1. Podcasts
  2. Excess Returns
  3. Last Call | Breaking Down the Post Election Decline
Excess Returns

8 Nov 2026 · 1h 16m · 24 chapters

Episode artwork

Last Call | Breaking Down the Post Election Decline

In short

Post-election market reversal and what it means for AI stocks, volatility, and the broader economy (midterms, AI/data-center spending, consumer wealth effects, and oil/inflation dynamics).

Guests (backgrounds)

  • Brent Kachuba: options/volatility strategist focused on dealer flows and implied vs realized volatility.
  • Ben Hunt: Epsilon Theory / Panoptica narrative analyst tracking political-economy “common knowledge” shifts.
  • Ahan Menon: macro/systematic investor (framework-based) analyzing elections’ materiality and AI’s economic transmission.
  • Eric Pakman: tracks energy/oil tanker markets to infer inflation pressure from crude price moves.

Key claims

  • The election triggered a “head fake”: volatility premium collapsed immediately after results, then expanded violently the next day, driven by options/negative gamma dynamics and forced liquidations.
  • AI is becoming politically “auto-tuned” along red/blue lines, creating narrative risk for markets.
  • Elections matter little unless fiscal policy stance changes; AI affects the economy mainly indirectly via the consumer wealth effect.
  • Crude price drops can mask inflation pressure (via shipping/transport channels).

Notable examples

  • CoreWeave/Nebius/Iron (weak “neocloud” names) failed to bounce with the rally; correlation across equities spiked.
  • VIX/VXN surged (VIX gap higher from ~16 to >28); put trading hit record levels; levered ETF selling cited (~$52B).
  • SpaceX IPO (mid-June) used as a parallel to upcoming Anthropic IPO timing.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:00

Market Reaction Post-Midterms

Analyzing the market's rally after the midterms and its subsequent decline.

“Stocks rallied the day after the midterms, then sold off sharply the next day.”
2:25

Market Dynamics and AI Stocks

Discussion on how AI stocks and political changes impact the market.

“I mean, we got some more excitement than we've had in a while, man.”
4:26

Investor Sentiment and Strategy

Exploring investor strategies and sentiments amidst market volatility.

“But before we start, I mean, I think it's just you and I, like how are we as advisors thinking about this?”
6:24

Volatility and Market Trends

Understanding how volatility affects market predictions and investor behavior.

“And so you have to think about it with understanding that backdrop as you analyze how the market's reacting to what's going on.”
14:01

Market Reaction to Democratic Sweep

Learn how the market reacted to the recent election results and its implications for AI stocks.

“moving up and, you know, AI was in related names.”
15:01

Indicators of Market Health

Discover the signals indicating the health of the tech market post-elections.

“Now, this was weird because Wednesday, the day after the elections, vol contracted so sharply when all the news was already out, right?”
17:03

Volatility and Market Dynamics

Explore the relationship between volatility, equity rotations, and market sentiment.

“If you can't, if you can't generate a bounce on that stuff that is just the poorest of quality, again, then that that's a very bad signal for, you know, risk in the market overall.”
19:24

Negative Gamma Environment and Its Impact

Understand the implications of a negative gamma environment on market movements.

“So maybe you make this argument that the volatility contraction around elections, just because the event passed, did indeed allow for the market to have this real pause.”
22:21

Risk Factors Ahead of Earnings and Events

Examine the risks associated with upcoming earnings and market events.

“particularly get into 7 ,300 or 7 ,200, which keeps fuel for a downside market move in place.”
24:24

Market Sentiment and Liquidation Dynamics

Analyze the current market sentiment and the dynamics of fund liquidations.

“meaning that they have a lot of downside hedging to do if markets start to break.”
Show all 24 chapters
28:00

The Impact of Upcoming IPOs on Market Dynamics

Explore the potential effects of major IPOs on market movements and investor behavior.

“Jack, do you know what happened right here, right around mid-June?”
30:28

Market Reactions Post-Election

Understand the implications of the recent election results on market dynamics.

“I know you're very, very busy with all this volatility.”
41:36

Analyzing Economic Impact with Ahan Banan

Dive into a systematic analysis of how elections and AI affect the economy.

“Make sure you check out Ben's work, Persean, Epsilon Theory, Panoptica, all the places.”
42:00

Impact of Elections on Markets

Exploration of how elections influence economic frameworks and market dynamics.

“So I wanted to go through in 10 minutes and really figure out what does this actually mean for the economy?”
47:19

AI Influence on Economic Growth

Discussion on the significant role of AI and capital expenditure in the economy.

“And I think it's important to keep in mind that that effect has built up over the course of many, many cycles.”
51:00

Inflation Dynamics and Oil Markets

Analysis of how data centers and oil prices affect inflation.

“Many people have argued building all these data centers is boosting inflation.”
53:42

PPI and Future Inflation Trends

Insight into Producer Price Index and projected inflation trends through data visualization.

“Zooming back from the AI trade, two of the underlying inputs that are not going away, even if we're not spending as much time talking about them right now, are inflation and the oil markets.”
56:04

Understanding PPI and Inflation Dynamics

Explore how PPI influences inflation and the implications for investors.

“And so what this is, is what I call the PTI scuba diver.”
1:03:00

Impact of Energy Markets on Inflation

Discuss the relationship between energy prices and inflation, focusing on oil transport and market dynamics.

“just to help understand what's going on in these headline numbers.”
1:10:00

The Implications of Oil Market Mechanisms

Learn about the risks associated with current oil market strategies and their potential impacts.

“Normally, we just say pay us for it, and then we can go back and buy back this crude later.”
1:11:20

Data Centers and Political Change

Explore how recent political shifts affect the construction and policies surrounding data centers.

“So as we wrap up, Matt, I want to talk about the whole thing with, I mean, data centers in general, where we're going with it, how much does it matter?”
1:12:28

State-Level Data Center Policies Post-Midterms

Understand the impact of midterm elections on data center policies and economic growth.

“conversation post midterm election than we did before the midterm election.”
1:15:40

The Role of Compromise in Politics

Discuss the necessity of compromise in political decisions and its implications on community projects.

“And like the way she's talking, she's talking about, like, I would agree with everything she's saying in terms of like the water usage and in terms of like, it's got to benefit the community around it.”
1:17:30

Reflections on the Political Landscape

Reflect on the emotional aspects and public sentiments surrounding recent elections and campaigns.

“It is just not a normal Philly sports experience to go to something where you're outranked.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Excess Returns, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Life is all about making decisions. Sometimes you make questionable ones, like buying a new TV that's too big for the wall because the electronics store employee was a little too good at their job. Then sometimes you make great ones, like protecting your home and auto with Progressive. You get customized coverage options so you can be sure you have the right coverage. Get your quote today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers not available in all states. The holidays are coming, but the Lincoln Wishlist Sales Event is already here. And with exceptional offers on select Lincoln vehicles, you might just cross the perfect gift off your own list.

0:43You know, the kind that doesn't need wrapping. Consider this a little reminder to be good to yourself this time of year. Visit your local Lincoln dealer or go to lincoln.com to learn more.

1:00Stocks rallied the day after the midterms, then sold off sharply the next day. In this episode of Last Call, we look at that reversal and what comes next from four different angles. Brent Kachuba explains why weakness in AI stocks gave him an early clue that the rally could fade. Ben Hunt looks at how the election changed perceptions of President Trump's power and what that could mean for the AI build-out. Ahan Menon explains how stock gains have supported consumer spending and what happens if those gains fade. And Eric Pakman follows the oil tankers to show why a drop in crude prices can hide inflation pressure.

1:27We have included this episode on the Excess Returns feed. But you can subscribe to Last Call on all major podcast platforms using the links in this episode description. Thank you for listening. We hope you enjoy the show. That was just kind of an incredible head fake there. Market commentators and all say, oh, this is going to be a market clearing event. It's a clearing event, but not in the way they missed. We generally come to the conclusion, unless there's a very material change in fiscal policy stance, elections don't really matter that much. Tinker rates are up to like$1.2,$1.3 million a day, when normally they're like$20 ,000 to$30 ,000 a day.

2:00Thanksgiving's right here. You have this giant rally that just unwinds this 9 % drawdown in the S &P. We're at the same exact point right now. And so what you need to be looking for are the narratives that emerge.

2:20Welcome to Last Call on Excess Returns. This is our monthly market recap where we talk to some of our favorite people and take a look forward into the next month. Joined as always by Jack Forehand. How we doing, Jack? Good. How are you? Excited. I mean, we got some more excitement than we've had in a while, man. We've got way more excitement. I mean, this has been, we've got crazy markets. We had the midterms. We had all this stuff that I feel like we've been talking about candidly for like a year. All seemed like it culminated in the last week of October into November. Yeah. And it's interesting because you talk to people in the podcast and they're like, here's how I think this might play out.

2:54And then like just the snap of your finger, you see it start playing out that way. It's crazy. Especially when it comes down to here are the things we'll be watching for on policy decisions with the midterms. Here's the stats on how markets do before and after midterms. Here's I keep going back in my mind. Kevin Muir pointing out however many months ago, hey, vol is underpriced going into midterms. There is a chance they're going to have to swing it in the other direction as volatility comes back onto the tape. And geez, look what happened on Wednesday and Thursday around this event. It's a lot of talk about what was expected.

3:28Now we had that fulcrum event. Now we're on the other side. And we usually use this to recap the previous month. We're going to throw that out the window this time because on November 3rd, after the previous month, we had something that changed things so much that we have to talk about that. So obviously our center, our topic today is going to be the election AI stocks. Obviously we have a big sell-off in the NASDAQ. We're going to talk about all that. And what we're going to try to do differently than what a lot of people are doing is we're going to try to look at it through a bunch of different lenses like we do every single time.

3:53And Brent Kachuba is probably our most important person to talk to you today. Because if you think about what happened here, the day after the election, we got a rally. Nobody expected a rally. Everybody's like this, you know, obviously Democrats way outperform what you think. People will typically think that's bad for the stock market, especially as we as AI data centers right now. The market rallied and then the next day, the bottom fell. And it's hard to argue that people were saying like, here's the value of discounted cash flows into the future on the first day and then change it in the second day.

4:19and went up one day and down dramatically the next day. And so a lot of this is the flows behind the scenes. And so we're going to talk to Brent about that when we get into it. But before we start, I mean, I think it's just you and I, like how are we as advisors thinking about this? Obviously the AI trade has held up the whole market. It's been a huge part of what we're doing. I think we're very optimistic about AI for the future, but also there's been a lot of debt has been taken on and we're in a changed political landscape. We're in a very changed political landscape now. And I think we'll come back to this by the end just to weigh in on some of these things, but the key things in conversations with clients are, right now it still looks like slower growth, but not necessarily no growth.

4:58We haven't flipped that role yet, where we go corporate earnings are all of a sudden going negative and or GDP is going negative and or some other bad shock is happening. We've got liquidity pinches, we've got volatility going nuts, and some trading that's making people seasick. If your longer-term plan isn't obsessing over these short-term moves just like a few weeks ago or last month with like munis when you had munis down for four and a half percent in a month's time like you have opportunities to rebalance and do little things in the face of this volatility if you have a plan to make up for it but certainly right now it's it doesn't feel like we're in full batten down the hatches run for the panics mode it's just stick to your plan stick to your goals but you gotta have something emotionally to get through this because if you do so much look at a television or your smartphone screen or log into your even your email it is scary out there right now yeah it's hard but you have to always separate the economic reality of what's going on with the market reality of what's going on potentially the change in the economic reality of ai might not have been as massive as people think but it certainly has changed and you have to think about like how does data center deployment affect the actual impact, actually impact AI and how it diffuses throughout the economy.

6:15Like these are very complicated things to think about, but those are two separate things. Like what's going on economically with AI right now and what's going on with the stocks. And we had a lot of expectations built into AI stocks. And so you have to think about it with understanding that backdrop as you analyze how the market's reacting to what's going on. Yeah. The reaction function, as we talk about all the time, these are about changes in the rate of change itself. So directionally, you still want to know what direction we're pointed in. I think we can all look at where we basically the direction of up, down or sideways.

6:46Do you think things are pointed in? And then where are we moving from and to? So the status we were just in to the status we're currently in and understanding it's those rate of change that creates all this volatility. And you have to figure out where you think this is going over the medium to longer term to stay aligned. Let's go ahead and get into Brett because he's probably got the most important segment for us to talk about this time. As I mentioned before, crazy stuff going on behind the scenes of the stock market. And it's hard to argue option dealer flows didn't play a role in that. So here's my conversation with Brent talking about this whole thing.

7:17Brent, welcome to Last Call. Thanks so much, Jack. It's wild times out there, so it's fun to be talking to you. It is wild times. And you were the person I wanted to talk to today because we're going to see if Jack's masterclass from Brent over the years has worked. Because I think we could fairly say that what's going on in the flows in the markets right now is probably driving a lot of those. that probably rallying the day after the election and then plummeting the day after that is probably not a fundamentally driven thing. Yeah, that was just kind of an incredible head fake there. And what was interesting to me about that is you think about the idea of volatility as an asset class.

7:51And what that basically means is that, you know, the options values going up and down and volatility, implied volatility going up and down, you know, is a way to trade and generate, you know, alpha. Right. And so there's a lot of strategies dedicated on that. And we had a pretty elevated volatility market or markets in implied vol were pretty elevated. The spreads were pretty wide. And I mean, the spread between implied vol and realized vol was wide. And so immediately after the election, you know, that collapsed, right? When we got that rally on Wednesday, that volatility premium really collapsed.

8:29And to me, that looked like what was getting monetized. Now, I'm not sitting here saying I predicted that we would roll over so incredibly violently the next day. But normally, after you have an event pass like elections, volatility contracts. That's just the natural way that it works. And that really seemed to be what happened. I mean, you could see it across all these single stock names and across everything else. And it just looked like this moment where it's like, OK, they monetized the volatility premium. And then all of a sudden, the air just got sucked out of the room, you know, later on that day and into yesterday.

9:01And then what we saw is a giant volatility expansion, you know, one of the biggest VIX moves ever. And, you know, that volatility is so bid now. And a lot of the dynamics that were in place going into the election, you know, those are those are really unwinding and it's creating a lot of turbulence out there. So getting back to what I've learned from you, I want to think about this through the lens of what we've talked about before with elections and events. And so what we know typically is people hedge aggressively into these events. Most of the time when the event passes, that comes out, you know, the air comes out of the whole thing.

9:34It's not as bad as people think. And then another thing I've learned though, over the years is sometimes that initial reaction is not necessarily the way people feel about the event because the options flows are driving that initial reaction. And so sometimes that can continue, but sometimes it can reverse. And so let's go from the beginning. Like, how much were people hedging coming into the election first? If you look at what the volatility premium is into the election, you had to look up the exact number here. But let's say it was like five or six vol points is what I'll say. So what I'm quoting that is if you look at the VIX and you look at one month realized volatility in the S &P and you look at that spread, it was probably five points, roughly six points maybe into the election period.

10:17and that number contracted down to about four points. So one or two vol points came out after the election. Now, it depends on what tenor you look at, like wood expiration, but that's roughly what I saw. And then yesterday, that number expanded to 11, right? So things really got squirrely. At one point, it was even 15, so that volatility premium really widened out. So historically, if you look at the spread there that I just quoted, it's about three vol points, right? The difference between the VIX and one-month S &P realized volatility is about three points to four points. So that's what's typical.

10:50And how does that work? Well, your best guess for what's going to happen tomorrow, the next day, or the next week is what has happened over the previous one week or one day, right? So realized or historical volatility is your best guess for what's going to happen going forward. So if you think about the VIX as a gauge for how much the S &P is going to move, VIX is a forward interpretation of that. So if you look at the last month and say, okay, the S &P is moving at a 10 realized vol, or annualized volatility of 10%. Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident.

11:24The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates Limited Availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions. The holidays are coming, but the Lincoln Wishlist Sales Event is already here. And with exceptional offers on select Lincoln vehicles, you might just cross the perfect gift off your own list.

12:02You know, the kind that doesn't need wrapping. Consider this a little reminder to be good to yourself this time of year. Visit your local Lincoln dealer or go to lincoln.com to learn more.

12:20forward vix should be 10 plus a little bit of premium because of the unknown right you know who knows there's always some news that could come across that could cause a lot of problems right so you have to have a little bit of forward premium because of uncertainty and hedging and some things like that so if the vix vix should be at 13 to 14 if you assume that one month realized vol is at roughly 10 right so that that three points of premium is generally what you'd expect. So if you go into the earnings event, or excuse me, the election event with five, six points of premium, that's a little bit elevated based on not only the election, but you have the war and Apple was just about to report.

12:56So there's a couple of different events kind of wrapped up in there, but that's roughly what it was. So it was like a healthy premium, but it wasn't anything super significant. And then obviously you get the contraction the next day where that premium goes back down to, again, about maybe four points. So you had about a two point of vol premium if you just use these sort of relatively, you know, slightly naive metrics, but they're pretty good guidelines. So it wasn't anything like Trump presidential elections, though, right? The premium that was coming in going into this? No, but you wouldn't, you know, you wouldn't expect that.

13:25I mean, it's a midterm election. I think a lot of it was being priced in already. Like people knew it was going to be a Democratic sweep. I don't think that was really surprising. That's what all the models were. Could you argue that, you know, some of the surprise was because of, you know, how much or how violent the sweep was, like Texas flipping and stuff like that, that maybe wasn't being priced in? You know, OK. But what if you look at the movement of charts, I don't know if I'm hesitating, like if you look at the movement of charts, there was a lot of price action that was already starting to price in arguably the Democratic sweep, like health care moving up and, you know, AI was in related names.

14:04We're a little bit weak into that. So, you know, markets are forward looking. And I think a lot of people already knew that this dynamic was in play. I think what maybe caught people off guard a little bit more was just how extreme the Democratic sweep was. And then the ramifications that for AI, which was already kind of weak, right? But then immediately after you have the results, the narratives all start up. Well, you know, know this is good for the democratic suite because then maybe we can't spend so much on the ai dentists right it's like it's like someone's like ready to shoot themselves in the head and like we took the gun away it's like um you know that they okay they the hyperscalers have to throttle their spending so that was the argument for the bounce um but i think overall like what what you know maybe the market wasn't pricing in that level of extreme you know sweep right democratic sweep and anytime you have something happen where the market's not pricing in the extreme you know that causes or generates a little bit of volatility.

15:01Now, this was weird because Wednesday, the day after the elections, vol contracted so sharply when all the news was already out, right? That, you know, how strongly the Democrats won. So that day of contraction was indeed a little bit weird. And with hindsight, we can say that was clearly a head fake. And that kind of gets to my next question, which is how much, like, to your point, when the market was rallying, you started hearing people say, oh, you know, maybe the market's thinking this is great. You know, this Democratic win is actually good for the market, trying to come up with a story. But how much of that reaction the next day was about what's going on, like what you see in the flows versus people actually having an opinion on the election?

15:37Here was the the bat signal that things weren't right. The neoclouds are, you know, the. The problem children of the technology realm or or they are in this risk off regime. They are what the problem is. Right. So CoreWeave, Nebius, Iron, all those names are the names that are being talked about so much in terms of the poorest AI quality and the names where the credit issues are flaring, where they're on the outskirts of the fringe of this AI movement. And they are the signal for technology. And they were all down on Wednesday. That's election day. And so, you know, we wrote about this in the morning saying the thing that doesn't look healthy to us is the fact that these names are not bouncing with everything else, right?

16:27That's a problem when the worst names, which are already so oversold, that had very high implied vols, they didn't bounce with everything else. Now, I didn't go out there and tell everyone, hey, we should short this rally because of that, you know, because of that neocloud selling off. But that was clearly a signal that things were not right. And those names have been, you know, they just traded lower and lower and lower. Today, actually, they're bouncing a little bit after iron earnings. You know, they're up 20 percent. But those names were down 5 percent on Wednesday and then lost another 10 or so percent, you know, yesterday.

17:01And so when you look at the poorest quality names and you say that they aren't rallying, then that's a suggestion that, you know, what is ailing the tech complex has not been solved. Right. If you can't, if you can't generate a bounce on that stuff that is just the poorest of quality, again, then that that's a very bad signal for, you know, risk in the market overall. all. If someone was to come out now and say, hey, NVIDIA buys CoralWeave, then suddenly I think you would see a very sustained rally in the market, right? But instead, what you're seeing is, or what you saw is, you know, those, again, the worst names are really continuing to sell off rather sharply.

17:35Here's the other thing, Jack, that was so interesting about this is that much of what has held the market up has been a rotation amongst equities, right? So what do I mean by that. People were selling tech, but they were buying consumer staples, financials, utilities, healthcare, all these other names. So that kept the S &P relative price performance in tech actually fairly stable. S &P was not selling off that much, even though NASDAQ was selling off quite a bit because of that rotation trade. And you and I have talked so much about correlation and Core 1M. In fact, I have this chart up for you where I think a lot of people into the Democratic win, though this rotation trade was doing quite strongly, right?

18:18And you could see that drop in correlation right here on this chart where, you know, here's into the election, then the election printed is really low bar. And then look what happened yesterday. Yesterday, correlation spiked. What does that mean? Suddenly everybody went from, we're going to rotate amongst equities to we're going to rotate out of equities. And that was a huge state change for the market on Thursday because there was no place for safety, right? There was no, hey, I can't hide out in healthcare stocks or consumer staples or MAG7s or whatever. All equities got sold and sold hard. And so the fact that this correlation is moving up is telling me that this is not just about tech being weak right now.

18:59Right now, there's sort of a moratorium on equity exposure writ large. And a lot of that was driven by the fact that yesterday we had risk off in liquidation in this equity space in a very violent way. And what is concerning for me right now, as we look at this, is if you want to say the elections triggered this, then maybe that's true, but you can see correlation already was starting to pick up. So maybe you make this argument that the volatility contraction around elections, just because the event passed, did indeed allow for the market to have this real pause. But what it seems to have unleashed on the backside is a lot of equity liquidations, enforced trading that has really started to infect the whole equity complex instead of just the tech sector.

19:49So how are you thinking about where we are now in terms of going forward? I have to probably say this, it's 1051 here on Friday because God only knows what's going to happen between now and the close. But are we in a negative gamma environment? Are we in an environment where you'd expect the options market to exacerbate moves in both directions? What are you seeing going forward? Yeah, the gamma environment here is really quite negative. And what we saw yesterday was puts were rolled down. So, you know, what do I mean by that? If you were long puts yesterday, and fortunate enough to be long puts, volatility spiked in a crazy way.

20:20So if you just look at the VIX here in this move yesterday, Jack, yesterday on a percent change basis, yesterday was the third highest, on a percentage basis, was the third biggest VIX move ever, going back to 1990, I should say. Now that's a percentage basis. And what that tells us is that the VIX moved from this extreme low of around 16 to at one point was over 28, right? So on a percent basis, that was massive. If you look at a point change basis, it was around 17, so still pretty significant, right? But vol just absolutely, implied vol just absolutely just gapped higher in a way that it was extraordinarily unusual, right?

20:54And if you look at the VIX, the NASDAQ VIX or the VXN, the spike was even more extreme. So yesterday was in a lot of ways a volatility event. Now, people did smartly roll some hedges down. So the put exposure is now at lower strikes. The big negative gamma now is at lower strikes. It didn't get removed from the board, so to speak. And here's why this is a problem. um number one you would expect to have a market bounce today which if we look at the s &p and the nasaq you can see we are indeed getting a little bit of a bounce today right see this jack uh 70 basis points after this giant bar down so we are getting a little bit of a bounce and that bounce makes sense why because we were so oversold and vol was so expensive yesterday so when vol gets so expensive you can't you know i mean you can buy puts but they're so expensive that no you know no one reasonable is going to say, hey, I want to bet on the shorting the market here.

21:51So I'm going to buy a bunch of put options. Like that doesn't make any sense. Now, if you have to buy put options because you have to hedge and protect yourself from being liquidated, well, okay, you go and do that. But instead, what most practitioners are going to do is they're going to sell their puts into the extreme volatility. They're going to sell some of their VIX calls and then roll their exposure down, which alleviates near-term pressure, but the pressure now has been shifted lower. So what do I mean by that? If we start to slide lower from 7 ,400 in the S &P, then that gamma, that negative gamma is going to pick up, particularly get into 7 ,300 or 7 ,200, which keeps fuel for a downside market move in place.

22:28Does that make sense? Yeah, it makes complete sense. If you were to have a situation where, let's just say, NVIDIA comes out, they buy NeoCloud, a huge market event, then suddenly say that shows value in the space. Kind of like, remember when Jamie Dimon in the, I think it was a great financial, it was a great financial card. I can't remember when it was, but he bought like$50 million worth of stock. And that suddenly made everybody go, okay, like flag planted in the ground. Like we can start buying stocks. Like this guy says there's value. We're fine. Like if we don't get some type of market event like that, then what is clearing risk from this board?

23:02I would argue sort of nothing, right? Now, if you, so, so what do I mean by that? We're getting a dead cat balance. And I think that's all this is. We're also going into the weekend when I know you're going to release this. And, you know, the nastiest of market moves and sells tends to happen on a Monday. I haven't gone back and scanned and fact check that. But if you consider the last time, you know, we had a huge market sell off and create a lot of liquid trading or wide spreads and, you know, hedge fund redemption till selling and all this kind of thing. It was at the start of August in 2024.

23:35If you remember that over that weekend, there was a, and I could show that on the chart here. If you remember over that weekend, Jack, there was a, I believe it was a yen carry trade. Trying to find the exact date right in here, right? There was a yen carry trade that allegedly blew up on the weekend, and then the VIX opened over 60. And people were saying, well, this whole thing was created by this yen carry trade. That's why the VIX went over 60. But we had a 10 % drawdown in the S &P into that event, right? So this final blowup was like this market clearing event. we haven't had that market clearing event.

24:11And we're going to go into this weekend of, things are kind of illiquid. Is there stuff going on in Iran? How do we digest all this? And to me, that says that next week could really bring in lower lows because there's nothing to clear out this negative gamma and this sort of dealers are short vega around this level, meaning that they have a lot of downside hedging to do if markets start to break. right? So that's what's concerning. If you forward a little bit to mid-November on 11-17, we have NVIDIA earnings. We also have the potential of the Anthropic IPO right around that time as well, right?

24:43Then we're going to hit VIX expiration on the 18th, and then we're going to hit OPEX on the 20th. And then that's going to play into Thanksgiving. So why are expirations so important here? Because the expirations clear out the most gamma, right? The negative gamma, all these put positions, right? That can drive a lot of volatility. So you're going to get a opx that will clear out a lot of risk. And then you're going to go into Thanksgiving. Why does Thanksgiving matter? Because that holiday week is a time when traders don't want to be long vol either. So that's an incentive to sell your put options because they're expensive and you don't want to carry your put options over that decay period.

25:18So if you look back last year, so look at this, Jack. I think this analogy is fascinating. This is the end of October of 2025. And here is mid-November. We're actually right here, right now. Isn't that kind of fascinating? This is the same day. You get this dead cat bounce, and then look at the sell-off that goes into what date. We do OPEX all the time, right? That is OPEX of November 2020. And then all of a sudden you have Thanksgiving week. Thanksgiving's right here. You have this giant rally that just unwinds this 9 % drawdown in the S &P. We're at the same exact point right now. And so I think that the dead cat bounce, maybe it lasts until Monday, particularly if nothing happens on Monday, then the rally should continue because vol can continue to contract.

26:01But again, we haven't cleared out the risk that drives these positions. Here's another thing, right? Yesterday, we had Levert ETF selling$52 billion, according to Morgan Stanley. That was the biggest since June 5th. We had record retail selling, apparently go back to COVID. It was only$350 million, but it talks about the sentiment. We had the most number of S &P index puts traded ever. That was a new record of around 4.5 million. So you have all these derivatives now that sit on top of the equity movement. There's a lot of talk about funds liquidating stuff. I know it's kind of a trope, but the fund liquidations were actually less interesting or more interesting than I think people just getting forced selling.

26:41There were people who struggled in August or October like Walleye saying, we're just unwinding all this. This is not a planned liquidation for today. It's just the trading's been so difficult. These guys and gals aren't being successful. We're just going to close up shop. So there was just a lot of pure liquidations in and around yesterday. And then you add on the volatility of the huge options flows and the levered ETFs and derivatives, and suddenly you start to get things kind of spiraling a bit out of control. And there's nothing really to clean or mop up that dynamic, again, unless there's some type of risk clearing event, which would be a significant, you know, NVIDIA type, you know, situation or an OPEX.

27:23So to me, all the risk that, you know, is embedded in the system is still sitting there. They're alleviating things right here in the short term, but I don't look at this and say we're out of the woods at this moment. And if I can go on one other sort of rant, Jack, I know I'm sort of talking over you a lot. I wanted to bring this up because if you go back to, you remember I said that we just had the most put options since June 5th trade, right? So this is June 5th. You can see how sharply we traded down from June to the end of June right here. That was about a 5 % or 6 % drawdown. Jack, do you know what happened right here, right around mid-June?

28:04Do you remember what that event was? I don't know. That was the SpaceX IPO. Oh, yeah. Why is that interesting to me? I mean, I'm talking a little bit out of my depth here, but Anthropic is about 10 days away as what is predicted right now. And they were supposed to be$1.5 trillion. Now they're saying it's going to be closer to$1.2 trillion. You know, SpaceX is roughly the same realm, right, or regime. A lot of people have to raise capital. Big funds have to raise cash, right, to buy Anthropic. And it's probably going to go into the NASDAQ pretty quickly. Who doesn't, you know, even now with the Democratic sweep, I think a lot of people are going to want to add Anthropic to their books, right?

28:41So how much selling, and I'm not saying that this was responsible for the whole drawdown, but there's the tailwind here of people having to free up about a trillion dollars of capital potentially for the IPO, right? So is that another just headwind for the equity prices and tech specifically when you have that type of event coming up? Again, right around this moment where I think we're going to, you know, have a risk clearing regime with NVIDIA on the 17th, maybe have the Anthropoc IPO on the 16th, 17th. That's roughly what they're saying now into OPEX. Like to me, that's a great bounce to buy.

29:17Whereas right now we're still in this sort of window where I think there's more reasons to liquidate bounces on bounces than there is to sort of want to get aggressive and buy dips. Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates.

29:50Limited availability in California. Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions. The holidays are coming, but the Lincoln Wishlist sales event is already here. And with exceptional offers on select Lincoln vehicles, you might just cross the perfect gift off your own list. You know, the kind that doesn't need wrapping. Consider this a little reminder to be good to yourself this time of year. Visit your local Lincoln dealer or go to Lincoln.com to learn more.

30:28Well, Brent, thank you so much. I appreciate it. I know you're very, very busy with all this volatility. I appreciate you taking the time to talk to us. Thank you for letting me talk over you for the last 10 minutes, Jack. I appreciate it. People don't want to hear from me, Brent. They want to hear from you. Thank you again. Next up, we have Ben Hunt. And if there's one thing we know, it's that the narratives moving the market this week were pretty well in place and pretty well entrenched before the moves. So here's Ben on an update on the signatures they're tracking and what he's doing about it.

30:56Ben Hunt of Epsilon Theory and Persian is with us. Ben, how are we doing? We're doing great. We're doing great, Matt. Kind of an interesting week, you know? Kind of an interesting week after kind of an interesting month, quarter, and last, I don't know, infinite time. Yes, yes. You are talking like we're having another common knowledge moment here. We were just talking about that, Matt, and I think that's the thing to talk about. That the election Tuesday night, it, you know, you saw all the, or I saw a lot of kind of the market commentators and all say, oh, this is going to be a market clearing event.

31:38And it, it's a clearing event, but not in the way they meant, right? So what we saw, we're recording this on a Friday after a Thursday where, whatever,$2.5 trillion was knocked off the NASDAQ and I just went like that. Now, so there was a clearing effect, but I don't think in the way that was intended this. And so the clearing effect, my strong view is that in the same way that the Biden-Trump debate performance, Joe Biden's debate performance, was a clearing event politically, what we call a common knowledge moment. My view is that the Tuesday night election results were a similar common knowledge moment for Donald Trump and his presidency.

32:36So that has a range of implications. Some, I think, market positive. Others, as we were seeing yesterday, probably market negative. But it is what it is. And I think we should talk about that because I think that that was a clearing moment. It was a seminal moment in the political and economic world that we've got to live in for the next couple of years. Yeah, teed up by the prior two years in the policy environment we were in, which a lot of the times policy is slow moving and it's just a lens through which to see markets investing and everything else. But it's around these moments, as you've shown us, that they can be really informative when you see those transitions.

33:23So walk us through why you think we're in a common knowledge moment with Trump right now. So what a common knowledge moment means is that we can have our own views, our own personal views of a politician, of an event, of anything. and we still have to act as if our personal views don't matter so long as the crowd or as long as we see the crowd acting as if what we personally believe isn't true so the the story example this is the emperor's new clothes emperor's walking down the street naked as a jaybird we all see with our own eyes he's not wearing any clothes but it doesn't matter. We all act as if the emperor has clothes because we look around and we see the crowd acting as if the guys got clothes.

34:24We're all having that experience, and so we all just say, we're just going to go along with it.

34:36What happens, though, is that when you have an event where the crowd is all there and the crowd knows that the crowd is all there. For example, the Biden debate performance. You could think your own eyes prior to that, the guy's not all there, but it's different when the crowd sees that the crowd sees it. There's no coming back from that. There's no coming back from that. What happens is that the courtiers, the internal group, they see that too. And so they can't keep the lie going. And the whole edifice of belief and trust crumbles, just poof, like that. That's exactly what you saw with Joe Biden.

35:25And I think that's exactly what you saw with Donald Trump on Tuesday night. So the emperor has no clothes. And what I mean by that is that he's got no juice, right? The unilateral force of will that he exerted over the Republican Party, over the country at large, it's gone. You saw this immediately with J.D. Vance essentially breaking from Trump the next morning and saying, oh, we lost the election because of the war and our close relationship with Israel. We got to do something about that. And it's like, okay. And look, he's not wrong, right? Those were definitely issues. It's interesting the issues he picked and not some of the other issues.

36:23But it was absolutely a break. And what everybody saw that everybody saw is that the guy in the White House doesn't have that pull anymore. He doesn't have the juice. And once that's broken, just like we saw with the Biden debate performance, it's gone. I did say it's a humpty-dumpty fell off the wall, and you can't put those pieces together again. So what does that mean? What that means is tariffs as this capricious weapon of policy, gone. Forget about it. It's just not going to happen. Escalation of the war and, you know, doing this or doing that, gone. It just can't happen anymore.

37:20The levers of power of that unilateral, capricious executive action, it only works if everybody believes in it. And once you have that crowd-watching-the-crowd moment where we all saw with our own eyes that he's been repudiated, it's over. It's over. Now, what does that look like over the next two years? Well, I say, though, that you've got specific market-impacting ramifications like tariff as this capricious weapon. Not going to happen anymore. war as a, as a capricious weapon, not going to happen anymore. Regardless of what you think about the merits of these things ain't going to happen anymore.

38:14Now, the one that we're all, I think after yesterday, really consider that, well, what does that mean for AI? What does that mean for AI? So I want to kind of highlight some things that we're picking up in our narrative work right here.

38:32The first is that AI is being auto-tuned on a red versus blue dimension. And that I'll call them political entrepreneurs on the left and the right are actively trying to do that. Meaning that you've got people on the left and the Democratic Party who want to say, we are the party of anti-AI. You've got the White House really pushing that idea of we are the party of AI forward and AI implementation. Now, I think that's really dangerous for our country. It's natural that's why the political parties, especially those on the edges, try to identify these issues where they can go against the other side.

39:30So that dynamic is happening. At the same time, you've got Hinojosa in Texas saying, nope, everything that's been permitted to date is fine. We're not going to cut anything, go forward. You've got people way on the AI side, like Gavin Baker saying, oh, we can work with, you know, so there's work in the middle being done to try to prevent this polarization, this political polarization of AI. But I think that's the thing to really watch for on narrative world. The degree to which people on the left and the right are trying to make this a politically defined issue and the way that people in the middle, who I'm certainly supporting, are trying to keep this from being a politically polarized issue.

40:21But that's the main thing that I think is going to impact markets going forward and what we're worth looking at with our narrative world. All right. Last beat before I let you go on this. When we have one of these moments and we have a common knowledge moment, the most important thing to do is watch for the next narratives that are already leading, watch what's going to emerge. How do we do that? so the the the old what happens is the old ways are done right so so everyone who was trying to make these kind of rear guard actions around joe biden no he's fine it's just a cold that fails i'm just telling you that fails so all the efforts that we've seen in the past about oh the election was rigged or stolen or oh you know he's it's it's still trump's party and stuff that's over That's just done.

41:11And so what you need to be looking for are the narratives that emerge. Some of the narratives will be to try to find new political cleavage points like AI. Other narratives are going to look for how do we govern in this world and looking forward to 2028 for who those candidates are going to be. And it ain't going to be a Trump handpicked candidate. Ben, thanks for joining us. Thanks, Ben. Make sure you check out Ben's work, Persean, Epsilon Theory, Panoptica, all the places. All the places. An important way to look at this whole thing is through the economy. I mean, a lot of people are maybe not paying attention to that right now, but this idea of what does AI mean for the economy?

41:51What does this change? What happened in the election mean for the economy? And a great person to talk to about that is Ahan Banan, because he has a very systematic process here. He's not going to overreact to what's going on. So I wanted to go through in 10 minutes and really figure out what does this actually mean for the economy? How much does he pay attention to things like elections? So here's my conversation with Ahan talking about all that. Ahan, welcome to Last Call. Jack, thanks for having me on. I'm excited to have you on because as we record this, we've got a little bit of panic going on in the market.

42:20It seems like the S &P is down 4%. The initial reaction to the election turned out to be the opposite of what the reaction was after that. And I'm excited to have you on because I want to take a step back and think about what all of this means. because obviously you look at the economy, you look at it in a systematic way. And I think it's good when there's a lot of craziness around you to kind of take a step back and say, what does all this mean? So the first thing I want to ask you, and I probably know the answer already, but I want to ask you anyway, is how much does something like an election impact what you do, impact your framework, impact how you view the economy and the market?

42:56You know, as you probably guessed, it doesn't impact what we do very much. From a framework standpoint, it's not that we're just not thinking about the election. I think it's after thinking through whether elections generally matter for markets, we generally come to the conclusion, unless there's a very material change in fiscal policy stance, elections don't really matter that much. And so when you kind of contextualize today's election, the fiscal dynamic in the United States is unlikely to change regardless of party. And so the only real major change that you can get out of an election is a change to the Iran war dynamic.

43:44And now even that, the changes won't happen until later next year. And given that we probably already have a lot of shut-ins, we have a lot of geopolitical risk baked in, geopolitical just general risk baked into operating through the straight-of-home moves now, you're going to continue to have supply problems in oil markets. And so between the fact that fiscal dynamics are probably not going to change and the war dynamics are not going to change that much, in a way at least that changes oil, the election is not something that we think is super, super material for markets right now. How about the AI and data center part of it?

44:19Because that seems to be what everybody's worried about right now. Like, how much do you think all of that influences the overall economy? I think very much so. So I think it's apparent to anyone that the AI story is very important for markets just because of the shell cap weight, the cap weight size of the hyperscalers, the indexes. But I think that they have an indirect effect on the economy. So the CapEx itself, if you look at broad tech spending, tech investment in the economy, that accounts for roughly about 1 % of normal GDP growth. It's not nothing, but it's also not the biggest driver of the economy.

45:03The biggest driver of the economy is the U.S. consumer today. But I think that there is an indirect channel through which AI is supporting the economy, which is through the wealth effect. And so when you think about the U.S. consumer today, the consumer has a variety of sources of funds that it can pull from to create spending. Those sources of funds are basically two areas. There is balance sheets and then there is income. Income has not been growing very strongly over the last year or so. But the household balance sheet, because of equity holdings, has been growing very, very strongly. And so the aggregate sources of funds for consumers have still been rising, even though incomes have been a lot slower.

45:51And so the AI CapEx story really kind of flows through to the economy through that wealth effect. Are you ever shopping online and suddenly a discount that helps you save pops up? It makes your day, sometimes even your week. Want that feeling month after month? Well, new customers who save by switching their home and auto insurance to Progressive save hundreds. Cue your happy dance. Get your quote today at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company affiliates and other insurers. Not available in all states.

46:28The holidays are coming, but the Lincoln Wishlist sales event is already here. And with exceptional offers on select Lincoln vehicles, you might just cross the perfect gift off your own list. You know, the kind that doesn't need wrapping. Consider this a little reminder to be good to yourself this time of year. Visit your local Lincoln dealer or go to Lincoln.com to learn more.

46:57Yeah, it's interesting. I was thinking about that. They say these days the AI trade is something like 50 % of the S &P 500. And if you think about it, the market's probably more important to the economy than it's ever been. 50 % of the trades in AI, that's kind of how you get back to the idea there can be an economic effect. Even if you look in GDP and say, oh, this is only single digit percentages, you still can have that indirect effect. Yeah, that's absolutely true. And I think it's important to keep in mind that that effect has built up over the course of many, many cycles. And so as we've had an increasingly financialized economy, and the U.S.

47:34is in particular an asset-owning economy, consumers and households own a lot of assets, over the course of many cycles, the sensitivity to asset prices has increased. And so we've actually looked at this where the total sources of funds of households have become more and more correlated to equity markets over the decades. And so today we're basically at peak sensitivity to equity markets relative to prior decades. Yeah, I was trying to think through my head right before we got on. I'm thinking about like, all right, let's say they just shut down all new data centers, just finish the ones that are left.

48:12Like, what does that mean? I was going back to my, I don't know the training you do, but I was going back to Economics 101. And I'm like, all right, less supply, you know, lower quantity and higher prices is basically what that ends up with. And I assume, you know, the growth of AI slows down. I'm just trying to like think through what that even means for the economy if we do have like a complete lockdown on the data centers. I mean, I think it's a difficult dynamic, right? Because if you think about what's happening right now, it's we have a CapEx funded profit cycle. And what I mean by that is that CapEx in itself, contemporaneously at the macroeconomic level, is extremely conducive to profits.

48:53Because the costs of CapEx are not today, they're in the future. And the hope with CapEx is that eventually you don't have to keep doing the CapEx, it turns into consumption. Now, the question is whether it will turn into consumption. And, you know, you've talked to my co-host of Macro Talk a couple of times about this. And so I'm not going to get too deep on that aspect. But I think the main thing to recognize is that for the current profit party to continue, you need one of two things. You need either ongoing capex to continue at the same rate or higher rates, or you need consumers to continue to disave their incomes at a historical pace that we've almost never seen over the last 60 years.

49:40And so between those two things, both of those things are kind of tied to this AI story. CapEx is kind of contingent on AI conditions being good. And the wealth effect is really what's powering the saving. And so all of it really kind of does come back to this AI story being very central. But it's not because it's only the spending alone is what's driving everything. It's the profits, the expectations of those profits, and how that flows through the household wealth. Yeah, it's interesting. You've kind of got the near-term story, which is all the building. And then you've got the long-term story, which is the productivity.

50:13And then you have to think through it in both ways. Like if you're a big, if someone is a big believer in the productivity, then you potentially slow down that productivity. If you slow down the growth of AI, you build less data sims. Yeah, yeah. And, you know, I'm not one to focus too much on the far out picture. I think the main thing that we want to be focused on is that we're already at what seems to be pretty extreme levels of both these things. Like the amount of CapEx that's been, the CapEx momentum we've seen has started to crest. And we've also started to, we haven't started to see any turn into savings yet.

50:50But the thing is that the sources of funds as equity markets have begun to slow down, have begun to slow down as well. And that's only natural as you approach these extremes. How about the inflation side of it? Many people have argued building all these data centers is boosting inflation. I mean, do we think if we stop building them, does inflation come down to some degree? I think that the bigger picture, the more important picture probably when it comes to inflation has less to do with data centers and probably more to do with the oil story. And I think that when you think through the fact that even though we've had a couple of weeks of oil seeing some sell-offs, you're still talking about oil prices that have risen between 50 % and 60 % over the last year.

51:32And that oil price pressure makes its way through to the entire economy. And so while the CapEx story might be marginally impactful to the inflation dynamic, I think that the real underlying story is that one, you have really, really strong nominal demand in the economy, which we still see that across the board. And two, you have this oil supply shock, and the combination of those keeps you in this inflationary backdrop. And so, yeah, I mean, CapEx could, you know, the AI story could have a marginal effect, but I think those are really the two drivers to focus on when it comes to inflation. RAOUL PAL And you've seen in your Nowcast, and I think you think this is temporary, but your Nowcast has come down in the 2 % range recently, right?

52:22Yeah, yeah. And, you know, I think a lot of that has to do with the fact that the now cost is actually a now cost for month-on-month inflation. So month-on-month inflation, when you have oil volatility as high as it is today, is very, very sensitive to what happens to the energy complex. So, you know, that from in any given month, you can have a lot of volatility. But then when you start thinking about the core components of the model, which is core inflation, there is a lot of stickiness to the underlying core components. And so I think when you think about applying that model and kind of using it today, it's definitely telling you that there is less pressure on fixed income markets.

53:04But the question is whether that reduction of pressure can persist. And for that reduction of pressure to persist, you have to have oil continuing to fall the way it is. I really ask that question because you've been known on Twitter for saying bonds are the worst. And I know your model went below 2%. And so I was just wondering if I could get you on tape saying bonds are the best for at least a short period of time before you go back to bonds are the worst. You know, I would love to say it. I'm not going to actually say the phrase, but the thing is that when I eventually change my mind, I'll get a lot of flack for it.

53:38So I'm going to stay with the party line for now. Well, Han, thank you for doing this. I appreciate the time. Thank you so much, Jack. Zooming back from the AI trade, two of the underlying inputs that are not going away, even if we're not spending as much time talking about them right now, are inflation and the oil markets. Eric comes to us with a background in oil markets as an engineer, running refineries, doing all the math on how the money goes in and out, how the oil comes in and out, how the product gets distributed around the world. Eric gives us a quick update on where we stand on both the inflation calculations and the functioning of oil markets that will dominate the conversation for months yet to come.

54:19Next up, we've got Eric Pakman, data for the people, data with the number four. we're going to talk a little bit about why investors need to think like engineers, of which Eric's a reformed engineer of sorts. Eric, welcome back. Thanks for having me. So I know of the many things you've been writing about lately, we wanted to get you back for an update as we're going forward here on inflation and the energy markets, where you have been so spot on in explaining so many of these things as they're happening, both in how we measure inflation also to the way that energy markets are operating due to your own background.

54:55So where do you want to start? Are we going to look at PPI first? Yeah. Yeah. I think let's look at PPI. So for, for years, for some reason I ignored PPI. I don't know why, but I think that CPI just got more attention. And so, you know, back when I was in the investment business, I, you know, focused on PPI, I focused on PC. But, you know, recently, I mean, with all the tools that we have, I was able to create basically like an item level data visualization on PPI, which if I could pull up my screen, I'd love to show it to you right now. Yeah, let's share some screen. Okay. So this is what I call the PPI scuba diver data visualization.

55:36So what I've tried to do at Data for the People, in the days pre-AI and cloud code, this was impossible for me to do. I have nowhere near enough data visualization talent to create something like this. But now, you know, you have to know the underlying databases and be able to audit them and validate them and everything, which thankfully I'm able to do. But man, besides that, like anything that you dream up, you can really create, at least with the process that we've created. And so what this is, is what I call the PTI scuba diver. so all the items underneath the scuba diver i think of it as kind of like you know these weights on the scuba diver that are dragging them down and so this is an inverted scale so zero is up here for inflation and then 12 is down here and you can actually just play this over time kind of like a video game then just watch the scuba diver like rise and fall and in fact like you may actually see like a shark that kind of swims up by down at the bottom eventually link.

56:36Let's see if he comes in on cue. But anyway, so you'll see what happens down here is down in 2021. We know what happened back then, right? PPI inflation like really shot up towards like the 10, 11, 12 % range. But what you can see right now is as we're making our way through 2024, not much is happening through 25. And then now down into 2026, he's falling, right? Shoeba diver is falling. These are all the items that are kind of like floats that are trying to bring them up. There aren't that many left. You can click on any of them. These are all the ones that are bringing the scuba diver down. You can click on the table, by the way, because I mean, some of these are very, very small, right?

57:19So you can't see everything that's in here, but you can click on the table and then just sort this any way you want. And the real important part about this is that it actually is, it is not only the unweighted numbers that you see. So you'll see in here that jet fuel is up like over 100%, right? But it also has the weighting on that. And then everything actually adds up and ties out to this final demand prices number of 6.3%. And when it doesn't tie out in early years because of rounding, we tell you that. So all the information is here for you to do that. All the code lives on GitHub. Go out, recreate it yourself, come up with a different analogy, whatever you want.

57:58Anyway, 6.3%. It's a pretty high number, right? So that got my attention. And it's one of the reasons why I was like, I probably should dig into PPI a little bit and create this data visualization. Well, I created something else. And this is especially for XS returns. I have not published this yet, although hopefully I will soon. And so what this shows is it takes that same data that we just looked at. And it's looking at the share of items that are, call it, going through some sort of extreme movement. There's hundreds of items that are in PPI, a lot more items than in CPI. And so right here, if we look at this first one, this is the share of items that have more than one standard deviation above the items average.

58:45It's just the share of the items though, right? So right now, 22.2 % of all items are one standard deviation and above of their historical average. But then you actually have to look to see that by weight, right? Because some items have larger weights than others. And this is kind of a scary chart, right? So, Jamie, 33.3 % of all the items by weight are actually one standard deviation or above where they have been in the past, going back to all the data that we have. now in the 2021 to 2022 surge that only made it up to 60 so i mean when you look at these charts and you know it's very very hard to be like oh this is normal like yeah no no problem here especially on the producer side which eventually those you know as we know will flow through to the consumers either that or they're going to eat away at the producer's margin so investors probably shouldn't be happy either way.

59:44This is the share of weight more than two stair deviations above. So look, I mean, 21, 22 was really bad. Like 46 % of all items above two stair deviations. That's a lot. We're not anywhere close to that yet, but we're creeping up. We're not where we were in 2014. I mean, typically this is around zero, right? So if we keep scrolling down, I created this for you, Matt. Thank you. This actually also made me really sad because remember back in like going into 21, 22, it was like, oh, inflation is temporary. It's temporary. It's going to reverse. Look how long the Fed waited before it started raising.

1:00:26By the time that it started raising, there were already 60, 70 % of all items that were above one or state of deviation above their mean. So we had already pretty much peaked by the time that they were raising. So, you know, if anyone from the Fed is listening, like, please look at this type of analysis. Like, I mean, you really could have caught something that was going on much earlier than that. And to be fair, like, we are starting to react a little bit earlier in that right now. But this is not normal from a breast perspective, at least within PPI. So this is all, this is all new. And I'd say it's the way an engineer would look at this.

1:01:05We don't just look at the top number, the overall number, the number the media feeds And thus, the tools that we have out there can let us look at the entire breadth of all the information, look at percentiles, look at standard deviations, so on and so forth, and understand that this is relatively broad-based inflation. Down below, and again, I'll try to publish this so everybody has access to this, but these are kind of the items that are most out of whack. So these are the highest weight items that are trading above two standard deviations above their mean. And so we wrote about this a little bit earlier, the long distance motor carry, trucking, that kind of stuff.

1:01:45It's kind of going haywire right now, which, again, doesn't portend well for all of our groceries and stuff like that. Anything I do is by truck. Any questions? Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California.

1:02:22Driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy. Coverage subject to policy terms and conditions. The holidays are coming, but the Lincoln Wishlist sales event is already here. And with exceptional offers on select Lincoln vehicles, you might just cross the perfect gift off your own list. You know, the kind that doesn't need wrapping. Consider this a little reminder to be good to yourself this time of year. Visit your local Lincoln dealer or go to lincoln.com to learn more.

1:03:00No, I think this is super important for investors and people alike just to help understand what's going on in these headline numbers. because they're big, scary numbers. The felt experience is different than some of what looks like it's measuring. And this is a really useful way to actually understand the look through. Whether or not the Fed doing anything is going to make much of a difference here is anybody's question, how much of this is policy. But understanding what that overlap is, I think is really critical. Yeah. Yeah. And so I guess the next question is, how is this going to change going forward?

1:03:34And that's where we have to drill even deeper and we can kind of get into kind of the latest work that we've done on energy markets, if you'd like to go there. Yeah, I want to take this straight to energy because I think that also separates us. You can't unpack the grocery prices from the energy and the transportation prices. And when we get into the energy situation, you've been way out in front of this one too. And especially as it relates to what's going on in the Strait of Wormuz, in Oman, and also with the SPRs. You've been having some of the more interesting stuff here. tell me what's going on yeah so i think that you know there's a lot of um i would say just maybe not an understanding of exactly how oil gets transported again like you know oil could be a number on your screen that goes up or down or whatever that the entire kind of like virtual market or paper market as we call it but in reality at the end of the day we have to consume oil, we have to refine it, we have to put it in our gas tanks, we have to put it in those trucks where, you know, prices are going up and so on and so forth.

1:04:38And so you, you have to go back all the way through the market, like an engineer would to say, well, like, how is oil getting transported across the globe? And is that working well? Is it functioning properly at this point in time? So I think everybody knows straight up Hormuz is not in a healthy position right now. and so i had claude put together just this little diagram so you know this is the direct taker route that sure you know pretty much has always worked um this is the pipeline bypass that you know the hushies are attacking the drones and so on so forth and so that got shun off and then also you know all the chaos and everything went over to the red sea and then And this is the handoff at sea, which has actually been working.

1:05:25At least when you actually track the numbers, it looks like the oil coming out of the Middle East is actually going up. Well, so you can actually analyze that. And I would encourage you to just kind of ask questions to your own quad or whatever AI you use about how that handoff at sea works. I did that. And so what's happening is you have a certain number of takers. And if I kind of just go down here, there's a certain number of takers that are just willing to take the risk to cross the orbit. These are the shuttle tankers that are going basically from like the most dangerous leg. And the best that I've been able to find is that about 30 of these vessels have actually been hit in October through October 27.

1:06:06So it's really, really dangerous to go across, but you could make 30 to$40 million to do this. And so some of them are taking a risk. Most of the takers don't want to take a risk. So now we need one taker, like this is a very large crew cherry. These are the most expensive tankers to be the shuttle. And then they hand off to the other tanker once you get to the safe side on the other side of the Gulf of Vermont. Right. And so now all of a sudden it's like I had one tanker that could transport that oil all the way through. Now it takes two tankers. Well, guess what? That just cut my tanker supply in hex for all the tankers that were going to be on that route.

1:06:41Meanwhile, I have other tankers that are going on these long circuitous routes that instead of taking 20 days to get through, they take 40 days. Guess what that does? That cuts my tanker supply in half as well, because it takes twice the amount of time to transport the same amount of crude. Well, what this has happened is it's creating chaos in the tanker market. So we've written about this. I'm sure some investors have heard about this because it's made front page of a lot of like, you know, high profile news. tanker rates are up to like 1.2 1.3 million dollars a day when normally they're like 20 to 30 000 a day but the one thing that i wanted to show which i haven't reported on yet was it's not just the the lanes that are going from the middle east to china it's not just the lanes that are going through the straight-up one boots it's everything right it's the very large crude carriers it's a smaller suez maxes it's the ashram axes i mean they are all just going up as we're just losing supply eating up supply some cases bombing supply literally of all of these tankers that are transporting oil and so then i would ask you if you know that you know a rumor comes that we're going to sign a peace deal or this or that it's like well but if you can't transport the crew you know it's so freaking expensive we're running out of tankers like what why does that even matter you know this is this is why i keep coming back to you know with the refineries, with the supply chain, with the actual vessels.

1:08:09Like we have created COVID for oil markets. It's that simple. Like you can't just snap your fingers, shoot a vaccine in there, open the street, wear a mask, and then immediately expect it to recover. This is a, we have a long road ahead on this. And I'll transition real quickly to it. We're running out of voice in our strategic petroleum reserve to kind of like act as a buffer. Like this is supposed to be our virgin sea oil. Well, literally coming into recording this, this data was just released. So it just popped up on my screen that, you know, what happens, and we wrote a lot about this, so I won't, you know, I'll assure you to reading about the strategic petroleum reserve on our website.

1:08:54But what happens is, is that the government comes out and says, Hey, we are going to offer 40 million barrels to the market as a loan. Who wants it? and we need a premium that you're going to return us through to us at some point in time in the future, which may or may not ever happen, by the way, right? Loans that we've, you know, given out in the past in 2022, we're still waiting on that oil, like a year and a half after we were supposed to get it back. So, you know, take that with a grain of salt. So this, the last FY26 release, we actually gave out another 23.8 million barrels. This shows you that ExxonMobil took 16 million barrels of it.

1:09:33Macquarie took three and so on and so forth. FY27, the first release, that was almost fully subscribed. So 16.75 out of 17 million barrels. Look at who took it though. Oil treating firms. So then it's the financial market that took it. Why? Because the curve's in backwardation and because the ARBs are open and because they can basically get this oil for free, lock in their profits on day one through financial markets and then spit it out onto the global market so this oil is not going to refineries this oil is going under the global market like kind of pissing in the ocean type of situation so that we wrote a lot on this i would really encourage you to read it this is the first time that the government really has tried this lulling process, which I personally think is a very dangerous mechanism.

1:10:29Normally, we just say pay us for it, and then we can go back and buy back this crude later. There are a lot of implications for the mechanics on how this all works, and I would really encourage you to read this because it could shut us up really poorly in 2027 if this oil shock continues to proceed. I think the risks coming from both inflation at the consumer level and at the global macro level, what's going in oil right now. I think, unfortunately, we have a lot more to talk about in the months ahead. Unfortunately. Yeah. Problem's not going away. Eric, people want to bug you on the internet.

1:11:04Where are we sending them? Dataforthepeople.com, number four. All of our work is free. Sign up for a distribution list. You can find me on Twitter, LinkedIn, Eric Pakman. Email me anytime. Eric at dataforthepeople.com. Thanks, Eric. So as we wrap up, Matt, I want to talk about the whole thing with, I mean, data centers in general, where we're going with it, how much does it matter? Like, I'm not an expert at data centers, but I've just been thinking about this a lot in terms of how much does this political change actually impact the construction of data centers and how much does the construction of data centers actually impact the impact AI is having on this whole thing, both near term, because it's creating, you know, some economic growth and jobs when we build them, but also long term in terms of the productivity we're expecting to get.

1:11:47And that's the part I'm still struggling with to some degree, because on one hand, obviously we're going to need, demand is way outstripping supply right now. So we're going to need a lot of data centers. On the other hand, a lot of the data centers that are going to be built next year, early the year after, are already contracted. And they don't seem to be talking about stopping any of that. So that's the thing I struggle about is like, how much does this really impact, getting away from how the market's reacting, like how does this really impact the deployment of AI into the economy and the big companies behind it?

1:12:17How does it impact their success because if we do have a, you know, a headwind here against these data centers. Headwind is here and the policy move just pretty much told us that we have a very different conversation post midterm election than we did before the midterm election. I'm working on a piece, hopefully Panoptica will get this up as a zeitgeist sometime in the near future, but some of the stuff that just really shocked me to actually dive into. So right now, Virginia leads operating data centers right now at about 353. Texas leads on the pipeline. There's 191 under construction, 1 ,007 announced.

1:12:54Pennsylvania, 41 operating, but 362 announced. Why do numbers like this matter? This is happening across the country right now. We have a limited amount operating where the money's already been deployed and it's up and running. And then a bunch more in process, some of which are partially built, some of which just haven't been plugged in yet because we don't have an energy solution for them. The midterms change what historically is not part of what matters in midterm elections, which is these governors. Governors normally don't have a lot of say, a lot of power. But when we look at the shift from Republican led states that flipped and they flipped on things like data center policies, this is where this becomes a major issue because it impacts the bailout.

1:13:36We saw five governorships flip in Texas, Georgia, Ohio, Iowa, and Nevada. And that represents about 37 % of planned data center capacity. So this build out to follow through with the hyperscaler plans is right in our faces right now is where will policy meet the road on the build out to further complicate things. I know you like hanging out on truth social. You're there all the time. All the time. Getting all the truths. Yeah. Yeah. But buying Trump's tweets, you know, the whole thing. Actually, I think that we can say that's come to an end now for whoever's buying. those tweets that probably is that that's probably not gonna go on anymore well he he's out there he's out there as of friday you know truths tweeting whatever we call whatever gets said on on truth social basically like for the states who still want to play and who want to make money on super intelligence he wants to throw federal money behind those and make sure those projects still happen so it's like the midterms alone aren't the final card in this there's still going to be all sorts of political games that get played where this money gets pushed and spent to the degree that it can still be raised and still be deployed.

1:14:43But we are in a totally new environment now that the policy has started to shift than we were before November 3rd. Our super intelligence comes to an end now, too. Do we go back to the previous name? He's still truth socialing about super intelligence. So the whole the whole message was basically, I'll send it to you if we put it up on the screen is up to you or your editorial real discretion here. But the whole thing here is like, you can, you can look at this as a black and white thing. You can look at it as data centers, good data centers, bad, or the Democrats are coming into power can say, listen, they're not necessarily bad.

1:15:16We're going to take a thoughtful process and we're going to make sure that they're positively contributing to the community we're putting them in. And I think there's a middle ground in there where some of these continue to be built. And that's what, I think her name was Gina Inahosa, the governor, new governor of Texas. That's basically what she's been saying. And sometimes when a political party wins power, they come in and say, listen, you know, we're going to blow the whole thing up here. Like no data centers and we're going to do this. And sometimes they come in and say, I'm going to have a thoughtful process.

1:15:41And like the way she's talking, she's talking about, like, I would agree with everything she's saying in terms of like the water usage and in terms of like, it's got to benefit the community around it. Like there's plenty of land in Texas. We don't need to build it next to someone's house. Like all that stuff makes complete and a hundred percent sense. So if that's what ends up happening, you might see a slowdown in data centers, but you're not going to necessarily see like a halt to data centers. Whereas if they come in and be like, no more data centers, that's probably a very different outcome.

1:16:06Well, and this is the critical point here. So you have this policy change. So now you have to think about the economic impact. Now, all these people don't have to start thinking about reelection today, but they have to consider what's the impact because we know how well entrenched this is, not just in capital markets, but also in the economy. The economy, GDP is a bet on this actually taking place right now. So if any of these people are going to come in, any of these governors and say, we just want to block and hard know everything, you're kind of shooting yourself in the foot politically. So I think what's going to happen is we have an extended period in front of us, certainly over the next three to six months of a lot of these governors and a lot of these politicians looking at those policies and starting to figure out what's a potential way through this.

1:16:47I would expect more of a compromise to come out of this than like a hard black or white answer on it. But that nuance isn't going to get solved overnight because now the question's been raised first compromise that is that part of the thing we do at the field these days i don't think so listen the the pennsylvania attack ads like i am just i am ready not you must have been like that you must be so happy this thing is over it it it was utterly it was utterly agonizing it was definitely i will say on the topic of compromise did i tell you about the the knicks game the knicks 76ers game we went to don't tell me about it because i'm a knicks fan and i know how it ended up you know how it ended up it was glorious so the the 76ers the the Xfinity arena was basically 50 50 Knicks and Sixers fans as expected I firmly expected to arrive there and was kind of worried there'd be like in the playoffs last year there'd be more Knicks fans than Sixers fans in attendance it's probably an even split still jarring for a home game to have not a dominant audience especially that will change throughout the year by the way Sixers got a really good team this year so I have a feeling they're going to get those Knicks fans out of there and more Sixers fans are going to start showing up.

1:17:55It is just not a normal Philly sports experience to go to something where you're outranked. But anyway, we, you know, so we're there, everybody's kind of like, there's some tension before the game and waiting in the line and whatever else. People are saying stuff to each other, taking pot shots, but fine, peaceful. Then this guy gets up to sing the national anthem. He is a, like, double amputee in a wheelchair. They wheel him out and, like, i've i've seen some amazing national anthems i've heard some on television and whatever else like every other line everybody cheered for this guy it was the most emotional national anthem i have ever experienced in my life john brooks i want to make sure i have his name right something like that uh if you look it up utterly incredible utterly incredible so can compromise exist can compromise exist yes compromise can exist we can still be patriotic stuff can still come out If a 76ers and Knicks fan base can get behind a national anthem together, I don't think all is lost as of yet.

1:18:55Yeah, I know. We would love to see that everywhere. And hopefully that's the way this plays out. I mean, you always have to be, I feel like always after election day, I always try to be optimistic. Most of the time, that optimism is dashed. But nonetheless, let's feel like we all can get along here. And there's certainly a path forward in the middle that makes sense here. And you hope for both the economy, for people's lives, for the markets, that that's the path we choose. I hope so, because those political attack ads, by the end, there was a big thing in Pennsylvania that was baloney themed.

1:19:22So we had one politician saying the other person was full of baloney and had this like baloney sandwich with all this baloney in it. And the other politician's response is he had like the deli roll of baloney, like the kind the butcher has behind the counter. And he's like slapping it. And I'm like, what? Who was changing their mind based on baloney themed policies? So I got a little taste of those because they came into my area. my area of Connecticut is pretty democratic. So it's, it's usually not too much of it, but like these things, I didn't recognize it. You do every election, but I didn't recognize like, these are like Bob Johnson wants all animals to die.

1:19:53It's like, like these ads are just like so terrible. Jam packed. I mean, anything you watch with commercials, you would see a bunch of those. And then more texts and phone calls than I've ever gotten, including creepy stuff where like somebody knocks on the door and you're like, I don't open the door. And then like five minutes later, your phone goes off and it's like, I was just at your front door and wanted to see if you'd be voting for, you're like, Oh my God, you open the door and there's a bunch of stuff stuffed in there. Like this is a little bit creepy. It's a little bit, a little, it's a little bit creepy.

1:20:22I'm going to go have a bologna sandwich in celebration. I think, I think we did probably a good way to wrap things up. All right. Excess returns on Substack. Check us out over there, wherever you are watching or listening. Thank you so very much. Make sure before you go to like comment or subscribe, all the things are below route. Thank you for tuning into this episode. If you found this discussion interesting and valuable, please subscribe on your favorite audio platform or on YouTube. You can also follow all the podcasts in the XS Returns Network at XSReturnsPod.com. If you have any feedback or questions, you can contact us at XSReturnsPod at gmail.com.

1:20:57No information on this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed in the podcast may be holdings of the firms of the hosts or their clients. Progressive's Accident Response can contact emergency services if you're in a major accident. The only thing worse than someone you love being in an accident is not being able to help them. So Progressive is here to help when you can't. So get peace of mind knowing your loved ones are protected with Progressive's Accident Response. Learn more at Progressive.com. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and Affiliates. Limited availability in California.

1:21:31driver is responsible for emergency and towing charges not covered by the policy coverage subject to policy terms and conditions the secret society of semi-homemade listen up sam's club has pre-made dishes for a thanksgiving feast that's ready in two hours all while tasting suspiciously homemade come join us sam's club individual oven times may vary

From the publisher

Brent Kochuba, Ben Hunt, Aahan Menon and Eric Pachman join Matt Zeigler and Jack Forehand on November’s Last Call to make sense of the post-election selloff and the pressures facing businesses and households.

Follow Last Call on Spotify⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠

⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Follow Last Call on Apple Podcasts⁠


Brent Kochuba explains why the weakest AI cloud stocks caught his eye even while the Nasdaq was rallying. Ben Hunt argues the midterms changed what investors could take for granted about presidential power, with governors gaining a bigger say in where data centers get built.


Aahan Menon traces how a decline in AI shares could reach the dinner table as households that grew wealthier on paper rethink their spending. Eric Pachman follows a different cost all the way to the grocery aisle. When diesel gets more expensive, a grocer has to decide how much of the freight bill to absorb and how much to pass on to shoppers.


Topics covered:

- Why Brent Kochuba watched the weakest AI cloud stocks for confirmation of the rally

- How negative dealer gamma can amplify selling and why November options expiration matters

- What Ben Hunt means by an election making the limits of presidential power “common knowledge”

- Why governors, electricity bills and local jobs matter to the next data center permit

- Why Aahan Menon sees little immediate change in federal spending after the midterms

- How stock gains support consumer spending and data center investment feeds corporate profits

- How Eric Pachman uses the Producer Price Index to see how many industries face unusual cost increases

- Who borrowed oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve and what it will take to return those barrels


Guest research and links:


Brent Kochuba | SpotGamma

https://spotgamma.com/

SpotGamma on X

https://x.com/spotgamma


Ben Hunt | Perscient

https://www.perscient.com/

Epsilon Theory on X

https://x.com/EpsilonTheory


Aahan Menon | Prometheus Research

https://www.prometheus-macro.com/

Aahan Menon on X

https://x.com/AahanPrometheus


Eric Pachman | Data 4 The People

https://www.data4thepeople.com/

How the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) Works in 2026

https://www.data4thepeople.com/p/spr-exchange


Chapters:

00:00 A post-election rally gives way to a Nasdaq selloff

05:06 Brent Kochuba on unwinding election hedges

12:05 The AI cloud stocks that missed the bounce

16:38 Negative gamma and what could break the selling cycle

26:28 Ben Hunt on what the election made common knowledge

37:31 Aahan Menon on fiscal policy and the AI wealth effect

43:03 What a slowdown in data center spending would mean for profits

48:35 Eric Pachman on price pressure across industries

57:31 Tanker traffic, freight costs and emergency oil loans

1:05:10 Who gets a say when a data center comes to town?

1:10:48 Political compromise and a Philadelphia sports story


Learn more about the Excess Returns podcast network:

https://excessreturns.co


No information discussed in this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed may be held by the hosts and guests, their firms or their clients.


More from Excess Returns

All episodes