In short
Podcast Summary: Empire Episode 338 - *Chairman Mao: Birth of A Dictator (Ep 1)*
Podcast and Episode Overview Podcast Title: Empire Episode Title: 338. Chairman Mao: Birth of A Dictator (Ep 1) Hosts: William Dalrymple and Anita Anand Guest: Rana Mitter, Professor of US-Asia Relations at Harvard University Episode Description: This episode explores the life of Mao Zedong, a pivotal figure in modern Chinese history, viewed as both a revolutionary hero and a brutal despot. The discussion delves into Mao's early life, his upbringing, and the societal context that shaped him into the leader he would become.
Key Themes and Discussions
Early Life of Mao Zedong
- Background: Born in 1893 in Hunan province, Mao disliked Confucian traditions and had a tumultuous relationship with his father, whom he described as overbearing. His mother was depicted as gentle and devout.
- Education: Mao was a self-taught individual who read broadly, moving away from his rural roots to pursue education in Changsha. He showed an early interest in literature and revolutionary thought.
- Societal Context: The episode discusses China in 1893, highlighting the Qing dynasty's struggles and foreign colonization, which fostered a sense of urgency for reform among Chinese intellectuals.
Mao's Ideological Development
- Influences: Mao was influenced by various philosophical and political movements, including social Darwinism and European revolutionary ideas. He developed a vision for societal reform that included a critique of traditional Confucian values.
- Revolutionary Sentiment: The discussion covers the emergence of the May 4th Movement in 1919, a pivotal moment in Chinese history where students protested against imperialism and sought to redefine China's future.
Character Examination
- Personality Traits: The hosts and guest analyze Mao's complex personality, noting his mixture of intelligence and ambition. His rejection of traditional values and desire for change are emphasized.
- Cult of Personality: The episode touches on Mao's iconic status, exploring how his image has been both revered and condemned in contemporary discussions.
Critical Events Leading to the Rise of Mao
- Cultural Shifts: The episode outlines the sociopolitical upheaval in early 20th-century China, including the Boxer Rebellion and the end of the Qing dynasty. The failure of the imperial system to modernize contributed to widespread disillusionment.
- Transition to Leadership: The narrative sets the stage for Mao's emergence as a leader within the nascent Chinese Communist Party, underscoring the critical relationships he forged during his time in Beijing, particularly with key figures like Li Da Zhao and Chen Duxiu.
Conclusion and Next Steps
- The episode concludes by preparing the audience for the next installment, which will explore Mao's rise within the Chinese Communist Party and the effective actions he took to consolidate power.
Key Takeaways
- Mao's Dual Legacy: The episode emphasizes the dual nature of Mao's legacy as both a revolutionary leader who aimed to modernize China and a dictator responsible for immense suffering.
- Historical Context: Understanding Mao's rise requires a grasp of the historical and cultural context of early 20th-century China, including the impact of foreign powers and internal strife.
- Thematic Continuity: The conversations highlight themes of power, identity, and transformation, which are relevant not only to Mao's story but to broader discussions about leadership and revolution in history.
For a more comprehensive exploration, listeners are encouraged to join the Empire Club for access to the full series on Chairman Mao.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOMao's Iconic Status
2:54 to 4:01
Explore Mao's iconic image and public perception in China.
“So Mao is one of those faces that was so iconic and so everywhere.”
The Cult of Personality
4:01 to 6:36
Discuss the cult of personality surrounding Mao Zedong during his rule.
“So he's a capacious figure in terms of that iconography.”
Mao's Childhood and Background
6:36 to 8:16
Learn about Mao's upbringing and its influence on his later life.
“is something that you don't necessarily get quite, well, you certainly don't get it at all in that period of his lifetime, which is Mao's universality, but ironically.”
China in 1893: A Crisis
8:16 to 12:20
Understand the political landscape in China during Mao's birth year.
“biography by Joseph Terrigian from the Hoover Institute.”
Colonial Powers and China
12:20 to 14:01
Explore the impact of foreign colonial powers on China in the late 19th century.
“1893 is a moment in the midst of what probably counts as the greatest crisis of modern Chinese history.”
Mao's Early Influences and Family Dynamics
14:01 to 17:40
Explore how Mao's relationship with his parents shaped his worldview.
“be sliced up like a melon and become a lost country at one war?”
Education and Intellectual Development
17:41 to 20:40
Learn about Mao's education and how it influenced his rebellious mindset.
“He's thrilled to see landlords toppled and humiliated and this sort of thing.”
Mao's Stance on Arranged Marriages
20:41 to 24:28
Understand Mao's radical views on marriage and societal norms.
“I think it comes in his quest to move to the next phase when it comes to education.”
China's Political Climate in the Early 20th Century
26:51 to 28:02
Gain insight into the political upheaval and societal changes in early 1900s China.
“We've been following Mao from his rural background through his first marriage, his fight with his father and his escape from his village.”
China's Turbulent Early 20th Century
28:02 to 31:42
Learn about the socio-political upheaval in China leading to the republic.
“And not only are the rebels defeated, but the Chinese court is forced to pay huge indemnities, you know, taxes, basically, in punishment for having encouraged these peasant rebels.”
Show all 16 chapters
Mao's Formative Years Amid Change
31:42 to 36:29
Discover Mao's early life and his burgeoning revolutionary thoughts.
“And instead, hello to a new formation, the Chinese Republic.”
The Shift to Modern Education
36:29 to 40:07
Explore the transformation of the education system in early Republican China.
“And that is writing that has a social Darwinist trend to it.”
The May 4th Movement Introduction
40:07 to 41:51
Understand the significance of the May 4th Movement in shaping Chinese nationalism.
“There was often actually quite a lot of martial training as well.”
The May 4th Movement and Its Impact
42:00 to 43:59
Learn about the origins and significance of the May 4th Movement in China.
“The end of the 19-teens is yet another turbulent time in Chinese political history.”
Mao's Early Years in Beijing
44:00 to 46:19
Explore Mao's experiences and influential encounters during his early years in Beijing.
“It is being eaten away by imperialism from outside.”
The Foundations of Communist Ideology
46:20 to 47:10
Discover how Mao was introduced to communist ideology and its future implications.
“Li Da Zhao was the head librarian of Peking University, so technically Mao's boss.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00William:If you want access to bonus episodes, reading lists for every series of Empire, a chat community, discounts for all the books mentioned in the week's podcast, add free listening, and a weekly newsletter, sign up to Empire Club at www.empirepoduk .com. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. Stop waiting around for the perfect candidate.
0:25Anita:Instead, use Indeed Sponsored Jobs to find the right people with the right skills fast. It's a simple way to make sure your listing is the first candidate C. According to Indeed data, sponsored jobs have four times more applicants than non-sponsored jobs. So go build your dream team today with Indeed.
0:41William:Get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. The best part of waking up? A full cup of Folgers coffee and music on full blast.
1:00With a big smile on my face.
1:02William:The moment I wake up. Oh, my, oh, my.
1:08Anita:The best part of waking up is Folgers in your cup.
1:14William:Shop Folgers K-Cup Pods and more at your nearest retailer. Let's be real. Whether you're filming for TikTok, YouTube, or that one client who thinks viral means vertical, you don't have time to dig for decent stock. Storyblocks gives you unlimited royalty-free video, audio, and templates that actually look good. Just drag, drop, done. Go to storyblocks.com slash explore, search the library, and see what you've been missing.
1:49Anita:Hello and welcome to Empire with me, Anita Arnand.
1:53William:And me, William Durrumpel. And today we are launching a brand new six-part series, exploring the life of one of the most influential, but also one of the most controversial figures in human history, Mao Zedong. He's a figure of titanic proportion. Some hail him as a revolutionary hero who restored China to its rightful place on the global stage and lifted millions out of poverty. But he's also condemned as someone who killed more civilians than Hitler or Stalin, a brutal despot who built a revolutionary one-party state.
2:26Anita:To take us through this extraordinary story of an extraordinary man, we are very lucky to have Rana Mitha with us, S.T. Lee, Professor of US-Asia Relations at Harvard University. He is the leading expert on China and has written numerous books on this, including Forgotten Ally, China's World War II, and Modern China, a very short introduction, which, let me tell you, is now in its, count them, third edition. Thank you so much for being with us.
2:53Rana Mitter:Lovely to be here with you, Anita, and you, Willie.
2:56Anita:So Mao is one of those faces that was so iconic and so everywhere. You know, Warhol got his hands on it. He was on T-shirts. He was on magnets. He was on badges. He was all over the place. And I just wondered, sort of in China, the iconography was very much of this sort of red sun, that he was almost divine. The people of China were the sunflowers all looking up to this great broad face of Chairman Mao. Tell us a little bit about actually the true story and how much did Chinese people know of the real story of Mao?
3:29Rana Mitter:Anita, you're absolutely right that Mao is perhaps one of the very few figures in certainly modern Chinese history, maybe the only one, who gets that adjective, which is overused, but in this case is probably correct, which is iconic. I think, you know, the Warhol portrait that you mentioned is probably one good example of that. And the fact that his name was used often in a, you know, pretty loose and ropey kind of way from everyone from Paris students rioting in the streets in 1968 to the actually murderous insurgent group, the Shining Path in Peru back in the 1990s. They all tipped the hat to Mao.
4:03Rana Mitter:So he's a capacious figure in terms of that iconography. And the irony is that in some ways, in China itself, both during his lifetime and in the present day, there's much more restriction in terms of how he's perceived and what you can say about it. we're going to talk about him in much more detail over the course of the next few episodes but to put it it's most simple i'd say that during his period in power it became essentially taboo almost impossible to argue that there could have been any pathway to ultimate power other than through mao now doesn't quite make him a religious figure but it's not far off in other words when the communist party started off and we'll talk about that too there were plenty of other people who probably could have risen to the top.
4:50Rana Mitter:And if Mao dropped dead one day, then they probably would have done. What Mao did during his lifetime was to create a cult of personality, as you said, the broad phase, the image of the shining sun, that suggested, in quite a Marxist style, that this was a historical inevitability. Now, fast forward to the present day. We're, you know, more than half a century after Mao's death. And it's certainly fair to say that Mao is not regarded today with the kind of cult-like status that he had in, say, the Cultural Revolution. But it is fair to say that you still have to tread very carefully in terms of what you say about Mao.
5:23Rana Mitter:On the one hand, he's one of the very few figures who there's been some official grudging condemnation of the Cultural Revolution under his rule. But broadly speaking, he still has a pretty sacred status. And therefore, what people know about him today is more historically informed than it would have been 50 years ago, but still leaves out a lot of the more dubious parts.
5:42Anita:Do you still, if you go to China today, do you still see those epic portraits, you know, the side of billboards or...
5:49William:Oh, the Tiananmen Square sitting out over the central...
5:52Anita:Yeah, with Mao's face on it. Is he still ubiquitous? At least his face ubiquitous in China.
5:58Rana Mitter:Well, his face is certainly, as Willie says, very much there on that big portrait in Tiananmen Square, right in the literal and political heart of Beijing. And as far as I know, it's not going anywhere. So that's there. He's also on all the banknotes. That's less relevant now because you may have gathered China is one of the most cashless societies in the world. So the number of occasions you'd actually have to get out a red 100 renminbi bill with Mao's face on it is more limited, but he's still there. So in other words, he certainly hasn't been cast into outer darkness by any means. One element, though, of ubiquity, it's probably not ubiquitous in the sense that everyone would have had their little red books back in the 1960s, but certainly pervasiveness is something that you don't necessarily get quite, well, you certainly don't get it at all in that period of his lifetime, which is Mao's universality, but ironically.
6:45Rana Mitter:Because, of course, he's now seen as someone who, of course, was, you say, central to the founding of the People's Republic of China. But at the same time, because so many people went through the horrors of the Cultural Revolution, and because, of course, he has been in his sarcophagus in the mausoleum in the center of Tiananmen Square now for more than half a century, You do get, you know, daring artists who now and then will do the Warhol thing and try and at least sort of playfully put out the image of Mao as something that you can question and play with. But you have to be careful. Even now, that could still be politically dangerous.
7:20William:It's still difficult to criticize Mao. And an example of that is, I think, Paul Yung Chang, who we've got on a bonus episode coming up, who has had her life made very difficult, including getting into India recently because of her criticism. of Mao.
7:36Rana Mitter:Oh, I didn't know about India. Gosh, that's very worrying to hear. I mean, certainly having read actually her most recent book, which is called Fly Wild Swans. It's a sort of sequel to the famous Wild Swans book. She does talk there about how she sort of could still get in and out of China relatively okay after publishing Wild Swans, which became a sort of international bestseller. But after she published her Mao book, that made things much more difficult. So yeah, you know, there are people who are known as the Chinese expression is a bit snappier. It's sort the Hong Ar-Dai, Hong San-Dai, the second and third generation Reds.
8:08Rana Mitter:In other words, children of those who were kind of leadership. I mean, Xi Jinping is a Hong Ar-Dai, you might say. He's a second generation Red because his father, Xi Jung-Xun, subject to actually a fantastic new biography by Joseph Terrigian from the Hoover Institute. And this is, you know, just one example of someone who basically was born into the party and, you know, carried on the legacy. There are plenty more of them and they regard the memory of Mao as very, very important to keep quite sacred.
8:36Anita:Can we talk about the man, you know, rather than the myth? Because, you know, he must have had a birth and a childhood and what was it actually and what do we know for sure about it?
8:46Rana Mitter:Oh, we do know quite a lot. I mean, he was born in 1893. I mean, I think that's not contested. It's also not contested that he was born in Shahran, a, well, people often say village, I mean, sort of perhaps large village, small town, certainly small town these days out in the countryside of Hunan. And for those who don't know so much about the interior of China, Hunan is a very distinctive place then and now. It has a sort of reputation that say, somewhere like Bengal, Hunan is associated with spicy food. People say often spicy food, spicy personalities. A lot of revolutionaries come from Hunan.
9:23Rana Mitter:Also very thick, distinctive accent. It was often said that Mao, particularly in his later days, partly when we now know he was beginning to suffer from AMS and there were other problems, would speak. At least some of his Politburo colleagues allegedly couldn't understand what he said because his accent was so thick and so strong.
9:40William:What would be the equivalent in an English accent? Would it be Liverpudlian or what would it be?
9:44Anita:Well, I mean, yeah, would it be sort of smart or yokel? I mean, what would people regard it as?
9:50Rana Mitter:Well, I would say that I have friends from Glasgow who would argue that listening to a very posh, upmarket, southern English voice is not only very difficult to understand, but very offensive. So, you know, there are people who might take it in different sorts of directions. I mean, I think it's not an uncommon place thing in a lot of countries that people from one place think that they have the natural accent. I think Hunanese would point out that they have, you know, the best accent going. And then everyone else is fitting into them. But I think it's fair to say that people who study northern Chinese Mandarin, standard Mandarin Chinese, do find southerners like Hunanese perhaps not as easy to understand.
10:29Rana Mitter:But you could argue that's the fault of the northerners rather than the southerners. I should add as a very quick addition that when I was doing doctoral research many, many years ago in the northeast of China, and it used to be known as Manchuria in the frozen north, they would always show me there that they spoke the purest Chinese of anyone in the country.
10:45Anita:Okay, but was he born in this, you know, the legend of the mud hut in poverty and he rises up from, you know, the paddy fields?
10:53Rana Mitter:Not poverty, no.
10:55Anita:No? So tell us what was it? Okay.
10:57Rana Mitter:No, no, no, actually quite prosperous. One of the things that you actually find with revolutionaries in general, I mean, I'm now sort of caricaturing wildly, but all the same, is that they do quite often come from, you know, quite middle class backgrounds. Lenin certainly did. So in the case of Mao, he didn't come from a bourgeois background. He was a peasant, but his father, well, put it this way, he, I think in later years, when he got very obsessed with the classification of different classes and struggle with each other, would have classified his own father, who he hated, as a rich peasant.
11:29Rana Mitter:And so this is someone who owns a certain amount of land, who has access to it, and is able to kind of cash crop a bit. I mean, there are different definitions, but basically Mao did not grow up in poverty. He grew up in highly acrimonious circumstances because he said he adored his mother, hated his father, you know, read your own Freudian messages into all of that. He didn't lack education. I mean, he was an autodidact, but there were opportunities clearly for him to learn. And that wouldn't be the case if he was a genuinely illiterate, impoverished peasant. So yes, peasant background, but no, not a mud hut with him sort of hard scrabbling for survival.
12:05Rana Mitter:This was someone who had reasonably tolerable material conditions when he was growing up in the countryside.
12:11William:And Rana, paint us a picture of China in 1893. The Qing dynasty is facing a terminal crisis. It looks like the mandate of heaven has been taken from them. Paint us a portrait.
12:25Rana Mitter:1893 is a moment in the midst of what probably counts as the greatest crisis of modern Chinese history. And goodness knows, China has had an awful lot of those. But the reason I say that is that essentially it marks a low point from China's point of view in what had become an increasingly urgent series of incursions, invasions, occupations of parts of China. They start essentially in the late 1830s, early 1840s with the famous Opium Wars.
12:57William:And we had those on our pod last year. We had a 10-part series. Yes.
Read the full transcript
13:03Rana Mitter:So you basically have a dynasty that has the doors of China smashed open through the force of industrialized capitalist empire. You know, the British Empire is able to bring semi-ironclad warships to the coast of the south of China near Guangzhou, Canton, as it was known then. And against the wooden shipping of the Qing dynasty, this was, you know, really no contest. And very quickly, China had to sign a series of what became known as unequal treaties, which had lost for nearly a century till, you know, World War II, in which essentially foreigners, the British, the French, the Americans, Japanese, Russians would all be given preferential treatment on trade, on partial immunity from, you know, prosecution, all sorts of privileges that were forced from the Chinese, not given willingly.
13:51Rana Mitter:And so very quickly, China's young intellectuals, their thinkers, their ruling class, began to feel a sense of existential panic. Could the China that they had known be, in a rather evocative phrase of the era, be sliced up like a melon and become a lost country at one war? Although Mao himself was only born in 1893, the debates over how China could reform and become strong and push back were very, very active at the time. Some people looked at Japan, the Meiji Restoration, when Japanese in the same position push back hard against the West, but also modernize very, very fast. And many people looked at Japan at that point in China and said, well, Japan has always been the sort of little brother to our big brother, but maybe we should learn from them.
14:36William:How much of the Chinese coast was occupied by foreign colonial powers at this point, 1893?
14:43Rana Mitter:Very little of it was occupied in the sense that India was, you know, fully colonized, partly because it was difficult and expensive to do that. And it turned out that it was much better from the point of view of Western empires to have the Chinese empire stay in power and run things, but add concessions where needed. So the main colonial possession was Hong Kong. That was ceded in 1842, the island of Hong Kong. Famously in 1898, when Mao was five years old, an extra slice known as the New Territories, a big slice actually, was added. And since that was on a 99-year lease, that ended up, leading up to what we now think of as the Hong Kong handover back in 1997.
15:20Rana Mitter:But in those days, His 99 years, I think, was thought of as like forever. You know, there was no thought that the empire in which the sun never set would eventually sunset.
15:29Anita:Getting back to the man himself. I mean, you said he hated his dad and he loved his mum, which sort of seems to be a familiar story of despots. Stalin, much the same, hated his father, could have killed him very happily. What was the problem here? What was his father like? What was his father doing to make him so unhappy?
15:46Rana Mitter:We only really know Mao's father through the accounts of the son, which obviously by definition are biased. The story seemed to be that he was overbearing, not only overbearing to Mao, but also to his wife. And that this, I mean, in Mao's own telling, this essentially inspired the kind of thinking about a need for an overturning of society that would eventually, of course, become revolutionary communist thought. we'll get in time to how the sort of feelings of rage and anxiety and anger turned into an actual ideological worldview but at this point thinking of Mao as a child as what we now call a teenager I think needs to be understood in the context of his father being this very very overbearing very domineering kind of character and I think you're right that in the case of other you know authoritarian dictator figures that pattern seems to be one that you find over and over again.
16:38Anita:Was he brutal? Because, you know, the problem Stalin had with his dad is that his dad used to beat up his mum and he used to beat him up.
16:44Rana Mitter:I think we do have a sense that it was a violent household. I mean, it wouldn't have been unusual for fathers to beat their children anyway at that time in many societies. But certainly, I think the idea that in the peasant countryside of China at that stage, that doesn't seem entirely surprising. Although, of course, one of the many traumas that no doubt shaped the Mao that we would know later. I think it is relevant to think about that because one of the things that characterizes Mao's thought throughout his life is reactions to violence. And there's a strange contradiction, really, in that he both, you know, seeks to talk about violence and coercion as something that must be resisted, but also glorifies it.
17:28Rana Mitter:You know, he talks frequently when he writes this down about how actually the transformative value of violence is something that can remake society. And the ultimate, of course, expression of that was the Cultural Revolution.
17:40William:Absolutely. He's thrilled to see landlords toppled and humiliated and this sort of thing. There's a genuine excitement in the writing.
17:47Rana Mitter:This is part, of course, of the wider way in which revolutionary movements developed during that time. You can also find it in Russia. You know, Lenin is also a great advocate of terror as a tactic. But I think it's worth noting that although the violence that Mao feels and sees in his childhood, both at home and around him, clearly shapes his sense of what his political project is going to be, he doesn't reject violence. If you want to kind of contrast him and Mahatma Gandhi and two more contrasting characters in some ways you could hardly think of, that might be one of the major differences between them.
18:19William:Tell me about his mother, a Buddhist, gentle, devout, bound feet, all those things.
18:25Rana Mitter:These are amongst the things that are reported. But again, we don't have, as unsurprisingly, much of a sense of her from herself. And so much of the report that we have is about Mao, particularly years later, he would tell these stories amongst others to Edgar Snow, the American communist journalist who would sort of create the mythical Mao that we know. And in some ways, just as much writing about China for a Western audience sort of adapts things into ways that will seem comprehensible, I think that this may be in that category. There's no reason to think that she wasn't gentle and kind. But the idea that I had a violent father and a wonderful mother is something that actually, again, sits in a sort of set of tropes as well.
19:09Rana Mitter:It's worth noting, by the way, you know, there are other figures in Chinese history, Confucius, to name one, who had missing, in his case, a missing father and was largely brought up by his mother. And that's part of the mythology of Confucius as well.
19:21Anita:What do we know of his education? I mean, you mentioned Confucius. I guess he would have been steeped in Confucian literature.
19:27Rana Mitter:From what we can gather, he would have had what was probably typical for a reasonably educated son from a rich rural background. And being in the countryside didn't necessarily mean you're illiterate if you had money and access to education. And we certainly know from his later life where he actually became quite a skilled writer of classical Chinese poetry, that he certainly had training in the Chinese classics. He also told stories about when he was at that sort of age, but he loved reading the kind of classic romantic novels of the Chinese tradition, The Water Margin, Outlaws of the Marsh, Tale of the Three Kingdoms.
20:00Rana Mitter:And I think that's also part of what makes his mindset, the idea of himself as a kind of rebellious leader on horseback, leading a fight back on behalf of the poor. Those novels, which are written in a kind of form of readable classical Chinese, I think in the form that he would have read them, very much sit in that tradition. So we know he was able to absorb and understand those.
20:20Anita:You mentioned those Edgar Snow interviews and he sort of describes himself, I think, in those interviews as, you know, being hungry for knowledge. I think this is a phrase that he himself uses about himself, a buffalo charging into a vegetable garden. I love that. He was hungry, you know, wanted to lap everything up and came from that background. At what point do we see him sort of breaking out of that model of boys his age from his background and showing himself to be something a bit special?
20:48Rana Mitter:I think it comes in his quest to move to the next phase when it comes to education. And again, that may be a product of what we understand to be this kind of huge anger with his father when he leaves home. But moving from Xiaoshan and then heading up not to Beijing immediately, but to the biggest provincial city in Hunan, Changsha.
21:11William:Abandoning already a first wife in the process.
21:14Rana Mitter:So it seems, I mean, again, this is one of the things where we have, you know, kind of limited background. But we know that actually, again, there's something about Chinese leaders and first wives. Chiang Kai-shek, who became his sort of deadly rival through much 20th century, also had a first wife, who was then abandoned and made way for, I think, at least two more before finally marrying Song Mei-ling. So being betrothed to a girl, a child, really, out in the countryside at that stage was still not particularly unusual. We are, at that point, beginning to move out of the phase, thankfully, when such girls would have had bound feet, which, of course, is one of the things that marked most Han Chinese girls, both from high and low level families during that time.
21:59Rana Mitter:But in terms of marriage, it was still very traditional. Of course, one of the ways that we know that in your phrase, Anita, that he was sort of moving away from convention to something a bit more than that was when he gets up to Changsha and starts studying and writing and reading, railing in anger against traditional arranged marriages, not his own, but other ones that came up at that time became part of his core brand.
22:24Anita:The first wife, you know, she's not even given a name really, is she? Woman Luo is what she's referred to. Luo. Yeah, thank you for the pronunciation. But it was, I think, you know, from what he said later on or didn't say, it was a way of his father trying to control him. You know, as a 14-year-old boy saying, you know, settle down, you rebellious little git. And, you know, we'll have control over you because you'll be married and you'll be...
22:49William:Says the mother of a 14-year-old. 15. 15.
22:53Anita:let it all out an easier is that i would not inflict that boy he's lovely i love my life but
22:58Rana Mitter:to marry him off bloody hell god no good god give him a few decades he'll be fine um yeah i mean i think all of that is true i think it's worth noting though how prevalent traditional marriage would have been in the countryside at that point in other words i'm not necessarily convinced that what was happening to Mao at that point was unusual. What was unusual was his very strong reaction to it and decision for, you know, a variety of reasons that, again, we'll talk more about, that he was going to take a different sort of path. So the wonder, in a sense, that point is that there was someone who was willing to actually do something different rather than necessarily what we would now rightly, I think, regard as being, you know, deeply patriarchal, deeply controlling set of acts from society at that time.
23:45Anita:Yeah, I mean, some of the things he said, Rana, I mean, are so powerful when he talks about arranged marriage and coming out against arranged marriage, you know, saying things like Chinese parents are all the time indirectly raping their children. It's strong stuff.
24:00Rana Mitter:This comes from one of his most famous, actually, sets of writings. It's called On the Suicide of Miss Zhao, but actually there's a series of other essays that are sort of follow-ons from that iconic classic essay that people who read Mao's early works certainly get to this essay. It's about a young woman who'd taken her own life rather than be placed in this arranged marriage, which really was a forced marriage rather than just an arranged marriage. And Mao wrote, as you say, in this absolutely devastating manner about how this symbolized the wider oppressiveness of Chinese society at that time.
24:34Rana Mitter:And you're right, he uses this phrase, he says, we all know what rape is, but essentially by forcing these marriages, Chinese parents indirectly are causing the rape of their daughters. You know, compared to what would have been the very hierarchical, Confucian way of thinking about marriage, which of course is not just a relationship, you know, a romantic relationship between one man and one woman, but part of a huge network and hierarchy of family relationships, this was, you know, sacrilegious indeed.
25:03William:We're going to take a break now. After the break, we're going to ask Rana to pan out to the crumbling of the Qing dynasty.
25:17William:When you want your spring break to feel like... And your kid's pool day to feel like... And your hotel bed to feel like... Ooh, and room service to feel like... Because at Hilton, hospitality feels like...
25:37Anita:Your cabana's ready. Would you like fresh towels?
25:38William:It matters where you stay. Book now at Hilton.com. Hilton, for this day. We're leaving today and entering a world of Mickey Mouse waving, princess meeting and greeting, lightsaber clashing, the Twilight Zone Tower of Terror dropping, Banshee flying, Space Mountain launching, galaxy rewinding, what is the moon that looks galaxy rewinding, Fireworks igniting World of Other Worlds For whatever you love Infinite worlds await at the most magical place on earth Walt Disney World Resort AI is incredible It can teach you how to fry an egg And even write a poem Pirate style But it knows nothing about your work Slackbot is different
26:30Rana Mitter:It doesn't just know the facts It knows your schedule It can turn a brainstorm into a brief And it doesn't need to be taught. Because Slackbot isn't just another AI. It's AI that knows your work as well as you do. Visit slack.com forward slash meet Slackbot to learn more.
26:51William:Welcome back. We've been following Mao from his rural background through his first marriage, his fight with his father and his escape from his village. Rana, pan out a little bit and show us what's happening around, what, 1900, 1911, that sort of time. What's happening in the wider China?
27:13Rana Mitter:China is in the early 20th century on the brink of an earthquake. But at that stage, you are still feeling the tremors. The actual collapse hasn't yet happened. So it is a decade where one has to sort of summarize briefly because there's so much. you to want all the detail that you couldn't fit it all in. A bit like our own decade, I would say, actually, Willie and Anita. But first of all, you know, as the new century opens, 1900, there's a devastating war, the Boxer Uprising, the Boxer War, which basically is a peasant uprising, which tries to kill Chinese Christians and missionaries. The dynasty under the basically ruled from behind the scenes by the Dowager Empress Tzu-shi, quite a character in her own right, fails to kick out the foreigners.
27:59Rana Mitter:And with long fingernails, amongst other things, too, Basically, it goes horribly wrong. And not only are the rebels defeated, but the Chinese court is forced to pay huge indemnities, you know, taxes, basically, in punishment for having encouraged these peasant rebels. So the China that limps into the first decade of the 20th century is, amongst other things, deeply indebted. And that's one of the factors that tips things over the edge. Nonetheless, for a brief period, a little bit like those who know Russian history, where there's a sort of brief period of constitutional reform at about the same period before things kind of tip over the edge.
28:32William:1905, yeah.
28:33Rana Mitter:First of all, 1902 is when a series of reforms called the New Government reforms are put in. Now, spoiler alert, they don't succeed. But the reason I mention them is that they point towards what could have been a very different China. A China that if there had been a slow but steady introduction, as the reformers proposed, of constitutional government voting, regional assemblies, then China could have turned into a constitutional monarchy like Japan or indeed like Germany or even Britain, which were some of the sources to draw on for that. So that's the direction it was going in those years. And it's one of the reasons why people thought even if there were tremors beneath the surface, they could be dealt with.
29:12Rana Mitter:But you mentioned 1905, which of course was the year of the liberal revolution in Russia. It's also the year that there is an educational and bureaucratic earthquake. in China. It's the very last year that students are able to take the traditional bureaucratic examination, which for a thousand years since the Song Dynasty... That ends in 1905. 1905 sees the abolition of more than a thousand years of the system of bureaucratic entry through classical examination into the bureaucracy of China, making way for a new system of modern languages, science and so forth. And that moment of the ending of this, you know, millennium plus of Chinese traditional bureaucracy is, you know, organizationally an earthquake.
29:58Rana Mitter:But also one of the things that creates seismic tremors, there's a whole bunch of people who spent their lives studying for these exams, who suddenly find themselves, you know, cast out, there's no longer a bureaucracy of that sort into which to insert themselves. And it creates yet another constituency of people who have no vested interest in the imperial system continuing.
30:16Anita:They've done everything right from their point of view. I mean, it's sort of almost, you know, like in India, when you suddenly had reservation of jobs, where you had people sort of saying, hang on a minute, I've done everything right. This is meant to be my super highway into my future, and you've just taken it away from me. And so you have a lot of cheesed off intellectuals.
30:35Rana Mitter:Yeah. And that's not a good thing for any regime to have running around, because intellectuals who are underemployed get ideas about changing things. And eventually, things come to a head in the year 1911. Now, nobody expects them to. It's not sort of foretold or foreseen in that sense. But basically, a small local rebellion and a garrison in the city of Wuhan, which has since become much more famous because of COVID, but was actually a kind of very longstanding and important port city in China for centuries. A local garrison rebellion there between sort of soldiers just sort of suddenly explodes, not just in uh wuhan but actually city by city province by province and within the space of a few months what seems to be the you know re-stabilized reforming dynasty of a type that's existed for you know 2 000 years suddenly finds itself on the verge of collapse and it is by the end of that year the moment when the five-year-old boy emperor famously you know immortalized in Lucci's film, The Last Emperor, is confronted by a warlord, a man named Yuan Shikai, and told that basically he's going to have to step off the throne and it's curtains for the Chinese empire.
31:42Rana Mitter:And instead, hello to a new formation, the Chinese Republic.
31:46Anita:So you've got all of this change happening. You have talk of, you know, changing the system and revolution. Is Mao immediately swept up in all of that?
31:55Rana Mitter:Yes, I mean, he's still very involved in education and study and, you know, revolutionary work in Changsha and in Hunan. This is still, you know, the home province from his point of view. But he's beginning to see not only the way in which the overturning of the old regime creates all sorts of new possibilities, but also begins to develop the sense of disillusionment that many young men and women, both of them, began to feel at this particular point. So bearing in mind that when the revolution happens, when the imperial system falls, you know, never to be resurrected, he's 16 years old. So it's, you know, an exciting time, a perilous time.
32:37Rana Mitter:He's still very young. He develops a thought at this point, and we don't know exactly when, but it's clear that it must have been around this sort of time, that actually even Changshai, even Hunan province isn't big enough for him. And he really needs to get to the heart of the action. And that, of course, from the point of view of any ambitious, young, would-be revolutionary thinker, is to go to the capital city to get to Beijing.
33:00Anita:So is it at this point that he decides that he's going to make a physical change in himself? Because, you know, from what I understand, that he and his friends, you know, they have that traditional pigtail, the queue, am I saying it right? And they both sort of do this thing of, you know, symbolically just hacking it off, that the past is the past. our attachment to the Qing dynasty, we're cutting that off too, because this is a very new different tomorrow.
33:25Rana Mitter:That's right. The Q, I mean, that's the way the sort of the braided hair at the back was a symbol that the Manchu dynasty, so the Qing dynasty was run by ethnic Manchus, insisted that men of the majority Han ethnicity should wear such a braid, you know, essentially as a sort of marker. And for a while, cutting off your Q was regarded rightly as a very dangerous act. I mean, you think about, say, women who don't wear head coverings in Iran today, a sort of similar sort of thing by your behavioral choice. Cutting off your cue became important as a symbolic moment of leaving the imperial past behind.
34:01Rana Mitter:But also, this wider sense was still there that the revolution was unfinished, that by changing your dress and your behavior, you could symbolize your connection to the new world. So for instance, people started making, you know, wearing new types of clothes, something that's sometimes called the Mao suit. That actually starts as a Sun Yat-sen suit because Sun Yat-sen, as the man who briefly becomes president of China for a few months after the revolution, wears such a suit. And following him, following that kind of clean-cut revolutionary look, becomes part of defining yourself through dress and appearance as someone who has indeed cut off your queue and instead is going modern and revolutionary.
34:42William:So Mao has cut off his queue. What's he up to? drifting around, starting and finishing stuff, right? He goes to soap-making school at one point, as well as police school and law school. Why?
34:55Rana Mitter:I think probably the soap period is a relatively limited part of the, after all.
35:01William:Not what he glorifies in his later writings.
35:04Rana Mitter:Well, no, you shouldn't downgrade these things. After all, the founder of one of the most influential religions in the world, I believe, used to make furniture at various points with his father. So, you know, the carpenter background is good for some. Anyway, I think it's fair to say that, yes, Mao is still sort of bouncing around a bit, full of ideas, full of, you know, to use what's called a cliche word in our era, but I'll use in this case, passion of one sort of other. Probably actually in the 18th century, he has these sort of strong feelings, but not necessarily a sense of direction to where to go.
35:34Rana Mitter:You know, if it's a sort of enlightenment battle between rationality and romantic, you know, kind of revolt, then he's very much on the romantic revolt side. He wants to be a big person, be a big deal, but he's not sure what about yet. Just remember, though, he's still very young. You know, he doesn't turn 20 until the year 1913. So, you know, he's still in the aftermath of this revolution, making his way through Hunan. And he's reading, huh? He's reading a lot. He is, you know, he used this metaphor of the buffalo who makes his way into the grass patch and devours everything. Yes, he's an utter autodidact.
36:12Rana Mitter:I mean, we know that some of his earliest writings that we have are very much around, you know, European writers who've been in translation. They're there from the late Chinggivisty, who he absorbs. But there's one particular strand that he begins to develop at this time. And because it precedes his communist convictions, his Marxist convictions, it comes before that, it's worth noting. And that is writing that has a social Darwinist trend to it. this idea that, again, emerged from 19th century Britain, that races or peoples were in competition with each other for survival of the fittest as biological species were.
36:51Rana Mitter:I mean, for the avoidance of doubt, it's regarded as pseudo-biological claptrap in the present day. But in those days, actually in East Asia in particular, in Japan and China, a social Darwinist view of how races and nations would compete with each other was very popular. And it was very literalistic in some ways. The idea that the body personal and the body politic were links, which is one of the reasons that when you look at Mao's earliest writings from this time, they're not about Marxism or anything at all. They're about personal hygiene and personal exercise. In other words, you have to keep your own body fit and strong as a means of building up the body politic.
37:28Anita:But is he also reading sort of the Western thinkers like Adam Smith or John Stuart Mill or, you know, those, does he get his hands on that kind of thing as well?
37:38Rana Mitter:It's difficult to know exactly because he's reading eclectically and we don't necessarily have notes from the earliest, but there are now actually English translations of the very earliest writings of Mao and they become more detailed as time goes on. We do know about the social Darwinist partly because, not his very first, but one of the first things that he writes is literally a personal exercise plan. So if you want to kind of get fit the Mao way, you can look up his guide and basically see it. A lot of it involves sort of thrusting up and down and sort of touching the buttocks at various points.
38:05Rana Mitter:We won't go into huge detail, but people can look it up for themselves if they want to. And that fits into this idea very much of there being a kind of physical element to national renewal. He wasn't the only one. Again, bearing in mind that other young men in particular who were beginning to sort of follow this path, like Tsai Khosun, who would also become sort of founder member of the party, he took a different path with this sort of social socialist idea. He felt he should harden his body by exposing it to the elements. So he would walk around Beijing in the middle of winter, which is very, very cold, just wearing a thin shirt and therefore had sort of asthma for most of his revolutionary career.
38:41Rana Mitter:You can see similar things, actually, I would say, in parts of Sheffield late at night in November and December, but not necessarily for revolutionary purposes in that particular case, though, who knows? So there was a very literalistic take on many of these sort of social Darwinist ideas. And Mao certainly seems to absorb them in a very enthusiastic manner. So he's a voracious student of many different schools of thought at this point.
39:06Anita:But then at some point in 1913, he goes from being student to wanting to be a teacher. And he ends up in teacher training college. Tell us a little bit about that aspect.
39:17Rana Mitter:Yes. I mean, he goes to what in China is, it's an English term, but it's actually used, I think, more commonly in translation in China these days to a normal college, which is actually normal in the sense of teacher training. I mean, he's clearly got in his mind at this stage the idea that there's going to be a revolution transformation and that education will be a large part of this. And he wants to sort of make sure that there is this sort of shift in terms of wider mindsets in society as a whole. So we have to assume at that time that he's, you know, reading widely, I'm guessing in modern studies, you know.
39:49Rana Mitter:He was never a linguist, unlike some of his contemporaries at that time. But certainly, you know, thinking about science and scientific change are these things that were very, very much part of the teacher training establishment. Bearing in mind that, as I mentioned before, the old Confucian education system had been formally abolished in 1905. So the turn towards modern education and scientific education became much more central in reforming efforts at that time. And certainly we know that the governments of the early Republican period are keen to do various things, including standardize the form of Mandarin that people use around the country and also try and create a sort of new generation of younger people, men in particular, who would have the kind of scientific and technical training that a newly emergent Chinese republic was going to need.
40:34Rana Mitter:There was often actually quite a lot of martial training as well. The idea that sort of drill and learning militarist values was important. This became important, A.Y. Mao directly, who was heavily influenced by it, but also because it's another rejection of that Confucian past. It was said that, you know, the ideal for a Confucian gentleman was to be this, you know, sort of person who's slightly languid, would, you know, concentrate on studying by sort of reading through, leafing through a book while sitting back on a couch. I'm sure Willie's day-to-day life must be exactly like this. Very similar.
41:07Rana Mitter:Very similar. And the modern ethos that was being put forward in that sort of teacher training college and more broadly in education in China, very much taken from the kind of, you know, Victorian, muscular Victorian ideas, was that no, you should be exercising, you should be training, you should be drilling, a healthy mind and a healthy body. That, I think, would have been very much the dynamic that he would have encountered in that sort of teacher training college.
41:30Anita:And the same thing's going on in India at the same time. You've got the idea of the Shaka, the Brits taking over. And if you want to be worthy of running your own country or getting hold of your own identity or your own destiny, you have to be strong. And so you can only be strong if you drill, drill, drill.
41:47William:Yes.
41:47Rana Mitter:So tell us about his time with the May 4th movement, Rana. So let me explain a little bit what this phrase means, because it's one that actually will be understood even today, I think, by any educated Chinese who's read a bit of Chinese history in high school or elsewhere. The end of the 19-teens is yet another turbulent time in Chinese political history. And while Mao is making his way from Hunan province up to the big city, up to Beijing, to the capital of the country where the real action is going on, there's huge ructions going on. But the most important thing is the rise of a new youth-oriented patriotic nationalist movement, which is often called for shorthand the May 4th Movement, attached to a student demonstration of about 3 ,000 students in the center of Beijing on the 4th of May 1919.
42:37Rana Mitter:19. Why that date? Because a few days before the end of April, the Paris Peace Conference that ended World War I, in other words, the Great War, being held in Paris. Now, again, many people who don't know the European side of things may not realize that China and Japan were both very much present there. And essentially, to cut a much longer story, really quite short, China, which had sent 100 ,000 plus workers to the Western Front in Europe to dig trenches and do all this kind of behind the scenes work as part of the Allied effort, was expecting to get back the territories which Germany had had on Chinese soil to Chinese sovereignty instead as a reward for being on the right side, the winning side in the Great War.
43:19Rana Mitter:And through a combination of sort of the Japanese intervening to take them as well, and also because of some skalduggerous action by Chinese politicians who were playing both sides and turned out to actually be doing secret deals with the Japanese in a way that quite shocked Woodrow Wilson when he found out. Essentially, China did not get those former German colonies back. They went to Japan instead. And this caused outrage amongst the young patriotic nationalist students in Beijing, in particular at Peking University, Tsinghua University, these sorts of places. And a whole group of them, thousands, you know, demonstrated in front of the Gate of Heavenly Peace, the Tiananmen.
43:52Rana Mitter:And although the demonstration itself breaks up after a bit of kind of scuffling and even violence, it sets a sort of symbolic moment going that on the May the 4th, China's youth, the elite youth of the university say no more. China is weak. It is being eaten away by imperialism from outside. It's being eaten away by warlords from inside, and this has to stop. And this is a very inspiring movement that, you know, spreads through the media of the press, through student groups who have talked to each other, and inspires a whole variety of shifts, some of which are also given the new culture movement.
44:26Rana Mitter:In other words, the idea that China's old culture, the Confucian culture, was the problem and putting something new in its place was the solution to this particular issue. What does this have to do with Mao? Well, by this stage, Mao has got himself up in the late teens, early 20s to Beijing and heads to, you know, the beating heart of all this, a place actually which some Chinese students at the time called Beijing's Latin Quarter. In other words, the sort of lively university zone where people are drinking tea, eating snacks and discussing big ideas at this time. One of the biggest ideas comes from what's happened just a few years before in 1917, which is the overthrow of the Russian Empire and the rise of the Bolsheviks in Russia.
45:04Rana Mitter:Lots of young Chinese are very interested in this. And then they're discussing anarchism, communism, liberalism, a whole range of very, very free-thinking ideas in and around the surrounds of Peking University, then, as now, the most prestigious educational institution in China. It's headed at that time by a chancellor, a president who is a real liberal, a man called Tsai Yuanpei. And he said that what we do at Peking University is we give you education for a worldview. In other words, we don't tell you what to think, we tell you how to think. A very kind of liberal-minded idea. Also, those days, you know, there's no sort of security tags that you need to get into the campus.
45:43Rana Mitter:Everyone's just like crowded and listened to lectures by famous figures. So this is exhilarating for Mao. But he needs a way to keep Bolly and Seoul together while he's in Beijing. He's still not very well trained for anything but he's done a bit of teacher training as you say. He's done a lot of autodidactic reading and he gets a job. Not a very glamorous job. Library assistant. If I remember correctly, his pay slip actually is in the museum up there at the old Peking University site just north of Forbidden City.
46:10William:And it's pretty low pay.
46:12Rana Mitter:It's eight Chinese dollars a month is my memory which even then was not that much. But it didn't matter because it was enough to keep body and soul together and enabled him to meet people who would be crucial to his later life. Two people, Li Da Zhao, Chen Duxiu. Li Da Zhao was the head librarian of Peking University, so technically Mao's boss. And then Chen Duxiu was the dean of humanities at Peking University. And they're remembered in Chinese history because Li Da Zhao and Chen Duxiu were two of the founders, as maybe the two founding members of what was in a tiny little outfit, started in 1921, called the Chinese Communist Party.
46:51Rana Mitter:And not to spoil the end for listeners, but that would be quite significant for Mao's life for the next few decades.
46:57Anita:This is a very good place to leave this. A young man who's suddenly been introduced to, you know, communist ideology, which is then going to define what we think of him, what we associate with him. In the next episode, we're going to see how Mao manages to turn these ideas that he's surrounded with as a young boy into effective action, rising up through the ranks of this nascent Chinese Communist Party. And if you want to hear that next episode right now with Rana, join the Empire Club at empirepoduk.com. Cheaper than a price of a pint a month. You get early access, you get ad-free shows, you get a weekly newsletter, you get book discounts.
47:36Anita:Just do it. Till the next time we meet, it's goodbye from me, Anita Arnon. And goodbye from me, William de Rimpel.
From the publisher
A revolutionary hero or a brutal despot? Mao Zedong has one of the most recognisable portraits on Earth. How did he rise to become the founder of the People’s Republic of China?
** Binge all six episodes of the series on Chairman Mao by joining the Empire Club today at empirepoduk.com. **
A child born in a rural village, Mao hated the Confucian traditions he grew up with. He read profusely and rebelled against his father. But how did his early life shape him into the dictator he would become?
William and Anita are joined by the brilliant Rana Mitter, author of A Bitter Revolution: China’s Struggle with the Modern World, Modern China: A Very Short Introduction and China’s War with Japan 1937-1945, The Struggle for Survival (or Forgotten Ally, China’s World War II) to discuss the origin story of Mao Zedong.
Join the Empire Club: Unlock the full Empire experience – with bonus episodes, ad-free listening, early access to miniseries and live show tickets, exclusive book discounts, a members-only newsletter, and access to our private Discord chatroom. Sign up directly at empirepoduk.com
For more Goalhanger Podcasts, head to www.goalhanger.com.
Email: empire@goalhanger.com
Instagram: @empirepoduk
Blue Sky: @empirepoduk
X: @empirepoduk
Editor: James Clayden
Researcher: Imogen Marriott
Assistant Producer: Alfie Norris
Producer: Anouska Lewis
Executive Producer: Dom Johnson
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
