Are the US and China about to end their trade war?

29 Oct 2025 · 41 min · 22 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode links Donald Trump’s Asia trip—especially his upcoming meeting with Xi Jinping—to whether the US and China are nearing an end to the trade war, then pivots to Karine Jean-Pierre’s critique of the Democratic Party’s strategy after Biden/Harris.

Guests

Karine Jean-Pierre, former White House press secretary (2022–2025) and senior advisor (from Oct 2024), later left the Democratic Party and became an independent; author of Independent. Also featured as a correspondent is Anthony Zerker (BBC sound recordist/press pool), describing Trump’s trip.

Key claims

Trump is softening on China (rare earths, tariffs) and expects a “good deal” with Xi; China is less likely to flatter him and will bargain hard. Jean-Pierre argues Democrats “lost their soul,” aren’t fighting for vulnerable communities (LGBTQ, migrants), and should focus on moral ground and issues like the economy/democracy.

Notable examples

Trump’s YMCA welcome in South Korea; talk of soybeans, TikTok control, fentanyl, and pausing rare-earth export restrictions; Jean-Pierre cites the “No Kings” protests (7 million) and Mamdani’s campaign style (talking to people on a train).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Trump's Pomp and Circumstance in South Korea

0:30 to 2:38

Discussion about Trump's welcoming ceremony in South Korea, including military honors and gifts.

“Yes, that really was a military band rendition of President Trump's favorite song, YMCA.”

AmeriCast Hosts Introduction

2:38 to 3:30

Introduction of the AmeriCast hosts and their locations during the episode.

“When Donald Trump calls, they say, yes, sir.”

Insights from Karine Jean-Pierre

3:30 to 4:38

Discussion about insights and perspectives from former press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre.

“And that is going to be the most part of what we talk about.”

Anthony's Coverage of Trump's Trip

4:38 to 6:20

Anthony shares details about Trump's meetings and events in Asia, including key figures met.

“minister of Japan who was assassinated, who was a close friend of Donald Trump's.”

Trump's Optimism on Foreign Relations

6:20 to 7:58

Trump discusses his views on international relations and peace agreements during his trip.

“He actually came to the back of the plane on that trip.”

Trump's Mixed Messages on Running Again

7:58 to 9:20

Discussion about Trump’s conflicting statements regarding a potential third presidential run.

“and he enjoyed playing golf with Shinzo Abe and that it was a touching gift.”

Evolving Tone on China and Trade Talks

9:20 to 12:25

Analysis of Trump's changing rhetoric towards China amid ongoing trade discussions.

“Now, he's changed his tone about President Xi a bit recently, hasn't he?”

Navigating US-China Economic Relations

12:25 to 14:00

Exploration of the complexities of US-China relations and potential economic implications.

“that if they give the very best ones to China, the feeling is that China then gets a march on the rest of the world and it allows them to do all sorts of things in the longer term that are not in America's interest.”

The Impact of US-China Trade Relations

14:00 to 15:11

Discussing the potential impacts of trade negotiations between the US and China.

“And I think he knows that if he does not try to find some way of working with China, that it could have long term disruptive effects on the American economy.”

Cultural Diplomacy and Trump’s Approach

15:12 to 16:58

Analyzing Donald Trump's approach to diplomacy with other nations, particularly China.

“Throughout this trip, starting in Malaysia and through Japan and into South Korea, it has been the United States operating from a position of strength.”
Show all 22 chapters

Taiwan and Human Rights Issues

16:59 to 18:58

Examining Trump's handling of Taiwan and human rights in relation to China.

“And when it comes to the hard graft of that relationship, there are obviously some difficult things.”

Transitioning Topics: The Future of the Democrats

18:59 to 19:48

Shifting focus from Trump's China strategy to the current state of the Democratic Party.

“doesn't like and what it wants to get from China as their initial starting point.”

Karine Jean-Pierre's Insights on the Democratic Party

19:49 to 21:02

Discussion with former Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre about her views on the Democratic Party's future.

“Now, Karine Jean-Pierre, if you were looking at stuff during the Biden administration, will be a pretty obvious face to you.”

The Party's Identity Crisis

21:03 to 23:20

Exploring Karine Jean-Pierre's concerns about the Democratic Party's direction and identity.

“But when I talked to her, I thought I'd start the other way around, as it were, with the future.”

Moral vs. Political Strategy in Party Politics

23:21 to 25:16

Debating the balance between moral issues and political strategy within the Democratic Party.

“And that actually led to me trying to figure out my voice in this moment in the book.”

Candidates Who Resonate with Voters

25:17 to 27:19

Identifying candidates in the Democratic Party who effectively connect with voters' concerns.

“are afraid and not going into the gutter or going down a rabbit hole about what the other side wants us to talk about.”

Mobilizing Voter Support for the Future

27:20 to 28:07

Discussing the importance of mobilizing voter support amidst the current political climate.

“I mean, I guess West Virginia is an obvious example.”

Engaging the Young Voters

28:07 to 29:26

Discussing the importance of engaging young voters in democracy.

“And if we don't do that, then we're going to be in a world of hurt as a country, as a people.”

Kamala Harris and Public Perception

29:26 to 31:12

Exploring doubts about Kamala Harris's electability and public perception.

“But Justin, let me, I'm going to lay this out for you.”

Biden's Decision and Party Accountability

31:12 to 34:15

Analyzing Biden's decision to run and the Democratic Party's accountability.

“If you think it's holding you back, the thing to do was to have the open contest, was to persuade Joe Biden to drop out earlier, was to do something, do something, and you never did anything.”

Future Elections and Current Challenges

34:15 to 35:30

Discussing the immediate challenges facing the current administration and future elections.

“And he will lay out what his thought process is.”

Reflections on Democratic Strategies

35:30 to 39:46

Reflecting on the Democratic Party's strategies and future direction.

“Well, Justin, that was really, really interesting.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Anthony:This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:06Anthony:How did the United States build the largest soft power empire in the world with the help of some tiny metal objects? I'm Tristan Redmond, one of the hosts of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. To mark 250 years of the United States, we speak to Roman Mars of 99 % invisible. This soft power, this influence was an incredible invention. For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

1:00Anthony:Enough, enough. Yes, that really was a military band rendition of President Trump's favorite song, YMCA. It was recorded for us on location by none other than top sound recordist Anthony Zerker. Anthony, where on earth were you? What were the circumstances? It sounds fantastic. I was at the airport in Busan, South Korea. We had just landed on Air Force One and the South Koreans had rolled out the reddit. carpet for Donald Trump. They had that military marching band. They had a 21-gun salute. They had all these dignitaries welcoming him. When he came down the staircase, they played Hail to the Chief.

1:41The cannon shot off. And then, as you heard, this military band and their pomp and circumstance uniforms transitioned to the village people playing YMCA. I don't know if Donald Trump appreciated it, but it was indicative of the kind of attention to detail the South Koreans have had here in trying to curry Trump's favour. It's amazing, isn't it? The way country after country is trying to up the ante and how they flatter Donald Trump with all of this pomp and circumstance. Have you seen the gifts that the South Koreans gave him? It's remarkable. It is a copy of an ancient Korean crown, which is very, very shiny gold covered in gemstones.

2:21It's a huge, really, really tall crown that Donald Trump looked delighted to receive and could see no irony at all, I think, in the fact that just a couple of weeks ago, seven million Americans were on the streets on those No Kings protests because it's bright gold, it's very, very shiny, and he loves it. It was a masterstroke, I think, from the South Koreans.

2:40Anthony:The Trump circus goes east. Welcome to AmeriCast.

2:47AmeriCast. AmeriCast from BBC News. When Donald Trump calls, they say, yes, sir. Right away, sir. Happy to lick your boot, sir. We are the sickest country in the world. Oh, dear. Are you worried that billionaires are going to go hungry? Of course the president supports peaceful protests. What a stupid question.

3:03Anthony:Are you still talking about Jeffrey Epstein?

3:12Anthony:It's Justin at home in South London. It's Sarah here in the BBC's Bureau in Washington. And it's Anthony in the, well, let's see, the Asia Pacific headquarters of AmeriCast, the South Korea headquarters of AmeriCast. I am in Gyeongchang, South Korea. All right. We are an expanding enterprise. No question about that. We'll get to Anthony in a second. And that is going to be the most part of what we talk about. I just want to say right at the beginning, I've been talking to Karine Jean-Pierre, the former press secretary for Joe Biden. She's got a book out, key figure, of course, in the Biden administration, also very close to Kamala Harris.

3:51Anthony:She said some interesting things about where the Democrats should go next. So there's all sorts of stuff about her and what she thought about Biden, what she thought about Harris. And we do get to that. But I know from what you tell us, you AmeriCasters, is that what interests you is what happens next to the Democratic Party. She's got some quite interesting views on that. Anyway, before we get to that, Anthony, tell us about your trip. Well, yeah, I joined up with Donald Trump in Tokyo, Japan. That was in the second leg of his trip to Asia. The first one was in Malaysia, where he presided over a normalization, a ceasefire agreement between Thailand and Cambodia.

4:30Add another peace deal to Donald Trump's growing list that he likes to tout. In Korea, he met with the new prime minister, the first woman prime minister of Japan, Sanae Takeuchi, and she gave Donald Trump a golf bag and a putter that belonged to Shinzo Abe, who was the former prime minister of Japan who was assassinated, who was a close friend of Donald Trump's. also nominated Donald Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize, which is what people tend to do these days when they're trying to curry favor with Donald Trump. Had a big dinner. They had a rally on an aircraft carrier together. It was quite a spectacle.

5:09You're a long, long way away, Anthony, with a pretty killer time difference, I think, don't you, of about, what, 12, 13 hours from where I am here. Have you seen some great stuff? You've been posting some photographs that look pretty spectacular. The flight that we had from Japan to here in South Korea was actually spectacular. The Air Force One, it looked like it took a bit of a scenic route. It actually occurred by and flew right over the top of Mount Fuji. So we had an amazing view of Mount Fuji as we were coming by. And then as we got into South Korean airspace, we had about four F-16, Air Force and Marine F-16s accompanying us right on the wing of Air Force One.

5:53This is something that started with the Saudis on Donald Trump's Mideast trip at the beginning of this year. They had some F-16s and Donald Trump talked about how great it is. So now it seems like every time Trump visits a foreign country, there is a military jet escort. So I guess now the Americans are going to do it as well. But it provided some pretty remarkable views out the window as we were coming into Busan for our landing in South Korea.

6:18Anthony:And has Donald Trump himself come to the back of the plane at all? He did. He actually came to the back of the plane on that trip. He spoke with those of us in the press pool for about 20 minutes. I got to ask him a variety of different questions. I asked him a little bit about Mideast peace and the ceasefire between Hamas and Israel that seems to be a bit in jeopardy. And he still expressed optimism that the ceasefire would hold and that Hamas would ultimately lay down its arms. I asked about Hurricane Melissa, which is hitting Jamaica, just hit Jamaica. And he said the United States was willing to support Jamaica, would be sending aid.

6:58And then I also asked him about the big Xi Trump meeting tomorrow, our time here in South Korea. And Donald Trump expressed optimism. He said a lot of groundwork had already been laid in meetings by his Treasury Secretary, Scott Bessent, and that he wasn't going to that meeting cold. He knew what was going to happen and he thought that good things were going to result.

7:21Anthony:Does he like you, Anthony? I just want to because he hasn't always had a good relationship with the BBC, has he? But he must see quite a lot of you on these trips. Do you get on with him? Is there a bit of joshing there? Yeah, you know, he seems pretty friendly. He's he always there was one time when we were in the Middle East where he brisked a little bit at a question. I asked him about Vladimir Putin and whether the Russians were taking negotiations with Ukraine seriously. And he asked me, you know, where I was from. And I said, BBC, and he kind of scoffed. But but, yeah, you know, I asked him about the golf club he got from Takachi.

7:54and he said he was really appreciative of the golf club and he enjoyed playing golf with Shinzo Abe and that it was a touching gift. He generally has been in a good mood for this entire trip, although he did have dinner earlier this evening with about seven other heads of state here for the APEC conference, and one of them was Mark Carney, the Canadian prime minister, who he has feuded with recently, and he seemed to be giving a bit of a cold stare across the table at Carney. So that was the one time he expressed a little bit, maybe not quite as jovial. And he's made some controversial statements, hasn't he, Anthony, on this trip?

8:32First of all, a couple of days ago, saying he did want to run again in 2020 for a third presidential term. And that said of all sorts of speculation about what he meant, about how he was going to get around the constitutional bar on that. And now, on the course of the same trip, he's come right out and said he cannot run again for a third term. Is that right? Yeah, he walked that back on Air Force One today, and he had said that he thought it would be too cute to do the idea that maybe he could not run as vice president and be elevated to president. I think he understands that the obstacles to becoming president for a third term would be pretty great.

9:11It's pretty clear in the Constitution that he can't do it. But I think he does like needling, maybe trolling people on the left with it. And it also keeps him relevant, right? If we're thinking about maybe Trump will be around for another seven years, it gives him a sort of power and influence that a second term president who, you know, serving out the last few years of his term and everyone's trying to think who the next president will be. It helps him avoid that. Now, he's changed his tone about President Xi a bit recently, hasn't he? Because this meeting that's coming up is the big highlight, really, of this trip to the Far East.

9:48And a few weeks ago, he was posting on Truth Social how terrible the Chinese were, how he was going to up tariffs, how appalled he was with rare earths law that the Chinese had passed, saying that if you wanted to export anything that had even a tiny amount of rare earth minerals from China, there were going to be export controls on those. And he went from being furious about that to more recently talking about the very well-respected President Xi and that kind of thing as he's softening his tone as they move towards these trade discussions. And he sounded pretty optimistic about it all. And whilst he was at an event of that Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation Summit in South Korea, he actually said that he really does think the U.S.

10:31is going to get a good deal with China. The President Xi of China is coming tomorrow here and we're going to be, I hope, making a deal.

10:38Anthony:I think we're going to have a deal. I think it'll be a good deal for for both. And that's really a great result. You know, that's better than fighting and going through all sorts of problems and, you know, no reason for it. I think it's going to be a great deal for both. So I'll be meeting him tomorrow. A lot of people are interested. They're also interested in what we're doing, but they're interested in that. I can tell you a lot. The world is watching. And I think we'll have something that's very exciting for everybody. Donald Trump really does seem optimistic about this meeting. I think he feels like China is going to start buying soybeans again, which is something they haven't done recently, which is really hurt American farmers.

11:17It sounds like there might be a finalized deal on TikTok and handing some control over to American interests, maybe something on fentanyl. Certainly the restrictions on rare earth minerals being exported from China appears to be easing or not even implemented whatsoever. And Donald Trump, for his part, has already backed away from these 100 percent tariffs he was threatening to putting on China. So it is there's a sense of optimism, not only with Donald Trump, but in the stock market, which is booming as he likes to know over and over again. And so it feels like tomorrow might be a breakthrough.

11:57But the Chinese and Xi, they drive a hard bargain. You know, they are going to be coming in and they don't want to give Donald Trump an easy win. So nothing is decided until they sit in the room and reach those agreements. But it feels like the United States and China might be on a precipice of something a little more normalized.

12:15Anthony:But it's worth saying, isn't it, that there are plenty of people in MAGA world who are upset about that and will not react very kindly to a wider deal with China, particularly one that gives more in American advanced technology, particularly semiconductors, computer chips, that at the moment they're restricting, that if they give the very best ones to China, the feeling is that China then gets a march on the rest of the world and it allows them to do all sorts of things in the longer term that are not in America's interest. And also, to an extent, over Taiwan. You know, how strong is Trump going to be about Taiwan?

12:50Anthony:I mean, you do pick up, don't you, a sort of sense of unease as well about a deal that Trump might, in the enthusiasm of the moment, you know, with YMCA ringing in his ears, just be tempted to me. Yeah, that is a very real possibility. There are China hawks. There are people who view China as a, you know, communism line, communist influence in the world within Donald Trump's administration. Marco Rubio, his secretary of state, used to be a China hawk, although he tends to match whatever Donald Trump is saying at this point. And there are people within the conservative movement. I mean, I can remember going back five, six, seven years to CPAC, the conservative conference, having a very decided anti-China bent with concerns about Chinese ownership of American land or American businesses and the malign influence that that might have.

13:39So I think Donald Trump has to walk a fine line. But what he is sensitive to is that every time he rattles the economic sabers against China, every time it looks like things might devolve into a trade war, things might go south. the American stock market tanks, drops hundreds of points, drops percentage points within just a matter of hours. And I think he knows that if he does not try to find some way of working with China, that it could have long term disruptive effects on the American economy. And no doubt, if he gets the kind of deal that they've been hinting at over the weekend, and the Treasury Secretary Scott Besson has been, you know, teasing us some of the deals about like, as you were saying, Anthony, for instance, the rare earth mineral restrictions being paused for at least a year and the Chinese starting to buy soybeans again.

14:29It's only going to get us back to where we were, isn't it, before Donald Trump started this with the tariffs. You can see what he's done with other countries. And in fact, compared to what's happened with South Korea just this week as well, he's signed a deal that's very, very advantageous for America with South Korea. And so that with a threat of tariffs, he has forced the South Koreans to do a bunch of things that Donald Trump wanted. With the Chinese, because every time he's up to tariffs, they have also upped the ante by doing things like restricting exports or also putting reciprocal tariffs on, stopping buying American goods.

15:04All you're talking about is Donald Trump will ease the tariffs if they ease their countermeasures and we'll end up back on a level playing field, won't we? Yeah, that's exactly right. Throughout this trip, starting in Malaysia and through Japan and into South Korea, it has been the United States operating from a position of strength. All of these leaders in all of these countries have tried to find ways to appeal to Donald Trump, to win him over, whether it's playing YMCA or giving him a putter or letting him broker a peace deal on their soil. They're trying to stroke Donald Trump's ego. And China doesn't play that way.

15:42I mean, just to illustrate stroking the ego, let me read to you the menu from the lunch that Donald Trump had today with President Lee of South Korea. It was billed as Korean flavors meet American spirit, celebrating the enduring friendship through taste. And the first course was reminiscing the success story of New York. Korean seafood meets Thousand Island dressing, a salad of shrimp, scallops and abalone with tossed with autumn herbs and a classic Thousand Island dressing. Then he had Korean platter of sincerity with U.S. beef, side dishes of kimchi and mini beef patties with ketchup. And then the final, the piece de resistance was the dessert, the Peacemaker's dessert, golden citrus dessert with gold adorned brownie and seasonal fruit served with buckwheat tea.

16:31So that gives you a taste literally of what these countries were trying to do. The Tokyo Tower in Tokyo was red, white and blue when Donald Trump came in with a gold top on it. I mean, it was almost a little, you know, nausea inducing what some of these countries are doing. But China doesn't operate that way. And China, Xi is going to be meeting with Donald Trump at an airport. No glamour, no glitz, no currying to favour, just two superpowers trying to figure out a way to work together.

17:02Anthony:Yeah. And when it comes to the hard graft of that relationship, there are obviously some difficult things. We've talked about trade, but it's not just trade, is it? But it's also, well, crucially, I suppose, Taiwan and its future and the pressure, the increasing pressure that China seems to be putting on Taiwan. But also, I was fascinated by this, Anthony, because he was asked about Jimmy Lai, wasn't he? He was this British businessman, been in prison for several years now, Hong Kong newspaper magnate, freedom campaigner, who the Brits had been trying to get out for a long time. And he kind of I was surprised that he sort of ran with it in a way and said, yeah, I might talk to Xi about it.

17:43Anthony:And we might have some sort of progress, which I just don't associate with Donald Trump. What do you think's going on there, if anything? I'm not sure either. That was surprising. And maybe it's Donald Trump sees this as a way of gaining some sort of advantage, some sort of leverage on China by hitting them on human rights. Funny thing was, he was asked on Air Force One today what he thought about Taiwan and if he was going to talk to China about Taiwan. And Trump kind of brushed it off. He said, Taiwan is Taiwan, whatever that means. But he didn't want to try to push China on that. So it's a kind of a confusing game that Trump is playing on whether he wants to be confrontational with China, whether he wants to try to back off on things and where he is drawing the lines and where he is deciding to put a spotlight versus where he doesn't really want to engage.

18:31If you look at his negotiating style, I think what he's very likely to do with this meeting is start off with a long list of complaints about the way China is operating, about where he sees the trade balance between the two countries being unfair, any of the measures that they've introduced recently. And he'll have a whole screed of things that he thinks that China are doing that are bad. And so he can, you know, add human rights abuses or things like that to that list so that he's kind of berating Xi with everything that the U.S. doesn't like and what it wants to get from China as their initial starting point.

19:05And then he'll back down from that and they'll agree a few points and he'll let some of it go. So it could be that he's just looking to add to that list without necessarily wanting to put Taiwan on it, because we've heard very little from Donald Trump ever really sort of supporting Taiwan and its position. So maybe he just doesn't want to go there, but he needs to find a whole whole list of stuff to try and hit Xi over the head with to open the meeting.

19:27Anthony:We will let Anthony go, won't we, Sarah, because otherwise he'll be he'll be completely he'll be a basket case. Too late. We can't have basket cases following the president around on Air Force One. um anthony go to bed or or i don't know is it morning is it evening do you even know it's approaching midnight i am going to bed now because it'll be an early start tomorrow and a long journey home okay talk to you soon see y 'all later righty ho let's turn back to the future of the democrats which is something we talk about i think we talk about almost every podcast uh at the moment but rightly so because it is a huge subject and it's of great interest to everyone I've been talking to Karine Jean-Pierre.

20:04Anthony:Now, Karine Jean-Pierre, if you were looking at stuff during the Biden administration, will be a pretty obvious face to you. She was the face of the White House, basically. She did that job where you come into the press room every day and you face the press. So she was press secretary from 2022 to 2025. She was a senior advisor to the president as well from October 2024. So she was there. She was in the room, as it were, when decisions were being taken. And then in June of this year, she announced that she'd left the Democratic Party. She was now an independent. Though, as you'll hear, she's very much still a supporter of the party.

20:47Anthony:And she's an independent in the sense that she is outside it now, but still wants it effectively to win. She's written a book. It's called Independent. A look inside a broken White House outside the party lines. A lot of the book is about what happened with Joe Biden and what happened with Kamala Harris. But when I talked to her, I thought I'd start the other way around, as it were, with the future. What does she think of the current state of the Democratic Party? What needs to happen now? Well, what my take is, is that the party is lost. I feel as if the party has lost their soul. One of the things that concerned me very early on in the Trump administration was when the administration was trying to push forward some very unqualified nominees.

21:33And you had Democrats in the Senate who basically rubber stamped Trump's nominees, which for me sent a signal that they were giving up their power. Project 2025 was loud and clear. And the fact that they were not prepared for a Trump administration the moment he stepped in was concerning. And now what I'm seeing even more that's more concerning is there's just continues to be no fight. And because mentioning them doesn't hold test well, they're throwing communities under the bus. And so that's concerning because we're supposed to be the Democratic Party, supposed to be a big tent party.

22:13Anthony:That's interesting. Who is being thrown under the bus in your view? When you think about the LGBTQ community, when you think about migrants and immigrants and you don't see enough fight and they're silent, you know, they're not really coming up with a strategy. And it is very much, oh, okay, that doesn't poll test, you know, well, oh, the country's afraid of migrants. So therefore, we're not going to be mentioning them or fighting for them. Oh, you know what, the LGBT community, we can't, we really can't support the LGBT community because no one wants, you know, some of the policies or some of the issues or some of the freedoms that the community should be having.

Read the full transcript

22:48And one thing to know about me, Justin, is that I'm obviously a Black woman, I also am part of the queer community. I'm also an immigrant. And when you hear things like that about communities that you participate in, that you're part in, then you feel like you're not representing and no one's fighting for you. When I came out of the administration, the Biden-Harris administration, obviously in January, very early on this year, I was hearing from people. They were saying to me, what's going on? Where is the fight? Where is the fight? Why aren't we ready? And that actually led to me trying to figure out my voice in this moment in the book.

23:28Anthony:I mean, just to take one issue then, which is biological males playing in women's sports. So that's an issue that really harmed the Democrats, didn't it, during the election. Are you suggesting that on that issue, the Democrats just say, look, we think it's a moral issue. Do we think people who are trans should be able to choose where they play their sports? We're going to stick to it. And if you don't like that, then don't vote for us. I mean, isn't that a kind of isn't that a way of just committing electoral suicide? I actually disagree because we should not go down a rabbit hole because Republicans are telling us don't say woke or this issue or that issue.

24:14We should stand on moral ground and really, really, really try to do our best to protect people who feel vulnerable.

24:21Anthony:But what if that doesn't work politically there, Karen? That's the problem for you, isn't it? It's not about having a debate. Don't have the debate. Just say where you stand and move forward and focus on things that will move the country forward. Focus on the economy. You know, focus on issues that matter. Focus on democracy. Yeah, but you'll be asked about those things, won't you? Yeah, but here's the thing. I mean, I wasn't part of the campaign, so I can't speak to their strategy. Obviously, I was part of the – as White House press secretary, I was speaking for the president, and I was part of the government and the White House.

24:56And I think what I am trying to say is that there are issues that have been issues in the past, again, civil rights issues, human rights issues that were not popular, where the country wasn't there. But it is, it cannot, there has to be a time where it's not about politics, where it has to be about your moral compass to doing the right thing and standing up for people who are afraid and not going into the gutter or going down a rabbit hole about what the other side wants us to talk about.

25:27Anthony:Let me ask you then, are there any, is there anyone in the party at the moment who you think is doing that? So we on the on the podcast quite recently, we focused on the campaigns in Virginia and in New Jersey, these very important gubernatorial campaigns. And you've got two. I mean, I suppose you could describe them in shorthand as moderate Democrats in Spanberger and Mikey Sherrill, who are who are going for those and likely to win. And of course, also, and we've done an entire episode on Zoran Mandani and this incredible campaign. Yeah, very different story. Yeah. Well, who excites you from there or do any of them?

26:06Look, Mamdani obviously is an incredibly impressive candidate. He has managed to get young people excited. And he has done something that you don't see politicians, certainly Democrats, doing, which is going directly to the American people. When he was riding the train and having conversations with people, they felt heard. They felt listened to. They felt seen. And so those are the things that are missing. And I think there are things that he's doing that certainly on the national level, Democratic leadership could listen to that and take some direction on how to communicate with people. I believe Democrats should go into Republican district and talk to Republican voters about the economy.

26:50I believe they should also be standing in front of a hospital that's about to shut down because of GOP hikes and have a press conference and say, hey, this is what's going on. There's so many things that they can do so that voters see them and see them fighting for them. And I think that is one of the things from Mamdani that has been quite impressive and something for them to learn from.

27:13Anthony:And are you happy to see the Mamdani kind of candidate in a place like New York, where it looks as if he can win and win big, but also a completely different sort of candidate? So one of the things we've been discussing on the podcast is this business of whether you should run, for instance, people who are not keen on abortion in some states where there are more conservative voters, including voters who used to vote Democrat but don't anymore. I mean, I guess West Virginia is an obvious example. Or should you have a kind of litmus test of what is acceptable and what isn't acceptable? Where do you where do you stand on that?

27:51Look, I believe that right now, if you are a part of a community or if you identify in whatever way, just know that when they come for one, they come for all of us, which means we have to stand together. We have to stand together. There's a large fight ahead of us. And if we don't do that, then we're going to be in a world of hurt as a country, as a people. And so what I want to see, I think what's important is that you have candidates that listen, acknowledge and speak to what people really care about. Look, one of the best examples that I can give you, and it's not even coming from elected officials, coming from the people, the people of this country.

28:37When seven million people came out for the No Kings rally not too long ago, and it was the third one, which meant that it grew by millions. That is telling you, like elected officials, these leaderships should see, OK, this is where seven million people came out. This is where many, many voices are. They're afraid about what's going on in our democracy. And that is something to tap into. I actually believe we need a functioning two-party system in order to have a democracy. You learn that in poli-sci. And what's happening now, our system is broken. And we have too much of politics in it, and we need to bring people power in it.

29:14And so that is what matters to me. How do we get people more engaged, more involved, especially young people, who, by the way, young people are becoming more independent by the day?

29:25Anthony:talking of saving democracy um i mean one of the things you write in the book that i think will amaze people in particular is that you you didn't think that kamala harris after she took over from joe biden you didn't think she was going to win and i think a lot of people will say what well if you didn't think she was going to win and if other people didn't think she was going to why on earth did you run her wait first of all i didn't run anybody i don't have that power so thank you so You were closer than the rest of us. You were in the White House. But Justin, let me, I'm going to lay this out for you.

30:00Sure. Two things could be true. And the two things are, I was proud that she was running. I was, I think she's more than qualified to be president of the United States. And I think she did a phenomenal job in those 107 days. And as a black woman who lives in this country and walks through this world, I could also have doubts because of my personal experiences in walking in this body and looking like the way that I do. You know, only people who've been othered or live in, you know, live in spaces where they don't see themselves can understand that. It is a feeling that is sad, but very real, very, very real.

30:46And she actually touches on that a little bit too, as well, in her book, from what I understand, and I've heard her speak to it as well. But that is just the reality. Those two things could be true. You could think someone is more than qualified and able to do the job, but then also you're like, oh my gosh, is the country ready for this? Now, don't forget, as you know, in 2016, we had Hillary Clinton. So it's not out of the norm for me to have thought that.

31:11Anthony:I mean, I suppose that's the point, isn't it? That so many people around the world who are so distressed about Donald Trump coming to power again, and all that you, you writ large, you as Democrats, which you were, of course, at the time and a very prominent one, all that you were warning the world about Donald Trump, they would say, just run anyone, the actual identity stuff. If you think it's holding you back, the thing to do was to have the open contest, was to persuade Joe Biden to drop out earlier, was to do something, do something, and you never did anything. I just well, first of all, you know, I was not on the campaign.

31:49I was the spokesperson for the president of the United States. So but I will say this in the loss of 2024. I agree with you. We all should take accountability, not you know, not just the Democratic leadership. All of us should take some accountability. And I do as well. in what happened. I believe in the time, the summer of 2024, the way Democrats behaved actually hurt us. And remember, we had a primary, 14 million people came out, they voted for Biden and Harris, 14 million people, that's not nothing. There was a process that went through, and a decision was made. And I think that the decision by the Democratic Party was made, And I think that did hurt us.

32:32And you have to be hopeful in the moment that we're in. And she ran a fantastic campaign. She just did at the end of the day. And there were many, but there are many reasons why it didn't work out.

32:47Anthony:isn't it isn't in a sense isn't it obvious why you had a a presidential candidate who all the polls said was going to lose and he and he didn't get out at the right time and then when he did get out to be kind to her it didn't leave her enough time to run a really good campaign but the party could have intervened earlier couldn't it or could it not was it just impossible you were there on the inside yeah yeah yeah no just a couple things there was an incumbency issue i mean you saw that with other G7, G10 countries. COVID, the economy, right? So there was an incumbency issue and we saw that across the world.

33:25And the economy, even though it was improving, people weren't feeling it. And so it's not just the person, it's the party. It's the party that has the power. So there was that that existed. In 2023, and I always like to take people back to 2023 when President Joe Biden made the decision, it was a different time. party leadership was encouraging to him to to run because of the midterms and how the midterms turned out it wasn't a red wave it wasn't as bad as we thought it was a historic midterm for an incumbent first midterm for uh for a president and so that was part of it he was the only person to have beaten donald trump he objectively had a good couple of years of his presidency and so those were the decisions that went in again party leadership were encouraging him to run And so that's why that decision was made.

34:16Joe Biden is going to write his book. He will tell his story. I can't wait to read it. And he will lay out what his thought process is. But we can't forget the facts that existed during that time in making that decision.

34:31Anthony:Final thought from you. Yes. And thank you for saying my name so well. Thank you so much. Not many people do that, so I appreciate that. best. We don't always get it right. I have to say, we're equally capable of getting it very wrong. That's the French way. Just a final thought. People keep asking us who's going to run, who should win, who's going to run. What's your thought about, name names, go on for 28. So here's the thing, Justin, I don't want to talk about 2028, not with you, just in general, because we got to get out of 2025. We got to get out of 2026. We have a president who is already right now in 2025 is saying that he wants his Justice Department to monitor elections that are happening just this year.

35:18We have a president who is essentially saying he's going to cheat in 2026.

35:24Anthony:Kary and Jean-Pierre, it's been a real pleasure to talk to you. Thank you very much for sparing us the time. Thanks, Justin. Appreciate it. Anytime. Bye. Bye-bye.

35:41Well, Justin, that was really, really interesting. If I had any position at all in the Democratic Party, I think I would have my head in my hands listening to it, though, because it did not sound like somebody who was masterminding a comeback, does it? I think we should point out to any AmeriCasters who don't know this already that one of the things Corrine says in the book is the reason she left the Democratic Party is she was so disappointed with the way they treated Joe Biden and basically chased him off the presidential ticket. Now, there are not very many people left in the party who think that he should have carried on with that candidacy and that if he had, he would have beaten Donald Trump in the election last year.

36:21So that's a fairly remarkable place to begin for her. And she has to say been widely panned for that here. This book has not been very well reviewed in the United States. But the lack of insight into how badly everything went wrong was what really took me aback.

36:38Anthony:Yeah, I mean, exactly that. And you're right, it has been widely lampooned, hasn't it? The book itself, and actually also, frankly, some of her performances afterwards. And I thought, you know, you can make what you like of that conversation. I wanted it to be a positive one, and one that was interesting to people rather than sort of combative. but she's had some pretty combative ones where what what she has seemed to be saying exactly as you suggest there has been sort of fundamentally number one in complete denial of what everyone thinks they knew was going on uh towards the end of the Biden administration but number two also just inconsistent actually because as I said to her at one stage in the book she says she didn't think Kamala Harris was was capable of winning she thought she was wasn't going to I mean in those circumstances what is she saying they shouldn't or they should have picked her and it's still not entirely clear to me actually what she makes of that whole business you remember there was a chance albeit a small one but some sort of a chance particularly if biden had dropped out earlier that they'd have some kind of contested primary um or at least a competition between a few of them to work out who the best one might be she doesn't seem to be in favor of that but she also doesn't seem to think that her her candidate had a hope of winning which is just when you think of all the stakes involved.

37:57Anthony:Just bizarre to me. And when you were talking to her about LGBT issues, I think you were trying to hint at, were you not, that there can be a sort of purity test performed on Democrats standing for election, whereby if you don't agree with certain positions on things like trans rights, abortion, same sex marriage, whatever, then you're not good enough to run as a Democrat and whether or not they have to ease back on that. And there are many, many conversations happening now about the ways in which candidates in more rural places, for instance, shouldn't have to say the same kind of things as people in metropolitan New York.

38:35But no, that wasn't something that she was prepared to talk about either. It was almost as though if you can stand on moral ground that's high enough, somehow your righteousness will win out, which I think is exactly where they went wrong.

38:49Anthony:well i mean they've tried that haven't they that's the thing it's it's not us saying they've gone wrong because we disagree with it or agree with it it's not it's not neither you nor i have a dog in the fight or an interest in telling people what we think it's empirically the case isn't it they tried these purity tests and they tried the um the identity politics stuff or at least you know they got trapped into it and they couldn't get out of it it's probably a better way of putting isn't it Sarah but that they went down this line and it didn't work out terribly well and I suppose the interesting thing is whether you do double down on it which she seemed to be suggesting I think from her personal standpoint is what she wants them to do because eventually you'll win out or whether you you you change course and I I don't know I just think the party has to address this and address it openly if they're going to get anywhere at all plenty to keep us going though, which is the good news.

39:46If we leave it there for today, but whilst Donald Trump is over there in South Korea, we should play just one more time, shouldn't we? That military band and their rendition of his theme song. It's too good to be true. See you all later. Bye bye.

40:24AmeriCast. AmeriCast from BBC News.

40:27Anthony:Well, look, thanks for listening all the way to the end of today's AmeriCast. You are now officially an AmeriCaster. It is, of course, a ride, a wild ride navigating the US news, particularly in the era of Trump. You have made it. If you have a comment, a question about the things we've talked about, or anything at all, actually, get in touch with us. The email is americast.bbc.co.uk. The WhatsApp is 0330 123 9480. We answer your questions every single week, actually, on the podcast, so keep them coming. You can join the online community as well on Discord. The link is in the podcast description on your app.

41:05Anthony:We will be back with another podcast very soon, so until then, see you all later. Bye.

41:24Anthony:How did the United States build the largest soft power empire in the world with the help of some tiny metal objects? I'm Tristan Redmond, one of the hosts of the Global Story podcast from the BBC. to mark 250 years of the United States, we speak to Roman Mars of 99 % invisible. This soft power, this influence, was an incredible invention. For more, listen to The Global Story on bbc.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

President Donald Trump is topping off his whirlwind trip around Asia with a long-anticipated meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping on Thursday. After months of an escalating trade war, Trump says a “good deal” is close to being agreed. It also includes negotiations on TikTok's US operations.

Anthony joins Sarah and Justin from South Korea, where he’s been hot on the president’s heels throughout his trip, to discuss how the meeting is expected to go and how much difference it could make to everyday Americans.

And Justin speaks to former White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre about her belief that the Democratic Party unfairly pushed Joe Biden out of the 2024 race, and why she thinks they are abandoning LGBTQ issues.

HOSTS: • Justin Webb, Radio 4 presenter • Sarah Smith, North America Editor

GET IN TOUCH: • Join our online community: https://discord.gg/qSrxqNcmRB • Send us a message or voice note via WhatsApp to +44 330 123 9480 • Email Americast@bbc.co.uk • Or use #Americast

This episode was made by Rufus Gray and Alix Pickles. The technical producer was Michael Regaard. The series producer is George Dabby. The senior news editor is Sam Bonham.

If you want to be notified every time we publish a new episode, please subscribe to us on BBC Sounds by hitting the subscribe button on the app.

You can now listen to Americast on a smart speaker. If you want to listen, just say "Ask BBC Sounds to play Americast”. It works on most smart speakers.

US Election Unspun: Sign up for Anthony’s BBC newsletter: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-68093155

Americast is part of the BBC News Podcasts family of podcasts. The team that makes Americast also makes lots of other podcasts, including Newscast and Ukrainecast. If you enjoy Americast (and if you're reading this then you hopefully do), then we think that you will enjoy some of our other pods too. See links below.

Newscast: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/series/p05299nl Ukrainecast: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/p0bqztzm Radical: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/p0gg4k6r The Global Story: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/brand/w13xtvsd

More from Americast

All 207 episodes
Are the US and China about to end their trade war?Americast · 41 min
Listen in VO