1. Podcasts
  2. Bloomberg Law
  3. Justice Alito & Botched Tennessee Execution
Bloomberg Law

7 Oct 2026 · 25m · 10 chapters

Episode artwork

Justice Alito & Botched Tennessee Execution

In short

The episode is about two legal stories: Justice Samuel Alito’s new book “So Ordered” and a Tennessee execution that went badly. In the Alito segment, Bloomberg Supreme Court reporter Greg Storr interviews Alito about whether he will retire, why he published the book now, and how his originalist method leads to conservative outcomes.

Key claims

Alito says he will not retire after a Democratic Senate takeover; the book is mostly revised speeches with some new material responding to criticism of the “shadow docket”; he says he will compromise to craft majority opinions (including in Dobbs) and has no regrets about Dobbs.

Notable examples

Dobbs (abortion), limits on the Voting Rights Act, curbs on labor unions, religious-freedom expansions, and gun-rights rulings; his reaction to Citizens United criticism. The execution segment covers Krista Pike’s botched lethal injection in Tennessee (second in 2026), where she received pentobarbital, survived, and later was reported awake and speaking.

Guest

Bernard Harcourt, Columbia Law School death-penalty expert.

Key claims

likely drug “infiltration” due to failed venous access, possibly degraded drugs, and use of inadequately trained personnel; states obtain drugs from “shady” sources.

Notable examples

comparisons to Dole Ham and the 1947 Willie Francis double-jeopardy case; Harcourt argues a second execution should be barred and Pike’s attorneys seek commutation.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:54

Justice Alito's Background and Influence

Discussion on Justice Alito's tenure and notable opinions on the Supreme Court.

“Justice Samuel Alito has been on the Supreme Court for 21 years.”
2:50

Alito's Retirement Speculation

Speculation around Justice Alito's potential retirement during political shifts.

“There has been a lot of speculation that either he or Justice Thomas might do that, because that would be a way that Donald Trump could appoint and get confirmed a successor who could serve for another 20 or 30 years.”
3:52

Alito's Book and Judicial Philosophy

Insights into Alito's new book and his views on constitutional interpretation.

“Are these all his speeches or is there new content?”
5:47

Alito's Majority Opinions and Compromise

Analysis of Alito's approach to writing majority opinions and compromise.

“of big opinions to Justice Alito, because he's the guy who can, you know, sort of bring it home.”
7:02

Alito's Controversial Opinions

Discussion of Alito's decisions, particularly around Dobbs and its implications.

“suggested earlier, he's written a lot of the biggest decisions of this era of the 6-3 conservative majority.”
8:55

Alito's Reactions and Frustrations

Exploration of Alito's emotional responses and frustrations during his tenure.

“He says, no, I'm willing to say I like this result and it's justified by the it's required actually by the Constitution.”
11:01

Court Independence and Public Opinion

Alito's views on court independence and its relationship with public opinion.

“Did you talk to him about the Democrats wanting to overhaul the court?”
12:23

Upcoming Segment on Tennessee Execution

Teaser for the next segment about the botched execution in Tennessee.

“He doesn't seem to have major concerns about that.”
16:55

Tennessee's Botched Execution Case

An in-depth discussion on Krista Pike's botched execution and its implications.

“Joining me is an expert in the death penalty, Bernard Harcourt, a professor at Columbia Law School.”
28:21

Tennessee's Botched Execution Case

An in-depth discussion on Krista Pike's botched execution and its implications.

“legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcast.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Bloomberg Law, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Some people treat ChatGPT like some kind of smart search engine, and some use it to get work done. ChatGPT Work is a new way of working in ChatGPT that can take action across your apps and files, stay with a project for hours if needed, and turn a goal into finished work. It's designed to help you move from a chaotic starting point to a reviewable first version. So all the source materials, briefs, and scattered information that you have to grind through to turn into something useful can just become something useful. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting Work Mode, available on Plus and Pro plans.

0:42If you're a business owner, you need a card that can keep up. With the Delta SkyMiles Reserve Business American Express card, everyday purchases transform into miles you can use towards future travel. So business as usual can lead to a well-deserved getaway. And for a limited time, card members can earn 200 ,000 bonus miles, the highest miles offered this year. Whether you're traveling for business or planning your next adventure, now's a great time to make every purchase go further. Apply today at www.delta.com slash podcast. Offer ends November 4th. Minimum spending requirements and terms apply.

1:44Asana, where humans and agents workflow together. Try it at asana.com. That's A-S-A-N-A dot com. This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio. Justice Samuel Alito has been on the Supreme Court for 21 years. He's one of the two most conservative members of the court, best known for writing the majority opinion in the case that overturn the constitutional right to abortion. He's also written major opinions cutting back the Voting Rights Act, curtailing the power of labor unions, bolstering religious freedoms, and expanding gun rights. Bloomberg Supreme Court reporter Greg Storr had a wide-ranging interview with Alito about his new book, So Ordered.

2:34Greg, so you asked him the question that's been on everyone's mind for a while. Is he retiring? Jim, what he told me is that he is not going to retire in response to a Democratic takeover of the Senate in the November midterm, if that happens. There has been a lot of speculation that either he or Justice Thomas might do that, because that would be a way that Donald Trump could appoint and get confirmed a successor who could serve for another 20 or 30 years. But the justice said he is not going to do that. It was a pretty Sherman-esque statement. So then the Senate would have to push it through before the new Senate is sworn in.

3:16Is it even possible for them? I guess Mitch McConnell did it with Amy Coney Barrett. So I guess it is doable. Senator Thune, the majority leader, said it could be done. And yes, you're exactly right that they pushed through Amy Coney Barrett in a very short period of time. So it was doable. And, you know, you have to imagine that they would absolutely try. And why did he decide to put out this book at this particular time? So what he said was it actually happened by chance because he was talking to an editor who ended up being the editor of the book who he met at an event. And the editor pitched the idea and he started thinking about it.

3:52And he said he decided he wanted to sort of bring some things together that he hadn't brought together, how he interprets the Constitution, how he interprets federal statutes, what he thinks the role of a judge should be, and some more specific stuff on things like religious freedom. Are these all his speeches or is there new content? It is largely a collection of his speeches with some small tweaks to them. There's a little bit of new stuff responding to some criticisms of the way the court has handled the emergency or so-called shadow docket, but it is mostly things he has said before. I mean, does he see himself as being one of the drivers of the movement on the court to move the law on the court to the right?

4:38He certainly acknowledges that one thing he does and he takes pride in is crafting majority opinions. And, you know, that really is, especially if you look at him compared to Justice Thomas, whose views are a bit more, say, idiosyncratic. They are more his views. And sometimes the court comes around to his views. Justice Alito is willing to say, look, I will compromise to put together a majority opinion. That's what you have to do on a multi-member court. And that ability that he has is what has let him write the court's big opinions like Dobbs and a number of others. When he says he'll compromise, does that mean he actually will change some of the points in his opinion to get five votes so that he can write the majority opinion?

5:26He acknowledges, yes, he will do that because that, he says, is part of being on a multi-member court. And of course, he was a judge on the Court of Appeals beforehand. He does, you know, value having clear guidance from the Supreme Court. And that is something that you can't do if you're falling short of that majority. You need a majority voice. And, you know, it's why you see the Chief Justice John Roberts assigning a lot of big opinions to Justice Alito, because he's the guy who can, you know, sort of bring it home. When Dobbs comes up, probably the most controversial opinion that he's written.

6:02I mean, does he have any apologies about it? Does he have any regrets about it? Absolutely no apologies. He believes that was the right decision. He, in a different interview, used the word courage to describe what he thought the members of the majority were showing, because, of course, the opinion was leaked. There was, you know, a great storm of controversy. And there were death threats against some of the members of the majority. And of course, there was even somebody who attempted to assassinate the justice in Brett Kavanaugh. And people were wondering, would anything change from the leaked draft opinion?

6:39And the answer is no. And in fact, the vote stayed the same as well. Greg, tell us more about his position on the court and the opinions he'll be known for. Well, he will always be known first and foremost as the author of that Dobbs decision. That's going to be, you know, in every obituary about him. But that's really just the tip of the iceberg in terms of the imprint he's had on the law, because as I suggested earlier, he's written a lot of the biggest decisions of this era of the 6-3 conservative majority. And even before that, he has written big decisions on religious rights. He has written big decisions limiting the Voting Rights Act.

7:21He wrote a very big decision a number of years ago, limiting the power of public sector unions and giving workers more power to say, We don't want to pay for the costs of unions representing us. So he's covered a lot of ground in his opinions. And of course, he's also been a pretty prolific dissenter on those, well, certainly minority of occasions where the court is going against the conservative view, going against the Trump administration. So you write that he insists that the outcomes aren't the driving force. But how does he explain that his analysis always gets him to a very conservative result?

8:05You know, as you said, cutting off voting rights, cutting off union rights, but giving more religious rights, giving more gun rights and almost always siding with President Trump. How does his analysis get him to the same spot? Well, he starts with the notion that he thinks this is a really good constitution we have and a constitution that protects the rights for the most part that he thinks ought to be protected. So he kind of has a big point in his favor going in. What he told me is that what he'll do is he'll do the legal analysis he thinks is required, looking at the original meaning of the words of the Constitution.

8:41And he'll sort of check that against to make sure there aren't absurd results, to make sure it kind of passes the common sense test from his standpoint. And as it turns out, he says that for the most part, I like the results. And he says that's something that originalists should not apologize for. In fact, in the book, he warns against what he calls insecure originalists who might sort of pull their punches or put a thumb on the scale in the other direction to try to avoid coming to the result that they like because they don't want their personal results playing into it. He says, no, I'm willing to say I like this result and it's justified by the it's required actually by the Constitution.

9:24I'd love to know what the absurd results might be that he ended up rejecting, because originalism depends on which examples from history judges pick. Just adding my critique of originalism. Going back to Alito, he seems to be the justice who is most inclined to express frustration, shall we say? I mean, the classic case is his shaking his head back and forth during President Barack Obama's State of the Union, where he criticized the Citizens United case. We've seen him react more than other justices. Yeah, he acknowledged that. As he put it to me, he feels strongly about the issues and, quote, maybe I don't hide that as much as a lot of other people.

10:12He is certainly a justice who wears his feelings on his sleeve. He is somebody who you can see have reactions while sitting on the bench. And we've certainly seen a number of occasions over the years where he's really lashed out at criticism. One of the interesting things about the book is that some of the speeches are a bit more detached and scholarly and even-tempered in tone. Then when you get to the one where he's talking about criticism of the emergency docket, where you can just tell he's mad and he's not pulling his punches. And he especially doesn't like the phrase shadow docket, which he says suggests that the court is, you know, acting as a kind of secret cabal doing nefarious things.

10:57That is certainly a part of who he is, is he doesn't hide his irritation. Did you talk to him about the Democrats wanting to overhaul the court? I did. I asked him about the proposals out there in the discussion about adding seats to the court, about imposing term limits, which would probably require a constitutional amendment. Expanding the court is actually something Congress could do on its own. And he said he didn't want to talk about specific proposals, but, you know, say in a not so veiled way that people should think about the impact that those would have on the independence of the court.

11:33The implication being that those would would just make the court more of a political body and more subject to the whims of Congress whenever it would change hands. He also did talk a little bit, or at least he alluded to a brief that was filed a number of years ago that really got under his skin by a number of Democratic senators who in the brief suggested that the court might need to be restructured. And he took that and said in his speech that to be trying to intimidate the court into an outcome in a particular case. I always wonder if any of the justices care when they see that their approval numbers with the American public are at all time lows.

12:17Does Alito have any concerns about the fact that the court is slipping in people's opinions? He doesn't seem to have major concerns about that. In fact, he takes pride in the notion that the court should not be responsive to popular opinion, that sometimes the court has to do things that it thinks are right and sort of let the chips fall where they may. The court is not designed to respond to public opinion in his mind. That's why Supreme Court justices have life tenure. Well, it sounds like you've covered a lot of bases with him, Greg. Thanks so much. That's Bloomberg Supreme Court reporter Greg Storr.

12:59Coming up next on the Bloomberg Law Show, fallout from the botched execution of a woman in Tennessee, the second failed execution in that state this year. What happens next? Remember, you can always get the latest legal news by listening to our Bloomberg Law Podcast. And attorneys looking for legal research? Whether you're an in-house counsel or in private practice, Bloomberg Law gives you the edge. With the latest in AI-powered legal analytics, business insights, and workflow tools. With guidance from our experts, you'll grasp the latest trends in the legal industry, helping you achieve better results.

13:39For the practice of law, the business of law, the future of law, visit BloombergLaw.com. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg.

14:15to turn into something useful can just become something useful. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting Work Mode, available on Plus and Pro plans. The world of business is constantly evolving. Every day, new challenges, new opportunities, new ways of working. Comcast Business keeps you totally in step with secure AI-backed networking built to power the way modern business gets things done today in more than 100 countries around the world. That's some serious muscle. And get this, Comcast business powers over 90 % of the Fortune 500 and millions of small businesses.

14:59Behind it all, network engineers, cybersecurity specialists, support teams, thousands of experts answering your call at 2 a.m. like it's 2 p.m. Always on, always ready. That's a lot of coffee. One partner powering how business gets done for companies of every size all around the globe. When you add it all up, no one does business like Comcast business. This is Robert Smith from Business History. If you're listening to this, there's a good chance you're a small business owner. And like every small business owner, you started with a dream to do what you love and watch it grow. What you probably didn't dream about?

15:36Keeping up with cyber threats. That's where MasterCard can help, with access to tools that help identify cyber threats to better protect your business. Building your dream business? Priceless. For cybersecurity in a changing world, there's MasterCard. Learn more at MasterCard.com slash smallbusiness. So far as we know, the Department of Correction followed exactly the protocol that was outlined and vetted and approved by the Attorney General's office. Tennessee's Governor Bill Lee has ordered an investigation into the state's capital punishment system after the botched execution of Krista Pike last Wednesday night, the second botched execution in the state this year.

16:20Pike, now 50, was convicted of torturing and killing a teenage classmate in 1995. Prison officials gave Pike two doses of the lethal injection drug pentobarbital, but she survived. She was unconscious and on a ventilator until today when her attorneys say she's awake and speaking. Some of Tennessee's top Republicans have said they want to explore alternative ways of executing condemned prisoners, eyeing potential changes to the state's execution laws during their 2027 session. Joining me is an expert in the death penalty, Bernard Harcourt, a professor at Columbia Law School. In legal filings before her execution date, Pike's attorneys had argued against using Pinobarbital because of a blood disorder she had.

17:13And so the prison was on notice. Maybe I can give you some background first. I represented a man in Alabama in 2018 who had serious problems with venous access. and it was a case that I litigated strenuously through the state and federal courts back in 2017-2018 telling them that they wouldn't find a vein and the execution went forward ultimately and they spent two and a half hours pricking and prodding him in his legs and his groin and they were unable to place a line and so he survived that execution. It was a gruesome ordeal and so So when I heard about the Krista Pike case, and I heard that the attorneys had raised some warnings about the fact that she would have difficult venous access, that her veins were compromised because they were small veins and also because she had a blood condition.

18:12And as I followed the execution, it really felt like deja vu, tragically, of what had happened in Dole Ham's case, but also in a number of other cases recently involving lethal injections. So the attorneys had warned the state, but the state nevertheless went forward, kind of barreled forward, and encountered extreme difficulties. It seems as if, I mean, we don't have a medical examination yet, but it seems as if the catheters, which are intended to enter the veins, actually entered into her flesh rather than into her veins. And that's something that's happened before. It's extremely painful, as Krista Pike was telling the executioners.

19:01But also what it does is it means that the drugs have an effect of reducing the heartbeat and reducing the oxygen that goes to the brain. And so effectively, it seems as if Krista Pike suffered pretty extensive brain damage as a result. So then in this case, it's not that the drugs were bad? It's possible. It's possible that the drugs were degraded. It's possible that basically that their shelf life had passed and that the drugs themselves were degraded. That's the other best explanation for what might have happened. But I'm pretty confident from the reports and having spoken to some of the best doctors who know this business, it's anesthesiologists really who know this business, that it was infiltration.

19:54She repeatedly stated during the execution that her arm was burning, and that is typically associated with infiltration of the drugs into her muscle, into her flesh, rather than into her veins. I mean, that's a classic red flag that what we've got is infiltration. But it is possible that what may also have been partly responsible may have been degraded drugs. So I was shocked in reading about this that, I mean, you don't know where the states are getting these drugs from because the pharmaceutical companies are not making them anymore. And in some instances, they're paying for them in cash. Yeah, it's a very shady business.

20:36Some of the reporting that's been done on this has revealed that, you know, states are obtaining these drugs from these kind of you can't even call them pharmacies, really. It's kind of like these backdoor kind of enterprises that are basically compounding some of this stuff practically illegally, coming from foreign countries where drugs are not regulated. It's a real mess. The drug companies have prohibited states from using their drugs to conduct executions. I mean, you know, these are medical substances that are intended to keep people alive for purposes of health, for purposes sometimes of anesthetics, for purposes of reducing heart rates for people who have a rhythms in their heartbeats and whatnot.

21:23I mean, these are intended to be lifesaving medical drugs. And so the pharmaceuticals have basically said they don't want them used in their executions. Now, some states, despite that prohibition by the drug companies, nevertheless use some of these drugs that they've obtained some way or another from these companies. So the result is that the states do try to obtain these drugs through the shadiest of dealers. And as a result, the quality of the drug itself is highly suspect. But also they have some reserves that the shelf life is passed and they continue to use those anyway. And what about the quality of the person administering the injection?

22:13That's the biggest problem. I mean, the biggest problem here is that the people who are actually trying to achieve venous access are, for the most part, incompetent and not qualified. That's really what makes lethal injection such a problem. If you have a top doctor at a good hospital in the operating room under the ideal conditions of a surgery, it's not hard to place a line. Even with someone who has difficult veins, it's not that hard for someone who's really qualified. Here the executioners have to insert two catheters. These are pretty big catheters. I mean, these aren't like butterfly needles that are used like when we draw blood, but it's done every day in the operating room by talented doctors who, you know, would be able to place a line on practically anybody.

23:07The difference is that these executions are taking place in the dark bowels of some prison somewhere, usually late at night under extremely stressful conditions by people who are essentially unqualified to be trying to place a line. Who is it? Well, usually it's somebody who's kind of like a local EMT, someone who's got emergency EMT training and not a doctor who's in the operating room every day placing line. The reason is, of course, the doctors don't want to be involved in executions because they take a Hippocratic oath. They've taken an oath that they're going to use their skills and their talent and their mission to save lives.

23:50So you are not going to be getting a good doctor willing to do this, right? It's usually just some EMT who maybe has some training, some basic training, but really doesn't know how to do it. Or, you know, in the case of Krista Pike, it's some doctor who hasn't placed a line in something like 13 years. And that kind of person is not going to be able to put in a catheter in someone who's got a difficult venous condition. That's all there's to it. And the result is that we've just seen more and more of these cases where the lethal injection is basically botched. Those cases are torturous ordeals.

24:34Krista Pike's case was not only torturous in terms of trying to insert the needles, and I believe the reports are that there were seven needles that were used. On top of that, of course, was the infiltration of the drugs, which means that she was basically overdosing with this poison and losing consciousness at some point because of lack of blood to the brain. In other cases where there were problems with the administration of the drug, did the state try to execute the defendant again? try to execute those people again for the most part? Yeah, that's a fascinating question. And actually, it takes us back to 1947 in Louisiana, and an incredible situation involving a young man by the name of Willie Francis, who was actually 16, African-American young adolescent, who was 16 when he committed a crime and was accused and convicted, and 17 when he was put to death at that time in 1947.

25:43in Louisiana, they had a mobile electric chair. It was an electric chair that was on the back of a pickup truck, and it was transported to his county. It turned out that the sheriff who was driving the truck was drunk, and so he got his wires crossed, and so Willie Francis was still alive. But the state of Louisiana decided that they were going to execute him again by electrocution, and it went all the way up to the Supreme Court. There was an attorney who took the case pro bono and said, look, you can't execute them again. It would violate double jeopardy. Now, double jeopardy is usually used when you've been acquitted.

26:18If you've actually been acquitted in state court, say, of a charge, you can't be prosecuted again. That would violate double jeopardy. And the attorney's argument was that, you know, they've tried to execute them once and you can't execute them again. Double jeopardy would bar that. That's an interesting argument. And what's more interesting is that what the Supreme Court said was, no, you can go ahead, Louisiana, because it was a complete accident. So there was a Supreme Court case from 1947 where the Supreme Court allows a second execution. However, and of course, this was my argument in Dole Hamm's case, in Dole Hamm's case and in Krista Pike's case, it wasn't an accident.

27:00And that's the point. It wasn't an accident because the state was warned and told that they weren't going to be able to achieve Venus access. In Dolham's case, back in 2017, 2018, I spent seven months litigating this in the state courts, in the federal courts, at the 11th Circuit, up to the United States Supreme Court. I took the position that it would violate double jeopardy because it wasn't an accident. So the Willie Francis logic didn't apply, right? This was the exception, not the rule. I don't think that Krista Pike's, what tragically happened to her was an accident. They were warned, again here, Tennessee was warned that they were going to have a difficult time getting Venus access because of her veins.

27:42So I don't think that it's an accident. As a result, I do think that double jeopardy would preclude a second execution under the United States Supreme Court's decision in the Willie Francis case from 1947. Right now, Pike's attorneys are asking the Tennessee governor to commute Pike's sentence to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Thanks for joining me today. That's Professor Bernard Harcourt of Columbia Law School. His forthcoming book is called A Time to Live, Doyle Ham's Decades-Long Struggle on Death Row. And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember, you can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcast.

28:24You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www.bloomberg.com slash podcast slash law. And remember to tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at 10 p.m. Wall Street time. I'm June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg.

28:46This November 11th at COP31 in Antalya, Bloomberg Green brings together policymakers makers, business leaders, investors, and innovators to examine practical climate solutions for resilience, investment, and the energy transition. Join the conversation exploring the policies, technologies, and investments shaping the global economy. Bloomberg Green at COP31. Learn more at bloomberglive.com forward slash COP31. Bloomberglive.com forward slash COP31.

From the publisher

Bloomberg Supreme Court Reporter Greg Stohr discusses his interview with Justice Samuel Alito. Then death penalty expert Bernard Harcourt, a professor at Columbia Law School, discusses the botched execution of a woman in Tennessee. His upcoming book is entitled, “A Time to Live: Doyle Lee Hamm’s Decades-Long Struggle on Death Row.” June Grasso hosts

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Bloomberg Law

All episodes