-old Phoenix or her two dogs. Elrond and Elros were wolf hybrids. You wouldn't know they were hybrids.

6:49They looked exactly like wolves. They were very, very protective of her. When Phoenix did not show up for work again on Saturday, Deputy Clark drove up to the mountain to talk to her friends and co-workers. Everybody knew Phoenix. Everybody really cared for her. Though everybody there knew her as Phoenix, for many years she went by her legal name, Susan. She had two adult sons, Jesse and Dakota, who she had raised in California and Kansas with her former husband, Fred. She loved being goofy. She loved being silly. She loved being an artist. A very distinctive memory was being in kindergarten and her rolling up to the school on a motorcycle to pick me up and all the kids on the playground being really excited.

7:37Wow, your mom rides a bike? That's awesome. Coolest mom in the world. Coolest mom ever. But sadly, their lives were upended in 2009, when Fred died in a car accident. Give me a sense of his death, the impact on the two of you. Devastating. She lost her soulmate. I don't want to say she lost her way, but she definitely struggled to realign herself. There was nothing keeping us in that area anymore, so she was looking for a way to escape with us. Several months later, Susan met Michael Fournier, a divorced French-Canadian long-haul trucker who spent a lot of time on the road. That was pretty much his life, running his truck, making a life.

8:24Susan's brother, Mike Lane, says she was struggling to raise her teenage sons alone when Michael came into her life. He sees Susan and the kids, and he goes, hey, wow, I can contribute to this. This could work. Susan got her trucking license and the two began driving as a team, trading shifts behind the wheel. A trip later in 2009 would change the course of their lives. She kind of stumbled across Mount Hood and fell in love. She's like, this is where I want to be. She bought a fixer-upper just off Highway 26, and they all moved up to the mountain. It was kind of a run-down home, but I mean, she wouldn't have wanted it any other way.

9:07I mean, that's what she really desired was simple life up in the woods. Susan and Michael married in 2012, and she later adopted her new name, Phoenix. All the trials and tribulations she had been to with her husband dying and rebuilding her life, that she felt that she had built herself up from the ashes. So she gave herself the name Phoenix. She was into meditation and energy work. Phoenix made deep connections with like-minded friends in the mountain community, including Kristen Prudence. I would lead guided meditations. Deepen and slow your breath. And we would have these beautiful, restorative women's circles.

9:53And we had Phoenix join us and do a sound bath at one of them. It's the first time I'd ever heard of it. What is a sound bath? A sound bath is where participants will relax, usually in laying down. It's channeling the vibrational frequencies of the instruments, which provide healing. In 2023, Phoenix began working at the Hoodland Bazaar, where her art adorned the walls. She sold Afghan rugs and Turkish lamps along with crystals and rocks, often dispensing her New Age wisdom. She had so much knowledge. The crystals and just the way that energy works. It was almost like the store was made for her to be there.

10:43She found herself here. She found her nirvana. But in November 2024, six days before Thanksgiving, Phoenix was now missing from that special place. Deputy Clark started a missing persons report and went to Phoenix's home himself on Saturday to look for her. Dakota, who lived there with his mother and stepfather, answered the door. Deputy Clark said, did you know that your mother's missing? Put that into words, what that was like for you.

11:16Shocking. It was blindsided. Dakota told Deputy Clark he had worked all day Friday and stayed out late in Portland an hour away. He and his mother had last texted on Friday morning and he said he didn't know people were looking for her. And Michael was still not at the house? Not at the house, no. Did Dakota know where he was? No. Shortly after leaving the property, Deputy Clark got some news. A member of the mountain community had made an unexpected discovery.

12:15control of your peaceful sanctuary. Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com. There are a lot of reasons Chicago homeowners have chosen four seasons since 1971. An A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau. That's one. Two, BBB Torch Awards for Ethics. That's another. And service around the clock every day of the year. That's a big one. For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-4-SEASONS.

13:08Back on November 23rd, 2024, a Saturday, you were out on this highway. Where were you going? I was going up Salmon River Road, was taking the dog to go for a little run out in the woods. That morning, Carrie Gesh set out on a hike, unaware that her friend Phoenix Lane had gone missing the day before. We're technically entering the National Forest here right now. While the majestic Mount Hood National Forest covers more than a million acres, for locals like Carrie, their favorite spots are as familiar as their backyard. So she couldn't help but notice something strange on her way home that day.

13:49It was right here in this pullout. A white pickup truck parked on the side of the road. The pickup truck was parked right about here. Now, there's hundreds of pickup trucks in this area. Why did this one catch your eye? You know, this is not a normal spot for someone to park that time of year. It just looked out of place. As odd as it was, Carrie didn't think much of it until she got home. and a post on Facebook caught her eye. Sarah Caswell had asked if anyone had seen Phoenix or her white Ford F-250. And that's when it clicked. I think that was her truck I saw up Salmon River Road. So I went to the pizza shop.

14:39Word got out that Phoenix's truck had been found seven miles from her home, but with no trace of her or the dogs. Deputy Clark was notified and says the truck's location suggested something could have happened to her out in the woods. So there's concern that she may have gone up one of these more challenging trails and that she might be out there injured. It was certainly possible that she was out hiking and had gotten hurt and couldn't get herself back. Within hours, a search and rescue operation was underway on Salmon River Road. Jim White and Alex Monarch are detectives with the Clackamas County Sheriff's Office.

15:20The majority of the efforts are volunteer searchers from a number of organizations that come in and blanket these areas like Ansa to Pygna. They're all over the place. They're incredible. And they know these trails. They know the landscape. They are really seasoned searchers, correct? Yes. Although the authorities were focused on that area around Salmon River Road, Phoenix's friends were searching elsewhere, because they were convinced she would not have gone hiking there. She liked to have her dogs off leash, so she would have never taken her dogs there, because there's too many people there.

15:56And when they said missing hiker, I was like, we all knew. What they also knew was that Phoenix and her husband Michael had been having problems. She would talk about crystals that she would place behind her husband's chair to absorb his negativity. And it seemed like she would come alive when he was gone on the road. I know that she struggled with paying the bills. It was a struggle to get the money sometimes from Michael. The last month and a half is when she really started talking, and the stories were getting stranger. One of those stories was about some soup Phoenix had donated to the community food pantry.

16:40She said Michael had found out that she had donated the food out of her own pantry and was really angry, so he put a padlock on her pantry at home so she couldn't take anything else out of it. Sarah says in October, a month before Phoenix's disappearance, Phoenix told her she'd grown tired of Michael's controlling behavior and was making plans to leave him. She had to be secret about how she texts or even made phone calls because he would look through her stuff. So slowly she was bringing some of her items, even her laptop, to the hood of the bazaar and just storing it there. And that wasn't all she was bringing to the bazaar.

17:23She started bringing her dogs to work, and she said that it was because he's threatening the dogs. Her biggest fear was that he would try to do something to the dogs. And that's all she could think about. When Phoenix went missing, her friends and family shared their concerns with authorities. and they couldn't understand why it seemed investigators weren't focusing on her husband. I thought for sure he did something. Investigators had tried calling Michael but got no answer. No one had seen or heard from him until Sunday, two days after his wife had gone missing. My name is Mike Fournier. I think they want to talk to me.

18:12When he called the sheriff's office. And why do you think the police want to speak with you? I don't know my watch has been missing for a few days. Authorities say they found Michael's lack of emotion in that call unusual. He could have been more enthusiastic if he was ordering a sandwich. Investigators went to the home Michael shared with Phoenix, where he met them in the driveway. A body camera recorded the interview, along with Phoenix's birds chirping in the background. Michael soon acknowledged the elephant in the room. I got a big target on my back. My wife's gone. He told the detectives they'd been living separate lives and Phoenix had served him with divorce papers just days earlier.

19:02It's been going rough for quite a while. You know, I can't even talk to her anymore. She's wanting to send a text. Michael said he'd last seen her at home Friday morning and told a strange story about his whereabouts that day.

19:26So Michael Forney provided this story that was almost farcical. He said that he hitchhiked into town to get this car park all the way into Portland, Oregon to this Halsey Auto Parts. I believe it's about 33 miles. How did you get back? Hitchhiking? Yeah. Michael explained that he had been in and out of the house the rest of the weekend, and he had not been concerned about Phoenix's absence because he believed she was seeing someone else and simply hadn't come home. He allowed the detectives to swab him for DNA and take his cell phone. Important transaction for me is I gotta get out of the door.

20:08It seemed his biggest worry was leaving the next morning on a long-haul trucking job. Investigators were suspicious, but couldn't detain him because they still didn't know if anything had happened to Phoenix. They continued searching at Salmon River Road, and the mountain community grew more frustrated. There were a lot of people who called in who said they thought Phoenix had been murdered by her husband. And I think there was a lot of anger at the sheriff's office that we were focused on a search and rescue mission. What the community didn't know was that at the same time, the sheriff's office was also running a criminal investigation.

20:53One they were keeping secret for a very important reason. I think if the sheriff's office had told the community all the things that we were doing, that would have tipped him off. That would have made it very hard to track him down.

21:30The End

21:38Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com.

22:08knows the truth. Listen to and follow Unsolved Mysteries. Available now, wherever you get your podcasts. There are a lot of reasons Chicago homeowners have chosen four seasons since 1971. An A-plus rating with the Better Business Bureau. That's one. Two, BBB Torch Awards for Ethics. That's another. And service around the clock every day of the year. That's a big one. For all your For heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-4-SEASONS.

22:53On Monday, November 25th, with Michael Fournier now back on the road, detectives started collecting cell phone records to build a timeline of the day his wife went missing. They learned Phoenix sent a message to her friend Kristen at 10.28 a.m., half an hour before she was supposed to be at work. She reminded me about her upcoming sound bath on Sunday and to help spread the word. It was the last time anyone would hear from Phoenix. but investigators were still able to track her phone's location the cell phone left that residence and it's traveled west toward portland we got all the detectives together and we went along the route we went to businesses and said hey we're looking for some video and when they reviewed the video from those security cameras just after noon they spotted something significant susan lane's truck was driving with those dogs in the back they tracked the phone and truck moving west all the way to the portland airport around 1 p.m from the airport security video were you able to tell who was driving we were not they couldn't tell where Phoenix's phone or truck had gone from there.

24:21When that cell phone got out towards the airport, it went dead. So no more location data. But the airport wasn't far from the auto parts store where Michael had said he'd hitchhiked to that day. I need to go over it. And policy. Store security video confirmed he'd been there. But when they checked the cameras in the parking lot at 1.38 p.m., just before Michael entered the store... The truck shows up at Halsey Auto Parts. And who's driving? Well, we believe Michael Fournier is driving. Detectives found even more video of the truck, two hours after Michael left the store, this time with one noticeable difference.

25:11We caught more surveillance video driving back towards the mountain without the dogs. The only conclusion is that he disposed of the dogs somewhere and was driving back to his home.

25:29Detectives now knew Michael Fournier had not told the truth about hitchhiking that day. But they still hadn't found Phoenix, so they went to look for her phone at its last known location. We went roughly shoulder to shoulder down that runway, and we looked for that cell phone. No dice, no cell phone. So we decided to do a search over by the river. We were just trying to get organized when all of a sudden one of our detectives said, I think I can see it in the water. This is extraordinary. And what happens then? Sure enough, we went down there and you could see there was a rectangular device that looked like a cell phone.

26:10Yeah. Detective White waded into the frigid waters of the Columbia River and retrieved the phone, but found it was too damaged to provide any more information. The phone had been broken apart intentionally with Primarchs. So not only was the phone thrown into the river, there were efforts made to destroy it more than that. They continued their investigation, but stayed tight-lipped about what they had found, leaving Phoenix's sons Jesse and Dakota desperate for answers. Jesse, who lived out of town, had come back to the mountain. On Thanksgiving Day, he was driving down Highway 26 when he caught sight of Michael.

26:55I see his semi-truck coming up the mountain. And instantly, I'm like, I'd like to talk to him, you know? She's missing. Let's see what he has to say. So I just turned the car around. Jesse says he got to the house a few minutes after Michael. Both men stood in the driveway. What do you say to him? I mean, at first, it was nothing. It was a long, long silence. I just stood there and stared at him for a good three, four minutes. You're serious? Yeah. So you're standing there in the driveway and no one is saying a word. Yeah. Who breaks the silence? He did. He did. What did he say? He said, I wish I had answers for you.

27:46I didn't really push. I was just expecting him to come clean. Did you ask him directly? did you kill mom? I did not. I kept trying to get him to open up and he just wouldn't participate. And I just finally left. Jesse says it was clear he wasn't going to get any answers from Michael. And it seemed the sheriff's office was no closer to finding Phoenix. By then, after days at Salmon River Road, they had called off the official search and rescue operation. I was devastated that they had spent that time searching in what I felt was the wrong area. And why not broaden that? Why give up and not pivot?

28:35What did the locals do? We did not give up. We kept broadcasting her flyers on social media. James Evans was forming a search party. Hey, James. Peter Van Sant, 48 hours. Nice to meet you. Thanks so much for coming out here. James Evans had been out searching for Phoenix on foot and even in a kayak. But he says when he learned no one had looked in these woods off Highway 26, just a few hundred feet from her house, he posted on Facebook to get a search party together here. Even if there was little hope Phoenix would be found alive. He arrived before anyone else the day after Thanksgiving. So I just got out of my truck and surveyed the area and walked back through it this way.

29:27And so I started coming through the woods here. And I seen this, like, a pile of garbage and a couple of tarps. Right in this spot here. Yeah, right in this spot right here. So I'm like, oh, let me get this tarp out of the way. So I went down, I picked up the tarp, and that's when I seen boots and legs. and I knew it was Phoenix.

29:59It's the middle of the night. You hear a sound. You freeze. But the real horror isn't outside the window. It's on it. The terrifying truth? Outdated broken blinds are exposing your private life to the street. Your beautiful home has become a crime scene of zero privacy. Take back complete control of your peaceful sanctuary. Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com. The first freezing night is the worst time to find out something's wrong with your furnace. Get peace of mind with the Four Seasons 35-Point Safety Inspection and Tune-Up for just$89.95.

30:41That's right,$89.95. Backed by a one-year, no-breakdown guarantee. From the team with over 35 ,000 five-star reviews. For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-4-SEASONS.

31:08Soon after James Evans found his friend Phoenix's body, word spread through their tight-knit community that she was truly gone. She was face down in the dirt under a tarp next to a heap of trash. She was just left out like garbage. My heart broke. Within hours on that Friday, November 29, 2024, investigators approached the home Phoenix shared with Michael Fournier, with guns drawn and found him outside. Hey, Michael. Hey, come here, Sheriff's Office. Nope. We're just going to head that way down the driveway, okay? Okay. They did not tell Michael his wife's body had been discovered, and he agreed to go to a nearby police station with Detective Monarch and another investigator for an interview.

31:59He was not yet under arrest. When you do these interviews, are you supposed to have attorneys around here or something like that? Well, I'm going to go ahead and I'm going to advise you of your rights. Anything you say must be freely and voluntarily said. Do you understand these rights? Yeah. In other words, shut up. Despite his attempt to lighten things up, Michael agreed to answer questions. After again saying his marriage was over, Michael took the interview in a different direction. He claimed that just a few days before Phoenix went missing, he'd gotten sick at home after taking heart medication with an open bottle of Gatorade.

32:45Michael said his heart was racing, so he drove to the hospital, but said that while in the parking lot, he began to feel better and never went inside. He told investigators that he thought there was something wrong with the Gatorade. Did you think that you'd been poisoned? Yeah, I've been poisoned. And suggested that Phoenix was behind it. I think she, I mean, there was no one else. Detectives then asked Michael again about his whereabouts the day his wife had gone missing. We walked through everything. Is there any way that you drove her truck? Oh, no, I never drive her truck. Okay. All of those things that we knew he had done, and he denied all of those things.

33:34After nearly three hours, Detective Monarch decided it was time to reveal what they knew. Is that you at the auto parts store? Yeah. The problem we found is the auto parts store also has video cameras in the parking lot. There's her truck and her dogs and there's no one else in that truck. And you obviously drove the truck there. His physical demeanor significantly changed as he was being confronted with the information that we have. They urged Fournier to come clean. You do have the ability to make this right. I'm void and I do. I can't help you. Did you wrap her body in a blue tarp, Mike? I don't know.

34:21He decided that he no longer wanted to communicate with us, so we notified him that he was under arrest for murder. An autopsy later found that Phoenix had been shot three times in the head, neck, and chest. Investigators determined she was shot with a.22 caliber weapon, likely from the side and behind. This sounds like an execution. Any one of those bullets was fatal. We believe that she was likely ambushed as she left the house to go to work. Michael Fournier was charged with second-degree murder. He pleaded not guilty. But what had happened to Phoenix's beloved dogs, Elros and Elrond? Do you know where the dogs are?

35:07Fournier told investigators he didn't know. But soon after he was taken into custody, word came that their bodies had been found. Off the highway along the Columbia River, on the way out of Portland. The dogs were found down a steep embankment, and they had zip ties fastened around their neck tightly. What did this suggest about who could do something like that? Cold-blooded. Detectives continued to shore up their case, processing evidence from the property, including Fournier's Volkswagen truck. It is our belief that her body was stored there or her body was moved using that truck. In January 2025, almost two months after his arrest, detectives got a message from the Clackamas County Jail.

35:58Fournier was ready to talk again, and his story had evolved. I veryly believe that I've been poisoned. Fournier was now claiming that Phoenix had actually handed him that Gatorade bottle laced with poison, which caused him to, quote, lose it for days. Now this was the reason for everything. You believe that your behavior and your actions will result in being poisoned. Yes, sir. To back up his claims, Fournier said he had left the Gatorade bottle in his truck. It was on a passenger seat. But since he never entered the hospital, there was no record he had been there. He did, though, give the detectives a helpful suggestion.

36:44You guys did a fantastic job tracking me with the pickup truck. I believe that you can do the same tracking and find me at the hospital. After some time, Fournier's tone shifted, and he finally was ready to say what he did. That's when he confessed, not to murdering Phoenix, but to killing her dogs.

37:11He justified it in a very strange way. Michael seemed to be implying he knew Phoenix was not coming back, and wouldn't be able to care for them anymore. He discussed the dogs as if they would suffer more by being taken to the pound or even being euthanized there. After Fournier's unusual interview, detectives set out to verify some of his claims. We took that Gatorade bottle and we sent it to the Oregon State Police Forensics Laboratory, where they did testing on it for basically known poisons and heavy metals. None were found. They did, however, find something they believed gave Fournier a reason to want his wife dead.

37:55It was a detail in those divorce papers he had been served. Susan Lane was requesting the property that they lived on. Do you believe that the realization that he could lose everything for him became a motive for murder? Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. With that motive in mind, Clackamas County Deputy District Attorneys John Miller and Alexander Hayes prepared for trial. Because this is a circumstantial case, there are certainly things that we don't know. We never gathered the murder weapon. But forensic testing had revealed Phoenix's blood was in the back of Fournier's Volkswagen truck. They also found.22 caliber ammunition in the house and a shell casing in the driveway.

38:42Did you feel you had a powerful case? Most definitely, but there are no guarantees in the criminal justice system. And indeed, within months, Michael Fournier, dressed in clothing from the jail medical unit, asked to speak with detectives one more time. Glad to see you, gentlemen. With a proposition. Glad to see you folks here. We can work something out together.

39:20On March 24th, 2025, four months after his wife's murder, Michael Fournier welcomed Detectives White and Monarch back to the Clackamas County Jail. We have to start somewhere. And asked for a favor. It's a bit of a long shot, but I need some time out to take care of my personal affairs. He basically asked that he be allowed to leave jail for a period of time. He's like, you can put an ankle monitor on me and I'll stay around. Fournier said he needed to get rid of his trucking equipment and liquidate assets. In return, he indicated he might be willing to give Phoenix's sons some more answers. I'm trying to bring a closure so we can move on.

40:08Was that actually considered? No, it wasn't considered at all. That request is absolutely absurd. In February 2026, Michael Fournier went on trial for the murder of his wife, Susan Phoenix Lane. The prosecution began by presenting its theory of the crime. The evidence is going to show that Ms. Lane wanted to get out of a bad relationship had the defendant served with divorce papers. And then about 41 hours later, he shot her three times in the head, in the neck, and in the chest. Fournier was given court-appointed lawyers. They and Fournier declined our request for interviews. What was the defense team's strategy?

40:58So the defense team's strategy is to hold the state to its burden, to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt. Fournier did not testify, but his voice was heard throughout the trial. I've been poisoned. We ended up at trial playing about eight hours of interviews. Fournier's attorneys had claimed he was in poor health during those interviews and should have had a lawyer present. And they argued that detectives never searched for security camera footage that could have substantiated Fournier's story about being poisoned. But the prosecution maintained that Fournier spoke to them freely each time, and searching for video of him driving to the hospital would not have proved he was poisoned.

41:46There's no evidence to support that he was, and it was tested by a forensic scientist. It's irrelevant. What matters is what happened on November 22nd of 2024. After seven days of testimony, the defense did not call any witnesses, and the case went to the jury. The jury deliberated approximately three hours, and that included lunch. Michael Fournier was found guilty of second-degree murder.

42:18I'm very grateful for how much effort and work everybody involved has put into it. From the community to law enforcement, countless hours of effort and resources to see that he didn't get away with it. That same day, he was sentenced to life in prison, with the possibility of parole after 25 years. At his age, this is essentially life in prison, right? Michael Fournier talked about his poor health. We don't know his specific medical condition, but he's in his 70s, and he'll probably never get out from behind bars.

43:00For Phoenix's sons, moving forward brings new challenges. Jesse, his wife Gina, and two young daughters adjust to a future without their free-spirited grandmother. The hardest thing is she doesn't get to see my girls. She doesn't get to see my kids. We've gone through so much together, and now it's this time where we can really enjoy something beautiful, and she's gone.

43:28Dakota now owns and is fixing up the property his mother loved so dearly. It's her legacy, and it might go into a trust where if eventually I have kids, they can benefit from it. My nieces can benefit from it. Use it as a seed to make a better life and let something good grow from this tragedy.

43:57And up the road at the Hoodland Plaza, the Mount Hood community holds Phoenix's memory close. I just, I miss her being next door. I miss her light. She made a huge difference in a lot of people's lives up here. She was able to bring, even in her death, bring so many people together. Weeks after the trial ended, the community gathered at the Hoodland Bazaar to rename the room where Phoenix led her sound baths. The Phoenix Room!

44:33I want to welcome everybody in. Our intention is to celebrate that justice has been found, that her story will continue to be spread and shared.

44:50I hope that this space can be a place of healing and safety, just to continue her legacy. This place is special. Her presence is still in here. We can still feel her spirit.

45:35the window. It's on it. The terrifying truth? Outdated broken blinds are exposing your private life to the street. Your beautiful home has become a crime scene of zero privacy. Take back complete control of your peaceful sanctuary. Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com. The first freezing night is the worst time to find out something's wrong with your furnace. Get peace of mind with a Four Seasons 35-point safety inspection and tune-up for just$89.95. That's right,$89.95. Backed by a one-year, no-breakdown guarantee from the team with over 35 ,000 five-star reviews.

46:19For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-FOUR-SEASONS.

From the publisher

When a beloved Oregon woman goes missing, her community in the mountains bands together to help solve the case.

More from 48 Hours

All episodes