1. Podcasts
  2. Ad Age Marketer's Brief
  3. Don't kill a working campaign, evolve it, with Dr Pepper's CMO
Ad Age Marketer's Brief

4 Nov 2026 · 18m · 7 chapters

Episode artwork

Don't kill a working campaign, evolve it, with Dr Pepper's CMO

In short

How Keurig Dr Pepper’s CMO, Drew Panayiotou, decides whether to keep investing in a long-running campaign (Fansville) or evolve/replace it, using data, brand strategy, and consumer listening; includes how they managed risk when adding real college football personalities and how they personalize storytelling across the season.

Guest backgrounds

Drew Panayiotou is Chief Marketing and Innovation Officer (and previously served as CMO multiple times) at Keurig Dr Pepper.

Key claims

Marketers often get tired before consumers do; keep campaigns running if they still drive engagement and sales and align with brand mission. Use engagement signals and business performance KPIs, plus sentiment and relevance rankings (Disney/college football brand relevance). Don’t avoid risk—support bold creative that stays strategically true.

Notable examples

Keeping Fansville rather than restarting; adding Lane Kiffin despite internal risk concerns; trying the new character “Bushy Bill”; using personalization based on fan data and team outcomes (via media partners like Disney) to extend the narrative across paid/earned/shared/owned touchpoints.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Evolving Successful Campaigns

Drew Panayiotou discusses how to evolve successful marketing campaigns without losing their essence.

“world, Lane Kiffin, into this season's ads, even though some people on the team worried it would be too much of a risk.”
2:47

The Role of Data in Marketing

Discussion on the importance of data in decision-making for marketing campaigns.

“When you came in, the Fansville ads were already a long-running series.”
4:40

Risk and Innovation in Marketing

Drew explains the balance between taking risks and maintaining brand equity in marketing.

“But what is the argument for saying we should maybe consider some new roads?”
8:35

Personalization and Fan Engagement

Exploration of how personalization enhances fan engagement in marketing campaigns.

“And when people feel like you're supporting what they believe is the right thing to do in decisions like this, and you're willing to kind of be bold from a creative standpoint, that's when I think great things happen.”
11:22

Recognizing When to Retire Campaigns

Insights on identifying when a successful campaign may need to be retired or evolved.

“We now have technology that enables us to be more innovative as marketers.”
14:01

Evaluating Campaign Relevance

Learn how to determine when to evolve a successful marketing campaign.

“When we see it drop off, we ask ourselves a question on, OK, how do we show up in a more relevant way during this time of the season?”
16:00

Data-Driven Marketing Insights

Understand the importance of data in assessing brand campaigns and listening to audiences.

“So for us, it's very much an end, not taking something away and replacing it with something else.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Ad Age Marketer's Brief, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:07Hello, and welcome to the Marketers Brief podcast, where we leave listeners with a better understanding of how marketing leaders make decisions. I'm your host, Erica Wheelis. When a marketing idea is still working, how do you know whether to keep investing in it or move on? This week, I speak with Drew Panayiotou, Chief Marketing and Innovation Officer of Keurig Dr. Pepper. When he took over marketing at Dr. Pepper, he inherited Fansville, the brand's long-running series of ads set in a fictional college football town, and chose to keep them going. We dig into how his team keeps a long-running idea fresh, what would tell him it's time to change course, and how they decided to put a real person from the college football world, Lane Kiffin, into this season's ads, even though some people on the team worried it would be too much of a risk.

0:53Make sure you like and subscribe so you don't miss out on the reasoning behind your fellow marketers' decisions. And now, here's my conversation with Drew.

1:08Drew, thank you so much for joining me today. Excited to talk to you.

1:12Drew Panayiotou: Great to be here. Good to see you, Erica. So, when a marketing idea keeps working, how do you know whether to keep investing in it or move on? It's interesting. I've been a four or five times CMO, and I think I've come across great campaigns and programs. And I always say this, marketers get tired of campaigns before their consumers do, especially when they're loved campaigns. And when I got to Dr. Pepper, I really looked at the things that are just amazing and that work. And when you have a brand that has been powered by a great campaign that's been growing. Dr. Pepper has been on a tremendous growth rate, beloved by Gen Z.

2:02Drew Panayiotou: You don't come in and say, hey, I want to change this thing and leave my imprint. What you want to do is say, what is great about it? And then how do we keep moving it at the same pace as the thing that we're talking about, which is college football? Fansville is a story about the thing that you're actually watching, college football, which makes it really unique. And so the challenge is how do we keep moving and evolving the storytelling narrative of Fansville at the same pace as the sport that we're talking about. And in a way that keeps it as engaging for our raving fans and the people that love the brand and the people that we're also trying to recruit.

2:47When you came in, the Fansville ads were already a long-running series. So did you assume it would just come back in your first year, or did you consider starting over? What did you look at before deciding?

3:02Drew Panayiotou: One of the things that I do always is get with our agency partners. And the epicenter of Fansville, I say this, proudly sits in our relationship with Deutsch in L.A., with inside the brain of a great, brilliant, creative officer, Ryan Lear. And when I went down to meet Deutsch, one of our key agency partners, I just wanted to understand their work and the work that had been going on. And we immediately went into Fansville, and I think they brought up this question. They said, Drew, we think everyone asks us, and we get questions on when, how long does it go? and Ryan said this and I completely believe this, we'll just keep telling stories as long as the stories are interesting around college football and that well keeps getting more interesting because there's so many storylines that have come from all the things that are affecting that sport and until you know our consumers and our fans of Dr.

4:04Drew Panayiotou: Pepper tell us it's time to stop, I believe we're going to keep going. I always am following and listening to our consumers through my feeds, right, on Instagram or TikTok. And you see the comments. And there's a bunch of comments that are like, hey, I'm just as excited that Fansville's back as much as college football. Yes, I can imagine that there may be someone on your team or at an agency who may say, we know it's still working, but should we start thinking about maybe our next iteration? Clearly with Fansville, you guys said, let's move forward. But what is the argument for saying we should maybe consider some new roads?

4:48Drew Panayiotou: Well, one, you have to look at the data, right? And not only do we look at the data around engagement and engagement in the campaign, which we have multiple ways to do. We have people like EDO, we have our own testing of our creative and things like System One. But we also look at does it move the business and you know is it driving more sales and and that's been true. We've delivered better and better business performance through this campaign and so one that's a big check mark because as a CMO your ultimate accountability is to steward brands, build equity and drive sales for your company. The second thing I would say is apart from the data, you always have to ask a strategic question, which is strategically, what is the mission of your brand and the work that's related to that?

5:44Drew Panayiotou: So I always go back to the strategic questions on why a campaign exists and why should we keep moving it forward? And it's both strategy and results. Can you talk a little bit about how do you decide what stories in college football to pull through into your work? How do you decide on new characters or characters that return? Some of those characters, by the way, are real live people from the sport. And we've had over the years, real live athletes and people that are from the world of college football. and this year one of the characters was Lane Kiffin and there were a lot of questions on Lane and should we have done it and even inside the building right you're taking people that are from the sport and with that inherently could be risk but if you're true to being a brand that has Fansville and we are about talking about the sport you have to talk about the sport and the real elements of the sport.

6:49Drew Panayiotou: And all the feedback we have is that it's been wildly positive. We look at positive sentiment around all of our spots. And that was something that was great. Before it makes it into the ad, I'm sure that you all had to have some internal conversations about this. For folks who were maybe on the like, I'm more concerned side, what was their argument? What were they saying to you of like, we should not include him? And then what did you say back to them to convince them. There's risk, right? And this goes back to the question I think you asked earlier, which is how do you make it keep working? What do you do when you inherit a campaign like this?

7:28Drew Panayiotou: What you don't do is not take risks. And I use the word risk as, you know, it's not a bad word. Risk means that you are going to do something that inherently you may not know the outcome for. But strategically, if you stay true to, hey, is it strategically should we have done, you know, added a character from the real world to college football that had some controversy? Yes, because our mission is to reflect and talk about the narratives around the sport. As a CMO, you have to have confidence in that strategy. And that strategy really comes from the team and as a CMO you want to back that strategy from the team and and and your creative partners that are part of that strategic orientation around the narrative of Fansville and everyone on the team felt really strongly about it some people were like oh it is a bit too much risk but this is one where I'd say as a CMO, you not only make decisions, but you also support the ecosystem of people working on the brand.

8:40Drew Panayiotou: And when people feel like you're supporting what they believe is the right thing to do in decisions like this, and you're willing to kind of be bold from a creative standpoint, that's when I think great things happen. But ultimately, if we had perfect research, we would always have perfect results. And we know that's not the case, right? Because then it'd be easy. It'd be a plug and play. And the world of brand building and the world of marketing is not a linear sport. It's a team sport. And so as long as you create the conditions for the team to challenge themselves, take some risks, quote unquote, then you're always going to be making the brand interesting, storytelling is interesting, and the relationship with your consumers grow.

9:35You also, you mentioned at the top that marketers can get tired of an idea maybe before consumers do. How do you determine that? And if your team is kind of like, we're still doing this? How do you rally them?

9:52Drew Panayiotou: By challenging the team to make it more and more innovative. I think having been a CMO for over two decades, you see that there's so much change in our industry and change is a constant and change is good. But I also think that on big iconic brands with scale, you have equity and equity that has an existing fan base. And yes, we want to keep growing new fans. You want to evolve. I don't think you ever want to have hard 360s. A brand like Disney, you don't want to have a hard 360. It has amazing equity. It has amazing resonance. And I always say this, the harder challenge is to say, how do you evolve and innovate?

10:42Drew Panayiotou: And so when And we have our marketers and our brand marketers on Dr. Pepper. The challenge is, hey, how do you innovate something? How do you evolve something and keep it fresh? And I think that's a different challenge and often a harder challenge than let's just change. Let's just move to a completely new campaign or way of connecting and look for the innovation opportunities. And I think personalization has been one of those. like integrating and looking for opportunities the intersection of creative technology and content and personalization and the technology around it has opened up massive opportunities to say okay how do we take fansville and evolve it and evolve the narrative during the season it's not about six or seven spots it's about the entire paid earned shared and owned model the narrative through the season, which is months and months, and then using personalization to show up in key moments in ways that we couldn't before.

11:47Drew Panayiotou: We now have technology that enables us to be more innovative as marketers. You have mentioned the balance of like, we have equity in this brand, but we also want to innovate. So in a long running campaign or idea, how do you determine like this needs to stay the same, but these are some variables that can change each year? With Fansville, we have new characters that show up, right? And it's almost its own bit of a show. And so we have characters that come in and out. We talk about like, you know, should we amplify by one character or not during the season. And that's part of the, I'd say, the storytelling innovation.

12:33Drew Panayiotou: And I love that we've tried things and we just bought a new character on last year called Bushy Bill, and we're like, all right, let's try it. And we found that there was resonance with Bushy Bill. We'll look at how do we leverage increasing data around Fansville? Some of that comes from our media partners like Disney. they allow us to have the ability to leverage their data during the season, to leverage their fan data, and then combine that with ours to say, how do we tell more interesting stories to certain types of fans? And how do we do that during the season? If we know your fandom, then let's extend the story in a slightly different way based on whether or not your team won or lost.

13:21What would be the first sign to you that a long-running idea might be losing its pull or magic a little bit? And how do you separate, like, the creative may not be performing as well to maybe, like, some external forces, like, just market forces, the way the market is reacting or consumers are feeling?

13:46Drew Panayiotou: We look at the engagement that it drives online. That's always the first sign of are people getting bored or not. And they're clearly not because the brand attention increases during the Fansville campaign. It gets better. When we see it drop off, we ask ourselves a question on, OK, how do we show up in a more relevant way during this time of the season? I think that's why we've been looking towards personalization to say, how do we take the stories and pull them into the moment more? Is there anything that would convince you, any evidence that would make you say it's time to retire an idea that is working?

14:28Drew Panayiotou: There's a poll or survey that's done by Disney and it looks at brands during college football and ranks them. And we have always been at the top of that list, which is we're the most relevant brand associated with college football. Any of the folks or any of the brands that are college football partners of Disney and the media partners that are part of college football. And so I say, hey, if you're at the top of that list, then obviously what you're doing is working. When we start slipping and the world tells us that Dr. Pepper is not the most relevant brand in college football, and if we're five, six, seven or eight, then we'll definitely say, okay, there's something going on here with Fansville.

15:17Drew Panayiotou: But that has not happened and it hasn't happened for a long time. It's a weird thing to say, but we are part of college football. We are not college football. We're not the thing. We're part of something that's bigger than us. And it feels like the sport will continue to just be amazing. In beverages, I say this, you're always recruiting, and you're always recruiting the next generation. And so we have intent focus on Gen Z and having this brand be as relevant to that audience as possible. College football is one of the things. And then we're adding new things and we're looking at new ways that we connect based on where culture is going and the consumer is going.

16:00So for us, it's very much an end, not taking something away and replacing it with something else. What should another CMO evaluate before committing to bring back a long-running idea for another year? What is a signal that you would tell them or a KPI that they should really take a look at?

16:23Drew Panayiotou: I believe you have to look at your brand resonance and with your core fans and what they're telling you, and then the new fans that you want to reach. We have no shortage of data as marketers. We have to just be great at listening. And social channels give us amazing ways to listen. We get immediate feedback on our brands. And we have great research partners that give us longitudinal knowledge on a campaign over months and is it working. But we have both real-time feedback and long-term tools that give us that feedback. And so for me, I always tell CMOs, be true to the data. The data is not going to lie.

17:03Drew Panayiotou: And then keep listening to your core fans and understand your new fans really well.

17:16That was Drew Piniotu, Chief Marketing and Innovation Officer at Keurig Dr. Pepper. And I'm Erica Wheelis. I'd also like to thank our producer, Lauren Chiardio. If you enjoyed our conversation and you want to hear more like it, make sure to hit subscribe and you can check out more on adage.com. Thanks for watching and we'll see you next time.

From the publisher

Replacing a campaign that's still driving sales can feel like the bold move, but evolving it is often the harder job. Drew Panayiotou, chief marketing and innovation officer at Keurig Dr Pepper, inherited Fansville, Dr Pepper's long-running college football ad series, and kept it going by changing the storytelling around the idea rather than the idea itself. He explains how new characters, personalization and fan data from media partner Disney keep it fresh each season.

He also says what would make him retire it. Dr Pepper has always ranked first for relevance among college football brands in a Disney survey, he says, and a slide to fifth through eighth would tell him something is wrong. Panayiotou also explains why he backed featuring Lane Kiffin in this season's ads despite questions inside the company, and why he treats creative risk as part of the job.

Dig deeper:

~Dr Pepper's college football marketing playbook includes mixed reality, AI and Pat McAfee

~Dr Pepper turns viral creator TikTok jingle into a CFP National Championship ad—behind the strategy

~How 20 years of Dove's Campaign for Real Beauty have changed marketing

~Inside McDonald's global marketing playbook—how CMO Morgan Flatley is scaling 'fan truths'

~MasterCard CMO: How We Keep 'Priceless' Fresh After 17 Years

More from Ad Age Marketer's Brief

All episodes