1. Podcasts
  2. Dateline NBC
  3. Hunted
Dateline NBC

17 Nov 2026 · 1h 21m · 29 chapters

In short

The Dateline “Hunted” episode investigates the Dec. 10, 2005 murder of Laura McNaughton, a 30-year-old waitress in Clovis, New Mexico, found nude near a road ravine during pheasant season. Her body showed blunt trauma to the forehead and strangulation; she was “displayed” face-up as if placed carefully, with piercings and a butterfly tattoo on her back. A can of Bud Light was found near her, and her home appeared orderly, suggesting she was taken elsewhere.

Guest backgrounds

The episode features law-enforcement and family perspectives. It includes investigator David Loera (DA’s office/major crimes), DA Matt Chandler (Clovis native), Detective Robert Tejas (Clovis PD), and family members including Laura’s mother “Lucky” and sister Jackie (Beardmore family). It also includes the Cookta cousins (hunters who found the body) and interviews with suspects’ context.

Key claims

Investigators initially focused on Jeff McNaughton (Laura’s ex-husband, a local radio host “Duffy Moon”) and Joel Delaney (a railroad conductor Laura planned to meet). Jeff passed a polygraph and was cleared; Joel’s truck had bird blood (not human) and he was cleared. The case pivots to a fixated Rib Crib customer described as a mid-30s blonde man in medical scrubs who visited Fridays, demanded Laura’s section, drank beer, flirted, left cash tips, and vanished until the next Friday.

Notable examples

The “mannequin” discovery by hunters; the butterfly tattoo identification; the Bud Light in the trash matching the scene; luminol revealing blood in Joel’s backseat; the scrubs-customer canvass across clinics/hospitals.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

2:28

The Discovery of a Body

Cousins find a woman's body during a pheasant hunting trip, leading to an investigation.

“Clovis, New Mexico It's the kind of place where you'd have to search to find a stranger Where it seems everyone's got a 4x4 And if you're driving through town, odds are you'll spot cousins Josh and Todd Cookta.”
5:56

Investigation and Identification

Law enforcement investigates the murder and begins identifying the victim.

“The victim looked to be in her late 20s.”
9:49

Laura McNaughton's Background

Exploration of Laura's life, family, and relationships leading up to her murder.

“That lunch he remembered was with a police officer at a spot called the Rib Crib.”
14:03

Sisters' Support and Struggles

Explore the journey of two sisters as they navigate challenges in their lives.

“On the radio, Jeff went by the name Duffy Moon.”
15:46

The Shocking News

Learn about the heart-wrenching moment Laura's family learns of her death.

“when Lucky's terrifying premonition turned out to be true.”
15:56

The Investigation Begins

Discover how investigators started piecing together the crime scene.

“Now David had to make the devastating calls to the rest of the family.”
18:34

The Long Drive to Clovis

Experience the emotional journey of Laura's family as they travel to the scene.

“It's nearly a thousand miles from San Diego to Clovis, New Mexico.”
19:06

Searching for Answers

Follow the family's quest for answers regarding Laura's death.

“18 hours of my parents sitting in the backseat, you know, just crying, no music.”
21:58

A Killer's Method

Examine the disturbing details surrounding Laura's murder and the perpetrator's possible identity.

“They took pictures of all of our boots, both left and right.”
24:25

The Divorce and Its Impact

Understand the dynamics of Laura's divorce and its implications for her life.

“investigators would need to dig into her personal life.”
Show all 29 chapters
28:00

Morning Drive and Controversial Humor

Explore the dynamics of a popular morning radio show and its host's personal struggles.

“The Rooney and Moon show dominated the morning drive.”
30:00

Unusual Stunts and Suspicion

A Christmas fundraiser stunt raises eyebrows and links to a tragic event.

“During the skit, Jeff McNaughton had been buried into a hole, and they were raising money for Secret Santa.”
31:48

Interrogating the Radio Host

Investigators confront a radio host about his ex-wife's murder, revealing red flags.

“Now the DA picked up the phone and asked Jeff to come in.”
34:08

The Search for Joel Delaney

Investigators track down a man who had plans with the victim on the night of her murder.

“they were giving up people that would know where Laura was that night, you know, who would she be with, and Joel Delaney's name came up.”
38:29

Investigating Joel Delaney's Alibi

Police delve into a suspect's nervous behavior and shaky alibi after a murder.

“military base which was one small comfort during a terrifying and anxious time how did you guys get through, especially those first few days?”
42:00

Investigating Blood Evidence

Explore the shocking discovery of blood in a suspect's vehicle.

“and he had agreed to do a polygraph examination and then decided to stop the interview that evening.”
43:52

Polygraph Tests and Suspect Eliminations

Learn how polygraph tests impacted the investigation and suspect list.

“Or would another clue send them to a place that even seasoned detectives couldn't fathom?”
46:03

The Search for Other Suspects

Understand the challenges detectives faced while examining other suspects.

“Police took a closer look at Joel's story and concluded the window of time he'd been away from the bar was just too tight to commit the murder.”
48:28

Laura's Impact and Family's Grief

Discuss the emotional toll of Laura's death on her family and friends.

“There were several people that would come in and sit in her section.”
51:14

The Investigation Deepens

Follow the detectives as they search for a potential new suspect.

“For those left behind, that loss is just the beginning.”
56:00

Investigating the Suspect: Dr. James Smith

Learn about the investigation of Dr. James Smith following the murder of Laura.

“Were the offices typically pretty willing to help?”
1:03:37

Laura's Disturbing Experience with Dr. Smith

Explore Laura's unsettling encounters with Dr. Smith and the investigation's progression.

“Monday on NBC, the new season of The Voice has arrived.”
1:10:03

Investigating a Dark Plan

Learn about the chilling evidence collected against James Smith.

“Investigators kept digging, and what they would find next still haunts them to this day.”
1:14:40

James Smith's Confession

Discover the details of Smith's confession and his claims about Laura.

“This time, instead of downplaying his attraction to Laura, he admitted going to the rib crib every Friday to see her.”
1:18:05

The Plea Deal and Aftermath

Understand the legal proceedings following Laura's murder and Smith's plea deal.

“We went from sitting on the couch talking to you grabbing her loan name.”
1:24:00

The Plea Hearing: A Family's Pain

The emotional turmoil of the plea hearing and its impact on Laura's family.

“Smith, I explained to him, I've talked to a psychologist and his job is, it's going to get into your brain and he's going to walk around and he's going to try to figure out why these things happened.”
1:25:14

Reflections on Justice and Regret

The feelings of regret from Laura's family regarding the plea deal.

“What was it like for you to sit there that close to the person who had done that to your sister?”
1:26:24

Healing After Tragedy

The family's journey of healing and remembrance for Laura.

“James Smith was sentenced to life plus 27 years He'd be in his 90s before any chance of parole Laura's parents aren't taking any chances So you've been calling every year to make sure that he's still in prison?”
1:27:42

A Mother's Legacy Lives On

How Laura's daughters keep her memory alive in their lives.

“And living means helping Laura's daughters feel their mother's presence.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Dateline NBC, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This podcast is brought to you by Yellow Jackets on Paramount+. The Emmy-nominated series about a 90s girl soccer team stranded in the wilderness after a plane crash returns for its final season. And this season, the Yellow Jackets are finally coming home. But a swarm of endless questions awaits. How did they survive? What really happened out there? And what did they do to finally escape? featuring Melanie Linsky, Christina Ricci, Tawny Cypress, and Hilary Swank. Catch the final season of Yellow Jackets streaming November 20th on Paramount+. Brought to you by the Capital One Saver Card. With Saver, you earn unlimited 3 % cash back on dining, entertainment, and grocery stores.

0:39That's unlimited cash back on ordering takeout from home or unlimited cash back on tickets to concerts and games. So grab a bite, grab a seat, and earn unlimited 3 % cash back For the Saver Card, Capital One, what's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com for details. Tonight on Dateline. It was just like, Laura? It was super hard. I cried because I loved her so much. This one was disturbing right off the bat. It was a young lady. She was displayed almost. Displayed? Displayed. Her hair was slicked back like she had just got out of the shower. She was a beautiful mother trying to make a better life for her girls.

1:28Those girls were the world to her. She had an ex-husband, a very popular local radio host. We do a little morning show here on Mix 107.5. He made comments about his wife on the radio. It was public to everybody that hurt her. We discovered that Laura was in a dating relationship. They were going to meet up after she got off work. She's a waitress at the rib crib. That restaurant itself could have just been chock full of suspects. Right. We come across a box. We get that open. Shocked. Such an evil mindset. This was gonna rock the community. He had caused so much pain. I wasn't gonna let him take anybody else.

2:09A young mother murdered. A calculated killer. And an investigation that would uncover the darkest of secrets. I'm Lester Holt, and this is Dateline.

2:28Here's Blaine Alexander with Hunted.

2:44Clovis, New Mexico It's the kind of place where you'd have to search to find a stranger Where it seems everyone's got a 4x4 And if you're driving through town, odds are you'll spot cousins Josh and Todd Cookta. How long have you lived in this neighborhood? It's lovely. 30 years. Growing up here, the early days of December meant one thing. Pheasant hunting. Anyone you talk to, they plan their weekend around. Everyone would take off work, we'd get out of school. It's like a holiday here. Yes, yeah, exactly. In reality, pheasant season was more like pheasant weekend, just four days long. But for decades, it was the event of the year, bringing visitors from all over.

3:36There used to be thousands of people out here bird hunting. And I'm not even exaggerating about thousands. So it was pretty much bumper to bumper. And you could see cars, lines of cars just going to fields.

3:51On December 10th, 2005, the Cookta cousins loaded up their truck and hit the open road before dawn. Their crew had gotten a good morning haul, taken a break, and were headed back out when they spotted something. We're just cruising around. We've seen the, we thought it was a mannequin at first. It's kind of December after Halloween and people throw stuff out. Sure. Josh and his buddies thought they'd play a joke on the other hunters, propping this mannequin up against a fence. Josh got out of the truck and walked toward the figure. They looked at me like, stand it up against the fence. And I noticed that her fingernails were different than her toenails.

4:36They were painted. Who paints mannequins nails? And so they finally got out and they thought I was messing with them. And when they got out, they kind of realized what was going on. It wasn't a mannequin. It was a woman. She was naked and not moving. So show me about whereabouts y 'all found her. It's kind of in this area. Right down here? Right in here. About 10, 10, 15 yards from the road. So we're talking very close to the road. Oh yeah, yeah. Not far at all? No. And at the time, this ravine wasn't this deep? No. No. It was, the bar ditch was maybe a foot or two deep. So she wasn't hidden? No.

5:13At all? One of the men checked the woman's pulse. Nothing. Josh called 911. I made the phone call, but I had to give the phone to him. Because, yeah, I couldn't talk. It was a loss of words. You were that stunned? Oh, yeah. 100%. Little Clovis. Yeah, yeah. I don't expect that. Soon, law enforcement was swarming the area, including David Loera, an investigator with the DA's office. For the population, we have quite a bit of murders in Clovis. But a lot of them are two guys fighting over a football game. This case was different and more disturbing almost immediately. Absolutely. The victim looked to be in her late 20s.

6:01Did you notice any signs of trauma, any blood? There was a blunt trauma to her forehead. The investigator noted she had some body piercings, but no jewelry. She had a piercing on her eye, on her nose, and on her navel that had been removed. Was it by her, by the person, covering it up? What else did you notice about her body? How was she positioned? She was displayed almost. Displayed? Displayed. She wasn't just thrown out there. She was almost like placed, like gently placed. She was face up, her right hand was up on her side, and her legs were just straight in front of her. Was there anything around her, any of her clothes?

6:45Were they scattered around her? A purse, a wallet, anything? No clothing. The only thing that I saw that was kind of, that stood out was a can of Bud Light beer. Bud Light? Bud Light. And it wasn't, it didn't look like it was old. It didn't look like it had been out there for a long time. Was it put there at the same time that she was? We didn't know, but it definitely stuck out. So did this, one very distinctive mark on the woman's body. She did have a tattoo of a butterfly on her back. A mystery victim and a killer who apparently made no effort to hide her. And there would be more secrets hiding in plain sight, darker than anyone could imagine.

7:30She was concerned. You could hear it in her voice. He was just weird. He would creep her out. He was obsessed with her. No blood, no DNA. It sounds like whoever did this was somebody who knew what they were doing. Very much so. This was truly just such a dark, evil plan.

8:04There are some places where crime is almost non-existent. Clovis, New Mexico isn't one of them. In your line of work, you've seen more than your fair share of dead bodies. Yes. But it sounds like just something about this one. This one was hard. It was a young lady. It could have been your daughter. It could have been your sister. And just to be placed out there the way she was, that was very disturbing. A woman left on a remote stretch of road. Who was she? Officials deployed the county's Major Crimes Unit, a team of investigators from law enforcement agencies across the region. Matt Chandler was the director of major crimes at the time and district attorney.

8:49He grew up in Clovis, and it seemed knew almost everyone in town. You got a good look at her face. Did you recognize her while you were out there at the scene? I had this gut feeling that I knew her, but I could not place it. I would imagine that in a town the size of Clovis, that's not too unexpected, but it's got to be really eerie, really troubling. It was. They didn't have much to go on, just that butterfly tattoo and some piercings. But as D.A. Chandler was driving away from the scene, something clicked. It dawned on me that I think this was a waitress that had waited on us in Clovis during the lunch hour.

9:35But I didn't know anything about her. I didn't know her name. I didn't know any of her background. but it dawned on me that this was someone that I had some type of conversation with. She must have been pretty memorable for that to stick in your mind even those weeks later. Obviously, it's a small town. One connection quickly led to another. That lunch he remembered was with a police officer at a spot called the Rib Crib. Matt called that officer to see if he remembered the waitress. The officer did. He once taught her as a student in a self-defense class. But he was just the sub that day, so he called the teacher of that class, Clovis Police Detective Robert Tejas.

10:20He said they had a body that they were trying to identify, and he said he was pretty confident that I might know who this individual was. Detective Tejas rushed to the funeral home, where police had moved the body for a preliminary autopsy. When he saw her, there was no doubt. I walked in, recognized that it was Laura. Laura McNaughton, just 30 years old. Around the same time officers were learning her name, about 1 ,000 miles away in San Diego, Laura's mother was at home, where she was struck by a sudden and terrifying thought. It was 10.30, I looked at the clock, and I said something happened to Laura.

11:02Laura was lucky in David Beardmore's firstborn. Did you think, oh, there's something to this, or no, I just need to move past it? I didn't want to believe anything happened. It just came in and out so fast that I just kept on doing what I was doing that day. Laura and her parents had always been especially close. We had a real special connection with Laura. Very unique. She was the oldest of four sisters. And David, for you, you were so clearly outnumbered. I was outnumbered. My mom phrases it's like, friends are going to come and go, but your sisters are going to be always there. Jackie was two years younger than Laura.

11:47Then came Maria, and then Crystal, the baby. What was Laura like as a big sister growing up? She was just so sweet. She was the sweetest out of all of us. Like, she didn't even know how to be mean. She was just... She tried. And then it'd be like, did she just really say that? Her personality was extremely contagious. Like, anybody who met her would remember her. Oh, I admired her a lot. Crystal especially admired her big sister's work ethic. Laura started working during high school at the local roller rink. That's where she met Jeff McNaughton. She says, Mom, I met a really nice guy. She was all bubbly.

12:29and everything, you know. But for Laura's dad, a naval officer, any boy dating one of his daughters would have to pass inspection. I'd have to say, as a young man coming to court, any one of your daughters, getting grilled by a military officer can certainly, sounds like it could be intimidating. I just said, if you have wrong intentions, I do have a bat. And Jeff did come over one day when I got off work, and he was different, you know. nice, polite. Laura and Jeff dated during her senior year. And after she graduated from high school, she had some big news to share. She was pregnant. And I remember just crying and I said, oh, she's going to leave us.

13:15She's going to have a family of her own now. But Laura didn't go anywhere. Jeff moved in with her family. Lucky watched their baby girl while Jeff and Laura worked. Jeff had a job at the local radio station. They're trying to make their way in the world, working, juggling, being new parents. That's a lot to balance. But they got through it. He worked two jobs. He worked as a DJ in the weekends, and then she was a waitress. They married in 1997 and had another daughter. What kind of mother was she? Oh, she was very attentive. I mean, her girls were everything. thing. When the kids were still young, Jeff saw a chance to take his radio career to the next level.

13:58He and a business partner bought a small station in Clovis, New Mexico, where they would host a popular morning show, Rooney and Moon. On the radio, Jeff went by the name Duffy Moon. I'm Duffy Moon. That's Steve Rooney right over there. For Laura, the move was sudden, her family says, and not easy. Crystal saw how much her big sister missed home and the big city. I promised her that after I graduated, I would go and live with her. So I went two weeks after I graduated high school. Wow. That's such a stunningly mature thing to do. Yeah. For a sister. I mean, because you're a San Diego girl yourself.

14:36Oh yeah. I knew she needed me. She moved in with Laura's family and the sisters worked together at the rib crib. She was so friendly. Like, I mean, everybody knew her there and she knew everybody. She was really leaning into this position. Like she was being the very best that she could. And I mean, this is a type of position where kindness is currency, right? Yes. Like, yeah, if your customers like you, you get better tips. Yeah. Oh, she was always going. A great waitress. Yes. But Laura was working toward more for her and for her daughters. She was going to school to earn her associate's degree, and she had big goals.

15:16She wanted to get her degree, so either become a military officer or she wanted to be a school teacher. But one part of her future did not work out as planned. Laura and Jeff's marriage didn't last. They divorced after nearly seven years and shared custody of their girls. You know, work, school, the kids, she had this, you know, I'm just going to keep, I got to keep going. This is what I have to do. And she never stopped. Until that cold morning in December 2005, when Lucky's terrifying premonition turned out to be true. Laura's dad got a phone call from Laura's divorce attorney. His daughter had been killed.

15:57Now David had to make the devastating calls to the rest of the family. He said, Lucky, get home. And I'd never heard that voice before. I said, what's up? He says, one of the girls got hurt. So when I pulled up my three daughters, Maria, Crystal, and Jacqueline, Laura, there, and I said, oh, it's Laura. They wasted no time jumping in their cars and driving to New Mexico. Once in Clovis, Laura's family joined the many visitors there for pheasant season. But they would be on a hunt for answers. There was a killer that was loose. This looked to be well thought out and calculated.

16:44The Mighty Dollar. Once had a whole menu named after it. No more. But$1 a day lets you add Progressive renter's insurance to your auto insurance. Something your younger self would roll their eyes at, but your current adulting self? Appreciates. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Average premium costs based on progressive home data from 2025. Product and prices may vary by state. Mint Mobile took what's wrong with wireless and made it right with premium wireless for 15 bucks a month. All plans come with high-speed data and unlimited talk and text delivered on the nation's largest 5G network.

17:27You can even bring your current phone and your number. So what are you waiting for? To get your new wireless plan for 15 bucks a month, Go to mintmobile.com slash dateline. That's mintmobile.com slash dateline. Cut your wireless bill to 15 bucks a month at mintmobile.com slash dateline. Limited-time offer, upfront payment of$45 for three months, $90 for six months, or$180 for 12 months. Plan required,$15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. Initial plan term only, greater than 50 gigabytes, may slow when network is busy. Capable device required. Availability, speed, and coverage varies.

18:06See mintmobile.com. This is the story of the one. As a shipping manager, he's running the dock, stocking supplies, and making sure every order goes out on time. And Grainger helps him stay prepared. From shipping supplies to PPE to hand tools, he counts on Grainger to keep products moving and trucks rolling. So his operation runs smoothly, no matter the shift. Call 1-800-GRAINGER. Click grainger.com or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.

18:48It's nearly a thousand miles from San Diego to Clovis, New Mexico. Hours of sprawling desert usually make for a pretty peaceful drive. But for the Beardmores, it was sheer torture. I don't even know how we did it. 18 hours of my parents sitting in the backseat, you know, just crying, no music. As you're making that ride up there, what are you thinking? Are you starting to get any idea in your mind of what could have possibly happened? No, I just... Just such disbelief and it's just like she's gone and she's... I'm not going to come back. Like, are you serious? Like, she's not going to come back.

19:36She's not going to be here tomorrow. She's not going to call the phone. Like, this is going to be the last moments. Once they made it to Clovis, Laura's family met with Matt Chandler. And he had his whole task force for the police, the sheriff, state troopers, DA's office, all there, and introduced all of us to them. How many officers would you say were in that room? About 15. 15. And they all sat before you and said, we are going to solve this case. Yes. It was probably shortly after the details came out and they were, she was in a field, found nude. Yeah. So I mean, those days we were there were painful and a blur.

20:20Investigators were already conducting a full search of Laura's home. It was empty when they arrived. Her two daughters had been spending the night at their dad's. There was nothing really out of place in the residence. There was a, her apron from the rib crib was setting on her dresser. We did notice that her book that she usually takes her orders from was placed in her room. Her kind of waitress notebook? Yes. So that means she made it home after work. She went into her house. They learned Laura got off work around 9.45 that night and probably got home not long after that. The only thing out of the ordinary, it was a bottle of Bud Light beer in the trash.

21:02The same beer? Same beer. That was found out at the scene? Did you file that away? Yes. And in conversations with her family, she wasn't the type that would drink beer. And so that was suspicious. But otherwise, everything was in place. Judging from the orderly home, investigators reached at least one conclusion. Wherever she was killed, it wasn't the house. She was taken somewhere else. The medical examiner determined Laura's cause of death, blunt force trauma to the head, and strangulation, a very personal way to kill. All we knew is it's someone she knew because she put her stuff down. There was no struggle, so she either opened the door or left the house with someone she knew.

21:48Even if Laura willingly let her kill her inside that night, investigators still had no idea how she'd ended up here. Police kept the hunters who found her body at the scene for hours. They took pictures of all of our boots, both left and right. And I remember taking pictures of the ground around where we had walked. It sounds like for that first little bit, they were questioning you guys. Oh, yeah. Trying to see where you had been or if you were possibly involved. Yeah, right. We got grilled pretty good. Yeah. We were out here for probably six hours after we found those questions. And then they'd leave us by ourselves for a while.

22:26and then they'd come back and talk to us again. How were you feeling during that time? I was still in disbelief. It was bad. Anxiety was high. For a long time. Yeah, just for questioning, but it was a scary situation. The hunters were finally cleared. Now investigators had to consider others who were in town for pheasant hunting. Is there conversation about wanting to keep some people in town or at least get a chance to question some of these folks before they come in and leave? Well, is it possible that some of these hunters went by the rip crib and first made contact with Laura or had any conversation with her and then tried to keep them in town?

23:11While we investigate, that's very difficult. As investigators continued to process the crime scene, they made note of the bizarre way Laura's body was left. She looked like she had just got out of the shower. Her hair was slicked back and used to have the comb marks on there. That's not common. Either did they catch her coming out of the shower somewhere or did they clean her up before they placed her out there? To Loera, it was as if, in some twisted way, Laura's killer had cared for her, placing her just so. And if the killer had washed her body, that spoke to a certain intimacy, as well as a way to erase evidence.

23:55No blood, no DNA, she's placed out there. It sounds like whoever did this was somebody who knew what they were doing. Very much so. We investigated a lot of homicides throughout my career, and so all of them are disturbing. But I knew this one was going to rock the community. What made you say that? There was a killer that was loose. There was someone that was very meticulous. This looked to be well thought out and planned and calculated. To find out who'd killed Laura, investigators would need to dig into her personal life. And they had an obvious place to start. I think all Clovis knew that it was not a friendly divorce.

24:38The whole city knew? Yes.

24:53Police were focused on the people closest to Laura McNaughton. And in Clovis, it didn't get much closer than this. The first person we're going to look at is going to be the ex-husband. Jeff McNaughton. Laura's family told police their marriage had been rocky for years before the divorce. It started when the couple moved to Clovis. They said Laura felt forced to uproot her life to support Jeff's radio career. Him starting a business out there and stress, you did see a drift in their relationship. Crystal saw the tension firsthand when she lived with them. He worked a lot. Long hours and then coming home and not much interaction, I think.

25:38What would Laura say to you during that time? She just felt that wasn't for her there and that she wasn't really loved or wanted. Because she loved him deeply. It just, the move was just too hard. Laura missed her family terribly and felt, in Clovis, she just didn't fit in. She was having a hard time making friends. They're a little different now. You know, it's more country. And she was having a hard time finding a place out there for herself. She was just so unhappy. and you got this beautiful bright light and then you start to dim it and it's like I just want her to shine again, you know? You felt like she deserved a better life.

26:18I felt like she deserved to be happy. She deserved everything that, you know, she should have had. What do you think was the final straw for Laura? She wanted to come home. She felt that if she got a divorce that she would be able to come back home. Come home with her girls, of course. But that didn't turn out quite as planned. He wasn't going to let go. and he was going to fight tooth and nail for her to stay. A custody battle dragged out in court. In the end, the judge ordered the daughters to stay in Clovis, where Laura and Jeff would share custody. Oh, she was really upset. She was really crying real hard in the parking lot, very hard.

26:57And I said, babe, you know, even though you have to stay here, I'll come out as much as I can to visit you. Do you think that she was caught off guard by how hard Jeff fought for custody? Yes, she was. I mean, she loved him, and she even loved him after the divorce. And I think how it had gotten so ugly that she didn't think that would ever happen. That really, that hurt her. So now you're here in this place where you are having to rack your brain and think of who could possibly hurt your sister. Is he coming to mind? He's the only person that we knew out there that would do anything. You know, he was the only one that would gain from her not being here.

27:40He would have the girls. They're there forever. Laura's family shared the details of the divorce with investigators. But to them, this wasn't exactly new information. I think all Clovis knew there was not a friendly divorce. The whole city knew? Yes. That's because around town, Jeff was very much the local celebrity. The High Plains Fest morning. With Rooney and Moon. The Rooney and Moon show dominated the morning drive. And back in 2005, I mean, this is before podcasts. Right. Morning radio really was something that grabbed the attention of everybody in the community. It was kind of how you started your day.

28:20If you spent five to ten minutes in your vehicle getting from one spot to the other, you're going to listen to these guys. So it's no stretch to say that everybody in town knew his name. Not sure if they knew his real name, but everybody knew Duffy Moon. We're Rooney and Moon. Steve Rooney and Duffy Moon. Did you listen to it? Oh, all the time. You're a fan? I was a fan. You know, they're funny. I see you smiling. They're very comical. You know, they were always talking about different things, and they were definitely entertaining. Jeff and his co-hosts were known for their witty morning banter about, well, everything.

28:55And that included Jeff's personal life. He definitely wasn't shy about making comments about his divorce. and definitely didn't hide that he wasn't happy with the divorce. It threw more like jabs, like jokes, and then they'd laugh about it. Not everyone found it funny. He was being nasty, you know. He said she was a bad cook, and he got down on who she was as a person. You know, if you're getting divorced, I mean, to be saying that on the radio station, she listened to the radio all the time. The whole town heard it. It upset me when I heard about it. That's not cool at all to do that. She was just so hurt that he had made some comments and that they had spent so many years together and they shared children together.

29:40And that it was public to everybody in the town. That it was embarrassing. That everybody kind of knew their business as he put it out. Yeah. That was hurtful. Investigator Loetta remembered something Jeff said on his show just a week before Laura was killed. The station had hosted a Christmas fundraiser, with Jeff taking part in a rather unusual stunt. During the skit, Jeff McNaughton had been buried into a hole, and they were raising money for Secret Santa. And people were donating money. Once they reached a certain amount, then they would pull them out of this hole. He'd essentially been buried alive.

30:21Yes. And he made several comments about, hmm, I don't know how I could get my wife down here in one of these holes. Which was odd. At the time, I'm like, that's kind of, you know, he went a little bit overboard. Did your mind immediately flash back to that comment? Oh, absolutely. And I brought it up as soon as I identified her. I said, this guy, he wasn't happy with his divorce. I said, everybody knew because he talked about it quite often on the show. And then a week later, she's dead. She's dead. As Duffy Moon, Jeff had plenty to say about Laura on a hot mic. Would he be just as talkative with police?

31:00You just flat out ask him. Did you kill your wife? Yes.

31:17Jeff McNaughton had made no secret about how bitter his divorce had become, and he shared it with every one of his morning listeners. I've known Jeff for a long time. Matt Chandler was friends with Jeff. He'd even been a guest on his radio show. At the time, being the district attorney, he was covering the majority of the things that we were doing. He was very supportive of law enforcement. He was very supportive of community initiatives. And so we had a professional relationship. Now the DA picked up the phone and asked Jeff to come in. I remember it clearly. He came in and we sat down with him in the briefing, showed him the tattoo, and he immediately broke down and he said, that's her tattoo.

32:01Knowing him personally and seeing just the confusion and how distraught he was, it was a tough moment to sit through. To the DA, Jeff appeared devastated. But homicide investigators still had a job to do. You go into this interview, you've got somebody who's literally been openly broadcasting the fact that he does not like his ex-wife. Somebody she would have opened the door for. I mean, it sounds like this is your top suspect going into this interview. You never want to go with tunnel vision into an interview. But definitely he had a lot of red flags pointing his way. And we thought this is our guy.

32:45So sitting down there in that room with him, how did that conversation start? I was always looking at him thinking, okay, this guy's a personality on the radio. They're pretty quick. They think quick on their feet. So I was expecting him to be really sharp. He didn't come across like that. He was distraught. So immediately you're seeing a distinction between his radio personality and the man who's sitting before you. Yes. At some point, you just flat out ask him, did you kill your wife? Yes. What did he say? No, absolutely not. He pressed Jeff on where he was the night his ex-wife was murdered.

33:20Lay out his alibi. Home with the girls. They watch TV. He puts them to bed at eight. He's there at the house by himself. No one that could verify that he was there. Could he have left when the girls fell asleep? Absolutely. Certainly not the most solid of alibis. Jeff seemed cooperative to investigators. And after almost an hour, they had no evidence to hold him. but they weren't ready to take him at his word. I had a thought that this guy was telling the truth, but at the same token, is he performing? Is this a performance? Is he used to being asked questions and answering on the spot? Jeff agreed to come back later for a polygraph, and police turned to other people in Laura's life.

34:06Talking to Laura's co-workers, they were giving up people that would know where Laura was that night, you know, who would she be with, and Joel Delaney's name came up. As a guy that should date in there in Clovis. Joel Delaney. He worked as a railroad conductor in Clovis. Crystal hadn't heard much about Joel from her sister, just that he and Laura had been casually seeing each other. I knew that they were hanging out, that they were friends. I didn't think much of it. I want to say he was a few years younger than her. So I just thought, well, he's younger, so I don't think she looked at it as anything.

34:46Serious. Like a fun little distraction. Yeah. Kind of. When police spoke to Laura's co-workers, they found out that the night she was killed, Laura and Joel had plans to get together after she got home from work. So you go and look for Joel Delaney. Yes. And you find that he'd left town. Yes. Was that immediately a red flag for you? Oh, absolutely. Laura had plans to meet him after work. And then when we go looking for him, he's out of town. He's gone. They talked to some of his friends who'd seen him the night of the murder. They were all at a bar together earlier in the evening. When he first showed up, he was kind of quiet.

35:21He had a couple beers, and then he left. Then, a little while later... He shows back up. Same night? Same night. About an hour and a half, maybe two hours afterwards. But he's changed. He's showered. And they said, where'd you go? oh, I just went home to go change and get ready. That's it? That's it. No explanation? No explanation. Did his friends who saw him at the bar, did they seem to have questions about that? They thought it was odd that he showed up, they're having, you know, beers, all of a sudden he leaves and he's just gone. A shower and change of clothes in the middle of a night out certainly seemed suspicious, especially since they estimated he left the bar around the time they believed Laura was killed.

36:05I mean, as you spell that out to me, That sounds pretty sketchy. Oh, definitely. Because now we're looking at the time frame that she died. And would he be able to go get her, knock her out, kill her, make it out there? It could have happened. Or if he still had the body with him as he went back to the bar, to have an alibi saying, oh, no, he was back at the bar. Yeah, that would have been a good alibi. That would have been a good alibi. Investigators really needed to find Joel Delaney. And when they finally did, they would find something else. How would he explain this? Blood everywhere, all over the backseat.

36:46A strange thing happens when you put off finishing your college degree. Maybe next semester turns into five years, and the thought is still lingering, waiting, haunting you. That's what Southern New Hampshire University understands. They have more than 200 affordable, flexible online degree programs. And the application takes just minutes to complete. Don't let your degree linger like an unsolved case. Apply today at snhu.edu slash dateline. Hey, what's up, guys? It's Haley Bailey. Okay, I need to tell you about something. I just got YouTube Premium. It's got tons of awesome features like offline downloads, so I can download my favorite videos before I travel and watch them whenever I don't have Wi-Fi.

37:30because we all know airplane Wi-Fi is the worst. I get ad-free, I get backroom play, and there's like a ton more in there. You should try it. If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. Try it now for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel any time. That's a mouthful. When an intruder approaches a home, they expect a camera. What they don't expect... Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way. Using smart AI cameras, live U.S.-based agents help deter intruders in under 30 seconds. Don't just record a break-in, stop it from ever happening.

38:03Plan starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70 % off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com slash sxm. 30 seconds response time requires monitoring plan with outdoor protection starting at$49.99 a month. Visit simplisafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information.

38:28in Clovis David Beardmore's position as a naval officer meant the family could stay on a nearby military base which was one small comfort during a terrifying and anxious time how did you guys get through, especially those first few days? I don't know. Just trying to find out who did this. And I think your mind's just all over the place. Yeah, you're still in shock that you're not going to see your baby again. I mean, we were walking in the town looking around like, you know, we went out to eat one night and it was just like nerve wracking. We all looked at everybody kind of. Because you're sitting in the restaurant thinking the person responsible could be sitting in this restaurant.

39:17Investigators had their sights set on a suspect, Joel Delaney. He was supposed to have seen Laura the night she died. And now the railroad conductor had apparently sped out of town. Police were looking for him and word spread fast. I knew Joel. He was a railroader too. Even cousins Josh and Todd Cookta heard about it. You both knew him? Yes, and Joel was the one that I kind of thought, well, maybe it was, because they said that Joel split town, didn't tell anybody where he was or anything, and he was gone. And so we were like, well, you put two and two together, you're kind of freaking out. That's a good guy.

39:56I don't think it would be him. But did it make you question him when you heard that? Personally, it did. And I don't want to be that guy, but it did make me question it. Police kept watch on Joel's house, and after two days out of town... He finally shows back up to his house, and we catch him at his house. Where was he during that time? He just said he was in Albuquerque. And he agreed to come to the station to answer some questions. He did cooperate. You know, he wasn't forthcoming right away. As the same token, he was, I think, a little nervous because his girlfriend that he was supposed to be with was just found dead.

40:30And now he's being brought in and questioned. Joel told investigators that Laura canceled their plans at the last minute. He said he received a call about 10.15 that night, and she told him, hey, something came up, I'll talk to you later. Any details of what came up? She did not say. She told him, if something came up, I'll talk to you later. And this is all according to him? Yes. So what are you thinking as he's telling you this? Is he being truthful on the time? You know, we know he's supposed to meet her, but we also know that he showed up at the bar by himself. Investigator Loera continued to press Joel on his movements that night, and the interview became increasingly tense.

41:13You could tell that he was uncomfortable. Yes, very uncomfortable. Fidgeting. I can't believe this. I can't believe this happened. Getting a little agitated, because we're going after the same question after the same question. He says, that's my answer. I can't tell you no more. I went home, I changed, I came back. It was getting heated. It became less questions and more accusations. And the more accusations, the more Joel pushed back. It was kind of shutting him down. He was getting defensive. He was very defensive, very defensive. At that point, the pressure's on, the clock's ticking, and not getting the answers that we want, albeit it could be his best explanation of where he was, but it still didn't make sense.

42:02and he had agreed to do a polygraph examination and then decided to stop the interview that evening. They let him go and he promised to come back the next day for the polygraph. When you're looking at this big picture, where is he in your kind of list of suspects at this point? He's frankly at the kind of the top of the list of suspects at this point. I'm just thinking we're going to have to search more. We're going to have to look into his whereabouts. We're going to have to search his house. We're going to have to search his vehicle. There's a lot more here than meets the eye. And you guys did search?

42:38We did. They started with his truck, with Joel's permission. So the first thing they do in the backseat, they use luminol. And that whole backseat just lit up. Blood? Blood everywhere, all over the backseat. How do you explain blood in your backseat? At first he said, I don't know how I got there. I don't know how I got there. I don't know how the blood got there. I can't explain it. There's no way. And to be clear, this isn't just open blood. It's blood that has been cleaned up. Yes, or soaked in. And we're like, with a blunt trauma to her head, she would have bled out quite a bit. On second thought, Joel said maybe he did know where it came from.

43:17He said that it was bird blood, that he had also been hunting, and that he had killed a bird or birds and had put him in the backseat of his truck. As a hunter yourself, did that make sense to you? I've gone hunting a lot of times and I've never thrown my game in the backseat of my truck or anybody else's truck. Are you immediately thinking, These guys, we got them. Bingo. Yep, we got them. Investigators cut out part of the backseat and rushed to get it tested. Was this the break they needed? Or would another clue send them to a place that even seasoned detectives couldn't fathom? One of the detectives called me aside, and he said, we got an interesting find here.

44:05The note was to his family. They're trying to frame me for the death of this girl. If I could take justice into my own hands, it would have been done. He was a wolf in sheep's clothing. I mean, this was a cold-blooded killer. But in reality, he's more than that.

44:33The man Laura McNaughton had been dating had bloodstains in the backseat of his truck and an explanation that seemed to defy common sense. So hearing blood in the back of his truck, what did you all think? Odd. Yeah, like, who does that? Growing up being a bird hunter and stuff, you never throw birds in the backseat of your pickup. You throw them in the bed. Throw your pickup. Why would you ever throw it in the backseat? That's just common knowledge if you're a pheasant hunter. Yeah, 100%. As police awaited the results from the lab, Joel agreed to take a polygraph. Patrick Whitney was the polygrapher at Clovis Police.

45:11I was actually in my polygraph office constructing my questions. He had already said yes, and then I guess he had consulted with an attorney, and his attorney advised him not to take the test. What did you think? That made me a little more suspicious of him. To essentially pull out like that? Right. Then the lab results from his truck came back. What does it show? It's not human blood. When you get that news. You're like, I was for sure. Especially with the way that backseat lit up. Joel had been telling the truth. It was, in fact, bird blood. Wow. I bet when you got those results, you could hardly believe it.

45:51It wasn't the results that I honestly expected. Just because of such the bizarre nature of it all. And this was a guy who, I mean, you said was at the top of your suspect list. Right. Police took a closer look at Joel's story and concluded the window of time he'd been away from the bar was just too tight to commit the murder. Joel was cleared. We're still investigating this. We're still just trying to figure out who did this and where are they? Joel was eliminated as a suspect. But what about Laura's ex-husband, Jeff? He showed up for his polygraph. When he comes in for the polygraph that day, how is he?

46:35He's very glum, very sad demeanor. Having met him before, he's a very gregarious, outgoing person. So I asked him the question, did you strangle Laura? And then, do you know for sure who strangled Laura? So how is Jeff responding? to those questions. He had no problem saying no to those questions. He passed. He passed. There was no gray area, none at all. He passed with flying colors on that test. Investigators also looked at Jeff's story that he was home with his daughters. We were able to confirm his whereabouts on that particular day. Jeff was not the killer. Jeff was clearly put into a set of circumstances that he had no control over.

47:23I respect him and the things that he's done to raise his daughters, but he has certainly helped us out through the investigation, and we were grateful for that. I didn't think he had it in him or it would, I mean, even though it was an ugly divorce. That would have sucked for the girls. You know, the girls wouldn't have their mom, and they wouldn't have their dad either, you know, but I'm glad it wasn't him. Was that a feeling of relief? Yeah, but then it was also like, then who else? How frustrating is this for you? Extremely, because now you're like, okay, my ex-husband. And if it wasn't him, we're looking at the blood in the truck of the boyfriend.

48:01And then both of them come up with no evidence saying that it was them. So you have to keep your eyes open and see what other avenues you have. Which meant looking at anyone and everyone in town who knew Laura. Was there anybody that you could think of that she had issues with that could have been upset toward her, that she'd had a clash with or anything like that? Not at all. What were her fellow employees there saying about her, just personality-wise? The same. She was very friendly. She got along with everybody. There were several people that would come in and sit in her section. They loved conversations with her.

48:42Her sister Jackie says Laura's kindness was a natural draw. People just wanted to be around her. But it also brought unwanted attention. There was always some guy trying to hit on Laura that she just, she wasn't interested. Even if you told her how to let a guy down, she wouldn't even know how to do it. It was like par for the course. Yeah. Popular waitress there? Very popular. I mean, that restaurant itself could have just been chock full of suspects. Right. Anybody that she could have become familiar with, become friendly with, possibly might have opened the door for. Oh, absolutely. And it wasn't long before investigators were on the hunt for one customer in particular.

49:23And this is just a random customer, like somebody who has come in and is upset that she's not there. Yeah, she thought it was weird.

49:34If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. It's destroying athlete, creator, and YouTube maxer. YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads so I can download my favorite training videos before I hit the gym. So no Wi-Fi doesn't turn leg day into loading day. Plus, I get ad-free videos, background play, and so much more. YouTube Premium is like YouTube got some extra gains. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel anytime. time. Traditional home security only alerts you after a break-in and that's too late.

50:09SimpliSafe is changing that. Stop. This is SimpliSafe. Police are on the way. We don't just alert. We help stop crime before it starts. Plans starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70 % off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com slash sxm. SimpliSafe, ahead of crime in real time. Outdoor deterrence plans start at$49.99 a month. Visit SimpliSafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Over the years, I've met people whose lives were changed forever in a single moment. In my new podcast, Before and After, I explore what happens after that decisive moment.

50:46Personal, powerful conversations with Colin Kaepernick, Jeremy Renner, Gabby Giffords, and others. Join me wherever you get your podcasts. Listen to all episodes of Before and After with Lester Holt now, wherever you get your podcasts.

51:13Few things are as painful as losing someone at the hand of someone else. For those left behind, that loss is just the beginning. And all that's left to fill the void is the constant reminder of what was. We lost everything. I think we all lost a piece of ourselves. We're never going to get it back. We're reminded all the time because we're with each other. And you know there's something missing in the room. Laura's move to Clovis had been hard on all of them. Now, after her death, there was one thing they could finally do for her. It was important for you all to bring her home to San Diego to lay her to rest.

51:58Tell me about the service out here that y 'all had. Oh, the service out here. I almost passed out that day. The emotions were so high. It was a final. Like, I know it's true. The service here was a little hard for me because it was seeing her for not her bubbly personality. It was, I needed to make sure it was her. It was just so hard. It was very hard. It was hard to even leave my house to go. In the midst of their grief, Laura's family received a reminder of what Laura had been working toward. Laura got her associate's degree and it was sent to me. Being able to posthumously receive that had to have been special.

52:47Yeah. She was so determined. Yes. She was. Laura's family was just as determined for answers and thought they had a lead. They told investigators how a couple weeks before Laura was killed, she was with them in San Diego for Thanksgiving. During that visit, Laura got a call from a colleague at the rib crib. So she had got a phone call from a worker saying that this guy had came into her section and was asking for her and that he became very agitated when they said she's out visiting her family in San Diego. Agitated like what? Like aggressive, like, well, how long has she been there? When is she coming back?

53:33and just took off out of the place, like didn't even want to be there anymore. And this is just a random customer, like somebody who has come in and is upset that she's not there? Yeah, because he wanted to sit in her section and he was asking specifically for her. What did she tell you about it later? She thought it was weird. When investigators spoke with Laura's co-workers, they confirmed there was a regular customer who seemed fixated on her. This person would frequent the restaurant and would always come in on Fridays, only Friday afternoons, demand to sit in her section and have a beer, but then leave a large tip, cash tip for her, and was flirtatious with her.

54:20And then would leave and not come back in until the next Friday. Her co-worker said that he was a young white male, maybe mid-30s, blonde hair, and always came in in scrubs. Scrubs. Medical scrubs. So you're thinking doctor, medical assistant. It could be anything. It could be a nurse. It could be a lab tech. It could be a doctor. Investigators filed into their war room at Clovis PD. We started going through a list of every doctor, every medical practice, every dentist office that we knew. And we started with a dry erase board and we were writing names on the dry erase board. Who's the leader of this practice or who's the doctor and who's the dentist?

55:07And let's just start going out into the community and asking them to report back. How many names are up on that white erase board? It was like the old school yellow pages. So we're talking, I mean, dozens and dozens of names, I would assume. Any medical practice in Clovis. We're just shooting in the dark at this point. Detectives took the list and fanned out across town. We sent a group of guys down to, I said, hit every clinic, every hospital, give you a card, ask questions about, you know, if anybody matches this description. That's got to be a fine line to walk. walking into medical offices as investigators, I mean, do you say, hey, we're investigating a homicide.

55:50We're looking for a killer. How do you get in there? You never give them too much information. So we just said, hey, we're trying to find this guy. This is his description. Does it match anybody that you have? Were the offices typically pretty willing to help? Most of them. It's a small town. Everybody knows each other. Are people getting names back to you? No. So it's not really turning up much. No. Detective Tejas was one of the investigators canvassing the area. He left his card at a health clinic that had offices in Clovis and Portales, another town 20 miles away. That visit would lead to a phone call and to a name, one that surprised everyone.

56:32He says, hey Matt, you remember me? And yeah, of course I remember you.

56:50The Clovis Major Crimes Unit was working around the clock. Their two potential suspects, Laura's ex-husband and the railroad man she'd been dating, were both cleared. Investigators were trying to ID that customer from the rib crib, the one who had seemed infatuated with Laura. But that was proving harder than expected. This is a time when there's a killer out there. Nobody knows who it is. But everybody's looking around at people that they possibly know, people that they possibly see every day. How did it feel in the community during that time? It was intense. There was a real sense of urgency behind the investigation.

57:30There was obviously an understanding that there was someone out there that committed this crime that was walking the streets of Clovis. People are pointing fingers at each other. They're pointing fingers. And they're saying, I heard this, I heard that. But sometimes all it takes is one phone call to break a case wide open. You all are in this war room and you get word that somebody's calling and looking for you. Yes, I get a phone call from the district attorney's office and we're kind of off site. We're in a briefing room. And the phone call was that Dr. James Smith had called and wanted to talk to you about the investigation.

58:11Dr. James Smith. He was a dentist at that health clinic with two offices. I knew James Smith, Dr. Smith. He knew me, went to the same church, kind of had the same circles a little bit. D.A. Chandler called him back immediately. He says, hey, Matt, this is James Smith. You remember me? And yeah, of course I remember you. And he said, hey, there was a detective that came by and left his card and wanted me to call you guys back and talk to you about the homicide that happened over the weekend. He mutes the phone call. Matt Chandler. Matt Chandler. And he says, did anybody say anything about looking into a murder?

58:55And they said, no. We just said, hey, we're just looking for a description of this guy. So he's volunteering information that was never even given. Never given. That was interesting. And so was the fact that he matched the physical description of the customer they were looking for. White male, blonde, worked in the medical field. Dr. James Smith came from a well-off family in Clovis. Though he left for college in Texas and dental school in Oklahoma, he came back home to settle down. He was married with two kids and a third on the way. And Chandler wasn't the only member of the major crimes team who knew him.

59:34Detective Tejas remembered him from high school. I remember when he was playing football, he was a pretty tough dude. And like many in Clovis, Investigator Loera knew a lot about his family. Very well-off family. They own several gas stations throughout Clovis. Very prominent in the community. Very active in the church. Definitely a pillar of the community. Smith's father was involved with the local chamber of commerce and the United Way. That sort of creepy description of the person from the restaurant, the one who gets upset when she's not there, doesn't seem to match with a dentist married with kids involved in the church.

1:00:16Yes. So you bring him in for an interview. Yes. Is he willing to talk? Very, very cooperative. Like, I'm not sure what you want to talk to me about. At first, he denied knowing Laura or even having any conversations with her. As the interview progresses, though, what else does he say? He does say that he, yeah, yeah, yeah, I think that's the name of that waitress down at the rib crib. So he did know her. But the investigator noticed James Smith avoided actually saying her name. The girl. He would not put a name on her at the beginning. And you've identified her name. You've said her name. Yes.

1:00:57Yes. Does that stand out to you? It does, especially, you know, if he was the one with the rib crib, he definitely knows her name. You know, he talked to her enough. What are you thinking? I'm thinking he told you the name several times. And he's still not identifying her as Laura. And according to Smith, it was Laura who took interest in him. He played it that she always approached him. Almost to the point that he was explaining that she was the one pursuing him. And to be clear, that's not what you've heard from anybody you've spoken to. That was not what any of the other coworkers saw. But he was making it seem like, oh, yeah, I go have some beers.

1:01:39And this waitress would always approach me and always want to talk to me and always switch sections if he was sitting in a different section. So already you're catching him in some sort of a lie. Yes. He's minimizing the connection with her. And he denied having anything to do with her murder. So where was he on the Friday night Laura was killed? He told investigators he was home alone playing video games. His wife and kids were out of town for the weekend. Through it all, investigators said he was cooperative. And once the interview wrapped, he seemed willing to help however he could. You're welcome to look at my truck if you'd like.

1:02:22You're welcome to go by my house. He's saying, go take a look at my truck. Yeah. So they looked. And what did they find? The investigator that was searching the truck recognized it immediately.

1:02:36If you like YouTube, you'll love YouTube Premium. It's destroying athlete, creator, and YouTube maxer. YouTube Premium enhances how I use YouTube with awesome features like offline downloads so I can download my favorite training videos before I hit the gym. So no Wi-Fi doesn't turn leg day into loading day. Plus, I get ad-free videos, background play, and so much more. YouTube Premium is like YouTube got some extra gains. Try YouTube Premium for two months free at youtube.com slash premium. Trial eligibility varies. Terms apply. Cancel anytime. time. The real cost of a break-in isn't your valuables.

1:03:09It's the feeling that your home stopped being safe. SimpliSafe keeps danger away from your family with three layers of protection. One, smart AI cameras and live U.S.-based agents help stop intruders before they break in. Two, we sound the alarm at points of entry. Three, our agents request emergency response. Plans starting around a dollar a day. Right now, get 70 % off your new system with professional monitoring at simplisafe.com slash sxm. Outdoor deterrence plans start at$49.99 a month. Visit simplysafe.com slash licenses for alarm license information. Monday on NBC, the new season of The Voice has arrived.

1:03:42I'm so excited. Fan favorites Adam Levine and Kelly Clarkson are back to take on two new powerhouses, the legendary Queen Latifah. The queen is in the house. And country superstar Riley Green. Riley is super charming. He is a whole vibe. Can we put that on my chair? It's going to be a wild ride. The Blind Auditions continue on The Voice this Monday on NBC.

1:04:18Laura McNaughton and her mom had the kind of relationship many mother-daughter duos dream of. Laura told her mom everything. So when, about six months before she died, Laura had a dentist appointment that made her feel kind of uncomfortable, she, of course, told her mom about it. And now, Lucky Beardmore was telling investigators. She went to the dentist, and she called me, and she had said, Mom, this dentist was really flirting with me. And I thought, well, you know, that's pretty normal, Laura, for you. And so I didn't think much of it, but she was concerned. You could hear it in her voice. Laura called her mom again the very next day.

1:05:04She called me and startled. Mom, I said, what? She goes, that dentist is in my workplace now. How did he know where she worked? Probably the information that she left at the office. Armed with this detail, investigators were confident the dentist, James Smith, was the man they'd been looking for. Now, they were standing with him in front of the Clovis Police Department, looking through his truck. It was spotless. And let me tell you something, in December in eastern New Mexico, there is no vehicle that is that clean. with the winds that we get and the sleet or the rain. And everything's dirty, except for his truck.

1:05:48His truck is spotless. In fact, it was still a little bit wet from the car wash that he drove through on the way to the interview. You could tell that he had just gotten that thing cleaned. Oh, you could tell. It was strange. So was his behavior. So he's standing right there. He's standing right there. As the investigators are going through his truck. He's standing right there. He would kind of try and engage with the detectives, almost like a distractor. as they opened up doors and started to look through and look closely. To the point where he was walking up close enough behind one of the investigators, who obviously has a firearm on him.

1:06:23It was making him nervous. He was saying, don't stand right behind me. I need you to back up. Like, you need to back up, James. And then... One of the detectives called me aside, and he said, we got an interesting find here. There was a map pocket on the bottom side of the passenger rear door that had a small dried weed or vegetation, almost like a stick, that was probably no bigger than an inch and a half long. What was interesting about it is it was the same vegetation where we had found Laura. It was a clue. And you recognized it immediately from the scene? The investigator that was searching the truck recognized it immediately.

1:07:10At that point, it was time to get a search warrant for the truck. James Smith's strangely spotless truck was impounded as evidence. Techs went through it with a fine-tooth comb, and they found more. There was a strand of hair that was found in the back seat of the truck. To investigators, it looked like it could be Laura's hair. And then on the running board of the truck, there was a small, small drop of what appeared to be dried blood. Considering the fact that he had run this through the car wash, I mean, just how unlikely is it that you even find something like that still in his truck? It was extremely unlikely that we were going to find anything.

1:07:55So it was a real blessing to the investigation that we did. Where did you leave things with James at that point? At that point, we had an agreement that we would come back together the following day, and James would show up for his polygraph examination. So the next day, you, all the investigators, you're all still together, and you get another phone call. Around the lunch hour, we get a phone call from James Smith's wife, and she said, Matt, I think he's going to kill himself. He just called to make sure the kids weren't coming home and that he was going to commit suicide, and he's at the house.

1:08:33So we immediately, the entire team, rushes lights and sirens. Detective Tejas got there first. He had stabbed himself in the gut with a butcher knife. Then the rest of the major crimes unit arrived. James Smith was kind of rolling around the ground in extreme pain. At least he was showing that he was in extreme pain. Are you seeing blood? I mean, describe what you're seeing. There's blood, but not a lot. Not what he's showing on his actions of the pain that he had been in. There wasn't a lot of blood. I'm detecting a note of skepticism in your voice. Yes. He's a doctor. Granted, he's a dentist, but he still had some medical experience.

1:09:12He has an understanding of the human anatomy. And if he's going to kill himself, he'll probably find a better way. Because some of those stab wounds, they look superficial. Patrick Whitney, the polygrapher, had a theory. He thought the wounds were more strategic. I talked to the detectives that were there on scene, and they told me that it looked like he had stabbed himself in the diaphragm muscle just along the ribcage, the bottom of the ribcage. So the place where he stabbed himself would have been essentially where you would have hooked him up for his polygraph. Right, and I wouldn't have been able to do that.

1:09:49I wouldn't have been able to administer the polygraph based on what he did. And I think that's why he did it. After James Smith was taken away by ambulance, investigators found a note on his dining room table. The note was to his family, to his wife, and to his kids, that they're trying to frame me for the death of this girl. Investigators kept digging, and what they would find next still haunts them to this day. You find a box of DVDs. Yes. This was truly just such a dark, evil plan. It was sick. It was all shocking.

1:10:43James Smith was in a hospital, recovering from self-inflicted stab wounds. He stabbed himself. He's left this note. What do you think of all this? We're hopeful that this blood's going to come back to her. We didn't have concrete evidence against him. Investigators got a search warrant for the two health clinics where he worked. They didn't find anything notable at the clinic in Clovis. But in Portales, their first surprise came as soon as they closed Smith's office door. Behind the door, there was a poster of Hilary Duff. Hilary Duff? Yes. Hilary Duff, the then-teenaged actress. Which, not a big surprise, but...

1:11:25Kind of is, though. Yeah, but what's surprising is the piercings that he put on that poster. Piercings, hand-drawn on the eyebrow, nose, and navel. The same spots where Laura had piercings. And he's now kind of edited the poster to have these piercings that resemble. Those of Laura's. And does Hilary Duff resemble Laura a little bit? I guess you could say so. You know, same type of color hair. But those piercings was the exact location. Why would you put that there? Wow. That wasn't all they found. We come across a box. And on the box, he has a little note, give this to my wife. Give this to my wife.

1:12:11Yeah. I'm like, that's kind of odd, you know. So we get that open. Okay. And we find some DVDs in there. They took the DVDs back to headquarters and started to watch. And they all had the same type of scenario. It was in a kind of in a morgue type of setting. Is this actual video of a mortician or is this a produced video? I mean, what are you... It's a produced video. But every one of them had the same scenario of the guy in the morgue setting, the body being brought in and the attendant, you know, washing her up, brushing her hair. So as all of this is going on, I mean, does it become clear to you what you're looking at?

1:12:49Yes. Someone who is infatuated or has a fixation of dead bodies. Investigators had never seen anything like it. Though they were actors playing dead, investigators thought this was evidence of a bizarre fetish. James Smith seemed aroused by dead bodies. The attendant, you know, talking to the dead body, talking to her and caring for her and washing her up. Talking to her saying what? Just like, you know, you're a pretty little girl, or, you know, that's so sad that this is going to happen to you. Just, you know, weird comments that he was making to the corpse. The investigators reached out to the producer and learned those videos were a custom order.

1:13:39He basically said that this guy by the name of James Smith sent him scripts of what he wanted to be created into these videos. So after you all go through those videos, what was the mood in the room there? Kind of sickened, because now we know it wasn't an accident that she was washed up and placed out there. He had an infatuation for her with her piercings, with who she was. he wanted to kill her and play with her body afterwards. That's terrifying. Extremely. This was truly just such a dark, evil plan. It was sick. I mean, it was all shocking. It was all shocking. Then investigators also got the results back from the state crime lab.

1:14:31The drop of blood on Smith's truck was Laura's.

1:14:38James Smith was arrested.

1:15:05Yeah, that's not. So James Smith started talking. This time, instead of downplaying his attraction to Laura, he admitted going to the rib crib every Friday to see her. Were you interested? Yes, interested. Had some very friendly face. Yeah. But he denied being obsessed with Laura and said that poster in his office didn't mean anything. That's complete. My staff got me that, and I grew that stuff two years ago. As a joke, as a joke for that. As for the Friday night Laura was killed, Smith seemed hesitant to say much. What happened, James? I really don't remember what happened. Look at me, James.

1:16:18A witness saw James Smith in his truck near the rib crib around the time Laura got off work. Now, Smith admitted to investigators he followed her home and said Laura was happy to see him when he turned up at her door. But hey, she was gay. Smith said Laura agreed to go to his place to have a beer, though investigators knew Laura didn't drink beer. Once you got home, what happened at the house? Continued to drink some beer. Yeah, with Bud Light. Bud Light, the same beer found at Laura's house and at the crime scene. And then just talking, it was awkward because it seemed like she was waiting for me to say or do something, and I was waiting for her to say or do something.

1:17:18He said that there was an attraction. This is what he's saying? Yes. There was an attraction both ways. I just remember this real physical kind of hug to Bryce or something. Did she push you away? Did she go along? I'm not so sure it was going along. It was, I don't know what happened. And it just turned, either she kind of went with me or I don't know. But she was dead pretty quick. Was Smith saying this was some kind of consensual encounter gone wrong? We went from sitting on the couch talking to you grabbing her loan name. So I felt it was embracing each other or something like that. with each of your hands on each other's throats.

1:18:19That's kind of what you're showing me. Is that what you're saying?

1:18:25I don't know. I mean, she wasn't fighting. But still, something happened. She had a hit on her head. Maybe she fell. Smith didn't have an explanation for the blow to Laura's head. He did admit, after removing her jewelry and clothing, he threw them out. As for getting rid of her body, he said he decided to leave Laura where someone would find her. I figured I'd take her someplace. I knew it was honey, pleasant honey. Can you explain something, James? Well, before she was taken out there, she was cleaned up. Did you clean her up? Just like on the videos. I went down. I guess I'll make sure there's no blood or anything.

1:19:12On her? Right. Any similarity to those videos in his office was just a coincidence, Smith said. He claimed he'd ordered them as research for a book he was writing.

1:19:28There was one thing he insisted he never did.

1:19:43There's no way. Loera and his partner were done. Can I stand up just to stretch the line? James Smith had tried to convince investigators that Laura's death was just an unfortunate accident. What would happen when he faced a judge? He had caused so much pain, unbelievable pain. If I could take justice into my own hands, it would have been done.

1:20:20Laura McNaughton's accused killer was behind bars, and Clovis could breathe a sigh of relief. But once they learned who it was, well, that brought a sense of fear in itself. This is somebody who, as a dentist in the town of Clovis, would have had proximity to a lot of people. Yes. A lot of people coming through his office. And two different talents. Yeah. I know my sister said, hey, that's my dentist when we arrested him. I was like, that's creepy. It could have been almost anybody. But for whatever reason, James Smith had chosen Laura. Kind Laura. He made her feel uncomfortable, but she never could have imagined what he was capable of.

1:21:01He was a wolf in sheep's clothing. I mean, there was nothing about him that if you had an encounter with him or if you had a friendship or relationship with him, that would certainly shout that this was a cold-blooded killer. But in reality, he's more than that. Smith was indicted for murder in the first degree, kidnapping, and sexual assault. How do you, as parents, cope with the thoughts and the knowledge of your daughter's final moments? Those are the worst. that repeats constantly in your mind for years and how she suffered. I even cry and say, you know, Laura, I'm sorry the way you had to die, so brutal.

1:21:50And I just kept on apologizing to Laura. Babe, I hope you didn't have to suffer so much. And me and David, we had wished that she had died fast. Mark Earnest was James Smith's attorney. Mr. Smith's position was that her presence there was consensual, that she came to his house, and that the choking, as he described it, was consensual as well. And he was always adamant that he didn't have any kind of sexual intercourse with her. Laura's parents certainly didn't believe any of that. They thought James Smith was worse than anyone knew. You're also convinced that your daughter was not his first victim.

1:22:37That's correct. Laura's parents took it upon themselves to look for other victims. They talked to the press in Lubbock, Texas, where Smith had gone to college. Investigator Loera was already wondering about his time in dental school. We started looking at different cases in Oklahoma, especially the route that he would take from school to the house he was living at. And there were several cases where prostitutes were picked up, murdered, raped afterwards, and discarded. While Smith was awaiting trial, an FBI profiler and an Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation agent visited him at the Clovis jail.

1:23:13And he agreed to speak with them, denying any involvement in anything in Oklahoma. My understanding is that eventually they ruled him out as a suspect in those cases. The DA in Laura's case was seeking the maximum punishment. You're preparing to seek the death penalty. Why? In New Mexico, the death penalty at the time was available and James Smith was eligible for it based upon the aggravating factors in which he committed this crime. When the death penalty gets into a case, it changes everything. The defense attorney told his client the death penalty meant preparing an additional strategy, getting ready to persuade a jury to let him live if he was found guilty.

1:24:01During one of my visits with Dr. Smith, I explained to him, I've talked to a psychologist and his job is, it's going to get into your brain and he's going to walk around and he's going to try to figure out why these things happened. James Smith wanted no part of that. He and his attorney decided to try to make a deal to avoid trial entirely. This was going to be a high-profile case. This is a small community, very unusual facts. He was aware what that would mean in terms of his family being thrown into the limelight. He was married with two young children. He didn't want all this exposed in a courtroom.

1:24:43And at that point, there was a change of mindset from not only the defense side, but also just hearing the evidence was difficult for Laura's family to go through. And so there was a negotiated agreement. On December 12, 2006, one year and three days after Laura McNaughton was murdered, everyone gathered in a Clovis courtroom for a plea hearing. James Smith's family was there, and of course, Laura's loved ones. What was it like for you to sit there that close to the person who had done that to your sister? Anger. A lot. He had caused so much pain, like unbelievable pain. Yeah. If I could take justice into my own hands, it would have been done.

1:25:32Laura's mother addressed the court. I told him, you know, how did he become this way? You know, he had the opportunity to go to a priest, minister, counseling to not let this happen. Did he ever look at you? No. No, he avoided looking at us. James Smith took an Alford plea, which meant he acknowledged the state had enough evidence to convict him for murder, kidnapping, and attempted sexual assault, but he never actually said he did any of it. Later, after Lucky thought about what that plea meant She regretted not insisting on a trial He never has to admit what he did And that's why I wanted to go to trial Because I wanted him to be convicted of the crime James Smith was sentenced to life plus 27 years He'd be in his 90s before any chance of parole Laura's parents aren't taking any chances So you've been calling every year to make sure that he's still in prison?

1:26:39Right. And not up for parole? Right. Every single year? Mm-hmm. 20 years later, James Smith is still there. Here he is in a recent prison photo. Laura's father will keep checking.

1:26:57Six months after Laura died, her family put a cross where she was found. I built a cross this high and real big. I carved in, I love you, Laura. So we decorated it and we put it out there. That's beautiful. That was good. It was a step toward healing, but it's been a long road. I stopped leaving the house. It was extreme panic attacks. I mean, it was very difficult for all of us for many years. and then just got to a point where I was like, okay, I'm like, I love you still, but I just, I got to do this for myself. Got to keep going. I wasn't going to let him take anybody else. You knew you had to live again.

1:27:42Yep. And living means helping Laura's daughters feel their mother's presence. We just talk about her. We talk about like growing up or our stories or silly little things. It's just everything but nothing. When you see her girls today? I look just like her. I see Laura, definitely. Mic up, yep. Just that little tilt of the head or the smile. Yeah, that's her.

1:28:16That's all for this edition of Dateline. And don't forget to check out our Talking Dateline podcast, which will go behind the scenes of tonight's episode, available Wednesday in the Dateline feed, wherever you get your podcasts. We'll see you again next Friday at 10, 9 Central. I'm Lester Holt. For all of us at NBC News, good night.

1:28:49Oh, look. you just got added to a meeting about coordinating another meeting to prepare for the pre-meeting ahead of the follow-up meeting which will, of course, require a recap meeting and then another meeting. Hit your booking point, book with Southwest and enter airplane mode.

From the publisher

After a woman's body is discovered along a remote road in New Mexico, detectives uncover a disturbing secret that leads to an unlikely suspect. Blayne Alexander reports.


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

More from Dateline NBC

All episodes