In short
Taylor Barratt discusses the ethics of facilitation and how practice and theory correct each other in designing and running Authentic Relating/ATM-style containers. He emphasizes “rightness” as moments that feel real, lucid, and mutually convergent after the fact, not merely confirmation of bias.
Guest backgrounds
Taylor Barratt is a long-time Authentic Relating Toronto co-leader and facilitator; he later joined the Verveke Foundation and helped start the ATM platform. John (co-host) is a teacher/facilitator who has partnered with Taylor in a business integrating his teaching with Taylor’s facilitation platform. Ethan (co-host) collaborates with them on practice design and runs the series.
Key claims
Facilitation should integrate structures (Western psychology), states (Eastern traditions), and shadow work (to address fallibility). Good practice is marked by feedback that it “lands,” plus impact, aliveness, beauty, and landing/reorientation. Ethical facilitation requires inviting both positive and negative feedback, avoiding bullshit, and balancing guidance with participant agency (zone of proximal development).
Notable examples
A VIA intensive exercise where Taylor and John later debriefed with mirrored meaning; and the ongoing practice-design “lab” with others (including Christopher Master Pietro) used to refine practices and check for gatekeeping or misuse.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOIntroducing Taylor Barratt
0:45 to 3:26
Discussion about the role and contributions of Taylor Barratt in the conversation.
“Last week we did John, he was at the center with myself and Taylor kind of midwifing through any thoughts that you might have around theory, practice, relationship between.”
Reflections on Previous Conversations
3:26 to 5:34
John and Taylor discuss insights gained from their previous conversation.
“you know, a different area that I wouldn't be paying attention into, you know, say cognitive science or even, you know, philosophy.”
Exploring Rightness in Practice
5:34 to 7:30
Taylor elaborates on the concept of 'rightness' in their practice experiences.
“And I don't think that's because, I mean, maybe in some subtle way, you know, there's some longing for a particular type of or a quality of connection.”
Beauty in Shared Experiences
7:30 to 10:34
Discussion on the beauty and depth found in meaningful shared moments.
“So there's just something about those particular moments.”
The Journey from Practice to Theory
10:34 to 13:12
Taylor shares his transition from practical experience to theoretical understanding.
“i mean when you're talking about movement here i'm thinking about the you know the experience that i named there's it feels more you know i would call it like calling like feeling called Yes, very much.”
Integrating Perspectives
13:12 to 14:01
Discussion on the integration of different theoretical frameworks into practice.
“And in there, it used the argument that wholeness requires an integration of states of consciousness, structures of consciousness and shadow work.”
Navigating Theory and Practice
14:01 to 18:19
Explore the dynamic relationship between theoretical understanding and practical application in facilitation.
“And then, of course, you have the states, which is largely represented by the great traditions and Eastern traditions.”
The Collective Process in Practice Design
18:20 to 20:37
Discuss the importance of collective intelligence in refining facilitation practices.
“We've all worked together repeatedly at the designing of practices.”
Reflections on Ethical Facilitation
20:38 to 25:48
Delve into the ethical considerations and personal reflections in facilitation practices.
“Like, what's your process of going back, looking at something and coming back to a practice?”
Preparing for Co-Leadership in Facilitation
25:49 to 28:03
Anticipate challenges and opportunities in co-leading facilitation sessions.
“I thought you two were starting to resonate.”
Show all 29 chapters
Co-Leading and Collaborative Facilitation
28:03 to 29:09
Explore the dynamics of co-leading in facilitation and the excitement it brings.
“And I also believe in many ways, it's going to be challenging, but challenging in a good way.”
Personal Growth Through Facilitation Challenges
29:10 to 31:18
Learn about the personal challenges and growth experiences in a facilitation role.
“This is the one thing that I've actually really appreciated by, you know, because, you know, I'm not going to go through my full story.”
Trusting Feedback and Letting Go of Control
31:19 to 33:38
Understand how to trust feedback and manage the urge for control in facilitation.
“because it's in service of the thing I want most.”
The Role of Norms and Standards in Practice
33:39 to 36:24
Discuss the implicit norms affecting facilitation practices and participant engagement.
“Normativity is the philosophical jargon.”
Feedback, Responsibility, and Human Experience
36:25 to 41:24
Delve into the importance of feedback and responsibilities in facilitation dynamics.
Measuring Impact and Optimal Experiences
41:25 to 42:00
Explore how to measure the impact and quality of practice sessions through participant experiences.
Markers of Effective Practices
42:00 to 44:15
Explore the markers that indicate a successful practice experience.
“seems something like they didn't just have a pleasant experience or a wonderful experience they are reoriented in some way they're looking forward back into their life after the practice in some fashion.”
Balance in Facilitation
44:15 to 46:30
Discuss the importance of balance in guiding participants without overwhelming them.
“Like I'm trying to get them to just have the experience because I don't want to.”
Agency and Wisdom in Participants
46:30 to 48:24
Learn how to support participant agency and acknowledge their wisdom.
“So there's also a way of like helping people one find their way.”
The Role of the Facilitator
48:24 to 50:16
Understand the facilitator's evolving role in learning and teaching.
“right now um and how can i you know bring you know bring this group more into coherence or if that feels too challenging, then how can I separate the group such that they can continue to flourish separately?”
Ethics of Facilitation
50:16 to 53:05
Examine the ethical considerations and responsibilities of facilitators.
“And for her, you know, she's like, I need to get a taste of all these different types of, you know, she would call them contractions.”
Integration of Facilitation in Daily Life
53:05 to 56:01
Discuss how facilitation practices can translate into everyday interactions.
“but I actually want to give credit to the two of you at least and a little bit to myself that this is bloody difficult to do.”
Parenting and Facilitation
56:01 to 57:29
Explore how facilitation skills enhance parenting dynamics.
“Although, you know, I have my own, as I think a lot of people with children of this generation, have my own challenges in that particular area.”
Facilitating Meaningful Connections
57:30 to 59:32
Learn about the impact of facilitation on personal relationships.
“facilitation and stuff that I could make it easier for him that somebody else who maybe has just done it and they don't have facilitation training, they can be really clunky with it.”
Navigating Self-Involvement in Facilitation
59:33 to 1:01:55
Understand the balance between personal involvement and facilitation effectiveness.
“But, but, but I've noticed like, it's like, Oh, I can carry, I can, I can, I can properly when I'm doing it well, and I don't always do it well.”
The Ethical Imperative of Facilitation Training
1:01:56 to 1:04:48
Discover the importance of ethical considerations in facilitator training.
“This is a year and a half ish sort of, you know, container, depending on how long you are inspire, you know, the facilitation end of it.”
Practicing with the Right Orientation
1:04:49 to 1:08:36
Learn how to engage in practices that promote a service-oriented mindset.
“what, you know, see what we don't know or what we didn't know.”
Training and Service Opportunities
1:10:03 to 1:10:27
Learn about training opportunities and service offerings in various locations.
Zoom Room Setup and Etiquette
1:10:27 to 1:10:58
Understand the importance of camera and microphone setup for the upcoming session.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:18Hello, everybody. Welcome back. Welcome back. This is the second of a series of three conversations that we'll be having on theory and practice, practice the theory and the relationship in between for those of you who were fortunate enough to be able to join us live. Same thing as we did last week, we'll have an hour and a half practice session after this one initial one hour conversation. And then each of these conversations kind of revolve around one of the three of us. Last week we did John, he was at the center with myself and Taylor kind of midwifing through any thoughts that you might have around theory, practice, relationship between.
0:57And then this week, we're putting all our attention on Taylor Barrett, who I imagine some of you might have seen before, but perhaps is a little bit more of a mysterious figure.
1:11And Taylor has done so much, so much work for me personally. I know I'm also having introduced John to circling in the first place. And so like I work very closely with Taylor on ATM. John, you have also worked very closely with Taylor in the past as well. So this is really an opportunity for you guys to also get to know Taylor hopefully as well, if not more so than myself and John have over a number of years. We never know what comes up. So yeah, I guess that's what I have for a preamble. anything that you would like to say John before we kind of dive in Taylor as well? No, I mean Taylor and I have an ongoing relationship we formed a new business together basically integrating me as a teacher with me as a facilitator with already the facilitation platform that Taylor has working and this makes me very happy I'm happy for this partnership and so that's another piece of important news.
2:26All right, my brother. So given that this is a series, I'm wondering if you sort of take a little bit of like a trip back to last week's conversation. Was there anything that really stuck out to you that perhaps is still has like a little bit of a liveness for you? today?
2:52Well, I think the thing most on the surface for me that's, you know, I think I've always known, but in sort of going back and taking a look at that, just to help with the continuity of our conversation, the thing that stood out for me was how we're often talking about the same things, we just use slightly different language for it. So it was interesting, you know, and that's the thing that I've always sort of enjoyed about, you know, working with John and, you know, watching his work is like, it just gives me, you know, that slightly different perspective from, you know, a different area that I wouldn't be paying attention into, you know, say cognitive science or even, you know, philosophy.
3:33And it's like, it just seems to speak to like, fundamental truths, right? Like I have a particular experience and it was informed in different ways. and there's just something like a sense of like a rightness or maybe right orientation that starts to get sort of solidified now of course some of that could just be you know you see what you want to see or you hear what you want to hear you know if you're wearing uh you know if everything's um everything's a nail um you know that sort of thing but uh but i think that was the thing that stood out the most for me and it and it speaks to i think a good reason why i don't know if it's why we like working together, but I think it speaks to a particular value of the three of us working together because, you know, it's really just a matter of degrees.
4:19And I think there's also a way in which, you know, sometimes we have to hear something in a particular sort of language or from a particular perspective for it to really land, even though the same thing was said, but different language was used and we're trying to parse that out or trying to map it onto our own knowing. so uh yeah i think that's kind of the thing that i'm mostly left with um from the conversation at least as it pertains to you know our topic around practice and practice into theory and theory into practice could you say a little bit more about like rightness because there's a way in which i'm i'm sort of drawing it out for myself as you're speaking kind of in your head like when you say there's a matter of degrees it's like we come in like maybe john might come in from this angle, I might come in from this angle, you might come in from this angle, but they ultimately kind of converge around the sense of right proportion or right orientation.
5:12Can you say a little bit more about that rightness?
5:20So I think for me, it's sort of this piece of, there's my experience in practice, even as a practitioner, there's my experience as a facilitator, but my experience in practice, somebody sets up a container they set up the framing for it and i have an experience that hopefully is more real um because of my awareness of the moment because of the intention that's set everything you know certain things become more salient to me in that particular space and often for me there's i i don't know how to really describe it but there's just sort of that sense of like i don't want anything i wouldn't want anything else to be happening than what's happening right now.
6:04And I don't think that's because, I mean, maybe in some subtle way, you know, there's some longing for a particular type of or a quality of connection. That's possible that that's there. Although after doing this for many years and being able to cultivate a certain quality of connection, it doesn't feel like it's elusive to me. But there could be a piece of that. But there's just something about, you know, John uses this term, it's really real. So I think about those moments that feel really real. Like for example, last year in the VIA intensive that the three of us were leading in along with Tataya and Kasha, John and I were meeting in an exercise and there was just sort of a way of how we followed the moment.
6:54and it led to something rather profound that you know when we came out of it you know john's like um so we need to talk about what just happened there you know and i told him like yeah i said and i just want you to know that's like what happened i wouldn't want it any other way and we didn't really get to talk really for us to sort of debrief it until uh ishtenbol last year. And we both sort of made sense of it in the same way, even though we didn't communicate it, like it landed in us in a particular way. The meaning that we made of it actually seemed to mirror one another. So there's just something about those particular moments.
7:36Now, as it relates to, you know, different perspectives, I think there's just something about, you know, I hear that and I try that perspective on and I'm like, oh yeah, that lands for me. Like that lands for me based on my knowing experience of those moments that are really real. Um, so I think that's probably what I'm talking about when it's just sort of those, you know, when something clicks, it doesn't feel like it's clicking cause it affirms my bias. Although of course there could be a little bit of that. Um, but it feels like it clicks because it's just, it's speaking to, uh maybe a divine truth about what it is that we're doing or at least we're how we're doing it together um yeah yeah that's what i would say it's interesting uh because um one of the classic definitions of beauty is that for to which nothing should be added or from uh nothing should be removed and not our current sense of of easily consumable pleasure-driven kind of experience and you get a kind of so for me that beauty shows up in a kind of lucidity you get a sense of the appearances are no longer diverting us or distracting us or misleading us suddenly they are affording us they're conducing us and I feel like I I feel like the beauty often has a transport notion to it, like I'm being carried in to something.
9:05And that's definitely what I felt in that experience. I felt there was a momentum to that experience that I was being carried into, and we were resonating in that way. And the fact that our, as you correctly note, a much later retrospective attempt to interpret it, we came to very powerful convergence around That also, I think, bespeaks the fact that we're orienting in such a way that we're starting to see into the depths of things.
9:39And of course, all of that's fallible. I mean, none of us are making any claims about we've got the algorithm for certainty. But the fact that nothing is fallible doesn't mean that some ways are not much better than others. so i wanted to i wanted to uh ask you um that that sense of movement is implicit in some of what we are framing our shared framing theory into practice practice into theory and i'm wondering does is there any connection there between that sense of movement we were discussing here when we're moving into the real and movement we're trying to afford between theory and practice and practice in theory or is that orthogonal or is there something to be explored there or that's a good question i mean i'd also be curious to see what you guys think about this as well um i mean when you're talking about movement here i'm thinking about the you know the experience that i named there's it feels more you know i would call it like calling like feeling called Yes, very much.
10:46Voluntary necessity. Yeah. Yeah. And I think for me, you know, which I articulated a little bit on our last call, you know, my experience, you know, so before getting into any sort of, you know, personal development, character development work, authentic relating software developer, you know, very logical, you know, this is my process. Right. And, you know, I would learn about things and it's like, it's like step one, step two, like it's very, very strong. structured. And then finding and coming into authentic relating where, you know, there's a lot of opportunity for chaos, right, to sort of happen.
11:25And that's not to mean that it's, you know, out of control. It's just that, you know, intersubjectively, you know, if I'm owning my experience and being more myself, I'm also affording for somebody else to also do that. And, you know, people can clash as they tend to in one way or another. And we can learn a lot through that process. But that's what interests me. And, you know, as people around me, we're talking about, you know, theories, things like integral theory, Ken Wilber's integral theory and stuff like that. I didn't pay much attention to it because I was sort of in that place because this is early in my sort of journey of like, and, you know, this speaks actually to some of the stuff that I was talking about before.
12:05I'm like, I don't know that I need that right now. But I don't think that was so much a necessary ignorance. It was like there was still so much for me here in practice that I felt like I didn't want to like grasp in some particular way, some sense of I need to have it all. You know, I think there was, I don't know what that was ultimately, but I just spent that time in it and in the practice. And then I noticed that some of the novelty faded at the practice and this isn't so much, you know, it became less impactful. It's just, you know, I knew what we were doing, you know, so I could just do it.
12:42I could drop into it. So that meant I had more spare resources in my brain that I could take on more complexity. And that's when I started to get a little bit more interested in like, okay, maybe now it's time for me to read out why so many other people in this space have their attention over here. And for me, that sort of lit like, oh, okay, now I see what is now I know as effectively the benefit of practice into theory and then being able to bring that back into practice. So now for me, I would say there's a calling towards the structural framing. What we've used in Authentic Relating Toronto for quite some time is sort of the glasses that we would put on and we would check to see if what we were offering did this is based on a white paper that Ken Wilber and Dustin DiPerna wrote called Towards a Deliberately Developmental Civilization.
13:37And in there, it used the argument that wholeness requires an integration of states of consciousness, structures of consciousness and shadow work. So to me, within that particular perspective, which is, you know, long before I met you, John, you know, that's sort of holding that that theory into practice and practice into theory because the structure is represented in, you know, in the North American Western sort of tradition of psychology and things like that. And then, of course, you have the states, which is largely represented by the great traditions and Eastern traditions. And then, of course, the necessity of shadow work because of all the fallibilities that we were talking about in the last session about an overemphasis on the proposition, an overemphasis on a participatory.
14:18So for me, the integration of that has just now created more of a calling that didn't necessarily exist for me before. So I would say I do have that movement towards holding that balance or coming out and sort of checking my work or stepping back and looking at and using some of the frameworks. So it's there now, but it wasn't there at the beginning. I had a journey I had to go through before that became something that I could really appreciate through having a taste of how ultimately, selfishly, how it could benefit me. That's interesting. um again similar but different as you mentioned um i i share what you're saying i mean i came totally out of theory into practice so mine was a very clear uh clearly different trajectory but for me there's i i've come to like appreciate appreciate that when i get that sensing of theory calling me into practice that the theory there's something there's something truer about the theory i'm being truer to the theory i'm not right and also but the reverse for me when i feel the practice like calling me out to the theory and no no that that also makes me feel like the practice is in touch with something uh and and and there's a realization happening in it that needs to be properly reflected upon.
15:50So does that land for, oh, that lands for you too? Well, I, again, I would use, you know, slightly different language for it. I think, and again, sorry, going more to the selfish aspects of it. It's, it's like, I see now how, how it affords different things for me. So there's a way in which it, it, it keeps me out of bullshit is probably the way that I would put it. Right. So I think there's that thing of like, Like, oh, I'm enjoying this a bit too much, you know, not that, you know, you shouldn't be able to enjoy and experience pleasure, but there's becomes that thing of like, hang on a sec, like, where might I be?
16:28You know, I'm misleading myself. And I've found that, you know, being able to step back and of course, you know, collective intelligence. So, you know, we were talking about sort of depending on one another is like sort of leaning in like, hey, how do you, how do you, you know, I've gotten this, this feedback, how does this sort of land for you guys? Right. So sort of moving out of the present moment experience, but moving into something a little bit more of a cognitive framing to sort of take a look at something. So I think I would extrapolate that a little bit more out a bit into the theory because I noticed for me still, when I hear you talk and of course I've watched a series and a lot of talks, but if I ever go back and watch something, I'm able to pick up something that I didn't notice before.
17:07because there was so much novelty at that time that I could only hold like this insight once that sort of settles it's the same thing I'm watching film right yeah like I have I have films that I love a lot and you know I watched Black Swan with my daughter uh this week and that movie hit me in a way this time it's probably my fourth time maybe fifth time seeing it in a way that it never did before like I was actually quite moved by it in a way that before I was just sort delighted and entertained by it. I think this speaks to just the general notion of we're never quite finished. We're always unfolding, unfolding, unfolding, unfolding.
17:45I see that theory and the propositional is still an important part of that, going back to the thing about multiple capacities and not over-relying on one because they will fail us from time to time. That all just comes right back into what really landed for me as as true or right around that integration of structures of consciousness states of consciousness and shadow work so that's how i still integrate that i still feel the pull for it because i've believed to whatever degree the rightness of it up until and i'm open to being shown something different but i i haven't come across that yet i haven't come across a different framework where i'm like oh actually this is just all sorts of problems you know I haven't I haven't found that yet so Ethan if I could just ask one more because it's a series and then and then I'll turn it over to you because we're now close to something we didn't really talk about extensively last time but I thought we should because it seems to be a proper place especially when we're talking about this movement and how it's correcting us and and so forth.
18:51We've all worked together repeatedly at the designing of practices. And we're doing that. And I thought, oh, we should talk about that because it's a place where theory into practice and practice into theory. And we're also doing it collectively. It's like the lab of what we're talking about here. And that's, so these movements we're talking about. And I remember when we were doing that, I found, that's when I sort of saw that loop I was discovering, discussing with you, right? Oh, oh, oh, I see. Right. And I noticed, anyways, I'm talking too much, but I thought we should, we should move into, you know, reflecting upon this issue of this movement and how it's correcting us.
19:34And we've got this mutual correcting going on both between theory and practice and between each other. That's what I hear you saying. And how that showed up in our, you know, the process because for me that process was as powerful a landing of the logos as any DID we've done because you know we were all like I looking back you know it's very hard like who who thought of that part and I it's all just like it's yeah right so anyways you know what I'm talking about we just so those of you who are listening we have we have designed several practices together and we've also refined practices together often with another person who many of you know of Christopher Master Pietro but I just thought that's also a crucible for where what we're talking about takes place in a way that's generative and we in a way in which we're trying to bring things to other people so I'm wondering if you wanted to comment on that yeah absolutely you said your mouth yeah i mean john because john you anticipated my question actually quite well i was going to refer to um a little bit more pointedly when you mentioned earlier taylor your practice the the kind of stepping back and checking like hey am i bullshitting myself here like like i'm actually quite curious like what's the process by which you do that because the way that I've seen that done with the three of us and you know with Chris or with Ryan and Rick is that it's so good to have other people with different frameworks different experience come in and like check that knowing that the practice we're trying to birth or create or refine is ultimately in service of people who are not yet in the room with us won't be until they are, but we also want them to leave better than they were when they came in.
21:32So that shared orientation has always been kind of like my touchstone, but I personally wrestle with it, with the difficulty of doing that, that process of like, hang on, am I bullshitting myself here by trying to confirm this thing that I used to do all the time because this thing can fit it? Like, what's your process of going back, looking at something and coming back to a practice? Oh, well, I mean, I think the thing that stands, shines out to me the most, um, with that question is the awareness of how difficult, uh, it has been for me to try to do it on my own. Mm. Um, where I find that I can create a bit of a bind for myself, where it's very helpful to have others sort of reflect or, or bring in a new perspective.
22:16And I certainly had a recent, I mean, I've had a number of them, but I've had a semi-recent experience, um, when Christopher and I were talking because I was noticing there's this way in which I was showing up often in sort of holding what I would refer to, not to suggest that I'm bringing something that other people aren't holding an ethical standard, but I would bring sort of an ethical aspect forward, you know, around what some people would see as sort of gatekeeping practices, but I saw as like taking real responsibility for the power of the practices and understanding how they can be misused, certainly based on my experience of going through challenges with, you know, the second, more onto the third wave of sort of circling and authentic relating.
22:58And, and, you know, I felt a little alone sometimes, like I'm always doing this, right? And so it's like, what am I missing here? Like, what is it about myself that's in here? Because I felt like, oh, maybe I'm grading or here comes Taylor sort of bringing this thing and, you know, taking the fun out of it for other people or something. And Christopher and I had a good conversation about it and he really helped me articulate and understand in a way that actually landed for me where you know for me you know i i've learned over the years you know many years of authentic relating you know for me when somebody says something and it like has that pang of truth like i always sort of look for that to see like oh yeah you've touched on something you've just helped reveal something that you know was hidden to me it's like okay you're right about that.
23:44And he helped me be able to sort of see what that thing is for me. And that sort of freed me up to maybe double down or something, but to sort of stick to my guns. So there was a way in which it felt intrinsically right for me, but there's a way in which this is where, you know, being reflected by others can also create, you know, a certain degree of confusion as well. But then I can also go to others to sort of help settle that confusion. So I think, you know, ultimately what I'm speaking to is noticing for me some sort of a contraction and how I can benefit by the reflections or the people that I depend on to help me see something that I couldn't see, help me see the water that I was swimming in, help see name something that, you know, was in my blind spot.
24:31And I think ultimately that translates over into, you know, sort of John's question in practice, you know, in the design of practices, because we have come in with a particular intention, like, oh, we want the practice to kind of do this thing or be modeled after that thing. And then where we end up with is not quite what that was, but actually a lot better than I think, I certainly hope, but a lot better than what it was or what we thought it was going to be. So, you know, again, the distributed cognition into collective intelligence, hopefully into collective wisdom, which then, of course, because I've had these numerous experiences, for me, it's like, and I want to keep doing this stuff with you guys, doing it together, because I know the product of it is better than anything that I could come up with on my own, which is why I'm quite happy that Ethan's now, and Tiamat is now in Awaken to Meaning.
25:24And so now there's a team of us sort of working together under this particular umbrella. And while we were in parallel in so many ways, it's like now we're much more in sort of a shared specific intention. And in that time, I'm trusting that the product of whatever it is that we're doing is better than the sum of the individuals.
25:47Do you have something, John? No, I want to pick up on that. I thought you two were starting to resonate. So I'm just giving space. Yeah. So this is, so one, one thing we're sort of just like, I'm like, I'm interested in just sort of picking up on, but it might end up being trivial. Was, why was it depend on in quotes? Well, I think I'm going back to, I'm going back to last week's conversation where John was sort of making the distinguishing between dependency and also, you know us depending on one another in a generative sense rather than you know in mesh codependency sort of you know negative type of dependency so i think that's why i said it is just to articulate any i think anytime i do this it's like i'm i'm acknowledging that the word i'm using could land multiple different ways i mean that could be true about any word i use but really about these words so i always anytime i talk about safety i put it in quotes right because it's like there's more to just the term here um so that's that's all that was about but it's a common thing that i do because i'm aware of the the challenge of language sometimes right and but you see this is also like one of those things which like i see as a playful thing to pick up on because like i i dare say well with quotes or without now that i depend on both of you very much to um help check my work for lack of a better term right and to bring things forward and to go, hey, you know, like given years of experience across each other, I think between us, we have some like 50 years of experience being in the room with folks, right?
27:2510 here, I think you're on 14, Taylor, and John, you're in the 30s, right? So there's a way in which all of these kind of experiences land together. And with that comes a great deal of history of things that we've seen happen in the room, patterns that we see sort of like emerge across the board when we're running like maybe a three day thing or like a five day thing or like an eight week long course that I imagine because we've talked about this before Taylor like where things are happening that we can almost anticipate a trajectory like happening right and we're going whoa what is oh this thing this thing is occurring so I'm really curious like as you sort of step into in a way like a different it's not quite different contexts like we're now much more co-leading um things together to the extent that might be novel in whatever degree that it is right how are you um wow this is an interesting question how are you wrestling with how are you reckoning with um not just like on a design level talking about a practice that we together bring to other people but actually bringing different minds in the room together directly working with others yeah so one is on a design level the other is on like a facilitation level yeah um how do you see that um well i mean that's that's going to happen a lot in in a couple weeks here we've got a big series of things that we're all sort of running together four times specifically yeah yeah but um and i'm so excited for it um because I think it's going to be a lot of fun.
29:04And I also believe in many ways, it's going to be challenging, but challenging in a good way. This is the one thing that I've actually really appreciated by, you know, because, you know, I'm not going to go through my full story. But before I got into this work, I was fairly misanthropic. You know, I largely blamed other people for everything that was going wrong in my life. A great thing I learned from my father, don't get me wrong. I love my father and I miss him dearly. But, you know, he had a perspective and I definitely picked up on it um and of course now that's not sort of the way that i hold things but there was still a way in which i was doing a lot of leading sort of on my own and you know me and my wife uh were sort of the ones that started leading in authentic relating toronto together but then she went to school for psychodynamic psychotherapy and she's got a full practice so she really is doesn't have the time for that um but that was sort of the only time in which i was like really working with like Sometimes I would do things and I would just hand off a chunk of time to somebody else.
30:03It's a little bit different than really working together on something. So that was what was so exciting for me about joining the Verveke Foundation a couple of years ago and starting the ATM platform. because I had a team of people who I knew were, you know, largely, you know, 99 % overlapped in terms of intention, as well as also like the, the, the urgency or the, the being called forth to do this work. Um, but of course there was challenges cause now I have to like share, I have to share some of the leadership with other people and it's, it's becomes a different kind of trust in other people, as well as a different kind of trust in myself.
30:49So admittedly, it has been challenging. It's still, I think, in some ways, a bit of a growth edge for me. But it's also one that I've been enjoying noticing how much easier it's getting for me. And I think it helps, you know, as we've talked about the practice development to see the benefit and the strength of the project that we created together. So now I kind of know it has to be this way. So I need to, you know, need, but I want to continue to make this process a lot easier because it's in service of the thing I want most. So even if it creates a certain personal struggle or contraction or thing, and that's something for me to look at and to work on, which is great because I'm committed to doing that.
31:41But this is one of those areas, you know, like still a recovering control freak, you know, I'm still recovering from trying to control for the future. You know, I don't like to be disappointed. It really, really sucks for me to be disappointed. Yeah. And, and this is sort of a thing of, of just finding different layers. Like, I feel like I'm really good at being in the moment and trusting it, but when I'm outside of the moment before I'm in that hyper presence where, you know, I'm just, I'm being, there's still a lot of this degree of control. And yeah, that's still there. And I feel really excited about it because I think, as I was saying at the beginning, there's a way in which I think we can start to resonate, you know, or maybe perhaps jazz together in a way that I think is actually quite, quite conducive and adds quite, quite a fair bit of value for the participant base.
32:39Cause it's not like we're in conflict with one another. It's just like, Oh, actually, you know, I would articulate it this way. And, Oh, actually we should say this. And, you know, even, you know, with, with John last week, there was a couple of moments I said something, he's like, well, some people might pick up what you were saying, but this, but that's not what you mean by that. Right. So we're really helping each other deliver our message or deliver the thing that we're trying to deliver. And my belief is that it helps land four more people because everybody's a little bit different. Yeah.
33:14So there's a lot of things that we could pick up on, but there's one that's been very backgrounded, but also very present. And I guess the question that's coming to my mind in both practice, designing practice, being in the room and getting minds to come together.
Read the full transcript
33:37There's an implicit set of norms or standards or something. Normativity is the philosophical jargon. How do we know when we're doing this well? Right?
33:53That's a great question, John. my trajectory in the past has been if i get positive feedback and i tried really hard i did a good job what was really tricky for me is when i didn't feel like i was trying really hard and i got positive feedback i didn't trust it so it was a real process of me sort of having to learn that like life doesn't have to be hard like yes of course there's going to be the things that we struggle with but i always like taking that on that like if there's no struggle i haven't earned anything um and there's a bit of validity to that in terms of uh you know in terms of you know self-transcendence and sort of the complexity and you know the butterfly effect you know through you know that sort of thing like i think that's that's uh very much a part of one's unfolding and development but it took it took a little bit of time for me to really trust like okay hang on this is easy for me because I've been doing it for so long.
34:55So I'm just, I'm, I'm more in that, you know, as Ethan and I've referred to it, I'm more in that self as instruments sort of place that I'm not, you know, consciously trying to going back to the control thing. I'm not consciously trying to control for the moment to lead to a particular thing. I'm just actually following the moment and responding to the moment as it's happening. And that has become substantially easier. Um, but of course that's just not my experience, you know, for the previous, you know 40 30 30 plus 40 years of my life is you know protestant work ethic gotta hustle and if i'm not hustling you know i'm not actually accomplishing anything um so so there was that was sort of the trajectory for me um sometimes i still have those moments where i do something and for me i'm like i don't know was that good and i'm sort of looking for the feedback and the shares to sort of get a sense of like was that you know how did that actually land for some people But and I've learned to trust that a lot more because it allows me to recalibrate, you know, my expectations.
35:54It allows me to also be a little bit more easier on myself as well to say, like, that was, you know, that was impactful. That was, you know, that was good, especially if I've set up the container where I can invite feedback and also invite negative feedback. Because in some spaces that tends to be sort of, you know, tampered down or like, no, no, it's going to be love and light in here, you know, which is a great capacity to be able to cultivate. but it can't be the only one. Um, cause you know, then we're, we're really susceptible to the bullshit. So I really try to invite a lot more of that.
36:27And I try to do it also oftentimes through sort of modeling, um, you know, uh, contrary, you know, uh, opinions or, uh, you know, some sort of resistance, you know, like even within myself, like just acknowledging that it's there. I think the difference to whatever degree between maybe myself and a new practitioner is like, number one, you know i can notice the resistance number two i can name it but number three i can also let it go um and sometimes that can't because i'm not subject to it right it's like oh it's there and there's still something you know a young part of me or something that's happening like you know but it's not appropriate right now what's appropriate right now is for me to acknowledge it name it to tame it um model that hey that's coming up for me but then choose something different right it's not what happens it's what you do about it um so i think in that invitation of of the feedback and then being able to then trust what comes from participants that's helped me really recalibrate um that sense and then of course having a broad ecology of practices affording a broad perspective such that i'm looking at other practices that i did before where for me it was just like oh is this person you know really alive right now okay great they've got a lot of aliveness that did my job but i've it's i've also been able to sort of notice a little bit more where the container or the thing that we're doing might actually be exacerbating even though it's a positive energy it might actually be exacerbating um or enabling sort of a maladaptive pattern right um so sometimes you know that ability to step back and notice that and like ask sort of the right questions like oh i noticed this is happening you know is it like this for you is it like that for you right and then and then sort of recording and noting that like okay so maybe not you know feed that particular demon because that can certainly happen in any particular container right again we go into the into the heavy propositional set up a container where all we do is just you know uh try to make ourselves look smart well that's not what the container is for but you know then we like oh there's an opportunity for me to look smart or here's an opportunity for me to gaze at my navel the whole time.
38:41So feedback has been a big piece of it, but also just taking the experience. I think this draws the huge distinction between what is a facilitator and what is a leader. And I know there's whatever negative connotations around the idea of leading for some people. But for me, I think that's a really important distinction is that I'm taking a certain degree of responsibility for what's happening in the container. Of course, I can't take all the responsibility because there's other agentic human beings here. But I also know, and we'll talk about this as we move into our practice session, we have this golden rule generally in AR or anything we do on ATM is to honor yourself.
39:21And I actually know that some people actually don't know how to honor themselves. So I take some responsibility for the fact that one, I know that, so I need to know that. I know that trauma is always in the room. and I'm able to sort of, based on the experience and the moments and, you know, sometimes when it's gone wrong, although I think I've been fairly, I don't know if lucky is the right word, but I haven't run up against too much of the adversity in that and getting it wrong too often. I think because I've, you know, done more of the experimental stuff with a group of people that have a lot of trust.
39:55And then when it comes to the, you know, the public things, I'm not, I'm not using people to experiment on. So I think sort of that whole experience of seeing the matrix and being able to track what's happening in the room to avoid potential pitfalls and to come out on the other end of it in somebody's like, the big one that I appreciate the most is they come in and they're check-ins like, oh, I'm really tired and I wasn't sure if I was going to come today. And at the end, they're like, yeah, I feel so much better. I'm, you know, so much sort of here and alive. And it's like, okay, good. You know, yeah.
40:32Okay. Positive experience. But that just tells me like, okay, they got to express themselves. They got to let something go there. They're being more themselves. They're not stuck in the contraction of filtering or, or trying to wear this mask. I mean, I'm sure they're still doing it to an extent, but at least they were able to relax it. So it's sort of those sort of moments that helped me, you know, understand that what is happening in the space is good like you know in the transcendental sense of good um and you know going back to the thing that you named about beauty is also being able to appreciate the beauty in the negative um or the more conflict moments because there's something there's a dignity that's there for people in these particular moments and being able to just like appreciate you know the raw humanity of something that's happening um so there's lots of different touch points that sort of suggest to me that what's happening is is good um yeah yeah it's but it's hard to say there's any one thing you know well i i hear i i hear a bunch of different touch points so it's not that there's multiples there seem to be multiple kinds uh there seems to be something that is uh i hear you often refer to as landing something is landing for people and you're getting a sense of they're taking it up you can read them they can read you you're getting feedback that it's landing you've also mentioned impact which seems something like they didn't just have a pleasant experience or a wonderful experience they are reoriented in some way they're looking forward back into their life after the practice in some fashion.
42:13So I hear impact. And then I also heard aliveness, which is a sense that there's something like, you know, on the continuum, I won't go into heavy theory here, but on the continuum towards resonance and the flow state is happening for them. And so that's a reason to believe that they're having some kind of optimal experience, optimal performance. So I heard at least, I'm not saying I'm giving you an exhaustive list, but I've heard this, I've heard landing, I've heard impact, and I've heard aliveness. Is there anything else that perhaps I did miss when, in terms of, you know, the kind of, not the number, but the kinds of markers that are showing up for you to say, yes, this is a good practice, this is a good practice.
43:01You also, oh, sorry, you did mention another one. You picked up the point I asked about beauty. There's a sense of beauty. So there's four. There's the beauty. There's the impact. There's the aliveness. There's the landing. Is there anything else? Because sometimes articulating the normativity of the practice is a good place to see how the theory and the practice are talking to each other. Yeah, that's true. Yeah, that's true. Yeah, there can be those moments also when, you know, somebody comes back and reflects something that wasn't articulated for it. And it's like, you got it. You figured it out, right?
43:41Because sometimes, you know, I'm more guilty than this, probably than the two of you, is sometimes I want, I don't want to give people too much context depends on the exercise we're doing. I want them to have their own experience because I'm acknowledging in many ways that we all come in a little bit differently just in terms of our past experience, you know, life experience, stuff like that. But even just how we're doing that day or whether or not we got a good sleep or something. And, you know, in many ways, sometimes, you know, I'll articulate something or I'll use a phrase and they're like, well, what do you mean by that?
44:12And I'm like, just go with whatever way it lands for you first, right? Like I'm trying to get them to just have the experience because I don't want to. sometimes I'm cautious I don't want to guide or the power of suggestion too much such that then people come out and what they reflect back is the thing that I already told them yeah so there is you know as we always talk about balance you know throughout a container and stuff like that there are a number of moments where I just want you to have the experience and I want you know I wanted to hear why it was challenging or what you liked about it or what you didn't like about it and then I might make a correction or at least a offer a perspective that may actually you know reframe the exercise for the next time they do it.
44:52Right. So there's a way sometimes for me, I'm not being completely exhaustible, um, or exhaustive in my explanation of a particular practice, because I really want people to actually wrestle with the practice. Um, but, you know, of course with the appropriate guardrails, you know, that they're, you know, going to stretch and not tear and not hurt themselves. So in that, I heard another term then, which was balance. There's a sense of balance and what you're trying to, I mean, it sounds very much like Vygotsky. It sounds like the zone of proximal development. We're trying to balance between giving them enough that they can do it on their own, but they couldn't do it on their own if we weren't there to facilitate, right?
45:34Because if you're too heavy-handed, then you're not learning. And if you're too absent, right, they'll just spin off in in various ways so it sounds like you're trying to articulate there's a balance point you're sort of also looking for between those two extremes it's kind of a golden mean right between deficit and excess all right not giving enough uh context and giving too much and and so you get a sense of oh this is balancing because people are right i i'm not feeding them what they're feeding back to me. I'm feeding them a learning situation and then they give back to me their own insight, but it jives with the insight that I was holding something like something like that.
46:19Is that, is that, well, yeah, I also want to afford the truth of their own wisdom. Yeah. We were talking a lot last week about remembering and in many ways, a lot of the stuff, you know, that I'm doing is I'm helping people remember. And, you know, so, you know, the innocence of youth and childhood and things like that, where everything was sort of, you know, easy before, you know, a parent or society sort of tamped it down and put you into the, you know, the tube towards, you know, you know, marriage, kids, you know, a job, that sort of thing. So there's a lot of sort of that such that, you know, and again, acknowledging that everybody's a little bit different, there's often a lot of neuro neurodivergence, you know, in at least in my experience, in authentic relating containers, which makes a lot of sense.
47:03So there's also a way of like helping people one find their way. So affording still affording them agency, right? Like in a very gestalt sort of way of like really, um, in enabling them to do their own development, right. Rather than me saying, well, hang on a sec, you know, this speaks to the thing, you know, I'm not giving you the right way. Cause for everybody, it's not really the, there's no, there isn't a right way that what works for me isn't necessarily going to work for you. So, um, so yeah, I think that's a big part of sort of that balancing is to afford and try to acknowledge the wisdom that's already in the room.
47:38And then if we run up against something that maybe seems like foolishness or is a little less wise, then we can maybe make, you know, offer a perspective into the space that helps them reframe that, or at least to consider it, right? So another part of the balancing sometimes is sort of offering, like in some ways, it's like, I'm going to offer you your perspective. And there's a way in which I don't want to say, you know, take what works for you and leave the rest. But there's also a way in which that actually might be the wise thing for that person to do right now um so there has to be a certain degree of giving up to what's to the entire group and not to grab it and really like this has been the real thing around control is really letting go and and track the emergent of what's happening and what does this group need right now um and how can i you know bring you know bring this group more into coherence or if that feels too challenging, then how can I separate the group such that they can continue to flourish separately?
48:37You know, again, speaking to, you know, stuff more on the leadership end, then you would run into on a facilitation part of like, well, here's the next step in the practice and okay, now we're going to rotate this way. So yeah, that's what I would say about the balance. Like that's, sometimes I'm not as successful with that. Sometimes I get a little bit like on my own role and I'm just like, download, download, download. Because, you know, So I'm liking how this is working, you know, in that moment. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And then, you know, and I've gotten feedback sometimes about like, okay, you know, maybe you don't need to say it, you know, as much.
49:11And it's like, yeah, no, I know I got carried away. You know, I'm also infallible. Well, there's a balance there because sometimes when you're on a roll, I mean, I've been teaching for a long time. It's because you're learning as you're teaching. And for me, the best teaching is when you are learning as you're teaching. Yeah, it's true. Yeah. I mean, that was, I think, you know, I've said this before and this is, you know, a quote from Guy. I don't know when he said it, Guy Sengstock, but he said, you know, the person who actually gets the most out of a circle is the facilitator. Yeah. Which you, you know, it's not the way that we set it up and we're not selfishly doing it.
49:50But the fact is, is there's so much growth and unfolding and understanding of the self. And I often use, you know, the generalized frame, you know, from cognitive science as something that circling has really afforded me. It's really helped me build a very strong generalized frame of the other. Right. Such that I can notice a lot of implicit patterns and stuff like this. And this maps onto other work that I've done with, you know, facilitators, you know, a mentor of mine, Alanya Forsberg, who's, you know, slightly, I say this crazy with a lot of affection because, you know, her whole thing was, you know, trying to answer the question, why do some people end up in jail and other people don't?
50:39Plato's pivot problem. Yes. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. And for her, you know, she's like, I need to get a taste of all these different types of, you know, she would call them contractions. In some ways, we could refer to them as trauma to sort of so that they can sort of live within her so that she can notice it or pick it out in other people as she works with them. Right. So she's talk about somebody who's working with sort of an ecology of practices. So a little bit more of an emphasis on some faculties than others, but just so dynamic. I mean, I've never met somebody who can switch from the feminine into the masculine as the moment calls it and so strong and of course, so, you know, generally clean, at least in practice.
51:22And I mean, I've heard, you know, answer early complaints as well, but I've been very impressed. And I've learned a lot from those particular moments in those containers. I can't I can't let that go by. I just can't. So before I explicate that piece, I also want to explicate the first thing, which is what you're describing in terms of this larger balancing
51:47where some people come into containers and they really want the explanation of how all of this works. Tell me the thing. And I'm happy to do that when we're at the dinner table and then I can wax lyrical about theory. And I know that for myself because I can sit in the besetting sin of being a teacher. But what this participant might need in the moment right now is to lean into the experience of like what it is to sit in that ambiguity. And the opposite is also true where, you know, I've even just yesterday, we ran the TMX session and folks were, you know, some folks were saying like, I really want more of an experience, but I find myself like really outside.
52:27How do I dive into that? And I see kind of what the three of us are having to do to varying different degrees in different contexts. is to kind of like bookend it a little bit such that there's a highest probability that they can have a balanced experience as much as possible that affords them something. Some of us might go the way of explaining the framework. Some of us might go in the way of try this. But this piece that you had named, first of all, doing all of that is really, really hard. Really, really hard. I don't think, maybe people who are watching right now I'll be willing to give us some credit, but I actually want to give credit to the two of you at least and a little bit to myself that this is bloody difficult to do.
53:11Maintaining that balance is difficult. But this piece that you had named of like, you know, I mean, I don't know Alanya personally, but I always wrestle with this question, having gone through many years of practice, being in the room, being a participant, that I think there's something that Sarah Bin had said in a conversation we had a few weeks ago, which is that teachers also need to be self-actualized. Oh yeah. That, you know, as we're doing the work. Yeah. It's kind of echoing a little bit of what you were quoting from Guy there, which is like, the practice is also actually like, we're learning stuff, as John was naming, right?
53:46How is the, how is the, okay, the, how is the practice of facilitation, right? Leadership, being able to hold containers like this, actually transferring into daily life. Like that for me is an important question. You mean with trust for me? um well i love your take on it yeah like how are you how are you transferring what we're doing in the work in a context in a container um and integrating it is more of an integration question
54:18oh sorry i just want to make sure i'm on the same page you're you're sort of stepping back and there's a meta practice of doing the practice of doing all these practices and and what's it like to do that meta practice in terms of it being a ritual that transfers back into your life is am i understanding you correctly ethan okay good we are the same pebble john yeah yeah that's a good question um i feel like i'd have to think fairly hard at that to figure out what the distinction is about oh no i got you know this thing that i now do i got that because I was a facilitator as opposed to because I was just doing the practice.
54:57The one thing that I do want to say though, is while I agree with you, and that's all entirely true, I want to highlight a key distinction that I'm not doing that in service for myself. I'm doing the facilitation leadership in service of the context that I sat in for the participants. I just happen to benefit from it. So I often articulate this thing where I say, I don't believe there's anything as a truly altruistic act. I believe that we do things for, and we call them self-ish reasons that are inherently good and therefore benefit others, you know, and I would love to debate anybody about that at some point to see whether or not my mind could be changed on it.
55:36But, you know, and a lot of that's just a projection of, of how I've come to think it's certain things that I accept about myself is like, oh, I, you know, I like doing this because of the value that it gave me, but also recognizing, you know, and taking on the ethical responsibility to, to do it, you know uh with with right orientation um the benefit and the good for other people as well so that that drive for me to turn around and offer that to others you know and that projection actually is like a good thing because it's like i want others to have the experience that i so so deeply appreciate it in terms of so you know there's going to be that right is that a bit it's of being of i'm in many ways it's sort of the being of service thing i actually think it maybe shows up a little bit more in my parenting.
56:21Although, you know, I have my own, as I think a lot of people with children of this generation, have my own challenges in that particular area. And I'm also co-parent with two other people. So there's a way in which, you know, I have to also include their needs and their different ways as well. And maybe part of that actually is, you know, I'm able to work within groups and recognize, you know, different needs in the space and stuff like that. So I think that might be a place where it's actually been very helpful is at least in the air traffic controlling of parenting, a single child with three adults that, you know, do things, everything a little bit differently.
57:04So it's possible that's a way in which that's shown up and has benefited me from that perspective. I think another one has been me bringing the practice back when my father was alive, I actually got him to come out to Authentic Relating and to events that I was running. And I actually got to learn and understand him in a way that I couldn't before that. So there was a way in which I took that home, but because I had the capacity in the facilitation and stuff that I could make it easier for him that somebody else who maybe has just done it and they don't have facilitation training, they can be really clunky with it.
57:43I mean, You know, I certainly remember very early on in my circling training, one of our homework pieces was to circle somebody in our life. And I remember my wife and I, we went to to go do this with one of our friends. And, you know, we articulated all this stuff. Hey, we're still training this, that. But we totally dropped the ball, you know, so there's a way in which, like, you can really sort of, you know, mess that up. Relationship was was fine and everything but that. But, you know, stepping back and look at it's like, oh, yeah, we were definitely in training at that point. Right. So there is probably something about the experience of it and the confidence and the trust and then sort of bringing it into those situations where it really matters.
58:21You know, like maybe it's a little bit safer because everybody is in this, you know, yes, I want to do authentic relating. So 20 people show up because they all want to do the same thing. There's a certain degree of safety in the shared context there. My father was not somebody who talked about his feelings ever, ever so to be able to invite him into something like that and that novelty and to to earn his trust in that place it uh so i think that was another area in which the work that i was doing was really transferring into my life in a very meaningful way i'm sure there's lots of other subtle ways um could i ask you about one sure because one that's become sort of and it goes back to Plato's pivot problem.
59:03And I don't think this is the total answer, but I've been struggling and you guys know since, since, since Bergerac, and we've actually engineered and designed practices around this, how to involve the whole of the self without becoming self-involved. And I find the more I'm doing the facilitation, I get the taste, the sense of what it's like to show up like and have my myself fully involved without becoming self-involved in a situation and it seems to me that that's beneficial to the people around me I show up to use the current lingo the best I possibly can and that doesn't seem I can't put my finger on that to any I mean it's probably the whole ecology practices but to my mind that the the facilitation because of what you're talking about, the way it's oriented, you have to bring sort of all you are to it, but it's to the other people.
1:00:04I don't know if I'm making much sense, but I've developed, I've developed a taste for like, and it's really tricky because you don't want to, you don't want to turn into a facilitator when you're involved in a existential or personal or relationship with people because that's, that's bad too. Right. But, but, but I've noticed like, it's like, Oh, I can carry, I can, I can, I can properly when I'm doing it well, and I don't always do it well. Right. But what I can, I can integrate that. I know what it feels like. I know what it tastes like. Um, if I, I, I really, you know, fully involving myself, but I'm not self-involved and that there's something, there's something deeply satisfying Because I don't know if we want to be self-involved as much as we just want to be fully involved, the whole of the self.
1:00:58And learning that and learning how to bring one in without drifting into the other. I mean, that's something I'm grateful for when I'm a facilitator. I've picked that taste up. And I don't want to, this is about you, I don't want to hug the spotlight. But I wanted to know if that's resonating for you as something. Totally. Yeah. I mean, I think in many ways that's what we're trying to do at the higher levels of training. Right. We're trying to get people out of the self-involvement part. Yeah. Yeah. You know, the thing that I've often, you know, have sort of said is, you know, and I say this to the facilitators, you know, the thing that we need to get clear on is our why.
1:01:40Why are we doing this? Why is this important to us? And until you can answer that question, you're subject to it. and you which could then could mean you're bullshitting yourself and everything else so you know a lot of reasons why you know so inadvertently advertising this thing but you know guy runs the circling training it's a two-year training to get into facilitation for circling it's not because it takes two years to understand the structure of circling that is not what that's about it takes that amount of time similar to tm at being you know largely you know depending on how we place it.
1:02:12This is a year and a half ish sort of, you know, container, depending on how long you are inspire, you know, the facilitation end of it. It takes that long just to get out of our own way, to remember, to build up the experience, to sort of make the mistakes, to have the oversight and the, you know, the supervision from the lead facilitators, to help us do all that course correction, to shine the light on the thing that we didn't notice in the middle of our facilitation. So in many ways, that's the thing we're doing in training for sure, without a doubt. And I think the thing that you're talking about, or at least the way, the way it landed for me as you started is like, that's the self as instrument part.
1:02:51That is using yourself as the instrument of transformation, right? So that, and I think that's a big distinction between what we do and many modalities of therapy, right? Is that we are participants often, I mean, depending on the container, but we are also participating with you. We are in relationship with you. And we are also using, you know, hopefully that we've built up, you know, a fairly strong set of, you know, resilience and capacity and dynamicism or whatever the word is I'm looking for. That's the word. Yeah. And, and therefore we are very responsible, bubble, right? So again, it's not what happens is what we do about it.
1:03:34And I think that's the thing that we're cultivating, but we have to do it within ourselves. I think before we start to take on the responsibility of others, that's why, you know, the trajectory is getting you into your own self-leadership before you're in a position of power or of influence for other people, because you just got to, you got to figure out, you know, you're not going to completely understand yourself, but you got to understand yourself probably a lot more than you are. already do. And I just see that as an ethical imperative. I mean, this goes back to the thing that I was saying, you know, that Christopher helped me understand.
1:04:08It really goes back to the ethical imperative of why I believe facilitator practice, especially most of the practices we do is very important, but then also why we do training, right? We're not doing training in that like coachy way, like I'm going to coach the coaches. You know, it goes back to that thing of like there are people who are interested in doing this and my hope is to help them you know more reach that right orientation and that that real sort of cleanliness that clean up right the you know wake up grow up clean up show up i want them to clean up and i think that's basically why that you know it takes that time because we have to get in here we have to rub up against each other we have to you know opponent process all these different practices together so that we can see what, you know, see what we don't know or what we didn't know.
1:04:57And we need to do it in a group so that we can help get those reflections. So total resonance. I mean, it's the, it's the whole, it's the whole reason why I love training. Um, because that to me is the real trajectory of unfolding and practice is just a vehicle, a vehicle for us to come more into our fullness. Yeah. And I saw, I saw what you're talking about. We went in a second, I saw what you're talking about uh when you guys were running designing and running uh the extensive uh did uh course and you were like 12 weeks and and and i was like what and then i was looking at it was oh yeah there's there's skill refinement and there's some scaffolding going on here but a lot of it was like the zen socratic can you get out of your own way um right and so the logos can show up right right yeah yeah yeah yeah i mean we had a thing in there right where we were doing like rapid proposals and had like this ham horn that i would put to the microphone right and every 90 seconds you know like you got to drop it and create a new proposal like we would just squeeze them into you know and they had a lot of fun uh they had a lot of fun with it but it allows them to not be precious right to shoot from the hip right so sometimes we create a container like that so you can have that experience that you wouldn't otherwise cultivate for yourself and you come on the other end of it it's like actually that was pretty good that was actually a fairly decent proposal for courage you know and i did it in 90 seconds it didn't take me you know you know you know 20 minutes to do it or something like that and of course you know there can be a lot that comes out of uh you know the additional contemplation the additional rigor that's available there uh through your midwife but uh the 90 second you know quick rapid like just finding the beat of the practice in a way in which you can just sort of shed this stuff and start to have fun with it start to be more in it rather than you know in it up here yeah i just wanted to um pick up something which you kind of like which i want to i want to deliberately bring attention back to it because i don't want it to get lost which is the sense of like the orientation towards service but you're doing that by virtue of showing up and the way that i i I understand that difference is that it's, you know, there is one thing to practice, but it's another thing to be practiced, right?
1:07:18So there's a way in which I've definitely been guilty of like strong manning exercises that I've learned such that, you know, every conversation now becomes, you know, noticing followed by what's that like? And then now I'm going to paraphrase this thing and then that will magically make this conversation better than I've ever had. and I can go away feeling that way. But I definitely have experienced moments of like, kind of going through a conversation, coming out going, there was something different about that. I'm not in a container. Taylor's not here. Maybe it's here. But you know, there's nobody here pulling me along or asking me for shares.
1:07:57But there's something about that which is different. And only in retrospect does it come to that, oh, hey, for some reason I actually cared about, like deeply cared about it. I really could sense my curiosity here, you know, in a way which perhaps wasn't present before. So, you know, it's almost like a Zen Cohen, what you sort of like outlined. And it's actually quite elegant, right? Which is this sense of like, go in, do the practice with the right orientation, come out, keep the orientation, but keep the awareness a little bit of the ways in which that practice might be working in ways that are not here and necessarily conscious but show up in relation when they are necessary, when they're most necessary.
1:08:42And all of that is oriented towards service. Now, I mean, I've said this, but I also have to preface that we are at our time.
1:08:54so you know let's move over to the zoom room um i think uh taylor you have the link to put in the chat um right so but first you know thank you good sir um for allowing us to sort of like see into your world a little bit more the chat's been going um absolutely bonkers which is amazing to see. Now, we're going to have another one of these next week. Same time. Oh, I've always wanted to say this. Same time, same place, right? Like on Sunday. This time, I think we're circling right back around to me and then I'll be at the mercy of both of you. And then we'll be also doing another one and a half hour practice after that.
1:09:35So if you would like to get in, if you are here already, I think you guys are in the Riverside room. Hello, all of you. If you would like to be in on this while this is recorded before it gets produced so you're here live with us and in practice, please sign up for the newsletters, 5 to Midnight, lectern, awaken to meaning. You'll get the same link there just so we can all kind of be together. And yeah, tomorrow, next week will be the last one of these conversations. And then if you would like to train with us or be in our spaces and we can be of service to you in some way, we're doing containers us in toronto we've got la as well um and then maybe a few more i mean we're doing the netherlands but there's no space it's sold out no more um yeah so all the info is available on awaken to meaning uh thank you all very very much and we'll see you all uh in the zoom room yeah yeah well one one one thing uh so copy that uh that link just in case because after you close riverside you're lose the link so cut and paste it somewhere um and then also just as a heads up um please come into the the space uh being able to turn on your camera uh and with a working microphone if if that's not able to work then you got another week to to try to get that set up so that you can do it next week for practice but we will want cameras on uh due to the nature of the practice so anyhow thank you gentlemen this was a blast and i hope to see all of you over in the zoom room in a few minutes.
1:11:04Absolutely fire. Ciao everybody. Bye.
From the publisher
What does it mean for practice to become "really real" - and how does theory help keep that experience honest?
In this episode - the second in a live-recorded three-part series with Taylor Barratt, Ethan Hsieh, and John Vervaeke - the conversation centers on Taylor as he reflects on the movement between practice and theory. Taylor describes how different vocabularies can converge around a shared sense of rightness, how moments of deep practice can feel lucid, beautiful, and more real, and why theory became meaningful for him only after he had spent enough time inside practice for the novelty to settle. John and Taylor compare their opposite trajectories: Taylor moving from practice toward theory, and John from theory into practice. Together with Ethan, they examine collective intelligence, practice design, and the need for mutual correction between theory, practice, and other people. The conversation deepens into the ethical responsibility of facilitation: designing for people not yet in the room, balancing explanation with experience, and learning to bring the whole self without becoming self-involved. Taylor explores how facilitation transfers into parenting, family life, trust, and ordinary relationship, and why facilitator training is not simply about learning structures, but about supervision, mistakes, cleanup, self-leadership, and getting out of your own way. The episode closes on service: the difference between doing a practice and being practiced by it, such that the orientation carries into life when it matters most.
Taylor Barratt is the Director of Practice and Education at the Vervaeke Foundation. He has over a decade of experience in relational leadership through Authentic Relating Toronto.
LinkedIn
X
Ethan Hsieh is the Director of Community Development and Partnerships at the Vervaeke Foundation. He comes from an acting background focused on character development.
LinkedIn
00:00 Welcome to the Lectern
01:30 Introducing Taylor - the second conversation in the series
02:10 John and Taylor's new collaboration
02:20 What stayed alive from the previous conversation
03:00 Different languages, shared truths
04:30 Rightness, right proportion, and right orientation
05:10 Practice, salience, and moments that feel "really real"
06:20 The VIA intensive and following the moment
08:10 Beauty, lucidity, and being carried into reality
09:40 Movement between theory and practice
10:20 Calling, voluntary necessity, and practice
10:40 Taylor's path from software development into authentic relating
11:30 Chaos, ownership, and being more fully oneself
12:00 Why theory became useful only after practice matured
13:00 States, structures, and shadow work
14:40 John's opposite trajectory: theory calling into practice
15:40 Theory as a guard against self-deception
16:20 Collective intelligence and checking our work
17:00 Returning to theory with new eyes
18:30 Practice design as the lab of theory and practice
19:20 Mutual correction between theory, practice, and people
20:30 Designing practices for people not yet in the room
22:00 How do we know we are not fooling ourselves?
24:00 Shared orientation and collective sense-making
27:00 Balancing experience, explanation, and ambiguity
30:00 Maintaining the developmental band of a practice container
33:00 The challenge of leadership in transformational practice
36:00 Practice as something that teaches the facilitator
39:00 When structure supports experience
42:00 What participants need in the moment
45:00 Holding theory lightly while serving the room
48:00 The difficulty of maintaining balance as a facilitator
53:40 Does facilitation transfer into daily life?
54:50 Service, participants, and ethical orientation
56:00 Parenting, co-parenting, and tracking multiple needs
57:00 Bringing authentic relating into family life
58:40 Whole self vs. self-involvement
01:01:20 Getting clear on your "why"
01:02:00 Why facilitator training takes time
01:02:30 Self as instrument in transformation
01:03:20 Self-leadership before influence
01:04:20 Wake up, grow up, clean up, show up
01:05:40 Rapid proposals and learning not to be precious
01:06:40 Orientation toward service
01:07:00 Practicing vs. being practiced
01:08:30 Closing and invitation to the live practice room
01:09:20 Newsletters, future recordings, and upcoming trainings
01:10:20 Practical notes for joining the practice session
The Vervaeke Foundation is committed to advancing the scientific pursuit of wisdom and creating a significant impact on the world. Become a part of our mission.
Join Awaken to Meaning to explore practices that enhance your virtues and foster deeper connections with reality and relationships.
Follow John Vervaeke: Website | Twitter | YouTube | Patreon
Thank you for listening!
