

The episode is a “meta” discussion about why wisdom and the work behind it can be hard to access, and what the hosts are doing to balance epistemic/academic precision with broader accessibility and ethics.
John (the lecturer/creator of the work; emphasizes scientific/philosophical integrity and shareable meaning). Taylor Barrett (practitioner/facilitator focused on everyday relational impact; also discusses neurodiversity and practical barriers). Ethan Say (works on implementation/support systems; focuses on practice pathways, newsletters/teaching assistance, and content organization).
Accessibility is not just lowering cognitive/financial barriers; it also involves scaffolding progression, relational “porousness,” and habit formation. There’s no single solution because students are heterogeneous. Trade-offs are inevitable, so multiple pathways are needed.
pre-framing and reviewing prerequisites in lectern courses; bringing other lecturers onto the lectern; Teaching Assistance Program and live cohort support; shorter public videos and thematic “pathways” through John’s large YouTube catalog; an app with 12 short modules (5–15 minutes/day) including AI “coach” journaling; and a tiered events plan including the “Reframe” festival (June 3–6, 2027, Northern Colorado).
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Exploring the challenge of sharing wisdom with a broader audience.
“But the thing is, is that if we're always reaching for the optimal maximum thing, we leave the rest of the population behind.”
Discussing the dual responsibility of academic work and accessibility.
“This isn't so much about the content of my work.”
Examining the need for multiple approaches to reach diverse audiences.
“sort of step into that, like still speak something that was very much a little bit more accessible, but very still very much an academic lecture course, but on YouTube, right?”
Inviting the audience to share their thoughts and comments.
“We want you to help us, if you can, with some helpful comments.”
Addressing the risks and uncertainties in making wisdom accessible.
“I'll turn it over to Taylor and Ethan, some of your initial thoughts.”
Discussing how vocabulary affects the accessibility of wisdom.
“the vulnerability part of like, it might not work.”
John discusses the progressive nature of education and its accessibility.
“more inroads for people to this work and to your point earlier john around the vocabulary like i I have to say, the fluency of vocabulary is not a prerequisite to your work.”
John reflects on the challenges of teaching complex material while ensuring accessibility for all students.
“And so the problem we often face, for example, on the lectern, we'll introduce a new course.”
Discussion about measures taken to improve student engagement and understanding.
“following this an example of this is it's really tricky trying to get this right balance.”
Exploring various avenues to improve the accessibility of philosophical content.
“But I think, you know, you speaking about the thing about pre-framing and bringing in and summarizing the previous work to help people continue into the progression of your work through the lecture series.”
Plans for reorganizing John’s YouTube content to improve user accessibility and navigation.
“Then there is also the nature of the beast.”
Ideas for releasing sample episodes and creating pathways for different interests.
“such that the work comes in in a way that is relevant to our context today as opposed to being in COVID and people have much more time to really sit down and sit with ideas and digest over a longer period of time.”
Discussion on developing an app aimed at helping people cultivate habits of practice.
“can we sort of create pathways through all the material on the channel, on the lectern, that can probably be multiple pathways organized to this interest or that interest or that interest or that interest.”
Learn about the app designed to enhance clarity and connection in a noisy world.
“So there's going to be all sorts of caveats.”
Discover how AI can enhance the coaching experience while maintaining accessibility.
“So I think that's probably a decent intro.”
Discuss the importance of accessibility and community in practice through the app.
“from the corpus of John's work rather than kind of just going well you know I got a coupon I'll I'll take a chance, you know, I'll see what happens.”
Learn about upcoming retreats and the structure of new transformative events.
“We're talking about we offer intensives right now.”
Discover the specifics of the Reframe Festival including dates, location, and activities.
“I'm glad you remembered to name that because we were talking about it before the video.”
Understand the importance of making transformative practices accessible to diverse participants.
“I know John's been talking about maybe doing something where Christopher Master Pietro retreat.”
Explore the varying levels of engagement and training for intentional relationships and mindfulness.
“I may use the term dysregulating, but sometimes dysregulation is very helpful and can help us learn and grow and sort of stretch and expand what we're capable of.”
Learn about the interconnectedness of various practices and communities within the ecosystem.
“So I think in some ways we've already done it, but I'd like to mitigate it even further.”
Learn about the importance of community feedback in shaping practices and ideas.
“She's going to be my interlocutor in Kyoto about Dogen and the Kyoto School.”
Discover the details of a new six-week program designed to encourage practice.
“Yeah, there is one thing, another thing that I want to sort of name briefly that is actually happening.”
Understand how to lower barriers for participation in philosophical practices.
“So that was one thing that I wanted to mention.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Dr. John Vervaeke, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00But the thing is, is that if we're always reaching for the optimal maximum thing, we leave the rest of the population behind. And that doesn't feel like we're doing justice to the work that we're doing and trying to help sort of bring people up to a potential reframe of how they perceive and act in the world.
0:41Welcome, everybody, to the lecture. I'm here with two people that many of you already recognize, Ethan Say and Taylor Barrett. And this is a little bit different. This is not a discussion about theory and practice per se like you've seen us do. It's not a Silk Road seminar. not a lectern dialogue. This isn't so much about the content of my work. It's an other issue that's been coming up a lot. So I've been meeting a lot of you as we do the intensives and retreats and even talking to some of you virtually. And one of the things that comes up quite frequently among many different kinds of students of my work is something to the effect, I really like your work.
1:26There's a lot in there that speaks to me. It's very resonant. It's been meaningful to me, et cetera. And I'm very grateful for all of that. I'm not in any way being dismissive of that. But often what people do is they'll say, but I find it hard to share with other people. It has an issue of accessibility. Now, we're not sure if that's exactly the right word, but we're going to use that word to sort of point to this problem. And we want to wrestle a bit with this issue of accessibility and also the ethics around accessibility. And along the way, we intend to share a couple of ideas with you that we're having.
2:04So this is kind of weird. This is kind of like a meta discussion we're having here. We're trying to figure out how can we better do this? So some of the initial issues that I struggle with just to get us going, And then I'll, you know, Taylor and Ethan can jump in whenever we want, whenever they want. So I, of course, carry a strong sense of responsibility that pulls me in two different directions. The one sense is I feel a tremendous amount of epistemic responsibility to the work, the scientific, philosophical work, and the work around designing practice. This is often, for lack of a better word, complicated.
2:52It's sophisticated, a lot of argument, a lot of evidence, a lot of reflection, a lot of refinement. I often have to craft new words, neologisms, which some people really hate, other people really like. And by the way, that's a clear example of the very problem I'm facing here. Many people say, what I like most about your work is the vocabulary that you generate for us. You give words and concepts. And what other people say is, what I most hate about Rebecki's work is all this fancy new terms. Why can't he just speak more plainly? And so the one thing is, I care about precision. I care about accuracy.
3:31I care about reliability. I care about integrity. I care about how I'm trying to model the pursuit of conjoining truth-seeking and relevance-seeking together. because it's all about meaning. But on the other hand, you know, I've been making a lot of arguments about that meaning has to be ultimately shareable with others. And of course, I happen to think the issues we're addressing, issues around, you know, meaning, issues around the cultivation of wisdom and how that's lacking in our culture. I happen to think these are very important existential issues. And so I have an ethical responsibility pulling me in the other direction is how can I make this as accessible as possible?
4:18And Awakening from the Meaning Crisis, as some of you might be familiar with, it was an attempt to sort of step into that, like still speak something that was very much a little bit more accessible, but very still very much an academic lecture course, but on YouTube, right? It was supposed to make it more accessible. And ever since I've been wrestling with this issue about how do I meet those two responsibilities. And there's sort of ethical issues, normative issues on both sides. And it comes up frequently among the three of us about things we're doing and what we're attempting to do. And like when we're designing this or designing that or planning this or planning that.
5:00And the intent of this video is to give you access to this so you can participate in Maybe share some helpful, useful comments. Those would be very welcome to this video. And then we'll give you also some ideas we're sort of wrestling with in terms and things we're planning to do to try and get a different kind of balance between accessibility and I'll use two A words, accessibility and sort of accuracy. and my initial proposal is I don't think there's one golden solution to this problem because that would presume something that I think is quite false, that we have a homogeneous body of students following this work.
5:50We do not and we've talked before about how we have people more interested in theory than practice and practice than theory and we're having success and getting them crossing the aisle between those two. And that's been very good. So I think we're going to try multiple ways of trying to balance between accuracy and accessibility. But that's the initial framing and what we're wrestling with. We want you to help us, if you can, with some helpful comments. Please, helpful comments here. If you don't like what we're doing, just leave this video, please. We're sort of being very vulnerable here. And we're trying to be responsive.
6:30And therefore, I think it's important that people be responsible. And we're asking for you to generate some ideas. And we're going to share some ideas we're planning to put into action. So that's enough from me. I don't want to make this a monologue. I'll turn it over to Taylor and Ethan, some of your initial thoughts.
6:55Yeah, yeah, Rob. scissors um actually i noticed i want to pick up a little bit on the vulnerability piece that you mentioned john because it occurs to me that for you and most of the work that you do you tend to sort of you know of course the orientation towards you know science and cognitive science and you often do it sort of in you know in a dialogical you know thing with an interlocutor um although probably your your home base is as a lecturer as an educator and you know of course the academic institution or sort of a framing of education. And I imagine that is, you know, old hat, very comfortable for you.
7:31So I think in some ways, I'm imagining when you name vulnerable, it's also like branching out into areas that are less traveled, but also, you know, it's that question of like, as you say, the thing we're wrestling with, it's like, if we do this, what is lost? There's almost an existential ignorance perhaps here of not quite knowing what's going to happen? What are we going to lose? Like we can, we can intuit it, you know, as we have been doing to hopefully, you know, steer ourselves in the right direction with some of the things that we're working on, but we don't yet quite know in that particular area, I imagine is maybe speaking to the vulnerability part of like, it might not work.
8:13And then the question is, okay, well then what next, you know, but trust that this is an ongoing sort of dialogue within us about how do we sort do this how do we make john's work more accessible how do we reach more people um you know in a slight uh side piece youtube is great in many ways but as we all know it skews heavily male as well so there are all sorts of you know things that often come up how do you know how do we make this more attractive um you know to people who aren't male um and also just sort of this idea of what What other platforms or ways can we sort of get John's stuff out?
8:52And in the way that it's been done is the accessibility thing has been John goes on, you know, a podcast that has a broader reach or isn't necessarily academically focused in the hope that there's something in there that spurs interest or intrigue when John's working with somebody else on their platform. and you know those are usually hour two hour long discussions which that in of itself is often a barrier for some individuals so John could say the most accessible and amazing thing possible but if they're scrolling through YouTube and they see you know an hour and a half video some people just keep scrolling on so in that you know we're kind of breaking out of the way and ways in which you're all sort of used to John delivering his work or us supporting the delivery of John's work and into some other areas.
9:48So that's, I think, the thing I would say about vulnerable or at least what feels vulnerable or I don't know if risky is the right term, but there's some risk here in that it's a less sure thing. And in that, there's a bit of humility like, I don't know, but let's see. Let's see. So that's what I would say, at least at this time.
10:14I think I come in with a little bit of a different angle. Because for me, the question as somebody who has been in training and in systems with people who don't have a vocabulary for what we do, a lot of it is intuitive, a lot of it is magical, a lot of it is you know learn by do and do by feel. I was one of those people who when I encountered awakening from the meaning crisis i was like oh great now i can put words to this and i can trust that they're backed and the question that's been sitting for me over the past i think four four five i think almost six years that we've known each other now um is where does the rubber hit the road like where does the the consumption of material the understanding of ideas actually the land that is important in everyday life and as a practitioner for me that the rubber hits the road in practice and I prefer to use the term an action like it needs to have a way of showing up in the world that is tangible impacts the relationships around and brings meaning in life a little bit more to the forefront however there is also a way which I imagine for some people, perhaps if you're listening to this, part of the place where the world really lands is in recognition, understanding of like, oh, this is what's happening.
11:44For others, it might be declaration, just being able to talk about it with other people and finding a sense of community in that. All of those are great. And I'm very guilty of being one of those people who tries to do everything at once. and I think that's the kind of complexity that sits at the heart of this issue when we talk about accessibility that anytime that we open a door there there's going to be a trade-off somewhere and we're just trying to open the right doors to the right degree in such a way that most people can benefit from this work as much as possible now where is most pressing for me actually is in the relationship aspects of encountering your work John and I've heard this from people who have come into containers and practice with us you know that um primary relationships like with their married with their spouse or or um with their parents or family or close friends there's been feedback that is like oh i kind of don't really get you now or like there's like they've articulated some degree of distance um which is a concern for me when i hear that because i'm going ah but i don't like i really don't want that for me i don't want this work to form a different kind of wall that looks pretty on one side but is impenetrable from the other so i'm trying to constantly try and address this issue on multiple levels like say at the lectern how do we make it not just pedagogically accessible um that people can come in at different levels of education experience discipline um and and get something um but also like financially how do we make it accessible such that people who um who don't have to work an extra job just to pay for a course uh with you or with anybody else that we bring onto the lectern these are very important things that we've tried to scaffold over the years and make um make the bar increasingly like closer to the floor and so i'm really glad that we're talking about this guys because i for me i really feel that this impacts people on a day-to-day basis i see it in my inbox i see it in the zoom calls i see it in practice and i hope that we can kind of get to a place where where that opens up more inroads for people to this work and to your point earlier john around the vocabulary like i I have to say, the fluency of vocabulary is not a prerequisite to your work.
14:18And that's one thing that I found. I'll turn that over to you on that note.
14:25Yeah, so the issue, thank both of you, the issue is a good education is progressive. I don't mean in the political sense. I mean, you're building and you're not just repeating, right? You're building, you're building, you're building, you're building. And that's why we use metaphors like scaffolds and building. And so the problem we often face, for example, on the lectern, we'll introduce a new course. I've been wrestling with this. We did two courses recently that I taught. One of the things, by the way, that we're doing to address this issue of accessibility is have people other than me on the lectern teaching courses.
15:13Like Mark Miller is charismatic, and he has a great capacity to be very accessible. And we're going to do, you know, Charles Stang, and he's very also, he seems to be able to catch fire with a lot of people. His current video, for example, is doing very, very well. So we're doing that. But back to me in particular, the like when we did the course on between east and west where i was trying to sort of this was the initial first in i've talked before about the possibility of zen neoplatonism was the this is the first time where i was trying to think this through with the help of some very gifted authors and some very uh enthusiastic students um and then the the difficulty i faced there was what relationship did that have to the trilogy I had taught Seeing God Again for the first time, part one and two and three.
16:06And then now we're doing a course on the Kyoto School, which overlaps in a significant degree with Zen Neoplatonism. But I can't presume that everybody that's coming into the course has done the courses, but I know that there are people who have done it. And it's a very different thing for me. When I teach a course at the university, I know what the prerequisites are. I know what people have to have done. I know what I can presume when I come in. And I've had a lot of times where I've made mistakes around this. I just jump in and presume because, you know, 30 years, what, 30 whatever years teaching at the university, I fell into that habit.
16:54And some of the students actually pushed back and said, I don't know what you're talking about. And I realized, and so like, this seems like trivial, but now I try and make sure that I'm not presuming. I try to explain any term I'm using, even if I've taught about it before. I do a preview of what's coming in the lecture, a review of the previous lecture, and a summation of what we did in that lecture as a way of trying to address the concerns of students who have come in and said, like, I'm this is my first introduction to your work. And so it's it's it's it's it's been I mean, sorry, I'm not asking for sympathy.
17:39I have a responsibility and I'm trying to meet it. I'm trying to give you everybody who's following this an example of this is it's really tricky trying to get this right balance. I mean, I'm under no illusions. Whenever you educate, you can't teach everybody. There's always going to be some people that it doesn't land for. But on the other hand, I think it's reasonable to believe right now that we could make this material more accessible while still respecting all the pedagogical needs and my integrity as a teacher, as a scientist, as a philosopher. But I just want to give a concrete example and then how I've been trying to modify that.
18:28Ethan has done some important modifications around the newsletter that have addressed concerns we've received about accessibility issues from the newsletter. I don't know if you want to speak to that or not, Ethan. Well, there's not just that. There's also the teaching assistance program. So there's also the ability for people to go into sort of the catalog of the previous years of lectures and have somebody there to work with in a live environment on the material, which is not a thing that is scalable for John to do. But it's us bringing Ethan in, who's obviously very familiar with John's work, very capable, as well as a facilitator, to come – I mean, Ethan, you should be talking about this – but to come into that environment and to help a small cohort of people who are chewing on John's lecture course and also bring it into a relational sort of thing to help reinforce that learning, like actually creating a kind of a type of practice in the group dialogue.
19:30So I think that's another huge thing that we've actually done, even though I don't know we framed it so much as accessibility. But I think that's very much what I imagine it's doing at that already higher level. Right. I mean, there's obviously everything below that before, you know, somebody signs up for a lecture course. But I think, you know, you speaking about the thing about pre-framing and bringing in and summarizing the previous work to help people continue into the progression of your work through the lecture series. But then there's also, how do we go back for the next group of people who are turned on to your work and also help them through that progression a little bit more actively?
20:11That's a very good point, Keller. Ethan? Yeah, I also want to address that it's not just TAP, it's not just the newsletters, it's not just the other lecturers that are coming on to the lectern, but also folks like Christopher Machopietro writing the books for Awakening to the Meaning Crisis. I've gotten a chance to speak with folks that were working on adapting things like Isai Spinoza's God into a book. So there are so many avenues at which I think we're trying to address the issue of accessibility through different mediums in different ways as much as we can. now I think there's also a big elephant in the room which is John you have a very big YouTube channel and I'm not talking here about followers I'm not here talking about subscribers or views I'm literally talking about like the amount of stuff the amount of content that is on that thing is insane and because it goes all the way from you know I think Voices with Vaveki had like like 200 over episodes even 300 maybe right um and i've been talking to uh ben our producer who sort of works on on all of these things behind the scenes around like excellent excellent producer by the way yeah yeah excellent it's like how do we um how do we almost like soft reboot uh the the channel how do we organize it in such a way that if somebody comes in clicks on john bavish his YouTube channel is like, oh, here are the things that I know that I can find are relevant to what I'm trying to look at right now, what I'm really interested in.
22:00Then there is also the nature of the beast. And nature of the beast is that the work that we're doing all the way from the research level up to the teaching level is complexifying in real time because there is hot stuff coming in. like mark talks about the research being live um that he's doing and say the predictive processing frameworks right um something that you may have talked about just last year has now developed a new shift right about like six to nine months in you know from that point and it's that in in that there is a kind of tension of okay how do we stay you know um relevant to what's actually at the forefront right now, what the conversation is in the zeitgeist right now, but how do I also catch up on the conversation that has been happening up to this point such that I know why that's relevant, right?
22:57So, you know, there is a process of curation that is happening at the moment, which is to say, okay, what if we started from here, from this point, what is it that people need to know about your work such that they can just get started, put it into practice, find that personal relevance, that piece of weaving it in, not just propositionally, but also participatorily in a regular basis like habit forming, such that the work comes in in a way that is relevant to our context today as opposed to being in COVID and people have much more time to really sit down and sit with ideas and digest over a longer period of time.
23:46So, yeah, maybe we can talk a little bit about some of the ways that we're trying to address this already, perhaps more detail. Sure. A couple of things we're thinking about doing. So I'm not making any promises right now. I'm talking about things we're thinking about doing. We're thinking about releasing on the public side of things the first episode of some of the lectern courses. So people could get a peek to what it looks like inside a lectern course. And we get it. Some of you will look at that and say, I'm not interested in that. That's fine. But again, we're trying to get a way in which we can provide more avenues.
24:32As Ethan said, there's a large project of, can we sort of create pathways through all the material on the channel, on the lectern, that can probably be multiple pathways organized to this interest or that interest or that interest or that interest. Like, I'm really interested in the science. I'm really interested in the religious side of it. I'm really interested in meaning. I'm really interested in wisdom. I'm really interested in the relationship between theory and practice. I'm really interested in the stuff about Zen Neoplaton. We've got to try and organize it thematically and progressively so that people have better access to it.
25:20Ethan has proposed to me, and we've just done a discussion that I might do some shorter videos, like 20 minutes long or so, as overviews of certain important themes. So that's another thing we're considering doing. I think I'd like to move to another thing we're in the midst of doing, and it's probably the one we've wrestled with a lot most recently, because it has some very important concerns attached to it. And so So we've been working with Studio to create an app for access to my work. And I'm going to let Taylor and Ethan describe what it is. And then we'll address some potential concerns just again to show you how just it's never just let's do X.
26:12It's always trade off, trade off. What's like? So who wants to introduce it first? Tanner, maybe we start with you and then Ethan, you can add some stuff. Sure. Yeah. So again, you know, this is the context of everything we're talking about, sort of the accessibility piece. So John's speaking a lot about the lectern and this presupposes that people are coming in with a particular interest or love of philosophy, you know, academic propositional thinking, that sort of thing, and want to wrestle with ideas. Not everybody wants to do that. And yet there's a benefit to John's work, to the things that are being talked about, to, you know, plugging into the idea of there being a meaning crisis and reframing the way in which we perceive or act in the world.
26:59And another way of doing that is, you know, again, is to offload John. We can't, you know, box up John and put him in every context and turn the dial up or down on complexity. So how do we sort of take that and do that? And one way is through an app. So the way this was introduced to us was like a coaching app. And we sort of thought like, well, you know, John's not really a coach. That doesn't really make sense. But as we looked more and more into what they were offering, we saw this as an opportunity for people to help people build a habit of practice. Because that's really, you know, for me also, practitioner facilitator, facilitate, that's primarily what I do.
27:36Ethan's somewhere in the middle, and of course, John Moore. We all facilitate, but that's sort of the back orientation. And that's sort of the thing is, how do you engage people into this? And again, lowering the barrier of entry, how can they do it on their own as well? So of course, there's all sorts of caveats about just doing single individual practice on your own, et cetera, et cetera. So there's going to be all sorts of caveats. But the thing is, is that if we're always reaching for the optimal maximum thing, we leave the rest of the population behind. And that doesn't feel like we're doing justice to the work that we're doing and trying to help sort of bring people up to a potential reframe of how they perceive and act in the world.
28:26So the framing for this app is around finding clarity and connection in a noisy world. So for those of you familiar with John's work, you can obviously see, you know, it's a slight linguistic reframing, but we're really speaking to, you know, how does one engage, you know, while experiencing sort of this meaning crisis that John's, of course, talked about for a number of years. and it has i don't remember how many modules are in it 12 i want to say i think it's 12 modules yeah so there's 12 modules and they're all sort of broken down into different you know sort of things you know different pair of glasses to put put on as you progress again you know the teaching and being progressive and this is the same thing with practice being progressive um and it's it's something that you can do in like anywhere between five to 15 minutes a day so each week as you go into one of these modules, John's is there to introduce and set a framing like he would for, you know, any particular idea or argument that he has.
29:27And then there's a practice and, you know, something for you to sort of do in the moment, you know, timed and stuff like that. And then you can also type in what the impact or what you notice might be different around, you know, now having done the practice. But then other pieces as well is just also, again, using John's work, looking at the framing, you know, additional framing that's maybe not in the video. And this, you know, this will shift each day as you do the practice, as you sort of respond to what's happening for you in the practice or what you're noticing or what you're even struggling with in the practice.
29:59And this information carries forward into the next day while you're still working under this particular module. So there's a certain degree of customization that's there, which actually happens even before you get to the first day of the first module is, you know, what, you know, there's various questions. I don't remember exactly all the questions on them in front of me, but what has you interested in this? What are you wrestling the most with, you know, sort of a multiple choice thing? And you fill that in five minutes and it starts to customize the course to the things that you're struggling with and what you're interested, but it's all still framed within John's work, as well as this idea of building up a habit of practice.
30:40so this this whole idea is that hopefully at the end of these 12 weeks you've got a strong habit of practice you've looked at these various ideas that that you know john has introduced that are you know less you know um you know they're not at an academic level but of course you can graduate up to that go you know check out the the massive youtube library that's there join the lecture the lectern and stuff like that but within the app we're really just hoping to help create a bit of a shift for individuals that is backed by John's work, backed by these perspectives of the meaning crisis, backed by the four Ps, relevance, realization, all this stuff, but just delivered in a much more accessible sort of general public.
31:25I don't have an interest in academic, rigorous argumentation. I don't have necessarily a philosophical, an interest in philosophy. I'm just looking for how to find clarity and connection in a noisy world. And we're really hoping that this, you know, speaks to people such that as they engage in it, they start to take on and notice some of the framing and, you know, implicitly John's argumentation. And this starts to engage people more in this way of looking at or perceiving the world. So I think that's probably a decent intro. I think one piece though that's probably important for us to discuss is there is an AI element to it.
32:11And the AI element of it is under the frame of the coach, which again, there's sort of this thing. I think if you ask, I don't know this for sure, but I would intuit that if you ask the three of us, ideally, what we would want to see people do when it comes to a coach is to hire an individual, work with somebody one-on-one, in building up a relationship with somebody, whether that's business coaching, life coaching, that sort of thing. However, going back to the accessibility thing, depending on who you're talking to in a coaching role, it's anywhere from a hundred to several hundred dollars an hour to interact with somebody based on things that you're noticing and experiencing through your practice through your day and getting some feedback.
32:55The thing that we've built, it's less than$5 a week to engage in. And it's still very much like a coach as you sort of do your debrief at the end of the day. So one thing that I'm always sort of encouraging people to do that's a very low barrier of entry is journaling. And that's actually kind of baked into the app such at the end of the day, you know, it gives you a few boxes to type into in terms of like, well, oh, what did you notice as you move throughout your day around the quality of connection you had with each person? And you can just sort of type in there, which is one sort of journaling and accountability for you that helps land your day's experience.
33:31You know, there's plenty of, I'm sure John could talk at length about, you know, the science behind something like that. But then the thing is, is that where the AI bit of it really helps is it actually takes that and it brings the framing your experiences into the next day. And that's a thing that we couldn't do with like a flat based sort of application. We can't cover all. This is actually where a large language model can be particularly useful. And it also comes with normal caveats, which we're very much aware of and wanted to try to address as we're building it to limit some of the things, some of the, you know, some of the things that John has been, you know, arguing for or against in terms of AI, things that I share, I'm sure Ethan shares as well, of these concerns so we spent a fair bit of time trying to you know lock down that thing so it doesn't do the things that we see that makes us all cringe and concerned for the future of him so i think i'll leave it there i've probably said enough um but uh yeah anything that maybe i've missed about the app but functionally that's how it works fair bit of time uh i i take i i take issue with that sentence it was unfair on my bio clock i was like up till two o 'clock in the morning um as we were talking through actually like well what is the ethical way to um home this particular component um within the app and actually now that i sort of look back on it it's like it's actually a very small portion um the the big part of it which i think is what excites me more than anything is that there is a pedagogical program laid out within the 12 modules.
35:17It introduces very key ideas. One of the great things that I was just mentioning earlier that the work complexifies, that's great. But in the course of that complexification, we also can look back and understand like, oh, what actually stayed? What actually is really solid, you know, as a theoretical framework, as a foundation? And we can tap on that. And those are the things that are coming into the modules, more front and center. So you'll be introduced to four piece of knowing, you'll be introduced to relevance realization, you'll be introduced to the dime framework as well. So the progression of the videos will take you through that and then bring it together and so the last one third, the last four modules or so.
36:04It's also important to note that John and I challenged ourselves that each video had to be sub 10 minutes. so you know in terms of like total watch time is something like you know 100 120 minutes max um over 12 weeks the whole over yeah over 12 yeah yeah yeah yeah um and you know i remember sort of like being in those sessions and trying to record those videos with you john that like what was coming up for me really uh as i suppose the the experience that i've heard from people trying to take the work into practice is that if we try and go from like awakening from the meaning crisis into building a habit it's actually quite a large jump like from that side of it it can feel like oh yeah that's doable but actually to to to sort of make it a daily thing by yourself without like group practice without um forming a like a kind of watch party uh that's interested in this material right that is building secure relationships so you have a strong partner that's willing to sort of sit with you and go through this stuff right it can feel pretty hard now having said that there some people whom i've met who have really dived in fully um and in getting to know like a number of these folks sometimes they show up for tap or drop me an email and i'll have a conversation there is a real like um wrestling with oh i i really enjoy this work and i wish that i could share what was so good about it with other people there is a desire to be with others in that too there's a kind of desire for a kind of community or a sense of belonging.
37:56And at the same time, it's hard to just drop into a room full of strangers and do something completely novel with no promise that anything will come out of it that will last beyond that two-hour or three-hour session. So I think one of the benefits about having an app like this is that you can start getting those training wheels on like you can at least start getting used to the motions like oh okay you know I have a daily meditation practice or I have a meditation I have a journaling practice meditation practice I move I can start to find places like a contact improv group in my neighborhood or something like that but you go in with the framing that comes from the corpus of John's work rather than kind of just going well you know I got a coupon I'll I'll take a chance, you know, I'll see what happens.
38:51You can go in kind of like set and ready to notice something new about it that you might not have had you just gone in somewhat randomly. So this is, I think, something that I hope when we talk about accessibility is not just about an exchange of resources, whether it's cognitive load or finances, but it's also about a sense of like porousness and openness. How do you go through something with an orientation, with a sense of building a commitment or building a habit at the end of the day? Yeah. And one thing that came up for me while you're speaking to that, Ethan, that actually hadn't occurred to me before, but one actual benefit of the idea of using an app and the way in which it's structured and sort of guided.
39:39and you know I say this with my wife as well as my daughter both having ADHD is in some ways that offloads the executive functioning such the only thing I have to remember is to open the app each day or at least follow the prompts when they come and that actually make it very easy for you to start building a habit whereas if you generally have to rely on your own sort of memory that these things might not come into play so there's actually a way in which for the thing that some of us find really annoying, you know, looking at our smartphone and getting way too many notifications. They actually set this up consciously, you know, around the idea of building up a habit of practice.
40:14There's a way in which the app affords something that nothing else that we're doing can. Everything else that we're doing, you know, requires you to say, oh, I want to join that workshop and I'm going to do a three-hour workshop. Or, you know, for some people, again, you know, the framing of ADHD, I'm sure this extends to other neurodiversions as well, but it can be very hard to sit through an hour, two hour, three hour long discussion, there will be a certain degree of overwhelm of ideas into how do you start to parse the note. So again, it's sort of this dissemination, simplification, shorter videos, guided thing, five to 15 minutes a day.
40:50Actually, I think we should really speak to a certain demographic of people, regardless of whether or not they're even interested. Like maybe you had people who were really interested in philosophy and they've got interested in it because they had a really good teacher. And the teacher helped keep them engaged, but it's very hard for them outside of that environment to be engaged. This actually offers an opportunity to sort of help continue that love and interest in a much more structured thing that does not rely on you having a great handle on executive functioning. So actually, unintended sort of benefit here, I think, in having this structure is very much present.
41:33And I'm actually somewhat delighted to actually notice that because I think that actually really speaks to what I imagine is a quite serious need. And again, okay, yes, not financial, not just complexity, but also in terms of structure as well. Yeah. Thank you, my friends. That was very helpful. I'd like to move on now to another thing we're considering around accessibility. We're talking about we offer intensives right now. And that word is intended. You know, Tiamat, you know, and this is for people who really want to go full in and do very, you know, very challenge, like challenge themselves to very significant transformation.
42:20And we, of course, believe that this is, you know, a very important thing for people to have access to, because I think a lot of the transformations we are facing, both individually and collectively, are quite serious in their demand that they will place on us. But I've also had some experience, and Taylor and Ethan also have, of offering retreats, which are a little, like quite a bit less intense, a little bit more of what it might be like to do some practices and live with people, you know, for, you know, three or four days or maybe over a weekend and get a sense of just, oh, being in a practice community, kind of like a dojo and getting some practices, right?
43:11But not like not where you're going to be sort of pushed to your limit or something like that. So we're working on, you know, designing retreats. And then we have even a layer of accessibility below that. The idea of like a festival where people can come in and they can dabble in some practices and they can see some talks and they can meet different groups. And so we're also planning, again, to try to create more of a tiered structure in terms of venues of practice, as you might put it. So, you know, intensive. No, no. I want to like I want to really I want to really consider a very significant and profound transformation retreat.
43:58I want to be exposed to the possibility of transformation festival. I'm curious about all of this stuff about practice and transformation. And so we're trying to also design all of those. And I'll let maybe we'll go to Taylor and then Ethan on that. Yeah, thanks, John. I'm glad you remembered to name that because we were talking about it before the video. So one thing is actually happening. So it's not like, yes, we're in planning stages, but we have a date we have a venue um like it's happening and that's uh the festival which we call reframe so reframe is happening next year uh in 2027 june 3rd to 6 up in northern colorado at a at a retreat center called uh drawla mountain it's a it's a buddhist uh retreat center sort of community um and that is the thing that we are doing um they have a lodging they have different pricing tiers, you know, in terms of sort of, you know, needing support, you know, the flat rate, help subsidizing the other ticket costs.
45:07This is a pricing structure that we haven't used in the past. So that's sort of a thing that's new for us, as well as just this environment to sort of choose your own adventure, you know, in nature, you know, Northern Colorado. I mean, I used to live in Colorado. It's beautiful there. And it gives you sort of this opportunity while we don't have anything necessarily yet specifically for you know how you spend your time in nature it's just more or less going for walks but you can sort of you know again speaking to the intensive versus the retreat restorative sort of thing is that you go into an intensive we got like a 10 12 hour day bang bang bang bang like it's it's it's a lot it's an intensive that's the name of it with the the festival you sort of have this choose your own adventure scene come in for the lecture and if you want, go for a walk, you know, hang out or talk to other people, you know, just in an impromptu sort of discussion about that lecture or move over to one of the several practice sessions that will be there where we'll be myself and Ethan and others at Rick Repetti.
46:06Folks will be there to sort of help, you know, introduce you to certain types of practices, the potential that exists within the practices. Maybe you do that. Maybe you go have lunch and maybe you take the afternoon off, right? So it's sort of this idea of coming together in sort of a broader sense community around these ideas, around philosophy, spirituality, practice, and coming together in a beautiful environment with maybe people that you have some sort of interest in and sort of starting to engage into this idea of what I've been mentioning before, sort of reframing one's you know relationship or awareness of how they're uh relating to themselves others in the world so that thing's happening june 3rd to the 6th of next year i'll be there too by the way yeah well yeah sorry yeah yeah john will bring it yeah and you can get information for that at reframe festival.com so there's that and then john and myself uh you know and and you I'm sure Ethan will become a part of it over time.
47:12We've been talking about retreats. I know John's been talking about maybe doing something where Christopher Master Pietro retreat. I don't know where that's at, so I don't want to speak too much to it. But again, sort of this idea of something in the middle, right? Where it's just like, okay, I'm a yes to this, but I don't have 10 months. We just did a 10-month TM at X. We're almost done. We're a couple of weeks away from closing that out. That's a 10-month commitment. Not everybody can do that. It's great if you can. And if you're a yes to that, but again, accessibility, some people can't do that.
47:43So something more in the middle that starts to open you up, you get a sense of sort of what it's like to be in residence with people, sort of separating yourself from the outside world and the distractions that are there to really immerse yourself in practice. And, you know, I've been running, I mean, I haven't run, well, we ran something last year that's a bit like that, but it wasn't a residential one. It was sort of a three and a half day thing. But of course, we had a lot of key facilitators. The price tag on that was pretty high. So we're trying to look for something that's a little bit more financially accessible.
48:16But also just that idea of maybe a three-day weekend where you only have to take a day off work. And because it's more restorative, more oriented around wellness, that when you're coming, you can just go back to work. You don't need a long integration period. Now, one would hope and expect that there's still a lot that you're working on and that's salient for you. but it's not so challenging such as to be, I may use the term dysregulating, but sometimes dysregulation is very helpful and can help us learn and grow and sort of stretch and expand what we're capable of. But in the retreat sort of environment, that would be like, you could hop back into the work and work the next day.
48:58It's not a big deal. And again, John will be there for these. such as you can engage with them in this type of environment through the practices that the three of us, as well as others, have been a part of developing, and we're continuing to develop new practices as well. So that's, yeah, that's sort of where we're at with the retreats and, of course, next year's festival, which would be excellent if it could become an annual thing, because we've got lots of ideas about what we do with that, if it gets sufficient sort of participation. Ethan, anything you'd like to add? Yeah, I mean, in contrast, I'm not much of a retreat kind of guy.
49:41I'm much more of an advanced kind of guy. Like I'm a bit more hardcore in that sense. So, you know, I can speak a little bit to the training orientation. And when we're thinking about like Tiamat, I think in the past, the way that I've done it was just sort of like offered these intense things for folks to come in but over the past year especially Taylor and I have talked at length of well you know there are different kinds of people some people really just want the experience of what it is to be more intentional about relationships be more intentional about mindfulness right and getting a sense of hey what's possible out there and then there are folks who are for some reason or other already feel called to like no i want to invest my my life and my intentions into affording transformation for others and you know of course that starts from oneself like how do i get to know the principles and processes that underline my own transformation and then be able to afford that for others is a responsible progression and think that's where the more training um comes in where tm has found the proper home it's that if you really want to be more you know skills focused and get good it's like that's that's kind of where again put your feet to the fire a little bit and of course taylor and john will be there as well right um have been will be have been yes and that extends itself you know not just across like uh tier met tier one tier two tier three right but also into a facilitation training kind of program right which is how do you build leadership um capabilities in yourself afford it in other people um and that has a much more i think a high bar of intensity not everybody wants that not everybody wants to go do that so people want to stay at home and you know well and there's been a caveat that you and I have been talking about too, in terms of how we structure things over at ATM, because I know this in the past from, you know, all the work that I did in Authentic Relating Toronto, and we see a little bit of it, a bit less so.
51:56So I think in some ways we've already done it, but I'd like to mitigate it even further. Some people are like, yes, like they're, they're into John's work. They've seen Ethan talk about something, whether it's T-MAT-X or whatever, and they're like, oh my God, I want to do something with these guys. And then the thing we offer is a intense training container and they say yes um and it's like like it's just whoa right so having sort of a tear down for those like we're wanting you know when it comes to training we're looking more for the people who are like oh yeah like you know they're they're a 10 out of 10 right like i want to do this you know typically referred to this as an f yes you know um we want more of people in that because that actually helps the cohort and everything else move much more quickly because there's a shared particular context.
52:43One of the beauties for me of this past year is working with this group of guys who've been training a group of, in an organization in Los Angeles who work with men who are, you know, struggling, failure to launch, you know, dual diagnosis, you know, like just the meaning crisis for young men right now. And I've been working with this group and it's just so rewarding and satisfying to work with them because they have such a shared context and shared intention such that we just like we're really flying when it comes to the training so i'm wanting to see a little bit more of that when it comes into tiamat as people who are really like let's go um and and try to mitigate the number of people who sort of overextend themselves because like i want to do something and it's you know i'm going to get some practice and then it potentially being you know uh you know a tad much for them um and therefore like okay so you're maybe not ready at that level yet so do a retreat you know like come in so sort of again that progression um such that we're uh we're helping that we've got a place for everybody and everybody in their place i guess very platonic yeah to play devil's avocado a little bit um there is something to be said here for there is a ecosystem that we're building at this point and it is completely viable for somebody to download the studio app you know and then attend the reframe festival wow look at all of these different schools of thought right ideas workshops you know come on to atm do some practice uh while taking a course on the lectern and then eventually get turned on to hey you know maybe i want to take this seriously um and then go do tier map for the next you know couple of years whatever that progression is that is a roadmap that very much can exist but the thing that i feel cautious of and this is the avocado bit is you know it's not a closed system right so it's the the ecosystem that we have here needs to be in relationship with other lineages, traditions, communities of practice that still exist.
54:56We are a part of a larger system. And one of the things which, you know, I was really glad to see, I don't know if you all got in your emails, but because we got to meet with Nicole Barden when we were in Prague last month now. Yes, that was August. She gratefully, graciously, sorry, graciously of which we are grateful, extended invites to all of us, including the Spire aspirants to join in the newest course on the Dharma Academy. And then they've all been enrolled and can take that course. So that there is an exchange of practice and philosophy with other communities of practice like Nicole's at Dharma Academy running on Black Forest.
55:45Yeah, and she actually did between East and West, the course on Zen Neoplatonism and gave me some very encouraging feedback on that. And she has agreed. And we're starting to actually plan it. She's going to be part of the Philosophical Silk Road. She's going to be my interlocutor in Kyoto about Dogen and the Kyoto School. So, yeah, Ethan, you know, we're trying as best we can to make a lot of these connections to various communities. Yeah. I think that's everything I thought we had on our agenda to address. In a minute, I'll ask if Taylor and Ethan have anything more they want to say. I just want to, again, encourage you, if you have any helpful ideas, how we might finesse this balance that we're trying to do and structure it and scaffold it, please put them in the comments.
56:52We will read these comments, again, under the caveat that you're coming in in good faith. If you come in in good faith, we will look at them. We won't obviously be able to because of the medium to respond to you, but we do take things if they're offered in good faith seriously. And I would look forward to, we have no illusions that we are complete or exhausted in what we're doing. As we're trying to present this to you, it's like, this is what we're trying. This is what we're trying to do. And then these are some ideas we're having and these are some plans we've made. But I invite participation in helping us because the more we hear from you, and your participation might be, I really like the idea of a festival or I really like tap.
57:40And that's great. Appreciate that too. If anything really landed for you, let us know. Like we're really making an appeal here. We're trying to get a feedback, a sense of, you know, how we can better address this very important issue. That's probably all I'll have to say, other than I'll close things out, but I'll let Taylor and Ethan, any last things they want to say. Yeah, there is one thing, another thing that I want to sort of name briefly that is actually happening. And again, I think it speaks very much to the context of accessibility that we've had. So over on Awaken to Meaning, which is sort of the online practice platform, you know, that we sort of also refer to as a dojo.
58:28we have developed a new course because we've been talking about you know how do we sort of encourage people who are doing things on the lectern to come into practice you know on a repeated thing that's not like a huge heavy lift again sort of speaking to a 10-month program and so what we have is a six-month program that on completion gives you access to a year's worth of weekly practice you know one to two sessions a month or six weeks sorry six weeks six weeks did i say six months bro sorry six weeks six weeks six weeks starting at mid-october um and the idea here is it's less of a uh it's an implicit training you know when you're in practice you're always implicitly training but it's not it is a uh it is a practice sort of course that introduces you to an ecology of practices so this is something that we were doing on atm a couple years ago, we ran the Verveke Foundation Ecology of Practices, which was a daily practice for about an hour and a half across a number of the practices we did as well as some authentic relating.
59:32And this was fairly successful. We had a number of, but there was a sustainability issue with, in terms of the finances of it and the facilitation resources we had and everything else. And we didn't really have a thing once you did that, what it sort of pointed to. it. So we sort of shuttered that and went back more to the training thing. And now we're, you know, sort of the training is going to continue to happen. We're pulling back from it and revisiting, you know, how do we have accessible, you know, practice again, that building up a habit of practice, but going deeper, deeper than you're going to get out of say the app.
1:00:05But something like I can commit a couple hours a week, you know, to doing this, to, to sort of staying fresh, to sort of reengaging with a group of people. So we introduce you to all of these various. So again, sort of introducing you in the six weeks to the idea of the potential of practice. And then the barrier of entry is gone in that now you have access to a year's worth of practice, which of course at the end you could re-up and continue to join and be in this community of practice with people. So we've got that. It's already launched. I don't know when you'll be viewing this, but we start middle of October and we plan to run these quarterly.
1:00:44So this is another thing that we're trying to do to help people get into and stay into practice, provide them a structure and something that's hopefully more financially available for somebody to practice over a long period of time. So that was one thing that I wanted to mention. Yeah, just speaking again to our consideration and of course, as Ethan names sort of the ecosystem, system such that hopefully we people find a place for themselves within the ecosystem that allows them to engage into this work that's aiding the process of sort of reframe breaking and frame making so Ethan I'm not sure that I have actually that much to add because I think the barriers to entry are always going to be of a different combination for different folks.
1:01:40I know that some folks who come onto the lectern have never done practice before and so you know bringing the the barrier down on practice right to be able to move a lot of the knowledge that they already hold into a different form is going to be very very different from somebody who has come in from a lot of practice and is just starting to get to know like okay what's the argument here what do you mean by philosophy of science right like oh and taking a different spin on it so as far as i'm concerned i really really hope that all of the different kind of gateways that were opening at different angles for whatever that reason is removes moves whatever was in the way at least to some degree such that it might open a different angle of looking at something or being in a particular way that then cascades throughout the rest of the of the system and in your life so I would just you know want to want to encourage folks to like maybe try something else within the ecosystem that were you know named here and then see what that might bring you now.
1:02:58Thank you, my friends. This has been excellent. Thank you, all of you who have stuck with this. I would appreciate it. This is us reaching out, trying to marshal the collective intelligence of distributed cognition to help us better basically serve the task of trying to help people address some of the pertinent issues that we're wrestling with individually and collectively. So thank you everyone for your time and attention. Thank you, Ethan. Thank you, Taylor.
1:03:44Thank you.
How do you make deep philosophical and transformative work accessible to more people without sacrificing the precision, rigor, and depth that make it meaningful in the first place?
John Vervaeke, with Ethan Hsieh and Taylor Barratt, discusses recurring feedback that his work is meaningful but hard to share, and the ethical tension between precision and epistemic responsibility on one side and making ideas broadly shareable on the other. They describe practical steps already taken or planned: clearer scaffolding in Lectern courses, additional instructors, a teaching-assistance program, adapting content into books, new pathways through the large YouTube catalog, and shorter thematic overview videos.
They also introduce a 12-module Studio app built around a 5–15 minute daily practice habit, with an AI "coach" designed with ethical constraints, to translate key ideas (the four Ps, relevance realization, DIME) into accessible practice. Finally, they outline a tiered practice ecosystem of intensives, retreats, and the Reframe Festival (June 3–6, 2027, Colorado), plus a six-week Awaken to Meaning practice course, and invite good-faith audience feedback.
Together, they explore:
00:00 Why Accessibility Matters
00:30 Welcome and Video Purpose
02:00 Accuracy vs Accessibility Tension
07:00 Taylor on Vulnerability and Reach
10:00 Practice and Relationship Impacts
13:26 "How do we make it accessible such that people who don't have to work an extra job just to be able to pay for a course?"
14:30 Progressive Teaching and Prereqs
20:00 Multiple Mediums and Channel Overload
24:00 New Access Pathways and Shorter Videos
26:00 Introducing the Practice App
28:30 App Modules and Daily Habit Design
32:00 AI Coach Feature and Ethics
34:30 Ethan on Pedagogy and Core Ideas
36:30 Habit Gap After Insight
38:00 App as Training Wheels
39:30 ADHD Friendly Structure
42:00 Tiered Practice Pathways
44:30 Reframe Festival Details
47:00 Retreats Between Intensives
49:30 Hardcore Training Track
54:00 Ecosystem Not Closed
56:30 Feedback and Next Steps
58:00 Six Week Practice Gateway
01:01:30 Final Encouragement and Thanks
Resources
Find Clarity and Connection in a Noisy World App
Teaching Assistance Program (TAP)
Reframe Festival from Awaken to Meaning
Relational Ecology Program (REP) on Awaken to Meaning
Explore courses and teachings from The Lectern
Support the Lectern and join a growing community of wisdom seekers on Patreon
Follow John Vervaeke: Website | Twitter | YouTube | Patreon
Thank you for listening!



