The Football Reporters: Tottenham turns toxic for Thomas Frank

4 Nov 2025 · 50 min · 12 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Premier League matchday fallout—Tottenham’s toxic home atmosphere after losing to Chelsea, plus Man United’s resilience at Nottingham Forest, UEFA’s struggle to find host cities for the Champions League final, and how hard it is for players to return from long injuries (Rodri).

Guests/backgrounds

James and Rob (podcast reporters; James at Tottenham, Rob at Forest). Ken Marcotti (host/voice for segments, also writes about Rodri and other topics).

Key claims

  • Spurs’ home defeat vs Chelsea (XG 0.05) contrasts with their league position (still 3rd at full time, later 5th).
  • Thomas Frank appears to have lost dressing-room control: Mickey van de Ven and Jed Spence ignored him and walked straight down the tunnel.
  • Spurs fans are turning on Frank due to poor home performances and perceived lack of creativity, not just results.
  • Man United under Amorim showed progress: they drew after Forest scored twice in 90 seconds; Casemiro’s importance is highlighted.
  • UEFA may need Champions League finals outside Europe due to limited suitable venues; US/Saudi are plausible.
  • Rodri’s ACL return is complicated by confidence/comfort after setbacks; City can’t ease him in because they need him.

Notable examples

  • Spurs set-piece decline in the second half; multiple aimless deliveries straight to Sanchez.
  • United equaliser via Ahmad; first goal involves Gibbs-White feeding Ahmad at the back post.
  • Rodri cameo vs Bournemouth after hamstring injury; Monaco knock showed panic/confidence impact.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Tottenham's Home Defeat Analysis

1:22 to 2:47

Discussion on Tottenham's disappointing home loss to Chelsea and the response from fans.

“Coming up this week, I'll look at a sour situation at Spurs as Frank's men lose at home to Chelsea.”

Contrasting Fan Reactions and Team Performance

2:47 to 4:23

A comparison of current fan sentiments towards Thomas Frank and previous managers, particularly Postacoglu.

“and it appeared as though two of his players, Mickey van der Ven and Jed Spence, ignored him as he tried to say something to them as they left the field.”

Set-Piece Strategy and Player Dynamics

4:23 to 8:59

Exploration of Tottenham's set-piece effectiveness and the dynamics between players and the manager.

“Now, you can I think a lot of people make too much of expected goals as a barometer of what's going on.”

Injuries and Future Matches' Impact

8:59 to 13:44

The impact of player injuries on Tottenham's performance and upcoming crucial matches.

“Colin Mouane, of course, arrived injured and he's only sort of himself getting back up to full fitness and probably isn't still in a place where he can play 90 minutes.”

Evaluating Thomas Frank's Future

13:44 to 14:00

Discussion on the potential future of Thomas Frank at Tottenham amidst mounting pressure.

“But at this stage, because of the situation that is beginning to bubble away at Tottenham, they are massive games now.”

Evaluating Thomas Frank's Position at Tottenham

14:00 to 17:08

Discussion focuses on Thomas Frank's current job security and squad fitness as Tottenham faces Manchester United.

“I suspect that if Tottenham lose to Manchester United at the weekend, that the focus on Thomas Frank will go up another notch.”

Manchester United's Performance Analysis

17:08 to 23:54

Examining Manchester United's recent matches and the implications for their current squad, focusing on key players and tactical adjustments.

“parts of the game that highlight that this isn't the squad that Amrind really wants.”

UEFA's Challenges in Hosting Champions League Finals

26:15 to 28:00

Discussion on the difficulties UEFA faces in finding suitable cities and stadiums for future Champions League finals, including potential venues outside Europe.

“There have been some issues around finding cities who are willing to host it, even though it's obviously quite a prestigious event.”

Champions League Final Locations and Issues

28:00 to 31:11

Discussing potential locations and logistical challenges for the Champions League final.

“Infrastructure in the Italian capital is not great.”

Future of Champions League in Global Markets

31:11 to 34:24

Exploring the potential of moving Champions League finals to the Middle East and US.

“I've done games there before and left and not felt safe.”
Show all 12 chapters

Rodri's Return from Injury Challenges

35:41 to 42:00

Analyzing Rodri's struggles and pressures as he returns from ACL injury.

“Yeah, I mean, in terms of his recovery, you kind of get the impression that he's quite frustrated, really, because obviously he did his ACL against Arsenal more than a year ago.”

Managing Player Fitness Amid Fixture Congestion

42:00 to 50:14

Discover the challenges teams face in managing player fitness due to fixture congestion and injury risks.

“And you say, you're right, he's spoken, probably one of the major voices last year, about fixture congestion and what it was doing to players.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Gab Marcotti here for Gusto. Right now, everyone is trying to run leaner, tighter budgets, smaller teams, higher expectations. Now, the last thing you have time to waste on is manual payroll or chasing down an HR form. Gusto is how small business owners get time back when every hour counts. Gusto is online payroll and benefit software built for small businesses. It's all in one, remote friendly and incredibly easy to use. so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. Automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it.

0:40Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget. And it's all built to save your time with built-in automated tools for offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. Plus, you get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price. No hidden fees, no surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash FC and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash FC. One more time, gusto.com slash FC.

1:22Welcome to the Football Reporters. Coming up this week, I'll look at a sour situation at Spurs as Frank's men lose at home to Chelsea. With European cities hardly rushing to host, we look at the chance of the Champions League final being played in the US or beyond. And as Rodri makes his Man City return, just how difficult is it for players to come back from a long-term injury?

1:44So it's been an eventful matchday 10 in the Premier League. I think the two biggest games, the two biggest story points were Tottenham losing at home to Chelsea, and Man Utd's glorious winning run coming to an end at Nottingham Forest, albeit in heroic fashion with a late draw. So James and Rob, you're both at Tottenham, Rob, you're at Forest. We'll start with James first. Obviously, another home defeat for Spurs. Got quite messy at the end for Thomas Frank. How do you view the situation at the moment? Yeah, I mean, the piece I did from the game was to sort of compare. It was almost two years to the day since Tottenham lost 4-1 at home to Chelsea and it was Ange Postacoglu's first defeat and they serenaded him.

2:23They sang him, you know, they literally sang him off the pitch and so kind of enamoured were they with the style of play and with the sort of free-flowing champagne football that Postacoglu was serving up right at the start of his tenure. And it just served as such a contrast to the situation that Thomas Frank is currently in where his team was booed off at half-time, they were booed off at full-time and it appeared as though two of his players, Mickey van der Ven and Jed Spence, ignored him as he tried to say something to them as they left the field. Presumably, can you go and acknowledge the supporters?

2:58And they decided to walk straight down the tunnel. I think we'll be hearing more about that as the days go on. But the situation, I had to check, I had to keep checking that the Premier League table showed that at full time they were still in third place. Now, okay, they dropped to fifth as a result of what happened elsewhere and of course they could drop the time recording, they could drop again with Sunderland due to play. But it's a remarkable juxtaposition of the results versus the feeling. And I guess that kind of brings us back to where we were with Postacoglia, which is that a lot of those Spurs fans had the feeling, but not the results.

3:36And it became this whole, I think we thought this whole existential crisis of what the Tottenham want to be would be over when they won that trophy. that, OK, they've won the trophy, the sort of monkey's off their back in that regard. Now they can go and build and try and become a club that really establishes themselves right at the summit and challenges for the big prizes year on year. And that's the frustration that Frank is feeling at the moment. It's again something that transcends the current manager. It's not been put to bed by that Europa League win. It's now a case of, well, look, we want to see some proper good football here.

4:12We don't want to just win games through sort of defensive resilience and set pieces. Now, I think we should also say that it was one of the worst home performances you will ever see from a Premier League team. Statistically, their XG was 0.05. Now, you can I think a lot of people make too much of expected goals as a barometer of what's going on. But that is stark. I mean, that is they could play that game 20 times and score one goal. That's how bad it was statistically. And, you know, you can understand from that point of view why the fans wanted to see a little bit more. Just what you said the moment ago, James, about the Jed Spence and Van de Ven situation.

4:51You were there, so you got a better feel for it than Rob or I would have. But I've seen it back a couple of times. I'm thinking, what's the fuss about? You know, obviously, Thomas Frank wanted them both to stay on the pitch and Spence probably more than Van de Ven was like, no, but the players just want to get off the pitch. When did it start to become a necessity for players to basically put their hands up and say, I'm really sorry guys, I didn't play very well today. It seems to have come in the last couple of years where players on the slight demand to be forgiven from the fans for having a bad performance, where they just want to get off the pitch.

5:19Now, is it real and disrespectful? I'm amazed that you've gone that way. I thought you'd have gone completely the other way. No, I thought it was nothing. It's about the descent though, isn't it? Yeah, it is. The optics of it. They weren't having to go at each other. It just got off the pitch. I don't know. It's not that. It's that the manager is telling the players to do something and the players are ignoring him. Now, that probably goes on 100 times a day, but we don't see it. And what we're seeing there is Thomas Frank clearly, because you can see the lingering kind of look he gives them as they walk past him and go down the tunnel.

5:53They've clearly disobeyed him. But whatever he was asking, they've clearly disobeyed him. That's more on him than them though, isn't it? Yeah, but the point is not about, it's not about should they say something to the fans, should they show some sort of conciliation or apology to the fans. It's more that it's a sense that he's losing control or he's not entirely in control of that dressing room. And that is a dangerous thing for fans and journalists and all of us to see publicly because it starts to undermine his authority. And when results are not going your way and if this conversation continues to turn into a negative sense for Thomas Frank in a wider point, that is going to be a stick that he's going to be beating.

6:32You're right what you say. That's why it's a big deal. You're right what you say about how he's seen us from fans. I remember watching the Super Cup, the PSG game, and thinking then, long throws, long free kicks from the goalkeeper. The Spurs fans will not like this when they start losing games. Are we at that point now where they had a decent start, three wins out of the first four games, and then all of a sudden it's gone off the rails a bit and they don't like the football, they don't like losing. But like you said, the fifth, certainly they went into Monday morning before Southern played Everton.

7:00In fifth, it's crazy that they're already turning on him. But maybe it's deeper seated than that. Maybe there's a reason why they are turning him already. Well, this is why I go back to my first answer, which is that I think the wider context transcends Thomas Frank. This is about the frustration that Tottenham fans feel that their club is not where it should be. And they can't protest towards Daniel Levy anymore. He's not there. He's not there anymore. The change in or slight tweak in ownership that many of them have been calling for has happened now. So the fans, if they're frustrated, they've got to point it somewhere and they're pointing at the team.

7:37I was really surprised about how loud it was because, let me tell you, it was unavoidable at half-time and at full-time. And you sensed it throughout the second half because you mentioned the set pieces. The reason why that was lauded, particularly at the start, was because Spurs were so bad at them under Postacoglu. They famously did not have a specialist set-piece coach, which in this day and age looks like an outlier, looks like a bit of a mistake when you look at what the top sides are doing. And defensively, we all know how easy they were to play against, and Thomas Frank had sort of sorted that part of it out and actually made them quite effective from set-pieces.

8:14But in the second half of that game, there were a couple of instances where Pedro Porro would have a free kick, and he just aimlessly put it into the box straight for Robert Sanchez to collect as a goalkeeper. and a couple more times, Kudis had a corner straight into Sanchez's arms and right at the end of the game, the final act was Vicario to Spence, Spence back to Vicario to Spence, to Spence knocking it forward straight into Sanchez's arms and you could hear with every single play, it getting louder and more frustrated and more anger and more hostility growing in that fan base. You just felt as though there was nothing, there was no creativity, no clue and if the set pieces aren't going to get them out of it, then it shifts the focus to the lack of creativity in the team as a whole and this point is where I have a lot of sympathy with Frank because Spurs didn't have a great window you know they tried to sign Morgan Gibbs White they didn't get that deal over the line there were a lot of mitigating circumstances there in Spurs's defense but they didn't get that deal over the line they tried to get Eberichi Eze he ended up joining Arsenal and right at the end of the window they got Xavi Siemens and Randall Kalamwani now Siemens has taken a while to get up to speed and doesn't look a natural fit, but it's very early days.

9:24Colin Mouane, of course, arrived injured and he's only sort of himself getting back up to full fitness and probably isn't still in a place where he can play 90 minutes. So then you're relying on Richarlison because, of course, Dominic Zolank is still out injured. Kulaseski is injured. James Madison is injured. So to sort of ask Thomas Frank, with all of these various situations, to produce this kind of free-flowing attacking football that they want to see, allied to the defensive side of the game, it's too early to expect them to be that cohesive at both ends of the pitch. So I understand why he prioritised safety first, let's organise ourselves properly and be a threat from set pieces.

10:03The rest can come later because the rest is the difficult bit, isn't it? We all talk to top coaches past and present. If you want to organise a team, that's the easy bit. Getting them to create and sort of roll teams over, that's the hard bit. I get, I mean, Rob, I mean, you've got your point on this, as well, make the point that it was Chelsea, wasn't it? If it had been Arsenal or Chelsea, that's the worst possible opponent for Spurs to lose to in that fashion. But, Rob, go on, you were... And it's at home. I mean, I think part of the problem is the home form. You cannot get away with losing games at home.

10:35You can get away with losing games away, particularly when you're at the start of a managerial tenure. I think it's really important to win games at home when you're starting now because it gives the fans something to buy into and you know look at the premier league obviously this has been recorded before suddenly neverton on monday night but at the moment spurs are fitting in the table they're unbeaten in the in the champions league there's obviously they're obviously not doing an awful lot wrong and i think in the premier league if they'd had the results at home that they'd had away that just the home and away form was flipped i don't think that we would be having the same conversation just because simply the results will come at home and you're and you're in front of your own fans, and you give them something to kind of get behind.

11:16And I was looking at some of the stats, and obviously Thomas Frank is not responsible for this entire record, but over the last year, so going back to October 2024, Spurs have had 20 Premier League home games and won four, which is only one, well, one fewer, I think, than West Ham, which says everything about their home form. Obviously, Posta Coglu is part of that, but it's obviously something that Frank hasn't been able to fix either. And I just think if you start winning home games, it solves half of this, regardless of the style of football you're playing and the lack of creativity. So, James, is it the Spurs fans?

11:50Are they unrealistically impatient? I don't think we'd be talking about this as much as we are if the Spurs fans hadn't reacted as they did. And I can understand it because Rob's right. They've been turning up for weeks, well, for a year now, basically. and more likely than not their team is going to lose and that builds its own sense of frustration but I do think they need to show a little bit more patience and just accept that there's been a lot of change at the top end of the club this summer we know we know about obviously Enoch stepping back we know well sorry Enoch kind of taking control I should say rather Daniel Levy stepping down all of those changes in the boardroom obviously they've changed the manager there have been transfer market changes as well and they missed out as I say on a lot of targets you can't expect to put all that together and then sort of sit here at the beginning of November and think oh we should be you know top six oh by the way we are it's it it did feel as though there's not been enough of a it was a frustration I think at just how bad of the performance that was in isolation I hope I don't think it was a wider commentary on Thomas Frank and and his management just yet.

13:07I think it's literally 0.05 XG. You play that game 20 times and they score one goal. I don't know how to put it clearer than that. That is a difficult watch. And I hope from the Tottenham fans' perspective that it's a frustration about that rather than a judgment on Thomas Frank, who I think it's just too early to say if he can be a success in that role. It's his problem, though. And I totally agree with what you're saying. It's way too early, and Tottenham fans need to kind of take a reality check and realise where they are, they've won a trophy, etc. But next two games, Man United at home, we beat four times last season and then Arsenal away.

13:43Now, they're two big games in any season, aren't they? But at this stage, because of the situation that is beginning to bubble away at Tottenham, they are massive games now. Because if you come out of those features without a win, maybe with two defeats, then where do we stand then? Yeah, I mean, look, they are two big games. They come either side of the international break. I suspect that if Tottenham lose to Manchester United at the weekend, that the focus on Thomas Frank will go up another notch. But look, we cannot be sat here thinking Thomas Frank's job's in jeopardy. I just feel we're nowhere near that stage at the moment.

14:22He needs to get his squad fully fit for starters. I don't think he wants to start with Richarlison or Colin Mwani. I think he wants to start with Dominic Solanke. Solanke's it's been a sort of slow process in being able to get him fit there there is some chat that he could make one or two one either one or the other of those games I think if we if they can get him up back to speed obviously Madison and Kuliseski are key elements of this as well I think if you can you we can only really judge him when he's got those attacking players fit and available and then see what they can create and what they can produce I mean he was quite bullish after the game Thomas Frank he sort of said you know people who see me as a defensive coach I mean they've obviously not watched my style of play that you know I've always managed teams that create and score goals well he's going to have to do that because if he doesn't then that that noise is going to grow louder and louder.

15:13So Robbie you were at the forest ground the city ground at the weekend and I know Amren said to your question that this time last year United would have lost that game and they lost it by more goals and I must admit that for me looked like a good point It looked like a decent performance. They fought back to get a decent point against the Forest side that seemed to fend their feet again after that little brief interlude with Hans Postacoglu. So where are United at right now? Was it a good result or was it a two-points drop? Obviously, Amorim afterwards is going to say it's two-points drop because it's a game that they've drawn after taking a lead.

15:45But I think the big step forward for him is that it looked like a game that they would have lost last season. And actually, the answer that he gave was that not only would we have lost that game last year, we would have lost it by even more goals, which I thought was quite telling. And it did have that feeling about it, especially when Forrest scored twice in 90 seconds. If that had happened last season, they would have lost by three or four, I would have thought. But they had the kind of resilience to get back into it. They score a really good equaliser through Ahmad, had a chance to win it at the end.

16:19So while Amrim kind of has to sit there and say that he's disappointed in dropping two points, I think once he was on the team bus going home, he would have felt that's probably a good point, a point gained. It keeps the unbeaten run going. It's now four games unbeaten. They've got that trip to Spurs at the weekend, a game that they will feel like they can win, particularly because Spurs aren't playing well at home. And it just keeps the momentum up. He's not talking about another defeat. I think also it does, though, show where United are at under him. There has been progress the last couple of weeks.

16:51But United are still capable of chucking in those periods of games where they look quite rattled, and they were rattled early in the second half at Forest. The city ground was up, Dijon was getting the fans behind and the supporters were into it, which is tough when you're an away side. Also, you've got situations, again, highlight, parts of the game that highlight that this isn't the squad that Amrind really wants. Ahmad scores a great equaliser and is probably United's best right wing-back at the moment. but the first goal comes from Morgan Gibbs-White just peeling off onto Ahmad at the back post and bulldozing a header in the net because Ahmad's so small.

17:28You know, Amrim is doing his best, I think, with the players he's got available. And that's why I think he needs a couple... He needs January, if he can get players in. Probably needs next summer to get more players in. And then you can really start to see and judge him on his team. I think now it's still round pegs in square holes a little bit. Rob, it was Jamie Carragher who said, leave the football before the football leaves you, about Catherine Muro. I mean, it's such a damning line. But has he been one of United's better players this season? And also, I noticed a couple of weeks ago, I think you did a story about that they could potentially extend his contract.

18:09I mean, is that realistic? What's the sort of story behind the story there? Do you think there's a chance that they could actually commit his future beyond next summer? Yeah, I mean, he's certainly important or has been important this season. Before the Forest game, there was a stat that did the rounds that United had conceded 16 goals in all competitions and Casemiro had been off the pitch for 13 of those. So while he'd been on the pitch, they'd only conceded three goals. Now, obviously, there are other factors around that, but it is quite a telling stat. And it was even more evident during the Brighton game in that United were winning 3-0.

18:43They were absolutely cruising. Casemiro had played really well. Casemiro suddenly comes off. Brighton get on the front foot a little bit and score twice and could have maybe nicked a point if it had gone differently. And he did the same. He just looked really kind of comfortable at Forrest. The problem that Amarim has got with Casemiro at the moment is that he probably hasn't got the legs to get through 90 minutes every week. And when he comes off, you have to put on Mainu or Ugarte. And I don't think Amarim sickly trusts either of those. So he's kind of having to nurse Casemiro through games because he's so important.

19:18In terms of his contract, he's out of contract at the end of this season. He's one of United's highest paid players, probably United's highest paid player now that Rashford has gone. There is an option to extend his contract by a year, one of those trigger options that United have. But they would have to do it on the same wages. And United have said repeatedly that they're trying to bring the wage bill down. That's why they wanted to get rid of Rashford. David De Gea was one of them. Raphael Varane, another one, another high earner that they let go on a free. So as things stand right now, he is going to leave.

19:48But I think if Casemiro, who apparently is quite settled in Manchester, if he showed a willingness to renegotiate his contract, take what would be a quite significant wage reduction, which obviously that would be something for him, I think United would be quite keen on that. Now, the problem is that a club in Saudi maybe comes in and says, well, here's this many millions a year. And when you're faced with that kind of decision, it's a tough one for Casemiro do you stay at the top level in the Premier League on a reduced wage or do you go to Saudi Arabia and basically make sure that you don't ever have to earn another penny ever again it's a tough one but I think right now Casemiro is certainly Amrim's most important central midfielder he doesn't trust the other two, he may do and Agate and I think you would quite like him to stay if the right terms can be agreed.

20:35I think the point you make there Rob is right, he has been United's most consistent midfielder, he's the only one who can play that role with any kind of reliability. And obviously when he gets taken off, you see the massive drop-off, don't you? You see Agate coming on Manu and then it's almost like all hands on deck trying to survive for the last 20 minutes. So he's important, but he's 34 in February. There's no way I don't think he's staying at Man United because why commit to another year to a player who is 34, whose time at the club has been pretty much, ever since he arrived, he's too old.

21:04So why would you then almost like take a backwards step? I mean, I was speaking to somebody recently and their view was that they can get a million pound a week off the wage bill next summer by letting Casemiro go, letting Maguire go, and Rashford and Sancho will be out of the club, they hope, as well. So that's a lot of money to spend on a new player coming in or a couple of players coming in terms of wages. So I think it's clever management by United, isn't it? If they kind of hang the carrot out there for people like Casemiro or for Maguire that, yeah, if you keep doing well, guys, they'll be a new contract at the end of the season.

21:32The alternative is to say, no, I'm not going to keep them and then all of a sudden it's like, well, if you're not going to keep me, then why am I busting a gut every week? So I don't think Casemiro can have a future at United if United are serious about where they want to go. Next summer, they have to bring in two proper midfielders, two midfielders who can get around the pitch. They're not going to get a Caicedo, but they need a Caicedo, they need a Declan Rice. And they've had the opportunity to get both of those players in recent years and, for whatever reason, decided not to pursue it. So that's on them.

21:59They have to find the next Caicedo, the next Declan Rice, to get themselves where they want to be. And I don't think Casemiro can be part of that future, despite the fact that, you know, Kobe Maneu doesn't have much of a future either. If he can get rid of Agate, they will. But sometimes you have to move people on. I think Casemiro gets to the summer and I think it'll be farewell. I think the issue though in midfield is if you're getting rid of Casemiro, and I take your point, right now he is going to leave on a free transfer. It would take, you know, a certain circumstances for him to stay. But you lose Casemiro, Amarim clearly doesn't fancy Maneu.

22:29He clearly doesn't fancy Agate. If you lose three of those, you need three central midfielders. And that's a lot of business to do in one summer. It's all very well saying, like, we want Belaber or we want Adam Wharton or someone like that, a£100 million player to come in. But you also need the depth. And I think that if Maynud does leave in January, which is a possibility, I think it's probably more likely that he goes next summer because United need players. And say Agarte goes because he's just not playing games, that maybe Amirim in the club would look at it and say, well, if Casemiro is going to take a hefty wage cut, we would rather have someone in the squad who's maybe not going to play 60 games, but could play 30, 35, 40 on reduced wages.

23:10And we know that he can do the job that Amarim wants, even at 34 years old. That's a better bet than sticking with someone like Mainu and Agate, who right now, Amarim just doesn't seem to want to play. I mean, it was really telling on Saturday at Forest that he's talking about energy and you could see the energy of the players dropping and still didn't put Mainu on. Now, that is really quite telling, I think, for his future. And I just think that when the club look at the squad as a whole, if there was a possibility maybe of getting... And I'm not saying that you keep him on 400 grand a week, but maybe you can get him on half that or even less.

23:47And it's really incentivised. And there are bonuses for games, all that kind of thing. If he's someone that Amory knows he can trust, that is an awful lot better than having two lads in there in your squad who you just don't fancy putting on in really testing circumstances. Just one last question on United, Rob, before we move on the next bit but what are they going to do when Brian Mbouma and Ahmad Diallo go away for the African Nations as well as Nusim Azraoui because obviously Mbouma and Ahmad have become a really big part of that new attacking unit. We're talking about the depth. They haven't got the depth because Joshua Zerch who comes in hasn't been playing at all, not very good.

24:21Where do they go without Ahmad and Mbouma? Yeah, it's a good question and he was actually asked that in the press conference on Friday before the Forest game and you could see the colour sort of drain from Amarim's face when he kind of considered it. He was like, please, let me solve one problem and then I'll deal with the next problem. But you can tell that he's already thinking about it. I think he knows that it's going to be really, really tough. I mean, Brian Mbwemo has probably been his best player this season. Ahmad, in his strongest team, would play every week. Masraoui hasn't been fit, but I think would play most weeks if he was available.

Read the full transcript

24:52Losing those three players is going to be catastrophic, really, for Man United. Because as you say, they just haven't got the players to come in to do those jobs. I think that Amriem will hope that by then maybe the team is a little bit more stable, that the results have stabilised a little bit and he can maybe get away with bringing other players in. But the drop-off from losing Mwemo and Ahmad in particular will really, really hit Man United. And it's possible that they are going to, and I said on the last pod, that they're going to have bad results anyway, regardless of the players that are in the team.

25:26But if you take two of your best players out in a really stressful period of fixture list in December, where there are games coming thick and fast. I think it's going to be really, really tough for Man United. OK, time for a break. But when we come back, we're going to talk about UEFA's difficulties in finding cities and stadiums willing to host the Champions League final. So your team just got knocked out of the FIFA World Cup. Brutal, right? Well, the good news is you're not done. It's time to jump on the Leeds bandwagon and nobody loses on the bandwagon. No upsets, no heartbreak, no stress.

25:57only good times. So join Leys on the bandwagon. Grab a bag of Leys. Get ready for the next match. Cheer for whoever you want. Leys keeps the party going. Leys' official sponsor of the FIFA World Cup 2026.

26:14So Mark, you're writing a piece about the Champions League final and the destinations for it. There have been some issues around finding cities who are willing to host it, even though it's obviously quite a prestigious event. What are the issues are ongoing and are we at the start of a journey that might lead us to a Champions League final in the US or Saudi Arabia possibly? Well I mean right now I think the public stands from UEFA is that no they're happy to keep it within Europe but the situation is they're running out of cities to host the final. Now they announced last week that the 2028 and 2029 hosting bidding process and 2028 has got one bidder Munich and Munich had the Champions League final this year so basically in the space of three years the Allianz Arena will host two Champions League finals the year after that 2029 Wembley has announced itself to be a bidder and Barcelona's new Camp Nou and I'd imagine it'll go to the Camp Nou because it's 30 years since the last Champions League final but still you know Wembley is always there thereabouts and I've been speaking to somebody about this and they're saying that UEFA and they're basically down to four or five venues that they can rely upon that can do it because it's not just about of stage in the game the champions league final it's first of all you need a stadium that can host at least 65 000 fans so that rules a lot of stadiums out but it's also about you know infrastructure you know airports can fans get there and back can they get in and out of the city hotel space can they actually find a place to stay as we we all know but i've met the champions league finals it costs an absolute fortune to stay in these cities you have to stay miles out of town so you need a city that's got the ability to host the event you've got two cities in russia muscow St.

27:48Petersburg are off the rotor. You've got Paris, which again is unlikely to be considered for a good while yet because of what happened in 2022 with the Liverpool fans. Rome seems to have dropped off the rotor as well because it's deemed as being an outdated stadium now. Infrastructure in the Italian capital is not great. So you're basically looking at Wembley, Munich. I think the other one is Barcelona and Atletico Madrid. The Bernabeu Stadium is obviously an amazing stadium, but I don't think Real, their relationship with UEFA right now is at a point where they would get a Champions League final.

28:17So if you've only got four stadiums on rotation, obviously Budapest is hosting the final at the end of this season, but I've been told they're going to really struggle again. One airport, hotel space is going to be difficult. So will it get to the point where it could be in the US? Alexander Chaffer said last year that it's something that's on their thought process. It'd be hard to sell, but I think it's inevitable at some point that a New York or a Dallas or a Los Angeles will want to host a Champions League final because all of the issues that UEFA face in Europe about stadium size, infrastructure, they're not an issue in the US.

28:49I don't know what you guys think, but I think maybe in the next 10 years we'll see a Champions League final outside of Europe. I think it's disgusting that the profiteering that goes on around the final every year and the fact that the way that even the draws are done now, the delay between knowing that obviously there's a fixed date for the Champions League final, But for the knockout rounds and even for the group stages, we know the match weeks, but we don't know the days. And the days now take, you know, what, 48 hours sometimes for it to be confirmed. And by that stage, suddenly all the hotels are three times as much as they would have been otherwise.

29:29All the flights are a lot more expensive. I mean, wherever they hold it, somebody should be looking at that part of the process as well. that it's always the fans of the two teams involved that are getting turned over by the methodology through which they select these cities. And that should be part of it. I mean, my view is that a European competition should be settled on European soil. Why are you taking it elsewhere? I don't know whether maybe they could do, just thinking about tennis, you know, the men's tour finals, had a residency for a number of years. I mean, they had it in London, they've had it in Shanghai, they've had it in Italy as well.

30:13Do you think there's a scenario where they could say, okay, for the next three years, Wembley has the Champions League final. And then after that, we go to Munich for three years. And actually, you sort of fix it so that everybody kind of knows way ahead of time. And then actually, you could control a lot of this profiteering that goes on because you know it from three years out. if UEFA were able to they would have it at Wembley forever because first of all it's a neutral venue so you're not going to have a situation like in Munich or in Madrid where you could have the host team or Barcelona hosting their final secondly three, four airports in and around London which can host the incoming fans, loads of hotels it's a global city and Wembley holds 90 ,000 fans almost 20 ,000 VIP facilities so it is the perfect venue for UEFA they love having it at Wembley because of all those reasons but you know possibly but I think obviously Munich would be happy about that Madrid Barcelona would not be happy about every Champions League final being in in London but there is an argument for that there's an argument you could say those four cities that you spoke about have it on rotation over the next 20 years because you know yes Barcelona and yes Real Madrid might get to a final but still that can happen now you know Bayern Munich had played a Champions League final at home they lost to Chelsea in in 2012 so it's possible but you know they are running out of cities that can host it and we've all been i think james me and you were in in paris for the champions league finally 2022 it was chaos wasn't it it was absolutely yeah paris one of the again a global city but hotels were ridiculously expensive the infrastructure was a joke and the stadium just not fit for purpose but if you can't hold the champions league finally in paris what chance have you got because yeah but there's i mean there's a unique set of circumstances to that particular stadium i would say and and it didn't i i don't know if you felt the same way.

31:58I've done games there before and left and not felt safe. Trying to go from the station, sorry, from the stadium to the station or waiting for a taxi. I think that's a unique situation with that particular stadium, but I don't know. It's going to end up in Saudi Arabia, isn't it? It's going to end up in the middle. It will just go to the highest bidder. I was on a tour with United a couple of years ago where we had a briefing with the governor of New Jersey, he was there talking to us about the World Cup. But the subject got on to Champions League games and he said that him and his team would push really hard for meaningful Champions League games, whether it's group games or knockout games or obviously the final, they would push quite hard to host that.

32:43I did a trip to Saudi Arabia to see Ronaldo when he first played for Al Nasser. And while I was there, the Italian Super Cup was there at the same time and the week after, they were going to have the Spanish Super Cup. I'm amazed that the Community Shield hasn't been moved away from Wembley to Saudi Arabia or the Middle East or America. You've got a situation with La Liga where that Barcelona-Villa Real game was going to get held in Miami before there was protest. It's obviously where the game is headed. And when you have these kind of big, prestigious showpiece events, the likes of the FA Cup final or the Champions League final, when they're meant to be held at neutral venues anyway and you don't have two set teams in it, I think it's quite easy to move that game to Abu Dhabi or Dubai or Saudi somewhere because it's not like moving a Premier League game.

33:35Because if you tried to do that, there would be absolute outcry. The home fans would say it's not fair. The away team wouldn't want to travel. I think if you could move the Champions League final, I'm not saying it'll be done in a year or two, but in 10 years' time, if you just say, well, we haven't got enough bidders for this game, so we're going to take it to Riyadh where they do want it, I think it's the kind of situation that you can envisage. I think probably we're all just going to have to get used to it because it is going to happen. I think the point you made there about the La Liga game in Miami, which has now been called off the Barcelona-Villa Real game, UEFA reluctantly gave that the green light as well as an Italian game in Australia.

34:12For me, UEFA reluctantly giving those a green light was basically them just making sure they've got a kind of a fallback option. If they suddenly decide to play Champions League final abroad, they basically almost paved the way for it to happen. So interesting times ahead. Okay, we'll wrap up this section. And next, we're talking about players who struggle to come back from lengthy injury layoffs. Ken Marcotti here for Gusto. Right now, everyone is trying to run leaner, tighter budgets, smaller teams, higher expectations. Now, the last thing you have time to waste on is manual payroll or chasing down an HR form.

34:44Gusto is how small business owners get time back when every hour counts. Gusto is online payroll and benefit software built for small businesses. It's all-in-one, remote-friendly, and incredibly easy to use, so you can pay, hire, onboard, and support your team from anywhere. Automatic payroll tax filing, simple direct deposits, health benefits, commuter benefits, workers' comp, 401k, you name it. Gusto makes it simple and has options for nearly every budget. And it's all built to save your time with built-in automated tools for offer letters, onboarding docs, direct deposit, and more. Plus, you get unlimited payroll runs for one monthly price.

35:27No hidden fees, no surprises. Try Gusto today at gusto.com slash FC and get three months free when you run your first payroll. That's three months of free payroll at gusto.com slash FC. One more time, gusto.com slash FC.

35:48Well Rob you've written about Rodri and his stop start return from his ACL injury we saw him for a quick as a flash cameo against Bournemouth where is he at the moment and and given City are obviously trailing Arsenal in the league how much pressure is he under to not only come back but come back as the linchpin that makes the whole thing tick for City. Yeah, I mean, in terms of his recovery, you kind of get the impression that he's quite frustrated, really, because obviously he did his ACL against Arsenal more than a year ago. He's had an operation. He's kind of gone through that long road to recovery, spent the first part of it in Madrid, and then he's come back to City.

36:35You start training in the gym, and then you're back on the grass, and then in April he comes and is part of the squad again, starts his first game in the Club World Cup in June. And then there's this kind of assumption that once you've gone through all that, that you're back and then you're right as rain. And it's not really been like that for him. He's played occasionally this season. He's started games. He started three really intense games in a row against Man United, Napoli and Arsenal. Afterwards, Guardiola said, I'm not really sure whether he's in a position where he can do that week after week.

37:06He's then had a hamstring injury. He's missed four games. He came back against Bournemouth at the weekend. So, I mean, the piece that's on the site is essentially just about how tough it is for these players to come back because it's not just those sort of long days and long months spent in the medical room on your own, you know, kind of staring out the window, looking at your mate's train. It's actually when you come back and how tough it is in that instance as well, because we're in a period now, and Pep has kind of said it himself a little bit, where Rodri, all of his physical metrics when he's fit might be right there.

37:37You know, he's covering the same amount of ground. His sprints are there, the number of sprints. But there's an awful lot that goes on in a player's head in that kind of situation where he's got to kind of feel comfortable in his own body. He's got to feel comfortable twisting and turning into challenges, you know, that kind of thing. And I was in Monaco watching City a couple of weeks ago where they drew in the Champions League and Rodri started that game. In the second half, he gets quite a significant knock in the second half and goes down. And you can see immediately he looks a bit panicked, that his teammates look a bit panicked.

38:09In the end, the City saw physios come on and he carries on for five or ten minutes. But you can see in that life of five or ten minutes that he's not really himself. I don't know whether it's his confidence he's knocked or he's a bit worried about having a knock on his knee again. He gets the ball taken off him at one point and Monaco break quite quickly. And then five minutes after that, he's taken off by Pep Guardiola, who brings, I think, Nico Gonzalez on to kind of shore up the midfield. And really the piece that's on the side is essentially around that. And it's difficult for him and it's difficult for Pep because he's obviously, like you mentioned there, such a massive part of the team that they want him back as quickly as possible and in the best form that they can get him in.

38:49And it's just not as easy as that. And we're in this little kind of awkward phase now where they're trying to ease him back in, but they also need him desperately. I think part of the problem is the fact that City are obviously having a few collective issues and they're in a state of flux themselves. I mean, he's not coming back into a settled side. It's a lot easier for players, you know, when they've been out for a while to come back into a team that's winning, knows its patterns of play, that is sort of settled in terms of personnel. It feels as though it's doubly difficult for him because City is still trying to work out exactly what kind of team they are.

39:26Yeah, and that is part of it. And, you know, he had all this kind of rehabilitation last season where City obviously sort of form-wise fell off a cliff. And every sort of week towards the end of last season, the question to Pep was, when's Rodri coming back? When's Rodri coming back? Because if he's at this cure to every problem that they have, and you're right, you know, this season has been better than last season, but it's not been perfect. It's been quite mixed. They've been good in games. They've been poor in other games. And there's still this kind of narrative around City that they need Rodri to play well.

39:57And there is, you know, that part of that is true because he's so important, but there isn't any kind of, there's no way of easing him back in because City need him. You know, it's not, if they were winning sort of every week and they'd won 10 on the bounce, you know, the need for Rodri to be in there wouldn't be as great. And you could say to him, well, you know, maybe take an extra week to get yourself right. Maybe you sit on the bench for two or three weeks and we play you five minutes here, 10 minutes there, then 15 minutes and we build you back up. Guardiola hasn't really had that luxury.

40:31And even though he said repeatedly that they're going to be really, really cautious with him and they want to make sure that he gets back to his best and they don't want to rush him because they know if he breaks down again, that could have serious consequences for his career. You always feel like right at the end when he's kind of, Rodri's right there. And I'm sure there's an element of Rodri sort of saying, I want to play. And Pep has touched on that a little bit in the past. But you kind of feel that he gets to kind of that level and Guardiola kind of can't help himself but to chuck him back in because he just knows that he's so important and he's so integral to what City are trying to do.

41:04I mean, you mentioned sort of Rodri's view on this. I mean, he's obviously one of the players who's spoken out publicly about the fixture scheduling and suggesting that the players could be quite close to striking. and obviously he's very conscious of that whole kind of workload conversation. I mean, do you sense any hesitancy in him that as he's come over, you know, he's come over obviously a very serious injury trying to recover from it, that he doesn't want to be rushed himself because he knows what a big year this is with the World Cup at the end of it, you know, and then obviously into the following season where there won't be much of a break because it's an expanded World Cup.

41:43But do you feel that he's conscious of that wider debate as much as he is of his own situation? I imagine he is because he's a really, really intelligent guy. I mean, we've spoken to him in press conferences and mixed zones. You can tell that he's very, very switched on to issues outside of his own and outside of his own club. And you say, you're right, he's spoken, probably one of the major voices last year, about fixture congestion and what it was doing to players. I think it's quite difficult though for Rodri because he will understand that his body probably can't get through a 10-month season unscathed with a massive World Cup at the end of it.

42:24But also, and it's something that Guardiola has touched on, that I think that footballers inherently just want to play. And so while Rodri will take advice from all City's medical staff and the physios about you need to build up and we can't rush you back too soon and you might feel great now, but we need to wait till the morning to decide whether you can play at the weekend. And I'm sure that Rodri is the type of player that will take all of that on board and will go away and be really quite considered. I think when Pat Guardiola has got his little tactics board up in the dressing room that he wants to see his name up there because he's just desperate to play, particularly after missing so much of last season.

43:02So it's a difficult situation for Rodri because he won't want to push himself, but he also wants to play. It's a difficult situation for Guardiola as well because he doesn't want to risk the health and the future of one of his best players, if not his most influential player next to Erling Haaland, but also knows that if City want to challenge Arsenal for the title, want to get quite far in the Champions League, as good as Nico Gonzalez is and Kovacic when he comes in and Reinders can play there, you can't replace Rodri. So it's really tough finding that balance. And essentially that is what the piece on the site is all about, finding that balance for these top players and making sure that they can play and be the influence that they always have been, but also not risking Rodri for the long term.

43:49And that, you know, as great a player as he is now, that you're kind of risking the next three, four, five years of his career because you want to get him back right this second. I mean, you mentioned Arsenal there, and obviously everyone's talking about their squad depth at the moment. And it's sort of interesting, this debate, actually, because, you know, if you look at even the Burnley game last weekend, there's a definite shift this season in the way that Arteta's managing his players. Jokerez says he has his best 45 minutes in an Arsenal shirt. He comes off at half-time because he's felt something.

44:24Martins Zubimendi, one of the signings of the season, stitches the whole thing together. Not unlike Rodri, of course, for City. He feels something. He's taken off at half-time. A couple of weeks ago, Bukayo Saka, they're only 1-0 up against Palace. He comes off after an hour because he wasn't able to train in the build-up to the game. he felt a bit of sickness. These sort of decisions that he's made, I think he took Saliba off at halftime in that game as well. Again, he felt something. He's coming straight off. And in the past, Arsenal, I think, have been guilty of maybe pushing their players or their players have wanted to push themselves a little bit too much because the squad depth hasn't been there and they've needed to take those risks to try and keep pace with City and Liverpool.

45:08And it feels a bit this season as though what Arteta and Arsenal are doing now is being a bit cleverer, a bit cuter, and managing that squad better because they feel they've got stronger options. You know, we're talking about an Arsenal team that was obviously clear at the top of the table and they're missing their captain, Martin Odegaard, who up until this season was widely regarded as the guy who stitches all their attacking play together. You know, and of course, now they've got Eberichieze who can come in, they've got Ethan Lognieri who can come in in those central positions. They can play Mikel Moreno in there with Declan Rice with Zubimendi as a three, they've got so many different kind of options that I think because they were overusing, particularly Odegaard and Saka in the last couple of years, that were leading to these injuries.

45:56You look at Kai Havertz, obviously he's out at the moment. I remember sitting in a press conference with Arteta where he described Havertz as a genetic powerhouse about two weeks before he got injured and was ruled out for the rest of the season. And what he was trying to do was sort of say, it's all right, these guys can take the load. But I think in the summer, by signing all the players they have, they've looked at and gone actually to compete in four competitions. This is no criticism of those individuals. It's just to compete in four competitions. We just need more than what we currently have.

46:24Do you think he'll be able to do that and continue to be as cautious the closer Arsenal maybe get towards the end of the season where that big prize, the Premier League or the Champions League is in sight? And you've got players like Odegaard, maybe Saka, who are kind of on the verge or just coming back from injuries, because it's one thing being able to do it in October and November, I guess, and another thing having that same caution in March and April when you can really kind of see what's in front of you a little bit. Well, I mean, that will be the temptation, won't it? At the moment, they're winning every week.

46:58They're still in the four competitions. They're in a strong position in Europe, which means he could rotate a little bit more towards the end of the group stage if they've qualified, which you assume they will have with a game or two to spare. the FA Cup obviously kicks in in January. There are enough games to rotate and keep everyone happy. I think that's an aspect of it as well, is that it's all well and good having this big squad. But if they were to get knocked out of a couple of competitions, you'd start to think, well, there's going to be big players there on not inconsiderable salaries who are getting 10, 20 minutes at best at the end of a Premier League game.

47:33And that becomes an issue for them. But it's a problem that they want to have. is the reason why they've built the squad the way they have. And I think what they'll feel is that in rotating Saka, obviously Odegaard, that's been enforced because of his injury, but in rotating those players a bit more now, he'll feel as though in March and April, he can push them a bit further because there are fewer games in their legs. It's a little bit less of a risk. One other thing that just came to my mind actually was, I sat in a briefing last season with a doctor at a Premier League club. It was all a bit impromptu, but they wanted to sort of explain about how the rise of Achilles injuries was explainable through the data.

48:16And he talked us through how every Achilles, basically, if you have an Achilles problem or your Achilles flares up at all, you need a minimum of 72 hours for that to calm down before you can train the muscle again. And I thought it was really interesting because obviously 72 hours is three days. And at the moment, you know, teams are playing every three days. And after this international break, we'll play for every three days until March, pretty much. And it just shows you how much the fixture calendar is contributing to a lot of these problems. That if the doctors are saying you need 72 hours before you can train this muscle again, and obviously to train the muscle, you then make the muscle stronger and you make it less susceptible to injury.

48:59If all you're doing is maintaining a sort of level of Achilles fitness, if you like, well, you're risking injury as the season goes on because you're not able to train that muscle and build it up and make it more immune to the demands. And, you know, I think it's a really good example of how the fixture list is just compounding the problem. Yeah, I mean, there's a situation with Palace, I think, coming up where they possibly might have to play Sunday, Tuesday. City did it last year. They played a game Sunday. They played a cup tag, I think, on Tuesday. Obviously, lots of the players were changed.

49:34But it does feel like we're getting away from that, at least having three days between games. And it seems to be more and more common now that the teams are being asked to play Sunday, Tuesday. So instead of actually fixing the problem, it seems to be getting worse. And you're talking there about 72 hours to rest a muscle. there is a possibility that next season we could see that reduced even further because there's just so many games to get into such a short space of time. Palace at the moment are facing in December three games in five days. It's incredible. Huge injury risk for all concerned.

50:14I'm sure that topic is going to run and run but thanks for that Rob and thanks to everyone for joining us this week. We'll be back again with another Football Reporter soon.

50:30That's the sound of zero sugar, 200 milligrams of caffeine, and the power to burn body fat. Storm, energy for life. Storm Energy Blend helps boost metabolism, which in combination with exercise and a healthy diet helps burn fat. This product alone does not produce weight loss. Individual results may vary.

From the publisher

Rob, James and Mark break down an ugly weekend for Spurs and discuss Casemiro’s resurgence at Manchester United. The trio also debate the prospect of a Champions League final in the U.S., and discuss Rodri’s return for Manchester City.
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

More from ESPN FC

All 572 episodes
The Football Reporters: Tottenham turns toxic for Thomas FrankESPN FC · 50 min
Listen in VO