1. Podcasts
  2. Discovery
  3. The Life Scientific: David Canter
Discovery

19 Oct 2026 · 26m · 14 chapters

Episode artwork

The Life Scientific: David Canter

In short

Investigative psychology—how David Canter applies behavioural science, data analysis, and statistical rigour to understand offender patterns and support police investigations, plus his parallel work on place, emergencies, and the arts.

Guest backgrounds

David Canter is Emeritus Professor of Psychology at the University of Liverpool and founder of Investigative Psychology (now embedded in police training). He previously studied environmental/architectural psychology (The Psychology of Place) and emergency behaviour (e.g., fire evacuations; football stadium disaster inquiry). He plays clarinet and has a PhD in musical composition.

Key claims

“Profiling” is media-driven; the focus is behavioural patterns from “muddy data.” Early emergency behaviour is about regaining agency and understanding “rules of place.” In investigations, the best prediction of future behaviour is past behaviour (“consistency principle”).

Notable examples

1985 railway rapist case (John Duffy convicted in 1988; David Mulcahy later convicted in 1999). Football grounds redesigned to be family-friendly with seating.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

3:08

Understanding Investigative Psychology

Learn about the key concepts and methodologies of investigative psychology.

“David, in a nutshell, what is investigative psychology?”
4:30

The Role of Offender Profiling

Explore the significance and misconceptions surrounding offender profiling.

“And when it comes to these sort of criminal investigations, some people use the term offender profiling, which it is of sorts, but you aren't a fan of that term, are you?”
5:44

David Canter's Early Life and Influences

Discover David's childhood and the experiences that shaped his career.

“The simple answer is I'm fascinated by counterpoint, by the way in which different melodies and rhythms play against each other.”
7:43

Education and Early Career in Psychology

Learn about David's academic journey and his initial focus on environmental psychology.

“David, when you were just 16, your father died.”
9:26

The Psychology of Place

Understand the concepts introduced in David's influential book on place psychology.

“Well, the origins of it are that buildings were systems without any feedback.”
11:40

Adventures in Japan and Research Contributions

Hear about David's experiences in Japan and research on emergency behavior.

“The book is still widely cited today, but I gather this year you've published a significantly updated edition.”
14:00

Understanding Human Behavior in Emergencies

Learn how people react during emergencies based on psychological research.

“Well, an experimental psychologist would put people in a room, blow smoke under the door and see what happened.”
15:22

Transforming Football Stadiums through Research

Discover how psychological insights reshaped the experience at football grounds.

“They'll only act once they realise the rules of place have changed.”
16:31

The Birth of Investigative Psychology

Explore the origins of investigative psychology and its application in policing.

“And I'm so delighted when I see television now, a big football match, and there's families with children and there's lots of women there.”
18:27

Analyzing the Railway Rapist Case

Learn about the analysis behind the railway rapist case and its implications.

“But we could understand that they were trying to find opportunities and avoid detection and that there would be a relatively understandable pattern.”
Show all 14 chapters
20:59

Impact of Investigative Psychology on Training

Reflect on the impact of investigative psychology in police training and academia.

“with multiple victims and lots of media attention.”
22:29

Advice for Aspiring Forensic Psychologists

Get insights on pursuing a career in forensic psychology and its challenges.

“So, David, as you've mentioned, in 1994, three decades after graduating from the University of Liverpool, You accepted a professorship there.”
24:20

The Allure of True Crime Narratives

Explore why true crime stories captivate audiences and the psychology behind it.

“Why is it, do you think, that these terribly dark cases attract so much interest?”
25:49

The Intersection of Art and Psychology

Discuss how artistic pursuits complement psychological insights and research.

“I'm going to see if I can write a novel.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Discovery, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30day outfits. What I love about Boehm is that everything feels really current and on trend, but still wearable. These pieces you can actually mix into your closet and wear over and over again. Whether you need a cute date night look, something for the weekend, or just want to give your everyday wardrobe a little fall refresh, they have so many good options right now. Their new fall arrivals are dropping all the time, so definitely go take a look at it before your favorites sell out. Shop now at bohm.com. That is bohm, B-O-H-M-E.com.

1:26November 3rd. Restrictions apply. Offers may vary. Visit julesosco.com for more details. Hello. If you're a fan of crime fiction, you'll recognize the classic setup of a grizzled detective or plucky psychologist bucking the system and following their hunches to track down an elusive killer. You probably won't be surprised to hear that in real life, serious crime investigations are rather less reliant on gut instinct, including when it comes to using psychology to help track down offenders. David Cantor is Emeritus Professor of Psychology at the University of Liverpool and the founder of Investigative Psychology, a discipline that applies data analysis, behavioural science and statistical rigour to investigations, and which is now embedded in police training and procedures.

2:15So a quick warning here that we will be discussing criminal cases in this programme, including mentions of serious sexual assault and murder. But David didn't set out to work in criminal investigations. His early career focused on how environments like buildings or cities shape behaviour and moved on to explore how we act in emergency situations. But in 1985, when police asked for his help on what became known as the railway rapist case, David applied his rigorous methodology to help track down the offender and changed the course of criminal profiling in the process. Since then, he's contributed to numerous investigations and given evidence in court cases, authored influential books and built an entire discipline from the ground up.

3:01And we've also found time to get a PhD in music composition as well. Professor David Cantor, welcome to The Life Scientific. It's a delight to be here. David, in a nutshell, what is investigative psychology? It really has two strands to it. One is the study of offenders' actions and experiences in a detailed and systematic way and building up theories and models of that behaviour. And the other is seeing how you can draw on that research to facilitate all aspects of investigations, particularly police investigations. So when it comes to police work, what is involved for you? I think I have to, right at the beginning, set aside the idea that the psychologist comes in and solves crimes.

3:48The idea of the outsider who can see things that the police can't see and somehow solves the crime for them. It doesn't work like that at all. It's feeding into an understanding of criminal behaviour, the underlying structures and patterns in that behaviour and how they can be drawn on to facilitate the effective scientific development of policing. And I think that's the key to it. It's part of a movement in policing to make policing more based on scientific evidence. In fact, the first senior police officer I worked with said, up until now, we've been collecting evidence, but what we really should be collecting is data.

4:29and that was a whole other insight into how the police can become much more scientifically based. And when it comes to these sort of criminal investigations, some people use the term offender profiling, which it is of sorts, but you aren't a fan of that term, are you? No, the term offender profiling is one that the media is hooked into And it doesn't really capture the idea that there are certain aspects of what an offender does that are relevant to the investigative process. The key thing is the behavioural patterns that can be understood from looking at a number of crimes of the same type and understanding the underlying structure there.

5:15And that requires a very special kind of statistical analysis because you're dealing with what I call muddy data. the material that's collected by the police can be inaccurate in all sorts of ways, incomplete. So you've got to find ways of finding the structure within it. We're going to come back to the science in a moment, David, but aside from psychology, I know music is another great love of yours. You play the clarinet and I mentioned you have a PhD in musical composition. So what sort of music do you write? The simple answer is I'm fascinated by counterpoint, by the way in which different melodies and rhythms play against each other.

5:55And very pompously, I've claimed that that's what life is like. You have all of these different themes over each other. So my music tends to work with the instruments against each other in a sort of what you might call a modernist classical tradition, really. But it's a fascinating endeavour and it's so different from being a scientist. Well, David Cantor, you were born in 1944 in Liverpool. Tell me a bit about your parents. My father had come to Britain from Central Europe at the age of about 16, just before the First World War, I think. He was never terribly well and he was, although he was interested in lots of things, he'd come at such a young age, he never really managed to get an education.

6:39But he survived what was known then as a credit draper, selling people made-to-measure clothing that they would pay off over a period of time. And my mother was a nursery nurse. What was your childhood like then? It was perfectly pleasant, but there were issues around Judaism. Although my parents were not orthodox religious Jews, there was still the issue of, For instance, I tried a primary school nearby and my parents quickly decided that it just wasn't going to work because of the way they were treating me. So I went on to the local Hebrew primary school that was in the middle of Liverpool. And my father had wanted to set up a shop and start developing his business, but it was smashed by an anti-Semitic sort of attack on it.

7:30So my friends and contacts tended to be amongst Jews, which is very odd because I've really now become rather antagonistic to many aspects of Judaism. David, when you were just 16, your father died. I understand he had health issues for many years, but that must have been a very difficult time for you. Yes, my father had been ill for a long time with various sorts of problems. And I think he died as the result of an operation, actually. I remember the headmaster came to tell me in class and I told my close friend there that I had to go because my father had died. And their friend said to me, oh, can I have your sandwiches then?

8:12I mentioned that anecdote because in a sense, there was a sort of distance because he'd been ill, because he'd been in hospital for a while. And because I was still really very, very young, it took a long time for it to sort of really have an impact. And really the impact was all the things that I never got round to asking him. Yeah, that's often the case, isn't it? So after he died, it was just the two of you, you and your mother. But then she had to take in lodgers to help make ends meet. And one of them was a psychologist. That's right. At the top of the house, there was a psychologist there who talked to me about psychology and its benefits and the interesting aspects of it.

8:56And I had managed to find a book that gave some introduction to psychology. And it just struck me as a really interesting area of science and research. I was never really interested in people or helping them. I was interested in studying human behaviour and experiences and activities and the challenge of the complexity of those sorts of studies. Well, that's what you did, because in 1961, you went to study psychology at Liverpool University. And you went on to start your PhD at Liverpool, where you focused on the effect of office size on worker performance, which is really your first foray into the world of environmental psychology.

9:39What does that field involve? Well, the origins of it are that buildings were systems without any feedback. And what you've got to do is start getting some evaluation of them. And the important component of that was people's reactions to them. So that's why I was brought into a unit that was studying office buildings. And my job was to evaluate the buildings. And they were very concerned about the impact of these huge open offices. And one I studied had a thousand people in one big open room without any divisions above seated high level. Goodness me. So, I mean, they wondered if that was going to have an impact on the workforce and so on.

10:19So there was a lot of that was the sort of start of it. And we called it architectural psychology. And there are many aspects of the meanings of buildings and people's reactions to buildings. But what we find very quickly is people bring an awful lot to their interactions with the environment. and therefore there's no simple impact as everybody tries to claim. It's really about attitudes towards the environment and how that influences people's behaviour. Well, at this point, David, your PhD supervisor moved to Strathclyde University in Glasgow, so you went along too. You completed your PhD based in the architecture department there, working with the Building Performance Research Unit.

11:03You went on to become a lecturer in architectural psychology at Strathclyde, and your work led there to your extremely influential book, The Psychology of Place, which was published in 1977. Talk me through what it set out. In essence, it proposes that places are a combination of a physical form, a set of meanings and associations which would be embedded in history and culture, and a pattern of activities. And these all feed on each other to create a particular experience and way of dealing with that place. The book is still widely cited today, but I gather this year you've published a significantly updated edition.

11:46Yes. So I have taken the opportunity over 40 years on from when it was first written to extend it and to demonstrate that this concept of place implies actually some very interesting social phenomena and what I call rules of place. Our reading of a place, how we understand it, influences what we expect to happen there and that gives rise to different ways of using it, which means people have different rules depending who they are and what they're doing in that location. Now, David, you met your wife, Sandra, while you were both studying at Liverpool. She's a clinical psychologist. And in 1969, just after your first daughter was born, you were offered a year's fellowship at the University of Tokyo.

12:33So all three of you moved to Japan, which sounds like quite an adventure. It was amazing. And it was insisted that I had one-to-one Japanese lessons while we were there, because this is 1969, 1970. You needed some Japanese to move around the place. There weren't many English speakers there. Yeah, and I mean, if you wanted to go to a small village and stay in a Japanese inn and in a ryokan, they wouldn't take you unless you spoke some Japanese. So we were able to travel around Japan. And what a different culture it was, such a rich, different way of dealing with the world. And what were you doing on the work side of things?

13:12Well, I was assigned to work with people in the Building Research Institute there. one of the things they were doing was looking at how buildings were dealt with in an emergency because of their earthquakes and the need to really be ready for that. They were studying how people moved in evacuating buildings. And I was fascinated by this idea that you could actually explore that and get some understanding of the patterns of behaviour. And that was quite influential in that when I came back to Britain, And by then, I'd got a lectureship at the newly established University of Surrey. I got in touch with the local building research station and said, I'd been looking at behaviour and emergencies in buildings on fire and so on.

13:56I'd like to follow that up. And they funded me, in fact, for 10 years. And what does that work involve? Well, an experimental psychologist would put people in a room, blow smoke under the door and see what happened. But that's not a real situation. So what I determined to do was interview people who'd experienced fires. That was actually quite difficult to organise, partly because if there had been a fatality in a fire, the police were very reluctant to let me go and talk to the people involved. But what I discovered is if there had been a fatality, the police interviewed everybody as if it could be a murder investigation.

14:34And once the investigation was over, they had all those interviews. so I started exploring those police interviews and from that was able to build up a model of what happens in an emergency particularly a building on fire And what did it tell you about how people behave if they're in a building that's on fire? What became very clear was in the early stages of any sort of emergency people don't really know what's going on and they want to take control the key thing is they have agency And so they will look to make sense of what's going on and that will slow things down and they will keep searching until they realise that the place they're in is now a different place because it's now threatening and then they will leave.

15:22They'll only act once they realise the rules of place have changed. And that gives rise to a framework of how you inform people about what goes on in emergency and how to deal with it. Well, your research into emergency mindsets led to you giving evidence at a government inquiry into football stadium disasters. What insights did you have for them? My main point about the experience of being in a football stadium that we found from the studies we did was that in some cases, the place was seen as a very macho location where people would be standing on the terraces, which were often a very nasty environment.

16:08And that was driving out families and people who just wanted to go to enjoy the match. So although people enjoy standing on the terraces, it's creating the wrong sort of place with the wrong set of expectations. You have to have seats. And it led to a total change in the whole way in which football grounds were being thought about. It sort of changed the whole experience of being at a football ground. And I'm so delighted when I see television now, a big football match, and there's families with children and there's lots of women there. And it's a totally different type of place. Absolutely. Well, in 1985, David, your career took an unexpected turn when you were asked by Scotland Yard to help them with offender profiling.

16:53I'm putting that into the air quotes because I know you're not keen on the term. But how did that come about? A couple of senior police officers at Scotland Yard had heard about the FBI profiling and they were looking for somebody to contribute to investigation in the same way. And quite rightly, they were very sceptical because in the FBI talks, there was no systematic research. So they thought either the Americans were overselling it or it wouldn't really be relevant to the British situation because American crime patterns and what happens in America are really quite different. And they found their way to me.

17:29And because I'd been working with the police statements from the fire investigations, I said to them, well, I've got a way of examining statements in investigations. Let me have a look at them. And they gave me a closed case and asked me to have a look at it. And I did some analysis on that and brought really an environmental psychology perspective to bear on it and gave them a report in which I commented on some of the value of what the FBI were doing, which was trying to build up behavioural patterns. And the police officers thought that was very interesting. So I did that little study for the police just to show what was possible.

18:07And then they had a series of rapes and murders around London. And they asked me if I could, the way they put it, could you help us catch this man before he kills again? So this is what the media dubbed the railway rapist. And you were applying your new methodology to this case, what would become investigative psychology. So what I did was to regard the criminal as doing things that we may not approve of or understand why. But we could understand that they were trying to find opportunities and avoid detection and that there would be a relatively understandable pattern. So I analysed the patterns of behaviour, used some statistics to draw out the descriptions that the police have to find a coherent pattern there.

18:56and also to do some geographical analysis of where the crimes had occurred. And on the basis of that, I gave them a profile, which I wouldn't do these days, but I gave them a description of the offender based on the basic idea that the best prediction of future behaviour is past behaviour, what I call the consistency principle. If you look at what a person is doing in a crime, there are going to be similarities in their life. And it seemed terribly obvious to me that an individual who was attacking women and had killed some of them would be known to be violent to women and would be in the police system somewhere for that violence, not necessarily for sexual violence.

19:35So I gave them a description and I also suggested that the crimes that had occurred early on were when the individual was still exploring the possibilities, almost, you could say, learning his trade. And therefore that's probably where he had some sort of base. And in fact, the railway rapist case was huge news in the UK at the time. This was a case involving a string of rapes and murders near railway stations in and around London. And in 1988, a man named John Duffy was convicted of two murders and four rapes. And it turned out he had a lot of the characteristics that you'd predicted. That's right.

20:12I heard on the radio that they had arrested somebody for the crime, so I got in touch with my police contact and said, what's going on? And he said, well, I don't know, David, if what you told us was all just flannel, but it was very useful. And that was really the breakthrough because they had a variety of suspects, but only one fitted that simple description. Just to wrap up that case story, there had in fact been a second man involved in several of the attacks. It wasn't until 1999 that David Mulcahy was convicted of three counts of murder and seven of rape after Duffy shared evidence from prison about his involvement.

20:54Duffy also admitted to several more rapes himself. But coming back to you, David, this was obviously a serious investigation with multiple victims and lots of media attention. What was it like to suddenly be immersed in this very dark case where the stakes were so high? You say immersed, but I was always kept at arm's length and I was just dealing with data and trying to make sense of it. So from my point of view, it was a research project. In fact, of all the years I worked with the police contributing to investigations, it was always hands off, which is the way I prefer it. Certainly your success on this case meant you started getting regular requests for help on other investigations.

21:38You came up with a name for this new field, which was, of course, investigative psychology. And you wrote a book about it called Criminal Shadows Inside the Mind of the Serial Killer, which won some prestigious crime writing awards. On top of that, this methodology is actually now embedded in police training and decision making. How does it feel to reflect on the impact your work's had? It's a strange sensation because it's all so sort of distant in a way. But one of the great successes, unexpectedly, was students were fascinated. And when I set up the first course in investigative psychology, masters and then doctorates at Surrey and then Liverpool, I got literally hundreds of people applying.

22:23And they're all developing the whole area in all sorts of different ways. So that success is very satisfying. So, David, as you've mentioned, in 1994, three decades after graduating from the University of Liverpool, You accepted a professorship there. You moved back to your hometown and set up the university's Centre for Investigative Psychology. It's now another 30 years on, give or take. What would you say has been your biggest achievement there? Well, I still have to come back to the probably nearly 200 PhD students and then very more who've done master's degrees with me and have developed the discipline in doing that and taken it off in all sorts of directions.

23:06So, I mean, I like to quote the Talmud who say, how do you evaluate a teacher? And the answer is by their students. And these students are doing tremendously well all over the world. And thinking about this new generation of psychologists, do you have any advice for those that are starting their career and considering working in a field that overlaps with serious crime, be that investigative or criminal or whatever? Because that in particular must come with specific challenges. A lot of people get in touch and say they want to be profilers. And my first reaction is, forget it. Really? It's not a career option.

23:44Forensic psychology is a much broader based area of activity and has many opportunities. But psychology itself opens so many doors. That's the way to think of psychology. don't get hooked on to just some narrow aspect of it early on because it opens so many opportunities. And it's such a broad-based discipline from philosophy right into sort of neuroscience. You say that people come to you wanting to specialise in criminal profiling. That does reflect what seems to be an enduring public fascination with criminality. Just look at how many true crime TV shows and podcasts there are nowadays. Why is it, do you think, that these terribly dark cases attract so much interest?

24:27True crime is such a range of phenomena, but what it shares is jeopardy and a whole movement forward, an unfolding narrative. And it also has this issue of trying to solve a problem. There was a famous young psychologist in Russia in the 1910s, 1920s, who pointed out that those puzzles that we haven't solved are the ones we find it difficult to forget. For instance, I've done a lot of work on Jack the Ripper, and the reason that people are so fascinated is partly because it's never been solved. So there are those two streams, the sort of unfolding narrative and the fact that there's a puzzle to be solved.

25:10And it provides a fascinating framework for a myriad of different ways of creating stories using those. Yes, I mean, of course, you mentioned stories. Have you ever been tempted to write crime fiction? Yes, I have started various sort of goes as a novel and I've been asked by various novelists to help out with storyline, which was great fun because I could create something earlier on in the story that could be solved later on using psychological ideas. But I do realise from all my writing and from trying to write popular books that it's not easy. It's a lot of hard work to put that all together.

25:47And I've been so busy with my music and with making sculptures that I've never had the chance to just say, OK, now I've got a year. I'm going to see if I can write a novel. That's not happened yet. Well, I mean, as you say, you have all these other wonderful creative outlets that are keeping you busy. You know, of course you're composing, but you also write poetry. you've done some photography and you've created pieces of art. You mentioned the sculpture. How's that going? Well, I did a piece that has recently been accepted by the Royal Cambrian Academy for its open exhibition. And I had another piece that was accepted for the London Royal Academy open exhibition.

26:28So that's quite interesting. And it's essentially metal sculpture that I weld. And it's all bits of metal I find around where we live, which is an old farmhouse and there's all sorts of bits of metal laying around and I sort of got interested in what you could do welding them and obviously there's an interest in that. It's lovely that you are the personification of bringing together C.P. Snow's two cultures in the arts and the sciences. Well, actually, one of the things I've realised is C.P. Snow got it totally wrong. The idea that these are two different cultures is very misleading because artists, writers, musicians, they all have ways of understanding and ways of knowing about our experience of places.

27:11And psychology got hooked on this idea that it's a rigid science rather than realising it's a way of exploring people's experiences and understanding of the world. I was going to ask you if there'd ever be a time when you might set aside psychology and just devote yourself to the arts over the sciences. but I'm guessing what you will say is the two are so intertwined in what makes you who you are that you couldn't possibly separate them. Well, just today I've been asked to review two journal articles so as long as I keep on getting asked, that will continue. But I do find release really in the art because it is a different way of experiencing and relating to the world.

27:54Quite right. I hope you keep enjoying both worlds. David Cantor, thank you very much for sharing your life scientific. It's been my pleasure. Thank you.

28:27Jess Maddox. And me, Thomas Germain, for The Interface. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

Although books and movies might suggest otherwise, catching criminals is of course less about hunches and gut instinct, and more about gruelling analysis of hard data - including when it comes to the psychological side. David Canter is an Emeritus Professor of Psychology at the University of Liverpool, who took exactly this approach in the 1980s when he was asked to help police track down a serial killer. David had built his reputation as an environmental psychologist, studying how people behave in emergency situations and even advising the government on how to prevent disasters in football stadiums. But when he was asked to apply his unique methodology to help track down a serial killer and rapist, he realised that data-driven analysis of a suspect's behavioural patterns could be invaluable to any investigation. David tells Jim Al-Khalili about how he founded the field of investigative psychology - and went on to advise on major criminal investigations, write award-winning books and even make time to pursue a parallel life as a composer.

More from Discovery

All episodes