In short
Episode topic: The hosts discuss whether you can separate “the art from the artist,” using Pablo Picasso as the case study, while also riffing on intimate, gross anecdotes (including a fart/smell incident) and how artists’ personal lives affect interpretation of their work.
Guests and backgrounds
Bebe Cave (engaged to host Horatio Gould; described as interested in pre-Raphaelite/Victorian romantic art and “whimsical, dreamlike, feminine” aesthetics). Horatio Gould and his wife Mrs. Horatio Gould appear as co-host/guest figures; the episode is framed as “Great Artists: Picasso.”
Key claims
Picasso is portrayed as extraordinarily talented early (traditional mastery as a teen; “unlearning” later), but his legacy is “tarred” by alleged misogyny, abuse, and exploitation of women. The episode claims his women were treated as “machines/vessels for suffering,” and links his early sexual experiences (father taking him to a brothel) to later patterns. It also argues that romanticizing suffering can coexist with producing great art.
Notable examples
Picasso’s “Blue Period” (after a friend’s suicide), the “Rose Period,” Marie-Thérèse Walter (17 when met), “Guernica” (bombing depiction), “The Weeping Woman,” and the Minotaur-themed erotic/violent imagery.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOEngagement Announcements and Personal Stories
2:20 to 5:07
Discussion about Bebe's engagement and humorous personal anecdotes.
“and the podcast has essentially become the back pages of the times where high-owning individuals earn out their engagements.”
Picasso's Artistic Influence and Life
5:07 to 6:28
Exploration of Picasso's life and how it shapes his art and public perception.
“I should just say that, but I would like to add that as a link, I think Picasso, obviously, I think you were shitting on the bowl in a sort of quite Picasso-esque way.”
Picasso's Legacy and Misogyny
11:15 to 14:00
A critical discussion on Picasso's legacy and the controversies surrounding him.
“Picasso once said of women, there are two types of women.”
Introduction to Picasso's Early Life
14:00 to 15:00
Learn about Picasso's early challenges and influences as a child artist.
“After Queen Victoria has been made the queen, but it's before King Edward is made the king.”
Picasso's Artistic Prodigy
15:00 to 17:28
Explore Picasso's early talents and his journey to becoming a master artist.
“that the midwife thought he was a stillborn.”
The Pressure of Genius
17:28 to 19:10
Discuss the psychological impact of being a child prodigy and its effects on Picasso.
“He's the one that can put his art out there.”
Influence of Women in Picasso's Life
19:10 to 21:20
Examine how women influenced Picasso's art and personal life.
“It'd probably be like if I, because my family's all intensely musical, really, really musical.”
Misogyny and Artistic Archetypes
21:20 to 23:19
Delve into the representation of women in art and the problematic nature of such portrayals.
“But I guess the idea is that you sort of, you see off the new ball in a brothel.”
Picasso's Relationships and Legacy
23:19 to 25:20
Discuss the complexities of Picasso's relationships with women and how they shaped his legacy.
“To me, in a way, his crazy life is actually quite feminine, but because he's so masculine about it, because he doesn't apologize for himself, we associate it as being this very masculine man.”
Reflections on Being a Muse
25:20 to 28:00
Consider what it means to be a muse in the context of art and the treatment of women.
“He's not had sex with his granddaughter, so she's objective.”
Show all 33 chapters
Picasso's Early Influences and Blue Period
28:00 to 29:18
Explore Picasso's early influences and the emotional depth of his Blue Period.
“Yeah, so he repeatedly reinvents himself, as you said.”
Cubism and Artistic Innovation
29:19 to 30:50
Discussing Picasso's role in the development of Cubism and its impact on art.
“Rather than depicting objects from a 2D normal viewpoint.”
Picasso's Controversial Relationships
30:51 to 33:24
Examine Picasso's complex relationships with women and their influence on his art.
“This is the first time you've been on the pod since your fat Elvis comment.”
Picasso's Darker Side and Artistic Justifications
36:01 to 37:36
Delve into the darker aspects of Picasso's life and the ethics of his art.
“So, now, we should probably get into the alleged abuse, right?”
Guernica and Picasso's Political Statements
37:36 to 39:48
Analyze Picasso's painting Guernica and its historical significance.
“I was gonna say, when do you get some of your patrons to fight?”
Legacy of Picasso and Artistic Value
39:48 to 41:18
Consider Picasso's legacy and discuss the perception of his art over time.
“Now we've talked about this from the very early days of the pod.”
Reflections on Picasso's Impact
41:18 to 42:01
Reflect on the lasting impact Picasso had on art and culture.
The Problematic Weeper Woman
42:01 to 43:35
Exploration of a famous painting of a crying woman and its implications.
“Dora Ma, sorry, that's the other one who fights.”
Coping Mechanisms and Gender
43:36 to 46:16
Discussion on emotional responses and societal expectations of women.
“And it like tends to get me out of a lot of troublesome situations.”
The Legacy of Artists and Their Families
46:17 to 47:48
Analysis of the challenges faced by the children of famous artists.
“must have been sad who was the other guy?”
The Burden of Artistic Genius
47:49 to 49:36
Debate on how artistic genius can affect family dynamics and personal identity.
“And if you then raise kids who are born with the money from your art, but don't have the talent, I think they feel this sense of imposter syndrome that leads to depression.”
Surrealism and Its Roots
49:37 to 51:41
Introduction to surrealism and its connection to historical events.
“So now Picasso becomes a surrealist officially.”
Dali's Controversial Legacy
51:42 to 54:28
Discussion on Salvador Dali's surrealism and political views.
“But you're wanking at something that's on your wall.”
Art, Money, and Fame
54:29 to 56:00
Exploration of the relationship between art, commercial success, and personal identity.
“Because it does show a lack of curiosity about the extremes of humanity.”
Franco's Clock and Dali's Fame
56:00 to 56:50
Explore how Franco's changes affected time perception and Dali's obsession with fame.
“Except really in the first place, they only have half a day.”
Dali's Publicity Stunts
56:50 to 57:45
Discuss the eccentric publicity stunts of Salvador Dali and their implications.
“At some sort of an event, and he passed out.”
Dali and Disney Collaboration
57:45 to 58:56
Examine the relationship between Dali and Disney culminating in the film Destino.
“And it took 58 years to finish this short film called Destino, which I guess finished both after they'd both died.”
Interpreting Surrealism and Modern Art
58:56 to 1:00:07
Analyze the nature of surrealism and the interpretation of modern art.
“And it is funny when you sort of compare.”
Art and Historical Context
1:00:07 to 1:02:02
Discuss how historical context influences the interpretation of art, particularly regarding Dali's works.
“and a little postcard image of postage stamp of Hitler.”
The Evolution of Art Post-Warhol
1:02:02 to 1:04:28
Explore the shift in art after Warhol and the challenges of contemporary artists.
“Here in David, there's a compilation of David Lynch talking about every time he forgets an idea, he wants to kill himself.”
Bebe Cave's Edinburgh Show
1:04:28 to 1:06:56
Learn about Bebe Cave's upcoming Edinburgh Festival show and its themes.
“Because now, in many ways, the British art scene, certainly in Europe, is the bigger, the most emerging one, but they're sort of...”
Bebe Cave's Edinburgh Show
1:08:04 to 1:08:52
Learn about Bebe Cave's upcoming Edinburgh Festival show and its themes.
“Hey, I'm running out to drop off a stack of letters and packages.”
Bebe Cave's Edinburgh Show
1:09:22 to 1:09:52
Learn about Bebe Cave's upcoming Edinburgh Festival show and its themes.
“Avatar Fire and Ash is now streaming on Disney+.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast. Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode available on Plus and Pro Plans. Who says Halloween only lasts one day? With Wayfair, one night of Halloween becomes a whole season at home. From larger-than-life yard decor and moody lighting, to festive accents for every room in the house, Wayfair has what you need to make Halloween feel like magic all in one place.
0:46Because the best Halloween memories aren't made in just one night. They're made all season long. Shop Halloween decor now at Wayfair.com. That's W-A-Y-F-A-I-R dot com. Way fair, every style, every home. Still waiting in line? Again? That's time you'll never get back. Save time and money with Stamps.com. Over 4 million businesses have skipped the line with Stamps.com. Join them to save up to 90 % off carrier rates from your computer or phone right now. Print postage for certified mail, registered mail, and packages in seconds. Then schedule a pickup right from your home or office. For a limited time, go to stamps.com and use code podcast for a free welcome gift.
1:29Taxes and fees apply.
1:42Welcome back to Finn vs. History. I'm joined by Horatio Gould. Hello. And Mrs. Horatio Gould. There he is. BB Cave. Look at this for the first time. The second time. Second time what? But it's the second time she's been on the pod. Yes, I guess. It's the first time that you've had a repeat guest. Yes. And it's the first time that you've had a guest that's engaged to one of the hosts. This is the first time we've had... First of many. Yes. We're going to... Henry VIII is going to sort of... We're going to become bloated and just have a sort of carousel. Victoria's been on twice. This is the first female guest we've had on twice.
2:12Yes. A second BB Cave has hit the podcast. Yes, a second Horatio Gault has hit the podcast. Also, I like the idea that you're here to announce your engagement and the podcast has essentially become the back pages of the times where high-owning individuals earn out their engagements. Yeah. It's really convenient timing, actually. I'll make sure to hold my microphone like this. Just to get the ring in. Was the last time you saw Charlie skiing, pretty much?
2:39No. Yeah, because it was good to have a first-hand account of... Yes, yes, we should have a sort of... Do you want to explain what happened from your perspective? I really don't. I really don't. Just from your perspective, just set the scene. Don't make me do that. That's quite, that's quite, what I'll say about Stephen Bartlett's podcast is he kind of eases the trauma out and you've just kind of like a fucking truck driven into it. You've asked me to do my least favourite thing, which is be gross. Oi, love, talk about how bad this shit's were. That's essentially what you've done. I knew I shouldn't have told you.
3:08No. I knew that you would commodify. No, you ran back and you're white as a sheet and you said on the landing, it was one of the worst spells I've ever smelt in my life. I feel that's unfair. You said, You said that I heard him furiously flushing, I believe. It was only because it happened two days in a row and I thought that might be something genuinely wrong. So was it on the second day that you... It was on the second day that I thought... God bless you for buttoning it up for a day. That's nice of you. I thought maybe there was something wrong with the drainage and then it was the second time nearing the flushes from upstairs.
3:44I just thought to myself, that really is so severe. that I wonder if it's, if it's, we're all going to get sick. Do you know what I mean? I had to. Yeah. Did it change the fact that for lunch, you saw him eat a giant steak tartare? He literally looked like he was eating a dog's dinner. It was the most revolting plate of food I've ever seen in my life. No knife and fork in my head. No knife and fork. And it's, you know, the thing is when you stay with people for the first time, even if you know them quite well, there is a real, there's a real kind of, there's an intimacy to it. There was intimacy to it.
4:20I saw him wandering around in boxes and a little vest. I mean, you see that here in the office. It doesn't mean anything. I also did talk to you because... Oh, Charlie, I don't want to embarrass you. Go on. It was obviously because we were playing cards. And I went down to the basement to get some fizzy water. And it was in both the bathroom downstairs as well. And so I knew it was you. Because the thing is, it was because we'd been playing cards. I'd go in there to fart. Where'd you go to fart? To the toilet. I think that's fine. Because it was such a recognisable sense. It was a very distinctive busk.
4:57And he realised it must have been you then. Because he'd done upstairs and downstairs. I'd seen you go downstairs a few times during the court games. And I wondered what was going on there. So today we're talking about Pablo Picasso. I don't want to talk about it. I should just say that, but I would like to add that as a link, I think Picasso, obviously, I think you were shitting on the bowl in a sort of quite Picasso-esque way. I think it looked like an actual poo I think you were just kind of spreading I'm really sorry Charlie I know you didn't want to talk about that Absolutely Picasso-esque shits in the toilet of the Airbnb that you guys were staying in But in a way it's kind of interesting because if we're thinking about the themes of the episode and you know the relationships that people have what is moral to include an art can you include every aspect of somebody's life What is moral to include in the toilet No I mean you know you decided to share this intimate detail of charlie's because you knew that it was going to be beneficial for your art he benefits from it in a way too because it's funny is it pretty i don't think i'm pretty that's not what i thought you're going to say i thought you're going to say it's interesting as to how much you can romanticize yes someone who is uh you know public facing yes quite fun yeah or like entertaining but actually the reality to live with them very very difficult man exactly but also maybe the hangover of sharing so much yes and i think charlie obviously shares a really wonderful whimsical side of himself is it whimsical i think so i was a paedophile for a year oh what a whimsical waif back there thinking he's a fucking nonce for a year well i think it's not about 20 bollocks for you It comes with cons, doesn't it?
6:36You know? Yeah. So maybe the Charlie - Are you surviving Charlie Milner? When that documentary comes out, you can have a talking head. I'm going to have to be one of those people that shuffles the microphones. How much can you separate the fart from the farting?
6:51I'm really sorry, Charlie. No, no. We brought it up. Now, we brought Mrs. Horatio Gould on the show. And in my head, I'm saying, you know how when we were on tour in Bristol and that guy in Bristol - What's your name? And he went, yep, and you're staying with Mr. Horatio. It was like a travel lodge in Bristol. He completely had never seen anything like it before. And I understand it's not a normal name, but to go Japanese and he goes, Horatio Gid. That's how I now think about it. Mr. Horatio Gid. It's Mr. Horatio Gid. Because you're quite an arty couple, I suppose, now, aren't you? You often say this is probably the sort of thing your missus wears.
7:31and it'll be like a mad hippie flower dress. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Healing feels. Because Amanda's quite, she's quite earthy and real. She's a bloke, really. She's not intending the star sign stuff, astrology. Whereas, Bebe, you're, now that the relationship's more locked down, I feel you're kind of going quite far that way. I think so. Maybe because I feel more comfortable that you won't leave me. Because at the beginning you used to laugh about star signs and said it was only just, but now I've recently seen you in the middle of the night getting pieces of paper and out the window, you rip it up in front of the moon, which is pretty like horror film sort of stuff, exorcist sort of stuff.
8:10Really, you throw paper at the moon? No. Wow. It's a full moon ritual. I don't even dream at night. I'm just asleep. Look, it's a full moon ritual. And, you know, it's the same thing as manifesting. It's the same thing as, you know, tech bros fucking waking up at six in the morning and I don't know, going to the gym is a ritual. It's just, it's ways that human beings compartmentalize big feelings and try and, you know, be happy. Yeah, but you said you were getting more hippie-ish. I would say that - You said you were going to end up as a fat witch, is what you said. Yeah, I did say that. Did she?
8:41Her words. I do think I probably, my future is that I will be a fat witch at some kind of big stone. I think I will be traveling to see a big stone. Yeah, yeah. To recap, right, in the last episode, we did it with Vincent van Gogh, comprehensively. We never have to talk about it again. He was an insane Dutch man who killed himself eventually, not for want of trying, and died in poverty. He was a fucking nightmare. He was a fucking nightmare. Toughest hang. Very tough hang. Difficult pint. And yet because his sister-in-law was sort of fanatically promoted to his artwork after death, he becomes this archetype of a tortured artist.
9:19And he's sort of this beginning of, can you separate the arts and all that? Charlie's a tortured fartist. Yes, tortured fartist. Now, today, we're going to get into Pablo Picasso. I'd say these are the two biggest names in art. Yes, definitely. Picasso, now I'm into Picasso. But you just like his view on young women. I like the man. I like the things he did as a man. The art, take it or leave it. But how he lived his life is a template for us all. Yeah. Hey, I'm running out to drop off a stack of letters and packages. Need anything shipped while I'm gone? Save the gas. Stamps.com lets you print postage and schedule pickups right from your desk.
9:59Sync your contacts into the address book, get detailed accounting insights, and get notified the moment your certified mail is delivered. All from my desk? All from your desk. Join the 4 million businesses using Stamps.com right now with code podcast and get your free welcome gift. Stamps.com code podcast. Taxes and fees apply. This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast. Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports.
10:41Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode available on Plus and Pro plans. Who says Halloween only lasts one day? With Wayfair, one night of Halloween becomes a whole season at home. From larger-than-life yard decor and moody lighting to festive accents for every room in the house, Wayfair has what you need to make Halloween feel like magic all in one place. Because the best Halloween memories aren't made in just one night. They're made all season long. Shop Halloween decor now at Wayfair.com. Wayfair, every style, every home. Picasso once said of women, there are two types of women. You're already loving this.
11:22Goddesses and doormats. You know, what's that saying? You want to be a gentleman in the street and a, what's the thing? Yes, I want to be a goddess in the street and a doormat in the street. Because he has had, his legacy is tarred with accusations of alleged, alleged, alleged misogyny and abuse. But he's also, you know, separate to that or entwined with that, probably the most recognisable artistic style of the 20th century. There is a Citroen called Picasso, right? Yes, there is. With his signature. How many other artists could be named after a car? Hitler, I guess. You wouldn't call it Citroen Hitler.
12:04Citroen Hitler. Golf Hitler. Volkswagen Hitler. But that's true, actually. You're really bridging the gap there from gay to straight, aren't you? naming a car after an artist. But I guess Picasso bridges into the commercial age, right? Yes, you're right. So the modern idea of branding, near the end of his life, he kind of reaches that zone where you can become distilled into a brand. I guess Van Gogh has been, but not anything to do with him. Obviously, he likes impressionism of Van Gogh. Bibi, what's your kind of artistic taste? Well, I really have a big interest in the pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood.
12:33We'll talk about it on Patreon. Which we can talk about on Patreon. I think that my view towards art is, especially if you're somebody that entertains ideas of wanting to be an artist or a painter or something like that if you actually go to art school it turns out you have to learn about all the different kinds of disciplines and when i was 20 and kind of confused with what i was going to do with my life i vaguely thought i might go to art school and realize that it's not all just pretty pictures of like girls smelling flowers in the garden and that's actually mostly that's your shit right i like so girls smelling i very much am interested in sort of like victorian romantic sorry because that's girls smelling flowers in the garden there's an escape from your holidays with Charlie, which is girls smelling shit in an Airbnb.
13:13I like... You know, that's what art's about, isn't it? It's escapism. It is. That's what I was going to say. I like art that is really whimsical and dreamlike and feminine. Yeah. Rather than the masculine, visceral reality that you inhabit. Truly. Picasso is born in Malaga. Malaga on the 25th of October. but 1881. Oh, she's in Malaga. BB, would you like to place this? You're aware of our placing system by now. She's not great with dates. Okay, fuck you. Sorry. I'm going to say he was born in 1881, which is around 40 years after Queen Victoria has been made the queen. Okay, lovely. Not bad. And it's just before...
14:06Anything. Pick anything. After Queen Victoria has been made the queen, but it's before King Edward is made the king. Okay. Boom. Okay. That's good. Is that good? Sorry, guys. I'm really not good with dates. That's fine. That's fine. It's just a history podcast. I'm not good with history. Should we do some drawing? Because it's an art episode. That's a good idea. Why don't you draw Bibi? And we'll all draw throughout the episode. No, no, no. Can you draw the scene of Bibi on the kind of platform, smelling your shit for the first time. Okay, yeah, yeah. Just trying to recreate... Just because you're fucking engaged me now doesn't mean you get to do all this stuff I don't like.
14:44No, no, no. It's an artistic, it's a really... No, I'm reclaiming it. It's an interesting moment. I think all of us should draw throughout the episodes at different times. And so we get a sense of the different expressionisms that we all use. So Picasso was born in October 1881. So weak was he at birth that the midwife thought he was a stillborn. And then supposedly the myth goes an uncle blows cigar smoke into Picasso's face and he wakes up and then starts breathing. That's a good uncle. That's a great uncle. Sounds like your dad. It's a terrific uncle. So this is him very weak as a boy but a loving mother and an artist father who specialised in drawing pigeons.
15:24So basically an early Nepo baby. He's a fucking pigeon botherer. Yeah. So supposedly at the age of kind of a toddler my kid's age he's drawing some things that adult artists probably his first word was pencil. Really? in English I imagine Penfield
15:43Penfield so apparently like as a kid he's drawing things that adult artists are like whoa I can't even do that he's a prodigy he's a prodigy the number one thing about Picasso probably when you start really respecting him is how good at traditional art he was as a teenager right yes he could do he could do it photorealist paintings in his sleep so he's chosen to make it look like a fucking drop trifle Picasso did a painting at age 13 that it made his dad vow never to paint again. We saw that in real life, Rishi. We did. So this is the painting we're getting up now. He painted this one at 15 years old.
16:14So he goes to all these art schools, but basically he then spends his whole career kind of unlearning all the... Deconstructing. Deconstructing. He becomes so bored of being so perfect, which is quite all right, mate. Yeah. Quote, it took me four years to paint my Raphael, but a lifetime to paint like a child. Pablo you nailed it would you say the Berlin facial aesthetic is quite Picasso 100 % you take a normal face and it's like how do I make it it's Picasso
16:47yeah I'm going to put a piercing on my eyebrow I'm going to cut my hair in a stupid way that's deliberately bad because that's how confident I am or you're a two and in disguise because the hot people are dressing the same as twos it's not a disguise though it's not a disguise it's going I'm owning being a two I'm looking even uglier which can make you think that I'm makes you think I'm not ugly because it makes you think I've made myself ugly and actually if I was trying to look fit I'd still look ugly that's what they're thinking they're sneaky and they should be shot but do you think that it's something interesting about genius that if you do become so masterful so early on that everything just does become boring do you think it leads to sort of this like sense of rebellion as a teenager you almost don't want your child to be too good at things too smart in case they get so bored that they end up having to become this pedophile crazy man yeah yeah what's interesting about picasso though is that that's not it's quite a rare journey that someone is so perfect and so um amazing as a kid that they then become avant-garde and uh they've invent a whole new style normally they just become like a child child actor they get bored of it just goes to the head macaulay culkin overdose and that's it right yeah they get bored it's sort of that's their life But that's because the art form that he's creating, he has total control over.
18:06He's the one that can put his art out there. He has all the authority. Child actors become fucked up because they stopped getting picked. There's another person above them that is the one that decides if they're going to. I think the reason why an artist is able to grow in this way is because they are truly the director of their own existence. Why are you sniggering? Why? Why are you laughing? I don't want to talk about the podcast, I don't know how good podcasting will be, but Charlie Wright wrote Picasso. Okay, no question. Fine. That's just a normal Charlie search. But then I saw that. I was like, oh, for fuck's sake.
18:38I looked at the way that Charlie was looking at me like. Just waited for me. Because I like, you know, like, so pleased with yourself. Do you think, when you were a child, what would be the thing that you were best at that would have made your father go, okay, I'm never going to do that thing anymore because my son is so good at it. Because his fucking car.
19:09I think I'm going to suck and go fuck me. This kid's really got it. He's a genius. It'd probably be like if I, because my family's all intensely musical, really, really musical. Granddad's got an OBE. To what? An oboe? Not an oboe. No, an OBE. He used to run like the National Youth Orchestra. Right. And then my dad was in a band. my dad was in a band before I was born when I was born and then he was like I haven't got any money so I became a teacher but my mum was a concert pianist for a time they're all very musical so if we went to church at Christmas or something they'd all be singing the Descan the like and I'm just going you didn't have that talent no no I would play double bass for a bit I just got so bored because I couldn't play bass how I wanted to play I wanted to play bass like Jaco Pistorius so you won't know who that is Is it Oscar's brother?
20:04Bass God not Oscar's brother no he's Bass God right oh right right right so that's what you thought you were but you were this was in your Gavin Plum era right yes I'm fat wearing a Hawaiian shirt wanting to be Bass God yeah but I couldn't do it obviously and I also couldn't be asked to practice so this is putting Emma Watson off how much but also maybe your parents wouldn't have approved of this type of bass playing I would put I would be not invited to Emma Watson's party I'd go home and take it out on my bass guitar
20:33He said to sound like trite, you know? He did an audition to be Dudley. Oh, I know. Yeah, makes a lot of sense. So let's get into Picasso's personal life because from a young age, I think maybe age 12 or 13, his dad basically goes like, oh son, check this out, takes him to a brothel. And from that point onwards, his relationship to sex never really changes. Well, I know people whose first sexual experience has been their dad taking to his brothels. And I think around the world. I've got friends who's first, yeah. But it is quite a regular thing. I think it's completely mad. I thought you were saying that's completely normal.
21:07Yeah. I know some boys at school that have that experience too. Really? Their dad took them to a brothel? I mean, father-son bonding is difficult. It is tough. But you don't want father-son bondage. Bondage, yeah. You don't want father-son bondage. Father-son bondage. Father-son bondage. That's where that stops being cute. But I guess the idea is that you sort of, you see off the new ball in a brothel. and it probably makes sense like it's your first you know because by the time then you have your first actual like emotional experience but also in terms of muses and the way that he uses women later on in his life for his art allegedly allegedly if you see women as providing you a service whether that's sexual pleasure or artistic merit I mean maybe it cemented something in his brain early doors that he associates women with use and you exit after you have extracted their value so he's 13 when his dad takes him to a Spanish brothel but his dad is Spanish So I guess the Spanish brothel.
21:58It's not like I went to a Spanish brothel. They love it over there. Like tapas. You have a little bit, you know, a little bit of anal over here, a bit of sucky sucky over here. And then we'll get a big, big badge for the table. You guys are so quick. I'm not going to be able to keep up with any of this. Quick? We're quick in certain subjects. Are they talking about muff, pedos? Yeah. Yeah. Dildos. We're very quick 14 year old boys. Even in the last year, since I came on, you've really got quicker. Oh God, yeah. Quicker. than last time. Oh, yeah. That's amazing. It's still the same soundboard, though.
22:29It's just Fred again.
22:33So work, sex and tobacco are his addiction, supposedly. He's married twice, has four children with three women. And yes, allegedly, several women suffer severe psychological distress after the relationship. Most women have psychological distress anyway, though. Yeah, and two attempts suicide. But again, how much can he be, you know, how much... Which is an amazing quote about women are born to suffer. Cumbuckets. Charlie. What did you say? A cumbucket. Cumbuckets. Charlie. Cumbuckets. What's Picasso's amazing quote? Women are cumbuckets. Charlie, that's disgusting. As Picasso once said, women are cumbuckets.
23:10Vessels for suffering. Machines for suffering. Machines for suffering. Not vessels. Yeah. That's quite a misogynistic term. They're machines. Machines, of course. The problem with the art is obviously there's now been that kind of Hannah Gadsby relook at you know artists and it's like problematizing them but it is undeniably romantic and it produces great art this this we talk about now there's a documentary saying it's awful they treated women like this but women themselves find the ideal romantic and you know in art don't you think the idea of the suffering woman still is as an artistic archetype absolutely it's still people will play up to it's still what the great artists but i also think there's something interesting because his mania and the way that he constantly reinvents himself with all of these different eras, maybe because of boredom, maybe because he's too talented.
23:57To me, in a way, his crazy life is actually quite feminine, but because he's so masculine about it, because he doesn't apologize for himself, we associate it as being this very masculine man. I think he's just like an unapologetic woman. The reason why he's so artistically interesting is because there's this femininity to it as well, with the mania and with the constantly inventing himself. He's Catholic. Yeah, he's Catholic. I'd say it's Catholicism. Really? Yeah. Is it hard to work when you're in love like this?
24:33Is it hard to work when you're in love? I find it hard to work being in love. Yeah, I get distracted all the time. So Picasso's ground door. You have ADHD. Yeah, it's true. And you're struggling beforehand. Yeah, and to be honest, I'm actually just really lazy and jobless. Yeah. So I don't really have to work anyway. Anyway. Not now. gonna become the Erica Kirk of fucking Bumble Risky. She's saying she's gonna Erica Kirk me. I mean, fake my assassination and then try and become my potential when Horatio gets assassinated. We are joined by Finn vs. History's very own Erica Kirk. Get the video of her dancing like three days after the...
Read the full transcript
25:07I love the video of her dancing I don't think she might have killed him. No, I just think she's... I don't think she's taking it that badly. So, Picasso's granddaughter is the first time where I suppose his legacy is really compromised. That's not true. So many of his wives wrote books. Yeah, yeah, yeah. His wife doesn't write books. Yeah, exactly. He's not had sex with his granddaughter, so she's objective. Aha, that's true. So he's not Gandhi-ing her? No. Right, no. Doesn't give her the Gandhi treatment. Quote, he submitted women to his animal sexuality, tamed them, bewitched them, ingested them, and crushed them onto his canvas after he had spent many nights extracting their essence.
25:49Once they were bled dry, he would dispose of them. So that's Picasso's granddaughter. But your new show that you're doing in Edinburgh is about being a muse and wanting to be a muse. The whole idea of the show, if I'm not wrong, is that it's about what happens if you don't even get picked to be a muse. Think about all the ugly women who didn't get ingested into canvas. Yes. And you talk about it, it's awful how you treat these women. But think about the ones who don't get that. They would still be looking at the women who... Well, because I think that actually as women, even though we know that this kind of treatment and, I don't know, like boiling down to your essence and then being extracted or whatever.
26:23We know that it's kind of toxic, but at the same time, it's all we know. So therefore, it's difficult to not desire your own objectification in a way. It's difficult to not want to be amused when that's seen as the most important thing. Or is it just that it's still, even though you're still being liked? Exactly, you're being observed. You're being desired. Yeah, being desired and being observed and that makes you feel like you're real. It changes the Fritzl case entirely. Well, exactly. You're still being liked. Well, he liked me. He liked me. At least someone out there's got my back. More than some people could say.
26:57Someone out there's blown my back out. If somebody's really talented and somebody's seen to be a great artist and he picks you and he takes you seriously. You're picked. You got picked. Yes, you're picked first. No, but it does make you probably feel like you probably are capable of great things yourself. So in 1927, Picasso... That's how I feel that Horatio's picked me. Right, I see. Picasso, so he's Picasso, age 45. In 27, he meets Marie-Thérèse Walter, who was 17. Ooh! That's you ripping paper at the moon. Ooh! Now this is game, okay? Game recognized game. He meets a 17 year old outside a department store in Paris and says, I am Picasso.
27:37You and I are gonna do great things together. That's his classic line. That's what he messaged me on Instagram. Grab your coat, love, you pulled. It's essentially that. Now, Marie Therese is the real, is probably the worst of the abuse, maybe? I think so. I suppose you see abuse. Yeah, the alleged abuse. Not Mother Teresa, Charlie. Not Mother Teresa. He does not sexually abuse Mother Teresa. So he, yeah. Has there been another one? Sorry? Are there any more Mother Teresas? Or is it like Ganty? It's not like the Dalai Lama, no. It's not a hereditary sort of. Yeah, so he repeatedly reinvents himself, as you said.
28:11so at what point does he is it basically when he's like in his 20s that he starts just being the Picasso that we recognise when does he unlearn when does he stop doing this incredible it seems like his 20s or even younger than that it seems like pretty much from the off so he has his so called blue period 1901 to 1904 which follows the suicide of his close friend he shot somebody who turned his proposal down so this is artist Karls Kassam Kassam in 1901 he proposed to a model in Paris. Nice. She rejects him. He draws a pistol and fires at her. The bullet missed but knocks her to the ground. He thinks he's killed her so he kills himself.
28:51That's an amazing... So you were saying that you fucked your engagement a bit. Yeah, yeah. Not quite as bad as... No, no, no. This is... That's a real botched job. Yeah, you've really fucked your engagement up. How did it go? Well, I... Well, she's fine but I'm now dead. I imagine that happened all in about 10 seconds. Yeah. I'd love to see that 10 second video. That's incredible. No. and she gets up and is like fuck Christ so anyway but this inspires Picasso's kind of more sombre period so okay so these are these are still quite conventional but it's still quite conventional quite sort of blue dark tone it's the 1900s so it's right on the turn of the century the surrealism hasn't fully come in yet no and cubism will break through just after this sort of around 1907 1907 cubism he is one of the inventors of there's a school yes co-founder A Cubist school, which is a slur in my head.
29:43He's a member of the Cubist school. Rather than depicting objects from a 2D normal viewpoint. Depict them as cubes. No, you just see it from loads of different perspectives, right? Right. Or maybe it's kind of influenced by sculpture, isn't it? So this is more Picasso that we don't understand. So what year is this? This is more like the Citroen Picasso. Yeah. That doesn't really do anything for me. What, this stuff? Yeah. Why not? Because there's no people in it. It's just guitars. I think it's probably just because maybe it's influenced so much of art through the decades and then even advertising.
30:18I think the colouring and everything like that. For some reason to me, it feels a little bit like an advert on the tube. Yeah, it's commercialised now. Yeah. Yeah, 100%. It reminds me of those graphic design people, you know, the people that have become really popular in like sort of adverts for like oat milk that have really big bodies and tiny heads. A bit like your pocket bill. Don't point at him and say that. That's so rude. You can point with your finger just like your body. Like a Picasso. The massive bodies and tiny heads. Yeah, yeah. Sharp point as well. To me, it screams a little bit like 2010's millennial graphic design.
30:51This is the first time you've been on the pod since your fat Elvis comment. Yeah, you struck again. Yeah, a second comment has hit the... I love that fat Elvis thing you did in your poster. No, it's just Elvis, baby. I think growing up To be fair That was one of the funniest things Funnest things that happened I really am sorry about that But I think growing up Is the process of realising So flippant We all think that we're good people And I actually don't ever think About anything Before it comes out of my mouth And I'm only learning To do that now I was going to say something Very rude to him yesterday And I thought to myself No that's going to happen That turns out They mean it When your mum tells you You have to think Before you speak I actually never did that And I really apologise I always think before I speak Yeah famously Famously Okay Always thinking Sorry about the fact Should we have a look You look in great shape now.
31:37So, Charlie, just, what's this work called? My baby. It's called your baby. My baby. Did you draw my tits? Did you draw her tits out? Did you draw me my tits out? Charlie! I'd say that looks like a baboon with tits, is what I would say. But is this her smelling? Is this the moment she's... Why am I naked? Why are you drawing me my tits out? Wait, wait, you say she got her tits out when she smelled the shit. Possibly. It's very Picasso-esque. Yeah. Meaning I hate it. That's fine. We'll make sure we get some close ups for the people at home. But that's, so that's Charlie's. You've given her a real monkey face is what I'd say.
32:15That's what I'd say. But you know, you can't, you can't rush out. No, you can't. My boobs look good though. So now he had a very weird relationship to animals, Picasso. So he had a goat was walking around his house. He was fascinated by goats. Esmereld of the goat. Yeah. He couldn't believe his luck. Is it such a common theme among quirky male artists? Goats? No, they have animals wandering around their houses. I wonder if it's like... Affectation. It does feel like such an affectation to me. So he found an injured owl and kept it. And then he had a whole thing. So throughout the 30s, he basically has this alter ego of a minotaur, which is kind of like half man, half bull.
32:52And then he would depict the minotaur engaging in kind of these violent, erotic encounters. Yes. And then people now interpret that as, that's like him basically raping his girlfriend. But again, it's just a personality with a rapist. but it's justifying, isn't it? If you say that half of you is a monster, like a mythical creature that cannot help his own bad behavior. But if you're aware of it enough to put it in a painting, then it's like, but it's still justifying. It would be much braver to say that you, the man, the human being has done wrong things. It's just like, Oh, you murdered someone.
33:21You go, Oh, sorry. It's because half of me is. I'm a calf cow. Sorry. Sorry.
33:39starting or growing your own business can be intimidating and lonely at times your to-do list may feel endless with new tasks and lists can easily begin to overrun your life so finding the right tool that not only helps you out but simplifies everything as a built-in business partner can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S., from household names like Gymshark, Rare Beauty, and Heinz, to brands just getting started. Shopify has hundreds of ready-to-use templates that can help you build a beautiful online store that matches your brand's style, and you can tackle all the important tasks in one place, from inventory to payments to analytics and more.
34:27No need to save multiple websites or try to figure out what platform is hosting the tool that you need. And if people haven't heard about your brand, you can get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you with easy-to-run email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they're scrolling or strolling. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing. Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash realm. Go to shopify.com slash realm. That's shopify.com slash realm. Who says Halloween only lasts one day? With Wayfair, one night of Halloween becomes a whole season at home.
35:10From larger than life yard decor and moody lighting to festive accents for every room in the house, Wayfair has what you need to make Halloween feel like magic all in one place. Because the best Halloween memories aren't made in just one night. They're made all season long. Shop Halloween decor now at Wayfair.com. Hey, I'm running out to drop off a stack of letters and packages. Need anything shipped while I'm gone? Save the gas. Stamps.com lets you print postage and schedule pickups right from your desk. Sync your contacts into the address book, get detailed accounting insights, and get notified the moment your certified mail is delivered.
35:49All from my desk. All from your desk. Join the 4 million businesses using Stamps.com right now with code PODCAST and get your free welcome gift. Stamps.com, code PODCAST. Taxes and fees apply. So, now, we should probably get into the alleged abuse, right? He burned one of his mistress's houses down, didn't he? Or his wife's house down. I don't know what she did, though. One of my favourite things about Picasso is that at some point, so he has this, he's a 17-year-old girl. Awu. Awu, who he's with. And in the modern parlance, you now say that he groomed her. Sure. But again, I think that's a loaded term.
36:29Yes. There was an age gap. Love is love. Yeah, love is love. All right. But he took her as a mistress, either that or he had another mistress. Wait in the car. either he had another mistress right and at some point they discover each other uh and they confront each other and he then makes them fight like pokemon in his studio oh that's good isn't that the most like artistic thing he said it was the greatest moment of his life well it would be yeah that's incredible who won do we know i don't know do we know i guess maybe because it's proof that two beautiful things can love you at once that they can but it's going back to you saying about being desired exactly that's the male version Exactly.
37:12You know, a woman wants to be painted, a man wants two women to fucking fight over her. Exactly. Slapping their eyes out. So that's Marie Theresa and then one of the other women. I can't remember who. I mean, you both obviously thrive off of people watching you and you think that you would get to - Not women though, not women. Well, I'm sure that there are some women. It's not as cool when there's two Star Wars kids fucking lightsabering each other. I was gonna say, I was gonna say. They've got big sticks. I was gonna say, when do you get some of your patrons to fight? You could do one of those video simulations that they do like, you know, 10 rhinoceroses against like a thousand Roman.
37:45So you could do your patrons against... One woman. One woman. Well, they'd look at me and they'd all just fall over. Oh, no, no, no. So he had the blue period. After the blue period, he had the rose period, right? Yeah, where he painted loads of Harlequins. He was supposedly really happy. Yeah, so do we know why he got happy? Is it because he had two women fighting over him? Yeah, I guess he moved on. Well, he would be quite happy. So let's have a look at some of the... When does he start getting into that classic Picasso style that we know. What time is that? So the Blue Period, the Rose Period, and then I guess he's in the kind of golden age of, you'd argue, Paris artistically, potentially, the 1920s.
38:19Going to Montmartre. Going to the Amelie Cafe. He must have been having a great time. Yeah, in Midnight in Paris, he goes back to this period. Yeah. Picasso, Hemingway. It's the only film that Horatio will re-watch. Midnight in Paris. he does. He talks to me about it as well. Picasso is such a hoarder. He doesn't actually sell many of his paintings. he just keeps all his paintings around. Apparently he doesn't even let his fingernails go to waste because the Spanish are all superstitious like that. Doesn't leave any body hair around. Where's he putting it? Hey? Where's he putting it all? I don't know.
38:51Much like where the fuck did you put your laundry? Much like just everywhere. Yeah, everywhere. Oh, so 1937. So two women accidentally arrive at his Parisian studio at the same time. Walter demands Picasso choose between them. Picasso then just goes, go on girls have a go at it and then yeah he said they began to wrestle it's one of my choicest memories yeah he kept on painting he said yeah he was like well fucking yeah I'm gonna paint this yeah bit of peace and quiet finally so during World War I he basically just cops out stays in France because Spanish Civil War everyone's flooding in it's like war tourism and he's actually from Spain and he just fucking dips sorry World War I he misses out oh of course sorry World War II he lives in occupied Paris but he's probably most known for Guernica which is the depicting the bombing, alleged bombing of the Lufafa of a Spanish town.
39:48Now we've talked about this from the very early days of the pod. Yeah, that he made a mistake and he fucked it and then they were like, is that Guernica? He's like, yeah, maybe. Yeah, maybe. Yeah, I think he was trying to draw a horse and then he had several goes and he didn't change paper and then they went, what's that? It was like an abstract interpretation of the Guernica bombings. Yeah, sure, that. Yeah, what you said, yeah. Supposedly, a German officer saw a photograph of it and said, did you do this? And he said, no, you did. So he's on Reddit. Yeah, that's exactly what I was thinking. He doesn't strike me as a super political figure, even if people might interpret him as such.
40:23Would you say, is he a less difficult pint? He's definitely a less difficult pint than Van Gogh. Oh, I'd love to go for a pint of Picasso. Tell him about the time that your two side pieces had a go with each other. Yeah, yeah. That'd be fun. Van Gogh is just too much. A bit more laugh. Yeah, he's a laugh. Yeah, he's a laugh. He would sometimes offer a signed napkin as payment after he'd had a meal at a restaurant. I mean, to be that iconic that you can just any meal. Imagine that, you just scribble a piece of paper and there's breakfast, lunch and dinner. You're just fucking... But Van Gogh can never do that.
40:54No, because no one liked it. He's going to be like, no, we need money. You smell. Who are you? Who the fuck are you? You're a weirdo. Why are you bleeding out the side of your head? So he realised that the signatures... So I guess he kind of made it in his lifetime. And it's the opposite of that. He really enjoyed it. He loved it. Absolutely loved it. Because there's probably nothing better than being super rich and just doing it through painting and then you're really good at painting. It feels like you get everything. But then, so Guernica's, I think the fact everyone knows him for this is part of the reason that everyone then starts chipping him and going, actually, he was really abusive because there's a photo called The Weeping Woman.
41:30Can you get that up? Where he basically, in order to get this, he made one of his girlfriends just repeatedly cry over and over again so and like um not not but like made her cry not like act crying like actually was horrible to her um demeaning her etc um and then got this and when you see this painting you're like that you could have just done that without a woman there it looks nothing like a woman do you know what i mean it's so abstract it's like you didn't need to do that yeah but when people talk about you know this is an iconic painting. Dora Ma, sorry, that's the other one who fights.
42:05She's in the red corner. Therese Waters in the blue corner. But the Weeper Woman is an iconic painting we remember for hundreds and hundreds of years. Is it so bad that a woman got, you know, was crying? Well, stop clock, isn't it? Yeah, but everyone was like, it's so problematic. A woman was crying. Yeah. It's like, all right. But look, we've got a painting now forever. That's true. That's true. A woman cried. We should cancel it. What did she do? Yeah. What'd she ever do? Oh, she was an artist. All right, fair enough. But then, quote, she was known to Picasso as being always weeping because of their turbulent relationship.
42:39Yeah, well, when I lost my phone and wallet on holiday, we were stuck with just one car between us and it was very tough getting home. And BB's approach to any sort of situation of stress is you scream cry immediately. Would you not say? I would say. So like, if it... Really? Yeah, immediately. Scream cry? Yeah, it's kind of like... Not scream cry. Pretty much scream cry. More to 100. Yeah, and I think, You say you're taught this by your mother, right? Which is like a defense mechanism. I think that I, well, it's partly the way that I deal with stress. Deal is an interesting word. Respond. The way that's fine.
43:11Respond. Okay, fine. Respond. It's probably the way that I respond to stress. But I also think there's a. Uber canceled. That's what you see. If an Uber canceled to the airport, this is, you're getting that immediately. I think it's. It was more than an Uber canceling. it was that i didn't realize that with ryanair if you don't check in online that they charge you for late booking and because i didn't have an actual in-person card because well i didn't bring my cards out with me i thought i was gonna be able to use that well i didn't fucking expect this what do you mean my wallet what do you mean um but yeah i think it's also a female thing it's uh you know there's there's there's strength in weakness my mom taught me when i was a little girl when you get in trouble you cry because it makes men confused and slightly angry and uh but i'm looking at this painting hearing that yeah when you're in trouble cry right so she's crying over on a cord yeah and he's just painting it isn't he yeah but i'm just saying like as a little girl you can do that as getting out of trouble but but as a woman too it's about It's a fawning reflex that is like actually something in all of animal nature.
44:29It's about making yourself small. It's about making yourself vulnerable. And it like tends to get me out of a lot of troublesome situations. Yes, because I have to fix it. So nasty. He's so nasty. No, but I think when you reach a certain age, do you think the scream crying will be less... Yeah. Will it be less effective, do you think? It probably will get less effective. Post menopause Come on love Come on love You're fucking The thing is maybe that's my way of responding to it It's like I'm upset with the fact that I know that it's like This is going to be a very temporary period of my life Where I can make use of it So why not make use of it That's a good point The world gives a lot of opportunities for women to cry Hey is that crazy to say No Go on Charlie When did you last see Heratio truly cry I have seen him cry twice in our whole relationship When they were both at films Yeah And I bet those films had subtitles Wanker I think one of them might actually crazy imagine crying at a film of subtitles no it was Waves yeah and it was Return of the Fireflies never heard of it no I didn't I didn't cry at that the anime yeah you did but then I think she turned the lights on crying at anime fucking hell it's the saddest film it's a really sad drawing it's a really sad load of drawings well just like that it's a really sad drawing crying at anime but then she turned the lights on because she was like so shocked that I was crying that she wanted to capture the moment.
45:49But it's just like completely, it made me never want to cry again because you were like, you wanted to remember it so much. You can judge me, but I also think that there's something powerful in like letting yourself release emotions and there's clearly something artistically interesting about it. So Picasso, No one's saying you're holding it in. Picasso, by the 70s, I'm also just thinking about when my dad met your mum. Oh my God, that was incredible. And then my dad, because he's basically a gay man, to put it short, because he's an active listener. Yes. For a man in his 60s, very, very rare.
46:18your mother had never met a man who actually listened to her and I saw her entire world view change in seconds and then she was so entranced by my dad's spell that she missed helping you for your show which would be done every day for a month my dad is a witch doctor he's a dangerous man he's a dangerous man to a certain age woman anyway so by the 70s Picasso is the most famous artist alive so he lives to see his own success and he dies in 73, age 91 working till the end and his final wife committed suicide in 1986 so you know like 13 years later so obviously he's got nothing to do with that what happened in those 13 years?
47:07must have been sad who was the other guy? his son died of alcoholism people think maybe it was linked to suicide or depression but also his grandson shut up can't fucking concentrate but didn't his grandson also commit suicide I feel like a lot of people it's like Love Island in the Picasso circle like they kill themselves or they end up so fucked up and I think it's very interesting when you think about like genius artists with toxicity it's almost like this super resource that sucks the soil dry from everyone around them. I certainly think if you're like an iconic artist, it colours everything around you.
47:52And if you then raise kids who are born with the money from your art, but don't have the talent, I think they feel this sense of imposter syndrome that leads to depression. Stanley Kubrick's grandson is now started on Instagram and it's quite funny. He's basically like, I'm completely talentless, but I've got loads of money. Here's me on holiday. It's basically him on like jet skis, him going to like villas, saying like, yeah, sadly, I can't do anything. I'm rich in rubbish. He's filming his feet the most of the time. Can't even hold it to his face. It's funny, hardly a chip off the old block, is it?
48:25I mean, Brooklyn Beckham, Beckham's less aware of it than Kubrick's grandson. Cruz Beckham, phenomenally talented. What a musician. Probably my gayest opinion is that I genuinely love the music of Cruz Beckham. Isn't he like 17? Yeah, he's 19. Yep. You really are a very surprising creature. No, I am. And what? I contain multitudes. That multitude is Cruz Beckham. I like the Nazis on Cruz Beckham. I like to bend Beckham over a barrel. I love that moment in... Bend it like Cruz Beckham over a barrel. In the posh Spice documentary on Netflix, there was this really nice moment where David and Victoria are talking about their kids and it's intercut with a montage of them all in the kitchen together.
49:04This is before the Brooklyn Beckham... They might cry, can we get some Kleenex in here? But they basically both talk to Cameron. Their kids are all chatting. they're all together in the kitchen and yes they all come across a bit bimboish but david says so earnestly to camera they could have turned out to be arseholes and i'm i'm really really proud of his mom is fucking grinding on all the kids as well yeah i mean this was before this conflict but i i think that it's very difficult if you're a successful artist how do you raise children that are not going to be influenced by the idea that you're some genius it's like you're borrowing i almost think it's like when you take drugs and you borrow happiness from the next few days and you have this terrible come down maybe if you're a genius you borrow all of the energy and life force from the children that you're going to have it's going to take generations for people to have enough backstory and coolness to be talented again you kind of are selfish if you become a great artist and you have a family because it doesn't give your children a fucking chance i think that's what a fucking untalented artist says um yeah i did it for my kids being crap art yeah Yeah.
50:07So now Picasso becomes a surrealist officially. He's a card carrying surrealist. Now surrealism, I have a problem with. Why? What do you think it's random? Well, it is. So you don't like surrealism. Do you not like surrealism, Charlie? I don't. I'd never met it. You're a very surreal person though. Yeah, you are a Dali painting. So the whole point of surrealism is it comes out of World War I where they think, well, the realism caused this nightmare. And it's all about Sigmund Freud's theories of the unconscious. And why don't we paint dreams? Why don't we paint those unconscious thoughts? Why don't we render that?
50:43And I guess things don't have to make sense. Semi-PTSD from the war. Totally. You start having to look into what's going on in the mind. Because people's faces now look like Picasso's paintings in real life. So, you know, they're thinking, right, well, this is a bit crazy. A bit random. A bit random. That's what you say to a 1-1-1 master. My nose is but my eyes. Why is your nose by your ear? There's a thing called Dadaism as well. Yeah, type in Dadaism. Which is about anti-art, isn't it? So am I Dadaist? Oh, absolutely. So, I mean, you'd hate Dadaism. It is the definition of random. Dada. Mona Lisa with a moustache.
51:18Hey, what? It's quite smug. Mona Lisa with a moustache. Oh, God, it's tea towel art. Yeah. My first official wank. Do you want to see it? What do you mean official? What? What do you mean? Does the queen cut it with a red ribbon before you start? With the Guinness Book of Records there? What do you mean a fish or wank? What do you mean, Jolly? That poster. So is that Dada? That's the fucking picture you drew of me. So is that Dada? It's that. Don't know. Getting the Mona Lisa's chebs out. No, I don't think so. Wait, wait, wait. Did you actually wank to that? I had that on my wall for a long time.
51:50Who put it there? You're wanking looking at your wall. Your mum put it there. You're wanking looking at your wall. Yeah, she was on there. But you're wanking at something that's on your wall. So are you genuinely... That's crazy. Are you... This is like walking through a museum, wanking at the pictures. It's crazy. Normally you're hunched over looking at a magazine. Generally, the first time you came was at the Mona Lisa. Successfully, yeah. Successfully. That's unbelievable. What had you been trying to do before? Just trying to come. I was just watching porn like TV. It was horrible. What? You got Homer Simpson in an armchair with a fucking beard.
52:19Just like... Boring, boring, boring. Changing channel. But that did it for you? So artists believe that if rationality had created the violence of war, irrationality could be used to create beauty. I understand it up to this point. But then you get to have dream surrealism where they paint really lifelike, but it's things that were never - Photorealist, but mental shit. Yeah, exactly. So this is kind of Pink Floyd album cover stuff, right? So objects are bigger than they should be. This is Dali, right? So we're getting into Salvador Dali, who was born in the, what, early 1900s, I think? He was a massive Picasso fanboy, right?
52:52Was he? So he's Spanish as well, I presume. And he becomes the face of surrealism. and his face now lives on in the shit moustaches of bad improv troops at the Edinburgh Festival. He does look like a Victorian villain, doesn't he? Yes, he does. It makes sense that he actually was a fascist. Was he a fascist? He was like a Francoist. It's a bit muddy waters, but he certainly didn't hate the original. In fact, some kind of like quirky surrealist art fans now certainly find it interesting that he's the sort of face of the surrealist art movement when it's actually something that's really associated with communism and a lot of anti-fascists.
53:27random fascism it's a bit weird so it's kind of funny isn't it but it's also the same way that with like certain quirky brands of like comedy or acting you know clowning and all these kind of things really associated with very liberal spaces often times will be people that are actually really you know posh privately educated I mean this is something you both agree with but you're basically saying all clowns are rapists I didn't say that you can't say that I've got that tattooed above my arse but that's what what you're getting at is the guy with the Dawn books tone bag and his painted nails who's, you know, reading a fucking Simone de Beauvoir book.
53:59Why I'm talking to white people, whatever. Yeah, why you fucking hate white people about race and stuff like that. They're the ones who are going to be master manipulators and pedophiles, is what you were saying. It's not at all what I'm saying. I read it. I read it. No, I get it. Yeah. But it is interesting that Salvador, you know, he had like a fascination with Hitler and stuff, didn't he? But it's the 30s. You're allowed to be fascinated by Hitler. It's true. You would have been curious at that time. Who is this guy? You'd be like, what the fuck is going on? He's just done the Anschluss. What is that?
54:26I like this. It's suspicious to not have a fascination with Hitler. Thank you. Because it does show a lack of curiosity about the extremes of humanity. If you're a straight man... It's not extreme at the time. It's centrist. You know, this is the story of the German Lib Dems in the 30s. Uncle at Christmas. It's click mania. Everyone's having a conversation at the table. He's already retreated to the living room. He can still hear. He's shouting from there. He was an extreme at the time. Hitler was a communist. It was like a centrist at the time. It was like the Nick Clegg of its day. It's Clegg mania.
54:58It's the first Clegg mania. What's only bounties left? But I think with Spain, though, fascist Spain, it's like fascism originates in Italy, which makes sense because Italy, you know, it's a fucking, it's a wetsuit. Do you know what I mean? It hasn't got any starch. It needs order, it needs rigidity. Right, okay, yeah. I can see why if you're a Spaniard and you like money as Dali did, you would then be like, well, can we fucking get something going? please can we get rid of the siestas yeah it was a response to siesta ism yes well can we find out did siestas go down under the fascist regime huge huge uh study this we must know fascinating maybe ask chat gbt in spanish aseo means toilet and it's quite it's quite um yeah that's not what we asked charlie can you can you ask or phoebe or just anyone back there this is generally interesting the siesta culture change under franco it changed significantly under franco it was a survival mechanism during his dictatorship so it actually came up well so they're trying to do it to to hide well i guess it's it's it's fascistic it's enforced napping because it's spanish because it also gives you more energy that you're able to work two jobs that's what it i think of course i saw yeah i saw like a fucking manosphere guy saying i've split my day into two days and therefore i have 14 days in a week i've seen this so you can Maybe that's what they're doing there.
56:22Except really in the first place, they only have half a day. So really they're just making one day. Franco moved Spain's clocks forward by an hour to align with Nazi Germany. I like that. This is both Picasso and Dali, but especially Dali became obsessed with money in quite like a Warhol-esque way where he viewed fame, success, and how much money you have is a sign of how great an artist you are, which weirdly also doesn't go with this real sort of thing. And in a way he's kind of almost like one of the early influencers. He's promoting himself with these publicity stunts. he turns up in a really big, heavy, old-fashioned diving suit.
56:54Yeah, have you heard about this? No. At some sort of an event, and he passed out. He also had three ferrets he was walking on leashes. Oh, yeah, two white hounds. And then it was meant to be some sort of conference about art, and then he did his speech from this helmet, but then it got stuck. Yeah, diving suit, but it got stuffy. And then he nearly suffocated to death, and so people had to wrench him out of it. Oh, fuck, if only he died, that would be so fucking satisfying. and now this comes just in the queue for berghain yeah exactly there's three ferrets and his diving helmet also so he was became obsessed with money however to make money he thought if you're a genius you should monetize it as much as possible right uh genius this is genius genius genius yeah that guy's a pedophile so he did a disney collab as well yeah so he became he They're both fascinating in each other.
57:44He thought Disney was like a great artist, animator. And it took 58 years to finish this short film called Destino, which I guess finished both after they'd both died. It won an Oscar and it's, I guess, Salvador Dali's drawings animated by Disney. It's kind of amazing. Do you like his paintings? Do you know what? It's because it's surreal and I know it's surreal and I know that it's not meant to make me feel anything. So you're not surprised by anything? I'm not surprised by anything See that's how ADHD people see time Yeah That's what time blindness Well that's just a normal painting in Africa isn't it
58:22I find the arid landscape quite unsettling Looks like Cornwall I don't think it looks like Cornwall though I don't think anything looks like Cornwall at all Actually do you know what Charlie I think it does look like Cornwall My friend Kev lives on a cliff in Cornwall Oh yeah Which is completely irrelevant He lives on a cliff Wow Wow. In a cliff on it. And kind of on it. We eat stuff off the rocks. Samphires. You eat stuff off the rocks. You do live in a fucking Darley painting. That is true. Samphire. It's funny, you know, because a lot of hot girls on TikTok who are painters have a very sort of surrealist style.
58:57And it is funny when you sort of compare. It's always like a sort of a Pinterest board. It's just like these items. I can imagine Darley just sort of being like, yeah, cute. Clock. Would you think modern art has moved to the point where, I think there is now like the artist baddie coming along as a Instagram thing, where there's like attractive girl who will post loads of images as if she's attractive. And then part of her attractiveness is that she also does sort of art and it always nearly always is derivative of. But then how is any, I mean, all art is, you know, derivative mostly. Um, I think it's, what's that derivative of?
59:29Right. Let's get his Hitler one up. Cause Hitler one is kind of goaded to be fair. Yeah. I don't think that you should blame people for being interested in art, no matter how derivative it is um because in order to create your own style you have to you have to copy but this is very much this podcast the fact the fascination undeniably i guess a lot of this podcast is giving into animal urges and not being performative about and lying about things obviously if you're a man you are interested in hitler don't deny it and i think this uh painting you can't say he was pro hitler but it's terrifying let me look at it Little rotted pieces of food and a little postcard image of postage stamp of Hitler.
1:00:13And there's a bat. Oyster. And there's an oyster. And also it's a similar setting to the persistence of time. It could also be in Cornwall. Zoom out. There's a sort of ghost-like umbrella. There's a telephone. A black knob. Oh, no. No, no, no. It's a telephone knob. One end's like a scorpion, it looks like. Or it's dripping. Or it's dripping. It's a lot like a knob. It does look like a... I am seeing a big knob dripping. It always looks like a mustache a little. some cashews now do you know what the more I look at it the more I actually don't think it's about Hitler at all I think it's just a photo of Hitler in the middle right I mean what the fuck is that about what the fuck is going on there can you just tell me can you keep that up and then get a separate window up with some kind of Gemini saying what the fuck am I meant to think about that so you did that in 39 the cut telephone cord represents the severing of diplomatic communication that's very Beethoven's brother isn't it bad landscape is the sterility and the anxiety of the impending catastrophe.
1:01:07He always does a barren landscape. I think he just doesn't know how to paint a different type of landscape necessarily. My problem with this stuff is that it's a bit like you're seeing this and you're reading about why it means stuff and it's a bit like watching an A-level drama production. Absolutely. Yeah. But also you could be told that a painting means anything. Social media is bad. And I think that you would be able to draw conclusions if you said any item was linked to anything or emotion. you would be able to find some kind of link there. But do you not think, with the colour of Dali's normal paintings, the fact that it's 1939, the graveness of the feeling on the continent, I feel it represents that emotion quite well.
1:01:43It does represent that, but then because he's chosen these things, he's there going, hmm, how should I represent the seven diplomatic relations? But it's Radio 4, isn't it? It's Rye. That's a Rye painting. Now, if you were going to, you had to draw, in 1939, you had to draw a painter called The Enigma of Hitler. yeah how would finn taylor do that i'll show you it's like a like um like one of those japanese uh like just love hearts everywhere and it's got massive eyes he's like like that i thought you were going to say it's one of those octopus fucking wood prints no it's like a nigma of hitler and it's him going oh no it's hello kitty but hitler's like that hello hello kitty hello kitty hello kitty is good um so obviously darley without darley there'd be you know, David Lynch, you know, talking heads is quite influenced by Dali, I'd say as well.
1:02:33Do you like Lynch? Yeah, I like Twin Peaks. Twin Peaks is amazing. Here in David, there's a compilation of David Lynch talking about every time he forgets an idea, he wants to kill himself. And he said this in so different interviews, there's like three minutes of him just, and it is a very relatable thing basically. So perhaps more than any other movement in art, surrealism sort of opens a gate, I guess. so i suppose you know if you're tracing this back from van gogh which is in the impressionists are in the 1860s yeah in the speed in the space of 80 years what's possible in art has entirely changed and i guess the war probably has fed it all up yeah because everything's just got technology has grown at such a rapid rate but now i guess where does it leave art now because it does feel what have you sorry right what have you done there charlie what have you done talk because people are listening switch the video and tell us what you've done there can you replace this as the enigma of Finn Taylor, British comedian, make it similarly dark and a bit homosexual.
1:03:32Right. That's the prompt. Right. So it's just, it's basically kind of, it's still quite Radio 4. Funny, isn't it? What is that? Is that what it says on the mountain? Yeah. There's cum coming out of the cock, which I've made a bit more pronounced. That's meant to be you. It's like Bob Dylan. It's not just a joke, darling. And then there's a... It's classic Finn. It's quite you. I don't think that's me. It's beautiful. It's beautiful. Yeah. Really? Yeah. I guess where is art now? The female gaze will never understand. Because the thing about Dali, he died. He looks like he's got AIDS, that guy. I like him weak.
1:04:06Right, well, yeah, I guess that one tracks. He dies in 89. Yeah. Right, but at least Dali was a proper painter and he had incredible technical skills. And I think these painters still stand up. I guess now, post-Warhol, art has got to a point where it feels like technically it's all been stripped back, right? There's a sort of a bit of a death of fine art and oil painting. It's almost cringy to try and be good at art now, isn't it? Because now it's so conceptual. Who are the big... Because now, in many ways, the British art scene, certainly in Europe, is the bigger, the most emerging one, but they're sort of...
1:04:36What are they called? The young... I have no idea. There's like a name for them. The young... Young kings. I guess it's so interesting as well, because you think about what people would have... They would have had to spend so much time, actually, painting, learning each kind of fine brushstroke. People had so many less things to do. Of course they would become masters in a different way. I think that we're all too overstimulated now to spend our time becoming master painters. We're not going to see any more master painters. The new shit does leave me cold. Yeah, there's no craft to it anymore, I suppose.
1:05:09Yeah, and it's all about conceptual. What I don't like is so much of art is just recontextualising other things. And that's the art. Is it artistic that I put a toilet in the gallery? Isn't it artistic that I got an old telly and put this on the old telly? Well, have you read Retro-Mania by Simon Reynolds? No, I haven't. You should read that. okay it's about how basically past the 90s everything became a library of culture yeah and rather than there's nothing but then also it's like it's so cyclical that every 50 years or so we say that we hate modern art and then in 50 years from now people uh will say that they love well that's the i think that's the big question is that you look back at van gogh and picasso and people would have hated them at the time some of the stuff at the time and then you could view the fucking shit in the bed now and be like oh that's going to be like van gogh but is it because it does feel like everyone now is saying that we're living in a bit of a low point for art and it's partly the commercialization that these stuff is this stuff's going i don't think anyone's having to look back at like oh the baroque poo in a floor on the floor so the reuben-esque poo i mean but also we aren't the only thing we aren't the only beings that can create images anymore i think well no i just ai means that um we're not in control of images being produced anymore and in the same way and therefore um images are just changing in terms of what they're valued to us we can't trust that something beautiful we see has been made by humans so yeah it's going to change the whole way that we uh view it but oh look dogs campaign and you know what i mean it's not that much worse than van gogh sunflowers that's what i'd say anyway uh well charlie what have you learned um that you can still create great work even if you eat paint um yeah that's not the lesson i want people to take away from this series i don't endorse glue or glue or paint is fine basically right okay um bb you're at the edinburgh festival oh yes for the whole month what's your show called my show is called swoon it's about um the pre-raphaelite brotherhood who a group of Victorian painters and their muses and male artists and wanting to be a muse but failing to be one.
1:07:15The complicated male artists. The complicated male artists but also very similar themes to my last shows which is just essentially a girl wanting to express herself and failing. But also your shows are basically naked gun films and how many silly jokes are in them. They just got a bunch of accents. Yeah, you do some terrific accents and that's coming from me. Yeah, she's a real accent artist to be fair. Yeah, she really are. So when you're talking about how it's about the young Raph like blah blah blah. It's really funny and silly. That's nice. Thank you. If anybody wants to come, it's at 5.40pm at the Jackdome all of August.
1:07:465.40 the Jackdome, rabbit, dog. Let's see it. Get there. We're going to carry on chatting on the Patreon about the pre-Raphelite brotherhood, which I, I know what that is. This has been Finn vs. History. She's been Bebe Cave. We'll see you all again on the Patreon or next week for a brand new topic from all of us here. Goodbye. Goodbye.
1:08:23Hey, I'm running out to drop off a stack of letters and packages. Need anything shipped while I'm gone? Save the gas. Stamps.com lets you print postage and schedule pickups right from your desk. Sync your contacts into the address book. Get detailed accounting insights and get notified the moment your certified mail is delivered. All from my desk? All from your desk. Join the 4 million businesses using Stamps.com right now with code podcast and get your free welcome gift. Stamps.com code podcast. Taxes and fees apply. This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast.
1:08:57Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode available on Plus and Pro plans. I see you. Avatar Fire and Ash is now streaming on Disney+. It's the film critics are calling the best Avatar yet. Go, go, go, go. A true epic and completely jaw-dropping. This is the only pure thing in this world. Return to Pandora on Disney+.
1:09:39It will be an adventure for the whole family. And watch the Oscar-winning phenomenon at home. This is sick! Avatar Fire and Ash, now streaming on Disney+. Rated PG-13.
From the publisher
Picasso's ideal woman? Goddess in the streets, doormat in the sheets.
Great Artists (Part Two)
This episode of Fin vs History is brought to you by Surfshark.
Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code FVH for an extra 4 months at https://surfshark.com/fvh
The show for people who like history but don't care what actually happened.
For weekly bonus episodes, ad-free listening and early access to series, become a Truther and sign up to the Patreon
patreon.com/fintaylor
Chapters:
00:00 - The Ski Trip
05:56 - Goddesses And Doormats
12:38- Sucking C*ck
18:55 - Cumbuckets
22:19 - Awoo!!
25:26 - Fat Elvis
29:44 - Gouge Their Eyes Out
34:22 - He Loved It
41:39 - It’s Like Love Island
45:04 - Successfully Yeah
50:01 - Italy Is A Wet Suit
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
