Jay-Z and the Epstein files

5 Feb 2026 · 27 min · 16 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Fame Under Fire - Episode Summary: Jay-Z and the Epstein Files

Podcast Overview Title: Fame Under Fire Host: Anoushka Mutanda-Dougherty Description: The podcast dives deep into controversies surrounding celebrities, athletes, politicians, and other public figures, providing truth and clarity amidst misinformation and sensationalism.

Episode Overview Episode Title: Jay-Z and the Epstein Files Key Topics:

  • The inclusion of Jay-Z's name in the Epstein files.
  • Allegations made by Nicki Minaj against Jay-Z.
  • Legal implications and interpretations of the allegations.

Key Discussions

The Epstein Files

  • Definition: The Epstein files consist of an extensive investigative archive related to Jeffrey Epstein, containing around 600 million pages of information that includes tips, testimonies, and names associated with the investigation.
  • Significance of Inclusion: Just because a name appears in the files doesn’t imply guilt or wrongdoing. It simply indicates that the individual was mentioned in the context of the investigation.
  • Tip Line Mechanics: The FBI received numerous tips regarding Epstein, many of which were unfounded or irrelevant; thus, inclusion in the files does not equate to evidence of criminal activity.

Jay-Z's Mention

  • Context of Jay-Z's Name: A tip from 1996, which is vague and lacks substantiation, mentioned Jay-Z alongside other high-profile figures, but does not indicate his involvement in any criminal acts.
  • Implications of Inclusion: Legal expert Shaun Kent emphasizes that the mere mention of a name is not indicative of guilt and often involves procedural formality.

Nicki Minaj's Allegations

  • Claims Made: Nicki Minaj publicly labeled Jay-Z a "child predator" in a series of tweets, which led to a significant social media uproar.
  • Legal Ramifications: Minaj’s allegations raised questions about defamation and the potential for legal action from Jay-Z. However, the context of Jay-Z's inclusion in the Epstein files could complicate such a case.
  • Historical Context: Discussion of Minaj’s past, including her brother's conviction for child molestation, adds layers to her credibility and intentions in making these statements.

Public Perception and Consequences

  • Impact on Reputation: The episode discusses how quickly public perception can change based on mere allegations, particularly for high-profile individuals like Jay-Z and his wife, Beyoncé.
  • Dangers of Misinformation: The hosts stress the importance of distinguishing between fact and speculation, highlighting the potential damage that rumors can inflict on lives and careers.

Key Takeaways

  • Critical Thinking Required: Listeners are urged to approach sensational claims with skepticism and seek factual clarity.
  • Legal Nuances: The episode emphasizes the complexities of defamation law and the need for concrete evidence when making serious accusations.
  • Social Media Influence: The rapid spread of misinformation on platforms like Twitter can have real-world implications, as seen with the fallout from Minaj's tweets.

Conclusion This episode of Fame Under Fire encapsulates the intricate intersection of celebrity culture, legal frameworks, and the pervasive influence of social media, emphasizing the need for careful consideration in the face of scandalous allegations.

Next Steps

  • Follow-Up: Continue to monitor the discussion around the Epstein files and celebrity allegations through future episodes.
  • Engagement: Listeners are encouraged to send in questions and engage with the podcast on social media platforms.

Subscribe to Fame Under Fire on BBC Sounds to stay updated on future episodes.

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Current Events in Fame

1:28 to 3:10

Discussion of major celebrity news and scandals including Jay-Z's mention in Epstein files.

“a lot of messages from you concerned fans, people who are just curious, what does it say?”

Understanding the Epstein Files

3:10 to 6:39

Sean Kent explains what the Epstein files are and their implications.

“I just want to cover some ground that might feel very familiar for some people, but maybe for our younger listeners.”

Jay-Z's Inclusion: What Does It Mean?

6:39 to 11:43

The hosts analyze Jay-Z's name appearing in the Epstein files and its significance.

“Can you just talk me through where you can find them?”

Nicki Minaj's Controversial Tweets

11:43 to 14:00

Exploring Nicki Minaj's tweets regarding Jay-Z and other celebrities, addressing public reactions.

“That was the year Jay-Z released his first studio album.”

Lizzo's Allegations and Body Positivity

14:00 to 14:20

Discussion on Lizzo's civil lawsuit and the implications of body positivity.

“seen as she's always been sort of a mouthpiece for body positivity.”

Accusations Against Lizzo

14:20 to 14:49

Details about the specific allegations against Lizzo from her former backup dancers.

“I'm assuming she's referring to the civil lawsuit filed by three former backup dancers of Lizzo who allege they were subject to sexual harassment.”

Nicki Minaj's Controversial Tweets

14:49 to 15:36

Analysis of Nicki Minaj's controversial tweets and their legal implications.

“Everyone knows Chrissy Teigen has had a dick.”

Understanding 'Allegedly' in Defamation

15:36 to 16:22

Exploration of how the word 'allegedly' impacts defamation cases.

“just outright protect you against a defamation lawsuit?”

Historical Context of Defamation Cases

16:22 to 17:50

Review of a previous defamation case involving Nicki Minaj and its relevance.

“said, this rapper used cocaine and I know it to be true.”

Jay-Z's Legal Standing

17:50 to 19:42

Discussion on Jay-Z's inclusion in the Epstein files and its implications.

“Remember when she claimed that the COVID-19 vaccine enlarged men's testicles?”
Show all 16 chapters

Nikki Minaj's Motives and Allegations

19:42 to 21:11

Investigating Nikki Minaj's motives behind her allegations against Jay-Z.

“where are the actual damages that he has occurred because his name is in the Epstein file.”

Jay-Z's Response to Past Allegations

21:11 to 22:10

Examining Jay-Z's previous legal responses to allegations and its impact.

“Now, I just want to quickly touch on the conversation me and you had before about whether Jay-Z should sue.”

Listener Questions: Nikki's Brother's Conviction

22:10 to 23:35

Fact-checking listener questions about Nicki Minaj's brother's conviction.

“Everyone knows Jay-Z is notoriously silent and keeps to himself in a bubble and does not address these types of things.”

The Implications of Supporting Convicted Individuals

23:35 to 25:02

Discussion on the ramifications of supporting convicted family members.

“Sean, can you give us a quick fact check on that?”

The Fallout from the Epstein Files

25:02 to 27:00

Reflection on the broader impacts of allegations stemming from the Epstein files.

“Sean, you have really expertly walked us through the unfolding landscape of everything that's happened since the Epstein files have been released.”

Exploring the Dark Web's Hidden Realities

28:00 to 28:19

Discover the often-overlooked mission of special agents in the dark web.

“We focus on the part of the internet that most people don't know about.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Jay-Z:This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK. We focus on the part of the internet that most people don't know about. It's called the dark web. Undercover in the furthest corners of the dark web, US special agents are on a mission to locate and rescue children from abuse. Move in now. From the BBC World Service, World of Secrets, The Darkest Web follows their shocking investigations. Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

0:48Nicki Minaj:Hello and welcome back to Fame Under Fire with me, Anushka Matandadawati. Be prepared for some strong language from the outset and throughout. out. My God, do we have a lot to catch up on. You go away for two weeks and Nicki Minaj is holding hands with Donald Trump. Kanye or Ye is taking out an ad in the Wall Street Journal to apologize to the black community and the Jewish community. Elon Musk's company's office of X in Paris have been raided by the French authorities. And yeah, those unredacted exhibits in the Blake Lively Baldoni files. We have a whole deep dive episode coming on that shortly.

1:21Nicki Minaj:So stay subscribed. But as soon as this came up, I knew we needed to cover it. Jay-Z included in the Epstein files. I've had a lot of messages from you concerned fans, people who are just curious, what does it say? And separately, in a series of shocking tweets from Nicki Minaj, she's publicly called him a child predator. So what on earth is going on? Are they related? And there's reports that he's fled the country. We're going to get into all of that. Now, we should say right from the outset that, of course, Fame Under Fire has contacted Jay-Z's lawyer. That's Alex Spiro. Remember him? He's come up a few times.

1:53Nicki Minaj:We asked for a response to these allegations, but we haven't heard back. We do know that in the recent past, think back to those Diddy allegations that involved Jay-Z, he has issued vehement denials about these sorts of allegations. But let's get into this today and break it down. Joining me, of course, we are reunited, is our resident trial attorney, Sean Kent from South Carolina, which apparently is in the middle of a snowstorm or a blizzard of some sort.

2:17Jay-Z:It is blizzardpocalypse 2026. We got a good full half an inch of dusting of snow and the entire state shut down.

2:24Nicki Minaj:Oh my goodness.

2:26Jay-Z:Welcome to the South. We're not used to seeing snow. It's like dandruff all over the world.

2:32Nicki Minaj:It hasn't stopped you from appearing in a two-piece paisley suit with a striped lining. Oh my God, he's back. He's back with a vengeance.

2:39Jay-Z:We've been apart so long I decided to go very conservative together because I missed you.

2:45Nicki Minaj:Yeah, I'd say I miss you. but we talk all the time.

2:47Jay-Z:I think the world was on fire while you went on vacation, so let's make sure we don't go anywhere else anytime soon.

2:53Nicki Minaj:I'm never leaving you again. You try cycling around the rice fields of Vietnam and you're like, they did what now? What's been released? But we need to talk about the Jay-Z inclusion in the Epstein Files. There's a lot for us to go over here. But before we get into that, I just want to cover some ground that might feel very familiar for some people, but maybe for our younger listeners. Sean, can you just explain what the Epstein files actually are?

3:20Jay-Z:And I'm glad you asked that because there's been so much misinformation about the Epstein files because people hear the Epstein file, they're almost like the X files, and people think that it is the conclusion of an investigation of a bunch of people. All the Epstein files are just an investigative file. When I say investigative file, convicted financier Jeffrey Epstein, of course, was looked at for a bevy of charges. Chief among those charges were doing things with children. And so when the FBI was looking into him, they have a duty to follow up every tip possible and full information against Jeffrey Epstein.

4:02Jay-Z:So what the Epstein files are is everything. And I hate to say it that way, but it's everything. It's every bit of investigation that possibly could have happened against Jeffrey Epstein, whether it was about him or tangentially touched him. They had a tip line. It involves tips. It involves unsubstantiated tips. If Jeffrey Epstein's name came up whatsoever throughout an investigation, it involves it. If he went to the grocery store on the 16th and bought some watermelons from your cousin, your cousin's name is in the Epstein files, But it also includes his flight logs, people he talked to, trips.

4:39Jay-Z:So it is just a full investigative body. The best way to describe it is it is about three terabytes of information. So if you're sitting at home, it can fill up three fully charged iPhones with investigation and pictures and so forth. So the Epstein files is just 600 million pages of an investigation.

4:59Nicki Minaj:And there's so much for us to get into there about layers of investigation and what is personal emails, pictures. And we're going to talk about that. But really, at the center of all this are the victims, the survivors. And their names have cropped up in this, some of them unredacted. Can you talk about the handling of this a little bit?

5:18Jay-Z:One of my biggest fears as a criminal defense lawyer, as a human being, was the everybody said release the Epstein files. The problem with just releasing the Epstein files is our interest to know stuff has to be balanced by an individual's privacy rights. And so when we released Epstein files, we have victims who don't want their names released. People who are subject to horrible things at the hands of him. People are still going through psychological terror. We released it with such a haphazard reaction. It was so bad to me that it hurt more people than it possibly helped. And sometimes we have to balance the public's need to know versus a person's individual privacy.

5:57Nicki Minaj:Well, yeah, it's been re-traumatizing for a lot of the victims who are in there, some of them whose privacy has been violated. And it's already difficult enough having to go through what they've been through and then to have what many lawyers who've got clients who were victims and survivors of Jeffrey Epstein have said, just completely shoddy, just lack of care going through and not redacting people's names. I mean, some people's names have been in there hundreds of times. So I think we need to remember that those individuals are central to what's been released and have called for the release of the files.

6:27Nicki Minaj:But for people who are interested, and there is a great interest in this, because of the nature of the crimes and because we've heard so much about it, but also because he died before he went to trial, you can find the Epstein files yourself. Can you just talk me through where you can find them? Oh, yeah.

6:43Jay-Z:If you want to do the simplest part possible, you can find the Epstein files. If you got Google, you can find Epstein files.

6:50Nicki Minaj:Yeah. If you Google Jeffrey Epstein files DOJ, it will bring you up to a page. You have to be over 18 years old to look through. I would say, you know, sensitive material in there, triggering material for a lot of people who may have been through similar things. So approach with caution. But what you get is a page where you can keyword search terms. Now, if you go in there and you keyword search Sean Carter, you will find the inclusion, which is the real name for Jay-Z, of Jay-Z in the Epstein files. You've just covered how wide ranging they are, Sean. But I'm going to read out what is in there when you search up Sean Carter.

7:25Nicki Minaj:OK, so it came through a tip line. Can you just explain what that is?

7:28Jay-Z:So what the FBI does and most agencies do when they're looking at somebody who is this large in a crime, they set up an FBI tip line. And I'll tell you, having spoke to the FBI before on certain cases, as much as we think they love these tip lines, they hate them, but they are a necessary tool to try to get investigation and get information. because what happens in these tip lines is they get thousands of calls. They get fame seekers. They get individuals. And when they get these tips in, they send it out. They send a 1-800 number out. And they're like, if you have any information that might be related to, say, the Jeffrey Epstein case, please call our tip line.

8:08Jay-Z:What ends up happening is those informations come in. There is a body of people who sit there just in a room. It could be 100 agents who are listening to all these calls. And then they have to sift through them. There is an agency, a part of something that's called a taint team, and the team then breaks down the information first to see. And I'm trying to keep it simple, but what they do is they break down the first level of this is completely impossible. They're talking about. Astronauts, they're talking about aliens or talking about things as nature. We immediately remove those. And then the second part of the taint team sends the next bit of information that could have any logical information to what they're looking for.

8:49Jay-Z:And they investigate it. And that's all a tip line is.

8:52Nicki Minaj:So I'm going to read out what is in there. And it says, date time received 7th of October 2019 at 8.20 in the morning. It says, in approximately 1994, Redacted revealed herself to Redacted as a past victim of sexual abuse by Epstein. Redacted described the abuse occurred during parties. The next section is Redacted. Further identifies a few other Redacted names. Now, in relation to Jay-Z, it says in approximately 1996, Redacted resided with Redacted in Redacted. An unknown man abducted her from her home when she later awoke in the presence of Harvey Weinstein and Sean Carter, stage name Jay-Z.

9:32Nicki Minaj:While Weinstein had inserted his fingers into Redacted, Redacted believed she was in Epstein's mansion in Florida. So that is the specific reference to Jay-Z. And like you said, that's in the broadest sweep of the Epstein files. But Sean, that doesn't indicate criminality. It doesn't indicate that a criminal charge is coming against Jay-Z. It doesn't actually specifically reference any abuse committed by Jay-Z. So what should we take from this inclusion?

10:02Jay-Z:Nothing. And I hate to say it that way, and I'm not trying to be coy, but we should take nothing from it, but the world will. And here's why we should take nothing from it. If, these are massive ifs. Anushka, if you wanted to be included in the Epstein file, you could have called the tip line and giving that information with your name in it involving Jay-Z. And they would have had that in there. Until that investigative file goes to the next level, meaning there are possibly a criminal charges, maybe a grand jury has been indicted. Maybe he has been interviewed. Maybe he's been investigated. There is nothing there.

10:37Jay-Z:Just because this is the Epstein files, I want the world to understand this is nothing special. This happens every single day. Been doing this for 26 years. You would be shocked how many times we have clients, individuals, when I go and look at a criminal file where I see very random names mentioned in it and the cops are just like, yeah, that has nothing to do with the case. We got this tip. We just put it inside of there and no one ever knows. And so to answer your question, just being in the file means nothing because out there, believe it or not, somebody watching this podcast right now, Your name is in a criminal file because somebody has mentioned you and you don't even know it.

11:16So it means nothing at this point.

11:19Nicki Minaj:The inclusion is a procedural formality and it's because of what Trump signed to be released. But there are levels to the evidence that is there because there are other people, famous names, where there's pictures of them on Epstein Island. There's correspondence between Epstein and them. It's a couple of emails back and forth where they seem to be arranging to meet up. But that is all very different from what is in there pertaining to Jay-Z. I also want to say that the claim is that this took place in 1996 on that tip line. That was the year Jay-Z released his first studio album. And some people on social media have pointed out that perhaps he wouldn't be rubbing shoulders with Harvey Weinstein and Jeffrey Epstein when he just released an album in 1996.

11:57Nicki Minaj:But that, of course, is there for the FBI to investigate. And there are no criminal charges. And if there were, we'd be telling you about them.

12:08Jay-Z:We focus on the part of the internet that most people don't know about. It's called the dark web. Undercover in the furthest corners of the dark web, US special agents are on a mission to locate and rescue children from abuse. Move in now. Police! From the BBC World Service, World of Secrets, the darkest web follows their shocking investigations. Listen on BBC.com or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

12:41Nicki Minaj:so sean you've just explained very clearly that jay-z's inclusion and what we should take from it which you've said is pretty much like nothing at all but i want to say that this was taken then to another level by nikki minaj who is you and i know one of the most successful female rappers of all time and a former fan and collaborator of jay-z so yeah nikki minaj has long looked up to Jay-Z. She obviously has an album called The Prink Print, which is a direct reference to his album, The Blueprint. Like you say there, she's talking about if she hadn't signed with Lil Wayne to be on the YMCNB label, she'd have signed with Jay-Z.

13:16Nicki Minaj:She's done songs with Beyonce, on and on and on, which is why it's really quite confusing for people who are just casual observers of this, that she posted a shot of Jay-Z with Aaliyah, the R &B singer, with the caption, hashtag child predator. Now, this did actually come amidst a flurry of other tweets, some of where she was making fun of Lizzo's body. Sean, you've got that one, don't you?

13:36Jay-Z:I do. Quote. Not getting canceled. This is like reading mean tweets, but reading the tweet out, going with the glasses here, that way it shows. Fat Lizzo lost 300 pounds just to sell 300 albums. So now she has loose skin and a flop album and a weird charge. Sheesh.

13:56Nicki Minaj:So she tweeted that about Lizzo. Interesting thing for Nicki Minaj to tweet, seen as she's always been sort of a mouthpiece for body positivity.

14:04Jay-Z:Body positivity. She is the cult of inconsistency hypocrisy on some of these tweets based upon who she is and her history. But I'm sure we'll get into that as well.

14:13Nicki Minaj:I mean, I want to fact check that. First of all, Lizzo is not facing any criminal charges. You don't get charges with a civil trial. So it's an incorrect thing to say. I'm assuming she's referring to the civil lawsuit filed by three former backup dancers of Lizzo who allege they were subject to sexual harassment. Some of those claims are that Lizzo pressured them, one of her backup dancers, to touch the breast of a dancer in a nightclub in Amsterdam. Other incidents cited in the case include claims that dancers were asked to eat fruit from the naked bodies of club workers. Lizzo has denied multiple times all the allegations, saying, I am not settling.

14:46Nicki Minaj:I'll be fighting every single claim until the truth is out. Now, Sean, if I'm going to be really, really petty, I can fact check the weight loss claim technically lizzo has publicly stated that her heaviest she was 325 pounds so by nikki's math she'd be 25 pounds currently weighing 25 pounds um i know she's being facetious but you know just for the interest of taking it literally um in other tweets from nikki that she's released she's claimed that chrissy tegan has or had a penis allegedly sean Give me that tweet.

Read the full transcript

15:18Jay-Z:Everyone knows Chrissy Teigen has had a dick. D-I-K, period. Allegedly, period.

15:24Nicki Minaj:And look, Nicki Minaj hasn't presented any evidence for this claim and Chrissy Teigen hasn't responded. But yet again, another crazy tweet from Nicki. But I just want to ask Sean, at what point does slapping the word allegedly on the end of an inflammatory or potentially defamatory statement just outright protect you against a defamation lawsuit?

15:41Jay-Z:In a weird way, yes. because you remember you're trying to hold the statement out to say that it's true. And so you're not verifying its veracity. You're saying allegedly. So you're saying, I'm not saying that is true. I'm saying it's not. And let's not forget the statement in and of itself, just this statement by itself to me, isn't defamatory. I know you're like, what? It's an insult. We still have to use the whole sticks and stones may break our bones references when talking about these things. But yes, believe it or not, putting allegedly on there could save a lot of things because the defense, if she gets into trial, will be like, look, I didn't hold this out to be truthful.

16:21Jay-Z:If I can give you an example, in 2022, there was a lawsuit in which a rapper sued a podcaster by the name of Nosy Ho, H-E-O-H-E-A-U-X, Ho, or something of that nature, in which Nosy Ho said, this rapper used cocaine and I know it to be true. And so the rapper ended up suing Nosy Ho. Her real name was Marley Green and sued Nosy Ho and said, how dare you say this to be truth? This is defamatory because you have now accused me of a crime. It's defamatory per se. You can't do this. So they sued. Nosy Ho settled and said, you are right. And part of the settlement was you have to apologize and you better never talk about my family again.

17:04Jay-Z:And said, we'll never talk about your family again. And if you ever mention my family again, I'll give you$50 ,000. The reason I bring it up is that was Nicki Minaj. Nicki Minaj was the rapper who sued. Oh, what? Mind blown. Nicki Minaj in 2022 sued Marley Green because Marley Green said that she was a cokehead. Nicki Minaj says, you cannot say this stuff about me because it's insinuating that I have committed a crime. Why do we bring that up? Well, think about it. Mind blown. Well, you've been digging around in the archives.

17:39Nicki Minaj:Yeah, start looking. Well, maybe that's what taught Nikki to slap on the word allegedly to the end of her Twitter rampage. This isn't something new for Nikki. She's said inflammatory things on Twitter before. Remember when she claimed that the COVID-19 vaccine enlarged men's testicles? No proof of that, by the way, guys. And I mean, Boris Johnson responded to that. Nikki is known for saying some crazy things on Twitter, but the tweets about Jay-Z are brimful of criminal allegations claiming he's a child sexual predator without the use of the word allegedly, but also that he's been, quote, sacrificing children as a way of gaining and maintaining power, close quote.

18:16Nicki Minaj:She also said, quote, the guy was hugging and humping on teens in broad daylight, close quote. Once again, we asked Alex Spiro, Jay-Z's lawyer, for a response to Nikki's allegations and we've heard nothing back. Now, a listener question is coming from Sophie from London. Hi, Sophie. Thank you for the question. On TikTok, it says, surely Jay-Z should be filing a defamation lawsuit expeditiously, in all caps, if this is false. The allegations are so bad. Sean explained that, but also why his inclusion in the Epstein files kind of helps Nikki out in this case.

18:48Jay-Z:Given the fact that Nikki is in the rap game, she knows that you can take things to a different level if they're intended to be satirical, if they're intended to be entertainment value. So that changes, however, if you are taking it to a level and you are saying that I am alleging that this stuff is true and I know it to be a fact. How do we know Nikki knows about this? I told you about the 2022 lawsuit. She knows if you call somebody a criminal, you can say something about it if you're alleging criminal activity. Where the Epstein file makes it slightly different is because his inclusion in the Epstein file, even though, as we've talked about, doesn't really mean anything, it gives Nikki a little more pause with the community to say, you know, he's in the Epstein file and everybody else thought that there might have been something into it.

19:37Jay-Z:It might give her a little more leeway to make this leap. Where she could be helped would be where we always talk about is the damages element. where are the actual damages that he has occurred because his name is in the Epstein file. And if you do a simple search, people are talking trash about him.

19:55Nicki Minaj:That is interesting. Then if he sued her for defamation, she could say, well, I didn't say something, present something as truth that I knew to be false because I saw this document. I had a genuine belief that this was the truth. So then it adds credence to that defense against the defamation lawsuit from Jay-Z, right?

20:14Jay-Z:And then there's one more level to that, too. Actual malice, and you'll probably bring this up, is Nikki has a predisposed beef with Jay-Z and there might be a, she actually has actual malice. She might be trying to hurt him and I don't want to jump the gun, but Nikki has a problem with him.

20:29Nicki Minaj:If you were Jay-Z's counsel and say, well, you have clear motive to want to defame Jay-Z. You have publicly stated multiple times that you think he owes you hundreds of millions of dollars. Does that matter when you're fighting a defamation case to go, well, actually, there is a narrative here. There is motive here. There's a reason she would have said that to benefit herself.

20:49Jay-Z:Absolutely. All comes in together. And because of her history, you have filed your own defamation lawsuits, multiple. You know that you cannot accuse somebody of committing a crime. You know that you have a personal beef with him. You used to be friends. This is clearly you going to the next level. We believe you understand, and this is defamation per se. Pay us money.

21:11Nicki Minaj:Now, I just want to quickly touch on the conversation me and you had before about whether Jay-Z should sue. And typically you said your advice would be no. But because of what happened in the past, and I just want to cast everybody's minds back to when Jay-Z was accused, along with Diddy, in a civil lawsuit of raping a teenage girl at a VMA's after party in the 2000s, Jay-Z's response to that was to file a lawsuit against the accuser, to file a lawsuit against the lawyer, Tony Busby. and he spoke a lot which he doesn't usually do to the press he said those allegations are so heinous in nature that i implore you to file a criminal complaint not a civil one whomever would commit such a crime against a minor should be locked away would you not agree his own heartbreak he says is for his family his wife and his children so he spoke a lot and then he followed through with legal action those lawsuits have all been dismissed now the one accusing jay-z and diddy dismissed with prejudice can never come back the lawsuits jay-z filed against the accuser and tony Buzz be dismissed.

22:08Nicki Minaj:But Sean, in your opinion, because he did that, it now weakens his position with the Nikki tweets.

22:14Jay-Z:Everyone knows Jay-Z is notoriously silent and keeps to himself in a bubble and does not address these types of things. And when he came out so vocal against it, everyone's like, wow, Jay-Z never addresses these things. And he just went all in on it. And the problem is psychologically, and you have two problems, public perception. When you have attacked one so big time and then start ignoring the rest, you have the people who say, well, why did he attack that one? He doesn't attack this one. Maybe he thinks it's true. And if he doesn't attack every case with the same vitriol he attacked the first one, I think it could hurt his reputation.

22:50Nicki Minaj:Yeah, Jay-Z's lost a lot of followers. So is Beyonce, his wife. I mean, social media users are quick to point out that the allegations that were in that lawsuit where he was accused with Diddy were so graphic and so awful, more so than what is said in this tip in the Epstein files and that he specifically said that was hurting his family. And he referenced there, of course, Blue Ivy, his daughter, who was the same age as the alleged victim in that case. So there's an argument there for why he responded to that one and not this one. And now I've got another question for you from a listener. This one from Canada.

23:23Nicki Minaj:Shout out to Canada. Shout out to Shane Hollander. It says, isn't Nikki's brother in jail for molesting a child and didn't she defend him? Sean, is this true? Maybe Jay-Z should point that out. Sean, can you give us a quick fact check on that?

23:39Jay-Z:Convicted of sexual assault, child endangerment, I think in like 2017. And we don't have to say allegedly convicted for the rape of an 11 year old, like in jail, like right now. There's a difference from testifying for somebody during a trial. There's a difference from testifying for somebody and say, I don't believe this happened. After they are convicted, something happened that is called sentencing, which means the eyes of the law says he did it. After sentencing, then Nikki then presented a letter or a testimony to the court supporting her brother. So the world can say that after sentencing, after he was convicted, after we know he did these things.

24:17Jay-Z:She said, support him. He's a good person. Support him. You are supporting a pedophile yourself. You are openly doing it. You're writing letters. You're sending it to the court. You have to be careful with these type of things. Now, do I think Jay-Z should bring this up? This goes back to what I said earlier. No. You know, the little phrase is if you lie with dogs, you get fleas. You've got to be careful going back and forth with these types of things. So, no, I would not do that. I appreciate the listener's question. But the background on what the listeners said is absolutely accurate.

24:44Nicki Minaj:And look, that's Jelani Mirage, Nicki Minaj's brother. I mean, his counsel said that the accusations were false. He's obviously been convicted and said it was a cash grab. Nicki has tweeted to that effect as well, saying it was a cash grab by the young girl's family. But there was a wealth of evidence, including his DNA. DNA. Yeah.

25:02Jay-Z:We'll just leave it there.

25:03Nicki Minaj:Yeah. Sean, you have really expertly walked us through the unfolding landscape of everything that's happened since the Epstein files have been released. And then also what Nikki has tweeted and how people are reacting to Jay-Z and also Beyonce online. I just wonder, what do you think our listeners should take from this? The release of the Epstein files, but also the unfolding backlash of what we've seen here.

25:24Jay-Z:What we should take from it, from my point of view, is the danger of a lack of information, the danger of supposition, the danger of guessing because of the lives that can actually be destroyed. destroyed if you look at a couple such as and they're not the only names in the list but if you look at a couple such as jay-z and beyonce who have decades of years of capital to the world beyonce has the beehive jay-z and all these other situations and one rumor included inside of a list can destroy all of that capital without more and so that is the danger you have to worry about is be careful of just simply saying they're on the list.

26:09Jay-Z:They must be awful people because it can destroy careers. It can destroy lives. And we're talking about very rich and very famous and very powerful people, billionaires. Imagine the victims. Imagine the children. Imagine just the random John Q public name who is mentioned inside of there, because if that can destroy the reputation of a Jay-Z and a Beyonce, what could it do to just the random individual who is mentioned inside of there who has just happened one day is like, hey, I saw your name mentioned that Epstein list. What are people automatically going to be thinking about that?

26:41Nicki Minaj:Yeah, exactly. And also to add on to that, Jay-Z's name was mentioned, Beyonce's wasn't. There's no charge there to begin with. Sean, thank you so much for coming on and walking us through that today. Really appreciate it.

26:52Jay-Z:Thank you for having me per usual. I appreciate you.

26:55Nicki Minaj:That was our resident trial attorney, Sean Kent, joining us from South Carolina. And that's it for this episode of Fame Under Fire from BBC Sounds with me, Anushka Matanda-Dowdy. Keep sending me your questions on Instagram and TikTok. It's anushka underscore MD. And if you want to follow along for more reporting on the Epstein files and what's in them, please follow the BBC Live reporting page.

27:18Nicki Minaj:How does someone invent a political theory that reshapes the map of the world? How do you get to a scientific breakthrough that saves thousands of lives or create works of art that stand the test of time? How have brilliant thinkers through history done their best thinking? And what can we learn from them? From BBC Radio 4, it's the second series of Human Intelligence with me, Naomi Alderman. From Karl Marx to Marie Curie, from Emily Bronte to Leonardo da Vinci. How did those exceptional minds do their work? And are there ways of thinking we can emulate today? To find out, listen to Human Intelligence on BBC Sounds.

28:01Jay-Z:We focus on the part of the internet that most people don't know about. It's called the dark web. Undercover, in the furthest corners of the dark web, US special agents are on a mission to locate and rescue children from abuse. Move in now. From the BBC World Service, World of Secrets, the darkest web follows their shocking investigations. Listen on bbc.com or wherever you get your BBC podcasts.

From the publisher

The latest release from the Epstein files has once again thrown the spotlight on numerous famous names such as Bill Gates, Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor and President Trump. But within the millions of documents, other famous names have appeared, so what does it actually mean if your name is connected to the files? One of those mentioned is rapper Jay-Z, included after an FBI tip off many years ago. It’s provoked a big social media interest but is this really a significant development?

And in a series of shocking social media posts, rapper Nicki Minaj has made some wild allegations about child abuse involving Jay-Z. In the past Jay-Z has always strongly denied any wrongdoing.

Fame Under Fire gets the legal lowdown from resident trial attorney Shaun Kent and separates the fact from the fiction.

Host: Anoushka Mutanda-Dougherty Series Producer: Jim Frank Senior Impact Producer: Melanie Stewart-Smith Production Coordinator: Hattie Valentine Technical Producer: Cameron Ward Editor: Lisa Baxter Assistant Commissioning Producer: Rechmial Miller Commissioning Producer: Adam Eland Assistant Commissioner: Will Drysdale Commissioning Editor: Rhian Roberts

More from Fame Under Fire

All 78 episodes
Jay-Z and the Epstein filesFame Under Fire · 27 min
Listen in VO