

13 Nov 2026 · 59m · 19 chapters

Jurrien Timmer (Fidelity) discusses how markets are “regulating” the AI trade via capital-spending constraints and political uncertainty after the midterms, why earnings growth can be high without stocks getting more expensive, and how bond yields, inflation, and the Fed affect equity valuations. He also covers semiconductor cyclicality, the “Fed model” (bond vs stock valuation), 1994/2022 rate-driven analogs, the investment clock, stock-bond correlation, portfolio construction (60-20-20), and gold/commodities amid fiscal risk.
Jurrien Timmer is a Fidelity investor/market strategist focused on using history, market cycles, and data to interpret macro and equity/sector performance.
AI-related CapEx may cool via regulation/market forces; investors don’t pay for peak earnings (40–50% growth) at elevated forward P/Es; semis follow a ~40-month earnings cycle; higher real yields and fiscal risk can compress multiples; Fed transparency changes can raise term premium; bonds may not hedge stocks if inflation stays sticky; diversification should include uncorrelated assets beyond stocks/bonds.
CoreWeave bonds as an early signal; Magnificent Seven payout ratio falling to ~28% from ~90% due to CapEx; semiconductor earnings growth cited around ~180% YoY; 1987, 1994, 2022 analogs; gold up ~32% in 2025 then “overbought”/cooling in 2026; commodities (e.g., copper/energy) taking the baton.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on market dynamics following the midterm elections and AI investments.
“You spend a lot of your time at Fidelity helping investors break through the clutter using history, market cycles, and data to make sense of what's happening in the markets.”
Exploration of earnings growth trends and their impact on market valuation.
“Yeah, it's a good point that, you know, leading up to this, there was some cracks that were forming in different parts of the market.”
Analysis of semiconductor market cycles and investment strategies.
“And again, coming back to the glass half full, if they are forced to do that by market conditions or regulations in terms of the AI trade, that actually could boost their multiples.”
Explanation of the Fed model and its implications for stock valuations.
“Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
Learn how bond yields affect stock valuations and market behavior.
“So if bonds are yielding 5%, their PE, if you will, is 20.”
Explore the similarities between the market conditions of 1994 and 2022.
“You had talked about a comparison in 1994 in terms of the stealth correction we were seeing.”
Discuss the impact of inflation on interest rates and investment strategies.
“The Fed has to raise rates because it did not.”
Gain insights into which inflation measures are most relevant for economic analysis.
“But real rates were rising just as much as nominal rates.”
Understand the investment clock and its implications for market conditions.
“And I think that's probably one of the big reasons why we had the outcome of the midterm elections.”
Learn how the stock market influences consumer spending and economic health.
“Do you think the stock market is more important for the economy than it ever has been?”
Learn about the relationship between housing market fluctuations and consumer spending, and how baby boomers' investments impact the economy.
“Housing is another one where there is a wealth effect.”
Explore the role of gold as an investment during inflationary periods and its historical reliability.
“Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
Discuss the implications of rising real yields and the relationship between government debt and economic growth.
“You mentioned fiscal dominance, and that plays into this next chart I wanted to put up.”
Explore the Fed's current stance on inflation and interest rates, including potential future cuts.
“How about the current situation with the Fed?”
Understand how historical market analogies inform current investment strategies and behaviors.
“But we're in the mid threes, and that is too high for sure.”
Discuss the changing financial profiles of mega-cap tech companies and implications for investors.
“Yeah, I know when you put that chart out on a few of our podcasts, people were referencing how closely the performance was between the two periods.”
Analyze how the CAPE model influences expectations for future market returns based on historical performance.
“And one of the things that I don't think a lot of investors really can appreciate or understand is how strong the returns have been since the financial crisis.”
Exploration of historical market returns and future expectations.
“To me, that started in 2009, and we have been over-earning beta since that time.”
Insights on investor behavior and lessons learned from market experiences.
“Now at McDonald's, the new frosted cranberry splash with Sprite.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Excess Returns, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Now at McDonald's, the new frosted cranberry splash with Sprite. Because there's no better time of year for friends, family, Sprite, cold foam, and sprinkles.
0:42Now at McDonald's.
0:47Hi, Urien. Welcome to Excess Returns. Good afternoon. Good to see you. Nice to see you too. You spend a lot of your time at Fidelity helping investors break through the clutter using history, market cycles, and data to make sense of what's happening in the markets. And there's certainly plenty to talk about with you today. It's been two days or a few days since the midterm elections. Markets are sort of trying to digest sort of some of the changes that are coming politically, but also the questions around data centers and AI. And so let's maybe start there. I mean, we're going to work through a bunch of your great charts that you spend time putting together.
1:29And that's kind of the meat of the discussion, I think. But I think we'd be remiss if we didn't at least get your thoughts and opinion on what we've seen in the market over the past few days and kind of how you frame that and the way that you think of markets and macro, how you would suggest investors be thinking about what we're seeing. So in a way, and obviously I have no particular political expertise, but markets tend to regulate or get regulated either by market conditions or by regulations, like as in politics. And the markets were already, the AI side of the trade, if you will, was already getting regulated by the markets itself, right?
2:15I mean, the AI names, whether it's semis or memory or data centers or hyperscalers, they hadn't really gone anywhere since early June and actually were correcting for now five months on. And so the markets were already doing the work themselves because the CapEx, the demand for capital from the hyperscalers and the frontier labs is so vast that the markets were struggling to just absorb that need. And, of course, this happens at the time where one of the big frontier labs, of course, is about to go public. So the markets were already asking questions about the viability and the sustainability, not of the technology, but of the financial model, right?
3:04And that's not new. I mean, the same thing happened with the Internet. Boom. The same thing happened with railroads in 1873. And so the markets were already kind of going through that process. And of course, during the midterm or following the midterm elections, the answer is now perhaps even clearer that the growth needs to be regulated or will be regulated in some way. And you can argue that's bad because we're going to lose the race against China or whatever. But I would argue that it's actually good because if you slow down the development a little bit up front, you avoid crashing, going off the rails later.
3:48And I think the signal we saw, for instance, in core weave bonds, we're already kind of heading in that direction. And so I think of it more as a glass half full. And also the incumbents in the space, right, the big hyperscalers who have very solid businesses aside from data centers and AI will actually probably benefit from this because they are the incumbents and they have very generous cash flows. And maybe if they spend less of that cash flow on CapEx, the market actually will like that. So I think the markets will survive this and they will be okay. But there is a lot of rotation going on, of course, and we're seeing that in real time.
4:33Yeah, it's a good point that, you know, leading up to this, there was some cracks that were forming in different parts of the market. And then it just kind of went over the cliff in the last couple of days. But that's how markets sort of work sometimes. Good perspective. And I think this next question relates to that, which is, and you had a chart that you put out there where you were looking at the level of earnings growth. And typically when we see this types of, you know, strong earnings growth, it's coming out of recessionary type periods. But it was looking at earnings growth and where we are based on the forward P.E.
5:07multiple. And when you kind of put those two things together, high earnings growth and kind of an elevated forward P.E., how do you kind of think about that in the context of the way you're looking at the markets? So history shows that investors don't pay up for peak earnings unless you're in some sort of an irrational exuberance period, right? So earnings are cyclical, at least they generally are. And investors will pay up for good earnings and especially good sustained earnings. So let's say 10%, 15 % growth. But when you have growth at 40 % as the growth is right now or 50 % as it was in 2021 following the base effect recovery after COVID, investors generally don't pay up for that.
5:59because they don't want to pay for peak earnings growth. Now, there are exceptions, and actually 2021 was one of those exceptions where investors were paying 2021 times earnings, even though earnings were growing 50%. And, of course, we know what happened next in 2022. Today, investors are paying it about, especially after yesterday, about 18 times next 12-month earnings, which doesn't seem like a lot, and I don't think it is a lot. And, you know, that's several points below where it was even six months ago. And I think part of that is just a reflection of the likelihood that, you know, earnings, the forward estimate is up 38 % from a year ago.
6:43As bullish as you can be on earnings, those kinds of second derivatives are very hard to maintain. You just can't keep growing at those levels. And investors are just not paying for that. But there's a couple of other components to that. One, of course, is interest rates. You think about the discounted cash flow model. The denominator of that model is the cost of capital. And the cost of capital, until recently at least, has been rising. And that lowers the present value of future cash flow. So rising rates was part of that lower multiple as well. And I think another important part is that especially the Magnificent Seven, which, of course, are almost 40 % of the market, they used to pay out 90 % of their very formidable earnings growth back to investors via dividends or buybacks.
7:35Today, that number is only 28 % because most of them are spending a lot of their cash flow on CapEx. And investors are not going to pay for that because they want the bird in the hand, right? They want to know that they're getting those cash flows returned to them. So if you compare the MAC7, the price to earnings ratio versus the price to what I call the payout, so dividends and buybacks, their PE could be almost twice as high if they were returning their cash flows to investors. And again, coming back to the glass half full, if they are forced to do that by market conditions or regulations in terms of the AI trade, that actually could boost their multiples.
8:21So I don't think the market is expensive here, but investors don't pay for peak earnings. And that's what's happening. What do you think of semiconductors? Because I think some of your research shows that semis have followed this kind of consistent 40-month sort of cyclical cycle or cyclicality. And is that something that you think that they'll continue to follow that pattern here? Yes. It's never different this time, right, as we know. And semiconductors are a cyclical industry, and they follow a 40-month earnings cycle. And that earnings cycle is due to peak now, basically. And earnings growth is 180 % year over year.
9:11And now, of course, we're having possibly a squeeze where too much money is being borrowed, maybe not as much money, not enough money can be raised through IPOs. We'll find that out soon enough. And now, of course, We have a political sort of cloud, if you will, hanging over the space. So my sense is that, you know, even though there are still the industry is still very tight in terms of demand for chips is still outweighing the supply. But again, the market looks ahead and they're saying, you know, probably at 180 percent, the rate of change, the second derivative is likely peaking here. And again, that's that's part of the cyclical nature.
9:53So, you know, if you think about where to invest along the AI theme, or if you even want to invest along with it, you know, there's the picks and shovels, right? Power, data centers, semiconductors, memory. And then there are the hyperscalers, you know, the very big names with very strong boats and established businesses. And then you have the downstream beneficiaries, whether it's healthcare or financials. And so to me, those are the three pockets. And my sense is that the picks and shovels phase is over. And you can see that in the semiconductor charts. You know, the COSPI index looks like it just completed or triggered a head and shoulders top.
10:38But that doesn't mean that the trade is over. It just means that it's moving on from that particular pocket. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Now at McDonald's, the new frosted cranberry splash with Sprite, because there's no better time of year for friends, family, Sprite, cold foam and sprinkles.
11:28Now at McDonald's. Is that one of the sort of lessons embedded here that kind of in the cyclical areas of the market, stocks can look cheap when they're at peak earnings, but they're actually not cheap because they're at peak earnings. Yes. And that's a big distinction for investors in terms of investing in what we call long duration growth stocks, right? Companies that have such a strong network and franchise and such a large moat that they can thrive regardless of where in the economic cycle we are versus cyclicals, which, you know, will look the cheapest at the top and the most expensive. at the bottom, and you apply different rules for those.
12:19And the long-duration gross stocks tend to trade at a higher multiple because you have a longer, you have a more sustainable series of cash flows, right? So again, in the DCF model, you put in expected cash flows in the numerator, cost of capital in the denominator, and the terminal value is a very important component of that equation. So beyond the next five years, how much longevity is in that earning stream? And that's where, and we've seen this in the MAX 7, they have been leading for over 10 years. I mean, they haven't gone anywhere for the last year, but that's why they were such stars and maybe still are, because they had that sustainability of very stable, constant growth.
13:07That's one thing I think a lot of investors underestimate how much value of a company is in that terminal value, which is years out. And oftentimes it's very hard to predict what's going to happen in the future. So that's what makes investing so much fun, but so much challenging at some point. too. For sure. Let's move on to the Fed and interest rates. And I think to start, what's the Fed? Well, maybe let's start by explaining what the Fed model is. And then what is it telling you about stock valuations today? So the Fed model is an indicator that actually Alan Greenspan made famous back in the 80s, because that model perfectly nailed the 1987 crash.
13:54And the Fed model basically just, it's a comparison of the bond PE, which is the inverse of the yield. So if bonds are yielding 5%, their PE, if you will, is 20. So you're paying 20 times the future coupons, right? So when you compare the bond PE to the stock PE, The S &P 500, right, the S &P is trading at about 18, 19. The 10-year Treasury, its PE is around the same. Five percent is 20. And so when the safe asset, so the risk-free asset, which treasuries are still considered, not everyone would agree with that perhaps, but generally, when they are competitively repriced against risky assets, then when their yield goes up or their PE goes down, the theory is that the stock market needs to reprice itself to remain competitive because stocks are supposed to generate more return than bonds.
15:04And when bond yields were 1 % as they were in 2021. The Fed model doesn't work because stocks usually are 20 plus PE. And so the difference is so big that what happens in bonds doesn't really affect stocks too much. But when the yields are the same or the PEs are the same, the stock market needs to listen, which doesn't mean that the stock market goes down if bond yields go up. It just means its PE goes down. And then it's a matter of to what degree earnings are offsetting that PE decline. And so one thing I always stress to our investors is that we tend to be focused on price. Where's the S &P trading?
15:47Where's the Dow or the NASDAQ trading? But price is just the residual of earnings and valuation. And so earnings and valuation are the two moving parts. And valuations are driven by a number of things, but including interest rates. And so if the bond yield, which is now at 490, it was at 530 a few weeks ago, if that were to go to 6%, for instance, which is not a prediction, but if it were, you can look at the historical math and say, okay, that means the S &P needs to go to a 16 PE instead of a 19 PE. and that means an X percent drawdown in valuation. And then it's a question of our earnings growing 20%, 30%, and then you solve for price.
16:32And that's how I think about the Fed model. And just to reiterate 1987, what happened was bond yields were rising, the Fed was tightening, but the stock market was soaring in the first three parts of 87. And then so the stock market was completely ignoring the movements or the message from the bond market. And then, of course, then we had the crash in 87. And that wasn't all caused by rising bond yields, but it was definitely a disconnect where the rubber band had to snap. You had talked about a comparison in 1994 in terms of the stealth correction we were seeing. And I guess it got a little bit less stealth in the last couple of days.
17:16But what do you see in terms of parallels between what we're seeing now in 1994? 1994, to me, was very similar to 2022, actually. So 1994, Alan Greenspan, the maestro, was at the Fed. He, of course, the Fed was very opaque, was very non-transparent, unlike today. And it's interesting that Kevin Warsh is trying to bring the Fed back to that mode of operation. And I think, you know, Warsh maybe is going to be sort of the next Greenspan, or at least that would be a compliment if he can do that. But Greenspan raised rates out of the blue without any warning. He doubled the overnight rate from 3 % to 6%.
17:59It created one of the worst bond bear markets at the time. I mean, bonds went to like 9 % or 8.6%. It blew up a few institutions. Remember, Orange County in California. And the stock market, you know, a stock bull market will be stopped in its tracks if rates, if the cost of capital rises a lot. But the stock market never really went down a lot. It sat around for a year. It went down as much as 10 percent twice, which is really a rounding error in the grand scheme of things. And that's because earnings were growing very strongly. But PEs, again, are susceptible to rising rates, and the PE ratio fell.
18:47And so in a way, 2022 was a worse version of that. But rates, of course, rose. They rose very substantially from zero to over 5%. It was a tremendously bad bond bear market. And equity PEs fell by a third. And because earnings only grew 8 % that year, the S &P went down 28%. So that was a much more significant bear market. But they are similar in the sense that they were entirely caused by rising rates, despite strong earnings. And in that sense, 2022 and 94, to me, are similar. I mean, today, we are at risk of having an echo of 2022, right? because until a few weeks ago, rates were rising. The Fed has to raise rates because it did not.
19:43It took out some insurance rate cuts in 2025 because of fears that the AI story was going to eat the jobs. And that turned out to be premature, and now they have to take back those rate hikes, rate cuts, I should say. And at the same time, if long yields continue to rise or resume their rise, again, it puts pressure on the PE. And then it's a matter of to what degree earnings are offsetting that. So if earnings growth, which is at 30 % to 40%, depending on which metric you look at, if that stays very strong, let's say 20 % to 30%, and the PE goes from 18%, 19 % to 16%, you get a sideways market, just like 94%.
20:30If earnings growth is more than that, you could still have a rising market. If it's less, you could have a falling market. So I don't think if we end up repeating that pattern, it will be as negative as 2022. But to me, that is the bear case here. And it seems like that would be the big question here, because I think the current one has been more driven by growth, right? Rates going up, whereas rates going up there is more driven by inflation. And I guess what inflation does going forward and what growth does going forward will kind of determine how much of that parallel is true. Yeah, I don't think rates have risen as much because of growth, because they have risen all over the world, including places that have no growth like Germany and France and the UK.
21:12So I think it's inflation. I mean, inflation is running above 3 % and it's been above the Fed's target since 2021 or 2022. And so I think it's inflation and I think it's fiscal risk. I mean, we see that in France, of course. You know, the U.S. is not going to go bankrupt or anything like that. But I think investors are pricing in a higher term premium because the fiscal status of this country and much of the world is not really sustainable. And when real rates punch through that economy speed limit, which they were starting to do a few weeks ago, you know, investors take notice. So I think it's a combination of factors, growth being one of them.
21:57But a rising cost of capital can be forgiven, let me put it that way, if it's happening for the right reasons. But real rates were rising just as much as nominal rates. And the stock market, when it's priced at the same level, does need to pay attention to that. So I do think the bond market, as it always is, remains a very important clue to the future of the stock market here. How do you think about the future risks of inflation? I mean, you have some people who believe, you know, inflation staying where it is is kind of the risk. And that's not great because it's above the target. Then you have others who believe we might see a spike beyond this.
22:37Do you have any thoughts on that? I don't see a renewed spike so much, but we are very, very sticky at 3 plus percent. And it's interesting, Bloomberg just actually launched a trueflation type index where they track thousands and thousands of different indicators that feed into the CPI and their inflation rates running north of 4%. And so, you know, the stock market can do fine at 3 % or even 4%, but it just means a lower multiple, right? So earnings have to do more of the heavy lifting. And that's really the main message there, as well as the behavior of bonds relative to stocks, right? Like the 60-40 paradigm, and I know we're going to talk about this later.
23:32But, you know, that really hinges on the negative correlation between stocks and bonds. And that correlation flipped in 2022 when inflation went from below the Fed's target to above the Fed's target. And it remains well above the Fed's target. And that suggests that the correlation, even though right now short-term correlations have flipped negative because we have a growth scare, but my guess is that they will revert back to positive. And so those are the two main effects as far as I'm concerned. I'm just curious, do you have any inflation measures you pay more attention to? Because for someone like me who's outside of the economics world, there's just so many of them.
24:10You mentioned there's the real-time ones now, there's PCE, there's CPI. Do you have any ones you favor over others? Not really. I mean, the PCE is good. True inflation is interesting because it's a real-time daily indicator. But there are periods where it way under or over reports, if you will, compared to what we're seeing. So it's a black box. I don't know what goes into it. And so that makes me a little bit cautious to over rely on it. It'll be interesting to see what this Bloomberg indicator, you know, how that goes going forward. But the one conclusion I have is that, you know, over the long run, they all look very similar, like over the span of, you know, 10, 20 years.
24:55So it's really just the short-term observation. But, you know, the Fed has always looked at core inflation, core PCE, as opposed to headline. But I think that's a harder thing to justify because, you know, food and energy is why so many Americans are feeling, you know, that K-shaped recovery. And I think that's probably one of the big reasons why we had the outcome of the midterm elections. And, you know, so it's hard to ignore those two pieces that economists tend to strip from the CPI or the PCE. I want to put this on the screen because I hadn't seen it before, and I think it's really cool. Can you talk about what the investment clock is and what it tells you?
25:37Yeah, the investment clock just shows earnings growth on the vertical axis and financial conditions on the horizontal. So using the Goldman Sachs Financial Conditions Index, which is a kind of the Fed uses this a lot. It's a way to measure real time market conditions in terms of their possible impact on the real economy. Right. Because the Fed's dilemma always is if they look at real economic data, meaning the real economy like unemployment, inflation, they're they're always looking in the rearview mirror and they're setting forward looking policy. So that always leads to the potential of a policy error.
26:19So financial conditions are a real-time view in that. And so it's the stock market, it's credit spreads, short rates, long rates, the dollar. And so in this chart, that's on the horizontal. And so we've been in sort of the best quadrant, that 9 to 12 o 'clock, for some time, meaning earnings growth is accelerating and financial conditions are easy. So that's the best part to be in. And right now, we're sort of moving past midnight. As you can see, earnings growth is still great. We're still in a historic earnings boom. But, you know, it's the financial conditions are getting a little tighter. And when I say that, I mean short rates, long rates, the dollar's pretty strong, and credit spreads, at least on the high-yield side, are moving higher.
27:07So it's not a bad thing, but it's not as good as the 9 to 12 o 'clock quad. You mentioned the stock market is one of those financial conditions. Do you think one of the things we've talked about a lot in the podcast is this idea that, you know, people think the economy drives the stock market, but we're seeing a little more vice versa now due to the wealth effect and due to how much wealth is in stocks. Do you think the stock market is more important for the economy than it ever has been? Yes. I mean, the stock, I mean, they're, of course, they're very closely linked. And sort of this notion that, you know, stocks are owned by the very wealthy, which, of course, is true, but only by them, of course, is not true, because hopefully everyone has a 401k or a 403b or an IRA.
27:51and hopefully they're invested in equities because that is the best driver in terms of compounding returns. So there is clearly a wealth effect. Housing is another one where there is a wealth effect. And we saw that, of course, during the financial crisis in 2008, where people had monetized their home equity, home equity line of credit, that sort of thing. And then when the housing bust happened, you know, they went upside down and a lot of people got foreclosed on. And so the same applies to the stock market. People might be more removed from it because if it's in your 401k and you're not drawing on it, then that's a different story.
28:33But think about how many baby boomers we have in this country and people who are living on their retirement. And if they're invested in stocks and all of a sudden you're down, you know, 4 % in a day, you're going to notice. And that could drive consumer spending. And of course, the economy is 70 % consumer spending. So there is clearly a link between the two. As opposed to, for instance, like in Europe, where it's not that people don't own stocks in Europe, but I'm from Holland. I was just there two days ago visiting my parents. There people generally have pensions that are offered by the state.
29:13Think of Social Security, but a lot better. And those are invested more in a mixture of assets. And so there is not that as much of a direct link there as we have here in this country where people have to do it themselves. You alluded to this before, but I want to put up this chart of bond yields and stock and bond correlations because I think it's really important. And we just went through a very long period where people could count on bonds as their hedge for stocks. But as you know, that's over a much longer period. It's not as true as it was in that period. So how do you think in this new period with inflation above 3%, how should people be thinking about that correlation between stocks and bonds?
29:48So that is a critical component of a diversified portfolio is that behavior, right? So in 2021, when yields were a percent or half a percent, that was in retrospect, of course, these things are always hard to know in real time. But in retrospect, that was the worst time to own bonds because A, you locked in a negative real return because inflation obviously was higher than that. And there are times when you could be willing to pay a high price for bonds if they provide you with a cushion in case stocks go down. But that ended up also not happening because in 2022, bond yields went from 1 % to 5%, while the correlation went from steeply negative to steeply positive.
30:37So fast forward five years today, the good news is that bonds actually have value, right? The income is back into fixed income, as our bond portfolio managers like to say. And when yields were 5.3 % just a few weeks ago, the real yield was 2.9%. I mean, that's pretty generous. We haven't seen yields like that in over 20 years, but you're not getting the diversification. I mean, actually, the last few weeks we have, but I think that's a passing fad. But so, you know, there are times when it makes no sense to own them. There's times when it makes a lot of sense to own them because you're getting both the income and the diversification.
31:22Today, we're kind of in the middle where they are a viable asset with generous real yields. But when inflation is running, you know, at the rate that it is, even if it doesn't accelerate higher, it suggests to me that the correlation between bond returns and stock returns will remain positive. And that means that bonds may not be that poured in the storm when stocks correct. Now, again, that is exactly what's happening right now. They are being a port in the storm. So this can flip at any time. And it depends on whether we're dealing with a growth scare, like we're dealing with now, and like we dealt with a year and a half ago during the tariff tantrum, or whether it's a rate scare.
32:09And during rate scares, the bond side actually causes the problems on the equity side as opposed to being a port in the storm. So my answer is, and this is not investment advice, but I've been talking about the 60-20-20 for really the last four or five years saying, we want some bonds and we certainly want equities because they are the proven compounder over time. But I want other things in there that behave independently or are even anti-correlated, which is even better, from both stocks and bonds, not just stocks. So commodities is in there. Cash, actually, or short-term investments can be in there because when the Fed is on a tightening path and inflation is above average or above target, short-term rates are going to be not a bad place to hide, even though you can't really compound returns that way.
33:10And then you get into other asset classes like alternatives, you know, managed futures, equity long short or private markets, even gold, Bitcoin. There's a bunch of different sort of cats and dogs in there that that, you know, their correlations are always evolving. But generally that bucket, that last 20 is uncorrelated to the first 80. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast.
33:49Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. holiday drinks are now at mcdonald's like the new red bull frosted cranberry energizer it's red bull meets cranberry flavors topped with cold foam and sprinkles made to charge your holiday spirit now at mcdonald's how do you think about just since you mentioned gold like how do you think about gold as an inflation hedge because it doesn't seem to be that reliable in terms of going up when inflation is down it but it does seem to be a very good hedge against sort of the system bowling park type of thing.
34:30Will people become worried about that type of stuff? So gold is over a few thousand years. It's obviously very much a proven inflation hedge, but it goes through, it waxes and wanes through various super cycles. And in 2025, gold was the star player, right? It was up 32 % with no correlation to any other asset. But this year, that role has, that baton has been passed to the commodities, the general commodities complex, obviously driven by energy, but by other commodity indices as well, like copper. And gold got overbought last year. It was overbelieved. The fast money that was all in Bitcoin ETFs, they jumped ship and went to the gold ETFs.
35:23And gold just went up too much, and it's still sort of licking its wounds from that. And also, we had the Iran conflict where all of a sudden, gold as well as treasuries were seen as sources of liquidity, especially if you're a Gulf state and you can't sell your oil. And so I think gold is just going through a pause because it got overdone. But to me, it's a play on global liquidity growth. And in an era of what I call fiscal dominance, where fiscal policy, not just in the U.S., but around the world, is driving the bus and monetary policy is sort of playing along to some degree, gold is still a very viable asset.
36:09And for us in the States, gold is a little bit of a sideshow. It's sort of like, OK, if it's interesting, you can play, but you don't have to. It's not in your benchmark. But, you know, in Asia, it's a totally different story. I was there for three weeks over the summer and every central bank and sovereign wealth fund that I met with across Asia Pacific, that was one of their three questions, you know, top three questions, because they don't have the luxury of being in a reserve currency. So for them, gold is a necessity, not a luxury. You mentioned fiscal dominance, and that plays into this next chart I wanted to put up.
36:44You had a great chart of real yields versus fiscal risk. What do you think people could take from this? So real yields have been rising. They went from, again, five years ago during COVID or the aftermath of COVID when the Fed overstayed its welcome, if you will, by being too easy in the midst of a massive fiscal expansion. real yields were minus two and a half or so. Today, they're plus two and a half. So that's a massive swing. And when you have countries and regions that have a lot of debt and that have deficits as far as the eye can see, and we can't kid ourselves that deficits all of a sudden are going to stop being an issue just because of the midterms, because deficits and debt, no matter what the rhetoric is in Washington, that is not a partisan issue.
37:39There's no divide there. So that's going to be our reality for a long time. And the rule is, and there was a book on this by Reinhard and Rogoff some years ago, that when your debt threshold goes above a certain percent, I think it's 90 percent. And when rates, especially real rates, go above the sustained, and let's say speed limit of the economy. So let's say potential real GDP, that long-term growth rate, which is around 2%, 2.5%. When one starts going above the other, you run into issues. And think of it this way, right? If you start a business, you take out a bank loan at whatever, 8%, your business growing at 20, that's great.
38:26That was money well borrowed. But if you're growing at 4%, you're going to be underwater. And that's the same idea with real rates versus the speed limit of the economy. So I never look at rates in isolation. Four is good, five is bad. You have to compare it to something, just like you compare debt to GDP, right? That's debt to GDP. 40 trillion can be a lot. It can be a little, depending on the denominator. And so the Fed model is the bond yield versus the equity yield. This particular indicator is the real yield versus the run rate in the economy. And if it goes too far above, the debt becomes unsustainable.
39:08And that, I think, is part of the message of the rise in rates that we saw recently. I want to shift to the Fed. No one asked about what they're doing now, but first I want to talk more high level under Warsh. It's interesting, like throughout my career, I feel like the vast majority of Fed meetings have been 90 % plus odds they were going to do one thing or the other. And I feel like we've had a couple this year that were maybe like 60-40 one way or the other. So this removing forward guidance team seems to be adding at least some uncertainty to the market. How are you thinking about that? Yeah, and I think that's by design.
39:38I mean, Warsh wants, so I think a lot of what he wants to do, I think is commendable. And remember that the transparency of the Fed, including the dot plot and the forward guidance and all this, is solely a byproduct of the financial crisis and the period that followed it where we had deflationary pressures or risks rather than inflationary ones. And so Ben Bernanke, during the financial crisis or following the financial crisis, when he lowered rates to zero and they couldn't go any further, he had to resort to essentially jawboning the market. And that's, I think, why the dot plot came about, that was in 2012, is to show the market, look, rates are not going to go up.
40:27So don't worry, like, you know, you don't have to worry about this. But that was never an issue when you had a normal interest rate environment. So we're back to the old normal of inflation at three plus percent, bond yields trading at a positive real yield. There's no more financial repression. So I think it's very commendable to say that these tools that we had, because we were at the zero lower bound and couldn't go any lower, are not applicable anymore. And I think there's a lot there's a lot to be said for that. The consequence, though, is that when you take away certainty from investors, not that there's ever any certainty because the Fed doesn't know anymore what it's going to do a year from now than any of us.
41:19But when you take away some certainty from investors, they will want a higher risk premium, which in the bond market is called the term premium. And so I think part of the rise in yields that we've seen until just a few weeks ago was because of growth, because of inflation, because of fiscal risk, as we discussed, but also because the Fed wants to become, or at least Kevin Warsh wants to become less transparent. And less transparency means a higher risk premium. And maybe that's perfectly fine with him. Maybe that's what he wants. But it's at odds with what the Treasury wants, which is lower yields.
41:57So that is an interesting dynamic that's worth observing going forward. How about the current situation with the Fed? I mean, we've got inflation, as we talked about before. Inflation is above target. They hiked once. Now they pause. They seem to be seeing what the data is going to tell them going forward. What do you think about the position they're in right now? So I don't think the Fed is in a tightening. I don't think of it as a tightening cycle where they're going to keep on raising rates until inflation is below two again or at two. I think of it more as, as I said earlier, the Fed cut rates in 2024.
42:33Those were warranted because inflation was returning closer to normal. It went from 9 % to, let's say, 2.5%, 3%. And so a very aggressively tight policy, which they had at 5.38, was no longer needed. And so they could lower rates, which they did by 100 basis points. and that was fine. But then last year, they cut rates three more times. One, because inflation was moving closer to target. This is before the Iran conflict. And also because there were a lot of fears with the weak job market that AI was destroying jobs or was going to destroy jobs. And so the Fed took out some insurance cuts. And it turns out that those insurance cuts were not needed.
43:19A, inflation has come back up because of the Iran conflict in part, And B, and we saw this in today's unemployment numbers or employment numbers, the job market is just fine. And so I think of the current cycle as just they need to undo those insurance cuts. And so they've done one. The market was looking for two or three more as of yesterday. They're looking for maybe one or two more. And that's the way I see it. And there's no urgency, but the Fed does need to do it. And I suspect that in December, they probably will. They may not explicitly state this, but you think they'll be comfortable with a little bit higher inflation long term, like in terms of maybe something that starts with two, but not 2 percent?
44:03Do you think they're going to be OK with that versus really trying to force this down to two? I think so. And they always have to weigh the costs and benefits. And even, you know, before COVID, of course, they had this white paper that was discussed at Jackson Hole saying, well, you know, maybe two and a half is the new two. It was AIT, average inflation targeting. And so I think a two-handle is probably going to be good enough. And they have to, of course, weigh how much they would need to be restrictive in order to get that last mile from two and a half to two. And it may not be worth the cost.
44:46Mortgage rates are already 7%. And we already have a huge affordability issue, which, of course, they would be trying to address. But if you address it through higher rates, that can cause damage as well. So I think if they can get it back to two and a half, they'll probably call that a win. But we're in the mid threes, and that is too high for sure. Just one more for me before I hand it back to Justin. You mentioned 1994 before, and we're going to talk about 1999 in a second. but I first wanted to ask you about analogs in general. You use analogs a lot in your work, but there's a right way and a wrong way to use analogs.
45:24And I'm wondering if you could talk about what that is. Like what value do you think we can get from analogs and what should we avoid using? Yeah, so I always put out the caveat that when I show an analog and I show it to my colleagues here who run the funds, that it is for entertainment purposes only because analogs do eventually fall apart. But that doesn't mean that we can't learn from it because, you know, market behavior is a subset of human behavior and humans tend to repeat their behavior. And that's why we get bubbles once in a generation. And there is a lot of signal in the price. And so by looking at how the price action is similar or dissimilar.
46:10And again, in 2022, I looked at 1994. I looked at actually in 2021, I looked at the 1940s, the financial repression during World War II. And, you know, the markets don't behave the same way, but the circumstances, there were parts of the circumstances that were similar. And just like today, you know, we look at the Internet boom turned to bubble. And, you know, that started in 1995 when Netscape went public. and then it took a pause in 1998 during LTCM, and then it went vertical after that 20 % drawdown and the Fed was cutting rates, and then we had that blow-off bubble phase. There are a lot of similarities to 2022 against 94, as we talked about, and then 1998 to the tariff tantrum.
47:01That was also a very quick 21 % hit, followed by a melt-up, and we're kind of in the throes of that melt up now. But you know it's going to eventually break apart, but that doesn't mean that we can't study the slope of the trajectory and how things are different and similar. And of course, the valuation side is totally different between now and 1999, because back then the market was believing the earning story and it never materialized. And the S &P technology sector was trading at a 70 PE. Today, the earnings are so booming that the PE for the tech sector is like 18 or 19. And so in that sense, it's totally different.
47:47But then you look at core weave of CDS spreads versus telecom spreads back then, because they were the picks and shovels back then, right? Building all the fiber optic networks. And there are similarities there. So it's never going to be a thing where I'm just going to blindly follow this roadmap, but I see it as a potential roadmap. And just to poke the question of what is similar, what is not, and just start the conversation in that way. Yeah, I know when you put that chart out on a few of our podcasts, people were referencing how closely the performance was between the two periods. But to your point, the valuations are so starkly different that people kind of miss that point, maybe.
48:33Yeah, but, you know, from that 98 low, which to me was the launch point of the melt-up phase, the S &P has gone up by exactly the same amount over the exact same amount of time as it did from 1998 to March of 2000. So it is a little scary how closely the market can rhyme, even if it doesn't repeat. But again, it's a conversation starter. And even if people say, you know, this is stupid, say, okay, well, tell me why it's stupid. And then we can have a conversation. You mentioned the MAG-7 at the outset and how maybe this lower spending in CapEx might be actually a positive for some of these, you know, largest tech companies out there.
49:18but you do you also have a chart that shows just how much i guess their profiles have changed going from you know free cash flowing companies returning you know earnings shareholders versus spending on capex can you just talk about how sort of investors should be thinking about that that shift in their makeup yeah so to me this is a very powerful shift um and again it's it's It refers to what I call the buyback era, right? So from the mid-2000s until now, these large companies, these mega cap growers produced a lot of free cash flow. And they didn't really have any place to put it. So they returned it to shareholders via share buybacks on top of dividends.
50:06And, you know, there were times when you had very low interest rates back in, you know, 2020, 2019, 18, where there was even debt to equity arbitrage, right? They would borrow money in the corporate bond market at minuscule yields and then use that to buy back shares. So it's kind of a financial engineering. And for the MAG-7, that was a very powerful story because they had tremendous earnings growth, free cash flow growth, and they were returning, let's say, 90 % of those earnings to shareholders. So they almost became like bonds in a way. They were cash cows. And if you're investing in them and you know that you're getting those excess earnings back as buybacks, it creates a very continuous stream in terms of the discounted cash flow model.
50:59Again, long-duration growth stocks. The CapEx boom changed that because the payout ratio, so dividends plus buybacks as a percent of earnings for the MAC7, is down to the 20s from the 90s. And so I think one silver lining, as you mentioned, that if there is a slowdown in CapEx, these big incumbents who already have the data centers and who don't have to leverage their balance sheet to build more could actually emerge as winners again because they haven't gone anywhere for over a year. So they've been sort of very sideways. And so and the fact that they are almost 40 percent of the market, if they are the net winners of an AI bust, I mean, I don't want to sound too exotic there and I'm not calling it a bust.
51:52But if they end up being the relative winners, it actually could keep the market up because they're bigger than most of the semiconductor names other than NVIDIA, of course. Yeah, it kind of relates to it. But, you know, a lot of investors over the last few years were concerned about the level of concentration in the market. Like when you look at the S &P 500, how much of the largest stocks make up the index? Is there anything that you would, that history kind of tells us when we have that type of concentration that you would? Yeah. So for me, over the last few years, the two main risks were not a recession, but concentration risk and interest rate risk.
52:33So we talked about the Fed model, interest rate risk, and that continues to be a risk, I think, especially if yields end up going back up again. But concentration risk is the other one. And the market is very concentrated, right? So the S &P is up 120 % since the cyclical bull market began in October of 2022. But only about 30 % of the stocks in the S &P outperformed the index on a year-over-year basis. And that's very, very low. and you have to go back to the late 90s, which we discussed earlier, as well as the early 70s, which was the original nifty 50 era to get a market that concentrated. And, you know, it's just math, right?
53:19If 10 stocks are 40 % of the market and the top 50 stocks are 60 % of the market, if those stocks go down, the index is going to go down. And if you're a passive investor via an ETF or an index fund, you could be in a situation where most of the stocks are in uptrends, but you're not going to see it. And actually, and we see that in a way, we see that today. Like yesterday, of course, was a very bad day in the market. But the day before yesterday, as of that day, 72 % of stocks in the S &P were above their 200-day moving average, which means they're in long-term uptrends. But the S &P itself hadn't gone anywhere since early June.
54:07And that's the weight of the mega caps either pushing the market down or preventing it from going up. And so concentration risk is a thing. This is why, you know, having at least some assets actively invested makes sense. And these days, since about the last two years, painting the market with a broader brush in terms of global allocation is also a very good idea to consider because that payout dynamic I mentioned for the MAG-7, where the payout ratio went from 90 % to 28%, we've seen the opposite of that in non-U.S. developed markets. So Europe and Japan, where the payout ratio is now above 70%.
54:56And so the good news is the pond has a lot of fish and it's a big pond. And so there are ways to mitigate concentration risk beyond the S &P 500. One of the other charts that you had was the secular analogs and the CAPE model. And one of the things that I don't think a lot of investors really can appreciate or understand is how strong the returns have been since the financial crisis. when you look at something like the S &P 500. But when you kind of look at those returns in the context of the CAPE model, and I guess history, what is this chart sort of indicating? To me, the message is that, you know, we've all been very fortunate as investors that we've been over-harvesting beta, right?
55:42So beta is the market return. Alpha is the excess return from asset allocation or security selection. and by my count, the secular bull market, which is a prolonged super cycle, usually spanning about 15, 20 years. To me, that started in 2009, and we have been over-earning beta since that time. And just over the last 10 years, it's been around 16 % nominal, about 11%, 12 % real. That's well in excess of the average return, which is about 10%, 11 % nominal, 6%, 7 % real. And the CAPE model, which holds that the prevailing long-term PE tends to have an inverse forward correlation to the next long period of returns, whether it's 10 years or five is also at levels where it indicates that the next five, 10 years are not necessarily going to be down years, but there's going to be less beta going forward than we've experienced.
56:53And if you overlay that also with previous secular bull markets, such as the 80s and 90s and the 50s and 60s, it suggests, again, the same thing. And again, it's not necessarily a bad story, but it's an expectation story because you can't expect that if the average return historically over 150 years is 10%, and for the last 15 years we've been earning 15%, 16%, 17%, mathematically, unless something is permanently changing, you can't expect the next 10 years to also be at that level. It's got to be below it. And so my sense is that, you know, there are two components to a total return. There's the there's the price component and the income component.
57:40And we've been over earning the price component, meaning capital appreciation, capital gains and under earning the income side dividends and buybacks. And so that's why I'm focused for at least from a strategic point of view on sectors and countries and styles that emphasize the income part. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
58:19Get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Now at McDonald's, the new frosted cranberry splash with Sprite. Because there's no better time of year for friends, family, Sprite, cold foam, and sprinkles. Now at McDonald's. Yeah. And so I think when you were talking about this 60-40 or 60-20-20, I think in the 60 part, you've been advocating for strategically kind of going more global on the equity exposure, correct? Correct. Yeah. Okay. This has been a fantastic discussion. Thank you so much for joining us.
59:04We just have one sort of final closing question for you. And you joined Fidelity in 1995, so you've had a front row seat to the changes in the markets and also the changes in the investment industry, how much Fidelity has grown and expanded into different areas. But when you think back and look back over your experience in the markets, what's the biggest thing that you think you've learned about how investors sort of behave in the market? And I guess, what's the one lesson you would teach your average investor?
59:39When in doubt, zoom out, I guess, would be, You know, where we live in a world where there's so much data and so much noise and finding the signal to noise ratio is can be very challenging, especially with social media these days and, you know, 24 seven coverage. But, you know, I've I've been in this business for four decades. I ran a fund for a while many years ago. And the shorter term my focus has been, the worse the outcome has been. And so, you know, the markets are always going to have corrections. We're in one right now. And the question is, do you want to be a liquidity taker or a liquidity provider, right?
1:00:25Do you want to succumb to the selling and then be one of those people that sells potentially at the bottom? Or do you want to just take a step back, rebalance, you know, take stock of your portfolio, no pun intended, rebalance if needed, and be the provider of liquidity when other people are panicking? It's easier said than done because our fight and flight, you know, impulses take over. And we want to just, you know, our loss aversion impulse is so large that we often want to sell first and ask questions later. But, you know, having a financial person to speak to before you hit that sell button, I think is a very valuable resource because sometimes you need someone to talk sense to you when there's a lot of scary stuff going on.
1:01:18Excellent. Thank you very much, Yuri. We really appreciate it. Thank you very much. Thanks for your time. Thank you for tuning into this episode. If you found this discussion interesting and valuable, please subscribe on your favorite audio platform or on YouTube. You can also follow all the podcasts in the XS Returns Network at XSReturnsPod.com. If you have any feedback or questions, you can contact us at XSReturnsPod at gmail.com. No information on this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed in the podcast may be holdings of the firms of the hosts or... Holiday drinks are now at McDonald's.
1:01:52Like the new Red Bull Frosted Cranberry Energizer, It's Red Bull meets cranberry flavors topped with cold foam and sprinkles made to charge your holiday spirit. Now at McDonald's. Sam's Club is the club for every holiday club. Guess who's joining the club this season? Walmart Plus. Yep, Sam's Club Plus membership now comes with Walmart Plus at no extra cost. Two memberships, one great price. Just$120 a year can save you time and over$700. Want to get in on the membership duo of the century? Visit samsclub.com. Come join us. Sam's Club. Annual plan only. Auto renews. TNC apply. Estimate based on average combined.
1:02:28Walmart Plus and Sam's Club Plus savings among members of both for one plus year versus non-member or club member pricing slash fees. Excludes membership fees. See Walmart Plus terms and Sam's Club terms for more info.
Jurrien Timmer of Fidelity explains how he reads a stock market correction by looking at what has changed in earnings, interest rates and the price investors will pay for future growth. A selloff driven by higher rates can look much like one driven by fears of slower growth on a stock chart. The difference matters when you’re counting on bonds to cushion the decline.
Jurrien joins Justin Carbonneau and Jack Forehand to put the AI investment boom in that historical context. The companies building data centers once had enough cash left over to buy back large amounts of their own stock. Now much of that cash goes back into the business. He explains why a slower buildout could help some of the biggest spenders, and how a semiconductor stock can look cheap just as its earnings are peaking.
They also look beneath the S&P 500, where a handful of large companies can pull the index lower even as most stocks remain in uptrends. Jurrien discusses what higher bond yields offer a long-term investor, why he considers gold and other diversifiers alongside stocks and bonds, and how rebalancing can turn a market decline into an opportunity to buy when others need to sell.
Topics covered:
- What CoreWeave’s bonds signaled about the cost of financing AI infrastructure
- Why semiconductor earnings and price-to-earnings ratios can move in opposite directions
- How Treasury yields affect the price investors will pay for stocks
- What the 1994 correction reveals about strong earnings in a rising-rate environment
- How Jurrien Timmer’s investment clock pairs earnings growth with financial conditions
- Why bonds can provide income even when their value as a hedge changes
- How gold, commodities and other diversifiers fit into a 60/20/20 portfolio
- How the shift from buybacks to capital spending changes the economics of owning the Magnificent Seven
- What market breadth and long-term valuations suggest about opportunities beyond the largest U.S. stocks
Chapters:
00:00 The AI buildout meets the limits of financing
07:44 Semiconductor cycles and peak earnings
11:57 The Fed model and the competition between stocks and bonds
19:16 Growth scares, rate scares and inflation risk
24:01 The investment clock and the stock market’s influence on growth
29:00 Bond income and the case for a 60/20/20 portfolio
34:27 Real yields, fiscal risk and Fed policy
42:57 What comparisons with 1994 and 1999 can tell us
47:23 From share buybacks to AI capital spending
55:58 Rebalancing when other investors are selling
Learn more about the Excess Returns podcast network:
https://excessreturns.co
No information discussed in this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed may be held by the hosts and guests, their firms or their clients.



