1. Podcasts
  2. Creative Pep Talk
  3. If Nothing's Working Do One of These 3 Effective Projects
Creative Pep Talk

11 Nov 2026 · 25m · 8 chapters

Episode artwork

If Nothing's Working Do One of These 3 Effective Projects

In short

The episode argues that creative projects “fizzle” when you expect them to change everything. The fix is to right-size expectations and define success as one of three project types: mine (exploration), refine (turn raw material into workable form), and shine (present the finished work).

Key claims

don’t treat one project as a whole “village” replacement; pause when frustrated to uncover unconscious expectations; play with the problem instead of rushing drafts.

Notable examples

the host’s illustration career cycle (Sony PSP ads, then a published book) that didn’t deliver “game changer” results until expectations shifted; dating life before meeting wife Sophie; Amanda Gorman’s close-reading framework (read for pleasure, purpose, then alternatives).

Guests

none mentioned; no guest interview in the transcript.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:01

The Power of Close Reading

Discussion on how close reading can reignite creative passion.

“Sometimes you just need a creative pep talk.”
3:46

The Illusion of Game-Changing Projects

Exploring the disappointment of high expectations in creative projects.

“When I was just starting out as an illustrator right out of school, I remember getting a project with Sony.”
4:54

Right-Sizing Expectations

Strategies for managing expectations to achieve creative success.

“And ultimately I'm going to do the work and I'm going to be right exactly where I was having to fight for my career before this thing came in.”
7:20

Introducing the Project Framework

Introducing a framework for categorizing creative projects into three types.

“this is what I'm doing this for, I can actually maximize its potential for succeeding in that way.”
8:36

The Three Project Types: Mine, Refine, Shine

Detailed explanation of the three types of creative projects and their purposes.

“You see this best operating in the field of stand-up, stand-up comedy.”
14:00

Exploring the Creative Process

Learn about the three stages of creative projects: mining, refining, and shining.

“That's where the standup comedian is going to create the comedy special.”
18:39

Creative Call to Adventure: Escape Your Fate

Understand how to bring unconscious expectations into consciousness for creativity.

“All right, here's our creative call to adventure.”
23:05

Product Launch and Acknowledgments

Hear about a new sketchbook carrying case and appreciate contributors to the show.

“Real quick, I got to tell you about something that I am so excited about.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Creative Pep Talk, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Do you feel doomed to a fate of putting out projects that ultimately just fizzle and don't meet your expectations? You're like, what is the point in putting another thing out? Nothing ever goes how I want it to go. They don't live up to what I hoped they would live up to. I feel like that sometimes. Maybe you look at me and maybe you're more successful than me, or maybe you look at me and you're like, this guy's got a bunch of books and a podcast and all these clients, and maybe it looks really great, but nothing I do feels successful if I don't do this one thing. And I'm gonna share with you what that thing is in just a second.

0:37But if you stick around to the end, I'm gonna come back with our creative call to adventure. It's called Escape Your Fate. It's the one thing that Carl Jung believed you had to do to escape your fate. And if you want to escape a fate of doomed projects that feel forever meant to fail. I suggest you stick around for that. Let's go.

1:00Andy J. Pizza: On the creative journey, it's easy to get lost, but don't worry, you'll lift up. Sometimes you just need a creative pep talk.

1:19I've been feeling that end of year slump creatively and just feeling tired, but then I ran into something that completely switched my passion back on and reminded me what's so fun about all of this. It was poet Amanda Gorman in her class on Masterclass talking about close reading a poem or a brief passage of literature. Her close reading process looks like reading it once for pleasure, twice to think about why the creator is doing what they're doing and three times to think about what she might do differently. This sort of deconstruction of my favorite creative things always lights me on fire and I love that framework.

1:54Masterclass literally has the creative masters of the world teaching you their tricks with over 200 classes across 13 categories of business, writing, cooking, creativity, wellness, and more. There is going to be a master creative that you are a super fan and need to learn from on this platform. there's never been a better time to sign up because it's 50 % off right now for the holidays. Also makes a great gift for a loved one. Go find a teacher they're a major fan of and say, hey, this reminded me of you. Masterclass keeps adding new classes so there's never been a better time to get in. Right now you can get up to 50 % off an annual membership at masterclass.com slash pep talk.

2:30That's 50 % off of Masterclass at masterclass.com slash pep talk. Head to masterclass.com slash pep talk to get the latest offer. Today's episode is brought to you by Vented. I don't know about you, but our closets are often full of stuff we no longer need or just aren't getting much use from, but we don't have hardly any time to deal with it. However, recently we decided to try and sell some of it on Vented, a secondhand marketplace app and couldn't believe how quick and easy it was. Super easy to get an account, just minutes to start listing. Vented suggested price ranges based on similar products and even had checkboxes to easily categorize the brand and item type.

3:11We went from sitting on stuff we'd been meaning to deal with for months to listing them on Vented in minutes. Very cool. Plus there are no seller fees and the app is free to download. Once the item sells, Vented even creates a prepaid shipping label for you. Don't just sit on unused stuff, get it listed and sold to someone who wants it and all the while make some extra cash in the process. I mean, who doesn't want a little bit of extra cash? Ready to clean out your closet and make some extra money? Download the Vinted app for free and start listing with no seller fees. You keep every dollar you earn.

3:46When I was just starting out as an illustrator right out of school, I remember getting a project with Sony. It was Sony PSP. Kids, it was this handheld before the Switch 2, and it was just, I already had a PSP. I was super into it. I got to make this illustration for one of the ads in the UK. And I was so freaking pumped. I couldn't wait to put it on my website. I thought this is going to change everything. I put it on and guess what? It didn't. It didn't change maybe anything. I just kind of kept having to hustle to get new jobs and try to get the word out there about what I did. And then about a year later, I had a project come out that was a published book.

4:29And I thought this is it. this is going to be the thing that changes everything. And of course, boom, we put it out and it didn't change everything. And I just kept going through this cycle until eventually when something huge, seemingly huge would come my way, I just would feel jaded about it. I would feel like, yeah, this is not going to be the game changer I think it's going to be. It's not going to change everything. And ultimately I'm going to do the work and I'm going to be right exactly where I was having to fight for my career before this thing came in. And I don't really feel like that anymore.

5:06That's not my experience. I do a project often and I'm really excited about what comes out of it. And so what changed? I think I can see the same thing in what my dating life was before I met my wife, Sophie. I had a few girlfriends in high school and each one I was like, this is the person this is the person that's gonna change everything for me and then it went bad and it was in heartbreak and i was like oh my gosh i thought i found the person and i did that a few different times and so what changed obviously the number one thing that changed is that i met my my true soulmate sophie um we are super compatible and i do love her so much um and we did have uh you know, quite a falling in love, falling head over heel story.

5:59But I think what changed from high school to by the time I met Sophie, I'd taken a few years off of dating. I kind of invested in myself a little bit. And by the time we started dating and I met her, I fell madly in love, but I didn't think this is the thing that's going to save me. This is the thing that's going to change everything. That yes, this person was a much better fit for me, but the other thing that helped it succeed was not expecting it to be everything. And I've learned that the same is true for a creative project. If I go into any book, any self-initiated creative side quest, any new client job, any opportunity and think this is the thing that's going to change everything, it is doomed to fail from the start.

6:56And so the key that I had to find was that I have to right-size my expectations, not lower them, not make them nothing, not be jaded, but to say, what does this thing need to be? What is its purpose? And make that as small or medium, as large as it appropriately needs to be and have a clear understanding of that. If I go into it with, this is what I'm doing this for, I can actually maximize its potential for succeeding in that way. You've probably come across a relationship expert and therapist, Esther Perel. She's all over the internet, but she has this quote about this in regards to relationships.

7:38She says, expecting one person to give us what an entire village used to provide is a recipe for failure. And I think the same is true for your creative projects. When I go into a new book, I usually have that baggage of like, oh, this needs to be this. It needs to be that. It needs to tell this kind of story that I've been wanting to tell and that thing. And I get into that place. I start creating from that place. And I'm like, oh, I'm frustrated. I'm tense. Like, oh, why? It's not doing it. Well, it's not doing it because it can't do everything. And I have to, usually, I have to hit a wall of like, why is this not working before I stop and remember, oh, I need to right size the expectations.

8:18I need to let this project be what it needs to be and not be everything else. And so I'm going to talk about a little framework that I use to help figure out what kind of project I'm working on and what kind of success it needs to aspire to and how it doesn't need to succeed in all these other ways. So let's do that next.

8:46so i think of every project as sort of one of three types of projects they need to succeed in these very specific three types of ways and they build on each other i call it the mine refine shine those are the three types of projects and they rhyme which rhyme almost rhymes with mine, refine and shine. Mine, refine, shine, rhyme. That's not the fourth one. Sorry, that's confusing. Sorry about that. But it's mine, refine, shine. You see this best operating in the field of stand-up, stand-up comedy. They have the mine, the refine, the shine. The mine is the club gigs. Mining is a project you do when you're trying to find what you're working on, what you're curious about, where the next thread is going to come from.

9:38You have to do mind projects, man. I'm talking to you, Andy, 2010. Look, buddy, you can't just skip to the shine. You can't skip to, you know, crushing it and a successful career project. You have to mine your internal realms. You have to be curious. You have to take an interest in you. And I remember sometimes I talk to creative people and I'm like, hey man like tell me what you're all about tell me what uh you're into um and they often are like i don't know i like to draw that's the only thing i've got you're like no no you you have all these curiosities you have all these interests but the problem is you haven't taken an interest in you and until you take an interest in you you won't that that interest is an investment in who you are and what you're excited about.

10:29And so you haven't trained yourself to see the value of your curiosity. You have to do projects that are for you, that don't make sense, that you don't know how they're going to refine and shine into something that you could build a career on or connect with somebody else over. You have to do something that's saying, I don't know what this is. And this is you're mining for gems in the cave of your own brain. You're mining and they all look like just rocks. You're like, I don't have anything interesting in there. You do. You are a universe inside of a skull. Like this is as vast and complex and interesting as the rest of the cosmos.

11:08We understand it that much. That's how incredible it is and how full it is and how rich it is. But you've got to take an interest and you've got to spend time. You've got to do a project. And this is what the comedians do when they're just like trying to work stuff out. Like, come, is this anything? Like that's something they always say, is that anything? And they will just be like, here's a list of things that might maybe kind of might be something. And then they'll go into the club and those comedy clubs, that's a project where you're mining. You're like trying to figure out what is, is this anything?

11:39That's, you need to do projects like that. I did a project. It was a daily drawing project years ago where that's all I was doing was being like, I think this is the stuff that I'm kind of interested in these characters, these hiding characters, this like dreamy world. Like I don't know what it is, but it's inspired by these influences of Alice in Wonderland and Zelda linked to the past. Shout out to Ocarina of Time came out the day I'm recording this. If you celebrate, you know what I'm talking about. If you don't, what the heck is wrong with you? Get with the program. But that's a mining project.

12:11So the next project you're working on, if you know, like, I don't even know if there's anything valuable here. It's just something I'm interested in. Make it a mine project. That means it's a mining, you're mining the cave, but it's also yours, mine. It's just for you. Double meaning. The second, love a double meaning. Double entendre. I think that's what some people say. Is that what that means? Two, refine project. This is when you've got some of those rocks. You think some of these bad babies might be worse than them. They might be gems. You need to put them in the tumbler in a refine project and see what you got.

12:45Once they have enough stuff, they're like, there's some stuff here. That's when the comedians are going to go on tour and they're going to work out all the jokes, refine them into what they need to be to go into the final stage. And so the tour is a different project. It's not just a part of the larger project. It's not all just for the comedy special, which is the Shine project. It's all its own thing. They're enjoyable in their own way. But this one is where you're trying to figure out how you can connect what you found and know has some value and refine it into something that shines for the audience.

13:18And so there's a project that you might do where you're like, I'm just trying to take this raw material and turn it into something. And so for me, that looked like taking these characters and creating these posts to try to explain them on the internet to people like what's cool about this. And that actually went through a couple of different processes. I tried a bunch of different book proposals and different posts on the internet. And it just, that was my refining phase. The third one is the shining, not with Jack Nicholson, but with you shining those rocks. You are not shining. You've got them.

13:54You refined them. You got them. Now you know what you've got. You want to shine them to the world. That's kind of like, this is where we're going to show off this thing in its best light. That's where the standup comedian is going to create the comedy special. the third project yes it's they're all connected but this is its own thing and this is when it's ready to tape and film and for me that's when it was ready to become a book and this same thing happened to me and happens to me cyclically it doesn't just happen with that project happens all the time um i work out a lot of stuff in this podcast that ends up becoming talks that i do and those talks sometimes become classes or books um it looks like sometimes i'm doing a mining project where I'm like, okay, we need to find a new value, a stream of value for putting this stuff out in the world.

14:44And I'm going to try YouTube and I'm going to try Substack and I'm going to try short form video. That's what I did a few years ago. And we were doing this mining, this just like throwing stuff against the wall. That's what I, you can think of a mine project as a spaghetti project, just throwing stuff against the wall, seeing what sticks. Once you've got something that sticks, you want to take that and refine it until you like work out all the details of how to make this thing really hit. Once you have that, it's time to invest in the shine. Like, can we invest in the director, invest in the filming?

15:14Let's try to sell it to a network and really make that project that's going to shine in this bigger investment. So those are the three stages. And if you try to make a mind project a shine project, you're going to go down the drain. It's not going to, I was going to try to rhyme something, but it's not going to work. That's where it goes bad. So we just started a new book project and we were working on it. And I can feel like all of this tension. And it wasn't until we paused and stopped and unpacked all these unconscious expectations and all these ridiculous expectations we were trying to put on one project that we could let it be what it needed to be, which brings us to our creative call to adventure.

16:18This episode is sponsored by Squarespace. I freaking love having Squarespace as a sponsor because it's easy to sell it when you love something this much. I'm a big fan. Squarespace is an all-in-one website platform designed to help you succeed online. Here's what I love about Squarespace. They're intuitive and super versatile drag and drop tools. I mean, you can make a custom website without knowledge of code that makes people say, whoa, who made that for you? Looks like you built that from scratch. People have really said stuff like that to me about my site and I built it myself quite easily with Squarespace.

16:53You can check it out at AndyJPizza.com if you wanna check that out, what I did with it. It doesn't look templaty and it screams my creative brand. I also love that I have all of my domains through Squarespace now, which makes it seamless and easy to manage. I know the first thing as creative folks do when we get an idea is to grab that URL. Now you can keep track of all your websites and your domains in one place that's super intuitive and easy to manage. Head to squarespace.com slash peptalk for a free trial. And when you're ready to launch, use promo code peptalk, all one word, to save 10 % off your first purchase of a website or domain.

17:29The best pieces in your closet are the ones you can count on, whether you're heading to work, going out, or keeping things casual. In this time of year, Quince makes finding something great for everyone else just as easy. I would feel confident buying a gift from Quince for my wife, Sophie, because she loves the sheets and the pillowcases and the clothing that we've got from there. And she was just looking at fall and winter jackets and said that she felt spoiled for choice because there were just too many good options. Quince focuses on high-quality staples made with premium materials like 100 % Mongolian cashmere, 14-karat gold, and Italian leather, all timeless, versatile pieces that feel special to unwrap and become everyday holiday favorites.

18:10Everything at Quince is priced 50 % to 80 % less than similar brands. They work directly with ethical factories and cut out the middlemen, so you can give the luxury quality pieces without the luxury price tag. Give the gift of quality this holiday season. Download the Quince app for app-exclusive offers or go to quince.com. Get free shipping on your order and 365-day returns. Now available in Canada and the UK too. And when Quince asks where you heard about them, let them know it was from Creative Pep Talk. It's the best way to support the show.

18:45All right, here's our creative call to adventure. It's called Escape Your Fate. It's based on this quote that's often attributed to Carl Jung that he didn't say, but I do think summarizes a lot of his thinking quite well. And you've probably heard it. It's this idea that until you make your unconscious, your subconscious, conscious, it will control or direct your life and you will call it fate. And what that means is until you have the sort of metacognition to notice how you're feeling, what you're thinking, what expectations you're putting on to things subconsciously without even realizing it, until you make that conscious, until you make that aware, until you get aware of it, it will control your life.

19:32And you'll be like, well, I didn't have any control. That was just the fate. But you did have control. You had control of making that, of pausing before you stumble and crash into the project, Andy, and just be like, oh, this book isn't working. It's not doing anything. things I wanted to do. Yeah, because you didn't even define what success looked like in a reasonable fashion. And so what I suggest you do, maybe it's a project you're in the middle of, maybe it's a project you're about to launch or get into, or maybe it's something like you're getting ready to put out in the world. And right before you put out in the world, you can take a breath and just make that unconscious conscious.

20:09Make the unconscious expectations, hopes, and dreams that you have for this and bring it into your awareness and ask yourself, is this reasonable? First of all, like, is this possible? Is this, is it possible for this to be the mind refined shine? Is this possible that this thing is going to change my everything? Probably not. And so what was helpful for me is Sophie and I, while we're working on this book, we had this, we finally, we're getting frustrated. We're trying to make this, you know, if you're a creator, if you're a creative person, you can get really scared, like, are we going to do it?

20:41Are we going to do it? And you're just, you don't give yourself any time to play with the problem, which creative researchers say is the key to success creatively is not trying to rush us off the problem because you're so afraid that you can't do it. You have to play, you have to have fun. You have to be like, we'll figure it out. Let's have some fun with it. And part of that looks like, let's just, instead of like, you know, doing an eighth draft this morning with the three hours we have, what if we take this three hours, we We go get coffee and we're just like, hey, what are you unconsciously hoping that this project will do?

21:15Can we get that out in the open? And we did that. And it was such a freaking breakthrough to be like, oh, I'm wanting this to be what the next 10 projects need to accomplish. and now that I'm aware that I'm trying to do all of these things, I can like pick which of those expectations or hopes and dreams does this project actually have potential to solve. And then when we did that, the creativity started to flow. So all of a sudden it doesn't need to be the 50 things that you like in a song. You can just make a song that does one thing really well, that really like this is an appropriate place, an appropriate container for this.

21:55particular expectation. And so that's my creative call to adventure for you. Instead of maybe this next creative session, instead of hustling and grinding and panicking and trying to solve the problem as quickly as possible, just pause and be like, you know what? Today's creative session, I'm actually going to give myself the space to play with just brain dumping. What am I hoping this thing can do? And then what is it positioned to and what am I in the position to to actually do with this project? And if it was a mine project, if it was a refined project, if it was a shine project, how could I maximize for that instead of trying to maximize for everything and ultimately ending in failure?

22:56All right. I hope this process is as creatively generative and life-giving as it was for me in this recent project. And thanks for listening. Real quick, I got to tell you about something that I am so excited about. It's a new collab that I did with a company called Quell. And it It is a sketchbook carrying case and sketchbook. It's a creative pep talk artist series version of it. And I have been using a version of these products for maybe a year and I am obsessed with it. It is a little sketchbook carrying case that your sketchbook folds flat into and it's got, you can put Posca markers and pencils and your stickers in there and zip it up and take it anywhere so that you can actually be one of these people that sketches on the go instead of just doom scrolls.

23:51So instead of reaching for your phone, when you get a minute, you can reach for your sketchbook and you'd be surprised by how much time you have to doodle and create and note down ideas. And I have really loved this. I've loved traveling with this. I've used it to do live sketching at events. And you see it sometimes on the solo episodes, when I'm drawing on screen, you're seeing that folding thing in action. I'm a huge fan of it. We are selling it in our shop. You can go to creativepeptalk.etsy.com. There's a little collab, Quell Collab section or just look for the sketchbook case. It's a blue sketchbook case.

24:28Love the colors. I got to pick all the colors and all the little things. It's got a little tag that says Creative Pep Talk inside. It's got a cool swing tag, man. And it's got this new sketchbook in there. I just really, really loved this company. I've loved working with them. I love these products. I've been using them, like I said, for a while. If you're trying to up your sketchbook game, if you're trying to lower your scrolling game, this is a great product for you. Also a great gift for people in your life. Go check it out, creativepeptalk.etsy.com. You're gonna love this. I'm excited about it.

25:02I've been really anxious and excited to share it with everybody. Go check it out. Massive thanks to Sophie Miller for being an editor and a producer on this show. Thanks to Connor Jones of Pinning Beautiful for audio edits, video edits, sound design, and animation. Thanks to Yoni Wolf of the band Y, who has a new album out called Oh Galley. Oh Galley? Oh Galley, yes Lord. So good. Vice gave it 8 out of 10. I would have given it 9.5. It's a fantastic album. Might be my favorite album they've ever made. Honestly, it's so good. Go check it out. Thanks to all of you for listening. Until we speak again, stay pepped up.

25:56This is Phil Bredesen, former Democratic governor of the state of Tennessee. If you love digging into how history shapes U.S. policy, check out the new season of You Might Be Right. And this is Bill Haslam, former Republican governor. This season, we're asking the questions that has defined every pivotal moment in American political history. Is democracy really under threat, or is that just a story as old as the republic itself? We're tackling the biggest questions shaping the 2026 midterms, so join us. Follow You Might Be Right wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

Creative life force not flowing?

Nothing you’re making hitting with others?

If so, this episode is for you!

I share the 3 types of successful projects I’ve done and how to maximize their potential.

Plus stick around for the “Escape Your Fate” exercise to help you avoid certain creative project failure.

Episode 581

SHOW NOTES:

Producer / Editor: Sophie Miller http://sophiemiller.coAudio Editing / Sound Design: Conner Jones http://pendingbeautiful.coSoundtrack / Theme Song: Yoni Wolf / WHY? http://whywithaquestionmark.comSpotify Playlist of WHY? Songs Used on This Podcast: https://open.spotify.com/playlist/4ZIE7PHG5I1Ddg1BuVGRzj?si=4x_BzDZjQgqSpoaLXdVACg&pi=h4HsIKG0SP6Kg

SPONSORS:SQUARESPACEHead to https://www.squarespace.com/PEPTALK to save 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain using code PEPTALK

More from Creative Pep Talk

All episodes