Aly & AJ: Disney & Dating Disasters

8 Jan 2025 · 1 h 9 min

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Call Her Daddy - Episode Summary: Aly & AJ: Disney & Dating Disasters

Episode Overview In this episode of the popular podcast *Call Her Daddy*, hosted by Alex Cooper, the dynamic sister duo Aly & AJ discuss their experiences growing up in the spotlight with Disney, their musical careers, and personal stories about dating, breakups, and sisterly dynamics.

Guests

  • Aly Michalka and AJ Michalka: American singers, songwriters, and actresses known for their time on Disney Channel and their music career.

Key Highlights

Introduction

  • Alex welcomes Aly and AJ, reminiscing about their backstage meeting during her tour and expressing admiration for them as individuals beyond their celebrity status.

Sisterly Bond and Dynamic

  • Aly and AJ discuss their close relationship:
  • They share details about their sisterly roles and how they have evolved over time, swapping from traditional older-younger dynamics to more mutual support.
  • They mention how they used to live close but have since moved apart, shifting their routines and interactions.

Disney Channel Days

  • The sisters share their experiences of working with Disney:
  • Reflect on their iconic days and the transition to adulthood in the entertainment industry.
  • They talk about their early roles, notably "Phil of the Future," and the pressure and expectations that came with growing up in the spotlight.

Dating Experiences

  • Aly and AJ engage in candid discussions about their dating lives:
  • They recount major dating disasters, including AJ’s first kiss with Joe Jonas and challenge of navigating relationships while balancing their careers.
  • They openly discuss cheating, breakups, and the heartache that often accompanies young relationships, showcasing their growth from these experiences.

Advice on Relationships

  • The sisters provide insights on handling breakups, friendships, and romantic relationships:
  • They share advice on loyalty, honesty, and confronting issues in relationships.
  • Discuss the importance of having supportive friends during tough times and maintaining one's identity amidst personal upheavals.

The Impact of Their Parents' Divorce

  • Aly and AJ reflect on how their parents’ divorce influenced their views on love and relationships:
  • AJ shares how she struggled with trust issues stemming from the divorce while Aly took a more practical approach, focusing on her individual journey.

New Music and Future Aspirations

  • The sisters announce the release of their new music:
  • They describe their upcoming album and the creative process behind their new single, “What It Feels Like,” emphasizing authenticity and personal growth.
  • They discuss themes of motherhood and the deep emotional connections tied to their new work, particularly in relation to AJ’s son and significant life changes.

Final Thoughts

  • Aly and AJ express gratitude for their journey and reflect on the importance of sisterhood, creativity, and personal experiences in shaping who they are today.
  • They close with a heartfelt message about embracing one’s true self and the importance of genuine connections in their lives and music.

Key Takeaways

  • Importance of Sisterhood: Their bond as sisters is foundational, providing a steadfast support system.
  • Authenticity in Music: Both sisters emphasize the significance of creating music that reflects their real lives and emotions.
  • Navigating Fame: They highlight the challenges of growing up in the spotlight while maintaining a normal sense of self.
  • Personal Growth: The episode illustrates how personal experiences, including family dynamics and romantic relationships, have informed their art and identities.

Conclusion This episode of *Call Her Daddy* not only highlights the charming personalities of Aly and AJ but also offers profound insights into their lives as artists, sisters, and individuals navigating the complexities of relationships and family. Their stories resonate with listeners, providing a blend of humor, wisdom, and heartfelt authenticity.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:02What is up daddy gang? It is your founding father Alex Cooper with call her daddy. Allie and AJ, welcome to Call Her Daddy. Thank you. Thanks for having us. You guys, the last time we saw each other was we were hanging out backstage at my tour and you were the loveliest people. And I always have these moments because I'm like, I watched you guys growing up. Obviously, I love you guys, your music, all of it. But meeting you guys in person was so fun to be like, oh my God, you guys are like normal girls and we're all just hanging out. So I'm so happy we're finally doing this. Same, same. So happy to be here.

0:38It was meant to be. so happy to be here okay if you guys are not like touring if you're not working if you don't have all the chaos of your life what is your most fun thing that you guys usually like to do together we're big like spa people and we kind of have been since we were young like we were like hanging out in a spa at like 10 and 12 and we were just loving it and our parents would be like i don't know they just like love hot dry saunas and getting massages oh i love this for you so like so spa spa spa you You go into the spa. If you have a day off, you go into the spa together. Yeah, that's our number one.

1:09That's our number one. That or like, I mean, literally, it's like a movie, like just on AJ's couch, just like ordering in. Yeah. How like often do you guys hang out? All the time. Yeah, all the time. Like every day? Well, no, because now that she's a mom. We used to be, yeah. Uh-huh. So now that she's a mom, it's not every day. And also, we don't live down the street from each other anymore. We literally used to live, I'm not even kidding you. Like me in my car. Four minutes from each other. Driving to AJ's, four minutes. I could walk to her house in like 20. Wait, how far now? Now I'm like an hour and a half.

1:40What? Yeah, I know. What happened? She had a kid. I had a kid, yeah. She's like, bye. So changed. I'm like, see ya. Well, really we moved for like, to be closer to my mom. My mom lives out in San Yanez. So we were like, okay, if we're closer to her, that will help with, you know, just like childcare or whatever. Of course. And then having more space, because the house that we live in, that we lived in in the canyon that we ended up renting out is like a super cool pad. But it's more like it's for a couple. It's not really for a kid. So we ended up renting a place that just had more space. So we kind of were just like, we'll see.

2:14But it's only an hour and a half. I visit like every weekend. But would you ever move? I love Santa Barbara. Okay, you're happy in Santa Barbara. She would. I'd move there in a second. Okay, okay, okay. That makes me feel good. I really would. I'm not ready yet. I really love where I am. But I think down the road I would. I absolutely would. And I think it's a beautiful place to raise a son. Do you guys play the typical like older, younger sister roles? Do you feel like or is there anything that you're like, I don't act like a younger sister and older sister in this way? I think they were swapped when we were younger.

2:42Oh, really? Yeah, that's a good point. I was very much kind of younger sister and she was like older sister. And then it switched. Why? Like we always joke how when I was young, I was very shy and - Really shy. And I would have her just kind of, you were like my translator. Yes. She would like nudge me. It's like, and I'd be like, she wants a turkey sub. No. Cheese and - No mustard. No mustard. You know, whatever. And it was like, literally, I would speak for her. She like knew. It was very strange. I was very shocked. You got out of that, though. I got out of it. And then I think it swapped to being like, okay, now I get something.

3:11You don't translate for me, but yeah. No, no. You're like, girl, you never did. Never. But I think what's interesting is like, obviously, you guys then like at a pretty young age got into the spotlight. So like, you don't think that a kid would be shy that then gets into like this industry. when Disney entered the conversation were your parents at all like this is like too much they ever try to talk you guys out of it no at that point we were fully in like a sad card in hand doing commercials well not you not me because I got my sad card was still the future yeah yeah so like I didn't even have like I mean I knew the basics of like this is a mark and stuff but I learned like everything on that set oh my god wait your first gig was filled the future yeah that was like that's like kind of the biggest ever wait what that's funny yeah when you guys like I obviously was thinking before I like sat down with you I'm like when you look back at that era you think about like you think about you guys you think about Demi you think about Miley you think about Selena you think about the Jonas Brothers like when you were in the era that you were in because it shaped so much of our childhood I feel like did you guys realize it was that iconic in the moment or did it literally just feel like work.

4:19I think once Cowbells hit, we knew. Yeah. And I feel like when the music started happening on the channel and that was happening simultaneously with Phil, I think that's when we were like, oh, this is really like clicking with people. And I do remember going to, I don't know, I think, were we with Hollywood Records at the time? I don't know. I don't think so. Well, I think they signed us season two of the show. It was season two. But I think season one of fill the future had been out so no we weren't signed yet with hollywood but for whatever reason we were invited to hillary duff's concert at i think the forum or something oh yeah and i think you were with me yeah and like i got mobbed at this concert and i was like yeah because season one it aired it was weird it was like the first real time i remember being like oh like people know me from this show and then it was just you know after that it was still very we had a very normal life but i just remember being like oh people are stopping me because of this tv show oh my god i have hillary def concert like take me yeah back oh my god because i was gonna ask like how your life changed with fill the future because i feel like that was a very very very big moment and i feel like some shows popped some shows didn't that one i like feel like i watched every freaking episode and it was so good thank you um it did pop but like we only did two seasons which people kind of forget what yes that's it that's it i know it's a season 22 I think okay that's also so different like these days it's like sure episodes yeah yeah that's a good point yeah okay but 20 that's still a lot of way yeah so it's only two

6:08is this the unwell water no that's water that's real water you can then this is unwell drink yeah you can try it okay i'm trying it give it a go it's good it's yummy yeah yeah yeah it's yummy it's basically like a better ideally version of like pd pd light and gatorade like that's really good it's good right it's not sweet it's not oh my god i did so many you don't have to tone it down with water like gatorade the mango was my oh in college when i would play soccer i would have to literally dilute it and i would do like half gatorade half water yeah my favorite currently is the mango that you're currently holding and this one is what orange orange orange viscous oh that is good it's good right I think I think the mango is maybe the mango is the best my favorite it's my favorite currently this is orange viscous I like the mango yeah it's great um okay so back to because I was thank you so much because I was thinking about you guys and like now that I'm like a businesswoman and obviously like you guys can share what you want but I was thinking about you guys and I'm like you were so young and you guys looked like you're at the top of the world but like when you look back financially did you feel like as kids you were compensated correctly.

7:11I don't know if that's like a fair thing to say. I don't think we would have known anything to compare it to. Yeah, I don't think. I think it's crazy when you have a job that young. Of course. You know what I mean? And in a strange way, like any money that you're making. Of course. Seems like great. But like I made like$7 ,000 per episode on Film the Future. That ain't nothing. That's not good. Do you know what I mean? Yeah, that is interesting. I mean, I don't know what that would equate to today. True. Right. But I guess for a kids show, you're kind of like, that's great. That could go into their college fund.

7:41And how did you guys handle it with your parents? Because obviously I remember we were standing in the hallway of my tour. And I looked at you guys and I was like, how did you guys just stay so normal? And you guys are like so lovely. I feel like you guys are like my girlfriends from back home. And the unfortunate side of the industry, I feel like we've all seen, is like so many of these kids, whether it was like the parents were abusing the power and taking the kids' money. The parents were forcing the kids. We saw it all the time. The parents didn't help the kids, so they were just kind of by themselves on set.

8:10They're just like dropped off and left with the teacher. Right. Yeah. What attributed to you guys staying so grounded throughout this whole process? Well, I can tell you we weren't the boss of our household, that's for sure. Like just because we were working did not put us at the top. Like we were the kids. Yeah. And then second, like our parents were very, very clear about like, yeah, you can go to this event. You can promote this project. but like you're not going to go to like some late after party with a bunch of adults when you guys are underage. Like I just feel like when you're younger, you can kind of get away if you're in the industry, but just rolling into every situation.

8:44Yes. And you're like a little mini adult, even though you really shouldn't be. It's not really the time and place for that time in your life. Like you just shouldn't be at those kinds of things at that age. Like, you know what I mean? Yeah. I feel like our parents were very, they were pretty strict. And like our mom was on set with us like amazing if she needed to be somewhere for you and I was like on set she would be gone to like get you to the audition and then would be like straight back on set you know that I feel like that's like the biggest key that when kids come out now it's like there's this like missing element which was kind of like the parental figures yes and like to give the parental opportunity to people that weren't the actual parents totally they are just looking at these kids like they're cash cows and really your own parent hopefully would be the one to be like no no no I need to have some guidelines for my kids right is it true that you were going to possibly be Hannah Montana I mean yeah I I mean it's funny like she had the offer I had the offer and it was Phil hadn't ended at that point it was like they knew that Phil I think was on the way out or told us like you know we might not be doing a third season and and Gary who you know was the head of the channel, Gary Marsh, at the time.

9:55And Rich. Yeah. Was like, this pilot has come in and we think that you're really perfect for it. And I just remember reading it and being like, wait, but I'm doing music as Ally. And this might be really confusing being Hannah and being the character also playing Hannah. There actually would have been three of you. Three versions. There would be three of you. It would be very confusing. And I was like, you know, how does AJ relate to this? And then they, I mean, they literally said, well, then AJ could play the best friend part. Lily. Lily. I think, yeah. So they were like, why don't you have – and I was like, but it feels like it's my show.

10:29It's not really like the Hannah and Lily show. And I think at that point too, I was probably like close to being maybe 17 at that point, which is funny too because like we weren't on the channel for that long. Like I booked Phil at 13 and then by the time it was over, I was like, you know, whatever, 16 and a half or something. So I was like almost 17, I think, when that was offered. And I just remember thinking like, I've kind of done what I wanted to do here on the channel. You know what I mean? We had done Cowbells. The music had aired a lot on Disney Channel. Cowbells. I guess Cowbells we were just starting to like dive into.

11:08Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I did. You're right. I mean, obviously like that was meant to be for Miley. Yeah, totally. But that's so interesting how like those pivotal moments, obviously, like everyone was kind of up for certain roles that like it would have looked so different with you guys in that position versus her, obviously. OK, is it true, AJ, that you had your first kiss with Joe Jonas? Yes, that is true. Not me bringing up all the old stuff. I know. I'm like, of course. We got to go through it. We got to go through it. In a bowling alley. It was so innocent. Wee. A bowling alley. It was sweet.

11:42That's so cute. And did you guys like date for a long time? We dated for a while. I don't um I mean for like a young relationship like over a year is pretty good a half something like that's pretty solid that's a really long time yeah I feel like I was so curious like all of you guys were on such like different shows but like this was kind of your high school experience yeah so like how did you guys all hang out and like meet on different shows like what was the social dynamic like well we met on tour so the Jonas Brothers opened for us and that's when we started like there was like a spark and I was like oh this would be fun like we started dating on that trying to make like something happen with like me and Kevin and I was like it's not really vibing and then I mean bless but like yeah and then it was like no maybe you can like date the bass player Greg and I was like no it's still not vibing and I mean like again bless him too but of course but it just wasn't I was like no you can't like force it you can't force it it was like natural that I was yeah it was a natural buddies of course we were and it was a really fun tour um but I think beyond that so like for me it's like we were homeschooled our whole lives we didn't experience school dances we didn't but instead we had tour like at a really young age like to me i wouldn't trade yeah i wouldn't trade any of it because i'm like our experiences on the road were so cool and it's actually why i love touring as an adult yeah because i think it was ingrained in me at a young age that it was a really cool opportunity to have this moment to connect with your fans it's not jarring to like go on the road and i love it it's very natural like i think some people dive in as an adult and they're like i don't want to be on the road and we're like we love it bring it on right you're like this is all we ever know yeah yeah it's weird so anyway i wouldn't yeah there's nothing i would really trade back i just no no that's an amazing answer okay did you secretly date your phil of the future co-star for six years no no wait who said that that's funny is this like a thing on rumors online that you secretly dated phil of the future co-star for six years literally can attest never even kissed you guys didn't even it was always a friendship now although i remember like he's also older than you well and in that that age range felt huge like I was 13 and I think he was 16.

13:38I think he was a liar for years. That's a big gap at that age. But I remember during the test, like when I tested for Phil the future and I saw that he was the other boy that was up for it, I was like, he's really cute. And then of course you meet them and then you're like, oh, now we're just buddies. We actually became really good friends with his girlfriend during that show. Like he was dating a girl during that show. Yeah, that is true. Sweet. Yeah, so no, no, no. Okay, we're clearing up all the rumors. That is so funny. Years and years later. Okay, obviously we know Disney was like very strict now that like everyone kind of like knows the deal were you able to experiment at all like normal teenagers like have your first drink and like go to parties at all or no yeah yeah for sure you did yeah I feel like we had a healthy like teenage life yeah but like but we were like not party girls like for whatever that's worth I think the channel got very lucky having us yeah I mean in a weird way we should have been on for like 15 years because they would have been like they're good we don't need to be worried no it's true going like yeah for whatever reason we just were not like rebellious types both of us and i think maybe part of it was because we had each other yeah so it was like we didn't have to act out and prove ourself yeah to like our parents or it was just kind of nice yeah no you're right i don't even know what it is it's like luck i feel maybe it's just luck but also like ali and i this sounds kind of ridiculous but when we got a little older but we weren't quite like drinking age yeah people like kind of in la started like trusting us as the girls that would like go into ladue but not get hammered they're like let them in they can have a like like we knew some of the bouncers and they would just like mark our hand and they'd be like we trust you come on I'm not kidding like they're fine like they're never gonna be a liability no like truly and we kind of I mean and that was during the height of all of those girls you know where you see everybody like coming out of the club but like we were just fine you're like hi hi we'll just be like no problem in the club like a kiss ass it was just like who we were who we were which I think is which I think then made people be like oh my gosh you're so darling the a shocker girl is like they're just harmless sweet yeah that's pretty funny everyone knows you guys as Allie and AJ right like everyone it's Allie and AJ it's Allie and AJ have you guys ever resented that package deal concept no I think we've always like the duo aspect of it no we've never resented that I think the only thing that maybe we've been like gosh I wish we had had like a different band name that wasn't our names we didn't think it was cool like as kids we were the Ally and AJ thing because now it's just our names yeah it's very memorable no the duo thing didn't bug us didn't no no like when you guys were growing up at all obviously taking different projects and if like one was having more success than the other at a time like how did you guys handle that as sisters because I have a sister and I don't care what we're doing like we were competitive competitive you know what I mean and like we are always supportive each other but I do feel like naturally there can be moments where it's like oh like you're getting the better parts or you're getting the better roles or like did you ever have moments where you had to like sit down and be like let's talk this out I think the only time where we felt like okay we're getting um asked to go out for the same roles and we feel really strongly that one of us is really right for this and would you mind standing down like I think there were a couple times we both got the same audition or but usually one of us would come to the other and be like I'm really not right for this you should just go out for this and I'm just gonna and the other one wouldn't like that's happened before where we're like we've just like said okay fine you go for it like by the way it would never be between it would never be down to the two of us acting is so different yeah i think our ages our looks our energy like but we did get asked sometimes to go to the same yeah and i think some of that was just because of like i don't know some some parts kind of would overlap yeah yeah it's like you know 20 to 22 to 25 and we're like yeah but there was never a role specifically where i was like wow i really wish that had been me and like i kind of bummed was out like never like for me it was like I thought it was so cool that she was like an easy a and hell cats and like she's done great work and it always felt like it should be Allie you know what I mean that's and I always want to be her over anyone else so if I'm not gonna book it right it better be rather than be a family you know no that's such like a healthy way to look at it because anyone that has a sister I'm like I want my sister to win always and I think there's you're right there's like a natural also like aside from competitiveness you're also very protective of your sibling being like I want her to do the best but I also think it's very like healthy that you guys are able to have that because I'm not in the same industry as my sister like I can't imagine at some capacity you guys are intertwined and there is a slight competition in light moments that but that's kind of healthy that you guys are like we didn't feel it that much no no and like if anything where it was I mean I guess you could call it competitive it would be like if we like the same guy oh yeah let's talk about that yeah that would happen like that would happen every once in a while you guys had the same taste growing up similar right yeah similar i would say yeah our tastes were very similar yeah what are you guys adjusting now you're like i know i know adjusting wait stop so you guys at one point would like have a crush and how would you handle it well neither of us would get that guy yeah it was just like yeah neither of us we just both would be like we both liked him and both of us failed or like i remember this is funny that you asked us we were making a record in new york one that never ended up coming out and um we we have 10 of those yeah no just one but you're like one day maybe they'll come out yeah two um and we were we were feeling very cool that you were like you know living in new york for like a month no parents you know i don't know at this point we were like 21 and 22 and 20 right um and every night we were really obsessed with wanting to go out to all of these restaurants in new york we're like sometimes it didn't even make sense where it's like girl that's way on the other side of town all right you guys are from los angeles and you don't know shit love so we would be like okay we're going to catch or whatever and we went to this one restaurant called revel i don't know why i remember that how do you remember still around um and there was a cute guy that was our waiter and i left my number for him on the bill and i told aj and she was like what i was pissed and we left the restaurant i was like he was cute and she's like i know i left my number and i was like what like you mean i could have and i didn't like it almost was like judging me that i had done that you know and like put my so like put my neck out so dumb but obviously this guy never texted rude so you never called so right meanwhile i'm like i don't need to be competitive because i don't need to worry you either we i'm upset and did you guys ever ever ever hook up with the same person at any point in your lives like overlap of like years later you met up with someone like same kiss or yeah no no no there's been a couple like close calls yeah where it was like i liked that guy kind of and then it was like oh no like aj and him are kind of dating and then it would be like over after or there was a moment where i like tested for something and the leading guy i thought was really cool and then ally actually ended up dating him later yeah yeah but it wasn't like a i was also with him no no there's never been an actual crossover no thank god i mean that would be kind of weird we're so enmeshed in each other's lives already i know it's like you're literally like one in that concept like when i talk about because my sister's four years older than me and we've never dated the same guy yeah but even you talk about it incessantly with each other like when you start dating yeah obviously so it's like i couldn't go to her if i knew that she liked the guy that i was right she knows all the inside detail it out she's like i know i experienced all of it because with a family member i would be like katherine you need to get over it because i need to tell you everything she'd be like okay he was cute but now i'm over like literally held my hand while I broke up with a guy over the phone.

21:04I'm not kidding you. I did. She was like, do you remember that? It was in Calabasas. You were like, you can do it. I did. And I'm like on the phone with him being like, I really don't, this isn't right. Like I, and I'm like, is this good? And I'm like, you got it. No, that is like literal. That's also so, I mean, that just brought me back to that bedroom. Isn't that funny? Calabasas. Calabasas. Yeah. Yes, we were Calabasas kids. I know. Before it was cool. way before it was cool love that for you guys when it was a johnny rockets you know i mean like we're that far i love that for you we breaking up with someone is the worst feeling the worst it's sickening it's so hard it's actually sickening but that's why like people whenever i'm like it's there's nothing better than having a sister and it's i feel for my friends that are like i never had a sister i don't know what it's like it's like it's a friendship on steroids yes you are literally going to kill for her it's different than a brother completely it's actually almost It's just a diss to call it a friendship.

21:54It's like, no, this is living on another level. That's a great point. It's like an extension of yourself. Yes, yes. It's so fun hearing you guys talk about your dynamic together. And obviously so much of what you're writing also goes into like love and your life and your family. And but potential breakup song. I just have to ask the one question because I think it's like I saw TikTok. We're going to we have to make this TikTok. And it's someone being like, you guys remember when those two sisters walked into the studio and they really said this? I know. It's so funny. To this day, still such an anthem.

22:21What inspired that song? no you're not a real person not a real person stop it's actually the most like it's the most anti-climactic we answer there's no real person i need to pause you guys because the way you both just pause i thought i was about to get like yeah no sorry it's like record scratch it doesn't exist it doesn't okay tell me though i think we just were like what if there was a guy that was such a like I mean at this point we were 18 and maybe younger 17 and 15 writing this song which we had but like very little we had probably each had you would have probably two boyfriends I'd barely had one boyfriend because I was way behind behind her okay so like I'm like she was behind she was still a lot of the songs were like living in a dream world of what we thought a relationship was like because we were still really young yeah so to us it was like what if this guy was like so terrible that he didn't call you on your birthday and that you begged him to get your stuff back and he like wouldn't give it back and then you just had to deliver it in a box at your house.

23:22It's literally that. It's that. It's literally like you two sitting on your bed together being like, genius, let's go. Yes, let's go. But what's funny though was that we couldn't drive. Not a real dude. I do remember we were young enough that we weren't driving. Since there is no story behind it, tell me both of your like most brutal breakups.

23:58we've got a lot of girlies that listen how did you get through it what was your most like brutal breakup and how you got through it obviously like we're not naming names but just like the concept like have either of you ever been cheated on i mean age you go first yeah i was cheated on And I found out the guy was like hooking up with our really good friend at the time. No. How did you find out? It like blew up the friendship and the relationship. Yeah. I don't even know how it came out, but it happened in the Calabasas Commons parking lot. Stop. Yeah. And it was like – It was brutal. And we were young.

24:28So it was like – No. Obviously it hits hard no matter what age you are when you feel like, wow, I've been completely lied to. But this was like a friendship. Lied to. This was like a friendship, a girl friendship that was basically the breakup. It wasn't like the guy, if that makes sense. It was like we had found out some stuff about her that made us feel like we didn't really know who she was. And we had been friends with her for like a long time. And that was truly the worst breakup. And it was a girlfriend breakup. And then we mended. Like we're okay now. Years later. Like if we see her at a event or whatever, we'll DM and stuff.

24:59But we don't like hang actively, which is kind of sad because it was a big part of our childhood. That is so gross. That guy was like didn't even matter. Right. It's just the concept of what happened with the friendship. that's always the worst when like understandably people are like don't blame the girl blame the guy and it's like no no for sure but if you were almost closer with the girl than the guy that you were dating yes that's where it's like how do you recover from those moments and then it gives you like full trust issues because you're like how did I not know that and you could like hold my hand while I'm crying over this and little do I know I'm crying because of you oh yeah that's sick okay Allie go um okay I'm trying to think gosh worst um you haven't been cheated on I haven't been cheated on.

25:40That's nice. Which is actually good. That is good. I know. That's beautiful. That's good. That's good. I don't know what that says. Let's all clap for that. No trauma. Yeah. No trauma. I'm trying to think of. Hmm. I mean, I've had guys. I've had more guys probably break up with me than me break up with them. OK. So I've been broken up with probably quite a bit. Have you been blindsided by the breakups? I mean, I feel like I was blindsided many times. Yeah. Like. Not many. But a lot of them. It was like, you know, I was being broken up with because this person was like a professional athlete and was like, I need to work on my job.

26:18And like, you're a distraction. I'm like, bitch, I'm on a tour bus right now. You're a distraction. I need to work on my job? Yeah, I know. Wait. Ridiculous. Do you know where you're sitting? That couldn't have been a direct quote. No, that is the best direct quote I've ever heard. A professional athlete telling you I have to work on my job. we you know that I talk a lot about that yes yes we how long did you date it wasn't that long but it was very like um it was like a solid year maybe maybe a little I don't even know what sport hockey football football I remember being really heartbroken by that now I'm looking back on it being like but to any of the girls that are like I feel like around new year a lot of people end relationships because I feel like everyone's like oh my gosh like I want to start fresh I want to kick this person to the curb or I want to like try something different like do you have any advice when you look back at those relationships when people ended things with you as hard as it was in the moment now when you look back like give us some advice of how to get through those horrible blindsiding moments honestly like having a couple really solid guy friends was really helpful like I would talk to them about this and they'd be like this guy's a total loser like absolutely not and you know of course you could say well of course you're saying that they want to get with you but these were like truly platonic even if they do okay even if they do it's nice to hear but they were platonic relationships that were really like I would I would be on the phone like talking to Dan you know and be like can you believe this and he'd be like this is an absolute sign that this guy is not right for you and like he was only in it because he just wanted to like sleep with you and be done and over the next and you're like thank you Dan thank you Dan now let's hook up no I'm just kidding Yeah, totally.

28:03Okay, Daddy Gang needs some advice. And I feel like all I'm getting from this entire episode is you guys are very wise. And you've always been wise. And you've always been like. Or like little Yodas. No, literally. Like you guys. No, but actually. You guys have been like. People would let you into the club. Because they're like, Allie and AJ are going to keep it real. You guys didn't lose yourself to fame. You didn't lose. You guys have like seemingly like very normal lives. And you're still so successful. And you're still in the spotlight. So we need your advice. Okay. Okay. You want to end a friendship where you've been drifting apart.

28:33Do you have a breakup conversation with your friend or do you let it die out? I've done both. I've had more, if I'm being honest, I've had a couple die outs, not conversations, where it's just kind of like you kind of stop texting and then it's like. They also do. Yeah. And then it's like you kind of are like, we both know this isn't right. Which is kind of a form of ghosting. It's not great. It is. I think you should have the conversation. When you have the conversation. It's bigger to do that. Do you think those were more extreme moments? Like did something? Yes, it can make it too big of a deal.

29:01But it was usually because it was based on something that happened that I was like, I can't really not see this now. And it's here and let's talk about it. And this is why I can't go forward as a friend. But I think that's good advice. It's like you kind of have to gauge where you're at. If it's just like you never really see each other anymore, but you have this like weight over you and they're not that great to you. You can maybe let it simmer. Yeah, to me, some things don't need like a spotlight. True. Sometimes it's not like this big, huge fight. Sometimes it's like, I'm seeing some things about your lifestyle that doesn't gel with mine or that, you know, I don't know, you weren't there for me in these moments that I needed you.

29:37And it's kind of like showing your true colors. And that's OK. We just part our own ways. That's like sometimes that's part of just growing up and being a girl. I think that's what's like been so eye opening as I've gotten older, like growing apart from friendships is so sad. and it's like horrible to look back at like some of my like high school friends that I'm not as close with anymore whatever or just also like recognizing like we really grew up and we are different or like we live our lives differently and that doesn't mean they're a bad person you're just like it doesn't mesh anymore but it is sad when a part of your childhood in that way kind of dies like wait I just said bye to a friend in a way that I know I'm not really going to connect with again and I think it's like sometimes yes sometimes those are harder than actual breakups with men sometimes where you're like shit that hurt but I think that's a good like bit of advice is like you can do both but I think don't actively seek out a conversation if the person's gonna be like wait what are you talking about it's too much if something happens absolutely address it yes but you can also like let something simmer if that's like the natural course of where it was gonna go anyways yeah and it says a lot if both sides aren't really reaching out then it's like the natural course was for it to fizzle period that says everything in a way okay you find out you were accidentally the other woman do you reach out to her or do you stay out of it i'm the type that would reach out yeah we're both breathing so heavy we're all like i'm like yeah i think i would contact i think i would i think i would i'd say i'm the other woman i'm so sorry i didn't know um well what's funny is that we've seen one of our girlfriends, our close girlfriends do that.

31:14And I, it was like, I was kind of being like, don't do this. This is, this is cringe. Like why is this such a huge message? You know? I don't know if she did it right. She didn't do it right. I think there's a way you can. I mean, I've said that to her face. Like you didn't nail this. Oh, she literally wrote like a paragraph. Yeah, no, no, no. And also then that girl is like, uh, yeah, right. Sure, honey. You know? And then making her look like she's crazy when she actually was telling the truth are you making this up that you're really the other woman like yeah you look insane yeah oh this is really interesting yeah i think a paragraph to ever start something off bad you gotta go in shorter and just begin the convo rather than hit it hard where someone's like oh my god i need to like read this tonight when i have time like and sit down and actually think about this yeah but okay so you guys would both say something i would be like i'm sick i'm ill like this this happened I need you to know and I'm so sorry bye I kind of agree with that like I feel like if you were not again clarifying you didn't even know you were the other woman if you were aware like then that's a complete different situation that's like on you but yes but if you weren't aware I kind of agree because then even if she stays on her you know totally at least you had your moment to say like this moment happened and I said my piece and like I can live with that Love this.

32:28Yeah. If you knew one of your close friends was cheating on her husband, who you're also friends with, how do you handle that? That's really hard. That's really hard. That's never happened. Thank God. Has that ever happened to you? Maybe not husband or boyfriend. I have known – not husband, but yeah, I've known that there's like shadiness going on. And you're close to both of them. Yeah. And I kind of stayed out of it because I just didn't know. Did it dissolve on its own with you staying out of it? You know what's interesting? Are they still together? I'm not really that close with them anymore, so I don't know what happened.

33:00But I also think maybe that partially is because it was like bleeding into every part of their like when you're lying that heavily in your life. That's a good point. It bleeds into every other moment in your life. Like she was more distant because she was being so cagey. And then I was kind of like, I don't know. Oh, wow. Yeah. I think it depends on maybe who like who's the OG friend. Is it is it her or is it the guy? Like, I don't know. If you met him at the same. I mean, if you met at the same time, it's it's hard. It's so hard. I'd like to think I'd have the courage to say something or to be like, I don't know, like, is everything okay?

33:28Well, I want to think if I'm the same woman who's going to tell the person I was the other woman and didn't know until just now, I'd be that same person to say this. That's a good point. Like, I'd like to think those two ladies are the same person. You know what I mean? I agree. Like, bold. I agree. I think what's hard sometimes in friendship dynamics is, like, there's a lot of dynamics I feel like you start to feel as you get older and there's cheating involved. I have found sometimes I'm not privy to all the information of these people's relationships and a lot of times I'm like oh you kind of knew that sure like I didn't get the whole side yeah so I'm like if I'm super close if it was my best friend and I'm fine I'm hearing something I'm telling her obviously and be like I love you so much and I support you I just need to tell you I know this and then I'm here whatever you want to do yeah yeah because I think it's half the time the judgment that people feel when someone brings that information they get so anxious like I have to leave him now or I have to leave her now.

34:21And it's like, I don't know. Sometimes I feel like I come off as judgy when you tell them. So I also think your delivery has to be like, I love you. And I know this is so hard. But I saw so-and-so at this restaurant and this is weird. And I'm leaving this information. Yes. But I'm here for you if you want to talk and like, whatever you do, I love you. I think now in my thirties, that is how I would approach it. But it would take me a hot minute to come to that. Yes. Like bravery of like, okay, we're doing this. You'd call your sister first. Yes. We'd rehearse it. Totally. We'd rehearse it. I'd hold her hand while she says the conversation or we would go in person and I'd hold her hand in person.

34:52Thank you, Raleigh. Okay. You accidentally send a screenshot of the conversation to the person you were gossiping about. How do you play it off? Have you guys never done that? No. Oh my God. I have. I've never done that. Have you done it multiple times or just once? In college, I was talking shit about the guy that I was seeing and I was like texting my friend and I was sunbathing. I was at Boston University. I remember exactly where I was laying. I was in my little bikini and it was so bright out. and I was holding my phone up texting and I was talking to this hockey player. Couldn't see. He was so dumb and I was just like so over it.

35:24And you texted it to him. I screenshotted it, send it to him being like, hockey player wants me to go on his boat later. Like I'm going to have to have like a couple drinks. And it went to him. And then what was his response? Was he like, um. Well see now you can unset. I know. So we're in a good era for that. So now we're good. Guys, I literally responded. I'm pretty sure like first I called my mom. screaming like I you guys I am under the sun I realize I do it I'm pretty sure he responded like lol at first which is like actually yeah that's kind of he was probably thinking like oh that's funny this is a funny joke right yeah it shows how you're like yeah I'm like I am hilarious yes no and then I was like lol I'm just kidding like I just can't decide if I want to come like what are you thinking good job you guys did he did he roll with it he completely rolled with it wow Saw him later that night.

36:15But that says even more. You did start the conversation saying he wasn't smart. So like. Completely. Also why did I go? I don't know. I was bored. You know what I mean? Yeah. That's fair. I think it was an ego thing where I was like I have to see this man to like make sure that he actually forgave me. Like this is insane that he doesn't recognize that I was completely shit talking him. Insane. I would be more likely for sure to do something like that. 100 % it would be. Way more. You would. Way over me. Like I'm actually surprised that hasn't happened. But it has. Once or twice. Wait because you're just like you're gonna do some like clumsy shit where you're like how did i get in this situation where he's like hello you're on the wrong group chat it's like oh shit there will be times we're all like sidebar chat to her and i'll be like just so you know you're talking in a way that if this leads to more this you're in the wrong you're in the wrong you're on the wrong track here and she'll be like oh thank you totally thank you yeah that is kind of like younger sister energy though like correction officer i call my sister and i'm like are you okay and And she's like, what?

37:09And I'm like, why are you sending that to the family group chat? We were just texting. And she's like, oh my gosh, I don't know. Like, yeah, I'm kind of. That's funny. That is, yeah, that does track his younger sister. It is. It is. It's like, we know everything. Like, stay in line. Exactly. Okay, do you guys ever go on double dates? Oh, yeah. Yeah. I mean, with our people now. With our guys now. With our guys now. I don't think in the past. Have we ever really done that in the past? I'm trying to think. Before Steven and Josh? No, I don't think so. I don't think so. That's become more of an adult like.

Read the full transcript

37:34Yeah. It's been like three wheeling where it's like two people on a date and then I'm like, hey, I'm here hanging with you having lunch, you know, or that's true. Yeah. Let's talk about Steven and Josh. So serious. Ali, you met your husband when you were in your early 20s. Yeah. What made him stand out to you? I don't know. I just got a vibe like this guy is just different. Like he's really deep. He's very mature. He's just like tapped into something. Where'd you guys meet? uh we met on a set he was the dp and i was the like lead actor in this like really tiny little indie um and i don't know like i just picked up this energy from him that um like just instantly i was kind of like this guy is like i'm like safe with this guy like i can really be myself around him and he's like artistic and he really cares about this project and how he's talking about it and how he is on set.

38:30He has very much like a leadership kind of energy, even though he was very young and it was the first movie that he was, you know, a DP on. So I don't know. It was just like, it was a meant to be thing. And at the time I was seeing a guy that I was in, like I call it like a kept relationship. Wait, what? Like I couldn't get out. It was just like, he was a guy who was older than me. A kept relationship. That I had lost my virginity to, to be completely honest. And I was like, girl, we gotta get rid of him. I was like, I'm good. Like, it's all good. Like, this is a sweet memory and moment, but like, we're done.

39:03You did break up and he got you back. And he was like, I made you a woman. Like, bad. He said that. He did. Ali is cringe. No. Yeah. It's cringe. It's really cristic. We know. How long were you together with him? Like a year, year and a half. Yeah. I made – I know, I know. You hated me. AJ did. Well, you had an okay friendship with him in the beginning. In the beginning. It's someone that should have always been like a guy friend. Yes. Like, never should have dated. 100%. For a man to say that he made you a woman, I will kill you. No, I know. I know. I know. It's gross. But the fact that I was like kind of chill, like almost kind of like a bro, like this is nice.

39:37Like whatever. Like who cares? I lost my virginity to you. It's like not that big of a deal. And he like had it in his diary. Yeah. It was very much a big deal. Like, wow, I'm excited about this. Wait, how did you end a relationship with him? Because that's hard. Like to be like someone that's clearly he was more into it than you. Yeah. You called it a kept relationship. Yes. I know. I know. I mean, you did end it. And then remember he like convinced you to stay in it? To stay in it. So I like, we had broken up and then we got back together. And then I'm on this movie, like hanging out, you know, shooting in Sequoia National Park.

40:07We're all, we're all staying in these cabins at the base of the mountains. So like after we would wrap, we all would eat dinner together and hang out and like run lines or whatever. And I just remember like essentially like talking shit about him to people being like, I don't know. I'm like, I'm in this relationship, but like, I got to get out of it. But like, you know, at this time it was like what? It was like November, beginning of November. So I was probably thinking like, you know, I'm going to try to wrap this up and be on my way. But I knew that I had agreed to do a movie that he was directing that was next.

40:41It was the next film. So I had to do this next movie with him as the director. And I broke up with him at the beginning of the movie. I was so brutal. But then had to be in it. But had to be in it. Directed by him. Yeah. And he would be kind of trying to be like, no, like we can make this work. And I was like, we're done. I really don't want to do this. Wait, you're so strong for that. It was brutal. I do not recommend doing that. I recommend just bailing out of the movie and not doing the movie. True. But also that's like your career where you're like, do I do it? That's tough. Yeah, it wasn't great.

41:08That's also like, ladies listening, I have been in that situation before. When you try to break up with someone, anyone, whatever gender. And they don't let you go, okay? They literally won't let you. And they won't let you. That means it's really bad. Run. Run. Get out. It's kind of like firing someone that's like, you're not doing this. I'm not leaving. What? But why would you want me now? Like, if I'm firing you, we're not going to be a good match. He would always be like, no, that's normal. Like, there'd be, like, ups and downs. Like, sometimes, like, you'll be in and out of love. I'm like, no, no, no.

41:36That ain't how it works. No, when someone doesn't want you, listen to them and leave. Yes, believe them. Oh, my God. Okay, wait. So when you met Ali's husband, like, were you immediately, you like. No, in the beginning, I was like. I think she was a little judgmental. Hated. There's some. Not hated. I was like, there's some crossover that's happening here. I was a little judgy. I'm not going to lie. Okay. Even though I knew Allie was going to get out of it, I was like, you should have gotten out of it like six months ago and then you'd be like free and clear, but whatever. At least he turned into my husband.

42:02True. He turned into the husband, so I'm happy. Love that for you. And he's literally become like my brother. Like I love him. And I have so much respect for him as a husband and a dad. Like to watch him as a father, like it's really beautiful. But in the beginning, I was like, I don't know about this guy. Why? Like he was really shy. He was really quiet. I don't do great with quiet people, except for like when I was translating. Except for she's a translator. But like in general, like I'm like, come on, like let's go. Like let's have a conversation. Like I've got a really bubbly personality. And he was just very quiet.

42:31He's like an intellectual. He's very, he's super grounded, super smart. And I think I felt maybe like a little like, okay, here's this like Ivy League guy. I'm not going to be able to like carry a conversation with him. He's probably smarter than me. Like I think I was intimidated. I get that. And again, back to what we were saying with sisters, it's like you're so protective. and you have to look for her blind spots. Yes. That's how I am with my sister. Like she's dating right now. And I'm like, no, what is going on? And what it like, because I'm just like, I want the best for her. So naturally it is your job almost to be like, I don't like you until you prove that I should like you.

43:03Yes. And then he did. And I was like, I love him. Although two years later when he proposed, I like sobbed. Oh yeah. And you knew before. Yeah. I got so, not because I wasn't happy for Allie. I literally felt like I'm like, I'm going to lose my sister, I think. Like I had this weird, unrealistic idea that a marriage meant that then the sisterhood would be over. Like I literally went up. We were living together in Laurel Canyon and we were sharing a place and I went upstairs. I lived in the top loft and I like closed my closet door and I sobbed. I was so happy for her. But at the same time, I was like, I'm literally going to lose my sister.

43:33And it didn't happen at all. Of course. Here we are. Yeah, here we are. I do think that's really relatable. Like I've talked about this with my siblings, especially like around the holiday season. You get to spend more time with your family. and it is kind of like sad when you start to get older and adults and do all the things that adults should be doing and your core family starts to expand and it's like now you're creating your own family right and your own memories and traditions and it's so sad but exciting but I relate to that a lot of like as we are all growing older you're like we I want to hold on to my siblings and what we had in our core don't grow up and don't leave me yeah really it's more just like there's now more memories and there's more fun.

44:13Yes. It adds to it. You mourn that a bit. Nothing dies. No. But I get why you would freak out. Cause like I'm the same way. You're going to, on the wedding night, like God bless our dad. But like he, we were doing like a dance, even though it was a father daughter dance later down the road, it wasn't my father daughter dance. You had had yours, but I was like later dancing with dad. And I was like, this is a really sweet moment. And dad goes, honey, how are you doing? And I was like, I'm really happy for them. Like, I feel really good about this. And he was like, that's awesome. You know what?

44:37You lost a sister but you gained a brother and i was like what the huh i mean it was everything i had cried about he didn't mean my dad just our dad talks like that yeah like he and i was like huh you're like wait come again you're like dad this is why i've been mentally unwell for the past couple years yes unwell but this is also the same man love you dad shout out to dad and mom great people this is also the same man who like lost his father a few years ago and steven never got to meet him our grandpa and literally at the funeral i wasn't at the funeral because i was working at the funeral told steven i want you to meet my dad and he was dead in the car but he's in the like that's like we're just we're not we're not like that verbiage is interesting it's just interesting you're like dad i want you to meet my dad it's no longer okay he's no longer here shake his hand yeah i don't know how wait you were there to witness i was there you said that steven handled it as steven handled it so well he was like okay mark steven's like mark i am gonna meet your dad and we're gonna hit it off over here.

45:39Stares at the open casket. But dads can say some really, really wack stuff. You guys, it's unwell. The more and more they get older, dads, you have to smile. My dad has been saying some love you dad, some crazy shit lately. I'm like, huh? Love you dad. Love you dad. Happy holidays. Happy holidays. You're all insane. Okay, AJ, you have a boyfriend. I do. It's been six years yeah how did you guys meet we met at a film festival in napa oh yeah um allie and i i know it was actually bougie allie and i had made a film with her husband that had gone to the napa valley film festival and he had produced and starred in a short film that was shortlisted for an oscar that year that was also premiering at the film festival oh wow and it was an amazing short film and him and i met and like there was like a spark but at the time he was with his girlfriend there and i was dating someone in canada classic i loved long distance for a while which was just really an odd face.

46:33Yeah, Adrian was really on that kick. And I just was like, gosh, I'm going to know this guy for a while. And I don't know how or why. And it's going to happen at some point. But I remember he was wearing this like lumberjack, red, black flannel. And I was just like, this guy is hot. And he's like salt of the earth vibes. And then down the road, a year later, he was single, I was single, and we connected on Instagram. And we needed somebody in our video. In our video. To be a victim in our video because we were playing vampires. And you're like you. And you were like, can we kill you in a video?

47:05He's really hot. He should be in the video. Like, let's have him in it. Wait, what was your first impression? How did you meet him? When did you meet him? I met him at the festival. Yeah, I think you did. Like with you. Because maybe, was there like a crossover? We were on a panel or something together? I think, yeah, yeah. I think so. And then we did the video shoot and he was like super down. And then we had a couple girlfriends come and also be victims. And they were like down to just kind of like hang out for the day. When they started dating, were you protective or no? I don't know. What do you feel like?

47:32I feel like because you already had Steven in play for such a good chunk of your life, you've lost some of that because you're set and you're like, she's got this. Yeah. I think maybe when AJ was younger, I was more protective or more like, who is this guy? Like, what are you after? Are you actually a loser? And you're just like hiding it really well. Yep. But I feel like I've always been on like good terms with most of the guys that you've dated. I feel like you have too. Like kind of a friendly banter. Yeah. You maybe not as much where you've been like friends with my exes. True. In a way, I've been more judgmental about who she's dated than the other way around.

48:05Which again, maybe is the little sister, big sister thing. Oh, me too. I'm like, you're a fucking loser. You don't deserve my sister. My sister's like, Alex, I've gone on two dates with this man and you just ran into him on the street in New York. This wasn't even a planned meeting. I'm like, back off. Yeah, yeah, yeah. He's like, what? Um, okay. I'm like, yeah, that's a nightmare to have me. Your parents are divorced, right? Yeah. How do you guys think their divorce informed how you approached your romantic relationships in your adult lives? if I'm going to speak for AJ I think that oh oh no that's fine don't speak for you speak for me I think I mean we kind of do in general we speak for each other like maybe a bad habit but um I I think that AJ as the little sister vibes was more like heartbroken by yeah I took it really bad and took it really what age did they get divorced 19 and 21 okay okay 19 21 so like in a way you're old enough to know exactly what happened all the details like I I think there's a there's a positive and a negative to it but I think for us I was shattered it helped that I was on a tv show and I was living by myself alone for the first time out in Vancouver oh yeah and so I was just focused on that and you were like left at home to be at home with my mom still all of us at that point were living together and you were kind of mourning the divorce a little bit with her so I think in a weird way you like carried some of that trauma with you where I was kind of like bye I'm off shooting the show for eight nine months and then I came home but when we wrapped we ended up living together we lived with our mom while she kind of dealt with getting her life back together after the divorce like we it would end up being like a home of three women like yeah kind of it was like three's company but just yeah just ladies yeah no that kind of stuff like i know can like you're right affects people in different ways literally down to like logistically where you were at in the middle of your parents getting divorced can play such a role in like how it genuinely affected you because you got to be essentially removed correct yeah do you That's a good point.

49:55Did you notice anything with like how that affected when you started to like engage in romantic relationships? There was infidelity with what happened. We're actually like super close with both parents and I was able to forgive our father. And like I actually feel like we're in a great place now. But at the time it was really hard for me. And I think when I was dating people I immediately had this trigger that like they're going to cheat up. Like they're going to like because how could that happen after 23 years of marriage? Like I feel bad talking about it because I love my dad. But like it really was one of those things that became a trigger point that like didn't really need to be there.

50:25Like no one needs to be assuming you're being cheated on. You just feel like you've seen it now. So you're like it's going to happen. It's horrible. I also think like that's such an interesting dynamic because I could be sitting here with someone that had their parents get divorced when they were like six and it fucked them up. It is interesting hearing you guys talk about because I know this is a very, very, very relatable topic, which like I have a friend that has a similar situation to you guys with your parents. when you are that age and you're very deep and about to begin to explore your romantic adult relationships to have a foundation that was like pretty it seems like pretty solid yeah for your whole very well people would be shocked you know to find out to find out like yes what the machaca family they broke up so your reality was so like disrupted i can imagine that yes like then you're like we if i can't trust like my dad then i can't trust any of these men when really again it's like they're doing this for the first time too and that's their relationship or whatever but it affects you it does girls but I don't think it's like or at least I didn't feel like it turned me off from marriage or not believing in marriage for whatever reason no no I think we still like believed in the idea of it and and I don't know I think we always felt like okay there is a there There is a chance that you can actually have a successful marriage in this day and age.

51:47You just got to really work on it. And I think if I'm. They stopped working on it. Yeah, they stopped working on it. If I'm going to be the little Yoda that I am in my heart. Bring it. Here we go. That I am in my heart. I love it. I'm kidding. I love you. I'm joking. But I do love Yoda, actually. The child. Yeah, the child. We love Grogu. I think that not working on the relationship between the mom and dad, like, is the whole end of the marriage because everything was poured into me and AJ. And that was almost like a scapegoat. And then it was like, oh, we don't work on ourselves. We're not going to be in therapy.

52:23We're not going to do these things. We're not going to make sure that you are flown out on tour every, you know, two and a half weeks while my mom is out with us. being the parents that were really there for the two kids in the industry but then it's like but then your guys's relationship apart which then affects us right that's interesting i saw someone recently talking about um when people just become their identity as being a mother or a father it's like you can't just be one thing like what's your identity to yourself what's your identity to your partner and that's how you lose yourself if you're just one i wonder like obviously how old is your child he's he'll be eight months I mean I guess when he's when we when this is out like oh my god you know almost almost oh my god yeah how has like that concept of like recognizing still needing to pour because you're in the thick of it right now like you've got basically a newborn how have you tried to like work with your partner to make sure you guys are good even in the excitement of having like a new child and that's all you want to talk about well I think I think making moments where it can be the two of us or even if like our kid is around it's like okay well he's like asleep right now we can still kind of have like a little date night and go out to dinner and put him in his little stroller and like it can still be romantic or we can put a movie on or we can get away to our favorite place in big sur and it can be not just all about the kid you know no your son is so adorable like when he was at tour i was literally like this is the most calm baby i literally walk into your dressing room he's here yeah you can see him i see him after yeah yeah he's not in a match and we couldn't get miniature but he's in a little switcher you would have tried you know I'm obsessed the merch team was like we can't get that turned around they're like please calm down you're like okay fine okay we're gonna go through now I wanna do new music and we're gonna play one last game because I think it's fun because sister dynamic

54:27Okay, ready? Who is the more bougie one between the two of you? Who likes the nicer stuff? I don't know. Maybe AJ. She'll splurge on more like a skincare thing or doing like your nails. Your skin is beautiful. Thank you. Facials, massages. Oh, yeah, the spa, the spa. We both love a spa, but I tend to like maybe do it a little too much. I was going to say, is that like what is the luxury thing you can't live without? The spa? Yeah, facials. Like every, like three weeks. Well, it's paying off. Thank you. You have great skin. Oh my, you do at some days. Did you ever have bad skin, like as a teen?

55:02Did you? Oh my God, yes. So like, I will take all the compliments. No. Oh my God, you guys, I had like full accutane when I was younger. Oh wow. Really? But it was just like very hormonal and then like I got over it. And then it was gone. Wow. And now like, here we are. Blowing. Facials. Okay, who is more likely to take a secret to the grave? Me. Probably AJ. Yeah, AJ. Yeah. You just smiled so big. I was like come on you're like give it to me although yeah that is true AJ I'm like come on bitch it's me but I'm pretty good at keeping a secret no you are but with each other like got it to the grave together do you know what I mean but that's not to the grave I know but it's like it has to be between the two of us who is more likely to pick a fight between the two of you I mean we both can pick a fight with each other pretty like quickly pretty quickly if it's the right subject matter you know the right thing if it's like we're disagreeing on something like how something was handled like AJ will be like you had a bunch of typos in this one business email.

55:56I'm like, who cares? Yeah, I'll correct the correction officer. She's like, you're writing an email like you're texting. I'm like, this is sloppy. This isn't good for our business. I'm like, okay. I'm like, sorry, like that. But that's not even a fight. But I usually start something sooner, I feel like, than you do. That's probably true. Yeah, AJ's maybe a little more fiery. I love. If you had to say, what is your biggest pet peeve about each other? I just like start a full fight between you guys on this podcast. Oh my gosh, I have it. Wow. Oh, wow. Allie started doing this in the last, like, year very consistently.

56:27I actually don't think I have addressed it with you. Oh, my God. Where she'll go, maybe you could do that. Yeah, you're right. It's me. It's me being like. She'll start a sentence that she's asking you to do something, but instead it's like, maybe you could get that bottle, like, for Jack. Or, like, maybe you could get that. That's true. You know what I'm talking about. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't know how you word it exactly. I think it starts with maybe you could. Oh, interesting. And it's like a, you want me to? Like, you want me to? Or I could maybe do it. question and I'll do it. Okay. So I should just be asking the question or just be like, get me this.

56:53Can't stand it. Get me this. I mean, I'd rather you just say like, do that. Get the burp cloth. Maybe you could. Maybe you could. Oh, interesting. Oh, that's infuriating. That drives me nuts. That's a good one. That is a great one. Okay. Your turn. Ooh, AJ. Okay. We both are OCD and And we know this about each other. But AJ loves to reorganize an area that I've already kind of pre-tried to organize knowing that AJ doesn't like something moved. That's true. Like the shoes or something. I'm like, okay, she'll like it in this corner. And then it's like moved and it's like the shoes are just in a different corner but they're still on the ground.

57:27And you're like, I literally cleaned for you. I'm like, I'm clean for the OCD. Like just trying to get ahead of it. But that's OCD. You can't. It's a beauty. It has to be your way. You know what I mean? It doesn't make any damn sense but it's your way. No. There's nothing logical. Yep. Nothing logical. It's like this pile of clothes. You're lucky I did not reorganize this bookshelf. I can't imagine what you're feeling in this room. It's only in my own space. That's what's weird. Okay, that makes me feel good. It's never in someone else's ever. Who is the first to usually apologize if you guys are coming back from a fight?

57:55Probably AJ. Yeah. Allie, I don't even remember the last time you said I'm sorry. Yeah, yeah. I'm not good at saying it. She does not apologize. Yeah, that's true. Okay. No, but you said you're usually lightly starting it and then you're ending it. Yes. Love that for you. I'm a closer. um you guys your new music okay we're here let's talk about it you have a new album coming out and a single the single is coming out on january 10th love what is it called what it feels like we were supposed to do that at the same time but it's fine yeah let's do it again ready okay what is it called what it feels like wait and five six seven eight what it feels like gorgeous gorgeous okay talk to me about this album what is the inspiration behind the music I mean this record feels like it's never been more us obviously every single album you're hoping to achieve you know that 10 better right each time just like you would with like each you know season of the show but I do feel like we've really stepped into like our womanhood on this album And I think part of that is, is I think just seeing that this music has been so informed by our live show and touring and playing songs to a live audience and with our band that we've now been playing with for a few years has really helped us identify, okay, this is the kind of music we want to put on a record and what we want to then go out and tour.

59:22so I think it's looking at it from like the live show is the the top of the pyramid and how do we get to the live show um and I think a lot of this music was um created with people that we felt really safe with and was while I was like heavily pregnant I mean I guess we started writing it right before I got pregnant and then really the whole making of this album has been either me pregnant and then delivering and then album is finished and delivered itself oh my god yes her water broke in like day two of like pre-production at her house at my yeah in the guest room wait at like 6 a.m that's kind of like i was texting with steven it was very it was very like what's going on in there he's like i think her water broke i was like what we just started and then i got really nervous thinking ocd i was like she's gonna be pissed because this water is on her bed and on the ground not when it's like your child although that is pretty funny ali's like clean it up get Get the rags.

1:00:21We. That's funny. Oh my God. We. Okay. Yeah. So how long was the writing process of this album? The writing was finished. So I would say the writing took a solid year. Yeah. Yeah. I would say so. Before we really were ready to be like, these are the 15 songs we want to record. We're very like. Like just. Maybe just under. Maybe just under a year. Yeah. This is a hard question. What is your favorite song off the album? That's hard. I'm so happy with this record, but I really think my number one is Michael's song. We wrote it about a really dear friend of ours that we had worked with in the industry for years, and he passed away last year.

1:00:54Yeah. And we were like, we have to write about this. And we were on tour. We were on tour during the funeral. We weren't able to come. Our parents came on behalf of us, which was really sweet. We're really close to his daughter and his wife. Yeah. Literally like a longstanding member of the Alley Major team. Like the longest running team member. Yeah. For us. Like, you know, so it was like - He was our business manager for years. It was kind of almost like a father figure. Oh. You know, so it was very hard to come to terms with it. And then we we felt like this could be a song, you know, and it's so specific.

1:01:25Like when you listen to the song and you read the lyrics, you're like, oh, this is this is very specifically about like the very last time we saw him. And not knowing, of course, it would be that it was like our last dinner. But I feel like that's such a powerful message because everyone has experienced grief. So they'll be able to like transport themselves probably when they're like the last time they saw whoever it was to them that they lost. and they what is your favorite honestly it's kind of a tie between two and I think it's because it has to do with my son and then the fact that I was leaving Laurel Canyon to then live in Santa Barbara like away from AJ and I wrote I basically wrote this song with AJ about um like moving into this new house and this new space and it not feeling like a home and feeling like I was kind of like summoning it to be this place that I felt welcomed in.

1:02:18And not like it had like bad juju or vibes. I just was like, this isn't perfect and this isn't right. And I want to change out this doorknob. And my husband was just like, okay. And I'm like pregnant and like nesting. And I'm just like frantic. I'm like, fix this. This needs to be fixed. And it just, and I was like, you know what? This would be a good song. Like willing this to happen and to make this space a home. And I really love AJ's, the way she sings the bridge on that song. The song's called I Don't Know What It Is. And I think that song, just whenever I listen to it, it's almost kind of healing because I'm finally at a place where the home doesn't feel like – A shell?

1:02:56Yeah, like a shell. It feels like, oh, this is a place that has good memories and I associate like my birth. And I birthed in this living room right here. And this wasn't traumatic. This was all kind of what I hoped it would be. Oh. That's beautiful. Yeah. So I think it's like the end story of it is really great, but it was very much me struggling to find my identity within the home. And then the other song that's like maybe equal to that is a song called Dandelions, which is about Jack. And we kind of wrote this pre him being born, which is crazy. Knowing he was coming. Knowing he was coming and that we wanted him to like have this message of hope and like whatever dreams we're not able to reach, he is more than capable of reaching them himself, you know.

1:03:37And hopefully each generation reaches more. Oh my God. How crazy and cool that you guys like one day like your son will get to watch you perform a song about him live and listen to it and have it forever. Like that's such a beautiful gift. I mean that is the power of songwriting. Yeah. Like it really is. I think the other thing about specifically songwriting, and it's funny because I'm learning constantly about music we've actually already written, but I'm learning new things about what we've written after the fact. Like to me, when a song takes on a new life, but it had a different meaning when you wrote it.

1:04:08Yes. Like, I don't know what it is. Now, when I listen to that song and I picture your home, which you've now created from the ground up as like a beautiful nest, I'm like, whoa, this is so different than how we came at this song, writing it, thinking we're splitting up as sisters. We're no longer going to live in the canyon by each other. We're like, what are we doing? We're going to be torn apart. And it's like, no, we're just shifting into other parts of our life. Right. Now that song is like shows your growth because now your house is a home and now you're so happy. And this is what I love how songwriting teaches you something, but you wrote it.

1:04:38Like in a year later, you're listening to it differently. It's so cool. In a way. That's really cool. It is prophetic. How songwriting is. It is. And I think with this record, there was so much like feminine energy around it. And I think part of that was me being pregnant. But then part of that was us just going through the growing pains of like, we are getting older and we don't live down the street from each other. And we, this, like, we aren't living in our childhood really anymore. We're, we're out of that phase. And we're not in our twenties anymore, which we just got reminded by an executive.

1:05:05Yeah. Yeah. Literally. Stop. No. We went to have a meeting. Like, I'm not kidding. Like a label meeting. Literally like last week. The note was like, we love the record. We think it's amazing. But like, we're not here to break women in their thirties. Like we're here to break pop stars in their twenties. we need to be like 21 or something i was like i'm 35 i'm 33 i was like we're still young as hell and i was like now i'm reminded that we're not after the meeting she's like i'm sorry i just i have to kind of like like not after the meeting i had a process after we had heard that it was a no so it was like you know we did the meeting and then it was like you know whatever it was two days later it was like oh a call is coming you know and we're kind of going okay well i want i hope it's like positive and then that was the feedback and he was like i just need to sit with this for a minute because i'm like i've never even thought of myself as not being in the zeitgeist of you're But it's also like, is the music good or no?

1:05:49Right. Like, what does it have to do with how old I am? I know. And it's like, how many times do you think they've said that to a man? Probably never. Probably never. We're not trying to break a – what? I know. I know. Also, I'm like, we're not horses. Yeah, yeah. Totally. Like, you don't need to break us. Totally. And we've broken. You know what I mean? And also, I think part of it was, besides, you know, like you said, the fact that it's maybe not ideal age for breaking an artist, whatever, in the music industry. I think part of it was also like the album was completed and done they couldn't meddle and change stuff because it's finished it's not like hey here's some demos and they're like oh yes we love track one no to two three and six change this sound and you're like no and they were like you know and we wouldn't maybe go down this route like sonically for you I'm like like us playing music and writing the music like what do you mean yeah it's wild so it was though a blessing that you guys did it on your own and you don't want to work with someone that doesn't want to like doesn't want you in the way you are exactly at right now.

1:06:45Clearly, you guys said you have other records that you never put out. This feels right to you. So go with what feels right. It's a message that is very pure in what it is. There's no like a gimmick behind it. So they're not like, oh, I can like. It's harder to sell sometimes. Yeah, it's harder to sell something because they're like, what's the shtick? And it's like, just we're sisters. We play music. We write. We've been doing this since we were young. But I think that's like the best part about you guys. Like I have to say, growing up and listening to you guys, you have such incredible voices.

1:07:16But hearing you perform live at my tour, I remember like pinching my best friend Lauren being like their voices are so beautiful. Like literally you guys have like such incredible voices. And what I appreciate about you guys and about this album is actually more like that it is real. It is obvious when people have not written their music and when they're told to wear the certain thing and look the certain way. just kind of like you guys are describing you would go into meetings and you feel people trying to shift and mold you into something that you're not and i think if people are looking for something in their life music wise that's actually going to connect them to the real shit that they're going through this is more of the album i think like people right now are more interested in than maybe who knows no but sure you can love pop but like i really think that you guys are connecting to something that people are loving which is authenticity so it's exactly what you're sure I mean, yeah.

1:08:09And I feel like people gravitate towards that. You know, I think people are searching for that. That's why this show works. Like it's authentic. Because it's speaking to the truth of how women talk and how women feel and how we communicate with our friends. But you knew that was a missing piece. Yes. Yeah. Was it really going on? I think it's so exciting to see you guys like back at it. And I think it also is such a testament to like your ability to be critical of yourselves, to be like, we didn't put out certain albums because it didn't feel right and we weren't ourselves and so the fact that like this is all you this was done at a very incredible vulnerable emotional time in both of your lives like I think that the world is going to be so so so excited to hear and they're going to love it so I'm so excited for you guys you are so lovely as human beings I know we haven't spent that much time together but like I feel like I now know you guys enough to be like you guys are real ones so thank you so much for taking the time during the holidays and coming and sitting down with me you guys are the best happy new year you could be a little sister.

1:09:06Oh, I'm putting it on. You're an honorary. We look like we're related. You're the youngest sister. You are the youngest. I'm coming. I'm coming in. I'm going to put it on. Love you guys. Love you too. Thank you. Love you.

From the publisher

Join Alex in the studio for an interview with Aly and AJ! Aly and AJ reminisce on their iconic Disney Channel days, touring with the Jonas Brothers, and what it was like dating at the network. They also discuss their sister dynamic, judging each others’ partners, their most brutal breakups, and their advice about cheating, losing friends, and getting caught talking shit. Enjoy!


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from Call Her Daddy

All 350 episodes
Aly & AJ: Disney & Dating DisastersCall Her Daddy · 1 h 9 min
Listen in VO