Carrick on the Hot Seat?

17 Sep 2026 · 47 min · 22 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

The episode is an ESPN FC roundtable focused on football results and near-term pressure points. Topic 1: Manchester United’s early-season collapse after a Carabao Cup loss—City thrashed Norwich 5-0; Brighton beat Man United after criticism of manager Michael Carrick’s team’s lack of resilience.

Key claims

United’s issue isn’t just the cup; it’s the “whole package” (league form, conceding goals, squad depth, midfield balance after Casemiro’s departure).

Notable examples

United leading 2-0 at home vs Brighton then losing 3-2; earlier season defeats including Hull City; Sunday’s looming match vs Fulham as a potential pressure trigger. Topic 2: The Madrid derby build-up (Real vs Atlético) and Real’s reliance on Bellingham and Mbappé, with Vinícius Jr. under scrutiny.

Guests

Craig Burley (former defender/analyst), Dan Thomas (host), Xhaka (panelist), plus Phil Jones (former Man United defender).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Manchester City's Dominance and Carrick's Critique

0:00 to 0:25

Analyzing Manchester City's victory and the criticism of Carrick's management.

“ESPN's going to Super Bowl 61 and so can you.”

Manchester City's Dominance and Carrick's Critique

0:46 to 2:42

Analyzing Manchester City's victory and the criticism of Carrick's management.

“after coming from behind to beat Manchester United.”

Concerns for Manchester United's Season Start

2:42 to 4:50

Discussion on Manchester United's inconsistent performances and future challenges.

“Former Man Utd defender Phil Jones joins us.”

Manchester United's Squad Depth Issues

4:50 to 7:20

Exploring depth issues and injuries impacting Manchester United's performance.

“So they need to pick up the baton pretty quick.”

Recruitment and Management Decisions at Manchester United

7:20 to 11:47

Debating the effectiveness of recent recruitment and management strategies.

“I think technically he's been a fantastic player, fantastic servant to Villa, and he's come in.”

The Changing Dynamics of Manchester United

11:47 to 14:01

Discussing the evolving challenges faced by Manchester United and Carrick's role.

“Pretty much every team at the moment in the Premier League, maybe Coventry apart, have started really poorly.”

Analyzing Recent Signings and Team Balance

14:01 to 17:46

Discussion on the impact of recent player signings and team dynamics.

“You'd have to say some of the signings over the last few years, probably not.”

Upcoming Matches and Managerial Pressure

17:46 to 18:30

Exploration of the implications of the upcoming Fulham match for the manager.

“Mark Ogden was on yesterday's show tearing apart the owners and the way in which they have acted over the last few seasons.”

Sponsor: O'Reilly Auto Parts

18:30 to 19:18

Promotion for Rain-X wiper blades and O'Reilly Auto Parts services.

“They will even install them for free at O 'Reilly Auto Parts.”

Derby Talk: Real Madrid vs. Atletico Madrid

19:18 to 27:24

Discussion surrounding the Madrid derby and team performances leading up to it.

“I'm great, but I'm worried now that Craig's judging everyone's appearance.”
Show all 22 chapters

Barcelona's Strong Start and Future Challenges

27:24 to 28:00

Analysis of Barcelona's performance and strategies for the season ahead.

“But it's a continuation of Hansi Flick's work, isn't it?”

Barcelona's Tactical Evolution

28:00 to 29:48

Discussion on how Barcelona has adapted and improved their squad dynamics this season.

“They have the foresight and the decision-making to let him go back.”

Chesney's Role and Challenges

29:48 to 31:43

Analysis of Chesney's performance and the challenges he faces with injuries in the team.

“You've got to be loving what you're seeing in terms of the excitement.”

Previewing Brentford vs. Chelsea

31:43 to 34:16

A breakdown of the upcoming match between Brentford and Chelsea, highlighting team dynamics and expectations.

“Let's take a look at how the bookies have it.”

Power Rankings Discussion

34:16 to 36:30

A lively discussion on the current power rankings in European football and key teams' performances.

“I put City above Arsenal because they won on the road.”

Individual Awards and Recognition

36:30 to 38:14

A lighthearted conversation on the significance of individual awards in football and personal experiences.

“The spread that was put on for us today was delightful.”

Michael Carrick's Management Style

38:14 to 40:04

Examining Michael Carrick's approach as a manager and his impact on Middlesbrough and beyond.

“Shaka, when you won Hammer of the Year, did you say, no, I don't want it?”

Haaland vs. Rafinha Goals Debate

40:04 to 42:01

Debate on who will score more goals this season, Haaland or Rafinha, exploring their respective performances.

“He actually sent Craig into the positivity corner, if you remember.”

Memories of Madrid Nights

42:01 to 42:33

A humorous discussion about past nightlife experiences in Madrid.

“Kay, Sid told us once that Dan was fun on a night out in the mid-2000s.”

Cultural Bars vs. Nice Bars

42:34 to 43:10

A light-hearted debate on the difference between cultured and nice bars.

“In Spain, in a beautiful city like Madrid, going to a karaoke.”

Plans and Excitement for Football Americas

43:11 to 44:18

Discussion about upcoming plans for Football Americas and past experiences.

“I knew if I did overindulge, I would find the hotel.”

Beards and Personal Remarks

44:19 to 44:49

Light banter about personal appearances, particularly a beard.

Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00ESPN's going to Super Bowl 61 and so can you. Enter for a chance to win the trip of a lifetime. Four tickets to Super Bowl 61 plus a three night stay at Disneyland Resort where you and up to three guests can enjoy the magic of Disney plus the Super Bowl champion cavalcade. Enter at www.espn.com slash sblxi by December 31st, 2026 for your chance to win.

0:19Stewart Robson:No purchase necessary. Ends 12-31-26 at 11-59 p.m. Eastern. Open only to legal residents of the 50 U.S. states and Washington, D.C. who are 18 plus at time of entry. For odds of winning and full official rules, visit www.espn.com slash sblxi. Void where prohibited.

0:34Welcome in to the latest edition of ESPN FC. I'm Dan Thomas, joined by Craig Burley and Xhaka. Here's what we'll kick things off for the Carabao Cup. Manchester City thrashing Norwich by five goals to nil to set up a tie with Brighton in the next round. Brighton grabbing the headlines, of course, after coming from behind to beat Manchester United. Yes, they dominated the back pages of the UK newspapers. A lot of criticism towards Michael Carrick. Here is the Manchester United manager.

0:59Stewart Robson:The way we started the game, 25 minutes into the game, we were in such a good position, playing well, doing all the things that we wanted to do and it feels like it's a long time ago, the feeling at the start of the game to the end of the game couldn't have been further apart. So, yeah, you've got to accept, the game can't go in that direction from where we were. Do you see enough resilience in this changing room to come back on something? because that has been an up and down season performance wise and results wise. Did you see enough resilience in that training? Yeah, I mean, a couple of smallish things then to accumulate into, to be honest, the fields are bigger.

1:44I'm not asking the question, you know, I think if you go, yeah, but that's from a goal to the City goal to them, it creates a bit of a feeling.

1:54Stewart Robson:and the game today for what it is we fully accept we totally take responsibility we can't put ourselves in that position after being ahead in the game and the game finishing like it did so it's kind of a couple of things have gone and all of a sudden it becomes a greater thing from nowhere really so we've got to react to it we've got another game on Sunday we've got to react to it I think that's That's the crucial thing now. It's happened so quickly. To have the feeling it's happened quickly tonight in the game. It's happened over a period of a couple of weeks, maybe two, three weeks, where there's a lot of frustration and disappointment around.

2:36Stewart Robson:We need to flip that and start winning games again. Former Man Utd defender Phil Jones joins us. Phil, is this a big deal? Look I don't think it's a time to panic just yet I think they're only Four games into the season However I think it's Conceding the goals are conceding And the manner of the way that they're conceding them Is probably the more alarming factor Especially the other night Against Brighton Tuna look Started the game really well And then to concede the goals that they did And to sort of The game peters out in the way it did It would be a frustrating night for sure Certainly the Carabao Cup though, isn't it, Craig?

3:18Stewart Robson:No, it is, but I think it's a slightly more concerning overall start to the season if you put it in as a package. Particularly coming off the back of the Derby defeat against 10 men. OK, it was a horrendous decision to give the goal. But that apart, Man United did not play well. And they haven't really played well all season. You know, starting with that defeat at Hull City where Michael Carrick got angsty with Jan Agafiotov, our colleague, and then it just sort of rolled on from there. The concern for... I mean, it is early, but I think people will already be talking, we'll be saying... A lot of people will be saying the same thing.

4:01Stewart Robson:Oh, this is a repeat, a rinse and repeat of somebody comes in, takes the interim role, does particularly well, gets the job, and then it's all going to go flat again, and then they have to start again. I think that's the concern. I think it is early for that kind of talk, but I think that will be the talk maybe among some of the supporters. Oh, we've made the wrong decision again, and we should have done this and should have done that. So only results will, clearly, only results will turn that around. But it has been a concerning start to the season, particularly the way they've played. And yeah, being 2-0, and I know he made some changes, but being 2-0 up at home and then losing 3-2.

4:38Stewart Robson:Against a decent Brighton side, I have to say, they've started to pick up a bit of pace. but that's just another concern for Michael Carrick and the players and the confidence it's not the Carabao Cup because we know teams don't take this really serious the big teams until the latter stages if they're still in it but it's the whole package at the moment with United, that's the bigger picture concern, it's not just the Carabao Cup it's been the league form as well and that's going to travel forward when the Champions League starts and it's going to get tougher. So they need to pick up the baton pretty quick.

5:15Frank Leboeuf:Listen, it is early. Phil is absolutely right. But it's been an easy start this season, in all honesty. The toughest test for Manchester United was Manchester City and they had a man-send-off after 25 minutes. So while you want to say, and you can quite easily excuse this as the Carabao Cup, no real need for panic just yet, given what you've seen so far this season, wins against Ipswich and Sabah of all Manchester United have to boast of this season. That's a concern. And kind of given what we saw last season from Manchester United, where they got knocked out at this same stage of the competition last year, you just wonder if history is repeating itself.

5:57Frank Leboeuf:A history that nobody thought they'd be seeing when Michael Carrick came in and took over and they had the finish of the season that they did. Now all of a sudden we're sitting here and Sunday's game against Fulham just feels like a very big game this season.

6:13Stewart Robson:I mean, the game that they've been in control of, for example, that one against Brighton, the Everton game away, they were in total control, but they took their foot off the gap. They allowed a pretty poor Everton side with limited resources up front. They allowed them back in the game because they sat back. They sat back and allowed them back in the game. And then I think Sesco come off the bench, he gets what looks like the winner they then camp themselves inside their own penalty area for injury time and Maitland-Niles comes up and rifles one in the back of the net so I think it's games that again, it's not just one thing for this United team at the moment there's a lot of headaches that Michael Carrick has to deal with and the biggest headache surely Phil is the lack of depth that this squad has certainly when you compare it to teams like Arsenal and Manchester City and also adding the fact that as the boys mentioned you've got champions league football this season which wasn't a factor last year when Carrick did so well there's a lot of balls to juggle here and it's difficult to see how exactly Carrick's going to make this work considering the resources he's working with is that fair yeah it's fair I think you know he's going to have to balance that really well uh manage the two game week really well and the the load with the the lads during the week uh once you start picking up a couple of injuries then then it becomes a more of a daunting task I think the one thing I would say is the midfield balance.

7:36When they lost Casemiro, well, not lost, but chose to let him go and not renew his contract to the end of the season, there was a big stigma around the athleticism, power in midfield and how open they were on transition and the goals they were conceding. I like Tiedemann as a player. I think technically he's been a fantastic player, fantastic servant to Villa, and he's come in. But has that answered the problem in midfield? I would probably edge towards no it hasn't. I mean, he's not going to get you as many goals as what Casemiro did. I think in terms of mobility, he's probably similar to Casemiro.

8:15You've got Cobby in there as well, who you wouldn't say is the most mobile, but technically an incredible player. Santos, I've not really seen much of him yet. So have they got the balance right of those two sixes that they like playing with in midfield? Probably not yet. Sesko probably not performing to the level could have got rid of Zerksy to Everton and they decided not to do it so that probably screams that there was no reinforcements to back that one up as well so yeah like Carrick said and like you boys said in the studio that it's not a one big problem it's these small acute problems that are accumulative over time and unfortunately they need to find a way to start winning games they don't win on Sunday against Fulham and pressure will really start to mount.

9:00Are you surprised, Phil, that they didn't do more in the summer? There was kind of two trains of thought, wasn't there? Look, we don't want to be in the same situation we've been in previous seasons where we spend a lot of money on players who don't deliver, but they seem to have gone too far the opposite way, where they've sat on their hands and not spent any money. And this kind of feels inevitable. Yeah, I mean, I listened to what you were saying about Michael Carrick at the start of the show when you're talking, should they have given him, should they have not given him. Well, if you give it to him and he doesn't go well, then fans will turn around and people will turn around and say, well, we told you so, you shouldn't have done that.

9:33And vice versa, if you didn't give it to him and somebody comes in and there's no guarantee whoever came in, if it wasn't Carrick was going to do well, then people will be saying, well, why don't you just give it to Carrick? It's a sort of a no-win situation. But yeah, I agree. I don't think they've really got to grips with the problems that they sort of had last season in terms of personnel coming into the building. But they've got to find a way to win games. And at the minute, I think there's probably, you know, five or six players who are playing under par. And, you know, at that level, you can't get away with five or six players not playing, not being an eight out of ten every game.

10:05Isn't it weird? I suppose Manchester United, because we're of a generation that grew up, they had so much success and they drew all the big players. When's the last time they've got a player that you thought, wow. What a coup that is for them. When we used to pitch up at Old Trafford, you know, in the early...

10:23Stewart Robson:in 93-94, the year we played them in the FA Cup final, he pitched up, Brian Robson was just sort of at the tail end of his career. But it was Pallister and Bruce and it was Roy and it was Paul Inns and all these guys, Mark Hughes up front and then a few years later, not too long later, Eric Cantona's in there and the sort of list goes on. You looked at them and you thought, right, whenever you played them home and away, you thought, right, you've got to have a damn good day at the office to get some results here because they were bringing in and have always brought in quality players. You mentioned that it feels that they've given Carrick the job, which is fair enough.

11:00Stewart Robson:And I don't think anybody was saying, ah, he shouldn't get it, he shouldn't get it, because he came in and he did a good job, right? And there's not too many others out there. And they had been down the experienced route before and it had failed. So I can understand that to an extent. But then you have to really back him. And as you said, it felt a little half-hearted in terms of the squad. You've got Man City going out and signing quality players. You've got Arsenal going out and signing real quality players. You've got United going in, I think, a little bit tentative. And I agree with Phil, Telemans is a good player.

11:33Stewart Robson:But is he really what Man United need to take them to the next level? No, I don't think he is. So it just feels that it was a bit half-hearted. And we're seeing that, unfortunately, for Carrick at the moment. We've seen that in their performances. Pretty much every team at the moment in the Premier League, maybe Coventry apart, have started really poorly. Pretty much every team, Shaq, I think, thinks they can have a bash at this United team. Absolutely. And why not? Look at the starting 11, not only yesterday, but also at the weekend against City. How many of those players get into a proper big team that's competing for titles?

12:10Bruno, that's it.

12:11Frank Leboeuf:And that's about it. Even Fulham, who have one point, as we said right now, We'll be thinking, all right, this is the game to turn our season around. And now, here's my concern, and a lot of blame, a lot of criticism has gone towards the ownership group and those making the decisions behind the scenes. And I can't help but feel that they also got caught up in the finish to the season last year, where they think, as terrible as we were under Amarim, Michael Carey comes in and we play outstanding football. we finished third, deservedly so. Let's just leave Michael Carrick almost like a fan in how they're viewing their position of last season as opposed to a director of football or somebody's making decisions.

12:58Frank Leboeuf:Michael Carrick got this team to third so we can just stick with this team and just make a couple of cosmetic additions and we'll be all right. But then Craig mentioned it. You compare that to Arsenal, you compare that to City. You look at what Chelsea have done. No, not as a direct comparison. Gone out and spent and strengthened their team without question. That's how big clubs are run. Not this kind of, well, we were really good the last six months. Let's just keep that going. And now you're paying the price for that kind of fan approach to the business that needed to be done. For a team that is one of the biggest in the world, there does seem to be almost a small-minded mentality to the way in which they approach bringing players in, Phil.

13:45Yeah, I mean, if you look at the recruitment probably over the last five or six years, there's always a thing around, are we recruiting the right player for the club? You talk about the Manchester United DNA and what it takes to play for the club, are we recruiting the right player? You'd have to say some of the signings over the last few years, probably not. And it's been difficult. But, you know, I look at that team there and maybe, you know, I think they missed Dogu playing higher up the pitch, especially against City. I think that's where he was more influential last season. Kunja's not really, I like Kunja, I think he's a terrific player.

14:25Again, two great signings with Mbumo and Kunja, really like them. But I don't think he's a nine, he's not a false nine, he's sort of playing out of position there. I think, you know, you're probably better playing Rashford as a nine, playing Dogu higher up. but then Luke was injured so Dorgio had to slip back into left back. So, look, the balance just doesn't seem right at the minute and they need to turn it around quickly because, you know, I've been at the club and when things start spiralling, they don't half-spiral out of control and it gains a lot of traction very, very quickly and it's really hard to gain momentum back.

15:00Stewart Robson:I mean, if they lose this Fulham game, which they might not, but they go into this long international window a lot of the players will be away come back fresh or they come back injured or whatever it is, but he has no real time to, like every manager who's losing international players, they have no real time to go on the training field, but that just that's three weeks, if they have a bad result against Fulham that's the best part of a month to stew as a manager to stew on all the problems and what they need to do after the break when really, if you're in a bad run and we've all been there, somehow you've got to, the only way you stop it, you can't hide.

15:41Stewart Robson:You've got to get back out there and roll your sleeves up, win a game and get some momentum. It doesn't change anything. So that would be a long time to stew on it if indeed that was the case. And more so the fact that Fulham have struggled, they've got a new manager. So there's more expectation on United to go into this international break with a good result. Anything other than that will just exacerbate this situation because because of how poor Fulham have been. So in some sense, it's good to play a weaker team, but only if you can put them away, which is, there's a doubt that United can or will.

16:15Phil, you've been there, you've experienced it. When Old Trafford's behind you, what an arena it is. But as you say, when there are mumbles and there are grumbles and people are dissatisfied, how does that affect the players? Oh, massive, massive. I've been there. Like I said, I've been there myself when, you know, the team aren't in great form. there's individual players who aren't playing to the potential me being one of them at times and it's a difficult place to be, 90 ,000 you know, it's been shown around the world in hundreds of countries and you're at risk of being falling short and like I said, it's almost an infectious feeling one ball gets played back when it should have been played forward and there's mumbles and grumbles but my God, on the flip side of that you get it right and you get Old Trafford rocking what a place to play football and they've got to get back to that somehow, somewhere.

17:05But I even think a draw at Fulham doesn't really help situation either. I think they've got to go there and win and a good performance on top of it.

17:14Stewart Robson:Kindergarten stuff. Kindergarten stuff? Yeah, you want to go to Celtic and have bad results. Oh, God. I'm telling you. I'm telling you. Honestly. Have we made this about you? You said to Phil, oh, come on. Wait till you go to Fragment Park. There's crowds that get on your back and there's crowds that get on your back. Right, trust me. All right, there we go. Phil, thank you very much. By the way, they've lost tonight, Celtic, so we enjoyed it. Wow, okay. Thank you very much, Phil. We'll see you next time United lose. Much appreciate. Thank you, guys. Enjoy, enjoy. See you, man. Mark Ogden was on yesterday's show tearing apart the owners and the way in which they have acted over the last few seasons.

17:59as you can check that out.

18:00Stewart Robson:Oh, he's in his element. Oh, yeah, he is. He's in his glory, doesn't he? He is. He's not looking well either. Fits him well with the rest of the show. That's me, mate, over. It's happening to go Madrid against Real Madrid. Oh, boy. On Monday, 10.15 a.m., coverage starts at 10 a.m. on ESPN2.

18:29Frank Leboeuf:two times O rewards points and save$10 when you purchase a pair of Rain-X Latitude wiper blades. They will even install them for free at O 'Reilly Auto Parts. A new podcast series from ABC Audio in 2020 goes inside a case that has captivated the nation. To many people, Luigi Mangione is a modern day Robin Hood. People were cheering the demise of this person they'd never met, who was a father of two and a husband and had a life and was just doing a job. from the manhunt ending in a McDonald's in Altoona, Pennsylvania, to what authorities are saying about a possible motive. I'm ABC News legal analyst Brian Buckmeyer.

19:11Frank Leboeuf:Listen to Burden of Proof, Luigi Mangione, wherever you get your podcasts. There, from Madrid, for our K. Smiling away. Boy, enjoy the sunshine. K, how are you?

19:30Dan Thomas:I'm great, but I'm worried now that Craig's judging everyone's appearance. I hope I'm going to pass it. It's only because he said to me before, going, I'm not feeling very well. And I said, well, you look rough. And that didn't start things out very well. He's dragging everybody down. What are you doing in Madrid? Oh, you know, there's a small matter of the derby at the weekend, Craig. Athlete hosting Real Madrid. Just that. Yeah, exactly. Right then, Kate, what's the vibe going into it? What's the big talking point? I think the big talking point, Dan, on the Madrid side of things, which as you guys are seeing covering it every week as we do, is Jose Mourinho and Real Madrid just that failure to take control of games.

20:08Dan Thomas:And that's been a big talking point, especially with Atleti's big win over Osasuna. They've had two wins, obviously, that one against Real Sociedad, which on paper was a big win, but it didn't tell the whole story. But this one over Osasuna, they feel as though that was a bit of a warning shot. so what we're going to see now from Atleti against the Madrid side that aren't really finding the way to control games that are getting pegged back in games as we saw in that match against Elche what are we going to get here? Obviously that's a big one and Julian Alvarez will he be ready to play this game?

20:38Dan Thomas:The hope is that he will feature but he was ruled out against us as soon as a precaution he's got that minor quadriceps strain so will we see Julian Alvarez as well and will this be the game where he could really get the fans back on his side.

20:52Stewart Robson:That'd be a thigh strain, I believe. Is that right? A thigh strain to us. All right, Doc. I appreciate it.

20:59Dan Thomas:Thanks for the translation, Craig.

Read the full transcript

21:01Stewart Robson:Yeah, we don't know what we're going to get from either of these two teams. That's very true. And that's where we are. Barcelona, we know, is gold. It's attack. It's exciting. It's open. You and I did the Elche-Real Madrid game. Mourinho put it down to switching off. Not sure. I think that's the simplistic answer. as we see these goals going in from Adleti. I think that's the simplistic answer. Well, we switched off, let them back in the game. But I think there's more to it than that. Heavily reliant on Bellingham and Kylian Mbappe. Diamandi still finding his feet. Vinicius Jr., another bang average performance.

21:40Stewart Robson:His finishing was terrible. Giving up chances at the back. So we don't know. We don't know what version of either of these two teams. and that's good for Barcelona, but they can let these two squabble away and be inconsistent. So it's a really, I think, a really difficult game to call. But yeah, I was not impressed once again with Real Madrid and that match against Elche a few days ago. Yeah, Craig mentioned it, those misses as well from Vinicius Jr. just kind of piles on the criticism because 5 out of 10, 6 out of 10 has pretty much been his average so far this campaign.

22:16Dan Thomas:Yeah, that's a big thing as well, isn't it, Dan? and I know you guys have been talking about it on ESPN FC this week, that Jose Mourinho continues to support Vinny. But what are we seeing with Vinny? Is he lacking confidence? What's happened to him? And how long does Jose Mourinho stay patient with him? Because there's going to have to come a time that obviously he's hoping that soon enough, if he shows the confidence in the player, he's going to deliver. And we're going to see that Vinny that we know is in there. But if he doesn't, then Jose Mourinho's got a big decision to make.

22:47Stewart Robson:Yeah, I mean, but he keeps saying, doesn't he, Dan, he's working harder. And maybe he is, I mean, I don't know, I don't know the stats of that, he looks as if he's kind of the same to me. But here's the deal, he's cut him a fair amount of slack at the moment, and that's alright, it's a lot of love there. He's signed a new six-year deal, he's got his money, he's happy, blah, blah, blah. But we know he's not playing, as you said, five or six out of ten, particularly in the final third. And we discussed this two or three weeks ago. I've not really seen him skip past on a one-on-one, a defender, like he did when he was in his pump.

23:23Stewart Robson:I've not seen him drop a shoulder and skin the defender. And maybe the fact that he is having to do a little bit more of the hard work, he's maybe not as sharp. He's maybe not used to that because he's doing more defensive work. He's not as sharp going forward. But what if Bellingham and Mbappe have a dry spell? that's the problem for Vinicius Jr. and Jose Mourinho because somebody then has to step up because at the moment those two are pretty much carrying the midfield and the front line if, along with Adegula to be fair to him, he's played well if those three, but particularly the first two have a bad run of form and the goals dry up they're going to have to come from somewhere else and that's going to put even more pressure on Vinicius Jr.

24:09Stewart Robson:to perform and that's when I think the manager might get a bit angsty with him and have less support if this continues.

24:16Frank Leboeuf:I'm not giving Vinny that easy enough as he's doing more work defensively and as a result you're seeing some of the bad passes and the inability. No, I'm trying to find the reason. No, no, no, I'm just saying. Don't get angsty with me, Hizko. No, no, no, you're all right. But the thing is, who does Jose Mourinho turn to? Otherwise, kind of given Vinicius Junior and who he is when he's playing well and what other options there are. I'm not sure that Jose Mourinho has that answer other than to maybe stick with Vinicius Jr. and hope he plays his way out of this poor run of form. But you just don't know when that is going to happen, how that is going to happen.

24:56Frank Leboeuf:And as a result, you have this kind of imbalance to Real Madrid that I don't think anybody expected. And the added extra as well, Kay, obviously it's the final game before the international break. so no matter what happens in the derby this weekend it will dominate the headlines from now until we pick up the baton again in three weeks

25:14Dan Thomas:Oh absolutely it will Dan as you know they've got to fill those pages the two sports dailies here in Madrid and so that's a big talking point for both of them because can Atleti follow up what they've just done in that game against Osasuna can Madrid finally give their fans a convincing win and something for them to actually be happy about going into that break There's just so many things at stake. And then, of course, it's Jose Mourinho against Diego Simeone again. And you'll remember, Dan, from when we were living in Madrid, it was 14 years that Atleti could not beat Real Madrid. And, of course, that big win finally came for Atleti in the Copa del Rey final in 2013 at the Santiago Bernabeu when Diego Simeone beat Jose Mourinho's Real Madrid.

25:55Dan Thomas:So there's all that history as well. And you'd expect there's going to be loads of talking points after this game once again. Meanwhile, in the morning media... We were living in Madrid. In the more media future, the big talking point, Kay Murray is going to make her debut on Football Americas tonight. Oh, oh. To bring you more. What are you doing? About the Derby. All the latest on Julian Alvarez as well. Shaka Hissop, feet on the desk. That's going to be 3.30 in the morning in Spain. Dedicated, 2.30. Absolutely. 2.30, six hours. You were right the first. What a stupidity.

26:33Another very good day at the office of Barcelona as they set the record, as the guys discussed yesterday, unstoppable. The front page of both Sport and Mundo Deportivo. It's been an extraordinary start to the season for the defending champions, 100 % record. They've averaged 4.7 a game, which is just ridiculous. Ruffini with 11, Lomini Moua, Anthony Gordon with the assists. I've played a lot of the weaker teams. Yes, and that's the point I was just about to make. However, you compare them to their biggest competitor, who had to rely on a late goal from ESPY against Elche, who Barcelona put five past.

27:15And when you're doing that, you have to take your hat off and say, yeah, I know they're not the best opposition in front of them, but still, this is an opposition that put Real Madrid to the sword right to the end.

27:24Stewart Robson:But it's a continuation of Hansi Flick's work, isn't it? his ethic and his I hate the word philosophy but his way of playing and it's how do I take that make us a bit stronger defensively and we'll find that out probably in the Champions League and as the season goes on but how can they make us a bit stronger defensively and even better going forward and that's the key the key for them to win the Champions League and retain La Liga for the third straight season is to find some more solidity at the back they've got they've bought experience in the middle of the park and how do we take this team that was already super exciting going forward and scored a lot of goals as it did with Lewandowski and Ferran Torres and Laminya Mal and all the guys that are still there how do we make that better and you have to say thus far whilst they haven't had to do too much defending against teams like Racing Santander Elche Valencia away teams like that didn't really offer much going forward they if you said to me they're going to be better going forward than last year and I said nah that's going to be difficult I said what they need to do is be solid at the back but he's taken that model hasn't really well he has added to it in a sense he's brought Anthony Gordon and Adeyemi now if you'd have said to us last year Barcelona are going to sign Adeyemi from Dortmund and Anthony Gordon from Newcastle and that's going to somehow make the squad better and help make them better and Rafinha's going to go and play striker you'd be like, they're stupid.

28:56Stewart Robson:Rashford's better than Anthony Gordon. Rashford's better than Adiemi. But yet they allow him to go. They have the foresight and the decision-making to let him go back. Thanks very much. He did quite well, actually. But we think these guys are going to fit in here better. And they have. And it's allowed the others, particularly Rafinha, to go and just express himself. and then you look behind and Danny Omo in the number 10 or Fermin Lopez in the number 10. Take either of them. Does it weaken the team? No, it doesn't. You just take the piece of the puzzle out, you put the other piece in, the different piece in, it fits straight away and they go again.

29:38Stewart Robson:That being said, they've played some promoted teams and there has to be tougher tests ahead. But it's been sparkling. If you're a Barcelona fan, You've got to be loving what you're seeing in terms of the excitement. One negative, Shaq. Joanne Garcia, of course, getting injured. And we saw Chesney at half-time going, Oh, really? He didn't want to come on. Well, he could be bothered. Yeah, well, I get that feeling.

30:02Frank Leboeuf:And you saw that play out in real time in the second half. I know, when he gets caught. Listen, I... So... This is... I mean... Chesney... You're written all over it. No, because I don't control the ball. I'd never controlled the ball in my life. I just booted into the stand. I thought he sorts his feet out here quite well. So the weird thing is, right, and this story has been told time and time again, Chesney is retired. And then all of a sudden is brought in because of an injury crisis to Chester again and then makes his shirt his own unexpectedly. And now you're kind of seeing it play out again as though he's not expected to play.

30:45Frank Leboeuf:now he might get a run of games we'll see how long John Garcia's injury is how does Chesney respond? I know, granted this 45 was not encouraging I'll just put it like that but you're being very serious about this I'm trying to convince myself

31:07Stewart Robson:that Chesney's going to be okay it's how he stood on the ball he wants to be on the beach doesn't he? Yes, absolutely. He definitely has a Craig. Good real. Yeah, exactly. Barcelona looking to inflict more pain as Sevilla heads to the dentist on Saturday, 3pm Eastern. Our coverage starts at 2.30 on the ESPN app.

31:33Friday night action in the Premier League sees Brentford take on Chelsea. Chelsea are going to concede goals. How many, I suppose, is the big question. How do the bookies have this one set? We know there's no Caicedo. Probably no Gerald Pedro either. Let's take a look at how the bookies have it. Chelsea are the slight favourites, but it's pretty close, as you would expect. What's going to happen in this game, Craig? Brentford.

32:00Stewart Robson:Brentford will try and outplay them. And they actually outplayed them last year. And this was the opposite fixture. It was the game at Stamford Bridge. They outplayed them at Stamford Bridge and lost. I expect Keith Andrews side to try and go toe-to-toe. So they're not going to... Chelsea are not going to face a side that's sitting in in fear of these guys that have this expensively assembled squad. Far from it. I could see, particularly the way they defended against Hull, Chelsea that is, I could see Brentford winning this one. They're a really good side, he's done a really good job, Keith Andrews, they've got a lot of power up front and they play good football.

32:33Stewart Robson:This is a tough game for Alonso.

32:35Frank Leboeuf:I'm with Craig on this. I think Chelsea are still reeling from the horror show that was was Hull City looking for a bit of a response. I'm not sure it comes against a Brentford team at home, physical, who will play in Chelsea faces. I do not see Chelsea winning this. The best I think Chelsea come out from this is with a point. We'll be reflecting on that big Chelsea victory tomorrow then on ESPN FC. Alexis in the hot seat. Kane once again joining them from Spain. Checkers power rankings, ladies and gentlemen. Here they are. Not a whole lot of change from last week as the big boys just keep winning.

33:15Frank Leboeuf:There's three news in there. Yeah. Benfica top in Portugal. Oh, no. Porto top in Portugal. Benfica doing well in Europe as well. So they're in. Freiburg. Elvesburg were in a 10 last week, but they drew. Elvesburg, who were top of the Bundesliga. But Freiburg are in as my football romantic pick. They are... You just closed your eyes and you hit... No, no, no. It's still early in Germany. It's only three games gone. They're 100%. And explain to us why Manchester City are above Arsenal. Just because City had a better result in Europe a couple of weeks ago. Everybody won this week, so I just let them know.

33:55So where was City? Wait, didn't Arsenal beat Napoli?

33:59Frank Leboeuf:And City won away to... Who was it? I can't remember. So that was the differentiator last week. Right. I put City above Arsenal because they're both just about neck and neck in the league. City had a better result on the road in Europe. So I put City at... City won in Porto. There you go. I put City above Arsenal because they won on the road.

34:20Stewart Robson:City beat Porto. I think they beat Porto. Yeah, you got 2-0. And yet you've got Porto.

34:26Frank Leboeuf:Porto 100 % in Portugal. Seven wins out of seven. So are Inter, aren't they? Yeah, but they got demolished about five. They got five in Europe. That's no good. Who did it? Inter. They lost 2-1 to Madrid. There you go. What was that team you had?

34:40Stewart Robson:What was that team? That's what I said. I'm just going to turn my back. There you go. That's what I said. What was that team you had in? Elversburg. Oh, God. That is it. That brings us to the end of today's... Elversburg. Today's... I've never heard of power rankings. Newly promoted Bundesliga. Shaq will be back next week for his final ones, of course. Before that very long international break, Dan. You just watch the space. You've got to do a power rankings on the internationals. Yes. No, I don't. All right, Extra Time's next. Kay's back. Hey!

35:13Welcome in to the latest edition of Extra Time. Fear not. It's not just Craig and Shaka in the studio. Kay Murray is with us now and it's what? Approaching midnight, Kay in Spain.

35:25Dan Thomas:Yep, still lots going on here as you can imagine, but it's changed, Dan, since when we were here. Now I'm sat doing hits for ESPN FC instead of out on the streets with all those guys. Ah, they were good times. They were good times. What do they like to eat in Madrid? I assume that's not just people. I assume that's like you, Gay, and the boys. What was your go-to today? Oh, well, I went out for a little bit of tortilla, Dan. Nice. Which I know was not really on your list back in the day. What are you talking about? Of course I ate tortilla. You all just seem to think I ate pizza all the time. Yeah, I do.

36:01That's what I heard.

36:02Dan Thomas:Pizza, pasta. tomato sauce those were your staples

36:07Stewart Robson:we didn't have any money you wouldn't know a good pizza if it came up and slapped you right in the face anyway what else did you have I swear to god somebody made you a really nice thin crust pizza in a proper wood oven you wouldn't have a scooby you'd rather have one in the oven a frozen one from the supermarket anything else Kay shut up

36:29Dan Thomas:we actually got some posh tapas The spread that was put on for us today was delightful. There were the things that we used to hang about for when we didn't have any money when we lived here to try and get a little bit of food. You know. And what was your pick from that? What was the pick? Mini burgers, little mini tacos, a mixture of everything. Not really Spanish. Who's putting that on?

36:53Stewart Robson:Yeah, who paid for that Kate? The company putting that on.

36:58Stewart Robson:Maybe. How can you go to Spain and eat mini burgers?

37:08Stewart Robson:tapas and and and fish and right right many burgers what's stevie there cultured craig over here cultured craig oh yeah you bet your bottom dollar don't go away and look when stevie's going to tea jelly fridays for his lunch in madrid Well, I stopped short at smokehouses in Wales. For Craig, did you always hate individual awards when you were playing? No. Yeah, apart from when I won the Football Writers' Player of the Year. Scottish Football Writers' Player of the Year, 1998, it was very important. Right, but every other individual award... Well, I couldn't tell them that down. You could have?

37:49Stewart Robson:I couldn't tell them. With your principles about individual awards? I was esteemed from the journalists who voted for me for my performances that year. I just couldn't turn it down. Kay, when you were voted a Borough Babe, did you ever attempt to turn that down? Saying it's not about the individuals, it's about the team?

38:05Dan Thomas:Absolutely. It was all about me, the Borough Babe. And I'll tell you, it's the only cup we ever won this season that I was the Borough Babe, Dan. Shaka, when you won Hammer of the Year, did you say, no, I don't want it? No, I took it. Yep. Where is it?

38:21Frank Leboeuf:Somewhere. Did they give you a hammer? Is it an actual hammer? No, no. I got some kind of trophy something. Yep. Keep it moving down. For Xhaka, why are none of you on the ESPN FC panel considering Haaland for the Ballon d 'Or? He took Manchester City and Norway on his shoulders, won the Premier League golden boot, took Norway to the quarterfinals and had Sirloch passed. He had... He'd ha... Oh, sorry. And had Sirloch passed, he'd have taken them to the semis.

38:49Stewart Robson:That's a good point there. Commas. Patricia. I've got a commas apostrophe.

38:55Frank Leboeuf:Holland's in. I've just decided. He's your Ballon d 'Or. Yeah. We didn't talk about him.

39:00Stewart Robson:Mm-hmm. Yeah? Yes. That's it. Big talk in Spain about Ballon d 'Or at the moment. You're OK. Mbappe's got his campaign going on. Oh, yeah.

39:08Dan Thomas:Oh, yeah. He's absolutely on the campaign trail. He's got everybody on board with him as well, it seems. So we'll see how that all plays out. Let's see what sort of tapas he gives you and then see where your vote goes. Yeah, well, he's not eating mini burgers. Mini burgers, dearie me. Okay, with the character of United's manager being called into question for his passivity... Jesus, can you read? Why are you in a bad mood today? He's not feeling well, he's not feeling well, Dan.

39:37Frank Leboeuf:Oh, I'm feeling alright. He's not feeling well. Oh, babe.

39:41Stewart Robson:He's got a grumpy edge to him, even more so. Gotta get him to get some rest. Did I call in sick? No, I did not. You're a trooper. I'm feeling OK. I'm not feeling, but I'm feeling fine. A bit moody. I mean, I'm working with Peter who can't read. Were there times when managing Borough where he presented himself as tough and tenacious?

40:04Dan Thomas:He actually sent Craig into the positivity corner, if you remember. Shaq, you might have been on that show.

40:09Frank Leboeuf:I remember Craig being in the positivity corner.

40:11Dan Thomas:Back in the semi-final in the Carabao Cup against Chelsea. Yeah, there was the 1-0 win there. They got battered in the second leg, but let's not worry about that right now. That sent Craig into the positivity corner after the 1-0.

40:22Stewart Robson:Is he too nice, Kate? Mind you, Mini Burgers, if you come from Middlesbrough, Mini Burgers is like a fixed menu, isn't it? It's like Nouvelle Cuisine. It's your own fault, Kate, really, for this. Sorry, Craig, I forgot to bring you a Mini Burgers. If you come from Middlesbrough and somebody gives you a tray of Mini Burgers, you go, oh, this is fancy food.

40:47Dan Thomas:It is better than a plate of steam with a fork, that's for sure. Yes, Michael Carrick. Yeah, I suppose so. He was always known as being that calming influence on the players and known how to put the arm around them. But when he did come in at Middlesbrough, he took them from being relegation-threatened to the playoffs that season. But obviously that's Middlesbrough, not Manchester United. Percentage chance anyhow. He's managing Manchester United by the end of the season, Xhaka. I don't see him. Five. Five? Yeah.

41:16Stewart Robson:I'm not going to ask him. No, don't ask me. No, good. Who will have more goals this season, Kay? Haaland or Rafinha? Ooh.

41:25Dan Thomas:Oh, that's a good one, isn't it? Haaland. I don't think that's the right answer. There we go. You clearly think of Rafinha, Dan. Just go ahead and see it. Look at what Barca have done. We feel there was a bit of Haaland negativity on the show, so I'm just giving him a bit of love. Don't turn it down.

41:43Stewart Robson:Is it because Kier's in Madrid? Do you know why it is? And she's no cementer. It's absolutely crystal clear now that she's now the senior anchor on the show. I'll tell you what it is. We're talking about food. I haven't eaten. I've got colonoscopy tomorrow. I haven't eaten all day. And I've got you in a bad mood. Just have some. Daniel, do you have some? Just have some. Think of the sleep, Dan. Think of the sleep. I know, I know. Exactly. Kay, Sid told us once that Dan was fun on a night out in the mid-2000s. Not now. With his white shorts. What was your perception of Dan during this era?

42:18Dan Thomas:We had the time of our lives, didn't we, Dan? It was absolutely brilliant. Madrid's a 24-hour city. We took full advantage of that. And you always convinced us to go to a karaoke at the end of it all. Yep, it was good. Brilliant fun.

42:29Stewart Robson:You love a karaoke. Exactly. I mean, that's equally as bad as mini burgers. What's that? In Spain, in a beautiful city like Madrid, going to a karaoke. Beautiful city? What are you talking about? All right, I embellished that a little. What do you think? You don't go to a karaoke. That's like... Have pizza. Okay. And he had pizza there, you know, Craig? Think about all those cultured bars in Madrid you can go to. What cultured bars, Craig? Well, I don't know. I've not been. I'm being presumptuous. When have you ever been to a cultured bar anywhere? Oh, I like going to nice bars. Yes, but not cultured bars.

43:00Yeah, yeah. What is the difference between a nice bar and a cultured bar? Right. So, Xhaka, you've got the whole of New York to choose from. Right. What? What did you choose as your bar, your local bar? Oh.

43:15Stewart Robson:That's the oldest pub in New York? Yes, and it looked like it. It was open late.

43:23Stewart Robson:I mean, culture. I knew if I did overindulge, I would find the hotel. Yeah, right. From the aforementioned. The ear in, I think it was called. You were just looking for a hole in the wall, you told me. No, no, not. That was it. Culture. Ken, you're on Football Americas tonight. Can't wait. And then what's the plan for the rest of the night? Can't wait. What time are you going to finish? Like two? Not two, though.

43:50Dan Thomas:Yep. It's not like we haven't... That's early for us, though, in Madrid, Dan, from back in the day. Going on Football Americas tonight to talk about the USA contingent at Borough.

43:59Stewart Robson:Oh. Tell you what, that sounds super exciting. Hey, the sap will be here with that. I sure will. You must be recording that. You're not staying up to two in the morning, are you? Of course it is. It's professional.

44:10Dan Thomas:My wife saw the Football Americas couple. here in Madrid.

44:13Frank Leboeuf:And saw me and was like, who the hell is that? Oh, wow. That's my beard. Oh, she hated that beard. Yeah, she did. Well, I think everybody... It was popular, that beard. Absolute. It's a very beardly beard. That is it. It's a beardly beard. Thank you so much. Have a lovely time in Spain. I bet you wish you were here with him. I bet you're not. ESPN FC. I prefer to have a colonoscopy.

44:44Frank Leboeuf:Don't have any mini burgers!

44:47Stewart Robson:Let's get off.

From the publisher

The FC crew continue to react to Manchester United's poor start to the season and argue if Michael Carrick should be worried about his job going forward. Plus, the guys are joined by Kay Murray to preview this weekend's Madrid derby and marvel at Barcelona's perfect start to the season. The guys also explain why they think Brentford will beat Chelsea on Friday.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from ESPN FC

All 572 episodes
Carrick on the Hot Seat?ESPN FC · 47 min
Listen in VO