

Post–midterm election reflection on why Democrats won (or held) seats, what voters rejected (cost, corruption, cruelty), and what risks remain in the lame-duck period and beyond (Supreme Court, spending bills, possible Iran escalation). The episode also argues that “blue wave” framing may miss the role of new/returning voters and that culture/media and messaging will determine whether gains last.
Nat Towson and Matt Randolph (hosts). Chad Scott (military/foreign policy expert). Matt also discusses energy/oil industry politics; Chad focuses on foreign policy and institutions. The transcript includes references to other media figures (e.g., Jessica Tarloff) but they are not guests.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion about the midterm election results and the atmosphere in New York.
“I got to tell everyone, I am shocked at how tall Nat Towson is in real life.”
Panel shares their expectations and surprises from the recent elections.
“A blue meteor shower can disrupt up to seven Jewish space lasers.”
Analysis of voter behavior in light of the recent elections and potential future implications.
“There There were races I wasn't even following with big upsets in them where I didn't even think we had a chance.”
Discussion of significant historic victories, including firsts for various demographics in government.
“And that's one of the major things that's different from the previous administration, previous Trump administration, I should say, different from two years ago.”
Exploration of shifts in voter demographics and their impact on election results.
“So the, all of those firsts were really, really inspiring to me.”
Insights on Republican and Democratic voter behavior during the midterms and the implications for future elections.
“But that also I think there's this misconception in how we think about elections insofar as like, well, we have to win over the voters.”
Discussion on the importance of voter turnout for future elections and ongoing engagement.
“Republicans actually poll 10 points better than Democrats as a party even today.”
Discussion on new voter demographics and their impact on elections.
“I don't I don't think that's just Republicans switching.”
Concerns over potential political risks following midterm elections.
“I'm hoping that it'll trickle eventually.”
Examination of the changing dynamics of AIPAC funding and political candidates.
“Do you want to hear the second optimistic thing I have that connects to that?”
Discussion on Trump's statements regarding Israel and their implications.
“I'm sure they have a lot of data that we don't have.”
Exploration of changing loyalties within the Democratic and Republican parties towards Israel.
“I can't really say with any certainty that I have a strong opinion on it.”
Debate on the role of money in elections and the potential for campaign finance reform.
“And that's not, Israel's not America first.”
Discussion on the rise of grassroots campaigns and their effectiveness against corporate spending.
“So we will have to have legislation down the road to counter it.”
Analysis of big energy's participation in elections and its impact on policy.
“And that is something that doesn't feel like it's going to just disappear overnight.”
Exploration of how cultural trends influence political landscapes and vice versa.
“You're not going to get an ExxonMobil ever endorsing a company or a candidate or donating money.”
Explore how cultural shifts influence political landscapes and vice versa.
“What can any of our listeners do to sort of keep their feet to the fire on this stuff?”
Discuss the corporate influences on media and their impact on political narratives.
“You could only get like plaid at Target.”
Identify what citizens should demand from Democratic leaders for real change.
“Yeah, and let's focus first on what we need to see from government.”
Examine the importance of coherent communication within the Democratic Party.
“What do Republicans do with so much less?”
Learn about tactical approaches Democrats can take to counter Trump and maximize congressional power.
“Force Donald Trump to veto it so that it's on his record and we can use it.”
Explore the importance of rebuilding trust in institutions and the urgent need for Democrats to act.
“how little time Americans are spending around other people or doing leisure activities like reading for pleasure, but also how little institutional trust is left in the media, government.”
Discuss the failures of current Democratic leadership and the call for new leaders prioritizing progressive values.
“You know, oh, we we we really need to get the first black speaker.”
Discussing the disillusionment among voters due to common donor influences on both parties.
“You know, he's not making decisions in the interests of marginalized people, whether they're black or of other marginalized communities, domestically or abroad.”
Exploring potential new leaders in the House and the dynamics of political representation.
“Prediction markets have Hakeem Jeffries at 92 % taking the house 78 % for Chuck Schumer.”
Analyzing the challenges faced by progressive candidates in gaining leadership positions.
“I think she has aspirations of being president as much as she publicly has looked up to Pelosi for a lot of her career.”
Discussing the future of Democratic leadership, potential candidates, and their alignment with party values.
“That's, you know, you pass one bill taxing the rich.”
Discussion about the influence of APAC donations on Democratic leaders and potential candidates.
“And I do think it, by my standard, I do think it has to be someone who's not on the APAC payroll, but it also needs to be someone who can kind of galvanize people.”
Analysis of recent election outcomes and their implications for various demographics, including women and trans rights.
“No, I mean, the only thing I got to say left is do something, earn it.”
Emphasis on the importance of coalition building and maintaining political engagement post-election.
“So did Washington and several states made it harder for trans people to be alive.”
A humorous recount of a Halloween party where the host accidentally met the Governor of New York.
“On Halloween, I went to a large block party in a relatively affluent Brooklyn neighborhood that is adjacent to my less affluent Brooklyn neighborhood where I can afford to live.”
Reflections on the awkwardness and significance of confronting a politician in costume.
“Because I think I'm glad that you did it that way.”
A guest shares their surprising enjoyment of New York City, challenging negative stereotypes.
“Chad, what's the least worst part of your week?”
Discussion on how fear and myths about cities can misrepresent their safety and cleanliness.
“We flew back, we landed last night back in Boise.”
An anecdote about the peculiarities of voting in Oklahoma, illustrating voter behavior and ballot issues.
“And it's weird because Democrats in Oklahoma can actually get a lot of things passed if they can get it on the ballot.”
The discussion revolves around a controversial ballot initiative in Idaho to vote on a state gun, highlighting political maneuvering and public opinions.
“because they can't even teach their own people how to vote.”
A participant shares their feelings about not working on Election Day and reflections on the challenges faced by poll workers in educating voters.
“It was not a good election for my state.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On American Power, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This podcast
0:20Chad Scott: is brought to you by Nat Towsen and Matt Randolph. I'm joined as always by our panel of experts, our expert on the military and foreign policy, Chad Scott. Chad, it's good to see you back in the internet where you belong. Yeah, just in the little boxes instead of seeing you in person. That was a good time we had in New York. I got to tell everyone, I am shocked at how tall Nat Towson is in real life. It was really cool being there with the whole Find Out crew. And a big shout out to Tim and Jamila and Zach and them for putting that on. So, yeah, no, it was good. I'm just enjoying the blue tsunami or blue meteor or whatever they call the meteor strike that Ted Cruz said.
1:06So, yeah, I did miss Mr. Global being there. I think he would have been a huge asset, but good to see him in his top box here on the podcast video here.
1:15Chad Scott: And by huge asset, you mean he's taller than both of us. Chad and I were in person in Manhattan at the Gramercy Theater this past Tuesday for Find Out Media's midterm mania election watch results. Election results watch party? You can put it in any order. It still means the same thing. Unfortunately, we didn't get to see our other member of the panel in person. However, he's joining us right here for our special election reflection trademark pending episode. our expert on all things energy the oil industry renewable energy you know him as mr global matt randolph matt how you doing i am shocked to learn that ted cruz believes in meteors i think that's antithetical to his beliefs although he does believe in left-wing witches so or left-wing transgender witches to be more accurate i wonder if they wrote in on the meteor itself.
2:08Chad Scott: A blue meteor shower can disrupt up to seven Jewish space lasers. Oh boy. It's been a big week. I'm excited. I want to talk to you guys. A lot to discuss, a lot to unpack. That's why we are recording a special episode the evening of Thursday, November 5th, while we are still waiting on results from, I believe, Mississippi, which is extremely close right now with almost all the votes counted, and Alaska, which is down to a few ranked choice ballots that are likely to go Democrat, but neither race has been decided as of the point of this recording. However, a lot of other races have been decided.
2:48Chad Scott: Hard to know where to start here. Let's talk about some, what are your big, what are your big wow moments? What are your big takeaways? I think there were a few people we expected to win who, you know, who won by larger margins than we expected. There were a few big upsets. There There were races I wasn't even following with big upsets in them where I didn't even think we had a chance. What were your big takeaways from this past Tuesday and the results over the past couple of days? My big takeaway. So I'm going to be honest, going into the election, I had no idea what was going to happen. After 2024, I thought, yeah, all bets are off.
3:27Americans are checked out. They don't pay attention to anything. They don't care. Like, so I really didn't know what to expect. I thought we would probably take control of the House. I had no clue about the Senate, but it appears that Americans were watching. Maybe they were watching the gas pump. Maybe they were watching, you know, us shooting people in the middle of the street. I'm not exactly sure what they saw or what they were watching this time that they missed last time. But I do know that if they hadn't missed it last time, we wouldn't have had to deal with the last two years. I know that for sure.
4:03Maybe in future elections, Americans can pay more attention and we don't have to come back and fix or put out the house fire, you know, before it's completely burned to the ground like we had to do this time. But I didn't have a lot of expectations. That's kind of where I'm at. I wasn't surprised, but I also didn't have any expectations.
4:22Chad Scott: And just to tag onto something you said there, I think you're right. I don't think this is the end of disengagement or anything. I think, if anything, unfortunately, a lot of this came from, like you said, the gas pump, the pain of the cost of living. And that's one of the major things that's different from the previous administration, previous Trump administration, I should say, different from two years ago. I wish I could say that the American public was less reactive, but I do think that's what woke people up. Whether this is an opportunity to create more engagement, to fight disillusionment, I think that's what really remains to be seen here.
4:57Chad Scott: I don't think this is a switch back on from this massive problem of, which we'll discuss more in the episode, but this massive problem of, you know, mistrust in institutions, disengagement from current events in general, from politics, and overall isolation that has just been increasing in America. um chad i want to ask you you know you and i were together so we saw a lot of the results get revealed in real time but for those of you who were not those are the listeners who weren't privy to your uh authentic reactions what were some of the big upsets for you or what were some of the races that you were most excited about um i i had said originally that kansas was my litmus test but i was blown away just by in general i'm blown away by mississippi right now and it's it's really fascinating seeing some of the firsts and that this is kind of what uh really has me hopeful going forward i mean you have keisha lance bottom she's the first black woman elected governor of any u.s state ever that that actually blows me away i can't fathom that that hasn't been a thing like in the year by the year 2026 we haven't had uh a black woman elected as governor of any u.s state.
6:10And she's the first governor of color for the state of Georgia. I mean, we had the first Native American woman elected as governor in New Mexico, which is Deb Haaland. And then Peggy Flanagan, another Native American who was elected to the U.S. Senate. You have, obviously, everyone was talking about Abdul El-Sayed, who is the first Muslim elected to the U.S. Senate. So we're seeing a lot of these firsts. First openly gay man to the U.S. Senate, first Latina governor of Texas with Hinojosa and the gay man was Chris Papa. So the, all of those firsts were really, really inspiring to me. And I agree.
6:45It's, it, it boils down to the cost. Um, but also there was, uh, I was listening to, um, Jessica Tarloff. Uh, she's on, I wasn't listening to her on Fox. I was listening to her on a podcast, but she, she had a great discussion where she talked about the, the three C's is cost, corruption, and cruelty. And that's what people voted against. They were They're tired of the high costs. They're tired of the corruption. And frankly, just the cruelty. And it's not just the overt cruelty that ICE has subjected people to, but just being cruel online to each other. And I think people are really getting tired of all of that.
7:18And it's interesting because each voter block has a different aspect of where they voted. So the young man had a 38 point swing from Republicans voting MAGA last election to now voting blue. and a lot of it has to do with cost. They're very economically focused. Young men are worried about the future jobs they need, the money they want to make. But then you had a lot of the MAGA women moving because of the cruelty. They were very disgusted by a lot of the cruelty as well as the costs that come along. So it was just a very fascinating race. And people said, or Donald Trump came out and said, vote like I'm on the ballot.
8:00And they absolutely did. They voted like he was on the ballot. And that is absolutely what we're seeing. It is not just a referendum on Donald Trump's policies. It's just an overt rejection of Donald Trump MAGA. And I'm hoping it carries through.
8:20Chad Scott: Yeah, and I think it's interesting because sometimes I look at these election responses and I want to point out, we tend to look at the electorate as a fixed group of people. And so we go, oh, you know, Asian women voted more consistently Democrat in this election cycle. All these different demographics voted more consistently, not every demographic, but you know what I'm saying, all these different demographics, specific demographics, voted more consistently or voted more Democrat than they did in 2024. And in several cases, more voted more Democrat than in 2020. And so, you know, even the Times today had a graphic which sort of showing like an arrow of like, oh, we're moving to the right in 2024 and then back to the left over here in 2026.
9:03Chad Scott: And I think the problem with representing the data that way is the idea, again, that the electorate is fixed, that it's not aging, that there aren't new voters every four years, every day. But that also I think there's this misconception in how we think about elections insofar as like, well, we have to win over the voters. Whereas if you've ever worked on a campaign, the realistic that the war of attrition there is is fighting disengagement. There's so many more Americans who are eligible to vote than vote. And so I think when we look at these numbers, I think what's interesting to look at or to try to figure out is to what extent did these communities, did these voters actually shift positions?
9:45Chad Scott: And to what extent did people running on the Democratic ticket actually speak to the needs of these communities and turn out people who wouldn't have voted two years ago or six years ago? I think that's, I mean, it's very hard to tease apart, but I think that's responsible for a lot of the more exciting victories, at least in my opinion, is people speaking a more, if not populist, people speaking a more affordability, pragmatic agenda that's more based in meeting the material concerns of voters. And I don't think that's every Democrat. I think we have to find some nuance in there. But I think it's interesting.
10:19Chad Scott: And I think we have to make sure that we don't just see it as like, oh, well, people got with the program again. It's like, no, we created voters. And I think that's really how you make change. Yeah, I looked at a map that The Economist put up and it was really fascinating. It showed, it was one of those, you have a huge budget maps where it shows the sweeping graphic of the direction the country went by various district and all but like three districts moved left, even if they were still heavily Republican, like myself in Idaho or probably Matt in Oklahoma. Oklahoma. I'm wondering if, and I'm asking Matt as well, because we do have this unfortunate issue of being in extremely Republican states.
11:02If we're seeing what's happening across the country as I still think it is a blue tsunami, I still think it is this blue wave, the blue meteor, whatever you want to call it, or are we just kind of borrowing the voters that are just absolutely sick and tired of Donald Trump. They want more intelligent discussions. They want less corruption, less cost and less cruelty. And so what we're seeing is not really a blue tsunami, but a red riptide. And I kind of talked about this when we were in New York, where there's this, it's not necessarily a big push that everyone loves Democrats, because if you look at the polling, they don't necessarily do.
11:44Republicans actually poll 10 points better than Democrats as a party even today. So you look at that, is this really just, I'm so sick of MAGA and Trumpism that it was a riptide of red and now I'm just going to vote blue just to maybe kill the MAGA movement. But the minute a normal-ish, a J.D. Vance or a Rubio shows up, I'm right back to voting Republican. I don't know. That's the concern I have. And Matt, what are your thoughts on that? Is that something that you might be seeing in your world over there? personally i think you know if republicans had stuck to their votes the results would be largely the same if you look at like texas greg abbott got the same number of votes as he did last election um so these i think my take from that is these are largely people that either didn't vote in the last election or new voters yes we did have a lot of republicans that ended up voting for Democrats, but the margins were so huge.
12:44The margins of victory, I think even without that, the Democrats probably still win 95 % of the races they won. Like you don't win in Texas by, you know, over a million votes just by getting Republicans to switch the team. And I think when you just look at the numbers that the incumbents and mainly the Republican incumbents got, But it wasn't that they underperformed or they got less votes than last time. Like what I looked at, it looked like they were getting about the same votes as they did in the last election, which, by the way, is a presidential election, which turns out a lot more people.
13:21So they actually had more turnout for a midterm. But as Nat said, there's so many people in this country that don't vote. And when they do finally vote, it's because they're so pissed off they force themselves to go vote. And I think that's what happened here. There was enough people that had just had enough that don't normally vote that went out and voted. So I'm sure there's like the race in Mississippi and some of those, you know, Alaska, some of those really close races. Republicans switching sides for one election certainly could have tipped the scales. But in these big margin states and a lot of them were big margins, like the vast majority of them, Kansas was a huge margin.
13:59Texas was a huge margin. I don't I don't think that's just Republicans switching. I think that's new voters coming in, people that hadn't voted before, a lot of young voters, a lot of Hispanic voters. You know, it turns out if you try to deport an entire race of people, they don't want to vote for you next time around. It's crazy that we had to go through this for them to figure that out. But I think the hard part here is getting these people to continue to vote. I've always said that if everybody in the United States had to vote every election, the Democrats would never lose another election.
14:32and maybe I'm right maybe I'm wrong it doesn't matter all I know is when we have the biggest vote numbers Democrats always win they always win when everyone turns out or when big numbers of people turn out so we'll see um but I'm not convinced it was all just you know Republicans
14:48Chad Scott: switching teams what do you think I think you know I think you're right and I think that some of the engagement is also just people being mad at Republicans or you know you hear a lot of people talking about this like you know being just being sick of it being sick of of the non-stop cruelty and i think that's a valid reason to go to the polls i think the question here actually let me say this uh i'm gonna i'm gonna flip my usual uh leftist contrarian position and give a couple reasons that i think this is more than just a reaction and i think you're right about the voter bases and who showed up but how about how about this optimist matt i know it's rare but here's two things one i think well optimist nat is going to say good night for socialists a lot of socialist candidates in this blue nami pointing that to trademark pending election reflection blue nami edition god how did people miss that when they started saying blue tsunami people should call me more often anyway uh i'm available for pr election reflection blue nami report opinion number one is that beneath that blue NAMI is this sort of socialist surge.
15:56Chad Scott: I'll come up with a better one for that soon. But a lot of really strong democratic socialist victories, I mean, we can squabble as to are these true socialists or are these people, you know, pursuing a European style social democracy talking points. I don't think a lot of people won on prison abolition campaigns in this week, but I think we saw a lot of successful DSA campaigns. New York and LA, the two largest cities in America now have, as of today, as of this recording, now have DSA mayors or LA has a DSA mayor elect. Atlanta DSA sweep, New York City DSA sweep, and a lot of people who are not officially DSA members, but have been running on Medicare for All, affordability agendas other talking points that are some would call progressive i think the term progressive is too loose but are are democratic socialist talking points whether or not they are democratic socialist candidates a lot of success there i mean i'm very excited that we have the first black female governor but i'm more excited that we have keisha lance bottoms as a governor um that's a bigger deal than kamala harris being the vice president in my opinion uh i think that it's really important that we have representation in government and demographically that our government looks more like the demographics of the united states but it also matters that those are people from those demographics who are going to focus on improving the material conditions of everyday americans and i think that's what's really exciting to me is that there are a lot lot of people running on, you know, refunding these quality of life, these basic essentials that Americans need and are succeeding.
17:44Chad Scott: And we saw succeed on Tuesday. And, you know, El-Sayed is not a DSA member, but he ran on Medicare for All and, you know, called his shot one by seven points. And I think that's an exciting thing is seeing a lot of that rhetoric that expanded. You know, honestly, I think a large part of it is the popularity of not just Mom Donnie's campaign in New York, but this full year of governance of really pushing through these policies quickly. I think they've managed to, you know, I've mentioned this before, keep that popularity. There's this common refrain of like, we want our Mom Donnie. Well, a bunch of a bunch of cities went out and got theirs or a bunch of people, you know, voted copacetic politicians into the state legislature.
18:26Chad Scott: And I think that's something that makes it feel a lot more. Maybe there was a reaction getting people out to the polls, but a lot of people saw that moment and said, hey, this is this is our time to refocus the Democratic Party on values that actually benefit the voters. And I think that's really exciting. Before I get to my second optimism, do you guys have anything else to say about that? no i just i mean i'm i will say just briefly that i'm super happy for all of these cities that are are experiencing that and i i made a comment that um i'll be the downer this time on that is i sit here in idaho and it's like being a kid at the orphanage watching all of these other other people get scooped up by loving families and i'm still waiting for our loving family to show up, someone who gives a crap and cares here in Idaho and doesn't just want to help out big business.
19:22But yeah, I'm glad for everyone. I'm hoping that it'll trickle eventually. One person commented on that when I said that online. They said, we're fixing it in Texas and then we'll come get you. I'm like, all right. So yeah.
19:35Chad Scott: I mean, I didn't think I'd see Texas with a Democratic governor and senator at the same time. that's remarkable so i doesn't even speaking of you know i said there were more races than i was even following i did not think that the governor's race in texas was even going to be close that blew my mind yeah i thought talrico was going because he's such an amazing candidate but i didn't think and he had so much money pumped into that campaign the the moment i first turned on the news on an election night and they always show the florida results first you know florida's so fast and on the East Coast, when I saw how close it was in Florida, I mean, it was like, what, seven o 'clock at night, 730 in the evening.
20:16I was like, this is over. Like the whole country, this is, if Florida is that close, there's going to be a ton of blue on the map. And sure enough, it was, and so, but even like you said with Texas, I would have never imagined that. Like that was, that was crazy. I kind of half expected Tallarico had a really good chance to win, but I really didn't think that they would vote out Greg Abbott for a Hispanic woman. I really didn't. I didn't think she had a chance and she blew him away.
20:50Chad Scott: Yeah, and not to make everything about demographics, but that is surprising in a conservative state. Yeah, it matters. Texas is largely Mexican. And I think we think of these things as red states and blue states, but these states are not just demographically, but they are way more ethnically diverse than people realize. You know, Georgia is another one that people seem to think is this conservative state. It's got this huge Democratic population, huge black population. Big night in Georgia, big night in Texas. I think we're seeing that this idea of firmly red and blue states is eroding a little bit.
21:30Chad Scott: And I believe that the red and blue state phrasing and calling things red and blue states came from election analysis in 2000 of the Gore v. Bush election. This is one of our downstream effects of the adoption of the 24-hour news cycle. But it's not like we didn't say Democratic or Republican states before that, but you would generally say Republican led or a very conservative state or like a Democratic leaning state. The concept of swing states absolutely existed. But this polarized terminology, even though we all understand that states aren't all red or all blue, people on all sides of the aisle use that terminology.
22:10Chad Scott: And to some degree, there's this linguistic determinism of we accept the parameters that we speak with. And I think, you know, I'm not scolding any of us for later in the episode when we slip up and say red state or blue state. But I think and I hope that the way that we discuss politics can start to evolve in a way where we understand that states are I mean, state borders are somewhat arbitrary. State culture exists, but states are all nuanced. And more commonly, people want to be able to afford to eat and get to and from work in every state. So that has nothing to do with whether you're a red or a blue state.
22:45Yeah, well, not to rain on our joy parade here, I do have some concerns, though. And make no mistake, when I talk about concerns, this is within the context of this was an astounding win. And I was extremely happy for what happened. But as I was at the watch party, I saw this exuberance that was welcomed and it was wonderful. But I almost worry that it becomes a almost an ignorant exuberance where you start to think everything is going to be all right. And we're heading into, I think, a dangerous two months here where right now I'm surprised. I'm seeing a Donald Trump that is I almost think he's scared.
23:29I think he's shocked and scared. So he's coming going online and he's saying, like, I'm totally going to work with the Democrats. And today he's like, Mom, Don, he's doing a great job. in New York and he's talking about all of the great things that are taking place. And I'm sitting here looking at a lot of the joy that the left rightfully has and going, we need to make sure not only are we pumping the brakes on our joy when things happen and we see what the next two months could bring, this lame duck Congress, the Republicans still control everything. We won't take over until January 3rd, obviously.
24:11And a lot of things can happen. And the one thing that I'm very, very concerned about is Supreme Court appointments. Clarence Thomas is like 78 years old. Samuel Alito is 76. Neither have announced any plans to retire. They're kind of stubborn old men that feel power right now and they're using it. But if they decide to step down or pressured into that, you could see a replacement with a simple majority. It doesn't require 60 votes. And that simple majority means that, yeah, sure, we're replacing a conservative justice with another conservative justice. But the difference is we're replacing it with a conservative justice that'll serve for the next 20 to 30 years.
24:51And that could be a big problem. I have concerns about Republican spending packages. There's another budget reconciliation bill that's going to fund the war in Iran, potentially. And reconciliation bills can avoid the Senate's normal 60-vote filibuster. We have a regular funding bill on December 11th that will see Republicans potentially push for long-term ICE funding. And ICE is already funded through 27. So that's not changing. so we can change the policies within Congress but in the executive they have the money and they have the the marching orders and that so and then obviously we've all seen it we've talked about it the potential for after the midterms Iran erupting into something that Donald Trump's like well screw it I don't have anyone holding me back anymore I don't have to worry about elections I can make this even worse and we we already see the the ground being laid Netanyahu whispering oh they're making chemical weapons now and they're going to, and they're using the WMD excuse.
25:50And Trump doesn't need Congress to pass an authorization. Clearly he just does it. And so for the next two months, we could see an escalation in Iran that is far worse than what we've seen previously. So I do have concerns about that stuff. What are your thoughts on that?
26:08Chad Scott: Do you want to hear the second optimistic thing I have that connects to that? Oh, yeah. Sorry. No, it's fine. It's brief. It's just that I think we saw a really strong repudiation of AIPAC-endorsed candidates, of AIPAC-funded candidates at the polls. And I think that does not do anything for us in the next two months, and it doesn't guarantee anything in the following two years. But I think the fact that so many candidates are openly critical of funding Israel, openly, openly, you know, pledging to see not only military funding, but in many cases, all funding to Israel. There are definitely candidates I'd like to see be stronger on their language around that or be clear.
26:49Chad Scott: But I think we saw a pretty major shift in whether it was necessary to cooperate with AIPAC as a Democrat, whether it was toxic to criticize Israel in every way. I mean, this is a pretty major shift in very recent years. And I think that this election is the largest results of that, where we've seen candidates, you know, at the biggest example being El-Sayed beating Haley Stevens, one of the largest recipients, I think$36 million of APEC donations or of pro-Israel PAC donations for Haley Stevens. We saw her defeated by a candidate who didn't take any of that money. And we saw that be a big part of his campaign.
27:31Chad Scott: So I don't again, I don't think that gives us a lot of chance of fighting Trump's collaboration with Netanyahu over the next two months. How do you think that affects our ability to rein Trump in during the following two years after this new Congress is sworn in? I think I would say let's see if it sticks. You know, it was very odd to see Donald Trump come out on Election Day morning and say we're cutting off Israel. I mean, that's basically what he said. And I thought, they must know something. Like, things must be a lot worse than we think they are, you know, with the election. I'm sure they have a lot of data that we don't have.
28:06But to see Donald Trump, you know, a man that committed to a war on the words of Israel, to come out and just say that, like, out of nowhere. And then you have, you know, Netanyahu coming out or some official with Israel come out and say, we know nothing about this. And then you're wondering, like, OK, is this another one of the Donald Trump fly by his seat kind of statements or like, you know. But, yeah, I think the sort of. I really don't know how to say it, but the sort of loyalty and service to that country that we've had for a long time, for whatever reason, whether it's, you know, geopolitical leverage in the Middle East or whether it's a religious thing, whatever it is, I really don't.
28:53personally care what the reason is. It's too much for me. I think that's going to be blunted a lot. But to the extent of how impactful it is, I don't really know, because I half expect Republicans to kind of go back to their old ways once sort of the sting of this is worn off. On the other hand, maybe this is a severe enough rebuke that they actually change some of their behaviors. So I I can't really say with any certainty that I have a strong opinion on it. But I myself has asked for a long time why we give Israel so much money because they're a wealthy country. This is genuinely a country that doesn't need our help.
29:36And I'm, you know, although I am probably a lot more conservative when it comes to how much aid we hand out other countries, I never had a problem with us helping countries or people that need it. And I just never felt like Israel needed it, you know.
29:53Chad Scott: And I think it's worth noting also as to your point just there that we saw a reduction. You know, this is going to mark a shift in AIPAC-backed politicians in the Democratic Party, but also in the Republican Party. We're seeing a reduction. So I don't know if that's going to spring back at any point soon. But I do think it's becoming more, I mean, it's certainly no longer politically toxic to be a Democrat who has ever said anything negative about Israel, which was the case for decades. And so I don't know if, you know, if we're we've kind of inverted it to the point where support for the genocide is toxic, at least among certain voter bases, as I strongly believe it should be from an ethical standpoint.
30:31Chad Scott: I hope that stays. I do think the potential snapback you're describing could be different in the Democratic Party and in the Republican Party. Chad, what are your thoughts on all that? Well, I mean, I think a lot of it, again, it's just the MAGA, we see a, I don't want to say a common enemy because Israel is technically not our enemy, but what's happening is you have the MAGA base. They are wanting to be truly America first. That's what they were sold. And that's not, Israel's not America first. And then you have the stop funding, the genocide in Gaza, stop funding what Israel's doing with the settlements in the West Bank on the left.
31:13And so you have a kind of a meeting of, yeah, this, we both have come to a common understanding that, that we want to stop helping Israel do these things. But I do think that once the major problem of Netanyahu is gone, I, I'm, which I do believe that even though the election is still kind of up in the air for Israel right now, they have a way different election. and they do a parliamentary election. So they have to choose within their own parliament the leadership. Once Netanyahu is neutered or removed or whatever, I think you're going to see a heavy softening on the right of, and potentially even the left in what we focus on when it comes to Israel.
31:57But I also think that AIPAC is going to have to be very much more strategic in how their money goes because the old reliable, throw it at Republicans in swing states is just not there. Clearly, this was a big rebuke against AIPAC. We're seeing Netanyahu, who has been charged as a war criminal, rightfully so. The morals of the United States actually came out here somewhat against Israel on both sides, whether the morals were, I want more for me as an American, or I want the genocide to stop. those came together and because of that the money just didn't matter as much and i think that's a broader situation across all of the financing you look at someone who is so immoral and disgusting as an elon musk for instance throwing enormous record amounts of money like 400 what was it 446 million dollars at the races across the country trying to get tal rico uh defeated in texas and And you just see this groundswell of people and the grassroots overriding that money.
33:08And I think you see a lot of the billionaires, not necessarily spooked, but they have to rethink how they're going to do this. AIPAC has to rethink how they're going to do this. The whole Citizens United thing has to rethink how they're going to do this. Unfortunately, they are smart and they will figure it out. So we will have to have legislation down the road to counter it. And I said this before, Elon Musk throwing$400 million at an election is basically nothing to him. And I get he's not super liquid in his cash, but when you're worth$900 billion, that's like basically someone who's worth$100 ,000 losing 50 bucks.
33:45He didn't lose a lot of money relative to his net worth. No, he'll earn it back in like a day and a half. Yeah. And so that's why he's not crying about it right now. That's not why he's not out there worried about his investors and stuff. it's relatively, it's a 0.05 % of his net worth is what he spent on this election. And he got, he got his ass beat. Absolutely. But that's like betting 50 bucks on a horse and your horse coming in last, you're going to walk away going, Oh, well, whatever. And so I just hope that this, I hope that money becomes less and less impactful. And with the democratic Congress, I hope that they can do things that make camp through campaign finance reform and finding a way to override the Supreme court decision on citizens United as a way to eliminate the billionaire influence.
34:32That's really all it is. It's singular people influencing entire elections for states, and they have enormous power relative to the average voter. And that's not how our system was supposed to be designed. And so I hope that's one of the policies Democrats go after for sure.
34:48Chad Scott: Yeah, I'm seeing a lot of people react like, isn't it great that Elon Musk wasted all this money? That's not why that's good, because what he did was fund a bunch of pro-authoritarian PR firms with half a billion dollars. That money is staying in that same ecosystem. It's not trickling down to the people. It's not like, oh, he accidentally donated it to Planned Parenthood or something. But, oh, damn, all that money goes to mutual aid now. But I think you're right. The big takeaway is that the money means less right now and that we're seeing more grassroots organization be successful. We're seeing, I think an interesting that we're seeing, you know, I worried when New York City DSA ran multiple congressional campaigns right after, you know, one year after, months after, because of the primary is the really important election, months after Zoran won the general, which was a hard fought race.
35:42Chad Scott: I thought, wow, it took all that effort just to, you know, to win this primary and win this general because we had Cuomo in the race. How is the same organization going to win all these races? And we won, I believe, nine out of 10 races. And the thing I learned is that this stuff is galvanizing, like it grows, it doesn't, it's similar to the voter base, it's there's not a locked in amount of enthusiasm that can be harnessed. So I hope that means, like you're saying that PAC money and major corporate spending has had less of an effect. I do hope that we can, you know, overturn Citizens United as well and get a lot of this money out of politics, I hope that we can pass a law that prevents Congress people and senators from effectively insider trading or holding stocks while they are legislating on the businesses that they hold stocks in or passing laws that would affect business in America in general.
36:40Chad Scott: But I think the general social rejection of that spending And the fact that people are really coming together to volunteer for campaigns to fight that and the campaigns are getting small donations and winning is really incredible. And that is something that doesn't feel like it's going to just disappear overnight. Yeah, I had a question for Matt, though. One thing that surprised me, where was big energy at? We always hear about them. Maybe it was because Elon Musk eclipsed everything. but this is the type of election where green energy although it's not overtly being talked about as a primary policy initiative after maybe democrats work through some of the more core issues they're going to turn and focus on that and that could end up hurting i think big energy in my opinion maybe i'm wrong but in your space matt where where was big energy big oil they they usually are very hardcore Republican and I didn't see them make a peep in the Texas race at all, or maybe they did and it just wasn't effective enough.
37:43So I think it's important to note that when big energy or big oil shows up a lot in elections, it's because they're drug into it. They don't want to have any part in any of elections mostly. And when we talk about the money that was raised for Donald Trump in his last election, And that wasn't from big energy. That was from some individuals who happened to be in the business. Oil companies, they don't donate any money at all or endorse any candidates at all in any elections. You know, you'll never see on a national level. They will spread around some money at local levels. But big oil historically tends to stay away from elections.
38:25And so, like I said, you know, however much money ended up being donated to Donald Trump in 24, that came from a few individuals that happened to be very wealthy and it was attributed to all of big oil. That's not really how it works. So the only time you'll hear about big energy or big oil in an election is when one side or the other drags them into it. And it never really became a topic. Now, I don't know, you know, of those individuals that donated to Trump. I don't know how any of them donated or did anything at all. It never came up, as you said. It was never a topic during this election.
39:02I'm sure it'll be a topic again in the next election. People tend to focus on that more in presidential elections and midterms. But yeah, it's not unusual, especially in a midterm election, for people not to be talking about energy a lot. That's usually a presidential election type thing. But if you go back and look at all of Donald Trump's donations from what has been labeled big oil, you'll just see individual names and it's people that are rich in the industry. You're not going to get an ExxonMobil ever endorsing a company or a candidate or donating money. It's literally against their policies.
39:43They don't do that. They never have. And you have your individuals who are big names, like your Harold Hamm from Oklahoma, who initially in 24 pulled his donation from Trump and said he wasn't going to donate and then later gave it back. And then you have the Kelsey guy from, you know, the midstream company. I can't even think of it now. But it's always a few big name, very wealthy billionaire individuals that donate all that money. And it's not the industry itself.
40:11Chad Scott: Although I would add that private utilities do donate under the name of the utility. Yes. They donate the max to their favorite candidates every year. And as I said, these oil companies will donate to local things, local elections or local referendums or local issues on local ballots. But they stay clear of national politics and they're always just drug into it. I saw kind of a funny meme about Jerry Jones where, speaking of the big oil, the guy's owner of Dallas Cowboys saying Texans should be used to unlikable old men losing. They have Jerry Jones and the Cowboys. So I just thought it was a good – his sports – but I have a question.
40:52So not to steal host duties here, but I have a question for you, Nat. We kind of chatted. Mute his mic. Jameel, unmute his mic. we had so we had a kind of an interesting conversation when we were uh kind of in the green room about the cultural impact of um the shift i mean we we talked specifically about like target when you see like this swing the businesses swing back and forth as they see the the public opinion swing back and forth from blue to red are i mean you are in the mecca not that you're a major like capitalist consumer or anything in new york city but you're like in the mecca of consumerism to be a major consumer i live in new york city yeah exactly but are you i mean you you seem to pretty read into some interesting things in the pop culture whether it's in the movie scene or whether it's in entertainment or whatever are you do you think there's going to be this big swing from the yellowstone manly man like maga i mean it's interesting we always see i i have to believe
41:52Chad Scott: to some degree. And I want to say, I'd love to move this or transition as we talk about this into essentially, how do we avoid a huge retraction? How do we make steps going forward? How do we move forward effectively? How does Congress do that? And how do we as people who want left-leaning values and humanitarian values to prevail, what do we as constituents and voters and citizens or even non-citizen residents or whoever is listening or Canadian listeners out there? What can any of our listeners do to sort of keep their feet to the fire on this stuff? And I think one of the interesting things to talk about is, yeah, does culture precede political shifts or vice versa?
42:40Chad Scott: And I think there is this huge belief among liberals that culture precedes politics. And to some extent, I have to believe that's true. I literally wouldn't be doing this podcast if I didn't think media could affect the way that people feel about things. And I know that media and not just news media, but like stories, you know, everything from from novels to superhero comics I read as a kid strongly affected how I see the world, how I see ethics, how I see politics. So I do believe that that's true. And then conservatives tend to see it the other way around, which is that politics set the world of media and therefore the media ought to be reinforcing conservative values if conservatives are in power.
43:27Chad Scott: And this isn't my analysis. This is a known phenomenon. But what's interesting about that is that as much as we think of Hollywood as being liberal, media corporations are not liberal. Media corporations are over their corporations. So they are inherently owned by billionaires and are conservative. So what you see is you see them betting on conservatism a lot. And I was talking to Chad, but I told him this anecdote. I didn't remember this, but my fiance reminded me of it the other day, which was that I think before Trump won, the most recent time, we were going to see a movie and there was a preview.
44:05Chad Scott: You're saying Yellowstone, but there was a preview for Twisters playing. And this is a movie that, you know, coming out when it came out, sequel to a movie about a major weather event. not a mention of climate change, just like a good guy with a five o 'clock shadow and a strong jaw who's going to drive his pickup truck right at that tornado, that twister, and get it. And apparently, I didn't remember this, but apparently I said out loud in the theater, damn, they must think Trump is going to win. And I think I was right. I think they were betting big on conservative pandering media becoming popular again.
44:44Chad Scott: And you saw a lot of that. But even A24 did this movie about the Iraq War, which I was like, where is this coming from? A24, which is just another brand, but they're very beloved and the educated left in terms of being elevated art films. And they're making this movie that's kind of glorifying the Iraq War. And I think you're seeing – you see a lot of people betting on that. So to transition to, you know, what do we as what do we as voters expect? What do we as citizens expect to see? And what do we what can we do and what can we be vigilant about? I think we got to watch out for the idea that media is ensuring our values.
45:27Chad Scott: I think that we can talk about our values and reinforce them and give examples via media. But I think one of the major things that we have to look away from is that corporations, they'll flip flop immediately. You know, you're talking about Target. It's like Target. Gay, you know, gay marriage passes. Target starts selling pride gear. Trump wins. Target. Rainbows off the shelf. You know, it was a drab July for a couple of years. You could only get like plaid at Target. target's going to put out the rainbow flag t-shirts and sweatshirts made in china by slaves this summer they're doing it a hundred percent and i think one of the things that we have to look out for i'm not just saying don't fund target people are already boycotting target but that's an example of not only just being pandered to but it's also sort of an example of celebrating a victory that didn't happen right it's like oh we've shifted the culture It's like, no, you haven't.
46:22Chad Scott: You've given money to someone who's profiting off of both sides. So that's one of my like, and that's for voters. But I think that there's something we need in politics and as constituents to be really wary of is these aesthetic ideas of progress. Like, is this really progress or are people just saying this thing I believe more often in a way that can immediately be revoked? Because I think we saw a lot of that. Like, oh, the Oscars got diverse this year. Well, who cares? The second that Trump wins, the Oscars are going to be a bunch of white guys winning again. It's a propaganda machine. So I think that's one thing where I would encourage listeners to just watch out for like, are we winning real battles or are we punishing the people we don't like?
47:04Chad Scott: Are we winning petty aesthetic battles? Are we bullying the bullies? And I think a lot of liberal response to conservatism is let's bully them the way we're bullying us and they're bullying us. And it didn't work. So I think, you know, or like, let's celebrate the fact that we're so righteous is this other thing of like, look at how we're displaying our values by purchasing the right products. And that also didn't work. So I think that's something we need to need to be wary of. yeah i get concerned about like the we won and then the the kabuki theater of it all this performative exaggerated like gestures that we we have where oh look at us when we need to have something substantive and then you go to someone like myself or or even matt and you're like what what is the where the rubber meets the road what needs to happen and um i i guess yeah that that that would be my question for both of you.
48:02Cause I, I think it's kind of fun being kind of in the middle of here because you guys are different in this aspect where, what do you, what do you need to see? What do we need to see here for this to be real? I mean, is it a change in leadership? Is it a, is it a change in, and by leadership, I mean, democratic leadership, not obviously Trump, but, or is it something more substantive? Like Matt, what do you want to see happen for this to be real for you and not just a theatrical performance of hooray, we did it, and then more just concerned citizens and sternly worded letters.
48:37Chad Scott: Yeah, and let's focus first on what we need to see from government. I know I started with a thing that we as constituents should watch out for, but what do you feel like a Democratic-led Congress or Democratic-led government needs to accomplish, or what can we do to avoid that retraction? The things that I would like to see the most are, besides the obvious check on Donald Trump's power, is restoration of funding to – was that Medicare from the big, beautiful bill? Or Medicaid. I get those backwards sometimes. But restoration of that funding, restoration of the Affordable Care Health Care Act, subsidies that were cut.
49:20The things that are strangling Americans the most financially are the things that I would like to see quickly. Doesn't mean it's going to happen. And restoration of the checks on the president. Those are my big things. But more importantly than those things, it's not enough to just do it. It's not enough to do it. the Biden administration did a lot of things and they never sold those things to the American people. It doesn't make a shit what you do if the American people don't know it, because it's not enough to sell it in Congress and get it passed. Once you do that, you have to continue selling it every day to the American people so they understand what you accomplished.
50:01And at the end of the Biden administration, half the people in the United States had no clue what had been accomplished under the Biden administration. And because of that failure in messaging, which is a chronic illness with the Democratic Party, they lost a lot of the things they accomplished. You know, it does you no good to hit home runs when you allow the fans to throw the ball back on the fucking field and it don't count anymore because you didn't sell it to the American people. That's what I'm saying. You have to, Democrats have to get their messaging straight. Winning the election, they didn't win this election on messaging.
50:37This was not how they won. I will say the person that I felt had the best messaging in this election was probably Abdul El-Sayed. He was the one person that I could listen to and that when he would be asked some crazy-ass question, he would say, I want to talk about the issues. Why are you talking about this stupid shit? We need to be talking about what the American people want. He said that repeatedly day in, day out. He didn't go down the rabbit hole. He was very effective in his messaging in a way that I haven't seen Democrats do in forever. And Tallarico was really good at it, too. I got to give Tallarico props.
51:17But overall, the Democratic Party is horrible. And it doesn't matter what you accomplish, if the people don't know about it, to put you back in office or to reinforce your existence there so you can cement those things to stay, those policies to actually remain. And that's another huge thing I want to see from the Democratic Party is a huge improvement in how they communicate with the American people.
51:41Chad Scott: Yeah, I think one thing that's so admirable about El-Sayed is just that message discipline. Like there's just not a moment when he can't be caught off guard. He's not changing the subject. He's not dodging questions. He's likening it to what the actual issue is or he's connecting it to what the actual issue is. And we talked a few episodes ago about that clip of him shutting down the Josh Hawley intern who was pretending to be a random citizen at a town hall. But he's also, you know, message, message, discipline to the point of being willing to say, I know why you're really asking me that, you know, like really on message to the point of.
52:20Chad Scott: Being able to threaten other people engaging in bad faith. And I think that's something it's tough, but it's something that Democrats have done poorly for a long time, which is, you know, they don't really know how to behave around someone who acts in bad faith. And Republicans get them on it every time. And, you know, there's the classic Michelle Obama. When they go low, we go high. And. Republicans don't care. They don't care that we go high like, oh, well, enjoy your moral victory. while we strip away your rights and take all your money. Like that shit didn't work. So it's way more effective to go, no, that's not true.
53:04Chad Scott: And I know you're lying. And here's why you're lying about it. And like, that's a level of message discipline where it's not just, oh, let me take it back to the issues. But like, let's talk about why that is a violation of this American value, right? Like, let's talk about why that is reinforcing this thing that is against what most Americans care about. And that's like, you know, you saw Sanders when he was running for president was amazing at that. I always talk about the moment where he had a heart attack and then tweeted from his hospital bed about how good his healthcare was. You know, obviously, Mom Donnie was another of just like, no matter how many times they asked him about Israel, he would talk about how New Yorkers couldn't afford their utility bills and how our money going to Israel, you know, how we should be supporting New Yorkers instead.
53:54Chad Scott: And yeah, I think we need more Democrats willing to do that. The thing I would add and not disagree with Matt here, but the thing I would add is that it's not just messaging. The Biden administration did a lot of good things, but you also need to be ethically consistent. The Biden administration started a genocide. And that's a huge part of why, you know, when we're like, wow, blue wave, it's a little hard for me to be excited about the party that, I mean, Israel's been doing this for years, but the party that started the current wave of genocide in Gaza, that's the Democrats, man. Like a lot of the people who, the team that these guys are all joining, a lot of the people who are still on that team voted to authorize, you know, the most recent funding for the IDF.
54:39Chad Scott: God, there's still people in the Democrats who voted to condemn socialism in America. Just embarrassing shit like that. So I think a big part of this is like when you tell voters what you're doing, like a big reason that I don't know, the Mamdani administration has been successful is that they've focused on practical gains and they advertise them. But it's consistent with the campaign promises. It's they don't do this double step thing that Democrats often do, which is like we have to change X, Y and Z. And then they get in the office and they go, hey, be realistic. Incremental change is how we make a difference.
55:11Chad Scott: And then they meet Republicans halfway and lose territory and then lose the next election. So I totally agree that they need to advertise what they're doing. But I think that consistency of message also has to be a part of it. Like, we're learning that you can't play both sides of the aisle anymore. You can't have, you know, corporate donors that hurt you, you know, that are actively contributing to hurting your constituents. And I'm hoping that that is part of what sticks. First of all, I'm already seeing it in my comments and it's very frustrating, this notion of, well, we don't have the votes.
55:43We don't have a veto-proof majority. I don't care. What do Republicans do with so much less?
55:50Chad Scott: They stopped a Supreme Court nomination. Exactly. And that's my point is I don't care if you think – you know you're going to lose. Put it forward and force the Republicans to say no. Force Donald Trump to veto it so that it's on his record and we can use it. And then over time in 28, then maybe we'll get to that point where eventually we will have the majority in Congress and the presidency to do the things. In the meantime, do it anyway. And there's some quick wins that I think, and these are people, I worry that there's this notion that Democrats can't walk and chew bubble gum at the same time, where they can't, we got to just focus on one thing.
56:27These are things that can happen simultaneously. Like you can block judicial appointments indefinitely until Trump is out of office. I personally believe Trump has lost the privilege of picking his people until he's out of office because he picks people like fucking Pete Hegseth. So if a Trump nominee comes forward or a Trump judge comes forward, the Senate confirmation procedure just says, nope, shut it down. We're not doing that. And it would have to be a major concession on something else. like Medicare reform or even universal healthcare, something like that. Another one that is fairly easy, Epstein files.
57:10Just follow the law, launch the hearings, issue subpoenas. You can do, the Congress has special investigative subcommittees that they can launch. These committees are going to be a massive power for the Democrats. It's something that we haven't had, but because committees hold a lot of power, and the Democrats are taking over it, there's going to be a lot of movement in that. Pete Hegseth, I personally think Pete Hegseth is going to either resign or be fired by Trump before they haul his ass before Congress because he's such a dipshit and squirrely that he'll say some stuff that gets everyone in trouble.
57:44And so I think he will probably not. They still can. They can still subpoena him as a civilian. Be like, come tell us about all this stuff. And that includes things like the Venezuela situation. operations that are, we're basically just murdering people. We're in the Gulf and the East Pacific. Elon Musk before Congress to talk about all the nonsense with Doge, where he got a hold of something like all of our social security numbers. Like that's a huge violation. The Star Shield situation we talked about in a previous episode, we can start having these discussions and people are like, well, we don't want to focus on the impeachments.
58:27And I for one, and we talked about this now, I don't think trying to impeach Trump is a good idea. And I know there's a, there'll be a lot of pushback there, but, uh, my concern is twofold. One, it's going to eat a lot of time, a presidential impeachment. If you, I don't know if you remember the last one, it was Trump, obviously that ate so much time. And we got two years to prove to the American people that things can get done, but also what, what if it works? And that would be amazing. We would all high five, but then we're looking at JD Vance and JD Vance can stand up there and go, yeah, it was all Trump's fault, all of this.
59:00And he's relatively smart that he will start doing the things that people want, like pulling back from Israel. He's already talked about it. He's already distancing himself. Rubio is talking about resigning. These are people that are abandoning ship. The rats are jumping off the MAGA ship right now, and they're going to find a way. And if we don't, and if Trump stays in power, it's hard. It's, it's, it's either the devil, you know, or you're, you're dealing with someone who might be smart enough to win in 28 and all of it becomes for not. So looking at all of that, uh, those quick hitters, I think we can, we can show the American people that we're serious about some of the things they're concerned about, but also obviously we need to start holding hearings about things like the Iran war and congressional war powers, uh, come out with a statement.
59:50saying we as Congress absolutely support Ukraine and NATO and we'll do everything we can. I know that the president holds a lot of power in foreign policy. So whether it's moving equipment, whether it's stuff going to Taiwan or Ukraine or whatever, that would reinforce our commitments to them. But Congress can still come out as a strong body saying we won't allow you guys to be hurt anymore by Trump, but we still have to operate within the fact that Congress can't stop Trump from sending Kushner and Whitcoff to Russia to, to fricking bow down before Putin. So I think those things making strong statements and examining the weapons transfers we do to Israel, are those weapons being used against Gazans?
1:00:34Are they being used against Palestinians? Stuff like that. Um, the congressional, actually you touched on this, the congressional ethics, uh, the Senate already banned the Cauchy and Polymarket the prediction markets House do that too. Ban it just across the board in that I think there's just a lot we can do up front and I know housing affordability is a big one. Let's get the tariffs the workers, security, healthcare reform absolutely reproductive rights. That's something that we should focus on and voting protection. There's a lot that can happen, but I think they should triage it and just come out hard saying we did this, this, this we won here.
1:01:20They voted against us. We got a veto here, but we can start keeping that scorecard. And it's something that I think will absolutely show the American people heading into 28, that there is movement. And in mom, Donnie is a prime example of it. He hit the ground and just started filling potholes and fixing shit. And everyone was like, Hey, this is pretty fucking good. It would be real nice. If the federal government was like this, and I truly think that if they take that approach, they will end up in a place in 2028 where we can do the big sweeping stuff because we've handled some of the little stuff in these initial stages.
1:01:59Chad Scott: Yeah, and I want to liken this to I want to bring in another piece of information here, which is Matt's excellent American Power Extra from this week Americans are checking out, which is all about effectively analyzing this Bureau of Labor Statistics study showing how little time Americans are spending around other people or doing leisure activities like reading for pleasure, but also how little institutional trust is left in the media, government. all of our major institutions, governmental and non-governmental, are at nearly record low approval or levels of trust. This, to me, feels like a moment.
1:02:40Chad Scott: As I keep saying, it's not a fixed number of people. This feels like a galvanizing moment. I don't think, and if you haven't listened to that episode, pause here, go back and download that, listen to it, come back here, and jump back in, and you're back. Great. I think that in order to combat that, this isn't the answer to that. This is the beginning. This is an opportunity to start combating it. I think it's like I said, it's not just enough to brand what you're doing and advertise it well. It's to really live your values. And I think for the longest time, Democrats have paid aesthetic and lip service to disenfranchised minorities that are the core of their base, while supporting policies that don't provide education, health care, long term health for those people and or for all Americans, you know, but people from disenfranchised minorities are disenfranchised populations are disproportionately affected by lacks of health care and things like that.
1:03:37Chad Scott: I think a lot of what Democrats have done is, you know, paint a sidewalk or rainbow in a town where no one can afford to get public transportation because it's not funded. You know, I think we need to focus, like you're saying, get some big wins, get some pragmatic wins early, try to focus on actually meeting the needs of constituents. And again, I don't think it's nearly as red state and blue state as we've been led to believe. I think a lot of our values are more common than that. And I think, you know, we're seeing this clear rejection of AIPAC on both sides. I think you can't walk that, that you can't straddle that fence anymore.
1:04:12Chad Scott: I think a big one, therefore, in the Democratic Party is the leadership. You know, Schumer and Jeffrey's have just been writing checks for Israel for years at this point. And not only that, but have proven themselves. You know, you want to look at this last election cycle. I'm sure they're going to say, well, look how well the Democratic Party did. Chuck Schumer endorsed Haley. He recruited Haley Stevens. Chuck Schumer recruited Alex Vindman, who lost to Angie Nixon in Florida, said he would campaign for her and then didn't. chuck schumer could have poured some support into that florida race and gotten angie nixon over the line at a very tight race democratic party failed her there was there was a lot of things our leadership could have done that might not get noticed because it was such a successful night overall but they can't take credit for all these progressive wins for all these socialist democratic socialist wins that's happening within their party and they've been fighting it for a long time and refusing to endorse those candidates because, quite frankly, they at least Jeffries is likely to face a primary challenge in two years.
1:05:27Chad Scott: And, you know, we oppose all of his donors, too. But I think first start, I mean, and I'm not the first person to call for this. I think the idea of Chuck Schumer and Jeffries leading the party as speaker is toxic at this point, toxic to growing a Democratic Party. And I think I would I'm curious what you guys think about that. But Democratic leadership is already asking, like, you know, acting like they're a walk in like a shoe in, you know, and to remind you, Jeffries is also a guy who's been taking private meetings with the Kushners. You know, this is not the hard line Democrat who's going to fight for us.
1:06:04Chad Scott: What are your thoughts on that? Do you think that's even possible? The thing that bothers me the most about this and I got to do it, I have been a hater of Chuck Schumer for as long as I've known who Chuck Schumer is. So this is, this is nothing new. And remember, I'm speaking as an independent. I'm not a member of the Democratic Party, but I do not like either one of these guys. I don't think they're what the Democratic Party needs and I don't like them. And I got to tell you this, when I heard, what I've been hearing a lot is no one wants to challenge Hakeem Jeffries because he would be the first black speaker.
1:06:40And while I completely celebrate and acknowledge these types of accomplishments, I don't give a shit about him being the first black speaker. We need a speaker that is the best speaker, whether he's black, white, whatever. I don't care. So the fact that that language is already out sort of in the atmosphere, that alone just bothers me. You know, oh, we we we really need to get the first black speaker. You know what? Some things are more important than having the first black speaker. And I don't like Hakeem Jeffries for whatever reason. He's done absolutely nothing in Trump's term to combat anything Trump has done.
1:07:21And, you know, people will say, well, he's limited. Even his just speaking about things Trump has done is apparently limited, too. Like, he hasn't spoken out enough even to me. Like, even if all you have is your voice, use it. So I'm not a fan of Chuck Schumer. Not a fan of Hakeem Jeffries. I agree with you 100%. Chuck Schumer could have flipped, assuming he is the guy that was in control of the money. He could have flipped the entire state of Florida. He could have. They got zero money.
1:07:49Chad Scott: Nixon's funding compared to Tallarico. It's incredible. I mean, it's a magnitude larger. Yeah. And even if you just support one of the candidates, you know, that will have a huge impact down ballot. like it's not just about supporting uh the uh angie nixon it's about how that lifts up the entire party in that state and in that race so i agree with you that that was a huge failure but i think in all of this sort of you know feeling of even though we're going into winter it feels like springtime where everything's new and it's i believe i believe the speakers need to be new to. I believe that the leaders need to be new to.
1:08:33And, you know, Chuck Schumer can go home as far as I'm concerned. I don't even care if he stays in Congress. I don't feel that strongly about Hakeem Jeffries, but he's too institutional. He's too much in the pocket of too many, you know, I'm not sure of his relationship with AIPAC. I'm sure it's huge. But these are the things that that the democratic party can do to prove to the voters that they themselves want to change as well. And the way it's looking, they're already not going to do it. So I'm all for neither one of those guys getting their, their positions regardless of their race. I don't think race should be a consideration for who gets to lead an entire party.
1:09:18Chad Scott: I mean, it's what I said earlier. It's very important. It is what you do. It matters that we have people of color in government. It matters that we have people who demographically represent the people in our country. I do think that matters. I also, like I said, I think Keisha Lance Bottoms is a much bigger deal than Kamala Harris being vice president because she has good politics. Because I think she'll, more specifically, I think that she'll make decisions and support policies that also benefit all the little black girls for whom it's, oh, good to see a black woman in government. She'll also help them find education and fund their communities.
1:09:54Chad Scott: And Hakeem Jeffries is shipping our money away to Israel. Hakeem Jeffries would be the first black speaker, but he represents a largely black community in New York that has suffered from massive fossil fuel pollution, and he takes fossil fuel money. You know, he's not making decisions in the interests of marginalized people, whether they're black or of other marginalized communities, domestically or abroad. And again, he's taking secret meetings with the Kushners. So I think they both got to go. I think they are both among larger AIPAC donors in the Democratic Party. I mean, there are no Haley Stevens.
1:10:32But, you know, let me put it this way.
1:10:36Chad Scott: Mike Rogers, Speaker of the House, think about 1 ,001 ,000 in AIPAC donations. Hakeem Jeffries, 1 ,400 ,000, if I'm remembering those numbers correctly. So what's the shift in policy there? Israel's got a bigger control of our government if we let Jeffries. Again, red and blue states don't exist. Red and blue congressmen don't exist if they all have the same donors. And again, I'm not going to be the, oh, both parties are the same kind of person. But that's the exact way that you disillusion people. Anytime you have evidence that both parties are the same, anytime both parties act under the, you know, for the benefit of the exact same donor.
1:11:17Chad Scott: Yeah, you're going to drive up this checked out disillusionment among potential voters. And this is such a crucial turning point where that needs to not happen. The tricky thing, and I'll remind you, that party leadership is determined via a secret ballot. So you can call you as the listener or you as the hypothetical person. You can call your representatives and tell them, hey, we need new leadership. There's no way of knowing who they voted for. so i highly encourage people to sign petitions and call their leadership and put the pressure on them but it's going to be tough it's going to be tough to twist the knife if they don't so it'll be interesting to see what actually happens and i i genuinely am open to hearing about but i'm not really sure what does it look like beyond calling our reps and signing petitions you know what does a political movement towards finding new speakers look like and i think one thing is that alternatives have to emerge.
1:12:16Chad Scott: I think someone's going to have to get endorsed by some pretty major democratic clubs or orgs or a DSA endorsed leader is going to have to emerge. And then we're going to have to start to see a camp, you know, as much as I think it was a mess, you're going to kind of need to see that groundswell of support that had Harris replaced Biden, right? Where you are going to see the culture interact with politics and you are going to see support become undeniable if this is to happen. I don't know if it's going to happen, but I think if it is, it is going to have to, in some extent, be a coordination there with a campaign for a strong alternative.
1:12:53Chad Scott: We don't have any other black congressmen? Come on. I was just going to ask, because you said call your congressman. I think Chad's in the same boat I am. I have no Democratic representation in my state to call. so if anyone wants to loan me their congressman from another state we're we're the orphans matt i'd be happy to call them uh we're one of the only states that didn't uh flip a single nationwide seat um one of the few that didn't and only and only flipped one statewide seat yeah we didn't flip anything we went harder and that was a purple seat already so registered democrat in a democrat control my vote counts twice that's that's the rule actually yeah if you're a registered democrat and you vote democrat it's a little little known don't clip this out of context that isn't true this is going to become like a conservative talking point when people find out i used to vote for the board of elections too it'll be like he's double voting trump retweeting us yeah exactly i think no i'm i am a registered democrat because New York has closed primaries.
1:14:02Chad Scott: And in order to vote in the primary, you have to be registered with the party. It's the same reason I'm a registered Republican, even though I don't vote Republican. Yeah, to affect the candidates, right? The primaries. I guess the question I have then is, who are the alternatives? I mean, if you look at... So before we get into that, just, and I know I kind of vilified the prediction markets, but they have... Prediction markets have Hakeem Jeffries at 92 % taking the house 78 % for Chuck Schumer. So they're, I mean, they're not shoe ins, but let's be honest, they're probably going to get it and it's going to suck.
1:14:34And I worry that again, it's going to be one of those, that type of thing right off the bat is going to disillusion voters. And there are better candidates. I'm not saying necessarily like a Bernie Sanders, cause I worry there's an age situation there or an Elizabeth Warren replacing Chuck Schumer, but we do have like, I don't know, maybe Chris Van Hollen, he was endorsed by Abdul El-Sayed to be the Senate leader. And this is a dude that is outspoken Palestinian rights guy, immigration enforcement. He is big on immigration accountability for ICE and things like that, as well as congressional accountability.
1:15:12But then you have like Chris Murphy, who is big in the campaign finance and economic inequality. and I just don't know who has enough firepower to overcome Chuck Schumer because I already heard Chuck Schumer talking about how this was a huge victory and his work was instrumental. And then on the House side, you have Hakeem Jeffries. The one that can't replace him or would probably – the one that we would love to replace him is AOC, but I think she's about to fire up a presidential campaign and I don't think she's going to go to become the speaker if she's going to have to go try to campaign. Maybe, maybe not.
1:15:53That's a lifelong position.
1:15:54Chad Scott: Not officially, but in many ways that is where political careers end and you kind of... Exactly. That's where you don't have a candidate that can't be president, but they're still really strong. Put them in the speaker exactly is what it is. But so you get like, I can't, and I never can pronounce his name. Is it Greg Kesar out of Texas? I think is what it is. He's a, and he's another, he, he falls in line with that progressive caucus, the organized labor, immigrant rights, progressive coalition building, and things like healthcare and education stuff. So he's really good in that regard, but let's be honest.
1:16:30These are, I'm naming people outside of the AOC that a lot of people are like, who, who is this? Who's that? And we're going to, but again, I understand that Hakeem Jeffries at one point was that kind of who person. And you have, there, there are several that are qualified. I just don't know. And I would love to see any one of these become speaker or Senate majority leader over Schumer and Jeffries. I just don't know if they have the firepower. AOC does. If AOC said, I want to do it, she would get it. They would take her. But I think you're right.
1:17:00Chad Scott: I think she's shoring up for a presidential run. And I think she's honestly one of our best chances for the next presidential general election. And people, I don't think we're going to waste that endorsement. And the thing is, is people, when we were in the theater, people groaned when I said John Ossoff, who just won, is going to look into a presidential campaign. That shit starts now, unfortunately. That's already starting. And if you want to see some, there's, I think you were not, I think people are looking for something different than like a Newsom or something like that. So if you get like a Shapiro or an Ossoff and an AOC ticket, those people come off the potential for becoming the leadership.
1:17:50And obviously an Ossoff wouldn't be that. But I just don't think – it's a tradeoff, unfortunately. You rob Peter to pay Paul. You take away a strong leader in an AOC because you know she might end up either on a ticket as a VP or a president.
1:18:05Chad Scott: and i truly believe that this ticket is i know she's a superstar but you know so let's take it one one question at a time let's talk about the house um because i think you're right where you take a player off the table in the senate but it's a lot less clear who the emerging you know might be awesome but who's the emerging candidates going to be from the senate i think aoc is an easier call right now i don't think she's going well aoc's house she's house no i know what i'm saying is Senate's more of a toss up as to who would be. Oh, I got you. I got you. OK, OK. In the House, I feel like it's much easier to say, just take AOC off the table and look at who else is left right now.
1:18:43Chad Scott: Yeah, she could be speaker. She'd be great. I think she has aspirations of being president as much as she publicly has looked up to Pelosi for a lot of her career. I don't think I don't think that's her first choice. And I think you're right. So let's look at the house. Who do you think might emerge as front runners or, you know, could be a good compromise rather? For AOC? I mean, if you want to, and I know Matt doesn't like the... AOC is off the table. Who are we naming as our new speaker? I think it comes out of either Greg Kesar or maybe Robert Garcia is out of California. he's a pretty uh strong he's he's kind of aligned with the AOC his are and I don't again I'm sorry if I'm pronouncing his name wrong I really don't it's because because I've never I've just read about these people I did some research on some of these people leading up to this thinking about who I would and then there's also uh Pramila Jayapal who's out of Washington she's she's really interesting because she is hard in that health care realm and that's something people it's that's a top priority right now is the healthcare situation.
1:19:51And so the healthcare and immigration, that is something that she has gone hard into. And so I think she may emerge and maybe it's, it's, we always love to call it the Obama effect where out of nowhere, someone shows up and here's Barack Obama leading the country. Maybe we see that in a, in a house race. Um, I don't know. I think all three of the ones I've named have an equal chance, but I really don't know, uh, who and i and i'll be honest i think all three would do a better job than hakeem jeffries all and i did look none of them took apac money oh yeah from what i can tell is america too racist for like a speaker of the house rashida talib uh yeah speaker of the house ilhan omar those are
1:20:34Chad Scott: the people the best voting records and the worst detractors in the i would say planet earth if you I don't know, Matt, what do you think? I think if you have to ask, you know the answer. Yeah, that's hard. As much as we don't like to think of our country in that regard, I think, yeah. I think we would see a reaction that is kind of a revulsion, even though our vice president currently is married to an Indian woman. But not a Muslim woman. Yeah, and that's the thing. We're so specifically Islamophobic more than we are just anti-Promerunists. That's what I'm saying. If we're seeing that kind of reaction viscerally.
1:21:19Exactly. And that's the thing. There's still a visceral reaction to just a person of color. Throw a Muslim on top of that. That said, Hispanic female governor of Texas. Exactly.
1:21:31Chad Scott: But she's not a Muslim. Sure. But I also didn't think Michigan was going to elect the first Muslim center. Like, I think to some extent we have to stop doing the thing that the Democrats have always done, which is to say, well, the country as it is won't support that progress. We know it's important. I'm answering my own question here to some extent, and I don't think they're going to put Rashida Tlaib as the House. I think Omar has a better chance than Tlaib. Ilhan Omar definitely does have a better chance, but I think that would be extremely contentious. I would support it. But I think the point I'm saying is whether or not they do that.
1:22:01Chad Scott: But I do think this idea of like, you know, Democrats win and then they try to soft roll out progress by being like, well, we've done PR and people are afraid of, you know, gay people. So we can't fully support gay marriage, which, of course, affects the cultural slip. And, you know, what they it's the strategy of like, doesn't realize you can engender support via action, via passing bills. That's, you know, you pass one bill taxing the rich. The next one's more likely to tax, you know, to pass. It's just a side example. But I think. I think Ilhan Omar might be a reach, but also I think this past election cycle has proven a lot of the things that would have.
1:22:42Chad Scott: Statistically or demographically seemed impossible are becoming much more possible right now. Yeah, there's less of a need to whip people into shape. I mean, obviously, she's not the whip, but to when you have such a massive majority, especially in the House, you have some wiggle room. Like there was concern that we needed to get to like 52 in the Senate because of Fetterman. He could never be counted on. But now that we have 55 in the Senate, there's a massive majority there. So it's almost like the Speaker and the majority leader are in a position where it's easier than it's been before. So maybe we do put our superstars into places like AOC throwing her into the election ring.
1:23:27and I'll be honest, I don't even think for the Senate, I don't think Bernie Sanders, can he even be? Because he caucuses with the Democrats, but he's a Democratic socialist. He's an independent, isn't he? So I guess they can vote him in, but would the Democrats actually do that?
1:23:40Chad Scott: He did run as a Democrat when he was running for president, but I think he is still technically an independent. I'd have to double check that. But he's been a committee leader before. I don't know. So let's talk about the Senate then. Like I was saying, less of a clear answer of who the frontrunner from the Senate for president would be. So let's say everyone's on the table. Who would you choose over Schumer to lead the party? And I do think it, by my standard, I do think it has to be someone who's not on the APAC payroll, but it also needs to be someone who can kind of galvanize people. So what are we looking at?
1:24:12Chad Scott: Who's going to take those bold steps? Like you're saying, even the stuff that's going to get vetoed, who's going to lead a sort of activist senate to make material progress there's a name that came to mind but i don't know about his relationship to a pack we can always pause but you but you can set your own standards uh well matt you will know for sure um the name that came to mind was cory booker so fill me in on cory booker is he an a pack guy they call him booker the butcher for a reason my friend he is a big APAC donation recipient he is uh unfortunately uh pretty it's too bad he saved all those people from all those house fires I know all of those things with the news cameras just happened to be there right when he did a good deed isn't that so fascinating when he was the mayor people start rejecting APAC though I mean we keep saying that's a that's a discriminator right now and obvious for obvious reasons but do you think that because of what's happened they can come out and would they be more in your good graces if say a um like a hakeem jeffries not that he's an establishment guy but if he came out and said i am no longer taking apac money and i will show you through audits that i am not going forward would that help in your opinion i mean you know it's tough on one hand we want people who listen to their constituents right and that's what aoc did right you know aoc still supported the iron dome until last year and then came out fully against all funding for Israel officially, I think, you know, fairly recently.
1:25:42Chad Scott: And part of me was like, yeah, well, where was that from the beginning? If I knew that was wrong, you should have known it was wrong. But the entire point of a representative democracy is that people listen to their constituents and don't have fixed positions, that they actually listen to their constituents after being elected, rather than they're not, you know, politicians aren't this thing that we set in motion and go, well, we voted on the guy who makes the best decisions. They should theoretically be responsive to their constituents throughout their entire time in office. So I think if there's someone who's been taking APAC donations and chooses to reject them, I mean, obviously, I think it probably depends on how much of their campaign it was, how much money they've taken.
1:26:22Chad Scott: I do think that's a step in the right direction. I don't think a person who's taken three quarters of a billion from APAC and then suddenly denounces them should become the leader of the party. I think a person who's managed to be a leader without doing that is a lot more inspiring to me. But I don't know that we necessarily need to purge anyone who's ever taken that money. I think we need to make room for Democrats in office to shift, if only for the pragmatic reason of some of these people are in office for two more years and we have to deal with them. Like, while Trump is still the president, Jeffries is still in office.
1:26:54Chad Scott: You know, we have to deal with some of these people who are on the APEC doll. So, yeah, I want to make space for people in the party who have seen what their constituents actually care for, as if that wasn't obvious two years ago. But we still need to make room for politicians who change. But no, I don't think someone who made that turn after seeing the writing on the wall, after the Blue Nami, should suddenly be the leader of the entire party, a party that's turned against support for Israel. So I think among Democrats, the current, it's 84 % disapprove of Israel. So I think that's not a good sign for the leader of the party.
1:27:35It's even over 50 for Republicans.
1:27:37Chad Scott: That's crazy. Well, I tried to leave my bias out of it, but I really like the ranking member of the Energy and Natural Resources Committee. Oh, yeah? What's his name? The one that appeared on the podcast, Senator Martin Heinrich. That's a pretty flag he got back there. Yeah, that's not the one he sent me. Um, no, when I, when I met that guy, like, um, he just, his, his aura, like he just bled. Like I, I didn't sense anything negative at all about that guy. He's so positive and, and it's trying to do good things. Maybe that hurts him in that position. Cause you kind of need to be a, maybe you gotta be a cutthroat kind of shark kind of guy.
1:28:20and maybe, you know, but just an honestly, genuinely good person, if that's what you're looking for, then that guy just impressed me to no end. And it wasn't because he was the one that invited me there. Like, I felt like I've met a lot of politicians in my day, but I've never met one that sort of impacted me the way he did. You know, it felt like I was meeting the president. Yeah. Just a great guy.
1:28:44Chad Scott: And also, I think, you know, as much as I'm making that the litmus test, I think it's a big story for the party who is and isn't taking APAC money. But the defining, you know, aside from getting money out of our politics so that it affects every other issue, the defining issue of the moment is still the climate crisis. That's the biggest ticking clock. And you need someone like Heinrich who understands, you know, this is not my official endorsement, but I do think, you know, if you're making a case for Heinrich, that is someone who understands building and expanding energy capacity with a realistic understanding of the climate crisis rather than saying, well, we need to pollute a little less, but we still need to burn fossil fuels.
1:29:19Chad Scott: I think he's got a really pragmatic approach and a really informed and nuanced approach to that kind of thing. And I think, obviously, it's not the only issue that he has that approach to. But I think specifically, if I'm imagining that this is going to be... Clock's ticking to defeat authoritarianism and save our government. But in case we all forget, one of the major reasons we need to do that is because Trump undid every climate change regulation and is drastically worsening the crisis right now. There's a lot of things that we need to solve, but that's one of the clocks that we cannot dial back in any way.
1:29:59Chad Scott: So I think you do need someone who is not on a massive foreign ticket, like someone who's not taking a lot of money from a foreign country. But I do also think you need someone who understands how to modernize energy policy. Like we really need a, you know, we've been talking about it so much on this show. I'm almost surprised it hasn't come up. But as you said, it wasn't, energy wasn't that forward in this election cycle. I think the main way you saw it represented was in utility affordability. A lot of people ran on cost of living. Depending on who the candidate was, some ran more directly about naming the utilities.
1:30:36Chad Scott: Some people were just saying cost of living is high. All bills are high. But as much as it didn't come up in this election cycle, I mean, we've been saying for months on this show that most of this stuff has to happen at the state level right now just because that's where action is possible, even in red states. I mean, just there's so much more nuance to energy policy at the state level, whereas at the federal level, you know, they're basically running – they're flooding the zone with chaos right now. You know, they're basically deregulating everything and undoing as much progress as possible.
1:31:09Chad Scott: So, you know, we need we can't wait two years for that to end. We need a Congress that can actually modernize our energy policy. And while, you know, undoing a lot of the damage of the Trump administration. yeah because i think heinrich is that's an interesting pick because all signs show chris murphy he's not an apac guy although he has taken israeli money from like uh other other uh israel pro israel like j street and things like that not much it's like a hundred thousand dollars in his total funding which is kind of a drop in the bucket when you're that big chris murphy i thought would be he because unlike the house we're going to need someone a little little more fiery in the Senate.
1:31:51And that's just to try to get over, overcome filibusters perhaps. But Heinrich is interesting because he's really good at coalition building as well. I mean, I've seen some of his, when I was doing research for his stuff, I was seeing him be able to, to get the Republicans to, to pull over with him on some of these energy things. And if you can do it with energy, I think he can do it with other things too. So that's interesting. Yeah, I don't know. I mean, I think if I had to pick, it would probably be a somewhere between Heinrich. And again, this is not trying to be biased because we got to talk to him and he was super cool on our show and everything.
1:32:26But him or Chris Murphy, because we need fiery, someone fiery on that in the Senate, because it is going to be a harder path. but also someone who um is good on the on the policies and whether it's green energy whether it's uh affordability housing whatever everything we've talked about foreign policy but uh and then obviously if we can take uh nat's one of his his things that he's interested in making sure that they're not a big apac recipient neither of them are whether it's chris murphy or heinrich so So, yeah, that's kind of where I stand, I guess. Again, anyone better than Schumer at this point.
1:33:04Chad Scott: So I think we all agree it's going to be Chris Van Hollen, and let's move on. I don't know. It seems like a possibility. I've seen it suggested. I think, I mean, I do think Booker is possibly going to be a suggestion. He's, you know, turned his back on AIPAC finally. I don't know if he's still turned his back on the Kushners yet, but hey, speaking of people who love the Kushners, Cory Booker voting with Republicans to confirm Jared Kushner's dad is the ambassador to France. Let's not forget that. I do think it's possible he'll be in the conversation. I think maybe Jeff Merkley or Alyssa Slotkin, Chris Murphy.
1:33:40Chad Scott: I think these are all potentially people who those who don't I mean, who I think anti-APAC people will suggest. I imagine people for whom that's not as big of an issue might say Duckworth or I don't know. There's a lot of there's a lot of possibilities in the Senate. But I do hope that personally I'm hoping for an energy forward, a pack eschewing leader.
1:34:07Majority.
1:34:07Chad Scott: Any final thoughts on the election before we move to our final segment of the show? No, I mean, the only thing I got to say left is do something, earn it. Don't just say this is easy and you did it, high five, and then go back to what you used to earn this. Yeah, I think eschew the feeling of return to normalcy. This is both for our politicians and for the listeners. Like, I know everyone's exhausted and wants to kick their feet up after a victory. And that is what we did after. That's how Trump won twice. You know, Trump won twice because people took their feet off the wheels after the gas after a Democrat won the presidential election.
1:34:50Chad Scott: So we got to be more engaged. We got to keep, you know, the Democrats feet to the fire. and we've already got Obama tweeting about how people want to go back to the politics of unity. I don't want that. I want consequences for authoritarians and people who murdered innocent civilians. I want consequences, but I don't want a politics of pure revenge. So I think we need a way to move forward where we are establishing consequences and meeting the material needs of people. And, you know, any party leadership or really any moves in the Democratic Party that are not aligned behind that, I think, are antithetical to the progress that we have to make right now.
1:35:29Chad Scott: So no return to normalcy. I want consequences. I want a forward thinking leadership and create that enthusiasm, not just, you know, cater to what you think is already possible. Matt, any final thoughts? Yeah. One final thought on the impact of elections. The new attorney general of Texas. I don't know if you guys heard this, not going to enforce or sue out-of-state doctors that mail the abortion pill to women in Texas anymore. So that right there already has massive impact. I'm not sure if it's just the abortion pill or birth control or what all that's involved, but you can already see less enforcement there of a thing that's impacting women in Texas in a major way just from that election without really changing any policy.
1:36:13That's awesome.
1:36:14Chad Scott: That is great. That's important. And on a negative note, I want to remind people that Colorado passed three anti-trans resolutions on Tuesday. So did Washington and several states made it harder for trans people to be alive. And if fighting the way that we enforce these laws that are designed to hurt women and trans people and control other people's bodies is how we get back to normal. I think that's great. But I feel like I would be remiss in our whole discussion. We did not mention that, again, a lot of ballot initiatives that are very bad for trans-Americans did still pass. And if Democrats aren't going to stand up and fight for that population that makes up a very small percentage of America, there aren't enough of them to fight for themselves.
1:37:00Chad Scott: And we really need to have a party that doesn't let those things fall to the wayside. because I'm very happy that Texas is blue and that we've had all these electoral victories. But if the weakest populations can still get picked off by authoritarians, we haven't won anything. So sorry to end on a down note, but I feel like our election coverage, we do have to touch on that a little bit. But I also think we're building coalitions that, you know, like I said, there are more people running unafraid of talking about issues like that. And so my advice would be continue to be unafraid because the voters don't respect fearful politicians.
1:37:38Chad Scott: And with that, I want to go to our final segment of the show where we talk about the least worst part of our week. Obviously, big week. So maybe we have non-electoral anecdotes for this. And the name of that segment is called The Least Worst Part of My Week. I can go first unless one of you would like to. Yeah, go for it if you want. Go ahead. I had an odd experience. Not the best part of my week. Not the worst part of my week. Maybe the least worst part of my week. On Halloween, I went to a large block party in a relatively affluent Brooklyn neighborhood that is adjacent to my less affluent Brooklyn neighborhood where I can afford to live.
1:38:18Chad Scott: And I got to tell you, the costumes were a lot nicer. You could already see the... I don't know anything about the parenting culture over there, but there's the visible evidence of a homemade family-themed costume arms race happening. Of like, we gotta be five wide, nothing store-bought. Amazing experience. You know, I try to not say I feel like I'm in a movie because I think that's a detached thing to say. Movies are a reflection of life, not the other way around. Listen to Matt's American Power Extra. But I'm at this amazing block party, a lot of fun, big, loud. there's bands playing there's this group of uh guys playing they all have electric guitars and their own amps uh i believe they're called tilted axes and they're all playing like in harmony and marching around everything's at has things come to a head and i should mention that i'm there with my fiance and we are dressed as molder and scully from the fbi so we are wearing like nice clothing suits and fake fbi badges um and uh and that's how you know we're white is that we can impersonate law officers with just no problem.
1:39:25Chad Scott: I've never mentioned that my fiance is white. Now you know. Anyone can dress up as Scully. You can't wear a fake badge. But so we're at this party. We are dressed as, again, FBI agents. Someone comes up to me and he says, hi, would you like to meet the governor? And there's this woman dressed as Kathy Hochul, the governor of New York. And she's very small. And I go to shake her hand. And then I turn and I look at the guy who asked me if we'd like to meet the governor oh and i'm sorry my first reaction was i said well yes we're with the bureau um and i always forget that not everyone stays in character or at all as their halloween costume but i was walking around as molder being like oh look at the strange activity there has to be some explanation for this so i was you know in my mind i was like oh we're playing a game and i was like yes i'd love to meet the governor i'm with the bureau i turned to the guy who said that.
1:40:15Chad Scott: And I'm like, wow, he's doing a really good costume of assembly member Robert Carroll. And that was when I realized this was Kathy Hochul and assembly member Robert Carroll. No one's dressing as Robert Carroll for Halloween. I'm like one of 400 people who would recognize this man in public. And I'm a little face blind and it's dark. And again, as I mentioned, there are 11 men playing distorted electric guitars marching in a circle around me. So I'm a little disoriented when I realized that I am shaking hands with a woman who I have spent years trying to get within 10 paces of to yell at. And so we're shaking hands and this dawns on me.
1:40:55Chad Scott: And they're like, they're saying some platitude. And I looked her in the eyes and I was like, you need to build public renewable energy sources. And she said, as they start pulling her away from me and she pulls her hand out and she's like, we are, which is a lot. We are, which is a lie, by the way. and I like managed to like keep up with them and I was like not enough we need to build the full 15 gigawatts and they like hurried up and ran away so I had I wish I had done better I wish I'd gotten like a video with her you know pose for a photo and then say it or something but it was chaos it was dark you know there was I did everything I could and you know if I can jump scare the governor into realizing that regular constituents are on to her and that she's been paid off by the fossil fuel industry.
1:41:39Chad Scott: Well, that's a good Halloween trick on my part. And so that's the least worst part of my week. That's awesome. Because I think I'm glad that you did it that way. I think it was someone in costume because that's like the most real response. Would you have said the same thing? If I had no, I mean, by the time I said we need to build public renewable energy, I knew it was the real Kathy Hochul because I had clocked the assembly member at that point. That was when I I think if I'd known sooner, I might have, I don't know, I might have tried to get a video with her where I said something like that and caught her off guard or something.
1:42:11Chad Scott: But, you know, I'm going to, you know, I'm going to vote for her. I voted for her. I don't like her. But she's a shoo-in. But better than the Republican. But, you know, absolutely the exact person who is the stopgap for New York building renewable energy sources. By the way, funded by a bill that she already signed into law. So had I had more time with her, I would have called her a hypocrite, talked about that, asked her if she remembered the last time we met, things like that. But I think for what I did, I did my best in-character Halloween trick that I could possibly do for our governor. And I also, it's not lost on me that I'm dressed, and the moment this happened, I'm dressed by my favorite character from a teenager who is a muckraking skeptic who doesn't believe that the government has everyone's best intentions in mind and is trying to get to the bottom of corruption.
1:43:08Chad Scott: So I felt proud of myself in that moment. So I guess I'm saying don't go up to the FBI agents from the X-Files if you don't want people to know the truth is out there. Chad, what's the least worst part of your week? um so um i you you already know this i mean i was i went to new york city and uh i'm from boise idaho i've been to new york city i've been to big cities i love to travel but i just it's interesting because i come from an area that is very closed in people move to idaho because they want to isolate they want to uh there's and it's almost like they start becoming scared of the world.
1:43:48And it's unfortunate because I love the people everywhere. And my wife, she's from Portland, but she lives in Boise now. And it's just wonderful to leave our small community. And I say small. I mean, to be honest, Boise has about 800 ,000. It's not even remotely close to the size of my city, obviously. Yeah, exactly. But it's not a small town. It's a top 50 metro is what it's actually number 50, I believe, is in the top 50 metros in the United States. So it's not tiny, but it's not New York City. And I just, it's one of those things where you go, my wife was very much like, I don't know what this is going to be like.
1:44:28You start to buy into the nonsense that you see online. You start to buy into, oh, there's rats and everywhere and people everywhere and just like gangs roaming the streets. And it was a wonderful city. It was, whatever has been going on, to be honest, it's been about 20 years since I've been there. But everything that's happened in that time, it was, I was shocked at how nice it has become. And it's funny because you see, when you see it from outsider's eyes, I was talking to a New Yorker about this when I was just kind of standing around in Times Square. And they were like, they basically had this hateful view of New York City.
1:45:08And I'm like, I don't know, man, it's really nice here. And I'm only here as a visitor, obviously, but it's a lot cleaner than I remember it. I felt I didn't feel in danger whatsoever New York is the safest and cleanest it's been in decades
1:45:22Chad Scott: and that's the thing we keep hearing about how these cities whether it's San Francisco is one of my favorite cities Los Angeles etc these cities are these bastions of just evil and terribleness and crime and it's not they're really nice and the people are cool and there's just fun things to do it was just really cool I had a wonderful time and I just want to tell all of my fellow kind of suburban slash rural people, go see those places. And you'll see it's not what you're being told on the news. They're really nice places and they're really cool. And everyone's, it was a lot of fun. And we really enjoyed our time there, not only with just being tourists, but at the event, the Find Out event.
1:46:08So that was definitely the least part. We flew back, we landed last night back in Boise. and definitely will be back because it's a great city. I haven't been to a bad city yet in the United States. I've been to some bad blocks in like Oakland and Philadelphia. But yeah, no, I just really enjoyed my time. My wife loved it there. It was so much fun. So if you're scared of New York, don't be. It's cool. It's a very cool place. So yeah.
1:46:36Chad Scott: Well, I'm so glad you had a good time here. It is, yeah, it's funny being from New York because I feel like you could be on social media And from my perspective, there's these constant arguments of you'd have to be crazy to live in New York from people who've never been here. And then people from New York saying, well, I like it. And it's like then saying, no, you don't. It's, you know, it's a den of crime. I think ultimately people get scared of cities, but cities are so big that statistics meet out. Someone dies here. Someone's murdered here almost every day. And that makes New York sound really, really dangerous until you figure out that, like, yes, population density does that.
1:47:11Chad Scott: but also just eight and a half million people of that number, you know, there will be a murder every so often. And I think, you know, you only hear about the scariest things that happen on the news. If there's a shooting or stabbing on the subway or something that seems really high profile, but that is something that we, you know, we deal with that in our presence of mind every day. But I think stories like that are intentionally sensationalized to make people afraid of cities. And like, especially if you're a tourist, you're not visiting any place that's dangerous. you're visiting extremely you know uh friendly and shall i say a little corporatized parts of the city that are designed to be safe for tourists so i'm glad you had a good time next time you come i'll take you to a scary dive bar or something and uh we'll go to a punk show at a basement in bushwick and uh you and me are gonna hit up the the non-binary open mic but uh i'm so glad that you had a good your your your surface visit uh for the first time in in many years i'm so glad you had a good time and yeah come back come visit new york folks give us your money i'm kidding i'm not getting any tourist dollars unless you come to a comedy show matt what is the least worst part of your week mr randolph mr global so the least worst part of my week was if you know people don't know this, but voting in Oklahoma is very odd.
1:48:32And it's weird because Democrats in Oklahoma can actually get a lot of things passed if they can get it on the ballot. And the reason they can get it passed is because Oklahomans largely don't know how to vote. And it's the funniest thing I've ever seen in my life. So on election day, I'm at the polls. There's nobody there. There's like two people in the entire building. One old man walks in and I hear something I hear all the time. What is this crap? I have to read all this crap. All I want to do is, is because we have straight party ticket voting and it's at the very top of the ballot. All these old Republicans come in and that's why no one's ever at the polling place.
1:49:12Cause they're only there for like 90 seconds. They walk in, they fill in the box, all Republicans, and they walk out and the poll workers are like, Hey, there's stuff on the back of the ballot that you still have to vote for. And they're like, I'm not dealing with that shit. You know, these old Republican men. There was a big thing on the ballot this year. By the way, that's how marijuana got legalized in Oklahoma. Democrats got it put on the ballot. And since Republicans don't want to vote on the back of the ballot and they just want to do the all Republican straight party and they don't they rarely vote on the back of the ballot because they don't want to read.
1:49:44Chad Scott: So they didn't have enough votes to shoot down to overcome. Right. They didn't have enough. That's some bullshit. Idaho, we keep voting it down. We need to do that. You guys should get marijuana the real way, which is that your governor needs to have a huge sex scandal and legalize it retroactively effective immediately in a PR move during a pandemic. That's the way you're supposed to get it. So there was a big question on the ballot this year that was going to something that Republicans pushed really hard that they really wanted that had overwhelming support. That's like 80-something percent of Republicans supported it.
1:50:21And it was a way to reduce property taxes. It was simply or basically over time it would be a property tax reduction by capping the amount of how much they could increase your property taxes in any given year. And there's already a cap that exists, but it's kind of high, and they were like going to cut it in half. And this was a huge thing for Republicans in Oklahoma that they wanted, and it failed. because they can't get their own people to turn over the damn ballot and read. And I literally sat here and listened to this old man. And the woman's trying to, the poll worker's trying to explain to him, you know, this is the, this is the state question 834.
1:50:58It's about property taxes. And he's like, I got to read all this shit. And she said, well, a lot of people either just don't vote or they just vote no because no is a safe vote. And that's exactly what she told him. And she just walked off. And so I don't know how that gentleman voted. But before I left, another guy came in and I had to hear this exact same conversation. And I'm just sitting there like filling out every I'm reading. I read that state question three times to make sure I understood it like it. I probably took 45 minutes to vote because I read everything carefully when I vote. I'm very picky voter.
1:51:34But that entire state question that would have lowered property taxes in the state of Oklahoma failed because Republicans don't know how to vote. vote in this state. And it was just another example of, well, it's the least worst part of my week. We didn't have much to win, even though that is something I wanted to pass because that property tax impacts me a lot directly. I wanted it to pass, but I find it hilarious that it didn't because they can't even teach their own people how to vote. That's better than the state gun in Idaho. We voted on the state frigging gun. And it's funny
1:52:10Chad Scott: because it like the as in like state bird but it's a gun yeah but it's a gun and it was and so hell yeah just real quick because i know we're running long here but the what caliber was it it was the we had first of all it was a political ploy because they were scared that the independent candidate taught Achilles was doing well so they needed something to bring more conservatives to the to the polls and it worked but it ended up being the model 1873 made up detail sorry it just No, I'm dead soon. That feels like a South Park detail about like, oh, we have to name the, I don't know, state murder weapons.
1:52:41Chad Scott: This is a real thing. This is a real thing. So embarrassing. But what's even worse is the 1873, the Model 1873 won, and the M1 Garand is on. And I'm like, and I just said, you know what? The reason the M1 Garand should have won and the reason the M1 Garand should have won is because it was what won World War II. But here in Idaho, we don't like the tools that are used to fight fascism. So that's why it didn't win. So that's exactly why the M1 Grand didn't win. I didn't vote. I thought it was ridiculous. It's a waste of resources and dumb. And it's embarrassing that our state does that. And other people were like, well, other states have done.
1:53:16I don't give a shit. That's a dumb thing to put on a ballot. And they did it for political reasons. And you didn't even vote for the right gun in the last. Anyway, you voted for the – you'd rather just get rid of the one that fought the Nazis.
1:53:27Chad Scott: It's stupid to vote on guns. And also you voted on guns the wrong way, you idiots. Yeah, exactly. It was not a good election for my state. So everyone else, I'm glad you had a good time. And honestly, I want to also add to what Matt said there. God bless the poll workers. This is the first election that I have not worked election day in, I think, a decade. And partially because I had to do our find out event. And it feels surreal to not have a thing to be focusing on all day, to not have a thing to be anxious all day. But Matt's story is just giving me, you know, PTSD of the number of times people have come in not knowing there are ballot initiatives.
1:54:05Chad Scott: And I have I'm so committed to being nonpartisan and to doing my job as a bureaucrat. well as much as I'm a very you know opinionated person outside of that job but just trying to explain to a person who didn't know or maybe doesn't know what a ballot initiative is and like how they function what the ballot what they're voting on without giving away my opinion I'm just like okay so like do you think the government should be allowed to kill you right but just however you feel you know like should the police go to jail if they kill you you know like little things like i mean obviously it's not usually that straightforward but just trying to be like all right well how would you do education should it have more money but like i can't make it clear so if you work the polls and you're listening to this god bless you and if you you didn't work the polls and you're just listening to this uh next time you vote just bring a coffee in there and ask who needs it because someone in that room absolutely needs a coffee that's the end of our episode this has been our extra long extra exciting extra pessimistic at the same time and that's the way that we do it but with the silver lining of least worst election reflection blue nami trademark pending episode for matt randolph mr global and chad Scott.
1:55:25Chad Scott: I'm Nat Towson. And remember, power corrupts, but American power corrupts Americanly.
Democrats delivered a sweeping midterm victory, but is this a lasting political realignment or simply a rejection of Donald Trump?
In this special election edition of American Power, Nat Towsen, Chad Scott, and Matt Randolph break down the biggest surprises of the 2026 midterms, from historic Democratic victories in traditionally Republican states to the growing influence of progressive and democratic socialist candidates.
The team examines how affordability, corruption, and voter frustration shaped the results, why billionaire spending and pro-Israel political groups faced significant setbacks, and whether Democrats need new leadership to meet the moment. Plus, what could Trump do during the lame-duck session, and can Democrats turn their electoral momentum into meaningful change?
We’re always looking for new opportunities to partner with creators, companies, politicians, and organizations that share our mission. If you’re interested in partnering with us to help reshape the national conversation — get in touch! @wearefindout