In short
Football Clichés episode 14 (final 2025) is a comedic, football-obsessed “adjudication panel” built from listener correspondence and media clips.
Guests
Adam Hurry (host) and Charlie Eccleshare and David Walker (panelists). They discuss: Dominic Calvert-Lewin scoring for a sixth straight game and whether that puts him “in the England conversation” for a World Cup-year squad; Match of the Day’s unusual double-goalkeeper pundit setup (Joe Hart and Shay Given) and whether it signals a broader punditry shift; and a Reddit rules debate on whether Iago Aspas’s Copa del Rey penalty was “skyed” (trajectory must keep rising). Notable examples/claims: “clown in a Slough bunker” VAR jab; “head your granny” tackle joke; “Dreamland” as a toned-down “Dreamland” studio segment; and a critique of NWSL’s proposed “high-impact player” salary-cap exemptions using Ballon d’Or/Guardian/ESPN rankings.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VORecap of the Football Clichés Christmas Quiz
2:26 to 3:56
The hosts discuss their recent Christmas quiz event, its success, and some minor challenges.
“Hello everyone and welcome to Football Clichés.”
Kids' Football and Nostalgia
3:56 to 6:38
A discussion about various forms of children's football, including personal anecdotes from the hosts.
“It's not like it's my day job to fact check things or anything like that.”
Dominic Calvert-Lewin's Scoring Streak
6:38 to 8:16
The conversation shifts to Dominic Calvert-Lewin's performance and his potential inclusion in the England squad.
“There's a hint of weariness in you-know-who.”
Goalkeeping Punditry on Match of the Day
8:16 to 10:38
The hosts analyze the unusual occurrence of having two goalkeepers as pundits on Match of the Day.
“Because it could all be over by the time we get to March.”
Shea Given's Comments on Tackling
10:38 to 13:08
A humorous take on Shea Given's comments about defenders and the concept of tackling in football.
“Was this just a quirk of the scheduling?”
Commentary Observations and Football Terms
13:08 to 14:01
Discussion on commentary language and interesting phrases used in football broadcast.
“Tackling your granny and heading away an absurd object X.”
Gary Weaver's Commentary Style
14:01 to 21:21
Exploration of Gary Weaver's commentary quirks and moments.
“Is this an autocue situation, Dave, or do some people just want to call it Dreamland?”
Haunting Former Clubs in Football
21:21 to 21:41
Discussion on whether players can haunt former clubs they didn't play for.
“reports, analyzing data, Microsoft 365 Copilot is your AI assistant for work.”
Penalty Skied or Spoon
22:30 to 24:11
Debate on the terminology surrounding missed penalties in football.
“New spring arrivals are at Nordstrom Rack stores now.”
Nigel Clough's Honorary Doctorate
24:11 to 28:01
Discussion about Nigel Clough receiving an honorary doctorate and its implications.
“Or at least have that, give that impression.”
Show all 15 chapters
Bournemouth Cherry Controversy
28:01 to 28:58
The hosts discuss the naming of Bournemouth and its implications.
“And we've actually been doing really, really well the last few seasons.”
High-Impact Player Rule in NWSL
28:59 to 32:42
An analysis of the new salary cap rule in the NWSL and its controversial criteria.
“Let's stay in America, actually, over to the National Women's Soccer League.”
Debate on Scoring Definitions
32:43 to 33:41
A lively debate on whether a 2-1 scoreline is considered high or low scoring.
“Next up, bread and butter, a little debate for us.”
Dentist and Football Analogies
33:42 to 35:38
The hosts explore an amusing listener's story about dentists and football knowledge.
“Yeah, she knows the history of it or she knows the area.”
Keys and Gray Corner: Year-End Highlights
35:39 to 37:58
Discussion on a memorable send-off for Claire Tomlinson and classic Richard Keys moments.
“I don't know why they're going to different dentists anyway, to be honest.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Nothing brings people together quite like Team USA at the Olympic Winter Games. From NBCUniversal's iconic storytelling to the innovative technology across Xfinity and Peacock, Comcast brings the Olympic Games home to America, sharing every moment with millions. When Team USA steps onto the world stage, people aren't just watching, they're cheering together. This winter, everyone is all on the same team. Comcast, proud partner of Team USA. Protein is now at Starbucks, and it's never tasted so good. You can add protein cold foam to your favorite drink or try one of our new protein lattes or matcha.
0:40Try it today at Starbucks.
0:45This episode is brought to you by White Claw Surge. Great podcast pick, friend. No surprises there. After all, you're all about finding the tastiest flavors out there, just like White Claw Surge. And with big, bold flavors to enjoy, like blood orange, blackberry, cranberry, and more, It's time to go all in on taste. Unleash the flavor. Unleash White Claw Surge. Please drink responsibly. Hard seltzer with flavors. 8 % alcohol by volume. White Claw Seltzer Works. Chicago, Illinois. I'm sorry. You can sit there and look and play with all your silly machines as much as you like. Is Gascoigne going to have a crack?
1:19He is, you know. Oh, I see! Brilliant! The cheese! He's ran the goalkeeper. He's done it! Absolutely incredible. He launched himself six feet into the crowd and Kung Fu kicked a supporter who was without a shadow of a doubt giving him lip. Oh, I say, it's amazing. He does it time and time and time again. Break up the music. Charge a glass. This nation is going to dance all night.
1:55Charlie Eccleshare:The free-scoring Dominic Calvert-Lewin passes a very particular threshold. Ofcom yet to investigate match of the day having two goalkeepers on together as pundits. Shea Given ups the ante with a proverbial footballing granny. Hip-hop with Gary Weaver. Joe Cole turns into Harry Redknapp in front of your very ears. Lucas Paquetar's anglophone equivalent. Professional leagues basing their salary cap on where journalists rank their players in end-of-season lists. And a tree with the voice of Richard Keyes. Brought to your ears by Goalhanger Podcasts. This is Football Clichés.
2:31Charlie Eccleshare:Hello everyone and welcome to Football Clichés. I'm Adam Hurry and with me for the final episode of 2025 is Charlie Eccleshare. How are you doing? Very well, thank you. And David Walker. How are things? Things are good. Charlie, this is an awkwardly placed post-best-of adjudication panel for the final episode of 2025. So it can't be too good. It will undermine the whole concept of the best-of. Yeah, that's true. And it wouldn't be eligible for 2026, would it? It wouldn't kind of sneak in on a technicality. Yeah. So don't come up with any kind of all-timer lines tonight because it's just not going to work.
3:04Charlie Eccleshare:I'll reign it in. I had some really good stuff planned as well, but I'll save it. It's like any music you listen to in December on Spotify doesn't count for your wrapped. Yeah, you pick up some good tunes in December as well. Yeah, but listen to some good stuff this month. Yeah, get a lot of time on your hands. So yeah, you can really flow. So this episode is being recorded, Dave, mere hours after the Football Clichés Christmas quiz. What a night. The concept has been proved, right? It's happening. It's definitely a thing now. Yeah, it was great. Really good fun. Great to see so many people keen to get involved and raise a decent amount of money for shelter in the end.
3:41And, you know, it wouldn't be Football Clichés quiz slash event if something didn't go slightly wrong. There were a couple of little wrinkles in the last round. We managed to iron them out pretty swiftly. So I think everyone went home happy.
3:56Charlie Eccleshare:It's not like it's my day job to fact check things or anything like that. So incredible. Most of the questions were watertight. 700 odd teams as well. I can't believe it. A great night. Everyone seemed to enjoy it. And well done to Jackie Milburn Psychiatrists for running away with it. Not really run away with it at all, actually. They won by a single point to claim the big prize. So yeah, sensational stuff. Look forward to doing it again another time. writes the final adjudication panel of 2025 begins with this um returning to the theme of recent chat an incredible amount of correspondence we had about this dave on cubs football and the main takeaway from that discussion was just how many forms of football should kids ever be involved in and it felt like cubs football was extraneous basically rich temple writes in and says i was fascinated by dave mentioning that he played cubs football i never did but i did play for my village paper shop when i was at secondary school there was an annual five-a-side tournament consisting of teams from paper boys.
4:50Charlie Eccleshare:I can't remember any girls playing. There must have been. In the Chesterfield area held at a local leisure centre. It took place on a Sunday afternoon. I remember we once got to the final and lost in extra time. Games were typically of about 10 to 15 minutes duration. It just goes to show, you know, if kids gather in any meaningful way, you can make a football league out of it. Yeah, wow. Paper. Paper boys football. I mean, presumably all of them had good engines, Charlie. That's just a pretty dynamic sort of competition, you'd imagine. Yeah, good cardio. Yeah. This reminds me, did either of you play the Paperboy game on the Game Boy?
5:22Yeah. I had it on Amstrad. Right, yeah. I mean, that seems just so mad that that was a thing, but yeah, I just play that a lot. No one talks about the demise of the paper round, do they? In all the hand-wringing about the death of print, no one ever thinks about the paper round. That crucial route into the Labour force is gone for a generation.
5:41Charlie Eccleshare:It lives on in that kind of tough paper round thing, which is always chucked around willy-nilly, I think. It's very tenuous sometimes, but it's been replaced by the sort of low-key, slightly down-at-heel bloke who puts leaflets through doors, which doesn't have the glamour of Paperboy. Yeah, they're kind of resented, aren't they? Whereas Paperboy was performing a valuable community service. Yeah, leave them a Christmas tip and everything. Yeah, shame. But, you know, we'll find a role for them somewhere. Right, Dominic Calvert-Lewin, Charlie, has scored for a sixth game in a row over Christmas, which officially triggers this.
6:18And who else picked Dominic Calvert-Lewin for Leeds? Firmly in who else territory now, right? Yeah, yeah, it had to be him. I remember, I think the peak Andy Johnson got, it's you know who, which I think is even more, you know, if he scores in his next game. Because you've got to go somewhere, if you've done this already, what's the next stage? and yeah, that was one for AJ.
6:40Charlie Eccleshare:There's a hint of weariness in you-know-who. It's him again, for fuck's sake. Yeah, presumably after he'd scored another penalty for Palace that season, which he probably dived for. Yeah. On this theme, this came from Fraser Thomas, who was watching the World Feed commentary of Sunderland versus Leeds. Here's Paul Robinson on co-coms, addressing the Calvert-Lewin England situation. Of course, we're heading into a World Cup year, so the conversation will continue, whether or not summer's super season there's the back up to Harry Kane how do you view that situation Paul Robinson would you take Dominic Carver to the World Cup not at the moment he keeps scoring goals like he is he's got to put himself in that conversation as we've already just started a conversation about it now he keeps doing that he's going to be in the conversation he's going to be on people's lips in the next few weeks incredible over addressing of the concept of a conversation Dave wow yeah so has the conversation started or not Paul he's in a conversation my favourite bit Charlie by a mile was him just realising he's suddenly actually in a conversation about it which is really good he's an odd bloke isn't he actually Paul Robinson I have interviewed him before he is intense that distinction with the conversation and a conversation is a really good one and I thought he was going to go off in the direction we'd gone in on the how many games consecutively he sort of semi-addresses that he's like well if he keeps scoring at this rate he will be in He does hit on something in that there is a sort of, there's a desire for there to be a clamour around someone.
8:13And he's the most obvious guy at the moment. But because we are just so far away from the next international break and then the World Cup, it's like too early for a proper clamour to start, really. Because it could all be over by the time we get to March. He could have completely dropped off or injured or whatever. So, you know, it's not quite right yet, is it? But there's no point clamouring at this point because there isn't a squad for a few months. So it's kind of like a waste of breath. Like I don't want to shout and lose my voice for March, you know, it's kind of pointless. I mean, obviously like the conversation he realised, you know, is a kind of big, vast concept.
8:46But what is the closest conversation to the conversation? like i feel like i think maybe the news is so spread so thinly nowadays you wouldn't really get it but like what would that be would that be like on stick to football when you know neville keen and the others are fully going at it does that become the conversation is that the kind of moment that you know you've made it into the conversation that's a good point like yeah what
9:09Charlie Eccleshare:represents the conversation i mean to me dave it's into 606 like that's the national conversation It doesn't necessarily need to be agenda-setting people doing the conversation. It should be the general public, I would say. Not a Leeds fan as well. It needs to be someone who isn't a Leeds fan proposing him to be on the plane. I mean, look, we did a pod last week on the England pod where we picked our squad as it stands now, if the World Cup was now, and I've got him in there. So I've started the conversation. This is like a newspaper backing a candidate for privacy, isn't it? We're getting behind him officially.
9:43It was Dave Walker what won it.
9:46Charlie Eccleshare:we set the agenda here we did pose the question about how many how many consecutive goals it would take for calvin to be in the england conversation and he's living it out so this is great i get if he's if he's being talked about on match the day you're you're in the conversation then aren't you yeah that's pretty big time that's like i played a radio one or something yeah yeah that that is the conversation still even now sticking with match of the day let's go back to december the 20th and kelly cates introducing her studio guests good evening There are eight Premier League games to show you tonight and we'll find out who will occupy the number one spot at Christmas.
10:18Speaking of number ones, we're in safe hands tonight.
10:21Charlie Eccleshare:If they say a pundit is for life, not just for Christmas, well, we've got two keepers. Joe Hart and Shea Given are here. Yep, solid, solid punning for your double goalkeeper punditry team. But Ryan Leach writes in, Dave, says not having two goalkeepers and no outfield player doing punditry on match of the day. Only one keeper max allowed, surely. Are we seeing a tide turning? Was this just a quirk of the scheduling? Or was this deliberate? You can't have two keepers on, surely. It is weird. It's definitely not something you see often. I mean, I guess they're both just part of the team, aren't they?
10:53Maybe it's just the way that the rotation has fallen, the availability. I don't think it would be a purposeful thing. It's not goalkeeping special, is it?
11:01Charlie Eccleshare:They looked at the fixture list and thought, this looks really goalkeeping. It is a bit weird. Like I can imagine, you know, people being a bit like, you know, you want your analysis. Who's going to do the analysis of, you know, any sort of outfieldy stuff? Yeah, can't trust them. Yeah, it is so specialised. I mean, but then I was thinking like, you know, if it was a goalkeeper and a former defender, I guess you still have that absence. You know, if you're trying to analyse a forwards clever runs or something. But then I guess you've got the, yeah, as a defender, that's a nightmare kind of thing.
11:30And you can't do that as a goalkeeper. Like, oh yeah, those channel runs, you hate seeing that from your vantage point on your goal line. Well, I guess Kelly can chip in on behalf of her dad in terms of forward movement. She's the closest to it.
11:42Charlie Eccleshare:God. Maybe it's more of a subtle kind of issue than I realised, because the Telegraph didn't pick up on it as like, this is like the death of BBC Sport or something like that. Who would have been turning in their grave? Yeah, exactly. Loro turning in his grave. Jimmy Hill. On Shea Given, by the way, this came from David Russell. Here's Shea Given talking about Sunderland defender Dan Ballard. And I love Dan Ballard. He's absolutely brilliant in there. He goes and tacks over and he'd head your granny. He really would. He's absolutely brilliant in that position. This is a variation, Dave, on the classic of, you know, he'd tackle his own granny, which is seen to be the kind of hypothetical extreme of a player wanting to win the ball as much as possible.
12:27Charlie Eccleshare:But I've never heard it sort of used for somebody else's granny. is that worse if you headbutted somebody else's granny is that worse than headbutting your own it is worse it's worse than tackling as well because you know you could tackle the granny cleanly you could just get you know get the ball and she's unharmed but if you're heading her she's definitely she's going to be in pain game stops immediately the ref summons on the physio it's a head injury concussion sub for the granny just get another granny on yeah get the other from the other side of the family on nan comes on and that granny can't can't grandparent for seven days, according to the rules.
13:05Charlie Eccleshare:Charlie, this is actually a melding together of two kind of extreme hypotheticals. Tackling your granny and heading away an absurd object X. And I can't work out what the thing should be. He would head anything away. He'd head away a bus. He'd head a brick wall. Someone's thrown granny into the mixer. That's a flying granny. speculative looping granny can't keep saying granny I don't think there is a hypothetical object to be headed away no I can't think what it is but not a definitive one yeah but anyway yeah but yeah very extreme stuff from Shea Given let's move on this came from Jim Scarlett here is Sky Sports News reporting on Hearts vs Rangers and Hearts fans were in dreamland moments later Lauren Shanklin firing his shot has Jack Holland and your host.
14:01Charlie Eccleshare:Lovely to see a Dreamland, Charlie. It was always going to happen. Is this an autocue situation, Dave, or do some people just want to call it Dreamland? They want to sort of tone it down a bit. Yeah, I don't think it's an autocue thing. It'd be great if it was a Ron Burgundy-esque situation. But maybe it's just a North of the Border thing. Maybe any subscribers from Scotland, we can rebrand it as Dreamland for them. Dreamland, yeah. It really does tone it down. It doesn't quite have the same go at us at all. speaking of gravitas here's gary weaver on commentary duty for swansea versus wrexham now swansea of course are some shares in swansea are owned by snoop dog let's remember that he's got underneath it he's having to race back now and race back he does and he's dropped it and he is punished and amida is there to possibly win this game for swansea city Arthur Okonkwo dropped it like it was hot
15:03Swansea strike again and this Welsh City by the sea rises up to rejoice
15:11Charlie Eccleshare:Two things here Charlie One, clearly getting out of line he couldn't wait to get out had it ready for whenever the opportunity presented itself and then after he'd done it straight back into classic Weaver the same tone and everything amazing didn't break stride. On the subject of who else but, I mean, when Swansea versus Wrexham, you know, when that, you know, there's no issue there with the rotor. You know, straight away, you're not getting two goalkeepers in for that one. That is Gary Weaver all over. Yeah, it just lacked some sort of medieval structure to be involved here, Dave. Other than that, Gary Weaver very much on form.
15:45Absolutely. I mean, basically the only possible scenario for that line to be used, a goalkeeper in a goalkeeping era. So he must have been waiting for that scenario to happen all season. Yeah.
15:56Charlie Eccleshare:It was one of those ludicrous goalkeeper handling errors I've seen for a while. It was like proper Danny Baker video stuff as well. I wonder if he'll go to the well anymore this season if he gets Swansea. Go through the back catalogue of Snoop Dogg and see what you can do, Gary. Oh, God, I'm not encouraging it whatsoever. They'll be sipping on gin and juice tonight. I'm glad you had one. I'm glad you had one ready. That's all. Weaver's having a sort of villary kind of season, Charlie. He started off quietly, wasn't really on our radar, and now he's smack bang in the middle of the conversation.
16:24Yeah, over-performing on many metrics.
16:29Charlie Eccleshare:But he won't win commentator of the year. He's never going to win it. Of course he won't. No, he won't. This next one came from Bill Sims, Dave. It's from the BBC Match Report of Chelsea's 2-2 draw at Newcastle. It says, Chelsea forward Jao Pedro haunted former suitors Newcastle United as his side showed their powers of recovery. Can you haunt a former suitor, Dave? That's a weak commenting, isn't it? Who are you again? Sorry. Yeah, former suitor. like how advanced was the suiting at the time do i know you are you something for my past like oh what i mean given yeah he probably won't have well it depends how advanced he's talked got i don't imagine you know he was sort of if he'd got if he'd got as far because some transfers they have got to the training ground and that sort of thing sure so that might add it you know some credibility as a haunting i just i don't think that would even get close to a haunting you can't You can't haunt a club that you've never played for, I don't think.
17:23Charlie Eccleshare:No. And if it was just a link, if it was just reports or for Rixier Romano tweeting it out, whatever it might be. Yeah, you're right, Charlie. There has to be some level of properly advanced talks, concrete talks have to have taken place, I reckon. It had to be concrete at the very least. Could Willian have haunted Spurs, you know, having basically been their player, done a medical and all that sort of stuff? Yeah, I see because that was very close, wasn't it? So I do sort of see it, but no, you can't go back and haunt something. And I still think that would be more like Rob's salt in the wounds kind of thing.
17:57Like Ezra earlier this season. That wasn't a haunting. Yeah, I see what you mean.
18:01Charlie Eccleshare:Yeah, a narrative twist, but not a haunting. And it was a case of here's what you could have won. Yeah. The ghost of Christmas could have been. Or might have been for Scrooge. Right. This came from Ned Bolting, of all people, former MHD star. here is Joe Cole on 5 Live just before Christmas slowly gradually gently morphing into Harry Redknapp
18:27do you remember it? I don't but it does sound like something I might have said yeah yeah it was you see that should that should be in the book Coley that should be in the book yeah yeah I'm pretty sure probably we're in a relegation scrap and Joey's off to Barca Coley talk talk to me about Chelsea because you were You signed on the same day as Seba Varon, if memory serves me correctly. Is there not a tale about an argument over the number 10 in your dad? Yeah, yeah. I mean, we spoke to Claudio.
19:02Charlie Eccleshare:It took a while. One step forward, two steps back, and then finally went full head-napped at the end there. That is incredible. That is such a great spot. Wow. I'm chuffed that Ned Bolting is on the lookout for this stuff for us more than anything, Dave, actually, to be honest. It's great. You're right. Just that last little... Yeah, yeah. Just perfect, Harry. I guess, yeah. If you stay at West Ham long enough, that's what happens. Right. Speaking of West Ham, saw a tweet from a very angry West Ham content producer. West Ham today, woeful. Merry Christmas. Relegation form. Bowen, not at it. Somerville, a shadow of the player.
19:42Charlie Eccleshare:is signed from Leeds. Tadibo and Magasa, solid. That's about it. Paquetta, all tricks, no output, tantrums included. If he was English and called Luke Packett, he'd be fighting for championship minutes. Now, traditionally, Dave, we would laugh at this and go, that's ridiculous, but that's such a good championship footballer's name. Luke Packett. That's Gary Weaver Friday night, Sheffield Wednesday versus, I don't know. Luke Packett. Where's Luke Packett? What does he look like? What positions is he playing? Former England under 21, by 100 % Luke Packett Luke Packett it's almost a good darts name but actually when you think about it what's the nickname what would you actually have in the middle I think that would be the nickname Luke the Packet Luke the Packet Packet whatever his actual surname is yeah come on let's do better than that can't you Luke the real McCoy Packett yeah nice Packet Christmas I mean Luke Packett it definitely has the kind of shave sides and sort of you know side parting great blonde sleeve tattoos yeah yeah exactly um sort of dresses like a number 10s or styles himself like a number 10 charlie but isn't a number 10 he's basically just a functional eight at best yeah or could even be a fall but like an attacking fallback yeah matty cash kind of yeah exactly exactly look packet i mean whisper it quietly but they could do worse than luke packet i think he could do a job i think there'll be a number of premier league clubs sniffing around.
Read the full transcript
21:06Yeah, exactly.
21:07Charlie Eccleshare:He's in the BBC gossip page every week. Luke Packett 23. I really enjoyed that. It's good. It's good. It's good to have an example of this that actually does work. So in a roundabout way, Jamie Boyce, you came up with it superbly. So well done. Right. That takes care of part one. We'll be back very shortly.
21:36reports, analyzing data, Microsoft 365 Copilot is your AI assistant for work. Built into Word, Excel, PowerPoint, and other Microsoft 365 apps you use. Helping you quickly write, analyze, create, and summarize. So you can cut through clutter and clear a path to your best work. Learn more at Microsoft.com slash m365copilot. Start your day with Quaker Protein Instant Oatmeal. The instant oatmeal ready to help you tackle whatever your day brings. Like wrinkling your toddler into their car seat. That was fun. Coaching your sixth grader's soccer team. Go girls! And carrying all the groceries in one trip.
22:20Try Quaker Protein Instant Oatmeal, Granola, and Bars. Great taste and a good source of protein. Quaker. Bring out the good. So good, so good, so good. New spring arrivals are at Nordstrom Rack stores now. Get ready to save big with up to 60 % off Rag & Bone, Mark Jacobs, Free People, and more.
22:42Charlie Eccleshare:How did I not know Rack has Adidas? Because there's always something new. Join the Nordiclub to unlock exclusive discounts, shop new arrivals first, and more. Plus, buy online and pick up at your favorite Rack store for free. Great brands, great prices. That's why you Rack.
23:08Charlie Eccleshare:Welcome back to Football Clichés. Dreamland episode 14 will be out just before 2025 draws to a close. And it's the first edition of our Voices of Football series. We're kicking off with our comprehensive appraisals of Martin Tyler, Glenn Hoddle and Martin Keown. Three great choices, I think. and we really enjoyed delving into the psyches, at least, of those three. So if you're interested in that or anything else, sign up at dreamland.footballcliches.com. For just£5.99 a month, you'll get ad-free listening of all of our episodes, plus two episodes a month of Dreamland, our exclusive show, and other bits as well.
23:43Charlie Eccleshare:Right, part two of the adjudication panel from Reddit for the website was watching Iago Aspas skying a penalty as Albacete knocked Celta Vigo at the Copa del Rey. And quite simply, Charlie, they asked, Is a penalty skied if you can see it dip before it leaves the screen? Which I think is a fascinating poser. It's got to have an endlessly upward trajectory as far as the TV screen is involved. Yeah, is it maximum height or just continued trajectory? Yeah, I think it probably does need to keep going upwards as far as you can see it. Or at least have that, give that impression. Helpfully eliminates the potential for anyone to post a meme, you know, of Iago Aspas's penalty on the moon.
24:25or anything, if it's not still rising, it can't have got there. Then legally, you cannot do that.
24:30Charlie Eccleshare:That's one of the bread and butter kind of internet era bits of football banter, isn't it? It's a bit old now, isn't it? The ball ending up in orbit. It's a bit Twitter 10 years ago. Yes, at least. But yeah, so I mean, based on this camera angle, Charlie, Aspas's penalty cleared the bar, then started to loop back down and barely even made the front row at Albacete because they had a bit of a sort of running tracky kind of situation, like a moat in front of the stand. So if your penalty's not barely even hitting the first row, even allowing for the layout of the stadium, you can't call it a skied penalty, right?
25:03No, I think that's right.
25:04Charlie Eccleshare:Is it a spooning? Ooh. Has he spooned it over? Can you spoon a penalty? I mean, you could spoon a chance over from, say, four or five yards out, as we've seen many times in Premier League, blunder territory. If it's gone over and it's not hit the front row, there's a bit of an arc to it, isn't there? I don't think I've ever heard of a spooned penalty. I'm not against it. Maybe it's just too gentle a trajectory. a spooned chance, Charlie. He really has to go up and over like a pole vaulter. I mean, yeah, I think a spoon pen, like when, you know, sometimes someone will slip and they'll get really underneath it.
25:34That feels quite spoon-y, quite DJ spoon-y.
25:37Charlie Eccleshare:Yeah. I haven't delved into it too much, but I urge people just to go and find this thread on Reddit because a real faith restorer in the Clite's listenership if you'd ever lost it because it's just the investigation into whether this penalty was skyed is well worth a read. Now, a lovely addition to a well-documented genre. Here is Nigel Clough after he'd been made a Doctor of Sports by Nottingham and Trent Uni for him embodying steady leadership, deep understanding of the game and a commitment to developing players and clubs alike. And how did you react when you found out that you were going to be receiving one of these?
26:08I wasn't sure if it was a wind-up or not. But, you know, once we sat down and discussed it with the family and they all said, you know, it'd be a lovely thing to accept. And it is as well.
26:19Charlie Eccleshare:Charlie, would an honorary doctorate be a worthwhile wind-up for somebody i mean they know they haven't earned it so i mean you know not officially do you know what i mean so it's like it's not that much of a wind-up is it yeah well although i guess how chuffed he was then once he sat down with his family does suggest if that was then taken away from him he would have been you know proportionately disappointed by it so could be a decent april fools i suppose yeah april fools yeah okay or allow it i think it It could be actually quite a fertile ground for a good wind-up, actually. If you manage to convince Nigel Clough or whoever that they got an honorary doctorate and they go out to Eden Ravenscroft and buy their robes and their mortarboard and their hat and they turn up on the day and all the lads are there going, That would be mortifying.
27:10Charlie Eccleshare:Nottingham Trent, your alma mater, isn't it, pair of you? It's mine. Charlie was on the other side of town at Nottingham Uni. Oh, fair enough. Okay. But crucially, if anybody doesn't understand this story, neither of you knew of each other's existence back then. Incredible. We were at uni in Nottingham for the same years. Yeah, yeah. So who knows? We may well have brushed or crossed paths at some point. A sweaty nightclub. Yeah. Just a little less and fair play in each other's ear as you carry on. Yeah. Wow. Now, there's been plenty of North American investment in British football recently. Snoop Dogg, of course, as we've already established.
27:45Charlie Eccleshare:But this came from Mickey Onions, who was watching David Letterman's My Next Guest Needs No Introduction. And that guest was Michael B. Jordan. Now, I'm under the impression that you have something to do with a soccer team. Yes, Bournemouth Cherries. I invested in a team out here. And we've actually been doing really, really well the last few seasons. This is really annoying to you, Dan. How invested are you, mate? Come on. What other chances have them ever been called Bournemouth Cherry. That is so annoying. How dare you? Again, I know we say this a lot, but it's not Pro Evo, mate. It's not the South Coast Cherries or something.
28:23Is there any way he's trying to sort of put it in terms that the viewership will understand? There is that possibility.
28:29Charlie Eccleshare:We have to afford him that. He's been to games, hasn't he? I've definitely seen him at games. You'd like to think that if he's invested, literally invested financially, that he'll have been at meetings and stuff. But I mean, maybe they just, you know, they just don't really, they just can't get their head around it. It's just that's what football nicknames are. That's what they are to them. It's a shame. But yeah. I mean, they're already quite tin pot, aren't they? But it makes them sound so much worse. They've been doing very well in recent seasons, actually, according to Michael P. Jordan. So they're on the up, actually.
28:58Charlie Eccleshare:Anyway. Right. Let's stay in America, actually, over to the National Women's Soccer League. And they've done a very, very US soccer thing, Charlie. And they're proposing to introduce a rule which will allow teams to break the salary cap. and that is the high-impact player rule. It's a bit like the designated player rule in MLS. And so it will help them attract and retain star players. So they've come up with a set of guidelines for how players could qualify to be, you know, subject to the high-impact player rule. And the criteria are ludicrous. They have to be in the top 30 in the Ballon d 'Or voting in the two years prior to the current league season.
29:33Charlie Eccleshare:That I sort of get because it's kind of official. But then they have to be in the top 40 of the Guardian top 100 football players in the world in the two years prior. Top 40 of the ESPN FC, top 50 football players. Top 40 of the top 50 of the ESPN FC. What? I mean, I'm actually going to be semi-serious here, Charlie. We cannot have media outlets, qualitative analysis of players being involved in rule setting in professional football leagues. Think as well of how, like, you know, Pete Byron the Curtain, we've worked on these sort of lists. Like, you know, think how arbitrary when you're like, who should be 40, who should be 39, who should be 41?
30:14It's a complete coin flip. The idea there's science behind this.
30:20Charlie Eccleshare:It's dreadful. Where next, Dave? The Ballon d 'Or could be decided by someone writing a report card for a player saying, must do better, or something like that. You could have agents and club executives sweating on the outcome of the EMP and FC top 50. Oh, fuck, she's 41st. I mean, deal's over. You're joking, but this is the thing. that this could be worth millions of dollars to a certain player about whether there are some serious kind of sort of skullduggery surely going to be going on exactly brown envelopes everywhere wide open to corruption surely susie rack getting offered getting offered a few grand just put her in the top 40 it's really important she would never obviously of course she wouldn't i was never suggesting that she would nothing was suggested there um incredible but yes i mean other stuff like the player has to be in the top 11 minutes played for the US in the prior two calendar years for field players of all competition types.
31:12Charlie Eccleshare:Top 11? Top 11? When's a top 11 ever been a thing? Top 8 percentile on FB Ref for pass completion. Is it 11 because there's 11 players in a team but then it's also specified that it can't be a goalkeeper? So what? But there's a goalkeeper, there's a separate one for goalkeepers isn't there? Right, oh top 1 minutes played for the US WNT. Alright Cluffy, top 1 minutes. top one minute i can't believe this and then wow so then and then chucked in there as well as like the nwsl mvp finalist end of year nwsl best 11 so at least these are kind of semi-official awards charlie lends it a little bit of kind of formality but the media stuff blows my mind like nothing's really been made of this a few grumbles of how ridiculous it is but this should not be allowed to happen so yeah average rating of 7.2 on player ratings from newspapers or news got at least who scores like based on stats but the idea is just you know someone's player ratings they've tossed in at the end of a game congratulations you're allowed to break the salary cap because crossy on his video verdict on the mirror said you had a cracking game i can't believe this it's amazing but you know part of the mission statement for women's football davis is to undo or not repeat the mistakes that the men's game have done over the last 50 years or commercialisation, whatever.
32:32Charlie Eccleshare:So in many respects, I quite enjoy this approach. Maybe it is the way to do it, but I don't think it's going to work at all. Yeah, I mean, definitely one to keep an eye on. Blew my mind anyway. So yeah. Next up, bread and butter, a little debate for us. Beat Consistent6428 on Reddit, Dave, says, is 2-1 a high or a low scoring game? A friend has just asked this question. I'm saying of the two, it's low scoring, but I have a supplementary question. Is there such thing as a medium scoring game? No, no, obviously. But how do you feel about 2-1? 2-1's not high scoring, is it? 2-2 is the benchmark for this.
33:07Charlie Eccleshare:Minimum, yeah, 2-2. Yeah, 2-1 is not high scoring. You wouldn't say it was goals galore down at Fratton Park on Saturday as Pompey ran out 2-1 winners. 2-1's the average scoreline, right, Charlie, isn't it? Yeah, I've always thought that's kind of the default. And I think just statistically, the 23-24 season, it went to 3.28 goals per match. But that was like the highest ever. and it was quite significant that it was like comfortably above three but like yeah three is your sort of benchmark you know that's just like two one is totally standard yeah you can't have a medium scoring game um ad astra replied on reddit dave says total goals zero to one is low scoring two to three is standard not worthy of description on this point four to eight high scoring nine or more very high scoring absolute goal fest reasonable structure nailed it there i think yeah yeah nine's a lot but fine i did um notice that when sky sports are showing the uh the table at the moment they have like the most recent result in like green yellow or red and they have the score as well um and all four teams in the top four won two one at the weekend which looked very satisfying nice it was a very two oney weekend yeah yeah sort of victory you're going to grind out at this point of the season i guess joe wood writes in next charlie and says my wife and i go to different dentists for some reason we were talking about the possibility of one of us changing so we're at the same place my wife said she was reluctant to leave her dentist because she knows my teeth i don't believe this happened i i've read it several times and i just refuse to believe it you know it's fine to want to be on the football cliche podcast but i won't accept that this happened no i i can see this very much happening i think it's absolutely spot on if you are somebody who does things the right way and goes to the dentist regularly that relationship is crucial because like a knowing your teeth is genuinely probably quite helpful and also like you won't feel there'll be a rapport hopefully you won't feel like you're gonna get told off every time you go she's not gonna remember your teeth mrs wood it's every six months she gets a lit she looks up the x-rays as you walk in and goes oh how you doing how's your feeling been flossing have you yeah i mean i also think it's a slightly different emphasis because this is like it's not the i'm trying to think what the equivalent of it would be it's not quite the same thing as like knowing the club or something right it's almost it's it's almost like i don't know she knows the been through.
35:23Yeah, she knows the history of it or she knows the area. She knows the kind of teeth issues, the dental issues of this part of the world.
35:30Charlie Eccleshare:Joe Wood having to change his dentist against his wishes because his wife's digging her heels in. But yeah, she's come up with a better reason than you, son, so that's it. Move over. I don't know why they're going to different dentists anyway, to be honest. Madness. What's going on there? Right. MZ writes in finally, Dave says, My mum's carer is Brazilian and is planning a month off to go back to Brazil at the beginning of February. First thing that came to my mind is kind of worrying for my mum's care was, this is Edmundo at Fiorentina all over again. He had a carnival clause in his contract.
35:58Charlie Eccleshare:Clichés are rotting my brain. All right, Neymar. Yeah. All convenient injury, is it? I'm back you go. Got to get someone in on a loan now. Yeah. For fuck's sake. It's a crucial part of the season. Turns up in gloves in January now. And a snood. You can't do it. It's very mild out today, actually, mate. What are you doing? really really right up there is one of the best cliches is rotting my brain correspondence but yes um speaking of people living in our heads and rotting our brains it's time for keys and grey corner
36:48Charlie Eccleshare:final keys and gray corner of the year and as usual it's all keysy of course it is this is from keysy's blog published this very day um here he is talking about the fact that there's no set of Premier League games on Boxing Day. It also puts the EFL front and centre, which is no bad thing. The Championship is a terrific product. Curse-free, sorry, VAR-free. It makes such a lovely change to watch a match that isn't governed by some clown in a slough bunker. I love it. I haven't heard slough bunker before. Clown in a slough bunker is so good. It was Uxbridge before, now it's slough. Slough. Eight miles away, slough to Stockley Park, I checked.
37:28why does slough make it funnier yeah the combo clown and slough is just so good
37:34Charlie Eccleshare:clown in a bunker if you if you put that into an ai prompt i'd be fascinated to see it var's coming from slough trading estate yeah gareth keenan's operating it investigate he'd be good actually he'd be great on var yeah yeah he would yeah very efficient but yeah that bit where the guys like blows beans up your muff and this just reminds and then they're sort of both taking in like beans, muff. With this, I'm like clown. Slough. Slough bunker. So good. 100%. Right, this is great. It came from fitcomb4873 on Reddit. They say, I was taking the family round a light trail and it sounds as if they've used Richard Keyes as the voiceover for this creature projected onto a tree.
38:11Charlie Eccleshare:I was just having the most wonderful dream about a forest made entirely of sweets and chocolates. Oh, enough of that. You are here to embark on a journey filled with wonder and magic, aren't you? We are. Now you see that trail that you're about to explore? It is no ordinary path. It is a place where the very air you breathe is infused with enchanted.
38:43Charlie Eccleshare:That is absolutely incredible. I mean, it's not quite as good as the guy who was repairing that scooter about a year ago, but it's right up there. What is it? What is it about that voice that makes it so keezy? It's just that it's of a certain vintage, isn't it? You've got to be over 60. I love the little aren't you? Aren't you? Yeah. Wow. Daddy, why are you laughing so much at this tree? Why are you recording this? Again, it's such good news for us. I'm loving that people are just, you know, completely distracted from their actual lives. What could be in a nice evening and then this tree that sounds like Richard Keith.
39:22Charlie Eccleshare:Oh, God. Amazing. Amazing. Finally, as if things can get more classic keys, Claire Tomlinson signed off from Sky Sports after 27 years at the corporation. Listen, fair play indeed. She announced this on Instagram, Dave, and straight under in the comments was Keezy. Well done, Tomo. Top class effort. It seems like only yesterday I was telling you you'd be able to do it. You did it. And more. That is classic. It's classic. I said you should do it. I propelled you to stardom. Did you see the send-off video that they did for her? No. They got all sorts of people to kind of do a little to camera. Sorry to see you going, Claire.
40:03Well done. Great shift. All the best in the future. And there was... Ange Bosticoglu was in there, weirdly. But there was... Graham Soonis was in there. And Reedy, Peter Inge, was in there as well. And it was great. I'll drop the clip in. But he went, look, let's catch up soon. Let's have a bevy. Listen, let's catch up. Have a bevy. enjoy your retirement
40:24Charlie Eccleshare:well that is Reedy's job now is catching up and having a bevy imagine if that happened to be a fly on the wall oh god we didn't want this episode to be too good and we failed because there it is Richard Keyes getting in one more piece of credit for himself for somebody else's career in 2025 superb stuff thanks to you Charlie Eccleshire thank you thanks to you David Walker thank you thanks to everyone for listening in 2025 happy new year in a couple of days we'll be back on Tuesday the 6th see you then
40:55You know what they say. Early Bird gets the ultimate 30A vacation rental. Wait, they don't say that? They do now. Book early and save over$530 on select homes for week-long stays with Vrbo. That's the way to 30A. I'm here on the job site with Dale, who's a framing contractor. Hey, good morning. Dale traded up to Geico Commercial Auto Insurance for all his business vehicles. We're here where he needs us most. Yep, they sure are. We make it easy for him to save on all his insurance needs, all in one place, with coverage that fits his business and bottom line. Oh, I shouldn't have looked down. It's all right.
41:30We're so far up here. Look at me. Take a deep breath. No, I'm good. So good. Get a commercial auto insurance quote today at Geico.com and see how much you could save. It feels good to Geico. The sun is out, the birds are chirping, and the open road is calling. Bring on the spring at the Honda Spring Event and take that road trip you've been dreaming of. Now's the time to check out the Honda Civic and HRV from Honda, the 2025 Kelley Blue Book's KBB.com best value brand. For great deals, visit your local Chicagoland and Northwest Indiana Honda dealer today. Based on 2025 Consumer Choice Awards from Kelley Blue Book, visit KBB.com for more information.
From the publisher
Adam Hurrey is joined on the Adjudication Panel by Charlie Eccleshare and David Walker. On the agenda: the freescoring Dominic Calvert-Lewin passes a very particular threshold, Match of the Day exceeds its goalkeeper pundit quota, Joe Cole somehow morphs into Harry Redknapp on the radio, Michael B Jordan renames AFC Bournemouth, absurd salary-cap developments in the USA... and a tree with Richard Keys's voice.
Sign up for Dreamland, the new members-only Football Clichés experience, to access our exclusive new show and much more: https://dreamland.footballcliches.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
