1. Podcasts
  2. Americast
  3. Are the Democrats heading for a midterms landslide?
Americast

9 Oct 2026 · 39m · 18 chapters

Episode artwork

Are the Democrats heading for a midterms landslide?

In short

Whether Democrats are on track for a midterms “landslide,” focusing on Senate races and polling reliability. The episode argues Democrats may win surprising seats in deep-red states because Republicans are unpopular under Donald Trump and because local candidate quality and economic pressures (diesel, tariffs, and the Iran war’s impact on prices) are hurting GOP incumbents.

Guests and backgrounds

  • John Anzalone, Democratic pollster; worked with Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, and Joe Biden; co-founded a bipartisan Wall Street Journal poll with Trump’s former pollster (Adam Geller).
  • (Other voices are hosts Sarah and Justin; no other named guests.)

Key claims

  • Trump has a 61% negative job rating and Republicans’ “branding” has collapsed.
  • Polling may be accurate if done with expensive, modern methods; “rubbish polls” exist.
  • Rural and working-class Republican margins are narrowing, enabling Democratic wins in places like Texas and Kansas.

Notable examples

  • Texas: Ken Paxton trailing in polls; Paxton indicted/accused of fraud; Trump campaigned in Texas and even said he doesn’t like Paxton’s appearance.
  • Kansas: Democrat Adam Hamilton (pastor, no prior office) vs Roger Marshall; attack ad about Marshall suing patients over small medical debts.
  • Iowa: Ashley Hinson tied to support for the Iran war; Democrat Josh Turek (wheelchair Paralympian) running with high-profile messaging.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:00

Midterm Election Context

Discussion about the upcoming midterm elections and Democrat excitement.

“Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.”
1:30

Democrats' Unexpected Gains

Analysis of unexpected Democratic polling success in traditionally Republican states.

“And is there still time for Republicans to turn it around?”
3:00

Senate Seat Requirements

Exploration of the Senate seat requirements for Democrats and the challenges ahead.

“are suddenly, not only in the running, but potentially, according to the polls, possibly going to get a majority in the Senate after the midterms.”
4:30

Local Factors Influencing Elections

Examination of local factors and candidate quality affecting election outcomes.

“are not ones that it's easy for the Democrats to pick up or six, nine months ago it didn't look like it was going to be easy for the Democrats to pick up.”
6:00

Texas Senate Race Dynamics

In-depth look at the Texas Senate race and its candidates' challenges.

“They could be wrong, although there have been quite a number of them all pointing in the same direction, even if they don't have exactly the same numbers.”
8:00

Kansas Political Landscape

Overview of the evolving political landscape in Kansas and its candidates.

“while going through a security device and all things.”
9:30

Campaign Advertisements Influence

Discussion on the impact of campaign advertisements on voter perception.

“He'll never speak to me again, but that's OK.”
11:00

Cost of Living Issues

Analysis of cost of living and economic factors affecting voter sentiment.

“And this guy, he's not stood for office before, has he?”
13:00

War's Economic Impact

Consideration of how international conflicts influence domestic economics.

“Roger Marshall was a doctor who sued a huge number of his patients for medical debt that they hadn't paid for amounts as low as$99 or$50.”
14:00

Impact of the Iran War on Cost of Living

Learn how the Iran war's consequences are affecting American voters and the economy.

“So there's a kind of, yeah, unique convergence of events where the cost of living is at the top of everybody's mind.”
Show all 18 chapters
16:27

Iowa's Political Landscape: A Case Study

Explore the dynamics of Iowa's political climate and how local issues influence voter decisions.

“She's running against a good Democrat candidate who's a senator in the local Iowa State House, Josh Turek.”
18:55

Voter Opinions on Trump and Local Candidates

Understand how Iowans perceive Trump and how it affects their voting behavior in local elections.

“They're not only going to vote on the price of gas.”
22:38

Current Midterm Political Landscape

Gain insights into the current political landscape as midterms approach, focusing on polling data.

“I suppose the first question, Sarah, I think we'd both probably ask the obvious first question, which is tell us what is going on.”
26:55

Candidate Quality and Voter Dynamics

Discover how the quality of candidates affects voter dynamics and election outcomes in surprising ways.

“So we're going to see people vote for a Democrat for governor and a Republican for Senate or a Republican for governor and a Democrat for Senate.”
28:00

Analyzing Third Party Candidates and Polling Accuracy

Discussion on the impact of third party candidates and the challenges of polling accuracy in modern elections.

“And another narrative post-election is going to be third party candidates.”
33:22

Voter Sentiments and Republican Loyalty

Exploration of voter sentiments towards Republicans and the implications for voter turnout in upcoming elections.

“And I met plenty of the double haters that you're talking about.”
34:06

Polling Trends and Rural Voter Shifts

Examination of polling trends, focusing on shifts among rural voters and potential Democratic gains in traditionally Republican areas.

“Right now, we're seeing rural voters who Trump won by 70 to 30, right?”
35:58

Insights from Iowa and Political Identity

Reflections on experiences in Iowa, highlighting political identity and the visual cues of political affiliations.

“And we're all going to be thinking about 28 then.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Americast, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30long weekend sale, October 10th through October 12th at the Wayfair Store at Eden's Plaza in Wilmette. Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years. Having seen another million people die, I know that I could have done something when I had a chance. This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen, the Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media. And now she is the subject of Aaron Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain, and me, Jess Maddox, or The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

1:06It's less than a month until those crucial midterm elections. And to say Democrats are excited is an understatement. They are practically giddy because there is new polling showing them doing unexpectedly well in some solidly Republican rural states. But they are facing problems in some traditionally Democrat states as well, which they will need to hold on to. But how much can we trust the polls? And is there still time for Republicans to turn it around? Welcome to AmeriCast. AmeriCast. AmeriCast from BBC News. Whatever you want to talk about, Abdul, keep my wife's name the hell out of your mouth because she's way out of your league.

1:46The tide is coming. And this time we intend to win it all. See, he doesn't want to do the job. He wants to build his ballroom and travel with Natalie on their apparently defenceless flying palace gifted by the Emir of Qatar. When I'm not around, you're going to be broke. There's not going to be anybody to report on. Nobody gives a damn about anybody else.

2:16Hello, it's Sarah. And very excitingly, I have popped into the worldwide headquarters in London, England. And it's Justin sitting right next to Sarah and equally excited and delighted that you're here, Sarah. And we're going to be joined later on by John Anzalone, who is not only a highly respected pollster, he worked with President Obama, he worked with others as well. but also really crucially is someone who is very much plugged into what's going on at the moment with his polling and at the moment being, of course, in the run-up to the midterms and specifically when it comes to the Senate, because that, I think, is what we're going to be concentrating on today, this extraordinary rolling story that there seems to be that the Democrats, who really were not going to be in the running at all, were they, Sarah, are suddenly, not only in the running, but potentially, according to the polls, possibly going to get a majority in the Senate after the midterms.

3:11That's right. And not by winning, according to the polls, as you say, we don't know if they're correct or not, not by winning the states that you might think were the most likely to flip to Democrats, but they are polling astonishingly well in what we would call deep red for Republican states, ruby red states like Texas, Kansas, Alaska, possibly Iowa. These are places that voted for Donald Trump just two years ago by double digits, by 10, 11, 12 more percentage points supporting Donald Trump. Now, according to the polls, looking like they could elect Democratic senators, some of them for the first time in decades.

3:49Yeah. And Kansas for the first time in like 100 years. Yeah. I mean, it really is as extraordinary as that. And Texas as well. You think we just don't think of Democrats being elected statewide in Texas for an awful, awful long time. So before we go any further, let's just make it clear what this means in terms of what would then happen in the Senate, because the Democrats need four Senate pickups. Net. So say they were to lose one or two to Republicans, they would need to win five or six. But yeah, they need to flip a total of four seats. And that's quite a big ask, because remember, there's 35 seats up, not all 100 of them.

4:29and the seats that are up this year are not ones that it's easy for the Democrats to pick up or six, nine months ago it didn't look like it was going to be easy for the Democrats to pick up. It's a bad map for the Democrats, people would say and they'd nod as if, yes, bad map for the Democrats and that was conventional wisdom. As ever, it's gone. Yeah, yeah. It's absolutely fascinating and there are local reasons in some of the different states why this is happening. So the most surprising ones that we'll be talking about, Texas and Kansas, where it just seems astonishing that we're even discussing the idea that a Democrat could win, are both places where you have got a particularly strong Democratic candidate and a particularly weak Republican.

5:10And I think we'll delve into this a bit more with our guest. As you look across the country, it's really interesting that there is a nationwide story of dissatisfaction with the president and of people saying they're more likely to vote Democrat. But once you dig into it, there are usually local reasons in most of the states that might flip to do with the candidates or particular circumstances that exemplify that, what appears to be a nationwide trend. We ought to stress as well, even the pollsters would make clear, even those pollsters who say, hey, the Democrats seem to be ahead, goodness me, are saying they're not ahead necessarily by much.

5:47obviously there is a little bit of time before the election itself and also, and this is another thing I think we'll talk to with our guest is heck, the pollsters can be wrong and they can be wrong for all manner of reasons and they might not be picking up Republican voters in a way that we know from relatively recent history has been the case they might equally not be picking up Democrats I guess in other words the polls themselves number one, it's pretty tight but number two, they could just be wrong. They could be wrong, although there have been quite a number of them all pointing in the same direction, even if they don't have exactly the same numbers.

6:21What's fascinating is if you look at each election where Donald Trump was a presidential candidate, Democrats performed about 4 % or 5 % less well than the polls had suggested they were going to. So in other words, there were people who came out and voted for Donald Trump and then voted for Republican candidates as well across the country who had not been found by pollsters somehow or other. But in midterm elections, when Donald Trump is not on the ballot in 2018 and in 2022, the polls got it just about right in terms of the split between Democrats and Republicans. So if you go by those historical trends, then we should put some but not total faith in the numbers that we're seeing at the moment.

7:01Although, and we'll get into this a little bit later, my own personal experience of going out and speaking to voters is not nearly as optimistic for Democrats as the headlines in some of these polls would. Oh, you need to get to that, definitely. And yeah, I mean, you're right when you say there is a firm picture emerging. I'm not suggesting that the picture is anything other than a very good one for the Democrats from the polls. And you think of somewhere like Texas, where I think I'm right in saying the Real Clear Politics average, which is an average of a lot of polls that they run on Real Clear Politics, this very respected website when it comes to this kind of stuff.

7:34they have not had Ken Paxton ahead at all during the whole campaign. Yeah, the Republican Senate candidate in Texas. Which is pretty extraordinary. He hasn't been ahead at all throughout the whole campaign. In what should be a very, very easy state for him to win. Yeah, but then that comes back to candidate quality. We talked a little bit about him and that fantastic advert that's been run where he appears to be stealing someone's pen while going through a security device and all things. you know, they're troubled with some of their candidates. And it's another thing we need to talk to our guest about, the extent to which that really does matter this time.

8:11Yeah, and with Ken Paxton, it's extreme. I mean, he's been indicted by his own party in the state congress. He has been accused of fraud. He's going through a very messy divorce. And even President Trump doesn't seem to like him very much. He went to Texas last night. He had a rally there specifically because the Republicans are in so much trouble there. I mean, the idea of a Republican president campaigning in Texas in the midterm elections is practically unheard of. So he went there to try and bolster his Senate candidate, who is only the candidate because Donald Trump picked him and insisted that he win the primary.

8:44And his influence carried enough to get Ken Paxton through the Republican primary. And then he turns up and said again, as he has of him before, I don't like the way he looks. I don't like the way he dresses. I don't like the way he speaks. but he's a great attorney general and you should all vote for him because I'm telling you to vote for him. And I'll go backstage, sir, you shouldn't have said that. You've given them a say. Let me tell you, it's true. He may not dress right. He may not talk exactly perfectly and he may not be the best looking guy I've ever seen. But you know what he is? He's the greatest attorney general in America and he deserves to be your next son of a year.

9:30I'm sorry, Ken. Where the hell is he? I'm so sorry. He'll never speak to me again, but that's OK. We have to. So, yeah, even the president doesn't have total confidence in the guy who's running it. And it's worth saying the president was warned by none other than Anthony Zerka. I can remember this maybe even a year ago when they were saying, gosh, is John Cornyn the obvious candidate to win? Who was the sitting Republican senator? A sitting Republican Senate. But who had crossed Donald Trump a bit in the Senate and therefore Trump wanted somebody to knock him out. And we were discussing whether that was wise and Anthony was saying not only is it unwise in his view for the Republican Party, but he was saying, number one, they'd have to spend a ton of money on it that they could otherwise have spent on other things, which has come true.

10:16And number two, I think I remember him saying, I think the president himself might have to campaign there, although he wouldn't want to. And it would open up all sorts of obvious questions about why on earth are you campaigning in Texas? Are you that panic-stricken? That also has come to pass. Everything, Anthony says, in the end comes to pass. We need to talk about Kansas, don't we? Because, to coin a phrase, we are not in Kansas anymore, and not the Kansas that there has been for some time. This guy, Adam Hamilton, still is a pastor, and he's a kind of megachurch pastor too, isn't he? Biggest Methodist congregation in the whole of the United States, I think.

10:47So that's a good voting bloc to start with, isn't it? I'm thinking that's more than 60.

10:55he also I mean he's not only is he a pastor but he's not really a politician and I wonder if that's another theme of this year in a way in those places where the Democrats are likely to post surprising wins or there is a possibility that they post a surprising win they've put up people who are not out of the mainstream political world never mind what their views are whether they're left or right or whatever they're just They're kind of outsiders. And this guy, he's not stood for office before, has he? Well, he's not held office before, and that means he doesn't have a voting record that you can attack.

11:29And you've seen them yourself, Justin, the attack ads that you get on television at this time of year. And because I've been travelling in some swing states, if you put on the TV, that's all you get bombarded with these election messages. And if you don't have a voting record, there's less for people to make ads about criticising you for voting one way or another over border security or the war in Iran or taxation or anything else. It's just there's a lot less meat there for them to go after. Yeah. He, on the other hand, does have some meat to go after with his opponent, this guy Roger Marshall, who's a Trump ally.

12:01And my goodness, the attack ads. I mean, it's quite Old Testament. Albeit that he's a pastor and all the rest of it. I'm not sure what the New Testament, Old Testament balance is. Because if you listen to this ad, which was run against Roger Marshall, has been running quite a lot against Roger Marshall, his opponent. This is the ad that the Democrats think could win it for Adam Hamilton. I'm Adam Hamilton and I approve this message. One evening I see lights. I open the door and it's a police officer. They arrested me because I didn't make a$50 payment to Roger Marshall. I was eight months pregnant and I said, please do not handcuff me in front of my two-year-old daughter.

12:44Roger Marshall preyed on the low income families of Kansas. The health care system is broken, but not for Roger Marshall. He's absolutely profiting from it. Now, that's an amazing story being told there by a voter in Kansas. Roger Marshall was a doctor who sued a huge number of his patients for medical debt that they hadn't paid for amounts as low as$99 or$50. So this isn't going after, you know, health care, insurance companies or hospitals or something for thousands. I think that line, please do not handcuff me in front of my two year old daughter, is one of these ones that's going to resonate.

13:23I mean, OK, it's only relevant in Kansas, but that will resonate along with some of the, you know, the famous lines we remember. And it doesn't matter whether or not they did actually handcuff her in front of her daughter. It's just the line, isn't it? Because we don't know from that whether they did or whether they said, OK, and treated her respectfully. and all the rest of it, but it does hit home. And it's fair to say that advert seems to be important, but also there is this groundswell, isn't there, of just distress caused by the tariffs, I suppose. Well, it's two things, isn't it? It's tariffs, but it's also just the price of diesel, which has such an impact in these rural communities, and that's the Iran war.

14:01Yes, yes. So there's a kind of, yeah, unique convergence of events where the cost of living is at the top of everybody's mind. The price of petrol has gone up, so they're all paying more to fill up their cars and to commute. As you say, the price of diesel has gone up even more. And that's what runs all the farm machinery and the trucking and what gets your goods around America. So that puts the price of goods in the stores up. When farmers' costs have gone up, the cost of the price of food and groceries goes up. So consumers, voters feel like they're being hit all around. And the tariffs don't help either.

14:33They're increasing the input costs for farmers. They're increasing the cost of goods in the shops. If you're worried about the economy and you're worried about the cost of living, sometimes in some elections it's difficult to know who to blame. Is it the fault of Covid? Is it the fault of the international financial crisis started by subprime mortgages? No, this is caused very directly by the war in Iran, which is a decision that was made by one man on the 28th of February to start bombing that country alongside Israel. He cannot claim that this is some kind of international catastrophe which isn't his fault.

15:07And voters know very directly who to hold responsible for this. From one rural state then to another to Iowa, a state we both know well and you've been in recently. Yes, yes, I was just there a few days ago visiting some of our favourite old spots and some new ones. I had not before been to Otomo or Oskalooska. I don't know if you have before. I had a night in Muscatine that was rather good fun. Yeah, so the situation there is broadly similar. It's a big rural agricultural farming state. And the farming sector is being hit hard for all the reasons we have just discussed. And people are very worried about the cost of living.

15:41And interesting candidates there as well. The Republican, Ashley Hinson, is already a Republican congresswoman. She voted seven times already in favour of the war in Iran by either voting not to try and stop the war with the War Powers Act or anything like that. So she is being pegged as somebody who supported Donald Trump's bombing campaign. And she's put out ads herself distancing her from that, as have a number of candidates across the country. Very daring for people to disagree with Donald Trump. But quite a few of them have put out ads saying the war in Iran needs to end now. It needs to end soon so that we can get relief at the gas pump and in the grocery stores and things.

16:22Prices need to come down and that won't happen until the war in Iran is over. She's trying to distance herself from that. may or may not work. She's running against a good Democrat candidate who's a senator in the local Iowa State House, Josh Turek. He was born with spina bifida. He uses a wheelchair. He's a double gold medal winning Paralympian basketball player. He's a very articulate man who's put out a campaign ad with himself playing basketball with Barack Obama, no less. Because Iowa is such a fascinating state. It has voted in the last three presidential elections decisively for Donald Trump, but it voted decisively for Barack Obama in 2008 and 2012.

17:04It was the moment you knew. I mean, albeit he then stumbled a bit in New Hampshire, but you sort of knew, didn't you, in that night in Iowa. Oh, my goodness. Not only has Iowa voted decisively for him, but Iowa, which is, of course, very, very white and still very, very white. I think it's 97 % white. And the fact that they could vote for Obama in the numbers that they did sort of made everyone go, oh my goodness, this could be real. So the fact, yeah, and then as you say, they went for Trump. They are capable, the Iowans, hardy farming people, of making their own minds up about everything. They are, although traditionally you would see it as a red Republican state.

17:42And in fact, in that Senate race that we were just describing, it's either neck and neck in the polls or with like maybe a one point advantage for the Republican, but it's very tight. And, you know, by normal conventional wisdom, it shouldn't be that tight. It's because of these prevailing circumstances. And that's the reason why I went there to see if this predicted, suggested democratic blue wave could flip a state like Iowa. And it was really, really, really interesting what happened. I went all over the state talking to farmers, visiting people displaying their classic cars at a Sunday morning show.

18:19And I went to a Hawkeyes game. So Iowa college football, the Hawkeyes playing Ohio State, big, important match. and the story was very similar from a lot of voters. They are furious about the cost of living, really genuinely worried about it. It's altering their lifestyles, talking about not being able to drive to a neighbouring state to visit their kids as often as they would like, as well as not being able to go out to eat and things like that. So angry about that. Blaming Donald Trump pretty personally for it, a lot of them, and then saying that's not going to change how they're going to vote because if they are traditional Republicans, They are able to separate, they say, what Donald Trump has done from their local candidates, very much talking about who they're voting for, for governor, for Senate, for Congress, separating them from their view of the president and then bringing up other things, of course, which is easy to forget.

19:15these aren't single issue voters. They're not only going to vote on the price of gas. They talk about family values, talk about open borders that ran during Joe Biden's presidency and the surge in illegal immigration and about their distrust of Democrats generally. Their distrust, dislike actually, of Democrats generally means that no matter how upset they are about the cost of living, they might stay home, but they're not going to vote Democrat. So here's a range of the views from a bunch of Hawkeye fans in Iowa City. Yeah, there's just policies. I'm kind of an independent voter, so I'm an issues voter.

19:57I don't want to vote straight party. I really do look at the issues. But I think there's a lot of things that are getting out of control. So we have an opportunity to set a tone. So I want to help with that. President Trump's campaigning all over the country saying, pretend I'm on the ballot. Does that make you more likely to vote Republican if you're thinking about Donald Trump? I don't think he influences me one way or the other. I really truly try to vote issues. I wouldn't vote more or less whether he's on or not. Are you worried about the war in Iran and what it's done to prices? I'm not.

20:33To me it's a necessary evil. I'm a veteran, so we get paid to go do those types of things and I think it's a necessary evil. They're a bad thing and I think it's time to put an end to that. So I support it. And do you think with other people, there is a chance that the more Donald Trump puts himself at the center of the Republicans campaign, that it could put some voters off or even motivate some Democrats to come out and vote? I think it definitely puts voters off. There's no doubt about that. And I do think it probably raises the Democratic side to a level that isn't always there just because it's Donald Trump.

21:06Two things listening to that. Number one, it's great to hear real people who are not just put into categories by political parties and stick in those categories. People have actual views that are sometimes not necessarily the views that can be predicted by the political parties themselves. And they'll vote for people for reasons that the people didn't realize they were going to use to vote for them. And the opposite is the case as well. They vote against them for all sorts of reasons. And their people are more independent, I think, than sometimes we give them credit for, including people who are supporters of parties, that there is a sort of degree where they think they don't like to be thought of as slavishly following a party line or following an individual in the case of Donald Trump.

21:51And I wonder sometimes whether we are too keen to say of Trump supporters that they are sort of a cult-like and there's nothing that can be done to persuade them. They're thinking for themselves in so many cases. So that was fascinating to hear. Right. This is a good moment then to bring in John Anzalone, who I introduced right at the beginning, didn't I? Massively respected Democratic pollsters, someone who's polled for some time as well, which really matters because when you're a pollster who is pickled in the polling industry, you know your stuff because you've seen things go right and you've seen things go wrong as well.

22:27So John worked with President Obama, with Hillary Clinton and indeed with Joe Biden as well. So John, thank you for joining us. Nice to be hearing from you. I'm really pleased to be here. Thank you. I suppose the first question, Sarah, I think we'd both probably ask the obvious first question, which is tell us what is going on. So we've just had a stab at it looking kind of across the piece and at some various Senate races as well. But broad brush, what would you say the picture is at the moment? Yeah, I think the it listen to take a look at the broad political landscape right before the midterms.

23:02You know, I'll look at our bipartisan Wall Street Journal poll. I founded that with Trump's pollster in 2021. We do it with Adam Geller, who's now Trump's PAC pollster. And so this is this is a bipartisan poll. And this is kind of what it shows. It shows that, you know, President Trump goes into the midterm with the worst job rating of any president in modern history. Right. He's 61 % negative job rating. So just to put that in context is that Joe Biden's job rating was better than Trump's in October of 2022, but also George Bush, who was mired in the Iraq war right before Democrats took over the House with Nancy Pelosi, his job rating was better in October of 2006.

23:48So that's kind of how bad it is for Donald Trump right now. And so just to go through the diagnostics, 68 percent of American voters think the country is moving in the wrong direction. Sixty five percent of American voters give the economy a negative job rating. And 60 percent, all again, all from the bipartisan Wall Street Journal poll, say that the Trump's economic policies have actually made the economy worse. right, built on over two thirds of voters opposing tariffs, opposing the Iran war, which has increased the gas prices here dramatically, diesel prices for farmers in rural states. So you just almost couldn't have a worse political environment for the party in power.

24:38And there's one saying that I always relay, which is pessimism kills the party in power. And as you know, the Republicans hold a presidency, U.S. Congress and U.S. Senate. And so right now, this has nothing to do with how people are, you know, with the Democrats. Democrats have historic low branding. This is all about Democrats winning when Republicans are losing and Republicans are losing dramatically. Yeah. So that's a very interesting way of around of putting it, John, that we shouldn't look at this as any kind of Democrat or blue surge. It's being called the red undertow, isn't it, in the United States, that it is Donald Trump who's dragging down his Republican candidates with his unpopularity.

25:22Yeah, this is self-inflicted wounds. And Sarah, I think one of the things that you really need to look at is that, for example, Donald Trump has taken down the branding of the Republican Party. You know, Donald Trump's job ratings were very stable for a long time. It was hard to move them, Not much elasticity, as we say, in his numbers. And that really changed at the beginning of the year, really at the end of the first quarter. And, you know, when the Republican when you look at the Republican Party's branding in January of 2025, right after Trump got in office again and beat Kamala Harris, they actually had a slight net favorable.

26:04Right. The Republican, the Democratic Party, again, historic lows, 60 percent unfavorable. Well, if you take a look at how the Democratic Party is viewed today, no difference, literally no difference. But how the Republican Party is viewed, it's gone down steadily and now is viewed just as poorly as the Democratic Party. So there's been large movements in how people view the Republican Party, but not the Democratic Party. So we are in a pox on both houses, right, in terms of how people view the political parties. I think one of the narratives once we get the elections over will be we'll see more what we call ticket splitting than we have in a long time.

26:49People are not happy with either party. They're viewing and looking at these candidates individually. So we're going to see people vote for a Democrat for governor and a Republican for Senate or a Republican for governor and a Democrat for Senate. And that has not happened in a long time. And how then would you explain if Democratic popularity is not rising? It's just that the Republicans are being dragged down to their level, so to speak, that in some really surprising states like, for instance, Texas, Kansas, that you're looking at the possibility, certainly in the Senate race of a Democratic victory.

27:24Yeah, that's a great question. You know, one of the things that Democrats do really well is they recruit really good candidates. And so you have James Tallarico, who I think you could, you know, this is not a dramatic statement. Like, he is a once-in-a-lifetime generational candidate, right? He is a former teacher. He's a state legislator who's worked across the aisle with Republicans. He's a seminary student. He can talk about his Christian faith as a passion of why he wants to serve in public service and also as a rebuttal to some of the attacks and hypocrisies of the Republican Party. And another narrative post-election is going to be third party candidates.

28:06So in Texas, there's a libertarian and we'll see some Republicans, maybe two, three to four percent was what the libertarian will get. Those are all votes that should be going to Ken Paxton. And so every person who votes for the libertarian is basically voting for Tallarico. that then leads to the question Sarah and I were chatting about this John before you came on the line how believable is any of this in other words well how certain actually is the word how certain can you be and you think back to the polls uh at various stages of the last I don't know 20 years or so that have underestimated the number of Republicans who would come to vote for Donald Trump have underestimated occasionally the number of Democrats who do x y and z in other words with With what degree of certainty, given the real difficulties there are polling in the modern era, aren't there?

28:58With what degree of certainty can any of this be said? Well, I think that it's important to define the modern era, which is the modern era is the last 10 years. You said 20 years, and that's not really accurate. I mean, when we were polling for Obama, et cetera, I mean, like, you know, all the way until 2016, polling was dead on. Yeah, that's interesting. That's a really interesting. Hang on, just before you go any further, that's a really interesting corrective. So you're saying it all kind of went wrong in 2016. Yes, Trump distorts it because you've got people who don't normally come out and vote who are prepared to support Trump.

29:33I think there's a couple of things. One is, you know, Trump brought out a bunch of new people. And so that's not necessarily polling error. That is just, you know, how you pull a sample, et cetera, et cetera. And there were problems in terms of the types of non-college educated voters we were getting, et cetera, et cetera. All that was corrected. 2018 was a really positive year for polling. You know, I would say that 2020 in terms when I was Biden's chief pollster, there wasn't a state that we got wrong. Right. Internally, I think there's a big difference between what we do as political campaign polling professionals and what the media polls, which most media operations don't want to spend a lot of money on polling.

30:17The Wall Street Journal brought in Biden's pollster, me, and Trump's pollster, Tony Fabrizio, now Adam Geller. And they spend the money to do the right type of multimodal methodology and, you know, how to go about reaching hard to get voters, et cetera, et cetera. I mean, for example, we were one of the few polls that had Trump plus one at the end of the 2024 election. So polling can be accurate if it is done well. And if it's done well, it means it costs a hell of a lot of money to do. Right. And I think that's the difference than what you see now being flooded in the market with literally now hundreds of polls, which is kind of crazy.

31:00But there's no certainty because, you know, we live in a world, if you're a pollster, of margin of error. And if you're in Texas and if you're in Iowa and if you're in Ohio and if you're in Alaska and if you're in Michigan, these are all margin of error stays. Right. And so you're counting on where do the voters break? And just to give you a little vignette of what happened in 2022, you know, the undecideds broke towards the party in power, the Democrats. And it had a lot to do with Roe v. Wade stimulating our voters, motivating our voters. There was democracy issues. Republicans had a lot of terrible candidates.

31:37And so for the first time since 1986, undecideds broke towards the party in power of Democrats, and we won surprising races. That's really not about polling. It's about very unique situations. I think in 2026, given the fact that the Republicans are doing so poorly, I like to look at those people who give an unfavorable rating to the Democrats, an unfavorable rating to the Republicans. We call them double haters. And if you look at those people in our Wall Street Journal poll, they're voting for Democrats by a 55 to 27 percent margin. Right. Donald Trump won double haters in 2016. Guess who won him in 2020?

32:22Joe Biden by double digits. Guess who won him in 2024? Donald Trump. So these double haters, as well as looking at independents who Democrats are winning by plus 20, you can get a really good feel that undecideds aren't breaking towards the incumbent Republicans. And so we don't like to talk about uncertainty because you guys love that. But I'll tell you what, we're going to win a bunch of races that no one ever anticipated that we were going to win in January of 2026. The fact that we're not talking right now about the toss up states of North Carolina and Georgia, and instead we're talking probably Kansas and Texas, it tells you everything that you need to know about this election cycle in America.

33:13So, John, let me come in and just tell you about the experience I had visiting a few different towns and cities across Iowa in the last few days. And I met plenty of the double haters that you're talking about. And I would say most people I spoke to would bring up the cost of living on their own, very, very upset about it, directly blaming Donald Trump for the circumstances in which they find themselves. but deeply reluctant to switch a vote to Democrats if they were traditional Republicans. Maybe they'll stay home. Maybe they won't turn out for Republican candidates. But I met no one who was prepared to actively consider switching a vote from Republican to Democrat, despite their fury at the circumstances they find themselves in and the direction they think the country's going in.

34:00Yeah. Well, OK, I don't talk much about certainty. I was a great example. Plus, you know, 10 plus Trump state. Right now, we're seeing rural voters who Trump won by 70 to 30, right? And you have the highest diesel costs we've ever had in modern history for farmers, the highest fertilizer costs because of, again, the war in Iran. We see in rural America, healthcare being decimated because cuts in Medicaid, et cetera. I know that you talk to some people. But what we see, for example, in our Wall Street Journal poll is that if you live in a rural area right now, the Republican generic ballot, are you more likely to vote for Democrat or Republican?

34:44They're getting 56%. So let me put that in perspective there. You're right. They're going to get a lot more than that. But even if Democrats narrow that to 6535 or 6337 in a place like Iowa, Kansas, Texas, all really rural states, those narrowing of margins in the rural area really make a big difference. Same with white working class voters in those areas where we, you know, are the base of Donald Trump's and the Republican Party's electoral successes. Those have all narrowed. So we're going to we're going to narrow the margins of those universes. And again, if we step back and say, OK, maybe we don't even win in a place like Iowa, but it's a one or two point race, it still tells you a hell of a lot about where we are and political environment of the midterms.

35:40And it means that there are going to be a bunch of Democratic wins in plenty of other places. John, you're a rock star in the world of polling and you've been a rock star for us as well, because it's just been fascinating listening to you. Thank you so much for sparing us the time. I hope we can talk to you again when it's all, when the dust has settled. Absolutely. And we're all going to be thinking about 28 then. Then we'll talk about 28. Thanks for having me on. It was a lot of fun. Really nice to talk to you, John. Thanks, John. Bye-bye. Thank you. Thanks now. So he's confident. Well, you wouldn't expect a pollster to be anything other than that.

36:12No, I thought he was interestingly confident about the state of polling, actually. And he drew a really... Well, of course, he is a Democrat. And he's confident about polls that show Democrats ahead. No, but I think he's also confident about the kind of polling that he does, because I think there's a temptation at the moment. And he called me up for quite properly, called me out for falling into this trap, which is to say, oh, well, the polls can be wrong in a kind of broad and rather lazy way. Well, yes, polls can be wrong because some of them are rubbish is the point he was making. And there are a lot of rubbish polls because people won't spend the money on doing the kind of extra work that you have to do.

36:49And he didn't spell out quite what it is. But just to make it plain, everyone knows this, I suppose, that we no longer pick up the landline. Yes. Some some of us under the age of 40 maybe don't even have a landline. And that has made it really, really difficult for them. And they do have to spend more money. They've got to find ways of doing it online and all the rest of it. And then you get a load of people who, and some polls pay you to take part, and they're rubbish because you're only getting people who want the extra money, et cetera, et cetera. So if you are willing to really put the work into the groundwork, I thought this is one of the fascinating points that he made, then you can still trust the polls.

37:26That's his claim anyway. And I'm not one to counter him on that. I think it's a really interesting idea, and we'll see. Because after all, they live or die by this stuff. Yes, he's a Democrat, but also he is a pollster. And if his polls are rubbish and proven to be rubbish, then the Wall Street Journal is not going to be too interested in handing him a load of money in the future. Yes, well, we don't have long to wait, of course, until we've got actual results rather than polls. I'll tell you one thing that I found really interesting on that trip to Iowa. When I was doing things like going around a tailgate party at the Hawkeyes game, I particularly wanted to speak to Republicans.

38:01There's no point in talking to diehard Democrats who are going to tell you that, of course, they're going to vote Democratic. I specifically wanted to speak to Republicans and see whether or not they were changing their mind about how they were going to vote this year. So I was approaching people on the basis of what I thought they looked like. And nobody's wearing political badges. They're all wearing Hawkeye stuff, yellow and black football team colours. I was about 90 percent correct in being able to find Republicans, which that tells you something about modern America. I think whether it's the way people have sorted themselves into groups, whether people style their hair and buy their sunglasses and their trainers on the basis of their political preferences.

38:43But you can tell by looking these days how somebody votes. It used to be that the guys would be wearing kind of jackets and ties. Would be the Republicans. Yes, exactly. The kind of Brooks Brothers. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, Brooks Brothers and the women, what, Lily Pulitzer sort of thing and a lot of pearls and that. But that's not the case. You see a very hairy biker now with a ZZ top beard. He's going to be a Trump voter. And that tells you all you need to know about modern America or is politics. Brilliant. Well, I'm back to modern America at the weekend. So this was just a flying visit. Sorry about that, Justin.

39:18But you're going to come and visit me. Well, visit the United States anyway before the election. So maybe we will be together again soon. To say I'm looking forward to it is to put it very mildly indeed. That's it. Bye bye. Bye bye.

39:35Thank you for answering our call and continuing to send your messages to us. We do read every single one. We love to hear your thoughts, your feedback and questions as well. So please do keep them coming. You can send us an email. It's americast at bbc.co.uk. The WhatsApp is 443301239480. And you can get involved in the AmeriCast Discord server. The link to that is in the description. And don't forget to subscribe. That way you will never miss an episode. Until next time, bye.

40:3360 % off on everything home in person, like up to 60 % off area rugs, up to 30 % off mattresses and major appliances, and up to 50 % off kitchen and dining furniture. Plus, you can take home the small stuff that day and get the big stuff shipped fast and free. Shop Wayfair's long weekend sale, October 10th through October 12th at the Wayfair store at Edens Plaza in Wilmette. Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years, having seen another million people die. I know that I could have done something when when I had a chance. This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen, the Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media.

41:10And now she is the subject of Aaron Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain. And me, Jess Maddox, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

41:32Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years, having seen another million people die, and know that I could have done something when I had a chance. This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen. The Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media. And now she is the subject of Aaron Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain. And me, Jess Maddox, for The Interface. Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts. You

From the publisher

How confident should Democrats be about surprise new polling which puts them ahead in deep Republican territory? In states such as Kansas which haven’t elected a Democratic senator since 1932, Democrat candidates are doing well - why is that, and how much can we trust the polls?

The party’s hope for a blue wave in this year’s midterm elections rest on their ability to flip four Republican seats in the Senate. While the polls suggest the Democrats are ahead in Texas, Alaska and Ohio, the picture is more complicated in Democratic states like Maine and Michigan, which many believe the party must hold on to if they’re to reclaim control of Congress.

Sarah and Justin unpack the latest polls and what it tell us about Democrat and Republican strategy before we speak to the Democratic strategist and pollster John Anzalone. He’s currently working on Roy Cooper’s Senate campaign in North Carolina and most recently served on Joe Biden’s successful 2020 campaign. He tell us why Democrats should be cautious about hopes for a blue wave in November and the issues candidates need to focus on in the run-up to polling day.

HOSTS: • Sarah Smith, BBC North America Editor • Justin Webb, BBC Radio 4 Presenter

GET IN TOUCH: • Join our online community: https://discord.gg/qSrxqNcmRB • Send us a message or voice note via WhatsApp to +44 330 123 9480 • Email [email protected] • Or use #Americast

This episode was made by George Dabby with Alix Pickles and Nik Sindle. The technical producer was Ben Andrews. The series producer is Purvee Pattni. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham.

If you want to be notified every time we publish a new episode, please subscribe to us on BBC Sounds by hitting the subscribe button on the app.

You can now listen to Americast on a smart speaker. If you want to listen, just say "Ask BBC Sounds to play Americast”. It works on most smart speakers.

US Election Unspun: Sign up for Anthony’s BBC newsletter: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-68093155

Americast is part of the BBC News Podcasts family of podcasts. The team that makes Americast also makes lots of other podcasts, including Newscast. If you enjoy Americast (and if you're reading this then you hopefully do), then we think that you will enjoy some of our other pods too. See links below.

Newscast: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/series/p05299nl Top Comment: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/m001mssm Radical: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/p0gg4k6r The Global Story: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/w13xtvsd

More from Americast

All episodes