

A spoiler special discussion of Clayface, the third film in James Gunn and Peter Safran’s DCU, focusing on Matt Hagen’s origin into the DC villain Clayface—his shape-shifting, revenge arc, body horror, and tragic ending.
Chris Hewitt hosts. Helen O’Hara and Amon Warman are colleagues/podcast co-hosts. Director James Watkins (British horror filmmaker known for Eden Lake and The Woman in Black) is interviewed via Zoom. They also discuss performances by Tom Reyes Harris, Noomi Aki, and Max Minghella; Aaron Paul appears briefly as Matt’s father.
The film is praised for character-driven violence, audience complicity, and a noir/classic monster tone. Shape-shifting is treated as disguise and emotional consequence, not random combat. The Vesuvius nightclub sequence is highlighted as the turning point and best set piece.
A “Vesuvius” rampage where Matt changes disguises mid-assault; a brutal disfigurement/surgery-triggering sequence that earns the 18 rating; an improvisation-heavy scene where Matt impersonates Cory’s identity with Mia; a psychosexual “sleep observation” scene; and the final sewer ending where Matt creates a lonely version of Caitlin.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
James Watkins discusses why the term 'Clayface' is not used in the film.
“Welcome to the Zemper Podcast spoiler special.”
Watkins explains the standalone nature of the film and its character focus.
“You can just go and see it and it's a story about a guy and his journey and you can enjoy it on its own merits.”
A deep dive into the filming and significance of a key scene showcasing Matt's transformations.
“You know, at this point on his journey, he's on a vengeful path.”
Watkins reflects on the film's violent scenes and their narrative consequences.
“Violence has consequences and they show it and they show the nastiness of it.”
The discussion focuses on Matt's internal conflicts and how they drive his actions.
“But unfortunately, those voices in his head overwhelmed him, I suppose.”
Exploring the improvisational elements in a striking scene and its implications.
“which must have been an interesting discussion to have with a lot of actors.”
Discussing the complex relationship dynamics and emotional overlaps between characters.
“It was actually funny, but also kind of captured the sense of the character, I suppose.”
Delving into the psychosexual elements and emotional complexities of pivotal scenes.
“Never seen that before James that's a new one.”
Examining the motivations behind character actions and the theme of redemption in storytelling.
“the murder of John was that something that you needed to do in a way to put Matt in a place where he's beyond redemption at that point?”
Analyzing the climax of the film and the poignant ending involving the main character.
“What's really interesting about that scene as well is that we don't, for obvious reasons, because there's an ambiguity to whenever Caitlin comes home, whether John is John or John is Matt, but we don't see John die.”
Discussing the technical aspects and challenges faced while filming key scenes.
“And then, of course, you have the true ending of the movie, I guess, or the true ending for Matt, although it might be a beginning.”
The discussion focuses on the origins of the Clayface film and its inspirations.
“It was his pitch for this that made James Gunn go, ooh, I hadn't planned to do a Clayface movie.”
Analyzing the character development of Clayface and the nuances of villainy.
“It was just a straight ahead, kind of quite classic noir in a way.”
Exploring the implications of Clayface's transformation and its moral ramifications.
“So maybe he's the only one in Gotham who thinks, maybe this guy is able to reshape his appearance.”
Discussing the visual styles and thematic elements present in the film.
“just even impersonating John is crossing a line of no return, right?”
Highlighting significant sequences in the film and their emotional impact.
“It leads to the very end of the movie, which I think I was really, really impressed by the last shot.”
An in-depth discussion of the standout sequences in the film.
“I think Andy Marcian should appear at the end of every sex scene.”
Discussing the most unsettling aspects of the film beyond the gore.
“And so by the time that the very upsetting, objectively upsetting eyeball stuff came along, I was almost like, well, this is at least better than that stuff was.”
Analysis of the character dynamics and the impact of key deaths.
“anything with veins anything with people injecting stuff, you know, or something as simple as it.”
Exploring the legal ramifications of the character's actions in the film.
“Of course, it's his subconsciousness manifesting in an interesting way.”
Discussion on the actors' performances and their character interpretations.
“I think some part of what was still Matt was hoping that Cody would convince him otherwise.”
Examining the romantic dynamics and connections between characters.
“Yeah, Corey Johnson's American, but he lives here.”
Discusses the emotional depth of Matt and Caitlin's relationship in the film.
“about his background they have this similar experience of being betrayed by those close to them of being, you know, on the verge of something great and then having the rug pulled out from under them.”
Examines Caitlin's awareness of the dangers in her scientific work and the moral complexities involved.
“We'll get to that and the Batman, or lack thereof, in a second.”
Discusses the visual effects and representation of Clayface in the film.
“I don't think she thought it would be an action, you know, scene scenario.”
Highlights Rob Brydon's role and significance as a British entertainer in the movie.
“A couple of last things, we want to go about eight or nine minutes left.”
Analyzes the absence of Batman in the film and its effect on the story's atmosphere.
“Helen is Batman-splaining to a mom right now.”
Discussion on the character of Clayface and its significance in Gotham's world-building.
“So he is like, this is this American dream figure.”
Exploration of James Gunn's approach to building the DC Universe and audience reception.
“I don't think Batman's in Man of Tomorrow No, because apart from anything else the Batman part two is still coming out.”
Debate about the challenges of having multiple Batman portrayals in film.
“the Batman part 2 and sort of finish that oh that would be such a shame I want to live in that world I want to bathe in that world.”
Hosts share their final thoughts on the film and discuss upcoming episodes.
“They don't let me in, even when I've been invited, which is very rare.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Empire+, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:14Chris Hewitt: Hello, pod. I'm Chris Hewitt, or am I? And welcome to the latest in our series of spoiler special podcast, or is it dedicated to the latest film in the DCU, or is it etc, etc, etc, etc. It's called Clayface. And joining me to discuss this over the next 50 minutes or so are two colleagues of such lethal cunning disguising herself as Amon Warman. It's Helen O 'Hara. Hello. Hello. And disguising himself as Helen O 'Hara. It's Amon Warman. I love the score.
0:53Fair.
0:54Chris Hewitt: How we're going to keep this up? for the next 50 minutes. I don't know. I may have painted myself into a corner, but it's all. But anyway, no, it's Amon and it's Helen and it's me and we're all who we say we are, which is nice because this is a film about subterfuge. Dr. Peyton Westlake, Darkman himself, would love this movie. He'd be like, oh my God, it's about people pretending to be other people with a face. He would probably say, oh my God, it is my movie. It is my movie. Complimentary. Complimentary, of course, of course. This is what, the third film in the DCU, James Gunn, Peter Safran's DCU.
1:28Chris Hewitt: We'll discuss it in a few seconds, whether it is the best or most successful. Not at the box office, although it might make more money than Supergirl. But we'll talk about it in a few seconds. But first, that's here from the man who directed this movie, who is, of course, the fantastic British director of great horror films, things like Eden Lake and The Woman in Black. And speak no evil, It is, of course, the great James Watkins, and I spoke to him over Zoom a couple of weeks ago, and we got into all the spoilers you could possibly hope to eat. Enjoy. James Watkins, director of Clayface. Welcome to the Zemper Podcast spoiler special.
2:09Chris Hewitt: How are you? Yeah, good to see you, Chris. Nice talking to you. Likewise, likewise. So, James, I've only seen your movie once, so if I get anything wrong, then please do come over here and tackle me. this is one of the reasons why I'm not in the room with you so I can't be tackled but correct me if I'm wrong James is the word Clayface actually mentioned in the film at all I don't think it is which is clearly a deliberate strategy I mean yeah it's an origination story right so I guess he hasn't really become well I don't know this is a spoiler podcast I mean, he arrives at who he arrives at at the end of the movie, Clayface.
2:56So in a way, throughout the whole story, he's been a version of Matt Hagen developing and becoming the monster that is Clayface. So it would be a bit, you know. On the nose? Early, I think.
3:08Chris Hewitt: Because I can imagine there are cheesy versions of this movie where someone would say, hey, that guy's got a Clayface or something like that. And he'd go, ooh, that's interesting. Yeah, I don't love that kind of writing. no keep it subtle leave people guessing leave them come up with their own theories yeah well look mike flanagan hassein amini are two real world-class screenwriters you know they really you know when i first read mike's script it had real just kind of the journey of the character the tragedy of the character the emotion all those things that we kept leaning into so yeah their quality absolutely um and before we get into the film proper as well uh another thing that isn't mentioned on screen at any point again unless i'm completely wrong about this is a certain masked vigilante in gotham city now was that something you know was that something that you and james gunn talked about like you talk about planting seeds maybe leaving little hints of batman in there or or how did you approach that i mean it was always just the one of the things that most appealed to me about the film was the script was that it was a standalone story it's a different character in gotham in the way that the joker is you know and and you know there's many million people live in gotham and this is matt hagan's story so i think you know if you'd have crowbarred it in it would have just felt unnatural or you know unorganic or forced and so i think i think um what i love about the idea of clayface is that you don't have to have some sort of PhD in Gotham Studies or DCU Universe Studies to go and see the movie.
4:44You can just go and see it and it's a story about a guy and his journey and you can enjoy it on its own merits.
4:50Chris Hewitt: I love the idea that those PhDs actually exist and they probably do let's be honest. They probably do. There's probably in dissertations. There probably is. I thought it was really interesting as well. There were moments during this when Matt is beginning to understand himself and what he's capable of doing that i thought how the hell would batman even fight this guy i mean this is this is an unwinnable war he's got quite a sort of skill set power set whatever you want to call it um absolutely that notion and it's one of the things i really wanted to lean into so there's a scene later on in the movie where he comes into back to the nightclub um that kicks off all his problems and he's on a sort of journey of revenge i suppose and he's discovering his powers uh as he as he sort of tries to get his way in through the nightclub and the sort of darkly of him discovering his powers from a character point of view but also in terms of those power sets i had i had a lot of conversations particularly with the stunts department saying no he can't suddenly become a navy seal or a ninja you know warrior because i i see that in movies a lot where ordinary people suddenly develop this incredible ability to fight and the thing for me it was like his power is his ability to change to disguise himself to shape shift and that is an incredible power that already gives him such a huge advantage and so every sort of beat within that scene is fueled by character and by his ability rather than being a sort of generic fight and that's that's really important to me i'm so glad you brought that scene up because that vesuvius scene is is incredible uh where he you know he is he is blowing his top like vesuvius in in that moment and and he is flitting from place to place and from person to person and it's it's it's really terrific and how did you how did you track that scene in terms of matt's transformations in terms of being careful with him showing his true face all that sort of stuff well it was a scene that evolved because it wasn't originally there and i wanted to have a moment of you know if you're storming the castle you know if you see an old i don't know not robin hood movie before they get to made marion in the final castle keep or whatever there's a lot of stages to it right so i wanted to have that stage and then so i worked on the notion of the scene um initially he tries to bluff his way in there's quite a knowing reference to carlito's way as he does that and then at the table in carlito's way we watched that film but then yeah i did a lot of storyboarding i did it was that was probably the most exhausting scene because i was trying to work it out as i was shooting so every day i'd shoot a scene and then in lunch or in the evening or between takes i'd go and we'd i'd work and i'd work on the beats and the boards and because you need to track his point of view very specifically to understand what he wants you know that scene could so easily be confusing because it's purely visual storytelling so to try and follow the point of view and give john the editor something that he could work with it it took quite a lot of and there's a lot of mosaic pieces to try and make it work but it was it was a good challenge yeah probably the most trickiest thing i've ever shot i can imagine just a sheer number of moving parts uh as well and you have to keep track uh for the audience of of where matt is who matt is uh keep track of other characters being aware of matt as well those moments where he reveals himself yeah to people like and tone as well because you You want almost that permission to enjoy.
8:20You know, at this point on his journey, he's on a vengeful path. And I think that thing of that sort of audience surrogate, that vicarious thrill that we have when we watch revenge movies, people getting back in the way that in normal life we generally can't and being on that road with him and then enjoying it, enjoying the kind of little self-referential moments of glee. And then the audience is so locked in with him so that when you go later in the movie and maybe he carries on, it makes the audience question. and so that I think becomes even back to films like Eden Lake I've always liked to do that thing where you kind of go okay I'm on site I'm on site am I on site?
8:59so I think that's an interesting dance with an audience
9:02Chris Hewitt: yeah very much so and I want to talk about that moment where the dance takes us past that point of no return for Matt in a second but you're absolutely right about the kind of rip-roaring rampage of revenge that we are complicit, we are there with Matt throughout this rampage of revenge, and we're enjoying it. It's not always fun for him. I don't think the murder of Corey, for example, is a particularly fun moment for him. No, no. But certainly in Vesuvius it is. And you have this moment, you have this kind of sense with the scene where Sabo disfigures Matt, where you actually almost earn that.
9:41Chris Hewitt: You're making a down payment for his retribution later on. can you talk about that scene because this film's an 18 and that scene reminded me a bit of the scene in robocop where they kill murphy and it's absolutely horrific was that something that was on your mind in terms of the no holds barred nature of that scene yeah it's a very tough scene that scene and there's a reason why this film is an 18 and uh but as you say it kicks off his journey and uh and it's an unpleasant thing i don't know i look at scorsese films maybe or brian de palma and the violence in those movies. Violence has consequences and they show it and they show the nastiness of it.
10:20I know people have different tolerances for things and that scene we're pushing it right hard to the limit.
10:26Chris Hewitt: Did you push it further in some ways or was that as far as you wanted to go? There was a couple of moments I remember talking to people about we could have gone further but I think we've gone pretty damn far and also Also, I think even in the mix, I remember someone saying to me, oh, we can make more of his screams. And I said, no, we don't need to. It's not. There's plenty enough there. And actually, for a roller coaster ride, right, you want it to be pushing people to the limit. But you don't want them to feel that the roller coaster is going to come off the tracks. You don't want people. Do you know what I mean?
11:04It's got that thing of finding a point.
11:05Chris Hewitt: If you lose people early on, you're not going to get them back. I think so. And that's always, I think, a fine line for horror directors, and you are one, and this is a horror film, to tread. But what's really interesting about that is that it does give Matt permission to go on that rip-roaring rampage of revenge. What I found really interesting about that is that the first couple of acts of retribution are almost accidental. Yes. With Eddie Marston, that is clearly an accident with Corey. I don't know whether Matt is stepping into that trailer with that intention. No, indeed. Very deliberately.
11:46And I guess the idea of the inner struggle, the man becoming the monster, and the idea that, you know, Caitlyn says to him the best revenge is just to live your life well. and the idea that actually you know most of us when we're wronged whatever things in life whatever we you know we confess that we can have these things and we try and push them down and often we can't act upon them and but with matt with the nanos that kind of amplification of his the rising of his vengeful primitive urges i suppose which is what's unlocked and so you know rationally the rational thing is as naomi says let it go but the irrational the sort of the those primal atavistic caveman things that we have within us that's those rise up in that you know whether it's fueled by vengeance fueled by retribution for fueled by in it however in a dark night sort of a way not not the dark night but you know in a kind of way of you know for protecting caitlin because out of love, even though it might be messed up, you know?
12:54So those are all really primal forces that are within Matt and they're kind of bubbling up through him. So, yeah, absolutely. I think there's a heartbreak with the Corey scene. It's not, he didn't, he came in just wanting to silence those voices in his head. But unfortunately, those voices in his head overwhelmed him, I suppose.
13:13Chris Hewitt: How much does Matt's internal struggle shape how he approaches, for want of a better word, those moments where he does dispatch the people who have wronged him? Eddie's character, for example, he literally silences him, he rips out his throat. With Corey, he brings his best friend literally inside him. which is he's definitely fueled by the sort of unconscious forces within him you know and sort of slow kind of overtake of those forces i suppose they kind of finally i suppose in some sense consume him there's a that moment where after the death of cory he assumes cory's identity and you have this lovely thread that runs through the movie of people playing matt playing them uh which must have been an interesting discussion to have with a lot of actors.
14:04And he plays that scene with Mia and he completely improvises it.
14:08Chris Hewitt: That's a really, really striking scene. Can you talk about that? Was that something that was always in the script? I guess you're playing with the idea of actors and layers of personality. It was initially scripted as improv. And then we got into a conversation where it was like, well, hang on a minute. When would he have had time to learn the lines? and then so so it actually became more interesting leaning into the improv of it all and then leaning into the you know what's he saying and the sort of i got a meta-ness of what he's saying in terms of the truth of like you you've hurt people you've made me hurt people that didn't want to hurt and all that sort of stuff and so then we added the lines you know is he off script and you know and all of that and just tried to lean into that because i thought it It was actually funny, but also kind of captured the sense of the character, I suppose.
15:00Chris Hewitt: Yeah, yeah. It's a really, really striking scene. But all the way through this as well, James, as much fun as we're having watching Matt do this, you are tracking very carefully the development of his relationship with Caitlin. There is something there. There is this love triangle between Caitlin and John and Matt. but how much of it is real how much of it is caitlin being in love with the joy of her own creation how much of it is matt being in love with the idea that suddenly he's been given his life back by this woman is there something there really between the two of them for you i mean i think it's a good ambiguity i wouldn't answer but fully answer the question i think there's definitely a connection between them they have a shared background they have a shared project but yes that overlap so for example the scene where naomi is watching doing what we call the sleep observation scene where they're in bed and then tom is having a dream and she's trying to track his unconscious and then he sort of turns into her and then he's having this kind of sexy dream and they're you know it's almost having this kind of love scene with himself and her in bed and she's watching naomi's watching that there's this kind of psycho psychosexual scene to that you know she's watching it fascinated and appalled but she's is she fascinated as a scientist is she fascinated as a woman you know those the overlap between those things the bleed between those things is i think what makes it really interesting you know is matt that that blurring of the lines you know it's a thing i think we had a line in the script at one point that we took out but it was you know the idea of transference and doctors falling for their patients and patients falling for their doctors i think it's still there even though the line's not you know so there is definitely like um yeah a definite blurring of the love story which i think is interesting again i love this you have a knack for bringing up scenes i wanted to discuss before uh i've asked a question about it which is amazing because that scene that's a terrific terrific scene uh and you're absolutely right psychosexual it's weird it's kind of fucked up yeah i i just remember working on that developing the idea for that scene and and it just suddenly and i was like yeah wouldn't it be cool for her to have this kind of weird sort of threesome with herself and it'd be really like what's real what isn't what does she feel about him what does she feel you know how much of that and playing those boundaries so um and it's a difficult scene because you it's the kind of getting the balance right so the the sort of there's a kind of uncomfortable laughter in that scene which i've heard but it's good laughter you know what i mean as people watching it going i don't not sure how i should feel about this which i think is really interesting cinematically yeah um because it's so it is sort of transgressive and um i don't know if you look at a an obvious hero of mine in terms of this film is David Cronenberg and I mean that's what David Cronenberg did so many times you know so I've kind of leaned into that a bit.
18:12Chris Hewitt: Yeah I know The Fly was an inspiration for you as well and The Fly also has this very very strange love triangle in it the Cronenberg and this one is a love triangle that resolves in a really really interesting way also and you get Matt to that point in Vesuvius where we're totally on his side even as he's doing something that I've never seen before in a horror film where he pours his blood into a bad guy's face and then forces that guy to hemorrhage by bringing his blood up through his face into his own face. Never seen that before James that's a new one. I know, well I was trying to work out a way that you know the deaths could be again from him an organic and original and so I was again focused on not just you know blowing someone's head off so it was just again that's very much trying to find that out rightly so and genuinely organic as well which is nice but that is the point we're completely on Matt's side the last 10 minutes of the movie the murder of John was that something that you needed to do in a way to put Matt in a place where he's beyond redemption at that point?
19:27I mean did you need to do it? I don't know. I mean but from a storytelling point of view perhaps from a storytelling point of view it's the journey that he's on I suppose and that's the heartbreak of it I suppose. And credit to Max Minghella as well because when Max came on board that character of John could quite easily be the third wheel and quite a thankless task in a relationship and worked quite hard with Hussain and with Max to try and flesh out his character the humor he really you know I think he really liked John yeah he's a good guy but he's not a sort of Dudley do-right good guy you know he's got humor and he's got heart and so I think yeah I mean he has crossed the line into whatever you want to call it villainy but I suppose at the same time I'm on side with him I mean I'm not on side with him but I'm understanding his motivations you know what you know Matt slash Clayface is doing is it's correct for his thinking his thinking might be wrong I think you know his thinking is messed up so yeah he is on a journey to being however you want to see it deluded or whatever but but it felt like the right way to get to that right tragic ending.
20:52You know, it's, I don't know. I mean, it's a bit of a highfalutin comparison, but if you look at Hamlet or Macbeth, you know, they do a lot of really dark things, but in their heads, they're motivated.
21:04Chris Hewitt: What's really interesting about that scene as well is that we don't, for obvious reasons, because there's an ambiguity to whenever Caitlin comes home, whether John is John or John is Matt, but we don't see John die. we don't see that scene. The last time we see them, John is at Matt's apartment. Did you shoot anything? Did you choose to leave it out? Or was that always the way it was presented? It was always that way. Never shot anything. Okay. And that's really interesting as well, because the last time John, there are hints from him that he suspects Matt. Yes. But in your mind, what happened at that point?
21:42Chris Hewitt: Did Matt go there with intentions to do what he did to John? Was he worried that John might be on to him in some way? Did he want to make a point for Caitlin? I think he was just genuinely driven by his love for Caitlin, threatened by John, and wanting to put himself in John's position, I suppose. I think maybe he would have thought maybe he could get away with it as John. I don't know. And then she discovers the body, and then maybe he hasn't quite finished cleaning up the scene when she arrives. I mean, there's many different reads you could have on it. But I think in his mind, John became an obstacle for his future life with Caitlin, I suppose.
22:27Chris Hewitt: And you have this classic monster movie ending as well, where the monster is tormented and asks his love, his true love, from his point of view anyway, to step in and take care of him, to euthanize him, I guess, in a way. there is of course the ending I want to talk about the true ending in the sewers but can you talk about getting that scene right the scene with Caitlin and Clayface as he begins to really turn into this amorphous blob for the first time well it was very difficult to see and shoot we shot it all practically with lots of you know Tom in a suit and you know lots of hydraulics and things of him going into the floor and all sorts of stuff and then just so I had enough reference so that when we could shooting light reference or whatever so that when you can get into the vfx of it or you can build on and you've got but again it's trying to track that american werewolf in london is a really good comparison a really good template because that scene you know the death by cop scene as it were at the end of american werewolf in london that sense of how much humanity remains in the overtake of the monster you know are there little glimmers of humanity and i think there is um and then but obviously the monster is sort of overtaking so it was always trying to find the the human emotional human story within i guess a set piece i suppose you know that's set pieces i think in movies sometimes can become alienating because they're just i don't know two people flying around the sky beating the crap out of each other sometimes you And so I think this is a way of trying to land that, I suppose.
24:08Chris Hewitt: And then, of course, you have the true ending of the movie, I guess, or the true ending for Matt, although it might be a beginning. And this really, really very, very poignant final shot of him in the sewers taking his powers to a new level. But it's so lonely. He's creating a version of Caitlin. He's doing a dance. He's now two people. that's incredible but it's also a really really heartbreaking image to end on, can you talk about that? It was one of the things that most attracted me to Mike Flanagan's script was the ending and that was there and that idea of you've taken Matt from the penthouse to the sewer and there he is alone and isolated and trying to you know create this bomb i suppose or to try and create this this wish fulfillment um of of what he could have and the loneliness of that image the notion of the loneliness and the pain and leaving on that i thought you know guillermo del toro talks a lot about you know horror films the best horror films having heart as well as horror and and and i thought that was really there in the script and really wanted to make sure we honored it and and then actually in terms of those last two shots of the movie i took an awful lot of attention you know what's how the pain you see in his eye the quality of his scream the human within the monster you know blending both performance from tom and a more monstrous scream so trying to land all those things were were you know very took a lot of precision james it's been a pleasure talking to you thanks chris take care see you soon okay see you later all right okay that was james watkins or is it etc etc talking about clayface and now let's talk about Clayface.
25:57Chris Hewitt: Amon, let's start with you because you're the big DC guy and you were on set of this movie. I was not on set, but I did write the Empire feature. That is where you feel. And you wrote the Empire feature. You spoke to James Watkins. You spoke to Tom Reyes Harris. You spoke to Naomi Aki. You spoke to lots of people. All those people and Max Mingana as well. But I'm guessing not Aaron Paul who neither of us knew was in this movie. Neither of us. Even after we saw it, Aaron Paul cameos in one shot as Jimmy No Nut whatever his name is who's the dad of Matt Hagen so there's a scene in the Vesuvius Helen's looking very blank at me there's a scene in the Vesuvius where he's rampaging through the Vesuvius and he appears as was it Jimmy Nut Jimmy Nut Jimmy Nut a lot Jimmy Big Nut whatever his name is his dad is some sort of Gotham criminal with Nut in his name and there's a shot of him and it's Aaron Paul.
26:54Chris Hewitt: And the reason I didn't recognize him is because he looks nothing like Aaron Paul. At least as I recognize Aaron Paul, which is looking like Aaron Paul. And he didn't look like Aaron Paul. So irony, of course, of this movie in that the famous person shows up for one shot and looks nothing like himself in the movie in which the main protagonist, the main hero, can look like everyone. So why didn't he look more like Aaron Paul? Is what I'm saying. Anyway, there was apparently more of Aaron Paul, but they cut it. And so then they left just that one shot of Aaron Paul who's in the movie not looking like Aaron Paul.
27:23Chris Hewitt: Well, thank you for that incredibly detailed, some would say overly detailed cat joke. I'm exhausted, quite frankly, after that. But I'm on, you're the big DC guy. What did you make of this? Were you anticipated? Can someone please be me? I'm three podcasts into a five podcast stretch, one of which I didn't even do. And I'm so tired right now. But I'm on, were you anticipating this movie and did a payoff for you? I was anticipating this movie in part because Mike Flanagan, who was the original script writer of this film. The originator of this film, in fact. It was his pitch for this that made James Gunn go, ooh, I hadn't planned to do a Clayface movie.
28:07Chris Hewitt: I certainly hadn't planned to do a Batman villain movie before we have a Batman. But fuck it, I'm in. Yeah. But he was taking inspiration from the Feet of Clay Batman animated series episodes, which I absolutely know it well love I actually watched it this week did you? yeah I did some of us did our prep for this one Chris Helen I've been very busy I was at Legoland yeah of course how silly of me but those episodes are fantastic they have stood the test of time it's been really cool actually to see people refinding that episode where can I find this episode? is it on HBO Max or something? it's on HBO Max okay I have the Blu-ray at home as well just saying yeah but yes it's been really cool to see people seeking that out in the wake of Clayface hitting cinemas because it's a fantastic two-parter and yeah Mike Fandham has taken a lot of inspiration from that and Clayface is a really interesting character he's a very tragic villain and I do feel that we get some of that in this film I think it's very really effectively I think the performances especially Noomi Aki who is just on a fantastic run right now I think is great they really lean into the body horror of this in a big way.
29:21And when they do, it's really impressive and gross and nasty. And one of the things that I'm impressed by with good horror films is that to create new ways and fresh ways to bump people off is a hard thing to do given how much horror films and how many deaths there have been.
29:45Chris Hewitt: A lot of people have been bumped off. especially if you include everyone who dies in Avengers Infinity War I think we're in the quadrillions quite a lot yeah but this film finds new ways to bump people off that are really rooted in character that I think are actually really really impressively done yeah so yeah I've got some quibbles with a couple of things they do story wise which I'm sure we're going to get into but by and large I thought this was really really well done alright Hellspells you there's nothing that you don't know by bumping people off in interesting ways. That's true. But did this give you any new ideas?
30:20So many, yeah. If I ever get like shape-shifting-y gooey powers, I'm set after this movie. It's a technical term, yes. It's a technical term. I really enjoyed this. I started writing a review for another publication that started off as a three-star review, but then like I didn't really... Morphed. Yeah, I didn't really have very much negative to say about it, so it ended up a bit higher than that. I just, I really, really liked it. I thought it was really well done. I thought that there was just enough plot. It wasn't, you know, burdened down with introducing 16 other ancillary DC characters that we might see in the future or not.
30:56It was just a straight ahead, kind of quite classic noir in a way. You know, it's a, and it really, the extent to which it is a fall from grace is really quite impressive. I think a lot of other super villain focused stories, you know, the Venoms and the God help us Morbiuses and stuff like that, have, and even the Jokers, have been concerned with giving the super villain a lot of humanity. And I think what this one does is it gives the guy at the beginning a huge amount of humanity. He makes him hugely sympathetic, incredibly likable. So you're actually rooting for him a lot longer than you probably should be.
31:36But it does turn him full villain at a certain point. And I think that's a really interesting way to go. And that's one of the things I thought was most, most impressive about this.
31:47Chris Hewitt: The audience complicity is very, very interesting. I talked about this a little bit with James Watkins. It almost feels like there should be a kind of matometer on the screen, like how much the audience are rooting for him. Are rooting for him right now, yeah. You get him to the Vesuvius sequence and you're really rooting for him because he's righting it wrong and he's killing the people who did him bad. And then you get to the stuff at the end. Exactly. and you're oh god fuck I like this guy oh shit are we the baddies what happened to the nice guy yeah that kind of feeds into my biggest note on the film which is what happens after that Vesuvius sequence because even though yes he's killing everybody in that scene there's a part of you at least there was for me and I'm guessing there'll be others in the audience you'll feel a similar way in that the people he's bumping off, they're not good people.
32:46They're mobsters, pretty much, and goons. Yeah, and we've seen them do wrong to our protagonists, so, you know, you're kind of, it's justified vengeance in a way. And so, yes, even though he's doing villainous stuff, you're not feeling bad about who he's killing, you're not feeling bad about why he's doing it. He kills John, the Max Minguella character, and John is a good guy. And we see that, or we don't see that while it happens offscreen, I feel like if we were to see that on screen, that would really be the real downfall. But that's why you don't see it. And I think that's what's... I actually think that's a superb choice, if I'm honest.
33:26Because I think, first of all, you lose the reveal. The reveal there, when she goes into the other room, is devastating. Did the reveal take you by surprise? No, it did not take me by surprise, because I thought that was probably him pretending to be John. So it wasn't a complete surprise.
33:40Chris Hewitt: The only question was, was John dead? Was John dead or was John going to walk in and try and shoot him or something? Or arrest him? But it was a surprise that I didn't know John was dead. I thought that wasn't John, but that was about as far as I sort of decided. And I think the chilling effect of that was really, really worth not showing you the confrontation. You don't really need to see him kill a good guy. You don't need to see that happen. All you need to know is that that's now who he is. I don't think you need to see the death I it's interesting because they didn't film it and I asked James Watkins if he thought if he kind of had a headcanon for what happened because John goes to Matt's apartment and heavily insinuates that he suspects Matt of some chicanery I don't think he quite put two and two together because he knows what his fiance does for a living and he knows that she's been working with Matt.
34:41Chris Hewitt: So maybe he's the only one in Gotham who thinks, maybe this guy is able to reshape his appearance.
34:50Chris Hewitt: I'm very, I just think there's a step missing between that sequence, between that scene, where he goes to Matt's apartment and they have that kind of, it's quite a sinister little interaction that they have. And then afterwards, and, you know, I asked James Watkins if he kind of figured out what happened and why Matt then went to John's apartment. Did he go there with the intention of killing him? All that sort of stuff. For me, actually, weirdly enough, I think I would have liked to have seen Matt do it. I just think it would have been an interesting thing to see because then we would have been there with him when he tips over the edge.
35:23Chris Hewitt: Maybe it's good because now we can speculate endlessly about his motive, right? Was he doing it out of self-preservation because he knew that John was on to him so he kills the only cop in Gotham who could actually finger him for the Vesuvius mass murders? and the deaths of Eddie Marsan and Cody and all those other people? Or is he doing it out of some misguided love for Caitlin? Maybe it's a good thing that we don't get to see it, but I would have liked to have been there with him as he goes over the edge of the cliff. I actually think that that would then make the following scene with Matt disguised as John with Caitlin more interesting from a Caitlin point of view, because then that would be where the focus and our audience focus would be in terms of can she figure it out in time that Matt is actually John.
36:11But then that puts the audience ahead of her and she's meant to be a smart character, so I don't know that that's ideal at the same time. Because the actual reveal for us that, you know, that we both say that, that we all say, that we all knew that that was Matt pretty much instantly, not John. Yeah. If that was what they were trying to do in terms of hiding the ball, then it wasn't that effective. I'm not sure that they were trying to hide that. I think they were trying to hide what happened to John. I just think that it's kind of, it's an interesting scene this way because, you know, she still gets to be smart.
36:46She is figuring it out as that scene goes on. And you can kind of see those wheels turn, which I think is really, really good. And it's a beautiful piece of acting by Aki. I think it's a nice, there is a kind of romantic tension in that scene because he is kind of testing her feelings for him by pretending to be John. and he's kind of trying to see where he stands. So you get that, you know, playing nice. And because we suspect that it's Matt, we're kind of in on that as well. And then she is tempted. Like, she does like this guy. She is attracted to and attached to this person. So you have to feel that temptation and you completely lose that if you've already seen him kill John.
37:32because that is the thing that has to be the line for her. That is the absolute, she will not pass that line. You know that about her. She is a good person, right? So you cannot have any of that tension. You lose that completely if you've already seen him kill John, I think. And that kind of break for her, I think, is really important to see because she goes in a moment from kind of being tempted and thinking about leaving her fiancé, let's be honest.
38:01Chris Hewitt: Yeah, because there is a connection. because there is a connection to oh no oh no we done we are I am out of here and now I have to figure out a way to stop you which on some level is also what he wants I think I think he's really torn because I think he he does love her but also he knows he isn't he isn't himself anymore and he shouldn't well he's lost himself I think the Vesuvius scene is really where he begins to lose himself because he must know there's no there's no feasible way whether he was planning to hide John's body and she came back a bit early and interrupted him, maybe that's what happened.
38:37Chris Hewitt: But he must have known that even just the act of doing what he was doing, just even impersonating John is crossing a line of no return, right? In terms of, does he really think that she's going to go with him willingly after this? So that's the line where Matt stops being the man and starts becoming the monster. Yeah, that's maybe a little bit of a symptom of madness that he thinks he could get away from that. I feel like we've seen other films where somebody impersonates somebody's lover in order to find out how they feel about them. I mean, Sermon at Bergerac, apart from anything else, any number of Shakespeare plays, you know.
39:11So I don't think that that is so unforgivable as killing the guy, which I think is the break point. And I think he must know on some level it is the break point. Maybe genuinely killing him is also a cry for help. Because there is a cry for help element in his interactions with her in that scene. He does ask her to kill him. essentially at the end. Exactly. I mean, it's a literal cry for help at that point. But I think, you know, he's, I think he wants an out and he doesn't know if the out is running away with her or just her shutting him down. Because she's the only one who can, right? And I think it's interesting about, you were saying John's suspicions.
39:48He knows he's been working with, he knows Matt has been working with Caitlin, but he doesn't quite know, nobody knew what this tech could do, right? So he's still trying to put the last couple of pieces together. Patient doctor confidentiality.
40:03Chris Hewitt: What did you do today? Work honey? Well I came up with this experimental skin that I think might be driving my patient insane and he's killing all these people. Anyway but don't tell anyone I said that. All of this leads to this kind of lovely as you said it's very noir-y but it's also very classic universal monster hammer horror monster of the tortured monster at the end is revealed and you know falls in love with this beauty who almost reaches him, almost saves him, and then doesn't, and he's condemned to this horrible, horrible life of loneliness and solitude and madness as well. It leads to the very end of the movie, which I think I was really, really impressed by the last shot.
40:48Chris Hewitt: I think it's terrific. I love it. But not just from a kind of point of view of Matt is so lonely that he is now living in the sewers. he is a million miles away from the movie star Matt that we saw at the beginning of the movie. But also in terms of tracking what Clayface can do, the film is really, really interesting because it's like at first he can kind of begin to change the shape of his face. Oh, now he can completely look and sound like other people as well. That's kind of cool. Oh, he can also mimic clothing, which is he can change, he can literally change his mass as well, which Helen I'm sure is a big fan of as a science major over here and you know he can also change the massive and the shape completely and then at the end he can create two different people what the fuck this isn't just Clay face this is Clay everything yeah and that's part of the joy of this film like it's a focused character study on Matt Hagen it leans into the horror in a big way but it also doesn't forget to have fun with the shape-shifting with everything and the balance of all of those things I think especially comes through in the Vesuvius sequence which that club sequence is incredible I think after that sequence my favourite sequence in the film is the can we call it the sex dream sequence where where Matt I'm not sure you should but yes what else would you call it I think of you as a very pure person I'm on I don't like to see you being exposed to such things it's been a day for you I'm honest listening referencing a show that you may not have listened to but yeah I think that sequence was incredible and also in the midst of all that it ends with a jump scare of all jump scares with Eddie Marsden at the end of that which got me so good oh my gosh but yeah I thought both of those sequences were incredible but they really have fun with the shape-shifting of it all.
42:57Chris Hewitt: I think Andy Marcian should appear at the end of every sex scene. Wow. Okay. Yeah, I thought the use of his shape-shifting in the club sequence was really... That was really cool. That was like, ooh, he's got a handle on this. He can do cool stuff now. He can take down bad guys, which I think is why you're still with him as he's slaughtering a bunch of people. But they were all bad. They were all bad. but then yeah it gets gnarlier from there I think what's really interesting to me about this film is that it's not the gooey bits and the sort of super powered bits that are the most upsetting the most upsetting to me even over the airplane bathroom which is pretty upsetting but the most upsetting are the sort of the human level injuries at the beginning of the film like him being held down and disfigured and then the sort of the surgery scenes are the most I wanted to look away from the screen and did a few times because it was just too much.
44:01And so by the time that the very upsetting, objectively upsetting eyeball stuff came along, I was almost like, well, this is at least better than that stuff was.
44:12Chris Hewitt: It was really interesting. This film earns the hard R-18. It really does. Or 18 as it is over here in the UK where we live, Amon. But yes, it does. It does. It does. and there are some amazing deaths in this sequence. I've never seen the way he gets shabbo at the end. I've never seen that in a horror film before and that's always good. It's always nice when you can tick off something. I haven't seen someone being killed by the hero of the film ripping his blood into the guy's face and then recalling his blood into his face thus making the guy hemorrhage. I've never seen that before. Making the same scars as was made to him as well.
44:47Poetic vengeance unlocked. I don't know about the nano-cells defying gravity. They're not Idina Menzel. Do you know what I mean? or even Adele Dazeem. It's a bit weird. But they're one and the same, aren't they? Oh my God. Which is which? Don't we see that happen when he's demonstrating? But it still doesn't make any sense. Why would they go backwards? It's nanotechnology. Why would they suddenly be able to go uphill?
45:11Chris Hewitt: Don't make me science play to you, Helen. It's because of the neutrinos that have mutated. We all know that. Listen, as the great philosopher Blade once said, some nanosales always try to ice-cowl yeah yeah or drip up through air yes yes they can drip upwards yes they can anyway but the 18 of us all yeah there's some really really gnarly bits but weirdly I wasn't nearly as squeamish as I thought I was going to be going into this you know as you guys know I'm a horror guy I'm a gore hound I'm a gore fiend I do like my gore but anything that kind of has kind of real world connotations usually gets me looking away anything with eyes anything with veins anything with people injecting stuff, you know, or something as simple as it.
45:55Chris Hewitt: Like, I can watch the thing from Morning Tonight, but the blood test scene where one of them cuts his finger with a scalpel. I'm like, oh no, thank you. Oh, please, bucket please. And yet, things like the airplane sequence where he's on this rickety airplane and he's got these scissors dangerously close to his face. For me, there was the element of grisly jeopardy removed from the film because we knew that his face would just pop back into shape at some point. So like, it didn't quite push it as far as I thought it was going to push it. The death which made me gag the most was honestly Mia. And death by too much clay in your mouth.
46:31And that was, that's still, that's nice.
46:34Chris Hewitt: It's a very real live danger at Aardman. But you've also... It's how Wallace is going to go eventually. Oh boy. It's actually quite funny in that because you wrote an Aardman feature before my Clayface feature came out and the title of your Aardman feature was Peter Clay. Yep. which is amazing it's a phrase it's a phrase it is but taken from the Batman animated show of course taken from the Terry Pratchett book of course of course which he took it from the Batman show of course of course and not just like life just on life yeah but you also have hit Chris on one of the best ideas of the film for me which is that of the inner reflecting the outer and how severance Matt's state of mind is crucial to what he looks like on the outside.
47:26I thought that was really, really well done. Yeah, that was an interesting idea that basically the nano cells start to react to his emotions. The emotion that keeps setting him off and making the cells go cuckoo, cachu. And I think that gave him a lot to play with. That gave him a lot of both comedy and horror. I think, in this film, which was pretty effective. I love, in terms of deaths, I thought the most sort of striking to me was Cody, was his best friend.
48:00Chris Hewitt: And that sort of hugging him to death and seeing him basically screaming through his back, that was quite something. And also because at that point, you know, there's still that shred of humanity to him and he's basically cradling his friend's dead body straight afterwards rather than just going, Ha, screw you! The first murder, the Eddie Marsan one, is a complete accident. He doesn't know that he's doing it. Of course, it's his subconsciousness manifesting in an interesting way. So he does kind of mean it, but even so. Interesting mens rea, when the mens rea is also the actus reas. Ooh, how do we prosecute that?
48:41Fascinating.
48:41Chris Hewitt: I understood like three words of that, and one of those was le. What? what? Okay, so mens rea, guilty mind, that means the intention or the recklessness towards... You've mens rea explained to me endlessly on this show. Actus rea is the other part of the crime which is doing the thing, right? So, if you want to murder somebody but you never do anything about it, you've got the mens rea but not the actus rea. Okay. Okay? If you murder somebody but you do it while you're unconscious or brainwashed by Russians, then you don't have the mens rea but you do have the actus rea, right? You need both parts to be guilty of murder.
49:17Chris Hewitt: Like infinity stones. Talk to me in ways I can understand. So, mens rea is the power stone. And actus rictus? Reus. Actus reus is the space stone. And you get them together. It'd be the mind stone. It'd be the mind stone. Obviously, mind is in there. Come on, Chris. Feels like you're making this a touch more complicated. You're making it more complicated, not less. Okay. Okay, my point is, and this is something that kind of goes into, I think we've talked about it. I feel like we've talked about it with X-Men as well, like Phoenix, okay, or Charles Xavier in Logan, right? The thought for them can be the act.
49:57Like the thought is the thing that immediately causes something to happen. So if they just have a stray thought and don't control the thought, they could kill someone, right? Because they're telepaths.
50:07Chris Hewitt: Oh, okay, yeah, yeah, yeah. So this is more like the situation here. A stray thought from him is the thing that kills. because his body is so reactive to that thought and it's so it's kind of it's an interesting legal conundrum and I don't know how they deal with that well they don't of course we don't have to because he's been exploded into little clay particles at the end they know what he reconstitutes and they don't know he's alive at the end of this but it's interesting that the Eddie Marsan one is accidental the Cody one I think is also accidental I don't think he walks into that trailer planning to kill Cody no I don't think he plans it I think he's open to it I think he's considered it but I don't think it's necessarily on his agenda but then when he kills Sal you know when he bludgeons him to death having somehow got ahead of of Caitlin in that in that alleyway shh shh hand wave it it's fine that's entirely entirely intentional yeah I thought the Cody death felt I mean after fashion intentional when Cody reveals his betrayal he goes there with suspicions right yeah Yeah, but I think he was hoping against hope.
51:17I think some part of what was still Matt was hoping that Cody would convince him otherwise. And I think part of him that wasn't Matt knew that that wasn't going to happen. But I think there was still a part of him that hoped for it. It's a very intimate death. Yeah, really intimate. A lot of movies being interrupted in this film,
51:37Chris Hewitt: if you think about it. A lot of films get partway into their shooting schedule and then their main actor either gets horribly set upon by Gotham thugs or is killed. Eddie Miles and Death is the first of many instances we get of other actors not named Tom B. Harris playing Matt Hagen which is a cool gambit that this film has. No, not Gambit. He isn't in this movie. Walked into that one. It's good stuff. It's a cool idea that that one stood out. the entire film, which I like. The Vesuvius sequence especially, they really play with that in a really fun way. I love that idea. I liked it when it was in Darkman and I like it here as well.
52:22Can we talk about how great he is as Matt Hagen then? Yeah. Who's Dr. Peyton Westlake? Liam Neeson is Dr.
52:27Chris Hewitt: Peyton Westlake. Can you say it? Liam Neeson is Dr. Peyton Westlake, is Tom Rees-Harris, is Matt Hagen. Yes. Yeah, okay. But genuinely, for an actor that I hadn't seen a huge amount from, you know he's done some eye-catching work admittedly and things like Doctor Who and stuff but he hasn't been a big name but I think this is a real calling card I hope he doesn't get stuck in sort of horror roles as a result of this which I think is a risk but I thought he was absolutely terrific to be honest really really impressive yeah he's very very good well Shakhtar of course doing Gotham accent but modulating it as well so he you know he kind of I think Tom Lewis-Harris even talked about code switching at one point that he basically when he goes back to Gotham his accent gets a little bit thicker when he goes back to the Narrows it gets even thicker all that sort of stuff so there's really really interesting kind of little shades going on with his approach to playing Matt and of course you have that talk show appearance don't you with Rob Brydon I don't know we should spend the next 25 minutes talking about the fact that Rob Brydon is in this movie and has a scene where he is really really sinister but of course he's Matt playing him it's Rob fucking Brydon is there anyone American in this movie?
53:40Chris Hewitt: You know what? I mean, there might be a couple. I think Corey Johnson is American. Yeah, Corey Johnson's American, but he lives here. Because Corey Johnson's one of those guys. You'll have seen him. He plays Sal. He's in The Mummy. He's in everything. He's one of Matthew Vaughn's guys. He's one of Guy Ritchie's guys. He's in a lot of stuff. He's in Save and Private Ryan, Corey Johnson. But he's one of those actors, American actors, who is based here in the UK and as a result, shows up an awful lot in films that are shot here but are meant to be set in America as well. but that's a very very very good question about the main cast of this movie how many of them are actually American because I think David Denchik is he American?
54:22Born in Sweden. What? Of course he is.
54:26Chris Hewitt: Yeah Eddie Marsan you have Joana Ribeiro is Portuguese I believe who plays Mia Torres Aaron Paul Aaron Paul who stars as Jimmy Nuttalot he's American so there we go Joshua James as Cody is British Naomi Aki is British what? Joshua James is British? British oh my god this is incredible and this was filmed in Liverpool yeah Liverpool playing Gotham you see this is a film everything in this film has been designed meticulously to be something that it is not we're playing with 4D chess here this is this is incredible James Watkins is 25 steps ahead of himself, never mind us. This is wonderful stuff.
55:15But yeah, I second you, Halon, Tom V. Harris. He is fantastic in this. And I liked how as things got more fantastical, that relationship between Matt and Caitlin helps keep things grounded. And really feels effective. As we've mentioned, there is a connection there. There's a vibe there. and yeah
55:39Chris Hewitt: there has to be there has to be there has to be something in him that she finds appealing and attractive and I think I think that's it's really interesting it's really well done it's played well by both of them it's written really well but I think it works because that's the thing that kind of keeps you siding with him for a really long time you know like he's opened up to her he's told her all this stuff about his background they have this similar experience of being betrayed by those close to them of being, you know, on the verge of something great and then having the rug pulled out from under them.
56:11And I think that is, it's a really good place to start. And I think it's one of those, it's a little bit like Peggy and Steve. Like the attraction is there even when he doesn't look like that. Do you know what I mean? He comes into her surgery wearing the mask, you know, at his most scarred, at his most despairing, and there's already that connection between them and there's already that sympathy between them. and I think and that's what they then build on so I think you you get that sense of this could really be something and you're kind of invested in every touch every
56:42Chris Hewitt: and then obviously as I'm almost in the sort of the dream sex sequence where she's watching she's watching Matt and then she's watching herself and then she's you know he's having a moment and you know that's all loaded with significance to the point where almost every glance is freighted with meaning every every little touch has a significance and electricity to it as well, which is utterly lacking in her relationship with John. They've been engaged for ages, and it's all a little bit like, oh. He makes good pasta, though. It looks good. Yeah, you're right. And I think you get that sense of, this is a couple who are comfortable with each other, who trust each other, who like each other, but yeah, they don't have necessarily the same kind of spark.
57:23It's not making him out to be a bad guy or anything like that. They're not setting them in opposition that way. Which I really love, by the way, because again John is such a good guy that there's a version of this film where John is a lot more jealous and has a crash out that's very sort of toxic in a way not even toxic it would be deserved to a point because again there's a connection there but the film never takes it there he actually handles it fairly maturely before he gets bumped off and yeah I like that decision again it could have been a lot more cliche than that regard it don't go that way
57:55Chris Hewitt: the only good cop in Gotham and now they'll have to get another one Is James Gordon knocking around? We'll get to that in a second. We'll get to that and the Batman, or lack thereof, in a second. But another thing about Caitlin is that the film could have painted her as the kind of the mad scientist in league with Matt and enthralled to her own science in a way. But she's very much aware of the dangers of it. She's very much put guardrails in place to stop exactly what happens from happening. but it's Matt's action. So she's not responsible ultimately for the thing that really turns him into Clayface in the end.
58:34Chris Hewitt: It's his impetuousness. He has no patience. He cannot wait. And so he checks himself with all of it at the same time. Yeah. I think she doesn't act 100 % ideally. It is still off the books. It is human trials ahead of what is permitted. so I think that's that's important just to make it noir-y I think everybody's a little bit morally compromised we gotta shut this shit down but equally she's not nearly as as responsible as you say as he is but yeah that's an interesting choice actually because it does give him more responsibility than there have been in other Clayface tellings if we look at Feet of Clay yes he's addicted to a face cream but the thing that ends up turning him into Clayface is that mobsters basically attack him and force feed him the cream here he's doing it it's his choice is it the Matt Hagen iteration it is yes in that one yeah it is because there have been a few over the years right that have been Basil Carlo that one was that scene you mentioned with him being sort of force fed is kind of played out in silhouette and is something that has haunted people so my husband when I invited him to this screening was like no I'm still scarred by a cartoon I saw 20 years ago and wouldn't come literally wouldn't come and I talked to a bunch of people at the screening and every single one of them name-tracked that episode of the animated series.
59:55Really? I haven't seen that. I used to watch a show. It's such a stylized, such a stylish show anyway, but I do think that's one of the really strong episodes and one that has clearly stuck with everybody who saw it. Because it is quite gross. And again, it has the same kind of thing of, you know, he's dead or is he? Or is he still out there somewhere?
1:00:20Chris Hewitt: Yes. what did you make of as Clayface fans experts of the way that he's depicted at the end because we don't really get to see full Clayface until that scene where he's really beginning to melt into himself and is maybe about to attack Caitlin and then she loads up very very slowly the kill switch and she's tormented she's no but she's got no control but I would I would make that kill switch load a bit faster because she's sitting there going gotta get 100 % it's taking minutes Are you sure? I don't think she thought it would be an action, you know, scene scenario. I think she was... You've got to plan for every scenario.
1:00:58Chris Hewitt: She got to run all the alternate scenarios. 14 ,605 ,000 of them, maybe, if that's what it takes. But what do you think about the depiction of Clayface from a visual point of view? I must say, I was slightly disappointed, although I understand why, given that this was a$40 million budget, which may seem a lot to you or I, but it's very... It's peanuts. It's peanuts in superhero terms, yeah. But there was more CG morphine than I thought there would be. There was more like, oh, I'm Tom Rees. Morphine or morphing? It's Tom Rees-Harris one minute, and then I'm Eddie Marzahn the next, or possibly Aaron Paul.
1:01:30Chris Hewitt: Who can tell? And, you know, it just, what did the kids say? It's giving Michael Jackson's black and white video. I thought it was solid enough. Like, they were clearly trying to have an element of Tom Rees-Harris still there as he's saying, kill me. while he's melting into clay. And that's semi-successful. And the CGI, I feel like you can see the budget was a bit, maybe a bit stressed. But he is supposed to look gooey and ooey and kind of gross. Apparently, James Watkins said at the end, that's a suit. Yeah, no. When he's attacking Caitlin, that's a suit. I think it is, I don't know what the right thing to do would have been.
1:02:14And I feel like we've seen so much kind of morphing in different ways because that was one of the first things that sort of CG animation could do. So we've seen really bad examples of it for years and good examples as well. But I think just having him flicker almost from one to the next, A, probably saved them 10 million on the budget. But also I think was, it did give that scene a sense of propulsion and elegance that maybe it wouldn't have had if you'd had that sort of 30 seconds in between or even five seconds in between of him shifting from one to the other. And it allowed him to be more surprising so I think it was a kind of a plot necessity
1:02:49Chris Hewitt: could you have had though like a more practical effects where say in the Vesuvius where he's literally morphing physically from one character to the next and maybe he's caught half of his face is Matt Hagen half of his face is Sal wow maybe it's possibly yeah I was like hey that guy looks like Harvey Dent if Christopher Nolan made this movie they will still be making Clayface yeah I think I mean the other thing is I mean if you're going for somebody ooey and gooey and a bit lumpy the danger is he ends up looking like a monster you look directly at me because I'm talking to both because the danger is he looks like monster Eliza Sue at the end of the substance so you know I don't know how many ways there are to make a big gooey dude you know that looks any cooler than this one did or a meal from Robocop which of course there's big Robocop energy and how Shabo and his guys disfigure Matt at the beginning of the movie.
1:03:49Chris Hewitt: A couple of last things, we want to go about eight or nine minutes left. I don't think we've talked enough about the fact that Rob Brydon is in this movie, by the way. I don't know, like American listeners, Australian listeners, Norwegian listeners, other countries are available. I'm just listing countries where I know we have listeners. I don't know if you know exactly what a big deal this is for us over here. Rob Brydon over here is something of a national treasure. He is a comedian and an all-around entertainer, and he's brilliant. He's been in things like Gavin and Stacey. On the big screen, he's in Barbie for like two seconds.
1:04:24Chris Hewitt: He's in The Trip, of course, with Steve Coogan, and Cockabull Story. He's a host of Would I Lie to You and numerous game shows. And he's just brilliant. And he's a brilliant, brilliant actor, and he's fantastically talented. But it's still really, there's a disconnect when I see Rob Brydon in a film. But it feels kind of like they're doing a sort of Seth Meyers, that's the kind of energy that he's trying to bring to that part. And I thought it was nicely played. I thought it was a convincing late night show. You know, here's our local boy, come back to town. Oh, no problem with it at all. I'm delighted to see Rob Reitland in a film, but it's just, it's still, it's weird for me.
1:04:59Chris Hewitt: Yeah, I know what you mean. It's like seeing your dad dressed up as Santa Claus. It's just weird to me. But I did start to make the point about Matt on that talk show saying that line, hell coming with me. I think that's a line. And he does the, he changes the register of his voice completely. and the minute he does it you go, oh, he's going to say that later on. He's going to say that later on in a much more sinister context, conchitext. But anyway, Mr. Sinister Conchitext. Anyway. I kind of wish we'd seen a few more clips of his films. I would have liked to have seen a sort of clip, highlights reel of Matt Hagen's work.
1:05:30Because even in Feet of Clay you actually get a little bit of that. You get some of the, some of the clips of what he's done, certainly the stills of what he's done. It's one of the ways that Batman stops him in Feet of Clay Part 2, which is that he shows him images of himself in all these movies that he's done. I'm very proud of you right now, Helen.
1:05:46Chris Hewitt: Helen is Batman-splaining to a mom right now. I'm loving every second of it. I am very, very proud of you. I've never had anything against the animated series. It's just not foundational. James isn't here, by the way. We all love the animated series. We're fantastic. I just haven't seen every episode. But I must watch Feet of Clay. And what's the sequel called? Feet of Clay 2. There's also another Clayface episode called Mudslide, which is also very good. Okay, sounds good. Sounds vaguely sexual. Alright, so I want to talk about Batman in a second. But that scene where he infiltrates the premiere of the movie he was going to star in, that's one of the things I bumped up against.
1:06:23Chris Hewitt: Because let me tell you folks, it is not that easy to infiltrate a premiere. I don't know, maybe things were different in Gotham. Maybe in Gotham. I don't know. But that scene was slightly shonky to me. Once he gets onto the carpet, then everyone's like, shit, that's Matt Hagen. And then maybe they're just stars. And then they start fucking again and his dreadful agent or manager wants him back in the fold again. But that thread gets dropped very, very quickly. The idea of what would happen if Matt actually did come back? Would he be embraced by Hollywood? How would they deal with his increasing psychopathy?
1:06:57Chris Hewitt: That's a thread that's not really explored that much in the film, which is slightly disappointing to me, but obviously they have other things to deal with. Another scene involving acting that really stands out for me is the scene with Corey. after he dies and he has to go out and do that scene with Mia and he basically improvises it which was not the original idea the original idea was that Matt had somehow learned all the lines and went out but you know it's fun to know that on sets of these movies they have I don't know whether they kind of imagine an episode of the Empire Podcast a year and a half down the line going how would he have learned all the lines how would he like were the sides in his trailer?
1:07:39Chris Hewitt: Did he then just read them? I'm sure they would have been, yeah. And then they head them off at the pass bit going, oh no, he's just improvising, so it's all fine. But anyway, when you have a few minutes left, I want to talk about Batman or the lack of Batman in this movie and the fact that the word Clayface is not even said in this film, which is interesting. What did we make of that? This is set in Gotham. Gotham PD are very, very prevalent in this movie. But there's not a hint, nary a hint, of Bruce Wayne, I believe, or the man in the bad costume. I was surprised. And I'll say right off the bat...
1:08:12I'm disappointed. I'll say right off the bat, no pun intended, that this film does not need Batman. But I really thought, given the Gotham of it all, given Clayface as a Batman villain, I thought we'd get at least a whiff of Batman. It may well be a Bannerang or a Batsilloway. Nothing like... clear, like, you know, Batman has been cast and he's this guy, but something to that effect.
1:08:41Chris Hewitt: Or like a little Chiron on the TVs. Bruce Wayne donates to orphans or something. Exactly. I expected a little whiff of something. The fact that we didn't get any of that is a little bit surprising to me. I mean, I'm not surprised because I've seen Venom. Venom. Venom. And the like. And I think there's been quite a lot of those have, you know, Joker is unusual, or Joker Part 1 is unusual in having a Bruce Wayne cameo and having the Waynes be part of that story. But the Spider-Man, the spunk villains, for example, have not had really any Spider-Man. There's sometimes a mention. Yeah, maybe a Sharon on TV, but that's about all we could have hoped for, I think.
1:09:24I thought it kind of worked despite that. And I think what was interesting to me was just enjoying Gotham as a place and this idea of it being sort of just the dark underbelly of America and the sort of, I think the way, if you want to really overanalyze it, I feel like Matt has this whole American dream thing going on, right? He's the poor boy made good. He's the guy who raised himself up by his bootstraps and went from the slums of the Narrows, the very worst part of Gotham of all places, to, you know, Coast City, which has a striking resemblance to LA, to Coast City and to stardom and to an Oscar nomination and all the rest.
1:10:02So he is like, this is this American dream figure. And then he goes back to Gotham and he is pulled down into that underbelly and he is absolutely destroyed by it. And I think that's a really striking piece of world building for this universe's Gotham, actually. And it's quite gnarly. And I think it actually sets Batman up to be in a really good place. Or a bad place. Or a bad place, indeed. I think if Bruce Wayne was around, a useful thing that he could do is try to help people like Matt Hagen win their fucking court cases.
1:10:37Chris Hewitt: What he can do, that would have been cool. Is take all those billions and spend them on cool toys that can help him fight crime. Yeah. The great thing about Batman the Animated Series and the DC Animated Universe as a whole, he does both. That's why it's so great. He also did in Christopher Nolan's films. It can happen. But yeah, it's really interesting just Clayface coming at this point in James Gunn's DCU oh yeah and we should mention very quickly the box office as well where it's done okay at the box office with a 24 million dollar opening weekend at the States in the States it's not going to pull up any trees but I guess for a 40 million dollar movie it's going to make its budget back and then some yeah it's at 47 worldwide I think right and is it the best film in the DCU so far for me yes I need to watch Superman again to fully co-sign that.
1:11:29Yeah, I really like Superman, as you know, and I think this might be better, but it's certainly up there. I do think it's the best, for me, of all these fucking super villain movies. That's without question, yes. But yeah, it's just like, we have been conditioned to a point by what the MCU accomplished with the Infinity Saga and the way that they did that in terms of linking all the films and everything building upon each other james gunner's trying to go a different way with that um and this is a film he's trying to do standalone and connecting films at the same time that can be a bit tricky also we're in 2026 now 2008 what a hit looked like for a superhero movie means something different to what it means now it's much more difficult i think um so i think there's been some it's not a superhero movie either but I know what you mean in the comic book so there's been some there's been a lot of discussion maybe a little bit of backlash to sort of how James Gunn is building his DCU I feel like Man of Tomorrow is going to be a very important film for many reasons because he has stated that that does bring in a few of the threads that are lingering out there together and I feel like we are at the point where we need that
1:12:47Chris Hewitt: Do you think Batman's in that film and he hasn't been revealed yet? I don't think Batman's in Man of Tomorrow No, because apart from anything else the Batman part two is still coming out. Well, that's one last thing I wanted to say because we do have to wrap this up because there are people banging on the door and they will kill us if we don't let them in. The presence, the existence of the Batman, Matt Reeves, the Batman, and obviously the Batman part two and the Penguin show as well, I found it impossible to disentangle the two. I was watching this thinking of Colin Farrell. Every time he goes to the Narrows, I was thinking of Colin Farrell.
1:13:18Chris Hewitt: I was thinking of Oz Cobb. I was thinking of Batman. and I think I think that's a problem I don't know how they're going to tackle it because I don't because the obvious thing to do is to somehow bring Pattinson into the into the DCU and make it official I don't think I think having two Batman running around on screen at the same time essentially is going to be is going to be ultimately confusing that's why I think they're going to do the Batman part 2 and sort of finish that oh that would be such a shame I want to live in that world I want to bathe in that world. Gotham's obviously a shithole in that world, but it's so good.
1:13:56Chris Hewitt: The Batman is so good. The Penguin is so fucking good. I want to live in that world. I think audiences are smart enough to distinguish between... Have you met audiences, Amon? I don't think they are. Maybe it's because I'm fully in the bubble and of course I follow all the characters and the storylines and the news and whatnot, but I think audiences will be able to distinguish between the two. People thought Thanos was Hellboy. I don't think... Did they? Yes. so people who work for this magazine thought Thanos was Hellboy so I don't think I think you have much more faith than I do but I just would like there to be some way to cross his dreams I don't know maybe have some sort of crisis on infinite earths I don't know I'm just throwing out concepts it's a mad concept but just my work imagine doing that five films into the DC it's like it's already got two complicated guys we need to streamline but yeah it genuinely was a thing for me.
1:14:52Chris Hewitt: It wasn't a problem for me with this movie, but the Batman I was picturing was Pattinson, and I was picturing the Penguin, and I was just, we're in the narrows, so, I don't know, it's just a thing for me, but I really like this film, there are a couple of things I bumped up on, a couple of things in the third act, a couple of things we mentioned, like, you know, it's not that easy to infiltrate a premiere, I fucking tried. They don't let me in, even when I've been invited, which is very rare. But, anyway, I think we do have to wrap it up is there anything real quick in like 30 seconds that each of you would like to say about this movie or anything that happens in the movie or maybe just what's on your shopping list for this weekend Volker Bertelmann's score one of his six scores this year yes that's if you include De Gaulle as one film not two this is how I know that Amon is Amon thank you I was really struggling but yes it's very dark and elegant I like Recreate Face Dima a lot it's a really good one Okay, good stuff.
1:15:51Chris Hewitt: Is that it? I think that's it. That's it. All right. Well, on that note, on that confident note, is that it? Are we done? What's the film called? On that note, that is it for our Clayface spoiler special. Keep them peeled for more spoiler specials coming your way. I'm not sure which is going to be up first, a Wildwood spoiler special with Travis Knight. Did you set up Travis Knight, by the way, on that show? No, I did not. No, okay. Do you want to do it now and I can cut it in? Sure. All right. Now here's Helen very quickly setting up Travis Knight which I'm going to splice seamlessly in to the Wildwood spoiler special.
1:16:25Chris Hewitt: Go Helen! But before we get into us talking about Wildwood let's hear from the film's director. Please welcome Travis Knight. I was there for the first 10 minutes of that podcast. There's no way I can cut that in. There is no cutting point. There is no way I can do that. So that's going to be a fun challenge for me. We can just cut you out. Who needs me? I have been told by HR anyway so goodbye I'm on toodaloo toodaloo to you and it's goodbye from Helen O 'Hara peace peace be unto you my friend peace be unto you and it's goodbye from me hang on a second wait a minute which one's which no they've clay faced thanks for listening see you next time bye
1:17:16Thank you.
James Watkins' Clayface is the third film in James Gunn's burgeoning DCU, and acts as a body horror flick, a tragic love story, and an origin of an iconic Batman villain brought to the big screen for the first time, as Tom Rhys Harries' actor, Matt Hagen, becomes the shapeshifting spectre of the title. In this spoiler special, just in time for Halloween (or not, if you're listening to this after Halloween), Chris Hewitt talks to Watkins about the movie's key moments and twists and turns, before being joined in the podbooth by Helen O'Hara and Amon Warmann for a deep dive into the movie. Or is it Amon Warmann and Helen O'Hara? IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO TELL! ARGH!