Sen. Ron Johnson blames state and local leaders for Alex Pretti’s killing

30 Jan 2026 · 7 min · 5 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Podcast Summary: Consider This from NPR

Episode Title

Sen. Ron Johnson blames state and local leaders for Alex Pretti’s killing

Episode Overview In this episode, NPR's Ailsa Chang delves into the aftermath of the tragic killings of Alex Pretti and Renee Macklin Good by federal immigration agents, igniting a broader discussion about immigration enforcement, state and local cooperation, and pending federal budget negotiations concerning the Department of Homeland Security (DHS).

Key Themes and Discussions

  1. Context of the Killings
  2. The episode opens with the urgency surrounding federal government funding, set to run out shortly.
  3. The killings of Pretti and Good by ICE agents have intensified scrutiny over immigration enforcement practices.
  1. Political Implications
  2. Senate Democrats' Stance:
  3. Senate Democrats are looking to separate DHS funding from the broader government spending package.
  4. They propose reforms, including limiting the powers of immigration agents (e.g., prohibiting masks and mandating ID).
  5. Senator Ron Johnson's Response:
  6. Wisconsin Republican, Ron Johnson, shifts blame to state and local leaders for the fatalities.
  7. He argues that local leaders' lack of cooperation with ICE contributed to the tragic events in Minneapolis.
  1. Debate on Immigration Enforcement
  2. Johnson advocates for maintaining current immigration enforcement practices while emphasizing the need for border security.
  3. He rejects calls for reforms, insisting that ICE's actions are justifiable and that the real issue lies with the Biden administration's border policies.
  4. He accuses local officials of resisting lawful immigration enforcement, which he believes exacerbated the situation leading to the killings.
  1. Calls for Investigation
  2. Johnson supports an investigation into the actions of ICE but emphasizes that funding for DHS should not be contingent on these reforms.
  3. He expresses sympathy for ICE officers, framing them as operating under significant threat and pressure.

Key Quotes

  • "If Republicans refuse to work with us to rein in ICE and to end the violence, they're telling the American people they're choosing to protect ICE over choosing to protect people's safety." - Chuck Schumer
  • "What I agree is that we needed to secure a border... the problem in Minneapolis is we have a governor and a mayor who are resisting." - Ron Johnson

Conclusion

  • The episode encapsulates a critical intersection of local and federal governance regarding immigration enforcement, highlighting the tensions between political parties and the impacts of tragic events on policy discussions.
  • As lawmakers face a potential government shutdown, the episode raises questions about the future of immigration reform and budget negotiations within the current political climate.

Production Credits

  • Produced by: Brianna Scott
  • Edited by: Christopher Intagliata, Kelsey Snell, Courtney Dorning
  • Executive Producer: Sami Yenigun

Additional Information For more insights and to support NPR, visit [Consider This+](https://plus.npr.org/considerthis).

---

This Markdown file provides a structured summary of the podcast episode, capturing essential discussions and key arguments while remaining accessible and informative.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

The Looming Government Shutdown

0:46 to 1:35

Discussion on the urgency of Congress reaching a spending deal amidst the threat of a shutdown.

“The vote in the Senate this week was supposed to be just a formality.”

Senator Ron Johnson's Stance on DHS Funding

1:36 to 2:25

Senator Ron Johnson discusses his views on DHS funding amid the immigration enforcement issue.

“With hours left, can lawmakers even reach a deal?”

The Blame Game: Local Leaders and ICE

2:26 to 4:15

Senator Johnson attributes the violence in Minneapolis to local leaders resisting ICE actions.

“Johnson says he does want an investigation into the shooting of Alex Preddy, but not at the expense of government funding.”

Cooperation Between Local and Federal Law Enforcement

4:16 to 6:07

Discussion on the need for local officials to cooperate with ICE to prevent tragedies.

“President Trump has tried to shake up the leadership for the federal immigration crackdown in Minneapolis.”

The Debate Over DHS Funding in Spending Package

6:08 to 7:16

Senator Johnson argues against splitting DHS funding from the overall spending package.

“created the circumstance for that tragedy.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Midnight, January 30th. That is when funding for the federal government runs out. We've all been here before, many, many times, everyone waiting and watching for Congress to come to an agreement on a continuing resolution to keep money flowing into the government. Remember last year? I'm saying that Congress, with the help of the White House right now, is not doing its job since they are now barreling toward a shutdown if they can't agree on a spending deal by midnight tonight. Or remember back in 2021? Well, the clock is ticking. The threat of a government shutdown is looming right now if a short-term spending bill isn't approved.

0:37And let's go even further back. 2018. In just an hour, the federal government will partially shut down. But this time feels different. Because there was a deal. The vote in the Senate this week was supposed to be just a formality. That was until immigration enforcement officers shot and killed Alex Preddy on the streets of Minneapolis. If Republicans refuse to work with us to rein in ICE and to end the violence, they're telling the American people they're choosing to protect ICE over choosing to protect people's safety. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer stood on the floor Thursday challenging the funding that has been set aside for the Department of Homeland Security, even though his Senate Democrats do support the rest of the spending package.

1:21Democratic Senator Adam Schiff of California told NPR's Steve Inskeep how ICE operations must change. I'm not prepared to spend another dime on ice unless there's just a massive set of reforms. Consider this. Democratic resistance to the immigration enforcement operation in Minnesota could result in a partial government shutdown. With hours left, can lawmakers even reach a deal? And will Democrats even get the reforms they want?

1:52From NPR, I'm Elsa Chang.

1:58This message comes from TED Talks Daily, the podcast from TED. Curious how to introduce yourself so you actually get hired? Or why people are starting to sound like ChatGPT? There's a TED Talk for that. Listen to TED Talks Daily wherever you get your podcasts.

2:19It's Consider This from NPR. Unlike his Democratic colleagues in the Senate, Wisconsin Republican Ron Johnson doesn't think that DHS funding should even be pulled into the battle over the immigration enforcement operation in Minnesota. Johnson says he does want an investigation into the shooting of Alex Preddy, but not at the expense of government funding. I asked Senator Johnson if he thinks ICE even needs reforms. Well, what I agree is that we needed to secure a border. What I believe is that what we're dealing with right now is the enormous mess created by President Biden and Democrats who opened up our border, allowed millions of people to flood in this country, where ICE is doing enforcement actions, just like they've always done under the Obama administration and the Biden administration, where they're doing these enforcement actions and local police are cooperating.

3:11There's no violence. There's no problem. We're just enforcing the law. And the problem in Minneapolis is we have a governor and a mayor who are resisting. You don't think that ICE needs any reforms then? There should be no changes on the federal government side when it comes to immigration agents. When you ask that question, when Democrats focus on that, they're focusing on the wrong problem. The root cause of this problem is the border. They opened up the millions of people, including criminals, that they've allowed to fund this country. And now law enforcement has to take care of that problem.

3:43So what changes do you think need to be seen for law enforcement to better take care of this problem that you have identified, that you have characterized? The first change was we secured the border. It has to remain secure. The second change is there are people that need to be apprehended because they're criminals, murderers, rapists, sex, human, and drug traffickers that need to be apprehended and either jailed or deported. And that right now is what the sanctuary cities and people like Mayor Fry and Governor Walz are resisting and that have led to the tragedy. Had there not been an organized effort to resist those law enforcement actions, those two individuals in Minneapolis would still be alive.

4:21President Trump has tried to shake up the leadership for the federal immigration crackdown in Minneapolis. He's replaced the Border Patrol official Greg Bovino with Border Czar Tom Homan. Homan said today that he is going to, quote, fix the situation there. Do you believe it is possible to fix the situation in Minneapolis with this change of leadership? If Governor Walz and Mayor Fry would cooperate with ICE rather than resist them, rather than send people into harm's way to create these types of martyrs, yeah, I think it can be fixed. Again, I personally, I want to target the criminals. I don't want ICE targeting other people who are peer working and contributing to society.

5:00But there are a lot of criminals. There are a lot of criminals that have been let in that need to be apprehended and jailed and deported. OK, you keep shifting blame to the mayor in Minneapolis and the governor in Minnesota. Can you tell me specifically what you need to see from that? Well, what do you need to see from them that's specifically to fix the situation in Minneapolis? Do what other governors and mayors have done. Cooperate with ICE. Cooperate with federal law enforcement when they're carrying out completely legal enforcement actions. cooperate with them. Don't resist. Don't send to your citizens their harm's way to resist them and protest against them.

5:38Cooperate. When you arrest an illegal immigrant, hold them for detention. And what are state and local officials supposed to do if they see federal immigration agents doing unlawful actions, such as fatally shooting people when it's not in self-defense, when there is no imminent danger in that situation. There is no weapon being wielded right in the face of the federal agent. Their open borders, their lack of cooperation, created the circumstance for that tragedy. So they should have cooperated on the front end. Right now, there will be a thorough investigation in terms of exactly what happened.

6:19And I'm just saying I've got a great deal of sympathy for those ICE officers who are under constant threat. How would you like to be in law enforcement? And all of a sudden, you've got people who are opposed to what you're trying to do, showing up. You don't know whether they're armed, whether they're just brandishing cameras. You don't know. You're going to be on hair trigger alert. And that's what caused that tragedy. There are still legal requirements for when any law enforcement officer can use lethal force. It's not just if they don't know if the person is armed or not. Last question, going back to the federal spending package.

6:51Democrats, at least at the very least, they just want to split DHS funding from the rest of the spending package to keep the government open. Do you agree with that idea? Then they will never fund DHS. So it's a ploy. I mean, they'll do it. They'll convince people like you that, oh, they're just being very reasonable. This is a way that they can defund DHS just like they want to defund the police to disastrous consequences. So I can't support that effort. Republican Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, thank you very much for joining us. Have a good day. Take care. That was Ron Johnson, Republican Senator of Wisconsin.

7:26This episode was produced by Brianna Scott. It was edited by Christopher Intagliata and Kelsey Snell. Our executive producer is Sammy Yenigan.

7:39It's Consider This from NPR. I'm Elsa Chang.

From the publisher
The civilian killings of Alex Pretti and Renee Macklin Good by federal immigration agents have launched a larger debate in Washington about funding for the Department of Homeland Security.

Senate Democrats want to carve off DHS money from the broader spending package to keep the government open, and they want new limits on immigration agents, like a prohibition on masks and a requirement that officers carry ID. 

Republican Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin says he blames the actions of state and local leaders for the shooting deaths of Alex Pretti and Renee Macklin Good. He insists local leaders should have done more to cooperate with immigration enforcement efforts in Minneapolis.

NPR’s Ailsa Chang spoke with Wisconsin Republican Senator Ron Johnson to discuss his thoughts on whether ICE, and other immigration enforcement agencies, need the reforms Democrats have asked for.

At the time this episode aired, lawmakers were at an impasse regarding the federal spending package. But Senate Democrats now say they’ve reached a deal to separate DHS funding from the other five appropriations bills. You can read more details on npr.org.

For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.  Email us at considerthis@npr.org.

This episode was produced by Brianna Scott. It was edited by Christopher Intagliata, Courtney Dorning and Kelsey Snell. Our executive producer is Sami Yenigun.

Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices

NPR Privacy Policy

More from Consider This from NPR

All 431 episodes
Sen. Ron Johnson blames state and local leaders for Alex Pretti’s killingConsider This from NPR · 7 min
Listen in VO