In short
Part 2 of a Reformation deep-dive focused on Martin Luther’s summons to the Diet of Worms (1521), his “Here I stand” defense of conscience, his outlawing via the Edict of Worms, and his later hiding at Wartburg Castle where he translates the Bible into German and marries Katharina von Bora. It also covers the Zwickau prophets, the German Peasants’ War (1525), and Luther’s later writings on Islam and Jews.
Guests
Horatio Gould (co-host; discusses Luther’s “cold/realistic” personality and makes modern analogies). The episode also includes recurring banter from the main host/other co-hosts, but only Horatio Gould is explicitly named.
Key claims
Luther’s safe-passage walk to Worms and his day of prayer before answering are framed as conscience-based revolution against Catholic authority. The Edict of Worms makes helping Luther a crime and killing him legal. Luther’s exile and bodily preoccupations are portrayed as shaping his intense output. The German Peasants’ War is linked to radical Protestant offshoots (e.g., adult baptism).
Notable examples
Diet of Worms (1521); “Here I stand, I can do no other”; Edict of Worms; Wartburg Castle; translation from Greek into German; marriage to Katharina von Bora; Zwickau prophets; Battle of Frankenhausen (1525); Luther’s anti-Jewish work “On the Jews and Their Lives.”
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOThe Nature of History
0:45 to 1:23
Discussion about who history is written for and the portrayal of different groups.
“History can get the blood pumping, things like tank battles, amphibious landings, the exploitation of indigenous communities.”
The Nature of History
1:51 to 2:20
Discussion about who history is written for and the portrayal of different groups.
“That means that summer's officially here.”
Introduction to the Reformation
2:20 to 2:38
The hosts introduce the topic of Martin Luther and the Reformation.
“New customer offer for initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy.”
Martin Luther's Influence
2:38 to 5:32
Exploration of Martin Luther's impact on personal and social dynamics.
“When the dicks come out and they're putting people's hands...”
The Printing Press Era
5:32 to 8:00
Discussion of the printing press's role in disseminating Luther's ideas.
Diet of Worms and Charles V
8:00 to 10:32
Details on the Diet of Worms and the historical context of Charles V.
“If you're watching, we're looking at a photo...”
The Protestant Grind
10:32 to 14:00
Personal anecdotes about stress and its connection to Protestantism.
“love grief, I don't know what the fuck you call it.”
Luther's Journey to the Diet of Worms
14:00 to 16:34
Discover Martin Luther's dramatic pilgrimage to the Diet of Worms and its significance.
“And also Morgan having the kind of instincts to let that sit.”
The Stand at Worms
16:34 to 18:16
Explore Luther's groundbreaking declaration of conscience at the Diet and its impact on individualism.
“The notion that an individual's conscience informed by scripture is superior to the authority of the church council.”
Aftermath of the Diet of Worms
18:16 to 20:03
Learn about the consequences of Luther's defiance and the Edict of Worms that declared him an outlaw.
“And then later, Charles V releases the Edict of Worms, which declares that Luther's an outlaw who needs to be arrested.”
Show all 31 chapters
Luther in Hiding: The Wartburg Castle
20:03 to 22:40
Understand Luther's time in hiding and its effect on his mindset and writings.
“And also he doesn't have any direct control over the Holy Roman Empire.”
The Influence of Constipation on Thought
22:40 to 24:53
Examine the humorous yet insightful connection between Luther's physical state and his theological ideas.
“I feel the kind of misunderstanding of kind of you need ferments, you need kefir and stuff like that.”
Luther's Translation of the Bible
24:53 to 27:35
Discuss Luther's translation of the Bible and its revolutionary implications for religion and society.
“I think it's a Freudian thing where he, the idea he sees it as representing the shit and he throws it out the window.”
Cultural References and Humor in Lutheran Thought
27:35 to 28:00
Explore the comedic elements in discussing Luther's life, from scatology to cultural references.
Discussing Scat Play and Relationships
28:00 to 28:46
Explores the concept of scat play in a humorous context alongside views on relationships.
“Scat play does just sound, sounds too jazzy.”
Martin Luther's Marriage and Historical Context
28:46 to 29:40
Covers Martin Luther's marriage to Katharina von Bora and the historical implications.
“Tell the listeners what you just put on the screen.”
Luther's Struggle Against Catholicism
29:40 to 31:25
Discusses Luther's internal battles against Catholic teachings and his writings.
“Martin Luther marries Katharina von Bora.”
Diet and Health in the 16th Century
31:25 to 33:23
Examines the impact of the 16th-century diet on health and Luther's personal struggles.
“And the Protestant reformers are like, I don't know.”
Diet and Health in the 16th Century
34:03 to 34:33
Examines the impact of the 16th-century diet on health and Luther's personal struggles.
“Now, unfortunately, we're seeing rising costs across the country with possibility that big wireless hates you 100%.”
The Radical Protestant Movements
34:33 to 36:15
Describes the emergence of radical Protestant movements and the German Peasant War.
“they start toppling statues This is the first statue topless.”
Luther's Response to Radicalism
36:15 to 37:34
Discusses Luther's reactions to radical Protestant uprisings and their consequences.
“quite interesting because that's basically saying that you need to be an adult so you can consent to your own baptism.”
Legacy of Lutheranism in Scandinavia
37:34 to 42:00
Explores the establishment and impact of the Lutheran Church in Scandinavia.
“But here it's like, no one understands me.”
Luther's Influence and the Rise of Lutheranism
42:00 to 44:14
Explore how Martin Luther's actions led to the establishment of the Lutheran Church and its societal implications.
“And he starts a new church known as the Lutheran Church.”
Luther's Controversial Views on Islam
44:14 to 46:38
Discuss Luther's perception of Islam and how it reflected the tensions of his time.
Luther's Anti-Semitic Writings
46:38 to 48:29
Examine Luther's writings about Jews and their impact on history, including later associations with Nazi ideologies.
The Shift from Protestantism to Modern Views
48:29 to 56:00
Analyze the decline of Protestant influence and the cultural shifts in British society, including therapy and confession.
“These days, you can't drive around Saxony.”
The Enduring Power of the Catholic Church
56:00 to 57:31
Explore the lasting influence of Catholicism compared to Protestant sects.
“if you think about the power of the Pope I mean what even is Ireland now?”
Martin Luther's Final Words and Legacy
57:31 to 59:01
Delve into the paradoxical last words of Martin Luther and his poetic legacy.
Death, Poetry, and the Protestant Aesthetic
59:01 to 1:02:06
Discuss the unique aspects of Protestant art and literature in contrast to Catholic traditions.
“How can he polish the turd of that as his final words?”
The Peace of Augsburg and Religious Division
1:02:06 to 1:02:31
Understand the significance of the Peace of Augsburg in religious conflict resolution.
Calvinism and Future Discussions
1:02:31 to 1:03:52
Preview Calvinism and its implications in the next episode of the series.
“We beat Hamas and we're hurtling towards the Taliban.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00They say history is written by the winners, but it is kept alive by losers. Boring people with sad lives and body odor, National Trust employees are in a way their own kind of ruin. Much like this 12th century abbey, their genitals have long since been abandoned and now lie crumbling to be visited only by the very ugly. Excuse me. But if history is written by the winners, who is history written for? Well, the answer is obviously men. Not you. Go away. Women of course have fiction, novels, but that's not for men. Why should I care about some made up horny Irish people? History is about so much more than looking around a shit building staffed by sexless fatties.
0:43Mooring! What are you still doing here? History can get the blood pumping, things like tank battles, amphibious landings, the exploitation of indigenous communities. This is history that gets a man rock hard when we talk about things like slavery, war crimes or genocide. It's high time we realize that not all history is created equal. And that's why I'm delighted to announce that my first book, The History of Mankind in Its Entirety, an unsupervised PhD, is available now to pre-order in hardback or audiobook if you're thick.
1:21Oi, have you got permission to film here? This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast. Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode available on Plus and Pro plans. Do you hear that? That sound, right? That means that summer's officially here. It means that grown adults just sprint into the street for a frozen dessert shaped like a cartoon.
2:01But this summer, Mint Mobile has a better treat. Every plan, including unlimited, is$15 a month. And unlike ice cream, it won't drip down your wrist or look nothing like the picture. Does anyone have any cash? Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months, $90 for six months, or$180 for 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. see terms welcome back to fin versus history i'm joined by horatio gould and today is part two of our deep dive on the reformation yeah martin luther uh a great man loving this you're a pig in shit i am a pig in shit and i don't just mean in this episode i mean generally thanks to this man luther he has held up a mirror to me and i can see that i'm a pig and shit yeah and you like what you see it's my own relationship with shit i don't need some intermediary some middle man it's your own bureaucracity it's your own reading of what the shit means yes yeah um yeah i have uh i've been given a label finally to understand my own brain right yeah um presbyterian uh i'm an extremist and i'm just reading back my own history really yeah yeah but you're so hang on if you're mixed catholic so you're mixed race what how does that manifest though it's sort of like on the scale if you're it's all it's also in the straight gay scale isn't it yeah you know you drink back coffee i drink coffee with milk right i say no more do you know what i mean and it's like so i i definitely i enjoy subtext i enjoy poetry i enjoy art i enjoy visual things yeah but it does get too much sometimes right okay all right that's enough yeah yeah so i like a bit of gay stuff i like gay aesthetics to be honest i'm very visually gay yes you are just emotionally i'm straight as hell if you could yeah you would walk down the street in dungaree shorts wearing a little necktie but then the kind of uh crying at everything i don't relate to that no so that's the rare combination that is like i i want to be involved when we're gossiping it's all really fun yeah But when it gets too emotional, I'm like, well, I need to...
4:13When the dicks come out and they're putting people's hands... Yeah, I know that's my straight friends. So I drink black coffee. You drink coffee with milk. The Italians are putting ice cream in coffee. It's a new level. Okay? They are beyond repair. Who is working after that? Who's going to work having had a fucking affogato at 10 in the morning? Now, we didn't really deal with Martin Luther, the man. The man, the myth, the legend. The man, the myth, my king, my legend. But we find him now at the Diet of Worms. Yeah, I guess this is your love of German history as well. Martin Luther is a real...
4:49There's something intrinsically German about him. Yes, yes. The kind of intenseness, I guess. Again, he's the first sort of person... Is there a humorlessness to Martin Luther? Sure, of course. A serious, yeah. But also a... Groundedness to him. You know, there's no element of fantasy. No. Or like hope. Yeah. There's a realism. there's a coldness there's a logic but actually this I like it that you say these words as if they're positive that's the tone you're saying but they sound negative these are my prayer beads cold, he's boring it's fantastic he's difficult to be around, unimaginative he's not actually boring we're going to get into boring next episode you think Luther's boring hold my non-alcoholic beer I give you John Calvin but anyway now we're in the diet of worms 1521 in the first reich the holy roman empire and to recap martin luther has built on the work of friends he's been running his mouth he has been running his mouth he's gone viral yeah um he's been running his printing press running his printing press because this is not this is not him typing right no you have to build i don't know i think you you build it it's like a piano isn't it you push buttons and they i think how does the printing press work you build the type the type and then you press it all at once it's like a big typewriter it's like a piano and someone pulls a lever and a letter yes or do you build the whole you build the whole thing fuck so you you build the book yeah and then you press the book i guess you can do that loads yeah but it's once you've done it but then when did they work out when did they work out that a typewriter you could actually write the typewriter um invented because i feel like typewriters are quite late given how small a step it is in logic to go from printing press to typewriter 1868 yeah that is late very late because really i would have made that jump i reckon instantly i mean instantly i'd gone well hang on there's a we can make this more efficient i probably would come up with a with a macbook yeah i would you're right actually i would just come up with an iphone i'll just come up with chat gbt in 1600s and i would have been like done yeah uh yeah so yeah that is interesting that they hadn't quite worked they had they made the whole book the whole book was it just pages it's pages at a time but then they must have they must have like 200 plates i think they have every letter this is what i'm imagining they have every letter in the alphabet and they build each two pages at a time because it's a two-page spread yeah and then if you're making a thousand copies just do a thousand of those next two pages thousand of those next to the so it still takes fucking ages it is it's not actually that good is it yeah but what was the other option typewriter no no before this again you know what's this replacing because before this is replacing gossip this is replacing word of mouth yeah no but there's people writing the whole imagine if you want to make a copy of a book you had to write it oh god no to write it out but then no one's got anything to do also yeah anyway so the printing press has meant luther's ideas have spread and he has been summoned to the diet of worms by charles v the holy roman emperor now we should deal with charles v get a photo of him up because he looks insane charles v oh is this the guy with the chad jaw line yeah yeah yeah that's my guy so charles v is a hapsburg and oh it's got that fucking Habsburg jaw, which is now coming into fashion again.
8:23You're joking. Well, the clavicular, right? It's like jaw maxing. Yeah, but that's not... No, no, no, no. Surely that's not. You're saying this is the first... If you're watching, we're looking at a photo... In a way, it's a Lux Maxxer. Charles V. I guess he's incest maxing. He is incest maxing, yeah. But it means that he's jaw-mogging everyone in Europe. He is jaw-mogging everyone. I'd say he's also downs-mogging people. uh he looks like i mean he looks like richard iii if he had down syndrome i mean he's an astonishing looking guy but he's also one of the most famous people in european history that we don't really um yes because he was also was he also charles v of spain yeah he like owned most of europe and had the pope in his pocket and um fucking mexico the aztecs he's the emperor of Of course.
9:12When do they discover, when does that all kick off? It's around this time, isn't it? The Aztec nonsense, is that 1530s? The exact time of, just before the Dight of Worms, Cortez meets Moctezuma. That is weird, isn't it? So Charles V, and this is important, he's fucking busy. Yeah. He's a busy guy. He's also got the biggest jaw. Well, maybe that's from stress. I got so stressed during my debut at Edinburgh that my jaw has a click that has never gone. I had that, and it does go, Does it? It does go. Did you get, was it from Edinburgh? Oh yeah, I think so. I had a period where I had, yeah, I had, no, it wasn't actually.
9:48This is when I woke up. This is after I broke up with my girlfriend. I was, I was dumped and I. Dear reader, he was dumped. Dear reader, I was dumped. And I basically, I was grinding my teeth so much at night that at one point, now this is very, very Presbyterian. This is the kind of extreme as I am. Hustle grind set. at night, asleep, grinding my teeth so much with, I suppose, unprocessed stress or, I guess, love grief, whatever you want to call it. Charlie can write some kind of poem. I don't know. Anyway, I was grinding my teeth at night and then basically I heard this pop and I got a fucking black eye.
10:24I woke up with a black eye. Oh my God. That's about to be the most Protestant way to deal with the heartbreak. Yeah, exactly. When you're like, love grief, I don't know what the fuck you call it. No, I'm fine. But then you, bang. and so I thought I woke up I genuinely thought I'd punch myself in the face during my sleep and that's what I told people I went and did old rope the next night and they're like what and I went I think I punched myself in the face in my sleep they were like really I went yeah I don't know and then a doctor I basically had like a kind of locked jaw and I had a click and he was like you know that'll be and then a dentist actually said no your teeth you've been grinding your teeth haven't you that'll be what that is right so maybe it is a protestant uh clicking jaw that just happens from yeah i basically burst my eye socket from grinding my teeth but you know uh i didn't need therapy yeah it's fine it's fine you know you can just grind your teeth and you can just grind your teeth like that is always an option you know there is better yourself up by your molars there's better help there's also worse help i'm a representative of worse help where you just grind your teeth yeah black eye and then you know time passes and you're fine.
11:32Anyway, this episode is brought to you by chat GPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons podcast. Have you guys heard about chat GPT work? It's the new way to use chat GPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give chat GPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports. Get started at chatgpt.com by selecting work mode available on plus and pro plans.
12:26months or$180 for 12 month plan required$15 per month equivalent taxes and fees extra new customer offer for initial plan term only greater than 50 gigabytes may slow and network is busy see terms at farmers our honesty is contagious wait am i gonna catch honesty well when you're with farmers it's kind of inevitable well how long does it take to i lied to you when you asked if i knew what a deductible was i don't know my dad's birthday and i thought umbrella policies were for rainstorms actual rainstorms i have it don't i you don't just have honesty you have farmers learn more at farmers.com underwritten by farmers truck or fire insurance exchanges or affiliate products not available in every state i don't yeah he is stressed but he also he looks absolutely clapped uh and this is what is called the hapsburg jaw which is really is that really coming back in no no just the jawline the kind of yeah there's jawline but that that is that's mad okay anyway so uh he's the king of spain and he's the holy roman emperor and he's sort of a huge figure in european history we don't really know much about him anyway um he is elected uh in 1519 yeah and he's elected partly by frederick the wise luther's sponsor at the university of rittenberg um so he calls this diet of at worms and he's like right uh it's all kicking off in the holy roman emperor a lot of empire a lot of the princes in the regions are like oh this would be great if this luther guy was right because that would mean we could have more power over our regions so they're kind of latching onto it as a political course yeah so he's like henry 8th eventually did it's all very similar yeah so and i should say actually we're going to deal with the english reformation when we do henry 8th which is coming up this summer yeah separate thing it's a separate thing so anyway so at worms luther's like i don't want to go yeah because you're blatantly gonna do what you did to goose yeah and and so 15 20 luther eventually goes okay yeah i will i will go to the diet and i think he um doesn't he go there christ-like doesn't he sort of walk there with like barefoot with followers and he's kind of mimicking christ he's very consciously this is like a salt walk sort of like a salt but he's consciously mimicking christ uh on that whatever march christ does so he gets guaranteed safe passage and then at the diet luther gets they basically like did you write this yeah and he goes yeah yeah and then and then they say what of it yeah and what and what and what mate uh but they say do you stand by your arguments and then he says uh give me a sec give me a minute i just need to go to the toilet and then he takes a day a day of prayer which is kind of an awesome way to like be asked a question and be like can I just can I have a couple days give me a day or so I'll get back to you so he says he's going to take a day of prayer before answering you say it's like the viral Russell Brand moment yeah roughly what he's just there just going through I mean that is absolutely extraordinary television have you watched the whole thing you've got to give Pierce his flowers I mean that's an unbelievable moment there it is Morgan's got him there.
15:33And also Morgan having the kind of instincts to let that sit. The man who interrupts people more than anyone in TV, knowing this is the perfect - To not interrupt. Oh, it's extraordinary. It's incredible. Hilarious that he interrupts any woman ever. And then a serial rapist, he just, no, give him, here's the floor, please. Don't interrupt. Don't interrupt a man while he's looking for a Bible verse. Don't interrupt a man. Complete silence. What's that? A woman complaining. Oh, excuse me. No, I've got an opinion to say. Yeah, but that was, yeah, the Brand Morgan interview, if you've not seen it, the whole thing's extraordinary.
16:07I haven't watched the whole thing. Oh, it's joyous. He's throwing every word he knows out there. All of them. Back against the wall. Back against the wall. Fucking shitting out. Just getting a fucking tessaurus to everyone. Yeah, it's amazing. Anyway, so Luther takes a day of prayer before answering the second question, which is, do you stand by all this stuff? And then he comes back the next day, and I think he's like literally there's a council of whatever bishops or I don't know they're all like the Star Wars people right they're in the clothes and the and and the Emperor the fifth Emperor Charles V is there and he says unless I'm convinced by the testimony of the scriptures I am bound by the scriptures I've quoted and my conscience is captive to the word of God I cannot and will not recant anything since it is neither safe nor right to go against conscience so he's basically he's basically the first person to like bring up conscience the idea of a conscience yes because there's an argument that luther starts individualism yes very much so uh so he's the first person who goes to the church and says also having morality being based on an internal yeah idea as opposed to being told to you by a church yeah it's the first person who ever said I'm going to speak my truth.
17:28My truth, my lived experience. Yeah. That's very positive. It's the birth of identity politics. Interesting. The idea of a bound conscience. The notion that an individual's conscience informed by scripture is superior to the authority of the church council. He didn't invent the concept of conscience, but he basically elevates it to be on a par with anything the Catholic church does. Which is very radical. Hugely radical. Yeah. Yeah, he says at this Diet of Worms, here I stand, I can do no other. This is like, this shatters, shatters the Catholic worldview. Yeah. So he's basically stood up to the Holy Roman Emperor.
17:58So then Luther kind of escapes, sort of, because Charles V... Seize him? Maybe they... Or is it like that? Like Lord Farquhar. Yeah. Seize him. God, seize him. Nah. But I think actually the diet ends and then they all go home. And then later, Charles V releases the Edict of Worms, which declares that Luther's an outlaw who needs to be arrested. Because I think they take time to try and process what he said. Yeah, they must do. Yeah. They go home and bloody hell. They should have killed him. They should have. Crazy, they didn't. But they say he's an outlaw. He needs to be arrested, charged with heresy.
18:37His works are banned. It is a crime for anyone to help him and it is legal for anyone to kill him. Which is an interesting way of doing it because have they put a hit out on him or they just said, if you kill him, you're fine. But if you give him safe passage, you're a criminal. Right, yeah. Interesting. The interesting thing to do that, just it's because no one does that nowadays that it's legal for anyone to kill someone because this is saying it's not like legal for law enforcement to kill luther like any old fucking farmer yeah it's citizens arrest yeah it's that guy tried to be kind of fun if there was people like that well there are people like that they tried citizens arrest tony blair every day there's the guy yeah but it's not legal to kill him no they made it so it was like if you fancied killing someone it was you had a complete what but it's like the purge but for one person this is kia Keir Starmer says it's legal to kill one person.
19:27Yeah. Or whoever. Get out of your system. Yeah. So in order to protect him, his sponsor, Frederick III, gets him kidnapped by men dressed as bandits. And so Luther gets taken to Wartburg Castle in Eisenach. So Frederick keeps him alive and protects him because Frederick wants the devolution of power from the Pope. But also he's a star academic and he doesn't want the university to be like disgraced. Right. So yeah. Because it is surprising that the most powerful forces in Europe don't kill Luther. But this is also, I think at this time, maybe the Spain are at war with the French or something. And there's the Aztec stuff going on.
20:09There's a lot going on. I mean, he's stressed. He's waking up with a black eye. He's grinding his jaw so much. So Charles V can't really deal with it. And also he doesn't have any direct control over the Holy Roman Empire. This is why this didn't happen in Czechoslovakia with Hus. Because they didn't have that local power. In Saxony. In Saxony. So Martin Luther goes into hiding at a castle, Castle Vartburg, Fatburg, Fatburg Castle. And this is where, look, we're doing our best to stay off poo. Yeah, this is what I was reading the plan. I was like, in general, we've had meetings where we're like, look it's too easy to talk about shit there's obviously been moments where we've had to talk about it for a while but in general we need to aim higher as a podcast we cannot keep being lost in the realms of shit but sadly the historic relevance of shit we found ourselves once again having to do probably another 25 minutes on shit we are a protestant podcast okay we are all caked and shit and it's fine okay so just so you know we are trying to move away from shit we can't just this episode we do have to talk about shit we can't just talk to a priest about pooing ourselves and then suddenly we're free from shitting no okay this is luther's great thing we're all in the gutter i have a poo if you like is that martin luther king saying he needs to go to the toilet yes uh anyway so he goes into hiding and this is where um he kind of goes mad he grows a beard and bear in mind he has been he has been he's an intense guy he's an intense guy he's obsessed with his own bowel movements yes very much like Gandhi very very very similar to Gandhi he's also it seems like any his go-to analogy when he doesn't like something is to call it like shit so basically he's calling the Catholic Church like oh well your guys are all really pooey poopy pants you mean the poop rather than the Pope and he's like Beethoven's brothering it the great poop in Rome.
22:16So he's quoted as saying that he was in the sewer when he realized that spiritual salvation was achieved through faith rather than deeds and actions. He was constantly constipated. Now, while he's in exile, he is basically on the toilet the whole time. Which it must shape, a lot of his work shapes the Reformation. It's hard to know how much it is actual philosophical conscience and how much is the second brain as we know now. You're right. Which brain was he writing with? The first or second brain? I don't know. I feel the kind of misunderstanding of kind of you need ferments, you need kefir and stuff like that.
22:52This is probably the frustration is where a lot of this writing was coming from. But I don't, so hang on, just talk me through the extrapolation of Protestant theology from being constipated. Well, if you look at the fury and anger of his writings, because he's hauled away hiding in a basement. all he's got is a printing press and he's just sending up mad things the frustration of being constipated not seeing anyone that colours the type of writing he's doing and the intensity of the writing and that means that the flame of the refrigeration spreads a lot further because of how intense and heavy the writing he is I suppose it's keeping things it's keeping things inside isn't it much like me just grinding my drawers and my face explodes I just don't let it out bottle it up but he's writing from the toilet Yes, he is writing from the toilet.
23:39Yeah. So he invents individualism. Yeah, much like Gandhi, he's doing test cricket sessions on the toilet and he is saying revolutionary thought that comes to him. He has divine inspiration on the toilet. Yeah. He's obsessed with poo. So he does go mad when he's in the castle. Now, while he's doing this, he's translating the Bible from the original Greek into German. I'm just saying, maybe if he wasn't contemplated, he might have forgiven the Catholic Church. or yeah he might have gone out it's actually alright I should see the shit yeah that would be mad yeah I thought it was because I thought it was the god and devil because he also thinks keeps having visions of the devil and he keeps thinking because it's such a superstitious age he's feeling all these things he sees a black dog he thinks that's the devil he chucks it out the fucking window he does chuck a dog out the window yeah he defenestrates a dog you know and I think he probably just interprets this gut feeling this must be the devil trying to but if he was if he had cleared out his bowels he might have been like oh that's brilliant so what is it so it'd be like that being called the diet of worms in your poo yeah he'd be like I don't know why I was so angry sorry guys sorry I just really needed a poo you're not you when you need a shit yes that's the sort of so he's in the castle he thinks he sees the devil everywhere the devil's in his bowels he does as we said chuck a dog out a window but he had no choice no he was he was backed into a corner is that the new phrase for pooing I don't know if it's a euphemism I think he actually no he does actually chuck a dog out a window but I think that's symbolic of his frustration that he can't chuck all his poo out his arse.
25:08Oh, you think it's a cipher? I think it's a Freudian thing where he, the idea he sees it as representing the shit and he throws it out the window. Right, yeah. That's what he wants. He wants to defenestrate his shit out his arse. Because this is pre what's the opposite of Imodium? Laxative. It's pre-laxative. We should place this, shouldn't we? The Diet of Worms is in 1521. Yep. So keep it German. It's a So this is before we basballed Dresden. Yeah. Which is in Saxony. Yes, it is. You're right. Yeah. Before Dresden got taken to the cleaners. Yeah. And it's after Caesar holocausted the Saxons in Saxony.
25:53Did he? Yeah. You're saying there's another... There is another holocaust. The Celtic holocaust. How many are we talking? It's pretty big. One million. One million. I don't know about that. a million such a big such a big number so 60 bc yeah that's a lot of people i don't know about that i don't know anyway okay so we're in 1521 uh betwixt the holocausts yeah um yeah lovely that's the name of my new book between the holocausts in saxony yeah between the holocausts um so he's throwing a dog out a window uh he's he's he's writing constantly he's translating the bible into german scatology yeah what does that actually mean that's poo is it yeah but i was thinking that's scatting oh right but funny funnily enough uh scatology is obsession with um poo are there any courses in scatology uh well charlie's a scatologist he's a professional scatologist uh or a coprologist yeah now coprology is filth is that is that fucking poo what's what's fucking poo fucking poo is a charlie's native american name of course it is yeah fucking poo.
27:00No, but you can also, what's funny is that scatology is obsession with poo, but eschatology is obsession with the end times, the religious end times. They're quite close. They are quite close, so yeah. So if you're an eschatologist, you're talking about the apocalypse. And if you're a scatologist, you're talking about the poo-calypse. Yes? What if you're a scat eschatologist? You're a scat, you're an, right. You believe the end times is poo. We'll drown in poo. Yeah. Yes, you're right. you believe that when you go to the toilet and poo the world will end yeah yeah let's let's save our poo talk for the immense amount of quotes we've got coming up as well yeah we've got a lot coming up just just to be very clear because we need to make sure that everyone's on our side coprophilia is the psychological term for a sexual fetish involving feces coprophagia is the specific act of consuming feces so you're a coprophagist copro copro copro it's co-production um scatter Neucephilia refers to sexual pleasure derived from feces.
28:00Often used in the phrase scat play. Scat play. Scat play does just sound, sounds too jazzy. Yeah, but it is pretty jazzy. It's pretty jazzy. There's no structure to it. But again, that is all Catholic stuff, personally. We are in the missionary only world. Okay. Doggy is the devil. Yeah, okay. Okay. Reverse cowgirl is the devil. it's just about missionary yeah get it done get it done and do it with a don't don't do it like yeah do it like you're doing your taxes be as bored yeah also the female orgasm is catholic yeah yeah okay if we're being calvinist about this it's just for procreation so uh he's a grumpy old poo guy uh stuck in a castle chucking dogs out the windows um and he also now does he marry when he's in the castle.
28:55Charlie. Charlie. Charlie. Tell the listeners what you just put on the screen. Tell the listeners what you just put on the screen. A man called Simon packs shit into condoms and fucks and sucks them. And that's... I mean, I don't think we can't show that. We can't show that. Charlie. I'm going to be sick. It's absolutely disgusting, Charlie. I'm going to be sick. That is awful. I think he's in a car as well. Who's letting him in the car? We've got actual historical shit to deal with. Let's not bring up pictures of shit on Reddit. We've got enough. Sorry, that's one guy, three shits, isn't it? That's one guy, three cups of shit.
29:32Come on, Charlie, Charlie, Charlie. Get rid of it. Get rid of it. Get rid of it. So Martin Luther is in the car. Sorry, I'm going to be sick. Martin Luther marries Katharina von Bora. Bora. so he's a former monk and she's a former nun okay let the dog see the rabbit let's have a look at Catherine von Bora let's have a look at her let's see how von Bora-ing she is this is the original Ava Brown let's have a look at her a little bit of a von Bora last night fucking hell I don't hate it it's not too bad she's got a devilish knowing look oh lovely actually for the age I think I think she's a bit of a smoke show yeah so while he's in there while he's hiding obviously the Pope is supposedly trying to find him.
30:22Quote, Luther says, almost every night when I wake up, the devil is there and wants to dispute with me. I've come to this conclusion. When the argument that the Christian is without the law and above the law doesn't help, I instantly chase him away with the fart. He calls the Pope's teachings farts out of his stinking belly. Basically, if he ever has an argument in his head about Catholicism, he farts it away. I think he means he's constipated. The devil is constipating him. right and so him farting is an act of defiance against the devil right yeah the elimination is so hard that i'm forced to press with all my strength even to the point of perspiration he's sweating on the toilet trying to do a poo if it was mixed with blood then there was a relief and almost a pleasure in pooing so i was often inclined to defecate and if it was touched with the finger it itched pleasurably he's talking about the blood flowed but it's also like um Martin, why are you telling us this?
31:16He's talking about scratching his piles. Yeah, but Martin, why are you writing? Is he printing press in this? I think he is. He's in his diaries. Has this been put into the printing press? And the Protestant reformers are like, I don't know. Is this diary? Martin, I don't. Yeah, so I suppose. I guess we shouldn't be reading Martin's diary. No, we shouldn't be reading his diary. Dear devil, I have shattered my pants and breeches. Hang them on your neck and wipe your mouth with them. Is this what Anne Frank's diary is about? I've not read that one. Is she talking about this? anyway yeah he's he's going mad yeah right pooing in a castle he's married katherine uh uh and his friends say that he's just irritable and he's getting gout a lot yeah he's i mean listen a 16th century german diet yeah is not one that it's dodgy i mean we were talking about loose stools on the gandy episode this is some of the firmest stools you can get while he's in there starting or growing your own business can be intimidating and lonely at times your to-do list may feel endless with new tasks and lists can easily begin to overrun your life.
32:18So finding the right tool that not only helps you out but simplifies everything as a built-in business partner can be a game changer. For millions of businesses, that tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10 % of all e-commerce in the U.S. from household names like Gymshark, Rare Beauty, and Heinz to brands just getting started. Shopify has hundreds of ready-to-use templates that can help you build a beautiful online store that matches your brand's style. And you can tackle all the important tasks in one place, from inventory to payments to analytics and more.
32:55No need to save multiple websites or try to figure out what platform is hosting the tool that you need. And if people haven't heard about your brand, you can get the word out like you have a marketing team behind you with easy-to-run email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they're scrolling or strolling. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify, and start hearing. Sign up for your$1 per month trial today at shopify.com slash realm. Go to shopify.com slash realm. That's shopify.com slash realm. This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast.
33:38Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports. Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode available on Plus and Pro plans. Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile with your summer price forecast. Now, unfortunately, we're seeing rising costs across the country with possibility that big wireless hates you 100%. Now, over here at Mint Mobile, we're seeing sunny skies and dropping prices.
34:19Every plan to just$15 a month. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months,$90 for six months, or$180 for 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only. Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms. the Reformation he's kind of like set he's set something in train so now I can't remember the names but there are these guys that basically start a kind of their own like violent Reformation in and around Wittenberg and this leads to the German Peasant War of 1525 where these movements are inspired by Luther and they're actually much more radical than Luther in what sense?
35:00they start toppling statues This is the first statue topless. Topless? Statue topless. They're like tearing out of churches. They're tearing down idols. They're more kind of towards Calvin than Luther. Luther actually isn't that boring. He still believes in bread and wine. He just doesn't like the political organization of the church. He just likes the match of boringness. Yeah. He's simply the, yeah. But what I find about the Reformation is it's not like, often with these revolutionaries they have like a a figure who's the figurehead who's the revolutionary and there's a cult of personality he just gets it going and then everyone's doing their own thing and it breaks into a million different pieces yeah it doesn't really have like a focal point in the same way well this is judean people's front isn't it because suddenly once he ultimately breaks the monopoly the church has on like authority yeah everyone starts coming out of the woodwork so these guys in uh wittenberg the zvikal prophets they preach ideas like adult baptism and the equality of all men yeah right so this is communist filth this is google adult diapers exactly um and so the wittenberg town council asked luther to return in order to calm the revolts so adult baptism which we'll get onto a lot when we talk about the amish which is that's quite interesting because that's basically saying that you need to be an adult so you can consent to your own baptism.
36:25Like Russell Brand. He was baptized as an adult. Right, yes. But then he doesn't... Because ironically, he needed to consent to the baptism. Yeah. Yeah, so this is the idea that you should know, go willingly into what you're doing. So Luther returns to Wittenberg in secret in March 1522. And he basically tries to banish the Zwickau prophets and work with the authorities to restore order. Zwickau prophets is a good band name. It's Vickhouse. It's Vickhouse. Yeah. So, but the problem is, is that all the new, more radical Protestants, they think Luther's going to lead them. Not even... Why is Ian Watkins on the screen?
37:06The prophets. The lost prophets. Lost prophets. That's why. The lost Protestants. He got killed the other day, didn't he? He got killed in October. A year ago, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Minute silence. Mm-hmm. For Ian. Friend of the pod.
37:25right so not the Zwickau sorry yes the Zwickau prophets not the lost prophets sorry I can see what happened there anyway Luther banishes the Zwickau prophets who were radical but I suppose not as radical as some of Ian Watkins ideas this is where it's ended up go on unpack that one take us from the 95 theses to Ian Watkins it's your own truth isn't it yeah is that how it's your own relationship you know he was framing it is that how he was framing it i don't know or was he like yeah i think it was more like that fuck you man which is which is it is no hang on hang on i'll explain go on i wanted to get onto this actually but i might as well talk about it now but being an emo is protestant that this is the long road to fuck you mum yeah to be fair ian watkins wasn't saying fuck you mum he was saying yes but he he had his own interpretation on the text right i see okay he read between the lines i think he misunderstood crucially i think he was a violently misunderstood man but no culture treats their parents with more anger than a protestant culture everywhere around the world be it africa china south america the mediterranean yeah you're taught to respect your parents no and to not question that in protestant countries you're taught to say fuck you fuck you mom because all the kind of where are you that is yeah you're right you are angst yes you know yeah hamlet is a very protestant character in many ways you're dealing with your own consciousness and like your own relationship with these things that that's not a catholic thing it's basically saying all my i fucking hate my family oh like that is yeah you know yeah you can't do that you can't you could it doesn't really work in the cultures it's about getting around the table together as one collective unit.
39:18But here it's like, no one understands me. Yeah, they're in the bedroom. They don't get me. Self-harm is prostitutes, I suppose. Very much so. Yeah, you're right. I still don't really like the idea that me and Watkins are cut from the same cloth. Yeah, well, you know. Where is Watkins? Different sides of the same cloth. He's born in Wales. Okay, fine. Fine. He's Welsh. Yes. so anyway let's get back to the German peasant war rather than the war that Watkins had with his own cunty mugshot sorry he's got a very cunty mugshot I think that's the least of his crimes yeah I think can we get him off please yeah come on Charlie come on don't know what's worse just the amount of Watkins you've had on the screen or a man eating three poos in the condom anyway so now he's trying to keep the peace but this is what's interesting is that this is a tension a um you know luther's sort of a my moderate conservative so it's a social revolution by moderate conservative right yeah right so he's basically saying he's trying to keep the peace yeah and yet he's let loose this sort of people who want to go much further yes yeah the revolts basically kick off uh and this is the largest popular uprising in europe before the french revolution really yeah so there's these guys called thomas munter munter yeah all the names are brilliant brilliant and andreas karlstadt uh and uh he now luther says these guys are is the work of the devil uh and he comes out they're protestant yeah but they're too far they've gone too far this is you know but this is this is um woke twitter culture right yes it is yeah easy itself they're not real they know they don't fit the exact thing exactly yeah so um luther comes out against the uprisings and many of the rebels then leave the movement but then uh there's these massive battles between uh the kind of authorities the the holy roman princes yeah and these uh rebels led by munster and carlstadt and there's the battle of frankenhausen in may 1525 which i think is the uh inspiration for the biggest painting in the world is that right the biggest painting ever he's gone for it i've gone for it i think he's hang himself out to he's left his belly open oh here we go no it's the peasants war panorama the largest oil painting in the world um it depicts the 1525 battle of frankenhausen with over 3 000 figures and it's an east german painting it's an east german painting because east germany during the gdr they try and claim munster and carlstadt as proto-communists yes well there's there is a there is a link i do feel between luther and marx and a lot of this these ideas the purity if you think about the communist aesthetic yes yes there's something quite protestant there is something like yeah purity yeah stripping back uh luxuries like there's a huge the fact that they're both german brutalism yeah yeah definitely um so luther comes out against the uprisings uh and they get defeated and so then uh after the uprising uh luther um So peace returns.
42:29That's when he marries Bora. Yeah. And he starts a new church known as the Lutheran Church. So... And the Lutheran Church, it takes off in Sweden. Like, where's the Lutheran Church today? Sweden? Germany and Scandinavia. Yeah. We don't really seem to have Lutheran stuff here. You don't hear that said. We're Calvinists, and we'll get into what that is next episode. But Lutheran is... So part of the reason, like, Scandinavia is so kind of always on a level... do you know what i mean temp yeah temperate yeah um they're also there's they're more happy with a sense they have a small sense of communalism than the the sort of rabid individualists of britain and america it's true but so i got a swedish friend and he said that the swedish mindset is different if you look at any society there's like you kind of can have two or three things which is the sense of you're all together as one state you're all together as one family and the individual, right?
Read the full transcript
43:25And I think in like Italy, it's not as much about the state, it's about the family. But basically in Sweden, it's about the individual and the state. You're collective as a state, but not as a family. Yes. So that's where they're kind of different. They're, they have, most of them live alone. It's, they don't have like a big family sense, but they are collective as a state. Here, we're fuck the government, fuck the family, fuck you mum, fuck you Keir Starmer. Fuck you mum, fuck you Keir Starmer, fuck you Sadiq. Like that's, that's us, right? Yeah. And America's even more so. Yes. yeah right um so uh yeah so scandinavia like social democracy in scandinavia that's why i always find it funny when people are like oh why can't americans like why can't we just be like scandinavia the nordic model yeah you are different breeds of humans you think differently yeah like you just can two different types it's never gonna happen it's never gonna happen no so and now luther has set and trained the reformation and we're going to carry on the reformation story next episode but what happens to luther is that he um i mean much like gandhi the sort of a stop clock element to him in that he had this initial zealous righteous anger that was very captivating and he was sort of this peterson-esque firebrand but then um he keeps writing when it's similar to like if he died then maybe be revered like bill hicks eminem if he died after his third maybe fourth album greatest rapper of all time he lived to do maybe five more kind of quite mediocre albums and he's sort of diminishing his own a bit if bill hicks hadn't died he would just be joe rogan like yeah he's revered now yeah even yeah george carlin's last five specials are pretty poor like yeah i mean the back end was yeah but there's still some great stuff in there yeah anyway so uh now this is all this is happening by the way in the context of the turks being very close to uh christendom we didn't should have said that last episode but part of the reason for the luther's success is that it feels like the end times because the church so corrupt and the muslim the ottoman turks are like encroaching on constantinople was that 14 yeah constantinople fell 14 something um so uh now he believes that the ottoman turks had been sent by god to punish christians interesting to bring on an apocalypse um and after reading a latin translation of the quran luther publishes several works on what he calls muhammadinism well that sounds like britain first talking about what's happened to london is down to muhammadinism yeah um he said islam is a tool of the devil not my words right okay um but but which should be left mainly alone interesting and he was against the ban on the quran to allow it to be scrutinized that is interesting what did he think about a moderate man what did he think about the burqa what did he what did Luther he says leave it so he can scrutinise it yes you should be allowed to make fun of it but you should not ban it that's what you probably thought what did Luther think about the burkini I think the burkini would be so many steps that would blow his he might actually find he passes a bowel movement he sees a woman in a burkini I quite like the burkini for men right okay go on there were definitely periods of my life you know such as when I was hovering behind Emma Watson eras like when i was hovering behind emma watson like gavin plum okay there was eras where i would have really liked a burkini to go swimming in for modesty for modesty okay because i've said this i've said this before the straightest man men there are they don't go topless ever they wear skin tight wetsuits yeah when they're in the pool right they make them look more naked but it's about modesty it's about giving their wife a chance to not get too horny letting other women who are not your wife exactly that's what my wife my disgusting flabby soft belly torso is my wife it's not for these random tourists you know i would have appreciated that yeah you know since the great stretching since my person since my personal trainer was that 1054 no that was a great schism was 1054 the great stretching was probably about 2006 right okay uh since the great stretching since my work since since my personal trainer's harika's helped me get up the stairs i am now much more comfortable being topless in a pool environment but there were an era of my life where i would have very much very very greatly liked a burkini sort of empathy for a younger self and for other young fat tailors about yeah i don't think muslim women should wear i think christian fatties should right okay that's my position on the burkini anyway so uh yeah luther's but to be fair i don't know how much when people are like oh he had complicated views on muslims everyone at the time had people have complicated views on muslims now yeah i mean they're two entirely different worldviews right are people trying to cancel luther for no what we're about to do what we're about to go through the 1500s i don't know if you can yeah he's not He's not being like, this is fucking Saxonistan.
48:28Fucking German in the stand. These days, you can't drive around Saxony. Can't drive a fucking Ford Transit around Saxony now. Good to fucking Sharia Ulez. No, he's not going on about that. But we get to probably his most controversial writings. He wrote several things about the Jews, which when you said about anyone, you think it's never going to be love letters, is it? Is there anyone who's got some writings on the Jews that have not read? On the 1500s? No, just ever. Anyone's ever written about the Jews? Is it ever good? Okay. Do you know what I mean? Is it ever complimentary? Let's pull the band-aid off.
49:08What's he saying? He calls for the burning of all synagogues and to exile all Jews. Right. In his work entitled, quote, On the Jews and Their Lives. And he was considered a moderate at the time. Yes, he's just got the searing clarity of Errol Musk. so he targets the Anabaptists which later becomes the Amish and Catholics but it's primarily an anti-Semitic work because the Nazis they referred to the work as one of the most quote radically anti-Semitic things to be published ever wait they're saying that as if it's a good thing right okay but if they're saying that's anti-Semitic that's they're like they're like fucking chill out mate Christ I mean I agree but woof.
49:52And that's the Nazi party newspaper, which is called Der Stürmer, which is not Kirsten, which I can already see. That would be a riff that some people will comment on. Was it Kirsten? Kirsten? Oh, but Commandant Kirsten. Anyway, so it was displayed in a glass case at the Nuremberg rallies. And that specific work was given to the editor of Der Stürmer as a birthday present in 1937. uh much like you know there are there are patron members who send me uh nazi memorabilia yeah that they stumbled across i do have a relic i do have them i do have yes you are you're becoming into i am getting into hitler's farts in a jar yeah i do there are some relics that i'm interested in but again this is you know it's like protestant relics are world war ii bullets and spent casings because that's our religion.
50:47But I'll get into this more, but I was listening to an interesting podcast that was saying basically how this country's Protestantism has really died down in the last 50, 60 years to the point where it's blended a lot with Catholicism, right? With Anglicanism, I guess, yeah. Well, I think loads of fixtures of British life are becoming more Catholic in ways that there would have never been 50 years ago. For example - Gay pride. Gay pride. When Princess Diana died, the outpouring of emotion, yeah the um yes deifying her as a saint the relics yes and all of the teapots the teapots all of that that was kitsch a very catholic response very catholic and wouldn't have happened 50 years earlier no so it's more that the protestant philosophy is is definitely dwindling a lot well listen the whole mental health thing
51:38therapy right is Catholic is confession for Protestants ah fuck isn't it cooking you go and talk to a box don't call it that or whatever it's it's Protestant you know they're selling therapy as if it's some new thing it's just it's just confession isn't it yeah fuck but it's for people but it's been done with a Freudian scientific background so you feel more right about it yeah exactly it's not spiritual no but no but it's trying to unpack it's scientific no because a protestant has sinned like from birth that's luther says we're all we it's impossible for us to get our way out of sin right so what a therapy what confession therapy does if it's confession is go well this is your original trauma this is your backstory this is your childhood trauma this is you didn't pass your anal stage your villain origin story yeah exactly And so that is, whereas a Catholic would go, oh yeah, today I goosed a woman and I'm sorry.
52:38And he goes, yeah, you're free. And he goes, okay, brilliant. All right, I'll probably do it again. Because he's not looking to be cured. He's just looking for a pass. And he's also like, I've been a fucking bad boy. There's a horniness to it. Yes. Yeah. It's like I've been a, the Catholic drama, you know, these things, there's a cinematic nature that the the veil between you and oh yes yeah and it's just like i've sinned father are you gonna punish me for being such a bad bad boy and they do and they do and there's a lot of there's a lot of institutionalized pedophilia in the catholic catholic church is there yes but the way you were talking about it was that you're sort of victim-bated by going i've been a bad boy um so yeah anyway uh this yes you're right princess diana's uh the grief was yeah it's a catholic response it is the country's and she's british what are you doing her name wasn't fucking diano yeah he also talks about the what he wants to happen to the jews is them all to be burned he he is sort of thinking about the holocaust like at a time before that's even a thing yeah he's a very modern thinker and hitler basically you know because hitler's trying to create, as we said in the last episode, a Germany that is like, feels like a country more than it is.
54:03Because when Hitler's in power in Germany Germany is, what, 40 years old? 50 years old? He's trying to tie Luther into the German story and Luther's basically sort of like firing out ideas for a... He's firing a lot out. He is firing a lot out. Well, he's not firing a lot shit out, that's the problem. No. A lot of ideas but... But yeah, so he a stall a year. He lays the intellectual seeds for Hitler. Hitler's anti-Semitism. Damn. Anyway. And this is your favourite guy ever, right? I think this is the greatest man ever. Yeah, yeah. The proto-Hitler who couldn't poo. In 1933, the Nazis celebrated, quote, German Luther Day to link the Protestant Reformation with the Nazi Revolution.
54:44Well, you've snookered me there. Phoebe, you've snookered me. All right. You've got me. You've got me. A threesome with two beautiful women. Luther and Hitler. Rock hard place. I couldn't choose between them why can't we just all marry each other as the three but so Nazis were not a religious movement though and they didn't tie religion in that much no but as Tom Holland says on our disabled sister podcast or rather our able bodied sister podcast yeah
55:19Luther's train of thought leads to atheism yes because if your own relationship with the god is that you think it's bollocks yeah but that's what you think and that's your conscience then that's the most important thing yeah so you think it's bollocks the logical end point of the reformation is atheism is ricky jermaine because you yeah because um and that's why there's more protest countries are far more atheists than catholic countries yes and eventually why catholicism will far outlast the protestant revolution in a thousand years time i suspect you say that but ireland is essentially protestant now I mean gay people can get married and you know you can't kill babies that's a small country though if you think about the power of the Pope I mean what even is Ireland now?
56:04you can kill babies I mean what's going on? yeah you know yeah I guess so I mean Ireland's one example but I think that because Protestantism it breaks off into these small little sects those sects don't have the history and tradition and the staying power that the Catholic Church does now when you have the new election of the pope and there's the celebration of the thousands years history it's a church that thinks in centuries not in decades i think as a through line to the past that's made it so strong whereas what you got amish you got methodists you got like this is all sort of fading away and also people have lost conviction because there's no rituals or tradition in these churches it's about your own relationship well it's just therapy now isn't it it's just therapy but also So you don't need God anymore with Protestantism.
56:51No. You don't really need him because it's a constant act of stripping away things that corrupt your relationship with God. Get rid of all the stained glass windows, get rid of all of that. And eventually it's like, might as well get rid of God. Exactly. I've got rid of everything else. Fuck him off. But because there's no rituals, it doesn't have the sense of tradition. And I think eventually that will mean the Protestant countries will just be atheist and the Catholic. like since tradition will maintain still exist far longer um but they're also probably gonna outbreed us i love this level of like right wing where it's like it's great great place about catholics catholics it's not even no it's about the wrong type of white that's how niche it is it's white on white violence and we must fight back against the catholic menace great replacement he he thinks priests to be fair to him again he's he's he's thinking of the holocaust before that's even a thing okay he thinks all catholic priests are sodomites again this man is a prophet he writes he's getting visions on the toilet he is he's psychedelically constipated yeah he is he's putting so hard that he's on mushrooms right he writes that cardinals are trying quote not to keep as many boys in the future but that it was well known how openly and shamelessly the pope and cardinals in rome practice sodomy cook king damn he's firing off warnings 500 years ago shit all right it's an open secret it's an open secret luth i mean how much more of open can you get as an open secret yeah so martin luther uh ultimately dies in 1546 uh and one of his final words that he says to his wife is beautiful this one this is beautiful yeah and this is i think he's a great writer he is and he's an eloquent man uh and he's you know uh he's very articulate this is his final words quote i'm like a ripe stool and the world's like a gigantic anus and so we're about to let go of each other listen guys guys protestant poetry is not good all right i've never said it is i don't understand poetry okay because i'm protestant protestants can't handle subtext i actually disagree with you on that though because protestant art where it is good is non-visual art because it's not about the aesthetics catholic tracy emmon doing a poo on the floor yeah that's protestant art but it's not just that um it's the it's all about literacy and reading the bible yeah so they're more literate cultures and more poetic cultures the protestant cultures because america britain um scandinavia these are it's a more about the written words yes as opposed to what when you go to tradition it's more more more as opposed to going to a church hearing latin and seeing these beautiful images which leads to more visual culture yes so i'd say that's actually a split can you try and say it as beautifully as you can.
1:00:00Like, how can he say it in the... How can he polish the turd of that as his final words? Say it as kind of... So he's on his deathbed. Emphatically as you possibly can. In a German accent? Yeah. I'm like a ripe stool and the world's like a gigantic anus and so a bow to let go of each other. I mean, it's romantic. It is romantic. This is, again, this is a Protestant man trying to be romantic. But it just seems like he's he's been trying to have one shit for 30 years and it feels like he knows that finally he's going to have that shit and he will leave this mortal coil this is like the end of his now he's done that poo his job is done my work is done he yeah he rather than saying rather than saying i think you should give that 10 minutes he goes my work here is done and he just dies he ascends to heaven um god what have you found charlie really now the longest anyone's gone without pooing is 45 days from 2013 involving a 28 year old woman where's she from uh she is from the north of england really north of england yeah oh that's beautiful isn't it that's good stuff these severe instances often require surgical intervention for quote fecal mass removal do you have a fucking cesarean
1:01:22christ c-section for a poohers you've really you've really lost life i would say i don't think look i don't want to diet shame anyone you know i've been through my own struggles but if you're having to have a c an elective c-section for a poo you're a fucking idiot all right you you really yeah and you should be ashamed that you've had to put the doctors through that because these surgeons should how am i paying for that on the nhs i mean that's an argument for private health care christ pooper pooper jesus christ awful um so luther dies with his touching last words about how he's finally going to have a cloth have a poo i believed he maybe died of a stroke or heart attack he lives for 62 which is pretty old for pretty good innings for uh 1546 um now the the reformation that he's set in trail carries on and but in 1555 a fragile peace is signed uh the peace of augsburg and this is an attempt to prevent more religious conflict between catholics and lutherans it formally divides the holy roman empire into catholic and lutheran states and it's the first time where you ever say hey uh there's a latin phrase for it but it's your state your religion so you practice whatever religion you want so if if you live in bavaria and your prince is catholic you're catholic that's why catholic do you think germany is a protestant country well it is but it has these southern but it's that's because of this right um but the crucial problem with the peace of augsburg is that it does not recognize calvinism right what is calvinism you think luther was boring and in our next episode when they get into my intellectual air or rather I'm the intellectual air of him my ancestors John Calvin and John Knox the Presbyterian the head of the fun police these guys are the Christian Iranian morality police of which I am a member okay that's in our next episode now the rest of the other two episodes of this series are on the Patreon already Patrons will be able to get access to that now for three pounds a month We are the biggest in the country.
1:03:35Come on. Extraordinary. Got that. Absolutely extraordinary. We beat Hamas and we're hurtling towards the Taliban. We are going to take on the Taliban. The Taliban, I think, what was it again? I believe active fighters, 90 ,000. Yeah. It's a big aim, but we've got to aim high. We may have to have an alliance with them. This episode is brought to you by ChatGPT. Hey, it's Bill Simmons from the Bill Simmons Podcast. Have you guys heard about ChatGPT work? It's the new way to use ChatGPT for bigger multi-step projects. And when you need more than just answers, give ChatGPT work access to your apps and files, and it can create real work documents like spreadsheets, slides, and structured reports.
1:04:16Get started at ChatGPT.com by selecting work mode available on Plus and Pro plans. Ryan Reynolds here for Mint Mobile with your summer price forecast. Now, unfortunately, we're seeing rising costs across the country with possibility that big wireless hates you 100%. Now, over here at Mint Mobile, we're seeing sunny skies and dropping prices. Every plan to just$15 a month. Give it a try at mintmobile.com slash switch. Upfront payment of$45 for three months,$90 for six months, or$180 for 12-month plan required. $15 per month equivalent. Taxes and fees extra. New customer offer for initial plan term only.
1:04:50Greater than 50 gigabytes may slow when network is busy. See terms. At Farmers, our honesty is contagious. Wait, am I going to catch honesty? Well, when you're with Farmers, it's kind of inevitable. Well, how long does it take to... I lied to you when you asked if I knew what a deductible was. I don't know my dad's birthday. I thought umbrella policies were for rainstorms. Actual rainstorms. I have it, don't I? You don't just have honesty. You have Farmers. Learn more at Farmers.com. Underwritten by Farmers Truck or Fire Insurance Exchanges or Affiliate. products not available in every state. Hamas.
1:05:23We have buried Hamas. We've solved that actually. Yeah. And their membership's going down, I feel. I think it is. Yeah. While ours is going up. Now, do you think that's because we are getting active Hamas members? No, there's... Okay, core. We'll get core fighters. As of early 2026. Right. But that's the takeover strength. They think they... Yeah, to be fair, they are getting bigger than the Taliban. It's going to be tough. So are we. We're getting bigger. Right. So let's just say 150 ,000 Taliban fighters. Okay, guys, we are project, let's say project 2036. Okay. And to celebrate, as soon as we pass 150 ,000, we are retaking back Afghanistan.
1:06:00We're taking Kabul. All of us together. Yeah. All of us. We're going to take Kabul. We can take them. Man for man, we can take them. So sign up to the Patreon, which will be seen as joining the draft to take on Kabul. And we are going to implement a regime that is even worse for Afghan women. uh that's on the patreon enjoy that uh but if not we'll see you next time for a deep dive on calvin goodbye you
From the publisher
The Devil Is In Your Bowels.
The Reformation (Part Two)
Pre-order Fin's book here: https://linktr.ee/FinTaylorBook
Suits by Beggars Run: www.beggarsrun.com
The show for people who like history but don't care what actually happened.
For weekly bonus episodes, ad-free listening and early access to series, become a Truther and sign up to the Patreon
patreon.com/fintaylor This episode of Fin vs History is brought to you by Surfshark.
Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code FVH for an extra 4 months at https://surfshark.com/fvh
Chapters:
00:00 - These Are My Prayer Beads
03:21 - Incestmaxxing
09:11 - Back Against The Wall
14:06 - More Poo (Sorry)
18:25 - Scatology
26:00 - Pooey Castle
30:22 - Emos Are Protestant
33:48 - The Communist Aesthetic
37:55 - Fin Fat Taylor
42:51- Hitler’s Bath Water
47:05 - Dream Threesome
51:26 - Protestant Poetry
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
