In short
Breaking Points episode covering Trump’s claimed “nationwide crackdown” on D.C. crime via National Guard and federal takeover of the Metropolitan Police, plus Israel-Gaza controversy over aid starvation and the killing of Al Jazeera journalists, alongside economic and culture-war items.
Guests
Ward 4 Councilmember Janice Lewis-George (D.C. council; endorsed by DSA; previously represented by Muriel Bowser in Ward 4). Also discussed: Ambassador Mike Huckabee (interviewed by Piers Morgan; former U.S. ambassador to Israel).
Guest backgrounds
Lewis-George is a D.C. local elected official focused on home rule and budgets affecting public safety, education, and human services. Huckabee is a political figure and ambassador whose Gaza comments are defended/criticized on the show.
Key claims
D.C. crime is down (violent crime down 35% YoY; “30-year low” cited), so the “emergency” rationale is questioned. Federal forces are portrayed as doing show-of-force rather than targeted policing. Lewis-George argues for court challenges to Section 740 emergency grounds and warns of losing home rule. Huckabee denies Gaza starvation and defends “aid” distribution sites (GHF) as opposed by Hamas; he also argues Al Jazeera journalist killings were justified if linked to Hamas.
Notable examples
National Guard/DEA/FBI/Secret Service presence at D.C. incidents (e.g., mall/jogging patrol; Rock Creek Park moped/run stoppage). D.C. budget “missing billion dollars” affecting health, public safety, education, and human services. Gaza: claims of massacres at aid distribution sites; Al Jazeera journalist Anas al-Sharif allegedly targeted as Hamas-linked.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOIndependent Media Impact
2:07 to 2:21
Discussion on the role of independent media in elections.
“Independent media just played a truly massive role in this election, and we are so excited about what that means for the future of this show.”
Trump's D.C. Takeover
2:40 to 4:04
Overview of Trump's claims about crime in D.C. and his plans.
“Good morning and welcome to Breaking Points.”
Crime Statistics Discussion
4:04 to 4:24
Analysis of crime statistics in D.C. and related cities.
“So you definitely want to stick around for that, Ryan.”
Historical Context of Crime in D.C.
4:24 to 6:10
A look at the history of crime and gentrification in D.C.
“I mean, as as you pointed out, I'm not sure how many people really took seriously their undying devotion to sports and interest which had never been exhibited in the past.”
Federal Intervention Absurdities
6:10 to 8:20
Discussion on the absurdities of federal law enforcement responses.
“President, thank you for caring about our Capitol.”
Crime Causes and Context
8:20 to 11:00
Exploration of sociocultural factors impacting crime rates.
“Anyway, then yes, we are a much more violent nation than pretty much any other country in the world.”
Future Implications of Trump's Policies
11:00 to 14:01
Concerns over Trump's plans for other cities and potential implications.
“Like, you know, this was the scene in D.C.”
Trump's Threat and Military Response
14:01 to 19:22
Discussion on Trump's statements about using military forces in U.S. cities.
“and we're going to clean it up real quick, very quickly, as they say.”
D.C. Councilmember's Perspective
20:58 to 28:00
Interview with Janice Lewis-George discussing Trump's actions and D.C.'s legal position.
“The definition of what is a movie has kind of changed anyway, too, right?”
Navigating Legal Challenges to Autonomy
28:00 to 29:00
Discussion around the legal avenues and political strategies for D.C.'s autonomy amidst federal pressures.
“You know, let's have conversations, which we have to have.”
Show all 19 chapters
Concerns Over National Guard Deployment
29:00 to 30:50
Exploration of the National Guard's role and the impact of federal presence on local communities.
“In addition to that, let's be honest, the real threat fear here is that we would lose home rule, which gives us this ability to have autonomy.”
Impact of Budget Cuts on D.C.
30:50 to 35:50
Analysis of how budget cuts affect essential city services like education and public safety.
“I think that lesson should have been learned pretty well at this point.”
Pandemic Lockdowns and Their Long-term Effects
35:50 to 39:50
Discussion on the lasting impact of pandemic-related school closures on youth in D.C.
“it's so hypocritical because you're cutting the same budgets that support public safety, human services, and those things that you say we need to clean up and fix as a city.”
Casual Banter on Pop Culture
42:00 to 42:50
The hosts engage in light-hearted banter about pop culture references.
“It's images and words being spoken, captured by some sort of technology.”
Discussion on Gaza Starvation
42:50 to 46:21
The hosts discuss Mike Huckabee's interview about starvation in Gaza and its implications.
“Piers Morgan hosted a pretty extraordinary, I would say, interview with our ambassador to Israel, the one and only Mike Huckabee.”
Analysis of Media and War Reporting
46:21 to 49:18
The hosts analyze the assassination of journalists in Gaza and the implications for press freedom.
“you know, briefing him for his upcoming shift.”
The Ethics of Targeting Journalists
49:18 to 53:26
A deep discussion on the ethics surrounding the targeting of journalists in conflict zones.
“I also would point there are photos where this alleged journalist is hugging the head of Hamas and smiling and yucking it up for the cameras.”
Double Tap Strikes Explained
53:26 to 56:00
The hosts explain the concept of double tap strikes used in military operations and their consequences.
“And that's what people do for the most part.”
Gaza City Journalists Under Threat
56:00 to 1:02:38
Discussion on the dangers facing journalists in Gaza City amid military actions.
“And while he's walking around, seeing who's OK, you know, what are the injuries, what's going on?”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Ryan Grim:This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. What if the freshest thing you ate this summer didn't come from a store? Meet Garden. Garden is the smart indoor home-growing system that grows flavorful greens, herbs, fruit, and vegetables right in your kitchen. No backyard, no experience, no grocery run required. Garden automatically balances water and light, so nutrient-dense produce is always within reach. heading out this summer Kelby garden's AI plant assistant keeps your garden thriving while you're away so you can come home to a harvest with garden your lettuce isn't days old from a truck it's alive crisp and inches from your plate fuel your summer from the inside out visit mygarden.com that's my g-a-r-d-y-n dot com hey Portlandia fans Carrie Brownstein and Fred Armisen here the dream of the 90s is alive in podcast form We're launching Podlandia, AO Rewatch, our brand new podcast where we revisit every episode of Portlandia together, breaking down sketches, going deep on our iconic characters, and pulling back the curtain on how it all got made.
1:07Ryan Grim:And we'll also be joined by the people who helped bring it all to life. Guest stars, collaborators, and friends, including director Jonathan Kreisel, the mayor himself, Kyle McLaughlin, legendary musician Amy Mann, and many more. Kyle is going for it here. You fully improvised, not just words, but a song. Well, I thought you were all going to write a song. I remember you thinking that. Listen to Podlandia, AAO Rewatch on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:38Hey, this is Hayes Davenport. And Sean Clemens. We host the podcast Hollywood Handbook. Every episode, we're trying to help our guests improve their careers by mainly focusing on how they can help us improve our careers. The show is famously super accessible, so you can easily jump into any of our 650 episodes and understand what's going on. We recommend some of our recent episodes with Ben Stiller, Danny McBride, Riz Ahmed, and Mary Steenburgen. Listen to Hollywood Handbook on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Hey guys, Sagar and Crystal here.
2:08Ryan Grim:Independent media just played a truly massive role in this election, and we are so excited about what that means for the future of this show. This is the only place where you can find honest perspectives from the left and the right that simply does not exist anywhere else. So if that is something that's important to you, please go to BreakingPoints.com, become a member today, and you'll get access to our full shows, unedited, ad-free, and all put together for you every morning in your inbox. We need your help to build the future of independent news media, and we hope to see you at BreakingPoints.com.
2:40Good morning and welcome to Breaking Points. I am in the studio here alone today. Crystal got caught up at a National Guard checkpoint, did not have her paperwork in order. She's joining us, though, from an undisclosed location underground. Crystal, thanks for being here.
2:56Ryan Grim:Luckily not Alligator Alcatraz, at least not yet. So in any case, we are going to cover the Trump D.C. takeover. We got a lot to get to in the show today, actually. We were able to book a council member, a D.C. council member, to come in and talk about her perspective on what is going on in the nation's capital. We've also got a really pretty extraordinary interview with Ambassador Mike Huckabee, Piers Morgan, pressing him on starvation and on the murder of five Al Jazeera journalists. So definitely want to break that down for you, along with other developments in Israel and Gaza. We've got a bunch of economic news.
3:30Ryan Grim:The China tariffs have been paused and Trump made a pretty interesting deal. I'm actually very curious to get Ryan's take on this deal that he made with NVIDIA, where basically they've got to kick back 15 % of their chip sales to China to the U.S. federal government. We also have some updates on Andrew Cuomo crashing out hard in his race with Zoran and offering a really nonsensical and terrible law in order to try to spite or shame Zoran. And I regret to inform everybody we are going to take on the dildos at WNBA games controversy, along with some other gender-related developments. So you definitely want to stick around for that, Ryan.
4:09And you made a point discussing the formation of the show yesterday that Republicans have made defense of the integrity of women's sports central to their entire kind of reason to be. Yeah. And this is probably not what people thought they meant by that. Yet here we are.
4:29Ryan Grim:Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, as as you pointed out, I'm not sure how many people really took seriously their undying devotion to sports and interest which had never been exhibited in the past. But there's that to get to. And Pete Hegseth also elevating his pastor who doesn't think women should vote. So there's a lot going on there with regard to the lady kind that I have thoughts on. And I suspect Ryan does as well. But let's go ahead and get to this D.C. National Guard situation with Trump claiming crime is out of control and is such an emergency in the nation's capital that he needs to call in the National Guard and evoke a rule that has never been invoked before by a president to effectively take control of the city's law enforcement.
5:21Ryan Grim:Let's go ahead and take a listen to a little bit of what he had to say yesterday. I'm announcing a historic action to rescue our nation's capital from crime, bloodshed, bedlam, and squalor, and worse. This is Liberation Day in D.C., and we're going to take our capital back. We're taking it back under the authorities vested in me as the president of the United States. I'm officially invoking Section 740 of the District of Columbia Home Rule Act. You know what that is? and placing the D.C. Metropolitan Police Department under direct federal control, and you'll be meeting the people that will be directly involved with that.
6:04Ryan Grim:Let me be crystal clear. Crime in D.C. is ending and ending today. We are going to use every power we have to fight criminals here. President, thank you for caring about our Capitol. So let's go and put A4 up on the screen. I'll get Ryan's reaction to this. But, you know, the portrayal from the president is a lawless city with violent crime and crimes of all sorts spiking out of control. In fact, D.C., like many, if not all cities across the country, has seen crime go down significantly. You've got violent crime down 35 percent year over year. I know in Baltimore, just north of D.C., a city that's also often held out as like, you know, a hotbed of crime and justifiably so in the past.
6:50Ryan Grim:They're on track for a 50-year low in terms of the number of homicides. In D.C. specifically, the crime rate has hit a 30-year low. So quite at odds with the portrayal here from the president, Ryan. Yeah, and tomorrow we'll have both of our resident right-wingers on the program, so you'll be able to get their take on this. But I think one thing they could fairly say is that the left was in the beginning of the kind of surge in crime starting around 2020, too dismissive of the increase that was related both to the pandemic and to the and to the protests from that summer. And and the and the subsequent kind of going on strike by police forces all over the country.
7:36And so you did, for the next couple of years, have a significant uptick in crime. Any crime is too much if you're the victim of it. It doesn't matter if you're the only crime victim the entire year. It's too much for you. So there is that, we can acknowledge that. But at the same time, we need to acknowledge that we are strongly on a downward slope here. If you compare the capital of Washington, as some on the right have done, to the capital of the United States, to other capitals around the world, which I've seen. I've seen them compare it to Havana and et cetera, which is odd. It's like, okay, yes, there's not much crime in Havana, but that's really like that's the comparison you're going to make.
8:21Okay. Anyway, then yes, we are a much more violent nation than pretty much any other country in the world. So, yes, because Washington and D.C. is part of the United States, even if it doesn't get to be a state, it's going to have more violent crime than you're going to see even in Argentina or whatever. So that really isn't much of an argument to take over. But I think you've been in this area your entire life. I moved to this city around 2003. And, you know, it's important for people to understand the context here. You know, after the 1968 riots, after Martin Luther King was assassinated, a lot of the city was just laid waste.
9:07and there was no investment, no effort to kind of turn that around. And then you've got deindustrialization, neoliberalism, manufacturing jobs rolling out, unions getting crushed. And then you have the crack epidemic, you know, come into Washington, which is only abating kind of in the late 1990s. I was in the basically the tail end of the first wave of gentrification here in D.C. And do we have the big balls clip here? Big Walls attempted to stop a carjacking on the 1400 block of Swan Street Northwest and was beaten pretty severely. And interestingly, though, there were like eight police officers nearby.
9:51Officers ran to the scene and broke up the beatdown, immediately arrested two of them, and some of the other hooligans got away. And what you've heard from people is that the 1400 block of Swan Street, that's a nice neighborhood. But at the same time, 20 years ago, when I moved here, I moved close to there. I was 14th and W Street. It was not particularly safe.
10:16Ryan Grim:Yeah, I remember that area. Even when I moved to DC, let's say, early 2000s, it was transitional. It was definitely transitional. Right, so that kind of shows how much progress the city has made. That now, if there was crime 20 years ago on the 1400 block of Swan Street, people were like, yeah, that's what happens. Now it's shocking. So that just, I think, to me, demonstrates how much progress the city has made and that it's not as safe as it should be. No city is. But it's much safer than it was before. And I don't quite see how bringing in the feds helps that. Yeah, I mean, well, that's one of the things that's ridiculous about this is actually let's put a five up on the screen.
11:07Ryan Grim:Like, you know, this was the scene in D.C. is all these DEA agents because they not only called up the National Guard, they also pulled agents from DEA, FBI and other federal law enforcement agencies. and there you see them just like strolling along the mall as joggers are going past and no problem anywhere in sight presumably there's other actual crime that these individuals could be focused on but instead they're going for this walk along the mall and doing yes nothing i also saw a report i believe from npr apparently there was some like minor in uh incident between a moped and a vehicle and the police were there.
11:50Ryan Grim:And then you had two dozen federal agents also descend on the scene to make sure that the car moped situation was resolved. So that's the kind of absurdity that you're talking about here. And, you know, one of the things I've been thinking about with regard to crime, because there's always, you know, there's a heated debate among people who study this about what causes these spikes and increases in crime and which sort of police tactics are effective in dealing with it. And because you had this spike in crime really across the country, in cities across the country, and then a similar decline in crime following that, again, in cities across the country, not to say that the policing and the mayoral leadership and all that stuff doesn't matter, but it does seem like the biggest determinants of crime are these sociocultural factors.
12:46Ryan Grim:much more so than, you know, whether or not the National Guard has been called up in this particular instance. I want to get to the next Trump soundbite here because I think this one is really important. I saw a lot of people saying yesterday, D.C. was going to be a model for this sort of like authoritarian, militarized crackdown across the country. And I don't think that's really true. I think L.A. was the model that, you know, was the first one to go. And they've been allowed to get away with it, even though there was much more tenuous legal grounds in L.A. than, you know, the president does have powers under this Section 740.
13:23Ryan Grim:Now, granted, it's supposed to be an emergency. And I think anyone would say, like, this is not really an emergency that justifies this invocation. But he does have more legal standing here. Nevertheless, in his press conference yesterday, he made it clear that this is a plan that he would like to roll out in other cities like New York and Chicago and other, you know, notably more democratic cities across the country. So let's go ahead and take a listen to that. We have other cities that are very bad. New York has a problem. And then you have, of course, Baltimore and Oakland. We don't even mention that anymore.
13:54Ryan Grim:They're so far gone. We're not going to let it happen. We're not going to lose our cities over this. And this will go further. We're starting very strongly with D.C. and we're going to clean it up real quick, very quickly, as they say. And if we need to, we're going to do the same thing in Chicago, which is a disaster. We have a mayor there who's totally incompetent. He's an incompetent man. And we have an incompetent governor there. Pritzker's an incompetent. His family threw him out of the business and he ran for governor. And now I understand he wants to be president, but I noticed he lost a little weight.
14:33So maybe has a chance you know you never know what happens but Pritzker's a gross incompetent guy thrown out of the family business uh but when I look at Chicago and I look at uh LA if we didn't go to LA
14:49Ryan Grim:three months ago LA would be burning like the part that didn't burn if he would have allowed the water to come down which I told him about in my first term I said you're gonna have problems let it come down we actually sent in our military to have the water come down into LA they I still didn't want it to come down after the fires. But that was it. We have it coming down. But hopefully L.A. is watching. That mayor also, the city's burning. They lost like 25 ,000 homes. I went there the day after the fire. You were there. And I saw people standing in front of a burned down home. It was their homes were incinerated.
15:26Ryan Grim:So worth noting, Ryan, as many did yesterday, that the cities in the country actually with the highest crime rates are in red states. Memphis, Tennessee and St. Louis, Missouri. Other notable high crime rate cities are Little Rock, Arkansas, Cleveland, Ohio, Ohio being a red state at this point, Kansas City, Missouri, New Orleans, Louisiana. So you have plenty of red state city crime, yet that doesn't catch the attention of the president of the United States. And, you know, I think I think people are correct that this is another like attempted distraction from the Epstein file stuff, which has been Trump has obviously been like scrambling and panicking over.
16:07Ryan Grim:But it is that's not to say that it's not also extraordinarily important that you have the normalization of using the military in standard issue law enforcement and sort of just making that commonplace in America is truly an extraordinary and, you know, truly authoritarian step. So he's going to succeed in distracting from the Epstein files because he finally came up with something that is so wild and so like detrimental that people have to pay attention to it. And again, even as I think what we're going to see from this is similar to in L.A., the National Guard is not doing all that much, right?
16:49Ryan Grim:They're like guarding federal buildings. You'll have these, you know, you had ICE do this and a bunch of federal agencies do this big show of force of like riding their horses through a park. That's the sort of thing I expect here as well. But that's not to say it's not a major concern that we now have the president of the United States effectively saying he's going to seize control of major cities where he disagrees with the political leadership and the normalizing of this militarized law enforcement force in, you know, in the nation's capital in L.A. and projected in cities across the country.
17:23Yeah. And we have really no idea what the what the strategy is and what the kind of orders are, what the rules of engagement are for these, you know, deputized federal officers who are roaming D.C. So we don't know where it's going to head. My neighbor was telling me last night that earlier in the day she had seen a group of eight Secret Service agents. So apparently Secret Service are also, you know, being enlisted in this situation who were kind of corralling a homeless guy into the, and arresting him. She said that there had been an accusation that he might have stolen something. It wasn't clear, but like, you know, a whole bunch of, you know, a crowd gathered around, like what, you know, just wondering what's going on.
18:07Why is the Secret Service picking up a homeless person here. What the heck is going on? And it's an open question. Like, what is going on? Like, Trump saying that he's going to bring in the National Guard and take over the city and very quickly he's going to clean it up. Like, what does that mean? Like, what is the DEA allowed to do? What is the Secret Service tasked with doing? Got fish and wildlife. Like, who else is, like, involved here? What are they doing? Are they just patrolling are they where are they taking the people that they're arresting and how is this supposed to accomplish the goal and none of that see it all feels like you said i think he's wanted to do this for a very long time that the pressure of epstein made that inevitable it's like just yeah let's do this let's create this yeah we're gonna use the the uh reichstag fire
19:01Ryan Grim:that's available to us of big balls getting, you know, beaten in this car hijacking. And we're going to seize on that for something he's been projecting for a while. And again, that he's already done in LA. I do believe we have our council member standing by. So let's go ahead and get to her so we can get her perspective on what's happening here. Say big on your landscaping project at Menards. Whether you're looking for edgers, pavers, or wall blocks, Menards has the largest in-stock selection of concrete landscape block ready to take home today. Build a beautiful border for your landscape with our Interlock Edgers on sale now through August 16th.
19:42Ryan Grim:Save big on landscape block at Menards. Also, check out our weekly flyer on Menards.com for all the great deals happening now. Save big money at Menards. Hey, Portlandia fans. Carrie Brownstein and Fred Armisen here. You know us, or rather, you know them. Tony and Candace, Nina and Lance, Spike, and yes, the chicken. We've played a lot of iconic characters over the years, but today we're showing up as ourselves to tell you about Podlandia, AO Rewatch, our brand new podcast. Each week, we'll revisit an episode of Portlandia from the very beginning, breaking down the sketches, exploring the backstories of our most iconic characters, revisiting the Portland locations you know and love, and opening up about our creative process.
20:24Ryan Grim:How did any of this get made? Why do we think that was a good idea? We're ready to talk about it. And we'll also be joined by the people who helped bring it all to life. Guest stars, collaborators, and friends, including director Jonathan Kreisel, the mayor himself, Kyle McLaughlin, legendary musician Amy Mann, and many more. Kyle is going for it here. You fully improvised, not just words, but a song, a melody. Well, I thought he was going to write, I thought you were all going to write a song. I remember you thinking that. Listen to Podlandia Ayo Rewatch on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
21:21The definition of what is a movie has kind of changed anyway, too, right? What do you think it is now? It's images and words being spoken, captured by some sort of technology. Danny McBride. He loves Boba. Oh, that's fantastic. And you make it on, you make your own. That's great. I call him Taro Reed. That's a good name. They're all named after cast members of American Pie. Yeah. Oh, gotcha. I don't, I never looked up if she was in this, but I call him Leachie Sobieski. Yeah, I don't think she was an American Pie, but I still like that. Haven't looked it up. Haven't looked it up. She was prominent around the same time.
21:57Then Mary Steenburgen.
21:58Ryan Grim:Why are you guys talking to me like, why are you talking so down to me that you think I don't understand your little play game? I just really am trying to set you up for success here. Listen to Hollywood Handbook on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Joining us now is Ward 4 Councilmember Janice Lewis-George. Councilmember, thanks so much for joining us. Good morning. Thanks for having me. First of all, I want to play a little bit of Muriel Bowser, the mayor of Washington, D.C., who coincidentally represented Ward 4 before she became mayor, where you now represent, responding to Trump's press conference.
22:42If we can roll Mayor Bowser here and then we're going to get Lewis George's response here.
22:47Ryan Grim:We know, however, as most have heard from the president's press conference, that he has prerogatives in D.C. unlike anywhere else in the country, including his authority given by our home rule charter to require the mayor to require me to supply services of the Metropolitan State. Police Department and he also has control and the ability to deploy the National Guard. But let me be clear as our Home Rule Charter is also clear and the President's Executive Order restates Chief Pamela Smith is the Chief of the Metropolitan Police Department and its 3 ,100 members work under her direction. The Home Rule Charter requires the mayor to provide the services of MPD during special conditions of an emergency, and we will follow the law.
23:55Ryan Grim:Though there's a question about the subjectivity of that declaration. In fact, the chief has already provided a high-level liaison and point of contact with the federal government and made those initial contacts. The executive order is also clear that the president has dedicated his authority to make requests of us to Attorney General Pam Bondi. I have reached out to Attorney General Bondi and hope to schedule a meeting. So to set some context for viewers, you know, you were endorsed in your race by DSA. Mayor Bowser is known as much closer to business here in Washington, D.C. So, you know, I know you have your political differences here in the city with her.
24:48But how do you feel like she has handled the run-up to this crisis and this particular crisis? And what should she be doing differently?
24:56Ryan Grim:You know, I think she has taken the cautionary approach in how she's handled with the administration and sort of tried to find common ground with the president and Republicans and sort of tried in her best ways to sort of appease whatever they are trying to do. I think in some instances people could say, you know, say, you know, that's what we have to do because we're under home rule and we're in a vulnerable position. And I do think we are in a vulnerable position because of not having statehood and the home rule charter. But I think the mayor should be a little bit more active and forceful in fighting for district residents and saying and declaring sort of what Trump is doing is wrong, right?
Read the full transcript
25:47Ryan Grim:Like, you know, Yesterday, you heard mayors from all across the country and in the cities that Trump indicated, like Chicago and Baltimore and Los Angeles, unequivocally say, you know, our city is handling crime. Crime is low here. But also defending their city in a more forceful manner. And I would like to see the sort of notion of like, let's find a common ground and compromise versus let's defend our citizens and defend our citizens rights. At this point, it doesn't appear that there is going to be a legal challenge of Trump's invocation here of Section 740. Is is that something that you would like to see going forward?
26:30Ryan Grim:Do you believe that he's on strong legal ground in terms of his actions? Yeah. So I think one of the biggest outstanding questions is sort of what what is what is the emergency? Like what define emergency? Right. And I've asked the attorney general and the attorney general and the mayor have both said, well, you know, he has broad sort of, you know, powers here. And I said, that's great, but we have to challenge. I think we should be challenging or doing some type of injunction basically to say, what are your grounds for an emergency? Make the prima facie case for an emergency that serves as the predicate for seizure of control of the police or deployment of the National Guard.
27:11Ryan Grim:And we know right now the facts don't support Trump's claims of a public safety emergency in D.C. because of the fact that, you know, our crime is down in every category over the last two years. There's been a 52 percent drop in violent crime in D.C. And right now we're actually experiencing some of the lowest crime rates we've seen in 30 years in the city. So the real question is, then what is the prima facie case that the president has laid out that justifies sort of the notion of emergency? And I've asked the attorney general to investigate this question to determine what the district's best legal course of action moving forward should be.
27:49Ryan Grim:But I think yesterday what I wanted to hear is the mayor and the attorney general say we are going to go to the courts to get an opinion to see if Trump has met the legal requirements for emergency before just sort of leaning on. Let's compromise. Let's find a way forward. You know, let's have conversations, which we have to have. But also let's challenge the actions, because if not, we'll be in an endless cycle of the president declaring emergency. And with no clear definition and no court guidance here, we're setting ourselves up down a slippery road that could lead to us losing our autonomy.
28:31Yeah, and people can make up their own minds, but watching Mayor Bowser there, I felt she looked kind of shaken. Like it didn't seem like this was a person that's going to lead this fight here. If there was someone who was going to lead the fight, what could they do? Like, given the vulnerable position that everybody acknowledges D.C. is in, you know, what assets do you have? What leverage do you have? And how would you kind of organize pushback against this?
28:55Ryan Grim:Yeah. Well, you know, first and foremost, I talked about, one, we have to pull our legal levers where we can. I think it's so important for us to, you know, we've seen jurisdictions who are facing the same amount of attack on their local autonomy, you know, going to the courts and trying to get injunctions and fighting on the legal level to be able to do that work. In addition to that, let's be honest, the real threat fear here is that we would lose home rule, which gives us this ability to have autonomy. In order to overturn home rule, this will require a majority vote in both the House and the Senate, followed by presidential approval.
29:34Ryan Grim:And even with the majority in the House, a repeal in the Senate would likely face a filibuster, which will require at least 60 votes to proceed. So another thing we need to be doing is really getting going to Congress, getting our allies on Democratic senators, the House of Democratic House of Representatives. You know, we talked yesterday. We said, you know, we need to be going to the Congressional Black Caucus within Congress asking for their support. And many of them are calling us. How can we support? And so, you know, we need to be doing those things. Eleanor Holmes Norton, who is our delegate and warrior on the Hill representative, has put forward legislation to give D.C.
30:11Ryan Grim:its full autonomy. We should be trying to get those type of things done as quickly as possible. you know when we're up against what we're up against in this country you know the idea that you know conforming is going to create a space where we're not going to continue to have to give and give and give you know it's just not based in reality yeah you can ask Columbia University how that's gone for them when they you know bent over backwards to try to capitulate and it didn't matter they still had to pay the bribes the administration they've had the Middle East studies department taken over. And, you know, there's there's no there's nothing to be gained from capitulating to this individual.
30:54Ryan Grim:I think that lesson should have been learned pretty well at this point. I was curious your perspective, what you're hearing from constituents about their concerns about what this is going to mean for their lives. And also just what have you heard? How is the National Guard going to be used? We know that agents have been pulled up from various agencies, DEA, FBI, Secret Service, how are they going to be deployed? We were raising questions earlier about what are the rules of engagement here? Do you have any understanding of what this is actually going to look like? Yeah. In our call meeting yesterday amongst the mayor and the council and the AG, what our understanding was is that they are going to sort of just be a presence.
31:38Ryan Grim:Really, they don't have any sort of, the goal is to just be a presence across the city in different locations. I don't know how real that is. I will say I had a constituent reach out to me because Rock Creek Park, which is National Park Service land, is in my ward and her and her son were on a run and they were sort of stopped and told they couldn't, you know, sort of run in a certain section. And, you know, they just, you know, they really wanted to know, Council Member, you know, what do we do in these circumstances? You know, there's a vast amount of National Park Service land, which is federal land that is a part of, you know, Ward 4 particularly, but across the city in general.
32:25Ryan Grim:And in reality is what I've been saying to residents is when you're on national park land, when you're on federal land, they do have, you know, additional powers there. I, you know, have recommended people stay off sort of national park service land or, you know, make sure while you're there, you're there with others and numbers. And you also remember, you know, you have your constitutional rights. Be very clear about that. Make sure you have your identification on you. Make sure you let people know where you are. because the reality is with so many different law enforcement entities on the ground in the District of Columbia, it's really going to be hard.
33:05Ryan Grim:It's really hard for us to sort of determine who's doing what and where. And we've also been asking constituents to report to us where they're seeing national law enforcement so that we can try to make sure people can go to that area and at least observe what is happening between constituents and federal law enforcement. Right. And let me ask you about this billion dollars. D.C.'s missing billion dollars. You can put up a seven here. It's a tweet from my old colleague, Sam Stein. One way we could make D.C. safer and cleaner without using the National Guard would be to restore the one billion dollars in cuts to the city budget that was passed into law with Trump's signature, which Trump and Republicans were supposed to reverse but never got around to.
33:46So this was something they slipped into the budget or slipped into the spending bill, stripped a billion dollars from D.C.'s budget, said that, oh, we'll fix that next time. Just trust us. Don't worry. What's the status of that billion dollars? And talk about the portion of the budget that that makes up. Like how important to the city is this amount of money? Like to the federal government, a billion dollars, you know, they can lose that easily. But to the city, what's it mean?
34:15Ryan Grim:Yeah, for us, remember, you know, our largest parts of pots of money, health, right, public safety, education and human services. And so when you have big cuts like this, it means those are the four sections of our city budget that have to take a hit. And this is not the time where education can take a hit, where public safety, which, you know, as all the talks about wanting to make sure the district is safe and this being about safety, but you cut, you know, a billion dollars from our budget. And what is the city's whole budget if you count all four of those buckets plus? We have about a$19 billion,$20 billion budget given the year, but maintain about a$19 billion budget.
34:58So a billion dollars, that's cutting into bone there. So what gets hit if that billion dollars does not get restored? That's right.
35:06Ryan Grim:What gets hit are the – because it's such a – we have such large parts of money, public safety takes a hit because that's one of our largest budget expenditures. Our education takes a hit. And remember, many of our schools are on quarterly payments, especially our public charter schools. And so the inability for us to be able to give the, you know, actually expend those funds, you know, was a real hit to sort of our education nexus. Human services, the same people they're saying they want to support are unhoused residents, which have been, I must say, are under attack and being scapegoated in this moment in such a disgusting manner.
35:43Ryan Grim:Our unhoused residents, a human services budget is the budget that takes the cut when we lose a billion dollars. And that's our ability to put unhoused residents into shelter, into care. And so, you know, that's what makes this sort of just so hypocritical, because to say you want safety and you want to make sure we don't have homeless individuals on the street, which in and of itself is sort of outrageous to say and to dehumanize humans in that way. it's so hypocritical because you're cutting the same budgets that support public safety, human services, and those things that you say we need to clean up and fix as a city.
36:24Ryan Grim:Yeah, that billion dollars, I'm sure, could do a lot more than some National Guardsmen wandering around and federal agents harassing people trying to jog in Rock Creek Park. Councilmember, thank you so much for joining us. We really appreciate you taking the time, and we really appreciate your perspective. If you have a second, I did have one more question. Oh, yeah, absolutely. Oh, sorry. Go ahead, Ryan. I wanted to get your defense of what I think is the best criticism of the city. And you were elected in 2020. Is that right? So during the pandemic, D.C. had one of the most severe crack lockdowns.
36:56And if you were in school, let's say you're a fourth grader in March when they shut down the schools, you basically didn't come back into school until you were a sixth grader. and you know they had this like a year later in the spring they brought kids back for like two hours a week and tuesdays and thursdays or something but they really don't start bringing kids back till the year after that and then you know they're they're they're like doing lunch out and freezing cold and it was like it was a little bananas um and kids being out of school from let's say going from 10 to 12 um they they came back and you talk to the teachers you talk to the cops they're like you saw adults were when they were when adults were coming out of the lockdown like it took them a while to like figure out how to engage in like society again but for a kid who went from 10 to 12 or 12 to 14 felt like like an entire lost generation those 12 year olds are now 17 and you and you're they're the ones you're seeing out there um not all of them obviously But, you know, they went through this experience, which was in somewhat somewhat argue unnecessarily foisted on them.
38:09Yes, there was a pandemic, but there was an overreaction to it. What's your response in hindsight, I guess, to to that criticism?
38:19Ryan Grim:You know, I think we were just in unprecedented times and we were really trying to do what was best for the safety of students and the safety of our educators. and I think we did what we felt was best and what we were given guidance was the best thing to do at that time. And I don't think anyone could say it was the right way or wrong way to do it because of the fact that it was just such an unprecedented moment in our country and in our city. Do you agree with the link that people make that I'm making there that that time away for those kids at that vulnerable age had something to do with the spike in crime?
39:05I would disagree.
39:06Ryan Grim:I would disagree. I think our young people went through a lot and they needed to process that. And we have no idea as adults what it was like for them as students. We obviously needed to have more mental health supports for our students in returning. And that's a whole nother conversation about the shortage of supports that we have in our schools due to the pipeline issue we have. But I think, you know, I wouldn't correlate that to sort of the uptick we saw in our young people acting out in that regard. I wouldn't make that correlation. Well, Council Member, really appreciate you being here. We'll be following this story pretty closely.
39:53So, you know, hope you can come back sometime soon.
39:55Ryan Grim:Thank you. Thank you for having me. Shop the Sherwin-Williams sale and get 30 % off Duration, Superdeck, and Woodskates products August 14th through the 24th. Whether you're refreshing your interior or exterior, we've got the colors to bring your vision to life. And with delivery, getting everything to your door is easier than ever. Shop online to have it delivered or visit your neighborhood Sherwin-Williams store. Click the banner to learn more. Retail sales only. Some exclusions apply. See store for details. Delivery available on qualifying orders. Hey, Portlandia fans. Carrie Brownstein and Fred Armisen here.
40:32Ryan Grim:You know us, or rather, you know them. Tony and Candace, Nina and Lance, Spike, and yes, the chicken. We've played a lot of iconic characters over the years, but today we're showing up as ourselves to tell you about Podlandia, AO Rewatch, our brand new podcast. Each week, we'll revisit an episode of Portlandia from the very beginning. Breaking down the sketches, exploring the backstories of our most iconic characters, revisiting the Portland locations you know and love, and opening up about our creative process. How did any of this get made? Why do we think that was a good idea? We're ready to talk about it.
41:05Ryan Grim:And we'll also be joined by the people who helped bring it all to life. Guest stars, collaborators, and friends, including director Jonathan Kreisel, the mayor himself, Kyle McLaughlin, legendary musician Amy Mann, and many more. Kyle is going for it here. You fully improvised, not just words, but a song, a melody. Well, I thought he was going to write, I thought you were all going to write a song. I remember you thinking that. Listen to Podlandia A-O Rewatch on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Hey, this is Hayes Davenport. And Sean Clemens. We host the podcast Hollywood Handbook.
41:42Ryan Grim:Every episode, we're trying to help our guests improve their careers by mainly focusing on how they can help us improve our careers. The show is famously super accessible, so you can easily jump into any of our 650 episodes and understand what's going on. We recommend some of our recent episodes with Ben Stiller. The definition of what is a movie has kind of changed anyway, too, right? What do you think it is now? It's images and words being spoken, captured by some sort of technology. Danny McBride. He loves Ova. Oh, that's fantastic. And you make it on, you make your own. That's great. I call him Tarot Reed.
42:17it's a good name they're all named after cast members of american pie yeah i call i don't i never looked up if she was in this but i call him lychee sobieski yeah i don't think she was an american pie but i still haven't looked it up haven't looked it up she was prominent around the same time yeah then mary steenburgen why are you guys talking to me like i'm worried
42:36Ryan Grim:why are you talking so down to me that you think i don't understand your little play play game i really trying to set you up for success here. Listen to Hollywood Handbook on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. Piers Morgan hosted a pretty extraordinary, I would say, interview with our ambassador to Israel, the one and only Mike Huckabee. And we have a couple of clips here we wanted to share with you, starting with Piers asking him about the number of people who are being starved to death by Israel inside of the Gaza Strip right now. Let's go ahead and take a listen to Huckabee's response.
43:16Why does Hamas hate GHF? One of the things they demanded in one of the negotiations just two and a half weeks ago was that GHF had to be shut down. Why would Hamas want to shut it down? I'll tell you why. Because GHF method of getting food has really hurt their capacity to control the food market, and it's costing them money. Otherwise, they would say, sure, go ahead and bring the food. And all we care about is people getting to eat. They don't care about people getting to eat. They care that they eat. And if you look at the people from Hamas, when they get photographed, they're well fed. None of them are hungry.
43:53I guarantee you, look at their faces, look at their bodies. And instead of food, they could use some Ozempic.
43:59Ryan Grim:So there is a lot to say about that, Ryan. I mean, at this point, denying that there is starvation in Gaza. It just is in such a defiance of the clear reality. There were more kids who starved to death literally yesterday. Israeli military officials, not to mention the UN and other aid organizations, have said there was no significant looting of aid by Hamas. This is just a lie. And in fact, the reason why the UN and other agencies and Hamas or whoever don't like GHF is because it is the weaponization of aid and Palestinians are getting massacred at GHF sites practically every single day when there is a distribution, not to mention being forced to traverse through active war zones in order even to get to those few distribution sites for their poultry lentils and, you know, rice or flour or whatever the meager provisions that are being provided.
45:04Ryan Grim:And as Anthony Aguilar explained to us, not even water, because that would be too expensive. So all of these food goods that require water, but no actual water. Yeah, this is a pretty easy one. If you're on the side of defending GHF, then you're the bad guys in this situation. Like there's no question about it. Boston Consulting Group, just for two of its partners pitching business and getting involved in the early stages of GHF, those two partners were fired. The BCG is now facing an existential crisis with clients leaving, with staff leaving, with their reputation completely tarnished simply for being connected to this GHF.
45:49And this is months ago. To have, to this day, the ambassador defending it and saying that it's preposterous that Hamas would oppose this as part of a deal is utterly outrageous. Almost every single day, there are massacres at these aid sites. If you remember Adil Khalil, who's a doctor from Dallas who's been on this program. He's now back in Gaza for his third mission. And he texted me when he first got there. And he said that a doctor told him, you know, briefing him for his upcoming shift. He's like, if there's an aid, if aid distribution is open while you're on your shift, that is very bad luck for you.
46:34But if there's no aid distribution while you're on, then you're going to have an okay shift. So bear that in mind. That is how the hospitals understand this, that when the aid sites open, the bodies are coming in.
46:51Ryan Grim:Can I tell you something? And that's what Huckabee is defending. Yeah, go ahead. Even sicker that I just, I was listening to Theo Vaughn, to his great credit, and I'm extremely grateful to him for this, had on a doctor, American doctor who just returned from Gaza. And he said, you know, in Islam, it is forbidden to take your own life to commit suicide. And he heard of people who would say, you know, if my wife, if my family are killed, I'm going to one of the GHF sites, basically in hopes that they will take me out. like suicide by GHF site aid, quote unquote, aid massacre. That's how dark it is.
47:29Ryan Grim:And he also attested, as numerous doctors have at this point, he worked at Nassar Hospital as well, which is the primary hospital where these aid massacre victims would be brought. He said, you know, when there was an aid distribution, you would have roughly 300 people come in wounded with various wounds and, you know, plenty more who were killed. So that is that's what our ambassador, Mike Huckabee, great Christian, is defending here. We also have a clip here of him being asked by Piers Morgan to comment on the assassination of five Al Jazeera journalists. Again, we covered this extensively yesterday.
48:07Ryan Grim:Israel is not denying that they targeted and assassinated these five journalists, including among them, Anas al-Sharif. But they were, you know, there were Hamas. So it was fine for us to execute them. Let's go ahead and take a listen to what Huckabee had to say about that. The IDF has killed five journalists from Al Jazeera amongst seven people who were killed in a direct and targeted strike in Gaza City. Al Jazeera called it a targeted assassination and a blatant and premeditated attack on press freedom. Now, the IDF immediately put out a statement saying that 28-year-old correspondent Anas al-Sharif, who had become extremely well known in Gaza for his broadcasting during the war, they said that he served as the head of a terrorist cell in Hamas and produced documents, including personal rosters, lists of terrorist training courses, phone directories and salary documents that they said proved he belonged to Hamas.
49:07Ryan Grim:But since then, a number of journalists, including many from the BBC, have said that this evidence, to their eyes, a very experienced war correspondent, is not convincing. And the reason this matters so much is that if the IDF has deliberately targeted a group of journalists in Gaza City, and it turns out that that man, Al-Sharif, was not a Hamas terrorist, then that would constitute a war crime.
49:39I also would point there are photos where this alleged journalist is hugging the head of Hamas and smiling and yucking it up for the cameras. There is evidence that indicates that he was an asset for Hamas. And if it's proven that he isn't, then that's a different calculation. But right now, the evidence points to the fact that he was. and why would someone pose as a journalist? I mean, I know why they would do it, but I think that's incredibly despicable if somebody is pretending to be just reporting the news but is actually being a participant in the outcome. It's like if a referee at an American football game, instead of wearing the striped jersey of the referee, decides to put on a team jersey and actually root for one team over the other and aid and abet one team over the other.
50:35But the big difference is that in football, it's just a game, really doesn't matter. This matters. People are dying there every day. And anyone who helps Hamas, who is sympathetic to them, who aids and abets them, I can understand they would be a target. But there is no actual hard evidence that he was a Hamas terrorist.
50:58Ryan Grim:The only evidence appears to be old pictures of him with Hamas leaders, of which there would be many people in Gaza who would do pictures of that nature with the governing body. This is prior to October the 7th. I think judging people as terrorists prior to October the 7th, when this was a government that was being financially supported by Israel, amongst others, to the tune of billions of dollars, is pretty disingenuous. So first of all, Ryan, as Piers is pointing out there, there is no evidence that Anas was linked to Hamas or a Hamas militant at any point, let alone post October 7th. And you can all go out and watch his work product if you want to know what he has been up to for these past nearly two years.
51:40Ryan Grim:Second of all, I just have to note, it is quite rich for a former Fox News host to take this line about how if you're cheering, rooting for one team specifically, and you put on the jersey and you're not just being the neutral ref, then that should make you a legitimate military target is quite rich coming from this former Fox News propagandist. Yeah, it's utterly preposterous. If you live in Gaza and you're a high ranking, you know, if you're a journalist of serious repute, like the Hamas leadership wants to be seen with you. Like that's it's it goes it goes the other way around for the most.
52:20Yeah, that. Well, think about the other thing I was thinking about.
52:23Ryan Grim:Hey, all of our members of Congress are there taking photos with Benjamin Netanyahu right now. You know, does that mean they're fake Congress people and they're legitimate military targets? It's it's ridiculous. It's utterly absurd. Right. And also, Israel's own documents that they put out said that he left in early 2023 because of some explosives accident that, you know, cost him his hearing in one ear and vision and, you know, hurt his vision and other eyes. It's like, well, A, none of that is like evident in any of his work. But even assuming that this is the case, you're saying that he has not been a combatant since October, since before October 7th, 2023.
53:05the rule is that you can only kill combatants. Like just because somebody previously served, and I'm not acknowledging that he previously served, I'm not saying that he did because there's really no evidence that he did. But even if he did serve then, that doesn't allow you to kill him years later. You cannot kill Barak Ravid just because Barak Ravid served in the idea. Or same with any of them. Which he did. And that's what people do for the most part. They serve in the militaries of their country. But you can't then later kill them. So then yesterday, Israel put out again, they said, oh, clarification, because they saw they were getting clowned all over the world for this argument.
53:45They said, clarification, we have newly uncovered new secret documents that show he was still a secret terrorist. and people around the world have been getting their news from Anas al-Sharif and they know that he has been working from dawn all the way off and through the night because you can't sleep because of the drones and the explosions. He's posting and doing live hits constantly. And so now Israel's claiming that actually in his downtime, he was the secret terrorist. And they're only saying that now, their clarification, because the last answer landed like a dud. And they're like, oh, this is only working on our most loyal propagandists.
54:33Everyone else is like, no, this is not credible.
54:35Ryan Grim:Well, and they've murdered so many journalists, hundreds at this point. The number I saw was north of 240, more than in any war, including the Civil War. they've murdered so many most of the time they don't even feel the name to justify it it's just they just kill them and nobody hears anything about it and there's I think cannot be disputed at this point that journalists have been intentionally targeted you know you have international journalists are barred from entering the Gaza Strip so they aren't aren't there to shoulder some of the burden of being able to report out this genocide so it's fallen to Palestinians to be responsible for the full reporting burden of, you know, documenting their own friends and family members being starved and brutalized and killed.
55:25Ryan Grim:And then on top of that, they all, I mean, Anas was receiving text messages. He anticipated his own murder at the hands of the IDF and put together, you know, his final statement to be published upon his death. That's how much danger he felt his life was in. And, you know, we can put put this next before this is, you know, Israel targeting another journalist. Now, Ryan, my understanding is this journalist was able to survive this strike. But after the initial you're seeing the rubble from the initial strike. And while he's walking around, seeing who's OK, you know, what are the injuries, what's going on?
56:06Ryan Grim:And there's another double tap strike here, once again, targeting them. And I think you pointed out the likelihood likely they were trying to not only murder this journalist, but any aid workers who would come to try to assist. Yeah. And that was Motus Samtolul, a very high, very well-known journalist in in Gaza City. And yes, it does seem like it was a double tap and the double taps are aimed at, you know, you first hit a site and it's terrorist organizations that kind of pioneered the use of these double taps. You strike a site and then, you know, loved ones and rescue workers come to the site and then you set off or you launch a second explosion to hit them as well.
56:54Well, miraculously, he survived. At least 10 people were killed in that strike. He's also Gaza City. And so what's going on here, and Anas and his colleagues were in Gaza City and have been this entire genocide. Their tent was known to be outside of Al-Shifa Hospital. They were broadcasting from there constantly, which has also raised these questions about to the IDF, like, oh, wait a minute. You had this evidence that he's a secret terrorist. Why now? Like, why are you waiting until now? And the answer is quite obvious, that they have announced that they're going to do this incursion and take over Gaza City.
57:36So they are now methodically killing the journalists in Gaza City. I hear myself saying this, and it sounds insane that this is being done out in the open. But this is what is happening on a methodical day-to-day manner. Yeah. No, it's just you, you know, you can't believe that these things are unfolding and so clear.
58:03Ryan Grim:And yet somebody like Mike Huckabee goes on with Pierce. And I will say, you know, Pierce asked a little follow-up there. Pierce can be very dogged when he wants to be. And he was a little meek in this particular segment with Ambassador Huckabee for whatever reason. Also wanted to share with everybody a U.S. negotiator who was involved in the negotiations that led to the release of the Israeli-American hostage, Eden Alexander. Alexander, he is now coming out and speaking out about how he feels that it has not been, surprise, surprise, Hamas, that was the problem in the most recent negotiations, that it's actually the U.S.
58:43Ryan Grim:side that, you know, walked away and is speculating about why that might be. This is B5. Let's go ahead and take a listen to that. Both the mediators, the Egyptians and the Qataris, said that they felt that the Hamas response to the Israeli proposal with regard to the maps was positive. Hamas was not really rigid in terms of what it was willing to do. It was willing to negotiate, you know. And the same thing between the exchange of prisoners and hostages. So there was the opportunity to come to a deal. And honestly, I don't know why we did not pursue that. Because if we did, we would have had a deal about two and a half weeks ago.
59:28Ryan Grim:But somebody cut off that line of negotiations. Somebody is Israel? I'm presuming that the decision at the end of the day was an Israeli decision. What I was told by the mediators, that the Israeli delegation, when they saw what was presented to them, said that they were cautiously positive. I don't know what happens in Israeli behind-the-scenes politics, But clearly, it was not something that was at the time acceptable to Israel. And then? And then we've been nothing in the meantime. Things were frozen. So there you go, Ryan. I mean, he's just basically acknowledging outright that Israel was the problem in these negotiations.
1:00:13Ryan Grim:What more can you tell us from DropSize reporting about this? Yeah, this is Bishra Baba. This is the guy who kind of was the kind of head of like Arab Americans for Trump and like set up this back channel to Hamas for Wyckoff. And, you know, it's important that the history is laid out there just so we just so everybody understands what happened here. It was reported in Israeli media that he resigned from the negotiating team. That seems to be completely fabricated. He responded publicly saying, you know, I'm not technically a member of the negotiating team either way. I'm helping envoy Whitcoff.
1:00:57I retain enormous respect for Whitcoff. And then he did this interview, just making clear what happened. And based on the documents that Jeremy Scale obtained over at DropSite, what he's saying there conforms exactly with what we understand as well. that Hamas responded favorably to the offer. They were preparing to sign the documents and move into the implementation phase. And Witkow first, and then Israel announced that it was all off and that they were going to try, you know, other means to get the captives back. And those other means entail assassinating a ton of journalists in Gaza City and then moving into gaza city and then we'll see uh what comes next so but that is that is the accurate history uh that hamas was ready to make this deal and the u.s and israel decided not to make it so his dispute with
1:01:53Ryan Grim:i believe it was channel 12 israeli channel 12 saying he had resigned from the negotiating team is basically like well i was never officially on their negotiating team and he's still involved yeah he's he's still he's still involved there are just no talks right now um there's you know There's news of Israel and the United States kicking around ideas again that might lead to something, but there are no negotiations that he can be a part of.
1:02:38Ryan Grim:We're launching Podlandia, AO Rewatch, our brand new podcast where we revisit every episode of Portlandia together, breaking down sketches, going deep on our iconic characters, and pulling back the curtain on how it all got made. And we'll also be joined by the people who helped bring it all to life. Guest stars, collaborators, and friends, including director Jonathan Kreisel, the mayor himself, Kyle McLaughlin, legendary musician Amy Mann, and many more. Kyle is going for it here. You fully improvised, not just words, but a song. Well, I thought you were all going to write a song. I remember you thinking that.
1:03:12Ryan Grim:Listen to Podlandia, A-O Rewatch on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:03:21Hey, this is Hayes Davenport. And Sean Clemens. We host the podcast Hollywood Handbook. Every episode, we're trying to help our guests improve their careers by mainly focusing on how they can help us improve our careers. The show's famously super accessible, so you can easily jump into any of our 650 episodes and understand what's going on.
1:03:39Ryan Grim:We recommend some of our recent episodes with Ben Stiller, Danny McBride, Riz Ahmed, and Mary Steenburgen. Listen to Hollywood Handbook on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. On Solita, we share the messy reality of traveling alone as a woman. Your Duolingo is not going to come back to you when a man is inside of you. Oh, no! I'm Julie Pinheiro and I travel by myself because it's a rare space where I can say yes without asking anyone else first. I'm on a mission to reclaim the word Solita, trading the pity for possibility. Listen to Solita on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
1:04:20Ryan Grim:This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human.
From the publisher
Krystal and Ryan discuss Trump's deployment of the National Guard in D.C. and Mike Huckabee denying starvation in Gaza.
To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com
Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
