In short
Football Clichés episode mixes live-show recap (South Bank Centre, sunny post-show), listener anecdotes, and “ref watch”/media wordplay. It discusses pre-season prediction markets via Calci, then focuses on Arsenal/Chelsea press-conference banter about Gary Cotterell, kit/branding jokes (Man United kit resembling Arsenal 08/09), and refereeing culture—especially Mike Dean’s claim he went 20 minutes without whistling, plus Darren England’s VAR announcement wording (“penalty shout”) and RefCam free-kick positioning. It also covers EFL audio clips: Jay Stansfield’s Wolves goal, Gillingham’s “Ole” turning into “go on,” and Portsmouth’s extremely fast BBC Radio Solent commentary.
Guest backgrounds
Charlie Eccleshare and David Walker are the hosts/panelists; no other guests appear in the transcript.
Key claims
Cotterell’s Arsenal press-conference material is “laboured” and should be limited; Mike Dean’s whistle story was likely embellished; “penalty shout” is incorrect protocol; EFL audio is improved/“raw.”
Notable examples
Tom Cruise “me” pluralisation; “J.P. Morgan” front three; “Marcus Tavernier” mispronunciation; Crystal Palace 5 Leicester 0 (April 2018) as a Dean example; Brian Brobbby described as “massaging defenders”; Andrew Moon’s 38-word goal call in 7 seconds.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOSoccer Predictions Before the Season
0:00 to 0:35
Explore early predictions for the soccer season including league winners and trophy lifters.
“Before the season even kicks off, soccer fans are already making predictions.”
Reflections on a Live Show Experience
0:59 to 2:29
Hosts recount their experiences from a recent live show and the audience's reactions.
“And the easiest way to do that is to give the keys to Kirk Cousins.”
Memorable Moments and Audience Interaction
2:35 to 4:19
Discuss memorable interactions and funny moments with the audience during the live show.
“Hello everyone and welcome to Football Clichés.”
A Funny Story from the Live Show
4:19 to 6:03
Recount a humorous event involving a lorry driver during the live show.
“We were sort of spilling out of the pub, the Mulberry Bush, just down the road from the South Bank Centre.”
Adjudication Panel Discussion Begins
6:03 to 6:59
The hosts transition into their discussion segment about Gary Cotterell and his recent comments.
“We were speaking the other day about ex-athletic Bilbao midfielder Mikel Vesga and his so-called knack of scoring penalties.”
Critique of Gary Cotterell's Press Conference
6:59 to 11:23
Analyze and critique Gary Cotterell's performance during a press conference, focusing on his questions.
“I'm glad he stopped pluralising himself, Charlie, because why would Tom Cruise pluralise himself in this situation?”
Manchester United's Kit Controversy
11:23 to 13:21
Discuss the controversy surrounding Manchester United's kit resembling a past Arsenal design.
“If they were like a pair, like an SAS thing.”
Strange Stadium Behavior
13:21 to 14:00
Share observations of unusual fan behavior during a match, including a fan sneaking an iPad into the stadium.
“Warren Winrow writes in and says, I'm not sure if it's games gone or a minor quirk.”
The Joy of Commentary Names
14:00 to 18:14
Exploring the nuances and enjoyment of football commentary names.
“An iPad, that's distracting for other people.”
Mike Dean's Refereeing Fiasco
18:14 to 18:40
Discussion on Mike Dean's controversial claim about not blowing his whistle.
“I mean, it's funny because he must have been thinking like, you know, this is going to get people going to hang.”
Show all 22 chapters
Analyzing VAR Decisions
18:40 to 22:00
Debating the implications of VAR's review process and terminology used by referees.
“This is the under the coshification of football culture.”
Unique Referee Insights
22:00 to 23:35
Insights into the subtleties of refereeing decisions and player interactions.
“Here's a lovely description of Brian Brobby's forward play on BBC Radio 5 Live.”
Unique Referee Insights
23:38 to 26:17
Insights into the subtleties of refereeing decisions and player interactions.
“Listeners, I will admit to a frisson of excitement when I land in a foreign country, my phone slowly finds a signal and the unfamiliar name of the local network operator finally appears at the top of my screen.”
Martin Keown's Nut Allergy Lecture
26:35 to 28:00
A humorous recount of Martin Keown's unsolicited advice about nut allergies.
“For$5.99 a month, you'll get ad-free listening of all of our episodes, plus two episodes a month of Dreamland, our exclusive show.”
The Nut Debate: Martin Keown's Obsession
28:00 to 29:24
Explore the humorous discussion about Martin Keown's fixation on nut allergies.
“It's quite obnoxious, actually, in that response, but that's the only option you've got.”
Paul Merson's Premier League Predictions
29:24 to 30:56
Analysis of Paul Merson's predictions for the Premier League assists this season.
“Lower down in the Reddit thread, actually, a very important question was asked by Mark Ams Scientist.”
Chelsea's Summer Sales: A Profit Perspective
30:56 to 32:44
Discussion on Chelsea's profitable summer transfer window and Merson's comments.
“This window, I can imagine they must have been sitting in a room every day of the week for the last two, three months trying to get these deals done.”
EFL Audio Nuggets: A New Era
32:44 to 34:39
Highlights of the improvements in EFL audio broadcasts and exciting moments.
“What a trio of EFL audio nuggets for you next.”
The Fastest Commentary and Podcast Listening
34:39 to 36:53
Exploration of rapid commentary and the effects of listening speed on podcasts.
“I mean, they went early with this generation of the Ole and they just kept on going.”
Footballers in BBC History: A Comedic Twist
36:53 to 38:38
The humorous connection between footballers' names and historical events in podcasts.
“Fair play to Barry O'Driscoll from Dublin, who told me in incredible detail all the different speeds he listens to podcasts at.”
Football Rituals: Tube Station Sign Touching
38:38 to 42:06
A light-hearted discussion about football rituals and touching tube signs.
“And this is from all the way back from 2005.”
Footballing Behavior and Rituals
42:06 to 42:47
Explore the unconscious behaviors and rituals players exhibit in football.
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Before the season even kicks off, soccer fans are already making predictions. Who wins the league? Who qualifies for Europe? And who's lifting the trophy at season's end? On Calci, America's number one prediction market platform, you're trading against peers in a live market, meaning there's no house. And as the probability changes, you can buy in and out of your position. For a limited time, download the Calci app and use code CUP26 to get$10 when you trade 10. K-A-L-S-H-I, Calci. Trade the beautiful game. 18 plus only restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors.
0:32Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information, see calsheet.com slash regulatory.
0:59with their roster. And the easiest way to do that is to give the keys to Kirk Cousins. All on Europe's biggest sport podcast network. Find your next favourite sport podcast. Search Sports Social Podcast Network and listen wherever you get your podcasts. Sports Social Podcast Network. Verified comparison at content.sport-social.co.uk forward slash comparison. I'm sorry, you can sit there and look and play with all your silly machines as much as you like. Is Gascoigne going to have a crack? He is, you know. Oh, I fell! Brilliant! Pachee! He's ran the goalkeeper, he's done it! Absolutely incredible!
1:38He launched himself six feet into the crowd and Kung Fu kicked a supporter who was without a shadow of a doubt giving him lip. Oh, I say! It's amazing! He does it tame and tame and tame again. Break up the music!
1:57Charlie Eccleshare:Charge a glass! This nation is going to dance all night. Tasmania, truck drivers and top-class operators. The inside story of football cliches live. Tom Cruise's pluralisation, time to get tough on the enablers of Gary Cotterell. The new Adidas stripes are too thick. The Mike Dean content machine and other referees getting too casual on the mic. Martin Keogh, nut police. Gary Neville noises hiding in the plain sight of mid-2000s Kaiser Chiefs singles and resisting the Anfield side impulse in general life. Brought to your ears by Goalhanger Podcasts, this is Football Clichés.
2:39Charlie Eccleshare:Hello everyone and welcome to Football Clichés. I'm Adam Hurry and this is the Adjudication Panel. Joining me first of all, Charlie Eccleshare. How are you doing? Very well, thank you. Alongside you is David Walker. How are things? Things are good. what high energy from us all as we um well we plummet back to reality from a tremendous live show at the south bank center on saturday afternoon um goal hanger absolute class operators i felt like i was treated like a king dave especially when it went to hair and makeup before we went on stage hair and makeup was a lovely touch very unexpected i had a moment actually when the next morning standing on the touchline and clapham common when i realized i had i didn't i I rarely bother showering before football.
3:22I do that afterwards on a Sunday. So I stood there and I thought to myself, I think I've still got the makeup on from yesterday. Still got the blusher. Am I supposed to remove it before I go to bed or something?
3:36Charlie Eccleshare:I don't know. Your hair looked absolutely magnificent, I can tell you. So as did the South Bank generally, just gorgeous little venue. Two of the Valaraki 12 in attendance. That really boosted the gender numbers there. Barry O'Driscoll over from Dublin. Andy went on the London Eye. So what a day for him. Someone was there from Tasmania, which is just mad. Just witnessing Charlie Eccleshire and his monologue pomp as well. Always a tremendous thing. One audible intake of breath from 300 people towards the end of the show. That was lovely to witness. Just a Saturday afternoon post-show in the sunshine, which is a real novelty, Dave.
4:13Charlie Eccleshare:Never experienced that before. That was when your glistening mane really came into its own, around 7pm golden hour. It was a lot of fun. We were sort of spilling out of the pub, the Mulberry Bush, just down the road from the South Bank Centre. Some great happy hunting grounds, some familiar faces, but some people, I think it was like their first show, their first time coming to a show, met a really nice father and daughter duo, Ipswich fans. The daughter got the dad into the pod, which was very nice to hear. That's great. There was a funny moment when I was talking to a couple of lads about the various podcasting bits and I was mentioning Micah Richards for some reason at this point.
4:58And Micah Richards at that very moment sped past on a line bike.
5:03Charlie Eccleshare:And it was too perfect today. Hey, Charlie, you'd gone by this point, but there was an incredible moment of Happy Hunting Grounds where we enlisted the help of a guy reversing a massive lorry back into a side street. And as he sort of hit 90 degrees and sort of faced us out of his window, we were like, excuse me, mate, do you know who's called from Middlesbrough? He was... Don't care.
5:30Imagine if he had plucked one.
5:32Charlie Eccleshare:It would have been unrivaled if he'd plucked a name out of nowhere. Just give us a name at least. Dave, you recruited at least two people from the live show crowd for Ripplesdale Rovers on Sunday morning. Three, actually. Wow. So good. They all played on Sunday morning. Helped us to a 2-1 win in our first game of the season. Yeah. Are they going to stick around? They're in the WhatsApp group. Got them registered in time. Registered. Everything all above board. Right. Well, yeah, that really filled my live show cup. That did, Saturday afternoon. The whole day, absolutely tremendous. Other matters to take care of.
6:07Charlie Eccleshare:We were speaking the other day about ex-athletic Bilbao midfielder Mikel Vesga and his so-called knack of scoring penalties. This is incredible. Listener Samuel got in touch and says, Mikel Vesga missed a penalty in 24-25 that cost me 20 grand on a first goal scorer bet. So it sticks in the cross of what to hear him described as having a knack for scoring them. That's ridiculous. if the fun stops. Yeah. What must the stake have been? If he's to earn that much, that's a huge bet. That is a good point. Just on a single first goal scorer bet, unless he's done some sort of mad multiple across games.
6:44For a man with a known knack for scoring penalties.
6:47Charlie Eccleshare:Yeah. God, he must be so trick-head every time he sees Mikel Vezca. That's awful. Maybe listen to Samuel who's rolling in it otherwise and that was mere pennies to him. Yeah. So there could be more to it. sign up for Dreamland mate right anyway time for the adjudication panel love this to kick things off this is Tom Cruise being interviewed on the Pat McAfee show like you can have these artists all these greats they got to cut their teeth and learn in the same way that you get to act and you're learning it's you take it and the next one and the next one every single one of them the Inyaritus, the Spielbergs, the Nolans me, all the opportunities that I've had I want that for every writer, every director, every producer, every artist.
7:32Charlie Eccleshare:I'm glad he stopped pluralising himself, Charlie, because why would Tom Cruise pluralise himself in this situation? But just adding yourself on to the end of a pluralisation is extraordinary. I've never seen it before. Yeah, I feel like we have had someone saying the me's at some point. I think it was Nora Robson. Yeah, the me's. Yeah, it was Nora Robson. It did sound like that's where he was headed, and he sort of just stopped himself in time. The rhythm of it was just so good. But yeah, then just me. But I guess he is one of a kind. Tell you who else is one of a kind. I want to stop talking about him, Dave, but I want to move the discourse on about Gary Cottrell.
8:09Charlie Eccleshare:Here he is in the pre-match press conference for Arsenal against Chelsea at the weekend. The front three have become known as J.P. Morgan. J.P. Morgan. Yeah, so that's Palmer, Zhao and Morgan. Yeah, I get that. I got there quite quickly. But thanks for clarifying it. But with your defence, you'll be banking on keeping them out. I was thinking maybe a name for your front three, maybe the front three that finished against Villa. Oh, that surprised me. They had Saka, Ebzezer and Kai. That's S-E-E-K, seek. Is that quality the reason you didn't seek reinforcement?
8:54And sticking with Banks and finally, obviously you've got Goldman Sachs to rely on.
9:06Charlie Eccleshare:Yeah, he's been very reliable so far in the first tour. I think maybe we need to stop sort of complaining about Gary Cottrell, Dave, and start worrying about the causes of Gary Cottrell. There's people around him chuckling and enabling it. The root causes. He should be shut down. Mikel Arteta has a job to do here. He's the manager of the champions Tough on Gary Cotterell, tough on the causes of Gary Cotterell Exactly right Yeah, yeah Fucking hell I mean, sometimes I quite like his ability to You're just kind of Who's that knocking at the door? Parody, yeah Sometimes it sort of works As discussed many times Best doorstepper in the business But this is like, that was excruciating That was, none of it worked We must be at a point now, Charlie where Arsenal press conferences should have just an allotted 45 seconds maximum of Gary Cottrell and he's not allowed to go over that.
9:56Charlie Eccleshare:And if he does, he gets bundled out by some stewards or something. Security jumper. Yeah, there has to be a limit. There has to be an absolute allocation of Gary Cottrell. This was horrendous. I genuinely wonder, though, how Arteta feels about it because he does seem like he is quite enjoying it. Weirdly. It's probably, I guess for him, it's sort of like relief and it takes away any pressure on him because the point of this is surely not to elicit a good, interesting response. The point is to sort of create viral content, have a bit of fun. There is no world in which Arteta answers that question, whatever the question was about, is that why you didn't seek?
10:36And it's like him being like, no, that's a really good question. And yes, that is why we didn't seek. He's not going to answer that. So he probably quite enjoys it. It's a break from, this isn't a probing question. I can just relax.
10:48Charlie Eccleshare:But if he's humoured him so far, Dave, if he snaps now, it'll look like the precious telling on Mikel Arteta as they seek to defend their title. Yeah, I think Charlie's right. You can clearly tell that he's, you know, Arteta's grinning along to this. And he sort of dealt with the initial JP Morgan bit really well. If there was just something witty off the back of that from Cottrell, it would have been fine. but he just went down this ludicrous cul-de-sac of just awful like laboured efforts to try and come up with an equivalent well maybe this is it charlie maybe just needs better material could gary cotchier just get someone to write his material for him if he's gonna have to insist on doing this i mean if we're all gonna have to suffer it we might as well be better stuff the funny thing as well is like jp morgan firstly i was thinking that would work way better if it was just xiao pedro and morgan rogers that would work a lot better because presumably xiao pedro probably is known as JP a little bit.
11:40If they were like a pair, like an SAS thing. I mean... All right, JP? Yeah, I reckon there's a... He's not a JP, is he? He'll have it at least on his training top. Yeah. Whereas like João, Palmer and Morgan. And also JP Morgan is like, it's such like a boring institution. Like it's hardly glamorous. Like, oh, wicked. Like, you know, three in the playground. Oh, sweet. We get to be, you know, I love the M &A at JP Morgan. This is great.
12:06Charlie Eccleshare:I mean, yeah, from start to finish, the whole thing is a shambles but um i really don't know where cotchell goes from there elsewhere this weekend there was widespread multi-platform uproar charlie over how much manchester united's kit from a distance looked like arsenal 0809 specifically um yeah i wasn't on board but then as the game wore on against everton i thought wow yeah it does it is it is really odd having seen this mentioned then looking at it i do know totally what it means you are sort of instantly transported to a hapless Mikhail Sylvester or something like that. If I were to nail my colours to one of the two particular masts, I'd say I've always been an Adidasman over the years, never really been a Nikeman.
12:47Charlie Eccleshare:But these big, thick Adidas lines are testing my real allegiance, I have to say. They're not for me. That's the problem, yeah. It just, from the distance and at a glance, it just looks like they've got white shoulders as opposed to you can't really make out the three, the iconic three stripes. Do you want to look like Arsenal 08, 09 though, Charlie? Is that ever a good look? You definitely don't. I mean, you know, drawing four all at home with Spurs, went four to up going to 90th minute. I mean, that was like height of the sort of banter era. Elsewhere at the Hill, Dicko, Dave, Warren Winrow writes in and says, I'm not sure if it's games gone or a minor quirk.
13:26Charlie Eccleshare:At Everton versus Manchester United, the guy next to me had snuck his iPad into the stadium and was watching the Italian Grand Prix. I was astounded at the weirdness of this, but too polite to say anything. Around the 12-minute mark, a lad behind inquired as to whether he'd renewed his Tory membership card, and thus the iPad was quickly put away. Good little quip. Well done. Well done, that man. More as the highlights later if you have to. Yeah, and an iPad as well is a step too far. If you must sneak a glance at something on your phone, and maybe you can get away with it, just, you know, just tuck down there.
14:03An iPad, that's distracting for other people. Yeah, yeah, quite right. Is there an ooment for a Formula One race?
14:11Charlie Eccleshare:I don't know. Just generally watching another sport, I don't think that's really odd. Yeah, I think it should be against the regulations. Next up, a player whose goal-scoring name has been well-documented as an audio treat, but this could be the pinnacle of it. This is Tom Gale on Match of the Day for Newcastle against Bournemouth. Barnes. Harvey Barnes! With an instant reply to half the deficit! Lovely delivery, Charlie. The weighting of it as well. sort of Harvey really giving it the propulsion and Barnes taking it from there. And we've noted Tom Gale's delivery before for other names, but so all those ingredients together made for a delightful pronunciation pie.
15:07Yeah, it was. It's almost Conor McNamara levels of sort of risingness. Yeah, top work.
15:15Charlie Eccleshare:Conor McNamara, Dave, the star of Charlie's, can't say anything else but this before the live show. I think he was having a piss in the toilet and he was saying Marcus Tavernier. Tavernier. It's just a great... He scored, right? He just scored, yeah. That was why. And I just can't hear that name without saying it in a con of Matt and Matt. Sometimes before live shows, Charlie's just like a little toy that you could just pull a string and you'll just carry on saying a phrase. It really is fascinating. I thought I had nervous energy, but yeah. Wow. Ref Watch. Lots of chat about referees early on this season, especially this weekend.
15:49Charlie Eccleshare:The latter stages of the Mike Dean fuss. Dave if anyone somehow hasn't been exposed to this he confessed on Jamie Vardy's podcast that he went 20 minutes of a Premier League game without whistling deliberately as part of a game that he was playing with himself lots of doubt cast upon this and scorn indeed Dave as well but I knew where this was going to go I knew that Dale Johnson of the BBC was going to go through every single bloody game that Mike Dean had ever refereed to see if this had ever happened but fair play to Dale he sort of filtered it down he filtered it down to just the 200 games that were nil-nil after 15 minutes, meaning that there would be no need for a whistle for a kick-off after a goal.
16:25Charlie Eccleshare:So he's gone really strict with his whistling here to narrow it down to find out when Mike Dean had done this. Was this strictly necessary? Because I think it was pretty obvious early on that he'd embellished his story. Yeah, I also saw, there was a video, I think it was Adam Cleary, who'd gone through the games as well, and he claimed to have found, I think it was a West Brom. Man U, West Brom. Yeah, West Brom Man U, yeah. Did it in a day, fair play to him. But yeah, I think when I first heard the claim from Mike Dean, I did immediately think, well, I mean, like maybe he didn't blow his whistle for like two or three minutes and is claiming it was 25 minutes, you know, clearly like just embellishing it for effect.
17:03But also then I thought about it. How could you get away with not blowing your whistle? Because you can, I guess you could just sort of still give decisions. Like for throw-ins and free kicks. Yeah. You could just communicate, right? You've got to blow for a free kick, though. Well, yeah, you should do. But, I mean, you could. Or is there a way you could? Maybe you could get away with kind of not doing it. When it's so obvious. When someone stumbles over and you're just like, yeah, go on. I don't know if I've seen that happen.
17:32Charlie Eccleshare:But the technicalities of this are interesting. But Dale Johnson got into some examples of games where this may have been the one. Crystal Palace 5, Leicester 0, April 2018. Dean finally blew his whistle at Selhurst Park after 60 minutes and 3 seconds, awarding a free kick to Hamza Chowdhury. That is a fair way into the match again, but not close if he's claimed to have gone 20 to 25 minutes into the game without stopping it. However, the referee blew his whistle on 3 minutes 8 seconds to indicate a corner had been awarded. So it's difficult to say this one really counts. Don't put it in the list then!
18:04Charlie Eccleshare:i mean fair play to mike dean he's created a lot of content for a lot of people and uh including us so fair play but yeah um uh the end of this story charlie the sort of the book end of it came on soccer saturday where he had had this sort of sort of hand-fisted climb down from the story just saying yeah i was just you know i've you know maybe sort of got the wording wrong here but yeah i guess it was a good platform to be sort of put right about it but i think this story should probably end here shouldn't it yeah i think it's probably run its Of course. I mean, it's funny because he must have been thinking like, you know, this is going to get people going to hang.
18:35I'm an absolute legend for this. Yeah, obviously completely unraveled from very quickly.
18:40Charlie Eccleshare:This is the under the coshification of football culture. You feel like you've got to say something that happened in your career that probably didn't. I don't know. HMRC of football. It's all good news for him, I guess. Next up in the refereeing world, here's Darren England ripping up the VAR review announcement protocol at Portman Road on Friday night. after review there's a penalty shout on Sir Bozlay however in the build up to the penalty shout Sir Bozlay is in an offside position I will not abide the phrase penalty shout being uttered by one of our elite officials Charlie Eckert that is so amusingly casual penalty shout and as we pointed out Sir Bozlay as well is that a Premier League thing because we're used to the sort of Paraguay number 10 or whatever it is.
19:30Yeah, it should be red number eight, basically.
19:32Charlie Eccleshare:I mean, I'm not saying it should be, but yeah, I mean, at least, should he be full-named? Should it be more formal than that, Dave? I mean, a penalty shout. I mean, it's the vaguest of punditry chat at the very least. So for a referee to say, it seems very strange. Well, what should be the correct wording? Like the official wording of a penalty appeal? Appeal? Or what is it? There was a penalty award? Because was it awarded in the moment? Yeah, you've got to address the decision that was made. you can't sort of speculate what people might have thought of it which is what Penalty Shout is doing so yeah you've got to address the decision made and then say whether it stands or whether it's been reversed so but yeah but as plenty of people also said well what's next is he going to say six of one half a dozen of the other or whatever Gabriel just booted Martinez in the kisser but I haven't seen it that way after review it's one of those really
Read the full transcript
20:25Charlie Eccleshare:if I hear one of those before the end of the season I will die Next up, this is Sam Barrett, who features in the latest RefCam video. It's Liverpool versus Nottingham Forest. I always enjoy these videos. I think you glean always one reassuring thing about the refereeing fraternity from them. But here's Dominic Sabosla himself lining up a free kick against Forest. Dominic, it's for my position to know. Are you having a bang? Are you having a shot?
20:50Charlie Eccleshare:Goal kick. I sort of both respect this, Dave, because it's thorough. Like, he wants to get his positioning right for the free kick. but I don't think you should have that inside information before it happens. You shouldn't know. You're having a bang. What does that do? I mean, there's so many ways that that could have gone, could go wrong for the ref though. With like, I mean, Sir Boz like under no obligation to respond. And why should I tell you, mate? Wait and see. Maybe it's going to be a cross come shot. I'm just going to try and fade one into that sort of area, that corridor of uncertainty.
21:24Do you remember that? Yeah. Spend one. Do you remember when David Seaman got down at Stamford Bridge in 2002 by a cross? I'm just going to do that, I think. Just put it in that area and see if anyone comes across it.
21:34Charlie Eccleshare:What is his position going to be if he says cross comes shot? Halfway, I guess. I don't know. Do you think he could have a bang, Dominic? That would really help me out here. Now that this information is public, surely you can then look at what his positioning was and then in the future you will know whether or not they're going to have a shot based on what the referee does. Exactly. It's not a level playing field anymore. this season is void. All thanks to Sam Barrett. Oh dear. Right, let's move on. Here's a lovely description of Brian Brobby's forward play on BBC Radio 5 Live. As there's a goal at Brentford, Charlie Slater.
22:09Charlie Eccleshare:And Sunderland are in front. Long ball forwards up towards Brian Brobby. What a handful. He massages defenders out of the way and it falls to Dan Ballard. Strike is finished from the big centre-half. Love this, Charlie, the idea of a player massaging defenders out of the way. It's almost like, I don't know, you want to squeeze past someone you like at a party, you sort of just give their shoulders a little squeeze. Yeah, you're like, all right, fella, just got to get past that, all right, mate. Yeah, I don't think of Brian Brobby as a massager of defenders. He's too, I don't know, he's too dominant for that.
22:39But it's not a thing at all, let alone for Brian Brobby. Yeah, no, it isn't. But if someone was to do that, I mean, like Kai Havertz, I think, would be the closest, because he doesn't look big or strong, but he does use his body to get past people. and I can sort of see him giving them a little squeeze as he just eases past.
22:57Charlie Eccleshare:Well, if we were to kind of rationalise this, Dave, it isn't maybe like the idea is that Brian Brobby isn't sort of banging against defenders. He isn't barging. He's not all elbows. He's just kind of sort of muscling his way gently, sort of keeping the contact consistent all the way through and then getting round them. So I suppose, you know, muscle against muscle, it is quite massage-y, I suppose. Yeah. If you're rolling a defender. We've seen Adama Traore cover himself, cover his arms in oil. for, haven't we? Maybe there's something in that. Also, massages do really hurt. It's a big sort of, you know, you think like, oh, massage, that'd be really nice.
23:31They're really painful, so maybe it is more accurate. Okay, fair enough.
23:35Charlie Eccleshare:Anyway, this episode of Football Clichés is brought to you in association with Saley, a new eSIM service app from the creators of NordVPN. Listeners, I will admit to a frisson of excitement when I land in a foreign country, my phone slowly finds a signal and the unfamiliar name of the local network operator finally appears at the top of my screen. But after that excitement, usually comes fear about the charges I'll rack up if I use my data abroad. But these days, I don't have that fear because I can download Saley. Before I leave the UK, I open up my Saley app, buy some data for my destination, so when I land, I'm connected to a safe and secure internet connection that doesn't cost the earth.
24:11Charlie Eccleshare:They offer different data packages depending on how long I'm going for, and they can be up to 10 times cheaper than roaming fees. Saley offers data plans for over 200 destinations along with 24-7 support, so they've got me covered. but it's not just saving me money salie enables me to switch my device's virtual location to access apps and content from back home to try it out for yourself you can download salie that's s-a-i-l-y in your app store and use our code cliches at checkout to get an exclusive 15 % off your first purchase full details are in our episode description or simply visit salie.com forward slash cliches we'll be back very shortly
24:54Before the season even kicks off, soccer fans are already making predictions. Who wins the league? Who qualifies for Europe? And who's lifting the trophy at season's end? On Calci, America's number one prediction market platform. You're trading against peers in a live market, meaning there's no house. And as the probability changes, you can buy in and out of your position. For a limited time, download the Calci app and use code CUP26 to get$10 when you trade 10. K-A-L-S-H-I. Calci. Trade the beautiful game. 18 plus only restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Event contract trading involves risk and may not be suitable for all investors.
25:27Prices, values, and available markets may differ from those mentioned. For more information, see calsheet.com slash regulatory. Imagine buying your kid a toy only to find the batteries aren't included or buying furniture but missing the tools to build it. Frustrating, right? Now imagine the exact same feeling but you're paying way more. That is what buying business software usually feels like. fragmented, disconnected, and incredibly expensive. Odoo completely changes that. Odoo is a complete, fully integrated business suite where all your apps actually talk to each other. We're talking automated lead routing for your sales team, seamless AI integration, and intuitive point-and-click website builder.
26:09It's everything your business needs to scale, saving you time, headaches, and money. Stop piecing your software together. Go to odoo.com. That's O-D-O-O dot com to learn more.
26:25Oh, look at that! That is wonderful!
26:32Charlie Eccleshare:Welcome back to Football Clichés. Into September we go, so we've got two more Dreamland episodes coming your way this month. For$5.99 a month, you'll get ad-free listening of all of our episodes, plus two episodes a month of Dreamland, our exclusive show. So access to the premium section of Happy Hunting Grounds, lots of other things as well. In a related note, we've got a very exciting announcement for you on this Thursday's pod. So if you like a live quiz, perhaps that may well interest you. More on Thursday. Martin Keown. Next. What a story this was. We were sent by rbarker82 on the Reddit.
27:09Charlie Eccleshare:He'd heard us talking in a Dreamland episode about Martin Keown on a train telling someone off eating nuts because someone nearby might be allergic. Well, this trumps that story by, well, quite a lot, Dave. He says, I have my own similar story about this. I was at the Phoenix Picture House in Oxford and Keown came in and sat in front of me. I had a bag of crunchy pretzels, which I wanted to eat before the film started as they were quite noisy. Keown turned around and said, are you eating nuts? I said, no, they're pretzels. Do they contain nuts? Because they smell like they might. Me, no. Right, okay.
27:39Charlie Eccleshare:Well, you shouldn't eat nuts in public places as some people are severely allergic. Yeah, I know, but I'm not.
27:47Charlie Eccleshare:Now, I want to make clear that none of us are making fun, making light of nut allergies, but the line, do they contain nuts because they smell like they might, I think actually might be too Keone, Charlie. I love the, yeah, I know, but I'm not. It's quite obnoxious, actually, in that response, but that's the only option you've got. I'm not eating nuts. What do you want me to say? I am aware of that. I mean, no one likes being lectured about something that actually it turns out they're not guilty of. I don't like the post sort of verdict lecture. Well, don't do it anyway. Yeah, I always hate that, but yeah.
28:21But it's also completely futile to, you know, Martin Keown's made his mind up. He thinks you're, as far as he's concerned, there are nuts in what you're eating and no amount of, like, we're going to flash him the ingredients or something. There's no point arguing with him at this point.
28:35Charlie Eccleshare:Because they smell like they might. Ridiculous, man. Surely there has to be a reason for Keown to be so hot on this. Maybe someone in his family has got a severe allergy or he knows of someone who died because of a nut contamination thing. I don't know. Well, don't take this the wrong way. But I kind of want either of those things to be true. I don't want him to have just taken on the cause himself. Like he thinks it's underreported or something. And he's sort of taking it on as his number one thing. That would be weird. I do hope that's the case. I think that would be very Keown to sort of just, yeah, get really interested in this topic and then become very, very serious about it and become a sort of vigilante for people eating nuts in public places.
29:20We'll find out when he's on BBC Breakfast to champion the cause. Yeah. Lower down in the Reddit thread, actually, a very important question was asked by Mark Ams Scientist. What film was he there to watch? Like, what did he go to see? and the original poster couldn't quite remember, but checked his booking history to see. And he reckons it was either The Salt Path, 28 Years Later, or The Ballad of Wallace Island. What of The Salt Path? Maybe the most Keown of those?
29:51Charlie Eccleshare:28 Years Later perhaps has the Keown intensity that we're looking for. But yeah. But he also attended Titanic the musical. So we don't know. We don't know what Martin Keown's cultural taste has actually evolved. On to another Arsenal legend, Paul Merson. A couple of Paul Merson-isms for you. This first one came from Charles Jones. This was among Paul Merson's Premier League predictions for this season. Most assists. I'm going to go Cole Palmer. He'll be out to prove people wrong. He's had a summer. You've got to remember, them players who didn't go are going to be so fresh come what Christmas.
30:23And you can have a point to be out of their plan once a week.
30:26Charlie Eccleshare:Have we had a come what Christmas before, Charlie? I can't remember. I don't think so. I don't think so. Come what Christmas. I like come what Christmas. I mean, the alliteration helps it. But yeah, it's got a real bounce to it, come what Christmas. Should be a film on one of the Hallmark channels. Come what Christmas. Starring Merce and himself. Yeah, maybe. A little cameo role. Next up, this came from our man, Jake Farrell, who I think qualifies for an our man these days. Here's Merce on Soccer Saturday, giving his verdict on Chelsea's summer sales. This window, I can imagine they must have been sitting in a room every day of the week for the last two, three months trying to get these deals done.
31:05But yeah, I think they've done absolutely amazing. But it's about£67 million in profit. Yeah, the sporting directors have done, honestly, have done amazing. I think they've pulled up trees.
31:15Charlie Eccleshare:I don't want to live in a world, Dave, where sporting directors should be known as pulling up trees, even if it were, you know, allowable in the affirmative. Well, yeah, I think maybe one of the only times you've ever heard it in the affirmative. Incredible from Merson. I mean, this does threaten the sort of hypothetical threshold for tree pulling up Charlie, making a£67 million profit for Chelsea in the current climate? They've really pulled up trees. Yeah, fair play. They've been tearing it up in the boardroom. However many directors they've got up there. Absolute madness. On that point, the emphasis that he put on, they've been sitting in a room somewhere.
31:54I thought he was going to slag them off at that point. But you just hear that so often, don't you? I heard Alan Shearer was having one of his VAR rants the other day, and he's talking about, imagine all the referees sitting together in a room. People have got to sit somewhere.
32:10Charlie Eccleshare:Yeah, why is that so deriving? What's wrong with sitting in rooms? It's often a kind of a windowless room. Yeah. I think it's because of... Your mum's basement. Yeah, a room is seen as it's like you're away from the action. You're sort of hidden away. It's all a bit clinical and corporate. You're not getting your hands dirty. Yeah, it's not on pitch, perhaps. You're just over there. Yeah. It's definitely not pitch. It's the business side. It's not with the real people. Yeah, and that's not a bad show, actually. Yeah, I think you've nailed it. Over to the EFL now. And someone somewhere in charge of the EFL audio has really, really improved things.
32:47Charlie Eccleshare:What a trio of EFL audio nuggets for you next. First one comes from Sam Parrish. Here's Jay Stansfield's belting finish against Wolves.
33:04Charlie Eccleshare:the hat trick dave of boot net and then the stanchion at the bottom coming up at the bottom that what a lovely little trio very nice very satisfying yeah seeing a lot of this charlie in the last few years with sort of commentary lists highlights reels where it the implication is you'll have you'll have absorbed the commentary either live or in the highlights now we just get to enjoy the football in its rawest sense you only seem to get that on a Monday I think it's a very Monday thing just let it breathe yeah have you seen that fella on on TikTok and Instagram who's trying to capture like the purest sound of the ball hitting the crossbar with like really um fancy microphones I have but I've missed quite a lot of the middle of it so I feel like I've I don't need to go back and watch loads of episodes of a box set it's annoying but I mean, he's on a training ground.
33:55Charlie Eccleshare:He's on a proper club's training ground now. He started off at a local park. Yeah. Someone somewhere should do a podcast on the explosion of kind of incremental social media content. There was a thing during the heatwave of someone watering a small circle of grass on their lawn every day to see how it changed. It's amazing the avenues that people go down. And I thought we were niche. Joel Shooter writes in next. He says, here's a great instance of a mocking olay turning into a go-on for Gillingham's fourth against Rochdale on Saturday.
34:38Charlie Eccleshare:I guess the Gillingham fans, Dave, just weren't prepared for James Brophy to go on that solo run. I mean, they went early with this generation of the Ole and they just kept on going. And then it turned superbly into go on. That's the problem when they were doing the Olays there, but Gillingham weren't really popping it around in the Olay sort of fashion. That guy was quite a long run from deep in the half. But yeah, they styled it out pretty nicely at the end. Charlie, you always hear about players talking about how they shut out the noise and that sort of stuff. I didn't really notice it, to be honest.
35:10Charlie Eccleshare:How aware do you think James Brophy was during his solo run that the travelling Gillingham fans were right at the top? like the upperest octave that they could manage before he shot. Like he's, I'm going to have to get my shot away here. Oh, they're in real trouble. Yeah, he's doing it perfectly in sync with them. Oh, please don't mess this up. Finally, this came from Hugh Davis. He says, does this goal for Portsmouth against Cardiff have the fastest commentary you've ever heard? I make it 38 words in seven seconds. So about five and a half words per second. Eminem holds the Guinness World Record for the fastest rap at 7.5 words per second.
35:47Charlie Eccleshare:And he didn't have to say Milovanovich twice. Dailik up against Milovanovich. Now Pompey have it and can break forward. And Kamal with a nice ball for second. And Milovanovich is free in the middle. He can be found and he's found and he's gone. Kuno to Portsmouth. Wow. That's extraordinary. I mean, as a man who trips over his words so often on this podcast, I'm doubly impressed, Dave. But yeah, we should make for extra context. This is BBC Radio Solent's Andrew Moon. So he's a radio commentator. He's already well-equipped to impart information in the sport in a short space of time. Yeah, but look, there's many commentators who would still fall foul of trying to get all those words in and keep your dexterity and the diction without rolling words into one another or mispronouncing stuff.
36:34That's superb.
36:35Charlie Eccleshare:He must have felt amazing, Charlie, when he had the release of the goal being scored and then could return to the goal-scoring cadence and not the play-by-play aspect of it. Tremendous delivery. I'm in awe. Amazing. And think about the people listening to this podcast on double speed. What that must have been like for them just now. I mean, mind's blown. Yeah. Fair play to Barry O'Driscoll from Dublin, who told me in incredible detail all the different speeds he listens to podcasts at. And we're a 1.2, apparently. which was that as slow as he goes it would seem so it would seem so because he wants to enjoy cliches so he goes for a 1.2 other podcasts he just wants to absorb the information so he just does it really get it in yeah i think it's really dangerous because i i went through a little brief spell where i was listening to a few things on 1.5 and you can get really used to it and then when you see something that's normal speed it feels really slow and it just ruins your attention span And even more than it already is.
37:32Charlie Eccleshare:And you think you've turned it down to like 0.8 by mistake. Yeah. That's the transition that's so hard to deal with. No, completely. And then you're asking yourself like, why am I doing, you know, this is meant to be like a pleasurable thing. I'll do the quick ones. If I need to listen to something for work or something, I'll sometimes go to 1.5. But you're right, it does then feel achingly slow when you go back. I've heard of some people who watch like Netflix series on 1.2 or 1.3. Wow. What are you doing? That's crazy. You don't have to finish it. It's not stat padding. I don't know. Footballers' names in things next.
38:04Charlie Eccleshare:Three for you. First one comes from Harry Gorst. It's former footballers' names in BBC history podcasts. Specifically, this is the invention of Spain. Now, Ferdinand, the survivor of the dynastic marriage which had temporarily brought Spain together, suddenly saw the entire legacy falling into the Habsburg family. So the embittered and angry Ferdinand frantically married little Germain de Foix, a blameless top. who had to endure his... Jermaine Defoy sounds like the way I would pronounce it if I'd never seen it before. It is, yeah, it's got that. What a finisher she was on a day. One of the best.
38:44Right to the very top.
38:47Charlie Eccleshare:Okay, this one came from Caelan Gohan. It's the Gary Neville sound in things. And this is from all the way back from 2005. It's Oh My God by the Kaiser Chiefs. I'd never thought about this before, but you'll never forget it.
39:15Charlie Eccleshare:I tried desperately in the lead up to this recording, Dave, to find which Gary Neville sound it sounded most like. But that is definitely there. But what specific scenario would Neville make that very excitable sound? That's quite it. And then I think that's sort of more early era, Neville, sort of around the goalgasm. Yes. You know, the Fernando Torres in the Champions League thing. But just, I think it's a goal. It's a spectacular goal in a big moment. It's not like a challenge or a red card or anything. No, exactly. It's a long range. Maybe someone just coming onto a, like, what's like the goal of the week, that Maitland-Niles goal of the weekend, where it's just like, what the fuck has happened there?
39:52Absolutely right. Instinctive.
39:54Charlie Eccleshare:Yeah, I'm glad you said that, because I was about to suggest it was like a ball rolling under a goalkeeper's foot, but I don't think it would get the same trajectory from him. Yeah, exactly. It needs to be something really emphatic and impressive at the same time, not calamitous. So I'm glad you said that. Yeah, so yeah. Wow. It's been sitting there in plain sight for 21 years, but there it is. The Gary Neville sound in Oh My God by the Kaiser Chiefs. Finally, listen carefully for this one because it is very good. It came from Ilan. It says, This one stopped me in my tracks. It's a current Arsenal player in a random Bob Marley track.
40:22Charlie Eccleshare:So much things to say.
40:40Charlie Eccleshare:he's definitely a what a find what a find yeah that's good i imagine it probably did stop him in his tracks charlie that's the sort of thing where you go i mean i'm not saying you know you know from from arrogance perspective that he the first thought was send it to the cliches pod but I reckon that would stop you in your tracks wouldn't it yeah before Eze became part of the Arsenal seek frontline of course yeah yeah thanks Gary Cottrell um finally this came from the great Collins mate Ryan he says I just got the tube home and as you walk down the stairs to the platform at Clapham Common there's a northern line sign above and a bloke just reached up and touched it like he was at Anfield I respect it um what would what would compel you to do that at a tube station Dave it feels like quite a Sunday night thing to do.
41:27Charlie Eccleshare:It's like you're wrapping up your weekend and that's it. Back to business. Well, if there was ever going to be a tube station where I would do that, I think Clapham Common would be it, given it's the home of the Rovers. So yeah, maybe he's a one-time Ribblesdale player from the extended squad. Do you think Northern Line as well merits that? Is that the most, sort of, this is Anne? For me, I would go Victoria Line if I was going to do a line. Not just because it serves me but it is objectively the best line it is the one i most respect wembley wembley park but charlie i'm less interested in in what would make particular tube sign touchable in the anfield sense more just the sort of footballing behavior and i feel like that taps into your mentality a bit i feel like i feel like you could do that like it's something in your armory to sort of touch a sign because it just feels like a football-y thing to do yeah it's what i think it's where it's almost like an unconscious thing when it's like a part of your brain kicks it you're like i've seen this done so many times i'm just going to do it out of habit almost or just like monkey see monkey do someone must have a live laugh love sign above their french doors as they go to the kitchen or something like that no i tap it as they go in just subscribe to that mentality one more time um yep there you go that was the football cliches podcast uh thanks to you charlie eckleshire thank you thanks to you david walker thank you thanks again to everyone who came to the live show on saturday hope you enjoyed it thanks to everyone for listening and we'll see you on thursday cheers
From the publisher
Adam Hurrey is joined on the Adjudication Panel by Charlie Eccleshare and David Walker. On the agenda: reflections on a superb afternoon at the Cliches live show, Tom Cruise deploys the football plural, Gary Cotterill plumbs new press-conference depths, Manchester United are Arsenal 2008/09 in disguise, the fallout from Mike Dean's embellished anecdote, slightly-too-casual VAR announcements, the Gary Neville noise in a Kaiser Chiefs song, and much more.
Play the Happy Hunting Grounds daily quiz at games.footballcliches.com
Sign up for Dreamland, the members-only Football Clichés experience, to access our exclusive show and much more: https://dreamland.footballcliches.com
Download SAILY in your app store and use code CLICHES at checkout to get an exclusive 15% off your first purchase! For more info, visit https://saily.com/cliches
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
