In Their Own Words: Andrew Cotton — Wipeout at Nazaré | 1

4 Aug 2026 · 38 min · 20 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Big-wave surfer Andrew “Cotty” Cotton recounts how he became a professional, then describes his career-almost-ending wipeout at Nazaré, Portugal, in October 2017, and his long recovery and mindset shift afterward.

Guests

Andrew Cotton (professional big wave surfer from North Devon, England; severe childhood asthma; lifeguard and trained plumber; known as Cotty). Other named figures: his father; Al Menny (surfboard-factory friend); Garrett McNamara (Hawaii-based big-wave pro); Nicole (Garrett’s wife); Hugo (rescue ski operator); surf pioneers Laird Hamilton and Derek Dorner.

Key claims

Surfing’s “magic moment” kept him chasing flow; jet-ski towing enabled bigger waves; the Nazaré wipeout fractured L2 and nearly threatened his spinal cord; recovery succeeded through physio/hydrotherapy and reframing his injury as “healing back”; fear is healthy but panicking is dangerous; big-wave surfing has no finish line—failure is essential.

Notable examples

First surf at Saunton Sands; apprenticeship at Gulfstream Surfboards; Ireland jet-ski towing incident with Coast Guard rescue; joining McNamara’s Nazaré team; 2011 78-foot record (Cotty driving); 2017 wave likely 50–60 feet; weightlessness then crushing impact; returning to tiny waves at Saunton Sands after rehab.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Cotty's Early Surfing Journey

0:45 to 3:47

Andrew Cotton shares his childhood experiences with surfing and how it changed his life.

“He thought if his son learned to surf, it might ease the blow of having to change schools and make new friends.”

From Apprentice to Big Wave Surfer

5:03 to 7:37

Cotty's transition from a surfboard apprentice to pursuing big wave surfing.

“By his mid-teens, Andrew Cotton had thrown himself completely into surfing.”

Challenges of Big Wave Surfing

7:37 to 9:07

Cotty discusses the learning curve and challenges of big wave surfing after an early setback.

“A remote spot on the west coast of Ireland had massive waves they might be able to ride.”

Survival and Determination

9:07 to 9:35

Cotty's harrowing experience of being airlifted after a jet ski incident.

“and there was particularly strong winds this day.”

Rebuilding After Setbacks

9:35 to 11:21

Cotty's motivation to improve his skills and regain respect in the surfing community.

“and comments started pouring in on internet surf threads.”

Opportunity at Nazaré

11:21 to 12:46

Cotty receives an invitation to join a team aiming to surf the biggest waves at Nazaré.

“But he kept training and improving his water safety skills working as a lifeguard, while still taking plumbing gigs.”

First Experiences at Nazaré

12:46 to 14:01

Cotty's first impressions and experiences trying to surf the giant waves at Nazaré.

“We were like, whoa, I can't believe he's ever heard of us.”

Safety Measures in Big Wave Surfing

14:01 to 16:45

Learn about the safety gear and protocols that protect surfers in extreme conditions.

“They had safety spotters with walkie-talkies on the beach and cliffs.”

Andrew Cotton's Rise in Big Wave Surfing

16:45 to 18:01

Explore Andrew Cotton's journey in big wave surfing and his sponsorship by Red Bull.

“Listen to Revisionist History, The Staten Island Problem, wherever you get your podcasts.”

The Anticipation of the October 2017 Swell

18:01 to 19:17

Cotton reflects on the excitement and expectations leading to a significant swell.

“He'd gotten sponsored by Red Bull and caught some of the biggest waves ever ridden, including one that was estimated to rival Garrett McNamara's record-setting 78-footer.”
Show all 20 chapters

Surfing Techniques and Strategy

19:17 to 21:04

Understand the techniques surfers use to ride big waves and the evolution of their approach.

“I didn't really just want to go to the bottom of a wave and fall off.”

Cotton's Attempt to Ride the Perfect Wave

21:04 to 24:25

Follow Cotton's detailed account of his attempt to surf a massive wave and the challenges faced.

“The swell was due to peak in the afternoon, but the conditions were so good and the wind was so good, and I could see these barrels on the first peak, and I'm like, we go now.”

The Accident and Immediate Aftermath

24:25 to 26:49

Cotton describes the moment of his wipeout and the immediate confusion and pain that followed.

“Cotty was in so much pain and shock that he couldn't deploy his inflatable safety vest.”

Injury and Its Impact on Cotton's Career

26:49 to 28:00

Learn about the extent of Cotton's injuries and the realization of their severity over time.

“Then the footage comes out and it goes absolutely viral everywhere.”

Cotty's Wipeout Experience

28:00 to 30:16

Andrew Cotton recounts the moment of his severe injury while surfing.

“It just literally crushed my spine together.”

Hospitalization and Recovery

30:16 to 32:13

Cotty reflects on his hospitalization and the mental shift towards recovery.

“Cotty now wondered if his pro-surfing days were behind him.”

Returning to the Waves

32:13 to 34:13

Cotty shares the challenges and emotional struggles of returning to surfing after his injury.

“Cotty was ready to surf his first waves.”

Finding Joy in Surfing Again

34:13 to 36:54

Cotty discusses rediscovering his passion for surfing and overcoming fears.

“And I'm still on this run of, like, getting the best waves of my life.”

Lessons Learned from Injuries

36:54 to 37:54

Cotty reflects on the valuable lessons gained from his surfing injuries.

“you can either find that frustrating, like there is no finish line, or you can embrace that and go, yeah, this is like the most dopest thing ever.”

Confronting Fear in Big Waves

37:54 to 39:00

Cotty discusses the balance of fear and excitement before tackling big waves.

“While Cotty continues to surf big waves, he still maintains a healthy fear.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Audible subscribers can listen to all episodes of Against the Odds ad-free right now. Join Audible today by downloading the Audible app.

0:11From Audible Originals, I'm Cassie DePeckel, and this is Against the Odds in Their Own Words.

0:25Professional big wave surfer Andrew Cotton, affectionately known in the surf community as Cotty, was eight years old when he caught his first wave. I actually remember it really vividly the first time I went surfing. Cotty's father took him to the local beach in North Devon, on the west coast of England, where the family had just moved. He thought if his son learned to surf, it might ease the blow of having to change schools and make new friends.

0:52Andrew Cotton:There was a corrugated iron shack with a guy that rented these really heavy boards and these really bad wetsuits, which weren't warm whatsoever. And it was Easter, it was freezing cold, it was raining, and I went in the water. While Coddy plunged into the frigid ocean, his dad went back to wait in the car. And I kind of like just loving it. In the end, like he had to come down and like, oh, literally like try and get me out the water. You know, I didn't want to get out. And I think he was shocked because it was so cold and I was so cold, but I was just like, I was buzzing. I loved it. And then it was just me hassling him to take me to the beach, you know, like all the time.

1:37Cotty was already a strong swimmer. Having had severe asthma as a child, his doctor suggested swimming at the local pool as a way to help with his breathing. Surfing, though, was game-changing. Unlike doing laps back and forth in a pool, it offered him freedom. The thing I loved about surfing, in particular, was that there was no one telling me to stop or start or do another length. There was no instructions. It was just like a free reign. I can remember those first few waves and those feelings, and I often feel like it's that same feeling now. The feeling you're chasing for almost like the rest of your life.

2:18It's that moment of being so present, time standing still. There's nothing else like it. You know, like you're like floating on water and you're flying along with the energy of the ocean and it doesn't always happen every time. Sometimes it can happen once a year, once every two years, sometimes longer, but the second that you get that feeling again, that magic moment and that moment of flow. It's like, okay, right, this is why I do it. This is the special thing, you know. The search for those magic moments has taken Cotty around the world, from those first small waves at the Saunton Sands Beach Club in Devon to some of the biggest breaks in Hawaii, California, and Australia.

3:02But you don't become an elite big wave surfer without your share of setbacks and wipeouts. Cotty's worst came in 2017 in Nazare, Portugal, the famed big wave mecca featured on HBO's 100-foot wave. He'd taken off on a perfectly curling 50 - to 60-foot wave when things went sideways.

3:23Andrew Cotton:The wave hit me so hard, it crushed me, and I instantly knew I was seriously injured. I was like, oh no, like, you've actually really done it this time. Today, Andrew Cotton is here to tell the story of his quest to surf the biggest swells on the planet and how he bounced back from the injury that nearly ended his surfing dreams. This is Wipeout at Nazare.

3:56The Emmy Award winning HBO original series Hard Knocks Training Camp brings viewers into the preseason with unparalleled access to the reigning Super Bowl champion Seattle Seahawks. Go behind the scenes with Sam Darnold, Jackson Smith and Jigba, and the legendary dark side defense as they prepare to make another run at the NFL title. See how the best in the world take the hype and pressure head on. Your football fix starts here with the personalities and challenges that define a championship team. Bonds will be built. Bloopers will be captured. Hard Knocks Training Camp with the Seattle Seahawks premieres Tuesday, August 4th at 9 p.m.

4:34on HBO Max. This is Actually Happening is a podcast that features extraordinary true stories of life-changing events told by the people who lived them. In a special six-part series called AI, A New Kind of Being, This is Actually Happening explores the powerful and unexpected ways artificial intelligence is changing human lives. Follow This is Actually Happening wherever you get your podcasts.

5:03By his mid-teens, Andrew Cotton had thrown himself completely into surfing. He'd become a fixture on the local scene in Devon and won some junior competitions. At 16, Cotty decided to forego college and instead landed an apprenticeship at a local surfboard factory called Gulfstream Surfboards. For the employees, the workday revolved around the ocean conditions.

5:29Andrew Cotton:I'd turn up at the factory, and the first thing we'd do is check the waves, check the tide. If it was good, we would work out when we'd surf. The best part of the gig was that the shop closed for a few months every winter. With a little money saved up, Cotty started taking his first surf trips. When I was 16, I went to Barbados for two months, just surfed every day. It was amazing. It was during these trips in his late teens and early 20s that Cottey first discovered big wave surfing, generally classified by waves 20 feet and above. I did a trip to Hawaii and ended up surfing some pretty big waves at Waimeo and Sunset Beach.

6:14And that's when I sort of realized that I was a good surfer, but not great. but big waves I felt like I could tune into the ocean a bit more as a bit of a more of a mind

6:26Andrew Cotton:game I could use the skills that I'd learned and my swimming ability to give me confidence and put myself in positions where actually some of my mates didn't want to put themselves you know like they were scared they were way better surfers than me but they didn't want to push it to the extremes that I was doing so that's when I sort of really discovered big waves but I never ever thought in a million years it was a career, it was a job, it was like, there was no way. Cotty had discovered his superpower within the sport of surfing. The problem was, surfing, and the little money he earned at the board factory, just wasn't paying the bills.

7:05So, in his mid-twenties, Cotty went back to school and trained as a plumber.

7:10Andrew Cotton:And I was on site from eight till five, and you can't surf, like, you're not surfing. And I did that for three or four years. And at the end of that, I was like, oh, this isn't going to work. You know, I cannot do this for the rest of my life. I hated it so much. Around the same time, Cotty got a call from an old friend from the surfboard factory named Al Menny. Al told Cotty he didn't have to fly across the world to Hawaii or Australia to surf big waves. A remote spot on the west coast of Ireland had massive waves they might be able to ride. We'd been watching these guys in Hawaii using jet skis to tow into big waves, and we just copied.

7:56Andrew Cotton:We were like, oh, let's try and do that. Up to that point, Cotty had been paddling into large waves. But the bigger the wave, the faster the water moves and the harder it is to catch. So the thought behind it is using this jet ski, you can match the speed of the wave easier. And then therefore you can ride bigger waves. By holding on to a rope attached to a jet ski and then letting go at the right moment, big wave pioneers like Laird Hamilton and Derek Dorner could get enough speed to ride waves 30 feet and above. How hard can it be? Almost immediately, Cotty and Al learned how hard it was. Just maneuvering a jet ski and surf that huge proved difficult.

8:42Andrew Cotton:Me and Al went out. Like, no radio, no safety kit, no clue what we were really doing. And the waves were big. Like, it was big. An hour into the session, having caught no waves, Cotty was driving the jet ski when it toppled off the top of a massive wave as it broke. When he surfaced, Cotty swam to the ski, but couldn't get it to start. I had this jet ski, which I was trying to swim back to shore, and there was particularly strong winds this day. Like, the winds were blowing from the land out to sea. And when I started, I was probably, like, 60 metres from shore, and within about half an hour, I was about two miles out to sea, like, in the middle of nowhere.

9:25Andrew Cotton:Someone had seen this, and they phoned the Coast Guard, and the helicopter got called and I ended up getting airlifted. The incident made the news and comments started pouring in on internet surf threads. The comments got pretty savage. These guys are clueless, they're kooks, they don't know what they're doing, leave it to the professionals, like give up. It was really, really hard to read. To hear the criticism from the surfing community stung. But instead of giving up, Al and Cotty redoubled their efforts. They took a jet ski course. Cotty got a job with the lifeguard service and trained harder than he ever had before.

10:09Andrew Cotton:The year after we went and we surfed again, and we ended up actually getting a couple waves, you know, and that was the start of it. The more waves you ride, the better you become. You figure it out more, and that was amazing. We're like, oh, using this jet ski to get towed into these waves. You're getting multiple waves in a session. You're making the most of the swirl and the conditions. So it was like Disneyland, you know, like this cold West Coast Irish Disneyland with these waves all over. And we had a lot of fun. That first winter, it felt groundbreaking. I felt like it was this new style of surfing and you're going fast and you're strapped in and it was really exciting.

10:56Over the next few seasons, Al and Cotty Surfing started getting attention from the surf media, and Cotty landed his first sponsor.

11:05Andrew Cotton:Getting these articles written about you and getting free wetsuits and some free clothes, and all these little things were happening at the same time. So it was really exciting and really motivating. Cotty still didn't imagine big wave surfing could become a full-time job. But he kept training and improving his water safety skills working as a lifeguard, while still taking plumbing gigs. And then in 2010, Al and Cotty got the email of a lifetime from a Hawaii-based big wave surfer named Garrett McNamara. Garrett was a big deal in big wave surfing. He probably was one of the very few professional full-time big wave surfers.

11:47Andrew Cotton:He had already surfed some crazy, crazy waves in Hawaii and around the world. And he'd won one of the first big wave tow competitions at Jaws with this crazy barrel and won like$50 ,000. Garrett and his team were in a small seaside town on the coast of Portugal called Nazaré. Garrett had surfed all over the world, but had never seen swells like these. He was saying that he thinks it's where the biggest waves in the world break. Do you want to come down and be part of his team to help him surf these waves in Nazare? Garrett's goal was to break the world record for the biggest wave ever surfed. He'd taken notice of Cotty and Al's success in Ireland, and needed surfers with towing experience to help with their efforts.

12:39Joining the team meant Cotty would be able to drive the jet ski and get a chance to surf some gigantic waves. Obviously it was huge for us. We were like, whoa, I can't believe he's ever heard of us. And I can remember being absolutely petrified, but at the same time, willing to just give it a go. Cotty had surfed his share of intimidating waves in Ireland, but nothing prepared him for Nazare. That first trip, we drove down to the lighthouse and we were looking at the waves. And I can remember being like,

13:16Andrew Cotton:what are we doing here? It looked horrible. It was giant. It was disorganised. These peaks were breaking everywhere. I was used to surfing big waves but the big waves in Ireland they always break in the same spot. They have big channels, safety zones. You drift into the safe zone. Whereas when we were looking at the waves the first time I just saw a mess and I'm like, what do you do? And I kind of didn't think it was possible. Garrett's team developed a system to take on Nazare's giants. They used two jet skis, one to tow the surfer in and another for rescues. They had safety spotters with walkie-talkies on the beach and cliffs.

14:05Plus, surfers wear impact suits and inflatable vests with CO2 cartridges they can deploy to bring them rapidly to the surface in the event of a pin-down. Once you inflate the vest, you come up real quick, like really quick.

14:19Andrew Cotton:If it brings you up two seconds quicker, it gives you that opportunity to get rescued one second quicker. And seconds matter. You know, they make massive difference. Soon after they arrived, Garrett took Cotty and Al out to catch their first waves at Nazare. Looking at the footage after, Cotty was blown away by just how big the swells they had surfed were. The waves looked way, way bigger than they felt. And it was like, oh my God, like, it was massive. Cotty joined Garrett's team and threw himself fully into the endeavor. And one year later, in 2011, Garrett set the record for the largest wave ever ridden at 78 feet tall, with Cotty driving the jet ski.

15:07Andrew Cotton:Being part of that project helped me get hundreds and hundreds of hours on the jet ski, hundreds of hours rescuing, hundreds of hours towing and hundreds of hours actually surfing. In Ireland, you'd maybe get an opportunity in the winter to surf big waves a handful of times. Whereas Nazare, like it was 20 feet every week. It was always massive. I saw my big wave surfing accelerate and my jet ski driving accelerate and there was no other way that I would have been able to get those hours in the sport without that. Thinking back to what those waves felt like, it was the first time on some of those biggest waves that I surfed that time slowed down.

15:59Like, you'd be going out of control fast, like so fast. But every water droplet was in slow motion. It was that feeling, that out-of-body experience, that meditation. And that was the first sort of time I felt that on a big wave.

16:2530 years ago, an island off Manhattan almost brought down New York City. Who will you trust? Your friends and neighbors? Or will you trust the people five miles overseas? This is a story about neighbors turning on each other. And what happens when a forgotten place decides it's had enough. But we're not stopping, are we? No! Listen to Revisionist History, The Staten Island Problem, wherever you get your podcasts.

17:15scream. They capture our anger and they try to do something with it. This is my attempt to take the Manifesto back from mass shooters and nihilists and return it to its rightful place with the warriors, the visionaries, the regular folks with just the right amount of crazy. I compare notes with radicals, secessionists, internet trolls out for a laugh, and punk singers screaming their guts out, all trying to turn their anger into the world they want to see. Listen to Manifesto wherever you get your podcasts. Audible subscribers can binge all episodes of Manifesto early and ad-free right now. Join Audible in the Audible app or by subscribing on Apple Podcasts.

18:01By October of 2017, Andrew Cotton had turned big wave surfing from a passion into a career. He'd gotten sponsored by Red Bull and caught some of the biggest waves ever ridden, including one that was estimated to rival Garrett McNamara's record-setting 78-footer. By then, Nazare had become a mecca for big wave surfers. But the ocean and big wave surfing's funny. There's no timetable or schedule. And every swell, big swell, is an opportunity. And we actually hadn't had a very big swell at Nazare for probably like two years. But from the swell brewing on the morning of October 8th, 2017, it looked as if that was about to change.

18:46It was one of the bigger ones we had probably since 2014, which was when I'd got one of the biggest waves I'd ever surfed. And I knew it was going to be some serious waves. And I can remember checking the waves in the morning with Garrett, and I just felt like it was going to be one of those swells where something would happen that could change my life. You know, like that wave that would change everything. And my surfing was changing. I didn't really just want to go to the bottom of a wave and fall off. In Connie's early days of big wave surfing, the trend was for surfers to take a straight line down the wave.

19:28trying to get to the bottom as fast as they could, because that's how big waves are measured. To determine its size, you need to see the smaller surfer against the full height of the wave in a photo or video.

19:41Andrew Cotton:You just want to get to the bottom and make the wave look giant, and that image might be the world record image. The method is imprecise, and still debated in the surf community. It's also more risky, since you're positioning yourself in a spot where a 70 - or 80-foot wave could crash. But this time, Cotty didn't want to just sprint to the bottom of the wave looking for a record. He wanted to surf the wave from inside the tube. I wanted to really focus about being deep in the most critical part of the wave. And the vision was really to get barreled at Nazare. The holy grail of surfing is like being in the barrel.

20:25Andrew Cotton:whether it's two foot, four foot when you're inside the wave, you're riding inside the barrel, it's like the dream, but riding inside a 60 70 foot barrel was like okay, this is what I want and I can remember seeing these waves that morning and it was kind of windy but offshore and the SWI direction was really good and I could just see these perfect peaks and they were like they were perfect and they were barreling Garrett was still recovering from an injury he suffered at Mavericks, a famous big wave spot near San Francisco, but was on board to tow Cotty Inn on a jet ski. Hugo Vow manned the second rescue ski.

21:08We actually decided to go out early. The swell was due to peak in the afternoon, but the conditions were so good and the wind was so good,

21:17Andrew Cotton:and I could see these barrels on the first peak, and I'm like, we go now. like no one else is out we go and we just focus on trying to get barreled and Garrett's like yeah let's go so we went out and he towed me into a couple waves and they were like pretty big waves but like not the ones and then this wave came through and we just looked at each other and we know I know he knows we just look at each other and he's like okay yeah this is the one and I'm like, OK, yeah, this is the one. And it was like bending and peaky, but with quite a long line. It was a set wave. It was solid. And in my head, I'm like, this is the one.

22:02Andrew Cotton:I let go of the rope and it was smooth and dreamy and I'm going so fast. To be in the barrel is quite hard because the way you position yourself, your brain is telling you to run to safety. and you've got to really commit. You've got to be really, really behind the peak and really put everything on the line. Cotty drops into the wave. He rushes down a towering mountain of water toward the bottom of the wave. But instead of riding it all the way down, he starts positioning himself for the barrel, which will form when the giant peak curls into a tube. And I faded a little bit. Fading is a surfing manoeuvre that allows Coddy to get deeper into the pocket of the wave.

22:48Andrew Cotton:And then I'm like, oh, maybe I'm not quite deep enough. And I decided to fail it a little bit more. The idea was to come off the bottom of the wave and, like, pull into this giant barrel. And as I positioned myself, the wave just changed. It went from this perfect-looking, peaky wave, which looked like it was going to barrel, to kind of like a funny lump and I lost speed and I was positioning myself too low on the wave. The positioning was just all off. But I was so committed, I had nowhere to go. And it was like, oh, I'm in a really, really tough spot. And I just kicked my board out and jumped off.

Read the full transcript

23:37Andrew Cotton:I like went into a ball and was expecting like this immense impact you know it's a pattern you fall off you know I fall off a lot and you get hit by the white water you get tumbled around and then you get held down for a little bit and then you pop up you know and then you you can breathe sometimes to get another wave on the head sometimes you get rescued straight away so it's a cycle you know those feelings and I jumped and I braced and I just felt nothing there was there was no impact and I'm like oh this is this isn't right I've never felt this I should be experiencing impact now and I was just weightless and it seemed like I was weightless for hours almost to the point where I'm like maybe like I've died or something I was floating and then almost began to relax and then I hit I hit so hard it crushed me and I instantly knew I was seriously injured instantly I can remember like the force being so hard And then in that washing machine, underwater, and with the pain, it was absolutely agony.

25:00Cotty was in so much pain and shock that he couldn't deploy his inflatable safety vest. I can remember surfacing, and I literally broke the surface of the water,

25:14Andrew Cotton:and I looked up, and then I just had another giant wave just crash from me again, straight away. I barely got a breath. And again, like, bam. My body was like, just agony, and my leg was tingling, and I was getting washing machined around. That's when I was able to calm myself enough to find the vest toggle to inflate the vest. And then I surfaced after the second wave, and the rescue guy, Hugo, came in to rescue me, and he said that he knew something was up straight away. Like, I remember, like, getting onto the back of the ski and we just went straight to shore and got to the beach and I was like, I've broken my back.

26:05I don't think I can walk. Nazare lifeguards rushed to meet Hugo and Cotty at the beach. They quickly stabilised his back, loaded him into an ambulance and headed to the hospital in the nearby city of La Ria. And before I knew it, I was in hospital like within an hour. I was being scanned within two hours and got told the news. Like, yeah, you've broken your back. Cotty had fractured the L2 vertebrae in his lower back. Fortunately, he still had sensation in his legs and feet. I can remember thinking, it will be all right.

26:43Andrew Cotton:It won't be that bad. I'd probably be surfing in like two weeks, you know, like that was my mindset. Then the footage comes out and it goes absolutely viral everywhere. And then you sort of realize what had happened. I started piecing together all those feelings of that weightlessness. The footage revealed a monster wave, likely 50 to 60 feet, cascading down on Coddy. A wall of white water shoots him into the air. The wave didn't even hit me. it sort of just like projected me out, like catapulted me out in front of the wave. And actually the impact was like me hitting flat water really fast and from a height.

27:24Andrew Cotton:And that's what broke my back. Just the water, just the face of the water. The wave had flung Cotty's body through the air before smacking him back down. That pain, that lower back pain, It was just, imagine, like, jumping out of the second or third story of a house, landing on your bum. That's technically what happened. We're always like, oh, yeah, but it's water. It's soft. It's like, you're fine. It's like, no, no. When you're going that fast and there's that much water moving, it's not soft. Like, it's concrete. It just literally crushed my spine together. But I got really lucky that that chunk of bone split off towards my stomach.

28:15If it was the other way around and that chunk of bone broke off the back, it would have gone into my spinal cord. So I do believe that I was really, really lucky. But even after watching the video of himself getting pummeled by the wave, Cotty still didn't grasp the severity of his injury.

28:34Andrew Cotton:I was sort of like, oh, in two weeks I'll be fine. it's bad but it's just what happens it's surfing you know like everyone has a wipeout it's just one of those moments but when it really hit I was in hospital for a couple days and they put this metal brace on me and I was just lying down and Garrett and Hugo were in the room and we'd been chatting and they're hanging out and the nurse came to sit me up for the first time and she was like okay we're going to try and get you to just literally sit up and we're going to try and get you to try and walk a little bit. And they sat me up and I just thought this nausea came through me.

29:16I felt sick. And they were trying to get me to just stand with this brace on. And I couldn't. And I looked around and it was the first time I'd ever seen Garrett look worried.

29:33Andrew Cotton:it wasn't necessarily how I was feeling it was the look on someone else's face which I'd seen Garrett do some crazy shit and I've never seen him look concerned you know he's seen me take some big wipeouts and it was just the look on his face was like the telltale it was like oh no like you've actually really done it this time this isn't going to be a two week job of actually properly injured

30:15Laying in a hospital with a broken spine, Cotty now wondered if his pro-surfing days were behind him. I was angry at myself. I was kind of like, oh, you've blown it. You had like one opportunity and things were just starting to work out. My career was just starting. And I'm like, wow, have you blown it all? You know, like, this is it. Cotty says the support of the people around him in those early days helped him think differently about his injury. Nicole, Garrett's wife, said some things that really stuck with me about healing and mindset. She said, people are going to be referring to your back as broken and constantly telling you you're injured, you know, and trying to switch that.

30:58And it's like, it's your healing back. and I think it really made a difference. A few days later, Cotty was up on his feet, walking around for the first time since the wipeout. After two weeks at the hospital in Portugal, Cotty was medevaced to the UK to continue his recovery. At home, Cotty threw himself into his rehab. This is going to sound really weird about the recovery, but I really enjoyed the physical aspect of that. I love throwing myself into the physio, the training. I was very fortunate to work with some amazing physios and specialists, and it was mapped out. And it was like, if you do this, this, and this, this will be the outcome, you know?

31:46And for me, that was super motivating. I did hours and hours and hours of hydrotherapy stuff in the pool, like walking, trans abs, and I just threw myself into that. I loved it. And it was like learning to enjoy that. Like I disconnected from the surfing, I disconnected from doing the things I actually really loved and learned to like the boring rehab stuff. Six months after breaking his back, Cotty was ready to surf his first waves. I went back to the beach where I learned to surf, Saunton Sands, and I bought a longboard and was riding tiny waves, and every time felt like a win. To surf again felt amazing.

32:31But despite the progress Connie made, he was grappling with the emotional weight of his injury. I think I was really not in a good place for a few years. I was petrified of getting injured again. My surfing was really struggling because you don't ride big waves with getting injured in the back of your mind. You can't have that. and that really held me back and it really affected me and I felt like I was underachieving a lot. And then I had a few back problems again, disc problems, and it took me a while to figure out the best routines of the warming up and the cool downs, better training programs, which were actually beneficial to my body rather than hindering it.

33:21Two years into Cotty's recovery, the grind had taken its toll. It got to the point where around 2019, I was almost done. I was almost like, OK, yeah, back's bad, it's hurting, I was in pain all the time, I was surfing bad, I wasn't where I wanted to be. I was still really fortunate to be living that professional surfing dream,

33:48Andrew Cotton:but it was almost like a nightmare. I go home and I'm like, oh, I hate it today. What am I doing? like this isn't fun you know like what's going on and you ask yourself like why are you doing all these things and what are you trying to prove and what's it all about you know like I was obsessed with wave size and surfing the biggest wave and getting that acknowledgement from your peers and it was just really really really unhappy but the funny thing with surfing is like there's no money in surfing you know you're not doing it for the money you're doing it for passion and love and when I really was like okay right I'm done you realize that I just love riding waves and I love big waves and I do actually like pushing my limits I just had to come to terms with what I was trying to prove and where I was at and figuring out the pain in my body and how to solve that and once I did that I learned to enjoy it again and and understand where I want my surfing to go and it's just like a switch it just turned and I figured out that I can't walk away from big waves like I can't walk away it's like you're not going to just retire from passion this is something that I've put my life into and I'd be insane to walk away now like I just gotta stick with it and I rode it out to be honest this last six years I've served some of the best ways of my life some of the biggest some of the most critical I've had some of the biggest barrels which is really weird because you know I'm 46 and I can remember when I first went professional I was 34 and even then people were saying you're too old to be a professional surfer you're too old you know you just stick stick to plumbing stick to your day job and then I was coming into my 40s and I felt like I was figuring it all out my mindset was right my body was feeling better My training was better.

36:01My goals more balanced. And I just had this amazing run. And I'm still on this run of, like, getting the best waves of my life. And for Coddy, that doesn't mean winning awards or getting official records.

36:18Andrew Cotton:The people judging that stuff know less about big waves than I do. They've never been to these places. So why am I trying to ride the biggest wave on the planet? And I probably have already done it anyway. Like I've already ridden the biggest wave of the planet, like numerous times. Like, what do I need someone else to tell me I've done that? Why am I seeking their approval? Surfing, after all, is ephemeral. The perfect wave doesn't exist. There's always going to be a bigger swell. There's always going to be a better wave. The wave comes and you might ride it, but you might not. You know, you can always ride it better.

36:52Andrew Cotton:It's never ending. And I think that's the most magical thing about big waves and actually surfing in general. you can either find that frustrating, like there is no finish line, or you can embrace that and go, yeah, this is like the most dopest thing ever. Like, this is never going to end. It's like the perfect game. Like, just enjoy it. And that's why I started surfing. That's what was lovely about it. There is no rules. It's just endless. Looking back on what I've learned from surfing big waves, It's actually not really about the waves you make. It's about the waves you don't make, really. I think it's really important to fail.

37:35You need those moments. Every one of my injuries, I learned so much about myself, my body, mindset. In that moment, and sometimes even for periods of time afterwards, it's like the worst time ever. And when you're in it, you hate it. But looking back now, I'm like so thankful. While Cotty continues to surf big waves, he still maintains a healthy fear.

38:00Andrew Cotton:The night before and even like that morning, you'd be absolutely petrified, feel sick and, you know, question yourself and like, why am I here? What am I doing? I'm not good enough. I shouldn't even be here. You know, like, who am I kidding? Sort of stuff. you know fear's healthy but like i never would ever panic panic is dangerous when you start panicking is when like shit goes wrong but once i get on the rope i just i change it's different even like one second i'll be thinking oh i don't really want a wave i don't want one i don't want to get hurt like the second that really i'm faced with the wave i'm going i've got like one opportunity at this i'm going and what will happen will happen you know we'll work it out, I'll be fine.

38:46I've had lots of injuries and I've been in lots of situations, but I've never really had a bad experience in the ocean when I look back at it.

39:00Thanks to Andrew Cotton for sharing his story with us.

39:09From Audible Originals, this is Wipeout at Nazare for Against the Odds. To keep up with Cotty's adventures, find him on YouTube at Andrew Cotton Surfer or on Instagram at Andrew underscore Cotty. And to learn more about his journey, watch 100 Foot Wave. Seasons 1 through 3 are streaming on HBO Max. Produced by Audible. I'm your host, Cassie DePeckel. Peter Arconi wrote and produced this episode. Sound design by Jamie Cooper. Engineered by Sergio Enriquez. Original theme music by Scott Velasquez and 2K for Freeze on Sync. Series produced by Emily Frost. Managing producer, Desi Blaylock. Senior producers, Andy Herman and Austin Reckless.

39:53Executive producer for Audible, Jenny Lara Beckman. Head of creative development at Audible, Kate Navin. Head of Audible Originals, North America, Marsha Louie. Chief content officer, Rachel Giazza. Copyright 2026 by Audible Originals, LLC. Sound recording copyright 2026 by Audible Originals, LLC.

From the publisher

Professional big wave surfer Andrew Cotton — “Cotty” — discovered he had a knack for riding waves that most other surfers wouldn’t dream of tackling. His journey took him around the globe, from California to Hawaii, Ireland and Australia. But when Cotty got an invite to join surf legend Garrett McNamara in a small seaside town in Portugal called Nazaré, he discovered swells bigger and wilder than he’d ever encountered before. Today, Andrew Cotton is here to tell the story of his quest to surf the world’s biggest breaks – and how he bounced back from the wipeout that nearly ended his surfing dreams.  

Follow Cotty on YouTube @andrewcottonsurfer, and Instagram @andrew_cotty

Audible subscribers can listen to all episodes of Against the Odds ad-free right now. Join Audible today by downloading the Audible app.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from Against The Odds

All 75 episodes
In Their Own Words: Andrew Cotton — Wipeout at NazaréAgainst The Odds · 38 min
Listen in VO