

ESPN FC/Extra Time episode focused on Manchester United’s internal crisis after a heavy loss to Champions League debutants Como, sparked by Bruno Fernandes publicly criticizing manager Michael Carrick and the coaching staff. Guests argue Carrick may be “dead man walking,” with debate over whether the root cause is Carrick’s lack of credentials or rotten dressing-room behavior and broken accountability. They also preview Barcelona vs Real Madrid (“El Clasico”), plus other weekend fixtures and Champions League/Europa League discussion.
Kay Murray (host), Alejandro Moreno (former pro/analyst), Xhaka Hislop (analyst), Dan Thomas (ESPN analyst, former player/coach background), Craig Burley (former Scotland/club defender, analyst), Don Hutchison (former Scotland player/analyst).
Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez “threw the staff under the bus,” trust is broken; Carrick can’t regain the dressing room; owners/structure (Glazers, Ineos, Brailsford, Wilcox) are incompetent; players are “rotten” and need accountability.
Bruno’s post-match comments; Como match performance; Carrick’s interim success last season; Barcelona’s dominant PSG win; Real Madrid lineup uncertainty; Liverpool vs Brighton goal expectations.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on Manchester United's poor performance and ongoing issues within the club.
“Hello and welcome into the latest edition of ESPN FC.”
Analysis of Bruno Fernandes' criticism of the coaching staff and its implications for the team.
“But it is not to be, Dan, because this is forcing us to talk about the problems that we are seeing at this club right now.”
Debate over Michael Carrick's managerial capabilities and potential future managers for Manchester United.
“You know, people fall out with technical directors and ownership and chief execs because you think, what the hell are they talking about?”
Discussion on team accountability, player performance, and the overall atmosphere in the dressing room.
“that's going to take Manchester United forward in the next five or ten years in the right direction.”
Critique of Bruno Fernandes' leadership and the team's lack of commitment during matches.
“He's got a nerve blaming Michael Carrick.”
Discussing the need for leadership and performance from Manchester United players.
“We're going to run for each other and show it.”
Analyzing the upcoming match between Barcelona and Real Madrid and its implications.
“it's going to be interesting to see what goes down I thought Dan's input was excellent in that segment.”
Examining Real Madrid's strategy and challenges leading into the big match.
“real madrid barcelona in first after nine games they are perfect so far this season and they are yet to lose a league game.”
A light-hearted anecdote about Craig's experience with a waiter in Barcelona.
“Does what happened midweek against PSG have any relevance to this game?”
Discussing upcoming Premier League matches and predictions.
“with former Manchester United manager Ruben Amarim returning to the UK with Milan.”
Analyzing Liverpool's potential against Brighton in the upcoming match.
“These guys, they know who they are, they have an identity, and that's all you can ask from a team, and Brighton knows that very well.”
Discussion of key Premier League matches to watch this weekend.
“Let's take a look at some of those fixtures once again.”
Analyzing the latest power rankings in European football.
“Shaq has power rankings PSG, Alistair, after two incredible results in the Champions League They're in at number one Barca are down, they've lost to the best team in the land In the land?”
Hosts and guests answer listener questions regarding various football topics.
“Welcome in to the latest edition of Extra Time.”
Discussion on the impact of an injury on PSG's season and their Champions League prospects.
“I mean, I've done an ACL and it's horrific.”
Analyzing the potential and impact of players Desiree Douay and Lamin-Yamal.
“No, I'll go CPA Don because CPA Don, I'll end up in prison.”
Discussing Brighton's chances of finishing in the top five of the league.
“and is he regarded at the same level as Lamin-Yemal?”
Hosts share humorous thoughts on trusting each other with babysitting.
“I think they've got off the top of my head, I want to say they've got Liverpool and Man City next.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On ESPN FC, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00The NBA on ESPN is happening now and we're here for all of it. From the superstar moves to the next gen revolution. Let's get who we are, boy. Another three. Bang! We don't just live it, we love it. Because the NBA is a world of its own. Can't stop me now. So from the biggest names to the biggest moments, ESPN is where you call home. I really can't stop me now.
0:36Don Hutchison: Hello and welcome into the latest edition of ESPN FC. Kay Murray, Alejandro Moreno and Xhaka Hislop here in the studio. And joining us tonight from Barcelona, we have Dan Thomas and Craig Burley. Don Hutchison will also be with us as well because we need to continue. We think he's with us. Look at the camera, Tom. It's your first time. We do need to talk about Manchester United. especially what happened yesterday. They were thrashed by Champions League debutants, Como. Lots of nice headlines from England, as you can see. But the big one is that Bruno blasts angry Carrick. Bruno Fernandes criticizing his coach and the coaching staff after the game.
1:19Don Hutchison: And Craig and Dan thought that by going to Barcelona, they would escape the chat about Manchester United. But it is not to be, Dan, because this is forcing us to talk about the problems that we are seeing at this club right now. Yeah, Lautaro Martinez, of course, spoke out last week and pretty much Bruno Fernandes went, hold my beer. Or Lissandro, or Lissandro, Dan. Lissandro Martinez. I'm still a bit jet-lagged. It's the time. Get a beer, have a beer. Have a beer, get over it. Come on, have a beer.
1:54Do you know the difference, though? what between Lissandro and Lotto apart from the name oh this has just gone so well you know the difference though here's the difference and I'm not saying either of them were correct certainly not at all Lissandro Martinez basically through the technical staff and the people running the football club most of the people that generally players don't deal with or maybe even don't like he threw them under the bus and somewhat protecting his manager and the coaching staff and in some sense some of his teammates maybe the signings obviously that didn't go down too well with the new signings but the straw that's broke the camel's back is the fact that the club captain or any player but the club captain has basically said the coaching staff and the manager have no idea what they're doing now that is a big sea change and that scenario only something has to give either the manager has to go or either Fernandez has to go, which we know won't happen.
2:56So I think we know what the outcome is. But you have a player here ultimately thrown his manager under the bus. That's the kind of group that you need. You know, people fall out with technical directors and ownership and chief execs because you think, what the hell are they talking about? But when it gets to the management and the staff, the people that you work with every day in that locker room, on that training field, there is no trust whatsoever. This is now completely broken. and I think Bruno Fernandes was completely out of order here in terms of a dressing room, a club, because he's come out and said it's everybody else's fault and I think Carrick's position now is totally, even not regarding results, is totally untenable.
3:40So he's a dead man walking? Yeah. Well, I mean, again, you know, he got the interim job, he did well. It's clear that it needs more experience. but the fact that Fernandes has come out and said this, one of them has to go. You cannot come out and just chuck the whole coaching staff and the manager under the bus and expect everything just to roll on smoothly the following week. It can't happen. In these scenarios, you have to have a situation where Bruno Fernandes comes out, takes accountability himself, talks about moving forward, talks about working together, tries to back everything to the hill until he can no longer do that and clearly results will take over.
4:25But he's not. He's came out. He's Chuck Carrick under the bus and Michael Carrick is a dead man walking. So who next? Conte? Nagelsmann?
4:34Don Hutchison: Southgate? Where are we going? Eddie Howe? Yeah, I don't know. I don't know where... Ineos and the people that they've brought in, amongst all the things the Glazers have done, and any of us have shown themselves wholly unable to have the knowledge and the nowest to run this football club in a proper manner and make good decisions. There's the list. Hutzler apparently ruled himself out today. Unai Emery apparently ruled himself out today. Obviously, Cesc Fabregas is flavour of the month. You can forget old Tommy Boy at the bottom because he ballsed it up in the summer with England again. So I wouldn't go that route.
5:13And I'm not sure I'd go down the Antonio Conte route because he's just going to eventually pour gas on it, set it on fire and walk away. So I have got no idea what the right way forward is for this football club. Does it matter?
5:30Don Hutchison: We talked about it before. If you had a Pep, Klopp, Ancelotti in charge, does it really matter with this squad of players? Well, you look at, you've got Uri Tielemans come in in the summer who's a good player, but he's not exactly going to take you to that next level, not at his age. They got Marcus Rashford came back from Barcelona, who'd done particularly well, didn't want to go back. Didn't want to go back, but they couldn't get rid of him, and he's back there. So it's just a mess. And it seems whoever runs this football club, do you remember before, who was the guy, the chief exec, Ed, what's his name?
6:00Woodward. Ed Woodward. Ed Woodward. Ed Woodward. He gave all these interviews to Mark Ogden saying, oh, we're doing this great job, we're doing the right things, I'm running it for the Glazers. He was making bad decision after bad decision. The football department got changed when NOS came in. Ratcliffe brought in Brailsford, who was a cycling guy. What the hell does he know about running a football department? He brings in Omar Barari from Man City. Oh, he was part of that, allegedly part of all that Man City time when they were allegedly cheating or they were cheating. Jason Wilcox comes in.
6:32Nobody likes him. So the whole thing is a mess. It just seems there is nobody capable there of making a proper decision that's going to take Manchester United forward in the next five or ten years in the right direction. Looking at how they've run it so far, they'll make a decision and 18 months down the line, they'll go, oh, we've made a mess of this again. We're going to have to make another change. It's a complete mess.
6:54Don Hutchison: It's the problem when you give a former borough manager this sort of responsibility. Ah, thanks, Dan. I knew there would be a little bit of a dig there. But Carrick will be in charge for the Bournemouth game. Don, I know you've got your own thoughts on everything that's gone down in the last 24 hours.
7:12Don Hutchison: Yeah, see, I don't pin this on Michael Carrick. This is a bigger problem than Michael Carrick. I would like to see the owners make a statement now, and apparently they've come out today and said business as usual. I mean, how can it be business as usual? I would like to see Jim Radcliffe get Lissandra Martinez, Bruno Fernandes in a room and tell them, get on the phone to your agents. You are going to be sold as quick as possible. Go and get yourself moves because you will never play for Man United again. and tell the world and tell the Man United fans exactly what you've told those two. And I would guarantee you, Man United fans would go, yeah, I like that.
7:46Don Hutchison: Because all those names on that list have still got to deal with the same players that's at the football club. And some of them are rotten. I watched the Como game and how Bruno Fernandes has got the nerve to turn around and blame the coaching staff when he didn't try a leg in the game and he was throwing his arms up, blaming everyone else. He's got a nerve blaming Michael Carrick. This is the clip here. He gives the ball away. Watch. Right? Who can I blame? Someone behind me. No, I'll spin around. They're on the attack. Shall I chase back? No, I'll tell you what I'll do. I'll just blame someone who's out wide or someone who'll give me the ball.
8:20Don Hutchison: It's scandalous. So as I said, I don't pin this on Michael Carrick, because Michael Carrick's the same man that got Man United third last year, and they've made silence on top of that, so it's a hierarchy problem. Go and tell Bruno Fernandes and Nassandra Martinez you'll never play for this football club again, and sort the dressing room out from within rather than just changing managers. Let's check it, the word from England. Go on, Craig. One second, one second. Are you giving Michael Carrick a pass here, Don? Because, you know, every other manager at United has judged their results. Michael Carrick, Craig, and rightly so, and he got them third last year.
8:57Don Hutchison: So you can't tell me that Michael Carrick can't do the job. He got them third. So why are this group of players failing on him? Because it's the individuals. You tell me what... It's the players. You tell me what his credentials were, really, to run Manchester United for the club as a manager. Don't worry about credentials. Because I guarantee you, if they fired him, on that list there, they'll go Kieran McKenna. They'll take the easy option. So don't worry about credentials. Credentials never worked in the past when Jose was through the door. It's the players. The players are rotten. That can happen.
9:31No. No. Well, but you have to have accountability. You have to be able to go in and manage the football club. What was it that Mike, apart from the interim job, where he goes in, the same as Solskjaer, by the way, he goes in, everybody's happy for a change because Amarim was stinking. He puts round pegs in round holes. All of a sudden, the player's going to boost and it's a happy place again. He gets results. But longer term, longer term, what's the credentials for the Man United job being sacked by Meadowsborough? I mean, come on.
10:06Don Hutchison: No, but what you've said there, Craig, you've said there it's a happy place when they get results. How about being a decent place when you don't get results? How about the characters that are at Man United? When you lose some games, who are the ones that's going to say, I'll tell you what, I'll roam my sleeves up. Not Lissandra Martinez, and not Bruno Fernandes, because they're just chucking managers and hierarchy under the bus. Ah, it's not our fault. We're playing, but it's not our fault. It's the club's fault. it's the manager's fault it's a scandalous place to be Two things can be true two things can be true Don in my opinion the players are not good enough and I think that's that's evident and there are some bad apples and also the manager cannot not be good enough I think two things can be true and I think we've got a perfect storm here that this is not this job is way too big for Michael Carrick and others and there's some rotten apples in that dressing room this is a perfect scenario of two things can be true and that's why it's such a big mess at Man United.
11:04Don Hutchison: Xhaka? Listen, I think, yeah, I'm with Craig. I don't think Michael Carrick is up to the task of getting this Manchester United team anywhere near what we saw of last season back into European places. Quite clearly, it's feeling like he's lost the dressing room. You can't have Lissandra Martinez making statements as he did, what was it, a week ago now? and then your captain following up after everything that happened there. And we sat down and we spoke and everything that kind of came out following that. Then you have Bruno Fernandes, who is your club captain, making these statements. Now, it says to me that either he's lost the dressing room or he's very close to losing dressing room.
11:50And we've all known, all seen in our experiences in this game, once that happens, there is no getting it back from a managerial perspective. For Bruno Fernandes, though, I do not know where you find the nerve to say that as the team captain on the back of that performance individually and as a team. Now, it's also not lost on me that both Martinez and Bruno Fernandes, their contracts are up next summer. So to Don's point about selling them, January might be the perfect time because given all their kind of posturings, you don't see them staying on. Though I'm not sure exactly where they go following from Manchester United, which club really comes in and gives them the kind of pay that maybe they are getting at Old Trafford.
12:40But they can't stay. They're bad apples in that dressing room. As bad a dressing room as it is, they're making it worse.
12:47Don Hutchison: And yet, Ale, from the big English media outlet, we're hearing that he'll keep the captaincy and he's unlikely to face punishment. Bruno Fernandes, that is. And that is lack of accountability from the club. And that's why Bruno Fernandes feels like he has the power and the latitude to say whatever he wants, because there is nothing coming his way. If you felt threatened in any way or if you felt like the club was running a proper manner or you felt like the manager had any power, you would not come out and say these things, even if you felt that that was the case. And even if indeed it is true, whatever Bruno Fernandes is saying, you still don't come out and say this because this exposes your team.
13:25It exposes the manager. It makes everything worse. It adds fuel to everything that is going on right now in Manchester United. And so while I understand that Michael Carrick may be a dead man walking, and this is further evidence of that, the fact that the club captain says these things and feels like there is no threat coming his way, I understand that fully. This guy cannot be your club captain. This guy cannot be your club captain. This guy cannot represent your club. Your club right now is on fire, burning hot. And you need leaders, which we continue to ask for Manchester United to have leaders.
14:02We need leaders to actually come out and get their chest out and say, we're going to do better. We're going to work together. We're going to run for each other and show it. Not only just say it, but then show it on the field. And from the evidence of what we saw against Como, there was no running. There was no leadership. There was no present. There was no game plan. There was no executional game plan. And there was no personality on the field. So all this personality that Bruno Fernandes is showing post-match, in saying what he says, if I were a Manchester United fan, I would ask for that personality to be shown on the field, where it matters.
14:35Not in front of the media, not in front of the microphone, on the field. Because that's where you are evaluated. it and this team right now when you evaluate who they are both on the field and off the field
14:46Don Hutchison: failure everywhere and on the field they could definitely do with a win this weekend dan well well one second one second if michael carrick who knows he's on his way out right probably uh it may not get to the weekend who the hell knows where are we thursday all right we're close but if michael carrick has any stomach right he knows his time is limited there. He also knows he needs results desperately if he's got half a chance of saving himself. But I think not only should he not be club captain Bruno Fernandes, I don't think he should play at all. If Michael Carradine has made a statement and say, I'm not having that.
15:26Alright, you might sack me, we might lose at the weekend, but I'm not having that. I'm not having any player coming out publicly, come to my office and say to me, your tactics are crap, and we'll have a discussion. Don't go on national TV. and drag us through the mud and say, we have no idea. You're out. You're not playing. And if I get sacked, I'm going to go down doing it my way. You think about that with Sir Alex Ferguson. What would have happened? I know he'd run in with Roy, Roy Keane and that, whatever. But any player who came out and said, and would have even intimated Alex Ferguson had no idea what he was doing.
16:03He wouldn't be at the football club. So he should not play. They've got to make a statement here and say, listen, when we put managers in charge you can't come out as a player and say this coaching staff that are employees of the football club have no clue what they're doing and if they've got anything about them Michael Carrick, and if he's going to go down which looks, the ship is going down go down with a fight and say you I'm not in the trenches with you Bruno Fernandes, you're out
16:30Don Hutchison: Alright, well we'll end that segment there on Manchester United it's going to be interesting to see what goes down I thought Dan's input was excellent in that segment. He really brought it. His Spanish was perfect. Now to a Martinez. He needs to step it up. Believe it or not, we were doing Football Americas earlier. And he was the pundit. I just sat here. But the wonderful thing was he accepted it so well. I can imagine. unfortunately we won't be hearing from the guys on tonight's extra time there will still be more coming from us in the show tonight though make sure to go check out the latest edition of extra time over on our youtube channel the big one hits the calendar this weekend it's barcelona against real madrid barcelona in first after nine games they are perfect so far this season and they are yet to lose a league game.
17:33Don Hutchison: Real Madrid, for their part, have already lost two. What's going on out there, Dan? There seems to be a bit of a clatter. The television was just blown over by the wind. Oh, no. And now it's being fixed. It's very exciting. That's great. Can you tell us about El Cosico then, Dan? Seeing as though you're there. Listen, if Freddie, our producer, who is fixing it, if he just steps up, you'll see a rather last bald head on your camera. You think it's Robbo. Right, anyway. It's a younger version of Robo with a smile on his face. Yeah, less bitter. Right, Real Madrid against Barcelona. This is all about Real Madrid, isn't it, Craig?
18:08Don Hutchison: In the sense that if they lose this, then they've pretty much lost the title. Yeah, nine points, you know, picking the end fight. Particularly, you know, we talked about this a little earlier. Particularly if Barcelona wipe the floor with them on Sunday, which is possible the way they're playing. You just never know. I don't think that will happen. I think it may be a bit tighter than that. but the goals have been pretty easy for them to come. If that was the case and nine points, you'd find it very, very difficult for them to come back. So it's huge. You know, if Real Madrid lose, there's going to be, we talked about Man United squabbling and infighting.
18:42It's going to be the same at Real Madrid. There'll be an inquest. There'll be a debrief. There'll be a blame game. So it is massive for them. I suppose the Leipzig result was a bonus for them, although they have been shipping goals for fun in the Bundesliga, got hammered by Bayern Munich. so it's really really intriguing and also we have no idea what Mourinho's team is going to be we know Mbappe will play we know Bellingham will play we know probably two of many people like that but where's Gouler going to play, where's Valverde going to play who's going to be the wide player on the other side from Diamandi what's the centre back pairing going to be Denzel Dumfries and Trent Alexander-Arnold we know Alexander-Arnold won't play but is Valverde going to go back in and Dumfries comes in you know, you didn't want I don't think Endric will play, I know he played last week but there lies the problem, one of the problems for Jose Mourinho that you know, we're so many games into this La Liga season and I think going into the biggest game of the season he's probably had four or five different teams down in paper and I'm not sure, I'm going to change there whereas Hansi Flick is pretty much putting his best 11 out, Rafinha's back we know pretty much where their team's going to be so that's a much slicker out
19:56Don Hutchison: Are we going to see a scrappy Real Madrid side like we did against Atletico in a sense where they're going to want to frustrate Barcelona? They're not going to want to give them any chances on the ball. There's going to be those niggly fouls. There's going to be time wasted. There's going to be complaining to the referee. Is that the way in which they're going to set out this stall to try and stutter this Barcelona attack? I think they may try, but I don't think they'll succeed doing that. I think if they're going to win it, they're going to have to play some football. And they can do that. We just haven't seen it with the regularity.
20:25we've seen at Barcelona. I don't think just sitting in defensively, trying to stifle almost Argentina-esque from the World Cup, not quite as horrible as that, obviously, and let's hope not. I don't think that's going to work for them. I think Barcelona, if that's the case, will cut them apart. So I think they're going to have to come out at some point and utilise their strong points. Get Gouler on the ball, get Bellingham forward, make sure Mbappe's making these runs. Diamandis is a much more confident young man now. He's got a couple of goals. So I think they're going to have to get on the front foot.
20:55I don't think they'll outpossess Barcelona. I don't even think that's up for debate. But it's how they can match Rodri and Pedri and Fermin Lopez and stop all that good stuff that Bayern do, that Basa do. And also, somebody's going to have to get out there, if it's Cucurella, and help stop Laminya Mao. He wasn't great. We've touched on it. He wasn't great in PSG and Paris in midweek. So he'll be looking for a big... He scored a great goal. He'll be looking for a big turnaround in performance. It's a really, I mean, it's a big, huge game anyway, but it's really intriguing for so many reasons and all the ones that we've mentioned, plus the fact that Barcelona could not quite, but almost nail down the title in October, which is very early.
21:39Does what happened midweek against PSG have any relevance to this game? Well, it's always nice to go out and batter teams by five goals every week, which they've pretty much been doing. But PSG are the best team in Europe at the moment. I don't think there's much debate about that and everyone else has to raise the game. Hansi Flick has said he made changes for that game. Obviously, Rodri didn't play. Rafinha got some game time after injuries, some sharpness. He came off. He made changes and substitutions, as we've discussed, with this game in mind. So, you know, it's a bit of a hammer blow in the locker room, but I think that's right.
22:12And Jürgen Klinsmann, our colleagues, talked about it with Hansi Flick. One of the many things he's good at is the management side of it. And I'm sure he's managed that particular match in midweek the right way. Kate, we'll head back to you in the studio. Shall I tell you a dinner story?
22:27Don Hutchison: I would like you to because I was told that he's been getting some shade, Craig has, from the Spanish waiters. Well, as you know, the waiters over here are older than those, for example, in the States. This is quite an elderly man. So maybe he watched Craig play when he was growing up. And he asked me if Craig used to be a footballer. And I said, yeah, yeah, he played for Scotland. He goes, no, what about clubs? And I went, oh, Celtic and Chelsea. and then he writes 15 down on the table and goes, he can talk to me when he's won 15 Champions Leagues. That was that. I didn't know a waiter in Barcelona had won 15 Champions Leagues.
23:03By the way, I need teeth missing as well. It was like his kindred spirit. He was grumpy. And he was bold.
23:12Don Hutchison: It's been a lovely time so far, Kay. I can't wait for my dinner stories. Keep them coming. Great stuff. We're going to let you go and rest, guys. Oh, thank you. No extra time? No extra time. No extra time, sadly, to do too tonight. But the big one coming up for the Vogue on Sunday, Barcelona against Real Madrid. Our coverage will begin at 3pm Eastern. Kick-off is at 4. It's available on ABC, on the app and on ESPN Deportes.
23:43Don Hutchison: Let's get you a little Europa League action now. with former Manchester United manager Ruben Amarim returning to the UK with Milan. Yes, and the rain. What did he expect? And it was Bournemouth who'd be hosting them. Bournemouth corner here. It's cleared away, but VAR have to have a look at this, and they spot that the header goes off the hand of De Vinta. Penalty to Bournemouth. Yeah, you see that replay. De Vinta's arm is well raised. That's a penalty. Justin Clyburn makes no mistake from 12 yards. Watch this. At this 27th minute, the whistle was blown. Mike Manyan would see a straight red for shoving Tyler Adams in the face.
24:23And you cannot do that to Tyler Adams for Americas! U.S. Men's national team! Oh boy! I don't think you can do that to anybody, but certainly not to Tyler Adams! Oh boy. 100 % of the cost! Not in my day. Well, your day was a while back, Shaq. Back in my day, that was totally fine.
24:45Don Hutchison: And then Amin Adli. It's a really nice free kick. Wall splits for some very strange reason. Finds that gap. Keeper, no chance. And now we are back to the Premier League, particularly for Bournemouth, because they are heading to Manchester United for their game this weekend. I see that Ruang Amorim is doing well in England. Yeah, good job for him. Lots coming up this weekend in the Premier League as we take a look at the schedule. Brighton in third as it stands right now. visits Anfield to take on fifth-placed Liverpool. And that's where we'll start by talking about what's going to go on in that game.
25:20Don Hutchison: Don Hutchison is still with us. What are we expecting to see here, Don?
25:27Don Hutchison: Goals, goals, goals. It'll be one of the most open Premier League games, I think, at Anfield you'll see for a long, long time because Brighton are just free-flowing. They spanked Palace last week by five of the top scorers, I think, in the Premier League. Herzl's men will not try and park the bus. They'll try and score Liverpool. And I just think when you get certain games that leap off the pages, Liverpool will score goals 100%. They've got too much firepower. They'll leak goals because they're not keeping clean sheets and Brighton will punish them. So pick your scoreline, but loads of goals.
26:01Do you want to pick your scoreline? I'll pick my scoreline and see that while we've got goals, Brighton will score more than the other guys. I think kind of given Some of Liverpool's own stumblings during the course of this season, at times they haven't been overly convincing. Brighton have just been a breath of fresh air throughout. I expect Brighton to continue to show the good form that we've seen, continue to play the form, the play football that Hitzler hasn't played. Right now, it's just difficult to pick against Brighton, especially when the opponent, even at home, is as inconsistent as Liverpool has been.
26:40I don't want to counteract your argument with facts, Shaq, but Brighton was held scoreless today in the conference league. Yeah, that's the conference league, though. That's the conference league. I'm just saying. That's the conference league. You know, the free-flowing, goal-scoring. And that was away in the conference league. That's all right. That's all right. That's all right. So the free-flowing stops away? Yeah. And at the conference league. When you go to Shaq Republic, it stops. Okay. Brighton will have no problem in the northwest of England. Back in England, they're fine. But to your point, and I don't know that this is, yeah, the fact that you knew this was the Czech Republic that we're talking about, that was impressive, Shaq.
27:23Don Hutchison: His geography is unmuched, remember. Well, I don't know. His geography and his record in geography is questionable. But neither here nor there. You digress. Yeah, I do digress. Let me get back to Brighton. And I don't know if it's apples to apples here, but I watch Brighton play and there is a Como feel to Brighton. There's a Como air to Brighton. And perhaps that's where the similarities end. But all I would say is that this is a team that you call them a breath of fresh air. I think it's a team that they're just fun to watch. They're fun to watch play. It has to be fun to be a player for Brighton because of how they approach the game.
28:02The high pressure, the willingness to go and create numbers and opportunities in the attack with numbers, committing those numbers forward, not thinking about, hey, if this guy goes forward now, let's see what's going on in our back line. These guys, they know who they are, they have an identity, and that's all you can ask from a team, and Brighton knows that very well. So they'll attack Liverpool. And I imagine that Liverpool, given what they have been defensively this year, they'll have difficulties hanging on against Brighton. However, because Brighton commits number fours, then, hey, maybe there is an opportunity for Liverpool.
28:41Maybe there is a chance for them to get in transition, to find open spaces. And what is the best part of Liverpool's game? Well, it's not defending. In midfield, they have very little structure. They don't really close the ball down all that much. But once they get into the attack, there is something there for Liverpool. So maybe there's a chance here for Liverpool to, dare I say, pull off the upset against Brighton. This is, this is. Is that where you're putting your hard-earned money when you go to the bookies later? I do not go to the bookies. You don't have a favourite, according to that. No, but I think, well, they may be the favourites, but I think that may be due to.
29:24Don Hutchison: They're not your favourite. They may be due to history. They may be due to name, but not to performances. So it's going to be an upset. Well, in my mind, I even think that Stidi said that last week was a good result and that, you know, it's okay because Brentford and this and that. And, you know, you're thinking, that's where we are with Liverpool? That this feels like a turning moment? It may just be that against Brighton. Yet another turning moment for Liverpool. There is an opportunity here. I'm just saying. We will see. More Premier League action coming up this weekend. Let's take a look at some of those fixtures once again.
30:07Don Hutchison: You've got Villa against City. City obviously top of the league, but Villa had a tough start to the season. They found their stride now. Chelsea taking on Spurs is going to be interesting because Spurs are looking to follow up on their first Premier League win. They're on a roll. Yep. Well, they might be about to be. And then, of course, there's Manchester United against Bournemouth. But which of these games are you looking forward to, John?
30:31Don Hutchison: I mean, Liverpool, Brighton, but I've got to say Chelsea Spurs should be a cracker. I mean, that's a game where Tottenham have got to show their mettle. It's all right beating Coventry and thinking we're back. They've got to go to Stamford Bridge and try and convince everyone they can go there and win. The pressure game, obviously, is for Man United at home to Bournemouth. And Bournemouth couldn't ask for a better Thursday night than beating AC Milan. and rested players, took players off, put players on for minutes because the game was done. So they'll be completely fresh. So, yeah, pressure game, Old Trafford.
31:02Don Hutchison: Goals at Liverpool. And our Tottenham going to be back in the bottom three after a loss. You know, we're done, by the way. He might as well just do the show on his own. You ask him about Chelsea's purse, and he brings up Manchester United Bermuda. I mean that. Yeah, and also touches on a game we just talked about. Yeah, yeah. Just do your own thing, Don. Do your own thing, Don. Knowledge out. Thanks, Don. Stick around, Don. We need you for extra time. ASPN is available every single day The crew will be back tomorrow to look ahead to more of these games Not just the ones that Don wants
31:32Don Hutchison: Always a brilliant time to be on the show on Thursday No Venezuelan teams in the top ten either Shaq has power rankings PSG, Alistair, after two incredible results in the Champions League They're in at number one Barca are down, they've lost to the best team in the land In the land? In the land. In all the land. All the land that's on the planet. All the land that you can think of. PSG is the best team in that. Oh, man. Arsenal, Betis, Atletico Madrid, Galatasaray are up. Azar Leon, joint points with PSG, good result in the Champions League. Inter back in. Brighton down two after they drew away in the Czech Republic.
32:17Goalless. Goalless draw. But that'll count. They're just down too. It's more about Inter rebounding as did Lyon. Okay, can I ask some questions? Yeah, if you like.
32:29Don Hutchison: Alright. Don's here as well. He might have some questions too. And I'm going to jump ahead of Don and ask about Inter because I know Don has a soft spot for Serie A. I know they lost last week. Don's the ten men this week. Whoa, whoa, whoa. Yeah, but they did lose to Club Brugge. Yeah, that was last week. At home. That was last week. They rebounded impressively with 10 men. So much so that he puts them back in the top 10. Yep. You know? And what did Galatasaray do? Because they got destroyed by Barcelona. That was last week. Okay. So what you're suggesting is that last week was important. What I'm suggesting is a brand new week, Ali.
33:10Okay. Leon, in this current week, they're ahead of PSG in their own league. By goal difference. Are they? Are they ahead? Yes. Yes. I don't think so, Ali. Yes, they are. Yes, they are. I don't think so. Well, that's what the stand-in say, Shaq. I'm in for my producers to confirm. Leon. But Leon is first. PSG is second.
33:38Don Hutchison: How many points have they all got? Yeah, but Leon is first. PSG is second. So what? So what? So what are we asking? I'm asking you have PSG ahead of the team that is ahead of them in their own league. Because PSG just beat Barcelona. They joined 10 points. PSG just demolished Barcelona in the Champions League. That's worth more than gold difference. You're inconsistent with your argument. No, no, no, no. So last week's argument is different than this week's argument. Last week is last week. Last week's price is last week's price. I didn't realize we had to make that differentiation. Donny, you going to give him a hard time too?
34:15Don't give me a hard time.
34:17Don Hutchison: Yeah, I think what's happened here is Shaq's had a couple of good months on the power rankings and he's got lazy. He's been lazy this week. We're taking exception with. Correct me if I'm wrong, Shaq. We're taking exception with. I'll tell you what I'm taking. Well, I'll tell you. Man City won and Barca lost. And Man City are behind Barca. How does that work? And that was this week. That was? Yes. This week, Shaq. But Barca lost to the best team in the land. that just beat Man City in all the land. All the land. They beat the team in the top ten. City lost last week. They rebounded to some, you know, who's a team who's not the best in the land.
34:58But that was last week, Shaq. Yes, Ali. That's right.
35:04Don Hutchison: Good choice. Betis. I remember you snubbing them a few seasons ago. Yeah, Betis. Betis has won all their games in Europe so far. So, good stuff, Shaq. Thank you, K. Appreciate you. That's Shakur's power. Ali and Don, not so much. Every Thursday you can get there. No Mirosbrother and no Real Madrid in that top ten. All right, thank you so much for being with us on ESPN FC. Extra Time is on the way next. Don Hutchison is rejoining us. Shakur and Ali will be answering your questions too. See you there.
35:35Don Hutchison: Welcome in to the latest edition of Extra Time. Shakur and Ali are here in the studio. Don Hutchison joining us too. First question. Start, bench or drop these games from entertaining to chaos. Barca vs PSG, Bayern vs Arsenal and Liverpool vs Villa.
35:57Go on, Dan. So, Villarreal.
36:03Don Hutchison: Oh, sorry, Villarreal.
36:07Don Hutchison: Start. Start PSG, Barca.
36:15Don Hutchison: Bench, Bayern, Arsenal, drop, Liverpool, Villarreal. I'm with Don, that order. All right. And you know, I agree with Don, but I think what sold it for me is how dramatic he was with taking his glasses off. Yeah. That really, I felt connected to that. It was like, fuck. He was taking this seriously. Yeah. It was like, fuck. Let me get my smart glasses off. A lot of strength behind it. So it was like, fact. Yes. Grade each of Manchester United's summer sign-ins. Balaba, Santos, Tielemans and Rashford. Oh boy. What's the scale? Zero to one. The glasses are back on for Professor Rush.
37:08Nobody's been gone. Why don't we ask Lisandro Martinez? He'll give us a good outlook on the signing. Oh, apparently we can also ask Lautaro Martinez. He would know too. We found out during the show today.
37:22All I'm going to go is feeling greed. There's no scale on this. None of them have been cut by any measure.
37:28Don Hutchison: I'll fail for you, Don. But Labour will be good. But Labour will come good. I think he's top draw. He's a young kid, launched into a Man United side that was struggling. He's only played a couple of games. He'll come good. All right, Ali. Don's pre-season predictions. Which was worse? Florian Wurtz, Player of the Year, on Manchester United top five? Oh boy.
38:01Well, the answer is the leather jacket. Nothing's worth it.
38:08Chelsea second. I think Florian Verth's player of the year. There was an argument to be made for Manchester United, given where they finished last season. But given what we saw from Florian Verth's last season, there was no evidence to suggest that he was going to take that leap from struggling to player of the year. I think we'll be talking more about Manchester United than we will floor and verse, but in terms of a prediction that was out of control, I think that was much more out of control than Manchester United finishing where he done had it. Yeah, I agree. There's enough time in the season for somebody to come in and do his character back in the last season and all of a sudden Manchester United come good, surprisingly.
39:01No, no, no, no, one of these ones.
39:03Don Hutchison: No, no, no, it's going to happen again, this one. All right, okay. Thank you, Keir. You're so kind. Right, where was I? There's still time for somebody to come in, turn things around in Manchester United, whether with this team or they spend a whole heap of money in January, who knows, for them to come close to top four, at least. I can't see Florian Woods coming close to play. The hands were going everywhere there, Shaq. You felt very passionate. I was involved. You know, you felt it. Good, I liked it. Ale, what's the matter with Vinny? Will Madrid wind up regretting that huge contract extension?
39:39Don Hutchison: This is from Xhaka's Vacation Planner. I'm surprised my vacation planner has had time to send a question in. I don't know why I enjoy more. Xhaka's Vacation Planner or give Xhaka more vacay day.
39:59Either one is a winner. I really thought that in him, in Vinny getting his contract, that whatever reservations or whatever resentment he had about Kylian Mbappe being there and him getting all the attention, that that was sort of going to go away. And he would focus more on being the player that we think he can be consistently. So a productive player, a difference maker, an impactful player. but we have seen Vinny Jr. struggle in the areas that are largely what make him a good player. 1v1 situations. Don't see him taking on players as much. Has a tendency now to just cut to the inside and look for the shot.
40:46If it doesn't happen, then he's just playing the ball backwards. It tells me there's a player that is lacking a little bit of confidence and still hasn't quite figured out what his role is while killing Mbappe is on the field. I don't think it's a coincidence that if you go back to last season, Vinny's best games with Real Madrid were when Kylian Mbappé was out injured or was not on the field or was absent, whatever the case may have been. When he was not on the field, Vinny then becomes the guy and feels like the guy, feels that love, feels that responsibility and plays better. Either he figures out how to play with Kylian Mbappé and understand that there is a role for him to participate in this team and to find what that role is, or Real Madrid, to answer the question and the vacation planner.
41:31Yeah, I think Real Madrid are going to try to figure out, like, wait a minute, what have we done here? We thought we had an answer, and now the answer is not quite what we thought it was. And if the team doesn't win, which is more important than everything else, then you start looking at reasons as to why they're not winning, and one of those reasons may just be that that relationship is not working.
41:52Don Hutchison: Okay. And I like the next name as well, Murray's Middlesbrough Americans. or his promo push. But I'm going to put it to you, Don. How big of a blow is Kovaritskeli's injury? Are PSG still favourites for you?
42:10Don Hutchison: Massive blow. I mean, I've done an ACL and it's horrific. That'll be his season gone. You're looking at nine, ten months. So, yeah, I think there's an argument to say the last 18 months he's been one of the best or in the conversation was one of the best wingers in world football so it'd be a massive miss i think the thing with phe is they've got you've got the serious options um duet can step into that position and be just as good but the thing that he does i think better than anyone else gravid skellia as he works back and he puts his foot in he does the defensive side of the work for all those attacking players and he's one of them himself he's the perfect example off the back of the viney junior chat there where he is just willing just to go do you know what if i've got to work back and run back 50 yards i'll do it if i've got to tackle people i'll do it then i'll take players on and i'll score goals and i'll be brilliant so i feel for him anyone that i see with an acl i haven't been there myself i feel for him he'll be back but this season this season will be gone i'm afraid but psg favorites yes or no champions league to make it yeah i think everyone yeah i think everyone's got to get to that level yeah i do i do have a hypothetical question for shaq and we saw don today with the glasses and now he gave us the prognosis for cabrascadia given his experience would you trust more don doing your taxes because we know math is is an issue for him or would you trust him being your doctor?
43:42Dr. Don or CPA Don? No, I'll go CPA Don because CPA Don, I'll end up in prison. Dr.
44:01Don.
44:04Don Hutchison: Are they still favorites for you even with him as your tax man? Who? CSG. Oh. Out for Barrett Skellier now that he's out for the season. Yes, they are. Yes. They're still favourites for me. Never mind that. That is not the definitive list. The power rankings is where everything is at. This week. Well, they were still able to use him in the game. Top of the power rankings. So, yes, they are. Top of your power rankings in a game they were still able to use him in. This is a game they lost him in. Okay. Is it going to change now, Shaq? Don't complicate it. I won't complicate it. Top of the power rankings.
44:37They're not top of the rookies list. Okay, don't bring facts into the conversation and discuss in Xhaka's power rankings. He keeps telling us that it's an algorithm, but I think it's more feel than anything else. Next week, to your point, Cade, maybe a different price, but this week is PSG.
44:55Don Hutchison: All right, well, while we're on PSG... Last week, they wouldn't admit. Even that Don gave a lot of love to Douay. For Ale, what do you think the ceiling is for Desiree Douay, and is he regarded at the same level as Lamin-Yemal? Well, a high ceiling for Desiree Due, not as high a ceiling as Lamin-Yamal. So if the question is a comparison between Desiree Due and Lamin-Yamal, I think Lamin-Yamal impacts and affects the game in more ways than Desiree Due does. That doesn't mean that Due is not a tremendous talent. Yes, he is. But according to the question, it feels like, can he be as good or is he regarded?
45:31Do we think of him as good as Lamin-Yamal to be on the same level? I don't think that's the case. As talented as Desiree Due, I just believe that there is something particularly special about Lamin Jamal in how he impacts the game, how he changes the game, and how dependent Barcelona have become on him, being the guy that can resolve problems for Barcelona, for Spain, for anybody. Give him the ball, let him resolve issues for you. Desiree Due can do that, but I don't think at the same level as Lamin Jamal.
45:59Don Hutchison: For Don, percentage chance Brighton finishes in top five.
46:08Don Hutchison: Oh, that's a good question. That's a good question. That is a good question. Okay. I think it's a good question, Don. I'm going to say... That's a good question. I didn't see it coming. I thought it was going to be like top three or four or something. So top five. I'm going to say a 25 % chance they'll do it. What about Manchester United, Don, since you put them there ahead of us?
46:36Don Hutchison: They'll be part of that conversation. Also 25 %? Nah, we've only played seven games. We've played seven games, man. All right. I think they've got off the top of my head, I want to say they've got Liverpool and Man City next. That'll be the test. Okay. Kay, if you needed a last-second babysitter for your kids, do you trust anyone on today's show with them? I mean, I think that question is self-explanatory, really. Easy. I could make you all laugh, but I actually would trust all three of them with them. It's easy. And that's the truth, because Ale has actually put his family to work to look after my children.
47:15Don Hutchison: It's already happened. And it was a resounding success. He always makes a big effort with them whenever I have to bring them in. Shaka actually found my lost son, Luca, who disappeared somewhere upstairs in the office. It's more about my mother in school. That's a different conversation. Different conversation, okay? Shaka found him and Don has got about a million kids so of course he's going to be able to look after my kid I mean I let Shaka off on that one so I see so yeah I'd actually trust all three of them with the boys so yeah there you go guys see the thing the thing that would happen Kate the thing that would happen if Shaka was in charge he'd have them by the computer doing his power rankings for next week that's what would happen there because he'd be lazy it might make more sense from five and six and he'd get them to do it or his taxes.
48:05Oh, yeah. I'm attacking, yeah, that's right. Who knows?
48:08Don Hutchison: All right. Lovely stuff. Thank you so much for sending in your questions. We will be back tomorrow to do it all over again. Be sure to join us on ESPN FC.
The FC crew continue to react to Manchester United's loss at Como and explain why they think Michael Carrick will not be in charge of the club much longer. Plus, Craig Burley and Dan Thomas look ahead to Sunday's El Clasico and break down why they think Barcelona should cruise to victory. Don Hutchison also picks out his favorite matches in the Premier League this weekend.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices