

27 Oct 2026 · 1h 55m · 46 chapters

The “Black Friday trap” for D2C/ecommerce brands—how chasing peak revenue with complex offers, excessive discounting, and over-reliance on Meta incremental reach can destroy profitability and create operational risk. Guests argue for full-funnel planning, offer simplicity, and “high-quality revenue” (profitability and retention), not just top-line sales.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Explore the complexities and challenges faced by D2C brands during Black Friday.
“We would have made the exact same amount of money, actual profit, if we just didn't do it.”
Meet the panelists and learn about their professional backgrounds and expertise.
“And now I'm a consultant for fast growing consumer brands in and around the health and wellness space.”
Discussion on the recent growth and strategy of brands heading into 2026.
Panel discusses the highs and lows in the D2C market and the need for differentiation.
Exploration of how effective brand positioning impacts business success.
Insights into preparing for the Black Friday peak and the importance of planning.
The hosts introduce the topics to be covered regarding Black Friday strategies.
Discussion on the struggles brands face with reaching new customers, especially on Facebook.
“It feels like the buzzword of this year of how people think about incremental reach.”
Exploration of media buying tactics, including partnership ads and creative diversity.
“And so working with clients, a lot of people are trying to understand what are the big tactics that drive that.”
Insight on using TikTok for customer engagement and addressing potential buying concerns.
Hosts discuss the importance of setting clear objectives for Black Friday campaigns.
Discussion on the shift towards profitability in ecommerce and understanding customer lifetime value.
Discussing strategies to enhance subscriber retention and value.
Examining the impacts of discounting and product bundling on brand value.
Strategies for acquiring high-value customers during Black Friday sales.
“And let's go and focus on acquiring the customers that we care about that we think are going to be high value.”
The importance of simplicity in promotional offers and customer experiences.
Sharing experiences of missteps and complexities faced during sales promotions.
How to craft engaging marketing campaigns that resonate with customers.
“I think much more about, oh, that sounds like a product I really need.”
Learn how to create entertaining content for Black Friday promotions.
“You're squeezing everything you can to improve your margins.”
Explore how consumer behaviors and expectations for Black Friday have evolved.
“How do you think consumer expectations have shifted like in now versus maybe like say four or five years ago?”
Understand the strategic considerations for when to launch Black Friday sales.
“early 10 20 days before and just goes like that if you're if you're going to do that tactic I just I think you kind of have to be really eyes wide open about it, which maybe is important for people to know.”
Learn about the importance of diverse creative strategies in advertising.
“December the 26th is the Black Friday for Southampton Browns.”
Discover how to effectively collaborate with influencers for brand promotion.
Learn the importance of fostering genuine connections with content creators.
Discover strategies to use TikTok effectively for increasing sales.
Understand the profitability challenges and strategies for TikTok Shop.
“So use the kind of creators to kind of build yourself so that when someone looks for you, there's loads of examples, like we said, of other people using the product, right?”
Explore the balance between creative volume and maintaining brand quality.
“So it's super cool to hear how it's working.”
Learn how to effectively forecast creative success and optimize ad spend.
“So in a category, if you were the one doing it, you'd have a pretty high hit rate.”
Learn how to identify and create hero assets in your ad strategy.
Understand the balance between ad volume and creative quality.
“I do think that's fair like I think big kind of statistical forecasting all of that stuff only really starts to make sense at a certain scale.”
Explore tactics for maintaining ad performance during high-demand seasons.
Discover how to adapt marketing messages for the gifting season.
Learn how to effectively utilize partnership ads during sales periods.
“Even if it's just like adding something to the top like whatever's been really successful for the year just add some messaging on top about that Friday.”
Understand the role of AI in creating and optimizing ads quickly.
“if it was like a one click and then make it really easy.”
Discuss the importance of consistency and planning in ad campaigns.
Learn how to strategically approach advertising during the Black Friday rush while managing stress and resources.
“And if you're spending a couple of hundred K over that week, plus you're going to get a pretty big outcome.”
Understand the importance of a seamless customer journey and consistent messaging during promotional periods.
“The worst thing you could do, don't do that offer where you say up to 70 % off and you get on the website and there's just like three things with 50.”
Explore unique marketing tactics and partnership strategies to elevate your e-commerce brand during high-traffic seasons.
“And then you've got like, you've not even checked the mobile journey.”
Discover how celebrity endorsements and community engagement can boost brand credibility and sales.
“and to think about that then i think it is massive for your business and can really transform it if you can execute it at the kind of depth that you want to do.”
Learn how successful influencer partnerships combine trust and targeting.
Explore the pros and cons of using gamification for customer engagement.
Discover the importance of email frequency and simplicity in campaigns.
“I actually think a lot of pop-ups that would just cost people money.”
Understand the importance of focusing on impactful business strategies.
Learn how to effectively respond to falling short of revenue targets.
“Because I'm sure someone listening will have this situation.”
Learn strategies for managing business risks in a competitive market.
Discover effective tactics for increasing customer engagement during sales.

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On D2C Diaries, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00Nick Kane: We would have made the exact same amount of money, actual profit, if we just didn't do it. If you're watching this podcast and then going away to change your Black Friday plans. Stop watching, go to work.
0:09Laurence Booth: Most D2C businesses die because of complexity rather than starvation, right? Everyone's getting gifts. These bundles are insane. We are all getting slightly sick of everyone kind of offering more and more crazy bundles, but there's actually a lot of value in it.
0:21Frederica Watson: People are going to buy. They're really primed to buy. Speaking on Black Friday, people just want to spend money. So is it going to make the difference to have that extra gift that's costing you£3? The mind of the type. It's like that£3 could be the difference. Just don't go too heavy without doing the numbers.
0:34Nick Kane: I'd rather 10 killer ads than 50 doesn't slop. Volume works. You won't fight every 100 million a year business that spends all the money on Meta. It makes over 1 ,000 ads a month. I'm pretty bullish on gamification, especially on site entry. If you see a wheel and you get 10%, all I'm thinking is somewhere on that wheel is 40%. The argument for going early is that you're going to capture the market. But the argument for going late, I don't know why the argument for going late is. Actually, somebody can tell me. It's Black Friday, day one. 40 % below revenue target. What are you doing? What levers are you pulling?
1:02Nick Kane: If I'm 40 % behind target, I'm not discounting deeper. And I'm not spending more.
1:10Nick Kane: Welcome back to another episode of D2C Diaries. New location. First ever panel episode. Yeah, really excited to have three guests with me today. Sadly, Lucas is bedbound. So it's all on me to carry the boats. um but yeah delighted to have lawrence nick and frederica from i'll let you do your own intros actually maybe we'll start there just can you fly around the table lawrence you're a returning guest yeah episode four i think we're nearly on episode 100 so yeah i would i would say you are an og as
1:47Laurence Booth: far as our podcast goes yeah uh yeah i'm lawrence uh dc founder uh i i started a business called the Mothership, which was we acquire and scale consumer brands. And now I'm a consultant for fast growing consumer brands in and around the health and wellness space.
2:06Frederica Watson: I'm Frederica. I'm currently working for Revive Collagen as director of e-commerce. Previously in the skincare world, I worked at Nip and Fab, Sarah Chapman, and then prior to that, fashion. So fashion, beauty, and now supplements.
2:19Nick Kane: Cool. Nick, I'm CMO of Magic AI. So we are an AI fitness mirror. So we use computer division and AI to track your form, count your reps, give you feedback. So it's just like a regular mirror when it's in your home, when it's turned off, you wouldn't be able to know what it is. When you turn it on, it's an AI PT at your fingertips. So you can quit your pure gym and train with Armour instead. Yeah, I'm delighted to have you here, Nick, because everyone gives me grief for not having anything other than supplement brands on the pod. Bit of a health and wellness theme, but can't get away from that, I feel, in 2026.
2:47Nick Kane: It's the moment, isn't it? Exactly. So quick one before we get into it. If you're growing a brand, you're probably trying to optimize everything right you test hooks you're watching your performance metrics you're trying to shave a few quid off your costs of goods you're even hunting for a better rate on shipping you're squeezing everything you can to improve your margins but what if you could do the same on the money that's leaving your account every single month for the expenses that you're making this episode sponsor is in card a financial platform that's built for digital businesses and essentially it helps you get more out of what you're spending right now they're giving you two cash back on your first year of ads, SaaS, travel, and even everyday business spend, all uncapped.
3:28Nick Kane: So the money that you're already spending, it starts to pull its weight like everything else that you obsess over within your business. You also get multi-currency accounts, corporate cards, and Shopify meta and Xero connected all in one place, which for me is massive because having to go to all of these different places is a bit of a nightmare. brands like soul aloe paris azio beauty ankway they're already using incard to save on their everyday expenses sign up for free use the code swu 2k26 to unlock two percent cash back for a full year links in the description back to the episode bfcm right around the corner i don't know how many days we are away maybe like six weeks depends when you launch it don't actually already launched someone will have gone somewhere um biggest moment of the year for many brands um for some it's like the easiest revenue for others it's a lot more complicated with that i'm sure than that i'm sure we're going to get into that but before we go into november peak q4 i wanted to just rewind like starting with maybe you nick what's what's 2026 look like for for magic how's the year gone overall it's been i would say it's been a breakthrough year for us to be honest i mean it's been a bit of a rocket since we started um but this year has been the year we launched in the us we hired some pretty like institutional talent on the team peloton that sort of thing launched our subscription um it's been mad i mean it's been a rocket since the beginning to be honest like our growth's been 350 every single year um but this year feels like the year we're starting to get some real traction multiple territories really starting to understand our unit economics bringing in a proper team you know we're slightly different to a normal d2c brand where most of our team are computer vision engineers phds that sort of stuff so we've got a very lean marketing team the reason we can do that though is because we're pretty differentiated like there's not really many people selling a product like ours but yeah this is it's been massive this year for us like every year it's but i'm blown away by the growth and every year continue to be surprised so it's um been big i mean it's not been without challenges though like we're a heavy capital intensive like difficult business supply chain is our biggest issue but um yeah it's been a massive year for us so if you were to sum it up in well maybe not sum it up in one word but what's been like the the biggest change versus last year would you say within the business or um tactically there's been a few the big one that springs to mind is just like territory and channel diversity so retail that sort of stuff but i think the big one for us has just been the talent and really understanding our numbers i think when you first start you raise a bit of money you start scaling you're just trying to get a certain rest whatever but like this year we've got some proper talent on the team proper cfo and uh we're actually paying attention to our numbers i think that's the big difference between this year and previous years and i start to see the benefits of that obviously now i think that sort of relates to black friday as well nice um what about yourself so i've been with ryan
6:29Frederica Watson: collagen since June so I can't talk too much about their previous year but from what I know it's been a really big year for the business they launched in the US um so they're now in Ulta, Walgreens so really exciting time for the business like you know going into new territories um they've got Mel B as their ambassador for their menopause range which is obviously new for the brand as well and then earlier this year launching Nootropics which was basically like functional mushrooms and collagen together in one sachet um so lots of things coming out and new like avenues and angles um but i think now is really the time when we just for me for d2c is getting back to the basics i think it's so easy to just be like yeah there's so many channels and you could be a magpie i want to do everything but how are the channels that you're actually like spending money on performing so i think for me from a d2c perspective it's website it's um the core channels that we have meta tiktok shop and really understanding like what's bringing the biggest value for the business where should we spending our time um and just getting yeah honestly it's back to basics i think optimization would probably be the word just optimizing what we've got now before we start looking at loads of other stuff as well but retail is a powerhouse and it's doing really well so
7:31Nick Kane: nice so products territory diversification channel product diversification for yourself what about you laurence you've got a little bit more of a cross yeah it's really interesting i
7:42Laurence Booth: sit across quite a quite a quite a few different uh businesses and types of businesses and and i think in in many ways i've i've sort of seen my word is sort of volatile volatility like i think i've seen extraordinary highs and i'm working with businesses that are just have found like a real moment in the market and and things are just going incredibly well but then also seeing the challenges that we're that we're seeing in terms of volatility especially on meta uh everyone's just trying to re consistently re-understand the the algorithm they feel like they understood three months ago or even six months ago you know is it is it creative volume is it creative quality is it uh andromeda or is it sequence serving or whatever whatever these things might be that we hear about all the time um and so you know what i'm what i'm what i've seen really is that uh the highs are really high but they come with a lot of challenges um and people have really started to actually kind of coming to echo your points and both of your points people are starting to really start to try and understand the fundamentals so so coming back to everything from my perspective uh running a great business in this space requires deep understanding of your balance sheet and your pnl and that's basically where every decision starts and then being really really clear about the game you're playing in the market um and and more and more i've started to work with clients and see clients thinking about market level changes in order to help them understand where they should go in their channel in their channel marketing and kind of how they're messaging but also in how to manage risk in a market so if the market's declining or changing then we need to understand how much risk we want to take with how much stock we're going to go how much growth is we can afford if we are say for example bootstrapped um so so that's kind of how i'm seeing the market um and maybe slightly differently from you guys because i've got that kind of portfolio view
9:33Nick Kane: they're really interesting we were having a conversation about one of your clients which we won't name that has this just a super differentiated products coming back to what you mentioned that are just on an absolute rocket ship right and it feels like that's still that's been the case for us as well obviously we're similar to you we have this cross-sectional view um and those with real unique value props real differentiation that are continuing to invest in product innovation just seem to be able to book every trend and still grow even if others are finding it more challenging to be honest i don't know i don't know how you'd grow a dc business without that these days though the margins are so slim like if you're in a completely saturated market i suppose what most people go to is start investing in brand and that sort of thing and just building better funnel and better brand and that sort of thing but like you know we've benefited massively just because we're the only people in the world doing what we're doing obviously the downside to that is we're a hardware business with really difficult to build but once you um once you have a differentiated product i think that does 50 percent of the work to be honest yeah i think you just you need to be cool in a sense like what
10:36Frederica Watson: you're just saying about like you need to be desirable basically in the market like if you there are loads of other brands out there that maybe have the ability to do clinicals other things maybe you don't what is it it needs to be something that desire of seeing it on someone and being like wow it's cool i want to use it because i want to have it because it's a cool thing i think like there's still merit in that especially in like the beauty fashion side of things i think Yeah, I do.
10:57Laurence Booth: I do. I do sometimes think that there are people in the market who can still trade at a really, really, really high level without not without kind of differentiation, but kind of who really understand all the levers and who are really, really deep into funnel execution and creative to an extent, maybe because they don't spend any time on the brand side and kind of the positioning side. they just want to scale and understand how to do it and I and I still come across those businesses and I'm kind of amazed by them in an amazing way but I think the vast majority of founders I speak to have you know big goals in terms of exit and and kind of what they want to think about and how they want to position in the business and I think if you do have that you have to lean into that as a strength because it's really really hard to execute to that level and keep that consistent because even those people who are able to execute it you never know what's coming the algorithm might change there might be a complete complete shift and at least with brand or positioning and having that differentiated product you have something really really tangible to fall back on
11:57Nick Kane: yeah yeah i agree yeah still you still see these we still come across them every now and then which is like this simple product just like top one percent growth or executor behind a computer 12 hours a day and that's all they're doing and they're just amazing at the the few things that create the most leverage yeah but i think that's a really unique set of skills and and is very volatile and probably is less defensible is less has less mo has less enterprise value um so yeah
12:25Laurence Booth: i think it's interesting to see how that continues to develop yeah i mean it's a weird thing to say for you know with with a bunch of executed at the table but like you kind of don't want execution to be the reason why you have to succeed or fail you want to be like planning for something different you want to have differentiation you want to have market forces you want to have you want to make the game as easy as possible to play um so so you know that's the thing we talk about
12:46Nick Kane: a lot yeah i think founders marketers take a lot of credit when they probably don't deserve it if you look at any big breakout success they drive they're sort of riding one or two big waves the classic one that everybody talks about is gym shot because that was like the first d2c successor and successor in the uk but they were riding about two or three waves at the same time like influencer early stage sort of athleisure that doesn't happen by pure execution alone that happens because you've got a good product at the right time yeah and that's an execution in itself
13:10Laurence Booth: right like they're really focused on that and they and i think the brands who are best at this spend they focus where the value accrues in their business and a lot of the value accrues to the story they're telling and kind of building the market and you do get you know the client that ollie's referring to it you know they are actually making this market they're expanding tam you know that you can see on whether it's amazon search query data or google trends data or even retail data that more people are coming to this category because of them and i and i think that is due to the quality of the execution but it's not just their ability to you know download all the saw with us uh uh execution things and go through all the steps it's it's it's also there's something intangible and there's something about how they're really positioning in the market and thinking about it that is driving it gonna go through black friday or we'll call it peak i feel like people
14:04Nick Kane: like the word peak these uh they don't know primarily because primarily because it's no longer like four days it's like two months yeah um before we do that so i'm going to break that down into i want to touch on strategy offer media planning creative and then just any little tactical bits before before the end of this this episode and hopefully people watching hopefully a lot of people watching have actually got their plans set in stone i feel like if you're watching this podcast and then going away to change your black friday stop watching that's a lesson you can take forward to next year that's probably not what you want to be building them but um just to before we do that i think um one thing i've been noticing especially we've had we always get this like last um i guess like two weeks of brands that are like panicking coming to us uh either changing plans or like looking to switch agency which again shouldn't be doing that in october um save save that for jan you're gonna lose about six clients but and one of the the theme that i'm seeing in these businesses that i actually think is going to and i think if you've if you've been experiencing this challenge i'd be interested to know if you if you guys have at any point that i think is going to really limit growth and impact through this period is this consistent issue with like new reach through primarily facebook but a lot of these brands are very reliant on that as a channel as their main awareness driver like the opposite i saw a business the other day that's basically all influencer marketing so they're doing that somewhere else i feel like that's been a challenge that is that almost every business i've spoken to has wrestled with at some part of this year i'm just wondering if you guys have faced that at any point the reason i think it's going to compound into q4 is because it's really hard to fix and you become more reliant on lower funnel traffic when you go into an offer period um is that something you've
15:57Laurence Booth: Yeah, I mean, I'm seeing it across multiple people. It feels like the buzzword of this year of how people think about incremental reach. We all get those incremental reach reports from meta reps. They get sent through. There's a nice stacked bar chart and it shows either you're a good boy or a bad boy.
16:14Nick Kane: I saw my first 0 % the other day. 0 %? 0 % for three months.
16:20Laurence Booth: But I think it's driving a lot of like everyone's decisions in terms of media buying and people. And I think it's a factor of this new world that we're living in where, you know, potentially we just have to start thinking about media buying slightly differently. My experience of kind of thinking and seeing this over so many years is that you kind of always have to rethink. And this is a big focus. And so working with clients, a lot of people are trying to understand what are the big tactics that drive that. And so from my perspective, there's sort of been three. The first one that everyone talks about is partnership ads.
16:55Laurence Booth: like hooking on to other people's reach is is massive and we've seen really big turnarounds and incremental reach through kind of leaning into partnership ads which includes like influencer and even celebrity which is another big theme that people talk about uh the second thing is obviously this kind of creative diversity world of how do you build out personas and also like new types of creative even considering putting sort of top of funnel style creatives into conversion ad sets to start building awareness through that through that uh through that channel and so putting putting ads that kind of tell your story into your meta account even if they have a conversion journey uh to to kind of bring different types of people into the funnel and the final thing is for the first time since i started doing this i have found myself uttering the words have you considered running an awareness campaign on meta um and have you considered youtube i was saying like i'm not sure and i think this is ollie and i've talked about this is kind of like the last resort maybe you need to to build this in and and i but but for the first time a for me jury's out on whether these things are actually starting to be effective and i and i'm less bullet like less belligerent about that being as as as bad an idea as i thought it used to be but then also just working with customers and working with businesses to think about how you build that in how you build that view of like building awareness into other channels so starting to run a lot more on youtube thinking about tiktok where where are you going to find that top of funnel awareness that can help your meta ads find those new people who are maybe just very early in the purchase journey so that's how i'm thinking about it have you guys seen that
18:33Nick Kane: play out this year you're a little bit more i guess you've got tiktok shop which i think is another one that's that's been a real like um driver of value especially within that landscape where some brands have struggled with it a lot of them have turned to tiktok shop to sort of raise the ceiling yeah it really supports but yeah yeah it's a difficult one you need to make sure that
18:50Frederica Watson: it's having an impact on the channels because the pnl doesn't look pretty i think we all know that um it's just making sure that what you're doing there is like you know you're seeing the impact for example on amazon or you know other channels you may have um but i agree i think people look inside the ad account but we all know like cac is lowered outside so it's what are you doing outside of the ad account even if that is just like influencer a lot of brands haven't really gone as deep maybe into it as they need to and partnership ads i always want to see like 30 percent of spend going towards partnership ads for sure especially in like a premium positioning where seeing your product with someone like whether it's a celebrity or like an influence that they trust is going to make the difference um but i have found that following actually doesn't really in a way you can get away with having a lot of smaller people even if they've just got a few thousand followers it still gives really great signals and it's actually showing that okay we're finding new people here it doesn't all need to be like massive one million followers again so I think having a mix of both and can be really good and now there's like platforms like tribe that basically turns like you know tiktok shop affiliate you can do that for meta now so yeah it's having a lot of that and I think for me it's I always talk about this middle of funnel on tiktok for me it's like if you've got a product and someone's going to be looking up on tiktok a lot of people do right if they see you they're like oh I want to see about this or maybe they're just in category um if they don't see someone posting a video but that answers their own questions or their own reasons that maybe they wouldn't buy then you've lost that customer so you just want to make sure that your brief you have quite a lot of different briefs based on the personas that you have and even the questions that might have like i had this example the other day that i was talking about which is like fake tan i was kind of looking at some brands and then when i searched the specific brand in tiktok literally a video came up with some girl saying oh yeah this good because you don't sweat off in the gym and i was like that's exactly why i was thinking of not buy so it's almost like you need to have these and and that content each piece of content answers one question that someone has like another one for the same brand was a girl like spraying on her white shirt saying it doesn't transfer that could be someone else's main reason for not buying so figure out the reasons people don't buy and then make sure you've got all that content there so just fill the funnel that way it doesn't all need to be just like yeah like i've been using it you know it's like let's get into the core reasons why someone might not buy and make sure we answer those questions across channels because then you might see your meta ad and then see that and think oh actually I will convert because you know it can't you know you can't answer every question in one ad so you know especially if you do a lot of branded stuff make sure you're answering those questions elsewhere and TikTok's a really good place for that because you can do your affiliates
21:11Nick Kane: on the shop really easily and quickly so yeah very intentional we we've sold it mainly through partnership ads like you said you're in other people's audience the interesting thing so I spent a Saturday reading one of your notion documents about what creative diversity actually means and it's you that put me onto this i think a lot of brands look at ads and they they probably rent out a studio and they do about 50 different ads maybe with different actors in the same day in the same environment but from what i understand of the docs that you sent was that you need a completely different environment completely different messaging it's not as easy just renting an airbnb for a day and just like renting through 19 different creators is actual creative diversity the thing that's i mean it's a phenomena that you sort of encounter once you're at large scale the benefit that we've got um is that we're a high aov so if we have like 10 000 customers in one year that's a phenomenal year for us right and so it's not something that we've struggled with that much yet but we do start to see like we've got an internal creator who does a lot of uh ads in in the sort of basement office underneath our studio and um we see that yeah yeah we see that those ads start to they don't perform quite the same ways like the truly diversified ads with different creators different like sort of problems that sort of stuff so yeah yeah nice i think that's going to be an issue for a lot of businesses watching this and it's really hard to solve um
22:29Laurence Booth: yeah i was gonna i was gonna say like just just the the not to not to pour water on this particular fire but the other thing that i think is hard to deal with is from from what i've seen um incremental reach is really valuable and very important and we know that it is and it counts to long-term account health and the ability to bring these things but in month there is no correlation between cpmr or frequency or incremental reach and performance in that month or at least not from what i've seen i mean you might you see more accounts like a leading so it's all about leading indicators and then you get back into this world of sort of you're almost immediately back into the world of attribution and brand spend and how do we actually think about this and is it is our cadence for bringing this in a 28 day buying cadence or a 60 day buying cadence and i think this is probably very in the weeds but but from a media buying perspective it does almost require you to think a little bit like a brand marketer say okay well i've got my future buying bucket and i'm doing stuff for future buying and i know that that's that the reason why i care about doing this stuff whether it's like i'm gonna do these partnership ads specifically to bring incremental reach in but i've still got to run my bottom of funnel really effectively um and you kind of have to balance the fact that you're kind of investing a bit um because it might not yield immediate performance i think some people now think it's like all i have to do is get my incremental reach report up my cac's going to go down by like 25 it's just not true i think it's all about starting to think about this more holistically i think meta and all these platforms are forcing us to be real real marketers performance forcing like performance people to start thinking really full funnel thinking about conversion journeys thinking about real customers thinking about real products like a thousand pound product is going to take quite a while for someone to part with their money for so it's okay that that that purchase journey is long um and you need to kind of almost build your funnel around around that rather than just thinking god what am i going to launch in the ad account tomorrow um which i think is like making things complex but also more interesting it's another
24:21Nick Kane: two-hour podcast yeah yeah sorry sorry yeah a bit of a segue but wanted to touch on that before we get into the meat of of the period i guess like starting with strategy like what we always i think it's easy to talk tactics through black friday cyber monday it's easy to talk about what content are we going to make but but i think like or how are we going to buy in the ad account are we going to spend what does what do our offers look like per day etc but i don't think enough brands spend enough time thinking about what is the objective and what what are you trying to achieve so i'd love to hear a bit about like what are your guys uh business's main objective and also like what how is your understanding of like a good black friday period changed since you first started in e-commerce like everyone must have got sucked into chasing those those juicy revenue numbers at some point still be not looking not looking at that bottom line and just like um so i'd love to yeah maybe start with yourself nick again yeah get yourself a good cfo i'd say shout out to ancus ancus batia um yeah just i mean i think you just nailed it it's like decides what you're trying to achieve and what you're trying to achieve is make money right i think when we it depends it also depends whether you're vc backed or not i think and it depends what game you're playing it depends on the category as well if you're playing the vc back hyperscale exit for multiple figure multiple revenue i don't think that actually exists anymore to be honest from what i hear in the ddc space like that whole you know blitz scale and then multiple of revenue sell to union lever like greens have done like the investors that we speak to these days they want a cash flow in business they want to see profitability if they don't see profitability they want to see an immediate path to profitability within 12 months the dynamics change since i started in the industry about 12 years ago um in terms of us what we're trying to achieve i mean there's some very specific things we're trying to double our uk revenue year on year from november we're launching the us in december last year and it's already about 30 percent of our sales we're trying to hit our first million pound month in the us but what that means really is from ground up instead of like two years ago it's just kind of revenue or costs and scale as much as possible within like a three four times row as it's more like what's your cm3 what's your cm2 what's your cm1 how much stock do we need how how far in advance do we need to forecast that stock we've got these you know these mirrors take two weeks to make or something so it's like you know we've got forecast this well in advance but uh i think the revenue is actually more of a secondary target especially now like we're out of the raising money era now it's about actually building the business it's less about the vanity of chasing top level metrics we can all share on on linkedin and more about like how do we actually make money and what does our ongoing path to profitability look like year on year and are we are we getting further or closer to that so um yeah that's what we're trying to achieve we're actually trying to high quality revenue rather than just loads of it i think that's the that's the trap i i was going to ask is bfc ever trap for wellness and subscription brands maybe maybe another i don't think so i mean i think for me
27:11Frederica Watson: like what we're focusing on i think what from why i can see what they've done this year it's just scooping up the demand that already exists because there's a lot of work to be done on the evergreen offers that they run and the website and things like that so i think a lot of people have seen the brand have they necessarily been convinced to convert maybe not so this is the time to scoop up that demand that exists and obviously like we're in a saturated category so there's a lot of people already market anyway so let's get that you know people who are already there right so choose us instead um and then also from like a retention side it's just making sure that subscribers have something as well because you know as i said it's not i've you know worked for brands that don't have that subscription element in the past so it's just making sure that we're doing what we need to to make sure that we not only make them feel like we have something for them but also how can we lock them in for longer as well um because you know at that time you still want to spend money but you'll subscribe with us especially because we don't have a lot of things to cross sell there's a couple of products you might use alongside but mainly it's you know the product that does everything which is obviously a good and a bad thing it has a pros and cons um so it's just about how can we actually lock them in for longer and make sure that you know we get more months out of the subscriber because also it's just gonna be good for them and especially people who've just subscribed the longer you stay on as we were saying earlier but the better benefits you're gonna see so it's just having both of those things um going at once but i think i agree in terms of looking at the numbers and really because i think in the past what i've seen brands do or it's just like oh we're just gonna throw everything out of all the gifts in the world but it's like but how much is this actually costing because people are gonna buy like they're really primed to buy speaking on black friday people just want to spend money so actually is it going to make the difference to have that extra gift that's costing you three pounds an extra three pounds you know especially because my background also coming in from mass like margins are tight it's like that three pounds could be the difference so just don't go too heavy without doing the numbers you know it's get excited and be like yeah we'll give all this stuff but you know let's just have a look and make sure this still makes sense for us because people are more likely to buy so we don't need to go too crazy as long as you've got good offer and you know what you're doing from like a you know whatever your channel main channels are then i think you can do
29:17Nick Kane: it without having to give away too much yeah i think we've we've we've seen a nice decrease in subscription brand discounting heavier which i think is a very big positive because whenever we've seen people do that the cohort value is just horrendous um i do think we're seeing we're seeing more utilization of what you mentioned sort of like 90 day supplies six month supplies all about aob gwps yeah do you think there's maybe a bit too much gift we're purchasing on it's like you have a gift you have a gift just like everyone's getting gifts
29:47Frederica Watson: these bundles are insane like yeah 90 days and then you get like half their catalog for free
29:52Laurence Booth: i just don't understand if it works i think i think uh yeah i i mean it's interesting i've i've been doing quite a lot of work in and around this area but i really agree that um quality of revenue and quality of cohort in a subscription brand especially like how you measure your quality of cohort is the most important thing you should be thinking about um and yet we are all getting slightly sick of of everyone kind of offering more and more crazy bundles but at the same time i i think there's there's actually a lot of value in it and what i've been looking at with you know there are some some businesses i've been working with where actually if you if you look at the cohorts of different bundles and what they what they worked on there is actually really different cohort behavior and i think it speaks to how you message it and what the bundle is there for and the value and the utility of those products like maybe the kind of random gift you chuck in is not nearly as volume as valuable as the very very uh complementary product that you've made to go around this or maybe actually if you tell a really clear story about the value proposition of that bundle um you can actually get discount led discount led or bundle led cohorts that retain at a high quality and and and i think that you know you're completely right like basically you You know, lots of people want to buy stuff on Black Friday and you want to participate up to the point where you can capture that demand and not necessarily beyond.
31:12Laurence Booth: So a lot of what I think about and trying to get my my kind of clients to think about is a what's the game we're playing and then what kind of customer we want to go and acquire. And let's go and focus on acquiring the customers that we care about that we think are going to be high value. And, you know, whether if you know, I'm a really big believer, partly from kind of clinical studies. right like these 90 day on a in a supplement most supplements take a long time to work you see benefits after a long extended period of time if you can tell that story really effectively you're actually getting people who acquire who get the right amount of products and actually what we see in some businesses i'm working with like those those those product those those cohorts tend to retain slightly better so okay then our black friday strategy is really about going getting those customers and focusing on that um i think it's really important i agree i think the
32:01Nick Kane: complimentary product that deepens the outcome yeah if it makes it if it makes it work it's like is the holy grail for this for this for the subscription um health and wellness businesses
32:11Laurence Booth: i think it gives you differentiation as well like especially in the in a bfcm world like doing like a 25 off site wide sale is sort of not that interesting anymore i think building story building stuff around doing almost you know i wouldn't say necessarily unique products but but but potentially kind of uniquely positioned bundles and things for that moment that can get you a story that can cut through, I think is actually really nice. And I think a lot of what you're trying to do is you're in a very loud market. How do you cut through? How do you provide value? And how do you also just not lose that customer to just discount?
32:46Frederica Watson: Yeah, I think the best thing you could do, it would be to have a unique product or a unique collaboration. That would probably be my dream scenario. So the Jones Road example is the one that I always think about is those like mini minis that they only do that time of year. like that's perfect because like you're not cannibalizing anything you're getting people on something new it's like something people wait for if you can have something like that a bit late for a collab now but maybe for next year um i think something that's unique like a unique product
33:09Nick Kane: would be amazing yeah not one of those whisks that everyone sells
33:16Nick Kane: the fact that you can take revive collagen straight from the sachet i'm like right well
33:23Frederica Watson: the bottle's out, the shaker's out, everything's out.
33:27Nick Kane: I actually think that 90 days, we're getting a lot of success with some of those mechanisms that we've just mentioned post-purchase at the moment and really building out like VSL-led funnels. So experts telling you why you should move from 30 to 90 days. So I think that we're going to see a lot of that. I feel like you can smell it though, to be honest. You can smell it when brands are doing it because it's the brand thing to do, but that doesn't mean it translates to like, that's what the consumer needs to do. if you've got clinical data you need 90 days to get you know use out of this product then yeah go for it but like if you're just another brand that's saying the best case scenario is if you do it for 90 days and you'll see but you only see it after 90 it's like you can kind of sniff it you know especially when you're like it's i don't know whatever it's like a hydration type thing you need to need to wait 90 days to get effective hydration probably not yeah but then but then i
34:13Laurence Booth: can also just to play devil's advocate because i do agree with you yeah i think i think just thinking almost pnl led like if you're in a game of cac aov and ltv and like you've got to get some kind of ability to play this game and like your current your current median cac is like basically one-to-one first purchase roas you're in a really difficult position unless you can find a way to get to get that aov up and i think that's what people are trying to also solve for which is and and and so then the challenge comes to the point of like because because i think too many brands look at their kind of model and say well what happens is cac needs to go like go half at the most busy time of year and then we'll all be fine and it's like i think that's a much harder game to play than trying to sit in a room and say okay how do we provide value to customers in a way that can get them to spend more money because actually what we've seen is if you do that well your cac doesn't increase but your aov can go up by 20 25 30 and that's that's huge um for you and your ability to flow cash back in the back into the brand and then build back because remember you get three months of cash on day one and then six months of cash on month three and that's like massive for your for your ability to scale it's hard to do i think if you're i think people are
35:24Frederica Watson: going to go a bit too early it's like if you don't have many reviews built up it's a bit difficult to sell someone on 90 days yeah do you know what i mean like it's almost like at the beginning i think you're really early just try and get some orders in at the door first because if you're trying to sell someone 90 days out the gate it's like you're not really getting anything back like get some orders in maybe if you're launching a new market just see what's going on like what is it taking like what kind of offers do you need to get them in through the front door like what kind of ads what kind of landing pages etc so yeah 100 is gold standard but i think people will try a bit too early looking at like ima are they doing 90 days yeah well they can you know because people
35:56Nick Kane: will spend them on it you also price out a lot of the market yeah which i think is something people I don't think about enough. It's like, as you go up in AOV and remove the ability to transact at lower AOV, you force out a lot of customers, which there's pros and cons to that depending on how you look at it, but not appreciated most. Anyone got any like howlers they've had over this period that they want to share? Any real stinkers?
36:18Laurence Booth: Running out of stock or two days before Black Friday. Running Black Friday offers two days before Black Friday, run out of stock. Had to like make up a bunch of bundles, put them on a website, merchandise them and sell them within like 24 hours that was stressful
36:32Nick Kane: yeah that's a howler pretty much I mean that's the big one isn't it which run out of stock I think the times when we've done the worst is always when we do the most complex offer which makes perfect sense it's obvious but like often brands do stuff that's good for the brand not the customer but not for the customer so it's like right we've got all this stock that we need to shift let's bundle that into our Black Friday offer because we need to get rid of that stock and then you know the sales are going to come in but it didn't work out that way because the customers don't need it the example for us what we could do at Black Friday would be we've got a mirror we sell accessories with it so you can buy dumbbells and bench but we know that 40 of our customers already have their own dumbbells and bench right yeah so we could bundle the dumbbells in and say you know if you buy those you get a massive discount but then to your point you just eliminate half the time because it's like they don't need them and i can't get your offer without without you know that's crap i don't need all the dumbbells aren't crap though they're great
37:24Frederica Watson: yeah anything tiered even like if i have to think about hang on how much do i need to spend to get this discount wait if there's multiple codes forget it like forget it like you just it needs to be super simple even putting the price even just saying 30 tell them how much they would have spent and how much they're going to spend now and even how much is per day versus what it would have been because if i have to work it out i think i think this is actually just if you're talking
37:45Laurence Booth: about is bfcm a trap like i think the trap of this is the complexity and the the stuff that the absolute knots you can twist yourself into trying to take advantage of this thing and you have to remember that we are actually in peak and you know we've just had prime day that was a great opportunity even if you're not on amazon to talk about a really high purchase intent moment we've got christmas we've got uh you know even q5 coming up after that and and you as a business and probably a lot of people listening to this are running pretty lean teams they've got they you know and and most d2c businesses die because of complexity rather than uh rather than starvation right like they need to they focus is everything and so you need to make your life as simple as possible and that's better for the customer that's better for you and i'm probably similar to you i've had i've had i was running we were running um i was once running a weighted blankets and hoodie blankets business which i know well ollie knows well and we had a lot of this where they were like you know you buy three you get another two but if you buy four you might get 25 off on top of that and you get a free thing and even just managing the back end of that took so long and then suddenly we were into christmas we didn't have anything for that because we focused for so long on trying to work out this black friday thing we we'd barely merchandise the next set stage and so so i do think there's a little bit of like keeping it simple in general is really really important
39:08Nick Kane: exactly and nail it and back to what you said before about like just why what you're doing it for there's been so many times with different brands where we've done an analysis at the end of the period and we're like we would have made the exact same amount of money as in like actual money made profit if we just didn't do it yeah we just sat there and just like you know maybe sacrifice 20 less sales but like we've all been busy we've packed thousands of orders we've all been stressed out and then spending planning for 2027 instead and had a bigger year exactly yeah i think what i was going to that i was it was quite a nice segue onto offer without me having to prompt it but i think um we've talked like very top line strategy like what we're trying to achieve i think it's important that brands get that super clear because then it trickles through everything tactical offer being the biggest right there's an epidemic of poorly positioned offers in the market right now a lot of its complexity a lot of its brand speaking like a brand like explaining a product like in the most technical way possible like peptide xyz it's like rather than through the lens of like actual customer language um but i think and i think this like almost multiplies through Black Friday again because of what you mentioned like tiered discounting I think it's like try to put yourself, I always try and think through like my grandma's shoes, maybe a bit too old but like uses the her phone on like 52 size font with one finger and it's like you've got these e-combros with these like sliders I don't think you even need to do that though
40:36Laurence Booth: you literally just go on Instagram and experience it as a customer yourself and you'll be like I don't think nearly enough people who spend this much time, as much time as we do in platform and thinking about this stuff, actually just go and look at their own purchasing habits and go like, oh, actually, I don't think about the kind of levels of this stuff. I think much more about, oh, that sounds like a product I really need. That sounds like a problem I have. I want to solve it with this thing. And, oh, yeah, it's a good deal. Maybe this is the time to buy. I don't know. Maybe it's as simple as that.
41:06Nick Kane: Yeah, I agree. Just like simplification. Less is more. um again i've been caught out by trying to overcomplicate offers it makes everything complicated right it makes the customer journey complicated it makes stock complicated it's just adds a lot of complexity um i suppose that does slightly jar with the
41:25Laurence Booth: whole question about differentiation at the same time and i that probably is a bit of balance like the simplest thing to do is say 20 off site wide and maybe or like 10 off site wide or or maybe nothing right but like something that's kind of broad based and easy and maybe again depending on your market but let's let's say for example you're in a very you know commoditized supplement market whether it's creatine or collagen or whatever there are going to be everyone giving giving that so you kind of have to find your way to do the simple thing that also cuts through so i suppose that is the balance i just think like you've got to have a good campaign
42:02Frederica Watson: you know it's not just about like 20 like what is the photo shoot like what are you actually doing what's the content that's going to go out on social media how does that carry across the site so we're doing a big campaign for black friday and we're also carrying that into a tiktok live as well and it's going to be dressed up in the same way like it's fun like it's fun for the consumer it's cool content i think that you're right how else are you going to do it your offer is going to be similar let's be honest to other brands out there but how can you have content that's actually entertaining and someone's gonna be like oh it's actually really fun like i'm gonna click and see what they've got going on rather than just like 30 on a red square a few statics
42:36Laurence Booth: you're starting to think like a real marketer just careful you want to be thinking
42:41Frederica Watson: statics minus 30 there's room for that as well yeah but yeah so quick one before we get into it
42:48Nick Kane: if you're growing a brand you're probably trying to optimize everything right you test hooks you're watching your performance metrics you're trying to shave a few quid off your costs of goods you're even hunting for a better rate on shipping. You're squeezing everything you can to improve your margins. But what if you could do the same on the money that's leaving your account every single month for the expenses that you're making? This episode sponsor is Incard, a financial platform that's built for digital businesses. And essentially, it helps you get more out of what you're spending. Right now, they're giving you 2 % cash back on your first year of ads, SaaS, travel, and even everyday business spend, all uncapped.
43:25Nick Kane: So the money that you're already spending, it starts to pull its weight like everything else that you obsess over within your business. You also get multi-currency accounts, corporate cards, and Shopify meta, and Xero connected all in one place, which for me is massive because having to go to all of these different places is a bit of a nightmare. Brands like Soul, Allo Paris, Asio Beauty, Ancway, they're already using InCard to save on their everyday expenses. Sign up for free, use the code SWU2K26 to unlock 2 % cash back for a full year. Links in the description. Back to the episode. How do you think consumer expectations have shifted like in now versus maybe like say four or five years ago?
44:13Nick Kane: I feel like Black Friday, like people are more aware, educated, sophisticated in many ways. There's still a need to keep it simple. But yeah, has anyone got any thoughts on like how, any of the meaningful ways that's really developed i mean i have a different maybe
44:30Laurence Booth: like adjacent take which i think is that i think we're seeing more and more of these discount events be meaningful in part because of economic pressure i think a lot more people are saving up for i mean i did this year like pre-prime day i had six things on my amazon basket i was i was the first time I ever done it I was basket watching just saying okay what's going to come come down I had three options for a product whichever one's going to be better deal I'll take it and I think that we are now going into a moment where economic pressures are high enough that yeah okay I think part of it is education but I also think part of it is that people are looking for value from brands and it kind of comes to this question of like should you play shouldn't you the one of the reasons I think commercial rate is going to go up is because this is the moment where people are like right okay this is the day I'm going to actually get a good deal and that's what I want because I really really want this product but I'm going to wait for them to do the deal because because maybe this is just how my my personal balance sheet like lets me think about shopping um maybe that's too macro a point but I do think it's a part of it so I don't think it's just education I think it's also I think life I think that's true
45:38Nick Kane: it's not too macro I mean I think that's pretty much first principles in it like people have less money they're gonna spend it's interesting though like um we have this debate I mean I've had this multiple different brands was like how late how early or how late do you go i think somebody made the point that we do it in i've read the script um so like the argument for going late i don't know what the argument for going late is actually somebody can tell me but the argument for going early is that you're going to capture the market and you're going to miss out and especially when you're in a competitive environment yeah like if you've got somebody that's selling the exact same products as you if they go a week before you you're going to lose out all those customers like drag revenue this is the thing which is why it gets gets further and further the obvious thing to say which we all know in terms of like just to your question is like consumers just know now they know the routine they know the extra discounts they know the staggered discounts like i've never fully understood the tiered approach where you get more and more discount closer to the time because like i mean people just know they're just going to keep waiting we just hit our best offer at the start but we're explicitly clear that this is the best offer there will be yeah so don't wait like you just got to say that and they haven't tried the opposite best best offer at the start and
46:39Frederica Watson: gets worse if you've got a big catalog i think you can do different things so like okay we know that we're going to capture this x customer at the beginning but then maybe i'll buy again so when i was at nip and fab it was always like because we had like quite a big skew count it was like how can we get someone who actually someone could actually buy all three offers like think about what would make them buy three times um because obviously we just wanted to maximize remember as much as we could so i think as if you have other products to play with it's a good thing to just say like okay well actually could someone buy every single offer um obviously it makes it more difficult if you're just doing deeper discounting on friday but you've got to do something extra on friday if you've been running since the beginning of the month
47:16Nick Kane: you're like going too early just puts so much pressure on new customer and like because you just rinse all of your repeat customer base and you get this like peak and then this natural decline and then you'll get the second peak on friday i think you have to
47:30Laurence Booth: be prepared for that though if you're going to go early you kind of have to model it say because I've done we've done kind of wait lists and early access and all those things and you do you know that there are just like natural peaks and troughs and if you're willing to accept that as how you're going to go but you're going to drag all that revenue early you're going to guarantee it someone's going to spend that 50 quid on you rather versus someone else then you kind of have to just go eyes wide open the worst thing would be to you know model your black friday that starts early 10 20 days before and just goes like that if you're if you're going to do that tactic I just I think you kind of have to be really eyes wide open about it, which maybe is important for people to know.
48:06Nick Kane: Yeah, 100%. When are you starting? Anyone want to go? We're going to start. I think it's been on sale for two weeks. So we went to retail this year, and we're in Curry's. We're in John Lewis from about 50 different stores across the UK, and Curry's have decided to go in October. And given that our product is in Curry's, if they're going to get an increase in demand, they're going to see our product is like, well, I can't buy it. So now we're in this space where we're no longer just a pure play DTC.
48:31Frederica Watson: we've got retail as well so we're kind of getting dragged into it which has been weird for us
48:35Nick Kane: because we've always been a super tight lean team that can do whatever we want and now we've got these sort of yeah this sort of pull of retail on us we've had a shocker with some degree being being dictated by that um again it's different for our product though because there's no real downside to going early like we're not really in a competitive environment we're not selling multiple products to your point like we kind of go whenever um but yeah because of retail we're going a bit early this year probably start of november one thing we do see though is every year i always look out for prime days that the amazon prime when they launch their offer and you look at google trends you see like the search intent for black friday offers spike on that day so historically at different brands with multiple products that's the date that i've used as like the kickoff tracked it back five years what amazon what have amazon done every year and use that but yeah for us we're going quite early this year we've had we've had a few shockers with retailers and clients where like boots has just gone on sale and we've lost 500 new customers a day to them bidding on brand terms and it's like you just have to and we had to try and get that in two days pulled it all forward and like scrambled to i could speak for three days about this and it's just but with retail as well the other thing you're paying them a commission yeah obviously like for product like ours most of the demand has been generated by our ads so you know they see our ads they then google us yes compete on google shopping so go to john so i'm going to go there instead we pay jr the commission so yeah i'd be interested to know what
49:56Frederica Watson: you guys think but anyway yeah it's that it's tricky um having a good relationship with them to make sure you know when the offers are happening it's obviously helpful and exactly what it's going to be but that isn't always possible obviously um i think it's just for me it's always been like obviously under like helping the business to understand the what meta spend actually generates and helping them to understand like it's not just like dc play if we're like you know in every store you can go into um then we're going to be driving that so it's just not ensuring that it's not cut you can't just look at it it's just like the cat that you have because you've got stores and people are going to be going into boots or especially if you are selling online with these retailers yeah like it's highly available that's the most difficult part um it's always a conversation you have i think when you go into a brand it's just to be like let's just like look at it as a whole business for a sec especially when everybody wants to put things under the dcp and our influencer spend all these things like we are impacting retail as well so we just have to make sure we're all looking at it together which is great when you have lean teams because you can all come together and really like help the business to understand how that spend affects the whole um business especially if the best is if you have some kind of underperforming skew in retail you're like i'm gonna prove this you know give me some money to prove it um and then you can show that actually we can drive yeah i mean it comes to data
51:09Laurence Booth: fundamentals as well i mean so many businesses even even at quite significant scale are struggling with their ability to house all their data in the right in one place have some understanding of attribution that's omni-channel which you know lots of mta solutions struggle with um and make some decisions about how they're going to think about the complexity of of omni um of omni-channel um to to the question about about time and uh and how to go how to go early i think i think the The thing that I'm finding really interesting this year made me work because last year I was working with kind of businesses more in the kind of beauty and skin care space.
51:48Laurence Booth: Going back to the supplement space this year, some supplement companies are thinking about this much more as like preparing for January. But January is peak for health and wellness. So actually the question is which offers start to work so we can get the right cohorts to actually go really hard in January? And how do we play the game enough to then build for a real story? and that comes back to this question of like is this a trap or what should you be doing it the question is what game are you playing and how and where do you actually think you're going to win and if if your bet is actually more people are going to buy my product in January when it's kind of like there's a big health and wellness trend CPMs are going to be lower there it's going to be a less competitive market for for other people's attention I'm going to just like put all my eggs in that basket then Black Friday looks really really different to you and I think seeing that play out and some people are in that world some people are much more in the kind of well we're going to gift we're all about ritual we're going to gift in this different way um you know that that that i think has been really interesting to see so i think it depends on what you're trying to get out of it which if you're really going to trade it 100 go early do i would i i'm a bit still a big advocate for list building lead gen all of those things to go early do early access dragging a lot of that stuff forward and building that awareness of offers great but if you're not then maybe you don't want to play that game and you need to plan for something else and that's okay.
53:06Laurence Booth: But just kind of be really clear with your team about where you're actually going to think you're going to win and what you're planning for.
53:12Nick Kane: I agree on the Q5. December the 26th is the Black Friday for Southampton Browns. It blows my mind how much that kicks off. I do think the CPM point is like, if you are going to be more exposed to a CPM increase, the benefit of launching and going early to offset that is possibly worth it. I think it's very dependent on the business though. We'll see how it plays out. Creative, our favourite topic on the podcast. I have to go. Luca's not here. Shout out to Luca. I'll try and do him justice. But like, obviously, we've created volume, created diversity. It's been a journey this year in terms of like, um even where we sit on that on that debate but like how are you approaching this sort of tactical channel creative through the period what's what's what's your yeah what's been your preparation
54:12Frederica Watson: i think uh especially for me like coming into somewhere new it's just like we everybody talks about the creative supply chain and making sure that you have the different areas of where that's coming from um especially with lean teams like it's not just what it was back in the days like one designer who's doing everything you need to have a few different avenues of where that's coming from um so as we were saying one could be those kind of partnership ads you don't have to do much there just obviously the relationships and making sure that you've got people that you feel like are really you know relatable for that one persona that you have for example and then there could be ugc like getting even your typical shop creators if you're running it you know get the ability to run that meta like make sure you can get the rights and then run all that on meta as well so that's your ugc covered then you might have like we haven't talked about ai once ai static ad generation systems like you know um maybe you've got like a system for generating statics that you want to use and then maybe it's more okay our social team are going to go out on the street and do some like social content and we use that so it's like making sure you've got all these different avenues um and obviously you have to work with other people in the teams to do that like everybody has to have their part to play for bringing in content um and even running stuff that just gets posted organically on your own instagram or if you have like fake Instagram accounts where you run content and then run it back as partnership ads and things like that.
55:25Frederica Watson: So I think just making sure you've got all those avenues covered, that gives you the diversity instead of just thinking like high prod, low prod. For me, it's more like where's it coming from?
55:35Nick Kane: Street interviews are on the comeback somehow. I feel like they were too back. I thought you did loads of those. We used to do loads of them two years ago, but they're so back. It's very weird. It's very weird how these trends are.
55:44Frederica Watson: I feel like it's really hard to tell someone, like go and get a street interview because like audio is terrible. It's not like anyone
55:50Nick Kane: can do it like you need to try doing them on the tube that's even more even harder to get a screeching um you mentioned quickly i just want to i wasn't going to touch on this but i will because you brought it up creators you you've obviously got this tiktok shop yeah um of the business how are you incentivizing them over that period like have you got an offer i assume you've got an offer for them or yeah i mean we don't have a group at the moment that we would like you know
56:15Frederica Watson: have like a discord with or anything like whether they're not at those levels it's just like sending loads of samples and seeing what comes back you know it's like what hits and but we have got a few people that have worked on meta so now we're like okay we're going back to them what can we do with you guys work with you more maybe like pay you put your retainer get x amount of content a month or whatever you know so um it's definitely something you want to build i want to have that for next year for sure um is being able to like activate people same from an affiliate's perspective like is that something we're still growing um but i think it's just more about trying to have like yeah that variety of briefs because you don't know what's going to work so i think brands are just sending the same brief which i understand because in your head you think oh but i want them to see the same thing again and again but if someone who doesn't resonate with that sees that again and again that's not going to change their mind so i think just make sure you've got that diversity of briefs and diversity of people who you're actually sending out to it's not always
57:01Laurence Booth: the same person i do i think there's also something where where there there's there's a lot of value in building depth of relationship with creators that really resonate for you and that that works I think all the way up and down the stack so whether that's the really small kind of uh TikTok shop affiliate all the way through to potential kind of celebrity or kind of high influence ambassadors the the depth of relationship is really valuable because then you get more connection between you and the brand and from them and their brand they actually if I think the content becomes more authentic over time then they can start to do specific offers they can start to speak to their audience and I think that there is you know we we kind of entered the period where everyone's like we need to do those partnership ads they're going to go really broad and i think that can work but i'm starting to think much more about how you almost go narrower and more deep so that you're working with people and they they kind of start to really build momentum and the connection to their brand and that's like and i think especially as you go up the chain you start to think about bigger and bigger and bigger influences i think that's
57:59Frederica Watson: really important i think a lot of brands have these community groups where it's just like people who love your brand and they're just like yeah but they just love us they talk about us i'm like yeah but what if you actually incentivize them yeah because i think a lot of people are like a bit scared to do that because they're like but they just love the brand they talk about it organically i'm like yeah but if you were actually giving them as incentive they talk about it more even more and i think you'd be and you're giving something back as well so use that community that you already have of people who love the brand because brands often have that just sitting there which you know they might do a couple social posts here and there but like use them i think yeah
58:28Nick Kane: treat them as mini cmos really in my opinion and also like once you get them to the and you can get the best ones to then become the coach of the community and it becomes like the self-fulfilling ecosystem of of output that gets better over time i feel like that's something that really wasn't present last year and i'm really interested to see how the brands use that because some of them are like some of them are incentivizing them to make hundreds of assets a week so it'll be interesting to see like how that plays out over this period when they're obviously going to go really hard on on volume and output and how that then flows out of tiktok shop into meta yeah i
59:05Frederica Watson: mean sometimes it's difficult to get p especially if you're like earlier stage it can be difficult to get people to want to like get gift your product get your product right but the more that you go live and the more you do things like that the more you're acting on tiktok yourself the better it is because they're seeing you they're like okay they're active they're doing this you know make sure you've got lots of good examples and maybe pay people to do it initially that can be like your flagship or she's done this piece of content look how good this is then people have something to use as like a benchmark of i'm gonna make something like that and also don't be i don't know i think we just need to think more creative ways of instead of just being like we were saying earlier like this is the product and i'm drinking it it's like how can you leverage the celebrity stuff you've got for someone to sit there and go oh did you see this celebrity used it you could literally brince that like medicube did with the whatever they paid like one of the kardashians it's like then they've got like hundreds of thousands of creators talking about it it's like that one kardashian post probably did absolutely nothing hundreds of thousands of people talking about it.
59:57Frederica Watson: It's like, oh, this... It's an amazing brand.
59:59Laurence Booth: How do you balance that on the TikTok shop side, though, with the kind of, as the P &L can be quite messy on TikTok shop and quite difficult. So you say you've got your kind of, if you want to go really hard and you've got your affiliate thing and you're an early brand and you kind of want to win BFCM. So you're going to have like top tier discounts. I'm going to take you to Ibiza if you do this much, whatever, whatever, whatever. Some of the big TikTok shops do. do how do you how do you balance that with the challenge of tiktok shop being i mean i don't know i've i've struggled to see that many businesses that are really really making a lot of profit on that channel um so how how have you thought about that i think you have i mean the
1:00:36Frederica Watson: lives honestly help a lot especially if you have a high average value product because on a live people spend a lot more money than they do just by buying something from the video they've seen so as long as you've got like a good live strategy that kind of helps to like push the p and l up because obviously you might, I don't know, if you have like a studio, even people doing it from home, that's not costing you that much and people will spend more. So use the kind of creators to kind of build yourself so that when someone looks for you, there's loads of examples, like we said, of other people using the product, right?
1:01:04Frederica Watson: But make sure you have that live strategy.
1:01:06Laurence Booth: And are you bringing creators into the live?
1:01:09Frederica Watson: Only people who are a bit more well-known. Yeah, exactly. And like we've seen really good success with hosts who are more traditional, like QVC, because they just know how to sell. so they're really good and also of course we have a founder who is like known and celebrity so when she comes on lives it's amazing so you know use what you've got but i think the live is where people will spend more money so like that's a good place to be and also on the lives like you can discount but you don't need to go crazy like you're selling it to the person there and then you know so i think they're getting sold more but also just show the value in other ways like we were saying if you use all those tiktok shop create videos on meta you can then go to the you know your like seniors and say like look at this like we're actually saving money we're not paying for creative we've actually saved money because we're using all that content and message is really performing so there's other ways to use it in the business to justify this yeah yeah
1:02:01Nick Kane: have you seen all these tiktok like hook farms now there's agencies that will basically send your products out to thousands of people all of them will run about 10 different creatives on tiktok they'll see which one gets the most most organic reviews ripped out put on the front of your ad and do it that way i'm seeing a lot of that yeah that's seen a few of those around i think the we've kind of got on a bit of a tangent on tiktok shop here but i think you've got to be
1:02:23Laurence Booth: like these kind of big deal days right it's the same thing that i think about i spend a lot of time talking to people about amazon as well like i think people are starting you know maybe to your point earlier that as the education about these events starts to go up or maybe the people are starting to look for more deals um like all of the all your sales channels whether it's retail TikTok shop, Amazon or your Shopify site, you need to think about how you're deploying the right kind of creative capital and the right discounts, right offers to them to be able to deploy them. So it makes a lot of sense to try and understand how that stuff works.
1:02:58Laurence Booth: You know, TikTok shop is definitely not my specialty. So it's super cool to hear how it's working.
1:03:03Nick Kane: I think you just got to accept that you're not going to make any money for like six to 12 months. And if you can break even, like, and then hey, look, you're winning. You're going to see some serious slop
1:03:11Frederica Watson: about your brand. and it is actually painful. You may get the old,
1:03:17Nick Kane: this brand's closing down this week. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Oh my gosh, they're closing down today. Honestly, I think you have to be like,
1:03:24Frederica Watson: if you've got an agency doing that, you need to be super on top of it and just be like, guys, no, we need one of that. I understand it's going to slow things down, but we need to vet people and make sure it's right.
1:03:31Laurence Booth: It is extraordinary to me that I still have conversations with people that worry about Amazon being brand damaging, but they're willing to talk about TikTok shop and I'm very confused by that. It's very strange.
1:03:39Nick Kane: Different stratosphere. Yeah. Are you planning asset volume intentionally for Black Friday for the month of November? How have you approached that? I'd never thought about that until I spoke to you and you put me onto that. We are doing now. At first, you just make as much as you can and run as much as you can. But obviously, different periods of the year, like Q1 for us, New Year, New Me, fitness, it's pretty massive. So now I'm forecasting and backloading a lot of the creatives into that period. But just go back on your point about what we're doing tactically. i mean i think you guys said all the important things uh as it relates to the actual creative itself the only thing about ad ad is we spend a lot of time looking at the actual creators and whether they resonate with the the audience like the by far the um best performing creators we've had is when there's a clear match between the creator and the audience and whether you can tell it's an ad as well like sometimes as soon as they start talking you know within talk about training consumers like you know now from going through insta feed when you're brain rolling uh like it's obvious it's an ad within two seconds that's i think that's why polished kind of struggle a little bit as well why polish creators because you see it and like i know instantly this is like a land rover driving through a mountain type thing i know it's an ad so i'm gone um i think that works but bottom of funnel once already kind of in marketing like you need to sell them in type thing but you need to be at one end of the spectrum you need to either be perfect dr polished yeah where it's like perfectly scripted the hook is like like so via like a vo sales letter or expert perfect studio execution yeah hook is like right on like their desire or their pain point and the script keeps them all the way through because it's like really speaking to them because you almost like feel like you've got they feel like you've got in the head as a company or I think you need to be on the complete opposite end where it just feels like a story or a narrative I feel like when you're in that middle it doesn't nothing works yeah and with partnership
1:05:30Frederica Watson: I was like make sure that the content looks like what they regularly post because otherwise it sounds like a sore thought and people are not going to be they're going to be like what is this like it has to look like what they would genuinely post day to day otherwise it's just going to flop i think that
1:05:42Laurence Booth: is a difficulty for brands isn't it when they want to almost almost control how they come across it is a very very difficult conversation to have with founders or cmos or whoever you might be working with it's like well we need to give this creator the space to create in the way that they create because they speak to our audience and it doesn't look the same as what we want how we want to look and that's and that's that's that's always a difficult conversation no one cares about that
1:06:05Frederica Watson: now i was like the other day i can't remember if it was with you saying like ima like they're not even using the same fonts in their ads yeah just get it on the third five it's just what works like yeah like they just you know so it's like what even is brand yeah and at the same time
1:06:18Laurence Booth: yeah yeah that is that is at the same time brand is getting more important weirdly like people really care about brand and then they will say it's just i think once you get to the website
1:06:26Frederica Watson: but i think do you remember the ads you came in on like for me we were at a talk the other day um
1:06:32Laurence Booth: which was really fascinating with the loop about this and they spoke about the difference between this is a tangent we're walking on back uh but they spoke the the they spoke about the difference between uh brand consistency and brand coherence and like cadbury's brand consistency everything needs to be purple and has the same font brand coherence is like a loop earplug is so distinctive as an asset that you can put it everywhere and everyone knows that it's loop and there's a coherence that it like speaks to almost the same object through different visual styles and everything like that and it's almost reframing how you think about this stuff to be like we all exist in the same world we're telling the same story we're saying the same thing but we don't look exactly the same and that's okay and I thought that was a really interesting reframing for people who come from the brand side into this world where they're thinking about offers and creative diversity it's almost like what is the mental reframing to allow yourself and create the mental space for you to to work through this I mean I spent a lot of time talking to to founders and CEOs about about this problem and that i think is one of the better reframings that i've found to try and explain the challenge of needing to win in algorithmic media in 2026 requires a quite different approach to winning in traditional media in 2004 you know like it is it's just different to your point on
1:07:47Nick Kane: creative uh volume and forecasting that sort of stuff i think andromeda came out like creative diversity was was the thing and the industry just went full send in that direction like a lot of agencies sort of like the smaller ones just took advantage of that went to local businesses and say you just need volume and they didn't take any they didn't pay any attention to the actual quality what we're doing a little bit now is just like kind of pulling back a little bit now like i'd rather 10 killer ads than 50 just slop we went too we went too far on i'll just say on the podcast we went too far towards volume because i actually think for a period it worked like we It really like we were early and therefore doing volume, no one was doing either diversity or volume.
1:08:28Nick Kane: So in a category, if you were the one doing it, you'd have a pretty high hit rate. I think that's the impact of that decreased at the start of this year. I still think volume creates outcomes as long as quality doesn't decrease.
1:08:42Laurence Booth: Well, I think I've spent a lot of time on this. I definitely have seen, I build custom win rate and creative volume forecasting work for clients. And I think one of the things I've seen definitely is clients scaling. You almost see it linearly like scaling volume as hit rate declines and CAC increases. And I think part of this is coming back to what I said at the beginning. Everyone's trying to relearn this algorithm consistently. And it might've been that eight months ago, volume was the way to go and now it's not. But all it takes is for someone to have gone into an event five months ago where they got told that that was the right thing for them to go and make this thing and actually it takes them quite a long time to make creative and this stuff lags really quickly um you know the biggest piece of advice I would give to people which I know sounds really basic but um like really decide what hit rate means to you like actually how are you going to measure it because there are so many businesses I walk into and the people will say oh we've got a great hit rate and I'm like what does that mean and they're like I don't know it's like really good ad and like i don't so you know for me it's some balance of what does what does scaled spend look like in your account so how do you think about it scaling first um and but then and then how do you think about it winning so is that within a target cac range and obviously you've got some attribution either side so do you so the way i build it is basically you say like you launch the ad did you test the ad did it get enough spend to to kind of judge it did it scale then did it win and then after that did it become a hero and the hero asset is really what you're looking for like all of us are trying to find assets that to me i think a hero asset is an asset that can spend over 10k in 30 days so like really take quite a lot of spend and then scale beyond that and those are the assets that will carry a lot of your ad account and if you can build that funnel and understand what your creative funnel is then i think you can start to forecast but you need to have a target win rate or hit rate that you need to hit because the moment you start to forecast based on previous data you'll forecast loads and loads and loads of volume if your hit rate's been declining for a long time so that was a lot but like i think that there's there's a lot of there's a lot of stuff to get right at the beginning and then you can do creative volume forecasting pretty well and it can be very very beneficial even just to stop the arguments and stop the conversation which is really important because there's so much conversation that happens about do we need more of that do we need more of that and ultimately you want to make it simple for sure volume works
1:11:12Nick Kane: you won't fight there's a reason why pretty much every 100 million a year business that spends all the money on meta makes over a thousand ads a month and i've not found any i've not yet to find a business making like 100 ads a month that's relevant to the brand that's doing 20k who should just focus on quality rather than just a bunch of like random no i think it should i think it's like a linear relationship as long as the quality measure doesn't see i don't know if it is a
1:11:35Laurence Booth: linear relationship because i think the quality measure is so hard to control like i think when you're sitting in your position and you're in in control of like an amazing set of creatives and you've seen this in so many accounts and that's amazing you you have a lot more faith in your ability to maintain hit rate when you're you know when you're a smaller scale and you're trying to do some in-house and maybe you're thinking about bringing an agency it's it's much harder to to really understand the control of what a great creative strategy right i think it starts with strategy but even then you're you're coming from that head where you see this so much funnel stage
1:12:07Nick Kane: persona or angle interchangeable in some ways and then it's like format vehicle message and it's like but then i think fluid is it but already i think you're in a world where like volume is
1:12:18Laurence Booth: actually less important than like volume of strategically thought through creative so it's almost like no creative gets into the account unless it has this stuff in it okay and and that again sounds simple but I think a lot of people out there would have been just like you know, church if you'd be team, maybe 50 variations, make mistakes kind of thing like the hypothesis driven I think the energy I'm coming from is like if I'm
1:12:44Nick Kane: speaking to a founder that's doing 15k in revenue a month and here's all this, holy shit I have no idea what's in here, like if you just create five ads that feel good they feel quite genuine as well and authentic like some of the ones, our best performing ads that we've been running for two years, I worked out a phone me and the CEO were at this like you know sort of home show two years ago and as I said like I explained the product and he talks it through for 60 seconds and that's been like it felt authentic it explains the product it doesn't really feel like an ad it feels like an info tech video that's been our best performer for like for years which is.
1:13:16Laurence Booth: I do think that's fair like I think big kind of statistical forecasting all of that stuff only really starts to make sense at a certain scale. Yeah I would agree when you actually have to think about it like a supply chain
1:13:28Nick Kane: I think when you're a lot smaller, you need to spend time in the research and the quality and understanding the message and understanding the customer. And it's like, how can you scale output without decreasing the time spent on research per asset, which is a challenge. Yeah. Four volumes, just to finish that off, is like, it's the antithesis of too much strategy. It's like the strategy comes from just doing stuff. You do stuff, you learn, you get feedback, you move. It's the classic lean starter method, isn't it? but like you get so many agencies that will sell you on a big strategy and tell you all this information and you'll be sat there just get shit and it's like what do I do?
1:14:02Nick Kane: Just start putting stuff out don't worry about it It's an outlier game as well right? Exactly It's all about heroes right?
1:14:07Laurence Booth: I do think there are lots of people who think you know I've been doing this for a long time I still have no idea which creative is going to win Exactly I just don't and all you can control is how many you make so it's like how many thoughtful strategic creatives can you make that you can get into an account if that's five great and if it needs and if you if you want to spend 500 grand in for bfcm then you should probably think about making more than five but you know how does your mix of creative change into
1:14:36Frederica Watson: into peak um i would i mean there's definitely a lot more like i would concentrate a lot on that like there's statics that we talked about you need to have that um you do people are aware there's sales going on you know maybe especially if you're trying to scoop up that demand they just want to see the offer and they want to be super clear about what it is um but i wouldn't scale back on things like partnership ads however it would i what i would tell people to avoid especially you're not you haven't got a huge budget is like using partners to talk about the offers like just have them do good content and then you just run their ad also from your own account with like the messaging on top so like a round or with the offer or banner but still run theirs is just an app because if something really works then you have to turn it off that's really painful so i would say don't spend the money asking someone to say unless it's organic and they just oh they want your partners they're just going to put on their stories fine but wouldn't pay for an ad that was talking necessarily about black i think that's super smart i think so
1:15:29Laurence Booth: much of video content is about generating interest reach and awareness and we know how effective statics are at the bottom of the funnel and statics are so much easier to produce that basically you just have to and and you know it's actually just an aside point but i think it's the same problem that people have sometimes when they work with celebrities or influencers where they have usage rights where like you just don't want to be running that many ads you have to turn off after 30 days it's really annoying so do everything you possibly can to not do that um so or or have assets that you can just delete and it's not a big deal and that's why statics are
1:16:00Frederica Watson: valuable and just don't stuff turn stuff off like if you if you're running an offer at the beginning and it's 20 and then later you go black friday it's 30 don't turn off the 20 if it's working people are just going to come on the site and be like oh i struck gold great better offer you know like if you're going to do that going on the offer just leave that stuff running if it's working like don't take stuff down if it's working so unless you've got something super complex going on where like something was now not available you can still run that stuff yeah for us it's more
1:16:25Nick Kane: about uh thinking about why people are what people are buying for in black friday so that the in november we start seeing gift buying which is it's mad that people buy our products as a gift it's a thousand pounds but there you go like it's pretty massive but like i think that's the big thing we start thinking about like who is this consumer what are they actually buying for rather than just like the tactical stuff of the offer and they're static and they're around all that sort of thing it's more like is the audience shifting a little bit one thing that we see so our products is primarily female 75 % female what we typically see in november is the the percentage of male to female shifts slightly where people start you know men start buying their wives as gifts for christmas and then you know and then yeah putting them in the basement type thing really christmas day but yeah it's more just about that it's like um the bau offer changes it's not just selling the mirror anymore it's like here's why it's a perfect gift for your wife this Christmas here's why the whole family will enjoy this product and really think about why people are buying it probably relates to other industries and other products but maybe maybe it's I think it's basically you know it speaks to what you were talking about right like
1:17:22Laurence Booth: real within BFCM there's a whole other set of personas use cases you know why would you want to buy at this specific moment we've got Christmas coming up a lot of people kind of use BFCM as a place to get their Christmas offers I think it's a really makes a lot of sense to try and think that through especially for a high OV product yeah this is our first year in the US as well in
1:17:41Nick Kane: black friday so it's gonna be wild i think um i think that's yeah supplements is a bit of a weird gift to give people i think it depends on that you know i've been told obviously but
1:17:56Frederica Watson: it's not obviously gifting's not been massive for them in the past but i'm no i don't know i think
1:18:00Nick Kane: it's probably growing because wellness is great it's getting more normalized i think if you do
1:18:04Frederica Watson: these kind of packs or especially if you've got something fun it's different if it's a capsule you know it's a bit different but with revive revive it's like liquid you know there's different flavors there's different things you could do i think it's quite could be quite fun especially if you have the right kind of packaging if you have it packaged up in a way where it's a trial set or something i think we'll see more of that i think also when when you're in the collagen
1:18:21Laurence Booth: category at least they're when we're starting to see brands that are being like starting to mix with things like matcha and coffee and like and like this is what reformed are doing right i think you can see more of a gifting world where you're like this is actually a matcha collagen gift there's a really nice product and it comes in a nice package and that kind of makes sense again
1:18:40Frederica Watson: if you're desirable people will buy it for people yeah do you know i mean if it's a cool product and you want to be seen with it i think for me the whole idea is like for someone to be seen with it because you just don't want it to be something that's in the back of your cupboard it's like you take it on you take it like yeah proud to have it you would buy that if someone because
1:18:56Nick Kane: it's a cool thing that you want to have you mentioned a few things that i want to build on i think firstly the the not turning things off i think that's true about the whole period like when i when we did we always do a big wash up like right around christmas where we look at every single brand's Q4 and like what were the trends and every year their BAU campaigns do the best. Really? Yeah.
1:19:16Frederica Watson: I always found that as well. Even if it's just like adding something to the top like whatever's been really successful for the year just add some messaging on top about that Friday.
1:19:23Nick Kane: Yeah, like hook, change the hook but also just the actual campaigns in meta will have the best performance through that period. The other campaigns may have like certain days where they really work but when you aggregate it out over a bit longer a lot of that's attribution related but you've got to but you've got to think about that. And I also think you've got to think about how you have enough creative coming out of that period so you're not having horrendous December performance. I think this is a definite thing. So I think keeping video, keeping partnership ads. I feel like we've spent a lot of time on partnership ads, which is good because I still think it's underutilized.
1:19:57Nick Kane: Most brands are at like 5 % of spend. Meta needs to solve the whole whitelisting thing. They need to make it so much easier to whitelist.
1:20:05Frederica Watson: How many back and forth?
1:20:06Nick Kane: I've got this like copy and paste five list thing where it's like, oh, she needs to go to this. That's the friction that stops us from doing it. It is annoying. We're doing some work with their tech team at the moment to try and solve this problem. Interesting. Which hopefully will happen.
1:20:20Frederica Watson: Yeah, I think it would make such a difference if it was like a one click and then make it really easy.
1:20:27Nick Kane: You mentioned lower funnel statics. Definitely agree there. It's like low cost, quick, easy. I actually think one format that I've found to work through other sale periods this year, which I think will move nicely into Q4 is like AI-driven short-form video with the overlays, like five-second. They can be very product-led with really bold overlays. Visual differentiation usually gets lower CPM than statics.
1:20:50Laurence Booth: As in like an animation, potentially.
1:20:52Nick Kane: Yeah, animation or just like AI your products onto a counter and just have it like swinging around with a big banner. Just more. Some movement, basically. Yeah, some movement really works for certain demos. I just think it's interesting. and you said we haven't touched on AI. I think this is the first year where AI and creative really feels like you can do it at scale and fast. And I feel like you can get a lot of outcomes from being iterative and moving fast through Black Friday. Like taking things that are working and iterating them in small ways. I feel like we're going to see a lot more of that this year.
1:21:29Nick Kane: Having someone like sprinting on assets daily. Like we're going to do daily sprints for our clients where we look at assets through that week and we try and make small changes quickly. Yeah, it depends how much trust is involved with you. I think for us, I'm selling to a 57-year-old woman who kind of has a natural, even have it like our brand is Magic AI. Sometimes I consider doing AI in the headline when you hear these stats about there's a 50-50 split about whether people are advocates of it or not. But yeah, I agree. I mean, the big thing that we're finding is like partnership ads that link to a dedicated landing page that relates to that partnership ad.
1:22:00Nick Kane: So we recently did a collab with Cathy Jones from BBC Straight to Come Dance. she's on the show right now so it's been really good for us because she's on tv at the same time but we send that traffic to a dedicated landing page that says it's got kathy at the top it shows her dancing do you want to dance with kathy johnson strictly come dancing and that definitely kills like i think that's something that you're on as well isn't it like personalized user journey did you build that using ai the landing page yeah no i just whipped up and chopped by in like 20 minutes it's super easy to do i'm so bullish on this i think the whole like last 12 18 months has been like creative diversity but I think we're getting to this stage of like the whole funnel needs to be diverse including the lander which is way harder to do and also I'd argue the CRM flows and the CRM pop-up if you can do that you're absolutely like top class and the post-purchase upsells but that's like long term if you can align the whole thing so have the search the same person to be really clear on like
1:22:51Laurence Booth: exactly what you're trying to do and how you're trying to do
1:22:54Frederica Watson: we've been whipping them up with Claude myself actually probably annoying the developers because I'm like I just made a new page like just put it in it's so quick and easy to do but it's so good because you could just stick up the video that is actually the one that they led them to the page so it's so much clearer and because oftentimes i find it with products that there's so many benefits you're selling one benefit in the ad but then when this gets the page it's like buried amongst like 10 other benefits and it's like you're kind of lost because you're like yeah what you were selling isn't what you're now saying so yeah once you've got the template you can run them up and do loads and yeah those
1:23:26Nick Kane: different things they're often lighter as well a lot of these listicle type things one thing we found our website got a big banner big video banner at the top so it's pretty heavy load speed's pretty slow and then you send in the performance is so much better like when you're on these super light pages it kind of looks like a listicle it almost looks like an article sometimes so it feels like they're reading something useful like he'll do this pretty well if you want to check out somebody's funnel like they do it really well yeah um and then anybody in the glp1 space
1:23:48Frederica Watson: does it as well like they rinse it yeah i mean i think that the next level that is like with the listicles if you have your own like imagine you start like a new instagram account which is and then run it through that as a partnership ad like you can have a whole funnel for like organic and everything like for you guys it'd be great because you could have different personas
1:24:05Laurence Booth: for it as well it's just really interesting how does your um how does your ai like changing changing ads on a daily basis can compare with the like stay consistent because i think my worry is always like when we go into this trading period we're like well we're just gonna like we're gonna be locked in we're gonna be in the war room we're gonna be launching ads today at left right and center is like actually the ads we thought about five weeks ago the ones that rip and actually a lot of this stuff is more us just keeping more stress they're like creating more stress because actually we know our personas what like let's say we plan well you know we know our personas we know our offers we've got our stock the only time where i've seen loads of value is the is the world where like we run out of stock and i'm uh trying to do pack shots in the office at 10 12 p.m for like new stuff and like launch ads for it whatever and like that is a i kind of sometimes worry that if we go into this period and it's like we're going to be so locked in that we have to be adding new things to the ad account changing stuff all the time yes if you're really in this and you're trading it maybe that's valuable that's valuable but actually on a kind of an 80 20 i almost think try and find ways to make the day less stressful
1:25:17Nick Kane: i'm thinking about it like over a week to a 10 day period and then it's like just put them in a cbo and don't doesn't reset learning so see what happens well like we have to that's our service isn't it like we try to deliver more value by creating more assets but if you're like a team that's not like that well resourced maybe that's not the way it plays to spend time but i do think
1:25:38Laurence Booth: you can like again i mean i think if you can get edge from it then but yeah you could find an ad
1:25:43Nick Kane: that's just like three quid better cac and it completely transforms the ad account. And if you're spending a couple of hundred K over that week, plus you're going to get a pretty big outcome. But yeah, I think it's relative to the resource you've got available. I think that about the complexity of the period as a whole, I was thinking about that when you were talking about wait lists and like crazy tactics that you want to do for the first three weeks of the month. It's like, I think that could be doable if you're like a gymshark and you've got 200 people on your e-com team or something but it's like if you're like four people in a marketing team and a brand it's maybe not i think if you've
1:26:19Frederica Watson: got a small team like the best thing to do is just make sure the offer is everywhere so like don't forget your automated emails don't forget the post-purchase offer like that should say black friday everything should say black friday so that anyone can do just make sure your emails are all branded to be the same thing because if someone sees something that's not black friday brands it's not relative you know it's a different offer just confusing so just make sure that everything has the words Black Friday on it and reflects the right offer.
1:26:44Nick Kane: The worst thing you could do, don't do that offer where you say up to 70 % off and you get on the website and there's just like three things with 50. Deep in category eight is like one product that's like 70 % off. Don't do that. I think people generally don't spend enough time on the site journey. They spend all of the time on the ads, all the time on the media planning, a lot of CRM, but they spend very, they maybe don't, they just add a banner to the website rather than like rebuilding the site around the offer. And I think they're very different things, like just putting a banner on the top and overlaying it on your products doesn't create the same level of outcome.
1:27:15Nick Kane: Are you guys building full journeys around the offer?
1:27:21Frederica Watson: We're doing things for the PDP. So we're just making sure that it's sort of branded around Black Friday. Again, it's not a high SKU count, so as long as the pages reflect the offers, it's fine. But we're also obviously putting it across the site. So just making sure if someone did land on their homepage, like it's gonna be easy to see what's on offer you know like there's an offer for every single person that whether you want to buy a bundle or you want to buy something you know subscription whatever it might be just make it very clear for someone to go there but i do agree that if you're at a certain level of spend like it would be better to have a funnel for each person and maybe even the offer is differing slightly if you can make it work i think we've been focused mostly
1:27:57Laurence Booth: on like making the whole thing understandable and navigable and clear that there are deals happening this is where you can find them this is what they're for but also because so much traffic is going through landing pages then it's also about making sure that landing page you know basically aligning those landing pages especially if you have like a main funnel that goes through a landing page that's focused on a certain problem solution whatever it might be if you choose to run an offer on that funnel make sure you're just like making sure the whole journey says to your work if you've got like 50 lps live to go through and update them but maybe maybe to your point maybe you don't and you just you just like you the whole the whole thing just lifts and you think why not did we do all this back friday stuff it could be just like do you know as well
1:28:42Nick Kane: like even now after 12 like people still so people spend all day on the laptops like working on the website and then they never check is never like look at the mobile user journey like ever and i'm guilty of it because you just you get locked on your desktop and i'm like have you checked it on mobile it actually doesn't work if i just just look at you're like five banners honestly like You've hired an agency to do like CRO split tests, A-B tests over time. And then you've got like, you've not even checked the mobile journey. It's broken type of thing. The CTA doesn't work.
1:29:10Laurence Booth: Add to cart being below the fold is the classic act.
1:29:13Nick Kane: So I think big banner at the top, add to cart drops below the fold. You're like, well, no. Yeah, it's a separate pod, but I reckon A-B testing for brands that are under a certain revenue is just a complete waste of time. Oh my gosh. Just make the change. Just make the change. We've got two chevrons on the CTA now instead of three. You've been working? I don't know. I know. Oh my goodness. Don't waste your time. I totally agree. I want to do a quick round the room of one tactic you're really betting on this year. So you've got a lot of conviction. Maybe something fun, different. Could be large, could be small.
1:29:42Nick Kane: And one thing that you think everyone's doing or does that's a complete waste of time. I can... So many. Yeah. You've maybe just given a while away with your AV testing. But yeah, anything you really think... You don't even have to be doing it yourself.
1:29:58Laurence Booth: but like something you're maybe seeing the tactic that maybe drive value i'm massive into these like big big bundles that tell a really strong and compelling story um whether that you know let's take it i'm i'm i'm advising everyone to try and find ways to build that kind of high ray of e-value um that 90-day subscription in the supplement space is really important but i think that there if you can find a journey so like you know whether that's like talking about sleep or you're talking about energy or you're talking about skin or whatever it might be find a journey that you can that has got a really really clear use case and build a great product and offer behind it i think that is massive to give you cut through and i think that will help you have the aov to buy the media at the scale that you want to buy and you know for me all of this always reverse engineers is to this question of like you've got CAC, you've got Aerie, LTV, you've got your stockhold and you've got your margin.
1:30:53Laurence Booth: Are all of those things actually in place for you to be able to do it? And that's why I think especially in 2026 but going forward those kind of larger bundles are massive for me.
1:31:05Frederica Watson: I think I would say like I said earlier if you've got a big catalogue like how can you plan it so that you're having things happen again and again so that someone might actually buy multiple times throughout the period. I think that's quite underrated obviously again it depends on the product you sell but if you can get have different offers still keeping it fairly simple but making sure you're having these different sort of themes throughout that maybe would appeal to someone a second time then yeah good uh one thing we're doing outside of the typical let's sort of d2c
1:31:34Nick Kane: stack meta collabio that sort of thing is uh finding brands with complementary products to ours and ours complementary to theirs and going in their facebook communities and just doing some sort of joint collab share like there's a man to bleep this out but there's this app that's somehow blown up called team rh they've got like hunt it's just got one influential sort of founder like hundreds of thousands of followers in this community like mental but like our product is complementary to theirs because they're like a glp one health planet type thing and ours is to theirs and if you can do a quick jv like with little commercials in place and get it up quickly that's i expect that to be pretty good the facebook community by the way is like one of when we launched that about two years ago that changed our business because people can see other people in the community there's one thing seeing trust palette reviews and everybody assumes i expect that you can fake reviews whereas you can't fake other people sharing their journey and their actual reviews of the product inside a community and that's completely changed our business especially high alv like you want to see other people that look like you're actually using it the comment we always get on live chat is how does it actually work what does it actually look like once it's in a home i've seen all your polished meta ads and stuff um but yeah facebook community is massive
1:32:41Laurence Booth: that's a really good tactic i mean the the tactical thing that i always i've been saying more and more is that people still seem to underestimate the value that like true celebrity endorsement and like really strong celebrity connection can have to a business like it's it's pretty extraordinary and if you're lucky enough to be able to have those conversations and to think about that then i think it is massive for your business and can really transform it if you can execute it at the kind of depth that you want to do. If you can go, you know, really, really go with those people if you're on their podcast, on, you know, in ads, kind of all over the place, I think it is massive.
1:33:17Laurence Booth: Yeah.
1:33:17Nick Kane: This is just getting David Beckham for one photo shoot and slapping on your company. I think association, like association with other products, association with other people, and like partnership ads is kind of a bit of that, isn't it? Like that ability to leverage someone else's credibility to lift your own.
1:33:32Frederica Watson: Well, even with, who was it the other day? I was seeing IMA working with this, I think they're called the Dodo. It's like this...
1:33:39Nick Kane: The content.
1:33:40Frederica Watson: It's the content. They're content people. They talk about animals. I've seen those, yeah. And basically, they're using their page to run out. And I was like, that makes complete sense because these people are like, that might be their target audience. It's like videos of celebrities with puppies and stuff. That's what they talk about. So don't just think influencers, think editorial too.
1:34:00Laurence Booth: Well, again, coming back to this Loop talk we were at, I think one of the things they do really, really well is like deep brand partnerships, like with McLaren F1, they're going to build a loop earplug that's limited edition. They're doing the same thing with Swarovski. Like I think you can do stuff with brands as well if you're willing to go all the way and build almost like custom products with them and then launch them alongside. And I think it's the same thing where with association, you can build a lot more value and you can build newness and difference. And I do think that within these big discount windows and offer periods, we think a lot about like kind of in the own brand like can we discount can we give GWP but like what about launching the new product at that point what about actually building new stuff that's kind of unique for that period I think those are the ways that you can really cut through if you can have have this and I'm pontificating because I'm not working with someone who's doing that but like I think that is a real that's a really really fascinating way to think about this to build difference almost make it more expensive don't discount it but make it exclusive that's that seems to be a really good way to think about it you're teasing my next episode because i've got
1:35:02Nick Kane: rob from loop coming on to tell us all right subscribe my tactic was going to be all like area that i think people that i am seeing brands bet on that i think is going to create a lot of value was going to be partnership ads but we've touched on that a lot because i just think it's that will also counteract cpm because it just indexes far lower in the platform just be careful
1:35:24Frederica Watson: if you don't if your spend is not huge don't spend five grand if you can't spend five grand on it that's such a mistake like oh we're going to pay this person like 10k but we can't even spend 10 grand on it like that's you know i mean i think start small with like start hacky as well start
1:35:40Nick Kane: internal start founder start with your team well laurence mentioned you mentioned depth i think that's a big thing so for us like we could go with a i don't know like a kevin hart a serena Williams I'll say but like the goal for me would be like a Stacey Solomon like she's well known the depth she's got in her audience like she actually moves in versus like just like super broad celebrities and there's one thing about when we're going to the US is like who do we actually collaborate with do we try and get our name on the map the huge name type thing or do we go for like about 10 different tactical kind of ones with well I think I think the so there are
1:36:10Laurence Booth: two things that I find really interesting about this the first one is that cost of content created is like not a metric that people are tracking nearly as much with this stuff so especially with 30-day usage rights right like even if you get a great ad out of it you're not going to spend to the level you might want to spend within the 30 days that you get and I think there there is a world where lots and lots of performance marketers are now starting to talk to like proper agents who think about stuff very very differently to how we might think about stuff so structuring your deals and I appreciate this probably not for everyone in the audience quite small group of people but structuring these deals well to think about like how can i get 100 pieces of content out of this partnership is just really important rather than just going like famous person i'm going to get a post it's going to go great because the mechanic is really to your point how much spend can i push into this person rather than um anything else and like my analysis of of at least celebrity uh ads is that they spent they can spend significantly more like just vehicles of spend with way cheaper cpr it's like three extra spend with a third of the cpr or a third in the frequency and it's like massive for your account doesn't mean that it's got to work like we so we did a
1:37:19Nick Kane: club with um jesse lingard who's a former manchester united football players you know phenomenal like strange choice it was well we we partnered with him before we'd really had any data on who our audience was right right so you know it could have been like gym bros yeah yeah but there's actually a different audience and we run his ads and our cpms are amazing the click-through great it's amazing but then when you go to the comments on the ads it's a bunch of 22 year old dudes talking about how he was chopped at manchester night i've been like through a football lens not even like a persona lens when i was saying yeah no no and it was like an amazing like the content's amazing we spent all this money on the jesse pod but like just doesn't resonate it just doesn't i think it's all about storytelling like how can they weave the product into a journey they're on as a person in a way that resonates with the audience you're getting in front of and there's i've seen there's a well-known supplement business in the uk that has done this very very well um but and i always interested me seeing the data like the ones that you think on the front end would do the best weren't the ones that did the best yeah because you'd see the ones that did were the ones that could really intertwine the two together i mean
1:38:18Laurence Booth: i've got the privilege of working at ancient and brave and and and spending some time with that team and to see the depth of relationship they built with davina over time and and and the kind of the the way that they've managed to execute that partnership which is really built off a deep trust in in the business and the product between both sides is really incredible but to your point that's also very much you know target demographic right time right moment it kind of everything panned out incredibly well for them um but you know i do i do also think that we shouldn't underestimate just the raw power of fame if that person is in your right demographic like famous people do really well and sometimes you're faced with this challenge of like do we go with the 10 sort of almost people and kind of bet and spread bet or do we put all our eggs in one basket and my my bet would be like if you have high conviction put your eggs in one basket go super deep because that i think that's where you get the most outside rewards um i think it's it's
1:39:19Frederica Watson: really cool especially in a market where you don't have as much around awareness because like you need people to tie your foot to something like they need to understand like you know yeah my tactic
1:39:28Nick Kane: that's not partnership ads yes i'm pretty bullish on gamification especially on site entry are you like the little you want the scratch card oh my god i hate that not the scratch card
1:39:41Laurence Booth: you're way back to wheels on the site
1:39:48Nick Kane: i don't i don't love it in like i don't love it from a consumer from like a like a always on tactic I actually think it's a bit tacky when you run it always on as a funnel why do you think it works? because I think there's a natural like when someone feels dopamine for a payoff it creates like an increased likelihood that they'll take action on that second step when they hit the page because they feel like they've won the season I can't act like I've never done one but if you see a wheel not to go too deep on this if you see a wheel and you get 10 % all I'm thinking is somewhere on that wheel is 40 % and I'm looking at one of these I don't like the wheel I like the select the Grunz one the Grunz one's very good Carpe is very good as well, it's a deodorant brand where they're doing like yeah it's a bit like Galwood yeah they do, that's where people call it from I think there's probably a way to do it really interestingly
1:40:41Laurence Booth: that combines the classic quiz with this which is like if it's find the right product for you, is there a gamified way that we could do that on the front that could provide some value and i'm sure there's a way to do it but my worry a little bit is that you know again not to sound too much like i'm kind of reforming performance marketer but like i do think there is something about if you go too hard into the tactical side like you do end up basically positioning yourself a little bit of like a binet brand and that that it works for some people but it just doesn't work for people who are really focused on a different kind of outcome for their business and ultimately bfcm 2027 could you know is really really important but you also got to set you up you know it's 26 sorry it's got to set up for 27 and 28 i feel like this is the i feel like
1:41:26Nick Kane: november's when anything goes i don't think i don't think it degrades brand by running a little bit of a site entry for like seven days which is definitely not it's a test right but so i think but i've seen it from firsthand like half cack when people run the good ones on the right audience and that's on like a BAU always on offer so I think if you're going to run it for a short period of time I think it could work really well I think we're going to see loads of them so it's going to annoy everybody over the coming months. I do think yeah I think there's a point on like running that all year round that's maybe not If you can make it relevant then I always think when I'm doing something like that I think about like imagine somebody on a commute to work with half the wifi they'd normally have like is this the thing even pop-ups like this to your head in like sometimes Pop-ups the opposite.
1:42:12Nick Kane: I actually think a lot of pop-ups that would just cost people money. Really? That's another hot take. Another hot take. Anything you think people are doing that's a waste of time other than gamification on entry?
1:42:25Nick Kane: Yeah, anything else?
1:42:25Frederica Watson: I think people aren't sending enough emails usually. Like just send loads of emails. Like no one's seeing your email.
1:42:31Nick Kane: Stop worrying about burning your list. That's getting buried after three minutes.
1:42:35Frederica Watson: Like literally you could send 50 and it wouldn't matter. Do you know where I think people
1:42:38Nick Kane: are spending a waste of time? designing emails send those plain text especially through black friday great i love that also you
1:42:47Laurence Booth: can you can have fun with it it was i think it was true classic last year did loads of like accidental leaking yeah i hate that i'll find you oh i hate that but if you could do it tongue in it's quite funny yeah true they did it quite funnily like they it was kind of like a wink wink situation but it kind of worked because it was it just cut through it could go super
1:43:08Nick Kane: but technically would be like, our VC's giving away contribution money. I'm into that. I think plain text emails, because you get really high deliverability and really high action rate, and compared to spending loads of time designing them through the period can work really well.
1:43:25Laurence Booth: I think in general, my view is that, despite having talked about this for a while, I think people do just spend a lot of time overthinking and over-engineering the whole thing. Ultimately, you need to make something that works for you, works for your customer, and can be simple enough to be able to execute well to your point if you're going to be able to have a campaign that people are excited about have an offer that makes sense be able to put it all over the site that's already quite a lot of work so don't have three offers or don't and don't kind of make this thing really really difficult just make it simple enough that you can execute it to a point where you're all going to be like confident and and like proud of it at the end of the day rather than ending up in a position where you've over-engineered it you're like running around like a headless chicken trying to trying to deal with the mess that you've creative yourself on the day i think it's important to like i see my job these days is just focusing the business on what's actually important like if i could cut out the 80 of stuff that just don't matter over the past few years like magic's been such a transformative experience for me because i
1:44:19Nick Kane: work for brands where i had a team of like 10 and you sort of you join the team late and you feel like you have to do all these things and you're in meetings and you're spinning your wheels and like came to magic like we're just running meta we're just doing clavio we're not doing anything else for two years and we've been on a rocket ship obviously it's not just that but like it's just it's the same thing that most of the agencies are pitching it's like just get very very very good at one time do less batteries do less bad just get very good at one thing the other thing i would say besides like just cut all the noise is um i mean i said it before we just say b testing just to qualify that like i think it's a complete there's so much observer bias in baked into the process the first time getting it set up is difficult the analysis of it is is almost impossible unless you're you know you know a thing or two about stats which most people don't and you know you've got a lot I spoke to a founder the other day and she was asking me for some advice and she's like oh I think I need to get an AB test agency or something she called it and I was like you're doing 15k in revenue
1:45:13Frederica Watson: there's not even enough traffic you'd have to run it for three months don't feel like you need to do it, do the big swings
1:45:18Nick Kane: less bigger swings is my whole mantra on Ecom is like do less but then when you do it do it properly and go big on the change so like build a full new PDP and try and find like a 12 15 % improvement I think the smaller you are the bigger the swings you need to take on it for sure but even now we're like I mean I can probably say we're at like 25 mil this year let's say across two territories and now we're starting to feel like the institutional effect of people feeling like we need to diversify channels like and that's the solution and we're a super lean team of like 20 people and most of them are engineers like for most of the time we've had a two man marketing team and it's like I'm trying everything I can to resist like we've gone into retail probably dragging our unit kind of mixed down we have some faith that people are going to see it in store and buy but like you know you start feeling like you need to do billboard ads and like maybe do tv and you know you look at the guys from purdy and fig and they're doing all this stuff you're like oh are we at that scale yet for me it's like up until 50 mil i'm not even sure we need to move away from i think
1:46:12Laurence Booth: i think again it depends on the game you're trying to play and what and how you're trying to position like you know maybe in one world you're and i think the having like a really really defensible product in the like tech hardware space is probably very different from working in the commoditized in a commoditized supplement space or drinks or whatever but i i do do really hear you when i like i get lots of calls from people who are saying well we really you know we should definitely launch some new channels i need to diversify like what you want to launch they don't want to launch tiktok sharp they want to tiktok ads and you're like why like i don't really get it you've got the world's most in like most scaled most effective ads ads um machine in meta and an equally big one in Google where you have access to basically everything from search through to TV, why would you give yourself another thing to log into?
1:47:04Laurence Booth: The most pernicious thing about it
1:47:05Nick Kane: as well is once you start doing it, it's very hard to pull back. Yeah, of course it is. Because you start talking about cross-attribution. It's not just some cost, it's like you can't pull it back because then it's like, oh well what if we lose sales by doing it? Now I'm investing in Pinterest and I'm doing TikTok and I'm doing it. Just don't even go there. The best thing is you know
1:47:19Frederica Watson: where your sales come from. You don't have to worry about this. Exactly, this is it. It's like it's all good for me. I know where they're coming from.
1:47:24Laurence Booth: as long as you can hold on having said that i also am starting to believe more and more and maybe this is a hard take the retail is extremely valuable for consumer because it is the most defensible channel that there is i think like getting in with buyers being able to be at the scale where you can actually have the supply chain that buys would trust you like be having the brand awareness that you can drive rate of sale all of those things are just so much more defensible than being in a category where someone can come and execute way better than you have better ads have a better position tomorrow and like i think that then it comes to the game you're playing and how you want to try and build your business because you can accept some complexity to build defensibility in the long term much like with brand building you might be like well our job is to actually now we've got a really good conversion machine we're going to do bfcm really well we're going to get loads of revenue now we have to go and get famous on top of that and how do we build arbitrage in the auction so that every time someone sees our ad our click-through rates and our conversion rates are higher than they would be otherwise how can we create like moments where we can maybe bring new interest to like create new moments of cash flow in our business so we're not just relying on BFCM and then how do we create inflection points so that our business is just exponentially bigger over a period of three months because suddenly we crack brand and so I think there are moments where if you're sitting in that strategic seat you're like I'm willing to accept the cost of this complexity because I'm trying to go over here and do this thing but the hard thing is actually having that conversation and being clear about it because ultimately lots of people go like we're going to launch retail yeah sure and then you don't know that suddenly your cash is going to go up and you're going to be cannibalized and you're going to deal with all this stuff and that's very very difficult and the time spent and the complexity
1:48:59Nick Kane: to your point we'll do another episode because we've got a few different hundreds i feel like we could continue to talk we're nearly at two hours of this i feel like we could continue to talk maybe a 2027 strategy episode would be good off the back of that would be fun i'd like um But yeah, I just wanted to wrap up on a theoretical question for those watching. Because I'm sure someone listening will have this situation. You sat there. It's Black Friday, day one. You're 40 % below revenue target. What are you doing? What levers are you pulling? I'll start by questioning the utility of the target in the first place.
1:49:34Nick Kane: Like if you're 40 % behind target. You'll reframe the question? No, no, no. That's what I was going to say. Bad target. My point is actually... Go to the CFO and go, you were wrong. yeah my point is actually how important is it to hit that revenue target and is it telling you a signal that's different to what you should be doing um if i'm 40 behind target i'm not discounted deeper no and i'm not spending more and there's only so much you can actually do um i think there's a lot of analysis in like why that is the case but fundamentally yeah i'm sort of holding my nerve and not discounting any further i think it's a little too late to change it almost at
1:50:05Laurence Booth: that point right like you're kind of in in this thing and actually going deeper and trying to and almost because what will happen is your team will be focused on another thing they might be focused on christmas and they might be going on january and so then you're going to pull resource that would be on the future where you could build that back up into this thing with little guarantee that you might hit because it might be that your positioning is wrong your offer is wrong or you've just executed badly like the first thing i would do is just like just audit the like basic things and I first like first and first analytics like the thing that everyone forgets like have my has my pixel stopped firing for whatever reason is my website broken checkup broken because this stuff does happen and it is often the last thing that people check rather than the first and I was like first thing I do is go into like go into events manager make sure pixels are firing go into uh like GA or triple l or whatever you're running make sure that it's all set up right and basically do an audit is anything broken if it's not broken then we've got a big strategic problem and then if you're trying to solve a big strategic problem with your hair on fire in sort of 10 hours that seems like a really dumb thing to do so instead i would like get the team in reframe where's the next place we can win are we like what are we willing to do right now is it something where we do have more we have deeper to go maybe we're about to launch our extra 10 off email just launch it now whatever it is but realistically i kind of agree with you that ultimately that that problem has to be solved in the future and it probably is telling you more about either your forecasting process your budgeting or your positioning than it is telling you about about
1:51:40Nick Kane: too early as well like if you've done it before payday in october when people's waiting to be paid yeah sometimes it's just like wait and see yeah wait and see you always think oof and then
1:51:49Frederica Watson: there was nothing to be worried about sure as well like so much of your successful failure is out of
1:51:54Nick Kane: control as well nobody talks about that we all like to assume that we can control that pull all these levers and stuff like again like you know some of the best periods some of the worst periods have been things completely out of my control and i can't take credit for the good ones and i won't blame myself for the bad ones if you're 40 down and you forecast and you've got stock against it and you've got all this debt tied up in that and you've got covenants and stuff i'd be a bit panicky but i certainly wouldn't uh discount any detail i think you've still got time to change
1:52:18Frederica Watson: messaging potentially so unity offers the same if it's like early november like maybe speak to the people who know your brand the best and try and understand like what was was it about that just didn't resonate like we need to change the page the landing pages like how are we framing this offer we still got this stock to sell like how are we going to do it um i do yeah i think if i i yeah
1:52:36Laurence Booth: if we're early then you've got time if it's on the day yeah if it's on black friday then you do find a new job yeah like if you are in a cash crunch you can always do more difficult things and if you're on a cash crunch then like everything's on the table but like i you know this comes back to what i was saying at the beginning that so many more people are starting to think at a category level and a like a like a macro level about where is the market moving and what's that's gonna what's that gonna give me in terms of information about how much risk i need to take in my business and so if you're in a category where composition competition is increasing uh but like category search volume is flat or decreasing then you're gonna be in a really really really competitive difficult moment you have you have to decide how you're gonna either grow that category or go and like eat someone else's lunch that requires a very different approach to margin to stock to offer than to something where like everything's exploding and we're kind of everyone eats and i think starting to think from that level and then understand what's happening in your business from that level to the point of like things are out of your control like there are so many things that are going on outside of you whether that's the economic situation whether that's how much interest people are whether there's been you know for example in the supplements category we've had like a lot of backlash in the media over recent weeks with um there's a bit like a book that's come out about about kind of the quality of supplements and kind of questioning a lot of science which is which is you know a helpful debate um for some people not so helpful for supplement companies right but um knowing all of those things doesn't give you excuse it gives you a framework through which to manage your decisions and your risk taking and what you want to think about um and i think that's really important yeah exactly and just to echo your point from before and just do more
1:54:17Nick Kane: don't worry about burning your list all these email agencies we've got to warm up our list for keep and like we're having this debate at the minute it's like nah just send it like do sms do one a day like do more pull the leather that you can do
1:54:30Laurence Booth: get in front of people's faces
1:54:32Nick Kane: just recently email again call people up if you need to get on the phone well we're going to have to end it there again I feel like we could have gone for probably another hour and a half two hours but we're coming up to the time when we're going to get kicked out of the studio. So thank you very much for joining us. Maybe just go around and where can people find you, Lawrence?
1:54:53Laurence Booth: I'm on LinkedIn.
1:54:54Nick Kane: Lawrence Booth-Livin, yeah.
1:54:56Frederica Watson: Yeah, same here. Frederica Watson on LinkedIn.
1:54:58Nick Kane: Yep, same on LinkedIn. Nick Cain or check out our website magic.fit. Get yourself a mirror. Check them all out. Thank you all for watching if you stuck around to the end. Please like, subscribe and we will be back for another panel episode very soon. Legend. Cheers.
1:55:15See you next time.
Most brands walk into November with a discount and a hope. Six weeks out, that pattern is already forming.
For the first-ever D2C Diaries panel, three operators take Black Friday apart: Laurence Booth from Internos Advisory, Frederica Watson from Revive Collagen and Nick Kane from Magic AI. What the episode focuses on is offer, media, creative, and the unpublished part: what operators actually do when day one lands 40% under forecast.
Disagreement is the point. The panel does not agree that peak is a straight revenue win. One guest makes the case that the same revenue would have landed without Black Friday at all.
Inside the episode:
- Why BFCM becomes a trap for wellness and subscription brands, and what discounting really costs inside a repeat-purchase model
- Offer architecture: what separates offers that scale from offers that burn margin, and why complexity kills most of them
- Timing: when promotion should start, and whether an early launch avoids the CPM peak or discounts full-price demand
- Creative and media: why the strongest Black Friday ad is often already live, Meta's incremental reach problem, and why partnership ads deserve closer to 30% of spend than 5%
- Demand shift at peak, the £1,000 gift signal, and the Friday-morning fallback plan: what to change, what to leave alone
This podcast is proudly sponsored by Incard.
If you're spending serious money on daily business expenses and getting nothing back on it right now, this dedicated offer gets you 2% Cashback for year 1 on Ads, SaaS, Travel and other everyday business expenses. Uncapped.
Sign up for free and use the code SWU2K26 to unlock your cashback: https://www.incard.com/?fpr=soarwithu...
0:00 The True Cost of Complexity
0:32 Quality Over Quantity in Ad Creative
1:08 Meet the Panel: Scaling Consumer Brands
4:06 Preparing for the Peak Season
7:40 Volatility and Market Shifts
14:05 The New Reach Challenge
24:27 Defining Your Peak Objectives
36:11 Learning from Past Mistakes
53:40 The Future of Creative Strategy
1:49:16 What to Do When You Miss Targets
Follow our guests:
Laurence Booth-Clibborn- https://www.linkedin.com/in/laurence-booth-clibborn/
Frederica Watson- https://www.linkedin.com/in/frederica-watson-a21bb4a4/
Nick Kane - https://www.linkedin.com/in/nick-kane-4b9a73102/
Hosted by Olly Hudson and Loukas Hambi - operators behind £200M+ in Meta, TikTok and Google spend across 250+ brands.
D2C Diaries is a weekly podcast breaking down D2C growth, performance marketing and brand scaling.
🚨🚀 If you’re a brand spending £100K/month, we’ll run your ads. Apply for your growth roadmap: https://eu1.hubs.ly/H0wjzrY0
Follow Olly: https://linktr.ee/ollyhudson
Follow Joe: https://linktr.ee/joe_marston
Follow Loukas: https://shorturl.at/TRI8B / https://x.com/LoukasHambi
Follow D2C Diaries: https://www.tiktok.com/@d2c.diaries / https://www.instagram.com/d2c_diaries/