1. Podcasts
  2. Capitalisn't
  3. Can Capitalism Be Popular?
Capitalisn't

19 Nov 2026 · 48m · 17 chapters

Episode artwork

Can Capitalism Be Popular?

In short

Whether capitalism can be popular in the US—i.e., whether it delivers enough for most people to sustain democracy—plus policy debates on health care, unions, taxes/wealth taxes, and money in politics.

Guests (and backgrounds)

Bethany McLean (journalist; author of A Capitalist for the People; hosts/hosts Capital Isn’t). Luigi Zingales (economist; Stigler Center faculty director; argues neoclassical economics underemphasizes power). Steve Kaplan (economist; argues inequality/poverty are overstated; points to Medicare/Medicaid and consumption measures). Ileana Kuzimenko (Princeton economist; proposes lowering Medicare eligibility age gradually). Eric Hosner (University of Chicago law professor; argues unions can counter employer monopsony power). Brad Markell (former AFL-CIO executive director; emphasizes power and rejecting “billionaires” false promises). Ray Madoff (BC law professor; wealth/income tax framing). Larry Lessig (legal scholar; critiques SpeechNow/super PAC structure).

Key claims

dissatisfaction drives populism; “give up this type of capitalism” not capitalism itself; democracy and capitalism aren’t inherently linked; health care insecurity and medical debt distort perceptions; unions may raise wages toward competitive levels under monopsony; economics ignored “power” (e.g., 1970s work minimizing firm power); wealth taxes are morally appealing but hard to execute fairly; super PACs aren’t the whole story—big money can buy media/academia too.

Notable examples

US political “seesaw” (Obama→Trump→Biden→Trump); cross-country populist pattern (Italy/Bolsonaro/Brazil; Thailand/Berlusconi-era parallels); Medicare pricing “inflation” vs real costs; Medicare eligibility history tied to racial exclusion; Norway/Sweden wealth-tax effects; California wealth-tax backlash; Citizens United vs SpeechNow discussion.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:00

The State of Capitalism and Populism

A discussion on the current state of capitalism and the rising populism in America.

“Ten years ago, we were ahead of the curve in discussing the changes in antitrust.”
2:59

Exploring Alternatives to Current Capitalism

A conversation about the potential need to change capitalism to better serve the majority.

“of the most important hits of the conference with some guidance from Bethany and I.”
4:26

The Trust Gap between People and Elites

Discussion on the growing divide and distrust between ordinary people and the elite.

“As this group of people become the majority, literally, there are two ways to deal with that.”
6:13

Case Studies of Populism Around the World

Examining international examples of populism and their implications on democracy.

“One of the first conferences that I ran as a Stigler Center was actually a joint conference with Harvard Law School.”
7:59

Debating Capitalism's Relationship with Democracy

A critical reflection on whether capitalism must coexist with democracy.

“And his argument that they don't actually have to be linked really opened up a different way of thinking for me.”
11:48

The Impact of Economic Indicators on Public Perception

Analyzing how economic indicators might lead to different public perceptions of poverty and inequality.

“what you're saying, which is there's this question of, is capitalism not working properly or is it not working up to snuff of the expectations of the people in the populace?”
14:03

Healthcare Costs and Inequality

Explore how healthcare pricing affects perceptions of inequality in the U.S.

“Now, I believe that the glass is half full because somebody has a full glass and somebody has none.”
17:41

Proposals for Medicare Reform

Discuss potential reforms for Medicare and who benefits from them.

“I can't recall the exact statistic right off the top of my head, but it's pretty stunning.”
22:32

The Role of Unions in Capitalism

Investigate the impact of unions on wages and economic power dynamics.

“And that's yet another piece of evidence about how arbitrary it is.”
27:31

Power Dynamics in Economics

Learn about the importance of power in economic discussions and its historical neglect.

“And if we don't recognize that power is at the center of what's happened in our economy and our society, then we cannot start to talk about what the solutions are.”
Show all 17 chapters
28:00

Power Dynamics in Economics

Explore the historical neglect of power in economic models and its implications.

“I think that it's not just because they couldn't get into work with their models.”
29:54

The Role of Power Today

Discuss the resurgence of power in economic discussions and its relevance.

“And now there is a professor at Stanford, Matteo Maggiore, that is bringing back into the neoclassical model power in an international relationship because surprise, surprise, is not only about competition.”
32:43

Debating Wealth Taxes

Examine the complexities and implications of wealth taxation proposals.

“They are like an easy answer to the problem.”
36:43

Political Donations and Influence

Analyze the effects of political donations on democracy and policy-making.

“that doesn't charge it, you're going to have a problem.”
42:01

The Influence of Big Money in Politics

Explore how economic power translates into political influence and the implications.

“But when I look around outside of the U.S., okay, so U.S.”
43:35

Debating the Efficacy of Capitalism

Delve into the ongoing debate about capitalism's effectiveness and its indicators.

“There is no doubt that there are many ways through which economic power transform itself into political power.”
46:31

The Importance of Public Sentiment

Discuss the significance of people's feelings towards capitalism in the debate.

“would be to follow the same kinds of households over a really long period of time and ask them, how much better off are you?”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Capitalisn't, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00How many people are satisfied with the current economic system? How many people see a brighter future for their kids? I think that America has always represented a dream, a dream that you can always do better. When the majority of people don't think that their children can do better than they have done, I think we are in a pretty bad situation. I'm Bethany McLean. Did you ever have a moment of doubt about capitalism and whether greed's a good idea? And I'm Lucia Zingales. We have socialism for the very rich, rugged individualism for the poor. And this is Capital Isn't, a podcast about what is working in capitalism.

0:40First of all, tell me, is there some society you know that doesn't run on greed? And most importantly, what isn't? We ought to do better by the people that get left behind. I don't think we should have killed the capital system in the process. As you probably know, the Capital Isn't podcast is produced by the Stigler Center at the University of Chicago. And here at the Stigler Center, we're very proud to try to be ahead of the curve in many issues. Ten years ago, we were ahead of the curve in discussing the changes in antitrust. We had conferences with Lina Khan before Lina Khan was Lina Khan.

1:14This year, we decided to dedicate a conference to a topic that seems to be becoming much, much, much more important now after midterm election, which is, can capitalists be popular? The inspiration for the conference was an increased consensus that capitalists in America does not seem to have delivered for a big chunk, maybe the majority of American people. As the author of a book with the title, A Capitalist for the People, this was a book more than 14 years ago, I'm sorry to say, but this topic is still very dear to my heart. When I wrote the book, I had a chapter titled Time for Populism, and where I was claiming that at this point populism is inevitable, and the question is what kind of populism.

2:04And unfortunately, I was right on the first point, and we're still struggling on trying to see how can capture some of the dissatisfaction or even rage that populism brings with it to actually improve capitalism and not destroy it. The goal of the conference was to explore in a typical Chicago style, i.e. with informed debate, how popular capitalist goals present across various policy arenas, and what, if anything, could enjoy broad support. This conference had academics, policymakers, journalists, union leaders, economists, and the discussion was extremely lively. And while I cannot claim we reach a clear consensus, you can judge on your own because the topics that we discuss are extremely timely, even more today than they were six months ago.

2:58And so what we're going to do now, we're going to provide a compilation of the most important hits of the conference with some guidance from Bethany and I.

3:11So Luigi, I want to start with you. As the faculty director of the Stiegler Center, this is the way that you started the conference. This was literally the first few lines that were said. We are confronted with a very important puzzle. If capitalists does not deliver for the majority of people, either you give up democracy or you give up capitalists. And my answer is we should give up this type of capitalists. We should somehow sort of change it. And there is a false alternative or false negative that there is no alternative. I think the alternative exists. First of all, look at other countries or look at the United States in the previous period.

3:51The distributional effect were completely different. So this is not technology. This is not given by God. This is a policy choice, a policy choice that is made to benefit the few, not the many. So explain for me in a little more detail what exactly this kind of capitalism, as you say, why that will force us to give up democracy. Like, do you really think things have gotten so dire? make the case for me that this isn't a hyperbolic situation. We've seen in the United States votes for more extreme alternatives as a result of the fact that they are unhappy with the existing one. As this group of people become the majority, literally, there are two ways to deal with that.

4:32One is to suppress, in many ways, the will of the people. And there are plenty of examples of people doing that without even really violating the formality of democracy, but substantially changing it, or to try to change things so that there is a broader consensus. I don't remember off the top of my head, but there is a gallop statistic about how many people feel represented by, for example, the people in Washington. And that number has been plummeting over time. How many people are satisfied with the current economic system? How many people see a brighter future for their kids. I think that America has always represented a dream, a dream that you can always do better.

5:13When the majority of people don't think that their children can do better than they have done, I think we are in a pretty bad situation. Has there ever been a revolution when people have been sure that their children are going to do better than they do and that the world is becoming more prosperous and fair for their children? I suspect the answer to that one would probably be, might be no. I worry a lot about this question about capitalism working, because I still think that capitalism is like Winston Churchill's old adage about democracy, which is that it's the worst of, it's the worst system in the world with the alternative of everything else that's ever been tried.

5:47And I would like it to work in a way that is fair for everybody. And to me, the most worrisome sign is the lurching between political parties that we're seeing. And that's not healthy in a whole bunch of ways. We've gone from Obama to Trump to Biden to Trump, and now we're going to lurch again. And that incredibly rapid seesaw back and forth, I think, is a sign of an economy that isn't delivering to most people what they want, because they keep hoping that somebody else is going to have the answers. One of the first conferences that I ran as a Stigler Center was actually a joint conference with Harvard Law School.

6:22It was in 2017, and the title was Populist Plutocrats, a lesson from abroad. We invited people from various countries, starting, of course, with Italy, but also the Philippines, Thailand, Peru. And they all brought their evidence. There were some journalists, some historians, some politicians. Each one told a separate story, but at the end of the day, they all look identical. And the story was, there is a major failure that in one country can be a financial crisis. Another country is terrorists. In the third country is corruption. But there is a major failure that basically creates a huge divide between ordinary people and the elite.

7:11And the ordinary people feel they cannot really trust the elite to run the country anymore. And so they start voting for the craziest people on the face of earth. And if that sounds familiar, you understand what. And you go to Thailand In Thailand, there was a populist that beat Al-Abelosconi, Taksim. They sent him to exile. He couldn't run for election. What happened? The daughter ran for election and won in a landslide. And look at what's happening now with Bolsonaro. The son, who is worse than the original because he's even more corrupt than the original, if it's possible, might win the next presidential election in Brazil.

7:53Are you trying to tell me that we're going to have Eric Trump for president? Actually, Ivanka Trump. In many countries, the first female president or prime minister tend to be a conservative, from Margaret Thatcher to Georgia Meloni to Angela Merkel. They tend to be all conservative. But back to your question, Matt, I think one of the most, I mean, all of our podcasts are interesting to me, but one of those thought-changing podcasts we did was our interview with Bronco Milanovic, because I think I had always believed the argument that democracy and capitalism were essentially linked and that they had to be.

8:24And his argument that they don't actually have to be linked really opened up a different way of thinking for me. You wrote, if Chinese and Singaporean meritocracies continue to consistently outperform societies where the social sphere is organized in a democratic fashion, there is, I think, little doubt that their appeal will be such that in 100 years, it may seem to those who are around so very quaint that people thought in a complex society, social decisions should be taken by democratic vote. So I think you're a little bit more skeptical about the idea that capitalism and democracy are linked.

8:57You know, I'm very much, in some sense, quite an economist of the role. And for me, I have to say, since I was really a kid, actually, when you alluded to that, I remember reading, for example, newspapers and reading, that was always in small letters, what was the industrial rate of growth of Yugoslavia over this month. And I would be, in those days, that was early 70s, I would be very disappointed if it would not be double digit. And it was not. It was like 7-8%, which nowadays looks high. Why did I mention that? Because I think really economic growth is fundamental. And I think that there is a trade-off that people are directly or indirectly willing to make between so-called political liberties and economic growth.

9:44And if you sort of think, as I think some people in China do, or maybe even Singapore, as I mentioned there, is that the organization of society is essentially such as an organization of a company. In a company, in capitalism, you don't have democracy. The company is run hierarchically. So you can say, okay, the society is also run like that, and let's see what is the outcome. Is the outcome good or is bad? And if the majority of people say, okay, it is run hierarchically, but the right people are there on top and they are running us, and I actually, I'm not interested how they have come there, maybe through some sort of, you know, mutual sort of decision-making as in the Communist Party.

10:34It's okay with me. So in that sense, I think that there is no, know that there is acceptance of a trade-off between democratic rights and economic growth. And secondly, I would also argue that if you look historically, there are many cases of successful capitalism without democracy. I'm not talking now about Pinochet and Chile. I will tell you, like Louis Napoléon III in France with economic sort of takeoff of France, with Bismarck in Germany, with Spain and Portugal, with Greece, with Turkey, with Brazil. So, you know, if you take all of these countries historically, and including the United States, it was, of course, originally, and, you know, and a slave-owning oligarchy.

11:22So it's not democratic. So I would question that even empirically, the link between the two is strong. And so if they don't have to be linked, then there also is a question that you can choose one or the other. It's not that they go together like peanut butter and jelly. They are not peanut butter and jelly or peanut butter and chocolate, either one. So anyway. There's something kind of underlying a little bit of what you're saying, which is there's this question of, is capitalism not working properly or is it not working up to snuff of the expectations of the people in the populace? And one of the people we brought onto the first panel to make the argument that capitalism is actually working properly was Steve Kaplan.

12:06Consumption inequality and after-tax inequality are up less than people think. So Luigi was very careful. He said it's pre-tax income. Look at after-tax income. After-tax income, actually inequality is only up modestly. And then if you look at consumption inequality, the increase is actually quite small and the 50-10 difference has actually come down. The 90-50 has increased. So the bottom has actually done reasonably well. If you look at, again, real after-tax incomes of all quintiles, they're up substantially since the 1980s. And there was a recent paper by Rosen Winship that finds that what's happened, there's fewer people in the middle class because some people have gone to the upper middle class.

13:01So it's a big success for a lot of people. Now let's look at the bottom at poverty. If you do a poll, so Luigi was giving us lots of polls, 68 % of the public believes poverty has increased over the last 25 years. And I think I blame the press for that because they always write about that. Absolute poverty has declined sharply in the U.S. If you use the 1980 standard of living, consumption poverty rate fell from 13 percent to 3 percent. If you use the 2015 measure, it went from 33 percent to 11 percent from 1980 to 2018. So we've done a great job on reducing poverty in this country. And you wouldn't know it from what's reported.

13:46What is going on here? You and Steve are both smart economists. You're both working with the same data, the same numbers. How is it possible that you're coming to two different conclusions? So number one, Steve is a very effective debater and he's a half full glass type. Now, I believe that the glass is half full because somebody has a full glass and somebody has none. If you look at the half glass and you see that almost full, I think you're more optimistic. But jokes aside, My understanding of Steve's number, they are very shaped by the effect of Medicaid and Medicare. The United States has a system that once you are really, really poor or once you're old, past 65, we have to be careful with this old, but when you're past 65, you are basically covered by Medicare.

14:36Now, what is interesting, this stuff is priced three times as much as in Germany. So if you receive a doctor visit, you are billed as you're receiving$1 ,000. But in reality, you receive$300, the doctor receive the remaining$700. But in an inequality number, you are billed for$1 ,000. So your consumption is great, but it's consumption made out of inflated places where the winner is somebody else. So if you call that a measure of reduction in inequality, I have something to sell you. Is there an issue with pre - and post-tax income, too? Or do you think it's the Medicaid numbers that are the biggest source of distinction between the two of you?

15:22There was a hearing before the Senate Finance Committee where the Joint Community Taxation Staff prepared a report for them showing the tax system was, in fact, more progressive than it used to be. And the senator said it had to be fake numbers. It had to be false junk math. So what we want to do in a study is actually look at what the data says and see how progressive our system actually is. What we try to do to do that is look at every study we could identify that measured progressivity or redistribution in the last 15 years. There's a lot of sausage making in doing these calculations. It's not easy to say how progressive the system is because there's all kinds of calculations that go into making that estimate.

15:59But here's the bottom line is every study we looked at, all the data we looked at, consistently found that the tax system is far more progressive now than it was 10, 20, 30, 40, or 50 years ago. And again, you see massive increases in transfers to the bottom quintile, relatively flat changes in tax rates at the top. There is no doubt that the American system does a bit of redistribution. So clearly, the after-tax numbers are better than the pre-tax numbers, as they should be in a system that should be progressive. But I think that at least my reading of the data is that the big role is played by Medicare and Medicare.

16:37The over-inflating of Medicare prices is actually making things look better. Now, some of the measures of poverty don't account for the in-kind transfer. besides Medicare and Medicaid, we have a lot of food stamps and the food stamps are substantive. So I'm not saying the United States do zero to reduce inequality. They do, and they're being successful in some dimension. What I object is the perception of people is that the middle class is eroding and it's not eroding because they all go up. There are a lot of people who go down and those are the people who go down who are upset. And those are the ones who tend to feed revolutions.

17:17So to what degree have we just discovered that the issue is really just health care? And if you could fix health care, then we could all retire and go home and stop talking about capitalism. It would make a huge difference. Another podcast we did talked about the idea of health care insecurity. So it isn't just the people who are uninsured. It's the people who are clinging desperately to their job for fear of becoming uninsured. If people were not as freaked out by health care. And I think medical debt is the number one source of bankruptcy and an enormous overhang on a lot of people. I can't recall the exact statistic right off the top of my head, but it's pretty stunning.

17:51But that's getting from here to there is the really difficult point. Well, during the health care panel, there was one economist from Princeton, Ileana Kuzimenko, who had an interesting proposal that I had never heard before for how to maybe resolve this issue with health care costs in America. Americans just don't make it to age 65. And I remember, oh, shoot, age 65 is, you know, the privately insured population largely. But once we get to age 65, again, this is for women, we're sort of in the bottom of the club, but now we're at least in the club. I do think just, you know, lowering the Medicare age of eligibility, you know, one year per year.

18:32So today, you know, about 11 ,000 Americans will turn 65. do you hear their howls of, you know, protest that they're forced to join Medicare? Of course not. You know, most people are pretty excited to join Medicare. Nobody would be forced. You know, you could still decide to pay your private premiums. But of course, insurance companies would be very upset. Doctors and providers would be very upset because Medicare reimbursement, while higher than Medicaid, is lower than private insurance. So, you know, in terms of the opposition from sort of the corporate sector, it would be intense. But I think on the public side, they would probably be like, oh, that sounds pretty good.

19:09I find it politically ingenious because it takes one of the scariest things about health care reform, the idea that somebody is going to take away the insurance you already have, which has done in health care reform in the past, and removes it. You don't abolish private insurance. You just keep expanding access to a public option people already understand and by and large seem pretty happy to join. It's sort of Medicare for all by attrition in a way. But I guess I'd add that I think the economics are where it gets interesting because Medicare generally pays doctors and hospitals less than commercial insurers do, and then Medicaid pays even less than Medicare does.

19:45And so expanding Medicare might reduce total health care spending, but, of course, hospitals and doctors and insurers would fight it fiercely. And then I guess the key question is whether lower Medicare prices would reflect genuine savings from bargaining power and lower administrative costs or whether parts of the system that are currently relying on high commercial rates to cover costs that Medicare doesn't are just going to end up squeezed out of existence. And I guess if you gradually moved millions of more people onto Medicare, you would find out the answer to that. But it might not be a great answer.

20:18One reason that hospitals have engaged in all these mergers and one reason that hospital chains like HCA have been so successful is because they've been very, HCA in particular, has been very, very smart about picking its locations in places with commercial plans. So it doesn't have to rely on Medicare or Medicaid. And so if you force more and more of the system to rely on Medicare, there are a lot of hospitals that for sure would end up struggling. And the question is, what are the benefits of going slowly versus the benefits of going big? Part of the problem and the political difficulties of moving to some form of universal health insurance is because some groups have a lot of insurance and they don't want to give that up, especially because at the moment is a tax advantage.

21:08And some of these groups are actually associated with unions. The union bargained very hard to have good health care plans. And these air cap plans are paid mostly by the employer, partly by the employees, but with pre-tax dollars. They don't want to get higher compensation than going by something in the open market because in the process, it will be severely taxed by the government. In equilibrium, we're going to have, like most other countries have, that you have a basic provision for everybody and then some supplemental insurance for the people who can afford. And that will be much more expensive.

21:44and then will be paying part for the more expensive doctors. But moving from here to there ain't easy. Yeah. Her proposal, though, does raise a really interesting question that underlies it, which is why Americans under 65 should continue paying substantially different prices for the same health care simply because of who insures them, right? I mean, it does lay bare a really interesting, I'll use the word interesting, feature of our system. Yeah, but let's be honest. The reason why this was introduced at 65, and I think Ileana came close to say that, is because at the time it was introduced, black people did not make it to 65.

22:25So in a country that was very divided by race, this was basically an issuance for old white people. I did not know that, and I'm not surprised to hear it. And that's yet another piece of evidence about how arbitrary it is. The second panel was supposed to be a panel about labor. It ended up just being a panel about unions for the most part. But there was a clip from University of Chicago law professor Eric Hosner that actually went viral by our standards on our social feeds. Wait a minute, you should say viral without by our standards. It went viral. It went viral. It went viral. Say it went viral.

23:02Don't be so sort of modest. Actually, it did. It went viral. Economists I talked to seem to be instinctively hostile to unionization because they think it will result in wages above the productive level, which effectively just means that consumers are hurt. And, of course, workers are also consumers. So it's not clear at all that this is beneficial to society. There is actually no economic evidence for that. So if you try to find some serious empirical scholarship at the level, the methodological level that economists insist on today as methods have been improved, there's really no evidence that the union wage premium actually causes wages in a systematic way to go above the competitive or efficient level.

23:53And in fact, when you take the monopsony perspective, there's a much more plausible view, which is that the workers are already being paid below the competitive level because the employers have a lot of market power. And what the union does is push the wage back up toward the competitive level. And if that's true, then workers are being paid more and there's going to be more economic output. So in their capacity, both as workers and as consumers, they benefit. So how did economists get this so wrong? And if Eric is right, is the answer to how to make capitalism popular again just more unions? So first of all, I will distinguish between public sector unions and private sector unions.

24:38Public sector unions are bargaining with their employer that also elect. So there is an element of capture which is much stronger than we see that with the police union. We see that with the teacher union in Chicago, we have the mayor who is the head of the teacher union at the same time. So I think that that's clearly a problem we don't have in the private sector union. The private sector union, I think, are very useful, especially in a system that is becoming more concentrated and where the power of corporations in our daily life is becoming much, much stronger. I come from a country where unions were very, very strong.

25:18But as a result of that, certain level of surveillance on the job, for example, are still to these days not legal. And the fact that here we legalize methods that are really quite coercive, it doesn't speak very highly of the country. So unions are an important element. I don't think that they're the only solution to all the problems, but might contribute to make sure that people pay the wage they deserve. Because as Eric said, in situation of monopsony, equilibrium wage is below what they would pay in a competitive market. Economists got it wrong because they ignore for a long time monopsony as an issue.

25:59I think I had always assumed, as many people do, that the reason to object to unions is that the wage before the union arrives is somehow the market wage and the union distorts the market wage. But if employers already have market power and that starting wage is self-distorted downward, in that case, the union isn't necessarily interfering with a competitive market. It's providing countervailing power in a market that wasn't competitive to begin with. And so that, I think, changes the moral framing because we tend to talk as though employer power is just the natural state of affairs and worker power is an intervention.

26:33But why, right? If one side has bargaining power because there are only a handful of employers and the other side gets bargaining power by organizing, why is only the second one treated as a distortion and the first one is treated as the natural state of affairs? One person on the panel who certainly believed that unions are the answer to everything was a former executive director of the AFL-CIO Industrial Union, Brad Markell, who had this quote to say. There's always some false promise out there about an imaginary future that requires us to give a bunch of power to billionaires. And if we don't, the future is horrible.

27:06And if we do, at some point in the future, then we will have some sort of nirvana that's always just out there. And I think right now with AI and what I would say are sort of a wannabe tech overlords, like it's time to deliver. You can't deliver. So I would say that if we cannot address power, that's not going to lead to any solution we want. And if we don't recognize that power is at the center of what's happened in our economy and our society, then we cannot start to talk about what the solutions are. The word I want to focus on there is power. And Luigi, before the conference, you wrote a paper, unreleased at the moment, but forthcoming, in which you argued that neoclassical economics has basically ignored this word because they couldn't get it to cooperate with their models and their mathematics.

27:57Explain that for us. And then also walk us through why you think this ignorance of power has caused the failures of capitalism as you see it. I think that it's not just because they couldn't get into work with their models. I think it was an ideological choice to ignore power as an issue, in part because it's something that is more dealt in other disciplines, like sociology is all about power. However, historically, economics did deal with power. Of course, monopoly power is number one. But in general, the idea that you need to be aware of concentrated economic power broadly is an idea that was very diffuse, including a Chicago, Henry Simons, who is the father of the Chicago School and a teacher of Milton Friedman, Aaron Director, and Joel Stigler, was very much concerned about the excessive power in general.

28:52There was a concerted effort in taking away from the vocabulary of economics, including in the most obvious place. I think that we discussed already on the podcast, that is this very famous paper by Arshan and Demsert, written and published in 1972, where they say that firms don't have any power above and beyond their normal market contracting. And so the fact that American Airlines file a pilot is equal to a customer of American Airlines stopping to buy American Airlines tickets. Any normal human being will find these superstars. But for a long time, this was the case. Now, I was taught at MIT, and one of my teachers was Oliver Hart, who is responsible to bring some of the idea of power, bargaining power, back into the normal economic language, even if he didn't push that too hard.

29:48But I think that at least provided a way to deal with it. I think there's been an underinvestment in studying power. And now there is a professor at Stanford, Matteo Maggiore, that is bringing back into the neoclassical model power in an international relationship because surprise, surprise, is not only about competition. It is about the United States very often flexing their muscles with other countries and so on and so forth. However, there was a period in which you were persona non grata in raising those issues. We need to raise them more directly. It was Baudelaire that said that the biggest trick that the devil created was to make people think it didn't exist.

30:29Once you think that power doesn't exist, of course, you cannot see it. The moment you start thinking about it, it's the only thing that exists. Do you think the Friedmans of the world, do you think they didn't see it or do you think they chose not to see it? Oh, that's a very difficult question. It was a combination of wishful thinking and aspirational thinking. You have element where you see even the biggest cartel breaking down. Think about what happens in the mid 80s. I remember as a little kid that the oil cartel, OPEC, etc. was super, super powerful. And then oil collapsed. Why? Because competition forced the cartel to break down.

31:10So there were some major victory of competition over concerted power that gave a bit too confidence that the world is flat, to use an abused term. And whether they chose to look it flat or they wish it was flat, that's into psychoanalysis, not as hard to tell. Are you holding your credit card? No. This is a discount that I play with. I didn't want you to flash your credit card. With my credit card number, no. $130 off. I don't know for what. While discussing power, Luigi waves his credit card around in the air.

31:58If you're enjoying the discussions we're having on this show, then there's another University of Chicago Podcast Network show you should check out. It's called the Chicago Booth Review Podcast. What's the best way to deliver negative feedback? How can you use AI to improve your business strategy? And why is achieving a soft landing so very hard? The Chicago Booth Review podcast addresses the big questions in business, policy, and markets with insights from the world's leading academic researchers. It's groundbreaking research delivered in a clear and straightforward way. Find the Chicago Booth Review podcast wherever you get your podcasts.

32:42we'll move on to panel four which is focused largely on a debate about um boston college professor ray madoff's argument that when we talk about taxes and the one percent we often get it wrong that the top one percent of earners are people with big salaries who really do pay 40 percent of federal income taxes and the top one percent of owners are a completely different group that don't pay any of the taxes let's just go back to our episode to hear more on that but i I wanted to focus on a question that came up at the end of that panel that actually everybody on the panel agreed on, which was wealth taxes.

33:14They are like an easy answer to the problem. We can't get the income. Let's get the wealth. But like a lot of easy answers, I think they are a lot less easy than it seems. There's a lot of practical limitations of calculating wealth, particularly in the world where these pass throughs, you have a lot of people, multi-layer partnership interests with people owning all sorts of things. I just think that they're not realistic. And I think they're a matter of bad policy because they send the message that we need to punish the rich rather than, hey, these guys aren't paying taxes at all. And so I think it moves the conversation from should rich people be required to pay taxes to should they have this extra tax?

33:55So I don't like the visuals of it. It would be helpful for folks that are advocating these policies to state more clearly what the goal is. So, you know, I could think of three goals of a wealth tax. One is to raise revenue. How much revenue this will raise really depends on how narrowly we define it. And most of the proposals define the base quite narrowly. Just not going to raise that much revenue. Second is limiting political power. I don't think Elon half as rich would have half as much political power because I just like feel like politicians are still pretty cheap. And so like, you know, we need to go more directly at the way influence and money affects political power and distribution.

34:37The third reason is like a sort of political message, like fight back and like, you know, I'm not a politician. I'm not very good at that stuff. So that seems like the strongest argument and seems like the reason why these things are gaining political steam, whether they'll actually make it into policy is a real question. I worry we end up having caught the bus and still having all the problems that we're talking about because not really solving the problems that we really need to be solving. What is your take on wealth taxes? I don't think I've ever asked you all directly about that. To me, the most important part of it is the essential fairness of the system and the idea that when wealth is compounding, that it's somehow different than income and that it does seem to let a lot of very wealthy people off the hook and contributing to taxes.

35:21And I don't like that in sort of a moral sense, because I think we've done so many podcasts that have focused on the fact that capitalism and a market doesn't exist without a society and without government. And so the idea that people that have created these businesses don't owe anything back to that society as that business does extraordinarily well seems to me, if you believe that their success can't exist without the success of the country, then that doesn't seem fair. So to me, the idea of a wealth tax is incredibly appealing. I think in the execution is where it gets really, really, really complicated and potentially unfair.

35:58unfair. I was just in Norway, and there's this big argument that they're losing. They don't have a successful tech startup scene. People go to Sweden instead, in part because of Norway's wealth tax, and that it's really difficult if you have an entrepreneur whose business is valued at a billion dollars on paper, and that has increased in X amount, and then they owe taxes, and they simply don't have the cash to pay it because the wealth only exists on paper. So I know Ray's idea was different than that, that it turns into an estate tax. And I think that's a more doable way. But then you also have to not have competition between jurisdictions, whether it's countries in the EU or whether it's states in the U.S., because we're watching the exodus from California, right, as people protest the idea of a wealth tax.

36:40And as long as people can leave to somewhere that doesn't charge it, you're going to have a problem. As for Elon half as rich, not being half as dangerous, I totally agree with that. I mean, Elon half as rich is still what, worth$500 billion? I mean, at these levels, it just doesn't matter. But I don't think the point of it is to reduce political power. Once you design a bad wealth tax, you do a terrible job in a lot of dimension. And this seems what is happening in California, where if you ask an economist, what is the most stupid wealth tax you will ever think about, etc., they would probably think that California will tax because this idea of doing in one state and not the other state, this idea that it's only once, you know that it's not going to be only once.

37:31All this stuff that are pretty crazy. And they show two things. Number one, how upset people are. So this demand for a wealth tax in California is the fact that people are upset with the system where people don't pay taxes. like I made of her. And, you know, I don't think that the average person is that sophisticated. The average person understands very well that we need to redistribute the burden of taxation. It's not very sophisticated in what is the most effective way. We economists have not provided alternatives sufficiently of effective ways. So my view of the wealth tax is very simple. I will have it as an alternative minimum tax.

38:13If you are worth a billion, you must have an income of a certain amount. And if you don't have an income in the center of mine, it's probably because you allude with the help of a lot of lawyers. And so let's talk to you anyway so that actually we take a little bit of a job off the lawyers, which is good for society overall. The fewer lawyers, the better the society. I think that on the issue of Elon Musk, I don't know why nobody has proposed this, but it seems to be obvious that what you want to do is tax donation above a certain level. And this is, we say you can donate up to$10 ,000, but if you donate above$10 ,000, we tax it at a 50 % rate.

38:55So, yes, Elon Musk donated$100 million to the campaign. He pays$100 million in taxes. That is a fantastic deal. As an economist, I think incentives matter. And, yes, it's still worth a fortune. But on the margin, he might be a little bit less inclined to spend the money that way. Luigi for president. I mean, I have to say, I want to be able to argue with you, Luigi, but I think both of these ideas are absolutely brilliant. I love the concept of an alternative minimum tax. And I also love the idea of taxing political donations, but it should be above a really small level. I'd be pretty punitive about that.

39:32Maybe that makes then turning, well, returning Citizens United or overturning the other one that Lessig argues, the Speak Now case, makes that less important. If you just say, OK, over$1 ,000, any kind of political donation is taxed. I mean, make it a small number. Well, speaking of Larry Lesky, he was actually on one of the last panels of the day, which was about money and politics, which also goes back to the Elon thing. Listeners may be familiar with his argument about the SpeechNow case. If they're not, they can go back and listen to our last episode where they can get that. But he's made this argument about a legal plan he has to essentially end super PACs and how he thinks that'll solve many of the issues around political donations and politics.

40:13Here's the part you're likely not to know. When you say, why do we have super PACs? You're going to say it's because of a Supreme Court decision called Citizens United. That's just false. We have super PACs because of a lower federal court decision interpreting Citizens United three months after it was decided, a case called SpeechNow. And the upshot of this is SpeechNow is a mistake. Under Citizens United, SpeechNow is a mistake and therefore fundamentally vulnerable. People like my friend Bernie Sanders make a million speeches about how if we believe in democracy, we must overturn Citizens United.

40:50Overturning Citizens United is technically impossible. It just cannot happen. There is zero chance the United States Supreme Court is going to overturn Citizens United. So the idea that you would rally people to an impossible cause is absurd. But the idea that the court would recognize that speech now doesn't actually follow from Citizens United is not impossible. I think it's quite possible. Our very own from the Stewart Center, Guy Rolnick, sort of pushed back during the final panel, and he had this to say. A couple of years ago, we had here Congressman Ken Buck. And so we went to drinks very late after the conference.

41:27Then I asked him, so tell me, Ken, what did you learn through your journey? Because the guy was not by any, he was, you know, he never dealt with antitrust. He had to learn anything. And he said to me, I learned how many kids of congresswomen and congressmen actually work for Google and Meta. So I'm totally sympathetic to what Larry is saying. And, you know, I feel for Larry because, you know, everyone believes that we are upstream and whatever I, you know, doing it. I always thought that whatever I'm doing is upstream. I'm swimming upstream all the time. But when I look around outside of the U.S., okay, so U.S.

42:06is the worst. because this is the only country in the world basically where it's totally legal to bribe politicians, okay? So you call it super PAC and it's fine, okay? But you know, Christina will tell you they don't have super PACs in Brussels and she's going to tell you what big tech is doing in Brussels, okay? And I can tell you what they are doing in so many countries around the world. And now when we totally normalize the idea that Jeff Bezos can buy the Washington Post and then tell them that you're going to go after Lena Kahn or Jonathan Kanter and tomorrow Mark Zuckerberg is going to buy it in the New York Times and Elon is going to buy ProPublica and David and Larry Allison just bought CBS and they're about to buy CNN.

42:49So what are we going to do? Do they need Pac-Money when you control all the media? Okay. Anat says it's much cheaper, okay? It's cheaper to buy academics. It's cheaper to buy universities. It's cheaper to buy think tanks. You don't really need$6 billion of super Pac-Money. Let's say that tomorrow morning we get rid of the super PACs, but we still end up with five guys that have spare$1 trillion cash and they can buy any, any, you know, watchdog or any check or any balance on our society. So what do we do? No, we only have 10 minutes left. I didn't want to end somewhere weak, pretty bleak. What do we do?

43:31So I think that guy is too bleak. If Steve is sort of the full glass guy, he's the full empty glass guy. There is no doubt that there are many ways through which economic power transform itself into political power. And clearly, hiring daughters and sons of members of Congress and important academics, et cetera, is one way. However, we need to start from somewhere. And I think that that's pretty big because most Congress people spend most of their time fundraising. I think that Ken Bach left politics in part is because it was too painful to do that under the current conditions. So I think if we don't have people that can succeed in politics without being completely sort of overtaken by the power of money, there is no way to change anything.

44:23So I'm not sure if it's too bleak or not. But I think maybe we overstate the importance of Citizens United because it was a continuation of a trend, not the beginning of a trend. The importance of money in politics and the rise of corporate lobbying was growing long before Citizens United came along. So the idea that then we fix the super PACs and suddenly we have this fair, perfect world doesn't square with the facts. But that doesn't mean we shouldn't fix it. It doesn't make it any less important to fix it. just because it doesn't fix everything doesn't mean it isn't an incredibly important step.

44:58So I want to both say that it is not the only problem in our system, but also say that that doesn't mean that it isn't a problem and you tackle what you can. And I think Larry is on the side of the angels in this one. One last question before you run. So I would say it's fair to say that after this entire conference about whether capitalism is working, Steve Steve was not convinced that it isn't. I'm wondering if there is a piece of data that even could exist that for Steve and people like Steve would convince them that capitalism isn't working as it should. Or is there a data that would convince you that it is?

45:36And what would that piece of data actually have to be? Actually, I think that at the end of the debate, we came closer. I think that Steve recognized, for example, that health care is a huge problem. which it didn't used to do in the past. So I think that that's an important step. We do have some successful welfare program, and maybe inequality is not as terrible as I make it to be. So I don't think that you need to have a complete overturn, but I think evidence does make a position a bit closer. I don't think there's one number that would settle it because part of the disagreement is over what counts as evidence that capitalism is working.

46:15So Steve can show us rising incomes, low unemployment, strong consumption. We could show him people who can't buy a house, people who feel economically insecure despite having a job, people who don't have health care, people who don't believe their children will do better than they did. I guess one way you could maybe measure it differently would be to follow the same kinds of households over a really long period of time and ask them, how much better off are you? How secure is your job? How much wealth have you accumulated? How are you feeling? How much mobility is there? And if that showed broad, durable improvement over time, I'd say that Steve is right.

46:48But I think we all take refuge in there's so many statistics and we all take refuge in statistics. And underneath that all, I tend to be a very highly rational, rational person who believes in numbers. But in this case, I'm going to give people some credence for feelings. If people feel that capitalism isn't working and that they're not getting a fair shake, that's a really important piece of data.

47:12capital isn't is a podcast from the stiegler center and the university of chicago podcast network in collaboration with the chicago booth review if you haven't yet you can now find our podcast as a video on youtube don't forget to subscribe and leave a review wherever you get your podcasts the show is produced by me matt hodap britney broaders with production assistance from Annie Nazaro, Matt Luckey, Sebastian Berka, Joey Prebst, and Andy Shee. The podcast is partially supported by a generous contribution from Luis Muniz and Cristani Medelius-Muniz. We are grateful for their commitment to advancing thoughtful dialogue and scholarly engagement on our show.

47:49If you'd like to take the conversation further, also check out promarket.org, a publication of the Stiegler Center, and subscribe to our newsletter. Sign up at chicagobooth.edu slash Stiegler. Thank you.

From the publisher

If capitalism doesn't deliver for most people, do you give up democracy or do you give up capitalism? That was the puzzle that opened the Stigler Center’s annual conference in April 2026, and Luigi Zingales's answer was that we may have to give up "this type of capitalism." 

Why can one doctor's visit carry different prices depending on who's paying? Are workers paid less than a competitive market would pay them, and does a union fix that or break something? What would a 50% tax on political donations above $10,000 do to campaign money? And who pays little tax relative to what they own?*

And if many metrics like low unemployment indicate capitalism is “working,” but many people feel like it isn’t, what is the truth? How should we measure whether or not capitalism works for the people?

Connect with us:

📺 Subscribe to our YouTube Channel

📱 Follow Capitalisn’t on Instagram & TikTok

✉️ Email your questions and comments to [email protected]


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.