1. Podcasts
  2. Excess Returns
  3. This $1.5 Trillion Manager Expects More Fed Hikes. So Why Is He Still Bullish?
Excess Returns

10 Nov 2026 · 1h 1m · 30 chapters

Episode artwork

This $1.5 Trillion Manager Expects More Fed Hikes. So Why Is He Still Bullish?

In short

Northern Trust Asset Management president Mike (Excess Returns) argues markets are resilient despite Fed hikes and geopolitical risk, driven by a “wealth effect,” while AI is a major positive supply shock that could boost productivity and earnings through 2027.

Guest backgrounds

Mike is president of Northern Trust Asset Management, overseeing about $1.5T+ in assets. He previously focused on quantitative and factor investing in portfolio construction.

Key claims

  1. Data points (GDP growth expectations ~2.5% for 2027, 5-year break-even inflation below ~2.5%, tight bond spreads, strong YTD equities) contradict bearish headlines.
  2. The top 20% of households drive ~40% of consumption; their wealth has risen sharply, and marginal propensity to consume out of wealth has more than doubled since COVID.
  3. Fed hikes (possibly 50 bps next meeting; 2–3 hikes in 12 months) matter more for bond markets than aggregate demand; monetary policy influence is diminished.
  4. Main macro risk: a ~20% equity drawdown that would eventually hit spending.
  5. AI is the “biggest positive supply shock,” with productivity gains expected to translate into margin expansion and higher aggregate output.

Notable examples

S&P 500 earnings growth consensus above 30% into 2027; AI productivity example includes AI solving a Clay Millennium Prize math problem; “beta is AI” and AI comprises a large share of S&P risk; IPO supply example uses SpaceX’s benchmark absorption.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

0:56

Market Resilience Amidst Uncertainty

Explore the current market conditions and economic resilience despite global challenges.

“The headline narrative is saying something else.”
1:35

Navigating Economic Challenges

Understand how geopolitical events and economic factors impact investor sentiment.

“You are president of Northern Trust Asset Management, where I think the firm oversees approximately or over$1.5 trillion in assets.”
2:48

Consumption and Wealth Effect

Examine the role of consumer spending and wealth distribution in the U.S. economy.

“Where I wanted to start with you is how are you thinking about today's market with some of the headwinds or some of the maybe challenges that investors are trying to interpret?”
4:19

Impact of Federal Reserve Policies

Discuss the anticipated rate hikes by the Federal Reserve and their economic implications.

“And I think the best indicator of that resiliency is simply looking at expected earnings into 2027 for U.S.”
7:24

Concerns Over Debt and Market Stability

Analyze the relationship between interest rates, debt levels, and market stability.

“I think that wealth effect is alive and well, and that overshadows any of the headlines that we see.”
12:07

AI as a Supply Shock

Discover how AI could represent the largest positive supply shock to the economy.

“And it's so tough because I feel like for 25 years, people have been, had this concern top of mind and yet, We still continue to be okay.”
14:00

Impact of AI on Productivity and Profit Margins

Learn how AI could significantly affect productivity and profit margins in companies.

“Not even the introduction of, you know, PCs on the desktop, you know, in the late 1990s, I guess, manifest that high productivity gain.”
15:46

Navigating Monetary Policy Amid Inflation

Explore the complexities of monetary policy in light of current inflation and potential deflationary forces.

“Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
16:57

The Disconnect Between Interest Rates and Equity Markets

Understand why equity markets are behaving independently of interest rates.

“but this could be extremely deflationary going forward.”
18:14

Changing Economic Indicators and Their Relevance

Discuss the evolution of economic indicators and their current effectiveness.

“They don't finance a lot of their exposure or their balance sheet through debt.”
Show all 30 chapters
19:50

The Wealth Effect and Its Implications

Investigate the relationship between the stock market and economic growth.

“Unfortunately, it's that lower end that tends to be susceptible to these delinquencies and things like that have a diminishing impact on overall economic output.”
21:04

Evaluating AI Hype vs. Reality

Analyze the balance between expectations and actual ROI from AI investments.

“But, you know, increasingly the the the growth expectations, at least of the U.S.”
23:34

CapEx Trends and Market Dynamics

Examine the rising CapEx among tech companies and its market implications.

“Because that seems to be the big question in the market right now.”
25:03

Comparing Today's Market to the Dot-Com Era

Compare the current economic landscape with the late 1990s dot-com bubble.

“Historically speaking, you're right that when we look at companies that have the highest level of CapEx, their subsequent returns tend to be relatively lower than the rest of the market.”
28:00

Market Perspectives on AI and Profitability

Explore insights on AI's impact on market dynamics and investor behavior.

“Compared to what we have today, yes, there's now a concern around CapEx and how that's going to influence the balance sheet.”
29:40

Evaluating AI's Value and Productivity

Discussion on the value of AI investments and expected productivity gains.

“Somebody had put the 90s price chart up against now and it basically matches exactly.”
31:00

Assessing AI's Impact on Market Indices

Understand how AI investments redefine the S&P 500 and other indices.

“The builders have also had the most productivity gains themselves.”
33:00

Investment Strategies in an AI-Dominated Market

Insights on diversifying AI exposure while optimizing returns.

“Do you think people need to think differently about things like the S &P 500 during a period like this?”
35:40

IPO Dynamics and Market Absorption

Learn about the effects of recent IPOs, including SpaceX, on market supply.

“You feel a little good about it after that period of value went through.”
39:50

Navigating Public vs. Private Market Investments

Discuss the balance between public and private market opportunities in equity investment.

“Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.”
42:00

Private Equity and Public Market Dynamics

Exploring the interplay and investment strategies of private and public equity.

“And I would say within the private equity space, there are examples like SpaceX that have been very, very good.”
43:20

Evolving Views on Value Stocks

Discussing how the classification of technology stocks is shifting towards value.

“Your point about outliers is so important because all of us tend to look at the outliers and then take lessons from them.”
45:07

Reevaluating Value in a High Intangible Economy

How to assess value stocks in a landscape dominated by intangible assets.

“Do you think we have to change the way we think about value?”
46:59

The Evolution of Factor Investing

Insights into the historical and current landscape of factor investing.

“How has your view, I mean, you kind of started your career with factor investing and quantitative investing, and how has it evolved over time?”
48:50

Momentum in Modern Investing

Understanding momentum through modern methodologies and data analysis.

“So 1993, Fama French come out with their paper and say value is, you know, price to book, price to market, you know, I'm sorry, book to market ratios.”
51:42

Factor Timing and Market Cycles

Exploring the effectiveness of timing factors based on macroeconomic conditions.

“anomalies is completely different than it was 20 years ago.”
54:05

Direct Indexing vs. ETFs: Current Trends

Examining the relationship and future potential of direct indexing and ETFs.

“But I would imagine, you know, you and the leadership team there is also thinking deeply about the product side and where investors' appetite is with certain types of products.”
56:00

The Future of Tokenization and ETFs

Exploration of tokenization's growth and its similarities to ETFs.

“that bespoke implementation can be very, very effective.”
58:34

Time Diversification in Investing

Discussion on the concept of time diversification and its implications for investors.

“That's not the case, in my view, that you get as much diversification over your time horizon as you do within your asset allocation.”
1:01:00

Lessons for Average Investors

Key lessons for average investors on managing risks and portfolio concentration.

“but also with some of the largest institutions in the world.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Excess Returns, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:01This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome? That's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. this episode is brought to you by indeed you're ready to level up your business but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense indeed sponsored jobs can help carry the load it boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast cut through the chaos with indeed sponsored jobs get a 75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast terms and conditions apply hiring now then this is a job for indeed sponsored jobs The market, I think, from a data perspective is saying one thing.

0:59The headline narrative is saying something else. Your biggest spenders are wealthier than they have ever been, and they're spending more out of their wealth than they've ever spent. There's a lot of gas in that tank. I would say the most significant risk for the U.S. economy is you get a 20 % drawdown in equity prices. I often joke that beta is AI. AI is the new beta. the biggest positive supply shock to the U.S. economy that we've ever seen. You have to get paid for every basis point of risk that you take. Mike, welcome to Excess Returns. Thank you very much for joining us this morning. Thanks for having me.

1:37You are president of Northern Trust Asset Management, where I think the firm oversees approximately or over$1.5 trillion in assets. You spent much of your earlier career focused on quantitative investing, factor investing in portfolio construction. So I think today's conversation, you're going to bring a unique perspective of someone who's been in the trenches, been a practitioner, but now is at a level where you're helping the advisors and the professionals at Northern Trust sort of navigate markets and advise clients in the best long-term way possible. There's a lot of uncertainty in the markets right now.

2:14I think both individual investors and professionals are trying to navigate an environment where we're seeing this global conflict with Iran, higher interest rates. There's maybe some uncertainty around what the Fed's going to do, which we're going to talk about. And then obviously the big 300-pound gorilla in the room is AI and the AI CapEx spend and where things go from here in terms of the return on this incredible amount of spending that's happening. So this is going to be, that's kind of the, I guess, groundwork for a lot of the discussion today. Where I wanted to start with you is how are you thinking about today's market with some of the headwinds or some of the maybe challenges that investors are trying to interpret?

3:01The war, higher oil prices, higher rates, you know, what's your sort of 30 ,000 view of where we are in the market today and both the market and economy yeah so it's it's a really interesting time in that if you look at the headlines there's never a dull moment right so every day goes by there's some new geopolitical events some new macro consideration um but then if you take a step back and just look at the data you look at gdp growth expectations for the us for 2027 still quite favorable about two and a half percent and that's our view as well uh you look at break-even inflation rates now they've been volatile but you know five-year break-even inflation rates still below two and a half percent uh you look at bond spreads uh still very very tight uh both in high yield and investment grade uh and obviously equity markets uh we've had a great year already, you know, year to date.

4:00So we're not quite at all time highs, but we're pretty close. So, you know, the market, I think, from a data perspective is saying one thing, the headline narrative is saying, you know, something else. I think that speaks to a tremendous resiliency that the underlying economy has. And I think the best indicator of that resiliency is simply looking at expected earnings into 2027 for U.S. corporations. S &P 500 consensus expectations above 30 % growth. That's fantastic. And we've had a good year already, you know, year to date. So we actually have a lot of optimism on markets in general, but the U.S.

4:47uh macroeconomic backdrop as well so we are risk on and our portfolio is going into 2027. Yeah and isn't that an interesting thing about like there's all these headline problems but you have the market's basically a lifetime high and wouldn't you think like the market you know would would discount those things you know the market's smart right so it's it's not like the market's missing something or it could be but that's kind of the interesting I guess tension here. Yeah so I think you have to separate two things So one is the headlines. And again, there's a lot of them every day. There's something new coming at us.

5:22But what I think is actually driving all of this is, and you hear inklings of this, is this enormous wealth effect that's going on in this country right now. So a couple of things to keep in mind. When you look at U.S. GDP, we're a little unusual globally in that about 70 % of our GDP is consumption. All right. Developed markets, it's 60 percent ish is the average emerging is a little bit lower than that. But a big piece of it is consumption. So consumers keep spending, then real GDP growth should be going in the right direction. But if you dive into that a little bit more, you'll find that a big piece of that total consumption is in that very top of the wealth spectrum.

6:09So the top 20 % of the wealthiest individuals or families in the United States account for about 40 % of total consumption. And what you've experienced in the last several years is that segment of the population is wealthier than they have ever been by far. You've had equity markets, double-digit returns over the last several years, where you're up 100 % in the last five. Real estate prices are up. Obviously, yields are up, meaning interest income is up. And another really interesting thing happened following the COVID crisis is that the marginal propensity to consume out of wealth, so how much wealth consumption exists, is actually more than doubled.

6:55So here you have a situation where your biggest spenders are wealthier than they have ever been, and they're spending more out of their wealth than they've ever spent. There's a lot of gas in that tank. And I think unambiguously, that is what has propelled the U.S. economy forward over the last several years and potentially will going forward as well. So barring any major volatility events, if you will, in markets, And when I mean that, I mean, a sustained drawdown. I think that wealth effect is alive and well, and that overshadows any of the headlines that we see. So, you know, these are major events, but from a macro perspective, I think that wealth, wealth effect is, is, is even more pronounced.

7:40It's a great point. And I think some investors listening to this might not know, but in the depth of the financial crisis, the S &P bottomed at 666. It's now at over 7600. So to your point about how well equities have done over that 16-year, whatever it is, period, is quite amazing. um what are your thoughts on so the fed is has hiked in september um what are you thinking with because that's obviously something that you know there's a don't fight the fed thing but how i guess concerned are you maybe that's not the right word what's your take on the sort of the fed here and what you think they're going to do over the next maybe six to twelve months yeah i think there's two or three rate hikes over the next 12 months i think you know The next meeting, we could get a 50 basis point hike.

8:32I see that in the cards. I don't think that matters too much for the actual macroeconomic backdrop. I think we've seen a big dislocation in monetary policy to the real economy. A lot of that has to do with AI implications, which I'm sure we'll get into. So I think it's very, very important for the bond market. But I think, honestly, the ability for monetary policy for the Fed to actually influence aggregate demand, which is the whole idea, is pretty de minimis in these days. So very important for bond markets, but as far as the macro economy is concerned. I'm going to go back to my wealth effect explanation and say that overshadows it by a long shot.

9:22One of the things that I was struggling with like a couple of weeks ago, and it was all in the headlines, was the 10-year. And it being over 5%, it seemed to be the market was getting concerned over that. And of course, it does impact borrowing costs of a lot of companies, particularly the ones that maybe aren't super high quality that need to pay more for their debt and their interest expense. But is that something, but when you look historically at interest rates, like 5 % is like, that's probably maybe average or lower than average. So is that, does the long end, I guess, ever, you know, where would you kind of get concerned and how are you guys thinking about that?

10:02Yeah. So the absolute level, and we're thankfully back down below 5%, I think, as of today. So that's great. But those levels, to your point, you know, are roughly, you know, close to historical averages. So it's not, it's rare for recent periods, but it's not outside what we've experienced in the past. And when you think about, you know, the 10-year rate, if you decompose that into a inflation component and a real growth component, that's spot on, you know, 2.5 % is your breakeven inflation rate, 2.5 % growth rate that puts you at 5 % yield, that's exactly where you would expect it to be. So nothing really shocking there.

10:45The one thing that we're very concerned about, though, is any term premium that accrues to concerns around the U.S.'s ability to pay debts. So right now we're at about 125 % debt to GDP ratio. I'd say even a conservative expectation is we're going to grow to maybe about 175 % over the next 10 years. That could put a significant credit premium on the yield curve overall to the tune of maybe 50 basis points, maybe even higher. that has nothing to do with, you know, growth or inflation expectations. That is everything to do with the credit worthiness of the issuer. So that is a significant concern.

11:34We're seeing a little bit of that in Europe right now at a smaller scale with France and some of the other, you know, economies. And I think from an investment perspective, anytime that you have a question mark on the credit worthiness of your, call it safe asset, that is much more of an issue than the absolute yield itself. So wherever the absolute yield goes, I think the economy can digest that. It's about, do we have that safe asset going forward? Yeah. And it's so tough because I feel like for 25 years, people have been, had this concern top of mind and yet, We still continue to be okay. So knock on wood, that's not any concern coming in the future here, immediate future.

12:23Let's pivot to AI. And I know this is something you've been writing about, thinking about, and everyone's been thinking about, a lot of people. You've called AI potentially the biggest positive supply shock the global economy has ever seen. What do you mean by that? yeah when you think about the ability of the economy to produce that's the supply dimension um the productivity gains that are expected from ai i mean it depends on who you read and where you go right so range is anywhere from zero to 40 40 i've seen estimates you know roughly in that range some even higher um if you take anything that's within that range and even if you discount it pretty heavily and i'll give you one you know one metric so uh in the most recent earnings uh period about 75 percent of companies uh ceos and cfos spoke about ai within their earnings report right so a lot of that has to do with productivity there's some productivity numbers thrown out there i would say if even half of that is correct this will manifest as being as you pointed out i've said this before in the media the biggest positive supply shock to the u.s economy that we've ever seen there has been no other instance in history where productivity gains have been anywhere close to what we think that they might be going forward.

14:01Not even the introduction of, you know, PCs on the desktop, you know, in the late 1990s, I guess, manifest that high productivity gain. But we're already starting to see some of it, you know, in reality, the margins on the S &P, for example, have been increasing. You know, we've, we've, and it's early days on that. But if the rhetoric that we hear out of these companies is even close to true. Yeah, this will have a very material impact on productivity. It will have a material impact on profit margins. And that influences aggregate supply to a positive overall. So I think that, you know, we don't know when it's going to hit.

14:42We don't know how big it's going to be. And that creates significant challenges for monetary policy because we don't know those variables. But I think something that's becoming increasingly clear is that it will be a real thing. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense?

15:14There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

15:52Yeah, it's interesting. like thinking about monetary policy, I wouldn't want to be the Fed right now. And I'll think, if you think about it, we've got a near-term potentially inflation issue, but we've got this long-term potentially massive deflationary force. And how should they, do you have any advice on how they should think about that? It seems like a very tough thing to navigate. Yeah. I would say, so just to reiterate, monetary policy influences aggregate demand. That's the whole idea. This AI is going to be a supply shock. In my opinion, the last thing that you want to do in the face of a positive or negative supply shock is try to materially influence aggregate demand.

16:30So basically, you've got one curve moving around, and you're going to try to move the other curve around to match. And that just doesn't work. So I would say in most cases in history, where you've had a positive supply influence from some external source, the best case scenario for monetary policy is just to hold tight. And I think that's what the Fed ultimately should do because there's just so much uncertainty, to your point, Jack, around, yes, we have inflation now, but this could be extremely deflationary going forward. If I'm going to start to influence the rate side of the equation to match that, I don't even know what that looks like.

17:10So give the market some certainty, give the market some stability in the face of this positive supply shock. That's what the Fed should do right now. And it seems like that's probably what they will do. One of the things I've learned about the Fed is they tend to move when it's obvious. There's a lot of questions in both ways. They tend to have to just stay there and say, like, let's just wait this out. Yeah. I mean, I think that, you know, I think they should stay steady. I think they will ultimately raise rates over the next few meetings. But, you know, by and large, my general thesis is, again, and I've stated already, monetary policy has a diminishing return or influence, if you will, on real variables overall.

17:5220 years ago, they had a much bigger impact. Today, it's much less significant. And just another data point there. When you think about what's going on in the equity markets, equity markets seem almost completely dislocated from interest rates these days. You can raise them, you can lower them, doesn't really matter. And a lot of that is because a lot of your revenue and profitability are coming out of technology sector where, you know, the cost of capital doesn't have a lot to do with interest rates. They don't finance a lot of their exposure or their balance sheet through debt. So I would say that it was, you know, 20, 30 years ago, it was a much more effective mechanism than it is today because not just the popularity and productivity of AI, but the balance sheet structure of AI companies as well means that that rate, you know, interest rate is increasingly less relevant.

18:54It's interesting because that's come up in our podcast with Jim Balson as well. The idea that we kind of have two economies right now. You have a normal economy that's sensitive to the types of things the Fed does. And then we've got a tech economy that really doesn't impact it at all. And it seems like that makes a much bigger challenge in terms of policy. You've got these two different things operating at the same time. Yeah, for sure. And, you know, 10, 20 years ago, you think about what the leading indicators were. People looked at, economists looked at things like credit card delinquencies and auto loans and mortgage delinquencies.

19:26And those are still very important from a social perspective. But I think that those kinds of things, and you can prove this out empirically, over the last several years have become more and more dislocated from what real variables actually manifest. So do they have a leading indicator ability anymore? I think that's a big question mark. It all boils down to going back to that discussion on the wealth effect, who's actually spending in the economy. Unfortunately, it's that lower end that tends to be susceptible to these delinquencies and things like that have a diminishing impact on overall economic output.

20:08Yeah, I think what you just said, they've said people have called maybe 50 of the last two recessions. And I think that's basically what you're getting at. There's these leading indicators that predict recessions. They haven't been working for a long time. A lot of people are asking why. Correct. Correct. Exactly. That's exactly right. On the wealth effect, do you think we always think about the economy driving the stock market? Do you think we have to rethink that? I'm wondering, because if you think about this idea, if you have a big wealth effect, now the market can drive the economy more. And maybe one of the biggest risks to the market or to the economy is the market going down.

20:38So do you think we have to rethink that? Absolutely. And there's an emerging platform of academic research around this topic where when you get into situations where the wealth effect is so pronounced, it is going to be the volatility, specifically the equity market, that will have implications on future real variables for sure. So, yes, I think we're in a situation where, you know, it's we're not sure if it's egg and chicken or chicken and egg. But, you know, increasingly the the the growth expectations, at least of the U.S. economy, are going to be really predicated on where the market is. So fortunately, we've been in a good spot, even though volatility has been, you know, a little bit elevated as of late.

21:27I would say the most significant risk for the U.S. economy, to your point, is you get a 20 % drawdown in equity prices, and that eventually will influence spending. That's going to be a real challenge. One of the things you hear people talking a lot about now is this idea that AI has a lot of hype. And you had this quote I found somewhere in the preparation that AI is 70 % hype and 30 % real. And you would think that might be coming from someone who's verished, but I think it's the exact opposite of that. I think you really focus on what's in that 30%. So can you talk about that? Yeah, sure. So, um, and when I, when I said that I was referring to the kind of the productivity expectations of, of AI overall, and I think people have a lot of plans and, you know, Hey, we can use AI for this, this, this, and this.

22:14And, uh, some of those projects will work and some of them will not. I would say that when I talk to CFOs and CEOs, it's a mixed bag as far as the ROI on AI projects. But I think we're just coming to the point within the economy as a whole of thinking about AI as the centerpiece of your process. Up till now, it's been a lot about, hey, I can automate my Excel spreadsheet or build a PowerPoint deck or whatever through AI. And that's great, but that's not where the productivity gains really are. Going forward is going to be process re-engineering or, you know, rethinking completely how we do things around that AI centerpiece rather than just do them at the margin.

23:02So I think 70 %-ish of the projects that are out there are, you know, are marginal. And, you know, that's the part we think about, oh, it's going to be great, but it's going to be, you know, the impact to output is going to be relatively small. But that 30 % where we're actually re-engineering, it's going to be extraordinarily potent. And we're just seeing that right now. It's hard to do. You have to change technology, processes, mentality around how you do things. So I think we're just on the cusp of that. Do you think we ultimately see the ROI here? Because that seems to be the big question in the market right now.

23:36We're spending massive amounts of money up front. You know, obviously the bearish people are like, you're never going to see the ROI. The bullish people would say it's going to exceed what we spent by a lot. How do you think through that? Yeah. Yeah. Look, in any innovation, any time in history where there's been a technological innovation, there has been disruptions in various parts of the economy and there's been a misallocation of resources. So we don't know exactly what this is. People are investing. Companies are investing. AI providers are investing in these technologies. There's going to be winners and losers.

24:09There's no there's no question about that. But I'm very confident that overall net net for the economy, this is going to be a positive thing from a growth and output perspective. And that's really what we're betting on. So will that mean that every single AI company does well? Absolutely not. There's going to be a dispersion there. It's just about, you know, where does the capital actually make sense at the end of the day? And there will be a point where we start to manifest that in aggregate. How do you think about the CapEx overall? And we don't talk about individual companies, but we obviously have a bunch of companies that were very high free cash flow companies.

24:49They're turning into massive spenders now. And I know you come from the factor world and we know CapEx is not a great factor thinking forward. So how do you think about that idea of the changing nature of the market because of the changing nature of the biggest companies? Yeah. Historically speaking, you're right that when we look at companies that have the highest level of CapEx, their subsequent returns tend to be relatively lower than the rest of the market. But that was in an environment where you had what we call empire building behavior if you're expanding too rapidly relative to your peers.

25:24And I think that's a key component of that thinking is that if you're trying to outgrow your peers, that tends to be a bad thing. In this situation, it's the entire industry is growing collectively, if you will. Is all of that capital going to be used wisely? No, no chance. We don't know exactly what we're even betting on as of this point. but when you know we see some of the potential of this am I confident that we're going in the right direction yeah 100 percent you know I'll just give you one example it's a little geeky so I'm a mathematician by training and when I saw that AI actually solved one of the you know hardest outstanding problems in mathematics is called a millennium prize problems a clay math Institute problem and did it extraordinarily successfully, that's the real deal.

26:20That's something that I think is going to have a major impact. So everybody's investing, yes. Is it the right level? Who knows? Is it in the right project? Who knows? But I do think that, you know, overall where we are as an economy, as an industry, doing what we should be doing here because that those benefits of productivity is real. And the other question is how long does it last too? Because it's not necessarily that this goes on forever. I mean, there might be a level where this capex peaks out and it starts coming down. I mean, obviously, there's some maintenance that has to go on beyond that, but it may not be the levels it's at now.

26:54Yeah, correct. Absolutely. And, you know, we are, as a firm, very bullish on AI stocks and technology, even more, a little bit more than the street is in the sense that we think that, you know, the return generating capability of those capital investments. To your point, there's a peak and it's not going to go on forever. You will start to generate cash flow and profitability after that. So our expectations are pretty optimistic. Do you have any thoughts on comparing this period to the late 90s? You see that happening all the time. And I wonder, I mean, sometimes it rhymes, but it's different.

27:31Do you have any thoughts on what's going on now versus what went on then? Yeah. I don't think there's any comparison, honestly. You know, maybe on the surface it looks the same or similar. But back then you had, you know, companies that had no revenues at all. Obviously negative profitability, names that were relatively unknown, you know, tiny balance sheets, trading at unbelievable multiples. If you remember, if you were around during some of the higher-flying stocks of the dot-com era, you'll look at what their actual underlying financials were. It was laughable. Compared to what we have today, yes, there's now a concern around CapEx and how that's going to influence the balance sheet.

28:18but to your point these were previously the highest free cash flow firms in the industry some of the most profitable firms in the economy you know some of the best balance sheets in the economy so it's hard for me to take a negative view on this segment or recognizing the strength of what they're producing and they're increasingly a larger and larger component of the overall equity market as well. So an underweight to AI currently means that you're underweighting upwards of 40 % of the equity market. I think there's an overarching point there too, with like investor behavior that a lot of times investors, both retail and professional, you're, we're kind of always like fighting the last battle or looking for something to relate it to.

29:05And oftentimes it's like Jack said, they kind of rhyme, but they're so different. A lot of times when you look, you know, under the surface at things. So, yeah. And I think the naysayers will find reasons to be correct, meaning that there will be blow ups in individual firms, there will be pockets of the economy where productivity does not manifest. That is absolutely true. But I think it's really about the big picture for us of where is this going as a whole that we have a lot more confidence. It's funny. I just saw some charts on Twitter. Somebody had put the 90s price chart up against now and it basically matches exactly.

29:44And then somebody else had put the 70s inflation chart up against now and it also matches exactly. So it's like, which one is it going to be? I don't really know. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Do you think there's any value? I mean, you hear the talk of a bubble all the time and obviously you don't think we're in one, but like, do you think there's any value in that discussion that people are talking about or we're in a bubble all the time? I have a real hard time with that for a couple of reasons one is if you look at the last year equity returns were almost all earnings generated not multiple expansion so multiples are pretty much where they have been for the last 12 to 18 months when you look at forward multiples you're actually around the 10-year average based off of what you know earnings expectations are going forward so So it's really, really hard for me to say that we're in a bubble when the valuation profile looks pretty attractive.

30:37And again, it's because we have those earnings behind it that I think this is a completely different scenario from the 1990s. Do you have any thoughts on where, like in the stack, the value might ultimately have true for A &D? Because if you look at past technologies, the builders weren't necessarily beneficiaries. So far, I think they have been the beneficiaries here. Do you think this is different? I mean, what do you think we can learn from them? Yeah, I would say two things. The builders have also had the most productivity gains themselves. So when you think about where real productivity has been generated from AI, it tends to be in coding, in software development, in the tech component of the economy as a whole.

31:17Things like GitHub Copilot are revolutionary in terms of their ability to create more productivity out of coders. So those are the tech giants, and they're reaping some of that. But also, again, going back to earnings calls and discussions around AI, I think a lot of firms are in the very early innings of their journey through AI and are only beginning to think about real CapEx in this space. So I would say that, you know, even though there is concern right now about the viability of this or the bubble effect of this, you have enough anecdotal information supporting the fact that there will be more cash flow into this space.

32:03There will be more investment in this space. That gives me a lot of optimism. Do you have any thoughts on the most important things you'll watch in terms of seeing if there is an ROI from AI? like you right now it seems like a lot of what we're doing is listening to ernie's calls and saying are they talking about it like eventually it'll have to translate into real numbers like are there specific things you would look for yeah margins so where where where are margins going now in general in the last few years uh they've been going up and so you got to kind of keep that in mind but um if uh if the first stop of ai productivity is margin expansion we should be able to recognize that, you know, relatively quickly.

32:41The second then is, you know, real economic output at the aggregate level. Economies that are, you know, as you look across the world that, you know, a lot of this discussion centers on the United States, but as you look across the world, there's different levels of investment in AI. And I'm very, very curious how that's going to play out in real growth going forward. So, you know, and it'll take a while to really manifest this or calculate this, but what is the impact of AI and productivity in aggregate, and therefore that should influence real GDP growth going forward, that I think is going to be a very interesting metric to look at as well.

33:19Do you think people need to think differently about things like the S &P 500 during a period like this? Some statistics will show maybe 50 % of the S &P right now is some degree of an AI bet. Do you think the risk within the index is something investors need to think differently about in a period like this? Absolutely. You know, I often joke that beta is AI. AI is the new beta. I would say it's probably even a little bit higher than 50 % of the total risk in the S &P 500. So when you have an equity exposure, and even if you extend that to like an MSCI world, you know, which in theory is the developed markets in totality, AI is still a huge component of that as well.

34:01So equities are essentially an AI bet. All of my clients are looking for diversification. How do you think about diversifying your AI exposure but not giving up the potential returns associated with AI at the same time? So there's a lot of talk about more equally weighted benchmarks or benchmarks that have an equal sector composition. Those are interesting things to talk about. or really bad investments at the end of the day. Our approach has always been, you've got to be intentional about how you think about underweights or overweights to the highest sectors or securities within a benchmark. We tend to be more focused on, hey, let's potentially underweight AI to an extent, but make sure that we have return generating capabilities from that active share that we free up using things like, well, you know, buying stocks that are higher quality or better value, lower volatility.

35:03That has been an extraordinarily potent approach over the last couple of years. Our factor strategies are knocking the cover off the ball. And that has been fantastic. So you're diversifying, but you're also getting that return potential. If you just sort of naively say, I'm just going to take a equal weight approach, you don't have any idea what risks you're actually taking. Yeah, I'm probably preaching to the choir here, but it seems like factors in many ways are a risk reducer right now. They're a better diversifier than they are in many other periods because they're so different than what's in the market.

35:34They're a risk reducer and they have been an alpha generator for sure. So you want to talk about excess returns? There's your excess returns. You feel a little good about it after that period of value went through. It was obviously a very, very long period of struggle. So maybe someday value investing will be back. Oh, it has been back and it has been back for a few years now. So and I think that's almost counterintuitive, you know, like, hey, you see these tech stocks do well and that's great. But there has been, you know, reasonably good dispersion in the market such that value stocks have also tended to outperform.

36:09Do you have any thoughts about equity supply? Like that's something people are thinking about a lot right now. Obviously, we're going to have three, maybe the three biggest IPOs in history, one after the other. And some people are concerned about that. like how will the market absorb that supply and some people say it's not that big of a deal like do you have any thoughts on that so there's a lot of a lot to talk about there um i would say that on the actual ipos themselves uh the the reality let's take spacex uh this year um the the amount of the float was only a small fraction of the overall valuation of the of the company so i I think it was 1.75, 1.85 trillion valuation.

36:48The number of shares that were actually issued was relatively small. So for the ability of the market to absorb that, keep in mind that these large IPOs are immediately gonna go into some benchmarks. Now, MSCI and FTSE Russell were first. S &P is gonna be a little bit later for SpaceX. So there's some staggering to that. But we didn't see any major disruptions as a result of that. the overall weight of SpaceX in these large cap benchmarks is still pretty small. Anthropic will likely follow the same pattern, although we don't know that. If they keep issuing new tranches, then obviously that weighting is going to go up and their influence on the overall benchmark is going to be higher.

37:35But it wasn't as big of a deal, I think, as we thought it might be when SpaceX did their IPO. Now we'll see how some of these other major IPOs play out. But by and large, from that perspective, from a purely kind of benchmark relative perspective, we were in good shape. With a company like SpaceX, and that's a good point because you hear about that, whatever, close to$2 trillion valuation, but a very small piece of it actually went into the markets. But I don't know, like what happens over time? Is it like insiders and VCs? And eventually, like a lot of that, a lot of those, a lot of that equity will come to the market.

38:12Is that kind of what will happen, like mechanically speaking? Yeah, potentially, yes. So there will be more. I don't think we have the final details on when all of that will take place. But, you know, they didn't want to go out there, rightfully so, and say, OK, here's all the stock. I'm just going to sell it all at once. That would be the wrong situation, a wrong approach. You test the waters and see how it goes. And I would say, by and large, you know, from my perspective, it has gone as perhaps SpaceX would have anticipated. So there will very likely be additional tranches released that will then increase the weight of SpaceX in the benchmark, whether it's an S &P or MSCI or anything else.

38:51Is that a problem? Not really. Is it unusual? Yeah. But, you know, by and large, we haven't seen any stumbling blocks from it. This episode is brought to you by Google Chrome. You think you know a browser, but Gemini and Chrome, that's new. It can help you with practically anything on the web, like restoring a vintage motorcycle from a 50-page restoration block, or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18+.

39:25This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed Sponsored Jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs. Get a$75 sponsored job credit at indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

39:58Go ahead, keep going. I would say another related concern there that, you know, some are talking about is it's not just the IPOs, but the fact that, you know, how do you capture a firm and its value, you know, or its development cycle? So if SpaceX comes out nearly$2 trillion in valuation, that's your initial introduction to the public equity market. Well,$2 trillion of value was created before it became a public equity, right? And where within that firm lifecycle do you really want to be? We fortunately were an investor in SpaceX in the private markets in the very, very early days. you saw a tremendous return as a result of that.

40:49I'd say a big concern with public equity markets is are these mega cap IPOs, have they already exhausted their earnings potential or growth potential? And has that all accrued to the private equity investors? That's a harder question to answer. And I don't have that answer, but I think it makes a really, really interesting concern around traditionally we think of ipos they you know ipo stocks tend to go up right but have they already you know where are they at in their life cycle and has that been exhaust is a great question how do you think about this idea of if your average investor over time needs exposure to private markets i mean some people argue that value of these big companies is is improving there maybe the you know the institutions and richer people are getting all that value and so they should have access and other people argue by the time it gets down to the retail investor, you're not getting that anyway.

41:40And there's obviously a lot of companies we don't talk about. We're not SpaceX. They're in the private market that don't do as well. Like, how do you think, I mean, do you think our portfolios like five, 10 years from now will all be different because of the way this is working? Well, I would say that is a great theory and I don't disagree with the theory, but the reality is public equity markets have done very well also. And I would say within the private equity space, there are examples like SpaceX that have been very, very good. But when you look across the full spectrum of private equity, you have a lot of dispersion there as well.

42:18So I do think there is a premium to be made for early stage investing in firms that will eventually go IPO. And that premium is probably bigger than it used to be in the past. But, you know, within the public sphere, the productivity benefits which we've been talking about are significant and potentially outweigh even that premium that you're earning on the private side. So the potential for AI to be a force multiplier in the public markets is huge. So I wouldn't rule out one versus the other, but I do think, I do know more and more investors are trying to think about public and private it collectively to say, all right, how do I think about this difference in return pattern?

43:09How should I think about risk in that context as well? A lot of asset owners are taking this total portfolio approach or total portfolio view. And I think a lot of it has been driven on this idea that, you know, publics and privates are related in some way. Your point about outliers is so important because all of us tend to look at the outliers and then take lessons from them. Like we'll look back and say, oh, Amazon was so obvious back in the day, but we won't remember pets.com or whatever that also likes to do well and never did. So it's probably don't want to extrapolate too much from like three huge companies and say like that reflects what's going on every day in the private markets.

43:45Absolutely. There's something on the order of 65 ,000 privately owned firms by PE shops. So one or two stories make great headlines, but the rest are there too. I want to pull this chart because you guys had a great chart talking about indexes and their exposure to technology and AI companies. And you have the Russell 1000 value index here and its sector weight and how it's changed over time. So can you talk about this? Yeah, sure. So looking at the chart, you actually see almost counterintuitively a growth in the allocation to some of these sectors. So you've seen that some firms that you classically think as growth turned to be value stocks, you know, and vice versa.

44:28So if I'm looking at the same chart that you are, you see, for example, communication services, a market change between June and March of 2026. You see a few others that have like information technology. June 2026, 18 % of the allocation was to Infotech. Just a few months prior, what was it, 12%. So So, you know, here's a great example of where you're seeing a shift in, you know, technology stocks that were, you know, historically thought of as exclusively growth are now in a lot of cases classified as value. Do you think we have to change the way we think about value? As you know, because you're a factor, you're a factor guy like us, like the price to book has not worked as well recently as it has in the past.

45:16And you could argue, obviously, so much so much of the economy is intangibles. Now, there's a good reason for that. So do you think we have to change the way we think about value in a high intangible world? 100%. So when you think about a valuation multiple, it's a point in time estimate. And it's really only one of two pieces that you need to think about stock in terms of value. So one is the price you're going to pay, but the other is the growth expectations. And this is where, you know, we have to estimate at best. So intrinsic value, true intrinsic value says, okay, what am I paying for that future growth path?

45:50PE multiples or price to book multiples only give you one small piece of the story. So more and more when we think about value, we do it less in the context of metrics like P ratios and more in the context of, hey, I've got groups of stocks like AI stocks that I think are going to grow at a certain rate. What is the relative, you know, P.E. multiple or price to book multiple within that cohort to give me an edge on selecting stocks within that group? That is far more potent than just saying, hey, I'm going to rank all the stocks in the S &P 500 by P multiple, and I'm going to buy the top half, which is truly the old style of value investing.

46:32You have to do a much better job of that to really find your cohorts that have those same growth expectations. Then your multiples can really come into play. But finding those cohorts is a challenge. But this is things that we work on a lot here at Northern Trust of how do we use AI tools, all this new data that we have to find groups of stocks that have similar growth expectations. That's the future of value investing. How has your view, I mean, you kind of started your career with factor investing and quantitative investing, and how has it evolved over time? Like if you were to go back to your initial, you know, factor-based sort of mindset when you started your career versus where you are today.

47:19Walk us through, like, the evolution for you and maybe even the evolution at a higher level in the factor space, but I'm just curious about that. Yeah. So let me start by talking about what hasn't changed. What hasn't changed is, you know, 10, 20 years ago, a factor was really about capturing a behavioral anomaly so 20 years ago uh investors overreacted to bad information they underreacted to good information this manifest is value this manifest is momentum okay so they also were risk seeking meaning that 10 20 years ago investors that were risk seeking would bid up the price of highly volatile stocks because they're looking for lottery tickets they're not looking for a, you know, 9 % return over the next year.

48:09They're looking for a 30 % return over the next two weeks. That hasn't changed. Investor behavior, I would say, has only been exacerbated in the direction of more risk-seeking behavior, less coupling to actual information and fundamentals, a lot more sentiment, a lot more animal spirits in the market today than there was just 10 years ago, which means that these anomalies are alive and well. If you capture them appropriately, they can be very potent in terms of their alpha generating capabilities. But maybe, Justin, to your point, how you capture them certainly has changed. So 1993, Fama French come out with their paper and say value is, you know, price to book, price to market, you know, I'm sorry, book to market ratios.

49:04Is that a good value indicator today? No, it's a terrible value indicator today. But can we do better? We talked a little bit about, you know, how do you think about value in this new context of you need to look more at the data you have available. 1993, we had this much data at our fingertips. Now we have this much data at fingertips. And so the methodologies for gauging sentiment, animal spirits, risk aversion, all these things that manifest as factors have changed dramatically. You have more data sources, you have new tools in AI, you have new ways of thinking about it. I'll give you one example.

49:48So in the olden days, momentum was simply something like a 12 minus one. So the price movement of the last 12 months minus the most recent month. Okay, just how a stock is trending on itself. That's the old style of momentum. Momentum today can be a lot more sophisticated than that. So now, through natural language processing, we can read or listen to anything that's ever been written or spoken about a company anywhere in any language and make a much better assessment of how companies are related to each other. So I know who your suppliers are. I know who your customers are. I know who your peers are.

50:29I know who your regulators are. I know in which countries you do business. And I have a much better ability to create a map or a constellation of firms to say who is actually related to whom. You know, we have a GIC sector classification or industry classification, which is almost meaningless. That's not how you group stocks. You have to group them based off of their what I'll call peer group or network. And what we found back to the momentum point is that there is a lot of momentum effects within that network, meaning that if your customers are doing well, that should ultimately mean that they pull you along with it, which ultimately means that you pull your suppliers along with it.

51:11So looking at momentum in that context has been incredibly potent in generating returns, excess returns or alpha. Also from the risk mitigation perspective to the point earlier, you now are almost completely insulated from this momentum crash phenomenon that we used to experience like stocks do well until they don't do well. That's great. But momentum within networks tend to persist and are not susceptible to that momentum crash. So how you think about these anomalies is completely different than it was 20 years ago. But the underlying investor behavior that has precipitated them hasn't changed a bit.

51:51And I would argue there's more risk-seeking behavior in markets today than there was 10 years ago. Thank you for sharing. That's a very interesting way to get at momentum outside of your traditional momentum factor that a lot of our audience would be familiar with. Obviously, not everyone has the tools and the natural language processing capability that Northern Trust does, but very cool nonetheless. And I could see how that could be a very interesting edge, I think. One of the questions that factor investors sometimes ask is about factor timing. Where do you fall on sort of trying to time these factor exposures?

52:32Yeah. I would say 10 years ago, I was emphatically on the negative side. today my view is almost completely reversed that now with you know all this data that we have at our fingertips new information coupled with the tools that we have we have a much better sense of the macro and sentiment sensitivities of factors and it is increasingly effective in timing factors overall. Now, the devil's a little bit in the details. It's not about just like growth versus value or momentum versus low volatility. You got to break it down to be more granular than that. At a country level, at a region level, a factor level, you need breadth within that toolkit, just like you need in any other portfolio.

53:27but we've done a lot of research lately that suggests that there is you know potency both in return generation and in risk mitigation to thinking about factor timing and it just makes sense value goes through cycles quality goes through cycles low volatility goes through cycles if you have a sense and these are you know multi-year cycles in many cases if you have a sense of where you're at in that cycle and where from a macro perspective you think you're going to be in a year, that can be potent. I know. I mean, you obviously spend a lot of your time thinking about the investment side of the house, I'd say.

54:05But I would imagine, you know, you and the leadership team there is also thinking deeply about the product side and where investors' appetite is with certain types of products. So I just want to ask you while we have you, I wanted to ask you just a few things. So it seemed like five years ago, direct indexing was going to just eat the lunch of ETFs. But that seems to have fizzled out. I mean, what do you think of that? I think ETFs are going to go only in one direction, and that's up in terms of their asset gathering. They are transparent. They're liquid. They're tax efficient. it is I think unambiguously the investment vehicle for a client that doesn't require a specific bespoke implementation but this is where direct indexing comes in as well I think we're still in the early days of direct indexing that custom portfolios whether it's for tax reasons for ESG and sustainability reasons for certain exposures from a geographic perspective that clients want are still very, very important.

55:17And evidence of that is that we have the direct indexing phenomenon that's going on with it, that's going on. But along with it, investors are increasingly going into long-short tax-loss harvesting vehicles, which are custom, they're bespoke, they're part of that direct indexing ethos. They're also going into custom fixed income, muni-bond portfolios for tax loss harvesting reasons as well. So what is happening is this DI idea has spread from just equities into munis, into long short, that what I think we're seeing is that for the right kind of client, that bespoke implementation can be very, very effective.

56:04So my bet is that both direct indexing and ETFs are going to see double digit growth over the next few years. Do you have any thoughts on tokenization? I was kind of fascinated with it, like when I first learned about it and it was kind of all the hype, it seemed like Robinhood launched some stuff, but then I haven't, you know, I know there's still a lot and I think maybe even some exchanges, the NASDAQ might be doing something with it. I mean, what's your view on, I guess, tokenization? So I think tokenization and ETFs are going to follow a similar path. So ETFs have been around for a long time, but it took a while for them to really take off.

56:44And I think tokenization is in the same bucket. Earlier this year, we actually launched our first tokenized product, a tokenized money market fund or share class of a money market fund. There's an express use case there. Now here you can actually use it as collateral for derivatives contracts and that's great. So that's an obvious one. Other asset classes I think the utility is obvious but how you get there is much more challenging. You have to solve a lot of problems on the way. If you can trade tokens you know in theory 24-7, 365 one of the top concerns that I have is well how does the trade of a token influence price discovery?

57:28Does it actually funnel through an exchange and be reflected in an exchange price at some point? Or is that completely off the exchange? You also have to think about the legal, you know, call it structure in place. A lot of the legal structure was grown up in the investments or asset management industry, grown up around mutual funds, commingled products, things that had a very specific way of being constructed and traded. Now you have tokens that there's a lot of legal ramifications to that and implications that have to be solved before we can really get there. But I will say this, that the use case, I think, is quite obvious that it is a more fluid, easier way to transact in markets.

58:17So it's coming. I'm very confident about that. Just like I'm confident about AI productivity it's coming but when and in what form i think a lot of that is going to going to revolve around the the nuanced details yeah that'll be exciting to see that innovation as we kind of look through it real time um we have two closing questions we like to ask all of our guests the first one is what's the one thing you believe about investing that most of your peers would disagree with you with um time diversification is a real thing and let me explain what that means So I think there's a huge swath of investors out there that say that markets are a random walk, meaning that they're kind of, you know, go up and go down randomly at their will.

59:06That's not the case, in my view, that you get as much diversification over your time horizon as you do within your asset allocation. and you know just a little bit of evidence behind that is that you know you consistently hear equity markets making all-time highs it's not a random event that time diversification is very very real unfortunately when you think about traditional asset allocation it's a point in time exercise say what's the correlation among my assets at a singular point in time boom that's it I think if you took time diversification into account, then you'd end up with a very, very different picture from an asset allocation perspective.

59:50More equity exposure, more risky assets, because if you have time on your side, markets are not a random walk in that sense. I think there is a convergence in that you can benefit from.

1:00:12from a 50-page restoration block or finally break down that long article you've had open for weeks. Gemini and Chrome is here for it. Ready to make anything online make sense? There's no place like Chrome. Check responses set up required, compatibility and availability varies 18 plus. This episode is brought to you by Indeed. You're ready to level up your business, but the pressure to find the right person to make that happen is intense. Indeed-sponsored jobs can help carry the load. It boosts your job post to help it reach quality talent fast. Cut through the chaos with Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

1:00:46Get a$75 sponsored job credit at Indeed.com slash podcast. Terms and conditions apply. Hiring now? Then this is a job for Indeed Sponsored Jobs.

1:00:59You spend most of your time working with professionals at Northern Trust, but also with some of the largest institutions in the world. But the last question is, because we do have a large retail audience that listens to us. Based on your experience in the markets, what's the one lesson you would teach your average investor? Yeah. I would say the average investor, even the professional investor needs to learn this, is that you have to get paid for every basis point of risk that you take. And I think it's a shock to many, even the many in the industry, that that is absolutely not the case right now.

1:01:40and hasn't really been through history. What I mean by that is this, is that you can form a portfolio and say, hey, I really have a lot of conviction on this group of securities, whatever it is, equities, bonds, commodities, whatever. And I want to form my portfolio based on that. Well, that's all well and good, but a lot of those portfolio managers don't really take into account the risks that they're taking in conjunction with that portfolio. So maybe they're over-concentrated in a specific sector. We talked about AI concentration. Maybe it's a specific region or idiosyncratic or security-specific risk that they're taking.

1:02:21When you look at, let's say, over the last, gosh, if you look at the S &P SPIVA research, if you're familiar with that, most active equity managers have underperformed their benchmarks, and pretty significantly. I think, and this is a rough guess, I don't have the data in front of me. Something like 80 % of active equity managers have underperformed their benchmarks over the last like one, three, five years. And by and large, it's not because they didn't have conviction or didn't make good stock picks. By and large, it was because what they didn't pick or what they underweighted went against them significantly.

1:03:01Now you say, well, aren't those two the same things? They're really not. you have to be careful about hey i'm going to source you know if i'm going to overweight a certain stock i got to underweight something else typically you got to be more careful on that that downside or that underweight side that is what's really caused a lot of the pain within active portfolio management so you know you buyer beware if i'm gonna if i'm a average investor or even a professional investor the first thing i'm going to ask of a strategy is it's great that you have a thesis around what's going to work and what's going to win what's not going to win and you have as much conviction around that that's what really really good investors do and that's the caveat that i think everybody misses is that you don't generate returns just from the the good picks that you have you also have to make sure that the things that you didn't pick don't crush you at the end of the day as well.

1:04:04Great conversation, Mike. Thank you very much. Well, thank you. Thank you for tuning into this episode. If you found this discussion interesting and valuable, please subscribe on your favorite audio platform or on YouTube. You can also follow all the podcasts in the XS Returns Network at xsreturnspod.com. If you have any feedback or questions, you can contact us at xsreturnspod at gmail.com. No information on this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed in the podcast may be holdings of the firms of the hosts or... Holiday drinks are now at McDonald's. Like the new Red Bull Frosted Cranberry Energizer.

1:04:41It's Red Bull mixed cranberry flavors topped with cold foam and sprinkles. Made to charge your holiday spirit. Now at McDonald's. Sam's Club is the club for every holiday club. Guess who's joining the club this season? Walmart Plus. Yep, Sam's Club Plus membership now comes with Walmart Plus at no extra cost. Two memberships, one great price. Just$120 a year can save you time and over$700. Want to get in on the membership duo of the century? Visit samsclub.com. Come join us. Sam's Club. Annual plan only, auto renews, TNC apply, estimate based on average combined Walmart Plus and Sam's Club Plus savings among members of both for one plus year versus non-member or club member pricing slash fees.

1:05:17Excludes membership fees. See Walmart Plus terms and Sam's Club terms for more info. Their clients.

From the publisher

Mike Hunstad, president of Northern Trust Asset Management, estimates that AI accounts for more than half the risk in the S&P 500. For an investor who sees real promise in AI, that poses a practical question. How much of the portfolio should depend on being right about it?


Hunstad joins Jack Forehand and Justin Carbonneau to explain where he expects the payoff from AI to show up first. A company that uses AI to do the same work at a lower cost could see its margins rise well before the gains show up in GDP. He also explains how the stock market can move the economy in the other direction. If wealthy households have been spending some of their stock gains, a 20% equity decline could change what they buy.


The conversation turns to what investors actually own. Hunstad uses the changing makeup of the Russell 1000 Value Index to show how a value fund can carry more technology exposure than its name suggests. He also shares the question he would ask an active manager after hearing their best stock picks. Which stocks did you underweight to pay for those bets, and do you have just as much conviction in those decisions?


Topics covered:

- What Treasury yields tell Mike Hunstad about inflation and the Fed’s choices

- Why profit margins are his first test of whether AI spending is paying off

- How the spending habits of wealthy households can turn a stock market decline into an economic slowdown

- Where quality, value and low-volatility stocks fit in a portfolio with a large AI exposure

- How much stock actually becomes available to investors when a large private company goes public

- Why price-to-book can miss value in businesses built on intangible assets

- How tracking a company’s suppliers, customers and peers changes the way investors measure momentum

- When a factor looks cheap and why timing a shift into it is difficult

- How the stocks a manager leaves out can overwhelm the gains from the ones they pick

Chapters:

00:00 What stock prices and economic headlines are saying

06:45 The Fed, interest rates and the 10-year Treasury yield

11:11 AI productivity and the case for a positive supply shock

18:31 How a stock market decline could reach consumer spending

22:51 AI capital spending and the lessons of the dot-com era

28:54 Who captures the gains from AI, and how to measure them

34:18 Mega-IPOs and how much stock comes to market

38:36 What private markets add to a public equity portfolio

44:11 Measuring value and momentum through investor behavior

49:10 Can investors time their factor exposures?

57:16 The portfolio risk in stocks you leave out


Learn more about the Excess Returns podcast network:

https://excessreturns.co


No information discussed in this podcast should be construed as investment advice. Securities discussed may be held by the hosts and guests, their firms or their clients.


More from Excess Returns

All episodes