1. Podcasts
  2. 48 Hours
  3. The Corn Rake Witness
48 Hours

9 Nov 2026 · 41m · 19 chapters

In short

The episode investigates “Operation Sideswipe” style fake-accident schemes and then focuses on “The Corn Rake Witness,” a real Iowa murder case. It centers on whether Amy Mullis was murdered or accidentally fell on a corn rake, and how new expert evidence is being used to overturn Todd Mullis’s first-degree murder conviction.

Guests (people featured)

Tristan Mullis, Amy and Todd’s son; Todd Mullis (in court testimony/letters, not interviewed here); Dr. Kelly Cruz (state medical examiner, testified at trial); Dr. Jennifer Hammers (defense forensic pathologist); Dr. Valentina Nye (biomechanical engineer); Dina and Daniel Neshwat (new attorneys); Erin Moriarty (reporter/segment framing); Amy’s family members including brother Jeff and stepfather Randy (pressuring/affidavit claims).

Key claims

Tristan says his testimony was pressured and that Todd had no time to kill Amy. New experts argue the wound pattern and clothing holes fit an accidental fall, not multiple deliberate strikes. They also cite possible dizziness from recent medication and a dark shed layout/tripping hazard.

Notable examples

six puncture wounds vs four rake tines; two wound directions; coat holes fewer than body wounds; alleged Google searches; Tristan’s “drink of water” timing demonstration; shed/auger tripping scenario.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:26

Tristan's Life Before the Tragedy

Tristan Mullis shares the emotional impact of his mother's murder.

“You know, there's that kid that his dad murdered his mom.”
3:08

The Night of the Incident

Tristan recounts discovering his mother and the immediate aftermath.

“Like, she was calling to get out, and then pissed and yelled, and I ran over there, and she's leaving.”
5:12

The Trial and Its Aftermath

Exploration of Todd Mullis's trial and the evidence presented.

“There's an innocent man rotting in prison right now for something he did not do.”
6:32

Life on the Farm

Tristan reflects on his childhood and the events leading up to his mother's death.

“This is where me and my brother and sister grew up.”
9:10

The Circumstances of Amy's Death

Details surrounding the events of the day Amy died and the investigation.

“We noticed that the pet carrier wasn't outside.”
14:00

Tristan's Testimony and Its Implications

Explore the crucial testimony of Tristan regarding his father's alleged crime.

“When Todd testified, he told the jury he never did those damning Google searches, that he did not know his wife was having an affair, and that he did not kill her.”
18:01

Tristan's Struggles After the Trial

Uncover the emotional challenges faced by Tristan after his mother's death.

“How would you describe the last eight years?”
21:41

Todd's Defense and Missed Opportunities

Analyze the defense strategy in Todd's murder trial and its flaws.

“of pressuring him on how to testify at trial if asked about how long his father was out of his sight.”
24:16

New Evidence and Expert Opinions

Examine the new findings and expert insights regarding Amy's death.

“Now Todd's family is leaning on new lawyers who hope to overturn his murder conviction.”
26:50

Revisiting the Circumstances of Amy's Death

Explore the conflicting narratives surrounding the cause of Amy's injuries.

“They hired experts, including forensic pathologist Dr.”
Show all 19 chapters
28:00

Reconstructing Amy's Death

Experts discuss the details of Amy's injuries and the circumstances of her death.

“But the most crucial question for these experts is how the corn rake ended up in Amy's back.”
29:40

The Expert's Conclusion

Experts provide their opinion on how the accident occurred involving the corn rake.

“After initially falling on the rake, Amy, they say, struggled to free herself from it.”
33:00

Accident or Murder?

Experts discuss the evidence that supports the theory of an accident rather than murder.

“They say that the layout of the red shed likely contributed to the accident.”
36:18

The Fight for Justice

Todd's new lawyers gather evidence to prove his innocence in court.

“Determined to prove that Amy's death was an accident.”
37:50

Challenging the Evidence

Discussion of the circumstantial evidence against Todd Mullis and its implications.

“At his murder trial, the prosecution argued that Amy's affair was the reason Todd killed her.”
40:00

The State's Argument

The state presents its closing argument against Todd Mullis's claims of innocence.

“But for Todd's attorneys, it's not enough to raise questions about the circumstantial evidence against Todd Mullis.”
42:01

Courtroom Tensions and Expectations

Listeners will learn about the emotional atmosphere and expectations during the courtroom hearings for Todd Mullis's case.

“And has that review caused you to change any of the opinions that you've given in this case?”
43:56

Judge's Ruling and Family Reactions

This segment covers the judge's decision on Todd Mullis's case and the family's emotional response to it.

“And then when those days turn into months, turn into over a year, it's very tolling on everyone involved.”
45:59

Continued Fight for Justice

Listeners will hear about the family's determination to continue seeking justice for Todd Mullis despite setbacks.

“Still, there are plenty of people who already have, and believe that Judge Parrish and the jury at Todd's trial got it right.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On 48 Hours, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00A trucker merges onto the I-10 in New Orleans. He checks his mirrors. The lane is clear. And then, boom, impact. A pickup truck seemingly out of nowhere scrapes down the side of his 18-wheeler. Multiple passengers inside. One man flees the scene. And the driver of the pickup, he doesn't seem all that upset. It didn't feel like a regular accident. Because it wasn't. Across the city, truckers were getting sideswiped. All on the same stretch of the same freeway. And behind most of the cases was one personal injury lawyer, a Hollywood stuntwoman turned attorney named Vanessa Mota. This podcast is a story about fake accidents that led to real consequences and a scheme that ends in betrayal and murder.

0:51Listen to Over My Dead Body, Operation Sideswipe, wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all episodes early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. This episode is brought to you by Rover. If your pet is anything like mine, they definitely have some unique quirks. Whether it's the dog who insists on sleeping with the same ratty plush toy, or the cat who lives to chase ice cubes across the kitchen floor. Finding someone who truly gets those little details makes all the difference when you have to step away. Rover connects pet parents with trusted sitters and dog walkers right in your neighborhood for boarding, house sitting, drop-ins, and dog walking.

1:36On Rover, you can look through sitter profiles and reviews from other local pet parents to find a sitter who understands your pet and their individual personality. You can even set up a meet and greet for a quick chemistry check before booking and enjoy peace of mind with daily photo updates showing your pet in their normal routine. On Rover, it's simple to discover personalized care that keeps your companion comfortable and loved while you're away. Exclusively for new users of Rover, use code 48HOURS20 for a$20 discount off your first booking. Valid only on eligible bookings. Offer expires January 24th, 2027.

2:15Terms apply.

2:25My family's name has been drugged through the mud. I get stared at everywhere I go. You know, there's that kid that his dad murdered his mom. Well... My name is Tristan Mullis. I am the son of Todd and Amy Mullis.

2:52I'll never be the same person as I was before. the 10th of November, 2018. I walked in the barn and saw her laying on the ground with a corn rake sticking out of her back. Delaware County 911, what's the address of your emergency room? How did this happen? She was halfway out of the barn. Like, she was calling to get out, and then pissed and yelled, and I ran over there, and she's leaving. Why did it happen to my family? You feel anything? Oh, Amy, Amy. It changed my whole life forever.

3:31I remember it like it was yesterday.

3:38You're 13 years of age. Can you tell me what you were feeling at that moment? Panic. Panic. Panic. I was panicking. I can't even imagine a 13-year-old finding his mom in that way. Very traumatic. You got a second? Yeah, we just, I just stepped out. Four months later... We got a warrant for your arrest. Put your hands on your back. Todd was arrested. You want to get me to come back to somebody, too. That's all I know. The case facts indicate that he was, in fact, the one that killed Amy. The prosecution has this theory that Amy is murdered by being struck with a corn rake in her back. You were the only witness there that day, other than your mom and dad.

4:30Tristan was called as a state's witness to testify at the trial. They kept saying he was the key witness of this whole thing. At some point, did you lose sight of your dad? Yes. I felt like whatever I said, I was going to make somebody upset. it. Tristan, would it be accurate to say that you don't know how much time you were away from your dad when you were working in the hog barn? Yes. We, the jury, find the defendant, Todd Michael Mullis, guilty of the crime of murder in the first degree, signed by the jury foreperson. It felt like a part of me died. I mean, I just, I've never been the same.

5:17There's an innocent man rotting in prison right now for something he did not do. Once somebody's had a trial, the odds are stacked against you. What is it that makes you guys fight for Todd Mullis? 100 % I believe Todd Mullis is innocent. He did not kill his wife. Believe the science, believe the facts, believe these experts. Finally, Todd's side of the story is going to be heard. This was not a murder story. If it wasn't a murder, what was it? It was an accident. Amy Mellis fell on the corn rake. I'm 20 now. About to turn 21. I get to finally speak my story. You know, set the record straight.

6:01But I know for a fact he didn't do it. And how do you know that? Because I was there. Nobody else was there but me. But they got it wrong.

6:18Erin Moriarty reports, the Corn Rake Witness.

6:31Tristan, where are we? We're at the farm that I grew up on. This is where me and my brother and sister grew up. These big white buildings here are the hog barns. Tristan Mullis, along with his younger siblings, Taylor, Wyatt, and his parents, Todd and Amy, lived on this 400-acre Iowa farm where they grew soybeans and corn and raised pigs. It's a whole family effort to run a farm this size. And what are you feeling when you, like, look out here and... Just nostalgia. It's just kind of peaceful, you know. And that November morning in 2018 started off routinely. While his sister and brother stayed in the house, Tristan, then 13 years old, was with his parents preparing for a shipment of baby pigs.

7:24This is the office? This is the office, yes. Tristan showed me inside the hog barn where they were working. Now we're going into the main area of the hog barn. This is where your pigs would actually be in. Tristan's job that morning was to carry heaters from the front of the barn to each pan. Todd was working on the water supply pipes. Amy was cleaning the lights. What she was doing is she would get on the bucket here and stand up and she would unscrew it like that, drop it down, get off the bucket, clean it in a separate bucket, and then get back up here and screw them back in. At one point, Tristan remembers noticing that his mom looked dizzy and unsteady.

8:12She was getting down kind of slow and really grabbing onto the gate. You could kind of see her loopy and swaying a little bit. Just four days earlier, Amy had had a minor medical procedure, and Tristan says he and his dad were concerned. This was her first day back on her feet. We knew something was not right. Tristan says his mom agreed to go into the house and rest. But before she left, they asked if she could do one thing on her way, get a pet carrier out of the red shed. Tristan says they needed it later that day to protect some kittens from heavy machinery. We asked her if she could get it outside of the door.

8:54Tristan says he saw his mom leave. She walked down the side there and walked out that door. The last time I saw her was through that window right in the wall there. Tristan says he and his dad continued working for about an hour and a half before taking a break. We noticed that the pet carrier wasn't outside. So he said, hey, can you go get the pet carrier out? We just figured she couldn't get it. Tristan went to the Red Shed to get the pet carrier.

9:30And that's when he found his mom on the ground with a corn rake in her back. I was just praying that she was still alive. Tristan yelled for his dad, and they got Amy into the truck. Delaware County 911, what's the address of your emergency room? Calling 911 as they rushed to the hospital. and she went in the truck and the son told me. Okay, you're headed to the hospital and she's in your vehicle.

10:00How did you hear that your mom didn't make it? Dad walked in the room and he had tears in his eyes and told us that mom had passed away.

10:15That was sophomore when she went to prom. She loved that dress, but I would not have picked it. Amy's mother Peggy, her brother Jeff, and her stepfather Randy are still coming to terms with what happened that day. Your heart stops.

10:37She was my best friend growing up. Amy was a very vibrant person. She had a big personality. She was always concerned about other people, about her family, about her children. Tristan says that he and his father assumed his mother's death had been a horrible accident, that she had just fallen on the rake. But less than a year later, Todd was on trial for her murder. In the name and by the authority of the state of Iowa, accused Todd Mullis of murder first degree. Committed as follows. Even though Todd and Tristan maintained that Amy's death was an accident, the state medical examiner, Dr. Kelly Cruz, said it was a homicide.

11:31She found a large bruise on the side of Amy's jaw and scrapes and bruises on Amy's knuckles, possible signs of a struggle, and noted that while Amy had six puncture wounds on her back, The corn rake only had four tines. There were two different directions of the six puncture wounds. And what do those different directions indicate to you? To me, they indicate that she would have to be impaled with the rake at least twice, possibly three times. Dr. Cruz determined that Amy's injuries had to have been caused by someone striking her with the rake. Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation Special Agent John Turbott now retired, was called in to help local law enforcement.

12:20I'm thinking at some point Todd and Amy end up in that red barn and Todd attacks Amy and she's hit two or three times with a corn rake. And he says Todd had a motive. We learned that the marriage is not maybe what it would look like on the outside. There were things boiling underneath. Amy was having an affair and according to her brother Jeff, she wasn't happy and planned to leave Todd. Her words to me were, Todd's going to flip out. And what did that mean to you? What did flip out mean to you? To me, that meant that he would not go quietly. He would not give up half of his land in a divorce.

13:05And that becomes a big part of his motive of killing Amy. And according to her friend, Patricia Christopherson, Amy was afraid of Todd. I asked her why she stayed, and she said she was scared of Todd. And if he found out about wanting a divorce or an affair, that he would kill her. Investigators say Google searches found on Todd's iPad show that not only did he think about killing his wife, he planned it in advance. You see searches on unfaithful wives and killing cheating wives at different points in history. According to prosecutors, Todd's plan was to send Amy to the Red Shed that morning, then ambush and kill her.

13:52But that wasn't all. He sent his 13-year-old son to go and find his mother, who he had just slaughtered. When Todd testified, he told the jury he never did those damning Google searches, that he did not know his wife was having an affair, and that he did not kill her. Todd, did you ambush your wife Amy in that shed that day and brutally beat her and chop her up with that corn fork? No, I did not. Since Tristan was the only other person working on the farm that day, his testimony was crucial. He initially told police that he had been with his dad all morning, essentially providing an alibi for his father.

14:40Tristan later added that he did leave his dad's side twice to get a drink of water and that he briefly lost sight of him. Because he was a minor, Tristan wasn't shown on camera. Do you know exactly how long your dad wasn't in your sight? No. Tristan, would it be accurate to say that you don't know how much time you were away from your dad when you were working in the hog barn? Yes. And according to prosecutors, that gave Todd the time to kill Amy. But Tristan says he was pressured to testify the way he did. Pressured by Amy's stepfather.

15:31Ever find yourself standing in front of your closet having a full-blown style spiral? You know the feeling. Staring at a rack of clothes, wondering if wide-leg jeans are actually worth the hype, whether an outfit is truly work-appropriate, or why finding a pair of pants that fits properly feels like a full-time job. You do not have to navigate it alone anymore because Maurice's is essentially that stylish friend in your group chat who always knows what looks good on you. Way back in 1931, their founder chose to focus on real women living real lives rather than chasing fashion trends. And that care still shines through today.

16:08Whether you're running out the door for coffee, handling school pickup, or getting dressed for a Saturday night wedding, Maurice's delivers versatile, approachable style and inclusive sizing that fits you perfectly every single time. Plus, with over 800 stores nationwide and an incredible website, you can pop into any store for free, personalized fit advice and outfit inspiration from their in-store stylist without needing an appointment. Next time you need a second opinion, head to Maurice's and walk out feeling effortless, comfortable and completely confident. Use code 48HRS for an extra 10 % off your total purchase at Maurice's.com.

16:47Let's be honest. Everyone hates bank fees, right? That's why Chime is changing the way people bank. Unlike traditional banks that often pile on hidden charges, Chime offers fee-free banking with no overdraft fees, no monthly maintenance fees, and no minimum balance requirements. Instead of working against you, Chime actually helps your money go further. You can earn 5 % cash back on your Chime card in a category of your choice, like gas or groceries, all while building up your credit score through everyday spending with no credit check required. Plus, your money grows nine times faster than the national average savings rate.

17:27And if you ever hit a tight spot, SpotMe lets you overdraft up to$200 with zero fee stress. Join the millions who are already banking fee-free with America's number one choice for banking. Head to chime.com slash 48 hours. That is chime.com slash 48 hours. Sign up now. It only takes a few minutes. Chime is a fintech, not a bank. Banking services and Chime card provided by Chime's bank partners. Qualifying direct deposits required. Terms and limits apply. Go to chime.com slash disclosures for details.

18:15How would you describe the last eight years? Hell. I would say hell. Tristan Mullis says his testimony at his father's murder trial didn't tell the whole story. And if he could do it all over again, here's what he would want the jury to know about how long it took to get a drink of water that day. I said, I don't know how much time. I wasn't saying it could have been 20 minutes or whatever. All he had to do, he says, was walk around this corner. It was a matter of seconds. Right here is the hose that I drank out of that day. And so where do you drink out of it? Like right here? Right out of the nozzle right here.

19:07You didn't do anything else in here? Nope. And then you walk right back in. And that, he says, is just not enough time for his father to leave, kill his mother, and come back. There were two ways Todd could have gone. Either through this door. If he went that way. He would have walked right past me. You would have seen him? I would have seen him and I would have heard him. So what's the only other way he could have gone out? The only other way he could have gone out is to the end of the barn. All the way down at the end. Oh, I see the door right down there. then to get to the shed, how would he have to do that?

19:43He would have to run all the way across the barn and then run all the way down. Then... He'd have to jump the gate, run through the trees, go into the barn, do whatever, and run all the way back. The round trip would have been about the length of four football fields. Come through the door, get back to the spot, not be out of breath, not be panicked, not be, you know, frightened in any way, shape, or form. Did your dad seem to be disheveled any time when you saw him there, or out of breath? Absolutely not. For a young boy, it was a lot to handle. I had to grow up really fast. Going from a 13-year-old kid, now taking care of two younger siblings, trying to lead them.

20:34When his father was arrested for the murder of his mother, Tristan, his sister Taylor, then 11, and brother Wyatt, 9, went to live with Amy's family three hours away. I'd always promised her that I would look after her children. But little did I know they would be living with us. Amy's mom, Peggy. It was hard for us, too, because we were still grieving. It was painful all around. The kids had to adjust to a new town and a new school. But for Tristan, there was no adjusting to the fact that he was living with family that he says believed his father was a killer. And to this day, I've tried to get them to change their mind and they still don't believe that he's innocent.

21:28It's caused a lot of tension in that side of the family because of what they believe and what I believe. So at 17, with the help of a lawyer, Tristan took action. He signed this affidavit accusing Amy's stepfather, Randy, and an attorney hired by Amy's family, of pressuring him on how to testify at trial if asked about how long his father was out of his sight. They said that if I did not answer the question with, I don't know, that I would get in trouble for my mom's death and be sent to a jail for kids called juvenile detention and that I would be taken out of school and away from my friends.

22:14Did you know Randy P. said in his affidavit that you would pressure Tim? Yeah. No, just tell the truth. Was that hard to read? Yes. Yes, it is. Very much so. because that's the last thing that we did with those kids is tell them to say anything. They speak their own mind. The truth is what we want them to say. Yeah, that was hard, very hard. Today, Tristan does not want to talk about his affidavit. It's kind of a sensitive area. But when he rewinds back through the murder trial, all he can see are mistakes and missed opportunities to prove that his mother's death was accidental, starting with his father's defense counsel.

23:05In a letter to his lawyer written from jail before the trial, Todd asks, is there any expert that could verify possibility of it being accident? In another, Todd made a rudimentary sketch of how he thought it happened. But when the trial began, Todd's defense attorney, Gerald Weyerhelm, didn't even argue it was an accident. He told the jury that Amy was murdered. Amy Mullis was viciously and deliberately murdered. Just not by Todd. Todd's sister Lynn and brother Mike watched on helplessly. Well, when the defense comes out and says, well, we know this was a murder, but Todd didn't do it. Well, that was an opening statement, my God.

23:55Where did this come from? It made no sense. When we reached out to Gerald Firehelm, he declined our request to be interviewed. But he has said that he never considered an accidental death for Todd's defense. Nobody got to hear any evidence of accidents. Now Todd's family is leaning on new lawyers who hope to overturn his murder conviction. Brother and sister Daniel and Dina Neshwat have taken over the case. Years earlier, the Neshwats were consultants for 48 hours when we covered Todd's murder trial. And when they dug into the case, they too concluded that Todd didn't have enough time to kill Amy.

24:46Daniel did the legwork himself, as this video demonstrates. I literally ran the distance that the prosecution was accusing Todd of doing so he could have committed this alleged murder. And being there and seeing it, it's impossible. It's quite a distance. There's no way it could have been done just on that fact. And at that point, I was 100 % convinced.

25:28True crime is full of unanswered questions. But earning your degree doesn't have to be a mystery. That's where Southern New Hampshire University comes in. SNHU offers more than 200 online degree programs with flexibility that puts you in the driver's seat and trusted support to keep you on track, even when life takes an unexpected turn. Find the answers you're searching for at snhu.edu slash 48 hours. I'm pretty confident talking into a mic. Hey, I'm doing it right now. But home projects? I second guess everything. Is that noise normal? Is that water damage? Who do I even call? That's where Thumbtack comes in.

26:10Just upload a photo or voice note and it uses AI-powered search to match you with a right top-rated local pro. So instead of guessing, you get clarity and can hire with confidence. For your next home project, try Thumbtack. Hire the right pro today.

26:33Convinced that Todd Mullis had not murdered his wife, his new attorneys, Dina and Daniel Neshwat, did what Todd said he had wanted all along. What is this here? So this is the shed. This is where Amy was actually found. They hired experts, including forensic pathologist Dr. Jennifer Hammers, a former New York City and Boston medical examiner, and Dr. Valentina Nye, a biomechanical engineer. And after going to the scene, examining the evidence, and doing tests of their own, they both say Amy was not murdered that day. This does not appear to be a homicide to me. At trial, the state medical examiner testified that Amy had that bruise on her jaw and scrapes and bruises on her knuckles.

27:26But if Amy had been hit in the face by Todd, Dr. Hammer says, there also would have been swelling. The area isn't swollen. If this area is impacted in, let's say, a physical altercation, we very often see pretty quick bruising, swelling of that area. As for the scrapes and bruises on Amy's knuckles, Dr. Hammer suggests that those injuries could have come from cleaning those glass light fixtures that Amy was doing earlier that day. As Tristan showed me, they were very narrow. Your mom was cleaning this out by hand. This is hard. I don't have big hands. But the most crucial question for these experts is how the corn rake ended up in Amy's back.

28:16At trial, basically, everyone said four times, six injuries, simple math, murder. That is not right. That's incorrect. Using the state medical examiner's notes, Dr. Hammers drew an approximate diagram of the wounds, labeling them A through F. And then she and Dr. Nye examine the direction of each wound. They, like the state medical examiner, say the wounds go in two different directions. If you look at A, B, C, D, these wounds travel through the body almost perpendicular, and E and F are sharply upward. But unlike the state medical examiner, they don't think the wounds came from Todd striking her with a rake multiple times.

29:05That scenario of swinging and re-swinging does not fit. It does not match the physical evidence. If you swing it, the entry points are much more steep. Any swinging with these tines causes a much steeper entry point and would not generate these wound trajectories. So if someone didn't strike Amy with the corn rake, how did she end up with six puncture wounds in her back? Are you trying to reconstruct what must have happened to Amy? Yes. They concluded that Amy accidentally fell on the rake and helped to create an animation. A warning, the video is hard to watch. After initially falling on the rake, Amy, they say, struggled to free herself from it.

29:55None of those injuries are going to immediately incapacitate her. So she would be able to move to try to remove it from her body. Trying to remove it from her body, they say, she wounded herself further. So what you're saying is that when Amy tried to get the corn rake out of her back, she inadvertently caused greater injury? Yes. Here's their opinion of what happened. When Amy fell, three of the four tines pierced her coat and her back, creating three puncture wounds. Dr. Hammers and Dr. Nye say Amy then tried to get up. She can't roll to her left, otherwise she rolls over top of the rake. She can't sit upright because the rake handles too long and it hits the ground.

30:45The only way for her to be able to get up is to roll to her right. As she struggled, they say she managed to free one tine from her back, but it still stayed under her coat. They say she fell again, causing the fourth puncture wound. Then Amy once again tried to free herself from the rake. She gets up to her knees and grabs the rake handle. Still trying to break free, Dr. Hammers and Dr. Nye say that Amy inadvertently turned the rake, changing the direction of the tines. They say she fell again, causing the fifth and sixth puncture wounds, while the tines were pointing upward. falling back onto those last two times explains that upward internal trajectory.

31:36Dr. Hammers and Dr. Nye say the clearest proof that Amy's death could not have been caused by someone swinging the rake is the coat that Amy was wearing that day. This is a photo of the inside of the coat, taken at autopsy but never shown at trial. The four arrows indicate where the medical examiner saw holes in the coat. It's an extremely important piece of evidence because it indicates that the clothing has less holes than the number of holes in her body. And why is that so significant? He was convicted on swinging this rake multiple times into her body. How do you swing a four-time implement multiple times and have less holes in the outer clothes and more holes in the body.

32:21That is illogical. And they think they know why Amy fell in the first place. Dr. Hammers discovered a potential clue in Amy's medical records, something the medical examiner later said she didn't look at. Not only did Amy have that medical procedure a few days earlier. She had three medications, all of which can cause some sort of dizziness or sleepiness. Remember, Tristan had said his mother appeared dizzy and unsteady.

32:56As part of their work, Dr. Hammers and Dr. Nye walked through the farm. They say that the layout of the red shed likely contributed to the accident.

33:10It's very dark. It's very narrow. There's a lot of things in there. To get the pet carrier, Amy had to walk down one narrow pathway, turn right, and then walk down another. Police photos from that day show the pet carrier sticking out. And Dr. Nye and Dr. Hammers noticed something else in those photos. On the ground, there were two pieces of farm equipment called augers that looked like giant drill bits. With the pet carrier being partially pulled out, it seems most likely that she was starting to pull that out. The barn being dark, the augers at your feet, a tripping hazard, falling backwards.

34:02This is the most likely plausible scenario.

34:09For Tristan and the Mullis family, the expert's conclusion is what they've been waiting for. Finally, Todd's explanation's right here. They proved it. Science doesn't lie. It was a farm accident. Simple as that. I felt like we had our answer. But when Todd's new attorneys get the chance to present this information to a judge, would it be enough?

34:41You know how many people talk about a capsule wardrobe for clothes? Jenny Bird does that for jewelry. They've basically redefined how to accessorize by creating the ultimate jewelry capsule. Instead of a box full of random items saving themselves for special occasions, Jenny Bird makes elevated essential pieces, from earrings to necklaces, that you'll actually reach for every single day. And if you wake up early like me, you know how great it is to have anything that makes your morning routine easier. Jenny Bird can do just that because their pieces are so versatile that you can mix and match without overthinking your look.

35:20Every time you wear yours, be prepared for someone to ask where you got it. And you'll love that you're not constantly rebuying trendy accessories every season. These staples just work with everything in your closet. Getting dressed is just so much easier when your accessories are this seamless. Plus, Jenny Bird pieces look and feel more expensive than they are. Get a free gift with your first Jenny Bird order when you shop at Jenny-Bird.com. A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between thinking about photography school and selling your portraits online. It's the difference between giving away those cookies you just made for free and running your cookie empire.

36:01A beautifully designed Squarespace website is the difference between having a movie reviewing hobby and a movie reviewing career. Squarespace. Because no matter what you're into, a website makes it real. Use offer code DIFFERENCE for 50 % off select plans. Terms and conditions apply.

36:24Determined to prove that Amy's death was an accident. You can't argue with the science. You can't argue with the biomechanical engineers. Todd Mollis' new lawyers, Dina and Daniel Neshwat, armed with their new evidence and new experts, filed a petition for post-conviction relief and got a hearing. They need to convince an Iowa judge in this courtroom that Todd's defense counsel, who never investigated the possibility of an accidental death, was ineffective, and that if the evidence they have collected now had been presented at his original trial, there might have been a different result. If they can do that, they hope to win Todd a new trial.

37:11On that day in court, Todd saw his children for the first time in six years.

37:20I broke down. I broke down. Just to see his face, it like, tore me apart. I just wanted to jump over the rail and hug him, tell him I loved him. When did... The Neshwads, along with a team of lawyers from both the Iowa Wrongful Conviction Unit and the Exoneration Project, are working pro bono to challenge Todd's murder conviction. Nobody listened to Todd at trial. The outcome of his trial would have been different if the jury had heard everything that the court is going to hear over the course of this trial. At his murder trial, the prosecution argued that Amy's affair was the reason Todd killed her.

38:00But the Neshwat say there's no clear evidence that Todd had any idea that his marriage was at risk. She was having an affair at that time, unbeknownst to Todd, but never took any action to actually take the steps to leaving. And in the month before she died, says Neshwat, there were affectionate texts between them. There's messages where they're saying, I love you, back and forth. But what about that conversation that Amy's friends said they had, about being afraid Todd would kill her. I think they were, for lack of better words, kind of throwaway statements. Just like if I said it, my husband's going to kill me if I'm home late, or things of that nature.

38:40If she believed he was going to kill her, she would have done something different, and she didn't. She stayed. As for those Google searches discovered on Todd Mullis' iPad, searches about cheating and killing unfaithful women, which Todd denied making, but the prosecution said, proved premeditation. How do you explain the Google searches? What happens to cheaters in history killing unfaithful women? That looks bad. Yes, on their face, they do look bad. In isolation, they do look bad. Dina Neshwat says that all those searches were made before Amy even began her affair. And she says that many of the searches were about history.

39:26But if you follow the search sequence, it goes into different cultures. Including one that asked what happened to cheating spouses in historic Aztec tribe? The state told the jury that all of the searches from Todd Mullis' Gmail account were done on the iPad, but that's not the case. Todd's Google account was used on more than just his iPad, including Amy's phone and a family laptop. So Neshwat says anyone in the Mullis' home could have done those searches. We don't know who did the search. In your capacity with... But for Todd's attorneys, it's not enough to raise questions about the circumstantial evidence against Todd Mullis.

40:10Success at this hearing hinges on the new defense witnesses. They testified without using the animation we showed you earlier. It was not yet ready. Did you reach an opinion in this case, Dr. Hammers, about how you would classify the manner of Ms. Mullis's death. I did. And what is your conclusion after consideration of all of the background evidence and the evaluation of the hypotheses that you considered in this case? My opinion is that the manner of death is best classified as an accident. Good afternoon, Dr. Nye. Good afternoon. During your investigation, did you come across any physical evidence that did not fit with this hypothesis of Ms.

40:53Mullis falling onto the rake in the way that you've described? No, every single piece of physical evidence supported this hypothesis. And are these opinions that you could have, you or someone else in the biomechanical field, could have offered back in 2019 based on the state of the science then? Yes. Given the evidence, Dr. Hammers and Dr. Nye said that Amy's injuries could only be the result of an accidental fall. That contradicts Dr. Kelly Cruz, the state medical examiner, who declined to speak with 48 hours. Is it true that at the time of Ms. Mullis' autopsy, that because you could not envision a circumstance in which Ms.

41:36Mullis sustained these injuries, other than someone impaling her with the corn rake, that that is the reason you determined that this was a homicide? There is no other way. Yes. Any of those opinions or characterizations, have those changed for you at all over this course of time? No. You've reviewed a report that has essentially criticized your findings in this case, correct? Yes. And has that review caused you to change any of the opinions that you've given in this case? No. Lawyers for the state questioned Dr. Cruz and did not bring any new witnesses to dispute the evidence presented by Dr.

42:17Hammers and Dr. Nye. Closing argument on behalf of the state. But they argued at the end of the hearing that Todd Mullis' murder conviction should not be overturned. The state submits that Mr. Mullis has not met his burden of proof on any of his claims. we asked the court to deny his application in its entirety. In addition to the record and issues that... Tristan did not testify at the hearing, but a deposition in which he described being pressured was submitted. He was a fixture in court throughout, sitting right behind his father. You were there every day. Every single day. I mean, why wouldn't I be there every single day?

42:56I know he's innocent. And for the judge to see that, well, his son is the one sitting behind him the whole time. You know? Mr. Mullis has established there is at least a reasonable likelihood that the outcome of this trial would have been different. With the overwhelming evidence that the court has seen, this is evidence of an innocent man. This is evidence of a man that deserves a new trial and a trial where he can have his day in court. And with closing arguments said and done, Tristan felt confident. I thought he was going to walk out of the courtroom that day after the experts testified. I thought they were gonna let him walk right out of there, to be honest with you.

43:36Now, they wait.

43:48I thought it was gonna be a quick, yeah, this is obvious he needs a new trial. This is completely unfair. It wasn't quick. Every day seems like a month. And then when those days turn into months, turn into over a year, it's very tolling on everyone involved.

44:09The hearing lasted six days, but it would take nearly 15 months before Judge Laura Parrish made her decision. She denied Todd relief on getting a new trial. Everything Todd's new lawyers argued was rejected. The judge ruled that Todd Mullis received a fair trial, represented by competent counsel. What's more, she placed blame on Todd himself. Dina described the judge's ruling. The gist of it was Todd wanted to go to trial so the attorney didn't have enough time to investigate. He knew he was going without an expert, which we disagree with. The judge also said that the jury found Dr. Cruz, the state medical examiner, credible, and that her testimony was consistent with the other evidence they relied on.

45:05But as for the arguments at the heart of the Neshwat's case, the work they did that shows that Amy Mullis died as a result of an accident, Judge Parrish said little. She summarized the science, but she didn't analyze the science. If the jury had heard the science, do you think that would have made a difference at trial? Absolutely. Todd would not be in prison right now if a jury heard the evidence that we have here or saw the animation. The decision was devastating to Tristan and the rest of the Mullis family, who had been so hopeful. We went through all the work to prove all this. To prove this.

45:45And then... Basically have it dismissed. Disregarded, basically. How frustrated is your family? Very frustrated. Very frustrated. I was dumbfounded that a judge could look at that and decide that. Dina had to break the news to Todd. He was just crushed. Sucked the air right out of him. I just couldn't believe it. What else do they want? What else do they need? Science doesn't pick sides. Still, there are plenty of people who already have, and believe that Judge Parrish and the jury at Todd's trial got it right. Is there any chance in your mind that this could have been an accident? No, I think Todd Mullis killed Amy Mullis.

46:29The evidence was put before and tested by juries and appellate judges, and I absolutely believe we got the right outcome on that. If you look at the evidence, there was no way that it was an accident. Amy's brother Jeff said he found the defense expert's conclusion far-fetched. It seemed to me that they were trying to retry the case with some alternate facts and alternate theories. It seemed almost nonsensical some of the things that were being said. Yes it was. Amy's brother, mother and stepfather are hoping the judge's decision will finally shift the focus from Todd and put it back on Amy. There's a hole in her lives.

47:20But we know she's up there. They haven't been looking down on us. What's the most important thing that you want people to know about Amy? The number one thing is how much she loved her kids and how great of a mom she was. We know how we feel about losing her. that I can't imagine how they feel. So what do you do now? We keep fighting. We have an appeal to go to next, and we're just going to keep fighting. The science is still on the record just because she didn't analyze it or agree with it, or it's still there, still on the record. So we're going to ask an appellate court to hear it now. You're not giving up?

48:04No. Absolutely not. Why not? Because we know he's innocent. I lost both of my parents at 13. Tristan told us he's not giving up either. He often thinks of his mom and is determined to get justice for his father. What keeps you going? Prayer. Prayer and faith that one day this will all be set straight. If he were sitting here right now, what would you say to your dad? I love you and I'm fighting every day for you. I'm fighting to get you home.

49:04Skyline Window Coverings delivers gorgeous custom shades that shut out the world. Schedule your free in-home consultation today at skylinewindowcoverings.com. The first freezing night is the worst time to find out something's wrong with your furnace. Get peace of mind with a Four Seasons 35-point safety inspection and tune-up for just$89.95. That's right,$89.95. Backed by a one-year, no-breakdown guarantee. From the team with over 35 ,000 five-star reviews. For all your heating, plumbing, and electrical needs, you know who to call. For all the right reasons, call 866-4-SEASONS.

From the publisher

Iowa son fights to prove his father did not kill his mother with a corn rake. "They got it wrong".

More from 48 Hours

All episodes