1. Podcasts
  2. Filmspotting
  3. Twin Peaks (Pilot)
Filmspotting

18 Nov 2026 · 30m · 12 chapters

Episode artwork

Twin Peaks (Pilot) | Archive

In short

The episode is an “Archive” Noirvember conversation about Twin Peaks (Pilot) (discussed as a 2020 rewatch/conversation). It argues the pilot works as an ideal entry point to David Lynch because it wraps Lynch’s unsettling, off-kilter sensibility in a mainstream whodunit.

Key claims

Lynch/Frost were largely allowed to make the pilot as “once in a lifetime” art; the show’s appeal is less about “who killed Laura Palmer” and more about what evil does to a whole town; the performances are intentionally heightened/misaligned to reflect that seepage; and Angelo Badalamenti’s score (especially Laura Palmer’s theme and the Twin Peaks theme) is essential, with Julie Cruz’s singing adding seductive menace.

Notable examples

the opening body discovery, Sarah Palmer’s staircase close-up, Cooper’s goofy thumbs-up and “we’ve got a lot to talk about,” and the Bobby interrogation.

Guests

Adam and Josh (co-hosts), plus referenced contributor Andy Mitchell (former PA) and Debbie (a listener/companion mentioned by Josh).

Written by AI. May contain mistakes.

Chapters

1:21

Initial Impressions of Twin Peaks

Hosts share their experiences watching Twin Peaks for the first time.

“It is Noirvember, so we're dropping something noir related.”
2:15

The Making of Twin Peaks

Discussion on the creation of Twin Peaks and its artistic freedom.

“It's one of those instances where even if you're watching two, maybe three episodes a night, we never fast forwarded through those credits.”
4:14

The Pilot's Impact and Viewership

Exploring the pilot's debut, viewership numbers, and cultural impact.

“And that's just one of the reasons why Twin Peaks the Pilot is so good.”
5:44

Twin Peaks as an Entry Point for Lynch

Debate about whether Twin Peaks is the best introduction to Lynch's work.

“In April 1990, we've already established you were watching Murder, She Wrote, apparently, with your mom.”
8:13

Exploring Themes of Evil in Twin Peaks

Discussion on the themes of evil and the nature of the town in Twin Peaks.

“Maybe you're not going to go down that path of now watching more David Lynch films because you've already seen them.”
11:15

Trivia and Personal Anecdotes

Hosts share trivia about Twin Peaks and personal viewing experiences.

“And first of all, I love that you've only seen the pilot episode.”
13:10

Significance of Music and Performance

Hosts discuss the importance of music and performance in Twin Peaks.

“It was the summer before my freshman year of college.”
14:01

Revisiting Twin Peaks: Initial Thoughts

The hosts discuss their recent experiences watching Twin Peaks and the impact of its music and performances.

“But I watched those first 15 episodes, Josh, in maybe three days, you know, three to five episodes a day.”
15:00

The Power of Music in Twin Peaks

A deep dive into the significance of the soundtrack and its effect on the series' atmosphere.

“I was a little bit surprised at just how invigorating and powerful I found the music, just how essential I thought the score was to the success of Twin Peaks.”
23:45

Character Performances and Empathy in Twin Peaks

Exploration of character performances in Twin Peaks and their emotional complexities.

“This season of my podcast, Who's With Me, I speak with two-time Emmy winner and weirdly one of my best friends, Kevin Avery.”
Show all 12 chapters
28:03

Complex Layers of Laura Palmer

Exploration of Laura Palmer's character complexity and the show's unique tone.

“So you're learning all these things about Laura as if she's she's really a troubled teen.”
33:00

Television's Changing Landscape

Discussion on the impact of Twin Peaks' original airing and its cultural phenomenon.

“Definitely wasn't watching Murder, she wrote, Josh, sorry, no offense, but I remember seeing it, you know, you would go to the grocery store, you were a kid and you'd see the TV guide with Laura Palmer on the cover.”
A man walking through an airport, asking his phone a question

Ask about this episode

Get the gist, explore an idea or ask about something said.

Claude

On Filmspotting, what are the key points of this episode?

Searching your listening

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00Adam Kempenaar: This is an iHeart Podcast. Guaranteed human. O, O, O, O 'Reilly.

0:07Josh Larsen: Check engine, ABS, or maintenance light on? Take the guesswork out of your warning lights with O 'Reilly Veriscan. The service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ASE certified master technicians. And if you need help, we could recommend a shop for you. Ask for O 'Reilly Veriscan today. O, O, O, O 'Reilly.

0:57Josh Larsen: Auto Parts app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.

1:07Josh Larsen: What kind of a show are you guys putting on here today? You're not interested in art? No. Now look, we're going to do this thing. We're going to have a conversation.

1:17Adam Kempenaar: Hey, film spotters, time for this week's archive drop. It is Noirvember, so we're dropping something noir related. Last week, Our sacred cow review of Chinatown from 2024 this week, you know, Sam can't probably play the battle of mente due to copyright reasons. Unfortunately, Josh, we're both hearing it. We're hearing the Twin Peaks theme in our heads and will be the entire time we're talking because we're sharing our conversation about Twin Peaks, the pilot from 2020. 2020. And if I'm remembering correctly, you had not seen the pilot at this point in 2020. Is that correct?

1:59Josh Larsen: That's absolutely correct. And based on that good experience and just the fact that I knew I had to get to it at some point, I've not only watched the series, but almost become a completist, have yet to get to the return, but have seen Firewalk with me just the last couple of months. And yeah, it's funny you say that about the score because watching it as we did, kind of binging twin peaks. It's one of those instances where even if you're watching two, maybe three episodes a night, we never fast forwarded through those credits. No, you can't. You had to like, it was just like to get you, even though you were already in the mind space, it reset you properly to get back in that weirdo uncanny universe.

2:44Josh Larsen: You needed those credits and you needed that battle of mentee score.

2:47Adam Kempenaar: Yeah. I'm sure someone has done that list before, but there's a top five or maybe even top 10 of TV series whose opening music and montage you never skip. And Twin Peaks is number one and can never be supplanted. That is just a given. I'm glad you pointed that out. So let's go back to 2020. We did an 8 from 84 review of David Lynch's Dune. That got taken away from him. Terrible experience. Guess what? it shows on screen. He pretty much had full control over what he was doing with Twin Peaks, especially because, and I know this because, Josh, I am currently, I've got Twin Peaks on the brain. I have Twin Peaks on the brain most of the time anyway, but I'm actually currently listening to the audio book, A Place Both Wonderful and Strange, The Extraordinary Untold History of Twin Beaks by Scott Meslow.

3:41Adam Kempenaar: And this isn't a surprise to anyone, surely, but when Lynch and Mark Frost made the pilot and got the entire crew together and all the cast and they made this movie. They really did think this is probably never going to air. Yeah. And no one's going to see it. No one's going to see this. There's not going to be more. We're getting to make this amazing thing. This is once in a lifetime isolated little piece of art. And they got left alone for the most part and got to make whatever they wanted to make. And that's just one of the reasons why Twin Peaks the Pilot is so good. So here's our conversation about Twin Peaks the Pilot from 2020.

4:24Josh Larsen: It's a nice, quiet place, something like this. Sheriff, let me stop you in the hallway here for just a second. There's a few things that we've got to get straight right off the bat. I've learned about this the hard way. It's best to talk about it up front. When the Bureau gets called in, the Bureau's in charge. And you're going to be working for me. Sometimes local law enforcement has a problem with that. I hope you understand. like i said we're glad to have you here sheriff what kind of fantastic trees have you got growing around here big majestic douglas furs douglas furs well if you've ever wondered why people

5:00Adam Kempenaar: love twin peaks so much maybe look no further than a scene like that one with kyle mclaughlin's special agent dale cooper and michael on keen's sheriff wait for it harry s truman the pilot episode of Twin Peaks debuted on ABC 30 years ago this year, 9 p.m. Eastern time on Sunday, April 8th, 1990. That's six years after Dune and four years after Lynch's return to critical acclaim with 1986's Blue Velvet. 34.6 million people watched that pilot, Josh. And for proof that we live in a very different time now, that's more than double the average number of people watching the highest rated program on TV these days, which is Sunday Night Football.

5:44Adam Kempenaar: That's craziness. Yeah. In April 1990, we've already established you were watching Murder, She Wrote, apparently, with your mom. And I missed it too.

5:52Josh Larsen: Hey, Adam, Angela Lansbury's Jessica could do no wrong. She's a queen. No, she's a queen. Absolutely. Well, Twin Peaks is set in the fictional town of Twin Peaks, population 51 ,201. It's just south of the Canadian border. And the pilot episode starts with the discovery of the body of teenager Laura Palmer. McLaughlin's special agent, Dale Cooper, is brought in to help solve the case. And along the way, we get to know Laura's friends at the high school, Laura's family, and some of the stranger characters of the town. Adam, Andy Mitchell, former PA here on the show, sent in a question that I think is a really good one and probably a good place to start, especially in relation to Dune.

6:31Josh Larsen: You referenced this earlier when we were talking about Dune. And Andy asked, is Dune the worst place for someone to start with the filmography of David Lynch? He also wonders, is Twin Peaks the best intro for someone who has never seen David Lynch? What do you think?

6:47Adam Kempenaar: I think he's right. I think it probably is. Now, Blue Velvet was my entree under the world of David Lynch. And then I saw Twin Peaks probably next. And I loved Blue Velvet from the first moment I saw it. I've mentioned it before, one of my transformative cinephile movies, really what turned me into someone who appreciated arthouse cinema. It felt that way to me at the time anyway. And I think if you were trying to turn someone on to Lynch, give them all that quirkiness and just that true kind of Lynchian sensibility. And I think we will get into that a little bit more and maybe define it as we talk about this episode, but still wrapped in kind of a mainstream package where you can watch it as TV and get caught up in the murder mystery aspect of it, the whodunit aspect.

7:37Adam Kempenaar: I think there's probably a lot there to latch on to if you are dipping your toe in. If you're just trying to dip your toe into the Lynch waters, I think Andy's right. I think Twin Peaks is probably the best. Now, you're coming to this, Josh, as someone who has seen all of Lynch's films except for Twin Peaks. You haven't seen the movie Firewalk with me. And if we are setting aside the technicality of Twin Peaks technically being TV and talking about it as an entree onto his film work, I am, of course, really eager to hear your answer to Andy's question and really just dying to know if you appreciated Twin Peaks even half as much as I do.

8:15Adam Kempenaar: Maybe you're not going to go down that path of now watching more David Lynch films because you've already seen them. But are you interested in going down the path of seeing more Twin Peaks?

8:24Josh Larsen: Yeah, so I agree. Andy's right. And it's that conventional aspect that makes it such an easy entry point because Lynch can be, you know, initially off-putting in a number of ways. He doesn't follow narratives. A lot of the material is strangely graphic in a way that's unsettling differently than maybe like an exploitation film that has the same content, you know? So it takes a little bit to adjust to him, and this is the perfect way to do that. Maybe the best example is I was asking Debbie the same question as we were watching it. You know, did you watch this in 1990? And she says, no, I remember my mom being really hooked on it and, you know, would eventually say it was like after 9 p.m.

9:06Josh Larsen: slot, you know, back when they had those more adult shows were on after 9 on network television. And she would be like, okay, to Debbie, you might need to leave the room after a certain point. So it had that balance, you know. It had that Lynch unsettling element at the same time that it had the conventional whodunit that would pull us along, pull someone into it who is maybe watching a police show the hour before or something like that. I'd have to ask her. I don't think Debbie's mom probably has seen a lot of other Lynch films, but she sure enough watched Twin Peaks. So there's your example.

9:39Josh Larsen: I think it's great. I mean, I'm absolutely hooked. Debbie is too. She wants to keep watching them. And I said, well, let's wait and see. You know, we've talked about maybe in the next year doing something with the show in terms of watching the whole series again. And so then we'd probably hold off. But, yeah, we're both hooked. I think it has, you know, my second go around with Lynch is resulting in greater appreciation. And I'm still teasing out why that is. But I think part of it here is just his kind of his exploration of evil, really. And how we experience evil, where evil resides, how you define evil, what is, what isn't.

10:25Josh Larsen: And this, I mean, like a whodunit like this set around the murder of a teenager, the unexplained murder of a teenager is just like the perfect locale to ask some of those questions because it is shocking, it is disturbing, but it's also pulp material we're familiar with. and Lynch finds a way to make this seductive. I think that's the key for me. And that's maybe why Twin Peaks does work so well as a series, because it's that serial aspect of keep pulling us along, keep teasing us. Not just because my sense already from the pilot episode, we want to know the next clue, because I'm already less interested in finding out who killed Laura Palmer than I am in figuring out what's going on in this town in general.

11:14Josh Larsen: What is happening to these people and how different really is it than what's happening to people in towns all across America? Hmm.

11:25Adam Kempenaar: Hmm. It's funny you mentioned that. And first of all, I love that you've only seen the pilot episode. And obviously you're basing this off of what you know about Lynch and his other films. But I love that you're tapping into this aspect of evil already without knowing really at all where this is going, because it just is so fundamental to this series. And as we said to his work now, I did want to acknowledge here one bit of trivia that Sam mentioned to me earlier today in our Slack. And it's so funny that he did because watching Twin Peaks again and seeing that sign come up in the opening credits.

12:00Adam Kempenaar: And I'll take a quick sidebar here. A while back when quarantine started and we were talking about the things that we were watching during this time, what we were streaming during quarantine, I mentioned revisiting Cheers on Netflix and it being one of those theme songs that I will never skip the intro song for. And I know we're going to talk about the music here, but I will never skip the intro for Twin Peaks. I don't care how many times I've seen these episodes. I will watch it every time. And when that sign comes up and you see Twin Peaks population 51 ,201, I definitely had the sense watching it that that didn't make any logical sense whatsoever.

12:38Adam Kempenaar: I'm like, this seems more like a town of 5 ,120. And Sam said, I don't know what number they added, but Sam said that he saw a note somewhere that the producers of the show, the network or whatever, felt like people wouldn't care about the goings on in too small of a town. So they did add a number to the population to make it seem bigger, even though now that doesn't match at all. Right. What we see in terms of the layout or the people and their relationships. But I know I've touched on this before. Twin Peaks was, before this became a thing, my first binge watch. It was the summer before my freshman year of college.

13:15Adam Kempenaar: My best friend, Matt, who turned me on to Lynch, got that VHS box set of Twin Peaks. And when I would get home from my summer job and anything else I had going on, I would just put on Twin Peaks episodes. And I think I got through those first 15 episodes. It's kind of an odd structure, right? Where it's two seasons, but it's 30 episodes, But the first eight are what comprise season one. And then you figure out who the killer is kind of halfway through the 30 episodes around episode 15. I did kind of take a break after I got there and then jumped back in later in the summer. And I did go a little bit slower after you you get some of that key information and maybe Lynch becomes less of an artistic touchstone, less intimately involved with it.

14:00Adam Kempenaar: the scope and the tone of things do change in a way that maybe aren't quite as satisfying for us David Lynch fans. But I watched those first 15 episodes, Josh, in maybe three days, you know, three to five episodes a day. I just couldn't stop watching. And then I proselytized from there. Everybody I met when I went to college, we had Twin Peaks night. Every week we would watch episodes from the show and watching it again for the first time here in 20 plus years. Honestly, It was still a treat. And I had two kind of mini revelations. And I'll say they're mini revelations because there's no way that you appreciate Twin Peaks without appreciating both the performance of Kyle MacLachlan and the music of Angelo Badalamente.

14:46Adam Kempenaar: I don't think you can even say that you're a fan of David Lynch overall without appreciating Angelo Badalamenti. It was always a key part of my love for this series. And yet watching it this time, I was surprised. Let me say that. I was a little bit surprised at just how invigorating and powerful I found the music, just how essential I thought the score was to the success of Twin Peaks. Did you have a similar reaction?

15:12Josh Larsen: Oh, man. Yeah. You're touching on the two things I wanted to make sure that we talked about. So let's start with Battle of Menti's soundtrack. It is just, to me, it was so off kilter. And everything going on in this show is off kilter because it has the familiarity, the conventionality, but then it's Lynch, right? And that's exactly what the music does. Because much of it, my impression, Adam, was almost like a, you know, we're talking like 90s, right? A movie of the week sort of inspirational theme to it. I think Laura Palmer's theme especially has that. But then at the same time, all of the pieces and the Twin Peaks theme particularly has this insinuating baseline, right?

15:54Josh Larsen: That is, I'm going to use that word again, it's seductive. But it's also kind of like burrowing away at the inspirational elements. And this is kind of what Lynch's stuff does, right? It's like forcing you to ask, like, is this really like Americana, like a feel-good Americana, or is something else going on here? And I'm not, I've mentioned before, like someone who listens to soundtracks while I'm working. I don't often do that. It takes certain soundtracks that will really make an effort. But I had this score going on all day today just to kind of re-immerse myself in it because it does what you're saying.

16:31Josh Larsen: It puts you so directly in that world. So it's definitely the score. But also I want to mention, too, Julie Cruz, the singer who appears here singing. I think she sings The Nightingale and Falling.

16:56Josh Larsen: Music by Battle of Menti, the lyrics by Lynch. she also is spookily seductive, right? That voice that is such a perfect match for what's going on here. And I knew that I knew the voice when we were watching it. And sure enough, just looking up, I realized, sure, she covered Elvis Presley's Summer Kisses, Winter Tears. That was on the soundtrack for Vim Vendor's Until the End of the World, which came out in 1991. So, yeah, I wasn't watching Twin Peaks then, Adam, but I did go to the theater to see Until the End of the World. And that's a soundtrack I did buy because of the Julie Cruz number. And there's another great songs on that soundtrack, too.

17:34Josh Larsen: But she's crucial, I think, to this. But it's Battle of Menti. I can't imagine this working a quarter as well as it does without that music.

17:43Adam Kempenaar: No, I felt the same way. And it's funny that you mentioned that kind of movie of the week feel. I mean, I wrote down in my notes, it is at its core a soap opera, right? And I agree. Laura's theme even feels a little bit at times like the music from Days of Our Lives or The Young and the Restless. And everyone here has a secret. Everyone is having affairs. Everyone is living some kind of double life. And I think that the magic of Lynch is in his ability to partly elevate those conventions and that structure and approach at times even deconstruct it, maybe. But he also so clearly, sincerely appreciates the form.

18:20Adam Kempenaar: And I think that's what really does come through that kind of dichotomy and that contradiction even. And it's all there in the music as well. The tracks themselves, I think, do express the layers of the characters and of the show overall. So I'll go back to Laura's theme. Early on, approaching the body, Doc Hayward, Sheriff Truman, we get those really dark, slow, ominous chords just holding. And then we discover that it's Laura who has been killed. And we get that almost lovely, romantic lift.

19:07Adam Kempenaar: And yet rather than it being discordant in some way, it's actually kind of heartbreaking. There's an ache in the beauty of that moment just as they see who it is. There's this suggestion, I think, of an innocence compromised, of something destroyed there. And that music plays across the cut to Laura's mom, who's trying to get her downstairs to come from school. And that perfect transition, Josh, I watched it like three times today, where we just quickly, musically, then go back to the beginning. Those foreboding, ominous chords holding. And it switches right as Sarah Palmer comes into close-up, peeking around the kitchen to the staircase, where we finally really see her face in full.

19:50Adam Kempenaar: And that staircase imagery is going to come back into play again.

19:54Josh Larsen: I can already tell that. And it's terrifying, even though I don't know what's going to come. It is.

20:00Adam Kempenaar: And it's a combination of obviously the way it's shot. It's the moment itself, what it's filled with and the music there. And what we read in Sarah Palmer, the worry so clearly on her face, the recognition, I think, in that moment, just when she rounds the corner, the music cues us to the recognition that something is profoundly, profoundly wrong. And then we we get something like the track. If you look at the soundtrack, that's called freshly squeezed, which is it's jazzy and it's it's snappy. And there is snap. Yeah, that's the other element. And then and then there's that, you know, you touched on this, the descending walking baseline.

20:35Adam Kempenaar: It's playful and it's light. But use the word seductive. I definitely say it's sensual and it is like this show overall, like Lynch. It's mysterious. So even when when the music is kind of just teasing that out of you, it's just adding that additional element, I guess I'd say even of wonder, which is also a term I would use to describe how Dale Cooper approaches most events that happen around him.

21:04Josh Larsen: check engine abs or maintenance light on take the guesswork out of your warning lights with o'reilly veriscan the service is free and provides a report with solutions verified by ase certified master technicians and if you need help we could recommend a shop for you ask for o'reilly veriscan today Oh, oh, oh, O 'Reilly. Auto Parts. What really drives the global economy? The Big Take podcast from Bloomberg News goes beyond the headlines to bring you reliable, data-driven reporting.

21:40Adam Kempenaar: To borrow a phrase here shamelessly, how does the U.S. make treasuries great again? It's a big challenge. China's not putting its saving into the U.S. treasury market anymore. The U.S. debt is blowing up. And AI is just absorbing capital from around the world.

21:52Josh Larsen: We follow the money, the power, and the policies. When Zelensky was on the phone with the president, the president just kept saying diesel, diesel, diesel.

22:01Adam Kempenaar: I don't think I have ever in my journalistic career confronted a journalistic subject that was genuinely secretive the way Jane Street was.

22:08Josh Larsen: One major story, 15 minutes, every weekday.

22:12Adam Kempenaar: So the previous game in the series, Grand Theft Auto V, has sold 230 million copies.

22:18Josh Larsen: The population of a small country is playing GTA. It is.

22:19Adam Kempenaar: It is bigger than a lot of small countries.

22:21Josh Larsen: We're just like swinging between fear and greed every day based on the latest headline, you know. Where are we today? My play is fear. I play greed. Listen to The Big Take wherever you get your podcasts. Yo, what's up? This is Big Boy One Half with the legendary Outcast. And I'm here with my two sons. This is Cross. And I'm Bamboo. And this is Bloodlines and Baselines. Real conversations between the father and his citizens.

22:45Adam Kempenaar: Talking about the music, the sports, the culture. Finance, romance. We gotta talk about them aliens too now. Get in here before they cut us off.

22:55Josh Larsen: He does that every episode

22:58Adam Kempenaar: There's some topics we gotta save for later They gotta get the real And we're gonna give it to you straight no chaser Like what happened to my brother Sneaker Game And then once COVID hit I kinda just like stopped being a sneaker head And then that's when I started wearing the Jesus Sandals Damn man So the COVID The COVIDs came out and brought you close to the Lord

23:17Josh Larsen: And now you just got a sandwich Or the day dad told us what he really does on tour. I'm a Pokemon master. I'm level 56 now because I've been busy. Bloodlines and Baselines is our new podcast with a K.

23:32Adam Kempenaar: You feel me? And that's Baselines. B-A-S-S like the 808.

23:35Josh Larsen: Dropping three times a week. I think we might be on to something, boy. Listen to Bloodlines and Baselines on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, wherever you get your podcasts.

23:44Adam Kempenaar: See ya.

23:53Josh Larsen: Hey everybody, it's me, W. Kamau Bell. This season of my podcast, Who's With Me, I speak with two-time Emmy winner and weirdly one of my best friends, Kevin Avery. Everything up to that point, Bill Jew is a comic. Us going on the road, doing Battle Mountain and Ely.

24:08Adam Kempenaar: Yeah, you took me, you were one of the first people

24:09Josh Larsen: who took me on the road, which is funny because at the time I was like, I don't know if I like this guy.

24:15Adam Kempenaar: With rapper, actor, Daveed Diggs. The jump off for me was Hamilton and it was the most popular thing in a very long time. But it was still, for me, it was me and my friends making something dumb. Bruce Lee's daughter and Brandon Lee's sister, Shannon Lee.

24:31Josh Larsen: Back to your initial point of stewarding my father's legacy and giving my energy to that. You're lending your life to stewarding somebody else's life. Listen to Who's With Me with Debbie Quimbell on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. yeah and that that's where we should go next because those jazzy elements often are accompanying cooper right as he's on the case it's it's kind of um bringing that whole feel to those moments and and audrey too yeah yeah but it but it's off it's off kilter as well and man is especially watching this after what i said about mccloughlin in dune and i know it's you know years later but what a delight he is here.

25:18Josh Larsen: He's goofy, but you also know that Cooper is competent, right? He knows what he's doing. He's good at his job. He notices things, but he's so lighthearted about it, I guess. And the way he can change an expression on a dime and keeps everyone off, I don't know yet if that's like a Columbo-style tactic of his, or it's just kind of who he is. And you would think that this would not be the right approach for a grim story like this, right? But if you think about all the performances, just about every performance here, and you mentioned Sarah Palmer, Laura's mother, played by Grace Zabriskie, like the outsized anguish she expresses when she finds out what happened to Laura is like so heightened.

26:00Josh Larsen: And Cooper is like so goofy and other people, it's weird. It's almost like there are times where they're muted too, and you expect them to be more outspoken about everything is like either too loud or too soft. Everything is either, sometimes the emotions come before they should in the scene. And it happens with so many performances that you know, it's on purpose. It's not just like Lynch. And we should also say, right. Mark Frost, the co-creator here. It's not as if Lynch and Frost are just casting quote unquote big actors. Like this is on purpose that all of these performances are off just a bit.

26:38Josh Larsen: And I think it's, again, to keep us disoriented, but also goes back to that idea of evil, where it's not just that these are bad people or that bad things have been done. It's like there's something seeping into this town that is affecting how they even respond emotionally. And so these bizarre performances, even as much as you're like, whoa, what is going on here? They make perfect sense, at least to me, with what the series seems to be interested in doing.

27:08Adam Kempenaar: Yeah, well, you can't have darkness without the light. You can't understand one without the other. I think that's so essential to Lynch. And we even get it in the fact that we learn everything we do about who Laura Palmer is. Again, she's dead at the very beginning of the episode, and we only see her in some home video footage at this point in the series. We really don't know who she is, and yet we know we think everything about her or we at least start to get a picture of who she is based off what we come to learn about the crime and the mystery surrounding it, but the impact she had on everyone in the town.

27:45Adam Kempenaar: And so there's that lightness, that innocence, again, the opposite of all the true darkness that we're seeing in the way people react to her death, even like Audrey's brother, right? The kid who's distraught because Laura's not going to come and read to him that day. So you're learning all these things about Laura as if she's she's really a troubled teen. And yet we also get the exact opposite. We learn how loving she can be and how compassionate she can be. And I think that ties back to what you were saying about what really makes this Lynchian. And I think what you were touching on, Josh, in terms of the performances and some of the dialogue, even in the tone, there's just an unpredictability to it.

28:31Adam Kempenaar: You think with material like this, you know what a response in a certain moment should be.

28:36Josh Larsen: That the only surprise is the mystery, which is reversed here.

28:40Adam Kempenaar: No, that's it. It's every moment. It's every reaction. It's every line and everything that's expressed just hits you in a way that I don't think any of us fully expect. And I think it it's teased out in ways like we know before everyone else does, as I said, that Laura is dead. So then when you see Sarah and Leland's response to it, right, and even Donna and James, we know it before they do. And they know it then before the rest of their classmates do, before the principal has finally announced it. It just lingers. The dread there lingers. And we even get the aftermath with the principal's response when he breaks down.

29:19Adam Kempenaar: Lynch really makes us sit in that dread for a long time in a way that's that's uncomfortable. But I also think is really appropriate for the subject matter. And then you take that and you get Lynch doing plenty of goofy Lynch things, too, like the bell ringing and kids going to class and a kid just break dances kind of across the frame for a second or even Bobby and Mike barking like vicious dogs and James when they're in the jail cell. It's totally silly. You can find yourself laughing at it, and then there's something inherently terrifying and primal about it as well. So you're going to get all of those layers.

29:54Adam Kempenaar: You're going to get, in addition to that, longing in these characters and earnestness too. And that's all culminated, I think, in Mulgachlan's Agent Dale Cooper where you said it. There's a professionalism to him. There's a no-nonsense aspect to him. He seems to carry the weight of his job, of this crime, what he thinks he knows about it, where it might be going that everyone else in the town maybe doesn't fully understand. But then he's also genuinely kind of in awe of this place. Sure. And in a childlike way, appreciates all these basic things like coffee and pie and the big trees and their smell.

30:31Adam Kempenaar: And even, Josh, I mean, who who can begrudge a clean room with a reasonable rate? You know, so so we get these touches. And I just want to really emphasize how much I love McLaughlin here. When Sheriff Truman calls for backup and Cooper gives him a thumbs up, that goofy thumbs up, or even when they're in that room, speaking of Paris, Texas a little bit, I was having flashbacks to the twitchy fluorescent light when they're looking at the body. Oh, that scene. Yeah, wow. That scene, right? And then his eyes as he turns to Sheriff Truman and says, we've got a lot to talk about. It's encompassing all those things we just said.

31:07Adam Kempenaar: It's this sense of you aren't even going to be able to believe or start to understand everything I could fill you in on. And yet, almost like a kid, he's saying, I can't wait to tell you, right? And the interrogation of Bobby is one of my favorite scenes in the pilot where Dana Ashbrook, who I think is really good as Bobby, gets angry and he lashes out. And McLaughlin just turns slowly to Michael Onkeen and smiles. And then the whole time, smiling, he says, Bobby, here's how this works. We ask the questions and you answer the questions that we ask briefly and to the point.

31:45Josh Larsen: It's delightful. He's not good cop. He's not bad cop. He's just like, he's Mr. In-between cop. Like it's just going to roll off him and he's just going to do his job. Yeah, that's great. So how bizarre to think about, you know, we mentioned that, what was it? 34 million people watching the pilot. And I'm trying to remember now. So this comes out, that many people watch it. If you missed it, are you out of luck? I mean, are you, or did they, did, uh, this was ABC, right? I think it was ABC. Did they like, did they replay it later? Like, you know, in the week to catch more people once it became a sensation, I wish I could remember that element of it because as you said, they're setting it up, Adam, the landscape is just so completely different.

32:30Josh Larsen: It is gotta be hard for younger listeners, you know, who have gotten into television and movies in the era of streaming to even fathom what it would be like, not just to have it doled out that much, but to have a sensation like this. And it was a huge sensation to just, to just drop. And then it was there and it's gone. Suddenly it just, it's gone. It's, I mean, it's kind of perfect for Lynch, right? But that's how this was released. A little ephemeral.

32:56Adam Kempenaar: Yeah. No, it's a really good point because as I said, I don't remember what I was doing at the time. Definitely wasn't watching Murder, she wrote, Josh, sorry, no offense, but I remember seeing it, you know, you would go to the grocery store, you were a kid and you'd see the TV guide with Laura Palmer on the cover. And you knew that this was a sensation. But to your point, you also knew if you were hearing about it and you were a little bit intrigued, you were like, oh, but but the horse is out of the barn there. I've missed it. I can't now pick up Twin Peaks and watch this. And you're right. There's still some series we all watch these days where they do unfold now week to week.

33:32Adam Kempenaar: And I know we're so used to streaming and binging that that is something that makes most of us angry when we have to do that, right? Because we're used to be able to just go, I want to see the next episode right now and I'm going to watch it. But waiting each week to watch Twin Peaks, that's not the experience, as I said, I had. And I appreciated that I got to just enjoy it all and consume it all as fast as I could. But I also think there would have been some magic in being able to look forward to that every week.

34:00Josh Larsen: Yeah. Yeah, for sure. Something like X-Files maybe is a similar experience I had where it was like, couldn't wait to see what was going to unfold next. Because mystery was built in there as it is here. Look at these pictures. Look how happy she is. You ever do cocaine with Laura, Bobby? We want to remind you that access to the Film Spotting Archive, that is just one of the benefits of joining the Film Spotting family. You also get bonus shows, a weekly newsletter, early access to events, and more. If you would like to join, and we'd be very grateful if you did, just go to filmspottingfamily.com.

34:36Adam Kempenaar: This conversation can serve no purpose anymore. Goodbye.

35:19Josh Larsen: Okay, mi gente, it's holiday season, and yes, we want to look cute, pero we also want to be comfy, ¿verdad? Like, why get all dressed up when you can slay the season in cozy PJs? You can be cute, take family pics, eat all the holiday food, and still be ready for a little siesta. I mean, priorities. And Old Navy has matching family PJs that make Christmas morning extra cute. So, en estas fiertas, keep it cozy, keep it cute, and let the slumber party begin. Old Navy. Sala and slay all the way. Shop in store or online at OldNavy.com. When the holidays start to feel a bit repetitive, reach for Sprite Winter Spice Cranberry and put your twist on tradition.

36:03Josh Larsen: A bold cranberry and winter spice flavors fusion, Sprite Winter Spice Cranberry is a refreshing way to shake things up this sipping season and only for a limited time. Sprite, obey your thirst.

36:21Adam Kempenaar: Building with AI should feel simpler, not harder to navigate. The challenge is finding the right resources to move from exploring AI to building with it. The Microsoft AI Innovators Hub brings together code samples, guided labs, and practical guidance to help you move from exploring AI to building with it. Learn by building at the AI Innovators Hub. Visit aka.ms slash AI dash innovators. That's aka.ms slash AI dash innovators.

From the publisher

For this week's Noir-vember Archive drop, we're sharing Adam and Josh's 2020 Sacred Cow review of the Twin Peaks pilot, which originally aired in April, 1990.

Unlock the full archive, Filmspotting Discord, ad‑free + bonus episodes, and more when you ⁠join the Filmspotting Family⁠. 

See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

More from Filmspotting

All episodes