In short
Six months into Trump’s second term, the episode argues the Education Department has been weakened and its power redirected, with major effects on K-12 funding, special education enforcement, and higher education.
Guests/backgrounds
Elsa Chang (host). Corey Turner (NPR education correspondent). David Downey (30-year Education Department employee, placed on administrative leave). Sasha Podelsky (AASA director of advocacy; superintendent association). Russell Vogt (OMB director; quoted). Brian Huber (Page County Public Schools superintendent). Emily Maroli (Education Department attorney; concerned about disability rights).
Key claims
The department is about half its prior size after buyouts/early retirement and nearly 1,400 layoffs. Nearly $5B in K-12 money was withheld despite congressional approval, justified as opposing “critical race theory” programs. Withholding could force 3/4 of districts to cut reading/math improvement programs; losses may hit Republican districts more. Cuts may weaken special-education legal enforcement for students with disabilities. Trump’s administration also uses the department to pressure elite universities over anti-Semitism (Harvard/Columbia) and pushes a sweeping student-loan overhaul.
Notable examples
Page County’s teacher training needs; special-education attorneys like Maroli; Columbia’s $220M settlement; Harvard’s ongoing case; districts’ budget chaos from delayed funds.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOImpact of Department Downsizing
1:30 to 2:24
Discussion on the reduction in size of the Department of Education and its implications.
“The Trump administration has drastically changed the federal government's role in education.”
Withholding Federal Funds
2:24 to 4:04
Analysis of the Trump administration's decision to withhold nearly $5 billion in federal funding for K-12 schools.
“Okay, so of all the changes in education policy that you've seen under President Trump this year, Which ones do you think have the most far-reaching consequences?”
Challenges Faced by Schools
4:04 to 6:15
Insights from superintendents regarding the challenges of teacher retention and academic resources due to withheld funds.
“She's the director of advocacy for AASA.”
Concerns for Students with Disabilities
6:15 to 8:13
Discussion on the risks faced by students with disabilities due to staff reductions and funding cuts.
“we also need to have funds that can help them get better and also feel better at the work that they're doing.”
Changes in Higher Education Policy
8:13 to 9:30
Overview of significant changes in higher education policy, including federal loan system overhauls and scrutiny of elite universities.
“Because you laid out two big changes already.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Back in March, President Trump began carrying out a campaign promise, dismantling the Department of Education. My administration will take all lawful steps to shut down the department. We're going to shut it down and shut it down as quickly as possible. It's doing us no good. We want to return our students to the states. Well, the department is now about half the size it was before Trump took office. Some employees took buyouts or early retirement, and nearly 1 ,400 federal workers were laid off, including David Downey. He's worked at the department for 30 years, and in March, he was placed on administrative leave.
0:38You know, I fell in love with my job somewhere along the line, and I love helping people. And we care. We are your neighbors. And our oath to the Constitution, it isn't going to end when Trump stops the paychecks. Downey is concerned about what all of this upheaval will mean for schools and students across the country. He says President Trump's goal of returning education to the states is a, quote, bait and switch. States already have the voice and the autonomy to make many, many decisions on what their curriculums look like and their hiring and all of that. What they're doing is disenfranchising the students in these states.
1:22The administration says the moves give, quote, parents and states control over their children's education. Consider this. The Trump administration has drastically changed the federal government's role in education. What does that mean for American classrooms?
1:42From NPR, I'm Elsa Chang.
1:52It's Consider This from NPR. Federal education policy has seen a lot of changes since President Trump's inauguration six months ago. There's the Department of Education itself, which Trump has vowed to close. But that hasn't stopped the Trump administration from also wielding the department's power, most recently by withholding billions of dollars for K-12 schools. We're going to spend the next few minutes looking at the first six months of Trump's second term with NPR education correspondent Corey Turner. Hi, Corey. Hey, Elsa. Okay, so of all the changes in education policy that you've seen under President Trump this year, Which ones do you think have the most far-reaching consequences?
2:34Well, there's obviously the effort to close the department itself. You know, between the buyouts, early retirements, and the cutting of nearly 1 ,400 employees, the department currently stands at about half the size. It was six months ago. On the higher ed side, there's the administration's high-profile fight with Harvard. There are also sweeping changes to student loans. You know, these are all huge stories. The change I want to start with, though, that I think is having the biggest impact right now on K-12 schools is the withholding of federal money that was supposed to be delivered three weeks ago.
3:09Wait, say more about that. Like, how much are we talking here and why is it being withheld? Yeah. So as of today, it's nearly five billion dollars. And to be clear, this is not the two biggest, most important funding streams that go to schools that support kids in poverty and kids with disabilities. But this is still a lot of money, and it was already agreed to by Congress back in March. The Ed Department was supposed to disperse it to schools by July 1st, but it was kind of mysteriously held up by the administration. At a recent breakfast hosted by the Christian Science Monitor, Office of Management and Budget Director Russell Vogt told reporters why this money was being held up.
3:49These are the programs that we have some of the gravest concerns with regarding the Education Department. Vogt argued the money was being used to fund programs that are, in his words, riddled with critical race theory. You have school improvement programs that are indoctrinating teachers to be cultural revolutionaries in the classroom. Now, Elsa, I spoke with Sasha Podelsky. She's the director of advocacy for AASA. That's the School Superintendent's Association. And she told me, you know, this funding goes to 13 ,000 districts and punishing all of them for the anecdotal mistakes of a handful is wrong.
4:28And for the most part, Podelsky told me this money is being used by schools to pay for teachers and teacher training and for programs that help kids learn math and the science of reading. It even funds some AP classes as well as support for English learners. It's never been done before. And this is not suddenly a future problem. This is a today problem because district budgets were set with these funds in mind and the sudden withholding of these funds by the Trump administration has thrown them into chaos. Podelsky's group did a quick survey, too, of hundreds of local superintendents from all over the country.
5:03If this funding isn't released soon, three quarters of districts are going to have to eliminate programs that help children improve academically in core subjects like reading and math. And one more point here, Elsa. This is a problem that's going to affect red and blue districts. There was an analysis of the data by researchers at the liberal New America. They found that on average, school districts represented by Republicans stand to lose 1.6 times as much funding per pupil as districts represented by Democrats. Oh, interesting. Well, still, I mean, there's like, what, nearly$5 billion that's being withheld right now for K-12 schools.
5:43So do you know what that means for schools right now? Yeah, I've been on the phone with superintendents, including Brian Huber. He runs the Page County Public Schools. It's a small, high-poverty rural district in the shadow of Virginia's Shenandoah Mountains. And he told me where he is, it is really hard to find and keep experienced teachers. So he often has to hire people with little or no experience. And then he relies on this federal money that's being withheld to train them. Not only are we bringing in people that are not experienced and not trained, we also need to have funds that can help them get better and also feel better at the work that they're doing.
6:22You know, no one wants to come to work and feel like a failure. You know, President Trump has talked a lot about how America's students are struggling at reading and math because public schools and the U.S. Department of Education, he says, have failed them. But Huber told me low-income rural schools have it really hard right now. If you want to talk about how we're not being successful in public education, then you need to fund it. And I feel strongly about that. OK, but can we talk about the department staff right now? Because with half of the staff gone, what kind of work is actually just going to stop?
6:59Because I'm sure there's no way they can do everything they once did with now just half of the people, right? Yeah, I mean, I know many of the employees who remain are being asked to juggle multiple jobs right now. But I just want to focus on one thing, one of the most important things the Ed Department does at the K-12 level, Elsa. Keep in mind, before federal laws guaranteed kids with disabilities a right to an education, in many states, these children were turned away by public schools. That is not allowed anymore because the federal government got involved. Now, I mentioned the money earlier that it sends to schools to help pay for special education.
7:34But it also employs staff, including attorneys, who make sure students get the help they deserve. And these are some of the people who are being cut, including attorney Emily Maroli. I am worried about students with disabilities and their families being left vulnerable and without a mechanism for making sure that their kids are receiving the services that they are legally entitled to and they are morally entitled to. I need to say, because Moroli won't officially lose her job until August 1st, she was sharing her personal views there. Also, I asked the education department for comment on this, but they did not respond to my request.
8:13OK, well, can we get to higher education as well? Because you laid out two big changes already. Can you tell us what's going on there? Yeah. So first, there is the Trump administration using the education department really as a weapon to go after elite universities over allegations of anti-Semitism. We saw Columbia University just agree to pay an enormous fine, over$220 million. The spotlight is also on Harvard. While that case is technically about policing anti-Semitism on campus, you know, Trump has used this fight to cast himself as a kind of populist fighter against elite, woke, liberal universities.
8:51For Harvard, though, and really for colleges and universities all over the country, Elsa, this is an existential fight for their financial and intellectual independence. The other big higher ed story I need to mention here, it's less visible, but it's still a big deal. And that is that Republicans just passed a sweeping overhaul of the entire federal student loan system. You know, I think borrowers will actually like some of the changes in here, but it is It's hard to overstate just how much work it's going to be for the department to implement all these changes, especially considering they've got half the staff they had six months ago.
9:29You know, on a personal note, Elsa, my email right now is a swirling vortex of borrower questions. I bet. I think that's because so much is changing and it seems to be getting harder and harder for borrowers to just pick up the phone and get answers. Maddening. That is NPR education correspondent Corey Turner. Thank you so much, Corey. You're welcome. This episode was produced by Catherine Fink. It was edited by Nicole Cohen and Courtney Dorning. Our executive producer is Sammy Yenigan.
10:02It's Consider This from NPR. I'm Elsa Chang.
From the publisher
But that hasn't stopped the Trump administration from also wielding the Department's power. Most recently, by withholding billions of dollars for K-12 schools.
The Trump administration has drastically changed the federal government's role in education. What does that mean for American classrooms?
For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.
Email us at considerthis@npr.org.
Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices
NPR Privacy Policy




