

The episode asks whether there was ever an idyllic, predator-free time before carnivores. It argues that even early life involved predation: microbes likely attacked via chemical dissolution and coordinated “wolf pack” hunting by myxobacteria (holes in algal sheaths). When eukaryotes appeared, the earliest likely grazed bacteria (less direct predation), but later some groups evolved to eat other eukaryotes. Even before animals, “carnivorous” amoebae cannibalized shelled relatives by stealing mineral plates. In the Ediacaran, some fossils (rangiomorphs) look passive (osmotrophs or suspension feeders), but evidence of early predators increases later: a cnidarian fossil (“Aurora lumina,” tentacles capturing prey; Guinness record for oldest predatory animal). In the Cambrian explosion, predator-prey arms races drove diversification; examples include Anomalocaris (large eyes, spiky frontal appendage, fearsome hunting) and trilobites evolving protective exoskeletons.
Professor Susanna Porter (University of California, Santa Barbara paleontologist studying earliest life), Dr Frankie Dunn (Natural History Museum Oxford paleontologist), Dr Imran Rahman (Cambrian specialist), and Lynn Isbell (UC Davis primatologist; “snake detection theory” explaining primate vision and alarm-call language).
no truly idyllic predator-free era; predation shaped evolution, including primate vision and language.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploring the harsh realities of life on Earth through the lens of carnivores.
“There were predator-prey relationships going back, you know, potentially a billion years or more.”
Delving into the very beginnings of life, focusing on early microbes.
“He wants to know, was there ever a time when there were no carnivores and was it idyllic?”
Discussion of early eukaryotes and their transition from peaceful to predatory behaviors.
“Was there a time before predators, where one life form, the predator, eats another life form, the prey.”
Examining the cannibalistic behaviors of early amoebae and their implications.
“And then at some point, some groups started eating other eukaryotic cells.”
Introduction to the Ediacaran period and its significance in the evolution of life.
“Scott's question was about carnivores, you know, animals, the kind that we see today.”
Investigating the feeding strategies of organisms in the Ediacaran period.
“Welcome to a period known as the Ediacaran.”
Uncovering evidence of the first predatory animals and their impact.
“This one is from my personal collection.”
Explore the transition from non-predatory to predatory life forms on Earth.
“But don't worry, things are about to get even more tense because predators are getting teeth and claws.”
Discusses the Cambrian explosion and its role in the evolution of complex life forms.
“So Frankie, we've come to the end of the Ediacaran period.”
Examines the evolutionary pressures of predation on animal development.
“If that's not there, then what's the point?”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On CrowdScience, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. and all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. Fall into paradise with Apple Vacations. Book from September 25th through October 22nd and save up to 55 % on vacations to Mexico, the Caribbean, Hawaii, Central America, and top domestic destinations.
0:45Whether you're dreaming of a beach escape with the family or relaxing getaway for two, now's the perfect time to plan some time together. Travel through September 30th, 2027. Start planning your getaway today at applevacations.com or contact your travel advisor.
1:07Life is cruel. There were things eating other things. There were predator-prey relationships going back, you know, potentially a billion years or more. Nature is famously unforgiving. The predators act as a culling agent, and then the ones that remain are better able to deal with the predator. That's what natural selection is about. Predators relentlessly chasing down their prey. There's all sorts of warfare that's going on in these ecosystems that we're not even aware of. Life, as the philosopher Thomas Hobbes noted, is nasty, brutish, and short. It was probably a pretty hellish place to be at times.
1:51I'm Alex Laffbridge and this is CrowdScience from the BBC World Service, the show that answers your science questions about the infinite mystery of life on Earth and our place in it. And in this episode, we've been wondering if life really has to be quite as brutal, quite as violent as it is. And that's because we received a question from Scott, who's been wondering the same thing. He wants to know, was there ever a time when there were no carnivores and was it idyllic? To try and find out, I'm going back to the very, very beginning. Before there was life, there were rocks. There would have been an ocean, we think, really early on.
2:37And not a lot of land exposed above that ocean. Okay, okay, too far back, too far back. not to the very beginning of Earth, just to the beginning of life. I'm imagining something like a shallow seafloor where there were these layers of slime and there were these different single-cells bacteria. This is Professor Susanna Porter, a paleontologist from the University of Santa Barbara in California in the United States, and she studies the very earliest forms of life on Earth. They're living in the slime that they made. If you think of, like, if you don't wash or shower for a really long time, you get this kind of black layer of slimy gunk.
3:23That's filled with microbes in the slime that they make. Okay, so there's definitely nothing that looks like a carnivore here. Just a bunch of single-celled organisms chilling in their own slime. I'm not sure how idyllic it sounds. They were consuming perhaps each other's waste or bodies of other organisms. They maybe were essentially scavengers. OK, so our listener Scott wanted to know if there was a time before carnivores, one animal eating another animal. But billions of years ago, there weren't really animals made of meat. So if we're going to go that far back, we need to open it up. Was there a time before predators, where one life form, the predator, eats another life form, the prey.
4:10Susanna says that based on what we know about the microbial world today, it's pretty likely that there was some predation going on, just on a tiny scale. I think about actually how terrifying it would be to be a microorganism, right? The ways that other microorganisms have come up with to attack each other. I mean, you could be swallowed, right? You can imagine if you were just minding your own business and someone came along and emitted a bunch of chemicals into your environment that started dissolving your skin. That would be really terrifying, right? That's quite rude. Here I am living my life.
4:52Someone comes over, emits chemicals. Oh, there goes my skin. Fantastic. I know. Susanna says that some of the behaviours of these organisms, tiny though they are, is terrifyingly sophisticated. There are these bacteria, myxobacteria, that are predatory. They are known to attack larger cells. And they'll do it like they're a wolf pack. They'll have this wolf pack behaviour where they coordinate. You'll see the sort of remains of this algal sheath. And it has a bunch of holes all in it from these wolf-like bacteria that have attacked them. For 1.5 billion years or so, this was life on Earth. A vicious, microscopic, dog-eat-dog, microbe-eat-microbe world of tiny bacteria and archaea invading and attacking and digesting one another.
5:43Chaos! But skip forward a billion years or so and eventually we see the evolution of an entirely new domain of life, the eukaryotes. Now these guys are important because all of the big things on Earth, plants, fungi, animals and even us are all eukaryotes. But back then, the very first eukaryotes were small, these single-celled organisms called protists or amoebae. Could they have pioneered a more peaceful, idyllic existence? It looks like the very earliest eukaryotes, we think, probably just ate bacteria. We think of them as like grazers, like the bacteria are the primary producers getting energy from the sun or for chemical reactions.
6:30and then the earliest eukaryotes then are just eating these little primary producers. So no predation here. Peace. Tranquility. And then at some point, some groups started eating other eukaryotic cells. So you can think of these as being like the equivalent of carnivores eating the other eukaryotes that are eating the primary producers. I don't know what the eukaryotic version of etubrutus is, but I feel like it's... Yeah, that's exactly right. Hey, I thought we were all happy eating these bacteria. Like, everybody's just minding their own business. But someone just decided to start eating each other instead.
7:12Now, our listener, right, they asked, was there ever a time before carnivores when life was idyllic? Now, it seems that this sort of really early period wasn't that idyllic, right? Yeah, absolutely. I don't think there was ever a time when life was idyllic. We even have examples of amoebae that build their own shells, their own little mineralized plates that arrange really carefully in their shells. But there are other amoebae that will attack and eat these shelled amoebae and take those little plates. So it's sort of like they're murdering their brethren and then taking the clothing, I guess, that their relatives have so carefully constructed and just using it to make their own outfits.
8:04So it's like carnivorous turtles eating one another. Yeah, that's a great analogy. It's like a turtle eating another turtle, getting those plates that form the turtle shell and using it to build their own turtle shell. And that was happening in these teeny tiny amoeba. Yeah, it seems pretty terrifying to me, actually. There's all sorts of warfare that's going on in these ecosystems that we're not even aware of. So primordial life on Earth was far from idyllic. Sounds like something out of a gruesome slasher film to be honest. But this is microbial life. They aren't even animals yet and none of them could really be described as carnivores, even those cannibalistic, shell-stealing turtle amoebae.
8:52Scott's question was about carnivores, you know, animals, the kind that we see today. So we're going to have to scoot forward in time another billion and a half years to a time when the first real animals emerged. And they got big as well. Welcome to a period known as the Ediacaran. So during the Ediacaran period, we see all manner of things happening, including the appearance of the very first animal fossil assemblages that we know of. I'm with senior researcher Dr Frankie Dunn in her office, which is located somewhere in the labyrinthine back corridors of the Natural History Museum of Oxford in the UK.
9:34So I'm a paleontologist, so I'm able to study fossils. I think I have the best job in the world. We have a very, very rich fossil record from this period in Earth history and means that we can peer back into the rocks to see what happened. OK, so just paint the picture here, because, you know, when I think of underwater life right now, I think of like, you know, a seabed, might have some crabs there, maybe a few fish swimming through. What did it look like back then? Well, it would have been a very, very different world back in the Ediacaran period. We are talking about a period in Earth history before the appearance of lots of the evolutionary innovations, which we think define animals today.
10:14More or less before the evolution of skeletons. So we're dealing with things which are exclusively soft-bodied and like two cell layers and some goo probably. These are unique ways of building a body. So in front of us right now there's a fossil about the size of my arm, a big rectangle, it's like a slab, like it sort of looks like little leaves, tiny little leaves. They don't seem like animals or what I think of as animals. What is actually going on here? What you're looking at are a number of fossils I would call rangiomorphs. So these are fossils which have this beautiful branch within branch within branch architecture a little bit like kind of feathery and some of these have hold fast discs which you can see here which would have rooted them to the seafloor and a stem and then a little frond which would have waved in the water column these creatures these ediacaran how did they eat oh now that's a very good question and it's one that's very much up for debate so there are two main schools of thought one is that these were osmotrophs, where you just passively absorb nutrients from the water column.
11:20So definitely not a predator. The other hypothesis is that these were suspension feeders. So they were filtering food out of the water column, but they wouldn't have been actively capturing. They don't have any appendages which help them to bring food in. So at this point in time, is there any evidence that can tell you if there were predators, you know, one sort of animal eating another? Yeah, so that's a good question. And I want to draw your attention to the most inconspicuous part of this fossil specimen that I've brought out. It's this thing here, which kind of looks almost like a dog paw.
11:53So what we think has gone on here is that one of these rangiomorphs has died and it's been overgrown by this horrible microbial mat. And that's really interesting because if you think about the seafloor today, when an animal dies, it is immediately scavenged. You end up with nothing in almost no time. But at this time, in this place in Earth history, we have nothing which is preying on these animals or even scavenging them. So a listener asked, was there an idyllic time before predators? Now, could you say that this Ediacaran period, at least for a little bit of time, was this idyllic place? This is as close as you're going to get, I would say, yeah.
12:33And it's led to some people calling this the Garden of Ediacara, this quiet, peaceful environment without actually too much going on. Is there any evidence for predators being in existence at this time? There is increasing evidence for early animal predators as we move through the Ediacaran period. So I have another fossil. This one is from my personal collection. So it doesn't have a special number or anything on it. I can see sort of a very tiny V, the letter V. So if you follow the V up on the left side, it opens out here. So we have two goblets and then emerging from the goblets, we have a crown of tentacles.
13:18Wow. And so is that the same creature? Yeah. So we think this is a colonial creature and it's a Cnidarian. So it's very closely related to modern day corals and jellyfish. So these are some of the first predatory animals that we observe in the fossil record. the tentacles will be used to filter out small animals from the water column and we called it aurora lumina because aurora meaning dawn and lumina because it looks a little bit like a goblet did you get to name it yourself i did proudest moment of my life so in the first fossil you showed these creatures very much passive feeders they sit on the seafloor basically taking stuff from the surroundings and then in this second fossil which is from a bit later where you've got creatures that have these tiny tentacles they're actively feeding they are actively capturing prey this is actually in the guinness book of world records as the world's oldest predatory animal so far in our hunt for an idyllic world without predators we've had violent microbes peaceful filter feeders, and the very first predator on Earth.
14:27But don't worry, things are about to get even more tense because predators are getting teeth and claws.
14:35Fall tastes better with better ingredients from Whole Foods Market. No added growth hormones or antibiotics in their meat department means slow-braised short ribs are even more satisfying. All seafood is wild-caught, like their vibrant sockeye salmon or verified responsibly farmed. And all sweets, including fall-themed cookies, are made without high-fructose corn syrup. Spice up fall at Whole Foods Market. O, O, O, O 'Reilly! Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on? Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE-certified master technicians.
15:19and if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts.
15:35You're listening to CrowdScience from the BBC World Service. I'm Alex Lathbridge and I'm on the hunt for an answer to listener Scott's question. Was there an idyllic time before predators? I'm running upstairs and down corridors behind the scenes at the Natural History Museum of Oxford in the UK. Luckily, I'm guided by paleontologist Frankie Dunn. So Frankie, we've come to the end of the Ediacaran period. What happens next? Oh, so the Ediacaran period ends and we move into the Cambrian period. It's a time of the famous Cambrian explosion. But if you want to hear about that, then I have to introduce you to my wonderful colleague Imran.
16:16Hello, my name is Dr Imran Rahman, and I guess I'm here to talk to you about the Cambrian. So we've arrived in a period that has an incredibly dramatic name, the Cambrian Explosion. I'm not going to lie, it does sound like the little awkward brother of the Big Bang. So what was the Cambrian Explosion? So this is the first time in Earth's history when we start to see animals appearing in large numbers, doing all sorts of different things, swimming through the water, crawling on the seafloor and in the mud beneath it. And in the space of just a few tens of millions of years, which geologically speaking is pretty quick, that's when we see all of these fossil animals appearing.
16:56So, you know, between the two of us, we might not call a million years a short period of time, but in the history of life, it's pretty short. We've just come from the Ediacaran period where it's been quite docile, where there have sort of been things that are passively taking resources from water columns. What does the Cambrian explosion look like? Well, much less passive than that. So we start to see much more complicated, what we call ecological interactions, predator-prey relationships, all sorts of modes of life that we didn't see in the Ediacaran. Probably something that looks much more similar to what we see today than we would have seen a few tens of millions of years earlier.
17:30Is there a way we can see some animals from the Cambrian explosion? Well you're lucky because you've come to one of the foremost places to see Cambrian fossils so we're behind the scenes here in what we call the Paleozoic Room and it's full of drawers of fossils from different periods of time. Okay so crack one open let's see what's inside. Okay let's do it. Okay so I'm going to open up one of the cabinets which contains some of our fossil material. So here we have some drawers from a place called the Burgess Shale which is a very famous site of exceptionally preserved fossils in Canada. It looks like someone has taken white marker and drawn an insect on there.
18:13It looks like one of those pill bugs, you know, those roly-poly bugs. Yes, so you're right though, it does look very much like a woodlouse or something like that. And this fossil and others like it belong to a group of animals called the trilobites. They're characterised by this kind of hard mineralised skeleton. Famously, we see examples of trilobites with W or U or V-shaped bite marks out of their skeletons, which were interpreted as evidence of things trying to crunch them. So do we have any examples in these filing cabinets of, you know, top predators? Yes, we do. So we have some examples of a fossil called Anomalocaris, which is one of the, if not the first, very large predatory animals that existed during the Cambrian.
18:57All right, show me these fossils. Okay, let's go look at the fossil. so you can kind of make out this is a sort of curved thing and it's got these little spikes sticking off one side of it so this is what we call the frontal appendage the sort of claw frontal claw of one of those larger animals right okay so that would be one of the claws on the front of this creature yeah exactly so the whole creature that had this claw they could get up to about 50 centimeters long certainly much bigger than the trilobites and other animals that were crawling around on the seafloor at that time. So what those fossils have are very large and sophisticated eyes.
19:33So that's really important because you can see all around you very clearly. You can spot your food, your next meal from quite far away. They're also potentially quite fast moving. And of course, we see the spiky mouth. So this is something that crunches up other animals around. This is quite a fearsome predator. Now this is more like it, a proper carnivore, a half-metre-long, fast-moving, hunting-chomping predator. The relative calm of the Ediacaran is over. If you were a trilobite, you had to watch your back. Well, actually, that's exactly what trilobites did. That hard-segmented exoskeleton that I saw earlier probably evolved exactly for this reason, to protect them from predators like the Anomalocaris.
20:20What we see is evidence for what we call a predator-prey arms race. We can see this kind of competition between the predators and the prey. So the prey will start to evolve spikes or thicker shells, and the predators will start to evolve new ways of breaking open their prey or damaging them. So that actually catalyzes this kind of evolutionary diversification, this explosive radiation of animals in the Cambrian, and potentially through many other periods of time as well. So without this predator-prey arms race, do you think we would have been able to evolve all of these diverse and complex traits that animals have today?
20:54I'm thinking eyes, mouths, fast movement. I think probably not is the answer to that question because this was so important for how these animals interacted with each other and the world around them. And animals don't evolve for the sake of it. They evolve because they're under pressure to do so. One of those pressures is predation. If that's not there, then what's the point? Why not just live happily on the seafloor, munching on slime for eternity? I don't know about you, CrowdScience listeners, but that doesn't sound particularly pleasant, even for me. Listener Scott's idea of an idyllic predator-free world sounds nice, but is it all it's cracked up to be?
21:32Think about it. Animals evolved speed, sharp senses, big eyes, and clever, problem-solving brains as a result of this predator-prey arms race. Without these adaptations, could we really say that life on Earth is idyllic? Is life beautiful if we don't have a way to perceive it? Is a peaceful existence worth anything without the brain to understand it? Could humans ever have existed without predators to shape us into who we are? Life in the trees, food and predators, those are the three main things that probably made primates the way they are. This is Lynn Isbell, distinguished professor from the University of California, Davis in the USA, and, most importantly, a primatologist.
22:18I focus on primate behaviour and ecology. I've also ventured into primate evolution. I've come to talk to her about her work on one very specific part of this predator-prey arms race, one that's massively guided the direction of our own evolutionary pathway and all our primate cousins too. Lynn's theory is that it was the evolutionary pressure from one particular ancient predator that made primates what they are today. She calls it the snake detection theory. The snake detection theory is an explanation for the origin of primates and the differentiation of their visual systems in particular. Primates became primates partly because of their better vision compared to other mammals.
23:08Tell me about primate vision. What makes it so different from vision in other animals? The monkeys and apes have the best color vision of all mammals, and their eyes face forward, and that allows them to see depth perception much better than animals that have eyes more to the sides of their heads. What features in particular do you think were influenced by these close-up threats, these snakes? Primate vision appears to be best close by and in the lower visual field, basically on the ground. And the predators who fit that bill are the snakes. With snakes, you don't have to see them far away and it's impossible to see them far away.
23:55When they're really dangerous is when they're nearby, when they're within stepping distance. And then you have to be able to see them clearly to avoid them. Lin thinks the visual system of primates is primed and ready to pick out snakes. So ready, in fact, that it happens consciously and unconsciously. The non-conscious visual system operates a little bit more quickly than the conscious visual system. Maybe you've had this experience where you're walking on a trail or something and suddenly you stop or you jump back and you don't know why you're doing that until you actually recognise that there was a snake right in front of you.
24:32the non-conscious visual sense picks up on these cues just slightly before you recognize what you're reacting to i feel as though all of this snake detection theory has come from one day you're walking down the trail and you freaked out a little bit you're like no no no there's a there's a reason behind there's a snake detection theory yes am i wrong uh i i have had those experiences yes i've had those experiences in Africa when I'm following monkeys around. The good thing about studying primates is that they give alarm calls to snakes when they see them. They're much better at seeing the snakes than I am.
25:10The sort of the classic example is the vervet monkey lives in Africa. When they detect a snake, they'll stand up on their hind legs and give a specific vocalization called the chudder. Is it, you know, the vervet monkey equivalent of snake, snake, snake, snake, Snake, snake, snake, snake, snake. Does it sound like that? I'll try to do a cheddar, but it's very quiet. And it goes something like, ha, ha, ha, ha, ha, like that. That means snake. No. Yeah, it does. Other monkeys understand it and they react appropriately by looking down on the ground to look for the snake. So it's not just vision. The constant threat of predators has influenced another really important feature of primate evolution, the development of language.
26:03And it's not just snakes. They have words for other predators too. Vervets are known for being able to tell others when they've seen a leopard and an eagle, and their vocalizations sound very distinctive. For instance, if they're on the ground and somebody gives a leopard alarm call, they run into the trees and if they give an eagle alarm call others will drop down lower into the trees so our listener had an interesting question they wanted to know was there ever a time before carnivores when life was idyllic do you think the idea of a predator free ideal is good you know is it actually idyllic?
26:47Yeah. So at an individual level, it would be great if all the predators that could eat us would not be around us. But on an evolutionary basis, yes, I think that predators have really been instrumental in creating the kinds of other animals that are out there. That's what natural selection is about. You end up having things like better vision and better vision is not just better for detecting snakes, but it's also better for seeing the facial expressions on others around you so that you can perhaps avoid a confrontation with somebody near you. I think that if there weren't any predators around, life would be really simple and boring.
27:33That's what I think. I like that. You know, hey, there's a chance that some of you might be eaten, but it's fun. So, there you go, Scott. The conclusion is, life wouldn't be idyllic without predators. To get to where we are today, ancient single-celled lifeforms melted each other's skin off, and not to mention anomalocaris going around with its special appendage. And early primates needed to point out snakes, which gave us our fantastic vision and our ability to communicate through language. And that's a skill that I'm going to use right now to do the credits. That's it for this episode of CrowdScience from the BBC World Service.
28:16The question was from Scott. The programme was presented by me, Alex Lathbridge, and produced by Emily Knight. If you have a question and want us to hunt down an answer, please email crowdscience at bbc.co.uk. Thanks for listening. Bye.
28:37Part of why I blew the whistle was I didn't want to lay in bed in 20 years, having seen another million people die, and know that I could have done something when I had a chance. This week on The Interface, we're talking to Frances Haugen. The Facebook whistleblower who leaked the documents that changed how the world saw social media. And now she is the subject of Aaron Sorkin's latest movie, The Social Reckoning. So join me, Thomas Germain. And me, Jess Maddox, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.
Was there ever a time when life on earth was peaceful? Free of violence? No predators, no prey, just... vibes? Or has nature always been 'Red in Tooth and Claw'?
Have we always been eating each other?
Our listener Scott sent us on a quest to discover the origins of predators and prey, and to find out what all this ‘eat or be eaten’ stuff is really about.
Taking us back to the very dawn of life on earth, Professor Susannah Porter from the University of Santa Barbara lets Alex peer into an extraordinary world of microscopic warfare. It’s a dog-eat-dog (or, microbe-dissolve-microbe) world, with single celled organisms doing battle with each other. For billions of years, this was life on earth! Tiny, violent, and completely fascinating.
But what about bigger creatures? More complex ones - animals? Speeding forward several billion years, Alex arrives in the Ediacaran Period – a time of unusual tranquility, where strange, plant-like animals lived in relative peace. At the Natural History Museum in Oxford, UK, palaeontologist Dr Frankie Dunn shows him around.
So where did real predators come from, then? Alex is joined by Dr Imran Rahman as he ushers in one of the most extraordinary periods in Earth’s history – the magnificently named Cambrian Explosion! Here we find real predators, with teeth, claws, and impressive hunting appendages. Through the fossil record, we can see an arms race developing – as predators get more sophisticated, so does their prey. It’s ON.
Finally, Alex wonders if our own evolution, shaped as it has been by this predator-prey arms race, might have been very different without the threat of being chomped. Professor Lynne Isbell from the University of California, Davis takes Alex on a trip into our primate past, and tackles one of our most fearsome predators: snakes.
Presenter: Alex Lathbridge Producer: Emily Knight Series Producer: Ben Motley