1. Podcasts
  2. Bloomberg Law
  3. Trump's Tariffs & Trump's 'Enemies': Jack Smith, James Comey & Letitia James
Bloomberg Law

1 Oct 2026 · 34m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

Trump's Tariffs & Trump's 'Enemies': Jack Smith, James Comey & Letitia James

In short

The episode (Bloomberg Law) covers three legal/political fights tied to President Trump: (1) a U.S. Trade Court challenge to Trump’s “third round” of global tariffs under Trade Act Section 301, arguing the tariffs are a pretext to revive measures struck down by the Supreme Court; (2) congressional hearings targeting former special counsel Jack Smith, focused on claims he subpoenaed members of Congress’ phone/text records and allegedly lied about being in Atlanta for a 2024 Hawks game; and (3) an appeal at the Fourth Circuit over whether interim U.S. attorney Lindsay Halligan was lawfully appointed when she obtained indictments against James Comey and New York AG Letitia James.

Guests

Zoe Tillman (Bloomberg legal reporter; attended U.S. Trade Court hearings); Harold Krent (Chicago-Kent constitutional law professor; comments on Smith hearing); Holly Barker (Bloomberg Law senior reporter; covers Fourth Circuit arguments).

Key claims/examples

forced-labor tariffs based on a single report and “handful” case studies; DOJ lawyers said “neither” subsection governs; judge questioned evidence linking forced-labor goods to U.S. economic burden. Smith perjury trap backfired due to mistaken Hawks vs Iowa Hawkeyes game. Halligan appointment issue: whether Section 546 allows successive 120-day interim appointments; judges worried about an “endless carousel” evading Senate confirmation.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:30

Analyzing Trump's Tariffs

Discussing the legal scrutiny of Trump's tariffs and their implications.

“Some people treat ChatGPT like some kind of smart search engine, and some use it to get work done.”
1:57

Analyzing Trump's Tariffs

Discussing the legal scrutiny of Trump's tariffs and their implications.

“President Trump's signature economic policy is under a judicial microscope again, and the administration faced skeptical questions from a U.S.”
4:25

Legal Arguments Against Tariffs

Exploring the plaintiffs' arguments regarding the legality of tariffs.

“You know, it's not every country in the world, but it's dozens and dozens of countries that they've now sought to impose these tariffs on.”
7:18

Judicial Scrutiny of the Administration

Judges question the Justice Department's interpretation of tariff laws.

“unprecedented, massive investigation, it only took two and a half months, where in the past, a single investigation might take seven months, that none of this is the way it's supposed to go under the law.”
10:59

Future Implications and Appeals

Discussing potential outcomes and implications for businesses regarding tariffs.

“But the judges really seem to be looking for more analysis connecting all the threads of information that the administration had proffered as the reason these tariffs were needed.”
14:00

Legal Challenges on Tariffs

Discussion on a legal challenge regarding tariffs and business refunds.

“But the idea, you know, the challenger said is they wanted a ruling that this is unlawful and that would open the door for other businesses to come in and get their refunds challenge it, what have you.”
16:53

Jack Smith's Congressional Testimony

Analysis of Jack Smith's testimony and Republican reactions.

“Our investigation developed proof beyond a reasonable doubt that President Trump engaged in serious crimes against our nation.”
24:29

Consequences for Jack Smith

Discussion on potential repercussions for Jack Smith by the Trump administration.

“And I hope that if there is a shift in the midterm, it just doesn't repeat itself.”
25:28

Legal Barriers and Future Actions

Exploration of the legal barriers surrounding the investigation into Jack Smith.

“You have the New York Attorney General Letitia James.”
29:45

Trump's Legal Battles Against Political Enemies

An overview of President Trump's legal attempts against Letitia James and James Comey.

“You may remember back in October when Comey was charged for allegedly lying to Congress about whether he had ever authorized leaks to the media, and James was charged for a supposed mortgage fraud scheme.”
Show all 14 chapters
30:25

The Fourth Circuit Court Case Explained

Discussion on whether Lindsay Halligan's appointment was lawful and its implications.

“The Trump administration is attempting to revive those prosecutions at the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals.”
31:39

Judges' Concerns Over Endless Appointments

Judges express skepticism over the government's interpretation of the statute allowing multiple appointments.

“So the question of whether Halligan was lawfully appointed revolves around whether or not the statute allows the attorney general to make successive 120-day appointments of NRM attorney generals.”
33:49

Arguments Surrounding Indictments and Ratification

Exploration of the arguments concerning the validity of the indictments and potential remedies.

“The panel of three judges were two Obama appointees and one was a Trump appointee.”
36:53

Federal Vacancies Reform Act Insights

Examining how the Federal Vacancies Reform Act applies to the current legal situation involving U.S. attorneys.

“presidential appointment and Senate confirmation.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Bloomberg Law, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01Who says Americans don't build big things anymore? Through innovation, Venture Global is not only building some of the largest energy facilities in the world right here in the United States, but delivering American energy at a fraction of the cost and a fraction of the time. So while others are busy talking, we're busy building. That's Venture Global. That's unstoppable energy.

0:30Some people treat ChatGPT like some kind of smart search engine, and some use it to get work done. ChatGPT Work is a new way of working in ChatGPT that can take action across your apps and files, stay with a project for hours if needed, and turn a goal into finished work. It's designed to help you move from a chaotic starting point to a reviewable first version. So all the source materials, briefs, and scattered information that you have to grind through to turn into something useful can just become something useful. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting Work Mode, available on Plus and Pro plans.

1:12If you listen to financial news, you know a lot of time to spend thinking about what's next. The next opportunity. The next investment. The next move. But sometimes what matters most is being ready for what you never saw coming. For more than 75 years, Cincinnati Insurance has worked with independent agents to help protect businesses, homes, valuables, and more. Because planning for the future isn't only about knowing what's next. It's about making sure you're ready for what you can't predict. Let Cincinnati Insurance make your bad day better. Find an independent agent at CINFIN.com. This is Bloomberg Law with June Grosso from Bloomberg Radio.

1:57President Trump's signature economic policy is under a judicial microscope again, and the administration faced skeptical questions from a U.S. trade court about the legal foundation underpinning Trump's latest round of global tariffs. Trump's tariffs have faced a rocky legal path, And one of the questions facing the judge is whether the tariffs under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 were a pretext to revive earlier global tariffs that the Supreme Court struck down. Joining me is Bloomberg legal reporter Zoe Tillman. She attended the hearings at the U.S. Trade Court yesterday. Zoe, explain which tariffs are an issue in this case.

2:42So every time I say I'm going to court for tariffs, someone says to me, I thought that was done. And I say, no, there are more tariffs. So this is the third round of, you know, what we often refer to as global tariffs that President Trump has sought to impose. There was the first round that was last year under international economic emergency powers law. Supreme Court said he couldn't do that. So then they announced what was inherently a temporary set, but again, of global tariffs under a different legal authority called Section 122, but those were always going to be short term. They have a time limit under the statute, so everyone knew there was a date, expiration date on those.

3:24In the meantime, they announced they were launching investigations under what's known as Section 301, which has to do with trade practices that hurt U.S. commerce and the U.S. economy. And they announced they were investigating I think dozens of countries for this, which the statute requires. It can't just be all of a sudden you wake up and decide to do it. So they announced an investigation. And on the day that the temporary tariffs expire, they say, we've finished our investigation. We've determined that these 60 economies covering 86, I believe, countries, because they count the EU as one economy, they all have unfair practices.

4:06And specifically, they don't do enough to deal with forced labor in the goods that they import, which in turn hurts the U.S. economy because it undercuts U.S. goods in their trade around the world because we combat forced labor, other countries don't. So what we're now dealing with is the third set of tariffs. You know, it's not every country in the world, but it's dozens and dozens of countries that they've now sought to impose these tariffs on. Small businesses, Democratic states sued. Tell us what the argument of the plaintiffs is. So the overarching argument is that this is all a pretext, that courts keep knocking down the tariffs that President Trump wants to impose.

4:51And so they are searching for any legal authority that they can find to do it, regardless of whether it's the intended or valid use of that legal authority. So that's their sort of sweeping argument here, that whatever they say they're doing, whatever reason they're giving to do it, is significantly undermined by the fact that Trump himself and other high-level officials have said, this is the alternative to the tariffs that we have been unable to keep in place otherwise. Otherwise, it's worth noting that the emergency powers tariffs were in place for months and months while the case was litigated.

5:28So they were collecting, I think it's something like 130 plus billion dollars in tariffs. They collected those when they lost in the Supreme Court. They've now had to spend months refunding that money back to businesses. So, you know, they were able to enforce those tariffs for a period of time. They lost. They've had to give all that money back. They collected more tariffs under the stopgap measures. Those were still in litigation when they expired. And now these new tariffs are in place. So they've sort of been able to do it just in fits and starts and getting knocked down significantly earlier this year.

6:02So that's a broad argument. Drilling down, and really what the hearing yesterday focused mostly on, were the arguments that this is just not what the statute and what Congress intended, that under Section 301, there are certain guidelines for what the U.S. trade representative has to show, what he has to do in order to impose these tariffs. And what the challengers say is that the way that they've gone about it, issuing a single report saying based on a handful of case studies, the economic principles at play here for how forced labor may implicate the U.S. economy, because many other countries import these types of goods where we know forced labor is an issue, applying these principles broadly, they all should be subject to tariffs.

6:52And the challengers say, no, no, this is not what's supposed to happen. It's supposed to be country by country. There's supposed to be unique, specific investigations and country-specific findings, not only that there's forced labor in their import of goods, but that that poses a burden on the U.S. economy and how. And so there's all these different steps that are supposed to be followed. And the challengers say that the way this administration did it, unprecedented, massive investigation, it only took two and a half months, where in the past, a single investigation might take seven months, that none of this is the way it's supposed to go under the law.

7:29And that's really the core of the challenge and what the judges focused on at the hearing yesterday. I mean, does the trade rep or the administration claim that they actually investigated all these countries in that short period of time? They do. They say that the trade representative, Jameson Greer, has broad discretion in making these types of determinations and that they essentially checked the boxes that they needed to. They provided an appendix showing that these different economies do import the types of goods that can be at issue when we're talking about industries where forced labor is a problem.

8:08No one is disputing that forced labor is a problem. It's not sort of in question here. So they say, you know, then applying these economic principles broadly, if you look at case studies involving, for instance, China importing Brazilian beef where there's a forced labor issue. And then, you know, that beef circulates in a way around the world that undercuts the U.S. beef imports that, you know, there's a implication there that you can apply these broadly and that they've done enough to satisfy the statute. Now, the challengers say, OK, but you exempted Brazilian beef from the tariffs. So that case study doesn't quite hold up the way that the government says it does.

8:48It's something that came up yesterday. But there's really this back and forth about how much detailed, specific analysis and concrete analysis. The challengers say this can't be a may hurt the U.S. economy. It can't be a likely to hurt the U.S. economy. They have to show it does and how. So at each step, the challengers say it's not enough. And at each step, the government says we did enough to satisfy the statute. Were there certain areas or questions that the judges concentrated on? Yeah. So they gave not a lot of time to the pretext argument. There were questions at the beginning about it. They wanted to test the waters on that a bit with the challengers.

9:33They didn't ask the government any questions about that. It's always hard to predict, but might mean that they're not super focused on it. On the more core legal questions, though, the lawyer for the Justice Department faced some very skeptical questions from the judges about how they were reading and interpreting the statute. where during one notable exchange, one of the judges was asking, you know, there are two subsections here that define unreasonable trade practices. The trade rep is supposed to base his decisions on one. Which one? And DOJ lawyers said, neither. And judge was sort of astonished and said, I don't understand.

10:12And they went back and forth. And the Justice Department lawyer said, we just disagree with your interpretation of the structure of this law and what's required. And there were a couple exchanges like that where there just seemed to be a disconnect between how the judges were thinking about this case and the Justice Department's interpretation of the law here. Always with the caveat that questions and arguments don't always predict what judges are thinking or how they're going to rule. But it did seem like they at least had a lot of questions about how the Justice Department was doing this. And they made some comments suggesting that they weren't quite sold on it yet.

10:48One of the judges pointed out that there was not a lot of depth in the evidence the administration cited to show how it determines certain goods were affected by forced labor. Right. There was a lot of discussion of lists of evidence in an appendix that was submitted along with the trade representative's report that listed, you know, all the countries that were subject to these tariffs and saying, you know, here are the goods that they import. But the judges really seem to be looking for more analysis connecting all the threads of information that the administration had proffered as the reason these tariffs were needed.

11:23You know, it's one thing to say, well, these countries import goods that we know are implicated by forced labor, but they were wondering what is the evidence that that is what's happening? What is the evidence that these goods from this country are coming to the United States and burdening U.S. commerce and the U.S. economy? So I think they were pushing the Justice Department lawyer to pull more of these things together and explain how they had done a sufficient, specific enough analysis to justify these tariffs against each economy. So is it possible that the judges could give the trade rep a chance to fix the gaps in the record?

12:04Yes. That was another notable exchange or several exchanges during the hearing in discussing what the remedy could be if they determined that the record just wasn't clear. Do they go back and give them more time to essentially try again? Do they just say, this is just not enough? And if you need to reopen the record to do better, then that means that this was a loss for you and you can't keep this case indefinitely delayed to do that. And the lawyer for the challenges, Pratik Shah, he explicitly told the judges that he would rather that his clients lose and be able to take this up on appeal than have it go back to the trade rep and leave the case in limbo.

12:47Obviously, you know, he thinks they should win and he certainly wasn't conceding anything. But the idea was that they don't want this dragging out for months and months and months while these tariffs are still in effect. They want clarity. Everyone, you know, I think the implicit acknowledgement was that this is probably going to go back up on appeal, probably going to end up in the Supreme Court, especially if the government loses again. So they don't want this to drag out the$130 billion in emergency economic powers tariffs that were collected before the Supreme Court said those tariffs were unlawful.

13:19The business community does not want that again. They don't want to pay$130 billion in tariffs and then deal with refunds a year down the line. There's not an appetite for that. So I think the suggestion was, give us a ruling on the law and let us move forward. It's worth saying that it's also not clear how broad a ruling might be. The judges discussed whether they could issue relief beyond the businesses that sued, whether they could issue relief that applied to tariffs beyond the countries that these small businesses import goods from. This is stemming from a ruling from the Supreme Court last year that really narrowed the ability of courts to issue sweeping injunctions that apply far beyond the parties in a case.

14:06But the idea, you know, the challenger said is they wanted a ruling that this is unlawful and that would open the door for other businesses to come in and get their refunds challenge it, what have you. So the short-term relief, even if they win, might be pretty narrow. It might just be that these businesses don't have to pay tariffs, not all businesses, but it would kick off litigation that everyone seems to acknowledge needs to happen to get a final legal ruling on whether these are okay. And we have no idea when the trade court will come down with its decision. Thanks so much, Zoe. That's Bloomberg Legal Reporter Zoe Tillman.

14:40Some people treat ChatGPT like some kind of smart search engine, and some use it to get work done. ChatGPT Work is a new way of working in ChatGPT that can take action across your apps and files, stay with a project for hours if needed, and turn a goal into finished work. It's designed to help you move from a chaotic starting point to a reviewable first version. So all the source materials, briefs, and scattered information that you have to grind through to turn into something useful can just become something useful. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting Work Mode, available on Plus and Pro plans.

15:24Hey, what's up, guys? It's Haley Bailey. Okay, I need to tell you about something. I just got YouTube Premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads so I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have Wi-Fi because we all know airplane Wi-Fi is the worst. I get ad free, I get background play, and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Try it now for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Hi, I'm Sean Evans from Hot Ones, and I want to tell you about YouTube Premium.

16:00It has offline downloads, so you can watch without Wi-Fi. Background play, so you can lock your phone, and it still plays, baby. Oh, and it is completely ad-free. Yes, I said it, ad-free. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel any time. Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Jewel Osco. It's time to stock up and save now through October 27th. Get$10 off when you spend$25 or more on participating items. Just look for participating item tags to earn on eligible items from brands like Chobani, Banquet, Pete's Coffee, Triscuit, and Ice Mountain.

16:42Clip once and save through October 27th every time you shop. Grab these hot deals before they're gone. Save on brands you trust. Restrictions apply. See website for full terms and conditions. In testimony before Congress, former special counsel Jack Smith stood by his prosecutions of President Trump for trying to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election and for storing classified documents at his Mar-a-Lago estate. Our investigation developed proof beyond a reasonable doubt that President Trump engaged in serious crimes against our nation. If asked whether to prosecute a former president today based on the same facts, I would do so regardless of whether that president was a Republican or a Democrat.

17:32But Republican senators were more interested in accusing Smith of abusing his power by subpoenaing Republicans' phone records and texts. Some, like Louisiana Senator John Kennedy, attacked Smith personally. You make me want to throw up in my mouth. But the questioning that drew the most attention was when Missouri Republican Senator Eric Schmidt tried to catch Smith perjuring himself about attending a Hawks game in Atlanta in 2024. What would you say if I had a series of text messages from your team that said you were in Atlanta at a Warrior Hawks game on February 3rd, 2024, the day after Willis and Wade announced their affair?

18:12Smith denied meeting Atlanta. Smith denied meeting Atlanta prosecutor Fonnie Willis, who was investigating Trump, and said he wasn't in Atlanta at the time. I recall going to a University of Maryland basketball game where Caitlin Clark was playing right around that time. And the Marshal Service was there with me. You could check if that was the exact date. It was Maryland playing Iowa. It turns out Schmidt had confused an Iowa Hawkeyes basketball game for an Atlanta Hawks game. But he never retracted his statements about perjury or calling Smith a dirtbag. Joining me is an expert in constitutional law.

18:57How what was the purpose or point of this hearing? I mean, the hearing seems to cover the similar ground of the administration trying to embarrass or go after or trip up political enemies. And clearly, Jack Smith, the special counsel who headed the investigations into whether Trump committed crimes, is a figure that attracts resentment and hatred amongst the MAGA faithful. He stood by his decision to prosecute the president. Was much of the hearing on his basis for prosecuting the president? Or was it more about the Republicans being upset about his obtaining their phone records and text messages?

19:43The focal point really was on the fact that Republicans felt that Smith embarrassed members of Congress by looking at their phone records. There was a relevance here. The relevance was that Jack Smith wanted to see whether outside agitators were trying to call members of Congress to upset the electoral vote at the time after the election for Biden. And so it's relevant. But on the other hand, it is an extraordinary measure to subpoena the phone records of members of Congress. They felt their privacy was invaded. They felt that some of their contacts should not be disclosed to the outside world.

20:21So it created that very deep tension. And, you know, in retrospect, maybe even though the records could have been relevant to an investigation, Maybe Jack Smith should have stayed his hand and not requested those and obtained those very private records of calls that members of Congress had. Now, interestingly, some of the interlocutors said that Smith violated the speech and debate clause by grabbing these records. And I have to say that's a frivolous argument. And I'm quite surprised that members of Congress would relate that. All the speech and debate clause does is protect members of Congress from being prosecuted for what they say on the congressional floor.

21:04These calls were not on the congressional floor and there was no prosecution. So simply, it's not relevant. But that was some significant discussion of that in the hearings as well. Could Smith be prosecuted for what he did? You know, he got a judge's permission, right? But he said that he didn't tell the judge it was for members of Congress. I don't think that he could be prosecuted for that. At least in retrospect, we have to remember there's been a lot of time there's there's a great crisis back around January 6th. But, you know, again, maybe history will say that that was a good move, but certainly it's not a crime.

21:39Maybe history will say that that was a good move, but certainly it's not a crime. Do you think it was unethical what he did? I think it was questionable judgment. I mean, again, going back to the time frame, we were really worried that there was a conspiracy to overthrow the government and that members of Congress would refuse to count all the electoral votes. And so, you know, Jack Smith wanted to unearth that at the time. And so to say, if there was this great conspiracy, we have to reveal it now and punish it. And, you know, I don't think the conspiracy was as wide as he feared. But I think that in terms of using his powers to get the phone records, again, at least with the comfort of history, was excessive and probably was a questionable judgment.

22:24Not unethical, not illegal, but a questionable judgment. The focus in reports about this hearing ended up being on Schmidt trying to set a perjury trap for Smith, which fell apart. Well, the whole idea of calling Jack Smith in front of Congress was, as in other cases, was to create a perjury trap. And what Senator Schmidt started out by trying to suggest that there was some conspiracy between Fannie Willis, as you mentioned, the Georgia prosecutor and Jack Smith, turned out to be kind of a comic part of the hearing because it turns out that Schmidt had the wrong basketball game and that there were even witnesses placing Jack Smith at a woman's Hawkeye game.

23:09so they could watch Caitlin Clark as opposed to in Georgia at that time. So that one backfired badly, but it does reveal the weaponization and the political nature of this whole inquiry. And, you know, the rhetoric from Republicans was just over the top. You had Senator John Kennedy saying, you make me want to throw up in my mouth. And Ted Cruz was talking about Les Mis. I mean, it was just so over the top. Well, I think that was Senator Tillis, the Republican, who commented well that we have to understand the dangers and the risks of politicizing this process. And I think he was right on the money.

23:49And in case we have a shift in the midterms, I think we have to give serious thought so that the Democrats, if they're in charge, don't just give vent to the same kind of base impulses as the Republicans did. I've already heard leading Democrats say, of course, the first thing we're going to do is impeach as many people as we can. And this kind of tit for tat is not good for the country. And I think we need to think of a different process, a different way to explore the past through commissions or other kinds of means so that we can get to what governing demands, which is some kind of compromise across party lines.

24:27We're not close to that now. And this kind of theater that we saw with the questioning of Smith is some of the worst kind of theater. And I hope that if there is a shift in the midterm, it just doesn't repeat itself. The Republicans are repeatedly complaining that the Biden administration weaponized the Justice Department. But the Trump Justice Department is weaponized against his perceived enemies. And obviously, this is a constant refrain under the Trump administration and the Trump DOJ, go after people like Comey, go after people like Jack Smith and more. And it just doesn't leave the country any better.

25:08And so I hope that if there is a shift, that some lessons from these kinds of waste of energy and this venom and this anger, we can try to mute it. So Smith said he expects to face personal consequences. He believes the Trump administration will do everything in its power to try to build a case against him. He's one of the top on Trump's list. You have Comey. You have the New York Attorney General Letitia James. You have Jack Smith. We can't forget Jerome Powell. Well, they tried and failed on Jerome Powell so far. And also, when he testified before the House, there was also that kind of perjury trap effort.

25:46And Jim Jordan referred Smith to the Justice Department for potential prosecution without going through a full vote of the House, saying he lied to Congress. So is it just a question of when Smith is going to be indicted or is there a question of if? I think there's a question of death. I mean, the Trump administration has moved very aggressively, as we talked about, against Patricia James, against Comey, against Jerome Powell. And it's gone much slower against Jack Smith, which suggests that they're having trouble with unearthing some kind of theory that at least looks good in the newspapers of nowhere else.

26:25So I don't think it's a foregone conclusion. It could happen. And obviously, this was an effort to make it happen by laying the perjury traps, as you suggested. But I don't think it's a done deal for sure. Their grand conspiracy investigation in Florida, the judge overseeing that is Eileen Cannon, the Trump appointee who dismissed the classified documents case and consistently ruled in favor of Trump. She was even overturned twice by the 11th Circuit. Smith said he couldn't talk about some things because the final report he drafted about the classified documents case, she has permanently barred the report's release and blocked officials from discussing it.

27:09But I suppose no one in the Justice Department is going to appeal that at this point. I think that's right. And so until another administration, everything that Eileen Cannon blocked, she's blocking. And we'll have to wait to see if the Justice Department moves against Smith. Thanks so much, Hal. That's Professor Harold Krent of the Chicago-Kent College of Law.

27:50starting point to a reviewable first version. So all the source materials, briefs, and scattered information that you have to grind through to turn into something useful can just become something useful. Put ChatGPT to work on your most ambitious ideas and projects. Get started at chatgpt.com by selecting Work Mode, available on Plus and Pro plans. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. It's DeStroying, athlete creator and youtube maxer youtube premium enhances how i use youtube with awesome features like offline downloads so i can download my favorite training videos before i hit the gym so no wi-fi doesn't turn leg day into loading day plus i get ad-free videos background play and so much more youtube premium it's like youtube got some extra gains try youtube premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium hey what's up guys it's hayley bailey okay i need to tell you about something.

28:47I just got YouTube Premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads so I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have Wi-Fi because we all know airplane Wi-Fi is the worst. I get ad free, I get backroom play, and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. So try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel anytime. That's a mouthful. Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Jewel Osco. It's time to stock up and save now through October 27th.

29:19Get$10 off when you spend$25 or more on participating items. Just look for participating item tags to earn on eligible items from brands like Chobani, Banquet, Pete's Coffee, Triscuit, and Ice Mountain. Clip once and save through October 27th every time you shop. Grab these hot deals before they're gone. Save on brands you trust. Restrictions apply. See website for full terms and conditions. New York Attorney General Letitia James and former FBI Director James Comey were the earliest targets of President Trump's push to have the Justice Department prosecute his perceived political enemies. You may remember back in October when Comey was charged for allegedly lying to Congress about whether he had ever authorized leaks to the media, and James was charged for a supposed mortgage fraud scheme.

30:12Last fall, a judge dismissed both cases after concluding that Trump loyalist Lindsay Halligan had been unlawfully serving as interim U.S. attorney in the Eastern District of Virginia when she secured indictments against Comey and James. Well, that case is not over. The Trump administration is attempting to revive those prosecutions at the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals. Joining me is Bloomberg Law senior reporter Holly Barker. Holly, tell us about the issue before the Fourth Circuit. So the appeal before the Fourth Circuit boils down to whether Lindsay Halligan, the former interim U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia, was lawfully appointed when she obtained indictments of James Comey and Letitia James, and if not, whether the appropriate remedy was dismissal of the indictments against them.

31:06The first question, whether Halligan was lawfully appointed, turns on whether the statute that authorized the appointment, which is Section 546, authorized the attorney general to make successive 120-day appointments. The statute at issue allows the AG to appoint an interim U.S. attorney for a period of 120 days. The question is whether or not they can do that more than once. once they've appointed somebody and they've served that 120-day term, can they then appoint another U.S. attorney to fill that position? So the question of whether Halligan was lawfully appointed revolves around whether or not the statute allows the attorney general to make successive 120-day appointments of NRM attorney generals.

31:53In this case, Halligan's predecessor, Eric Siebert, had already served out a 120-day term after being appointed by then attorney General Pam Bondi, plus a few months as the district court's interim appointee. The district court here was Judge Cameron McGowan-Curray of the District of South Carolina. He was sitting by designation for the Eastern District of Virginia. Passed the indictments because he said that that wasn't allowed. The statute doesn't allow the attorney general to make a second, third, fourth, fifth, 120-day appointment under the statute. In Curry's view and in the defendant's view, once the 120 days are up, the statute shifts power to the district court to make any further interim U.S.

32:33attorney appointments. During the oral arguments, the chief judge, Albert Diaz, said that the Trump administration's interpretation would allow the Department of Justice to make a limitless number of interim appointments, and that would evade the Senate's authority to approve U.S. attorneys. That's right. He was skeptical of the government's reading for that reason. He pointed out, you know, he used the phrase endless carousel, which I think he borrowed from the district court, an endless carousel of interim appointees, which would basically enable the AG to forever dodge presidential appointment and Senate confirmation.

33:11You know, very early on the argument, he said, how can that be? Later in the argument, you know, the government had sort of said, well, but the incentives are such that the executive is going to want to work with the district court. And, you know, I think that was seemed to be cold comfort to Diaz. You know, he said at some point under your reading of the statute, you know, that's the logical conclusion is sort of the carousel thing that on quote day 119 continue with succession of appointments, thereby essentially cutting off the district court in the sentence, advice and consent power. Under your reading of the statute, a nefarious ne 'er-do-well executive could do just that.

33:48So Diaz seemed reluctant to adopt a reading that would enable this kind of misconduct, even if the incentives in the government's view would foster cooperation between the executive and the judiciary. The panel of three judges were two Obama appointees and one was a Trump appointee. So Chief Judge Diaz is an Obama appointee. The other judge who was an Obama appointee on the panel was Senior Judge Henry Floyd. He was also skeptical of the Justice Department's argument. And then Judge Julius Richardson, a Trump appointee, seemed to be leaning in the government's direction. Was he doing a textualist reading of the statute?

34:31Richardson was heavily fixated on the statutory text. The judges also discussed whether if they find that Halligan's appointment was defective, whether dismissing the indictments would be the remedy. The court did spend some time talking about remedies and what the correct fix was and also whether or not sort of in real time the government was able to cure, you know, any defective indictment to the extent their appointment was defective. The first argument is that she was an attorney for the government. So for purposes of the federal rules of criminal procedure, she was authorized to appear before the grand jury.

35:13So her title really doesn't matter. The second argument is ratifications. And the judges did spend a fair amount of time on this particular issue. So the idea is that the government claims that Bondi retroactively designated Halligan as a special attorney. And so that cured any defect in her initial appointment. And they also say that because Bondi had the authority to indict James and Comey when they were indicted, that she can basically retroactively ratify Halligan's actions. And some of the argument about ratification revolved around laws of principle and agency. And one of the points that defense counsel made was, you know, is this concept that really is sort of a civil concept be imported into a context where somebody's freedom is at stake?

36:03The third argument that the government raised that the indictments can stand is the de facto officer doctrine. And it's basically that Halligan was performing official duties under the cover of authority. So not all of her actions should be invalidated. And their final argument was that the error was harmless. So even if the appointment was flawed, the grand jury's decision to indict was independent and should be respected. At some point, and I think much more than once, the government was using the phrase strong medicine. when talking about dismissal of the indictments as a cure. And so we should mention that the Trump administration has been trying to install loyalists in this way in many U.S.

36:45attorneys' offices across the country. And other appellate courts have ruled against the Trump administration. So three courts of appeals have weighed in on Trump's apparent efforts to sort of get around presidential appointment and Senate confirmation. But the three circuit courts that have weighed in, which are the second, the ninth, and the third, they were ruling on the attorney general's appointments under a different statute called the Federal Vacancies Reform Act. And that's a totally different mechanism for temporarily filling these seats. So those decisions, you know, aren't going to control this one.

37:25That said, not that they would anyway, because they're sister courts, but they were dealing with a different substantive issue. Still, they sort of signal this reluctance among federal appellate courts to embrace any sort of approach to this that would threaten to indefinitely circumvent presidential appointment and Senate confirmation. It's hard for me to see this as anything but trying to avoid getting the Senate's advice and consent. Yeah, it's interesting. So it's like sort Sort of, Halligan, they screwed up because they just, they didn't know what they were doing yet. And they sort of refined their approach to getting around Senate confirmation after Comey and James raised their objections to the indictments.

38:11You know, Section 546 might not work. So they got smarter after that. So these other three circuits, the second, the third, and the ninth, what the government was doing was under the Federal Vacancies Reform Act, the first assistant, somebody with the title of first assistant, automatically assumes the duties of the U.S. attorney when that seat becomes vacant. so instead of some of the president appointing a new u.s attorney for senate confirmation what they were doing instead was appointing a first assistant after the the u.s attorney seat was already vacant and they would just sit there below the u.s attorney seat but perform all of the functions so it's a different kind of workaround it's i think some courts have referred to it as a first assistant workaround.

39:03And what they've said is no, the statute doesn't contemplate that the vacancy will open up and that you can then appoint a first assistant who will then assume that role and responsibility. That automatic succession only happens if that first assistant is already in place when the seat is vacated. And it sounds like the Fourth Circuit, the majority of the Fourth Circuit panel was skeptical of the government's argument here. Thanks so much, Holly. That's Bloomberg Law senior reporter Holly Barker. And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Show. Remember, you can always get the latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcast.

39:42You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www.bloomberg.com slash podcast slash law. And remember to tune into the Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at 10 p.m. Wall Street time. I'm June Grosso, and you're listening to Bloomberg.

40:03Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Jewel Osco. It's time to stock up and save now through October 27th. Get$10 off when you spend$25 or more on participating items. Just look for participating item tags to earn on eligible items from brands like Chobani, Banquet, Pete's Coffee, Triscuit, and Ice Mountain. Clip once and save through October 27th every time you shop. Grab these hot deals before they're gone. Save on brands you trust. restrictions apply see website for full terms and conditions.

40:59Tech London.

From the publisher

Zoe Tillman, Bloomberg legal reporter, discusses a US trade court questioning the legal foundation of President Trump’s latest round of global tariffs. Then constitutional law professor Harold Krent of the Chicago-Kent College of Law, discusses former Special Counsel Jack Smith’s testimony before the Senate Judiciary Committee. And Holly Barker, Bloomberg Law senior reporter, discusses the Justice Department’s bid to revive criminal charges against New York Attorney General Letitia James and former FBI Director James Comey. June Grasso.

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Bloomberg Law

All episodes