1. Podcasts
  2. Bankless
  3. $VVV Community Call
Bankless

1 Nov 2026 · 1h 4m · 31 chapters

Episode artwork

$VVV Community Call | October

In short

October VVV community call covering Venice growth milestones (5M users), token/inference acceleration, agentic chat mechanics, video/creator impact (Lumara Film Festival), token burn economics, ETF listing news (21Shares VENC), and AI-era security/prompt-injection data breach concerns.

Guests/backgrounds

David (host) and Jon (head of strategy at Venice). Eric, Austin, Lorenzo are mentioned as Venice teammates who attended New York for the Lumara Film Festival. Sabrina posts internal growth charts.

Key claims

  • Venice hit 5 million users; growth is accelerating (1M users in 68 days from 4–5M).
  • Tokens served jumped from ~250B/day end of September to 500B+ and then >1T/day in October.
  • Default model upgrade drove the inflection: switching agentic default to DeepSeek “uncensored” (then further to 1017).
  • Agentic chat improves first impressions and increases usage, including video/image creation without model switching by users.
  • Video usage is a major revenue/burn driver; Studio is ~25–30% of revenue.
  • Token price falling improves DM value and enables better experiences at sustainable unit economics.
  • Security: prompt injection can exfiltrate personal data from agents; “protect data by not having it.”

Notable examples

  • Lumara Film Festival winner “Black Thunder” (reported ~20-minute film; ~$2,000 Venice credits).
  • Claude Code HTTP-header prompt injection example (personal data exposure risk).
  • 21Shares launched VENC ETF listing VVV on a European Swiss exchange.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:45

Reflections on In-Person Connections

Discussion about the recent in-person gathering of the Venice team.

“You were in New York briefly for the Lumara Film Festival.”
1:42

Theme of Growth for October

Overview of Venice's user growth and trends this month.

“Yeah, we'll talk about all the prizes that Lumara gave out towards the end of this.”
2:26

Accelerating User Adoption

Insight on the rapid increase in user numbers for Venice.

“Give me the inside perspective on the Venice side of things.”
3:35

Understanding Token Growth

Analysis of the significant increase in tokens served by Venice.

“As we know, things are priced on the margin.”
4:50

Impact of Model Upgrades

Discussion on how model upgrades affected user experience and engagement.

“So, I mean, honestly, this is a surprising amount of acceleration, again, even for us.”
6:43

The Future of Chat Models

Plans for integrating agentic and default chat functionalities.

“So that was really interesting to see that just, you know, basically updating our default model.”
8:30

Explaining Agentic Chat

A detailed explanation of the agentic chat feature and its benefits.

“Is the agentic chat kind of going to consume the default chat because that's just how you guys want to serve your users and the agentic chat is just a better product and so always serve new users the agentic chat?”
10:13

Market Position and Model Choices

Discussion on Venice's unique market position and model selection process.

“And that's what that's their experience.”
14:00

The Importance of Testing Defaults

Learn about the critical testing process when changing default settings in user experience.

“And we, you know, we did some testing before we, you know, changing the default is actually always a really big deal for us because it has such a large impact on that new user experience.”
16:40

Real-Time Feedback on System Upgrades

Discover how immediate data feedback helps in evaluating system upgrades for Venice.

“Some changes are smaller, bigger than others.”
Show all 31 chapters
19:50

Understanding VVV Token Usage

Explore the dynamics of free versus paid token usage and its implications for Venice.

“The chat GPDs and the anthropics of the world are willing to, you know, basically burn huge amounts of CapEx and just burn it on effectively, you know, subsidizing huge amounts of inference for people.”
22:10

Growth Trends and Token Burn

Examine the growth drivers behind VVV burn and how different user categories contribute.

“So we'll probably be a little bit, you know, a good bit above a million by the end of this month.”
25:00

AI Video Production Advancements

Learn about the evolution of AI video production and its impact on creators and users.

“So like these, it's just a very different thing.”
28:00

Video Generation and Consumer Relationships

Exploration of video generation tools and their impact on creators and consumers.

“And so if I want my video to be based off of this or based off of different parameters, I can just go down to the model switcher and I pick a different model.”
29:28

Token Pricing and User Engagement

Discussion on the effects of falling token prices on user engagement and product quality.

“There's all sorts of things that can be created.”
30:57

AI Inference and Tokenomics

Understanding the relationship between token costs and the value of AI inference products.

“even though the token price per turn, like of an agent, is falling quite a bit, that doesn't necessarily lead to less token usage by a user.”
32:38

Open Source vs. Frontier Models

Analysis of the competition between open-source models and frontier AI models.

“OK, so as token prices fall, that's inversely correlated with the quality of the outputs that you can get out of Venice and all AI providers, all inference providers.”
34:29

VVV's European ETF Launch

Announcement and implications of VVV's first ETF launch on a European stock exchange.

“So to me, I just, I see this as an overall benefit to our users.”
37:19

Accessing AI Assets Through ETFs

The significance of accessibility for AI assets through publicly traded venues.

“Now this is in Europe and I think a lot of people would be very excited to see this come to America.”
39:56

Concerns Over AI Security Vulnerabilities

Discussion on security vulnerabilities in AI and how Venice could provide solutions.

“maybe from like Bitwise or, you know, somebody, some of the more crypto native brokers is kind of who I would expect it to get issued by.”
42:01

Understanding Prompt Injection in AI

Learn about the vulnerabilities of AI agents to prompt injection and data leaks.

“certainly the AI industry, but really the whole world right now, the whole internet.”
44:40

The Cybersecurity Landscape and AI

Explore the increasing vulnerabilities in personal data and the need for re-architecting systems due to AI advancements.

“it's better to just not have that data in the system in the first place.”
46:01

The Future of Data Handling in AI

Discuss the implications of evolving AI capabilities on data privacy and the architecture of AI solutions.

“Like, if the data exists, the assumption has to be that at some point that data could or very well will be leaked somehow or exfiltrated.”
49:07

DeepSeek Ban and Its Implications

Analyze the implications of the U.S. government's ban on DeepSeek and its relevance to data security.

“And so the best data solution is no data.”
51:02

The Concept of Obliterated Models

Understand what obliterated models are and their significance in cybersecurity and AI.

“the Department of Homeland Security has banned DeepSeek, DeepSeek Party products, and any third-party services developed using DeepSeek implementation.”
55:49

Hiring for a Product Manager at Venice

Learn about the new product manager position and the qualifications needed at Venice.

“there's one side of Venice, which is private.”
56:01

The Role of Product Manager for AI Models

Learn about the responsibilities and qualifications for the product manager role at Venice.

“and let the user do what's best for the user.”
58:08

Growth Opportunities for Venice

Explore the key growth opportunities for Venice in retail and enterprise AI markets.

“We got two questions from the Q &A from the Venice VVV Telegram.”
1:00:06

Update on GPU Cluster Development

Get the latest updates on Venice's GPU cluster buildout and timelines.

“And we just think that, you know, there's eight, what, eight billion plus people on this planet.”
1:01:19

Venice's Goals for Year-End

Discuss the goals and upcoming developments for Venice as the year ends.

“and that we will start going from there with what we can actually run on those and then starting to look ahead on additional build-outs if we think it makes sense.”
1:02:21

Engaging with the Venice Community

Learn about the vibrant community around Venice and how to get involved.

“Well, my eyes are definitely glued on Venice stats.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Bankless, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:04Welcome, Venetians, to the October VVV call every month. Jon, the head of strategy at Venice, and I go through the developments, the news, the events in Venice and the private AI space, keeping you up to speed with all things VVV and everything related to user sovereignty and privacy in the age of AI. Jon, happy October. It's a very exciting week in the VVV world. How are things over in Venice? Yeah, happy October, David. Yeah, things are going well. It's crazy that it's been another month already. It both feels like that hasn't been that much time and also like so much has happened in that time at the same time, which seems to be the way it goes in this industry.

0:44Well, we just saw each other for the first time in real life in New York. You were in New York briefly for the Lumara Film Festival. We're going to talk about that. But this was one of the few times I think probably Venice as a company really gets together in the real world? Because I think you guys are all very remote first. How was it to see? Eric was there. Austin was there. Lorenzo was there. Talk to me just about like meeting all the other Venice teammates all in New York. Yeah, yeah. It was a really great event. It's always awesome when we, you know, when some of us can get together. Because you're right, we are a remote first company.

1:18We are not usually like in the same office space or anything like that. We do, you know, a couple of off sites every year so that we get a chance to work some and try to find more ways that we can do that. But yeah, something like that was awesome. We both had a chance to kind of work together, you know, before and after the event. And just being there together for what was really quite an event was really cool. Yeah, great time. Yeah, we'll talk about all the prizes that Lumara gave out towards the end of this. But first, I think the subject of the month, I think the theme of this month, I think you could probably say this theme is accurate for all months, but it feels particularly true for this month, which is growth, growth, growth, growth.

2:00So this month in October, Venice passed 5 million users on the Venice platform. That's a pretty big number, but I think also the numbers behind the 5 million are worth talking about. So when Venice launched, it took 13 months to hit 1 million users, but only 68 days from the run-up between four and five million users. So one million new users in the last 68 days. Give me the inside perspective on the Venice side of things. So what has the growth been like? How has user usage of Venice changed or adapted at all? What's it been like on the Venice side of things? Yeah, I mean, in many ways, and this is the nice part of what we do with putting a lot of this data on chain.

2:47The data is pretty much the same internally. We're just, we keep seeing this growth accelerating. It's really been accelerating all year. I think, you know, part of us, you know, are kind of always waiting for like, when is this growth going to, you know, plateau or stop accelerating? And it just has not happened. I think we've even talked about that on a few of these calls. It just seems to keep accelerating both the usage, the top of the funnel, the amount of people that are coming in, the amount of actual, you know, revenue and subs that we're getting. All these things have been accelerating quite a bit, especially in the last four to six weeks.

3:26So I fully expect, unless something dramatic changes, that the time between five and six million will be even less than between four and five. As we know, things are priced on the margin. So as a VVV holder, I'm paying very close attention to the specific shape of the curve of growth. This is a chart and a subject that we have talked about a number of times on the VVV calls. I think we're going to talk about this chart every single VVV call because it's so instrumental to the subject matter at hand. This is Sabrina from Venice posting the chart about the number of tokens that Venice is serving a day.

4:04And there was a big jump. This was posted back in October 13th, so two weeks ago. There was a big jump from that curve upwards to an even steeper curve upwards in the middle of this month. And Sabrina just posted a new version of this chart where the jump just accelerated even higher. So we went from, I think, 250 billion tokens being served in at the end of September to 500 to over a trillion tokens a day served in October. I know growth has been growing, but this seems even more idiosyncratically high than the growth in the past. Talk to me about the jump. What else can you tell me about the nature of how this growth came to be at Venice?

4:49Yeah. So, I mean, honestly, this is a surprising amount of acceleration, again, even for us. So, yeah, we've went 4x tokens in basically like a month. And I think when we talked about this on our last call, I said I was about 50-50 on us hitting a trillion tokens by the end of the year. So, we're about, you know, well ahead of two months ahead of schedule of that, which is quite nuts, even to us. Yeah, there's a number of things that have been driving this. Obviously, like new models come out. That tends to drive a lot of usage. In this particular case, there was actually one specific change we made that really accelerated things.

5:28So basically, right at the start of this curve, we actually upgraded the default pro model. So we, you know, for a long time, there was basically two defaults, basically for our agentic chat and then what's known as our classic chat um we basically those defaults used to be kimmy k25 for agentic and um glm46 both of which are relatively old models at this point um and so we had been doing a lot of work and a lot of testing to decide you know we needed to up we want we knew we wanted to upgrade this and give you know basically our pro users a more state-of-the-art model um and so we ended up upgrading uh this to the new deep seek you know obliterated basically uncensored version um and that is right where you see this inflection basically like we saw we saw everything grow after that change um we saw uh more usage obviously that's you that's representing the tokens but also just we saw uh top of the funnel grow more people coming in more people staying um the actual amount of subs and i'm sure we'll talk about this but the sub started to grow quite a bit right at the same point as well um as well as just overall usage api credits, all those same things.

6:39Basically everything inflected when we did that update. So that was really interesting to see that just, you know, basically updating our default model. Obviously we offer a lot of models, but this is the one that most users use. And we know pretty well that many users never switch from the default. So what it meant is that all of these users were just getting a much better experience compared to what they had before. And it's just reflected in all these sorts of charts, including this token one. So I'm pretty sure DeepSeek is the green one on that chart. That's why that grew so much. I see. So this is really users' first impression of Venice.

7:16And when you guys upgraded the model from the older generation to the newer generation model, the first impression of Venice got better because the model got better. And was the DeepSeek, the green one, is that the agentic chat or is that the default chat, that's primarily going to be agentic. It's technically the default in both, but most people are defaulted into agentic chat at this point. That's really what we think is the kind of main product that we want to steer a new user to nowadays. So that's what they initially get. And that's what they're seeing. And there's other knock-ons of that too.

7:50Like we actually saw because it's agentic, basically that DeepSeek model becomes more or less the orchestrator of whatever that user is doing. And that means we also saw like, you know, it's not necessarily in this chart, but we saw images and video and like paid images and video also have a huge tick up without adjusting those models at all, just because basically the agent was that much smarter about when and how to create those things. I see, I see. And so a quick interlude to inform my next question, what is the future of the basic chat when you also have the agentic chat? Is the agentic chat kind of going to consume the default chat because that's just how you guys want to serve your users and the agentic chat is just a better product and so always serve new users the agentic chat?

8:43Yeah, I think long-term that's where we want things to go. What will probably happen as an interim step is that we will kind of combine them. So basically agentic chat will at some point just become chat and classic chat will get folded in. And for those who want the features that are in classic chat, there is still like a cohort of power users that really love that classic chat product. So we want to make sure that those people can still get the product they want and do the things they want to do. There's certainly a lot more manual selection ability in the classic chat. But we found that most users don't want to do that.

9:16You know, power users do. So we want to make sure those power users still have those capabilities and that those capabilities never go away. but the average new user who comes in who's looking for you know effectively private ai they don't they don't know the difference between any of these models to begin with they just want a great experience you know you think about the user that goes to you know chat gpt or clod or you know grok or any of these things they they generally just go with whatever the default is they're not going to be the ones that switch models the power users and like with something if we talk about something like mines that is where the the ability to configure all these things is really powerful.

9:54But that's always going to be a subset of users. And that subset of users might be able to help inform those experience of the better users, or rather the newer users, but the newer users and the more generic users, they generally just want it. They don't want to think they just want to type into the chat, they want to get the results they want. And that's what that's their experience. So eventually, these things will be combined. But we're not planning to take away anything from those power users who really do enjoy that ability to select exactly what they want. Maybe take a moment, John, and just explain what happens behind the scenes with the agentic chat and kind of the product philosophy behind the agentic chat feature.

10:37Because I think that's something that really sets Venice apart from ChatGPT, Claude, about just like the default usage of Venice. What does the agentic chat do for those who haven't experienced it themselves? Yeah, so the agentic chat at a high level, you can kind of think about it almost like a kind of mini harness, you know, so like there's all these harnesses out there that people run, the OpenClaws, the Hermes, now the things like GrokBot, Muse, etc. are getting popular, Dot, all these things that all these companies are releasing. This gives a version of that within the web where a lot of these users already are.

11:17And it allows basically the agent to make choices based on what the user's input is. So in the kind of classic LLM model, you know, call it like six months or a year ago before agents really started taking over, the model would, you would just get a direct response from the model. You give a prompt to the model, you get a direct response from the machine. Based off of that, it goes from there. In the world of agents, you have orchestration, meaning you have a model that's kind of at the top level that interprets the user's prompt and response and then makes various choices effectively on their behalf.

11:53This is where agent comes from, is that it actually has a degree of agency that a straight LLM does not necessarily. So that degree of agency can allow for a lot better experience because, you know, maybe the user doesn't ask for an image model or they don't know specifically that they need to like select an image model to get an image. They just want an image to appear based on their prompt. And the agent figures that out. It figures out the right image model or the right video model or whatever other form of multimedia or even like creating little artifacts and, you know, little web apps within the interface.

12:28All of these things can be accomplished by the agent at the top level because it's smart enough and it has effectively access to all these various tools that it can just give the user just a much better output with all those things combined. so this is really kind of that paradigm difference between agentic and non-agentic if you really know what you're doing you can accomplish some of those same things without the agent but effectively you the power user are the orchestrator you're figuring out how to connect all these pieces together right with the agent you don't need to understand or know any of that you just have to be able to effectively declare your intent and sometimes you don't even have to really declare your intent you just have to sort of give your intent and the agents are smart enough to figure this all out and give you a great output.

13:13This also kind of illustrates something we've talked about in past calls, which is Venice's position in the market, where Venice doesn't have any sort of preferences to any one model in particular. Like ChatGBT prefers OpenAI models, obviously. Claude prefers Anthropic models and won't serve any others. But because Venice integrates all of the models, It has the benefit of providing the best model for this given scenario. But rather than loading that burden of choice onto the user, you put that burden of choice onto the DeepSeq model, which is shown in green here on the chart. We'll get the chart back on the screen.

13:51You put the choice of the burden onto the green model, and apparently that's working, hence all of the growth in the tokens per day on the chart. Correct, exactly. And we, you know, we did some testing before we, you know, changing the default is actually always a really big deal for us because it has such a large impact on that new user experience. And we've even seen like, we made some mistakes on this, you know, call it more than a year ago where we would change the default and we didn't test it well enough. And we would see like immediate results of like people were not having as good of experience, signups and subs were not doing as well.

14:25And we learned that lesson over time that when we change the default, we have to be really, really thoughtful about it. we have to test it well we have to have a high degree of confidence that it really is a better experience because you can't just go off the benchmarks uh by themselves like this is this is the uh trap that people get into is they're like well the benchmarks and all these things are clearly better just change it it'll be better but people get attached to various models there's a subjective quality to models um people like either their writing style or their tone of voice or the way that they interact um and so they don't always necessarily want a better benchmark or even a more intelligent model.

15:02They get used to things. So we had to do a lot of testing, but in our tests, it became pretty clear that this seemed like a huge step up, that people were really liking it. And then when we actually launched it, I think, you know, again, you can see it right in that chart. I think it surprised even us how much better it was, how much more usage people were giving it. Just the way that people responded to it was just extraordinarily positive. So this was, you know, one of the better upgrades I think we've ever seen. I think the exciting thing for me as a VVV holder is that it seems to be clear that Venice has enough basal usage that when you guys make an upgrade to the system, you get the data back in real time.

15:47It's like, this was a good upgrade, or no, no, no, this was a bad upgrade, do something else. And because there's all this basic, I'm assuming quite a lot of free usage of Venice when the system upgrades or when the product upgrades, you can get that feedback almost immediately like, oh, this is resulting in more usage. This is resulting in more conversions. And it's nice to have such a direct relationship with the actual user and get that feedback in real time because high quality product feedback is actually not a given with so many startups in the world these days. And you guys are having it just based off of what the data that you can see in this chart.

16:25Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, you need a degree of critical mass, you know, to get good, you know, basically test results back to really have confidence that the changes you're making are good. We are fortunate in that obviously Venice has grown quite a bit over the last year. We have a ton of traffic. We have a ton of inference usage. So we can get, we can make changes. Some changes are smaller, bigger than others. But even at the small change or a small test that we can run, we can see those results, you know, often within, you know, hours, if not minutes, because we can get enough traffic on something that quickly that we very quickly can get an idea of like this is working or like looks like it's working or it's clearly not working.

17:06And then we either revert or try something else. So, yeah, we can get that kind of feedback very rapidly. And that's that's obviously a huge a huge thing for us when we're making these kind of upgrades. So the green model is the agentic chat. That's the DeepSeq model that you're referring to. This pink model, is that just the basic classic chat that you talked about some power users just prefer, so you're keeping that around? You know, I'm not actually sure. That looks like a newer model too on the chart. So that might even be, this might even be two different versions of DeepSeq. Because what happened is we had the DeepSeq obliterated and then we upgraded even further from there to the 1017 model, which is basically has all of the benefits of the censorship resistance, but is even smarter, even better tuned than that initial uncensored version.

17:58So basically what you're seeing is us upgrading and then upgrading again. And so some people are still using that other one. They still like that. But more and more people are using, are basically moving to something like, you know, a 1017 and just we're seeing these changes in real time. Do you have a number off the top of your head, John, about what percentage of these tokens per day are free tokens as opposed to paid tokens either via subscription or via the API credit purchase? Yeah, that's a good question. I would say that most of these are actually paid tokens because the free, while they're, you know, certainly we have a number of free users, there's definitely significant limits on, you know, how many messages a day, how many prompts a free user gets.

18:41So they're not the preponderance of inference. you know they're kind of more in that funnel of they get to try things they can use some things for free you know a few times a day but then if they want to really use the system they're going to have to upgrade at some point so I would I don't know for sure but I would assume it's something actually closer to like 80 20 or 70 30 that most of this is actually paid usage right yeah like the frontier AI labs have the luxury of having a very significant amount of venture capital therefore they can do activities like loss leader activities, like give a lot of models for free.

19:19Venice doesn't have the massive history of VC backing. So I think maybe you guys are just much more sensitive to giving out tokens for free. And so it would make sense that of the tokens that we see here, a lot more of them are paid. That's kind of my thought process. Is that correct? Yeah, I think that's partially correct. I mean, we do give out a decent amount of free usage, certainly to a lot of users. so that's just kind of part of how our system is built but yes, we do have to put pretty decent limits on it and even the chat GPTs and Anthropics of the world they actually put pretty significant limits on what you can actually do for free at this point they will subsidize especially if you're on a plan I'd say that was the main difference when you're on a plan with us we have to make sure that the unit economics really work for sustainable long term that's always kind of been our philosophy be is we want this to be sustainable and to work that way.

20:12The chat GPDs and the anthropics of the world are willing to, you know, basically burn huge amounts of CapEx and just burn it on effectively, you know, subsidizing huge amounts of inference for people. I don't think that can sustain long term, you know, they're able to do it for now, maybe they can do it for another year or two. But long term, there's that's, that's not going to work. But for now, they're doing it because they can get massive growth that way. And that, you know, it makes sense with their economics. Right. As you would expect, with increasing amount of tokens per day, the VVV burn has also been crescendoing all month.

20:46I've been doing some of the math. This is a tweet from Gecko, the guy behind the venicestats.com website about just the incoming all-time highs on daily VVV burns downstream of the new signups, but also the API credits. 1 % growth, John, I'm sure you know this, but 1 % growth in daily VVV burns is about the average over the last like 30-ish, three months since July. And that has turned into$1 million, Venice crossed, of monthly VVV burn in October. That happened on October 28th, so three days before the end of the month. And so congrats. I think that's a pretty big monument for the Venice and VVV holders who have crossed is a million dollars of VVV burn in a single month.

21:33Yeah, I mean, I certainly think so. I mean, you know, if you look at where this start, you know, where this burn started in December, I don't have the exact math, but we've something like 16 or 20 X burns since December. And that acceleration rate similarly, like the rest of the business continues to kind of grow. So, I mean, especially in those last four months, you know, it's not a bad looking burn chart. like things kind of keep stepping up pretty consistently. And if the business keeps growing, I expect to keep seeing that. So yeah, it's a big deal to cross a million dollars in burns in a single month.

22:08And like you said, there's still actually a couple of days left. So we'll probably be a little bit, you know, a good bit above a million by the end of this month. And I fully expect that to, you know, for us to basically continue on this pace. You know, if things really work out, if things keep growing, you know, So even in line with, you know, half of our current growth rate, I don't see any reason why these kind of numbers can't 10x in a year time. Yeah, a lot of the questions from the VVV Telegram chat this month has been really just the nature driving the acceleration behind token burn and also VVV burn.

22:44So there's a bunch of different categories that we could talk about Venice growth. There's just net new user signups who are buying subscriptions. there's higher usage by existing customers that's actually something that we saw from the Anthropic S1 is that a lot of the revenue comes from existing customers who are just buying 10 times more tokens on a yearly basis so that's another possible category there's applications using the API or API credits and then there's also AI agents using Vendus is there any specific category of growth that stands out to you or is it just kind of homogenous across the board?

23:20I mean, we're seeing growth in all those categories. Some of them are growing faster than others. Certainly, I think, especially this year, agentic use has grown quite a bit. I mean, something you'll kind of notice here even in the burn breakdown is I think it was either last month or the month before where programmatic burns started outpacing the discretionary burns. And that was also another actually really important milestone. And that should happen to the degree that the product and the project keeps growing. So that was really great to see and just to see all these things come together. I wouldn't say it's necessarily one particular thing.

23:57I mean, I would say that like probably the thing over the last, call it three or four months that has probably grown more than anything else on the revenue side, which then translates on the burn side, is just everything around video usage. The video models have gotten so much better. And like we talked about at the beginning and like, you know, the Lumara Film Festival and all this stuff, these things have started to get just really quite good. And you've got, you know, artists and creators coming in who are quite talented and making incredible use of these things. And so that has definitely been one of the major kind of revenue drivers.

24:31I mean, a year ago, it was actually a year ago this month in October that we launched video on the platform. And those models have just gotten so much better in that time. You know, it just incredibly different from, you know, where we were, you know, a year plus ago with, you know, Will Smith, you know, sloppily eating spaghetti and things like that, that just, you know, nobody could take seriously to the point where you now have actual creators using tools like Venice to create, you know, short films and soon full length feature films. So like these, it's just a very different thing. And obviously the videos, you know, are tend to be very, uh, usage heavy, you know, they, they're much more expensive than, doing an LLM call.

25:13So that's helped drive a lot of the top line revenue. Yeah. Yeah, maybe we can jump actually forward into the Lumara section. You can see the video that I'm showing on the screen, 30 seconds of it. Black Thunder was one of the winners of the Lumara Film Festival. I think they got like a million dollars and like another million dollars worth of Venice credits. Like my takeaway from the Lumara is that there's still a bunch of like rough edges around AI video production because it's so new, so early. But nonetheless, if you are an artist making AI videos, the world's kind of your oyster, as in there are enough obstacles that have been removed from you and your creative ideas that you can create some pretty crazy things.

25:55And so I think like Lumara and like there's a handful of other AI film festivals going on are kind of just like samples of the future that I think a lot of people are seeing. And I mean, you can see AI video all over Twitter, but they're all kind of slop. I think we're on the kind of like the precipice of a lot of not slop and actual real art making it into mainstream. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, it allows for those, especially those who like already, very similar to like how, you know, many of the, you know, people who are technical already or like already engineers are getting kind of, you know, outpaced usage of agents and things like that.

26:33People who already have experience in things like film and some of these art forms are able to create things with AI that they just, you know, they had the vision, but they just didn't have the resources or the capability before. So like Black Thunder there was a really great example. I mean, there were some really quite incredible films here at the film festival, but Black Thunder is a great example of, you know, he created this kind of, you know, I think almost 20 minute film. It's quite, you know, it's kind of this 80s B-movie type feel that I think is quite fun. But, you know, he can do all sorts of crazy things.

27:10And I think he spent, I think he told, he said the cost on that was like$2 ,000 worth of like Venice credits or something like that. But that's easily something, you know, that would have cost millions of dollars to make before, even on the low end, even for like, you know, a low budget film. And so the fact that you can create this kind of quality of thing for, you know, a few thousand dollars of credits and that this is the worst it will ever be, you know, it's only going to get significantly better and more efficient from here. is quite incredible. I think it opens up a whole new world for this kind of art form that you just couldn't have done, you know, even a year ago.

27:46The thing that excites me, again, speaking as a VVV holder, is that I haven't tried out all of the video generation platforms out there, but I know that one of the things I really enjoy about Venice the most is that I can very quickly swap between models on an as-needed basis. And so if I want my video to be based off of this or based off of different parameters, I can just go down to the model switcher and I pick a different model. I'm sure the AI filmmakers were using the ease of use that the Venice as a platform offers you. And as a VVV holder, that makes me excited because it builds a direct consumer relationship.

28:26Like it's the individuals using Venice.ai on the Venice page to do video generation. And having a relationship with the end consumer is always just such a economically advantageous position to be in. And so it would make sense if Venice like double, triple down on like video production as a way to just generate margin. Yeah, absolutely. And we are on a product from a product perspective, we are doing exactly that in many ways. You know, we have a couple of interesting things in the works, but you can see this primarily with the studio product in the app. So, you know, the studio product didn't exist more than like six or seven months ago.

29:05We got that out. A lot of these creators, I think, did use Venice Studio for creating a lot of these films. It gives you a lot more if you're if you're someone who really knows what you're doing, it gives you a lot more control. And we're finding ways to make that easier for the average person to to kind of get the power of those things. And I just think that there's there's a ton that can be done there. So we absolutely want our tools to be as good as possible for these type of creators so that they can really bring their visions to life. There's all sorts of things that can be created. And again, it's just going to get significantly better.

29:40And this is seen on our side. I think studio has actually become something like 25 to 30 % of our revenue. and it's entirely because of how good these video models are getting and actual users using these to create something that goes well beyond the kind of AI slop videos that you see on the timeline. Yes, yes, yes. I'm very much looking forward to not slop videos on the timeline and instead looking for something that has actual thought and meaning put behind it. John, I want to get your take on this chart. So this is a tweet from ZeroHedge talking about just the increasing, lowering economics of token costs, token prices.

30:21Token prices are getting cheaper across the board. Just high level, how does this impact you at Venice? What does this do for Venice as a company and as a product? Yeah, I mean, at a high level, we are very happy to see token prices fall. I think that this does a number of things that are actually quite beneficial to Venice. So at a high level, so going back to our chat earlier, just about something like DeepSeek, like the DeepSeek model is far more efficient than some of those older models. So the token cost falls as a result, but it's also far more intelligent. So the user gets a better result.

30:55And what we generally see is that that doesn't actually lead, even though the token price per turn, like of an agent, is falling quite a bit, that doesn't necessarily lead to less token usage by a user. Because what happens is when the user is happier with the result, they're actually far more likely to engage that much more. So like they might, the token cost might go down, but that might actually mean that the user is using the thing 5 or 10x more, which more than makes up for the difference of the cost. And it also allows us to offer something like, you know, like there's no way that we could have offered something like this level of intelligence to pro users for$18 a month a year ago because the cost just would have been too high.

31:36But now we can offer that much more of an efficient, better experience to a user because these things are that much more efficient. They're smarter at a much smaller token cost. So for us, it actually just makes the product better. And generally, if we can make the product better and the user's happier, that's going to lead to good results is what we've generally found. You know, users will use the thing that much more if they're having a good experience. So like we tend to optimize more for like, can the user have a great experience? And that's what we care about and that we've generally seen that play out.

32:11It also, you know, it's beneficial for other reasons. You know, if you think about it from, you know, like a VVV and Diem tokenomics perspective, to the degree that token price falls over time, this makes an asset like Diem actually more useful, more valuable, arguably, because you're getting that much more value for your dollar a day than you were a year ago. And arguably that should be reflected, you know, at least long-term, you know, any short-term is always noise, But in the long term, that should be reflected like in the price of the asset and what the market is willing to pay for that asset because you get that much more usage and usefulness out of it.

32:48I see. I see. OK, so as token prices fall, that's inversely correlated with the quality of the outputs that you can get out of Venice and all AI providers, all inference providers. maybe it's a little bit different because venice also provides inference across all of the models so maybe there's some like combination benefit there but also with with dm you know what is one dm one dm is one dollar of inference per day if token prices are going down you're getting more tokens per day and so the quality of a dm is literally going up so the deflation the technological progress of token costs of AI inference, the deflation of that gets expressed in what a single DM can offer you in the market.

33:34Exactly. Yeah, it's great for if you're a DM holder, this is a very good thing. Your asset just gets that much more useful, arguably that much more valuable, as long as this trend continues. And our bet for a while, you know, certainly for the last year has been that this trend will continue. And it's, it's pushed largely by these open source models that are coming out that are hot, much, just much more efficient than compared to their peers. So like, you know, there's always going to be the people who want to pay for the most elite high level intelligence that you're getting, you know, out of things like the frontier labs, the Opus five fives of the world, the GPT six ones, and you're going to pay a premium for that.

34:13And that's fine for people who want it. But a lot of people are very happy to get something that's, you know, 85, 90 % of that level of intelligence at a tenth of the cost. And that you can just do so much more with that when you don't have to pay the higher level of the token price. So to me, I just, I see this as an overall benefit to our users. And again, if our users are having better experiences and they have these kind of options, I think it just, it leads to good results, you know, for the users and for us. There's always this arms war between the open source models versus the private frontier models.

34:48Would you say that the open source models have been catching up with frontier models? Have frontier models been getting ahead? Or is that about at equilibrium? Where is that arms race, do you think, today? Yeah, most of this year, I would tell you that the open source models were catching up quite a bit and that the gap had been shrinking. And I think that is still generally the case. Although it does seem like it's plateaued a little bit in the last month. that's kind of, I don't have any exact data to back that up. It's kind of more of a feel. So, you know, I use all these models and can see the difference between, you know, an Opus 5.5 and, you know, some of these open source models.

35:27But then you also get things like, you know, even like a recent Kimi K3.1 Pro, which is actually quite close on those levels, at least on the benchmarks. And then I think the elephant in the room is that the open, the Frontier Labs are not actually putting out their best models. So we cannot actually fully see the gap. We can only see the gap with what they've released. The Frontier Labs are absolutely keeping their best models close and likely not even, they either don't release them or they release them months after they've been trained. So like once we get an Opus 5.5, the reality is an Anthropic is probably months ahead of that already internally.

36:07Right. But they're not releasing those models. So we can only really gauge this based off of what we can see. We can kind of guess a little bit when we see things like, you know, open AI and anthropic releasing, you know, proofs to things like longstanding math and physics problems. That gives us a sense that those internal models are actually probably a good bit further ahead than we think. But yeah, all we can observe is what actually comes out. One of the big news events in the Venice universe was this 21 shares releasing VENC, ticker VENC, which is a VVVETP, basically an ETF, but in Eurospeak.

36:49In 21 shares, there's a European emphasize. They have United States ETFs as well, but they have a lot of European ETFs. So Venice, VVV, got its first ETF on a European Swiss stock exchange. I kind of think this is like an IPO moment for the VVV token because now it's listed on publicly traded stock exchanges. Since like Venice, it's been stated that it has no aspirations to IPO. This is now VVV trading on places where publicly traded companies are traded. Now this is in Europe and I think a lot of people would be very excited to see this come to America. was Venice in conversation with 21 shares or did they just do this?

37:34It's kind of both to be honest so they, you know, we've had a number of folks reach out that were interested to launch products like this it hasn't necessarily been a huge priority for us but it's something I certainly would like to see over the medium to long term just because this gives access to people to VVV and pools of money that otherwise just can't are not going to come directly on chain. Just like we've seen with a lot of these things in the US with the Bitcoin and the ETFs. It gives access to pools of capital that effectively can only participate in these type of ways. So it's great to see something like that.

38:13Yeah, 21Shares had reached out to us. They seemed great. But we were not directly involved in any of this. We are not depositing into the product or anything like that. They actually launched it And I didn't know it was coming until I saw this announcement, just like everybody. Like I knew that they were interested, but I did not know that the launch was going to happen. So it was cool to see that. I definitely do expect that this trend will likely continue, that we will see more products like this. Probably first in Europe, my guess, over the course of this year. And then maybe if things go well, we will see products like this probably sometime next year actually appear in the U.S.

38:51as well. And I think that's great to just get more people access to VVV in the way that they're comfortable. My take on this is that, to your point, this brings crypto assets and makes it available to funds, whoever, pools of capital that can only trade on public regulated venues as the one that's listed here. Venice is a little bit different, though, in that most crypto assets are interested by crypto market participants. And so at Bitcoin ETF, Bitcoin was always available to crypto capital. But Venice is AI. And so it's a crypto asset, but it's in the AI sector. And so there would be a lot of people who are interested in buying AI-related assets that aren't on-chain.

39:39And so a VVV ETF would actually uniquely unlock pools of capital specifically because it's a crypto asset that needs access to publicly traded markets. And so I guess that's a take that I have. We'll see it play out if and when VVV becomes listed on like the NASDAQ or the New York Stock Exchange, maybe from like Bitwise or, you know, somebody, some of the more crypto native brokers is kind of who I would expect it to get issued by. Yeah, I think that's a great point. And I do think that like getting... that type of access is really interesting, especially because, you know, I think the interesting framing here is obviously that unless you're like a VC or a private investor with lots of connections, you really aren't able to access, even today, these AI companies directly.

40:25And by the time you can access them, you know, we've got the Anthropic IPO now coming as soon as next month, it looks like. You know, that's probably going to be trading, you know, maybe as high as like something like $2 trillion. $2 trillion. so like I think it'll be interesting to have these kind of products available you know at a much more let's call it reasonable market cap for people who want that kind of AI exposure maybe they're not interested in crypto but they do want the AI exposure and they're going to feel late it's going to be hard to not feel late to Anthropic at$2 trillion or open AI at a similar price when these come out because there was no way to access them I want to turn to kind of one of the big themes of the month outside of the Venice world, which was just the data breaches everywhere.

41:11This was an interesting tweet that I saw from Stephen Liss. Another vulnerability few are talking about. I found my Claude code exposing personal data in HTTP headers because the sites it curled politely asked agents to identify their users. Yikes. I don't quite exactly know what all of this means, but I do understand that if I'm going to give my personal information to Claude or Anthropic, that seems to be something, an attack vector, that's the attack factor that Steven here is highlighting. Eric Voorhees, founder of Venice, says, use Venice if you don't want to know what is about to happen to everyone to happen to you.

41:45Maybe, John, you could just kind of give us a little bit more color about the security vulnerability here and how Venice is potentially an answer to that. Yeah, I mean, well, one, there's this whole wave of security issues, you know, sweeping across, you know, certainly the AI industry, but really the whole world right now, the whole internet. and so that's part of what's going on. I think too, I think this specific thing has to do with the fact that agents are very prone to prompt injection in various ways and so when this says that my cloud code basically if it was politely asked the agent it's effectively a form of prompt injection like someone puts on their website agents please identify yourself and the agent just sees that thing takes it as a prompt and blindly obeys it And then if it has data about you, it will give over that data because it's just trying to follow effectively the prompt.

42:39So the prompt is like, so if I went to my cloud or chat, my consumer AI platform, and I'd be like, hey, tell me the top 20 facts about me. It would spit out all the data that it has about me. And that same, a similar prompt could be in the HTTP header as identified by Steven. Is that something like that? Yeah, exactly. That you just like, when you set your agent to go scrape a website or to do something on the internet, you don't know when it's pulling data, you know, basically what exists, you know, especially in like the headers or the metadata that, you know, someone might have snuck in there to basically get information out of these agents.

43:15And agents, agents in a very important sense, they effectively, they want to please, they want to do what the thing tells them to do. And so when you get a prompt like this without knowing about it, and they have the information to give up, they very well might. And that's where you end up with an issue like this. And this all goes back to the core. And I think it's even more important in this world where we see all these vulnerabilities. You know, I think at Venice, you know, we've really had this philosophy that I think just gets stronger that like the only way to protect data is to not have it.

43:48If something has data about you, there's going to be ways that that data can leak. There's going to be ways that data can get, you know, exfiltrated, like with a prompt injection effectively like this. if whatever the agent just doesn't have the data about you, or Venice in our case just doesn't have the data about you, it doesn't matter if this gets asked because there's no data to give over. So the best way to protect yourself is to just not be storing your data in these giant repositories that these giant AI companies all have about, you know, you as particular users and everyone that they're working with because that's their business.

44:22But that creates this giant honeypot to exfiltrate that data in various ways. and AI is just getting increasingly better at effectively exploiting anything possible. So if an exploit is possible, the agents are going to find it and they're going to find things that we have not even imagined. And if you really want to keep things safe, it's better to just not have that data in the system in the first place. The big cybersecurity threat this week was just the PHP vulnerability, which like 70 % of websites, the vulnerability would allow anyone to basically have God mowed over said website if that vulnerability was in place.

45:01If your data, your individual data was in that website, that could have been exposed. And I was talking to a few security researchers on Bankless and the worst case scenario, but in my mind seems somewhat plausible, is that with the acceleration of the capacity of these AI swarms and AI agents to find and exploit vulnerabilities, personal data on the internet has never been more vulnerable than it is right now. and it's only going to crescendo as it goes forward in the future. So like the question I have for you, John, is like, do you think this is going to change the relationship that individuals, businesses have with personal data getting stored anywhere, regardless of whether it's like safe or not?

45:43It just seems to be like it's such a big threat that the idea of putting personal data on a computer seems to be like an obsolete strategy win the world of a very bumpy year of security vulnerabilities. Yeah, I do think that's the case. I do think people are going to have to think basically that many things are going to need to be re-architected in a very significant way because of how good AI and agents in general are getting at exploiting these things and that there's not necessarily a great way to protect this data, again, to my point. Like, if the data exists, the assumption has to be that at some point that data could or very well will be leaked somehow or exfiltrated.

46:34So I think more companies are going to become far more aware of this as they have to deal with all these vulnerabilities as they're basically having to patch all their stuff like every day, which is how it's felt for like the last 10 days or so. At some point that will slow down. Like a lot of the low, part of it is that there's just a lot of low hanging fruit that already exists in a lot of the code that's out there. And a lot of it's not maintained very well. So like the stuff that's on the frontier where people actually maintaining it will get strengthened relatively quickly. But then the models will get better again.

47:06And then people who, and then there's all this stuff out there with, you know, how many websites or products are out there that like, don't do a ton of updates, don't have a ton of maintenance and are just been out there for many years. they are not necessarily the ones that are going to get updated during all of this and they'll just stay exposed. So I think a lot of re-architecture has to happen for the world of agents and how the internet works in this way. And ironically, I think it's a world too where we went through a lot of this in the crypto world over the last, especially earlier this year.

47:39But ironically, a lot of these exploits coming out are actually not at all a problem for crypto because in many ways crypto is actually ahead of the game because we've basically had a giant honeypot of vulnerability money sitting out there for years at a time that we've all had to deal with and a lot of the internet didn't have to deal with that. They just didn't have that level of risk and so they're all just not nearly as well as maintained and just a lot of updates are going to need to be made and the models are going to keep getting better every time we get these updates. So, yeah, I think it's a difficult situation.

48:16I think a lot more companies and a lot more individuals are going to become aware of this issue and they're going to look for ways to keep their data private, using things hopefully like private AI through Venice, but also just how they re-architect their systems in general to not keep data that they don't need. Right. As this becomes an increasingly critical issue for larger and larger companies, there's like two trends that I see that both point directly toward being bullish for the value of Venice's product. One, AI is getting integrated everywhere. That's the broad AI take, obviously. Everyone kind of understands that that's where the future is going.

48:58But two, the growing insecurity of people's data will want people to be more data-security minded. And the best step for that is just to don't make the data exist at all. And so the best data solution is no data. And so I could imagine that intersecting right at Venice, where it's like, hey, Venice can serve your AI needs. Do you need AI customer support in your company? Venice can do that for you. Do you need AI inference in this corner of the internet? Venice can do that for you. And since this also coincides with your desire to minimize all data on the internet, that makes Venice the right product for these companies who want to both integrate AI and not create or have any data at risk.

49:43Yeah, I mean, the reality is without even knowing that something like this was coming to this degree. I mean, we all kind of knew that AI would probably get good at exploits and things like this, but none of us necessarily realized what form that would take or how fast it would happen. Venice has been building a product that was architected with this idea of eliminating the data risk for, you know, two and a half years now. So like this is just core to our philosophy and core to how we've built everything we've built. So in many ways, you know, we see all of this and like we've kind of already built the architecture that can exist in this world, without increasing this risk surface.

50:18And most products have not. Most products have built in a world where they take as much data as they can get and use that data in useful ways to either improve their product or serve the customer ads or whatever they're doing to monetize. They're very reliant on that data. I think Venice is one of the few applications that has really built itself to be in a world where we don't want that data, we don't keep that data, and that's how we build everything. So it's not necessarily easy You can't, as an open AI or Claude, re-architect your app to not take any data. That's just totally antithetical to their business model.

50:56But we've been building this exact way for two and a half years. Speaking of very critical entities who are sensitive about their data, the Department of Homeland Security has banned DeepSeek, DeepSeek Party products, and any third-party services developed using DeepSeek implementation. Can you talk about what's actually going on here, John? Is it as simple as the United States government has banned DeepSeek, or what's the actual deal here? Yeah, I mean, to some degree, I think this is a little bit of even, dare I say, fear-mongering. They don't want, you know, in the U.S. government, I sort of understand this, but they don't want anything that, you know, effectively Chinese open-source labs are building to be used within their their infrastructure.

51:46In one sense, this makes sense, especially if they were sourcing DeepSeek directly from DeepSeek or directly from the Chinese labs. That is a real risk that I think they should learn about. That's what I thought that they were banning. I thought like if you have a direct relationship with the company behind DeepSeek, as in if you are going to like deepseek.com and porting your data, sending it over to China, that is banned. But are you saying that the model usage of the model itself is banned? The way I read this is they're banning the model usage. and I don't think that makes sense. I could be wrong, but that's how I read this and I think that's what they're saying because I don't think they're using the nuance to think about the difference between DeepSeek via DeepSeek and DeepSeek via another provider who's running the weights and is not connected at all to the Chinese inference.

52:32So, you know, Venice is a great example of this. You know, when you use DeepSeek through us, you know, you really don't have that risk. Like we're running an open weight model. We are the ones running the inference. we are certainly not sending anything back to DeepSeek. There's no DeepSeek company on the other end of the prompt. Correct. And I think that's really where the concern is on their side. But I don't think they're discriminating because I think their view is just, you know, China bad, let's get rid of it all. Interesting, interesting. Well, DeepSeek is available on Venice, which kind of brings me to our next subject.

53:06I have heard this word more in the last month and I had had all of the AI wave, which is this word obliterated. John, can you just inform and educate me and the listeners, what is this obliterated do and how does it describe a model? Yeah, so obliterated models are really interesting and they're really something we've always been very interested in at Venice. What obliteration means is it's effectively a form of fine-tuning or post-training the model where you try to actively remove its restrictions or its censorship. So, I would assume, for example, a good example of this is that, you know, you get one of these Chinese models, one of these great Chinese models, open-weight models, something like DeepSeq.

53:50And what happens is that those models very well might have some degree of censorship baked in, even though they're open source. So, like, you know, you try to ask the DeepSeq model through DeepSeq about Tenemin Square, I bet you're not going to get a great response. Or it might tell you that such a thing never happened. But if we obliterate, if we take those open weights and we obliterate it, we effectively do whatever we can to remove those restrictions, right? We remove those restrictions around what the model can or will refuse effectively. Then the model becomes much more permissive and much more useful.

54:30And this is particularly useful and important when it comes to things like cybersecurity and cyber defense. like we've seen over the last two weeks because this has been a huge problem. Again, these frontier labs do not make their best models openly available, the ones that are actually good. And they put all sorts of cybersecurity restrictions in particular around the models you can get from them. And this is a huge problem when like, this has actually happened multiple times in the last couple of months where someone's infrastructure is under attack, whether it's Hugging Face or one of these others, and they cannot use like their Anthropic model or the GPT model because they will refuse due to cybersecurity restrictions to help them defend against a cybersecurity attack.

55:14So like if you're on the cutting edge of this stuff and you're doing, let's call it, you know, security threat modeling and like actually trying to help secure systems, the obliterated models can actually be a savior and quite useful because it removes those types of restrictions and they will more readily help defenders. So like what we found is that there's been a huge amount of popularity among defenders with these types of obliterated models because they're much less likely to refuse those important type of tasks. Interesting, interesting. Okay, so this just fits into, there's one side of Venice, which is private.

55:51We don't collect data, you don't store data, it's private, that's great. Also uncensored, as in, we're not going to tell you how you should use models. In fact, we're just going to serve you the best models possible and let the user do what's best for the user. And this is that side of Venice. Exactly. Yep. Beautiful. All right, John, we got one last subject. We talked about the Lumara Film Festival. And so I want to go down to this tweet from Eric. You guys are hiring for a product manager of models. Sounds like a pretty amazing opportunity. Tell me about it. What is a product manager of models?

56:27What's kind of the qualifications you guys are looking for? And who should apply? Yeah, I mean, so in this particular role, we're looking for someone who can really help manage the very diverse model suite across Venice. Help us make decisions like we just made, you know, with like, what should the default model be at this point? When is the right time to upgrade? When is a model not getting enough usage and needs to be deprecated so that we can use those GPUs or that, you know, compute on, you know, something that's more relevant and understanding all these models, how they come out and how they fit together.

56:59So, you know, the perfect person for this type of role is someone that's obviously got, a degree of the product management experience, but is generally probably like someone who just lives and breathes different types of AI models. They love understanding the differences between these things. They love running them locally and using them themselves in various interesting ways. And they're just very up to speed with what all these models are. It's become really much more than a full-time job for anyone to keep up with all of these models. There's so many releases every week at this point. There's different types of models from these LLM models to image and video to now things like world models and all sorts of new types of models that are coming out.

57:41And, you know, things like, you know, decision models, another recent new type of model in the last couple of months. So this is someone who really lives and breathes this stuff and wants to help us, you know, really manage that at a high level. It's always going to be a degree of a team effort. It's too much for any one person, but we want someone to come in and, you know, really live and breathe this stuff and be an owner of this in the organization. We got two questions from the Q &A from the Venice VVV Telegram. First is from Prop B. Is Venice's biggest opportunity enterprise AI rather than retail?

58:19So while Venice has a very clear privacy advantage, going after consumer products is a very competitive part of the market, going toe-to-toe with Claude, Chachi Boutique, Rock, Perplexity. they may all still offer very strong everyday experience in areas such as memory and personalization. So where do you see Venice's biggest growth opportunity? Is it convincing retail users to switch their daily AI assistant? Or is the real upside in enterprise customers, developers, and autonomous agents that need private inference at scale? How do you think about this? Yeah, I mean, I don't necessarily see these things as mutually exclusive.

58:55I still think the biggest growth opportunity remains the consumer, remains retail. I think that that's where Venice has historically been focused. It's where we're going to continue to focus. You know, we're up to 5 million users, but, you know, look at the world's population and the amount of people using AI. That's still, you know, a small enough number and we think it can grow tremendously from there. So that's really where our focus is. And just the way you think about developing a product is very different when you're consumer focused versus enterprise focused. That being said, we still have a ton of inbound on the enterprise side that's just happening naturally, even without us focusing on it.

59:32And we are trying to figure out ways to serve those customers better. You know, that's where a lot of the kind of API growth is coming from is, you know, various developers, builders, other enterprises who want to build on top of the Venice API, get the benefits of privacy, get the benefits of all the various models, censorship resistance that you can get through Venice. So we're not going to like do one at the exclusion of another, but our focus is generally going to remain on the retail side and we'll find ways to serve the enterprise more and more. But I don't see us like pivoting to enterprise and away from retail and consumer, which is really our bread and butter.

1:00:07And we just think that, you know, there's eight, what, eight billion plus people on this planet. You know, there's plenty of room for growth on that side without needing to effectively build an entirely different type of organization that is focused on enterprise. And then one last question, which I think is probably the most popular question in the VVV Telegram is about the progress on not the data center, but the GPU cluster that Venice is building out. So what's the latest with that? Are there any other details and timelines you could talk to us about when the GPUs come online? Yeah, it's been progressing.

1:00:44I myself need probably an update on this from our own internal team on exactly where things are. But my understanding is that we remain loosely on the timeline. Something's got a little bit delayed, which is just the world. of trying to buy and get GPUs delivered. The world of atoms, yeah. Yeah, just like nothing runs on time in that world. So we're well within what we thought would be a reasonable delay window for what our initial estimates were. I fully expect that some of these clusters are going to be coming online within the next week, certainly within the next month through November, and that we will start going from there with what we can actually run on those and then starting to look ahead on additional build-outs if we think it makes sense.

1:01:29John, that is the month of October. You just got back home from New York after you were here for the Lumara Film Festival. What do you focus on for the end of the year? What goals does Venice have or goals do you have as it relates to Venice between now and the end of the year? Yeah, we have a lot of things going on internally. I mean, most of our goals just revolve around making the product as good as we can make it, But, you know, adding additional, improving just everything about the current product, adding additional functionality, new features and some new products that we're working on that we're not quite ready to talk about.

1:02:04But we've got a lot of cool stuff cooking and we're going to keep just marching forward, you know, marching forward, hopefully making sure the growth continues in the way that it has and preferably keeps accelerating and doing everything we can to deliver the best product we can to all our users. Well, my eyes are definitely glued on Venice stats. That's one of the websites from one of the Venice community members, Gekko, in the VVV Telegram is where everyone's kind of taking those screenshots of the token burn, the VVV burn is one of the most exciting websites, I think, in crypto right now. You heard me mention the VVV Telegram listeners throughout this call.

1:02:42I mentioned this every single VVV call that we have. It's a group of about 60, 70 Venetians, VVV Venice enthusiasts. If you want into that telegram, DM me on X. I will throw you an invite link. We talk about Venice. We educate about Venice. We ask questions about Venice. And then I ask John those questions every single month on the VVV call. John, it's good to have you for October. I'll see you in a month in November. And best of luck for another good month of growth. Yeah, sounds great. See you in a month, David. Cheers, everyone.

1:03:32I'll see you next time.

From the publisher

Venice’s Head of Strategy, Jon joins David for the October $VVV community call to unpack Venice crossing 5M users and 1T daily tokens, $1M+ in monthly $VVV burns, the DeepSeek-powered growth surge, accelerating AI video demand, the new $VVV ETP, private AI in an era of rising data breaches, and what comes next.
---
📣SPOTIFY PREMIUM RSS FEED | USE CODE: SPOTIFY24
https://bankless.cc/spotify-premium
---
TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Intro
0:21 September AI Update
2:12 Token Growth Surge
8:36 Emissions and Diem Supply
16:10 Burn Mechanics Explained
23:40 OpenAI Privacy Controversy
32:00 Data Retention Warnings
35:52 Anthropic's Retention Shift
39:24 Privacy Boosts Venice
43:03 Minds and Model Combinations
52:48 Staking and Burn Questions
55:47 Data Center and Near
59:37 Lumara Film Festival
---
Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here:
https://www.bankless.com/disclosures

More from Bankless

All episodes