

How seashells are made, from living mollusks’ biology and chemistry to the mathematics of shell shapes and the science of shell color/patterns.
Dr Suzanne Williams, researcher/collection expert at London’s Natural History Museum (mollusks). Dr Leanne Melbourne, senior curator of climate change at the Norfolk Museum Service (shell guide at Wells-next-the-Sea). Alan Gorelli, Professor of Mathematical Modelling, University of Oxford. Derek Moulton, Professor of Applied Mathematics, University of Oxford.
Mollusk shells are built by the mantle using calcium and carbonate ions from seawater to form calcium carbonate (like “3D printing” along the shell edge). Spiral shells follow logarithmic/helicospiral rules (expand, coil, rotate). Ornamentation can arise from growth-rate “mismatch” causing mechanical instabilities. Color/patterns involve pigments (e.g., carotenoids) and structural color (nacre), with some patterns likely for predator avoidance.
Conus geographus “cigarette flesh” toxin; chitons/“sea cockroaches”; nacre’s hexagonal “brick” structure; “chicoria” frilly spikes; pheasant shells’ variable patterns.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Listener Tamsin shares her curiosity about the origin of shells.
“It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing.”
Discussion on the different types and patterns of shells made by mollusks.
“science from the BBC World Service, the show that answers your science questions.”
A tour of the shell collection at London's Natural History Museum.
“And why do some have bewitching patterns and ridges?”
Insights into the various mollusks and their fascinating adaptations.
“And those are these ones with eight interlaping plates, yes.”
Explanation of the process by which mollusks create their shells using calcium carbonate.
“As we continue our rummage through the treasures in the Natural History Museum's mollusk collection, we reach a row of jars.”
A teaser for an investigative story about an Islamic boarding school.
“the store, like maple leaf cookies from 365 brand.”
Learn about the investigation into the mollusks and their shells.
“And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence.”
Discover how mathematicians analyze the shapes and growth of shells.
“Now we're answering the next part of our question from listener Tamsin in Australia.”
Explore the colors and patterns in shells and their evolutionary significance.
“it wasn't just the shapes that caught your eye.”
Discover a new podcast exploring the dark secret of an Islamic boarding school.
“It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On CrowdScience, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30And Spice Up Fall at Whole Foods Market. It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing. This is the story of an Islamic boarding school in Indonesia with a dark secret of the school's head teacher. This was someone I respected above anyone else. And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence. If this is leaked to the media, I'll be destroyed. This is World of Secrets catching my teacher. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
1:29science from the BBC World Service, the show that answers your science questions. I'm Marnie Chesterton and this is listener Tamsin. There's this one particular one I found that looked like a zebra. The centre of it was almost a bit gold. It was so cool. Days spent beachcombing left Tamsin with more than just a few beautiful shells. She had questions, lots of questions and a confession. Tamsin you emailed a really funny email so you said you had an embarrassing situation when it came to seashells well yes I was asking my friend like where are shells from and she just said they're all from like little animals and I'd been pondering this for so long so I kind of laughed that like after 26 years I had no idea that every shell is just made by a little creature.
2:20I, on behalf of CrowdScience, forgive you for not realising that shells come from animals because they are everywhere, right? They're just, they're one of those things that I associate with beach holidays as a kid and, you know, and you pick them up and you put them in the bucket or you decorate your sandcastle with them. But they're just these shells. Like, I very rarely see them with the little animal inside them still attached. Exactly, yeah. So what is it you want CrowdScience to find out? Well, I want to know how do these little creatures make the shells and also why are some different patterns and different colours?
3:06Some are really small, some are really big. I'm just curious about why they're all so different. So Tamsin's giving us the opportunity to explore the fundamental science behind these common but exquisite seashore beauties. What animals make them? And why are they so different? And why do some have bewitching patterns and ridges? Come and have a look at the collection. Wow. Surrounding me are floor-to-ceiling wooden drawers full of shells, and more on every surface. London's Natural History Museum has one of the world's most magnificent collections of shells, and researcher Dr Suzanne Williams is taking me deep inside it.
3:48How many rooms full of shells have you got? There are many rooms. I think the current estimate is 8 million lots for mollusca. We don't know how many shells you've got in here. No, not exactly. It's hard to think that these were all once part of a living thing. Suzanne has a collection on the table for me. Combs, spirals, some spiky, some smooth, and they're all part of one big family. They're mollusks. So mollusks include a number of different groups. Some have shells, some don't. But the ones that make shells are either bivalves, so clams, oysters and scallops, or gastropods, marine snails and marine slugs.
4:29And the snails have all different shapes of shells. So you can have turban-shaped, top-shaped, auger, ear-shaped. There's lots of different shapes. That's a lot. It is. And these are the tusk shells, which have an unusual little animal that you won't see very often, or chitons, which are sometimes called sea cockroaches in places like Mexico. And those are these ones with eight interlaping plates, yes. It's about the size of a rugby ball. It is. Mollusca is the second biggest group of animals on the planet, and their shells feel like treasures spilling out of the drawers and cabinets around me.
5:10This is one of the largest gastropods Wow! This is Sirenx arowana and it comes from Australia It can get up to about 70 centimetres in length That's astonishing They are really rather special They live on mudflats and crawl around I love it
5:35Through another room, into another room
5:43So these are conch snails, so the ones that you see in the movies that they used to use as trumpets. These conch shells belong on a tropical paradise. There's a spiral of ornate bumps circling around one end and a long flared opening that leaves a hole big enough to slide your hand inside it. I want to pick it up and put it to my ear and imagine the sound of the ocean. They also have big googly eyes on extendable eye stalks that can see as well as rats. And they move really fast. Really? It's really heavy. Because this is quite weighty. It's a lot of energy you'd need to move yourself around. From another drawer, Suzanne pulls out the shell of a mollusk that may be less pacey, but is genuinely something to be feared.
6:30This is Conus geographus. so this is a very slow moving snail and yet it's able to catch fish and it does it by firing a little harpoon at the fish and it's full of a toxin that is so deadly it kills the fish and if you think of how slowly a snail goes if it killed the fish slowly and the fish was able to swim for a few minutes the snail would never catch up so it kills it instantly it's really really fast acting So this particular species is responsible for a number of deaths of people. In the Philippines, this is known as the cigarette flesh because you have just enough time to smoke a cigarette and then you lie.
7:12That's great!
7:16Cezanne is really helping bring these mollusks out of their shells. They can burrow, swim, grow as large as a dog and some can even kill you if you're unlucky. As we continue our rummage through the treasures in the Natural History Museum's mollusk collection, we reach a row of jars. What's this fella? So this is a prickly cockle, and it's just got this flabby white tongue thing lolling out of it. Between the two valves, yeah. Two sides of the shell, the valves. And so that's the animal that lives inside the shells, right? Well, yes. And what you can see here is this big muscular foot poking out.
7:57That's a foot. That's a foot. That doesn't look like a foot. That looks like a tongue. It does. It looks definitely... It's very muscular and very strong in this species. And that's because they can actually use it to jump away like a pogo stick.
8:15Tamsin, you got in touch with CrowdScience after realising for the first time that shells are made by living creatures. and I think we've grabbed some insights into the variety of lives these animals lead and the way that their shells help with that. And the shell's what's left behind. They can be so tough that they last millions of years. So how do soft-bodied mollusks go about making something so durable? A trip to the seaside is in order. Shell hunting time. so this beach big big sandy beach at wells next to sea which is in norfolk in the uk and leanne can i get you to introduce yourself please hi i am dr leanne melbourne and i'm the senior curator of climate change in the dynamic coast for the norfolk museum service excellent and you will be my shell guide for this afternoon oh i think i found one so i really like the one i've picked up which is a cockle and it's kind of round and it's got these lovely nice ribs on them and they're quite small and and why have they got ribs so the ribs help them kind of burrow into the sediment right i want another shell
9:31oh got one found an oyster shell yay this looks way less pretty it looks kind of more like it's been sort of splattered together like if you made your house in a panic as a reaction to something but you can also see on the oysters actually all of the predation that's going on as well yeah like all of the boring from different creatures we're not the only species that likes an oyster definitely not so tell me about how these mollusks form a shell i mean i'm presuming once you're born you're in the ocean you need to make a shell that surrounds you as soon as possible because otherwise something's going to eat you.
10:11Yeah, as it's growing, it's forming the shell around it, which is to protect it from the wider elements, so stormy conditions, the waves, but also predation from other creatures that might want to eat the soft body part. How does something small and soft-bodied get the hard shell in the first place? So in our oceans and our seas and the water column, the water has lots of different irons and more specifically the calcium ions and the carbonate ions and so these mollusks will take these ions from the water and react them to form calcium carbonate to make their shell. I think I'm growing calcium carbonate in my kettle in my house because I'm in a heavily mineralized hard water area and that's what I know as limescale right?
11:04Yeah yeah so it's all the same material but what the animal does they have this organ called the mantle and as they're growing the mantle is taking all those ions and laying down this calcium carbonate at the the periphery of where they're growing and basically like looks like chalk in there and it's very easy to see on like a broken piece of the oyster. So mollusks are taking minerals from the water and making chalky calcium carbonate. As they grow, a line of shell is piped out of the mantle. Back with Suzanne at the Natural History Museum in London, I get a closer look at this shell-building organ.
11:45This is the mantle, which kind of envelops the animal and sits against the shells on the inside. That white bit? Yes. It's very thin. If you think of like an envelope that holds the animal, and if you think of the snail it goes up the the spire of the shell ah okay so the mantle comes up to the edge of the shell and it's the edge of the mantle where the shell is laid down and the animal first lays down periostracum which is an organic layer and then it secretes calcium carbonate onto this organic layer and again it's just right at the edge that it's growing so it's laying down shell in a line and it's just making the shell bigger and bigger as it goes.
12:29Okay so it's kind of 3D printing along one end of this of this blanket. Yes that's exactly right. So mollusks have this sheet light layer coating the outer surface of their soft body like covering yourself in a bed sheet and then the animal takes minerals from the seawater concentrates them and runs them over the edge of this bedsheet, where minerals mix with a sort of matrix or scaffolding structure made by the animal, hardening much in the same way as a coating of limescale grows on taps or in my kettle. But then what happens to turn it from something like a layer of chalky toothpaste into some of nature's most elaborate, diverse and beautiful shapes?
13:16That's what we'll be looking at next. Fall flavors are waiting for you at Whole Foods Market. Cozy picks all through the store, like maple leaf cookies from 365 brand. Swing by the bakery for pumpkin cheesecake, here for a limited time, and pumpkin turmeric bread freshly baked every single day. Sip the season with 365 brand cinnamon spice coffee and pumpkin spice creamer while you still can. Spice Up Fall at Whole Foods Market. It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing. This is the story of an Islamic boarding school in Indonesia with a dark secret of the school's head teacher.
13:59This was someone I respected above anyone else. And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence. If this is leaked to the media, I'll be destroyed. This is World of Secrets catching my teacher. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.
14:25You're listening to CrowdScience from the BBC World Service. I'm Marnie Chesterton. So far, we've been meeting the mollusks who make seashells and hearing how they build shells up layer on layer using an organ called the mantle. Now we're answering the next part of our question from listener Tamsin in Australia. How do shells come in such intricate shapes? Well, if there's a pattern, then surely there's a formula. That was the thought process of two maths professors at the University of Oxford in the UK. And with French paleontologist Regis Schirer providing the shells, they have spent 15 years trying to crack those formulas.
15:07and it's looking like they've done it. So we started working to understand how is this shape actually created, the very basic patterns, setting the mathematical framework for it and every time we understood a little bit there was always another mystery, another puzzle that we were trying to solve. This is Alan. My name is Alan Gorelli, Professor of Mathematical Modelling at the University of Oxford. And this is his shell studying partner Derek. Derek Moulton, Professor of Applied Mathematics. In their office, they've laid out all sorts of different shells from around the world. And there's one shape I can see again and again.
15:47The spiral. One of the fascinating things about the spiral is that it's a pattern that's called self-similar. And what that means is if you zoom in or out, at every single scale, you see the exact same shape. And in a way, that's a very simple constructive rule. It says that the animal is always following the same formula to create such a self-similar shape. So let's try to imagine that formula. The mollusk is squeezing out calcium carbonate like toothpaste from a tube. And it's the shape of the mollusk's body that helps define the line of shell that gets drawn. These animals themselves are taking a shape that has sort of a coiled shape.
16:31So that spiralling shape is very natural for that animal because it is growing in a way that its body is already curved. Yes, as the animal grows, the spiral creates more and more space in its house, its shell. The mollusk doesn't swap to a different shell as it gets bigger. Evolution has a better option, which can get bigger as the mollusk grows. If you look at a one-year-old sea snail and a ten-year-old sea snail, The latter is just a scaled-up version of the same spiral shape. Mathematicians like Alan and Derek call this a logarithmic spiral. The logarithmic spiral is so universal that you find some aspect of it in almost all C-shapes.
17:15And once you recognise it, you'll find it everywhere in nature. So how do they make it? Alan and Derek have pinned it down to three rules. Expand, coil and rotate, that's how we describe it. So expand just means that at each next layer of shell secretion, the mantle is pushing outward slightly. So if you think of the shell opening as a simple circle, then at one time step and then the next growth step, the circle is slightly larger. That's quite simple. That's probably the easiest one. So expand is the mollusk growing in size, as we've heard about. And then coil. Coil, this is kind of what gives you a logarithmic spiral, is the combination of expand and coil.
17:58Coil is having a gradient in the growth along the mantle. The gradient is the amount of calcium carbonate that's laid down at one particular point versus another. So if you think of your circle again, and if we're thinking about building bricks of a house, if I have a smooth transition from short bricks to longer bricks on one side to the other side, then my circle starts to curve. But a curve isn't yet a spiral. If you just have that rule, you grow a donut, a mathematician called a torus. But if you combine that rule with expand, you get a beautiful logarithmic spiral. The third rule, which some mollusks use and others don't, is rotate.
18:44and what that means is that now the brick, the longest brick, has moved slightly, twisted around the mantle and that corresponds to the animal inside actually rotating a bit inside its shell with each increment of growth. If you add that rule, then your logarithmic spiral gets pulled out of the plane and you get this, what's called the helicospiral, like our towering unicorn's horn turritella and most gastropods have that rule as well. So there you have the building blocks of making basic shells. Expand, coil, rotate. But Alan and Derek aren't done yet, because shells can get really complicated.
19:28Some of them have very exquisite, exotic spikes, spines, protuberances, all sorts of extra features. and the way we've kind of deconstructed the rules is that there are rules to make a smooth shell and then on top of that we've tried to uncover the rules that create all of these extra ornamentations. And that takes us on to the fancier shells that are laid out on the table in front of us. There's a shell over here that looks like one of those frilly Italian lettuces. I don't know, what's it doing? Originally, when it was named in the 19th century, two different researchers at the time said, oh, it looked very much like the frizzy letters, chicoria.
20:17So these are called chicoria, and they have these patterns of repeated spikes. And for the longest time, for 15 years, we've been picking up these animals and trying to understand how a simple spike is being created. And we had this general framework where we called the mismatch hypothesis, the fact that the mollusk grows faster at some time than the shell itself and creates this elastic instability that creates a bump in the middle. So a mismatch is when the mollusk suddenly increases how fast it grows and the spiral doesn't expand with it in its usual shape, but instead the mollusk pushes against the shell and deforms it, making a bump.
21:03And this bump in the middle, because of the specific rule of a seashell, gets amplified. Every time the next iteration comes out, that bumps get a little bit sharper and longer and longer and longer. Yeah, you can make that pattern yourself. So if you take a sheet of plastic, say a plastic bag, and you tear the plastic, in tearing the plastic, you stretch the plastic. So some bits of the plastic are longer than the bits of the plastic next to it. And so all that extra material, there's forces that are being created in the material, and the pattern that you see is the resolution of those forces.
21:39The size of the mollusk and its mantle has forced the shell to expand, and that frilly, chicory, lettuce-like edge is all the extra material left. Just a little bit of mechanical forces either give you needle-sharp spines or something that looks like the edge of lettuce. Or a torn plastic bag. Or a torn plastic bag. I have to say, Derek, that you've made torn plastic bags seem more beautiful than I've previously thought of them. So, Tamsin, now the swirling shapes and spikes that make seashells look so ornamental have been mapped out by Derek and Alan. they can put their formulas into a computer and watch it output 3D models that look just like shell shapes that have evolved over 500 million years.
22:31It's quite incredible. And I'll never look at a plastic bag in the same way. Tamsin, when you were combing the beach in Australia, it wasn't just the shapes that caught your eye. You wanted to know why shells are so colourful and patterned. One of the most well-known shell patterns is a rainbow-like iridescent shimmer called Mother of Pearl or Nacre. And on the beach with Leanne Melbourne, I managed to find some. I think I've just found the oyster shell that nicely demonstrates this because, look, it's got this really pearlised bit on the inside and I haven't got that in my kettle. no that's beautiful pearly iridescent structure is these kind of hexagonal bricks that interlock together and if you cut through it and look at it under a microscope it does actually look like bricks on a house kind of cemented together which is really cool but that structure the way that light interacts with it and enters our eyes means that we get this beautiful iridescence that we call structural color but interestingly the structure of nacre of mother of pearl it's to do with the material properties to increase the strength of the shell.
23:44So that's the purpose of the structure, but it just so happens that the by-product of it is this beautiful iridescence that we all love. So one of the most alluring effects in the shell kingdom is a happy accident of making a strong material. But shells come in such a gorgeous array of colours and markings, all that beauty can't just be a by-product of practicality, can it? I mean, the world is so beautiful and so colourful, but the colours have not evolved for our pleasure as much as we enjoy them. They are essential for the survival of many species and they perform all sorts of different functions.
24:19Back at the Natural History Museum, Suzanne Williams has been investigating the origins of the different colours we see in shells and their purpose. Some pigments, some carotenoid pigments, have been shown to make shells more elastic, which makes them stronger because then if something tries to cut them, they just kind of bend instead of breaking. These bendy carotenoid pigments take their name from carotene, which is what makes carrots orange. But they can be other shades too. And when the mollusks eat food containing carotenoids, they flow through the bloodstream and so tend to give one overall wash of colour.
24:56Carotenoids from the diet are usually yellow, orange or red. And that's why you get a lot of yellow, orange and red in the shells. But not all shells are like that. Can I show you something? If I just turn this on. You can have a look under the microscope. Have a look down there, you can see. Oh, this is spectacular. This looks like really intricate beading work. One spiral that's just red beads and then black and white beads. One of the reasons people have thought that pigment might be important and pattern might be important is that it relates to shell sculpture. So as you notice, there are lots of little granules, and each one's different colour, So the black is located exactly on top of a little granule.
25:39The white is on a little granule. So there are cases where we see colour and patterns matching perfectly with shell sculptures. So the bead-like dots of pigment follow the contours of the shell's ornamentations, like the spikes. But it's clear we just don't know enough yet to really understand why they're there. Some colours and patterns are probably for non-visual purposes, so perhaps helping with sculpture or strengthening. In this case, we don't know. And then Suzanne shows me that pattern can be just as perplexing. This is a really good example where we think colour and pattern are not providing a visual function because they have this thick brown hairy mat over the top of the shell.
26:23This just looks like a shell covered in dirt, to be honest. You can see in this one where it's flaking off. Someone's dropped it in a really muddy puddle. Oh, and this one, OK, it's flaking off, and underneath you can see all the beautiful patterning. These are called tent markings, the little triangles. They're beautiful, aren't they? It's the textile cone, and you can see it does. It looks like a piece of fabric with very ornate markings on it. So that means it's making this beautiful patterning, and it's not for show because it's covered. It's not for show. Then Suzanne pulls out a set of shells with striking differences in their colouration and markings.
26:59These are pheasant shells. Pheasant shells. This sort of variation, you often get really variable shells when a predator has good vision and it fixates on a target, so it thinks, OK, this is what I'm looking for, this particular shell colour and pattern. And when there are lots of them, it keeps finding them. And these guys are safe because they've got a different shell colour and pattern and they're rarer. But then, when the predator's favourite runs out, you are in trouble. You're no longer rare anymore, you're just lunch. Suddenly there's more of the other type of colour patterns and then they become the targeted ones.
27:32And so having a variation in shell colour and pattern is sometimes a strategy for avoiding predation. Tamsin, thank you so much for your questions about shells. It's taken us to mollusks, materials and mathematicians. Now, you may have felt silly for not knowing more about these glorious structures, and I hope we've done our part to rectify that, but also to show that some aspects of shells, like their patterning and colours, have scientists scratching their heads too. Happy shell hunting to everyone enchanted by these treasures. Tamsin, over to you for the credits. You've been listening to CrowdScience from the BBC World Service.
28:12The question was from me, Tamsin, in Melbourne, Australia. The producer was Tom Bonnet and the presenter was Marnie Chesterton. If you've got a question, email crowdsites at bbc.co.uk or send a message or voice note on WhatsApp. The number is plus 44 8000 314 773. That's plus 44 8000 314 773. Thanks for listening.
28:42It felt like everything I believed in was suddenly collapsing. This is the story of an Islamic boarding school in Indonesia with a dark secret of the school's head teacher. This was someone I respected above anyone else. And the investigation led by students he's trying to silence. If this is leaked to the media, I'll be destroyed. This is World of Secrets, catching my teacher. Listen on BBC.com, the BBC app, or wherever you get your BBC podcasts. you
Where do shells come from? CrowdScience listener Tamsyn got in touch, a little embarrassed, confessing that she had managed to reach her twenties without realising that shells are made by living creatures.
Suddenly, her curiosity ran wild and she asked CrowdScience to investigate how these sea creatures have the architectural prowess to make shells in delicate ornamental shapes with beautiful colours and patterns.
The job of sea-creature-investigator-in-chief falls to presenter Marnie Chesterton. She heads to the Natural History Museum in London, UK, where they have more shells than they can keep count of. Researcher Dr Suzanne Williams pulls out drawer after drawer of amazingly varied molluscs for Marnie to marvel at.
Then, it’s off to the beach to go shell hunting with Dr Leanne Melbourne, Senior Curator of Climate Change and the Dynamic Coast for Norfolk Museums in the UK. They look at the structure of shells, and Leanne explains how a soft mollusc is able to make a hard shell so sturdy they can survive for millions of years.
Marnie then gets into some mollusc maths. With shells strewn across a table, Professors Alain Goriely and Derek Moulton at the University of Oxford, UK show Marnie how they have mapped their shapes. Can Marnie uncover the formula that underpins the formation of shells, from the most basic to the inexplicably ornate?
Presenter: Marnie Chesterton
Producer: Tom Bonnett
Editor: Ben Motley
(Photo: Close up of young womans hands holding seashells, Eilat, Israel - stock photo Credit: PhotoStock-Israel via Getty Images)