How Grammy Voting Really Works & Why It Matters More Than Ever w/ Harvey Mason jr.

4 Dec 2025 · 1 h 4 min · 25 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

How Grammy voting works (entry, two rounds of ballots, category-specific voting, and primetime vs Premiere Ceremony) and why it matters amid a global, fragmented music industry and AI-driven creation.

Guest backgrounds

Harvey Mason Jr. is CEO of the Recording Academy and its 501(c)(3) affiliate Music Cares. He’s a longtime songwriter/producer who worked with Brandy, Destiny’s Child, Whitney Houston, Tony Braxton, and Michael Jackson, and on soundtracks including Dreamgirls, Straight Outta Compton, and Pitch Perfect 1 and 2.

Key claims

  • Voting timeline: music is submitted for eligibility, reviewed for categories, then first-round voting; nominations are announced across 95 categories; second-round voting runs about three weeks; winners announced Feb 1.
  • Membership reform: about 66% of voters are new since 2019; all ~15,000 voting members are requalified with relevant recent credits.
  • Voting is by music professionals (not journalists; not popularity/streams).
  • Primetime telecast is ~10 awards; ~85 are handled via the live-streamed Premiere Ceremony.
  • Genre representation is driven by the voting body; country may be less visible in general categories but is represented across the full ballot.
  • AI use is widespread in studios; the Academy is balancing ethics and human creators while acknowledging AI is already here.

Notable examples

  • Chappell Roan highlighted artists’ lack of health care; Mason says Music Cares doesn’t directly provide insurance but the Academy is sourcing low-cost insurance options.
  • K-pop: Mason says category creation depends on proposals from the music community and Academy leadership; he notes a K-pop track (“Golden” by Hunter x Hunter) reached Song of the Year contention.
  • Genre assignment: committees evaluate whether submissions fit (e.g., pop vs R&B) and can move entries only with a supermajority (66 and a third) to override.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Understanding Grammy Voting

2:07 to 4:22

Harvey discusses the Grammy voting process and its timeline.

“As always, I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and I am thrilled to have Harvey Mason Jr.”

The Importance of Music

4:22 to 6:35

Discussion on the cultural significance of music and its impact.

“For those who are tuning in who don't really understand the timeline of how we lead up to the Grammys every year, what's the process of getting into it, the voting periods and all that?”

Transition to Leadership at the Academy

6:35 to 8:02

Harvey talks about his transition from musician to CEO of the Recording Academy.

“So for us, Grammy season, for me, it's the best time of year.”

First Memories of the Grammys

8:02 to 10:40

Harvey shares his childhood memories of the Grammys and his father's nominations.

“But like that's moving from a very creative career to one where it involves a lot of like business kind of management type stuff.”

Television vs. Livestream Grammys

10:40 to 12:15

The process of determining what is televised during the Grammy Awards.

“and there's kind of two separate sections.”

Changes in Grammy Voting Body

12:15 to 14:00

Discussion on the changes in the Grammy voting body since Harvey took over.

“I mean, so the Grammys this year, hopefully, God willing, are going to proceed as normal.”

Grammy Nominees & Genre Representation

14:00 to 14:53

Discussion about the nominees and genre representation at the Grammys.

“And in November, you guys announced the nominees, which is super exciting.”

Voting Participation and Its Importance

14:53 to 18:26

Exploration of voting participation among Grammy members and its significance.

“So we make sure that if we're under indexing in a certain area, we go into those communities and say, hey, we need you to be a part of our organization.”

Best New Artist: Myth and Reality

18:26 to 22:00

Analysis of the Best New Artist category and the myth surrounding its curse.

“And I say, well, you can't complain unless first you're a member and second you participate.”

Impact of Streaming on Music Trends

22:00 to 24:47

Discussion on the fragmentation of music taste due to streaming and its implications.

“But it's always great to celebrate and honor the group of musicians or creators or artists that are now finally coming through.”
Show all 25 chapters

MusicCares: Support for Music Professionals

24:47 to 28:00

Overview of MusicCares and its role in supporting the health and well-being of music industry professionals.

“So I want to make sure there's members from different parts of the world.”

Advocacy for Music Creators

28:00 to 29:39

Explore how the Academy addresses the challenges faced by music creators regarding health care and advocacy.

“Well, first of all, what Chappell said, I couldn't be more excited about the sentiment of what she brought up in her passion and advocacy for music people.”

Songwriter of the Year Category

29:40 to 31:09

Discuss the evolution and challenges of the Songwriter of the Year category at the Grammys.

“They've been wanting that for a long time.”

Understanding Grammy Categories

31:10 to 33:59

Learn about the processes behind how artists are categorized for Grammy nominations.

“And I love the fact that we're doing that.”

The Rise of K-Pop and Genre Classification

34:00 to 37:03

Delve into the K-pop phenomenon and the discussions around its classification at the Grammys.

“So if half the committee votes, it stays.”

The Global Nature of Music at the Grammys

37:04 to 38:57

Examine how the Grammys represent global music and the inclusion of diverse genres.

“And that's the beauty of the academy is we have so much expertise and knowledge across our 15 ,000 voting members to tell us, here's how we're going to define K-pop.”

AI's Impact on Music Creation

38:58 to 42:00

Discover the various ways AI is used in music creation and the implications it has on songwriting.

“I don't know where it was with, but you talked about how you're seeing from your friends who are songwriters and producers that pretty much everyone is using AI in some way in the studio.”

AI in Music Creation: Ethics and Perception

42:00 to 46:00

Explore the implications of AI in music creation and how it affects artist perception.

“But, yeah, I don't really feel like anyone's going to really disclose if they use Suno to like try to help them start.”

Legislative Efforts: The No Fakes Act

46:00 to 48:20

Learn about the No Fakes Act and its role in protecting artists' rights.

“I know you've been thinking about this for a long time.”

Impact of Streaming on the Grammys

48:20 to 51:00

Discuss how the shift to streaming is changing the Grammy Awards format.

“I mean, the statewide thing is just so patchy.”

Rapid Fire: Grammy Trivia

51:00 to 55:20

Engage in a rapid-fire trivia session about Grammy history and notable artists.

“Do you have to account for different segmented audiences?”

The Continuing Relevance of the Grammys

55:20 to 56:00

Understand why the Grammys still hold significance in the music industry today.

“And people, I think, respect the Academy and the Grammys.”

The Significance of Grammy Nominations

56:00 to 58:34

Explore the impact of Grammy nominations and the excitement of multiple category nominations.

“And when I would think about him doing his Grammy ballot and voting for me as a songwriter, as a producer, I don't know if he ever did or if he didn't, but that was what was in my mind.”

Make Me a Playlist Segment

58:34 to 1:01:04

Harvey Mason Jr. shares personal song choices and insights about music.

“And OK, so the prompts are, first one, what's a song you can no longer?”

Concluding Thoughts and Music Charts

1:01:04 to 1:02:39

Wrap-up of the discussion with a countdown of the Billboard Hot 100 chart.

“Well, Harvey Mason Jr., thank you so much for coming to On The Record.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00You have one new message. Translating. Disney and Pixar's Hoppers is now available on Disney+. You could say that again. Critics are calling it Pixar's funniest movie ever and a wildly entertaining ride. Blizzard Potato. It's certified fresh and verified hot. Now we party. This is incredible! Wow, I am clear in the rest of the day. Disney and Pixar's Hoppers now available on Disney+. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks.

0:45Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. Study and play. Come together on a Windows 11 PC. And for a limited time, college students get the best of both worlds. Get the Unreal College Deal. Everything you need to study and play with select Windows 11 PCs. Eligible students get a year of Microsoft 365 Premium and a year of Xbox Game Pass Ultimate with a custom color Xbox wireless controller. Learn more at windows.com slash student offer. While supplies last, ends June 30th.

1:23Terms at aka.ms slash college PC. The Grammy Awards. As they say, it's music's biggest night. I mean, where else are you going to see Lady Gaga hatching from an egg? Or see Tracy Chapman uniting with Luke Combs? Or see the entire lineage of hip-hop take the stage together on the genre's 50th anniversary? Although the awards are not until February, this is actually the time when the final round of Grammy voting is about to take place, and the preparation for the awards are in full swing. And as a podcast that's dedicated to giving you a peek behind the curtain of the music business, I actually think there couldn't be a better time than right now to go inside the event with my very special guest today.

1:58Today we have on the show Recording Academy CEO Harvey Mason Jr.

2:06Welcome back to On the Record, a music business podcast from Billboard and Sick Bird Productions. As always, I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and I am thrilled to have Harvey Mason Jr. on the show today to talk about the ins and the outs of the Grammys. Harvey got his start in the music business as a songwriter and producer. Both of his parents were musicians themselves, but Harvey Jr. made a name for himself in the late 90s, working with talents like Brandy, Destiny's Child, Whitney Houston, Tony Braxton, and Michael Jackson. He worked on iconic soundtracks like Dreamgirls, Straight Outta Compton, and Pitch Perfect 1 and 2.

2:40Now he's helping celebrate his fellow musicians in his role at the helm of the Recording Academy and Music Cares, a post that he's held since about five years ago. And today, the Recording Academy looks very different than it used to when Harvey took the CEO gig. Back then, the Academy was coming off of major scandals. So since then, there's been a lot of course correction by Harvey and the Academy to make things different. The Academy has made a number of changes to diversify its voting body, for one example, and it's opened up a number of new categories. This includes African music, Best Score soundtrack for video games and other visual media, and Songwriter of the Year, among others, to represent a wider swath of musical talent.

3:19Today, we'll cover a lot of topics with Harvey, including how Grammy voting actually works, what he's changed within the Academy's membership, and what it's like to lead this organization into a much more globalized and fragmented music world. So without further ado, let's bring him in. Please welcome to On The Record, Harvey Mason Jr. Harvey Mason Jr., welcome to On The Record. Thanks for being here. Thanks, Kristen. This is good. Is it On The Record? Okay. On The Record. That's probably like a journalistic term as opposed to a music term. Well, actually, we still call them records. It's double entendre.

3:49Okay. As a songwriter, I hope you can appreciate that. I love it. It's, yeah, on the record, journalistic term, but also records. Recording Academy. I know. Something to think about. There you go. Well, I'm so excited that you're here today. I know some people who are listening to this are probably like, why are we doing the Grammy episode now and not in February? Let's get it started. I know. We're kicking off Grammy season. The season is here. Yeah, but I do think if you're in the music industry, you're starting to really hear about the Grammys right now. Yeah, especially with nominations coming out and then Latin Grammys and now voting is about to start in a bit.

4:24So yeah, it's getting exciting. For those who are tuning in who don't really understand the timeline of how we lead up to the Grammys every year, what's the process of getting into it, the voting periods and all that? So you enter your music, has to have come out in a certain period of time. That process goes on for a few months. People enter their music. It goes under the first round ballot. The ballot opens up. You can go on your phone now. It's incredible. You go on an app and you scroll through. You look at the 22 ,000 or so entries. And now with our process, you're only voting in certain categories.

4:55So you don't have to worry about listening to every single entrant. But you are looking at the genres of music that you might have some expertise or some experience in. And you're voting in those areas. And then you're voting in the general field, of course, the record of the year, song of the year, album of the year, best new artist, songwriter of the year, and producer of the year. Everyone votes in those. And that's the first round of voting. The first round of voting closes. And then this year was, I think, November 10th. We announced the nominations. The nominations came out across our 95 categories.

5:23All the nominees hopefully were excited. And some people that weren't nominated were disappointed, sadly, because I hate that part. But then the second round of voting opens. And that's open for approximately three weeks. Again, same process. The nominations come onto your phone or your app. You can go through the portal and register to vote. and you vote on the nominees and we pick a winner. And this year on February 1st, the winners are announced. And again, we go through the process of a bunch of people being really excited and some people being disappointed. But all of us at the end of the day getting the time and the season to celebrate music and to celebrate all these incredible artists and talented people that do what they do.

6:00And for me, I come from the music space. My background is in music. I'm a songwriter and a producer. And I hold a special place for people who make art of any kind because I just really think truly, and specifically music, has such a place in our society, in our world to make a difference. Maybe it's a little bit corny, but there's nothing like music. I mean, I love food. I love sports. I love all the things that bring people together, but nothing, movies, TV, but nothing does it like music. You hear a beat. You might not even understand the language, but it does something to you. It's magical.

6:34It's medicine. So for us, Grammy season, for me, it's the best time of year. It's like Christmas for musicians. It does feel almost primal. Like music is truly across every single society, all ages. Throughout history. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, like you don't really get that kind of an experience with film. As much as I love film, that's probably my other artistic category. What? I don't even know what I'm saying. But like type of art that I really enjoy and know a lot about. But yeah, I mean, there's nothing like music. There's nothing like music, and it is primal regardless of technology and changes over time.

7:10Something about an artist who's a storyteller, something about what they've been through in their life and how that resonates with a listener. It's unlike movies because, you know, everyone is acting. Everyone's playing a role, and they do incredible work in that space. Actors are so talented as well. But for me, if you're watching a movie, you know that's not what that person's gone through, unless it's a documentary or maybe a biopic, something like that. But with music, every lyric, every song has to mean something to the artist that's singing, or at least I hope it does. And that transfers and that translates to listeners.

7:44And when you find that artist that says something that either you've been through or you're going through or something that you thought nobody else felt, and then you hear it in a song, that makes an impact. Yeah. And I mean, as a songwriter producer, you had a very long career doing that and you could just keep doing that. And I imagine going and getting more and more involved in the Recording Academy and eventually becoming CEO, like that really flips a switch on like whatever the left brain, right brain of you is. But like that's moving from a very creative career to one where it involves a lot of like business kind of management type stuff.

8:21I'm wondering what was that transition like for you? We call them suits is what we should call them. Yes, yeah, you're the suit now. You're a cool suit, though. Yeah. It's something that's been a part of my life early on as I started making music. I was always trying to envision building a company around it and how could I create an asset, whether that was publishing or a label, both of which I've had, and build a production company and create intellectual property and figure out how to leverage that and monetize it. So it's always been a part of my company and my upbringing as a musician, as a creator.

8:52but you're right it is two very different skill sets but the thing that i find across both is the ability to listen and collaborate and work with others and find solutions problem solving this is what i do in the studio every day you're making a song you're playing the piano you're like oh wait this chord's not working let me try this and somebody comes over and say hey have you tried this and you and you work together to find solutions so i love that about my work as an executive i also come from a long line of basketball teams i played basketball my whole life and And even in college where I went to the Final Four and played with a team with incredible athletes and great leaders, the lessons that I learned from my Hall of Fame coach, Lute Olsen, really have served me well as I've tried to do anything in my life, whether that's running the academy or collaborating music or raise a family.

9:39And so what was your first memory of the Grammys? If you can think back to being a kid, I know your parents were musicians, so I imagine the Grammys were always on every year. They were on, but my dad was nominated. And my dad's been nominated seven times. More than me, by the way. I'm so bummed. A little rivalry there. Big time. He's had seven nominations. So I remember each time he's been nominated and how excited he was and how honored he was. And as a kid, you're like, oh, my God, my dad's nominated for something cool. And maybe he's going to be on TV. So I remember my folks getting dressed up to go to the events.

10:09And it's been a part of my family since I was a young child. And then also just a lover of music. I've always watched the show. And I've seen the performances. I've seen the magic on that stage over the years and the people that have been put together that have sung just iconic classic copyrights and songs that I've never been able to forget. And that stays with me. So it is interesting to now be in the position that I'm in to be working so closely with the Academy and especially with the TV show. And Grammy season comes around. I'm like, I remember watching the show. Now we're making it. Part of the Grammys is televised.

10:45Part of it is not. and there's kind of two separate sections. And my first memories of the Grammys were just being a kid in Texas and watching it on my TV. How do you guys make the determination of what ends up on the televised part, the primetime part of the Grammys, and what doesn't? Because I know you're probably trying to balance also having the iconic performances and also getting some good categories in there. So what's that process like? It's iterative. We change every year. We evolve the process every year. we think about what makes the best TV show. Sometimes people receiving the awards and giving the speeches is as entertaining as some of the performances.

11:23So we try and balance that. We're looking at genre diversity. We're looking at which different categories have great nominees in them. But generally it's about 10 awards on the Sunday telecast, and then the other 85 we give away in a show called the Premiere Ceremony, which is live streamed but is not on television as of yet. hopefully that will change but it's a constant challenge because there's so much great music there's so many talented people and you're like I want all of them to have the spotlight I want all of them to be on the show and I there's a moment of discovery when you see a new artist that you never heard of and you're like oh my gosh that's incredible I want to go find all that music and I love that I remember as a kid being able to do that but there's also the time where you just want to see all the biggest stars in the world singing the songs that you love and know already.

12:11So that's another challenge to get that, find that sweet spot. Yeah. I mean, so the Grammys this year, hopefully, God willing, are going to proceed as normal. I feel like the last few years have been all over the place. You had the pandemic and then you have the Vegas Grammys, which I guess is still a pandemic. Yeah. COVID, Grammys, fires. We've had a lot of last minute issues. So I am going to just keep my fingers crossed and imagine this is going to be, This will be our first, I won't call it uneventful because it's going to be a massive event, but hopefully this will be our first event where we don't have an outside force affecting how we produce the show or the things that we're thinking about putting on the show.

12:50Man, that's crazy because you took the helm in 2021. 2020. 2020. Oh, God. Geez. Yeah. It's been a wild run. Yeah. And so over the last five years, you guys have changed the voting body a lot. I think the stat is 66 % of voters this year have been new since 2019. Is that correct? You've got it. You've done the research. Yeah, I tried. I try on the show. The other stat that's interesting is 100 % of our voters have been requalified. So everybody who's a member and who's voting of our 15 ,000 roughly voting members, we've looked at their credits. We've made sure they have relevant credits within the last five years and they know the music.

13:31They're working in the music because that's the cool thing about the Grammys. They're voted on by all music professionals. It's no journalists. No offense. Hey, it's okay. It's okay. I don't really think I'm qualified. It's no popularity. It's not about how many streams you have, how many followers you have, or people's opinions of you in the general consumer audience. It's about your peers, the professional music people, really listening, really evaluating the music, and nominating the people they think have done it best in that year. And it's subjective, so it's impossible. But we wanted to make sure the membership was relevant and knew what was going on in the different genres of music so they could vote accurately and have good outcomes.

14:07And in November, you guys announced the nominees, which is super exciting. It's exciting every year. One of the things I noticed about the nominees this year are that, you know, country music had a huge year in terms of popularity, but it didn't have a huge showing in the categories this year. I'm sure that happens from time to time with various genres. How do you guys like mitigate those kind of things when they happen? How do you make sure that there is good genre representation across the board in the general categories? We don't. That happens by the voters. And the way that we try and not mitigate it, but make sure that we are having what we think are equitable outcomes is make sure our voting body represents or is representative of the different genres of music and the different constituencies and groups of people that are making that music.

14:53So we make sure that if we're under indexing in a certain area, we go into those communities and say, hey, we need you to be a part of our organization. If you're a music professional, please join. And we do a lot of outreach. We do a lot of communication. But I also want to say that as much as country is not represented in the general field, the country is represented so well across the ballot and across our 95 categories. There's great country music being made this year and great nominees. I think we're going to have some really, really exciting, I don't like to call them races, but some really exciting, I guess, selections between different people and categories that I don't think there's a bad choice in the bunch.

15:31And with those general categories, like I think of Best New Artist sometimes, you often have like a really wide swath of genres that are represented in that category. but sometimes there's like a few artists that really, I guess, raised their hand that year that are really doing well, but they're all in the same genre and probably have similar peers and fans. Does that sometimes like divide up the vote? I hear some people like kind of. Yeah. Sometimes I would imagine just anecdotally we hear that votes get split because of exactly what you said. There are people that have shared, I won't say fans, but people that support their music that are members.

16:06and then an outlier would come in and maybe win a category. But we don't see that data. I never asked to see from Deloitte who's first or second or third. We just get an envelope with the winners, so we don't really know how those outcomes happen. Yeah, I think it would drive me insane if I knew who was second place. Yeah, of course. You'd be so bummed. You'd be so bummed. As far as splitting the vote, though, it's got to be a real thing, people who love this or who love that. So we'll see. It's always interesting to see the outcomes based on our membership and who they're going to vote for. And any given year, it could be anything.

16:41It's so subjective, whether it's an artist that's been extremely successful and popular, where the streaming numbers are through the roof, or there's just a new artist that's super cool and amazing and doing something different. And that resonates with the voters. So it just changes year to year. Yeah. And I imagine that sometimes voters forget to vote. Like, do you ever have like issues with people just not showing up, you know, during the time to actually cast their vote? And how do you deal with that? Do they end up getting kicked out of the academy at a certain point from inactivity or? So we market and push to our members pretty consistently and maybe in an aggravating way at a certain point to make sure they're voting and say, hey, voting's open.

17:24Hey, have you voted? Hey, voting closing. Make sure you vote. So that's what we do about it. We don't kick people out right now if they don't vote. Sometimes I tend to think maybe we should because voting is a big part of your obligation as a member. As a member, there are a lot of different things that are valuable to you and can be valuable to you, furthering your career, learning things, upskilling, professional development, collaboration. There's so many opportunities, services from music areas or the museum. But for me, voting is what makes the outcomes the best, and that's what makes our show the best.

17:57And a lot of people say, oh, well, it's just a show. It's trophies. It's shiny performances. But that show pays for everything we do as a not-for-profit organization. So all the education work we do, all the giving back to music people who need help, even think about the fires or the hurricane, the things that are happening, we take care of our music people with the money that's raised from the telecast. So if you're a member and you're not voting and you're sitting back to just see who wins, you're not helping the cause or the good of the work that we do at the Academy. And a lot of times if people aren't voting, they'll be quick to complain about the outcomes.

18:31And I say, well, you can't complain unless first you're a member and second you participate. But as far as who's voting, how many people, again, I try not to go too far into the weeds. We want to make sure our voting body's healthy and they're voting appropriately and there's enough people so that we have a clean election. But I don't dig into how many and who and who's not and who is. But we do try and make sure that all of our members know the obligation to vote and support the Academy. When was the first time that you voted? I've been a voting member for probably 25 years, so 25 years ago. Do you remember that first year?

19:09I remember how excited I was to vote on our member who I voted for or even what year it was. But I do remember getting the ballot. It was a paper ballot, you know, back in the day. You had to fill in the bubble and the whole deal. But I remember how honored I was and how proud I was to be a member of the Academy and to be in that collection of talented people and to think like, man, I'm a member of the Academy. I'm doing something. So one of the things I think is quite funny is there's this kind of myth of the best new artist curse. That dates back to the late 70s with what is the band called?

19:45the fact that I don't know the band name maybe says that Starland Vocal Band after releasing Afternoon Delight and then the next year they kind of weren't on the map anymore and so people kind of started to think maybe there's a Best New Artist curse. Do you feel like there has historically ever been any validity to the to the idea of the Best New Artist curse? No I don't I think statistically you could probably look back and see how many Best New Artists have turned into incredible superstars and we see that every year at least since I've been here where you see who's won that award and what they've gone on to do.

20:16In fact, I think this year we looked back, and maybe my number's slightly off, but I think there's 30 or so nominations for Best New Artist from the past in this year's show. So it just really depends on the records that they make and how they follow up with some of that early work and whether they can sustain that. And there's so many, you know, how many things go into making a successful artist. And if you think about all the millions of people trying to be an artist and trying to have a successful, self-sustaining career in music, it's tough. And the fact that they are the best new artists, I think, helps and gives them an advantage to continue forward.

20:52But ultimately, it comes down to if the fans and the consumers are liking what you're making, and everybody has the same shot to do that. I know that there are kind of onlookers who will always say every year, there's going to be someone in the best new artist category who's been going for 10 years in their career. But this is the first time they're nominated and they're in the best new artist category. I think last year, the year before was Kei Trinata. This year might be like maybe the Marias. Do you still feel good about like the kind of ethos of the Best New Artist category, just essentially being a category for people who've never been nominated before?

21:24Does that still feel like the right way to approach it? Well, it's more than just a category for people who haven't been nominated before. It's for an artist that breaks through in the year. And so if you ask, am I okay with it? I'm okay with the ethos of it. The name of it sometimes catches us up or trips us up a little bit because a lot of the artists aren't new. But it's the artist that has finally broken through. There's maybe artists that have been toiling and working and writing and creating for so long, but now they finally came to national prominence or a national consciousness. And for us, we want to celebrate those kind of artists.

21:56This is their first time really, really getting that recognition. So whether or not we want to say new artist or breakthrough artist or maybe that's where the conversation should be. But it's always great to celebrate and honor the group of musicians or creators or artists that are now finally coming through. There are about eight nominees in some of the general categories now, right? That's correct? Eight. We had 10 at one point. We had five at one point. Yeah. We've been trying to find the sweet spot. What's the right number without diluting it but while still honoring all the diverse people that we want to honor in those categories?

22:31Yeah. So do you feel like eight is like the final number? because I know it has varied. It's definitely not the final number. It's a good number for now, and it feels like it's working. But we look at our processes every year. We look at things like how many nominees go into a field, what are we classifying music as, what is the nomenclature around the categories and the genres of music, and what are the thresholds we have. There's so many things that we think about every year. So I'm sure we'll continue to revisit the 8 or the 5 or the 10. Yeah. And one thing that I've been thinking about a lot as a reporter, is I report a lot on tech, like streaming, that kind of stuff.

23:08And I think in a streaming age, when we can listen to anything we want to at our fingertips, our taste in music is fragmenting. The idea of just one mainstream where everyone's listening to the exact same thing on the same radio station is something that doesn't totally happen anymore. We often hear that about the Hot 100. I'll hear everyone say, oh my gosh, I've never heard of the number one song on the Hot 100. How is that possible? But so many people are listening to it. I imagine the Grammys are kind of dealing with the same thing. How do you guys approach the idea that listenership is fragmenting and people are globalizing in their tastes and evolving and moving into more subgenres than ever?

Read the full transcript

23:47I think that's the coolest thing ever, first of all. Everyone has their own identity and their individual things that they love and that makes sense to them and moves them. And I would much rather that be the environment we're working in rather than a few select people we're driving what we all think we should be listening to or what they think we should be listening to. And the ability to discover music and to try something and say, I'm not crazy about that, but you know what? I love this. Let me find 10 more things like that. I don't know if there's been a more exciting time in music than right now.

24:20I know there are things that we're all nervous about and scared about with the dreaded AI conversation and consolidation of label or power. But with what's happening in music and, as you said, the ability for music lovers to find different kinds of music and have it at their fingertips at any given moment is really, really exciting. As to what we're doing about it, I want to make sure, as the person who's running the academy, along with our board and our chair and our executive leadership, I want to make sure that we are – I want to make sure our membership is representing what's happening in the music business right now.

24:56So I want to make sure there's members from different parts of the world. We can't all be just from one place. We can't all just be people who love one kind of music. We can't all be people who look a certain way or a certain gender or a certain age. We need everybody to be a part of the process. And we need everybody to be able to come in and advise us as an organization. And I hate to, I'm not trying to sound over-important. I know the Grammys or even music, for that matter, is not the most important thing in the world. But I think what artists do is one of the most important things in the world.

25:28And I think music is what makes us human. And it's what makes society move and work. And so for us to serve music and to serve music people, we have to do a lot of things that maybe you're saying, well, that's not really important. But for us to get it right, those are the things that are really, really important. Getting the membership right. Make sure we're talking about music the right way. Making sure we're getting the right outcomes, the right nominations, the right wins so we have a great show and we can generate more revenue for our music community. And for those who are listening who don't know much about it, what does Music Cares do?

26:02Music Cares is the 501c3 affiliate of the Academy. And it is an organization dedicated to the health and well-being of music people. Anytime a music person, you don't have to be a member, just a music person, a professional in the industry. You could be a guitar player. You could be a yodeler. You could be a roadie on a tour. If you're a music person, you work in this industry, you need help, you call Music Cares. You might have a car accident. You might have medical bills. Maybe it's a drug addiction, mental illness. Somebody stole your tuba. You call Music Cares, and these people are taking care of you.

26:38And what I'm so proud of is what Music Cares has done in times of great need, crisis, disasters. We had so many people that had lost their homes during the fire or had been affected by COVID. During COVID, we gave out over$30 million to music people who needed help. Same for the LA fires in the last year, music people who need help. So that's what Music Cares does. And I'm just proud. And comparatively, the museum does kind of a similar thing on the education side and the preservation side, making sure young people are exposed to music and music teachers and music classes and have instruments.

27:17And there's just so many great things that this organization does, which is why I jump on a podcast like this and talk to you, because I want people to know we are so excited about our noms and our wins and our performances. But what we do really matters. What we do as an organization to support music and music people, I think, changes the world. And one of the things I thought was really inspiring last year was Chapel Rhone dedicated part of her speech when she won Best New Artist to talking about how artists don't receive health care and that can be really challenging for them. It's probably the most stressful job you could choose to do is being an artist, especially a pop artist, with the whole world watching you.

27:58And I'm wondering, could someone get some sort of health care covered by Music Cares? Like, is that one remedy? Well, first of all, what Chappell said, I couldn't be more excited about the sentiment of what she brought up in her passion and advocacy for music people. Because I feel the same way. I wake up every day thinking, what can we do for our community? And insurance and health care is a big challenge for us because none of us are, or at least until this job, none of us are working for companies that offer that, retirement packages or 401s or health insurance. And so as a music creator, and it's not just artists, it's the songwriters, it's the engineers, it's the musicians, we don't have access to that.

28:47So Music Cares doesn't do that specifically and directly, but the Academy has, over the last five years, been sourcing low-cost insurance opportunities for our members. And we're trying to develop more things like that where we can fill gaps. We haven't nailed it all because we also have a certain pool of resources to work with. But these are things that we are super passionate about, and we're really working closely with the artist community, the songwriting community, to try and also figure out what's the legislation. We have an advocacy department in D.C. and at the state level where we're fighting for the rights of music people, not just on copyright protection and AI protection, things like that, intellectual property.

29:25It's about how else can we be helpful to the music community. So these are things that we're working on every single day, including how do we solve some of the challenges financially for the creative community. One of the recent ads, as far as categories go for the Grammys, was Songwriter of the Year, which I know songwriters are so excited about. They've been wanting that for a long time. And the songwriter category specifically, correct me if I'm wrong, but it's non-performing, non-producing songwriters. So it's like true, like, you know, writing music and lyrics, songwriters. And over the last few years, I've started to see that some of the same names keep cropping up in the nominations.

30:05Is that category stagnating? And is there maybe too small of a pool of people eligible? Like, I don't know, what are you thinking about Songwriter of the Year as it evolves? I hope that it continues to grow, and I hope we get more and more songwriters, but this is the challenge. One of the things that we're concerned about is human creativity and the craft of writing songs, which is why I was so pleased to be a part of bringing that category to our list and to our show. We've had a deficiency in celebrating the craft, I would think. Maybe I'm biased because I'm a songwriter, But I feel like we needed to do a better job of recognizing and honoring the incredible people that are writing the songs that artists are performing.

30:51So that category was an attempt to do that. I hope we'll continue to get great support and people submitting for that category. I know there are some names that are the same, but I don't think it's stagnant. I feel like there's great different people. We've only done it three years, so we'll see where it goes. And I love the fact that we're doing that. Yeah. Yeah. And I think one of the things that people on the outside looking in at the Grammys might not totally understand is like how certain artists end up in certain categories. I think, for example, Justin Bieber getting nominated for Yummy and he was in the pop category, but he wished he was in the R &B category.

31:31But there's a lot of steps along the way to determine who is in what category. I know that you have to submit, like, correct me if I'm wrong. You have to submit and put yourself in a certain category and then it's reviewed. How does that happen sometimes that an artist will end up in a category that they were not intending? And how do you address those challenges when the artists are upset about that? Well, start with the process. You enter as an artist or as a creator, songwriter, whatever you are, you enter the material in a category and in a genre where you believe you should be competing. Sometimes you as an artist may have a different opinion of what type of music you think you're making.

32:12So with that in mind, and so we didn't get very disparate types of music competing against each other, being judged, I'll say, in the same category. We created committees of experts. So if you're talking about a record that's either pop or R &B, we have a committee of pop songwriters, producers, executives, artists, engineers that exclusively work in that genre. Then we'll have the same committee in R &B. And then music that's submitted in R &B go to the R &B committee. And the R &B committee listen to it and say, not is it good, is it bad, does it deserve a nomination? No. Is it R &B? That's the only determining factor that they have the ability or the authority to be able to say.

32:54And if they say that it is R &B in their minds, and again, we can only try and assemble the group of experts that we can because all this is subjective. Nobody can definitively, factually say a piece of music is definitely a certain genre. It's opinion. So we get people who we think are really smart and know the genres to evaluate whether or not it fits in that genre. And they keep it or they pass it on to the other genre committee. And so if R &B feels like it's not as R &B as they think maybe the artist does, they move it over to pop. If pop thinks that, yeah, it's pop, we'll take it, then it comes out in pop.

33:27If pop doesn't like it, then it goes back. The only thing, and I know that sounds complicated, The thing that we've tried to do over the last five years is pay much more reverence or respect to artist intent. And so when an artist submits in a certain category, whether it be jazz or pop or rock, that committee is instructed, is asked to make sure you're paying attention to where it was entered. And in order to do that, we've adjusted those committees' ability to move things easily. So we now have it where it has to be a supermajority, 66 and a third percent has to vote that it is not of that genre in order to move it.

34:03So if half the committee votes, it stays. 66 and a third, it goes. Interesting. Not 66 and a third, sorry, 66.66. Oh, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Math. Math. Whatever. It was mathing. We're music people, you know? Um, so one of the genres that has cropped up in the last like five to 10 years as a really popular one and a growing popular one in the States is K-pop. Um, one of my coworkers at Billboard wrote a story a couple months ago talking about whether or not K-pop should have its own category at the Grammys or if it's just pop music, basically. And what did they think? I, you know, I think they had a very balanced article.

34:46I think it was very balanced. Sign of a good journalist. Yes. Talk to all sides. I think there totally is an argument for both. So K-pop is an especially challenging one. But I think since that article came out, we got our nominations out. And we saw that a K-pop Demon Hunters track ended up in the Song of the Year category, Golden by Huntrix, which has been leading on our charts. If you watch the show, you know that it's been on the charts for a long time. So I think it kind of proves that K-pop at this point has hit some sort of a threshold where maybe it can actually compete in these mainstream categories.

35:23So I'm wondering now, what do you think? Does K-pop still need to be considered for its own category or should it be in pop? Well, it's a good question. And luckily, you or I don't have to answer it because our categories and any genre-specific categories that are created or developed are determined by the music community. So the music community will survey the landscape. Hopefully, we have enough experts based on our new membership to say, hey, you know what? K-pop is really doing its thing. We need a category for K-pop. They write a proposal. The proposal comes into the board. And the board says, you know what?

36:00I think you're right. Let's have a new category. And so that process happens every year. So I would imagine with what's been happening recently with K-pop artists and K-pop music, the prevalence and the popularity of it, there is going to be more and more momentum both in the music community and in the Academy elected leadership to discuss that and think about it. So we'll see what happens. Yeah. I feel like K-pop is so strange because it's really hard to define what it is. It's like, do you want to put everyone who is a pop artist from Korea into K-pop? That might not be fair, but also is something like Cat's Eye, which is based in the States, but using the K-pop model, is that K-pop or is it regular pop?

36:40I don't know. Well, the good thing, again, is we have people within our reach and our membership and our elected leadership who are immersed in K-pop and immersed in pop and they're experts. There's no way I could or you could or any one person could tell everything about a genre and be able to determine whether it's this kind of music or that kind of music. So we rely heavily on people who are working in the space, even executives, label people, managers, lawyers, to get together and to talk about these kind of things. And that's the beauty of the academy is we have so much expertise and knowledge across our 15 ,000 voting members to tell us, here's how we're going to define K-pop.

37:16Here are going to be the rules of how we talk about it. Here's the description. Here's what it has to have in it to make sure that it's in that genre. And that is hard. It is so difficult because it is music. It's subjective. and it hits everybody differently. Yeah. And when I think of the Grammys, I think of it as an American award show, but I know y 'all are increasingly adding more global genres. Like we were just talking about K-pop, not a category, but, you know, that is a global genre. You do now have a category for African music. How do you think of the Grammys? Is it an American award show or is it representing the globe's music, the world's music?

37:55I like to think that we're representing music, regardless of where it comes from, regardless who makes it. And we never ask where you were born when you send in a submission. We just make sure that the music is available to consumers. And as long as it used to be, if it was on a record or if it was on a CD or a cassette, it was eligible. Now if it's on a streamer and available to consumers, it's eligible. So we represent music, and we want to honor music. And we realize borders are falling figuratively, and languages don't matter when it comes to music. I've been singing along to music in Spanish.

38:26I don't know, a lick of Spanish. I'm singing the words. And same for K-pop. You're seeing people enjoy music from different parts of the world. Now with Afro Beats and I'm a Piano and other types of music from the continent, you're seeing stuff from the Middle East coming in. I just went to an artist from India that was playing at the Crypto the other night, and it was amazing how incredible this music is. And to me, it doesn't matter where it comes from. So my hope is that we continue to just celebrate excellence in creativity and music, and we'll see where that leads us. Yeah. Yeah. So recently you did an interview.

39:01I don't know where it was with, but you talked about how you're seeing from your friends who are songwriters and producers that pretty much everyone is using AI in some way in the studio. I was wondering if you could expound upon that. Like exactly what are you seeing? How are they using it? It runs the gamut of people texting lyrics or ideas or how they feel when they wake up and it generating an entire track and lyrics and melody. That's the far end of the spectrum. The other side of the spectrum is somebody just has produced an entire song, but they can't figure out the bridge section or they can't figure out one line or they can't figure out a melody to finish the chorus.

39:39And they ask one of the platforms to create that, to supplement what they've already done. That's the other end of the spectrum. Everything in between is what I'm seeing in the studio. People having one of the platforms writing lyrics where they've already played all the chords and they love the music but they don't know what to say. Or taking lyrics that have been generated and building songs around that. Or having AI vocal a song that you wrote because you can't sing. Or I know one person who writes on acoustic guitar and whistles the melodies and puts that into one of the platforms, one of the models.

40:14and the model spits out songs. I know another person who is a poet who just writes poetry, and they put that into the model and it spits out a fully produced demo. So it's all over the map. People that are professionals that I've been seeing are generally somewhere in the middle where they're using it as a tool. They're unlocking something or they're stuck on a lyric or they're trying to find 15 things that rhyme with this. How do you say things in a clever way? Here's a lyric. How can I make it better? Here are some drums, a bass, and a piano. Now make it sound like a fully produced song. Those are some of the ways I'm seeing professionals use it.

40:52Also, people are using it as inspiration, not just taking what it gives you and just using it. But, oh, I never thought about that. That's a cool way of thinking about this section or that beat or this rhythm. And then launching from there. Yeah. I'm starting to see that a lot, too. So I'm covering AI for us all the time. So this is something I watch really closely. And I have a few friends who are rising songwriters right now and producers who are just trying to get their start. So they're in that grind phase where they're like every day is a session, if not two sessions. Are they using AI? Yeah.

41:24A lot of them are using AI and they're super talented. Like they don't need to, but they're doing so many sessions that like I've heard this from quite a few people that they're just like sometimes the well runs a little dry and you need something to kind of like kickstart it. Yeah. And then they won't end up using almost any of it. But it's interesting because sometimes there are bits and pieces from that initial kickstart that might end up in the resulting song. But they probably won't disclose it because, I mean. No one will. The self-disclosure thing, I don't know. I have a hard time with it.

41:59I know there's like no really better option right now. But, yeah, I don't really feel like anyone's going to really disclose if they use Suno to like try to help them start. but you know i think we're in kind of like this wild west phase where ai detection isn't so great so we're relying on people just disclosing whether or not they've used ai i think we're also seeing a lot right now and we have in the past few years this idea of you'll see a headline where it's like an ai song it's number one yeah yeah yeah and didn't you just have a number one yeah song it It was on the country song sales chart.

42:36Okay. I'm going to fact check myself on the screen if I'm wrong about that. But yeah. And, you know, I can't really speak to like what goes on on our charts, but I do think like the idea of calling things AI songs is a little bit reductive at this point. I don't know what the better solution is, but a lot of times it's more of a gray area than just it's an AI song. It was just made by a prompt. You often have the things in the middle like you were describing. And, yeah, I don't really think we have the terminology yet to describe that. The next question I would ask you, and I wish I could ask all the consumers and fans of music, do people really mind if AI was involved in the creation of the song?

43:21I'm not saying an AI artist because that's different. As I spoke on earlier, I think you want to feel something from the artist that you love or that you're a fanatic for because of that human connection or the shared experience. But if you use generative AI to make some drum beat or a chord progression or a track, do you think people will mind that if their favorite artist is singing it? I think if they know, yes. If they don't know and it tricks them, I mean Deezer just put out a really interesting stat where they said 97 % of people cannot tell the difference between AI-generated songs and human-made songs, which is a pretty shocking stat at this point.

44:01I guess that just proves how good things have gotten. But do you think fans care if their favorite artists use autotune? They don't care about autotune. I think what they care about with AI is the ethics of the training. I think that's a huge part of it. So consumers are in the weeds around that, you think, to that level? They care about sampling? They don't care about sampling. Yeah, I do wonder if I was not in the industry at the time and sampling became a thing, but I know that it was extremely controversial at that time. And streaming. They know the ethics and the finances around streaming.

44:34So there's a lot of things that have happened, technological disruption and advancements that have happened that have affected the creative community. But at the end of the day, I'm trying to figure out, and this is the toughest part of my job and where I sit is I obviously represent overall beyond just the voting members, 40 ,000 members of the academy. And they're all humans, by the way. And we're trying to figure out what's the best place to sit. And I'm coming on your podcast to talk about it, and it probably sounds a little crazy, like this guy doesn't have his position together. But it's really tough because I want to advocate for our human members and human creators.

45:08But I also realize that this technology is here, much like other technologies that have happened all the way since piano players were angry when the piano roll came out. And live bands were mad when tape recorders came out, and you could record music and listen back to it. Everybody was mad, up in arms about it. All the orchestras were angry when somebody invented a synthesizer or a sampler. And so there's always been this technology that's come and changed how we create and make our art. So I'm struggling between resisting it and saying, no, this is bad, no AI, and knowing that it's happening with trying to understand how we can utilize it as a tool and use it to benefit our members and our human creators.

45:52in a way that is not eliminating people's opportunity to express themselves or their opportunity to monetize their art. Yeah. I know you've been thinking about this for a long time. I remember back in 2023, when I feel like AI music really actually became a headlines, was the Ghostwriter Heart on My Sleeve, fake Drake song. At that time, I think, again, using the term AI song is a little confusing. that song actually was entirely made by a guy in a, in a bed sheet and some sunglasses. Um, and he used AI to adapt his vocals into sounding like deep baking Drake in the weekend. Um, and at that time you made a statement to the New York times that because the song was made by a person that it could be eligible in song categories.

46:39Um, is that still the stance? Like if something has AI in the recording, but the song itself is human made, that it could still be nominated in a songwriting category? Yes. And, and converse, it can still be nominated in a performance category if AI created or wrote the music or performed all the music, but somebody, a human sang it. So using AI does not make your entry ineligible. It just kind of makes you have to choose the right categories to be considered in. And like, what about when something has an element of deep faking, like something where it's potentially offensive to another member of the Academy or something.

47:14Like in that instance where, you know, Drake and The Weeknd didn't give their permission for their voices to be used. Are things like that disqualifying? There are things that can disqualify a recording. Absolutely. If you're doing something illegal or something that affects an artist in a way that is protected, then there are things that we can do to avoid that. But all that is starting to look really blurry and needs clarification more now than ever. Yeah. And what are you guys up to on Capitol Hill? I know y 'all are behind the No Fakes Act, right? No Fakes Act, right? Yeah. No Fakes, No Frauds, it used to be called.

47:51I think now it's just No Fakes. We've got a lot of support federally, and that is legislation to prevent people from being able to do what you're talking about, which is take someone's voice and use it in a way that they don't approve or they don't have any monetary interest in. So that is getting a lot of support by camera, bipartisan, it's kind of, I think, undisputed almost. We just need to get it through and get it happening and get it signed off. But I'm confident we'll get that to happen. There are some states that have adopted it already, but we really need that on a federal level. Yeah.

48:23I mean, the statewide thing is just so patchy. It's so hard to do it on the state level. But yeah, I mean, we need the government to stay open so they can get to work and maybe think about actually passing that one. So it was funny because I was, I guess not funny, but it was interesting. I was on the Hill and we were meeting with members of Congress and I gave a talk and I said, how would you guys be okay if somebody used your voice and delivered a campaign promise with things that you didn't even believe in and were completely opposite to the way you felt. So that's how as an artist, we feel when somebody sings a lyric that we didn't write or raps a section that we don't believe or we don't live.

49:02it's inauthentic and it could really do harm to the artist brand and to the fans. So I think that hit them. And I think they realized, oh, we can't have people running around using our voice or our likeness in ways that we don't approve. Yeah. I do think that like the Recording Academy, the RIAA, like given you guys have such tight relationships with artists that senators and congressmen actually do really care about, it's touched everyone's lives. Like we were saying before at the very beginning, music is a very universal thing. My hope is that when artists actually speak up, they might actually mean something to these people and have some sort of positive impact.

49:43That's the coolest thing. You go to the Hill and you bring one of these artists and the members of Congress look out. And they're celebrities in their own right. But when they look out and they see an artist that they like, they turn into kids. And then you have their ear. Then you can spend the time talking to them about your concerns. And I think they're listening as much as they're looking at the artist and wanting them to sing or perform in their office. is they're listening to that artist and telling them the story of how they came up or how they make a living or issues they're having. And that is, I think, I guess I was going to say secret weapon is not even a secret, but that's the most powerful weapon that we have in making change is the artist community and them showing up and advocating for their peers.

50:20So the Grammys are going to be moving next year, not this year for 2026 and that award ceremony, but next year it's going to be moving over to ABC, Hulu, and Disney+. and I know we're now in this age where so many people are looking to watch the Grammys on streaming services. Does that evolve the way you're thinking about putting on the show, that it's not a traditional, that we're moving further and further away from traditional broadcast and moving more towards streaming? And what are some of the effects of streaming on a broadcast like the Grammys? Obviously the ability to reach more people in different parts of the world.

50:52But it is going to make or cause us to rethink and reimagine. If you're building a show now, what would it look like? Like, do you have to account for commercial breaks? Do you have to account for different segmented audiences? Or there's so many considerations when you're programming a show and you're trying to make a show for linear broadcast that maybe you wouldn't have if you were doing it for just streaming. The thing for us is we are still going to be on ABC. So we will still be making a show built for ABC, but also Disney+. So finding that sweet spot is going to be the challenge. It's really exciting for us.

51:26We've been with CBS for many, 50-plus years. So it's an opportunity for us to do some different things. Wow. I didn't know it was 50 plus. That is, that's crazy, man. Big changes ahead. Yeah. So Harvey, to end things off, I'm going to do a little bit of a Grammys rapid fire. Okay. Here we go. All right. So you can have your phone out for this one. Cause I know this is going to be hard to memorize. Okay. First things first, who is the artist with the most Grammy nominations? I know that one. That's Beyonce. Cool. I think she's got a hundred or 99, something like that. It's incredible. Okay. Who's the artist with the most Grammy wins?

52:00I know that one. It's Beyonce. How many wins? Do you know? 36, 35, 37, somewhere in there. And I know that Jay, her husband, has quite a few. And then her daughter has a couple. So I think between all of them, they probably have 70 Grammys. They probably are the family with the single. Oh, not even close. Yeah. Not even close. They probably have an entire room in their house with just floor to ceiling statuettes. Man, I want to see it someday. I want to see it. I want to get one. Hopefully they'll reveal it. I know. You should go in and steal a couple. They won't even notice. They won't notice, but I want to earn it.

52:33I want to earn it. Next one is the producer with the most wins for producer of the year. Wow. This is a great category and a good question because all these are my peers who have turned into my friends, which is crazy for me to say, because these are the people I looked up to when I was coming up as a songwriter and producer. So Babyface and Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis. Those, I think they have four each, if I'm not mistaken. Babyface has four wins. Jimmy and Terry have the most nominations with 11. So I was close. Whoa. 11 nominations. That's crazy. Isn't that crazy? I love that. Who is the artist with the most wins for album of the year?

53:09I know that one because it just happened, I think, last year, two years ago. It was Taylor, who won four. Wow. Okay. She's breaking records everywhere she goes. Everywhere she goes. It was so funny when the nominations came out and people were like, where's Taylor? I know. Like next year. I'm like, it's an eligibility window thing, guys. Yeah. She did not get shut out this time. It's weird. I think she released on the first day of voting. So obviously it's not eligible, but so she released on voting day. So. That's pretty crazy. Yeah. Do you see people adjust their timelines for the voting window?

53:42No question. Because if you release too early, then it's out of the consciousness by the time voting comes around the following year. So you got to time it the right way, which is too bad. But that is a function of how people listen to music and then other things come in and they like that and they listen to that for a while. So you see a lot of that. Yeah, I think that makes sense. I do think that there's quite a few artists who will adjust their album release window if they think that maybe they can have a better shot at like a number one on the charts or something. For sure. It's just how it goes.

54:10The politics are real, you know. Well, it's like when they release movies, they don't want to release them on other weekends where there's other blockbusters or things. I can get it. I understand. The stats are important and the Grammys are definitely important more than just saying number one, like having an actual trophy and having the opportunity for that is way bigger. And what I love is when you see somebody performing or you see somebody on a news broadcast or a podcast or doing the national anthem, it always says Grammy nominated or Grammy winning artist. Yeah. And on a sad side, you see it on an obituary.

54:42And that's the thing that somebody does that stamps them forever for as long as they live as someone who's been honored by their peers as a Grammy nominee or a Grammy winner. I mean, that gives me chills. Yeah. Defining achievement. How often do you get asked, do the Grammys still matter? I used to get asked that a lot when I first took this role. And my answer was a little more tentative. And it was, I think the Grammys really matter. I've always wanted to win one. I think my family's always respected. Everybody I've ever worked with has always wanted to win one. But I understand that there were some people that didn't feel the same way.

55:17But now four or five years later, I can tell you for sure the Grammys matter. And people, I think, respect the Academy and the Grammys. Not everybody. I wish everybody did because of what the Academy stands for and what the Grammys stand for. But I do think it's something people aspire to because of the fact that it is your peers. It's not just the popularity contest or who's got a bunch of streams. It's your peers, the people you work with, the people that you respect, the people that you've looked up to maybe your whole career. Them saying, those are the people that I want to nominate or those are the people that I want to win.

55:53To me, I look back at people like Quincy Jones, who is somebody that I always respected and wanted to be like. And when I would think about him doing his Grammy ballot and voting for me as a songwriter, as a producer, I don't know if he ever did or if he didn't, but that was what was in my mind. My peers, the people that I admired evaluating my work, that just means so much to me. And the final one for our rapid fire is an artist who's been nominated in two extremely different categories. There's a lot of people that do that. Justin Bieber's done it. I know John Batiste does it quite often. He's nominated in, you know, across the ballot in folk and pop and R &B and gospel.

56:35So I would say John Batiste probably holds the world's record for being nominated in so many different categories in a given year, same year. Yeah. Oh, wow. I think Justin's nominated in a couple of different genres this year. Is he? I think so. I think he's got an R &B thing and I think he might have a pop thing. I need to check. Yeah. I love that album. Swag. Swag. What a name for such like a critically acclaimed album. I love it. Swag and swag too. I was going to say, is this album title swag too, better than swag one? I think so. Swag on twos. Yeah. Like we have so much swag. We need a second swag.

57:09He had so many songs. I can't imagine how long he was working on it just because there's two albums worth that are fuller than most albums. It's pretty crazy. But I was so excited to see that album because Dijon is one of my faves. Yeah. I went to the concert last week. Oh, really? Did you see it at the Greek? Yeah. It's crazy. Yeah. He really pushes the arrangements live too, which is really fascinating. He goes for it. I love him. He really does. Well, I could definitely sit and talk to you about all my favorite artists, but I guess I'm not supposed to do that now. Because then people think, oh, you're supporting one, you're advocating for something.

57:44But I get so excited to listen to music, to talk about music, and there's so much great stuff happening. That's why I said earlier it's such an exciting time to be in this business because you can see on any given Tuesday a show that just blows you away and something like you've never seen before. Very cool time. Also the best part about living in LA for me as an adult, because I'm from Fort Worth, Texas. Not many concerts go through there. Not as many choices. Yeah. My parents were like, you're not driving to Dallas for that. Did you sneak out? You know, I didn't. Your parents are probably watching this.

58:17I know. My mom does listen to every episode. So she's going to be like - Kristen never snuck out to a concert, mom. Never. I would never do that. Sorry, mom. But okay. So Harvey, we also end off every episode of On the Record with a segment that we call Make Me a Playlist. And so we ask everyone to pick three songs based on some prompts. And OK, so the prompts are, first one, what's a song you can no longer? Gatekeep. So a lesser known song. I have so many deep cuts in my playlist, but I'm going to go with a personal response as a songwriter and a producer, some songs that maybe one that I've written and produced.

58:55And the reason I've always been a gatekeeper of the song is because I'm singing on the song. And I don't tell people that I sing. So I'm letting the cat out of the bag here publicly for the first time. Breaking news. Breaking news. Breaking on Billboard. Why Won't You Love Me, Toni Braxton. Wow. Are you in the background vocals? I am in a small feature in the fade, the second half of the song, which I never publicly talked about. But I can't gatekeep any longer. Okay. Okay. It's no longer gatekeep. The secret is out. Okay. So what is a favorite throwback for you? Anything over 10 years old? Michael Jackson, take your pick.

59:31Every song, every record. Maybe I would start with Thriller, and some of the songs on that album are my favorite. So influential for me as a young kid listening to music, watching MTV, seeing those first videos come out. And still some of the throwbacks that I go to are Michael Jackson throwbacks. Can't go wrong. Thriller ended up in the top 10 very recently for Halloween. Pretty crazy how that song keeps coming back. And the movie's coming. Oh, yes. Yeah. Played by Jafar. Jafar Jackson. Jafar Jackson. Yeah. Exciting. And lastly, what is a guilty pleasure for you? I'm assuming you're asking about a musical guilty pleasure.

1:00:08Yes. And not my food. Yes. I was going to say pizza, ice cream. No, guilty pleasure for music. I don't have a guilty pleasure because I'm never guilty about listening to any genre of music. I listen to everything. No, it's true. because is one genre of music more elevated and refined than the other? I think not. I love all music. There's not a genre that I don't listen to. It's honestly classical, EDM, pop, rock. There's some really cool things happening. And what I love right now and why I guess maybe there's no guilty pleasures is because it's all coming together. There's mashups of stuff, different types of music that you've never heard and you've never expected.

1:00:43One artist that just came out with a record, I won't say her name, but she blew my mind with just going left. They'd been doing one thing for so long and now all of a sudden I'm going to do this over here and it was the coolest work of art I've heard in a long time. Can I guess? Nope. I think I know who it is. I think I know who it is and I did love that record if I'm right. I did love that record as well. Well, Harvey Mason Jr., thank you so much for coming to On The Record. Kristen, thank you. That was a lot of fun. I love talking music with you and you're so knowledgeable about so many things.

1:01:11So thank you for having me. Thank you. I paid him to say that. Another very special thank you to Harvey Mason Jr. for coming on the show and talking to us about all things Grammys 2026. And now on to the charts. As we do every week, we're going to give you a countdown of the Billboard Hot 100 chart top 10. Here's your top 10 countdown for the Billboard Hot 100 chart for the week of December 6th. Coming in at number 10 is Opalite by Taylor Swift. Number nine this week is Mutt by Leon Thomas. Christmas music makes a big re-entry this week, starting with Jingle Bell Rock by Bobby Helms in the 8th slot.

1:01:51Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree by Brenda Lee comes in at number 7. Last Christmas by Wham! comes in at 6th. Number 5 this week is All I Want for Christmas is You by Mariah Carey. Man I Need by Olivia Dean is number 4 this week. 3 is Ordinary by Alex Warren

1:02:202 is Golden by Huntrix And finally, for its 8th week at the number 1 spot on the Hot 100 chart, it's The Fate of Ophelia by Taylor Swift Thanks for listening to this week's episode of On the Record and another special thank you to my guest, the one and only Harvey Mason Jr. from the Recording Academy for coming by the show and talking to us about the Grammys. If you like today's show, please consider hitting us with a rating, a follow, a thumbs up, all those good things. They really help a show like ours to grow and to reach new audiences. Again, I'm your host, Kristen Robinson, and tune in next week for another peek behind the curtain of the music business.

1:02:58I'll see you then.

1:03:37Good Energy in. Good energy out.

1:03:46Storm, zero sugar, 200 milligrams of caffeine and immunity support. Storm, energy for life. You can't reason with the sun. Trust us. We've tried. This summer, it's time to put that angry ball of fire on mute. Columbia's OmniShade technology is engineered to protect you from the sun's harsh rays that can burn and damage your skin. The sun is relentless. But so is our gear. Level up your summer at Columbia.com to spend more time outside and less time slathering on aloe lotion. You're welcome. Columbia. Engineered for whatever.

1:04:23Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile, with a message for everyone paying big wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop. With Mint, you can get premium wireless for just$15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying, no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment. Anyway, give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three-month plan, equivalent to$15 per month required. Intro rate first three months only. Then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees extra. See full terms at mintmobile.com.

From the publisher

The Grammys are music’s biggest night, but how are the votes really counted, and who decides which artists take home the trophies? Harvey Mason jr., Grammy-nominated producer, songwriter, and CEO of the Recording Academy, pulls back the curtain on how the Academy works, from membership to voting processes and AI’s role in modern music. He joins host Kristin Robinson to unpack his journey from producing hits for Brandy, Destiny’s Child, Michael Jackson, and Toni Braxton to leading music’s most influential institution, all while getting his Grammys knowledge put to the test. Mason explains the challenges of ensuring fair representation across genres, and how the Academy is evolving to serve music and musicians in a rapidly changing industry. He also reflects on moving from creative work to executive leadership, the collaborative process that has defined his career and what it takes to keep the Grammys credible, inclusive, and impactful.

Love what you hear? Don’t forget to rate, review and subscribe so you never miss an episode of Billboard On The Record.

Keep up with us on IG @billboardontherecord and @wordsbykristin.

Billboard On The Record is a podcast in partnership with SickBird Productions.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

More from Billboard On The Record

All 42 episodes
How Grammy Voting Really Works & Why It Matters More Than Ever w/ Harvey Mason jr.Billboard On The Record · 1 h 4 min
Listen in VO