


Joe Gebbia (co-founder of Airbnb) discusses “design we deserve” in public service, focusing on designing for trust, usability, and storytelling at national scale. He describes his work as the first Chief Design Officer of the United States and leader of the National Design Studio (NDS), created by executive order in Aug 2025, modernizing government interfaces and services.
Joe Gebbia is the episode’s guest. The host is Ed Jackson (interviewer).
Joe Gebbia studied design at RISD, built an early product (“Crit Buns” seat cushion) and learned sales and customer decision-making through in-person demos. He co-founded Airbnb and later Samara. In government, he leads NDS and previously worked on modernizing federal retirement applications inside OPM.
People “don’t deserve mediocre,” and design communicates respect—especially for captive audiences like government users. Trust must be designed for, but also earned over time. Origin stories and “why” narratives help users understand and adopt products. Government UX should be like an Apple Store: clear, modern, and easy to navigate.
America.gov (chatbot-style entry point using LLMs, including NDS-developed Rampart); ORA online retirement application (reducing retirement from months to minutes and eliminating printed paper); realfood.gov/new food pyramid; TrumpRx (real-time drug pricing and coupons; claimed $700M savings); Trump accounts (millions of accounts; $1,000 per child plus reported $1B contributions).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the importance of quality in design and the role of user experience.
“Why would you put something mediocre into the world, especially at the nation level?”
Introduction of Joe Gebbia, his accomplishments, and the goals of the National Design Studio.
“Welcome to Dialectic, episode 59, with Joe Jebbia.”
Joe Gebbia reflects on the beginnings of his journey in design and entrepreneurship.
“Now, here is my conversation with Joe Jebbia.”
Joe shares the story of creating a product to improve art critiques in design school.
“I want to start maybe going a little farther back with a quote that is exemplary of one thing I want to talk about, which is the storytelling side of your work and your design and your career.”
Experience of taking a product to market and the insights gained from interactions with potential customers.
“And then by the time I graduated, it had won a competition to be given out to the entire graduating class of mine as a gift from the school.”
Exploration of how storytelling enhances product appeal and customer connection.
“And the whole adventure continued from there.”
Discover how Airbnb utilizes storytelling at scale to connect with users.
“One is you have spent your career since then, since CritBuns, working on things with a little bit more scale, both a little company called Airbnb and now the U.S.”
Explore how Airbnb's narrative evolved from 'travel like a human' to 'belong anywhere'.
“So with Airbnb, the story was obviously the founding story of Brian and I in the apartment with the airbeds.”
Understand why Airbnb focuses on experience rather than just the rental product.
“that would emerge of, in that case, travel like a human.”
Learn about designing for trust within the framework of Airbnb and beyond.
“or why would you use Airbnb for a hotel?”
Discussion on the evolution of online transactions and personal connections.
“And so, you know, the timing really, really worked out.”
Exploration of the intersection of design and public service, with personal anecdotes.
“First of all, you are now in public service.”
Insights into the outdated retirement processes for federal employees and the challenges faced.
“hasn't had a lot of investment into really high standards with regards to user experience.”
Discussion on improving the retirement process through design and technology.
“They've had 20 years of contractors trying to crack this code.”
Detailing the journey to create an efficient digital retirement application.
“People are left in the dark when they went to retire.”
Reflections on successful experiences merging private sector innovation with government needs.
“And they very quickly became our closest partners.”
Explore the balance between rapid execution and high design standards in government projects.
“you know, in ways that inform what eventually became, we call it ORA, online retirement application.”
Learn how design can enhance the user experience of government services to improve citizen engagement.
“and more like your ultimate boss, but they're also kind of a captive audience.”
Discover successful examples of government initiatives that leverage design to benefit citizens.
“drug prices for the rest of first world countries.”
Discuss the evolving expectations of citizen experiences in the context of modern technology and design.
“to exceed the expectations of what the nation's received so far.”
Explore the transformational goals behind America.gov and its impact on citizen engagement.
“include your parents, your aunts and uncles, your grandparents, your siblings, your friends, your coworkers.”
Learn about the principles of good design and how they apply to government services.
“I was going to say, I don't even know what the main American website would be.”
Understand the importance of creating reliable and efficient government digital tools.
“That is what we're delivering with America.gov.”
Learn about the approach to designing reliable government tools that prioritize user efficiency.
“you are, it sounds like the wrong way to say it, but you're almost trying to design things that are kind of boring.”
Discover how backend integrations enhance user experience on government websites.
“Like why is something like that one important and what actually is it?”
Explore how America.gov simplifies complex government processes like name changes.
“Oh, it's just the, you know, version one.”
Understand the strategies for attracting top talent to work on government initiatives.
“It seems impossible to me that at least upon launch, that is broadly true across anything I might need to do with the government.”
Reflect on the unique experience of working on public service projects akin to the Olympics.
“And the scale of what we're doing and the ambition has attracted some of the most experienced designers, most experienced engineers, most experienced researchers that I've ever had a chance to work with.”
Learn about the role of government websites in shaping the perception of the US brand.
“One of the exciting things about getting to do this work like America.gov is it's one of the most apolitical things you could work on.”
Discuss the challenges of receiving feedback on politically sensitive government projects.
“And so are we working on the brand of the United States?”
Joe Gebbia discusses the challenges and successes from his first year in a startup environment.
“You have a big tent of what you would call feedback and criticism today.”
The importance of designing user-friendly interfaces that everyone can navigate, especially non-tech-savvy users.
“Yeah, and there's rigorous research that goes into all this.”
Joe Gebbia shares insights on how design can improve government services and user experience.
“And so this is the bar that we hold ourselves to.”
Discussion on the sustainability and impact of America.gov and the role of design in public services.
“have a relationship with this idea of the time ticking but it's very different here there's nothing that you can do that is going to have this two and a half year timeline at least go away.”
The transformation of product development processes through the integration of AI and rapid prototyping.
“Do you have any thoughts or pleas or ideas on its future and how you would hope that it could continue and particularly maybe like independent of the politics of it all.”
Learn how rapid iteration in design leads to better outcomes.
“The benefit is you got to realize it sooner with lower cost investment to bring it to life and realize, okay, that idea actually wasn't as good as we thought, let's evolve it.”
Discover the importance of collaboration and complementary strengths in a team.
“I'm just curious if you look back, anything that you particularly learned from or were inspired by from Brian and Nathan over all those years building Airbnb?”
Understand how to identify and build relationships with potential collaborators.
“And I think all three of us agree with any of the two of us.”
Explore how working at scale reveals the goodness in people.
“that the others didn't have as much of and the others filled the gaps of where we had deficiencies in.”
Explore how working at scale reveals the goodness in people.
“And I'd like to thank Notion one more time for presenting Dialectic.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Dialectic, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00I don't think people deserve mediocre. Why would you put something mediocre into the world, especially at the nation level? Is that how we respect Americans? Airbnb could not have launched years earlier. The internet had to grow up to prepare for Airbnb. I remember we were in the apartment when we were 10 employees and the early engineer gets a phone call. He goes, oh, hey, okay, go to the top right. Yeah, click where it says profile. No, no, no. Go back to page. No, no. Mom, mom, go back. We all looked at each other and we go, guys, if our moms can't figure out how to use our website, this will never become a mainstream company.
0:28Now in the government, it's different. because it's not just moms. We actually upgraded them, and we operate the team that has to be grandma-friendly. We've come up with not another website, not another way of bureaucracy, but an entirely new front door to the United States. It's called America.gov. Whoa. Taking 29 ,000 entry points and saying, let's just make one. It's the front door. You just tell us what you need, and we, meaning the government,
0:52Joe Gebbia: go get it done for you. To take that literally, is it like a Google or ChatGPT-style text box? Yes. One, people don't trust the government, And two, people don't trust AI. How do you increase the likelihood of people really getting the upside of what you're describing? The first part of your question sounds very familiar to the early days of Airbnb. How are we going to trust that? I don't trust that company, Airbnb. Yeah. I don't trust that host that's advertising their home on it, their platform. In some ways, there's a parallel of having to navigate through a gap in trust. Good design is when a user actively thinks or says out loud, wow, somebody really put a lot of care into this to make my experience better.
1:27Joe Gebbia: Welcome to Dialectic, episode 59, with Joe Jebbia. Joe is the first chief design officer of the United States and leads the National Design Studio, which was created via executive order by President Trump in August 2025. Joe is about a year in, and he and his team are leading a modernization of so many of the interfaces and systems that Americans use to access government services. And that includes the recently announced America.gov, a central entry point for accessing information from the government. America.gov is a chatbot-style interface with LLMs under the hood, including Rampart, a privacy-preserving open-weight model that the NDS developed earlier this year.
2:09Joe Gebbia: We talk about that as well as many of the other things the NDS has worked on, from TrumpRx to Trump accounts to realfood.gov or the new food pyramid, as well as the early work Joe did to modernize and speed up the federal retirement application process. Joe is also the co-founder of Airbnb and Samara. We had a conversation about why design matters, how he thinks about designing for trust, and the scale and stakes of a role that serves every American and that has a ticking time clock associated with it. I hope you enjoy the conversation and are inspired to think boldly about how you might serve others or your country.
2:47Joe Gebbia: If you enjoy the conversation, please share it with a friend. I'll also link to America.gov, the transcript, and everything else we discuss in the description. Before we get into things, I would like to thank Notion, Dialectic's presenting partner. Notion has become something like a Switzerland in the crazy era of AI that we are in. As new models release constantly and new capabilities and agents are always available, Notion acts as a context and consolidation layer for all of the ways you and your team work with AI and agents by sharing and storing context, skills via the skills API, and all the other ways that you work with AI.
3:23Joe Gebbia: Notion can be a command center, a control hub, or simply a resilience layer so that even if you change the AI model or product you're using, your context can come along with you. You can also work with agents right from within Notion, whether that be custom agents that you create there, workers via Notion's developer platform, or tagging other agents you work with across various tools. OpenAI also just announced that you can sign in with OpenAI right within Notion to use your credits there. And I suspect that will follow for many other services. I don't think the capability ramp on what these tools and agents can do is going to slow down anytime soon.
3:59Joe Gebbia: So it's great to have a single place in my workflow that doesn't change. Notion is that hub where all of my context lives. You can learn more at notion.com slash dialectic. Now, here is my conversation with Joe Jebbia. Joe Jebbia, thank you for joining me. Ed Jackson, thanks for having me. This is an honor. We're here in DC and I feel like we're not quite in the middle, but we're close to the middle of this crazy new endeavor of yours. So I'm excited to talk about it. We're very much in the middle. Okay. Okay. I guess we'll get into that. I want to start maybe going a little farther back with a quote that is exemplary of one thing I want to talk about, which is the storytelling side of your work and your design and your career.
4:42Joe Gebbia: is a quote, I think from a conversation with Tim Ferriss in 2018. This is you. Design is more than just a product. It's more than just a digital experience. That cushion is 50 % foam and 50 % story. What do you mean? Wow. Well, it was a great lesson early on in my design entrepreneur career. You know, I studied design at Rhode Island School of Design and look in design school, it's pretty theoretical. You work on an assignment, you make a prototype, and then you move on to the next assignment. And I was always curious, well, what happens next? What's the gap between that prototype you make and the shelf of the store?
5:25What is that mysterious black box? So when I graduated RISD, I decided to demystify it and decode it. A lot of my friends went off to get design jobs and they moved to LA or Brooklyn. And I sat in my apartment and spent the next year bringing a product to market so that I could decode this mysterious gap. And I used a design that I had created during my senior year for a seat cushion to sit on during art critiques. They also called crits, where you put your art up on the wall, pin it up, and you spend all day in the art studio going piece by piece, critiquing the art. You have to to defend yourself as the artist and your classmates and the teacher are all saying, well, why'd you do that?
6:09Why does it look that way? I'm confused about that. And you have to really stand in front of your art and defend it, which is a good skill for later in life. And so in these critiques, they're really long, it's uncomfortable. And early on in my art school career, it was sitting on the hardwood floors and it's just so, it's so uncomfortable. You know, by hour six, your butt really hurts. And by the end of the day, everyone stood up and walked out of the classroom. And I remember seeing the, you know, charcoal dust and the ink that's on the hardwood floors had rubbed off on people's pants and it left a bun print on people.
6:45I'm seeing everyone walk out with a bun print. I look at my own pants and sure enough, I had one too. And I was walking back to my dorm room thinking, I've got four more years of these crits. There's gotta be a better way to participate in these. It's comfortable and keeps you clean. Got back to my dorm room. I sketched that bun print shape on the back of people's pants and I called it crit buns. It'd be this foam cushion with a handle that would be affordable for college students and something to sit on during these crits. So that was the product. I'd prototyped it in school. And then by the time I graduated, it had won a competition to be given out to the entire graduating class of mine as a gift from the school.
7:31And so I had to figure out how to make it, 800 of these cushions in a very short amount of time. It was almost impossible in about four weeks. And the day after graduation, the school gave me the metal mold from the project, which was like$5 ,000.
7:47Joe Gebbia: So I figured my biggest capital expenses out of the way, let's bring this product to market and figure out how you get a product on the shelf of a store. And so I learned so much from this. It was, it's kind of like my own grad school in a way where, you know, I was doing everything, the manufacturing, the partnership, the website, the promotion, the sales, the web design, the graphic design, the branding, the packaging. It was all of these things. All stack, baby. Customer service. Yeah, yeah, yeah. All from my bedroom in Providence. And what I learned is, you know, after that summer, I went back to RISD and said, hey, that was great for the graduating class.
8:31What if we did this for the incoming freshman class?
8:34Joe Gebbia: A pipeline. A pipeline. Here we go. 400 fresh students that are going to look for would love a C cushion. School loved the idea, placed my first order. I tacked on my own inventory on top of that. And there was a tribute to all 400 freshmen. People loved it. Everyone's running on campus with these brightly colored, strangely shaped C cushions. And they're going to be like, what is that? I should say, there really are a bunch. I don't know what I was envisioning, but I was kind of envisioning, I don't know, those typical cushions, baseball, they are bun shaped. I'll link a picture, but it's amazing.
9:07Anatomically correct, as we say. And so that was an exciting fall of, this is going back to the year 2005. And so I tacked on a few hundred cushions and did the order for myself. And I remember they're in my basement in Providence. And one day I went down to the basement and I'm looking at these boxes of these sea cushions. And I realize nobody's coming to this basement to buy them. I have to go out into the world and actually sell these things. And that was an incredible learning experience of walking cold into stores, finding the store manager, and figuring out what is the right line? How do you frame this right way to get people excited about it?
9:46The first store I walked into was the Brown University bookstore. And I met with the buyer, sat down, I had a sales sheet that I designed, my best shoes, finest dress shirt. And in about 20 seconds of my pitch, she goes, I'm not interested and got up and walked out of the room.
10:05Joe Gebbia: I was like, oh shit. This is gonna be a lot harder than I thought. But I remember walking back to my house, which was just a few blocks away. And there was this equation that I was reciting in my head that I had heard the previous weekend at an entrepreneurship gathering, also at Brown University. I snuck in too as a RISD guy. And the person talking was about the sales process. And he was sharing how rejection is a normal part of sales. And some will buy your product, some won't. Who cares, move on. So the equation was SW squared plus WC equals MO. Some will, some won't. Who cares, move on. And so I was walking back to my apartment.
10:52I'm thinking, oh man, all right. So I'm gonna love it, some aren't. Who cares? I gotta move on. And the next store I went to, they didn't buy it. Next store, they didn't buy it. But the fourth store, they did buy the cushion and it made it to the shelf of the store. I went back later that night after they bought it, I dropped it off. And there through the window, I could see this cushion on the shelf of the store. And I thought, okay, now it's the next biggest store I can get. And the whole adventure continued from there. Another big lesson from that was that I would sell these, this cushion at these fairs for designers, where you'd get a small table and like in New York City at the International Contemporary Furniture Fair.
11:35Every May it's like Design Week in New York. And so this website called Design Boom would host these tables for young upcoming designers to sell whatever they create. And so I had a table full of crit buns and I got to interact with people and learn how they thought about the decision-making process. And so I literally, over the course of a couple of years, I did a few of these. I saw thousands of people. I observed them of how they came into the product, made a decision about it. And the most fascinating thing, I was able to break into five steps. There's the, what the hell is that phase? Especially for this product.
12:14Yeah. people would see it from across the room. They go, you see the face, they go, what is that? The design was cool enough to draw them in. They had to know what it was. So they come up to the product. Next is the touch and feel phase. They squeeze it and they see that soft. That's when the first smile comes in their face. They go, oh, the next third is the story. They flip it over and on the back of the label, it tells the story of how the product came to be. And you see there, they go like this, very discerning look as they're reading. And then they go, oh, and the second smile comes up as the dots connect about the origin of this product.
12:52Fourth step is the demo phase. They got to see if it actually delivers. So I always had a demo chair ready to go. Oh, we should have had some ready. And it's like clockwork. People go look around like, oh, demo chair. They sit the cushion down, they sit on it. And the third smile would come on their face. And so then I'd be sitting there next to them. And I learned the most important question you could possibly ask in that moment, which is simply, how do you see this product fitting into your life? And people would go through, oh my gosh, well, on my kids' soccer games, this would be great on the bleachers, or I go camping all the time.
13:29I'd love to take this with me. Oh, this would be great for my pregnant wife. Oh, my uncle has sciatica. This would take pressure off the tailbone. I heard dozens of things I never even imagined it could be used for. And here people are selling it to themselves. They convinced themselves why they needed this cushion. The next question I'd ask is, how much is it? That's it,$19.99. And they go, oh, that's it. I get a sale. Now, the sixth step is the answer to your question. I would see people sit up from the demo chair. They've got the cushion in their hand. The next person in line would go, what's that?
14:08And I would literally just sit there and I'd watch the person tell the story to a stranger that I had just talked to them about or they read on the back and the stranger would go, oh, that's cool. And they'd grab one and they'd sit down and the whole cycle would repeat. And it was in this moment, I realized that a product is 50 % foam, those crit buns and 50 % story. People walked away with owning the physical object, but they also own the story. And it was so, it was such a illuminating experience to see that any object you have is just foam. It's just a glass. It's just a pair of shoes. It's just a phone.
14:50It's just a - Pixels. Pixels. The other half of that product is the story that you wrap around it. And the more humorous or enlightening or memorable it is, I think it's as equally as important as the battery life of something or the technical features of something, the story has to match the product, the what can feel and the materials and the capabilities of it. They're, they're not different.
15:19Joe Gebbia: Yeah. And to me, the best products in the world find a way to marry those two things? What an opening answer. I have a couple of observations. One is you have spent your career since then, since CritBuns, working on things with a little bit more scale, both a little company called Airbnb and now the U.S. government, or I shouldn't say the U.S. government, products that probably something to the order of most to every American will use. and so what that introduces to me is two kind of interesting wrinkles on the on this idea one is your ability to um give that first person the story right up close like to hear it from you is obviously a lot more difficult and two the idea that some will like it some won't changes a lot certainly yeah there are people who don't like airbnb and prefer hotels especially your job now I would also add that Silicon Valley in general tends to have a view that like, maybe it's changing, but historically like storytelling doesn't matter that much.
16:25Joe Gebbia: Products, great products sell themselves. I don't think Airbnb is necessarily that kind of, it sort of became that, but it was definitely not obvious. So I'm curious how, given that kind of initial story, how you think about storytelling, particularly at the scale of products that hundreds of millions of people will use. i mean in airbnb's case storytelling was essential um there's certainly the origin story which helps people understand why does this thing exist how should i orientate to this you know what i've seen over the years is everybody loves a good origin story they all want to know like what was the genesis where did this come from why does this exist in the world they want to know the why.
17:09And I think any great company has a great why story. Nike, eBay, Apple. And it's kind of personal too. Even despite the scale. Sure, you know, in my experience, some of those best stories are somebody solving their own problem, which is a great way to start a company, by the way. Because it's, what I used to say is that you're married to the problem. Whatever the personal problem is, that you face the frustration every day and you can't stand it anymore. You're going to do something about it. You're not going to wait around anymore for somebody else to fix it. You're going to go be proactive and take this problem head on and you know it firsthand.
17:50It's personal to you, which gives you insights on how to approach it and how to solve it. It also gives founders very personal connections because when it gets really hard and you may want to stop working on it, the people who are personally attached to the problem, I think are the ones that continue through all the ups and downs and reasons to quit. So with Airbnb, the story was obviously the founding story of Brian and I in the apartment with the airbeds. And even to this day, I'll be on social media and there'll be some animation that pops up around the founding of Airbnb. And somebody's retelling our story with some AI animation or something where they've interpreted it in some way.
18:35and they're now promoting it on their own. And so I think it does have one of those qualities of being repeatable.
18:44Joe Gebbia: Yes. Most people have had to pay rent at some point in their life. And that's a relatable thing. In some cases, the rent's gone up and people have to figure out, well, how are we gonna make that rent check work? Also a relatable thing. And then the ingenuity was, well, what if we rent out this extra space on these temporary hairbed mattresses during this conference? and the idea was born. Now the story of Airbnb has evolved beyond the origin. I remember one of our early taglines was travel like a human and that became our story. Yeah. And it was this idea that instead of the generic mass tourism way of traveling, where you're going to wake up in a hotel room that looks very similar to the last one you stayed in, in a city where you couldn't tell exactly what part of the world you're in, you know, potentially alone if you're traveling by yourself, versus staying in a home that has character and life to it.
19:45And in most cases feels like the place that you're staying in. You know, it's this idea of giving people, you know, humanness back, that they're not just a number moving through a cattle line at the airport to get to some generic hotel that's in a box, that's sort of lifeless and lacks personality. We used to have business travelers tell us that they specifically use Airbnb because they'd be on the road like 200 plus days a year. And when you wake up in those rooms, night after night, you lose a bit of yourself. Yes.
20:20Joe Gebbia: You're nodding your head as if you've experienced this. I've done the commuting hotel thing. It is a little tough. Yeah, it can wear you down. and they stay specifically in airbnbs and specifically not even entire bingbs they stay in private rooms which means the host is there because it gives them a sense of dignity back that they can wake up and there's a kitchen where they can you know make a coffee and put a bagel in the toaster and maybe have a conversation with the hosts before they head out to the reason they're traveling so that was a very unexpected um i remember that that research came in it was business travelers love staying in private rooms.
20:59Wow. This is really interesting. You'd think that they want just the most efficient, get me in, get me out quickly experience. But the ability I remember to do laundry and a laundry machine gave them some semblance of home. Totally. Right. And so it's like enough of those little things added up where they're willing to pay for our experience versus a hotel. And so there's these different stories that would emerge of, in that case, travel like a human. Over the years, then it became belong anywhere. That you could travel anywhere in the world and there was a host waiting for you with a home to welcome you in so that you could go from feeling like an outsider to a foreign city to an insider.
21:46And I had this experience. I remember the very first time I was in Copenhagen many years ago. and i got into the airbnb pretty late at night it's for a work trip for the company we were opening our copenhagen office that's what it was i got in really late um had the whole place to myself the host left a note on the table welcome note and said you have to try this coffee place in the morning if you're jet lag this is the place you got to go they drew a little map is just around the corner. And sure enough, I woke up like 4.30 in the morning, still on East Coast time or West Coast time and got the key, put on my jacket.
22:26It was dead of winter. It was freezing outside. I step outside. I locked the door. The neighbor, it was like a townhouse. The neighbor next to me was also leaving at that exact same time early in the morning and looks at me in waves. i was like well that's such a cool feeling to have i'm not from here right right there's somebody who lives in this building waving to i waved back it was it was like oh that's that's a nice feeling kind of belong here a little yeah then i get to the um got down the street get to the the corner coffee shop go down some stairs there's like a a woman with her child and somebody at the counter serving coffee and I walk in, I feel like, oh man, I'm a standout like a sore thumb.
23:10I'm not a regular here, you know, American, when I'm not Danish. And I opened the door and they just gave me the warmest smiles. And when my counter was so friendly and so nice, and it was these little touches that I'm walking back, you know, throughout the course of the day, I've got this metal keto house in my pocket. You can feel it. It's a different feeling walking around the city with a house key in your pocket than a plastic card.
23:39Joe Gebbia: It's a very different experience. You would never think about it until you felt that though. It's like so subtle. It's so subtle. I remember another time I was staying in New York, I come out of the Airbnb and somebody approaches me on the sidewalk and goes, hey, do you know how I get to the L train? I'm trying to find the entrance to the subway. It's like, I don't know, I'm not from here, but they thought I was. And that was like, ah, you know, versus walking out of a hotel in the middle of a tourist zone, some downtown city where you stand like a sore thumb. There's an experience of staying in a home where you get to feel like you belong there.
24:20You don't have to feel like an outsider to a foreign place. And so we say belong anywhere. That's where we're getting at. I feel like an insider instead of an outsider. or why would you use Airbnb for a hotel? It's for that.
24:34Joe Gebbia: Yeah, it's funny. Both of those stories have experience. Like it's not, you're not really talking that much about the product. It's almost all about the experience. I think that, and there's one other input that I think frames a lot of the other stuff I wanna talk about, which is you've spoken, you gave a great Ted talk years ago on designing for trust. And I think trust continued to come up kind of over and over again in my preparation as I was thinking about this. And I think there's something interesting, which is when you're designing for trust at scale,
25:08Joe Gebbia: there's an old quote. You said, design can overcome our most deeply rooted stranger danger bias. It's kind of fascinating thing that like, actually a story of a story of a story told so many times about the founding of Airbnb can get somebody to let a stranger live in their house. I was thinking about this in terms of the current work. Like, people might disagree on to what degree, but I think there's a common narrative that a lot of Americans don't trust each other. And certainly a lot of Americans don't trust the government. And you are now tasked with designing services that every American either gets to use or has to use depending on how they see it.
25:44Joe Gebbia: And they need to trust you in order to have an experience that hopefully is frictionless or positive or any of these things. I'm curious how you think about when you can design for trust and when it actually takes it has to sort of be earned over time and ideally you're doing both of those but airbnb to me seems like an amazing story of that where at first it was like what levers can we pull and over over time it's like oh yeah obviously you'd use an airbnb but that i don't assume that wasn't instant or obvious that was not a norm when we started. In fact, I remember I told my dad about the first three guests that stayed on the airbeds and that they were coming.
26:27And he goes, oh, Joe, I just don't think that's not a good idea. People would have a knee-jerk reaction when it came to hearing about Airbnb in the early days. They'd be like, wow, what a cool idea. I went to Italy once and I stayed in the home of somebody picking me up at the train station because I didn't have a place to stay. And I had a local experience and other people would be like are you crazy how could you stay in the house with a stranger stranger danger literally like internet stranger by the way yeah yeah what's interesting is that airbnb could not have launched years earlier the internet had to grow up to prepare for airbnb we didn't know this at the time of course but i could look back and i could see oh my god you needed e-commerce to work you know starting the late 90s where people could trust putting their credit card into the internet which took some time by the way like my mom didn't trust e-commerce for a pretty long time, like into the mid 2000s.
27:21You needed people being comfortable sharing their location. So Foursquare, that was a big deal when it came out. People were like, whoa, you're sharing your location? Are you crazy? People need to be comfortable sharing their photos online. So if you remember Flickr and Facebook in the early days, they were like, whoa, did you post your picture online?
27:40Joe Gebbia: Even real name, by the way. Like ahead of all those things. I distinctly remember, It was like, you know, I never use your real name. And then Facebook kind of changed it, but yeah, wow. Facebook changed it. And then the dating sites, you know, the early ones, match.com and Cupid, OKCupid, the others, where you're going to meet a stranger in person somewhere. And so you needed, we needed all of these things to stack on each other so that by the time 2008 came around, it's like, okay, it wasn't, it was a stretch, but it wasn't a giant stretch to say, okay, wow, you're going to transact in line, share your location, with somebody's picture and go see them in person.
28:17And it's their home. That was the, the whoa moment. Right. And so, you know, the timing really, really worked out. All right.
28:31Joe Gebbia: First of all, you are now in public service. And that's a word that I think to go back to our experience idea, feels resonant. feels resonant with being a designer. As far as I understand, you were sort of initially engaged to help out a little bit with Doge when they first got started. But I'm curious, first of all, what went into that decision and two, what your relationship to that idea or that word is, particularly at a national scale? Well, I've been designing websites since I was 14 in my dad's computer in his home office. And I remember the magic of the first time I published was my first website, it was on GeoCities.
29:16And this idea that the thing that I just, you know, cobbled together in HTML was now available to the entire world, not just my small town in Georgia where I grew up. And there was something about that where I was deeply hooked. I was like, wow, this is so powerful that you can have this vehicle of ideas and creativity that anybody in the world with a web browser can participate in or view or interact with. And it's incredible from that moment to where I am today to think what an amazing responsibility to get to bring everything I've learned about building great internet products to a part of society that historically hasn't had a lot of investment into really high standards with regards to user experience.
30:14And that's why I'm doing what I'm doing is I feel very strongly that the United States deserves better. Don't we deserve the best? Why are we okay with subpar, frustrating, aggravating, annoying web experiences when people try to get things done in the government. I'm not okay with this. I don't think others should be okay with this. It's similar to, I remember growing up as a kid in Atlanta, we'd be driving around the city, going to a Braves game or something. It became known to me that we'd pass like a really dull gray building and it was a government building. It just somehow became known. No one ever said like, hey, look at that.
31:02it became known. And so I think I've certainly grown up with such a low expectation of government websites. They never really are held to the same standard of the private sector. And I think there's something wrong with that. I think it's an injustice to Americans. Why should the American public deserve anything less than the best? And that's why I'm here doing this work with National Design Studio.
31:38Joe Gebbia: What did you learn in the, I don't know exactly how long it was in the kind of initial engagement and a lot of the work with the retirement kind of process. But I'm curious, Doge was complicated. I think there were successes, there were things that didn't work. I'm curious, what if anything you took from Doge? And what, if anything, you're kind of doing distinctly differently as you kind of went into the properly forming out the NDS and the new role. When I came into this experience, it was only supposed to be six months. Right, right. To fix. Gotcha. Very, yeah, no kidding. I looked at him like, 18 months later, here we are.
32:16I have to give a special thanks to Elon. I wouldn't be where I am today doing this kind of work if he didn't lead the way and attract and bring in people like me into the government. And I think he really put his neck out there and made us all take a second look at this idea of working in government. And so I'm here thanks to him. The reason I came in was to fix a very specific broken part of the federal employee experience, which is that every year, a hundred thousand federal workers retire. It's one of the great perks and benefits of being a federal employee. and the process with which they go through to retire is stuck in the 1960s and really hasn't changed since the 1970s that was the last time there was a major improvement made to the retirement experience it's all based on was all based on paper it took upwards of six months at times and i also think this this is like an example of an injustice it's so complicated that federal employees had to go through two required training programs just to learn how to retire from the government hours long oh my gosh man it's it's such a headache i think it's the injustice is that these civil servants give us the best years of their working life and then they go to retire to get their benefit and they have to go through a freaking obstacle as well not retire some don't i learned some put it off because they're like i don't want to deal with that so they stay another year so i joked it's a retention program yeah yeah because it is so frustrating and so i had a chance to dive into this, build a small team around it, some ex-Airbnb engineers and designers and brought in Silicon Valley experience, where this problem, by the way, they've been trying to solve it since the Bush administration in 2002.
34:14They've had 20 years of contractors trying to crack this code. They spent over$100 million over those 20 years to no avail. And so I show up and I'm working inside of OPM, Office of Personal Management. It's basically the HR and benefits department of the government. And suddenly I have to become a quick expert on retirement. And so just like what we learned at RISD with design and just like what we employed at Airbnb to truly solve a problem at its deepest level, you have to put yourself in the shoes of the people you're designing for, which is what I did. Yeah, so we spent time talking to recent retirees, upcoming retirees, the HR teams that process them, the payroll teams that process them.
35:02So we can really holistically understand the landscape of the problem at a very personal level. And this is the old Airbnb playbook. We used to go talk to our hosts, talk to our guests, hold meetups to invite them in so that we can learn about their experience, hear from them face to face about what are the problems that you're facing with our service? What would make it better for you? What do you wish we did that we don't do today? And so through honing that research approach at Airbnb over 14 years, brought the same spirit into retirement. And we learned a lot. People are left in the dark when they went to retire.
35:44People, there's confusion about how to calculate their retirement in the first place. Nobody really knew exactly what the number was gonna be. like what is the amount of the check that I'm going to get for the rest of my life so I can plan my life. So I can plan that vacation with my grandkids I've always wanted to do or get the bed and breakfast I always wanted to buy or whatever the thing is.
36:03Joe Gebbia: And you're just, you guys are just interviewing these people? Yeah. It's the process that I learned at RISD and brought to Airbnb and now we're doing it inside the government. You call it user-centered design or there's a thousand ways to define it. And so we take those learnings and we look at the product and the user flow and say, okay, well, let's simplify this. What's actually required, what's truly a law that needs to be adhered to. And let's create an amazing user experience here and let's do it all online. Why are we using paper in 2025? Gosh. How is it possible that this process is largely still paper-based?
36:47And the reason it took many months is the paper moves by mail. And so one department would get it, fill it out. They'd mail it to some other part of the country so they could fill it out. It would bounce around the country. Why was it so hard? Could you, had they tried to like digitize stages of this and there's
37:06Joe Gebbia: restrictions around it or? It was so antiquated. They would get it in the mail. They would scan it, put it on a computer, fill it on the computer, and then print it back out and mail the paper out again. Gosh. It is so... And you guys presumably had to go down this rabbit hole, like a rabbit trail, like see every single step. I remember we, on my second week, we had a couple of career folks who've been in the government for a long time in the room, and we mapped out on a whiteboard each of these steps, and it looked like some crazy calculus, you know, equation. The meme with all the strings and - Yeah, it was that, but the retirement process.
37:51And I remember thinking, holy smokes, this is crazy. There's just so many outdated databases and antiquated processes that no one ever really looked at from a high level and said, people just over the years had been solving little tiny pieces, but never ended up cobbled together. Or they viewed it. And so we had a couple of the career folks around the table and one of the other guys on the project, we asked the question, how long do you think it would take for us to take one retirement, just one, the most basic one and move it through the system completely digitally, meaning that we never had to print out paper.
38:32Got it. It would be manual in that like, we'll email. We're watching it. we'll hand hold it digitally yes how long do you think it would take for that to work and everyone around the room had you know it was like some person said four months the person said six months somebody in the video call said it would probably be a year to figure that out and my partner on this and i said well what if we did it in a week and there's an audible gasp in the room. And then they realized we were serious. And then they started to think, well, what if we were to do in a week? And everybody got incredibly excited about it.
39:17And the remarkable thing about this is that they didn't do in a week, they did it in four days. And we had for the first time ever, a proof point of an entirely digital retirement that involved no printed paper whatsoever. And of course it was a one-off And of course it was not scalable in that form. You have a seed. Yeah, you have a seed and something you could point, a reference, guys, we did that one. What if we did 10 more like that? And this is the startup process. This was Airbnb in the early days. This is pretty much any company that you see today,
39:50Joe Gebbia: if you trace it back to its origin. All the YC, Paul Graham stuff. Exactly. This is, you know, go meet your host in New York City in Airbnb days, take pictures of their place. Like do the things that don't scale in order to learn what you're going to need to eventually build out the right technology and software to support an all digital process. And so that's exactly what happened. It's cool. For the next couple of months, we built the software from the learnings, the career teams that we partnered with, originally very skeptical about our presence and fairly quickly realized, wow, these guys are here to really help us, to help accelerate what we've always wanted to try to accomplish, which is create a better experience for retirees by making this process way less painful.
40:36And they very quickly became our closest partners. So it was, did it as one team. And I'm really proud to say that by that June, we had issued a memo out to the government, which stated that all new retirements could only use our software. Wow. And this was all within Doge. this is yes this is all within wow and so then uh a year after that this past june um opm issued a memo that said there will be no new paper accepted wow to the storage facility oh my gosh which is a mine in pennsylvania you may have heard about they store all this paper has to go somewhere there's a mine in pennsylvania where they stored paper oh what are we we're
41:21Joe Gebbia: There's so much room for activities in the mind now. I know, well. I guess they have backups, but wow. Yeah, and so we've really, and now the process through our software, if you have a basic retirement, it can take you a couple minutes to retire. So I say from six months to six minutes in some cases. That's cool. So it was a real success story of what happens when you take government experience and you overlay it with a private sector tech mindset with highly experienced engineers and designers. You can dive in, do the research, understand the needs and the problem set of the actual customer, look at holistically prototype, you know, in ways that inform what eventually became, we call it ORA, online retirement application.
42:13And it's a huge success story of that process. That's cool.
42:18Joe Gebbia: There's a thread here that is inside a lot of that answer, which is Silicon Valley, broadly, not the only place, but Silicon Valley especially is like, yes, like what is possible? We can do it. Yes, that story. And DC, at least from the outside looking in, but I think a lot of people would agree, kind of defaults to no, like big committee. I don't know.
42:40Joe Gebbia: I heard from somebody that you guys at somebody's birthday party or something had hats that said no fake blockers, which maybe exemplifies that. On one hand, that is like the classic, what people have heard about Doge, like crudely it's bulldozed through things. On the other hand, you are someone who cares deeply about experience and about craft and care and design. And so I would love to hear you talk about kind of the tension between that sort of like speed scrappiness, how do we just get stuff done, which is clearly, even if some of the Doge stuff was left behind, clearly is tremendously valuable in the example you just gave and understanding that like, it isn't a startup, it is the government and certain things have, are, are going to take longer and you can't break certain things.
43:27Joe Gebbia: You can break some things like that tension makes sense. It certainly does. I'm reminded of Steve Steve Jobs quote, real artists ship. Fair enough, fair enough. There's a ton of tension as a designer. You wanna perfect things and make them just so elegant, right, every pixel and every, you know, every detail. And if you spent your whole time making things perfect, they would never ship. And, you know, in this context of a startup, there's always some outside pressure, whether it's just your funding's running out or there's competition or other that you have to move at lightning speed. And in this context, there's a different pressure, which is that there's a countdown clock every day.
44:14This administration will end. And with it, you know, things cycle through. So there's an incredible amount of pressure to move quickly, make smart decisions, We're not cutting corners, obviously. And find that balance between the refinement and the, we have to ship, get us in the hands of people. You know, you'll learn a lot, of course, when something's out there in the world, people give you feedback. And so I think, to me, the line is around, what are you proud of? What can you stand by and say, I'm proud of that. I'm not embarrassed by that.
44:56Joe Gebbia: I was gonna say, you seem to have a very high bar in basically all aspects of how you think about things. You certainly don't have a mediocre bar. And so that default isn't conducive to like moving incredibly fast. And clearly you're - I don't think people deserve mediocre. Why would you put something mediocre into the world, especially at the nation level? Yeah, yeah. Is that how we respect Americans? Is that how we show respect? Is that how we - say what we value to me, design is value. And the level of design that a company or a government puts into the world communicates its level of value and of respect to the people receiving that design.
45:41So why wouldn't the United States communicate the highest level of respect to the American people when it comes to the products that they have to use, not that they choose to use. It's a captive audience. There's not a lot of places to enroll for Medicare and to get your Social Security. These are fundamental things that I think the United States can increase its level of design to increase the level of respect that an American feels when they're using these products.
46:17Joe Gebbia: You have this metaphor that I think is really beautiful where you talk about giving an Apple store like experience to all of these services. And while I think it's a great metaphor, it's also, I have to admit, like the Apple store on some level gets to choose who they serve. The DMV does not. And so in some sense, I'm curious what it's like to go from effectively directly serving customers to the American people are almost less your customer and more like your ultimate boss, but they're also kind of a captive audience. And how that changes maybe the approach, how you think about feedback. And maybe I should add the most important point, which is you are serving the widest possible demographic.
47:03Joe Gebbia: I mean, you're not serving the whole world, but at least within, it wouldn't shock me that on some level, even if Airbnb has more touch points, the US population is a wider and more distinct, or excuse me, wide demographic, yeah. It's the widest. and i have said when i started this group my vision was what if the government was like an apple store like experience and what i mean by that is it's a metaphor what does the apple store stand for stands for good usability great design running on modern software what if our government had those three qualities what would that look like how respected would people feel when they entered a.gov domain into their browser.
47:49And instead of met with a confusing interface where they don't know where to start, they agreed with something that was easy on the eyes. The exhale. And community it clearly, and was presented in a way that they actually wanted to engage with it, that they could find the thing that they were looking for quickly and easily. Versus today's world where it's like a maze. And I think it's incredibly disrespectful that we have people, we just currently They have to try to navigate a maze to find what they're looking for. The burden is on the American to figure out the org chart of the government, right?
48:23Like which agency do I go to? What's their website? I'm on their website. How do I find the link across a sea of links and buttons to get to the form, to get to the submit button, to get something done in the government? I don't think that's fair. And so we're fixing that.
48:45Joe Gebbia: is I understand that there's sort of two shapes to the type of work you guys do. One is things that maybe not to a complete degree, but you seem to be relatively owning yourselves. And then the other is like the broad range of partnership across various organizations inside of the government. I would imagine the first one has some perks, which is you own the ship date, you can move super quickly. It's relatively vertically integrated. The second one has a totally different set of constraints. and maybe we can talk about some specifics, but I'm curious what those kind of two modes of working are and how you think about kind of optimizing for success in both of them.
49:26National Design Studio includes software engineers, designers, a few operation folks, research. And there's two tracks of work that we do. The first track, I call it the policy work, where there's a new policy that's created and there's needs to be a bridge to the public. Cool. So how do people touch and feel what this policy is? What's the interface? Yeah, what's the interface? The literal, how do I access the benefits of that policy? So a couple of examples, one would be the new food pyramid and dietary guidelines. So USDA had a 200 page PDF and they came to us and said, how can you help us communicate these new guidelines to the nation?
50:07And so we got to work and we worked with them and came up with the new food pyramid and then the website realfood.gov that tells the story and educates people about what these new guidelines are. Then there's Trump accounts, incredible policy where every newborn gets$1 ,000 into a bank account. And it's in that account until the child turns 18. They can take it out or keep it in at that time, but it grows interest alongside the stock market. And so a kid grows up with the ability to learn about finances, about investing, about compound interests, about the stock market, about capitalism. And so what's the way that a parent and child can interface with this cool policy and this gift from the treasury?
50:54Well, we made the app and the website and did the storytelling around it so that people have on their phone, they can see their child's account growing over time. They can see the balance. You can see the stocks that the fund is invested in on behalf of the child. Trump Rx, amazing policy. For decades, Americans have been overpaying for prescription drugs and basically subsidizing drug prices for the rest of first world countries. Meaning in Canada, you could buy the same drugs in the United States, but you'd pay 10 times more in the US than you would in Canada. Exact same drug. Every president has tried to battle the pharmaceutical companies to level the playing field.
51:40They call most favored nation pricing. And President Trump in this term was the first one to successfully bring drug prices down for the first time, I think, in many, many decades. And so how do people experience this policy? Well, trumperx.gov is that we built the website. It's incredibly intelligent. It connects to hundreds of pharmaceutical companies. It's bringing real-time drug pricing. It allows people to find the drug they're looking for and have access to the coupon to show the pharmacist at the counter where they get the Trump Rex price. And to date, this launched in February. So this is a couple months.
52:22Americans have already saved$700 million. Wow. That's insane.
52:27Joe Gebbia: Yeah. That's crazy. like if you were a startup building an app that within six months of launching seven months yeah you would have you know transactions or booking value of 700 million dollars can you that like that never happens um so the same is true with trump accounts we had um there's over seven million accounts that have been created for kids and over a billion dollars of contributions. Oh, cool. Separate from the thousand dollars per child. Yeah, yeah, yeah. A billion extra dollars put into this by parents and family members and companies. That launched January 6th. We're barely six weeks out from the launch.
53:16What other app has a startup that in such a short period of time can achieve that kind of scale?
53:23Joe Gebbia: It's profound. For either of those two examples, are you guys also acting like a startup that's in charge of growth and ramping up those numbers are those handed off to another organization within the government typically like a silicon allee company would be like have all these dashboards on how many kids are signed up how do we get from 60 to 80 whatever and and be totally reasonable if that's outside of the jurisdiction but i'm curious how that works well there's agencies that handle we're doing this on behalf of agencies so for that one it's it's hhs got it got it um right it's in that domain under Dr.
53:57Oz.
53:58Joe Gebbia: Maybe there might even be a product team there eventually that's maintaining it. Oh yeah, there already are. Cool. So Trump accounts is in the treasury. Cool. So, you know, we're this compliment to these. But also kind of ignition in some of these cases. Yeah, we're initial lift. We help give these things shape. And I think you set them up on a trajectory that the teams in those agencies run with. And we still help out with things, of course. You're way more zero to one. The goal, the success in the NDS in many ways is about zero to one for, at least on the new initiative side of things, how can we get them going?
54:31Yeah, I think that's where we seem to be needed the most. That's where we were asked to step in the most. Yeah. And we're happy to do that. I think it's been really interesting to see how building these kinds of products inside the government, at least likely place, can get scale so quickly. and it's actually become my number one recruiting line when I'm talking to designers and engineers.
54:57Joe Gebbia: You got a lot of users baked in or potential users. Yeah, they're like, why would I join the government? I'm not thinking about the government. I go, well, first of all, I wasn't either. Nobody on our team was thinking about the government at all. Wasn't on anybody's career plans whatsoever. And they'll tell me there are other options thinking about it. I go, well, those are cool. And that startup, I'm sure it'd be fine. And you'll get an experience. And you'll get to scale eventually if you're lucky. What if day one, you start here, you shipped an update to fix a product and you had to install user base of 340 million people.
55:31And they go, I never thought about it like that.
55:33Joe Gebbia: Yeah, it's almost like, not a burden, but it's almost like, it's heavy when you think about it that way. Like the potential energy there is high. Of course, I tell people, come here if you want responsibility for that. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Like come here if you're excited by that scale. Yeah. and you're excited to ship at the highest standards to exceed the expectations of what the nation's received so far. The other thing I tell really talented software engineers and designers is that those 340 million people include your parents, your aunts and uncles, your grandparents, your siblings, your friends, your coworkers.
56:10You literally get to design for everybody in your life because that's who we get to design for. That's cool.
56:19Joe Gebbia: You said there was, you started talking about the policy side, new policy side. Was there a second component or maybe to follow up on kind of the other side of my question, which is, as I understand it, a huge part of the work too is just helping other existing government services, organizations, whatever, modernize, even if it isn't a new product. So the U.S. has changed a lot since our founding 250 years ago. We've gone from the quill to the microchip, from the cannon to the drone, from President Washington to President Trump. And despite 250 years of extraordinary progress, the greatest unrealized opportunity of our nation is the citizen experience.
57:04And how do people experience the government today? It's through 29 ,000.gov websites. Oh, yeah, they try not to basically. When I started this role, it was somewhere in the magnitude of 25 or 26 ,000. It just keeps going up. Gosh. It keeps going up. And at some point in history, people used to walk into government buildings to access the government. And when they did, the lobbies were beautifully designed, the investment from the government to have incredible citizen experience. it's still visible because they're the lobbies are around you can walk into around dc beautiful marble floors yeah brass inlay fresco ceilings great lighting the reality is the lobby of the government today is 29 000 websites through a browser or a phone that's how people touch the government and the number of people that walk into that lobby every day.
58:05Blow your mind. It's 40 million people.
58:09Joe Gebbia: Daily. Daily. What are the most common versions of that? Like what are the sites one through, maybe you can't share exactly, but as a ballpark, like 41 million a day, 40 million people a day. I looked up the viewership to the world cup finals last month, Spain versus Argentina. And the number of Americans that tuned in to watch the finals match 38.9 million wow it's a lot every day the government has a world cup finals audience walking into its lobby and what are they met with red card after red card of bad experience poor design slow page load time frustration and unnecessary suffering so luckily we know the only guy in history to reverse a red card oh gosh president trump set up this team and gave us the mandate to effectively make sure no american gets a red card again and so national design studio has been working to reimagine the relationship with americans and a year since our executive order we've come up with not another website not another way of bureaucracy but an entirely new front door to the united states it's called america.gov whoa taking 29 000 entry points and saying let's just make one whoa one place login.gov wow that's a that's crazy one place where you can get things done, like enrolling for Medicare, managing social security, your student loans, getting a new passport, changing your name all the way down the list.
59:59Joe Gebbia: I was going to say, I don't even know what the main American website would be. Wow. This is what we've been working on. Yeah. It'll launch by the time this comes out. Yeah. This will be one of the biggest digital product developments in the history of the country. Was this part of the original mandate? The original mandate was to improve the experience of the nation. Yeah, yeah, yeah. This is our answer to President Trump's request of us. It's thanks to President Trump that America.gov exists. This is his mandate. This is his wish to improve the user experience, to fix the issues that people have when it comes to the citizen experience of the United States.
1:00:45And just thank him for his vision and his trust in me to help bring his idea and his wishes to life in the form of America.gov.
1:00:57Joe Gebbia: Oh man, I have so many questions. Maybe I guess the first one that might sound uninspired, but I think is relevant is like, how is this more than a sort of like an, you think about like those old webpage, like Yahoo or something, like an index of all the websites. I'm so glad you asked. There's what I call legacy websites, which follow patterns that go back to the nineties when the internet was developed. that have a homepage and a bunch of links, a search bar that you get to get to the next page to funnel into what you're looking for and you end up going to a user flow to accomplish something, to transact at the end and make a payment or submit a form, whatever it is.
1:01:40And that these very linear experiences.
1:01:45What if we flip that all upside down? What if instead of the burden being on the American to try to manage that maze and hunt through it, like on an expedition to find the link and the form and the thing. What if they could just tell us what they needed?
1:02:03Joe Gebbia: Right, by the way, if a Silicon Valley or if really any real company did this now, their designer would get fired, the company would fail, the users would churn. It's funny how in some contexts things can be so intuitive and expected. And to go back to your earlier point, In other contexts, we can just tolerate mediocrity. Okay, so it's like the front door. It's the front door. You just tell us what you need. And we, meaning the government, go get it done for you. And to take that literally, is it like a Google or ChatGPT style text box? Yes. Wow. Yes. Wow. Our LLM is the 29 ,000.gov websites.
1:02:45Wow. Because we're inside the government, that's our LLM, which is source of truth data. And we've benchmarked our search results across the other frontier models. And we objectively have a better search result. And the reason is very simple. We're only pulling from source of truth information. We're not scraping the internet.
1:03:06Joe Gebbia: Yes, yes, yes. We're not going through Reddit forums and other places where there's inaccurate information and things that are out of date. Wow. Wow, so this, I mean, it's in the weeds, but you could totally imagine how something like Rampart plugs into something like this. Pretty, wow. Okay, so this is like, hey, I don't know, I got this tax thing or I got the social security thing. You just straight up tell, I mean, also to be frank, I would imagine many Americans for better or for worse are telling that to Chachy BD and Claude and Gemini today in a way that is at their very minimum security nightmare.
1:03:40Joe Gebbia: Wow. What is the kind of the initial formulation of a product like this? Like one, how does, how do you figure out if it's possible to how much like backend indexing do you have to do? I mean, yeah, we can talk about this for many hours, but maybe a better question is when did this idea first show up and how? We talked about this last October. Okay. And I remember writing something down in my sketchbook related to this. And it was still a bit of a stretch at the time of like, wow, you know, how would you pull that off? and the models are still evolving. And this platform is evolving so quickly, at a certain point, not that much later, everything clicked and it was like, wait a second, we can embrace these frontier models in a secure way, of course, that's safeguarded around the government to deliver an experience that you can't get anywhere else.
1:04:42and the reason is this because we're from within the government it gives us the ability to tap into databases across the government so not only can you search for a question you're trying to understand about the government and get a result faster than you can snap your fingers that's higher quality than the frontier model you can also action it right in the thread right, right and so if you go on chatgpt, great product and you say, what are some good vacations in Italy? It'll pull Airbnb listings and hotels and flights. But to book any of those, it's a link that takes you outside of ChatGPT.
1:05:24Joe Gebbia: And maybe even it gets more agentic, but that information, my hotel booking information in Italy is very different than my social security number. That's right. One maybe less sexy, but I think important question this brings to mind is for a lot of people, it's going to be, as you say, it's like kind of how people use ChetGPT. It's like asking Google a question. I need to figure out how to get to this, whatever. Assuming the second part of what you're saying, which obviously is where the potential lies,
1:05:55Joe Gebbia: people, I said it once earlier, many people don't trust the government. Many people don't trust this specific president and administration. There's that whole spectrum. But one, people don't trust the government and two people don't trust ai how do you increase the likelihood of people really getting the upside of what you're describing in a way where they have a baseline of trust and maybe that's storytelling maybe that's technical as i understand it what you're really describing is like an agent what can become an agent for how people work with everything related to the government which could be so magical i suspect most american i'm i'm a tech guy most Americans are probably going to be like, I don't want to give the government's AI.
1:06:38Joe Gebbia: Like, ah, the first part of your question sounds very familiar to the early days of Airbnb. How are we going to trust that? I don't trust that company, Airbnb. I don't trust that host that's advertising their home on it, their platform. And in some ways there's, you know, a parallel of having to navigate through a gap in trust. And if there's any lessons from Airbnb, be. It's using good design to reassure people that what you're engaging with is trustworthy. You know, it's like when you see it's the broken windows theory, you know, if you come across a website and it's kind of slow, it doesn't really load.
1:07:21Things aren't really lined up. You can tell It's like somebody didn't spend a lot of time on this website. It's rickety. It was rickety. Yeah, sure. Janky, rickety. It's wobbly, flimsy. It undermines trust. Well, what else is flimsy about this website? How they handle my data? What they do with my credit card? The way something's designed is essential to communicating trust. i've been asked over my career a thousand times joe what do you think good design is and i actually write that one down yeah i have a i have a new definition based on this experience of developing america.gov good design is when a user actively thinks or says out loud wow wow, somebody really put a lot of care into this to make my experience better.
1:08:18Joe Gebbia: Yeah. Yes. Bang on. That is good design. That is what we're delivering with America.gov. I want the nation to have that experience where they feel the 16 hour days we're pulling over in our studio with some of the brightest engineers and some of those talented designers to craft an experience that gets our nation to a whole new level of user experience. One that respects the American, gives them dignity back so people don't feel like an idiot when they get lost in a government website. Something that respects people's time to give them time back in their life. Something that people can take pride in and say, wow, my government really did that?
1:09:08Wow, yeah, heck yeah. And the fourth thing is they can feel the sense of, wow, somebody really cared enough to put in this effort to save me time, give me DV, help me feel proud in my country, make my life easier when it comes to getting stuff done in our nation.
1:09:29Joe Gebbia: It's hard to imagine. I'm very, very excited to see it. It's like, but it is so far from the default, right?
1:09:41On some level, it's funny.
1:09:44Joe Gebbia: I love that description of good design. And I also think there's a kind of similar version of your design that is much more commonly stated, which is like, it's invisible. I was thinking about this as I was prepping, like in some sense, certainly more than the average company or product, you are, it sounds like the wrong way to say it, but you're almost trying to design things that are kind of boring. Like they're supposed to be, they should be, when I think about like a great government tool or website, it's like really reliable, easy to use, and also kind of boring. Like you're not trying to dazzle people necessarily, or maybe what I really mean by the opposite of boring is like, you're not focused on engaging me and keeping me using this product.
1:10:29Joe Gebbia: I want to get what I want and get it done and get out of there.
1:10:35Joe Gebbia: Dealing with LLMs broadly, like LLMs are not deterministic. It's like the feature in the bug. How do you think about like broad-based reliability and testing and sort of like consistency for, you want it to be this like super boring, reliable text box that does exactly what I want and nothing more? We work very closely with the agencies that we partner with, both to integrate actions so that when it comes to renewing a passport, you can get it done right in America.gov. Right. So when it comes to comparing Medicare plans and then picking the one you want to enroll in, you can get it done right on america.gov.
1:11:14You don't have to leave the site to go back into the maze of government websites. So these backend integrations are what makes this so magical. And it's interesting enough, it's something that the frontier models haven't had to deal with yet because who are they integrating with? It's like they cover the whole world. We just covered the government. So we're vertically integrated.
1:11:39Joe Gebbia: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Maybe there's a passport app that is really reliable. It doesn't even use LMS. It just plugs in, but your route, you're really the job here is you're the ultimate router. Yes, we're the ultimate front door. We don't store anyone's information. It lives in the databases where it already exists in State Department or HHS or Medicare. We're just a front door that allows people to access it, manage it, action it, and we send it back to the agency. It's certainly in the technical weeds, but can you speak a little bit about Rampart, which as I understand was kind of like a side project, but either that specifically or that philosophically, it's easy to say, oh, we're just passing through your data or whatever.
1:12:22Joe Gebbia: Like why is something like that one important and what actually is it? Rampart wasn't a side project. Rampart was preparation for American.gov. Rampart is an open source model that is for the mobile web view, because we knew that people would be using an LLM on their device, on their phone. And so what we want to make sure is that if people put in personally identifiable information, PII, that it's encrypted and trustworthy and it stays on the device. So if you search Rampart open source model privacy on the internet, you'll come and you can read about how we've programmatically figured out a way to keep people's PII on the device.
1:13:03In a web browser, mind you, too, right? Correct. Which is cool. And the size of the file is small enough. I think it's about 12 megabytes. Wow. That allows it to be on a device. You know, the other front-end models have something similar, but I think they're in the gigabytes of size, which is completely unrealistic to ever get on somebody's phone. So that's what, I think that's why it's trending on Hugging Face right now.
1:13:28Joe Gebbia: We've been talking a lot about websites. Websites for a long time, and I think for the average person, especially the experience on a phone, like they're not really using websites as much. Everybody has an app. We're past the app era in some sense. What is so powerful about websites? Yeah, I mean, what makes websites amazing is they're so universal. Any device, any screen size, any operating system, you can reach the world. Yeah. In some sense, it almost feels like, you know, in a non-intuitive way, it's respecting me because it's light enough to do exactly the job. That's why I think it's so cool that you guys can do the private model stuff through a browser.
1:14:06Joe Gebbia: It's pretty amazing. Wow. America.gov. So you're done. And like, this is out. Oh, it's just the, you know, version one. There's many versions ahead. This is just, we're just scratching the surface of the capabilities of this platform to really deliver convenient experience for Americans that I don't think anyone's ever really seen before. When it comes to changing your name, as an example, this one comes up all the time. I've met so many women through this project who confide in me very quietly. By the way, I still haven't changed my last name. I've been married for years. Why is that? They go, it's just, it's too complicated.
1:14:46Joe Gebbia: Yeah. I can't figure it out on the websites. And they say with shame too. And it's like, they're kind of like, the subtext is, I couldn't figure out a website. You know, those days are over. We can integrate with the agencies required to change your name and a couple of keystrokes with validation of your marriage certificate. We can agentically go change your name for you rather than the burden being on you, going door to door to each agency, filling out paperwork, mailing it in, waiting months, et cetera. those days are over. I really think as America.gov matures and the platform builds out more, there'll be a certain point where people won't go back to the old way.
1:15:30I was gonna say, between now and then,
1:15:35Joe Gebbia: this is an amazing huge launch. You've also worked on a bunch of other things and presumably are gonna continue to. There are 29 ,000 different surfaces, I should say.
1:15:46Joe Gebbia: Even if you get amazing at routing, I'm curious how you think about back to this countdown clock prioritization across various different things. Again, maybe someday it gets the point where I don't even have to go to any of those individual websites. It's all done agentically. In the meantime, you're balancing new launches, like whatever, um, the food pyramid or Trump accounts, big long-term projects. You have two more years, you have two and a half more years. Is there like a preference stack? Is there like a, is it like websites numbered one through 150 that we're going to tackle? Will some of that start to get automated using AI tools or otherwise?
1:16:26Joe Gebbia: Is it about setting up design systems? The easy answer is we don't have to redesign any websites. America.gov is the front door to all of them. So let's take an example, the name change. um i go to america.gov i need to change my name what happens uh you would put in hey i just got married how do i change my name yeah a response would come back and say congratulations and go log in through login.gov and we'll find all the places in the government that you have your name already exists and we'll show you and then you can opt in to the ones that you want to change your name. You'd click next. The component would update.
1:17:11It would confirm your existing name. You put in the new name. You put in the reason. You hit next. If you said marriage, it's going to ask you for your marriage certificate. So you either upload it from your computer or hit the QR code to take a picture of it on your desk. I'll put it from your phone. And then you hit done.
1:17:31Joe Gebbia: My jaw isn't on the floor, but okay. That is amazing. I believe that that will be possible in some circumstances. It seems impossible to me that at least upon launch, that is broadly true across anything I might need to do with the government. Oh, for sure. On launch, a lot of these capabilities won't be available. Got it. These require deep integrations through... So maybe that's the right way to ask the question. Even when it comes to integrations, passport change, TSA pre-check, change my name, IRS, madness. Are you then, is the plan of attack sort of like go down the biggest surfaces and do the agentic integration how do you think about well a lot of what we want to do in america.gov agencies have been trying to do already i see it just you're building almost like an api that the agencies can tap this and vice versa they're building apis for us or have existing ones that we can accelerate a lot of what they're trying to accomplish anyway wow and do it in a way where the end experience for the american is simplified easy to understand and manage, and ultimately convenient.
1:18:39Wow. It's an amazing world to imagine.
1:18:43Joe Gebbia: It can't come soon enough. Yeah. Look, version one of this will have basic functionality. Yeah. And over the next two years, we're going to keep integrating, and there'll be more and more integrations and more and more actual implementations right in the chat, so that I imagine two years from now, when a student wants to get a student loan and somebody really wants to manage every component of their social security, and somebody's looking for HUD housing and somebody wants to really do, you know, the end-to-end experience of Medicare, they'll actually be able to do it all in one place. Securely, safely, in a way that respects their privacy, secures their data, and ultimately gives people respect.
1:19:30Also, none of this would be possible without Susie Wiles, the chief of staff, believing in us and me to lead this work, and the directors and the cabinet members across all the key agencies that have already integrated to America.gov or will be integrating into America.gov. This convenience that's being delivered to the American people is only possible
1:19:50Joe Gebbia: with their partnership and with their help. A lot of people, I would imagine. A lot of people. you spoke a little bit about the opportunity when it comes to people working on this. How have you actually tactically brought in the level of talent needed to build something this ambitious when it comes to, to be frank, working for the government, not everybody's dream? Yeah, no one on the team had any plans to be in the government. And the scale of what we're doing and the ambition has attracted some of the most experienced designers, most experienced engineers, most experienced researchers that I've ever had a chance to work with.
1:20:34And it's for somebody who likes the scale and they like the responsibility. They like the high stakes that these systems have to work. And ultimately, I think deep down, they like this ability to serve. They like this idea that they can take with their really experienced dad, software engineering, design, research, and actually direct it not towards a for-profit or nonprofit company, but towards the infrastructure that runs our nation. And they can actually put their fingers on and stamp their name to one of the most massive transformations that's ever happened in this country from a citizen experience standpoint.
1:21:20And this is why people are joining. this is why people are leaving high-paying jobs and um you know great positions and great titles to come contribute to this and in some ways it's like there's there's a parallel to the olympics which is most olympians leading normal lives then the olympics come up they they leave their job and their family they go train somewhere for a certain period of time away from their home then they go travel to where the olympics are and compete and they have this incredible life experience where they're operating at the best of their talent and their sport and their competition at the end of the olympics they go back to the normal life yeah this is that experience for soft renders and designers that's intense yeah come work with the best in class yeah on the biggest problem.
1:22:15Yeah. One of the exciting things about getting to do this work like America.gov is it's one of the most apolitical things you could work on. And what I've learned here, one of the biggest things that surprised me in the government is how unifying websites are, because everyone can agree. Totally. They wish government websites worked better, looked better, and loaded faster. Oh, man. It truly unites the country, unites the left and the right around a single common cause. And I think what we're doing for a designer out there who's watching this or for a software engineer who's now thinking about, wow, I never considered working on such a project at the scale inside the government.
1:22:58It's important to know that this is one of the most apolitical things that anybody could possibly do. It's for every American, north to south, east coast to west coast, young and old, men and women. It doesn't matter who you voted for. This is about improving the citizen experience for every citizen.
1:23:16Joe Gebbia: Right on. Do you do any work in the category that you would broadly call brand for the US? Not directly, but I remember something Jeff Bezos said once that a brand is defined by what people say about it when you're not in the room. And so are we working on the brand of the United States? In that context, yes, we are. Yeah. great brand in certain ways and websites they're on the app um i was thinking about how to talk about sort of the challenge of doing this thing on a national scale that everyone has an opinion on you brought it up at the very beginning um as i understand it i didn't go to art school but a huge part of that culture and particularly risdi is crit um and this idea of putting your work on display sort of like taking arrows as they come obviously silicon dolly has a different culture of that, but certainly like very, very tight feedback loops.
1:24:15Joe Gebbia: You have a big tent of what you would call feedback and criticism today. And that is colored on this kind of extreme level, which is that a lot of it is politically flavored. So there are certain people who think everything you do is amazing. And there's certain people who think everything you do is the worst thing ever. Maybe to start, I'm just curious for you to reflect on year one. I think at the time of filming your first year and your birthday, happy birthday, recently passed. What do you think went really well in year one? What do you wish you had done better? Or are you looking to improve in, I suppose?
1:24:49Yeah, year one was recruiting, was time consuming for the first couple of months. Yeah. You know, it had never existed before. And so just like a startup, you gotta convince people to join your team of which there's no precedent. They had a lot of baggage. A lot of baggage, well, baggage and dynamics. And so the first couple of months was really figuring out how to recruit for this unproven promise that we would actually have authority to get stuff done, that we were working on some of the biggest things possible, that real experienced people would be joining this team, which they have. and so you know the engine got going in this first couple months and eventually it's you know been racing down the road ever since um you know i wish we'd come up with america to gov sooner that's one thing i think it it took a little time to match the right technology and the right stack and yeah do all the testing and really proof of concepts just like we took that one retirement and push it through the system digitally in a week or in four days.
1:25:57So two, do we try America.gov out? It's like, how do we prove this concept quickly and give ourselves a reference or a new baseline of what's actually possible? And I was going to say, part of that is even believing it could be possible on this scale at this time of lives. Yeah, that's cool. Yeah, and there's rigorous research that goes into all this. Tons of testing on the back end. Tons of security testing like you wouldn't believe. more than I've ever seen before. It's incredible.
1:26:29And doing something that I learned from Airbnb, actually, which is I remember we were in the apartment when we were 10 employees. We're in the living room. We had one long table. I'm sitting here across from me is Nate, my co-founder. Next to him is one of our early engineers. And the early engineer gets a phone call. And we're all sitting at the table. We can overhear the call. He goes, oh, hey. yeah yeah um okay go to the top right yep okay now click over yeah click where it says profile no no no um go back to page go down no no uh mom mom go back and this went on for far too long to the point where he got off the phone and we all looked at each other and we go guys if our moms can't figure out how to use our website we're never going to go mainstream.
1:27:18This will never become a mainstream company. Wow. As 10 guys sit in the living room with this big dream, we have an artificial ceiling on our growth. If our user interface is not clear enough for moms to figure out without calling their tech savvy sons.
1:27:34Joe Gebbia: Yes. And so we employed this idea of our site's got to be mom friendly. And that drove our design. And it was a subtext of our design for a very long time. I'm sure it probably still is at the company in some ways where there's this universal usability where things have to be so clear and so intuitive that a mom can figure it out. In fact, I remember years later in our much bigger office, it's a much bigger company. We used to celebrate Mother's Day. And so in our food service area, we had all the moms of anyone, any employees in the company come visit. And we actually set up a research station.
1:28:22Wow. Where we could -
1:28:24Joe Gebbia: My mom would have gone crazy on that. She got opinions. We would put our latest designs, prototypes in front of moms there for brunch. And we got actual feedback from moms. And if they're different user testing over the years, we would do that. Now in the government, it's different. because it's not just moms. We've actually upgraded and we operate the team that has to be grandma friendly, which is true. And so this is the bar that we hold ourselves to. And with the things that we make, certainly with america.gov, we actually have a research cohort of mothers over the age of 55 that we put our work in front of for usability testing.
1:29:14Joe Gebbia: What does that practically look like? Is it like, I don't know, 10 of them in a room at a time and you've got your team in there? Like - We use the service to facilitate it. And so they recruit and they find these mothers over the age of 55. And we do research, use the research beyond that, of course. There's somebody to say that if you can have of your website working for a non-tech savvy grandmother or grandfather that you've really reached some high, high bar of usability, of clarity. Yep. In fact, accessibility is very important things for us. All our sites are accessible as they need to be, but there's an element of accessibility that's not required that we actually go the distance for, which is accessibility includes a website that's clear.
1:30:07And that people can comprehend. Because you can have an accessible website with really confusing navigation and really confusing language and copy. It's not required to do that. You take all the other boxes by compliance standards. But that's not enough for us. What we put into the world, it's got to have a level of clarity to it so people can actually navigate it. And to me, that again comes back to respect.
1:30:38Joe Gebbia: I love that answer. One of my questions was going to be like, especially given all the political stuff, how do you sort of actually like just seek this sort of like classic truth grounded feedback and like, what a cool, what a cool frame. The default that particularly considers the long tail of Americans from a technology standpoint is technology increasingly is part of our lives, but not always a thing that people love in their lives is, is important and cool. you mentioned the clock you have started many companies you've built an incredibly successful scale one that involved all the classic things and managing money and fundraising and all that people who have started companies especially venture backed companies have a relationship with this idea of the time ticking but it's very different here there's nothing that you can do that is going to have this two and a half year timeline at least go away.
1:31:38Joe Gebbia: There might be questions about what happens after and it's worth talking about.
1:31:45Joe Gebbia: What is the right frame and disposition around that? Like, I guess part of it is just keeping it in mind, but like you have two and a half years left. Is it a mad dash to cover as much ground as possible? Is it about investing in something like America.gov and having it stand the test of time? Maybe it's worth adding in the second question, which is like with that timeline in mind, how much are you thinking about endurance and continuity and the idea of whether the be these products or the NDS itself enduring past your, your term? I think the answer for America.gov will be people voting with their feet.
1:32:29It's what people choose the best products that they want to get. done what they're trying to get done.
1:32:35Joe Gebbia: That's also quite uncommon with government tools and websites, right? Yeah, we're creating a new option for people. Yeah. And it's there for them to use it or not. If they want to use, you know, traditional method, they can. It doesn't replace any website. It's just an additional option to create a more convenient way, time-saving way, right? User-friendly way to accomplish what they're trying to accomplish, to find the answer that they're trying to find. to get the information that they're seeking to make a decision and lead their life in the best possible way. Also, maybe a pretty strong case, regardless of who wins the presidency and otherwise, a pretty strong case to keep something around is that a whole bunch of people use it.
1:33:23Joe Gebbia: Beyond that, which I don't want to trivialize, I think that matters a ton. More broadly, the work, design systems, and very specifically, this is, you're the first chief design officer of the US. The National Design Studio is a really ambitious idea, regardless of the picks people have or how much people love it. The idea of something like this existing, as you've talked plenty about, is I think pretty remarkable. Do you have any thoughts or pleas or ideas on its future and how you would hope that it could continue and particularly maybe like independent of the politics of it all. It's hard to separate, but.
1:34:08Look, if anything, I hope I've kicked the door open and shown that design can improve society at this scale. If you find the right type of experience you'll have to bring in. We're here on executive order and those come and go at the whims of whoever's in the office next. I hope that we'll have proven that design has a role in the White House. Design has a role in the government at the highest possible level to help inform and introduce new policies to the public, improve things like access to government services through something like America.gov. Just make it simple. Make it user-friendly. Remove these stigmas.
1:34:58That people just automatically know that government websites suck. Let's just get rid of that. I don't think any administration going forward has to accept that anymore. And I hope we've proven that.
1:35:14Joe Gebbia: What do you think would be most surprising to people about working in government? I'll speak for myself. The most surprising thing is how much fun I'm having. I never would have imagined that the people I get to work with, the cabinet secretaries, Susie Wiles, the president, directors of agencies, been so receptive to our services and to coming to understand the value of good design as it relates to what they're trying to accomplish. AI and design. Probably not that relevant for normal people, but back in San Francisco, people are talking about it, thinking about it. Yeah, I'm just curious if you have any reactions reactions based on what you've seen so far, what you think is going to happen.
1:35:57Joe Gebbia: In some sense, it feels like, to go back to the thing, it's like somebody really cared. That's not mutually exclusive with using amazing tools to go faster and do more. Product development as I had known it in my previous life is over. Whoa. It's done. Gone are the days where you have this waterfall process, design, you sweat through every pixel, You finish the mock-up, you hand it to engineering, goes to some front-end devs that whittle away at it for days or weeks. Maybe build a prototype in there somewhere, test it out, then back in devs, connect it to databases and other things. I've been in meetings where we're discussing an idea, and in the meeting, it's already built.
1:36:54It's done, not done, but it's brought to life in a way where like the meeting has shifted. Now we're talking about the thing we were talking about 10 minutes ago, but looking at a screen and clicking through it.
1:37:07And the speed with which engineers can build changes everything. Not to mention speed with which designers can bring ideas to life through similar tools. But the cost of software development is plummeted, plummeted. And I don't, we're never going back, right? Like it's, everyone's using AI tools, right? It's like in the speed at which they can code is phenomenal. And so those old days are a distinct.
1:37:43Joe Gebbia: Where do you think the care comes in? I think in the polish, you know, vibe coding is one way to move very quickly. It's not a way to ship a rigid product. And so the care comes into, sometimes you gotta go back and hard code it. So sometimes you end up going back to the old days of how you would create something. The benefit is you got to realize it sooner with lower cost investment to bring it to life and realize, okay, that idea actually wasn't as good as we thought, let's evolve it. And so in the same span of time that you would have built one thing in the old days, you can now build 15 versions of it.
1:38:21and you've already iterated to a point where you're ready to really double down and invest in it. And then you can go really make it rigid and really clean up the code. It's about the extra details. Get it ready for production. Exactly.
1:38:36Joe Gebbia: Any open-ended, but any thoughts on why the EAMS were so inspiring to you as a designer? The EAMS were inspiring to me on many levels. One is that one of their quotes from Charles Eames is that the details aren't the details, they are the product. They cared so deeply about a holistic design
1:39:05that does have quality and does have that level of perfection. And I think the coolest proof point about them is that their designs are still relevant today. where the things they made 50 60 years ago are still as treasured and still as relevant and still as robust i have in our office here eames chairs from the 1960s and my you know our engineers here in their 30s or the 20s they can't believe it they're like how are these chairs from 1968 It's the Eames weather management chair. And I like to point it out to everybody as an example of good design lasts. I think the best design, if you wanna talk about the most sustainable design, it's the thing that becomes an heirloom that you both treasure and value, and you wanna pass on to somebody, but it's also built in such a way that it can endure,
1:40:04Joe Gebbia: it can last over time. It's not flimsy. it's not cheap, right? It's a quality to it that allows something, a share that we're sitting in today in 2026. It was 1968. It's inspiring for how we think about digital stuff. Certainly the digital maintenance, digital durability is not held at the same standard. Just a few final things. I'm just curious if you look back, anything that you particularly learned from or were inspired by from Brian and Nathan over all those years building Airbnb? I got incredibly lucky with my co-founders. There's a lot of stories in Silicon Valley of founding teams that don't exist anymore.
1:40:51Yeah, some drama, some quarrel, some disagreement and things imploded. Brian and I still to this day have a friendship and a brotherhood that hasn't changed. And throughout the company, we would refer to the three legs of a stool and that if you removed any one of those legs, stool will fall over. And when I look at the success of Airbnb and how we endured those early days, which were really difficult, a lot of forces against us. there was this notion that you know we had a triangle right one of the most robust pieces of geometry uh and in fact we did a personality test one time where some consultant came in and did the whole leadership team and they would plot your results in these concentric circles in each quadrant of the circle or you know section of the circle had you know leadership and creativity and self-awareness.
1:41:59And they plotted ours on the circles, all three of us, and we made an equilateral triangle. The facilitator was like shocked. She's like, I've never seen anything like this before.
1:42:09Joe Gebbia: She planned it. I'm just kidding. That's awesome. Yeah. So there's something really special about the two of them. Of course, we didn't always agree on everything, but because of the respect that we had for each other than the friendship, whatever we were trying to make a decision on, we'd net out somewhere in the middle of the triangle, right? Which was typically a very balanced and well-honed decision about where we're taking the company. Ryan's done a phenomenal job as a CEO. Nathan's done a phenomenal job as our, you know, technical, founding technical partners, seeing the company through growth and now running strategy and supporting the executive team and a lot of different initiatives to the company.
1:42:51And it really could not have happened. And I think all three of us agree with any of the two of us. It took the three of us to bring this, you know, unusual concept into mainstream.
1:43:04Joe Gebbia: Quite a heavy lift. It took three guys. Do you think outside of luck, do you have any advice or thoughts on finding great collaborators like that?
1:43:19i remember when i was at risdy during orientation the guy on stage the orientation leaders looked out to the auditorium to all of us freshmen and said look to your left look to your right these are your future collaborators your future employees maybe your future spouses and the message was to spend the next four years getting to know people like creating relationships And I remember thinking that moment, I was like, oh wow, they're right. And during the course of my time there, I had a sense that I wanted to start a company one day. I'd known that since I was a kid. And so my radar was always on in the background of meeting people, starting friendships, and building relationships.
1:44:00Is this somebody I'd ever wanna start something with? And by the end of my time there, it was a very short list. and Brian was at the top because we had experiences with each other where I saw how we complemented one another. We have different personalities, different styles. Ultimately, we both care about design and creativity. And we had this quality where we were on a project together. We got a parallel assignment to redesign products for this company called Conair, which makes like hair dryers and curling irons. Your mom probably has Conair. And so the summer assignment, him and I went off and we went so far outside the bounds of the brief.
1:44:46We went so far beyond designing like consumer products. We were designing Kanye or the company. We were coming up with a new framing for the company. I remember we went to their headquarters in Connecticut to present to the head of marketing and a bunch of - These guys. Directors. And we get up there and the look on their faces like, Who the hell are these two kids? But there was something in that experience specifically, remember Brian and I, we could come up with big ideas together. You put us in the same room and we'd bounce off each other and we would end up at a place that neither of us might've got to on our own.
1:45:24And this also manifested in our epic ping pong matches, which became a metaphor for us, which is we ping pong ideas back and forth. We make each other better.
1:45:35Joe Gebbia: Yeah. Both of us got really good at ping pong. The best. By playing each other. It was like this healthy competition. And within that story, there's qualities of what people should look for. Someone you wanna spend time with. Someone who you compliment. They can't be exactly like you. They gotta be kind of cover your bases on, you know, your strengths are here and your weaknesses are here. How are they complimenting you? and the ultimately like a deep respect for each other for your strengths and weaknesses. And that's what Nate, Brian and I all had together. We were all brought something to the table that the others didn't have as much of and the others filled the gaps of where we had deficiencies in.
1:46:17Joe Gebbia: Bing bong. One last thing from your Airbnb resignation letter or not resignation, but Eric. Farewell. Farewell. um the data proves that the golden rule is actually human nature in other words people are good how how has working at this scale affected that view if at all i wrote that because the numbers of airbnb proved it that the sheer scale of people who've stayed in strangers homes over the last now 17 18 years wow it's been that long been that long you know of course there are incidents and trust and safety things but the the fraction of the bigger picture you kind of look at the numbers you go well it's objectively clear here that by and large people can trust each other if you create the right vehicle and platform to exchange that trust with other people.
1:47:24Joe Gebbia: Yeah. All right. What are you going to do in 2029? What's next? Great question. You have a few things to do before then. Yeah. Joe Jebbia, thank you very much. This was an honor, a little bit outside of my normal wheelhouse and very cool to hear about the thinking. And I think, yeah, it's just, there's a broad bucket of politics. And outside of that, what I think government reminds me of, and you talked about some of it is, it's a reminder and an inspiration to think about how we can serve. Think about how we can serve the people right next to us. And we know really well, we're like us and the grandmas.
1:48:06Joe Gebbia: And so I admire it a lot. Thank you. It was an honor. Thank you. Thank you for listening to my conversation with Joe. All of the links in the transcript related to this episode are available in the description at a dialectic.fm slash Joe dash Jebbia. If you enjoyed it, please share it with a friend. And I'd like to thank Notion one more time for presenting Dialectic. Being able to work across all the AI products and agents you use makes Notion the ideal place to run everything through. That includes any of the agents you're working with, including new ones like Muse and Instinct, as well as every AI model the day it releases.
1:48:39Joe Gebbia: So anytime there's a new model from Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, Grok, and others, as well as open weight models, you can use them with all of your context, right in Notion with your teammates where your work already is. Notion also recently launched the Skills API, which allows you to share skills with anyone on your team and allow them to use AI tools just like you do. This can be especially helpful in helping the power users on your team give leverage to everybody else. Notion has also spent a ton of time recently speeding up the product across web and mobile, including a rebuild on the mobile app, and is doing the same thing with Notion Calendar.
1:49:13Joe Gebbia: As everything moves faster and faster, having one place for you and your team where you know your context lives, that works with every tool and agent you use, and that is a reliable place to see the work as it's actually happening is a great way to future-proof your work and your process. You can learn more at notion.com slash dialectic. And thank you to Notion, for their continual support of me and the show. Thanks again for listening, and I will see you next time.
Joe Gebbia (Website, X, LinkedIn, Wikipedia) is the first U.S. Chief Design Officer, leading the National Design Studio. He is also the co-founder of Airbnb and Samara.
The NDS and this role were created by executive order of President Trump in August 2025. I met Joe Washington, D.C, to reflect on the past year and talk about bringing the care and ambition of great product design to the digital services that every American uses. Joe & NDS just launched America.gov, their flagship project of the last year: the central entry point for how Americans get what they need from the government.
Joe believes that design is how you respect and value the people who use a product or service. At Airbnb, that meant helping strangers feel comfortable in each other’s homes. In government, it means refusing to accept a low bar for the websites and processes that Americans use to interact with the government.
We begin with CritBuns, Joe’s RISD project that taught him that design is as much about storytelling as it is about product. Then, we discuss what he learned about designing for trust at Airbnb and his initial work at DOGE, streamlining and digitizing the federal retirement process. Joe walks me through America.gov, a single, AI-powered front door to government services. We discuss the challenges of scale and designing for people who are skeptical of both government and AI, including what it means to pass the “grandma test.” We wrap up with why ambitious technologists should aspire to work in government and his collaboration with Airbnb co-founders Brian Chesky and Nathan Blecharczyk.
I hope this conversation raises your expectations for the things we’ve learned to tolerate, and inspires you to think about how you might serve your community or your country.
Full transcript & links at dialectic.fm/joe-gebbia
---
Dialectic is presented by Notion. As new models and agents arrive constantly, Notion acts as a context and consolidation layer for all the ways you and your team work with AI: a command center or simply a resilience layer, so your context comes with you even if you switch models or agents. You can also work with agents right inside Notion and share skills with your team through the Skills API. Learn more at notion.com/dialectic.
---
Timestamps:
0:00 Opening Highlights
1:26 Intro: Joe Gebbia
4:12 CritBuns & Why Design is Half Story
15:24 Airbnb, The Feeling of Belonging, & Designing for Trust
28:29 Public Service & Fixing Federal Retirement
42:16 Speed, Craft, and Respect
48:43 ND Studio Projects: TrumpRx, Trump Accounts, and Realfood.gov
56:18 America.gov: A New Front Door to Government
1:05:35 Trust, Privacy, and Government AI
1:15:30 America.gov’s Roadmap
1:19:54 Recruiting for ND Studio and Public Service
1:23:41 Reflecting on Year One & Passing the Grandma Test
1:31:05 A Ticking Clock Toward 2028 & Building Beyond One Administration
1:35:44 AI & Product Development
1:38:36 Closing Questions: Charles & Ray Eames, AirBnB Co-Founders, & Trust in People