

The hosts rewatch and debate Rogue One through the lens of Andor (especially after Andor season 2/3), arguing whether Andor “enhances” the film or instead exposes Rogue One’s narrative and production flaws.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Hosts share their excitement about revisiting Rogue One after watching Andor.
“If you go to the homepage now, the poster for Rogue One has Andor's face front and center and then very small in the background, Felicity Jones and everyone else.”
Discussion on how Andor's character development impacts the perception of Rogue One.
“that brilliant ending, ends with him walking into Rogue One.”
Hosts discuss the limitations of Rogue One's narrative and character focus.
“where that's coming from what he's doing weirdly the bit where he doesn't shoot Galen Erso was the bit that didn't ring true for that character for me I was like you would have shown him in a fucking heartbeat.”
Hosts delve into specific character arcs and their significance in Rogue One.
“And usually when we critique things, you're critiquing them based on creative choices made.”
Sophie shares her challenges analyzing Rogue One due to its production issues.
“And then Tony came on and it wasn't loose anymore.”
Discussion on the troubled production process of Rogue One and its effects.
“Like, I don't think anyone means anything by it.”
Hosts reflect on Gareth Edwards' role and involvement in the film's production.
“Miller's, I don't think Gordon Miller ended up, their name wasn't on the film, but who was the other one?”
Discussion on the broader implications of storytelling in franchise filmmaking.
“general but particularly in these ip franchises the story the writing the script is a complete afterthought.”
Discussion on the creative decisions and changes during the making of Rogue One.
“But it doesn't have to necessarily take months and months.”
Exploration of the film's commercial pressures and its tonal shifts compared to traditional Star Wars films.
“Yeah, there's still there are still moments of Star Wars-iness.”
Analysis of character arcs and themes of sacrifice in Rogue One.
“which is morally tortured man must come to terms with decisions, and then all those kind of, you know, the moral grey is so Gilroy and the slightly gloomy, it's all futile.”
Comparison of characters and themes between Rogue One and the series Andor, emphasizing character development.
“I did get a little bit frustrated with it, same as you, I think, the first time I saw it.”
Discussion on how Andor alters the perception of characters and events in Rogue One.
“and it's not the film's, I mean, I think it's not a great speech even in the film's singular context but the minute you add Andor to the context, you think, why the hell are they putting up with it?”
Analysis of Saw Gerrera's character and his diminishing relevance in the rebellion.
“Because, you know, at the end of Andor, as I sort of try to summarize to myself, what was Saul Guerrero's arc in that?”
Discussion of Cassian Andor's role in Rogue One and how it contrasts with his development in the Andor series.
“But I just love that they're all like, yeah, he's on Jedha.”
A conversation on the evolving opinions about Rogue One since its release and its darker themes.
“you know like so there was the bit where he was kind of going off and they were trying to talk to Bix behind his back going like, you've got to tell him to stop doing this.”
Discussion about the film's characters and the perceived lack of depth compared to the Andor series.
“or brave decision, let's say, to kill off all the heroes of your summer blockbuster, pretty much.”
Exploration of how Rogue One differs from more recent Star Wars content in terms of scale and storytelling.
“why we all poo-pooed it, going, oh, who gives a fuck about this guy, honestly?”
Reflections on the film's achievements and shortcomings in the context of the Star Wars franchise.
“or aliens, depending on your point of view.”
Discussion on the challenges faced during the production of Rogue One.
“build-up on the story leading to that point is really, for me, the version that I like is this strange Gareth Edwards short film at the end, which is just a load of nameless people dying on a beach.”
Exploration of the film's themes of nameless sacrifice versus the quest for recognition.
“But you've got the nameless sacrifice of all these people dying in the cause of the rebellion.”
Critique of the visual effects and character portrayals in Rogue One.
“No, it's more that I don't really, I mean, I do understand the decision.”
Discussion on the fan service elements and continuity concerns in Rogue One.
“But at the same time, you know, there was another way.”
Analysis of character dynamics and their impact within the narrative of Rogue One.
“He's like, my God, my old desert grandpa's dead.”
Concluding thoughts on Rogue One's strengths and weaknesses after reviewing it post-Andor.
“I feel really bad for Felicity Jones who I think lost all of her lines of dialogue to the edit probably because the character that they ended up with was not the character that they were filming.”
Exploration of Jyn Erso's role and character development in Rogue One.
“Like, I have family members, actually, who were so offended by that.”
Discussion on the pressures of the Star Wars franchise and character development.
“how many lines of dialogue she has, and I don't think their metric is all that accurate, but they claim in their weird little bot thing that she has 119 lines, which feels a lot.”
Analysis of the narrative choices in Star Wars and its storytelling implications.
“Just, like I say, just mild befuddlements, I think, sometimes on my part.”
A reflective discussion on Rogue One's reception and its relation to Andor.
“I'd have loved to have seen that storyline in Andor.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Empire+, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:15Chris Hewitt: Hello pod, I'm Chris Hewitt and welcome to the latest in our series of spoiler special podcasts and this one is dedicated to Andor Season 3, otherwise known as Rogue One. And basically what happened is we all watched, eventually in my case, Andor season two and fell in love with it and thought, you know what, it'd be good to go back and re-watch, re-visit, re-appraise Rogue One feud through the prism of Cassian Andor, which is exactly what Disney Plus have done. If you go to the homepage now, the poster for Rogue One has Andor's face front and center and then very small in the background, Felicity Jones and everyone else.
0:55Chris Hewitt: But anyway, joining me to discuss this are three Andorians of such lethal cunning. Helen O 'Hara is here. Hello. Sophie Petzl is here. Oh, hi. Hi, Sophie. How are you? Yeah, I'm all right. I'm all right. A bit damp from the outside, but otherwise happy to be here. What's happening outside? It's raining. It's raining. Oh, okay. I hadn't noticed. It's gone from full geonosis out there. James, our ferry on Luthan Rail, James Jimbo Dyer is here. I've been my life! Where are you from? I don't know. and yeah and I have literally just revisited Rogue One in the wake of watching eight episodes of Andor well first of all pretty much in a row we didn't get to hear you on Andor no one needs to hear me on Andor or Andor it's terrific it's great you enjoyed it good even though it's a check notes TV show yeah I didn't understand what was happening every now and again the movie would stop and then there would be some names and then the movie would start again so that was good who skips intro by the way You know when that Lucasfilm thing comes up and all the droids?
1:58Chris Hewitt: I do. I can't. I can't and I won't. Yes, but Andor is terrific. But we thought we'd get together today to talk about Rogue One and see whether it had changed now. Now we know everything about Cassian Andor and we love that character more than we did. Because there has been a big reappraisal of Rogue One in the wake of Andor. People saying that it's now a masterpiece, that it has completely reframed the film, that actually, you know, this is the film it always needed to be with all of this backstory and all this characterization. And so it made me very much want to go. It was not least of all because the final episode of Andor, that brilliant ending, ends with him walking into Rogue One.
2:32So you do want to see the story through to its conclusion. And in conclusion, I think... Can you see where he's going with this? Yeah, it does two things. On the one hand, some scenes hit harder because understanding who Cassian is and the weight of that and a lot of the things he says deliberately at this point have much more weight and resonate because they call back to elements of Andor. And I think the weight of character there really, really helps him. However, it also very clearly, I think, shines a light on the narrative shortcomings of this film and the character shortcomings of this film.
3:07And they did Mon Mothma Dirty, and it upsets me. I mean, that was kind of maybe baked in just because they were trying to make her look like she did in 1983, and hence the haircut. Oh, the hair was the least of it, but yes. Yeah, but I think the thing is that because we now have so much depth of knowledge about Cassian himself and about the rebellion as a concept that a lot of the kind of more quote-unquote crowd-pleasing kid-friendly adventure-y elements of Rogue One now feel wildly out of place with Andor. It feels so surface level. It feels surface level I think at times because there are scenes that we're getting the weight and we're getting the depth of Andor added to Rogue One.
3:53And it is really additive in those scenes. It really does enhance Rogue One in those scenes. But any time you have Per Jyn Erso trying to take center stage, it just feels a bit weird because, quite frankly, if Jyn Erso had come out of an Andor-like process, there'd be much more examination, like genuine emotional, moral examination of the fact that her father, under pressure, under threat, collaborated with the Empire, built the Death Star, was key to building the Death Star. And there'd be much more, I think, you know, unpacking of what that means for her and for him and for their relationship and for their relationship with the wider galaxy in a way that Rogue One keeps almost touching upon and then just glancing away from.
4:44And I find it frustrating from that point of view. but like certain things definitely hit harder I definitely cared much more about Andor himself in every scene I cared more about K2SO even I cared more about freaking Melchie oh yeah poor Melchie who I did not remember from Rogue One at all when he turned up in Andor at all yeah and you understand the character like when he shoots Danny Mays you 100 % understand where that's coming from what he's doing weirdly the bit where he doesn't shoot Galen Erso was the bit that didn't ring true for that character for me I was like you would have shown him in a fucking heartbeat.
5:19What are you talking about? Sophie, what was your take? I find it really tricky to analyze a film like this because I think, and I suppose this is your guy's jobs, but sort of as a layman and a fan, I sort of want to talk about anything Star Wars and ascribe it some sort of value. And usually when we critique things, you're critiquing them based on creative choices made. Like they've decided the character is this way and I don't think that works for this reason. But I think so much of this film is not a product of creative choices. It's a product of dysfunctional process. And so as a result, I find it quite hard to quote-unquote critique it because there's no intentionality to work from.
6:09I can't say, you know, Jin Asso feels like a weak character because she's not a weak character. well I mean I can say that of course we can get into that but for me it would feel almost disingenuous because she's not a weak character for clear choice based reasons and where I disagree with the creative at the heart of it She's a weak character because of the muddle She's a weak character because all of her lines got cut in the edit and she was playing a different character and her as far as I understand and from what I've read and what I've listened to Felicity Jones and almost every other actor in that film was performing a different role that they ended up compared to the characters that ended up being in the film so for instance Cassian Andor was a rule-obeying imperial spy, and I think that only changed in ADR.
6:51And Felicity Jones was, oh, God, I can't quite remember what I've read about that. Well, there was that line in one of the trailers about, you know, I'm a rebel, I rebel. And, like, you cannot imagine that in that sort of flippant tone connected to anything in Andor, because the whole point of Andor is really talking about the weight of rebellion and the difficulty and the cost and the sacrifice that is involved in that. And yet the necessity and the importance. And so none of that fits with that kind of a line. And that kind of a line, which was obviously from the earlier cuts, we think, of the movie, didn't end up in the finished product.
7:29That shows you kind of maybe how far they were kind of moving from one tone towards another, but maybe not the whole way there like Andor went. can we dig into that a little bit in fact Sophie you might be able to help me out here so it's never fully transparently come to like what happened on Rogue One I did a spoiler special with Gareth Edwards when it came out and he off mic did mention he goes one day when years have passed we'll talk about what happened oh yeah
7:55Chris Hewitt: I'd love to see a commentary with him and Gilroy Tony Gilroy going through the film and going yeah that was Gareth that was me that was Gareth that was me the only one the only thing I know I think that I can say for absolute certainty was a Tony Gilroy scene is the scene with Danny Mayes. Well, yeah, because Danny Mayes, I don't think he met Gareth. Because he said, when you interviewed him on camera at the Empire Awards, he went, yeah, the director, Tony Gilroy, and we were like, okay. And there was a really fun thing I saw last week where there was some sort of four-year consideration event and it had most of the cast and Alan Tudyk let something slip about how the dialogue was very, very loose the first time around.
8:35Chris Hewitt: And then Tony came on and it wasn't loose anymore. And you could see the other actors going, are we allowed to say this? you know you can see Diego going what? And when Ben interviewed Tony Gilroy for Andoy he said what was your first day like on Rogue One and Tony kind of laughed went nice try we're not getting into that like he clearly just isn't getting NDAs up the wazoo absolutely that and that's really interesting but Gareth even a couple of years ago said you know the idea that it had been taken off him that he'd been cut out during the edit was not true and he said I was still very present very doing things so he's still maintaining his involvement but Sophie you said you've been listening to a lot of podcasts like what have you unearthed what can you tell us it's not my work it's not my unearthing but I after Andor after Andor and then I watched Rogue One very quickly after I finished Andor season two and was so stunned by what a car crash it was and how how not you know rather than Andor enhancing Rogue One it for me exposed its its flaws and its inherent dysfunction and And I think I was just saying that I find it really hard to therefore sort of cross compare and discuss the themes of Rogue One because it would be me ascribing them arbitrarily.
9:47There aren't any themes. It's a complete mess. Like, I don't think anyone means anything by it. So as a result, I mean, I'm sure Gilroy and Edwards, they kind of had ideas and intentions. But through that muddle of a process, I'm not sure any of them come through very clearly for me personally. And as a result, I became so fascinated with the car crash that I went looking for info on it and was referred to a podcast called Going Rogue by Tansy Gardem. I'm sorry if I'm pronouncing that wrong. She is, from what I can tell, an Australian commentator who just did one of those kind of it's just me and a microphone podcast series where she seems to have gathered every interview that is available online and every piece of writing.
10:26I don't know how much she's inferring, but from listening to the podcast, it seems that everything she is referring to is something that she could find and source. And the thing that struck me as interesting, and this was something I knew, I was aware of, but hadn't quite attributed it to the process of Rogue One, was that obviously, so in the DGA, the Directors Guild of America, their rules, as far as I can recall, forgive me if this is inaccurate, are that if you are fired, if you're the director and you're fired, you still have to be present on set. You still have to be present on set while the new director is either reshooting your scenes or shooting new ones.
11:08It's something like that. So basically, yeah, I'm sure Gareth was involved, but he's sort of a hostage to fortune there. So I don't know how much of a kind of, yeah, that was joyful. They allowed me to be there as much as that's just what the GDA commands and that's what the rules are. so it's all sorts of things that just sound to me to be completely horrific I mean for me my personal takeaway rather than I think I would recommend you go listen to that podcast it's really entertaining really compelling and there's always something a little bit seedy and sinister for me like there's something about there but for the grace of God go I in listening to stories of TV and film car crashes but my sort of takeaway is these IP franchise movies and it is something of note that Gareth is he's the only director of that tranche that was greenlit whose name ended up on the film.
11:59I don't think the Miller's, I don't think Gordon Miller ended up, their name wasn't on the film, but who was the other one? Josh Trank. Maybe as producers, but not as directors. Yeah, but they, Gareth Edwards gets his, it's Gareth Edwards, isn't it?
12:10Chris Hewitt: It is Gareth Edwards. He gets a directed by credit. Yeah. But for me, these, I mean, this is my bias as a TV writer, film is obsessed with directors and they're obsessed with the latest new boy and the latest new boy has made a film in his basement so the latest latest new boy has made uh you know the found film superhero footage or he's made a great comedy and he's made some money and da da da da and these ip movies then want to attract those talents they bring in those directors and then they and and in film in general but particularly in these ip franchises the story the writing the script is a complete afterthought.
12:48We want the pre-vis starting before absolutely anything else. We hire a writer, they do a draft, we sack them. We hire another writer, we do a draft, we sack them. We start shooting because we've already picked a merchandising run line. We've already picked the cinema release date. We need the IMAX cinemas for this day and this day. Writer gets sacked, writer gets sacked, director gets sacked. It's story last. And I think it's a pure miracle that any of these films work. And I feel like this is actually what most films should look like. and it's a miracle that most don't. Anyway, that's my rant.
13:20I'm going to get me cancelled from my industry. I would love to read Gary Whitter's original script for this film and see what vague connection there is to what we ultimately saw. But I do feel that generally, and this is kind of what you're saying, in franchise filmmaking, it is, relatively speaking, very cheap to write a script, right? And, you know, with respect, writers should be paid more. But even if you're paying your writer really well, it's still really cheap to write a script. So why would you not get that bit right first? Like, it just doesn't seem and never has seemed logical. And this goes way beyond Rogue One.
14:01Is it time-related? Because that's the bit that takes time. But it doesn't have to necessarily take months and months. Like, you know, it can be done quicker. Lots of writers do it quickly. but also why not get that in place before you set the toy launch and the release date and look we all know what's happening what craziness is this but I do think there is a and I know again films can shift people can come in with a great idea on the day you get an activist star who wants to say a cool line or has their own ideas and that can enhance a movie but also just why not have a plan to begin with anyway
14:43Chris Hewitt: that's interesting with Rogue One because again we won't know because no one's really saying on the record definitively but I'd love to see that original Gareth Edwards version I'd love to see how far they got down the line what their intent was I know what their intent was because they've talked about it he's talked about it I've interviewed him about it John Knoll I spoke to John Knoll about it as well and they wanted to make a very serious harder edged film which I think they did for the most part, but about a rebellion and about a war, actually putting the war in Star Wars. But it is fascinating to see at what point in the creative process did alarm bells start ringing at Lucasfilm and with Kathleen Kennedy, and were those alarm bells justified?
15:28Chris Hewitt: Were they justified? Or was it sheer panic? We spent a lot of money in this movie. Because there are two schools of thought, isn't it? There's the, was it a post-Force Awakens box office recalibration, or was it a damage control because this is going south in a hurry situation. Was it a bit of both? I certainly, certainly someone connected to it lent more towards the first narrative when they talked to me about it. Very much off the record. No, no, not that it was going south. But it was very much after The Force Awakens. The feeling at Lucasfilm for what they wanted this film to be was different.
16:00That when it made that much money, there was definitely pressure for this film to also make. To what, go more kind of mainstream. Yeah, because it was basically very different. like a left field palette cleanser between Force Awakens and the next one. But then it was just like, oh no, we can make a shitload of money here. So actually we now need to course correct to make it much more like a Star War.
16:19Chris Hewitt: It made a billion. And that sort of strange tonal disconnect in the film is something that really struck me. It begins with a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. It ends with the Star Wars music and directed by Gareth Edwards, not in inverted commas, but actually directed by Gareth Edwards with the Star Wars music. and then it goes out of its way to be structurally and stylistically as different from George Lucas' Star Wars as you could possibly get. Well, mostly. For the most part. Yeah, there's still there are still moments of Star Wars-iness. Like I thought as we were flying into Jedi I'm like, oh, what do you know?
16:57A fucking desert planet. You do love your biomes. There's a shock. But, you know, and look, I get it's slightly different and it has a slightly different thing going on but that felt very Star Wars-y.
17:09Chris Hewitt: But the interesting thing for me with Rogue One, we're talking about commercial pressures and it's a mainstream movie, and you reverted it, Helen, a few minutes ago as kind of almost kiddie-esque at times. The thing, I don't know what you meant by that, so maybe we'll talk about it in a second. Because for me, this is definitely, in terms of his tone and intent, very, very different from anything Lucas made. But the thing that I still can, I think I'm still astounded by for all the rewriting, reshooting, redirecting, all of it, is that this is still a mainstream $250 million blockbuster in which everybody dies at the end.
17:47Chris Hewitt: And that's pretty bold. Yeah, that is still really bold. And that was a change as well because they originally lived, didn't they? It's interesting that if they were going... Giroir went, nope. He was trying to kill Ocean's Eleven all the way through that franchise. But it's interesting if they are recalibrating to make it more commercially viable. That's an interesting I thought so, yeah That is the thing That you would think Would be the least commercial Single decision Taken in the entire Thing, right? And yeah I mean, look No argument with it It works very well Off the back of Andor It's particularly bittersweet I got quite choked Same here Although I really, really took issue With when they're going In the lift Down from the tower And he's staring Very deeply into Gino I was like Fuck you you Bix is out there with your son, you absolute twat.
18:36But anyway. I did also feel like, and I think this is also maybe not just coming off of Andor, but also just coming off the whole of Rogue One itself. I don't know that they would have given up on the way down in the lift. Like, there's a sense that they're just kind of crawling out the other end going, well, there's no way off the planet for us now. And I'm like, isn't there? Because like a whole lot of... Give it a go. Yeah. Can you check a launch pad or something? But they just kind of go and sit on the beach. Earning 20%. I knew you were going to say that. Yeah. Also, I will say that when they use the Death Star and Tarkin is like, target the base of Jedha, they miss it by like 50 miles.
19:10Yes. It's the worst shot in history. They clip the tower and it's like... Fuck me. I know Imperial Stormtroopers can't shoot straight, but even the Death Star. I was thinking exactly the same thing last night because I watched it when I finished Andorra and then I watched it again last night. And yes, it clips the top of the tower. It gets rid of the director, Krennic. He might still be alive. We don't know. I think we can be fairly... Krennic, of course, not the only director who got rid of it. But anyway, carry on. Oh, too soon. Too soon. So they clip the top of the tower, and then that obviously gives us time for that sort of lovely watching the sunset moment just before you die horribly in a cloud of ash and fire.
19:50But they also kind of... Yeah, it's weird. It's a weird decision, militarily. It's a great decision, cinematically. Yeah, completely. Because if it had just hit it, you don't have the... You want the fire coming towards them. you need that almost that echo of the Jetta sequence as well. I think that's the only thing really that you can kind of find in the movie are the bits of Gareth, which is the intense visual set pieces. The things that work, work cinematically, and they don't work militarily or narratively. And then you get the little bits of Gilroy, which is morally tortured man must come to terms with decisions, and then all those kind of, you know, the moral grey is so Gilroy and the slightly gloomy, it's all futile.
20:38Yeah, so you get these moments and these senses of these creatives at the heart of it, but it's just hard to escape. Because I came in trying to think, you know, what do I like and what does feel like it actually tracks quite organically from Andor and really the only thing I could think of was Krennic. but sincerely he um you know ends and or as such a sinister bully boy and to cut to him then where he's the little runt at the bottom of this incredibly mystic and terrifying food chain um is really interesting and his performance is great and the only shot that i felt like well one of my favorite shot they're testing the power of the death star and tarkin turns back from the window and the crowd parts and krennic is just sort of revealed in shadow like hunched over and he's like you know it's something sort of like will you tell the emperor of my success and it's such a great shot and such a great line delivery um that's the one moment that kind of gave me chills and made me feel something the other thing to sort of to say to its credit and its connection to Andor is that theme, deliberate or not, of the nameless sacrifice.
21:54I think in many ways it's part of the film's story of dysfunction that so many of the key characters established in the film have very forgettable, almost off-screen deaths. And from what I understand, a lot of those are kind of just salvaged in the edit. They're not sort of deliberate choices. That said, the original Star Wars was a movie written in the edit. I'm very, very aware that you can complete a film, a film that made no sense going in and was a masterpiece coming out is still a piece of art that has value and can be dissected and discussed and stuff. But I think, you know, because I was quite hostile initially to the corridor sequence.
22:34I know that's quite a popular discourse. Yeah, yeah. And but actually watching it again, thought, well, that's one of the few sequences aside from the awful gelatinous layer. that has a thematic, a real sort of thematic resonance as you watch these plans get passed from nameless guy to nameless guy as they get hacked down the next guy, the next guy, the next guy. And yes, they hand it to the imperial, no, the imperial, but... Oh my God, there's a twist. Well, I suppose in her own way, Leia is an imperial force. You know, she is a royal line. You know, the magical superhero flies off with it at the end, but until then it's just nameless death after nameless death, which I think is sort of what Andorff is kind of all about.
23:13So I did enjoy that, and I looked at that corridor sequence with a little bit more fondness. Yeah, me too. For that reason. I did get a little bit frustrated with it, same as you, I think, the first time I saw it. And also, I kind of, you know, it goes to show Vader a little bit at his dumbest, because if he was less intent on killing every fucking fool in there, he could absolutely have just grabbed that thing and floated it back to himself, and everything would have been fine for him. He could arguably have grabbed the ship as it took off. But also, more to the point, when he finally... And obviously you can't always make the join seamless, but when he interrogates Leia in Star Wars, he's like, you intercepted a transmission.
23:54No, I didn't. I fucking saw you. I was standing there. I watched you fucking fly away. It could have been any blockade runner ship. You don't even know. By the way, just timeline-wise, the Rebel ships almost have taken off when C-3PO and R2 are still down on the planet. This is the bit that feels kiddish to me. That's the most kiddish shot in the entire film is R2 and C-3PO still on Yavin 4 going, oh, are everyone leaving? Oh, no. And they have to be on the blockade runner, which is attached to the flagship, which should already have left 10 minutes later. I'm just saying.
24:31Chris Hewitt: I missed him completely. Well done, me. I was probably too busy writing a letter to my MP about the fader sequences in this movie, which just feels so mandated and so fanboy. The Krennic one in particular. I like the Krennic in that sequence. I think the Vader performance is embarrassing. Careful not to choke on your ambitions. Just stop. The writing was not. When they're on Yavin and when Jyn does her kind of St. Crispin's Day speech, which is so curlingly terrible. It's awful. And then Mothma, obviously in that speech, she's weak and uninspiring. And that really upset me because she's such a commanding presence in the show.
25:06and she's so nothing here. But I like that we've established that the ruling council of the rebellion or whatever we're calling them are kind of shit at stuff and like very hard to get to agree on anything and very, you called them the centrist dads last time. Like they're very like middle of the road. Like, okay, we'll figure it out, but not today. And like, she is just, the impression I got from that watching Rogue One again in the light of Andor is like, she is like, Jesus Christ, can I ever get these people to do any fucking thing? so I was kind of like okay she's just holding back she's biding her time trying to figure out a different way to get this job done right like that was that was the only way I could make that make sense in my head
25:46Chris Hewitt: I like the character I think the actress name weirdly I know the actress name but not the character's name Jonathan Aris is the actress name the guy who basically goes oh we're done for the Rebel Alliance might as well we're just might as well just pack up and go home is he the one that I only for some reason even though I see him in loads of things I think I only remember him as the super fan in Sherlock is it him? yes that's him that's him he's one of the the Sherlockian like super fans who has theories about I can't remember the Baker Street Irregulars I guess in the books but they're homeless people of course do right so if you've talked about your superpower being hearing ADR right so during that council scene and everything when there's voices in the background going tell us what we should do then were you were your your prickles up were you just like oh Jesus also Also, the other one, because I rewatched the sequence today, when they take the plans and run, get them out of here now!
26:43You're like, uh-huh, uh-huh. Like, the text tells me that this is pretty urgent. The music is telling me this is pretty urgent. I don't need, like, Dave. Yeah, anyway, anyway. But, yeah. Yeah, I mean, that whole sequence, that's why I come back to, I think, Andor exposes its flaws rather than enhances its merits, because there are so many moments where you just think, Andor wouldn't say nothing to that Mon Moth is not letting her get away with that The fact that Jyn Erso gets to take center stage And deliver such a politically inept Again, in the Andor universe The Rogue One iteration of Jyn Erso Is like a toxic sort of Hillary Clinton liberal You know, the kind of Guys, if we just work together and we're just nice Hashtag be kind Like talking to them like they've never thought of this before in their lives She would deliver that speech and then walk out of the room and get hit by a falling barrel.
27:38Or somebody would go, fuck you, your dad's a war criminal. Who cares? You're cancelled. She would sort of be a kind of almost farcical figure, I think. And I think there's merit. It made me think we didn't really have the sort of toxic liberal fence straddler character who kind of thinks that the way to success is by hashtag be kind. But yeah, it is toe curling that speech. and it's not the film's, I mean, I think it's not a great speech even in the film's singular context but the minute you add Andor to the context, you think, why the hell are they putting up with it? Who the fuck is she? But there's so much of that and she does the bit where even when the squadron's going out and Andor's right there and she steps up and gives them a little...
28:19He nods to her. He basically says, you tell them, you give them one for her. And again, she says the least inspiring thing ever and it feels very weak sauce at this point. Let's not die, guys. But some of the lines, I think, do land in a slightly different way. like this bit when he's in the cage and he says they're like I've been in worse cages than this and Andor's like this is a first for me and all you can think is because there are no doors in the cells on Narkina like so again it just sort of lands slightly different things when he says we don't all have the luxury of deciding when and where we're going to choose to care about something and you can't help thinking about his early life in Andor season one you know and he's like every time I walked away from something I wanted to tell myself it was for a cause I believed in and I think all of that stuff lands does land in a different way I think they were all written by Tony Gilroy I mean I'm not saying definitely, but...
29:02All of Saw Gerrera's material, I think... Save the rebellion! Save the dream! My own guess... Save the trees!
29:09Chris Hewitt: Save the trees! My own guess is that that's entirely reshot, simply because in all those trailers, I was re-watching some of the trailers, because like that first Henry Cravel Superman movie, the trailer had a better idea of what the film was than the film did. It was a different beast when they cut the trailer, though, wasn't it? yeah yeah and in that Saw Gerrera has his Clone Wars bald head and dark beard and obviously in the film he's got some white hair well at the beginning he's got the bald head but they were a lot of save the rebellion save the dream sequence in the trailer so basically he had the same look the whole way and I think he was I think all of his scenes were re-shot and presumably apart from then the one on the video that you see at the very start because that's when he does have the bald head yes yeah potentially but the Saul Guerrero stuff for me was quite emblematic of how little Andor had to work with in some ways and how it's sort of a really interesting miracle that they've managed to make more sense of some of the stuff than seemed possible.
30:12Because, you know, at the end of Andor, as I sort of try to summarize to myself, what was Saul Guerrero's arc in that? It's like he just slowly loses his relevance to this increasingly centralized, democratized, rebellion business. and also he just slowly he's huffing jet fuel to be fair and he goes mad and then you realise right because I guess the end result of that is in Rogue One where the story makes his story makes so little sense and his role in the film makes so little sense he basically takes this pilot to a psychic octopus yeah and then we've all been there
30:43Chris Hewitt: and then shows Jin Erso a hologram and then died then chooses to die yeah I'm done running but he is yeah he is set up as an extremist he is set up as a guy who is not biding his time and waiting for the optimal moment to strike he's just fucking killing whoever he can kill as often as possible which I guess is interesting like you get it like you feel like you understand Saw more he was you're right he was a nonsense of a character when you first see the film and now having seen who he is and how he got there he does feel more around it and I actually think that does help the final episode of Hand Over they're like you're on Jeddah aren't you and he's like no I don't know who I am I love that meme You have no idea where I am.
31:29I could be anywhere. But I just love that they're all like, yeah, he's on Jedha. Yeah, we know he's on Jedha. Yeah, we know where he is. It's not a problem. We know where he is. We just need you to get him.
31:38Chris Hewitt: That scene on Jedha, I thought was interesting as well. In the context of, you know, the Andorification of this movie, you know, watching, it's weird because obviously you're applying context to it that didn't exist when they made the movie, but of Cassian, knowing that he was at the massacre, the Gorman massacre, and seeing some of the same building blocks put into place in Jedha City, you could see him reacting in an interesting way. I thought that was, you know, taking our Andorian context and plans for that and made the scene play slightly differently for me as well. He's also, he's strangely rulesy in the film.
32:15You know, big into following orders. Like that becomes his role in the edited version of that film is he is, she's the one going, why won't you just like you just do what they tell you to do and he's like well that's how I've got where I've got to and that's that's again it's unfair to apply context to it that didn't exist beforehand but that does but he's earned his rank now he's now Captain Andor as opposed to Rogue Andor but literally five minutes ago at the end of Andor he just wasn't like that but I do think it's they've tried a little bit to set that up at the end of Andor but you kind of feel like their heart wasn't in it you know like so there was the bit where he was kind of going off and they were trying to talk to Bix behind his back going like, you've got to tell him to stop doing this.
32:57Like he's in line for promotion. Like that's a thing that matters to him. And she's going well. They don't get wages, right?
33:03Chris Hewitt: They don't, you know, there's no pay structure here. This is a rebellion with a fucking training academy for pilots. Like they probably do have some kind of pay structure. And great housing. Yeah. And we know that Mon Mothma's been, you know, paying for them. What's she been paying for? What's she been buying? What have other people been buying for them? Christmas presents. We need another 12-part series to delve into this. It's interesting, though, because I'm slightly surprised that we've been fairly down as a group on Rogue One as a movie thus far. Hellspells, you really haven't talked that much about how you felt about the movie in 2016 when it first came out.
33:41Chris Hewitt: And have your feelings changed about the movie now? I definitely like it more now. I didn't like hate it, but I just thought it was, I think I just mostly thought it was odd. Now, maybe people are going to go back and listen to a spoiler special if we did one. We did do a spoiler special. And be like, Helen, you loved it. Maybe I did. You probably did. But my memory is just going, that's kind of a weird Star Wars movie, wasn't it? And partly, but not only because of killing everybody at the end. I think that maybe gives it a reputation and a gravitas that the rest of it didn't deserve. I think that's maybe fair or at least accurate.
34:21I think that it has a reputation for being cooler than it maybe is because it makes that one very cool, if you like, decision, or brave decision, let's say, to kill off all the heroes of your summer blockbuster, pretty much. That's a big deal. I don't want to sort of do that down. It did take that swing, and it didn't have to.
34:44Chris Hewitt: Yeah, Super Mario Brothers don't all die. And God, we'd all be better off. But yeah, I just remember being slightly sort of like, oh, okay, was that all? And there was stuff I really liked about it. I actually love the rebels in the fucking tropical paradise, like running through shallow seas to the next coral at all to, you know, fuck some shit up. Like, I love that. I love Baze and... Chirrut Imwe. Thank you, being one with the forest and the forest is with them. I love them, I love their relationship I like K2SO quite a lot I think everybody's unjustifiably mean to him if I'm honest I have questions about how bulletproof K2SO is or is not because when we see them at the Gormann Massacre they are absolutely impervious to Blaster Fire and here, one shot, boom, dead Well, it takes a few shots to be fair Well, no, but the other KX droid that they see on Jeddah literally one shot and it just goes straight down He needs like an XP bar, he needs a health bar I think he just wore down his health maybe you know they become more resilient I don't know what's going on with that yeah but I yeah I don't know I just it did feel maybe it was the muddlediness that I felt even then well interestingly because I I don't think I've seen this more than once before I rewatched it for this and we've talked about it a lot over the years Jimbo you said right at the beginning that a lot of people have reappraised it and reevaluated almost instantly actually after it came out I remember people going when we were doing Star Wars rankings people would go well Rogue One's going to be high up Rogue One's the best of the post-Lucas era.
36:15Chris Hewitt: A lot of people are saying that. A lot of very vain people. A lot of people on both sides. A lot of people are saying that Rogue One is the best post-Lucas movie. And over the years, I was just like, I don't really remember that. I remember the overriding argument. And again, people can go back and listen to the Sporting Special where I probably say something completely diametrically opposed to this. But I remember coming out of it and going, I liked a lot of it. I thought it was interesting. I didn't like the fader bits. And... The chief criticism of this movie, I seem to recall, focused on Jyn Erso and Cassian Andor, which led to whenever Andor was announced as a series, why we all poo-pooed it, going, oh, who gives a fuck about this guy, honestly?
36:59Chris Hewitt: He was a non-character. Yeah. And do you find that, even looking at this film again, that that still kind of stands? It's an interesting point. I mean, look, I did enjoy Rogue One. you'll recall I described it as triumphant you did describe it as triumphant I did enjoy it a lot poster dwelling horror for all of its flaws I enjoyed it a great deal and my relationship with Rogue One has become slightly more complicated over time so after we watched The Acolyte last year I watched Rogue One and my view of it was significantly more up and I was like oh my god this is Star Wars and I realised in watching Rogue One I hadn't seen the, you know, I'd been the first Star Wars film I watched in a few years and I was like, oh my God, these Disney Plus shows have really minimized Star Wars for me.
37:50They're so small and they're so slight and they're so trivial and while The Mandalorian is fun, you know, Obi-Wan, Ahsoka, it's like, oh, who gives a shit? You know, they're fine, whatever. But I watched Rogue One. They're just a guy traveling about, talking to people for the most part. I watched Rogue One, I was like, the space battle, I'm like, this is cinema, like this is epic, it's sweeping, there's lots going on. Yes, there's problematic dialogue and there's shit characters and whatnot, but it felt like Star Wars to me in a way that it was writ large on a grand scale in a way that is the absolute opposite of the Disney Plus shows, Andor notwithstanding.
38:19So I was really up on Rogue One, having come off the back of Acolyte. Having watched it again now, having come off the back of Andor, I had a very different response where I was like, oh, this is everything that Andor is not. Andor is all subtext and politics and characters and wonderful dialogue and all of this texture and grain. and this is none of that. This is incredibly surface level. It's incredibly disposable and these characters are just really vague sketches of human beings or aliens, depending on your point of view. And so actually, I felt more short-changed by it but equally, I do think Andor does enhance the character of Andor who, as we said, he was a cipher.
38:58He's a non-character in the film. No one gives a shit. No one wants to see a film about him. Having lived with him for two seasons, I feel that I know that character and even though I see him here as a slight afterimage of the Andor that we see on the show. And that doesn't sit brilliantly with me because he does still feel, he feels like a bit of a shit Andor in this. But having the weight of all that history and characterization made me appreciate, you know, when he says things like, you know, we've all done terrible things on behalf of the rebellion. Like, it really landed me. I was like, fuck, you really have.
39:29Like, he's suffered a lot. He's been through a lot. He's seen so much. And you feel the weight of it. And I have to say, even though it was butchered in the edit and it was ADR to death and Luna's performance is really good. Oh yeah, yeah, he is good. I remember being really impressed back when it came out with what you were talking about, Helen, about the sacrifice, the nameless grunts all lying dead on the beach and that none of the characters were alive by the end. I remember, I'm going to misquote the title, but writer, he was a pal of mine, Vinay Patel wrote a really fun blog post back when it came out.
40:09I think it was called something like Rogue One Doesn't Give a Shit About the Hero's Journey. And I remember having this. And it was a film that prompted people to write blog posts and it felt like, oh, there's at least there's kind of a brain here. There is an intentionality. And maybe it is really unfair of me to have said what I said at the beginning. Because I think when you do understand a process more, it really I think it robs you of the sort of the magic sheen that a film can give you where you can engage with a full heart and open mind rather than going yeah but how am I supposed to interpret this because I know how like none of this you didn't mean any of this it's just a fucking broken accident of whatever you know because back before I knew all that stuff I was like oh you know however that being said it was a film that there are some films where I didn't enjoy it very much and then I wake up the next day and go maybe it's better than And it grows and grows and grows on me, and I see it again, and I go, you know, I was wrong the first time.
41:04This was the total opposite. The more I thought about it, the weaker I thought it was. I think, and I still think, we said this about actually Endor season two, the first three episodes, that it was, oh, I'm so positive about that opening because the last sequence of episode three was so powerful and resonated in the memory so strongly. That last act of Rogue One, even though I think a lot of the deaths It's kind of choppy and half off screen, and it's sort of oblique for its dysfunction. It is memorable. It is epic. It is grand. Scarif is a really well-realized... All the stuff that required all the previs and all the stuff that Lucasfilm was really good at, of course, that was good.
41:42Fabulous. It looks really good. And I loved playing on the fucking Scarif campaigns in Battlefront 2. I loved all that. But when you watch it again now, and whenever I've watched it a few times over the years, I can't get away from how choppy and disjointed and all over the place the build-up on the story leading to that point is really, for me, the version that I like is this strange Gareth Edwards short film at the end, which is just a load of nameless people dying on a beach. doing Star Wars as monsters or doing Star Wars as Saving Private Ryan is a cool and ambitious idea I just, for all sorts of reasons and I know that for all sorts of reasons it just collapsed under its own weight and I think the process was completely dysfunctional and Kathleen Kennedy back, I was just doing it went down a huge scroll hole she made a statement when they got rid of Lord and Miller and it was something you know they're such great and talented guys and you know they have a process but ultimately we have to keep the train on the tracks and all I could think was I bet so much of this just boils down to an inability to make your days like you've got you've got to when you're on a set and you're a director shoot for a certain amount of hours a day and finish what you're scheduled to shoot and if you start if you keep not finishing you will start So you waste so much money and so much time, it becomes an enormous, enormous problem.
43:23And when you bring in these Wonder Boys, these new kids on the block who are really talented with great visual acumen and great vision, and then you put them under the weight of the enormous Star Wars machine and throw at them then the dysfunction of their scripting process, which, to your point much earlier, Helen, I don't really understand. And then you add to that their desire to, and I think the studio's desire, to have that creative do the thing that they're famous for, which is Lord and Miller. It's improv comedy. Similarly with Gareth Edwards, as far as I understand it, a lot of it's like improvised shots.
43:56A lot of it's like, oh, we're shooting this, but let's just have the actors kind of... Monsters, I think, all the dialogue was they just made it up on the spot and they were trying to do a bit of that. So in trying to kind of split the difference and have your talented director bring them in, try and have their process under the weight of this machinery where you have to shoot eight to ten hours a day and you have to shoot three or four pages and I think if you fall down under that process, you're just going to drown. So I think that to me is like the ringing legacy of this film is the dysfunction of the process, which is a shame.
44:29But yeah, I don't think it's very good. I guess if we're talking about like what you were saying before about sort of themes and so on, I guess the closest we can get is this point you're making about nameless sacrifice because I think there's an interesting kind of parallel maybe and I'll admit, I'm stretching here, right? I'm trying to find a theme. But you've got the nameless sacrifice of all these people dying in the cause of the rebellion. You've got these people who are just, you know, willing to give everything for the rebellion. They're not expecting a plaque. They're not expecting a, you know, memorial.
45:02They're just trying to do the right thing. I guess that's contrasted with Krennic, who is obsessed, and we see this throughout the Empire scenes in Andor, and there is a through line there, with getting credit and with getting, He's obsessed with, you've got to tell the Emperor, I did this. This is me. I got it done. And he's obsessed with covering his tracks for the mistakes that he made in trusting Galen Erso. He's obsessed with trying to fix anything that's gone wrong, get credit for everything that's gone right, and maintain or enhance his position within the Empire. And we see both Tarkin and Vader basically go, lol, fuck you, we're taking the credit, fuck off.
45:43But that's kind of the most interesting thing, I guess, that's happening in terms of a theme here. It's the quest for glory and recognition versus the quest to do the right thing. So needy as well, which is really interesting. So needy. He's got a lot of Cyril in him, which is really funny because that's not who you see at all in Andor. But obviously that's who he is, as you said, in the grand scheme of the Imperial hierarchy. Yeah. He's a little fair shore. He's a needy bitch. Yeah. He's a needy little bitch, yes. I still think those are my favorite scenes. I do wish they hadn't made Tarkin into gelatinous goo as well.
46:18Yeah, yeah. I mean, look.
46:20Chris Hewitt: It holds up a lot about Linlea. It holds up, yeah. Which is wild. Ten-year-old effects. Neither looks like a human. No, it's more that I don't really, I mean, I do understand the decision. The decision is The Force Awakens and look, it's him. Look, it's that thing you remember. And like, you know, that moment. I just, I remember. and I'm sure I was into it too but I remember it was such a my toes curling everybody going in the cinema when the red light saber ignites you're like that's kind of what this has become isn't it it's just a load of it's that thing you remember and yeah the actor who plays Tarkin in this movie Guy Henry does a really really good job and when you see the behind the scenes he looks exactly like him and in the Going Rogue podcast she spoke quite a bit about how he'd spoken about being so being really worried about getting it right and being quite paranoid about it and like fussy about it and working really really hard at it and I think you can kind of see that and he's a really good actor and Ben Mendelsohn's a really good actor and I really enjoyed watching him play off Tarkin and I just wish I hadn't been looking at a gelatinous mass with like teeth that looked like they weren't quite like on it's the same with Leia when she goes and her teeth are like floating away from her face I'm like, wow, that looks like when I try to do a Photoshop.
47:40But it's like judging the original special edition job at the heart, isn't it? Because it's just George Lucas saying, look, this is what I can do as a CGI character. And they're saying, look, look what we can do. We can do fake dead humans. But they kind of can't in either case because the technology just isn't there. I think this is merit-coated in my general antipathy and ick toward using these kinds of technologies to reanimate the dead, whereas George Lucas was trying to invent something new. you know we're trying to reach backwards to go forwards and I just have a general ick about all that especially in a film which you know played a blinder quite frankly in recasting Mon Mothma and didn't try to you know do that via CG why would you not just have done everyone else the same way they didn't even know how good they were at that point they didn't even know what Genevieve O 'Reilly could do in that role and they still got it right you know so anyway
48:34Chris Hewitt: I guess because they had Mon Mothma's in basically what, a couple of scenes in Return of the Jedi? Sure, sure. No one has a strong impression of her. No, I do understand that. But at the same time, you know, there was another way. Have you guys heard about the new series they've announced about the Bothans? I'm joking. But many of them died. The Bothans. Oh, I genuinely thought you said the Bothans. I thought it was like a cricket. A bit of Ian Bothans. Many Ian Bothans died to bring us this information. Very good. Speaking of effects, I love how Jimmy Smits turned into Benjamin Bratt and then turned back into Jimmy Smits.
49:11Chris Hewitt: You know what? That was great. It sounds awful. Especially, I feel, I hate myself a little bit because I love Jimmy Smits, but I really wanted Benjamin Bratt there. He's a good one. It really, it bothered me. He was good. He's only got such a brief, he just tells you everything, doesn't he? If you have a small moment, but it's in really, really good, strong, well-written stuff, that moment can really land. And he's, because Ben Bratt doesn't have a huge amount to do in Endor, but he's so memorable and so good and I absolutely love Jimmy Smits and I love Jimmy Smits as Organa but I was like wow God like what an impact you didn't like the scene where he's with Mom Mothma she's going what about your Jedi friend who lives oh yeah I'm just going off to I'm just going off to Alderaan I'm sure it's just for the weekend I'm sure it'll be totally fine and I'm going to mention that Jedi and do you have anyone who you can trust oh yeah I would trust her with my life and it's just all fan service yeah he's almost like in a way that like Benjamin Bratz carefully did not at any point go my daughter will help although that was what I thought he was getting at when he says like I can't leave and I think it was just like the script needs me to be here for the next movie I did wonder that when I wonder so I was watching Andor season 2 and he was becoming more and more prominent as Bail Organa I was like is it canon that Bail Organa was on Alderaan when it blew up and then of course Rogue One I'd forgotten that Rogue One I'm going to Alderaan now.
50:37I'll be back in no time at all. See you soon. I'll be right back. Leave the light on for me. And Leia's comforting Luke. She's like, my dad's died. Everyone's died. My planet's gone. He's like, my God, my old desert grandpa's dead. Who I just met three days ago.
50:53Chris Hewitt: The guy I just knew. Yeah. Oh, bless him. Well, he's one of the Force now. The Force is with him. The Force is with him. I like those guys. I do like those guys. I love those guys. I can't remember the name of the character. The Guardians of the Wills. The Baze Malbus and Chirrut Imwe. Yeah. I love the way he delivers lines. I like his lines. He's got good lines of dialogue. He's got really good. Well, I think if you're going to get, you know, in the end in your movie, you give him something to do. And I really liked his interpretation of the Force. And I remember that sort of got me interested in, oh, I'm interested to see if Tony Gilroy whoever does get into sort of Jedi stuff, and I was really glad to see that in Andor.
51:35I detested the Dr. Everson and Walrus face bit. You watch yourself. Oh, just stop. Oh, I hated that. And also, why is Walrus face's head so fucking big in this? Like, he's weirdly disproportionate in Rogue One. It freaks me out. So presumably then he immediately got off that planet? He immediately left the planet and went to Tatooine. He did. It's fine. And got his arm cut off. You're like, you're lucky you're about to get the next transport out of here to Tatooine. The one piece of kind of, I guess it's fan service that I really, really, really enjoyed was just sort of the rise of the Death Star over the planet.
52:11And if I had a note about that, it's like I would have liked to have seen the Death Star come out of hyperspace. I think that would have been cool. We just see it's there, but there's no sort of whomp and it appears. And I would have liked a whomp. Yeah, I thought that because they said something just dropped out of hyperspace and then you see it sort of looming over the curve of the planet. Yeah, something massive has dropped. And like, I don't know, I just wanted that little moment.
52:30Chris Hewitt: Or if it just appeared from the planet's point of view, suddenly it's there. That fun visual effect, I'd say, to imagine what would the effect of something that enormous entering your gravitational sphere... I want to know that too. Because even if it's outside of the atmosphere of the planet, surely an entity that enormous arriving in the space of the moon would completely, I mean, presumably... It's a water planet. Wouldn't there be tidal waves? It would presumably destroy the planet. like something like that would have some kind of impact on your atmosphere anyway I think a cool visual effect idea would have been to like have somebody watching the sky as this thing arrives and suddenly they're just knocked out by a 300 foot tidal or a hurricane or like I don't know it just that would be quite cool yeah I think so too alright anything else to say before we wrap this bad boy up I like Krennic I feel really bad for Felicity Jones who I think lost all of her lines of dialogue to the edit probably because the character that they ended up with was not the character that they were filming.
53:31She's a fantastic actress given very, very little to do here. And I'm really, really glad that it gave us Andor. Yeah. And I like, yeah, I like the Scarif-y bits and I like that it's got this sense of, at the time it felt quite ambitious that it was all about, like it was, as Vinay said, fuck your hero's journey. But I also think it didn't mean to fuck the hero's journey. I think it, well, I think maybe it did mean it and then they tried to un-mean it and then at the end it meant nothing. There we go. That's my two cents.
54:03Chris Hewitt: And that was Sophie saying something nice about the films. I will find something that I don't like. I hate, hate, hate Vader's castle on Mustafar. I think it's fucking stupid. It looks like it looks like fucking Sauron's holiday home. Yes, it does very much. I do wonder what people are doing like when they build these horrible lairs and they're so dark and it's literally got like lava fountains coming out the side of it. It's a classic, are we the bad guys? Yeah, it really is. What does he do all day? Does he have a pool table? Having seen Anakin Skywalker's, as in Hayden Christensen's one, you can totally understand.
54:36Yeah, this is how a villain would live. Like, totally. That's 100 % the place we'd live. I mean, talk about B2 emo. Right, exactly. I don't understand why he chooses to summer on Mustafar, the place where he got horribly burned and he thinks he killed the love of his life. But I know there's, quote unquote, canon for that and why he lives there. Reclaiming his trauma. Yeah, it's still fucking stupid, and the place looks rubbish. But apart from that, it's great.
55:01Chris Hewitt: This has been a really interesting reappraisal of Rogue One. Hell's Bells? Positive things. You don't have to say positive things. Okay, nice. There's just things. Look, like I say, I thought the emotion of this did hit harder post-Andor. I cared more about people when they died than I did originally. And I think some scenes definitely kind of benefit, but it just does feel so up and down, because every time it becomes Jyn Erso's story, you're like, why is she here? I don't even know her. I don't care. You're not wrong. I'm just going here. We're just going arms folded. Who are you? A little bit.
55:35And I realize that's bad. I mean, I'll be honest. So at one point, you guys did a podcast without me where you ranked What? Star Wars characters. Oh, that wasn't me. You did. Yeah. And you put, for example, Salacious Crumb, a character literally just cackles like everyone else just did. Above Gin Erso. I mean, I stand by that, to be fair. Way more memorable. Like, I have family members, actually, who were so offended by that. They were like, that is straight up, like, old man sexism. That's what that is. We have redone the canonical Empire list of great Star Wars movie characters. Gin Erso isn't even on the fucking list at this point.
56:16I mean, honestly, that's easier to understand than... First, I don't think
56:18Chris Hewitt: we were the ones ranking it. I think that was a reader poll that we were going through. Blame the readers. Blame the readers. I don't think we were the ones choosing it. But even if we were the ones who choose it, yes, Salacious Crumb is a better character than Jyn Erso. Well, I have to say, having watched it again last night, I'm coming around to that point of view. I went on Wikipedia a bit earlier because I wanted to try and find out. Because watching the film, I was like, Jesus, it really does feel like all of her lines have been cut in the edit because she doesn't say anything. She doesn't speak.
56:48and she doesn't have an arc to speak of either, really, if you really squint and try to work out what is her story in this film. So I went on Wikipedia to find out how many lines of dialogue she has, and I don't think their metric is all that accurate, but they claim in their weird little bot thing that she has 119 lines, which feels a lot. That's actually not, that's quite a lot, I think. But for context, BB-8 is given 125. That's harsh. I really want to know, they can't be going by screenplay. they have to be going by.
57:20Chris Hewitt: Could Generso be saved with a 20-part Disney Plus season, series type thing? I think we kind of know now that anybody can be saved in the right hands, in the right circumstances, with the right amount of magic dust, can't they? Because I think there are so many people who have died under the weight and the pressures and the enormity of the Star Wars machine and they're no less talented. Gareth Edwards is a remarkable director and there are so many great writers. says, my God, the list of writers were involved in this film. It's insane. Accredited and uncredited. Uncredited. Talk about nameless sacrifices.
57:56Chris Hewitt: Oh, my God. Yep. It's insane. And so, you know, I don't think it was a pre-written, predetermined natural occurrence that Gilroy succeeded with Andor, but you only hope it can happen again, I think, if it happens to Jenner, so that would be very nice. Well, Sophie, rebellions are built on hope. Oh, God. Rebellions are built on hope. And podcasts are built on hate. No, not hate. Not hate. Just, like I say, just mild befuddlements, I think, sometimes on my part. Fear needs to anger. Anger needs to dislike. Hate needs to suffering. And I'd quite like to have gone to Scarif before. Oh, I bet it was a fabulous holiday resort.
58:38Until then, as the Empire moved in, if you're going on holiday to Scarif, you're just as bad as the Empire. And then it just slid into an open war zone. and just, I'd have loved to have seen that storyline in Andor. Like those ads in the background, like Andor Twitter.
58:52Chris Hewitt: All right. Well, listen, if you've come here as a fan of Rogue One, I apologize for everything that's happened over the last time or so. You haven't made it to this part. Let's be honest. It's triumphant. It is. You've turned on yourself. I haven't. No, I still really like it. I'm just saying, I... Your eyes have been opened. I see its weaknesses very clearly in the light of Andor. I see its strengths much more clearly in the light of the Akron. light yes and what about in the light of the book of Boba Fett well it's fucking Citizen Kane five star masterpiece at that point isn't it or Obi-Wan Kenobi Citizen K2S now yes well that's it we're done here that's it for our Rogue One post and or reappraisal spoiler special hope you've enjoyed it all that remains now is for me to say goodbye to my three colleagues of such lethal cunning Sophie Petzl goodbye
59:47Chris Hewitt: it's the worst chinner so i've ever heard goodbye james dyer more gullet
59:58lies deceptions why why was this whole thing just just us doing saw guerrera
1:00:07Chris Hewitt: unbelievable helena hara do you have a saw guerrera no sorry i was just gonna say you were gearing up to say something there I was going to say hope. Hope. And I was going to do just as good an impression of Carrie Fisher. She sort of does like hope. Hope. Hope. Hope. Hope. Hope.
1:00:32See, I didn't want to pick the microphone. That's why I didn't do that.
1:00:36Chris Hewitt: See, I'm standing back. I'm standing back. Yeah, yeah, good. Well done. Never gets most delicious crumb. No, I've got crumb all over the place. Thanks for, oh, come on. Thanks for listening. See you next time. Bye-bye.
Andor is no more. Tony Gilroy's phenomenal Star Wars TV show has finished its two-season run and, unless there's a great disturbance in the Force, that's the last we'll see of Diego Luna's Cassian Andor, who ended that show (spoiler alert) about to head off to the place we first met him in Rogue One back in 2016. And this retro spoiler special is indeed focused on that movie, with Chris Hewitt, Helen O'Hara, James Dyer, and Sophie Petzal coming together to rewatch and reappraise Rogue One, and reassess it both in the light of its famously troubled production (which saw Gilroy parachuted into director Gareth Edwards' shoot), and in the wake of Andor. Does it add extra emotional weight to the story? Has anyone on the team changed their minds about Rogue One in the nine years since its release? Does James still reckon it's 'triumphant'? The answers to all those questions, and more, lie within. Enjoy.