1. Podcasts
  2. Crime Junkie
  3. MISSING: Lisa Jameson
Crime Junkie

16 Nov 2026 · 1h 14m · 29 chapters

In short

The disappearance of Lisa Jameson (last seen Nov 4, 1991) and how a 2016 song by her son, Kyle Collins, allegedly resurfaced overlooked details. The episode reviews the timeline, the discovery of Lisa’s red 1989 Pontiac Le Mans at an adult bookstore parking lot, multiple delayed/contested searches, and the later destruction of much of the original case file.

Guests and backgrounds

No named co-host guests. The episode features interviews with family and people connected to the case, including Kyle Collins (Lisa’s son; rapper who wrote “Red Coat”), Alan Jameson (Lisa’s husband; security guard/detention officer), Lisa’s sister Treva (Kyle’s aunt), Kyle’s cousin Shay (rapper; inspected the car), and Gordon (Lisa’s high school sweetheart; Kyle’s biological father). It also references Kirby Becker (related to Alan; messaged Kyle).

Key claims

Lisa was likely pregnant; Alan allegedly cut up Lisa’s credit cards; the car showed no struggle per police, but Shay claims visible struggle signs; Gilbert PD’s original case file and most early evidence were destroyed (discovered 2020); Kyle’s lyrics triggered family memories of him describing a “bloody mess.”

Notable examples

Pleasure World car found after ~10 days; car released to Alan then re-searched for trace evidence; apartment searched nearly a year later with luminol; polygraph results changed Alan’s stance; Kyle’s “Red Coat” line “flashbacks become nightmares… a bloody mess” prompted Treva’s question.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:50

Kyle Collins' Struggles

Discover rapper Kyle Collins' life and his mother's disappearance.

“In 2012, 23-year-old rapper Kyle Collins was experiencing a bout of homelessness.”
1:40

The Song Red Coat

Learn about Kyle's song Red Coat and its emotional impact.

“But right here, right now, an idea started to take hold.”
2:16

The Last Day of Lisa Jameson

Uncover the events leading up to Lisa Jameson's disappearance.

“would unlock a huge clue that had been buried deep within him for years.”
3:05

Family's Concern and Police Response

Explore the family's immediate actions and police involvement.

“On the phone, he says that he had just gotten home from his shift as a security guard at the County Superior Court and discovered that Lisa was nowhere to be found in their two-bedroom apartment in Gilbert, Arizona.”
3:58

Lisa's Final Sightings

Investigate the last known sightings of Lisa Jameson.

“According to the investigative file, by the next day, officers have gotten to work, having a number of very brief conversations with those closest to Lisa, like just enough to put together a timeline.”
5:00

Discovery of the Abandoned Car

Learn about the discovery of Lisa's car and its implications.

“A line in the case file says they spoke to her co-workers, plural, but nobody is called out specifically except for this guy that she carpooled with.”
6:27

Mistakes in the Investigation

Examine the errors made by police during the investigation.

“Or should I say where her car has been for almost the entire time she's been missing.”
8:10

The Revelation of Pregnancy

Discuss the shocking revelation of Lisa's pregnancy before her disappearance.

“No excuse, I think, will make enough sense.”
11:15

Alan's Statements and Behavior

Analyze Alan's behavior and statements during the investigation.

“Well, according to what Lisa's mom, Barbara, told the media, that is when Lisa relayed that she was pregnant.”
14:00

The Investigation Takes a Turn

Learn about the changing dynamics in the investigation of Lisa's disappearance.

“But he says that he never got anything back.”
Show all 29 chapters
18:08

Alan's Timeline and the Polygraph

Explore Alan's timeline on the day Lisa went missing and his polygraph results.

“So they end up asking Alan if they can search his apartment again.”
22:04

Alan's Life After Lisa

Discover what happened in Alan's life after Lisa's disappearance and its impact on Kyle.

“But contrary to what Alan told detectives back in 91, he now tells them that he believes Lisa is no longer living, that something happened to her and that some sort of foul play occurred.”
28:01

Kyle's Family Background and Complicated Relationships

Learn about Kyle Collins' family history and the complexities surrounding his parents' relationships.

“Kyle Collins' life had only just begun when it was turned upside down by the disappearance of his mom in 1991.”
30:26

Kyle's Journey Through Music and Personal Struggles

Explore how Kyle used music as an emotional outlet and his journey towards a music career.

“So Gordon told us that he hadn't seen Lisa in like six months when he found out that she had gone missing from her sister.”
33:02

The Creation and Impact of 'Red Coat'

Discover the story behind Kyle's song 'Red Coat' and its transformative effect on his life and family.

“And getting those songs out is cathartic for him, like all throughout high school, during which time he starts teaching himself how to produce and to mix with programs that he downloaded on his computer.”
39:01

Revisiting Lisa's Case and Uncovered Evidence

Examine the evidence surrounding Lisa's disappearance and family reactions.

“Kyle was dumbfounded after his aunt heard the song Red Coat and asked him if he was starting to remember things.”
42:00

Unraveling the Investigation Details

Discussion on the missing details and discrepancies in Lisa's case.

“So online, I see people talking about a broken red fingernail being found in her car, too.”
44:25

The Mysterious Destruction of Case Files

Exploration of how Lisa's case file was destroyed and its implications.

“There is a little dark cloud that has been looming over this case.”
46:29

Accountability and Consequences

Discussion about the lack of accountability in the police department.

“Earlier this year, they were being investigated by the state attorney general's office about a claim that they may have illegally destroyed or withheld police records.”
47:59

Tracing Lisa's Car and Evidence

Investigation into the whereabouts of Lisa's car and evidence found.

“I was going to say, like, put safeguards around it so like it never happens again.”
50:19

Kyle's Insights and Family Dynamics

Kyle's development of suspicion towards Alan and family dynamics.

“Did Kyle's family tell police like what he said when he was little, like back when it happened?”
56:28

Kyle's Unexpected Meeting with Gilbert PD

Kyle's first encounter with Gilbert PD raises more questions than answers about his mother's case.

“I mean, he hadn't heard from Alan since his seventh birthday.”
58:26

New Discoveries in Lisa's Case

Kyle learns about Lisa's affairs and the complexities surrounding her disappearance.

“Now, at this point, Kyle didn't have it in him to dig for the truth and to fight because he at that point was fighting for his own life.”
1:00:20

The Mystery of Pleasure World

The connection between Lisa's disappearance and a mysterious location raises new concerns.

“Lisa was allegedly having multiple affairs during the time that she was married to Alan.”
1:03:01

Unidentified Prints and Trafficking Theories

New evidence from Lisa's car and trafficking allegations complicate the investigation.

“Alan always thought that the car must have been planted.”
1:05:01

Kyle's Family and Trafficking Revelations

Kyle's uncle's arrest for human trafficking adds a shocking twist to the story.

“Police realized that the fingerprints that they had gotten from Lisa's car, those had never been entered into a database in all years since her disappearance.”
1:10:08

The Arrest of Miles and Its Implications

Learn about the timeline and details surrounding Miles' arrest and the charges he faced.

“On August 27th, 2018, a woman posted a missed connections ad on Craigslist saying that she had spoken with a nice man at Starbucks about him teaching her child.”
1:16:38

Ongoing Investigations and Evidence Issues

Discover the current status of Lisa's case and the problems with evidence handling.

“And for what it's worth, Shay, who was, remember, super close with Lisa and Kyle, told us that while what Miles did is sick, he doesn't believe that it has anything to do with Lisa's disappearance.”
1:19:41

A Call for Information

Hear a heartfelt plea for information about Lisa's disappearance from her son Kyle.

“I mean, there's people that, like, we spoke to that they say that they never even got a call from Gilbert PD.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Crime Junkie, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. Holiday stress is hard, but talking with a professional can make a difference. BetterHelp connects you with licensed, experienced therapists through a simple questionnaire to provide tailored support. Switch therapists anytime and prioritize your peace and well-being as one of the best gifts you give yourself this holiday season. Better Help is in network with over 125 health plans with co-pays as low as$15 for eligible members. If you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the U.S., you can still get 20 % off your first month. Sign up and get 20 % off at BetterHelp.com slash Crime Junkie.

0:36That's BetterHelp.com slash Crime Junkie. Hi, Crime Junkies. I'm your host, Ashley Flowers. And I'm Britt. And today's episode starts with a song. In 2012, 23-year-old rapper Kyle Collins was experiencing a bout of homelessness. That's why he was sleeping on the floor of a recording studio, in a sleeping bag, spending all of his time there. But little did he know, something was about to happen that would change the course of his life forever. Kyle had a flicker of an idea for a new song. But for weeks, it was just a loop playing over and over in his mind. Until it finally hit him what the song needed to be about.

1:24His missing mother, Lisa Jameson. Kyle had been suppressing memories about Lisa since she disappeared when he was just two years old. It was always too painful to talk about. Which is why in all those years, he never learned much about her case. But right here, right now, an idea started to take hold. And the lyrics for a song called Red Coat just started pouring out of him, setting off a chain reaction that would change his mother's case forever. I'm so sick of wondering why, waking up in these cold sweats, wishing I would just die. And why the fuck, I don't know yet what happened, what happened to the girl who was wearing this red coat.

2:07She came then, she went now. I don't even really know what I live for, but I'm... When Kyle eventually released the song Red Coat in 2016, there is a specific verse in the song that, unbeknownst to him when he wrote it, would unlock a huge clue that had been buried deep within him for years. But for you to understand the gravity of what is about to happen, we need to travel back to November 4th, 1991, the last known day Lisa Jameson was seen alive.

2:46November 4th, 1991 was a Monday, a pretty normal one for Lisa Jameson's parents, Barbara and Frank Collins, all the way up until about 7.30 p.m. when they got a call from Lisa's husband, Alan Jameson. He was calling to find out if they knew where Lisa is. On the phone, he says that he had just gotten home from his shift as a security guard at the County Superior Court and discovered that Lisa was nowhere to be found in their two-bedroom apartment in Gilbert, Arizona. And that alone wouldn't have been cause for concern right away. But then came the call from the babysitter. And she said that Lisa hadn't come to pick up their two-year-old Kyle like she was supposed to that morning.

3:27Kyle had been there the whole day. And when it comes to Lisa, this is the reddest flag there could be because Kyle was everything to her. I mean, her mom said that Lisa was crazy about him. She barely even liked to leave him at the babysitters for just a couple of hours between when her overnight shift ended and when Alan's began in the morning. So when Alan relays to Lisa's parents that he's going to wait the 24 hours that police told him to before filing a missing persons report, they go straight to Gilbert police and demand that the report be taken themselves. According to the investigative file, by the next day, officers have gotten to work, having a number of very brief conversations with those closest to Lisa, like just enough to put together a timeline.

4:08Now, what we know is that the day before she disappeared, what would have been November 3rd, Lisa stopped by her parents' house at around 4 p.m. And her dad said that she was acting totally normal and only left to go home and get some sleep before she had to go to her night shift at this electronics company where she worked in Chandler. Now, Alan's account picks up from there. He says that his wife was at home that evening and he last saw her just after the clock hit midnight on November 4th. 12.01 a.m. to be exact, as she was leaving their apartment in her red 1989 Pontiac Le Mans headed for work.

4:46And he mentions there is a co-worker in the area that she carpools with. And when police check with that guy, he says that Lisa dropped him off at his residence after their shift at around 7.15 a.m. So it sounds like she did make it to work that night. Seemingly so. A line in the case file says they spoke to her co-workers, plural, but nobody is called out specifically except for this guy that she carpooled with. And I couldn't even verify this independently because the co-worker's name is redacted throughout the file. So like if that guy is listening or anyone she worked with, I would love to talk to you.

5:21You can always email tips at audiochuck.com to get a hold of me. Anyways, even though his name is redacted, some of the information he gives isn't. He says that Lisa was acting totally normal. She seemed fine. And after she dropped him off near McQueen Road and Chandler Boulevard, the last he sees is her driving like northbound. And this would become the last sighting of Lisa ever. And is northbound the direction of her home? Yeah, her and Alan's apartment is north. Lisa's parents' house is north of there too. But she seemingly never made it. And for almost a solid month, that is all Lisa's family knew.

5:59She was just gone. Not a single person in her large family had seen her. And Lisa was the youngest of seven. So everyone was on high alert for her and her car, which was missing along with her. Now, for anyone who knew Lisa well, they knew that she would not have left on her own without a word. But perhaps some, maybe in law enforcement, saw the missing car as a sign that she took off on her own. Well, for those people, that fantasy ended December 2nd when Gilbert detectives found out where her car is. Or should I say where her car has been for almost the entire time she's been missing. It turns out that back on November 14th, Phoenix PD got a call about an abandoned car in the parking lot of a place called Pleasure World, which advertises itself as an adult bookstore.

6:52But per old newspaper articles, it seems like they offer a lot more than just books. Now, the manager at Pleasure World said that the car had already been there like 10 days before it had gotten towed away. And I thought this was odd at first, like how like you're clocking this car supposedly down to like the day before you even knew it was important. Like we never get specificity like this from potential witnesses. But Pleasure World is still at the same address. And if anyone follows me on social, you know, yeah, I went down a deep rabbit hole. I sent Brianna, our breaking news reporter, out there.

7:26And what we found out is the parking lot is tiny, like only a dozen or so spots right out front. So you actually, I think, would clock a car that was there or you didn't recognize or specifically that didn't move. OK, but did they not run the plates when it was towed, though? Like, how did Gilbert PD not get pinged about this? So it's written in the file that Gilbert detectives entered Lisa's car as an ATL attempt to locate in NCIC's vehicle database. So I'm not sure why they wouldn't have been notified when Phoenix PD found the car. Because per the file, Phoenix PD did run a license plate inquiry through DPS.

8:05But dot, dot, dot. Like you fill in the rest. Wires got crossed. Something slipped through the cracks. Regardless, it didn't happen. Like the match didn't happen. No excuse, I think, will make enough sense. Right. At least not with the records we have. And in some of them, it's not even consistent. Like some say it was actually Chandler police that recovered the car, not Phoenix, which is even more confusing. because Chandler is way down by where she worked and where she was last seen. Like, they don't operate up here in northwest Phoenix where Pleasure World is. It's kind of like a hike between the two places.

8:35So all I know is that Gilbert P.D. didn't make the connection until December 2nd, nearly three weeks after the fact, at which point the car had already been brought to a tow yard. Luckily, though, when they go to recover it, An employee at the towing company tells investigators that the car is in the same condition now as it was when it was recovered from Pleasure World. And I'm actually going to have you read the condition description because it will become hugely important later on. I loaded it up on your tablet. Sure. It says all the doors were locked and the driver's seat appeared to be normal for a person's height of five foot six inches.

9:15There were no signs of a struggle. Now, Lisa was about 5 '6", so the seat position makes sense. But they at least go to the car. They dust for prints in a few key places. They're able to lift three from the rearview mirror and one from the top window frame of the driver's side door. They also collect five items as evidence. Now, each item is redacted in the file, but I can see a detective's note about one item that he calls abnormal and says he is, quote, concerned with. Now, like I said, the manager of Pleasure World told police that the car had been sitting there for about 10 days by the time they call or it gets taken away.

9:58If that estimate is correct, that puts the car arriving at Pleasure World the same day that Lisa went missing. And is this somewhere she was known to go? No, at least not according to our sources or anyone we talk to. To me, though, like her car ending up all the way up here on the same day that she goes missing feels like a huge clue in my eyes. But 1991 detectives seem to disagree because shortly after the car is processed and they collect their few items of evidence, they just release it back to Allen. which is a move that Lisa's family members feel very weird about. And I don't really understand it either because based on what we've come to learn, Alan, as much as any intimate partner, should have been someone to look at pretty critically.

10:48And the first thing that doesn't look great for him is something Gilbert PD glosses over or maybe they redact in early reports, but it gets mentioned later in press releases under medical conditions for Lisa. It turns out Lisa was pregnant when she went missing. Now, we have no way to confirm this today without her medical file. But multiple family members believed this to be true. And remember how Lisa stopped by her parents' house the day before she disappeared? Well, according to what Lisa's mom, Barbara, told the media, that is when Lisa relayed that she was pregnant. And Barbara said that she seemed nervous to tell Alan because he didn't want any more children.

11:30But Barbara told Lisa, like, you have to tell him. Now, did that happen? Did it happen that day? Lisa's not here to tell us. But our reporter, Nicole, spoke to Alan. And this is actually the first time he has ever commented publicly on Lisa's case. And when Nicole asked him if he knew Lisa was pregnant, he sounded shocked. Said that this was the first time that he had ever heard that. How is that possible? I mean, like you said, it even came out in like media reports. Also, was he not talking to her family after she disappeared? So Alan said that he hasn't followed media coverage of this case.

12:10So by the time that came out, he didn't pick up on it. And as for Lisa's family, he was never super close with them. He said nobody ever told him. And basically he's like, this was a bombshell that we were dropping on him now in 2026. So perhaps Alan knew nothing about the pregnancy, which would take away a potential motive because nobody else seemed to have anything bad to say about their marriage. They thought that they were happy or at least it looked that way from the outside. But the other thing that raised my eyebrows is what he told detectives in the days after Lisa was reported missing.

12:46This is before her car has ever found her anything like that. But when detectives ask him about any type of credit cards that Lisa may be able to use, like I assume they're looking for ways to track her down, seeing if she's like has access to money. Alan tells them that he had cut up all of her credit cards. When did he do that? So the file doesn't say exactly. OK, then why did he do that? Well, so at the time, detectives don't seem to ask, which is a huge mistake because now when Nicole did ask, he said that he didn't remember even saying anything about cutting up her credit card. So he can't even fill in any of the blanks for us.

13:26There are no answers that we're looking for. I mean, why would he even have her cards to begin with? Wait, what do you mean? Like, did she not keep her cards in her purse? Like, wouldn't all that stuff, it should have been with her when she went missing. So that, I don't know. Like there's no mention of a purse or a bag or a wallet anywhere in the files, at least the parts that we can read. Though Alan said she did typically take a purse to work with her. So it either should have been in the car and is redacted or it would be wherever she is. Now, maybe it was in the car and that's one of the things that they collected.

13:59If they did and they turned that back over to Alan, that would make sense. But he says that he never got anything back. Now, one thought I had was that if this happens, like he could have done it out of anger. Like if he believed that she just took off on him, leaving Alan with a two year old to take care of, like maybe he wanted to make sure that the cards wouldn't get used. But she clearly doesn't have like the physical cards with her if he's cutting them up. I know. I know. And I ended up kind of like ending that line of thinking pretty quickly when I learned that almost from the beginning, Alan was telling police that he, too, thought there was no way that she took off.

14:33Like even in the early days of the investigation, Alan was telling detectives that he felt like Lisa had been abducted. But he didn't think she was dead because no body had been found. And he adds that nothing is missing, like money or otherwise. Like from the apartment. Well, he doesn't like specify that. I mean, they do specifically seem to be talking about like whether any money was missing from their bank accounts. And Alan says no money is missing. But from the looks of it, police. Here's the thing. Like, they didn't do anything to verify, from what I can see, that claim. So just like blind faith in her husband.

15:11Then, but that is not long lived. So about a month after releasing the car to Allen, police have a change of heart. They want to search it again. This is in January now. This is 1992. And why then? Honestly, I don't know. They sort of seem to reach out to Allen out of the blue, asking him to bring the car back in. And this time because they want to search for trace evidence. Now, he agrees. And detectives ask Alan if he has made any repairs to the car, applied a cleaning product or vacuum since their last search. Done anything that would change the car anyway. And he says the only thing that he did was wash the exterior.

15:47So, like, I don't know, cross your fingers. Hope that's true. Detectives do a thorough sweep. They vacuum compartments and floor mats. They collect all this debris. And everything gets placed into an evidence locker. They didn't test it? I don't think so, but I'm going to come back to this. I'm going to get more into this later. Okay. While we're on the topic of searches that don't really make sense to me, I want to talk about the search of Alan and Lisa's apartment. And if you think I'm jumping back in time here, I am not. The apartment isn't searched until September of 1992. This is nearly a full year after Lisa went missing.

16:27I have no idea why they waited so long. The file says that this is at the point in which, like, Alan, quote, allowed us to look through the apartment. I mean, surely they could have gotten a warrant if they wanted to, right? I would think so. But I also don't see any evidence of them asking Alan earlier and him declining. So, like, I don't know what is going on here. But a year later, when they finally searched, they say they don't find any physical evidence of foul play or anything to link to Lisa's disappearance or where she might be. And if you're wondering about trace evidence there, well, then you'd be a step ahead again because detectives don't get to that for almost another year.

17:09I mean, did we not learn our lesson with the car? It's so odd. There's like essentially a dead stretch for like 11 months where the case just sits. And when detectives do re-engage with Alan, it doesn't even seem super intentional. Like per the file, Alan had reported receiving some threatening phone calls, which is how he gets like wrapped back up with detectives. And there's not much more context. Alan told us that the calls he was getting actually were probably had to do with his work rather than Lisa. Probably? Like he doesn't remember threatening phone calls? I guess not. But to be fair, like by this point, he had switched jobs.

17:46So he was then a detention officer at the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office. And I guess it wasn't unheard of for inmates like relatives to contact him outside of work. And he actually bought a gun around this time because of it. But regardless of the reason, it's like this whole call scenario and him reaching out to them like somehow reminds detectives that they have this guy. Your wife's missing. Oh, we have this other thing going on. We should probably look into. So they end up asking Alan if they can search his apartment again. This time around, they want to do some testing, like spray with luminol, and he agrees.

18:20I'm sorry, if they didn't test with luminol the first time they were there, what was it that told them for certain that there was no foul play? Like, you can still have foul play and not have luminol light up even. Totally. I'm just saying, like, that feels like pretty basic, like, steam processing 101. Like, the first time they searched, they just go in and be like, well, doesn't look like anything's knocked over. A year later? Exactly. And they're like, oh, it's fine. Nothing happened here. I don't know. I just know that they're eager to try it now. And Alan seems like he's going to let them.

18:49And he also agrees to take a polygraph. And the polygraph happens first. And this is the first time in the file that we actually get a deeper look into Lisa and Alan's relationship. So they met in 1988 when Alan moved from Bolivia to Arizona and started working at the same warehouse that Lisa worked at at the time. They were like shipping and packaging stuff. So they began a relationship shortly after. They moved in together and then they married February of 1990. So they were only married for like a little over a year and a half. And Alan says that as far as he's concerned, their relationship was a good one.

19:28And then he walks detectives through the day that Lisa disappeared. He said that at 6.30 a.m. he dropped Kyle off at his grandmother's house and then he went to work at the courthouse where he arrived at like 6.45. and that would have been confirmed by other security guards he was working with. He says he took a 30-minute lunch break, got off work at like 3 p.m., and then he went to the gym to work out for a couple of hours, which he says can also be verified because you have to sign in at the gym. Then he went home, realized Lisa was gone, got that call from the babysitter saying that Kyle hadn't been picked up in the morning and that he'd been there all day.

20:04And what time did she normally pick up Kyle? So normally she would pick him up at 8 a.m. Oh, so that's like a really small window they're working with then. Exactly. She drops off the coworker at 7.15. And by 8 o 'clock, we assume something has happened that is keeping her from getting her son. And 45, I mean, this is just 45 minutes later. Right. And I assume they don't have like an exact time for when the car first appeared at Pleasure World. No. We just know that it was there around that day. No, but like I said, it is a hike from where she drops off the coworker. And I actually mapped it. And today, it's like 24 minutes.

20:37if there is no traffic. So if she drops off her coworker at 7.15 and she has to pick her son up at 8, there's no way she could have made it back down if everything we know is accurate. Not, at least, if she was the driver that dropped it off there. But we have no idea who the driver was because the manager who reported the car said that she never saw anyone arrive in, exit, or even approach the car in the time that it was sitting there. It was like 10 days or whatever. And out of curiosity, did they test Alan's prints against the unknowns in her car? They did, and not his. And in the very small window of time that we have for something to happen to Lisa, so 7.15 to 8 a.m., Alan is accounted for, or at least he should be.

21:24All of this info about his timeline and his whereabouts comes from a 1993 interview. I told you this is like a while after. There aren't any notes like after about police checking with his work or checking with the gym to verify any of this. They might have done all of that back in 91 or 92, but that's not like in the file either. Or if it is, it's redacted. What is not redacted is how Alan fares on his polygraph. To the question, did you cause the death of your wife, Lisa, in the polygrapher's opinion, Alan truthfully replies, no. But contrary to what Alan told detectives back in 91, he now tells them that he believes Lisa is no longer living, that something happened to her and that some sort of foul play occurred.

22:17And he also says that he's willing to cooperate with the investigation, which is interesting because later that very same day, Alan calls the PD back up and says that he has now changed his mind about letting them do additional testing in his apartment. Why the change of heart? Well, he told us that when detectives reached out to him again in 93, he had already lost a lot of faith in the investigation. He said that when Lisa initially went missing, he knew without a doubt that there must have been foul play because if Lisa left on her own, you can bet your bottom dollar she would have taken Kyle with her.

22:52So he went downtown every weekend to like hand out leaflets. He even went to Pleasure World after they found her car there to like ask around about her. But nobody ever seemed to care, including, he says, the police. So in his eyes, there was just a total lack of effort from law enforcement. And so then when they go back to him in 93, Alan feels like they're just like grasping at straws, basically. But listen, initially he said he didn't care because he's like, listen, I had nothing to hide. That's why he agreed to the polygraph and the apartment search. But he says during the polygraph, the guy started accusing him of knowing more than he was letting on.

23:31And that's when Alan decided, like, no, he'd had enough. He got up and left. He actually said he didn't remember calling off the apartment search. Like now he doesn't remember that. But if he did, it was probably because he was fed up. And per the file, Alan ending the search was kind of the end of the investigation. The case was marked as inactive due to no further leads or evidence being available at the time. And it also marks the last time investigators ever speak to Allen. I don't know if they had any intention of going back to him after 1993, but I do know that it wouldn't have been easy.

24:10Because two years later, he up and moved to Chicago and then shortly after that moved to Bolivia, where his mom is from. There he remarried, had a daughter, and started running a gym. What about Kyle? Alan left Kyle, who would have been around six, behind with his grandparents. And even though Alan's move, like, came as a surprise, Kyle's life honestly didn't change that much once the move happened. Because before Alan left, Kyle had already been living with his grandparents. He had moved into their house shortly after Lisa disappeared, which meant that he really only saw Alan on weekends. Still, Kyle said that Alan just sort of acted like a normal dad.

24:51Over the years, their visits became less frequent and then Alan moved. That's when Kyle's grandparents officially adopted him. And the two of them, plus some of Lisa's siblings, like many of whom moved back home to pitch in with Kyle, made sure that he never felt anything but loved. So Kyle lived a full childhood. He told us Alan sent him$100 on his seventh birthday, but then after that, he never heard from him again. And then just a few years later, he learned the likely reason why. And for the second time, the foundation of his life crumbled under him.

25:37Let's face it. If student loans are slowing down your financial goals, it might be time for a smarter strategy. That's where today's sponsor SoFi comes in. SoFi is helping you tackle student debt by refinancing your loans with flexible monthly payments that fit your budget. We're talking about the potential to lower your interest rate, reduce your monthly payment, or even pay off your loan sooner depending on the term you choose. You can also consolidate your student loans into one simple monthly payment, so you could save more each month and work towards achieving your long-term financial ambitions.

26:06SoFi offers competitive, fixed and variable rates and no origination fees, prepayment fees, or late fees required. It takes just two minutes to check your rate with SoFi, and they have already helped over 500 ,000 members refinance more than$50 billion in student loans. Visit SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie to see how much you can save. That's SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie and start making smarter money moves with SoFi. SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank and a member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891. This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. What is taking up your mental real estate these days?

26:45I catch myself pre-playing and replaying conversations in my head. Like I can't tell you the amount of brain time I have spent trying to write a script for a conversation that never goes the way I think it will, like endless hours. It has taken a total brain rewire to understand what I can and can't control and what should or shouldn't take up my brain space. There is a lot that we need to be present for, specifically around the holidays, and getting help differentiating between the things that deserve our time and don't is a game changer. And talking with a professional can make all the difference.

27:18BetterHelp matches you with experienced therapists, each with at least three years and 1 ,000 hours of practical experience. A brief questionnaire helps pair you with the right fit. And if it ever doesn't feel right, changing therapists is simple and hassle-free. Prioritizing your own peace and mental well-being is one of the best gifts you can give yourself right now. BetterHelp is in network with over 125 health plans with co-pays as low as$15 for eligible members. If you don't have eligible insurance or live outside the U.S., you can still get 20 % off your first month. Sign up and get 20 % off at BetterHelp.com slash Crime Junkie.

27:55That's BetterHelp.com slash Crime Junkie.

28:04Kyle Collins' life had only just begun when it was turned upside down by the disappearance of his mom in 1991. 11 years later, it was upended for a second time when his grandmother told him that Alan, the man he called dad and lived with for the first two years of his life, was not actually his biological father. His bio dad is a man named Gordon, who was Lisa's high school sweetheart. They met when they were around 16 and quickly grew inseparable. Gordon was drawn not only to Lisa by her big heart, but also her tight-knit family. It was something that he had always sought out being raised in a foster home.

28:46But things got complicated his senior year of high school when Gordon got Lisa pregnant. So Gordon always knew that Kyle was his. Well, no. So this was two years before Kyle. Lisa was actually pregnant with a baby girl, but ended up losing the baby during birth. And that's when Lisa's family sort of started to nudge Lisa toward seeing other people. Other people who might have been able to provide a little more stability. Her and Gordon still lived together for a few months after Gordon graduated, but it was hard to ignore the way that Lisa's family felt about him. So it was during this time that Lisa actually met Alan.

29:24Alan, who was older and had a stable job. After Lisa got pregnant with Kyle, Alan and Lisa move in together. Wait, Alan, did he know that Kyle wasn't his son? Well, so the timeline has it so that Kyle was likely conceived after Lisa met Alan, but before she married him. But we spoke with both Alan and Gordon, and both men said that during Lisa's pregnancy, they didn't know whether or not they were the father, both of them. Then when Kyle was born, looking everything like Gordon and nothing like Alan, Gordon knew without a doubt that Kyle was his. And Alan said that he knew too, but he loved Lisa, so he chose to overlook it.

30:08He said it was something that they just didn't really talk about. Now, Alan and Gordon never met, but Gordon saw Kyle a few times and says that he and Lisa were still best friends and never stopped loving each other. But they just sort of had to keep it all on the down low. Like actively having an affair when she was missing kind of down low? No, no, no. So Gordon told us that he hadn't seen Lisa in like six months when he found out that she had gone missing from her sister. And for some reason I cannot explain, he was never interviewed by Gilbert Police. I mean, his name never even comes up in the file.

30:45And he told us himself that he knows he should be a suspect, just like given their complicated history and all. But to this day, he has never been asked a single question about her disappearance, not just by law enforcement, by the way. When our reporter called him, he said that she was the first person to ask him anything about Lisa since her sister called him 35 years ago. What? His only thought is that like Gilbert P.D. like must know more than they're letting on. Like that's what he's been telling himself. That's a lot of faith in Gilbert P.D. I know. And that's like best case scenario. I know.

31:20Well, I think Gordon, here's the thing. I think he might partially be right based on what Kyle eventually comes to learn. So when teenage Kyle discovers that Alan is not his dad, it really messes him up. Like it didn't necessarily cause him to question Alan's involvement in his mom's case, though, or anything like that. Like to his family's credit, like even though they had their suspicions of Alan, they didn't share those with Kyle. He was raised to believe that it was some sort of random kidnapping. That's about all his family would say. Kyle said he felt like they were trying to protect him by shielding him from the case and not talking about it.

31:59So Kyle had to process everything on his own. And he said that at times it felt like he was in the Truman Show, like everyone around him knew something that he didn't. He was already in therapy, like he had been since Lisa's disappearance, actually. But that isn't really what gets him through. More than anything, what's been helping Kyle cope is music. So it's right around this time that Kyle's cousin, Shay, a rapper and one of the family members that Lisa was closest to, brings Kyle to his apartment for a studio session. And Kyle watches as he records and produces and like mixes three songs completely entranced.

32:41And that very day, he asked Shay to take him to a Walgreens so he could get a pen and a pad and start writing his own songs. And with Shay's help, he starts writing that very night. And Kyle still looks back on this as one of the most significant moments of his life. because from that point on, he has an outlet for his emotions. And Lisa is a front-running theme for Kyle in his music. And getting those songs out is cathartic for him, like all throughout high school, during which time he starts teaching himself how to produce and to mix with programs that he downloaded on his computer. Now at this time, Kyle is by all means planning to go to college.

33:21Not that he is desperate to, more that his grandparents really want him to. But then towards the end of his senior year, Kyle's music starts getting a lot of traction, like enough to make his family think that he might actually be able to like do this for a living. So Kyle decides to chase his dreams. And over the next few years, he starts performing and touring as the lead singer of a rock band. And he has his daughter, Delilah, with his girlfriend, all while working as a customer service rep at Dish Network. He's around 23 years old when he decides to quit his job, leave the band, and take a gamble on his solo career.

33:58So he and his girlfriend, they take a break. Kyle moves out. But the thing is, he knows that his grandparents wouldn't want him moving back in with them. So this brings us back to where we started the story. Kyle's period of homelessness. When he gets the inspiration for what would become the song Red Coat. And when he sits down to write the song, he doesn't have much raw material to work with. I mean, he was so young when his mom disappeared. There are a few things about her that he remembers like vividly, he says. Her voice and the way she used to hold a cigarette. Her laugh. He says his daughter has the exact same one.

34:38And there are things that his family has told him. That Lisa was filled with like total and complete joy. That she loved music. She loved going to the movies and above all, that she was absolutely devoted to him. But there is so much that he doesn't know about her life and her friends and her relationships, her passions. And so in this song, Kyle imagines finding his mom and exploring what could have been. Kyle sits on Red Coat for two years after writing it. Two of the most tumultuous years of his life, by the way, during which he, number one, suffers a severe nervous breakdown and anxiety crisis stemming from accumulated emotional stress and trauma.

35:28and two, completely antithetically, releases his first and second albums, has a single climb all the way to number one on the Arizona music charts, and he gets named as one of 10 rappers to blow up in 2015 by Mountain Dew. Mountain Dew like the soda. I have no idea why Mountain Dew is a player in this game, but here we are. Apparently they named some other big people too. I'll always welcome Mountain Dew into the conversation. Welcome Mountain Dew. Anyways, this success is what paves the way for Kyle's third album, which is dedicated to his mom and includes Red Coat. And the decision to finally release this song topples the first domino in a chain that has not stopped barreling forward since.

36:15By this point, Lisa's case has been inactivated and reactivated like a handful of times. But the release of Red Coat brings it back to life in a way that Kyle never expected. Because with his second verse, he uncovered a secret that he didn't know his family had been keeping from him. Flashbacks become nightmares. I see all the blood that you're covered in. I won't love again. Love again. I won't love again. I want love again. It ain't fair for a young boy to just lose the woman that mothered him. When Lisa's older sister, this is Kyle's aunt, Treva, when she heard this, she had one question for Kyle.

36:58Are you starting to remember things?

37:05Let's face it, if student loans are slowing down your financial goals, it might be time for a smarter strategy. That's where today's sponsor, SoFi, comes in. SoFi is helping you tackle student debt by refinancing your loans with flexible monthly payments that fit your budget. We're talking about the potential to lower your interest rate, reduce your monthly payment, or even pay off your loan sooner depending on the term you choose. You can also consolidate your student loans into one simple monthly payment so you could save more each month and work towards achieving your long-term financial ambitions.

37:34SoFi offers competitive, fixed, and variable rates and no origination fees, prepayment fees, or late fees required. It takes just two minutes to check your rate with SoFi, and they have already helped over 500 ,000 members refinance more than$50 billion in student loans. Visit SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie to see how much you can save. That's SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie and start making smarter money moves with SoFi. SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank and a member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891.

38:08Growing up, everyone called my dad Bargain Dave because that man loves a deal. And he passed it on to me. I've been hunting my whole life. I pride myself on finding high quality at low prices. So I was jazzed when I found the app Whatnot. Whatnot is the ultimate live shopping destination where you connect directly with amazing sellers in real time. I've been getting really unique household items as I redecorate, like vintage cookie jars and vases. stuff I literally can't find anywhere else. But there is a whole other side to the app too. Luxury handbags, rare collectibles, beauty products. You can live shop, which allows you to ask questions directly to the seller, request to see the items up close or from every angle, or sometimes if you're busy, like I am, and you know you want something, you can pre-bid before the store goes live.

38:53So if you love a deal or a unique find, you have to try this out. Get up to$20 off your first eligible purchase. Search Whatnot, W-H-A-T-N-O-T, in the App Store and take a shopping trip live. Terms apply.

39:11Kyle was dumbfounded after his aunt heard the song Red Coat and asked him if he was starting to remember things. And he's like, wait, what do you mean? And Treva says it was this one line that stuck out to her. The one where he says, flashbacks become nightmares. I see all the blood that you're covered in. And she said to Kyle, when you were younger, you told us that you saw your mom in a bloody mess. What? Treva said, she's like, I could never forget that because you used those words specifically, a bloody mess, and you were so young. Apparently, this actually was the catalyst that pushed Kyle's family to get him into therapy.

39:53Wait, did they think he actually saw that or were they just like worried about how he was processing everything? They have always believed his words. Because remember how I told you the condition of the car would be super important? Yeah. Well, police, their assertion is that the car showed no signs of a struggle, right? Like it was whatever. But that assertion is highly debated among Lisa's side of the family. Because according to Kyle's cousin, Shea, after Gilbert PD released the car to Alan, Lisa's family pushed Alan to give it to them. By that point, we're like a month or two in. Some of Lisa's family members were starting to get very suspicious of Alan, thinking that he knew more than he was letting on.

40:36So when Alan dropped the car off, Shay put his detective hat on and immediately grabbed a pencil and a piece of paper to take notes on every little detail as he started inspecting the car. Now, we can't corroborate this because Shay couldn't find his notes from back then. But he still has a vivid memory of what he says he saw. And what he saw, according to him, were signs of a struggle. I mean, in his own words, he said, there is no way you could have overlooked it. So according to him, the emergency brake was like completely pulled back and bent. The lock on the passenger side door was broken off.

41:16The passenger side seat was pulled all the way back. And there was a shoe print on the roof, which he said looked like it was left by a pointed toe, like flat shoe. Lisa used to wear that. And he said it looked like somebody had like leaned back and kicked up. Plus, there was a dark stain, he says, in the back seat. And he said it looked like blood that somebody had tried to clean up. Did they ask Alan about the damage? Yeah. Allegedly, Allen told them that the stain was from a soda that Kyle had spilt. Okay. And the other stuff, like the footprint on the top? According to Shea, Allen didn't address anything else.

41:58And I want to mention one more thing. So online, I see people talking about a broken red fingernail being found in her car, too. But we couldn't find a source for that in the files we have or in any reputable reporting. So, like, if someone out there on the message boards, like, knows more than we do, like, absolutely hit us up. We'll look into it. But, like, right now I'm just, like, discarding that as rumor. Now, when we asked Alan about the car, he said that he didn't remember even bringing it back to Lisa's parents' house, let alone there being anything off about it. And he didn't say there wasn't.

42:33He just, like, can't remember. So wait, what exactly is the implication here that police lied about there being no damage? Why would that happen? This is the part that I can't wrap my head around. I have no problem calling out shoddy police work. But, like, I just can't imagine making an error like this. Like, the signs of a struggle seem so obvious in Shay's account that I feel like even if you're not looking for trace evidence right away, you spot the broken lock. The footprint. Yeah, right. Like, if you're going to take the time to collect prints, surely you saw that. You're going to look around.

43:12I mean, you'd hope so, at least. But it's possible that maybe both things can be true because Shea reasons through it like this. Perhaps the car was in good condition when police processed it. But then something happened after the car got released to Alan that resulted in the damage. Like with Lisa? That is Shea's suggestion. But he admits that he doesn't know what that would be. And of course, we don't either. So is this what prompted police to ask for the car back then? So not that I can see, and I'm not saying it wasn't. Shea said that he reported all of the stuff that he saw to investigators.

43:54So that is a possibility. But there isn't even a mention of Shea reporting this in the files or any talk of how he describes the car. So either they completely omitted what he saw from the narrative or the second search had nothing to do with this. I mean, it's even possible that they got the car back like the family after the second search. Or there's some other option that might answer all of our questions, but we'll just never know. Because guess what? There is a little dark cloud that has been looming over this case. Something I've been hinting at that has affected the way I've been able to tell this story up until now.

44:40Somewhere along the way, Lisa's case file was destroyed. Not lost, not damaged in some natural disaster. Destroyed. What? Most of the evidence in her case was two. How did this happen? Who did it? Why? Like, why? Nobody knows. This wasn't even discovered until 2020, by the way. But they, I guess, narrowed it down to like this had to have happened sometime before 2005. So basically everything like 2005 and after should be intact. Everything before we just have scraps to work with. This is why so much about the early days of the investigation are unclear. Did they check Allen's alibi? Don't know.

45:30Which of Lisa's co-workers did they talk to? Don't know. Did they pull bank records? Still don't know. Those little intricacies. The entire first decade of the investigation is gone forever, which is really upsetting to me. It should be extremely upsetting to the people of Gilbert. When it comes to the destruction, there is just one line in the file. It says the original case file in this case was destroyed on an unknown date, along with the majority of the original evidence collected in 1991. Thanks. I mean, there has to be some record of this. Most most departments have like policies and procedures around like how long you keep something, when it gets destroyed, how it can even be destroyed.

46:15You are correct. And destroying her file and the evidence definitely went against policy and procedure. Gilbert P.D. told us hers is the only missing persons case they have where this has happened. Now, we know that other cases have suffered from this, though, because you might recall from one of our many recent episodes. This is not our first time in Gilbert. We're getting used to Gilbert P.D. Earlier this year, they were being investigated by the state attorney general's office about a claim that they may have illegally destroyed or withheld police records. And that whole investigation, that started with a sexual assault case that we haven't even covered.

46:54So I don't know if the investigation was isolated to that incident or when they did their investigation, if they looked at all of their records. But you might also recall that in July of 2026, the AG's office came out with a statement saying that their review found the files in question were deleted as a result of administrative error. So no criminal charges were filed. This isn't just an administrative error to me. These are people's lives. Like what portal time warp did we go through or that we're living in a world with like no accountability for anything? Like even if it was an error, because humans do mess up.

47:34I know that. But there has to be some kind of like repercussions. I mean, at a minimum, give the family the whole unredacted case file. It is like bare minimum. Bare minimum. Like it is like everything's been so wonked up to high heaven already. What like what's that going to do? Everyone's like argument is like, oh, we have to protect the investigation for prosecution. Really? There's no file to base an investigation on anymore. And figure out who got rid of the file. Fire them. Punish them in some way. And then look into why. I was going to say, like, put safeguards around it so like it never happens again.

48:07That's what I'm saying, because this is a mistake that should be made once and only once. If it has to be made at all. But clearly this department has a pattern of it. So why aren't we getting to the root cause? Okay, I hear you. We could rant about this for ages, but let's like... Back in. Really back in. The car. The car. Where is it now? Che told us that Alan ended up selling it. Alan told us that he gave it to Lisa's family. But I thought he didn't remember giving it to Lisa's family. His accounts are conflicting. And listen, I don't mean to imply that he's lying. Something might be getting lost in translation, but he seemed not to remember much about the whole car situation.

48:52So I just truly don't know. Now, I would love to track this down now, but without the license plate or the VIN number, like both of those are redacted in the file, I don't have a way to. Though again, good time for a call out if anyone out there remembers buying a red 1989 Pontiac Le Mans from someone with the last name Collins or Jameson, my email inbox is open, tips at audiochuck.com. If somehow that car still exists, like you could at least see if it could be tested for blood evidence or anything like that. And listen, maybe police already went down that path because they did actually go back later looking for blood evidence in Alan and Lisa's apartment.

49:39Even though Alan denied their request to search back in 93, by 2004, he wasn't living in the apartment anymore. So they got the green light to go in. But by then, the carpet had already been replaced twice. Yeah, I was going to say, that's such a long period of time. I know. And even the padding underneath the carpet had been replaced once. But I like, listen, I'll give those new investigators flowers where flowers are due. Like they still pulled up the carpet and the pad. They sprayed the bare concrete underneath it with luminol. There was no blood evidence identified, which could mean that there was never anything in that apartment to find.

50:18Yeah, or that it was long gone before anyone thought to look for it. Yeah, that too. Did Kyle's family tell police like what he said when he was little, like back when it happened? I think so, because there is this summary note from one detective that makes note that Lisa's son, quote, is currently seeing a psychologist and has possibly been making. And then there's this big redaction. OK, but people knew about this. Yeah. And if Kyle did see a bloody mess, to me, that really limits who could have been involved. So you can understand more why Lisa's family, who were with Kyle, just became more suspicious of Alan.

51:05But they never brought it up with Kyle again. They wanted him to heal. They didn't want to implant memories if he'd forgotten. So it wasn't until his song finally came out that he heard the full story from his family. But just as he was becoming suspicious of the man that he once called his father, Kyle also got a weird DM. Someone else heard his song and had something to say about Alan. So one day, out of the blue, Kyle gets this message from someone that he doesn't think he had ever even heard of before. The guy's name is Kirby Becker. And at first, Kirby writes that he heard the song, thought it was dope, and then he reveals that he's related to Alan.

51:52Alan is Kirby's uncle. Kirby and Kyle end up getting on the phone. And according to Kyle, on the call, Kirby says that Alan really loved Lisa and doesn't know what happened, had nothing to do with it, and only left town because he felt like he was being blamed for it. And for what it's worth, like we verified Kirby's identity and Alan told us the same exact thing. He said that he left Arizona because Lisa's disappearance haunted him and he felt blamed both by law enforcement and Lisa's family. He wanted to start fresh. So he gave over custody of Kyle to Lisa's parents and moved. Then in 1997, he says that he got a letter from Lisa's mom.

52:37This is when he's living in Bolivia, saying something to the effect of like, just tell us where you buried her so we can have closure. And that is when he says he decided it was time to completely cut off contact with the Collins family. So Kirby is explaining some of this to Kyle and says, listen, I 100 percent stand by my uncle. He thinks his uncle has been unjustly blamed. And Kyle also remembers him saying that Alan like wishes he could reach out to him, but like he doesn't think it would be a good idea. And Kirby said a lot of the same things when our reporter Nicole talked to him too. But we also got a few more details that actually just raised more questions for me.

53:17First, Kirby said that in the wake of Lisa's disappearance, he remembers his dad and Alan leaving town to do a job for like two weeks. Didn't Alan work at the courthouse? Yeah, when Lisa went missing, he did. So I don't think he was doing much traveling for that job. and Alan actually had no memory of what Kirby could be talking about. He ran through a list of jobs that he had with us, said that he did construction with Kirby's dad at one point back in the day. Then he had the courthouse gig. Then he worked for the sheriff's office. So like I don't see anything, at least with the ones he had, like at the time Lisa goes missing and then after.

53:55Like nothing with travel. Right. Now police would have been able to check and see if he was gone from work for two weeks, like if he took time off to do a project. I don't know if they did. This trip might have actually never even happened, but that's going to be hard to prove one way or another now all these years later. The second thing that Kirby said to us is that Alan once told him that he and Lisa got into an argument before she left for her last shift, which is the first we were ever hearing of that. So naturally, we asked Alan and he said he doesn't remember any sort of argument. Remember, he doesn't remember a lot now.

54:37He said that he and Lisa fought like any regular couple, but that he doesn't remember fighting before her disappearance. In fact, with their alternating shifts, he's like, listen, we barely even saw each other. And I'm sure that's true. But every couple I know, irrespective of schedules, seems to find time to argue about something. And as we have come to learn, there was potentially a lot going on in Lisa's life before her disappearance that could have caused an argument. But we only learned that because of someone else who slid into Kyle's DMs post his song release.

55:22Let's face it. If student loans are slowing down your financial goals, it might be time for a smarter strategy. That's where today's sponsor SoFi comes in. SoFi is helping you tackle student debt by refinancing your loans with flexible monthly payments that fit your budget. We're talking about the potential to lower your interest rate, reduce your monthly payment, or even pay off your loan sooner depending on the term you choose. You can also consolidate your student loans into one simple monthly payment so you could save more each month and work towards achieving your long-term financial ambitions.

55:51SoFi offers competitive, fixed and variable rates and no origination fees, prepayment fees, or late fees required. It takes just two minutes to check your rate with SoFi, and they have already helped over 500 ,000 members refinance more than$50 billion in student loans. Visit SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie to see how much you can save. That's SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie and start making smarter money moves with SoFi. SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank and a member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891.

56:27After Kyle's call with Kirby, he went into a really weird headspace. I mean, he hadn't heard from Alan since his seventh birthday. He's coming to learn all these things about what his family believes and his own trauma. So he was fully unprepared for the next DM he got from Gilbert PD. Why doesn't Gilbert PD ever slide into our DMs? One can only wish. But Gilbert PD is reaching out to him because they want to meet in person. Now, mind you, he had never had any communication with the agency in his entire life. But he flies from California, where he was temporarily living with a new girlfriend. She goes with him.

57:12And mostly the investigator was asking him whether he recognizes certain names that apparently came up in the file. He doesn't recognize any of them. And they're actually names like he'd never heard before. The only name that anyone's been talking about, like that he knows of, is Alan. Right. But he doesn't know what these names mean because the detective isn't like giving a name and then filling in the gaps there. Just throwing out names and like getting a check on them. Yeah. And Kyle told us that he got the sense that maybe the detective was being intentionally vague because Kyle's girlfriend was in the room.

57:47But he also got the sense that this meeting was actually about something else. He said that it felt like the detective was kind of trying to gauge his feelings toward how the investigation had been handled more than actually like sharing any new information. Now, Kyle didn't really know what they were getting at because at that point he knew nothing about the investigative steps that had or had not been taken. He had no clue that somebody had basically thrown away his mom's file and the evidence. So he didn't know yet how royally upset he deserved to be, which is why that meeting ended on fairly good terms.

58:25And I'm sure Gilbert Petey was like breathing a sigh of relief, knowing that this rising hip hop star wasn't going to start blasting them and putting their missteps on display. Now, at this point, Kyle didn't have it in him to dig for the truth and to fight because he at that point was fighting for his own life. because not only was Kyle a father at that point having to think about his kid, he said after this he was thrown into what he calls a mental health episode. And he spends the next five years working on himself, creating music and raising his little girl. Before he knew it, he looked up and there was the anniversary of his mother's disappearance.

59:07And a big one, 30 years. By this point, his grandpa hadn't made it. His grandma died that very year, both without answers, in the same house that they had lived in their whole adult lives. They refused to move because if Lisa somehow, someway ever came back, they wanted her to know exactly where to find them. So I think at this point, Kyle may have felt a sense of responsibility. They're no longer there to be a voice for Lisa and to fight for her. And now that he was in a good place, maybe it was his job. So a series of events led Kyle to sit down with detectives again in 2022. This time, he goes alone.

59:53And this time, he's asking a lot more questions. And in doing so, he learns way more. Not just about the original investigation, but about the work that has happened since that meeting he had with them in 2016. So between all of our interviews and the files that we've obtained from Lisa's case, here is what we've learned. Lisa was allegedly having multiple affairs during the time that she was married to Alan. Some of these men were tracked down and spoken to. Some were even given polygraphs. And we know that one man failed a polygraph. I'm going to call this guy Steve. Steve was Lisa's boss at the electronics company and had allegedly been having an affair with her.

1:00:47Now, what he said in the early days of the investigation, what his story was, his alibi, I know none of that. It's either redacted or it's part of the records that were tossed. But what I do see in the files is that detectives apparently went back to Steve in 2016, like right around the time that Kyle sat down with them for that first time. And according to what they tell Kyle, at that point, Steve claimed to not know who Lisa was or recognized her name at all. And then when they show him a photo, his response was something like, maybe. Maybe what? I couldn't tell you. how often are you being given polygraphs about missing people?

1:01:28Like, how would you not remember her, even if you weren't having an affair with her? Right? Like, it's very odd to me, the polygraph of it all. But the affair, I mean, it could have been pretty casual. It seems like Lisa had some casual affairs, though maybe many of these weren't affairs in the way that, like, you might think because police dropped another bomb on Kyle completely out of left field. They tell him that they think Lisa may have been a sex worker and that she may have been trafficked. Based on what? I have no idea. This wasn't something that we had heard from anybody who knew Lisa.

1:02:10And we asked everyone that we spoke to. The only thing that even came close was when we went back and asked Gordon. And remember, that's Kyle's biological father. Remember, he and Lisa are still super close. And even he said that if Lisa had resorted to sex work, she definitely would have told him. But he had heard from someone that she maybe started to work at a dance club, which Alan told us like he wasn't if that's if that's what happened. He wasn't aware of that, though. he did say that Lisa was looking for another job. So all of that context in mind, if this is true, I wonder if this could explain some kind of connection to Pleasure World, where her car was found.

1:02:54Now, both Gordon and Alan told us that there was absolutely no reason that Lisa would ever be at a place like that. Alan always thought that the car must have been planted. But what if Lisa was the one who drove it there? I told you they advertise themselves as a bookstore, but old newspaper articles make it clear that it is way more than just books. There was this advertisement I found from 1992 that promotes an in-person event with a local co-ed adult video star. It says, full-length videos personalized with you and then the woman's name. Then there was another article from 1993 about a priest who was abusing minors.

1:03:37But within the article, it referenced a previous incident from 1986 involving this priest in a, quote, live show booth at Pleasure World. Now, those articles clearly have nothing to do with Lisa. There is no proof that Lisa went there on her own. If everyone's timelines hold up, Lisa is at the electronics company all night and drops off her co-worker in the morning. But this, again, is my call out to anyone who worked for the company she worked at, which we believe was Mote Electronics, Inc. If you worked there in 1991, I am desperate to speak with you. Again, my email is tips at audiochuck.com.

1:04:23so if she's at work I don't think she can make it to Pleasure World and back to pick up Kyle in that time so I don't think she goes there on her own but if she doesn't where could they intercept her? like that's what's been nagging at me like I assume her first stop after the co-workers is the babysitter but she doesn't make it there if everyone's stories are true Yes, she is in her car and she has to go somewhere and interact with someone else. But we have no idea where. But this brings me to something else new that was uncovered in later years. Police realized that the fingerprints that they had gotten from Lisa's car, those had never been entered into a database in all years since her disappearance.

1:05:17They weren't her prints. They weren't Allen's, remember. There is one other person that they collect prints from. The name is redacted in the files. Obviously, they didn't match the prints either because in 2016, they were still trying to identify these. This is a big clue and one that they actually still had. So they run the prints. Now, according to reports, they got four prints. Only three were viable. One of the three comes back to the tow truck employee. Now, the file doesn't say whether that print was one of the ones from the rearview mirror inside the car or if it was from the, like, outside door frame, like, by the window.

1:05:59Like, which if it's the one on the outside, that makes total sense. And I suspect that's the one we're talking about. If it's on the inside, we might need to have another discussion. But we do know that the other two prints are still unidentified to this day. So someone was in her car. My question is, does that person have a tie to Pleasure World? You know, this idea of trafficking, it does feel like it came out of nowhere, right? Like, oh, maybe sex work and maybe traffic. It feels like left field. But after Kyle hears the detective say this, something starts to come back to him. Something that happened back in 2018.

1:06:47Now, I need to give a little bit of context here, but trust me, you're going to want to bear with me. So one of Kyle's aunts, his aunt Tracy, is one of the people that we spoke with for this episode and somebody who stepped up to care for Kyle in a huge way after Lisa disappeared. Kyle said that Tracy and her husband Miles were like second parents to him. He also says that they were very successful. They traveled around the world living in many different countries throughout his life. In fact, it was Tracy and Miles who loaned Kyle$1 ,500 to buy his very first piece of recording equipment, essentially what allowed him to record his first album.

1:07:27Now, Kyle told Miles for years that he would pay him back, But he wasn't in a position to do that until he got his first advance from his label. That is when he put$1 ,500 in cash in an envelope and left it under Miles and Tracy's doormat. And he says they were unusually grateful. By then, their finances had declined significantly over the prior four or five years. So that money mattered more than Kyle expected. And about a week after that, he gives him the money a week later, Tracy started planning like this get together for Kyle's 28th birthday at his grandmother's house. But on the actual day, Kyle showed up and nothing was happening, like no party.

1:08:10His grandmother seemed upset. And when he asked what was going on, she said, listen, Tracy wants you to call her. So he calls Tracy. And that's when she told him probably the last thing he expected to hear that day. His uncle Miles had been arrested the night before for human trafficking.

1:08:53on the term you choose. You can also consolidate your student loans into one simple monthly payment, so you could save more each month and work towards achieving your long-term financial ambitions. SoFi offers competitive, fixed and variable rates and no origination fees, prepayment fees, or late fees required. It takes just two minutes to check your rate with SoFi, and they have already helped over 500 ,000 members refinance more than 50 billion in student loans. Visit SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie to see how much you can save. That's SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie and start making smarter money moves with SoFi.

1:09:26SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank and a member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891.

1:09:39When we spoke to Kyle, he didn't really know too much more about his uncle's charges, though he did become less close with Tracy and Miles after that, Something that Tracy attributed to him just getting older. But obviously, when Kyle told us this, we started digging right away, trying to find out as much as we could, especially given the possibility raised by detectives that Lisa might have been trafficked back in 91. So here's how it all went down with Miles, according to the court records. On August 27th, 2018, a woman posted a missed connections ad on Craigslist saying that she had spoken with a nice man at Starbucks about him teaching her child.

1:10:26On August 28th, Miles responded. He said that he wasn't the man from Starbucks, but he'd be willing to teach the children. So the woman told Miles that her daughter, who was about to turn 15, was curious about men and assured him it would be safe and discreet. Is he allowed to get Chris Hansen? Miles responded that her curiosity was normal. And both he and the woman explicitly confirmed that the other was not law enforcement. So the next day, the conversation moved to email where the woman spelled out that she wanted her daughter to learn about touching, about oral and sex. And Miles confirmed that he was fine with that and agreed to come over that day.

1:11:09And the woman asked for money saying that she needed help with her power bill. So he arrives at the address she gave, asked about cameras, TV shows and sting operations. His mind's where yours is at. And while there's no Chris Hansen on the scene, the tables did turn. A group of undercover officers revealed themselves and arrested Miles. They found a large folding knife, glasses, four condoms, keys, and a cell phone on him. Though, of course, he claimed he never intended to actually go through with anything. Which is what they always say. So he ended up getting booked on three counts. solicitation to commit child sex trafficking, money laundering, and resisting arrest.

1:11:56Money laundering? All I can guess is maybe that has to do with something with him paying her electric bill. Like if it was like an electronic. I don't know. That charge threw me too. But actually there's a lot about the charges I had questions about. And believe me, we tried to dig. But this case is like weirdly blocked off. So all I know is that Miles did end up pleading guilty to the one count of solicitation to commit child sex trafficking. And he was placed on supervised probation for a term of life. Oh, but no prison time. No prison time. He was designated as a non-dangerous, non-repeat offender.

1:12:39And even though the court paperwork put forward by the state originally calculated him as a level one sex offender required to register, they later advised during sentencing that the registration statute had been included in the plea paperwork in error and they actually didn't recommend that he register. So Miles wasn't required to register as a sex offender. Why would the state do that? Why, Britt? I have no idea. And what's more is the case didn't end with that sentencing. The docket shows ongoing litigation as recently as this year, 2026, like motions to modify the terms of his life probation.

1:13:25There are discovery disputes and other sealed motions. Now, we have asked Tracy and Miles directly to comment on the charges. They both declined to discuss anything and promptly ended the conversation. But before that happened, we did learn a lot about their relationship and happenings in the years before, during, and after Lisa's disappearance. So in the 1990s, Miles and Tracy met and got married in California. It was both of their second marriages. Then came a period of lots of moving around. 1989 is the last time either of them recalls living in Arizona before this stretch. From California, they moved to the Philippines as expats.

1:14:12Miles for his work in technology, Tracy doing volunteer work. They came back from the Philippines around 1993, spent about three years in Arizona, then relocated to Korea for another like three and a half years before returning to Arizona for good, where they kept their home the whole time. I'm sorry, what does Miles do for work that he's like traveling the world like this? You mentioned electronics. So interestingly, when they or anybody in the family describes his work, they just say he works in electronics. Which is the same as Lisa. Yeah. And at one point I was like, I know electronics is broad, but like does everyone in this family like work in electronics?

1:14:50I mean, I guess like if you know people, they get you jobs where they work and stuff. I don't know. I know that they weren't at the same company. Lisa was at a company, like I said, I think was Mote Electronics Inc. Miles was at Amcor, which is headquartered in Arizona, but it has factories in Korea and the Philippines, which is like why. Yeah, and they were living in the Philippines. And Korea. But like the Philippines specifically when Lisa disappeared. Well, that's what it sounded like when they were like telling us about like where they were. But when our reporter asked Tracy about Lisa's disappearance specifically, Tracy recalled being at her parents' house in Chandler when Alan called about Lisa being missing.

1:15:33Now, she didn't flag this as a contradiction, though. Okay, but what about Miles? Tracy said both her and Miles were in Arizona driving around together looking for Lisa. So they were both in town when Lisa disappeared? That is what she said. Okay, did Miles or his company work with Mote Electronics or was he connected to that Steve guy, like Lisa's boss that she allegedly was having an affair with? Kyle floated this idea to his family, but he says that no one has ever really considered that. And for our part, there was nothing that we could find to connect the two men or the companies. And Steve didn't respond to our request for comment and Miles declined to comment.

1:16:19Now, with all of that said, I want to be 100 % clear. Per the documents that we have, there is no noted connection between Miles' charges and Lisa's case. And as far as I can see, Miles' name never even comes up in the file. And interestingly, when our reporter Nicole spoke to Tracy, she said that she had never even been reached out to by Gilbert Petey. not even after miles's charges in 2018 no but i also mean like ever which is kind of mind-boggling considering they told kyle that they were exploring the possibility of sex trafficking like honestly who knows maybe this is the first time they're hearing of it if they're listening to this episode i hope they're listening to this episode and like listen and again the charges His 2018 thing is so far away from 1991.

1:17:13And for what it's worth, Shay, who was, remember, super close with Lisa and Kyle, told us that while what Miles did is sick, he doesn't believe that it has anything to do with Lisa's disappearance. But right now, on the heels of the 35th anniversary of her going missing, it is really hard to know what is important or what is a distraction because so much has been lost to time. No charges have ever been filed in connection with this case. Nobody is even listed in the files as a person of interest, Allen or otherwise. Per Gilbert PD, Lisa's case is inactive. The date printed on the last page of the police report is December 13th, 2021.

1:18:01And as far as I can tell, that is the last time any work was done. In fact, I know it was because after covering three of Gilbert's unsolved cases, this is the first time the Gilbert Police Department agreed to do an interview with us. An officer told us that Lisa's case is the Gilbert Police Department's longest standing missing persons case to date. And while it can still be reviewed periodically and they are keeping their minds open to all possibilities, there are currently no viable leads to investigate or to look into. Because someone destroyed everything? So the officer we spoke with confirmed that evidence was destroyed in this case, which he says he hasn't seen in any of the department's other cold cases.

1:18:49And apparently there are now practices in place to ensure something like that doesn't happen again. But even so, there is still apparently some evidence left over. He just would not tell us what that evidence is. I mean, my question is like stuff they can test. I mean, maybe they're holding out, but he said that there is no current testing being done. He also said that he couldn't offer an explanation as to why the searches of the car and the apartment might have been delayed because we asked him that, too. And what about the conflicting accounts of like the state of the car? He said that he just has to go with what like the accounts that are in the report that are in front of him.

1:19:31And he also wouldn't speak on any current working theories. But he said that Lisa's case is on the forefront of the department's mind and it has never been forgotten. I feel like all the leads haven't been exhausted, though. I mean, there's people that, like, we spoke to that they say that they never even got a call from Gilbert PD. And again, we wanted to clarify this because, like, Nicole clocked it immediately. So she, like, asked about those people. Like, you said there's no leads. What about these people? but the officer declined to speak about any person specifically. So when it comes to Lisa's family and friends, those that we spoke to haven't lost hope that answers will come.

1:20:12But to be honest, I'm not sure what all can be done to restore their faith in investigators. But I have faith in what our crime junkies can do. So I want to end this episode in a bit of a special way with Kyle's own words. If you know anything at all about the disappearance of my mom from Chandler, Arizona in 1991, please contact the Gilbert Police Department. You might have known her by her married name, Lisa Diane Jameson, or her maiden name, Lisa Collins. But no matter when you knew her or what you knew about her life or her movements, the smallest thing might help. Also, you can share information with the team here at Crime Junkie by emailing tips at audiochuck.com.

1:21:05Crime Junkie is an Audio Chuck production. I think Chuck would approve.

From the publisher

When Lisa Jameson vanished on her way home from an overnight shift in 1991, she left behind her 2-year-old son and a car that would later turn up at an adult bookstore. Decades of silence later, a song written by her son brought the case back to life. Now, with her original case file destroyed and new questions about what really happened that morning, her family needs Crime Junkies’ help.

  • If you know anything at all about the disappearance of Lisa Jameson from Chandler, Arizona, in 1991, please contact the Gilbert Police Department by calling 480-503-6500. You can also email us at [email protected]. 
  • "Red Coat," performed by Sincerely Collins, written by Kyle Anthony Collins and Ryan Votejsak, courtesy of Lyric House, LLC.
  • You can listen to Kyle’s new album, with renewed reflections on his mom’s disappearance HERE!

 

Source materials for this episode cannot be listed here due to character limitations. For a full list of sources, please visit: https://crimejunkiepodcast.com/missing-lisa-jameson/

Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit https://crimejunkiepodcast.com/fanclub/ to view the current membership options and policies.

Don’t miss out on all things Crime Junkie!


Crime Junkie is hosted by Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat. 

Text Ashley at 317-733-7485 to talk all things true crime, get behind the scenes updates, and more!

Are you ready to go a layer deeper? Sign up for Crime Junkie’s email to get the latest cases and updates straight from Ashley and Brit: https://crimejunkiepodcast.com/email-signup/


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from Crime Junkie

All episodes