

11 Nov 2026 · 1h 7m · 23 chapters

Markets’ “bubble” question amid midterm-driven volatility: tech/AI infrastructure selloff while defensive consumer staples rally; debate whether AI-related stocks are cheap since 2022 and whether the defensive/offensive rotation will reverse quickly.
Robert Hackstrom, CIO at Equity Compass and author of The Warren Buffett Way; long-term, concentrated value investor focused on free cash flow and competitive advantage. Chris Mayer, co-founder of Woodlock House Family Capital and “100-baggage-splainer”; long-term investor emphasizing that AI will be central over the next decade and that drawdowns are psychologically difficult but manageable.
Market structure is less diversified and more flow/quant-driven, increasing volatility. Walmart/defensive stocks trade at very rich multiples (e.g., Walmart ~46x earnings) because investors buy low-volatility defensives during selloffs. AI infrastructure (e.g., Nvidia) is “as cheap as ever” versus 2022, but newer, pre-earnings competitors are more “bubbly.” In the long run, stock prices follow free cash flow per share; volatility is noise. Capital-market “why isn’t PE taking these private?” is puzzling.
Nvidia vs Walmart/Procter & Gamble/Costco; AI infrastructure drawdowns (AI infra down ~35% in a month); SaaS apocalypse last year (names down ~35%, then ~50% from highs); Amazon’s ~90% drawdown in 2000; Berkshire’s SPLB referenced.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes.
Discussion on the current state of the markets and investor concerns.
“We're getting the band back together on this one.”
Exploring how market structures have evolved and their impact.
“long-term thinking perspective, but midterms, market chaos.”
Assessing the value and prospects of tech stocks in the current environment.
“That doesn't make it easy to go through, but we understand why it's behaving that way.”
Strategies for navigating investments amid market volatility.
“Well, I mean, we were just kind of talking about the banality of markets before you jumped on, Chris.”
Exploring the psychological factors affecting investor behavior.
“I mean, it's already moved as Chris pointed out.”
Discussing how to remain focused on long-term investment objectives despite short-term market fears.
“And all of a sudden, they'll be on the offensive side of the board.”
Reflecting on investment principles and the nature of capitalism.
“Everyone thinks they're a smart, savvy, long-term investor until they go through a 50 % drawdown.”
Explore the relationship between stock prices, free cash flow, and market dynamics.
“That's the whole thing about capitalism.”
Discuss generational shifts in investment philosophy and media representation.
“There's all these periods, there's retail versus professional and all these layers.”
Reflect on the influences of Warren Buffett and address common misconceptions about investment success.
“I guess it was kind of the late 80s, you know, before it became financial...”
Discussion about the challenges of writing a book and the misconceptions about profit from it.
“details that I remember are scary, like specific things that I remember.”
Using the metaphor of detectives to discuss how to approach stock analysis dispassionately.
“But what was always great about Holmes reading the short stories in the novels was how dispassionate he was about the investigation.”
Exploring how past winners can teach important lessons, including the risks of complacency.
“I'd have to throw in Raymond Chandler's and then Dashiell Hammett in there.”
Discussing surprises in the market and how quick changes can impact investment decisions.
“and late to make move, make the move if you have to.”
Analyzing winners and their performance over time to understand drawdowns and successes.
“Both of you hold your stocks for a long time.”
Strategies for dealing with market fluctuations and maintaining perspective on investments.
“So with that as an overlay, you know, when you get into periods like this and you're going through downtimes and stuff like that, we recall that research.”
Discussion on the impact of indexing and market changes on the evolution of investing practices.
“Uh, if you don't have that, then you're going to be completely lost when they, when those drawdowns come, you're going to be reacting to the price, reacting to what other people say.”
Explore the debate on indexing versus stock picking and the impact of market evolution on investment strategies.
“You need to get to church, get to the pew and hear what the CEO is saying, right?”
Analyze market reactions to volatility and how they influence investment decisions and strategies.
“We're talking a lot about the price action today.”
The speakers discuss the potential of AI, contrasting skepticism with optimism about its future adoption and implications for investment.
“We're typically looking to add things at the bottom that are big discounts that have the same economic returns if not better.”
The discussion highlights the AI industry's public relations issues and the need for clearer communication from corporate leaders about returns on investment.
“I want to land this on this one, which is a little bit forward looking in it.”
The hosts delve into the significance of data centers for the economy and the challenges they face, including power supply and local perceptions.
“There's a big lack of faith in AI right now.”
A conversation about the future of data centers, their economic viability, and the bottlenecks in powering them, reflecting on the societal implications.
“I think this is why it's important to have a conversation like this with a long-term perspective now when this is going on.”

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.
On Excess Returns, what are the key points of this episode?
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.
0:00This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
0:31Whoever said good things come to those who wait, never shop Black Friday early at Lowe's. Right now, get up to 50 % off select major appliances. Plus, get free delivery, free haul-away, and free basic installation and parts when you spend$896 or more on select major appliances. Shop Black Friday early in-store and online now at Lowe's. Valid through 12-2 while supplies last. Selection varies by location. See associate at lowes.com for details.
1:22Thank you.
1:29You're watching Excess Returns, a channel that makes complex investing ideas simple enough to actually use where better questions lead to better decisions. I'm Matt Ziegler, Bogomil Baranowski, Talking Billions. Send a co-host seat with me. This is 100 Year Thinkers. We're getting the band back together on this one. We've got Robert Hackstrom of the Warren Buffett Way, CIO in Equity Compass. Say hello, Robert. Hey. Good afternoon, everyone. And of course, we've also got Chris Mayer, resident 100-baggage-splainer. co-founder Woodlock House Family Capital. How you doing, Chris? Hello, everybody.
2:02Good. Very good. All right. Well, you know, nothing's going on in the world of markets. I feel like you just call this a wrap, go back to sleep. Just another boring day. Just another boring day on just another boring week. So 100-year thinkers. So this is for a long-term thinking perspective, but midterms, market chaos. I mean, we're here on the 5th of November, the NASDAQ's getting wrecked today. You're long-term thinkers. Robert, you stressed about anything? You care at all? You making any adjustments on this? How are you interpreting a wild week like we're living through right now? Well, I think we've kind of come around to the recognition that the structure of markets, and we've talked about this before, guys.
2:42I mean, the structure of markets are very, very different today. The players are different. The species are different. The assets under management are different. You know, hedge funds are, what, five trillion today. How bad if you kind of picked inside the, you know, the pod shops are, I don't know, 350 billion, but they're trading like banshees every single day. Notional value of stock options are greater today than what we're actually trading on a day-to-day basis. So, you know, the market is, I don't think the market's very diversified in an efficient sense that we've got smart people, dumb people, we've got, you know, fundamentalists, we've got quantitative.
3:20It's not a fully diversified market. And what you have here is that the market loses its diversity, and when it loses its diversity and goes to one side, the volatility goes up. So we understand it. I mean, we understand what's going on simply by looking at structures and markets. That doesn't make it easy to go through, but we understand why it's behaving that way. Chris, any thought from you on this? yeah i mean i you know i've been going through this in the last year where it feels like markets kind of been broken in a way where things are trading you know just based on big flows of money coming in and out as robert's alluding to and seem unmoored from their financials and so you know uh i haven't really done much at all with the portfolio just sort of written everything out as you'd expect, but your point was specifically about midterms.
4:14And normally you would say, no, but we've had such tremendous volatility. And just looking at some of this AI infrastructure stocks, semis and things, things are down 35 % a month. Yep. So yeah, you can't help but take a look at that, right? So it's another one of those probably baby being thrown out with the bathwater mold. So we had this last year with SAS and we talked about software, I remember. And, you know, I was in the position then of having my babies thrown out with the bathwater, but they have come back and are now green. So now maybe this is the turn for the AI infrastructure stock.
4:53So certainly there's got to be something in there that's worth it, I think, for sure. Well, speaking of AI infrastructure, before we press record, Robert, you had a question about one of the players in the space, NVIDIA. Oh, yeah. Well, I mean, we were just kind of talking about the banality of markets before you jumped on, Chris. And one of the things that when you know that people are making decisions not on a fundamental basis, but on how does the stock behave basis. So that's kind of security analysis versus business fundamentals. Explain to me why NVIDIA and, you know, my guess is NVIDIA will be around for quite some time.
5:34And we can argue about what the returns on capital are going to be, what the growth rates are. But let's just say they earn above the cost of capital. And let's just say they're going to grow revenues at 10 % for the next 10 years. That stock today is trading at 19 times. Or I can go buy Walmart today that's growing at 5 % with much lower returns on capital for 46 times four earnings. Now, why is Walmart going up, Procter & Gamble going up, Colgate going up, Costco, all of them trading extremely rich relative to their fundamental value is because when markets sell off, you buy low volatility stocks.
6:13You buy defensive positions. And so it's not surprising at all that if you're going to flush down the tech space, you turn to the other side of the screen and you see the S &P, high dividend mobility index, it's through the roof. You see SPLB, which Berkshire's the number one holding, it's through the roof. So the offensive side of the board moves to the defense and they typically will buy things without thinking about whether they're undervalued or not. It's just that I'm going to own them because they're not going to go down a lot over the next few days and the next week or two, buy things that don't go down.
6:46And that's what the market's been doing over the last couple of days is buying things that don't go down. And so it's going to set up, as Chris points out, it's going to set up some very interesting dynamics where the reverse trade is you should be selling your consumer staples in here and you should be leaning into tech. Now, the timing of that is always a million dollar question, but that is probably the most thoughtful strategy is to lighten your staples and move into tech because it's already changed. I mean, it's already moved as Chris pointed out. Well, luckily, we have world-class day trader here, Chris Mayer.
7:19Chris. Yeah. Right. What about you? How are you making sense? That's the thing. Like, you think about a lot of this stuff happening is, of course, very short-term focus. But nonetheless, I mean, if you just take a step back, I think it's, I feel highly confident saying that AI technology in some form is going to be here in 10 years from now, and it's going to be used much more heavily than it is now. The other trajectory from here to there is what's going to be crazy. So you have that backdrop. Surely there are some very good businesses out there that are, you know, sort of like, I mean, remember, we've been through past bubbles of drawdowns.
7:55I mean, Amazon went down 90 some percent in 2000. Think about that, where it is now, or, you know, one of any number of other corrections and drawdowns. So what we're seeing is not really anything unusual. It always feels awful and different when you're going through it. But I think, you know, 10 years from now, it'll probably be pretty obvious. People will look back and say, wow, why didn't they buy, you know, X, Y, and Z? But it seemed like the AI infrastructure was obvious. Well, Chris, you know, my pushback on that would be, well, tell me what you take from sales and earnings. And even if you want to dial down your revenue growth rate or your earnings growth rate, and you may want to adjust your returns on capital, whatever the case may be.
8:31But at least you have a fundamental basket to work with to be able to draw some sense of probabilities about what you think it's worth. What I see in that space that I'm looking at is these things are as cheap as I've ever said. You'd have to go back to 2022 to start it. Now, there are some new kits on the block. The NeoCloud, the new people that don't have a head that, you know, tapped into the capital markets to grow new businesses and new data centers that aren't AWS, aren't, you know, aren't Google, aren't, you know, Azure. The new guys, they're going to get their head handed to you because they don't have any earnings yet.
9:10So those are the ones that are more bubblicious in my mind. But I don't think Amazon is in a bubble. I don't think Google is in a bubble. I don't think, you know, Apple is getting a little rich. But, you know, I don't think Nvidia's in a bubble. You know, it's just right now the story has changed and the narrative has changed. And what often happens in markets, particularly on the quant side, the technical side and stuff like it, is when they speak in stories, exaggerations can get pretty extended. But if you start to do the work, you'd have to say, you know, this doesn't look that expensive to me or this looks kind of undervalued.
9:46But the timing of when to get back into it, as Chris well knows, this whole, you know, catch the falling knife is very, very tricky. And Chris, I will tell you, I've gone on record. When this thing changes, it'll change within 24 hours. The change will be vicious. It'll be swift. It'll happen in seconds. And these guys will move computers. And all of a sudden, they'll be on the offensive side of the board. and everybody else that went defensive will be behind two or three days before they finally figure out, well, maybe I should own a data center after a while. So that's how quick the market will take.
10:19That's the extremes inside the psychology of markets. Obviously, I remember, you can go to the SaaS apocalypse last year, after some 35 % drop in some of those names, I was thinking, well, surely that's got to be it. You don't know. They went down 50%, 16 % from their highs. And some of those names were up 100 % from their lows. So the psychology is what makes it very difficult at taxing. And that's stuff that I don't really care that much about. You know, I'm thinking I'm gonna own something for a decade and just gonna have to suffer through these things. And I mainly try to continue to bring that message to my LPs and to understand, yeah, this is what's happening.
10:57This is what's happening. So that nobody, you know, makes the mistake of pulling out an inopportune dime. That's really something that I think that's the main function of us is what we can do as money managers is keeping people from pulling out at the wrong time. What 100 % said, Chris, and I guess maybe that's where my frustration lies is that this level of volatility creates a great deal of anxiety, even in some of our smartest investors. Guys that are really good, girls that are really good. They've been at it for a while. They've done it for 10 or 12 years. But, you know, even them, even them, you would think they would hold up better.
11:31They get nervous. This is wobbly. This is tough. You know, the phone rings a little bit more often when you've got these three sigma events going on and things are moving around. And I feel bad. I feel bad for, you know, your limited partners and for my advisors that the phones are ringing because this volatility creates a lot of angst. Even in a very seasoned investors, it creates anxiety. Yeah, I have a friend of mine who likes to say everybody's a retail investor at the end of the day. Everybody's a retail investor. Now that's probably unfair to the retail investor because as you know, the stats on some of the retail investors is actually better, you know, as far as holding things.
12:06But the joke is that everybody, it's kind of like a variant of a, you know, everybody's got a plan until they're hitting the mouth. Yeah. And it's the same thing. Everyone thinks they're a smart, savvy, long-term investor until they go through a 50 % drawdown. Then we'll see. Yeah. Yeah, I totally agree. I totally agree. It creates a lot of unnecessary angst. And this is where it becomes, you know, a real test of whether you put the money aside to invest over, say, a 10-year period of time. You know, then you shouldn't really concern yourself much with what the short-term outcomes are. But it's not worrying at all.
12:42Yeah. Would Charlie say that, you know, if you're going to do this over your career, you ought to be able to look at 50 % drawdowns a half a dozen times over your career and be able to treat each one of them with equanimity? He just really don't care, you know. Well, that's good in writing, and that's good in theory, and that's good in logic and all that other stuff. And maybe if you were able to manage your own money, it's also good. But when you're managing it for other people, it would be great, right? But, you know, it's a challenge. But Chip Mason, founder of Leg Mason, said to us one time, he goes, you know, you guys have got it so easy.
13:1470%, 80 % of the time, you know, you're just whistling down the sidewalk having a great old time. And about 20 % to 30 % of the time, it's hard. That's not a bad job. 70 to 80 % of the time, you're like, this is great. I feel like Frank Sinatra. This is no big deal. I've got this all figured out. And then 20 to 30 % of the time, you actually have to work hard for a living. And we're just in one of those periods where we've got to work hard for a living. Hard is relative. I mean, we're not shoveling coal or doing something like that. It's mostly a mind game. That's Frank Sinatra with a hangover.
13:48Territory. so i have to ask you this ben graham told us about the voting machine and the weighing machine yeah listening to you both i feel like we've been watching a voting machine for a while do you still both believe that it is a weighing machine in the long run something changed and it became a voting machine i would say yeah yeah i still think the uh the north star is the stock prices actually follow that free cash flow per share and returns and i mean the day i stopped believing that is the day i have to hang it up as a money manager that's yeah that's it that's it and yeah absolutely okay of course during times like this you always like question your sanity and you know look at your own approach and you know where you get it wrong or maybe specifically your names you made mistakes on but the general approach yeah the general north star is still stock price is going to follow that free cash flow growth uh even though there'll be volatility along that way Yeah, I think Chris has got it right.
14:45That's the whole thing about capitalism. As a preface, I would say, Charlie said, the essence of capitalism is that it creates new boats by destroying old boats. and so you know there's for a growth investor that's kind of what we think about which is okay who's coming on who's going to do really well and then who's at risk right so we know there's going to be a change in the lineup right um and and so we we think about that you know you know pretty hard all the time which is this change of the lineup that goes on there the other part is the reason why capitalism work is that there should be a price i'd like to hear Chris weigh in on this.
15:21There should be a price at which these things go down. Now, maybe you can't LBO a trillion-dollar business, but you can LBO today$50 billion businesses,$100 billion businesses. What I'm trying to figure out is that these things are so cheap in some spaces that people slam the table and say, you know, when value investing returns to the market, we're going to make a lot of money. And I said, well, what do you think is undervalued? And they'll say, well, XYZ is undervalued and the cash is this. And I said, okay, that sounds pretty key. Why isn't a private equity firm looking at them? Why isn't management LB owned the company?
15:56It's not like we're lacking capital. We got plenty of capital. That's not the problem. Again, you know, the reason is what the missing piece for me, Chris, is that everybody keeps boning and bedoning tech is doing this and other things are getting left behind and all these other stocks are being underserved, underowned. I thought, well, yeah, okay, that happens all the time. But the capitalist system should write that by having management go out and say, well, I can borrow at 7 % and, you know, my returns on capital are 15 to 20%. I can make a go of this, take it private. But you just don't see that.
16:29And that's real puzzling to me. That's real puzzling. Yeah. I mean, that's an interesting point. I mean, because the usual mechanisms you have to keep things you know in bounds like on a smaller company like you said you get so cheap then eventually some private buyer strategic buyer comes along and yeah well we'll take it yeah or uh failing that then at least uh you know we have management companies that can be opportunistic with capital and they can start buying back shares and sure i've seen that happen with a couple of my names where they've gone through drawdowns and the management teams um you know been buying back stock so you know that that we'd love to see that you know that's what you want to see and but when you get to be really big obviously you know like you mentioned when you get to be a trillion dollar market cap you don't have those normal uh guardrails that become sort of theoretical at that point unless of course they can always decide to buy back a bunch of stock but maybe that's probably not the best use even at this drawdown compared to the incremental returns they get now in their businesses good point yeah it is an interesting conundrum and i think uh yeah, without those anchors, I mean, the short term, like we're talking about, they can be extreme.
17:36I mean, variations can be extreme. And we've seen this in other markets. We've got a lot of really difficult times here where stocks can trade for net cash or absurd, ridiculous things. I mean, back on. But in the long, longer term, markets kind of sort that out. So we'll see. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast.
18:14Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
18:23You know you don't have to wait to shop Black Friday at Lowe's, right? Save up to$150 now and select power tools, equipment, and accessories. Got gifts to get? We've got plenty under$50. Plus, MyLowe's Rewards members get same-day delivery for free. Shop Black Friday deals before the rush at Lowe's. Valid through 1118,$25 minimum and loyalty membership acquired. Order eligible items by 2 p.m. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. terms at lowes.com slash shipping terms. I want to talk a little bit about, because there's these generational shifts that we're talking about inside of this too.
18:59There's when value was in vogue, when it wasn't in vogue. There's all these periods, there's retail versus professional and all these layers. And I know you've both unpacked this in your own experiences some. Chris, there's something that you've written about in your stories where like your dad worked at Geico, right your dad met Buffett yep so your dad meets Buffett thinks of Buffett in a very different way than you think about Buffett and some of these skill sets right like different understandings well I mean um I don't know yeah I mean I think I've told that story before like well you know when I was a teenager my dad worked for Geico and I heard stories about Buffett you know making his trek down to meet Lorman Davidson on that Saturday afternoon or morning wherever it was and and uh My dad had a subscription to Fortune magazine, and I remember this was like the late 80s, 90s.
19:51I'm reading Carol Loomis and Warren Buffett. She wrote some of her landmark pieces during that period of time. That's why when I wanted to study finance, the only person I could think of that I knew was an investor, really, Buffett. This was after the 87 crash. I was like 15 years old at the 87 crash, and I thought, wow, this thing is amazing. All these people losing money, making money. I was interested in all that, and that set me on the path. So I don't know how that ties in specifically what you were asking, but I mean, yeah, Warren Buffett has been an influence for me from the very beginning as a investor.
20:25What do you think for Lord's Stars today, I guess? I look at volatility. I look at how weird this all feels. The market just feels weird for the last year. It does. Who are people looking up to that it's... Yeah. Does that person exist in the world? We don't have somebody like that anymore. We don't have a Warren Buffett. Is that a bad thing? Well, I mean, look at who's the lineup on the talking shows, right? Who do they get on the talking shows? Very rarely is it a long, lonely equity manager with a 15 % turnover ratio. I mean, it's like watching Alistair Cook on Masterpiece Theater, public broadcasting.
21:01You know, it's kind of really, you know, so the people that get the, you know, the bandwidth with in the airtime are typically traders, you know, hedge fund guys, the millennial, you know, whoever the case may be, you know, they need action to sell eyeballs. And Chris and I, I don't think would be very good guests on fast money every week. What do you find tomorrow? You know, it would not be a good fit for us. Are you telling me the slow money rankings would be low? We would have been, you know, watching paint dry type stocks. But I think the market is filled to the brim with everybody that's going to tell you what's going to happen tomorrow.
21:41Never mind that there is absolutely no science whatsoever that's available that can give you any idea of what the complex adaptive system will do tomorrow, three days from now, five days from now, a month from now, two months from now. You don't know. But, you know, they're happy to put you on TV and have you prognosticate about what you think you're going to, you know, what's going to go on in the market. And guess what? It's sales. You know, you get eyeballs. You get advertising revenue. They love that craft. So that's what feeds the talk shows. And I would say that it's always been that way.
22:11Like, we were spoiled with Warren Buffett for that period of time. But before he came on the scene, there was nobody like that before. There was nobody who was a Warren Buffett before Warren Buffett. There was no voice of long-term reason that gave the calming words in times of trouble or wrote the influential piece in New York Times. There was nobody like that. So I think we kind of got spoiled having Buffett mung around. I think we do miss him. I would, from, you know, Templeton and his day would come on. You remember Louis Rukeyser? I don't know what you guys would say. Louis Rukeyser shows.
22:39But, you know, Wall Street would have a panel on Friday night. And usually there was three guys, and it was a half an hour program. And they'd sit around for, you know, the first 15 minutes and generally talk about markets. But that always seemed to be sensible to me. It always seemed to make a lot of sense. And then the guest typically was, you know, like a Peter Lynch or a John Templeton or somebody, you know, not equal to Buffett, but of Buffett ilk. you know, a celebrated, long-only manager. And that was Louis Rukeyser, for the most part. And then... I think Phil Correa made a show appearance on that show, too, didn't he?
23:12Who did that? Phil, Phil Correa. Yeah, yeah, yes. I believe he did as well. Those were the... That was Camelot, right? Those were the golden years. Then when the Financial News Network started, I guess it was kind of the late 80s, you know, before it became financial... And, you know, CNBC, it was Mark Haynes, that he's Sue Herrera and David Faber and Joe Kennan, you know, they had to put on a production all day long. And, you know, you needed mouthpiece. So you weren't doing 30 minutes once a day on the markets and how to think about stocks and businesses. You had to fill up the airtime, you know, from 8 o 'clock in the morning until 6 o 'clock at night.
23:51And the only way that you would ever get any, you know, consumers to watch your program is you had to have activity. You had to have drama. You had to have volatility. You had to have, you know, shake and bake going on because if not, nobody's going to sit around and listen to John Templeton for six hours a day. It's just not. That's not how TB worked. People are looking up to the both of you because of your books. They have exposure to your ideas. I think Matt and I are looking up to the both of you. At least I'm sure many play the audience. So I'm curious. I'll ask you. On the screen right now, you guys are above us and kind of looking down.
24:28I was going to say, I actually am looking down in this view. You can look down, very much down. But I'm curious, people get to know you also for this podcast, but what do they get wrong about both of you just because they know you for the books that, let's start with Chris. Oh, let's start with Robert on that. Okay, let's start with Robert on this. All right, well, it's interesting. I think about this quite a lot. I think, you know, the blessings that I have gotten and that Warren allowed me to have by quoting him in the book way back in the beginning when he didn't like, you know, people quoting him that often.
25:04You know, what Warren Bucket way and what portfolio and Charlie and, you know, all of them. You just cannot, I cannot express in words, you know, how much that is meant to my career. I think, though, because it has been so celebrated, that people think of me first and foremost as a writer and an author and don't think of me as a competitive professional investor. And that's what I am. I mean, I wrote the books to basically become a better investor, right? The idea was, and somebody said to me, well, if you wrote a book about Mozart, you're never going to learn how to play piano like Mozart. I said, well, that's not the point of the argument.
25:41If you read a book about most of them, you might become a better piano player than you were beforehand. But, you know, you may not be Mozart-like. So they said, well, you'll never be Buffett. I said, of course I'll never be Buffett. But can I be a better investor by writing? So I think people don't recognize in me that I am hugely competitive. I am hugely wanting to generate returns based on this methodology that Chris and I believe in so pertly that this is the right way to invest. that I'm hugely competitive. I have a, if you go back and look at a couple of the episodes when I'm in my office outside of Philadelphia, I have a wooden pig, corved pig, on my back.
26:22Phil. And nobody's ever asked me about that. I was wondering when one of you guys were going to ask me, what the heck is that pig doing on it? What is it? You're killing me right now, Robert. You're killing me. You know I wanted to ask you about this pig. Give me a story. Yeah, okay. So this pig was given to me in 1995. right after I went the Warren Bucket Way in 1994. I had done an interview in Newsweek magazine by Allen's, and Allen Sloan wrote it. And he was skeptical, as he should have been. He says, if you're going to invest with Robert Hackstrom, and the headline was, buying a pig in a poke.
26:56I don't know if you know that slang, but down in the South, you'd have a knapsack, and you'd put a pig in the knapsack, right? And you wouldn't know if that, and you'd bring it home to the wife, and that'd be dinner and she didn't know if it was a big pig or a little pig. You wouldn't know until you took it out. And so he goes, well, investing with Robert is like buying a pig in a poke. You don't know what he'd get. And I always, so that's my mascot. And he's been with me for, you know, for 35 years now. I think people don't recognize how passionately I want to do this business and how passionately I want to show you that by doing this business, you can generate better returns than the index.
27:33That's what I think people miss about it. I knew Robert would have a very good answer for that so I want him to go first good strategy good strategy no I mean what people get wrong I think uh I think like but most of the time I tell people are pretty much right I mean I've had a lot of really good encounters with readers and they sort of you know they sometimes they I guess because I have so much stuff out not just books but other interviews and podcasts that sometimes the details that I remember are scary, like specific things that I remember. But I do remember once in a while, you'll get a comment of somebody else that they'll think like, you know, I remember seeing someone when I put out Investor's Odyssey, someone made a snarky comment about it being a money grab, which I had to really give a good hard laugh at because there's no money in books.
28:18I can tell you that right now. No money. But the amount of time and effort you put into a book and the return you get is awful. It is not a good economic decision. So anybody who thinks that you are wrong 100 wrong that is not the case i want to pull another idea that's this is out of the robert robert's books and it's a metaphor here but i'm thinking about this in present markets especially that's the dejective and the investor idea and i'm thinking about this idea of going through a bad stretch now i don't even know if we can qualify the last month or quarter as a bad stretch yet historically like we're not down where we're going we're even an average for the year yet where we see a decline but i think this framework top of mind feels really valuable to me as a word mike arbor you want to just walk us through the analogy real quick but then how are you thinking about it i think i think when like you know sherlock holmes probably the most dispassionate of all of the great detectives there were three great detectives august upon who was the very first one from edgar allen poe and sherlock holmes and father brown and gilbert Keith Chesterton.
29:24But what was always great about Holmes reading the short stories in the novels was how dispassionate he was about the investigation. He had no preconceived notion. I mean, he basically, the facts ruled the day, right? He didn't automatically jump to, oh, you look suspicious. I think you're the bad guy, and I'm going to go make a case that you're the bad guy. He just basically looked upon a crime scene or suspects that might be involved and really had no organ conclusion, you know, who was responsible, what, you know, how did it occur and stuff like that. He just let the facts lead him. And I think, you know, that kind of takeaway is that, you know, sometimes we get too attracted to a stock too quickly, too early.
30:06And if that gets a hold of you, you may find yourself justifying why you should be buying this stock instead of, I don't know, you know, I try and look at each company and go, I have no idea whether to buy this stock or not, but I'm going to take a look at it and let it show me whether I should buy it, yes or no. And so instead of starting with a, I got to have this stock or this stock is running, I've got to put it in the portfolio, you know, and you talk yourself into it before you actually do the analysis, that's bad. And the great detectives didn't do that. I mean, they basically came upon the scene with no preconceived notions and just let the facts carry the day.
30:41And so that's what we try to do. And that was helpful in writing the book, was just trying to stay dispassionate about a stock when you're looking at it. I'd have to throw in Raymond Chandler's and then Dashiell Hammett in there. The multi-stop has great detectives. No, but I think that's definitely right. Yeah, there was a guy, I'll think of the detective coming back. Otto Penzler ran the Noter Bookstore in Manhattan. And it was a very famous bookstore and it did nothing but detectives. And I said, well, who were the great detectives? And he said it was, you know, Poe, it was Augusta Pound and Sherlock and stuff like that.
31:17And he did say that he thought Perot and Agatha Christie. And I said, why? And he goes, well, they all solved their mysteries by mental acumen. And he goes, when you mention, you know, Chandler and all the rest of them, well, it doesn't count when you can pistol whip a confession out of something. That's not the same strategy that you're supposed to be using in stocks, you know. But the great detectives just use the brain, you know, And they just kind of solve a mystery, find a mental acumen at that. And I always thought that was pretty clever. That shows my inspector gadget theory. I mean, that's right out the window.
31:49I was going to say to your point, Robert, you know, I also think like you were talking about, you know, not rushing in and pretty much trying to be dispassionate. And I think that's something I always remind myself and I tell other people, well, like never be in a rush when it comes to the doctor. It'll be there tomorrow. It'll be there day after, week after, on and on. You know, you do research on these winners. I mean, you know, you could buy them at their 50-to-week high month after month, you know, for many months and still do very, very well. So it's not, if you take a long-term view, it's not that important, you know, the day-to-day and the week-to-week.
32:20Yeah. Chris, you brought up winners, and I'm curious, has there been a big winner that ever taught you the wrong lessons, one that worked for reasons that you didn't fully understand? um i don't know about fully understand but certainly there's lots there's cases where you know i've had winners where you get a little lax on it i'm sure this is uh this is something that like just hard hard to fight against because naturally you as a money manager you spend more time with the things that seem to be struggling or there seems to be some risk or and you don't spend as much time on a thing that's just humming along and, and, and, uh, you know, flying along and, and bringing out quarter after quarter of great results.
33:04But, uh, you have to also pay attention there. So certainly I could think of instances where, you know, a stuff that has done well for a long time, you get lazy with it and then something changes and, uh, you're a little late to the party as far as getting it, um, and late to make move, make the move if you have to. So yeah, that's something tough to solve. Robert, what do you think about studying those winners? I, you know, I do, I, um, I was trying to think when you, when that question came up, I was trying to think about really how to answer that question. I guess with, with, when you buy a stock, I'm really surprised by something that came out of left field.
33:45Now, you know, I, I, those don't see, I don't seem to get those. Now, what I do get is things that are coming out of left field that are now going to hurt my business. And we've talked about this before, which I've spent all my time just thinking about who can take my business away. How does this, is NVIDIA not going to earn its cost of capital five years from now? And if so, why? So you kind of go through that. And I've certainly had a boatload of those. I mean, we've seen mistakes happen in the portfolio. And we talked about how we cut and go and move on. I don't think I've ever had a surprise that this popped up out of nowhere.
34:27I would say when we bought Navidi in October, we knew that AI was coming along. And the work we'd done at Santa Fe and other places was, yeah, AI was, it's probably going to be here sooner than later. I just didn't expect it to be here in six weeks after I bought it. Now, that's called luck. We can buy a stock and six weeks later, the leader in that new technological revolution you happen to buy six weeks earlier, that's just plague a lot. And that doesn't happen to me that often. But that was one case where something unexpected happened very quickly that I didn't expect was going to happen that quick.
35:01Yeah. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
35:33You know you don't have to wait to shop Black Friday at Lowe's, right? Save up to$150 now and select power tools, equipment, and accessories. Got gifts to get? We've got plenty under$50. Plus, MyLow's Rewards members get same-day delivery for free. Shop Black Friday deals before the rush at Lowe's. Valid through 1118,$25 minimum, and loyalty membership acquired. Order eligible items by 2 p.m. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. Terms at lowes.com slash shipping terms. Both of you hold your stocks for a long time. And from my experience, I can tell that the companies continue to surprise me.
36:11Obviously, there are negative things, but they also surprise them the positives. And I didn't even think that they would have another product line. I didn't even think they would enter the new market, right? So I imagine that there are those situations. I'm curious, should we study our winners as skeptically as our mistakes to learn from them? Sure. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, that gets to what I was saying before is that you can kind of get lulled into, you know, a little bit of false sense of security because they've done so well for you for so long. But you have to study those just as critically.
36:44I think that, again, psychologically, that's harder to do, but you have to do it. Put yourself in the shoes. Oh, go ahead. Yeah, no, I would just, you know, follow up on that. we've looked at our, you know, we have six, seven, eight stocks in a portfolio that we've had 12 years, you know, something like that, maybe, maybe four for 12 years and the other two or three for, you know, coming on 10 years. And, and they've worked out extremely well, but we spent a lot of time kind of going back through those stocks and looking at how they behaved over that period of time. So I think I mentioned, uh, you know, on the podcast before that even though, you know, we crossed our 12 years and, you know, one, three, five, seven, you know, whatever, you know, We beat the market.
37:24We beat our index. We're doing just fine. But the frequency of our outperformance, which then correlates to the frequency of the outperformance of the individual stocks in the portfolio. All of my winners basically only outperformed the market 50 % of the time. And they basically will only outperform the quarter, maybe two thirds of the time. And on an annual basis, you know, three quarters of the time. So what we began to learn from a lot of that was you could have a really good stock and it go in and we actually look at drawdowns We'll look at how long you went negative and stuff like that But I think we we look at stocks that have been successful for us and then go back and look and see their trading history that there are As Chris points out there are drawdowns.
38:06There are periods when you're underperforming there are periods But you've held that stock for 10 years because it did xyz and its revenues and earnings and your price appreciation over that time period has paid you extremely well for dealing with that periodic underperformance. So with that as an overlay, you know, when you get into periods like this and you're going through downtimes and stuff like that, we recall that research. It reminds us that even the best of the companies are not always going to shine every month, every quarter, every year. Chris, if you're looking, I know this is not your day job or anything I'm asking you about in your life, but I think it's important for people to hear this.
38:47And I wonder how you think of it. You look at your portfolio today, or you look at your portfolio this month. You look at your portfolio in the middle of the SaaS apocalypse situation a year ago. How do you judge your prior winners and your current losers and currently frustrations? How do you do that in real time? Well, I mean, he just suffered through it. I mean, the thing is, there's no magic bullet about any of that. So it's like, you know, you know the business is well enough, hopefully. So a lot of it's like preparation. Why do we study these businesses so carefully to begin with? And not necessarily, you know, I've said this before, but it's not necessarily you're going to find something that the market doesn't know about.
39:28You know, what you're really doing is you're building up your own knowledge and your own expertise so that when something happens down the road, you can make an intelligent decision about it one way or the other. So when these things happen and the market can freak out, stock drops a bunch, you can hopefully make a more intelligent form decision about whether this is just a passing thing. And then you're going to go ahead and zoom on upward or whether something has really changed with the business that you need to think about, you know, whether it's time to exit or whatever. So all that comes from what you've studied beforehand.
40:03beforehand. So what, so what you do in real time is you're really recalling and banking on all that research work you've done already. Uh, if you don't have that, then you're going to be completely lost when they, when those drawdowns come, you're going to be reacting to the price, reacting to what other people say. You'll be taking the Twitter to see what other people are thinking or whatever it is. Um, and you won't have that compassionate maintenance. And that's really, that's how you, you get through, you get through these periods. That work has to be done already. Robert, with you, you're doing it with advisors and clients.
40:35How do you? Well, I think when we look at, when I'm looking at prices, you know, changing every day, I kind of think about who do I think is changing those prices and for what reasons and objectives they have that may be different than mine. So it's kind of easy sometimes when you can, you can see the quants and the others infiltrating the market, you know, okay, you go, well, I'm in the jungle now and the species has changed and here's the big gorilla and he's going to swing and he's going to change prices a lot but you know that doesn't have anything to do with my company the way that i kind of offset that is that i did and i've said this before i just spend as much time as i can reading transcripts of calls reading conferences there's their services out there now that can track conferences for you you can put your portfolio into a app now they can tell you what conference they're in they'll give you the transcript of the conference they'll give you the Q &A of the conference.
41:26You obviously get that in quarterly calls as well. I found that to be very soothing, Chris, that, you know, on a day like today, probably tonight, I'll try to go through a couple of transcripts of the companies that have just reported again, you know, and just kind of go through and say, speak to me, speak to me, Mr. Manager, speak to me, Mr. CEO, speak to me, Mr. CFO. What do you see in your business? And when I hear them talk to me or I read their transcripts or things of that nature. I can then go back to the stock market and look at the prices and not be as upset about it as I wouldn't have been had I not spent the time reading about the company.
42:05So it's almost like going to church. You need to get to church, get to the pew and hear what the CEO is saying, right? And then does that make sense to you? And does that all follow pretty rational thinking? And if it does, then you look back at the stock market and you go, boy, this was of Tilly-ass day. You know, the hooligans were out there trading their asses off today and, you know, this is what we got for it. But that's how I kind of offset that. You know, listening to you, Bo, and you have concentrated portfolios, I'm thinking of picking winners over a long period of time. Indexing is taking over the market.
42:40Robert, you were talking about bots and algos. When you're thinking about evolution, evolution came up as a topic throughout these conversations. Do you think that the end goal, evolution as investors, reasons for all of us to index. Well, I, when, yeah, I thought about that as well. And I think indexing would be the antithesis of the evolutionary state of markets. I think what it would index does, I think it'd be kind of fortunate, but yet Warren said one time, he goes, you know, if I was offered all the companies in Omaha, the gas station, the restaurant, the, you know, the dress shop, you know, whatever they do, the farm is, I mean, I wouldn't own all of them.
43:17I would try to find the ones that really had good economic returns that were managed by people that were kind of really, really smart. But I wouldn't think about giving my money to every single business in Omaha. That's kind of the way I think about index. Why would I give all people? Now some of it is cap weight and you've got to think about that, but I wouldn't, I just think that the evolutionary nature of markets, why would you not be a stock picker? because that is the best way in which to generate XRS returns from a market that is evolving. You know, evolution is a constant in markets. And so I want that.
43:52Well, I can think of one reason. I can think of one reason why you wouldn't. What's that? Yeah. Well, if you just didn't want to, and people would say you're a doctor or a lawyer, you got some other business that you don't want to be involved in. Yeah. I think that's really the appeal, right? Is the indexing. Yeah, well, that's Buffett's appeal. Exactly. You're a guaranteed average, right? And average is not so bad. So, well, you know, and to his point, if you look at the SPIVA index, which is the S &P index versus active managers, go back 20 years on it. Just by, as Warren says, if you bought an index fund, you would have outperformed, you know, 85 to 90 percent of the professional investors over the last 20 years.
44:26Just knowing that, yeah, I get it like people would do index, you know. I know that why you would index. But if you, as Bob said, if you're a no something investor and you want to get into the game, then you don't want to be in an index fund. You want to pick the best businesses that are priced attractively, that have good sustainable returns. And that will be your biggest returns in your portfolio. So why wouldn't you do that as opposed to only 500 companies or something? And I think if this was, I don't know if this was Joel Replatt's story or Buffett's story, I don't remember. But the anecdote was, like, if you had a million dollars, let's say you sold a business, you had a million dollars, and you went in your town and you just sort of studied the businesses in your town, and you pick five or six of them and put a little money in each of those five or six, everybody would say you were very prudent and how wise that was.
45:15What are you doing in the stock market? And people are like, whoa, that's a lot of risk, everybody. So you hit it right on the nail. And there's the Buffett mystique, which is Buffett's success is largely because I think he both had the experience of owning companies and owning common stocks at the same time. And he decided at that earliest stage, back in the 50s, that he would analyze them in the same way. He would treat them in the same way. And that became the backbone of fracture. And then Charlie refined that over time. And, you know, it all worked out extremely well. But you're right, Chris, that is totally logical, totally rational.
45:56And had you done that with private business, they'd go, way to go, Chris. You're going to make a mitt. but if you own 10 stocks, they think that you're a very risky person and that you're misbehaving. That is some law. And that's the essence of modern portfolio theory that makes you think about that. And modern portfolio theory is what drives the returns of most active managers that are underperforming the market for 20 years. So once again, I don't know why we're spending so much time on modern portfolio theory, but it's still really the roost when it comes to long-lowly managers to the most part.
46:31So just a little bit of a taste of volatility so far in the recent weeks here. How much are you excited by some of the negative breadth, the volatility, the stuff that's gotten cheaper right now versus how much more is it heady? To you, Chris, with how you're looking at your portfolio. Well, I mean, it's a bit of both, right? I mean, we talked about earlier why it's a headache. And that is that, you know, it creates some anxiety in your LP base when you get this kind of, when you get a lot of volatility like that. I wouldn't say I'm necessarily excited because I try and knock the patient. I try to, you know, foster this very even keel, whether it's up or whether it's down.
47:11I try to be very level about it and just, you know, try to continue to treat it just very businesslike way. Get the results, keep, you know, analyzing businesses, keep going on that and not, you know, react either way. Sometimes it's hard to do because, you know, I've got other friends, people I talk to, and they want to text me or, you know, well, something up this much or down that much. You know, you can't help it. Suddenly you feel some emotion kind of trigger up. But I try to fight that. So, you know, we don't know if this is any particular great moment to be excited or not. For all we know, the moment could still be six months away where you really get excited.
47:47So I'm always very, you know, kind of humble about that, too. It might seem like a great opportunity, but it might be. Might be just the beginning. Who knows? So I'd say you can be open to all those possibilities and try to keep the emotions in check. Would you say anything? Is the shopping list? Is that on your... I assume it's always on your mind. Yeah, you always have... I don't know, Robert, you probably have this as well. But you always have kind of a shopping list. You know, you have a watch list of companies that you sort of follow and you've got kind of funnel. And then you've got maybe a handful of things or five to ten things that you really like and would love going if you get a shot.
48:24absolutely you know those are the ones where you start to kid you know start getting a little excited and you get a little interested that hey you know might be close to you know i'm doing something so yeah you definitely have though you definitely have a shop at least what are you and i bet the shopping list is longer today than it was a week ago absolutely i always tell people like the amount of companies i've looked at over the last nine months is way higher than the number of companies i looked at probably two three years before that yeah and that's you know that's the volatility that creates those opportunities.
48:54One of the things that we do, Chris, in our portfolio is that, and this is all just approximations, as Bill Miller taught me, you know, our valuation models are approximations of what we think they're worth, not the exact, you know, it's a cone of uncertainty and, you know, you think it's worth somewhere between$100,$125,$150, and you're just trying to buy that at a big discount. But what we've done over the last, I guess this goes back to COVID, is that, you know, we'll do a weighted average calculation of what is the intrinsic value of the portfolio and then look at it relative to price. And we see these spikes when COVID, we got down to about 85 cents on the dollar.
49:35And that was kind of interesting to me. In the fall, September 2022, which was our worst year ever, we were down 28 % versus the F &D down 18%, our worst year of 12. We got down to about 80 cent on the dollar. And I even sent portfolio to Morningstar. You know, I thought they did an okay job in thinking about cash flows, return on capital. And I said, what do you think it's cool? And they came back and they go, I think 81, 82 cents. I said, okay, we're probably at the same rate. Today, we're worth today. We're worth today about 75 cents on the dollar. We're cheaper today than we've ever been. Now, you might say that you readjust your intrinsic values for the uncertainty of a democratic and data center problem and stuff like that, and we'll massage them again.
50:22But when I have those inflection points like that, I'm on the phone, not telling, I basically said, you should be buying me right now. But what I tell them is, whatever you do, don't sell. Because right now, it is a very attractive time. And when I did that in 2022, and we stunk up the joint, it was really hard. You know, they're like, Robert, you write books, but you don't know anything about managing money. You're, you know, you really sing. And I said, well, you know, that's fine. But, you know, it's a growth market sell-off. It just writes up 400 basis points, la-di-da-di-da. And I said, whatever you do, just don't sell.
50:56And he goes, well, Robert, we're not going to sell you. And I said, well, that's unusual because brokers always sell underperforming managers. Why aren't you selling? And they said, well, because you own Apple. And, you know, you own Louis Vuitton, you know, and you, at the time, we owned Estee Lauder. moderns, you know, she goes, they don't want to sell those businesses. And I said, exactly. That's exactly right. So we do two things. We let them know when we're real cheap and we don't pound the table every week, every month, every year. We wait until it is demonstrably in their best interest to one, not sell or two, to add to the portfolio.
51:31And if we do that systematically, which I'll probably do, we'll see how the market reacts over the next couple of weeks. But, But, you know, I would think, you know, towards the end of the year, if we're at this same level, I'm going to be telling my people, look, I don't know if you're thinking about adding or what are you thinking about doing, but this is one of the cheapest times you can buy, so you ought to be buying. Now, to Chris's point, it could be six months before we get paid for that. But I'm kind of coming around to, I don't think that CTAs are going to wait that long. I don't think the hedge funds are going to wait that long.
52:00The one thing that we do know is that speed and magnitude are way up. So the speed will come quicker and the magnitude of the change will be greater than we will ever have thought. Just as this way down has been fast and hard, I guarantee you, which we're not supposed to use that in investing, I strongly suggest to you, I strongly believe that the bounce back will be equally as fast and equally as powerful on the way back. because when the momentum guys come back in and want to get along these stocks that they crush, it's going to have the pretty fans. It's going to have the brief. This episode is brought to you by Indeed.
52:39You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.
53:29Minimum and loyalty membership acquired. Order eligible items by 2 p.m. Subject to weight and size restrictions and availability. Terms at lowes.com slash shipping terms. We're talking a lot about the price action today. I'm guessing it's inspired by what we're watching in the markets. And I like that because usually we talk about the kinds of businesses you both like to buy. We all appreciate. But I'm curious about the price element. Is the price action often a trigger for you, Chris, to buy something that you've been watching for a while? or are you willing to buy at a multi-year high and don't really care about the prices where the recent price action no i mean when you get real when you get real volatility like we've had well like i said you have things dropping 30 or 40 percent of what that's a trigger for you to kind of take a look whether you buy something or not and but um yeah i mean i think you know you certainly react to prices now have i bought things that were cruising along sure i have done that as well i mean again it's not price alone right it makes price related to okay what else is going on you know what's the your overall ir could be more attractive with a business that's about as 52 week high than something that's 52 low it doesn't they don't necessarily have to get quarterly exactly so um i would say yeah so you do react to those prices but at the end of the day it's not price alone that should make you move you know it's it's it's a combination of that price and your overall irr over however long you're looking at owning it and whether that all makes sense or not robert do you think that in moments like this the market can be more wrong because it overreacts that's where i was going with that yeah yeah i i'm i'm kind of like chris My appetite is not high when the market or the stock is at its 52-week high.
55:21I mean, being value investors, you know, we always prefer lower prices. So these lower prices get my juices flowing a lot more. I'm a little bit more, you know, focused on, okay, what are we going to be adding to the portfolio? What are we going to be buying? And we, you know, we get the list going and stuff like that. And so, yeah, I think I'm more attracted to the stocks that are going down in price and are having these big, big drawdowns. And, you know, we'll go back and look at the thesis again and what has changed and what can we quantify to the best for our ability. But like Chris, it's hard for me to buy stocks that have already run and are at the top of the page.
56:00We're typically looking to add things at the bottom that are big discounts that have the same economic returns if not better. And on days like today, there's not going to be a lot of shortage of ideas. these last few days. I would say this. If you believe AI is a scam and we're not going to use AI a year from now, five years from now, 10 years from now, and all of this is nothing but a big bubble, which we've heard discussed before, then I'm going to be wrong and probably going to be writing cookbooks when it's all said. But if you believe that AI is going to work and that it's going to be universally adopted by pretty much everybody around the world.
56:41And I want to say again, around the world, everybody's doing this. Then you got to go, boy, this is, this is a big opportunity. Now you got to pick the right, you know, not everybody, you know, as Chris pointed out, not everybody's going to get it. But believe me when I say there'll be a few that will do extremely, extremely well over the next three, five years. Of course. That's what we want to know. I think, you know, the backdrop, I've said that too, you know, the backdrop, of course, I think we're going to use AI more, but you know, there's still little parts of me that remember history and say, well, you could have said the same thing about the automobile early on.
57:15Right. And there were a hundred automobile manufacturers. And so you had to pick the right ones, you know, that, that was, that was very difficult. So yeah, you know, it may not be, I try to keep open and open mind about it. So it may not be that the opportunity is the obvious stuff that we think of, like the AI infrastructure stuff per se, it might be, might be some other business around that's going to vastly benefit from using the tools you know not necessarily be a producer of the other thing so um you know the opportunity set i think is going to be amazing but it's it could be broader than we think right now and i'm sure there'll be some surprises you know it's like yeah the internet made certain businesses better than they were before i'm sure this ai is going to make some businesses better and they're not going to be businesses that you're necessarily I got to think of right away.
58:01Yeah, I agree with that. I agree with that. I want to land this on this one, which is a little bit forward looking in it. But for both of you, when you're looking at portfolio companies, you know nobody's having a fun conversation with shareholders probably when we get around to the next earnings report and saying whatever's just been going on in the recent past. Everybody's going to have comments. What kinds of things are you looking for corporate leaders, CEOs, executives to be communicating out as how they're reading this kind of unreadable macro landscape right now. Chris, you want to go first?
58:37Yeah. Robert. First of all, let me, I would say unabashedly that I think the AI industry has done the worst job in public relations I've seen of any industry. I mean, you know, they didn't do a very good job of discussing the features and benefits to the level that would have, I think, attracted a lot more interest, attention, and confidence that this is the right thing. I think they were in such a rut. It's like the Oklahoma land rush. They were in such a rush to get the frontier models out, such a rush to be first because of network effects, whatever the case may be, that they forgot to reemphasize why this is going to be important for you, the owner of a business or the owner of a stock, whatever the case may be.
59:20And so their PR problem now is front and center. As you said, Chris, they just got punched in the face. And we'll see what plan that they have to come up with in the next earnings call. They need somebody to tell them, you know, we need to understand returns on capital. I don't know why that's so hard. Just tell me what the returns are if they're not there. Now, interesting, Michael Mobison, who I've quoted many, many times, pointed out that Walmart, and, you know, I'm obviously beating on Walmart because I think it's very expensive. Walmart, the first 18 years, had a negative free cash flow. Yeah.
59:55But it earned above its cost of capital. But Sam Walton, just like Jeff Bezos, basically took all that capital and put it right back into the company. So he never reported much in earnings and free cash flow yield because he just kept reinvesting, which is basically what I think a lot is going on with Aon. If you look at the hyperscalers, particularly Amazon, Google, they're already earning above the cost of capital on the day. But they basically are just throwing it back in there as fast as they can. So their cash flow yields turn negative, just like Walmart did. So I understand that. That's not a thought to make.
1:00:26But they're going to have to start to let people know this is sustainable, this is good, people are making profits from it, it's got economic returns. They need to get on the bully pulpit and say, this is going to work out fine, guys. This is very profitable business for us. And they need to change that narrative. Because right now, the narrative, and maybe that's justification for the stock prices being low, is about as negative as I've seen in technology since about, I don't know, October of 2000. I figured out maybe there was a bubble in the internet. I mean, this is big time that they need to get their stories straight.
1:01:03They need to get them consistent, and they need to give people reasons to have faith in AI, which is lacking. There's a big lack of faith in AI right now. It's strange, Matt, because you ask what you want your manager teams to say, kind of what you're looking for. And on the one hand, you like them just focus on the business and give you a good update on what's going on in the business. This is part of why I'm asking this question, because I think this is a really important insight right now. Yeah, it's difficult because on the other hand, And then you've got, you know, this storm going on and you really want them to be commenting on that, you know, all the time.
1:01:45And so I think it's a little trickier and, you know, what you say and what you do. I mean, it is true, like stock prices are, at least in short term, seem to float a lot on confidence and narrative like Robert's talking about. So you can get these situations where the price has really become unmoored with financials for quite a while. but then you know again what do you want your management teams to be saying or doing i would prefer to have the management teams just be as ever focused on the business as possible and give you the updates and and then if you do have a big dislocation and they it makes sense if they you know to take advantage of it in some way you'd love to see that so like i mean mentioned earlier you know some companies are big drawdowns and they're taking some excess cash to buy back stuff that's a probably gonna work out really well uh but again it's a company by company story you We wouldn't necessarily want to see that.
1:02:38Every company do that, even if their share price is down, because it may still be that their highest incremental return is to do something else with that account. So it's... When you look at the space, I did this last night, pretty much every AI stock or AI-related stock, even in electrification that we have, all other technicals have been decimated. They've gone right through the 50. They've gone right through the 100. They've been right through the 200. So there's no technical support here whatsoever. So what happens next? Well, in every one of these sell-offs, the first thing happens is you eventually reach selling exhaustion.
1:03:13There is a point where people will be done selling. There'll be a point where they're done short covering. There'll be a point where they're to be defensive side of the board, as they say. What then happens, and Chris, correct me if I'm wrong, is that the shorts start to get nervous because they made some money and they've done it pretty well. They're filling the accolades and stuff like that, but their biggest fear is the short squeeze that they know eventually will come. And so in short squeeze episodes, you start seeing people say, I'll fold, I got my return, I'm out, I'll cover. Then the cover leads to better sentiment.
1:03:48The sentiment then starts to lead to narrative changes. Narrative changes start to lead to new buyers. So we've seen the cycle so many times. We know what's going to play out. But to the earlier point, I think management better get up and, yes, run the business, Chris. 100%. But tell us why this is growing our intrinsic value. Just don't tell us, you know, we're going to be the biggest, we're going to have the most data centers. We need to start to understand as much as you can help us understand what is the economic returns of this and how is that going to grow the intrinsic value of our business.
1:04:22If they start to lay that out at elementary school level, I think it'll do a lot for the industry right now. Now, and the thing about data centers, do you know that 80 % of the data centers are just in three states. Texas, California, and who? No, it was Texas, Georgia, and Ohio. Texas has 30 % of them. It was on the ballot in 10 states. You would have thought it was on the ballot for all 50 states. I think every state in the union has a data center going up. But that's how big the narrative changed, right? And every state played on that. Every politician played on this whole data center thing, and they got gravitas for them.
1:05:06They got boats for them. But by the way, let's be reminded, there are a boatload of data centers going up overseas. Yeah. I looked at something just recently and showed the total data centers in the U.S. is 4 ,700. Yeah. And they're spread out amazingly pretty well. I mean, the top one I'm looking at says Virginia at 651, Texas at 513, California at 296, Georgia at 274. You corrected me. Good. Okay. Well, I'm just saying there's sort of, yeah. Yeah. I think I saw a similar list. If you look at the list that I was looking at, there may be 100 of them on there, but a lot of them aren't even completed.
1:05:48Yeah. A lot of them are in delay. A lot of them. It depends how you count it, right? Yeah. And the biggest part, if you look at the reasons why they're not up and running, is compute. They don't have the electrification. They just don't have power. They can't get power to the data center. Okay. And that wigs out everybody because they think, well, if you tap into the grid, my electric bill is going to go up, right? So that just lays into things like GE Vernova, which is you've got to build these things. You've got to build them with their own power pack, right? You've got to give it the power to the data center and not let Mr.
1:06:19and Mrs. Jones pay for the data center. Yeah. So all that thing, you know, and 60 % of GE, Brnovus revenues are outside of the United, they're building power plants outside the United States for data centers. It's like, okay, well, what's the problem? What are we talking about? So there's a lot of political - I think over the long term, they'll figure this out. And maybe that, you know, they'll need data centers somehow. You know, maybe there'll be some other way, they'll figure ways out to do this. I don't know. But I'm just saying that, you know, I can kind of understand the other side a little bit too.
1:06:45I mean, you think about it, data centers are a hard sell. I mean, they're enormous. there, they make the sides of power in the water and they make a noise. And there's no people. It's not like, you know, like a lot of times at least, you know, Amazon would come in, not that they were popular, but at least they could say, okay, there's these jobs. And so they had some sort of impact. So I think it's a tough sell in that way, but I think they'll figure it out. I mean, like I said, this is genies out of the bottle. It's not like we're going back. So, yeah, I would argue that there actually is a lot of economic inputs to the state and local municipalities that come from a data center going up.
1:07:19At the end of the day, there may be 20 employees that run it. But the amount of money that goes into the community, into the state, into the treasury, when you build these things, the number of contractors that you need to build these things, and the ancillary jobs that are created because of all this stuff, is a positive economic return for municipalities and states. Fact. It's a fact. Now, the question is, how much is too much, and how do we spread out the compute cost? It's really the real problem with data centers is just compute costs. Where do we get the compute? And that's what you get.
1:07:52If you really want to think where the bottleneck is in AI, it's compute. It's not GPUs. We can make GPUs, right? We can get, you know, we're going to have CPUs. The bottleneck to me is not going to be in memory. We'll get that figured out. The big bottleneck for many, many years will be compute. How do we power these things? And that's the supply, demand, and balance. To me, that's where excess returns are made when you get a supply-demand balance in a particular category like we have in compute that becomes interesting. But I am talking my own book, Matt. I just want to let you know. I know you're talking your own book.
1:08:27I think this is why it's important to have a conversation like this with a long-term perspective now when this is going on. Yeah. Because the questions about where the data centers are, how many governorships just flipped over, what that means for policy, that's what we're seeing playing out in the market right now is the speculation what is this story dead is this story alive is this all the pod shop just made in trades whether people actually allocated capital and that's why we get you guys together yeah chris people want to bug you on the internet or are we sending don't bug me on the internet no that is the correct answer to that response underutilized when i ask people there was no way There's no way to contact me.
1:09:05I'm in Iraq. I mean, you know, it's the usual things. I, you know, I'm on X, sort of. I don't really, you know, check that very much. But, you know, if you Google Woodlock House, there's a site for that. There's a contact page. You can write me through that if you feel so inspired. But, yeah, that's it. I don't have anything to sell anybody. Don't sell it. Get that Investor's Odyssey book. Oh, yeah. Get that Investor's Odyssey book. I have one, though. Investor's Odyssey. Thank you. Mine's too high-reached. Beautiful and covered. There you go. Sold at a fine book store and everywhere. Robert, same question to you.
1:09:40I know you're taking a lot of calls these days, but who else and where do they bug you? Yeah, just Google equitycompancy.com and investment management. You go on there, go through the portfolios, go through my portfolio. The literature's there. The returns are there. Whatever you want. I don't do X. I don't tweet. I don't do any of that stuff. But I'm on Twitter. So you can, I've got Twitter on LinkedIn. end. So there's something we can do there. But I think the best way is just to go right to the literature on equitycompass.com. Thanks. Absolutely. Bogomil, thanks for doing this with me. You are watching XS Returns.
1:10:16Check us out on Substack 2. Like, comment, subscribe, all the things below. We're out. Thank you for tuning into this episode. If you found this discussion interesting and valuable, please subscribe on your favorite audio platform or on YouTube. You can also follow all the podcasts in the XS Returns Network at xsreturnspod.com. If you have any feedback or questions, you can contact us at xsreturnspod at gmail.com. No information on this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed in the podcast may be holdings of the firms of the hosts or their clients.
Chris Mayer and Robert Hagstrom explain how they decide whether a falling stock price has exposed a mistake or given them a chance to buy a business they already know well.
Subscribe to the 100 Year Thinkers of Spotify
Subscribe to the 100 Year Thinkers of Apple
On 100 Year Thinkers, Matt Zeigler and Bogumil Baranowski ask both investors to put that judgment to work during a Nasdaq selloff. Robert starts with an unlikely pair: Nvidia and Walmart. What assumptions about growth and returns on capital would justify paying a higher earnings multiple for the retailer? Chris starts with free cash flow per share. He explains what he wants to know about a business before its stock drops 30% and he has to decide whether to buy more, hold on or sell.
They give their winners the same scrutiny. Chris admits that a run of strong quarters can tempt him to spend all his research time on the companies that are struggling. Robert borrows a habit from Sherlock Holmes: look for the evidence that could overturn your favorite explanation. The conversation closes with a question for AI executives trying to win over a town that would host a data center. What does the community get in return for the power and water the facility will use?
Topics covered:
- Robert Hagstrom on why volatility rises when different investors start making the same trade
- What the valuations of Nvidia and Walmart imply about their future earnings
- Chris Mayer on free cash flow per share and Ben Graham’s voting machine and weighing machine
- What readers of The Warren Buffett Way and 100 Baggers sometimes miss about their authors
- How Robert Hagstrom uses detective work to test an investment thesis
- Why Chris Mayer revisits companies that keep delivering strong results
- What a concentrated portfolio asks of an investor and where indexing fits
- How a watchlist helps both investors put a sharp price decline in context
- When share buybacks make sense and what AI companies need to explain to local residents
Robert Hagstrom’s research at EquityCompass
https://www.equitycompass.com/author/robert
Chris Mayer’s books at Woodlock House Family Capital
https://www.woodlockhousefamilycapital.com/portfolio
Chris Mayer on X
https://x.com/chriswmayer
Chapters:
00:00 What a Nasdaq selloff tells long-term investors
12:23 Ben Graham’s weighing machine and free cash flow per share
17:58 Who sets the example for patient investors today?
22:07 What readers miss about Robert Hagstrom and Chris Mayer
26:07 Sherlock Holmes and the evidence against an investment thesis
32:52 Studying winners as skeptically as mistakes
39:05 The case for picking businesses in an indexed market
44:36 Building a shopping list before prices fall
49:12 When a falling price earns a closer look
53:37 What shareholders need to hear from CEOs
1:02:07 Why data centers are a hard sell for their neighbors
Learn more about the Excess Returns podcast network:
https://excessreturns.co
No information discussed in this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed may be held by the hosts and guests, their firms or their clients.



