


A “Budget Reaction Special” reacting to UK Chancellor John Healey’s first budget, focusing on whether it was “do no harm,” what it means for growth, taxes, youth employment/NEETs, and UK innovation (especially AI, data centers, robotics), plus concerns about living standards and consumer confidence.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Guests share their initial thoughts on Chancellor Healy's budget, assessing its effectiveness and implications.
“Eileen, what did you think of John Healy and his first budget?”
Discussion on missed opportunities in the budget regarding youth employment and the apprenticeship levy.
“But I think we need to, you know, we need to look at bigger picture things where we can actually make a difference, where things are in our control.”
Exploration of the government's approach to addressing skills and employment issues in the budget.
“You know, a steady-as-you-go budget is what we were told, but it's still a decision on trillion-pound odds worth of stuff going on in the economy.”
Insights from the tech sector on the budget's implications for innovation and entrepreneurship.
“So there are some initiatives already launching imminently but you know I think we've got to look at where the government is.”
Critical evaluation of the founders relief initiative and its potential impact on entrepreneurs.
“Maybe in a few weeks' time we'll see if that is what lands on the table, some plan to get involved in.”
Discussion on the government's perception and its impact on entrepreneurship.
“put all of his chips on the table, I think, and say this is absolutely where everyone needs to be in order to start a business or to try and be innovative.”
Exploration of the motivations behind starting businesses and the impact of government grants.
“parameters on the actual requirements of what actually qualifies, I think.”
Analysis of the budget's impact on business investments and tax fears.
“There might have been more taxes on the wealthy that might have actually then driven investors out.”
Discussion on the unique challenges faced by family businesses under current tax policies.
“They've excluded the transfer of family business as part of that.”
Insights into the societal contributions of family businesses and the impact of regulations.
“and it doesn't apply to me, but I was outraged at the time on all their behalf, whether it was farmers, whether it's businesses, because they just get on and do great things in their communities.”
Reactions to the budget and its implications for business sentiment and future investments.
“But no, I think, you know, and words like AI, I wonder how many times that was in the count.”
Examination of growth forecasts and challenges for the UK economy.
“Yes, there are real challenges ahead, but Britain has beaten the forecasts this year and with the action I'm taking today, I believe Britain can beat the forecasts again.”
Discussion on the potential of AI and innovation in driving economic growth.
“I think the UK is incredibly fortunate because we have such a density of talent in terms of technology and innovation.”
Exploration of the UK’s potential leadership in drug research and healthcare innovation.
“it would be great for you to do word count on Keir Starmer saying growth, that doesn't make it happen.”
Discussion on the budget's allocation for technology and innovation.
“But this is the area, the growth of tech that you've spent a career investing in.”
Exploration of the UK's potential to lead in robotics manufacturing.
“I don't disagree that we're not number one or number two for AI in the world, but we are a number three after China and US, which obviously are both going to have considerable more resources.”
Insights into the changing relationship between businesses and the government.
“Out in China, you've got Unitree and Agibot as the primary manufacturers over there.”
Analysis of AI's role in productivity and its implications on jobs.
“Is there a reluctance to take advantage of it?”
Examination of living standards post-pandemic and economic projections.
“artificial intelligence mean we have a growing economy but a higher rate of unemployment.”
Discussion on improving efficiency in business and healthcare services.
“I will be used to that rate of fuel cost.”
Reactions to the budget and discussions on innovation opportunities.
“Do you see when you see a budget like this and the fact that it's a country with a trillion pounds to decide what it has to spend on and where to put that money?”
Insight into the reactions and discussions among business leaders after the budget announcement.
“I want to just wrap up with getting a sense of what it's like to run a business, to make big investment decisions on and around the day of the budget.”
Reflection on how businesses prioritize customer delivery amidst budget uncertainties.
“I mean, inevitably you end up being desperately selfish in these situations.”
Discussing the implications of the latest budget and economic concerns.
“It's pretty much an irrelevance, if I'm honest.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Big Boss Interview, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30goals, or appetite for investing, Schwab has everything you need all in one place. Visit schwab.com to learn more. Balance your trading strategy by adding futures. CME Group helps you manage risk and capture opportunities in all market environments. Capitalize on around-the-clock access to highly liquid global futures and options markets across all major asset classes. Visit your online broker and get started. See what adding futures can do for you at cmegroup.com forward slash podcast. Derivatives are not suitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more More than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made.
1:02This is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell or attain any specific investment or service.
1:19It is time to throw out the usual structures. Forget the nice chatty intros. There's been a budget. And if we're ever going to do some form of emergency type podcast to break our norms, then today is the day. It's an excuse to get the klaxon out at the very least. Welcome to a special edition of Big Boss Interview. I'm Sean Farrington and we're going to crack right on with finding out what do those at the top of British business, employing thousands, making investment decisions worth millions and billions, what do they make of Chancellor John Healy's very first budget? it. I'm joined by retailer John Roberts, founder and chief executive of AO.com, one of the UK's largest online electrical retailers.
1:59John happened to be our first guest on Big Boss Interview as well. Welcome, John. Thanks. I've got Eileen Burbage, investor here with us as well, founding partner of the venture capital firm Passion Capital, NFG Ventures as well, one of the UK's best known early stage technology investors formerly, on David Cameron's Business Advisory Group as well. Hi, Eileen. Hi there, Sean. And Steve Rigby, who leads a portfolio of businesses as chief executive of Rigby Group, one of the UK's largest privately owned business groups, major interests across tech, real estate, aviation, hospitality. Steve, hello.
2:33Hi there, Sean. Right. There are the intros. We know who we're talking to, people who know what they're doing. Eileen, what did you think of John Healy and his first budget? Did he know what he was doing? I think he knows what he's doing, right? And it's not his first turn at this. I think he had a pretty difficult spec to navigate. And I think what he came out with was probably safe-ish, not necessarily earth shattering, but not as catastrophic as maybe other people were also suggesting it could be as well. Steve, we'll get into maybe an array of the issues, the policies that came up in it. 98 of those policies, I think, so maybe not all of them.
3:08But what was your hot take after it? I think we were expecting a do no harm budget. I think it definitely met that watermark. But I think it probably went a little bit further. Certainly, I'm more positive this is the third Labour budget. It's dramatically different than the first two. I think the total tax raises next year are about£600 million, and we compare that against raises of nearly£40 billion in the last two budgets. So, personally, for me, it's a good step forward. It can give us some confidence to build on. John, we were told it was going to be a steady-as-you-go budget. How did you react to it?
3:41Well, I never thought I'd feel sorry for him, but I felt his choices were extremely limited. He's got a straitjacket of world events around him, he's got no money, and the current regime doesn't really have a mandate for the things that I think they really want to do. So I felt like he was very limited, but equally, I also think they'd missed lots of opportunities. I'm an eternal optimist, so I think there's lots of things that we can do and lots of strengths that we can play to rather than just banging on it relentlessly relentlessly about the cost of living that a lot of that is out of his hands anyway.
4:16And when you say you're banging on about the cost of living, many people will think, many people who work for AO will be thinking, hang on, this cost of living is literally on my mind every day. So what do you mean by that? Well, it is, but he doesn't have the firepower to, in my view, make a meaningful difference for people. So, you know,£100 will be wiped out super quickly if President Trump decides to invade Iran again and petrol goes up further. So, you know, I think it's all done with the best of intention and, you know, genuinely I think it's well intended. But I think we need to, you know, we need to look at bigger picture things where we can actually make a difference, where things are in our control.
4:57So, you know, we've got over a million young people, not in education, employment or training, that are costing us$125 billion. Where was the plan for that? What are we going to do? Where are we actually going to take some action? And we sort of have been told, haven't we, there's a few reports in the pipeline where they've had big investigations. We've trailed a lot of them about what is really the problem with young people getting into work. So would you give them a bit of grace? No. So they overcomplicate these things. And what you need to do is you need to hand the authority on these things, in my opinion, to people who know what they're doing.
5:36and people who are motivated and in a position to make a difference. And it's a topic that I've spent a lot of time working on. And I think retail and hospitality are wonderful first jobs for people. They certainly were for me working in a hotel. You learn so much in terms of discipline, engaging with people and just getting into work. And so one of the biggest problems for that community is that the apprentice levy is a car crash. It's an administrative nightmare and it's not fit for purpose. And that seems to be generally accepted now. And I've been having conversations with the chief execs of lots of major companies, you know, the likes of Timpson, Amazon Web Services, with Sainsbury's, with Caffe Nero.
6:24These people employ thousands and thousands of people across retail and hospitality. And I have one simple proposal for the government, which is give about 20... Give all the major supermarkets and lots of big hospitality a sandbox for three years for their apprentice levy. Trust them to spend it well and give them the goal between them, because they're all very competitive, of reducing the number of NEETs and targeting that money at NEETs and looked after kids. So you didn't hear that today. You say it's a missed opportunity. It's a solution that's cost... This is costing us£125 billion a year.
7:04So for round numbers, the total debt, the interest that we're paying in one problem. And I reckon, and I could be wrong, but in all those retail and hospitality businesses that employ millions of people, they're up for the challenge. Steve, I'll take this one on with you because part of Rigby Group has some of those sectors that John's talking about there. You know, a steady-as-you-go budget is what we were told, but it's still a decision on trillion-pound odds worth of stuff going on in the economy. Were there opportunities missed there to make massive changes to some of the biggest problems we have in our country?
7:46If I'm going to show you, I think John's probably been a little harsh. I think the Milburn Review, you know, Alan's a good man, I know him. You know, that is due, I think, in three weeks' time. I suspect it's got consequences which had financial implications in the budget, which is why it's been delayed alongside the TIMS review, which is also looking at personal independence payments. So I think we are going to see a significant plan. I think we are going to see changes to the growth and skills, maybe that apprenticeship, maybe that John mentioned. So I don't think they're shying away from this issue.
8:13I'm slightly concerned that, you know, there are seven and a half million 16 to 24 year olds. A million fall into this neat category. I slightly worry we're going to abandon the other 6.5 million who aren't in that category. So it shouldn't just be about needs. I think young people more generally, where I'm with John, is absolutely hospitality and retail is a great place to start. It's where I started personally as well. And I think we've got to give the government a chance to try and get these things off the ground. But do we have to? I mean, they had a chance today. And I just wonder whether you're confident when those reports come out in three weeks' time, are they going to be, right, we need to digest this report, we'll respond to it we'll let you know what our response is and then we'll wait for a next budget or no i think we're going to see i think we're going to see action sean i think we're going to see a firm it'd be almost like another fiscal event will it but you know it's it's a it's a report that needs uh its recommendations accepting by the government first of all so but i i think i sense that alan and andy burnham are very lockstep together i think they're going to come out with some bold changes and initiatives we've already got some things on the table i think tesco's and John Lewis partnership have got 65 ,000 NEETs that they can take on board where they're two years or greater in the NEET category and there's a 25-hour subsidy for six months.
9:31So there are some initiatives already launching imminently but you know I think we've got to look at where the government is. John started with the fact they're in a fiscal straitjacket. You know this is a budget where you know it was a do no harm position. They've come out with very limited business taxes And I think John and I probably appreciate where they've come out on minimum wage. It's in line with what's happening in the general economy. And importantly, there's no further tax issues around employing people. So I think we've got to give the government some latitude where it's due. And personally, I see it as a positive step forward.
10:06John, I'll just let you come back to just a few of those points just before I want to speak to Eileen about what the tech world might make of some of that. But, you know, Steve, giving them a bit of grace there, the government, give them a few more weeks, big decisions come in. Yeah. So from my perspective, I've been campaigning for youth for a very long time. I've heard it all before. And the truth is, I don't think the politicians will write the apprentice levy any better. And giving people who run businesses who will not put their brand at risk, you know, putting them in a sandbox, Fox, Tesco, M &S, John Lewis, they're not going to put their brand at risk.
10:47And if you go to them and say, I was having this conversation with Jason Terry at John Lewis only a couple of weeks ago, if we just gave you a mandate to spend your apprentice levy as well as you think you can spend it, you know, he's a really good guy. We can hear. He'll spend it well. Businesses are up for something here. Maybe in a few weeks' time we'll see if that is what lands on the table, some plan to get involved in. Eileen, that concept, you wouldn't often hear anybody in the tech world. All the times I will have spoken to you about some major innovation, huge amount of fundraising going on, a big risk being taken in the tech world to advance the world in some way, being satisfied with a chancellor is just trying to keep things nice and quiet and calm.
11:38Well, I think like we were all saying, and I was a bit worried we were all going to be too nice, but I do love how much there is to cover. I think there was so much to grapple with. There was such a situation to come into and try not to rock the boat too, too much, but try to show a direction of travel is what I think he was trying to do today. And I think he's done that pretty well for the sort of tech sector or the innovation sector and the fast growth sector. And I was listening intently and didn't want to cut in because I do think the situation with NEATs, with apprenticeships, it's all incredibly important, as is social care, right, and health care.
12:13But in terms of for this fast growth innovation sector, yeah, they announced quite a few things that are, again, pointing in the right direction. Founders relief, even though they took away from what used to be called entrepreneurs relief in order to fund that. Just as we go with a few of these, I'll just ask you to explain sort of what they are a little bit. So what difference would, what is this founder's relief? How might it make any entrepreneur change their mind about doing things differently? Yeah, so it limits their tax on capital gains to a 10 % tax rate, which is considerable. What some investors and what a lot of people in the sector were probably hoping for was that they would also do a reinvestment type of relief and perhaps withhold capital gains entirely if some of that was reinvested in another business.
12:57But like I say, it's probably the step in the right direction. It's an early indication of what the government wants to do, presumably, or what the chancellor probably wants to spend more time thinking about. They've also done some measures to think about talent, which is probably what most entrepreneurs and people building companies, and we were just talking about domestic talent and needs, but trying to also get talent from abroad or highly skilled talent and attracting that. There was also some changes or some actual clarification on some rules for enterprise management incentive options, employee stock options.
13:31And again, that really relates to fast growth businesses. And then, of course, a number of topics about capital. And these are always hard to add up because sometimes these have been announced before. Sometimes it's just a reiteration of a commitment previously made. But there's real funding that's going towards the National Wealth Fund. So would you sum up, Eileen, with all of that? that would you come out of the budget feeling like the country was more of a place for entrepreneurs than it was before? I think it's like I was saying, they didn't rock the boat. The Chancellor didn't put all of his chips on the table, I think, and say this is absolutely where everyone needs to be in order to start a business or to try and be innovative.
14:08But I do think he tried to stem the tide of the sentiment, which was perhaps this government is not friendly. John, you've founded AO yourself? Yeah, so I think that the founders relief, I think if we're being candid, obviously there's no numbers attached to it. But I think if John Healy, he could probably take everybody that qualifies for it and was inspired by it out for dinner, would be the total cost of it. When you look at all the conditions that go with it, any entrepreneur that is inspired to start a business because of that should not be starting a business. I mean, oh, yeah, that won't be the reason.
14:51So it is not motivating anybody to start a business. It's a soundbite. And also they did, sorry to cut across, but they did say they're going to start a consultation, right, on the parameters on the actual requirements of what actually qualifies, I think. So yeah, to your point, it's pretty vague. Yeah, they've set some parameters out. And you know, you've got to have both grandparents on a Tuesday hopping on one leg and everything that goes with it. However, Sean, the reinvest grant where people are motivated to invest in early start-up businesses and roll some of that taxation across to take risks for providing capital and supporting entrepreneurs wanting to start businesses, I think that would be absolutely fantastic, but obviously that was conspicuous by its absence as well.
15:39So Eileen, what did you need to hear today that would have made you go, do you know what? Yes, for all the chat, you know, in a recent Big Boss interview, you've heard the boss of Microsoft saying that the UK could be the centre of the world's AI regulation coming out of a budget today that would have made you think, blimey, yeah, we really are grabbing this opportunity, grabbing the bull by the horns. I mean, I think it's really interesting because I'm an investor, so I'm very optimistic. But on the other hand, all three of us that you've got here, we're business people. So we're operators and we're very pragmatic.
16:13And you heard in our opening comments, we were all very sympathetic or at least alive to the challenges and the constraints that the Chancellor had today. So I don't think we're holding out for unicorns and rainbows and a pot of gold at the end of it. I think, though, there were people who thought there might have been an increase in capital gains tax. There might have been more taxes on the wealthy that might have actually then driven investors out. I think there was a genuine concern in the potential that we were going to see what was potentially punitive actions affecting those that want to invest, start businesses, hire people from abroad in order to try and give them options, equity grants and all of those things.
16:53And I'm almost just glad that there wasn't a lot of that by, you know, that that's all been omitted, even if the other positive steps were still just steps and still really early days. Steve, Rigby Group is a big family business with plenty of those different sectors covered, as I mentioned a bit earlier. Is the UK now a more attractive place than it was to do business? I think, you know, on the last point, Sean, the reality is that, you know, that threat of exit taxes, which are like capital controls, the threat of increased capital gains tax and normalisation, that those messages are very, very bad for the economy.
17:29So the fact that we've not had those is a positive step. We could do with firmer long-term sentiment that they aren't coming in the future. When it comes to family businesses, they did give a good piece of advice today in the budget. So there is some discussion around using the sale of businesses to create almost false capital events and therefore receive a lower tax. They've excluded the transfer of family business as part of that. We haven't yet won the argument around the family firm tax that came in in 2024, which really looks just at family businesses uniquely and penalises them when they transition from one ownership to another part.
18:06That doesn't happen in private equity, doesn't have listed companies. So we haven't yet won that battle, but we remain committed. I'm chair of Family Business UK. We remain committed to try and resolve that as we head through these coming budgets. Our business is not a family business. And I've never had a family business. I've invested in different businesses, but not family business. But what I do see from the outside looking in and know people who've got family businesses is that family businesses, and we talk about AO as a family business and the AO family, and we want a family business spirit in it.
18:38Why? Why? Because generally, and this is a generalization, family businesses think more long term. Family businesses tend to reinvest with a longer term time horizon. Family businesses tend to invest in their people and have longer lengths of service. And so I think societally, that is really good. Why on earth? I have absolutely no idea why the government for what is a relative. When you think we spend 500 million a day, a working day, on servicing interest payments, why they would risk probably about one day's income in that context to disrupt the network of family businesses that are the real heartbeat across the country.
19:25and it doesn't apply to me, but I was outraged at the time on all their behalf, whether it was farmers, whether it's businesses, because they just get on and do great things in their communities. They give charitably in their communities because their business is employing people in their communities. They're normally from their communities. And once that pendulum has swung too far, you can't get it back. And you're ripping the heart out of things. it's crazy. John, I would say even on a first generation business like yours, you still talk to your children around the dinner table about the business and to your wife and in reality you are a family business, it just happens to be first generation.
20:06Eileen, I just wonder when we, John's sort of alluding to past policies there about the approach to people running businesses, we did a bit of a word count and saw that John Healy today mentioned the word business or businesses 46 times and Rachel Reeves in the last couple of years has been more like 25, 26, 27 times. You know, make of that what you will. I'm sure that statistically wouldn't hold up very well in your tech world. But tonally wise, Eileen, did it change for you today? Did it feel like it was a business that approached a budget that approached business in a bit of a different way?
20:46Again, I think it's just that I'm relieved. there wasn't some of the more aggressive or punitive things that some people worried about. And I think even if we'd all like to have seen maybe more aggressive stance or more commitment to lots of things, there were a lot of things that weren't here and that does beg the question of how everything else is going to get funded because it does look like it wasn't as aggressive on the tax rises as maybe some had feared. But no, I think, you know, and words like AI, I wonder how many times that was in the count. I didn't check. But, you know, in data centres and regulation or even government procurement made it in there from what I saw and wanting to commit to the fact that, you know, the government's open for business and wants to encourage lots more commerce.
21:31Right. Well, I want you to all have a little listen to one part of John Healy's speech where he was talking about, it's never going to be a sexy thing to discuss, what the Office for Budget Responsibility was laying out in its growth forecasts for the UK in the years ahead. It followed the Bank of England and the International Monetary Fund in upgrading how it thinks the economy will do this year, 2026, but a bit bleaker after that. today the OBR has upgraded its forecast to 1.2 % this year, followed by 1 % next year, 1.6 % in 2028, 1.8 % in 2029, 1.7 % in 2030 and 1.6 % in 2031. Yes, there are real challenges ahead, but Britain has beaten the forecasts this year and with the action I'm taking today, I believe Britain can beat the forecasts again.
22:40Steve, are we settling for lower growth in this country? I don't think it's a this country issue, Sean. We're settling for lower growth in developed economies so I think we've all seen the fastest growing in G7 but it's a pretty low bar alongside the US for the first half of this year So I think it's pretty pessimistic, 1%. I don't know what John's view is at a consumer level, at a business level. For us in the UK, you know, billion plus UK revenues, the sentiment doesn't feel that way. I think there is large capital investment happening out there around AI and automation. I think there is hope of productivity gains in the economy, which are very difficult to bake in because historically we've failed to achieve them.
23:18But I think AI has that potential. So, listen, if we were running a company with this tight a position, with your bank breathing down your shoulders as they have with the bond market and very limited latitude on raising further revenue, there's only two things you can do. You either have to cut cost. Let's hope they achieve that with the welfare reforms that are pending or you try and grow the economy. I think today has gone a step towards helping shore up the economy. At the end of the day, that growth is partly down to what happens in the rest of the world as well. John, I'll come to you in a sec on that customer point and how the mood actually is and whether the numbers sort of tally with what we heard from the Chancellor there.
23:56Eileen, from an investment in a country perspective, is there a keenness to invest in a nation that is on a pathway to have growth below 2 % into the 2030s? I think the UK is incredibly fortunate because we have such a density of talent in terms of technology and innovation. We have a fantastic university system. We have a cluster of universities that rival or are better than anywhere else in the world. And we've had fantastic companies such as DeepMind and the like leading from the front. And so we do have now a real concentration of talent, which means that whether or not investors are keen to invest in the UK because of its growth rate or other reasons or not, it's inevitable that you can't ignore the UK for now.
24:45And so that's why I'm relieved that there weren't measures that made it more off-putting. It's still something – it's still a great concern. I do still think the UK is punching above its weight. Yeah, so from my point of view, Sean, from a mood perspective in the consumer world, I think we've got a worried consumer. And understandably, there's so much volatility around. And so from a discretionary spend perspective, I think things, and what I'm hearing is things are really tough. In our business, where it's a distressed purchase, if your fridge freezer breaks, you probably buy a new one. But I think that in terms of the narrative, when we talk about nothing bad happened from a business perspective, oh, right, okay, there's a narrative around the government like jobs, put jobs creation anywhere.
25:38They just don't seem to like people that create the jobs. And so then it's all about, well, they can pay more, they can pay, they can pay more. we need more inspiration. For me, we need more ambition. And I'll give you a great example. So AI, so obviously, you know, America is leading in AI. China's, or America or China's leading. They're absolutely miles ahead. I would say we're number three in the world. And so how can we, what can we do to growth? I think what I've heard over the last couple of years is, you know, particularly in the Keir Starmer years, was if you just say the word growth, it would be great for you to do word count on Keir Starmer saying growth, that doesn't make it happen.
26:22If James says something in his business, it doesn't just happen. There needs to be a plan that then happens and people execute to make those things happen. So if I give you one example, one asset that we've got in this country with our amazing infrastructure and our amazing NHS combined with AI and all the technological advancements that are coming now, this exists today. and so we could be the world centre for drug research. Is this stuff you've looked at yourself? Yeah, I have an investment in a business that does this and across the world in universities, in research and in big pharma there are hundreds of billions that are spent on that research and so you can take the pipeline of doing a clinical trial down from, say, two years on step one of that down to probably about 20 minutes by literally better matching what you're looking for out of that clinical trial.
27:23And the business that I invested in is doing this now with UK universities, and it's transformational for them. But we could open that up to the world, and the government could take the vast majority of the economics of all the income that comes in for that, and everybody gets drugs faster, cheaper, and the UK can be the global centre for that, for the whole of big pharma and the whole of research. Well, I'd like to hear Eileen's thoughts on that, because we've heard how you're happy with what wasn't in the budget and the size of relief might well go on for a good few days for you. But this is the area, the growth of tech that you've spent a career investing in.
28:14Why was it not a more dominant part of the budget today, given the skills that you and John have described that we have? I mean, I think it was probably proportionate, considering, like I said, we started this conversation talking about needs, apprenticeships, the issues that we have. I mentioned social care. We've talked about health care just then. So actually, with everything that the Chancellor was probably weighing up, I think the number of times or the concepts that were applied to artificial intelligence, to cybersecurity, to data centers, to investors, to the founders relief, whether that was actually just a relabeling of entrepreneurs tax relief or otherwise, I think that's probably proportionate.
28:58And I think the whole idea was we're not doing anything to try and drive away innovation. We're trying to tell you that the talent is here. The infrastructure is here. I don't disagree that we're not number one or number two for AI in the world, but we are a number three after China and US, which obviously are both going to have considerable more resources. and I think that the government was signaling that there might be more to come but the direction of travel is to try and continue to encourage investment here. Can you believe those growth figures in the years to come, Eileen, if we get AI and the benefits it can bring right?
29:39If we get it right, yes, I'd believe that and I believe there's probably upside to be had as well. As you've pointed out or you're intimating, the question is if we get it right. And then, but I think it was Steve who said at the opening, you know, the straight jacket of the macro and what's happening globally means there's always going to be something that's probably going to cause headwinds, even if we were to try and line everything up correctly here within the UK. I was going to say, I'll give you another great example, Sean. So things that are coming, okay, so Elon Musk, whether you like him or not, his predictions have a pretty good habit of coming true, and his batting average is pretty good.
30:19He's laying a footprint for the Optimus robots for Tesla of a 5 million square foot manufacturing facility as their first step. Out in China, you've got Unitree and Agibot as the primary manufacturers over there. There currently isn't one across Europe. And so when you look at the sovereignty issues, so the US have just mandated that 65 % of them need to be made in the US. And then there is natural caution around the influx of Chinese products and being in everybody's homes and everything else with it. So why don't we go and own that space? Why don't we make the UK the centre for robotics across Europe so that the manufacturing footprint is then here?
31:06All the high-quality jobs of the ecosystem around that are created and get on the front foot and act rather than try and correct it and bow down to the narrative that we must not engage with robots. If you look at what Andy Burnham wants to do, which is great and laudable with social care, we don't have the people to deliver that plan. Yeah, actually, when you go and look at what... To embrace all of that much more. So we could do it at much lower cost and you can see the use cases of it happening in China at the minute. Steve, you describe yourself as a critical friend of this government in a recent piece that you wrote about the world of business.
31:48Do you get a sense that there's a – is there a reluctance? You know, you hear John's enthusiasm for parts of the economy that could be transformed by this stuff. Is there a reluctance to take advantage of it? Yeah, I think because of this trade association I chair, you know, a little closer, perhaps to the centre than most. And, you know, we've seen a real change in the last hundred days. So their engagement of business, their willingness to listen. I've learned in government there are various forms of listening, the majority of which don't get results. But their willingness to listen seems to be to be better.
32:20So I think we're very this is this is a new Labour Party for all intents and purposes. I think we were all disappointed with the way in which the previous iteration got off, got out of the stocks and tried to change the economy, unfortunately, for the worse. So I do sense this change of thought. Now, we're always going to have the constraints we have. Sovereign AI, you know, which is the new initiative in the UK, backing UK AI businesses is placing some good bets. They've just had their budget increased by 160 million today. the messages on data centers you know ai growth and every postcode is possible by doing edge computing we can't win every battle you know we do have one humanoid um uh one robotics company called humanoid here in the uk but i think that's a difficult battle for us to win in every case but using our intellectual uh capabilities as eileen's mentioned is definitely our best route out of this the question for me is does productivity equal more employment or does that transition to artificial intelligence mean we have a growing economy but a higher rate of unemployment.
33:23So that's yet to pan out but those growth numbers could be modest if we can get AI deployed in the country. For your reference Eileen, AI or artificial intelligence was mentioned 13 times today by John Healy. Seems three times by Rachel Reeves last year and wasn't mentioned there the year before. We may not have been mentioning it too much ourselves a few years ago. So I guess that's an indication. I'm not going to keep doing requests though. The big boss interview team in the background. I'm impressed, John. Well, with the world of tech these days, Eileen, maybe don't give us too much credit for finding that out quickly.
34:01But it's the closest I'll ever get to being a Radio 2 DJ taking requests from people is what was the word map of the Chancellor's budget. Now, you mentioned, Steve, about how all of this can lead to productivity and employment. Part of the array of data we've got, and particularly with the Office for Budget Responsibilities analysis, is what's happening and what has been happening to living standards. So for all we've discussed about how the economy should grow and what should be done and which direction it should be taken and what wasn't mentioned today to give businesses a sigh of relief for people around the country working and looking to improve their living standards year on year for those who aren't able to work and and are looking for an economy that might improve year on year the the numbers there's been a negligible and that's to use a quote from the obr one percent increase in living standards it's predicting over the 10 years following the pandemic so from 2020 to 2030 people's living standards increasing by one percent yeah listen i'd love a silver bullet to give you an answer here that's going to change but we've just seen today you know a 3.9 wage increase on national living wage and that that links very firmly to the underlying rate of private sector growth unfortunately the inflation number was also 3.5 so there's a really tiny window there of 0.4 of real wage growth so i think this this this cost of living pressure will fall more.
35:34The only thing to note is that fuel will be baked into the inflation rises relatively soon. I will be used to that rate of fuel cost. So if we do get an end to the war, that's not in sight right now. But if we could, we'll start to see disinflationary measures coming through. That's my only hope for really a cost of living ease. But unfortunately, I suspect we're in for a pinch for the next year. Is it the case, John, that you get to a point, The Chancellor mentioned it right at the top as he was setting the scene for the economy, that we're not going to be able to drastically improve living standards while energy prices are this high?
36:12I just fundamentally disagree. So from a macro picture, yes. But Andy Burnham talks about wanting to take the small wins, and he's been mocked for a few of them. but I actually agree with his sentiment on let's get on with getting some stuff done so you know again if you look at the if you go and try and put a plan together so if you're coming if I was coming into this from a business perspective I'd be looking at it and saying right okay what are the actions that we need to take where are we spending the most money which logically is where you can have the biggest input so again I come back to something like the NHS, where the equivalent of self-driving cars, it's known as software as a medical device, you know it as an iPhone.
36:56It's got a camera on it. It can take a picture of a mole on your hand, and with 99.7 % accuracy, in about 10 seconds, it can tell you now whether it's cancer or not cancer, with more accuracy than you can with a doctor. Yeah. Why have we not made that completely universally available for people? I guess when these numbers are talking about living standards, they're probably quite, like Almost crudely looking at people's financial situation to a certain extent. I just wonder, for your employees, like when they talk about a 1 % increase in living standards over a decade, so for your employees, what would be needed for their living standards?
37:36But this is my point. The measure is almost wrong, not looking at... But your point is they want to have more money in their pocket, and the benefits bill is already too high. What we need to do is we need to fundamentally run the company, the country better and more efficiently and so we need to take more waste out so from a business point of view for me gotcha what the way i would be looking at something is how do i do this better for customers quicker uh and for less money for a customer so i've got to do it more efficiently so you've got to reimagine the process not just keep fiddling around the edges with it so eileen And that example, in the tech world, you know, the huge tech companies that you'll be working with, investing alongside, investing in, you know, when we hear how they are improving their productivity year on year, we had a glimpse of it with Anthropics pitched to the world to invest in it a few days ago about the, you know, the extent that they are using this brand new technology to advance what they do and storm ahead efficiently.
38:41Do you see when you see a budget like this and the fact that it's a country with a trillion pounds to decide what it has to spend on and where to put that money? Do you have that feeling that we should be taking more leaps, that we should be hearing more of the kind of stuff John's talking about there? I do think, again, I'm an optimist and I do think what they've tried to point to today does try to underscore that. So I do, you know, I'm happy that there was no increase to capital gains tax. I'm happy that some things that are working, they decided to try and incrementally improve, whether it was founders relief, EMI schemes, EIS tax relief, the Mansion House Accord, you know, recommitting to the British Business Bank, more money for the National Wealth Fund, doing away with non-compete clauses, for example, helping with talent visas.
39:30I think those are all directionally the right thing to do and sort of suggesting, listen, maybe we're not the party or the government that's going to be investing in business, but we're definitely not going to penalise it. And we're hoping that people keep growing, keep innovating and keep developing here. Right. I want to just wrap up with getting a sense of what it's like to run a business, to make big investment decisions on and around the day of the budget. Steve, from your perspective, what's the 24 hours been like? For those of us, even the rest of us that follow it closely, they might have it on in the telly in the background, have the radio on as we're getting on with something during the day.
40:15But for you, does it actually become part of your schedule? What have you been up to? I've been sat in a war room most of the time since 12 o 'clock with a team just going through every fine detail. So they are important sessions. I didn't think I'd be doing that a few years ago, but they are important sessions. But, you know, I think, you know, John – Why wouldn't you have been doing that a few years ago? I wasn't involved in a material trade association at that time, Sean. Oh, I see, I see. I'm with you. But, you know, I think what's interesting here, you know, I think John's clearly airing some frustration, and I understand his frustration and where it comes from.
40:47And if I'm honest with you, the majority of people I meet are very similar to John. They're frustrated not enough progress is being made. Somewhere in this, we've got to help ourselves as business leaders. So we've got to get our confidence back. We've got to get our stride back in what we're doing. We've got to be prepared to take some risk. We're all sat on more cash than we've historically been sat on. Ultimately, we've got a part to play here. The government's given us, if you like, a pass for this year on any budget changes. Our job as business leaders is also to get out there and make it happen.
41:16And so for today, when you're in that war room, was there a particular moment where there was, I don't know how many people were in that room. there was like an ooh or a shouting at a screen. I mean, inevitably you end up being desperately selfish in these situations. And, you know, we got the news through on the ability to transfer family businesses. So that was probably our highlight, even though it's probably a relatively small measure, Sean, in reality on what came through. John, from your perspective, are you poised before, you know, it's an important time of year for AO, Christmas round the corner.
41:49I don't know whether fridges break more frequently at this time of year or not, whatever might be the case with people having to do that kind of stuff. But you talked about consumer confidence being so crucial. How does a day like today play out for you when you've got a budget? It's pretty much an irrelevance, if I'm honest. As James said, we try and take matters into our own hands and we just focus relentlessly on delivering for customers and what will be will be. We'll deal with it once all the dust settles. So I just think that – and so on the one hand, there's not a lot to deal with. It's a pretty non-event in that context, so let's just crack on with what we're doing.
42:26And on the other hand, as I say, I think the mood music is good in terms of there seems to be a change, but we've got to get on and do stuff. And if I could get one thing out of this, we need to ban the words billions and trillions out of political language because our debt is 2 ,000 ,000 million. and we pay£11 ,000 million in interest payments every month, so£500 million per working day. And we just sort of go, oh,£2 trillion. No, no, no,£2 ,000 million is the debt. So there needs to be a dose of bringing this home to the country, of waking up, that the credit card's full. We have to do things differently and there's some difficult political choices, I think, that come in that.
43:22If you take a, you know, and I know it was the Conservatives that changed it, but if you look at the amount of people that have left this country, you know, even non-DOMs, whatever your politics are on non-DOMs, they now contribute nothing when they've left. So whatever they did contribute before, but they started businesses, they employed people, we got lots of money on stamp duty from them when they were buying houses, all that money is gone. It's interesting, John, that the sobering number today was 100 ,000 per household, which I bet is not far off the average mortgage value per household.
43:55Is that the size of the national debt? Yeah, and for comparison, Norway have about 500 ,000 of surplus in their sovereign fund per household. Eileen, I mean, we could talk for another hour, but I get a sense, Eileen, just from the amount of times you, We haven't yet done a word count on how many times you've mentioned the word relief, but we will do that by the end of this show. But I get the sense that actually you and probably many in your sector were a bit braced in the run up to today. How does the day play out for yourself? Are you sort of lined up to have conversations that you might need to have if those capital gains tax, wealth taxes came in?
44:42Honestly, no. Very similar to John, actually. I think for our sector, for investors, maybe individuals are thinking about their personal tax situation. So they were waiting to see if there was going to be an announcement about capital gains tax or exit taxes. But no, certainly founders, the builders, the entrepreneurs, they've been working on a thousand other things today. And I don't think they will have paused or stopped to listen to the budget or look at even a news headline. Maybe they'll get to that midnight tonight or when they sort of put down tools on what they're doing day to day. most of the things that are going to impact them are incremental a lot of things will be subject to consultation like we spoke about with the founders relief you know i think maybe some people were hoping there was going to be some reinvestment relief as well but nobody was bracing for the day as such and i think that's one thing that's fantastic about our sector right we do people do try and take matters into their own hands see what they can improve upon what they can build how they can solve the problems that are ahead of them well look one and all thank you very much for joining us on our Big Boss Budget Special.
45:43Eileen Burbage, founding partner of the London venture capital firm, Passion Capital, NFG Ventures as well. John Roberts, founder and chief executive of AOS. Steve Rigby, chief executive of Rigby Group. Thank you very much. Normal service will resume next week. If you want to listen to our back catalogue, have a search for Big Boss Interview wherever you get your podcasts.
46:30www.xrx.com Vaxor Excel.
47:10Recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or attain any specific investment or service.
Chancellor John Healey's first Budget has won cautious approval from business. Leading figures say it was a relief, but warn that relief is not the same as ambition. In this Big Boss Interview Budget special, AO founder John Roberts, venture capitalist and founder of Passion Capital and NFG Ventures Eileen Burbidge and Rigby Group chief executive Steve Rigby agreed the chancellor had little room to move, however they disagreed on whether he made the most of what he had.
Steve Rigby runs one of the UK's largest privately owned business groups, with interests across tech, property, aviation and hotels. He described the Budget as a "do-no-harm" statement that went a little further than expected. He pointed to the scale of the change: about £600m of tax rises next year, compared with nearly £40bn raised across the previous two Labour Budgets. He welcomed the absence of new taxes on employing people. He also welcomed a 3.9% rise in the national living wage, which he said was broadly in line with private-sector pay growth. For him, the Budget gives business a base of confidence to build on.
Eileen Burbidge, founding partner of Passion Capital, said what was missing mattered as much as what was announced. Ahead of the Budget, investors had worried about higher capital gains tax, wealth taxes and exit taxes, any of which could have pushed money and talent abroad. None of them came. She saw the new founders' relief, which caps capital gains tax at 10% for qualifying entrepreneurs, as a step in the right direction. She also welcomed changes to employee share options, talent visas and fresh money for the National Wealth Fund. But she noted that the details of founders' relief are still subject to consultation. She said many in the sector had also hoped for relief on gains reinvested in new businesses, and that did not come.
John Roberts was the most critical. He accepted that the chancellor was boxed in by world events and a lack of money. But he argued that the government had again failed to turn talk into concrete plans. He believes cost-of-living support on this scale will be quickly wiped out by any fresh rise in fuel prices. He thinks the government should focus on areas it can control. He dismissed founders' relief as a soundbite, saying no one should start a business because of a tax break. .
The family business tax was a point of agreement. Rigby chairs Family Business UK. He welcomed a measure that protects transfers of family firms from new rules on business sales, but said the wider fight over the family business tax introduced in 2024 is far from won. Roberts said his own company is not family-owned, but argued that family firms tend to think longer-term, invest in their staff and support their local communities. He warned that once that network is damaged, it is very hard to rebuild.
On growth, the panel was realistic rather than gloomy. The Office for Budget Responsibility expects the UK to grow by 1.2% this year, slowing to 1% next year and staying below 2% until 2031. Rigby argued that low growth is a problem across developed economies, not a uniquely British one. He said AI offers productivity gains that forecasters find hard to include. Burbidge pointed to Britain's universities, its cluster of tech talent and its position as the world's third AI power behind the US and China. That makes the UK hard for investors to ignore. Rigby raised the biggest unanswered question: whether AI-driven productivity will create jobs, or leave the country with a growing economy and rising unemployment.
Households are under strain. Roberts described consumers as worried, with spending on non-essentials under real pressure. The OBR expects living standards to rise by just 1% over the decade from 2020. Rigby said inflation of 3.5% leaves very little room for real wage growth. He expects another year of pressure unless an end to the war brings energy costs down.
Presenter: Sean Farrington Producer: Olie D'Albertanson Editor: Henry Jones
01:34 First reactions to the Budget 03:47 One million NEETs costing £125bn a year 13:08 Founders' relief dismissed as a soundbite 16:20 Exit taxes and the family business tax 20:52 OBR growth forecasts 25:17 Britain as a world centre for drug research 28:56 Robotics manufacturing and sovereignty 33:00 Living standards and real wage growth 40:53 Budget day in the war room