Armchair Anonymous: Bar Stories

1 May 2026 · 45 min · 16 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

“Armchair Anonymous: Bar Stories” features three guests recounting chaotic bar-night incidents involving violence, fake IDs, and injuries, plus a recurring theme of how quickly situations escalate and how authorities respond.

Guests (backgrounds)

  • Justin (from central Wisconsin; previously head of security in downtown Minneapolis, about 6 months at a busy college bar; martial arts/black belt; military experience).
  • Casey (from Johannesburg, South Africa; early-20s bargoer; later moved back and forth between Johannesburg and hometown).
  • Leah/Lee (from Northville, Michigan; Michigan State alum; stay-at-home mom and personal trainer; tells a 2014 Michigan State fake-ID story).

Key claims

  • Justin stopped an assault outside a Minneapolis bar, then suffered a severe infection from a bite/saliva exposure requiring IV antibiotics, surgery, and wound debridement.
  • Casey’s ex’s group escalated at a Johannesburg Hooters; a friend was punched through a window; the aggressor damaged the car; police arrested the other man; Casey was a witness.
  • Leah/Lee’s friend Janine used a fake ID at a Michigan State bar; the bartender/bouncer recognized the ID holder; police officers arrived; they escaped without a chase.

Notable examples

  • Justin: 2:30 a.m. fight; broken hand/tooth missing; infection spread past a drawn line; surgeon warned amputation risk.
  • Casey: group grew to ~8; windshield smashed; malicious damage/attempted murder allegations; detective said the aggressor lied.
  • Leah/Lee: fake ID named “Haley”; bouncer smirked “How do you know Haley?”; bar manager “Hank” confronted; officers described “blonde in the big pink necklace.”

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Setting the Scene for Bar Stories

1:47 to 2:36

Host and guests discuss the context and environment of bar culture.

Justin's Bar Security Story

2:36 to 11:20

Justin shares a harrowing experience as a bar security head involving a violent altercation.

“At that time, it was more of like a college place where kids would come from the U of M and go parties.”

Discussion on Personal Safety

11:20 to 12:25

The hosts reflect on the implications of Justin's story and personal safety in bar environments.

“But also, you know, there's a lot of stats around that.”

A Night Out Turns Intense

14:03 to 16:02

Listen to a recount of a tense night out that escalates unexpectedly.

“And a couple of weeks later or a couple of months later, I don't know exactly the time, I saw that the girl from this couple ended up being single and I decided to slide into the DM.”

Police Involvement and Aftermath

17:18 to 21:34

Learn about the aftermath of the confrontation and unexpected police interaction.

“And he's getting more and more aggressive.”

Chance Encounter at the Gym

21:34 to 22:58

Hear about a surprising run-in with an old adversary years later.

“And did he ever reach out to your then girlfriend about it?”

Fun and Games at Hooters

22:58 to 28:00

Enjoy light-hearted and humorous discussions about experiences at Hooters.

“They would only sell you two pitchers of beer.”

The Night Out Begins

28:00 to 31:19

A group of friends prepares to use a fake ID at a college bar.

“Now, Janine is about 5152, cute as a button.”

The Bouncer's Challenge

31:20 to 33:59

Janine faces the bouncer while trying to enter the bar with a fake ID.

“The bar is split because you go down the steps.”

The Great Escape

34:00 to 36:19

The friends try to flee as police arrive, leading to a frantic escape.

“And she comes to join the group and is like, we got to go.”
Show all 16 chapters

Teeth and Tumbles

36:20 to 37:38

A story about a drunken fall that results in broken teeth.

“It was literally glued to the back of a Blockbuster card.”

Unexpected Cab Ride Home

37:39 to 42:00

After the fall, the protagonist finds herself in a cab with strangers.

“This is part of a fort kit that my children own.”

A Night Out Gone Wrong

42:00 to 43:26

Katie recounts a chaotic night at the bar that led to her dental disaster.

“So they did frantically look through my teeth, but we never saw them again, which was also a blessing because the dentist would have tried to glue them.”

The Panic and the Aftermath

43:26 to 44:35

Katie's roommate contacts her boyfriend and brings her to the ER.

“So he's thinking I was dancing on the bar.”

Dental Disaster and Redemption

44:35 to 45:56

Katie's experience at the dentist post-accident and her mother's reaction.

“I have maybe like those juicy couture sweatpants on with juicy across my butt, Yeah.”

Veneers and Post-Apocalyptic Scenarios

45:56 to 46:39

Discussion on veneers and humorous takes on dental care in apocalyptic times.

“I already had to have them replaced once.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Welcome, welcome, welcome to Armchair Anonymous. I'm Dax Shepard and I'm joined by Buck Rogers. Hello. Today we have crazy bar stories. Bars are very fertile ground. I mean, nothing, well, I shouldn't say nothing good happens. People find their soulmates at bars. Me cute. Yes. But alas, that's not these types of stories. You know, we have every version of depravity happening. So please enjoy crazy bar stories. Thank you to our presenting sponsor, Grubhub. Gold Days is here, which feels like a dangerous time to be ordering food because suddenly everyone in your life is very interested in what you're eating.

0:40Grubhub Plus members are getting nonstop savings all month long. And if you're not a member yet, you can join for just 99 cents a month for six months. That's a 90 % discount off of the usual price. Grubhub Plus membership auto renews and terms apply. Sign up now in the app or at grubhub.com slash plus slash gold. This message is brought to you by Apple Card. Apple Card is designed with your iPhone in mind, making it easy to get started and even easier to use. Apple Card is a no-fee credit card you can apply for right from the wallet app on your iPhone. Apple Card has no annual fee, no late fees, and no foreign transaction fees.

1:21No fees, period. Every credit card should be this easy. Get started in the Wallet app today. Subject to credit approval, variable APRs for Apple Card range from 17.49 % to 27.74 % based on credit worthiness. Rates as of January 1st, 2026. Existing customers can view their variable APR in the Wallet app or at card.apple.com. Apple Card is issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA Salt Lake City branch. Terms and more at applecard.com.

1:55good times take them slow my life i had a boat but one thing you gotta know i'm gonna keep on shining you guys see me oh we can see you we can hear you what is this sound dampening you've put up are those trifold mattresses what are those no it's a nugget i don't know if you guys know what those are for kids you can basically make little shapes for them to climb on each one is about 18 inches thick oh and they're big cubes kind of that's fine yeah oh wow where are you justin i'm in central wisconsin right now when did you move there i moved here about three years ago i'd say from where minneapolis where the story takes place oh okay so you have a bar story please walk us through it all right so to set the stage this was back in december of 2018 i was working in downtown Minneapolis as a head of security and was head of security for about six months at the time at a bar.

2:54At that time, it was more of like a college place where kids would come from the U of M and go parties. So it was pretty busy. I broke up a lot of fights, literally almost daily. One time I had to go to the hospital due to another injury. Can I ask really quick two questions? How common is it to have to have a head of security? Is that just because it was a college town, do you think? Or is that common in Minneapolis? It's pretty common. Oh, okay. And then second, how do you qualify for the job? Like, what's the interview like? How are they determining whether or not you can handle your business?

3:21They've seen me before. I've broken up in quite a lot of fights. Okay, great, great. So one night at about 2.30 in the morning after the bars close, me and one of my security guards, we take one of the barricades and we're going to go around the building to put it into the garage where we put all the barricades and heat lamps. When we go around the corner, I see two men punching one woman. Oh, my God. Oh, boy. Oh, boy. I hesitated for a second because I remember my boss constantly told us, do not break up fights that are outside because liability issues. Only do it inside. But I'm not going to let two men beat up a woman.

3:53So I dropped the barricade and I ran over there and tried to pull off one of the guys. He tried to punch me, but I was sober and he definitely was not. So I kind of just stepped back. He missed. I kicked him in the stomach and I punched him in the face and I pushed him over. My other security guard went over there and held him there for a minute. And then I turned to the other guy. He has a handful of her shirt just holding it. And he's about to punch. And he kind of looks my way and he sees me. And he starts going towards me to punch. And I saw that coming. So I put my head down and he hit right on the top.

4:22So I don't know if you know that would hurt him a lot. Yeah, his hand's broken for sure. Definitely, yeah. After that, he kind of let go of her. I punched him two more times. I used my left hand. I had him in the temple. And then I had him right below the nose. I also heard something crack. Oh, okay. He goes down and he has blood everywhere. He's looking at me and I see that he's missing a tooth. So that was the crack. So I turned to the girl and I say, we should go. And I'll never forget the way she looked at me. She turns to me and she has two swollen eyes. She's looking at me and she goes, I want to stay here with my boyfriend.

4:57That makes me so sad. Yeah, I didn't quite know what to say to that. I felt really bad. But then I look over and I see my boss. He's outside the door and he's like, get back in here, Justin, right now. I told her I was going to go call the police. So I ran in there and I get my phone. I called 911 and I talked to them and they said they were going to come away. When I got off the phone, I looked out there and all three of them were gone. So I had quite an adrenaline rush. So I couldn't really feel my body at the time. So one of my coworkers said, hey, you're dripping blood off your hand. I looked down and I have about a half inch cut on my knuckle.

5:30And I'm like, oh, great. So I go find the first aid kit, which is empty. And so I was like, okay, I'm just going to put some cold water in this. Another co-worker said, you should probably go to the hospital because getting saliva or something like that. Yeah, you could go rancid. You could get that cat disease. So I ended up going to HCMC, which is a Hennepin County Medical Center. I got there. It was pretty busy. And after about, let's say, an hour or so, I got to see a doctor. They washed it out for me a little bit. And then they gave me two different antibiotics because I'm allergic to amoxicillin.

5:59Then they sent me home, but they drew a circle on my hand. And they said, if it gets past this, you need to come back. I go home and go to sleep and I wake up at about 11 o 'clock in the morning. I can feel my hand is throbbing and it feels like I could feel my heartbeat in it. It was pretty bad to say, look at it. And the circle was down low, but the infection was higher. It had gone up past your wrist? Yeah, only about eight hours after all that happened. Oh my God, what was he carrying? Rabies. I wish he was drinking more alcohol. It might have disinfected him. Yeah, yeah. I decided to go back to the hospital.

6:34And when I walked into the door, to the left was the emergency room. To the right was urgent care. So I was like, I'm going to go to urgent care because the emergency room is packed right now. I walked in there and I talked to a nurse and she's getting all my information. And I told her I was there earlier today, technically. She looks at my hand and she goes, oh, and she drops everything and she brings me into the emergency room and then I get to the top of the list. So I go in right away. When I see a doctor, he looks at me and he goes, okay, you're probably going to need surgery. What? Whoa.

7:04So they got me hooked up on IV antibiotics. And a little bit later, I had a surgeon come in and talk to me. And he looks at it, he goes, okay, so this is what we're going to do. And we're going to put you under. You're probably going to stay here for a night or two. About an hour later, they bring me down to get surgery. I think the surgery is about an hour and a half. When I woke up, the surgeon was there and he was talking to me. He goes, you're very lucky that you came in when he did, because you could have had a finger or your hand amputated from how bad it was infected. I sent pictures. So wait, they went in there and they actually had to like cut out the infection.

7:37I thought you were about to tell me they extracted the tooth from your hand. Oh, gosh. I was like, oh my God, the tooth lodged in his hand. Oh, that would have been horrible. He probably swallowed it. Wait, yeah, so they cut out. You can see the pictures. Yeah, let's go. They kind of cut it. It looks like an S sort of. Oh, yeah, it looks real gross. Like it's going to pop with infection. Ew. Yeah. So the first one, then you have, right if I got the circle in my hand. And then the other two were after the surgery. Oh, wow. Did they tell you, did they like send tissue samples away and then tell you what the, I mean, I guess it doesn't matter, but I'm so curious.

8:13What was it? I'm not sure. I didn't even ask that. It was very painful. As you can see in one of the pictures, it looks like they kind of forgot some of the gauze and they kept it in there. But that was kind of like a wick to get rid of. Oh, keep sucking up. Yeah. Oh, yeah. It's hanging. Look, Monica, it's hanging out of the. I saw. Yeah, you don't like stare at it. I don't need to keep looking. The most painful part was when they removed that. I thought it was just going to be like, you know, half an inch. There was probably an inch and a half or something. And he pulled it out quick. He goes, this is going to hurt you.

8:39Oh! And did you examine it when it came out? I would really want to see what was happening. Oh, yeah. It was very bloody. Yeah. I called my boss after that. And I told him, you know, I'm probably going to be here for a few days. He asked me if it was going to be workers' comp. And I said, oh, yeah, yeah, that'll be workers' comp. So he was pretty upset about that. So I returned to work about a week later. I was told to do a safety briefing for all the security guards. This is how you break up a fight. And this is where you break up a fight, not outside. What were you going to do? Not as your job, like as just a person.

9:14Yeah, they were actually going to fire me. But a few of my co-workers, female ones, said that they were going to quit if they did that. Okay, now this willingness and appetite to get involved in chaos. I want to know how much the red hair plays into it. I don't know if you've ever heard my theories on redheads. We have a temper. I have a few rules you don't fight. You don't fight a guy at a stoplight who, when he gets out, he casually takes his shirt off. Not to show off, but just he's ruined so many shirts that he's learned. Just move on. Get back in your car. In general, a married guy at the bar, just don't mess with it.

9:47He's been holding a lot in. And then I don't care what size the redhead is. Just keep it moving. I've seen a lot of little, little redheads in junior high and high school get the best of somebody. My friends, they'd say I ginger-stamped. I also have martial arts experience. I got my black belt and karate and some stuff in the military, too. The entire thing from when I saw them to him going down, covering his mouth, was about 10 seconds. Sure. It happened very fast. I wonder what was in his mouth. He had been eating someone that had flesh-eating bacteria. Oh, he's a cannibal. Oh, I took down a zombie.

10:25How much longer did you have that job? Probably for another five or six months. The month before that happened, I also had to go into the hospital due to a slight fracture in my elbow. I was trying to harass some of the waiters and waitresses and stuff like that, and I tried to escort him out. He tried to punch me, so I put him in a rear naked choke, and right then I kind of fell forward. and his weight and my weight landed on the tip of my elbow. You'd think I would have learned. Well, again, I don't know what you're supposed to do when you walk upon that. No, you got it. It's time to get down.

10:58Of course, I'm having a lot of envy listening. I know you are. As a job, I would have loved to have had. I know you are. I loved it. Yeah, yeah. Aaron ran a bar for 10 years and he didn't have security. He was the security of the owner and the bartender. Yeah, and he got to see a lot of action. I was always quite jealous. Well, Justin, I'm glad that there are people wired like you and I that would intervene in a situation like that. And then, of course, I'm heartbroken by the girl who wants to stay with the guy. It's so upsetting. But also, you know, there's a lot of stats around that. Like, she would have been killed, probably, if she did not say that or do that.

11:29Like, it's a really horrible situation. I don't have any answers, but it's, yeah. Yeah. Can I do a shout out? Yes! Of course! My significant other, Sarah. She was supposed to be here to watch her son while I was doing this, but I got the times wrong. I forgot it was Pacific time. Oh, sure. Central time. She's the one that told me to submit it. She's the one that got me to start listening years ago. And I think Monica would really like her because you guys have a very similar personality, but she's also a physical therapist. Oh, I love her. I just add her to my PT collection. PT club. The two other people would be our friends, Amber and Ethan.

12:03They're the ones that got us to start listening to your podcast. Oh, thank you, Amber and Ethan. Yes, we appreciate all of them. Keep converting people, Amber and Ethan. I have a lot of people who are going to start listening because I was like, I'm going to be on there. Oh, fun. Well, it's great meeting you, Justin. It's good meeting you too. Yeah, congrats on your family. I'm happy for you. Thank you. All right, take care. Bye. Are you so happy we have such a tough listener? Yeah, but also so sweet. Could you hear his sweetness? That's what I love. I doubt he's starting a lot of fights, but he's finishing them when they need finishing.

12:35Hello. Hi, is this Casey? Yes, Casey. Nice to meet you. Casey, where are you? Dax, I know you like to guess, so maybe you want to take a guess from my accent. Here's what's going to happen. And I already know what I'm down to. It's just down to two. And I know if I get it wrong, both parties would be very offended. But I'm going New Zealand on this one. Me too. I'm in South Africa. Oh! Triple wrong. Who's offended now? I don't know. It's pretty close. It gets mistaken now and then anyways. What city are you in down there? Johannesburg. Okay. What's the vibe in Johannesburg? I've never been. Jo 'burg's got the friendliest people, I would say.

13:11Have you been to Cape Town? No. No, I've only been to Tanzania and Kenya and Uganda. Cape Town's beautiful as well, but Johannesburg is way friendlier. Okay. And so you've got a bar story. Yeah. So let me set the scene. I was in my early 20s, like 1920 thereabouts. What's the drinking age down there? 18. By the time we're 21, we're veterans. I'd moved up to Johannesburg probably like a year before that from my hometown in George, very small coastal town. So small city to a big city, getting used to the vibe in Johannesburg. By this time, I've got a nice group of friends and we're starting to go out and meet people and whatnot.

13:51The story starts off at a braai. It's basically a barbecue. I love starting something off with a barbecue. Yeah, that's really fun. I went there with my cousin and I ended up meeting this couple there. Thought nothing of it. And a couple of weeks later or a couple of months later, I don't know exactly the time, I saw that the girl from this couple ended up being single and I decided to slide into the DM. Okay, lovely. After some time, we ended up dating. So that's kind of like the precursor to the story. So after a few months of dating, we decided to go out one night. We went to Hooters. So we also have Hooters here.

14:25I'm very happy here that you have Hooters. Hooters is very international. Best fried chicken sandwich. I maintain that. I enjoy their wings. Anyway, so leading up to this, the ex of hers was messaging me now and then on social media and not being very nice, let's say threatening me, but I thought nothing of it, blocked him, carried on with my life. We ended up at this bar and as I walk in, I turn a corner and I walk straight into this guy, like physically bump into him. And I kind of taken it back and I moved to the side and carry on walking to my table and we sit down, you know, think nothing of it.

15:02I forgot to mention this dude is super big compared to me. When you bumped into each other, were there any words? Bump in, no words, part ways. So thought nothing of it, right? So anyway, sit down at our table and we're having a good night, having a couple of beers, ordering food. And I see this guy starts moving closer to us and sits at a table adjacent from us. Oh boy. And he's like staring me down the entire time. Is your girlfriend with you? Yeah, my girlfriend's with me. I've got a lifelong friend with me as well. and then another guy friend of mine that's a pilot that was visiting he flies for doctors without borders in afghanistan but he's a british guy so it's the four of us sitting at the table minding our own business and every time i glance over to him he's mouthing or making as if he's swearing at me i can't tell what he's saying but you know you can see something not good

16:01We are supported by Quince. I'm pretty picky about what I wear. Not in a fashion way, more in a, if this bugs me even a little, I'm out way. And this time of year always makes me want to reset a bit. Clean things up. Keep my closet simple. That's why I keep coming back to Quince. The fabrics feel elevated. The fits are thoughtful. And the pricing actually makes sense. Quince makes high quality everyday essentials using premium materials like 100 % European linen. and their insanely soft flow knit active fabric. Their linen pieces are lightweight, breathable and comfortable, perfect for spring.

16:38And they strike that balance where you look put together without trying too hard. I got their linen pants. And honestly, I was surprised how good they feel. Sometimes you think linen can be coarse, but these are so soft and luxurious and nothing really flows like linen. The best part is the pricing. It's 50 to 60 % less than similar brands because they work directly with ethical factories. Refresh your wardrobe with Quince. Go to quince.com slash DAX for free shipping and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada too. Go to quince.com slash DAX for free shipping and 365-day returns. quince.com slash DAX.

17:27so we notice this as a group and we decide maybe we need to get out of here it's starting to get a little sketchy so as we stand up to leave him and his friends stand up to leave as well we walk outside and he starts to try confront me now i'm more of a lover than a fighter but i stand my ground my girlfriend at the time comes in between us and kind of like pushes him back and tries to calm him down a bit. And he's getting more and more aggressive. The bouncers decided to step in at this point. The bouncers at Hooters in Johannesburg are massive. So they kind of defused the situation. The bouncer then put his arm around me and started to walk me to my car.

18:06And the other bouncer was arguing with the guy behind me and just trying to handle the situation. Every time I glanced back, another one of this dude's friends arrived. So like it's turning from two people into like four and then six. And then at some point there was like eight of them. Now the bouncer behind me is starting to get obviously a little overwhelmed. And the one that's walking me to my car is like, okay, you need to leave now. Get in the car and go. Get in the car. The one female friend of mine, she got in the driver's seat and I was like, I don't think you should drive. Let me drive rather.

18:39Just in case we need to like get away or something like that. I feel like I'm a more evasive driver you know this parking lot that hooters is in it's like parking lots with parkades on either side but there's one entry and exit as we reverse out and we start going down this exit path him and his entire group of friends block the road oh god so now i'm like okay now what so he's standing in front of the car and he's swearing at me and trying to intimidate me. The friend of mine in the back, the one that was visiting from Afghanistan, had his window rolled down and one of this dude's friends punched him through the window and ended up chipping his tooth.

19:21His famous quote from that is, he spends his career in a war zone, but comes back for one night in South Africa and gets punched. This guy starts like pushing on the bonnet of the car, trying to stop the car. At this point, I've had enough. So I started to edge forwards. And as I moved forwards, he jumped onto the bonnet of the car and like smashed a massive hole in the windshield. Oh my God. Hammer fisted it. He's lost it. Yeah, he was pretty cray cray. So at this point, I just floored it and he kind of rolled off the car and we got home after that. That's not where the story ends though. Were police called?

19:59That's what I'm getting to. So So we got home and the friend whose car it was went to go lay charges at the police station. The next day, this guy contacted us and they were trying to negotiate so that she would drop the charges and he would pay for the damages. But it turns out he was contacting us because he tried to charge me as well. So he also went to the police station and he tried to charge me with attempted murder. Oh, my God. Oh, my Lord. When he was charged with malicious damage to property. So we ended up getting contacted by a detective. And now I'm super nervous. Like my first run in with the law.

20:38I'm like, what's going on? Am I going to get arrested for this? I go to the police station, make my statement. The detectives taken both of our statements. And he says, even a blind man can see this dude's not telling the truth. You know, so I shouldn't worry about it. So I was like, okay. And he said, he'll let me know if I need to come in for anything again. And that was the end of that. Then about a week later, he phones me. He's like, I need you to come to the police station today. I'm like, oof, okay. So I get my friend to go with me in case they can arrest me or something, that they take my car home.

21:09But yeah, it turns out that wasn't the case. He just wanted to tell me that they'd actually arrested the other guy, and he wanted to confirm some of my statements. So that's kind of where it ended. I ended up being a witness. For his trial. Yeah. I have no idea if he was convicted or not. I wasn't there for the sentencing or whether he was guilty or anything like that. So it was just stand as a witness. And that was kind of the end of that. And did he ever reach out to your then girlfriend about it? I don't think so. I ended up moving back to my hometown and then back to Johannesburg again. So a few years later, I bumped into him at the gym.

21:46Oh, you did? He didn't say anything. He didn't do anything. So I think he'd learned his lesson, whether or not he got charged or not. Like he was super young, so I don't know if he would have gotten a criminal record or anything from that. I'm sure the judge would have been lenient if it was like a first-time offense. People cannot control their temper. No, young men are wound up a little hot. Yeah, especially when the legal drinking age is 18. Oh, true, yeah. Yeah, alcohol, jealousy, massive size, maybe he was juicing. Who knows what's in the mix? Yeah, a lot's going on. Well, I'm glad you made it out of there.

22:20And I hope that didn't taint your feelings about Hooters. No, not at all. I still regularly go to Hooters for their all you can eat chicken wing special. Oh, they've got an all you can eat wing special. Yeah. Oh, it's pretty good. And you'd love the exchange rates for it as well. I'm surprised they don't do some sort of like chicken breast special. You're more perverted than us. All you can eat breast special. Oh, my God, mom. You're so perverted. I will say I hated this about Hooters. They were very ethical about serving people because my friend Scotty and I used to go and watch basketball in the Santa Monica Hooters location, eat wings.

22:58They would only sell you two pitchers of beer. Yeah, because it's dangerous. But we would always be a little frustrated with what they wanted us to consume. But again, very ethical of them. So I guess I am applauding them, even though I was frustrated. How about down there? Is it willy-nilly? Will they over-serve you or are they pretty tight? The portion sizes are pretty big. I have been to the U.S. before, and South African portion sizes don't really compare. Like, U.S. portion sizes are insanely huge. Yeah. I know. We're so gluttonous. It's crazy. I'm guessing you don't have 64-ounce drinks at the gas station either.

23:32No. None of that. Well, Casey, it's lovely meeting you, and we're so flattered you're down in South Africa listening. I think I might be a first for South Africa. I think so. I think so. Please spread the word. All right. Well, lovely meeting you, Casey. You too. Have a good one. Take care. Hello. Hello. Can you hear me? Yes. Is it Leah or Lee? Lee. You just never know what these spellings. That's tough. I was excited for you guys to guess. I get Leah a lot. I get lay a lot. Lay is inappropriate, but Leah and Lee, that's tricky. How do you spell Leah? Leah, Leah, Leah. Leah? Leah. No, Leah. How do you spell Leah?

Read the full transcript

24:16L-E-A-H, usually. Where are you at, Leah? I am just a stone's throw away from some of your many references in Northville, Michigan. Oh, I know. Northville, inside and out. Do you cruise Heinz Park? Of course. I'm like a mile away. Wonderful. Yes, we would go cruising in Heinz Park quite a bit. My very good friend went to Novi High. My husband went to Novi High. Wow. He did. And then we would cruise downtown Northville. That's the story, Monica, that I met the girl and I was lying about my age and she tooted when we were hooking up. Remember that famous story? Jesus Christ, Dex. I'm sorry, that's all from Northville.

24:52Oh my God. Bringing back all the memories. Lee, did you grow up in Northville? I grew up in Northville and I met my husband at Michigan State where this story takes place. And then we moved all around. I was by Wobby Wob in Chicago, down in Dallas, and now back in good old Northville. No stints in Atlanta? What do you have against Atlanta? You know, I worked for United Airlines, so they're very Delta country. So it's maybe my only rivalry there. Do you still work for them or no, you don't? Now I'm a stay-at-home mom and a personal trainer. Okay. Oh, nice. Oh, I have gains. Monica's worked out 1.2 times.

25:281.1 times? And my muzzles are huge. I'm sorry to scare you. How often are you working out? We're so off track, but I'm curious. Probably five to six times a week. There we go. Always a rest day, sometimes two. How about five or six days rest days? I like the six day workout. Okay. Sometimes seven on accident. Let's hear our story. Let's hear our story. Okay. So as we referenced Michigan State, sort of known as a party school, which is where the story takes place. This is January 2014, which would make me a 18 year old freshman at Michigan State. We are back for second semester, and I was on a sports team at MSU.

26:08And I actually want you guys to guess what team you think I was on. I think you were a soccer player. Lacrosse. We're going to go lacrosse because my husband was lacrosse. So I'm going to keep that part in honest, but I like lacrosse. Okay, so neither. Neither. Because I'm on the lacrosse team, there are girls who are a lot older that I've become friends with over summer trainings, and we kind of have this big age group of friends. All the girls who are 21 obviously are going to the bars on Friday night, and that gave a big incentive to the younger girls to find a way to also go to the bars. So there are two ways at the time it felt like you could get a fake ID.

26:42First one is the one I opted for, which was to take some sort of very sketchy passport-like photo to send to who knows what country via whatever boy on the dorm floor was willing to take on this endeavor. Get all of those fake IDs back in like a necklace box from, again, who knows what country and who knows when. And he would kind of go and pass them out. Terrible. Very clearly fake from Connecticut. Not great, but worked at the bars you knew it would work at. The more ideal way to get the idea was a cousin that turned 21, pretends they lose theirs. You look enough like them. You use a real Michigan driver's license.

27:19You know, more of a surefire. The real ID was always preferred. I didn't get to have that, obviously, because nobody looked like me. One time I used Callie's ID. We've talked about that. Anyway, go on. So I've got my fake ID. I'm 18, feeling good, getting into the bars I know I can get into with my older teammates. But some of the other girls in my grade were still looking for an ID. Well, it turns out, feels like fate. One of the older girls on the team is at a party and sticks her hand down because she drops her phone in the couch cushion and pulls out a driver's license. Oh, bingo. For someone, we don't know.

27:53But immediately, she looks at it. Blonde, blue-eyed. Could have been any one of our teammates. So she holds on to this morsel, and she decides that she is going to knight one of my best friends, another freshman, Janine, with this fake ID. Now, Janine is about 5152, cute as a button. And this ID does say 510. But other than that, we're going to roll with it.

28:31So Friday night comes around January. It's freezing cold. Monica, as you know, the best part of going out is the getting ready. We're getting ready in the dorms. Skater skirts, peplum tops, big chunky Charlie's necklace. We're ready to go. We're hyping each other up. Janine parts her hair the way that Haley, the fake ID name, has her hair parted. She wears it straight, which she never does. We're trying to make Janine Haley. She is living the role. We get to the bar and this is the bar on campus. Okay, Rick's American Cafe for all my fellow Spartans. I'm going to ask my sister about this. My sister is a MSU graduate.

29:06She will know. It is a basement bar, as all good college bars are. And the way it's set up is you kind of can see the front door and that's it because you immediately go down the steps. So the line goes out and around the corner and you have to wait outside until you get to the bouncer and go in. So we've got our group of all my teammates and we are strategizing here. We've got someone who's 21 with a real ID first, then me, then someone else who's 21. You know, we're intermingling the fakes. We think this is gonna help us. I co-sign on this. Thank you, appreciate that. We're there and we are strategizing.

29:39And while we're in line, we're all studying. Everyone who's underage is studying their info, right? address what's your date of birth what's your full name what's your middle name what's your hometown all the things and janine is locked in as haley she's ready to go and we decide because this is her first time using fake she's gonna go very last because the rumor is kind of like if you're cool with the bouncer even if he turns you away usually they'll give you your id back and just say i know this is fake scurry off she's like i'll just go back to the dorms if i don't get it so we get up to the bouncer somebody goes they get in i go i get it next person goes in and then we look at Janine and we're all kind of trying to like creep down the steps so that we can hear what's happening.

30:19Sweetie peaty, little farm town. She's been peer pressured into using a fake ID, really, is what's happening here. She hands over the ID and immediately the bouncer looks at it, smirks and goes, how do you know Haley? Fuck. Yeah, see, this is the risk you run. Oh, the bouncer knows Haley. We're on a campus of 50 ,000 just under grab, But Janine is fast on her feet and immediately, instead of trying to be the I am Haley, which is what I would have done, I would have doubled down, panicked, gone with it, immediately doesn't miss a beat, goes, we're really good friends. Like all my friends just got in.

30:53Can you just give me the ID back? And she was just, I think, trying to get the ID back. I don't even know if she wanted to get down the steps, but he kind of like rolls his eyes, gives it to her and lets her in. Oh, yes. Good job. And once I reveal her at the end, she's too cute to let her go home. So Janine gets down the steps and we are celebrating like it is Super Bowl Sunday and we have won. We are Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelsey high-fiving. This is the greatest thing that's happened to our freshman selves. The bar is split because you go down the steps. You go to the left side, we call the dark side because that was the dance floor, the booty bumping of it all.

31:28And then the right side was the light side. And that's where you would go to like watch the game, order a drink. It's a big oval. So you can walk kind of all the way around. So we're into the bar. We are there for probably 45 minutes, just enough to get a couple vodka crayons in us. Oh, yeah. That was my drink, too. Oh, yeah. It's every 18-year-old's drink. Actually, my 18-year-old drink was Amaretto Sour. Oh. That's what we were to all get. And then I worked my way up to vodka crayons. I like that you're also always like, it's a twofer. You're getting drunk and also kind of buffeting yourself from a UTI.

32:02Exactly. You're being healthy. It's the wellness choice. We're having a good time. We're booty bumping. Now, the manager of this bar, we're going to call him Hank because I'm pretty sure he still works there. And I want to be in good graces as an alumna. But he is exactly what you think of when you imagine a Midwestern bar manager, like big, burly. He's wearing the Rick's East Lansing t-shirt. Everybody kind of knows his face in East Lansing. We spot him walking over to Janine. So there's a couple of us that are all hanging out. And Janine is near the bar getting a drink on the dark side. Hank walks over, steps right in front of Janine and just puts his hand out, palm up, as if to say, hand it over.

32:40Right? Like, I know you're using a fake, hand it over. But he's saying no words. So from the opposite corner of the bar, I am watching this go down. And immediately I clock that the person standing next to him is Haley. Oh! Okay. The reason that the bouncer immediately recognized Haley is because they're coworkers and she's a bartender. Oh! Oh my gosh. What are the odds? That is a bad, bad sim. Bad luck is what that is. As she's fumbling through her crossbody to get this ID out, she goes to give it to Hank and Haley snaps it out of her hand and just turns and walks away. Kind of drew the conclusion that at some point in the bouncer shift, he ran down the steps and said to Haley, I just let your friend in with your ID.

33:27And Haley said something like, what do you mean, my friend? I lost my ID at a party. You're right. And that's why he let her in. He's like, oh, it's one of Haley's buddies. She works here. We're going to let it slide. I'm caught up now. That makes sense. So now we've pissed off Hank. We've pissed off Haley. And we've pissed off the bouncer. Yeah. There's a lot of lies happening here, right? From far away, I just see Haley get her ID. And Janine turns immediately and walks the other way. So I'm like, we're good. I've got three vodka crayons. And I'm booty bumping. Come on back and join the party.

34:01I think we're fine. And she comes to join the group and is like, we got to go. They're mad. This is bad news. Now, truly like out of a movie, cut to the next thing we see is we're trying to get up the steps. And at the top of the steps with the bouncer are two East Lansing police officers. Fuck that. No, we're going all the way. MIP. They were known to send the police officers in and kind of have a good relationship and say, oh, we don't know who's using fake IDs. But if you want to come down, you're allowed to go and ask people to see their ideas. So we're at the top and we just hear the bouncers say to the police officers, yeah, blonde in the big pink necklace.

34:42Oh. Describing. Oh my God. Ginny. She just pull off the necklace and throw it? Literally. So we are walking the steps. Our walk turns into a full blown sprint. We turn the opposite way from the police officers. And at this point, I don't know if it's the adrenaline. I don't know what's happening, but there are no words being said between the group of the three of us that are sprinting away from this bar. We are just like all somehow telekinesis going the same direction and getting out of there. End up running away from the police officers. They do not chase us. In my mind, I was like, we're now going to be on a foot chase.

35:18That did not happen. We ran around the corner, went into the drunk food spot, ditched the pink necklace in the bathroom, and all was well. Scary. That's exciting. All's well that ends well. The full circle, full circle of it is she obviously got her fake taken. I was like the young one. I didn't turn 21 until well into senior year. And I got very cocky with my fake ID because it had worked for so long. So for her 21st birthday, I tried to use my fake ID in Vegas. Not a good idea. And that's when I got mine snatched. Happened to the best of us. Two things. I used Ken Kennedy's at times when I needed to, but mostly we lived in downtown Detroit and they did not give a flying fuck what age you were.

35:58in downtown Detroit in 1993. They didn't care at all. You go into the liquor store and buy whatever you wanted. They're like, great. You got cash, you're good. Mine got taken my senior year right before I turned 21. It ended up being okay. I got three years out of it. What was yours? How'd you get yours? I had the bad kind, obviously. You bought it off a freshman in the dorm? I had a friend who was making them. Okay, handmade. It was literally glued to the back of a Blockbuster card. You couldn't take it out of the wallet. Oh. You know, you had the wallet with the clear thing, and you would just, like, give them that.

36:35You know, if they said, take it out, then you're like, actually, I got to go. Actually, I have diarrhea. I got to go home right now. Yeah, that's what happened. I just remembered I have diarrhea. So he made me, and I cried. This is a fugazi. You cried? Yeah. I was so embarrassed. Janine's coming out. Someone over here. hold on i'm giving my air pump oh my god look at this you're still friends roommates to best friends oh that is so cute third member i'm was not a part of the story i met them after but i'm just a huge armchair and so lee and i text all the time when episodes come out where i was just like bonding over it and she was like okay you have to come over some moral support for the story and sneak in and say hi if you can so just wanted to say i'm a huge fans.

37:22Oh, we love it. All right. Well, nice meeting all of you. Yes. Yeah. Nice meeting you too. Thank you for letting us talk. So fun. Bye. Katie, where are you camping? I'm currently camping in my living room. Oh, I love it. Are those rosettes? Oh no. This is part of a fort kit that my children own. Oh yeah. We had the same one and I come across big tubs of the poles in the joining pieces all the time and think, are we really still ever going to play with this? Can we please get rid of it? And we don't. Well, now they're also weapons. Oh, sure. Sure. Sure. Sure. Sure. Yeah. I mean, look at it. It's just dying to be swung at a sibling.

38:06Where are you at in the world? Outside of Washington, D.C. and northern Virginia. Oh, OK. Wonderful. What kind of weather do you have over there right now? It's a little chilly, but the sun is starting to come back out. So I'm slowly getting out of my seasonal depression. Oh, good. I'm happy for you. Driving with the windows down yet? Yes. Sunroof wide open. Oh, it's a big, big moment. You know, in my planner, I have to write down what I'm grateful for every day. Yeah. And yesterday I wrote sunshine. It's a good one. Because it's a real good one. So you have a bar story. I do. So this story takes place in a small college town in Virginia.

38:43I am a college sophomore in this story and I am not yet 21. So I am going to the bars with a fake ID that is pretty bad. And where did you get it? Tell us the variety of Yeah, we're learning a lot about fake IDs in this episode. I'm learning a lot about fake IDs on this episode. What was your variety? We found some guy that did fake. It wasn't like a real ID. It was created for me. And so I basically traded a Kate Spade bag that my aunt gave me for this ID. Oh, wow. That's pretty expensive. Better be a good fake. It was bad. Did you have to take a picture or did you use an existing one? How was it constructed?

39:21They took a picture and then it was horribly laminated and then they didn't even like sand down or round it. So it was pointy. Oh, sharp, dangerous to retrieve out of the wallet. Yeah. And how successful was it as a fake ID? Did it work? If they ever used the scanner, which they started using as I was getting closer to 21, I would not make it in. But for the most part, it did its job. Okay, great. I love that. It's a Thursday night. It's the local bar that everyone goes to. It's only college students. And it's one of those special college bars that has this big open space where you can dance and it's like a club.

40:01But then as soon as you enter these other doors, it's just like a restaurant and bar. So it's pitcher night. It's two for one. And I have two pitchers and I'm going to meet my friends. I'm already wasted. We're already making our way towards this club space. So it's like a different feel now. I am hammered. And as I'm walking, I'm in my heels and my black lacy going out top. I'm strutting my stuff. I slip on a puddle of something Uh oh And I fall face forward And I catch myself with my mouth Ah Okay, okay You break your fall with your teeth I did I broke my fall with my teeth Because you couldn't let those pitchers go I didn't I needed to It was a priority I had to get them to my friends So I fell And I knocked all four of my friends Oh Oh my goodness This is really a serious tumble It was in a crescent moon shape across all four.

41:00Oh, fuck. Oh, wait, they broke off? The roots didn't come out? No, the roots didn't come out, but they all broke off, which was actually pretty fortunate for me later that they didn't all actually come out. Wait, can I ask you quickly, what's the pain of your teeth cracking off? There's zero pain. Oh, that's nice. I feel nothing. But you're drunk, which helps. Could also be a little shock. Yeah. And you run your tongue along your teeth and you go, oh, there's a moon shape. Yeah, I don't run my tongue along my teeth. I just run my tongue through my teeth. Really quick. Do you look on the ground for the pieces of teeth?

41:40So this is where it actually gets bad. My guy friends that lived around the corner from me, they saw this whole thing and they watched me spit my teeth into my hands. Oh, boy. Look at them like really pissed off and then throw them across the floor of the bar. Gangster move. I like it. So they did frantically look through my teeth, but we never saw them again, which was also a blessing because the dentist would have tried to glue them. It wouldn't have looked good. Yeah. Big, big seam across your smile. I'm wasted at this point. And my guy friends being guys were like, we want to stay at the bar.

42:22So they usher me into a cab with people I don't know. So strangers are now bringing me home. They decided that finding my friends was not the best option. Oh, my God. Well, really quick. I mean, maybe they saw what disregard you had for your teeth. And they're like, oh, she didn't care about shit. She doesn't care. They can't care. They should care. It was just a normal night for me. So I get inside and I'm by myself and I'm not really sure what to do. I'm not really panicking. It could still be that I was in shock, but everything seems fine. I do call my mom and it's probably 11 or 12 at night on a Thursday night.

43:02She's sleeping. She's two hours away and I leave her a message and all I say is they're gone. Oh my God. And then my roommate comes in and so I hang up the phone and I don't say anything else. My roommate quickly calls my boyfriend, who is long distance, and she quickly just tells him what's going on before we go to the ER. And she says, Katie fell at the bar, which he heard as Katie fell off the bar. Oh. So he's thinking I was dancing on the bar. Oh, and he's pissed now. He's starting to get jealous. Uh-oh, I told her never to do that slut. Anymore. Yeah. It made me want to actually have danced on the bar.

43:46Like I wish I had done it. So we do go to the ER and the doctor is unfazed by us. We're wasted. He checks me for head trauma. I'm fine. He says, you just need to go to the dentist in the morning. Everything's fine. He does prescribe me Percocet. It was also fun to say at the pharmacy with my list. Percocet. So we proceed to go home. Everything's fine. I go to sleep and I wake up at seven in the a phone call from my mom. And she is just like, what is happening? What's gone? So I tell her everything. And she says, okay, I'll be there in two hours. So on her way, she does make a dentist appointment for me.

44:30And I went back to sleep. I made no effort to clean myself up. I have last night's makeup on. I have maybe like those juicy couture sweatpants on with juicy across my butt, Yeah. The crop top. I look like a mess. I smell like a bar. My mom is clearly ashamed of my choices. The caps off the Percocet bottle sitting on the nightstand. She did make me give her the Percocet. Yeah. Yeah, smart. She takes me to the dentist. And the minute that I walk in, I realize that my Jesus-loving mother has taken me to the most Christian dentist there could ever be. And I know that she's not acting that disappointed.

45:12but that this is her form of retribution for me. I proceed to spend the next two hours in the dentist's chair, smelling like bars, and staring up at scenes from the Bible, listening to all the Jesus's music there is in the world. Oh, so they had adorned the ceiling with Jesus' iconography? It was. Wow. So did this dentist, did he send you out with a smile? I mean, he's got to make fake crowns or veneers? It was actually really impressive. So I needed a root canal because I did kill one of my roots. So I had to do that. And then they had to grind down all four of the teeth so that they could put veneers on.

45:52Yeah, that's kind of fun. See, it's an excuse to get veneers. Have you had to have them replaced? I already had to have them replaced once. So that first time was on my parents' dime. And then this last time was not. They're pricey, right? They are pricey. You want nice ones. Well, you have nice ones. Your teeth look great. Thank you. My husband said that I need to make sure I brush them before I talk to you guys. Oh, that was nice of him. What I'm mad about in these post-apocalyptic shows is they don't show people whose veneers have fallen out. Like there should be a good percentage of the people in post-apocalyptic America who have the shark teeth.

46:28I really need to store up on like the dental glue just in case. Yeah, you're going to want to be able to put them back in there. Other people will be grabbing water and stuff and you'll be grabbing fix-a-dent or whatever it's called. Oh, well, Katie, it's lovely meeting you. Lovely meeting you guys, too. Thank you so much for all you do. Oh, our pleasure. Thank you for listening. All right. Take care. You too. Goodbye. Bye. All right. Love you. Love you. Have fun at the bar tonight, anyone who's going out. Try to keep your teeth. Yeah. Be safe out there. Don't get in any fights. Use a high-quality fake ID if you must.

47:00And condom. All right. Love you. Do you want to sing a tune or something? I don't know. A theme song. Oh. Okay, great. We don't have a thing song for this new show, so here I go, go, go. We're gonna ask some random questions, and with the help of our cherries, we'll get some suggestions. On the flyer, Rindish. On the flyer, Rindish. Enjoy.

From the publisher

Dax and Monica talk to Armcherries! In today's episode, Armcherries tell us a crazy bar story.

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

More from Armchair Expert with Dax Shepard

All 296 episodes
Armchair Anonymous: Bar StoriesArmchair Expert with Dax Shepard · 45 min
Listen in VO