In short
European football spying norms and World Cup squad news; plus Bundesliga promotion and a Serie A Champions League race.
Guests and backgrounds
Rafa Honigstein (ESPN/The Athletic contributor; football journalist), James Horncastle (The Athletic; football writer), Julien Laurant (ESPN; journalist). Lars Jerkel (Elf Freunde Elversberg fan group; supporter of FC Elversberg).
Key claims
Spying is common across Europe and often treated more leniently in German-speaking countries; examples include drones over training and scouts sneaking into closed sessions. Southampton’s “spy gate” sanctions included not just spying but alleged deplorable top-down treatment of interns. Manuel Neuer’s return to Germany’s World Cup squad is framed as a “number one” decision despite Oliver Baumann’s complaints. Carlo Ancelotti’s call-up of Neymar is portrayed as a controlled, non-starter/impact role with strict rules.
Notable examples
Werder Bremen drone over Hoffenheim (2019); Cologne spying on Hamburg in Dubai; Edin Terzic’s steward disguise at Dortmund/Real Madrid. Neymar’s inclusion displaces João Pedro. Elversberg’s promotion to the Bundesliga (town ~13,000; shipping-container changing rooms). Serie A: Como seen as a modern “story,” while Juventus’ Champions League hopes face crisis after a home loss to Fiorentina.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOSpying in Football: A Continental Perspective
2:54 to 4:59
Discussion on the culture of spying in European football and notable incidents.
“time and time again is, oh, this happens all the time in Europe.”
Journalistic Spying Tactics
4:59 to 6:39
Julien Laurent shares stories from his journalism career involving spying on teams.
“Well one of the funny stories of the last couple of years was Ivan Juric, who was a Southampton coach.”
Raymond Domenech's Mystical Approach
6:39 to 8:40
A humorous take on Raymond Domenech's astrology-based team selections.
“Now, you've arrived at the perfect time here because you won't have heard.”
Protecting Teams from Journalists
8:40 to 11:15
Julien recounts a story of how teams secure their training sessions from media spying.
“But Jules, Jules, I mean, to find out Dominic's lineup, all he needed was the astrology.”
Consequences of Spying: The Southampton Case
11:15 to 14:02
Analysis of the Southampton spying incident and its implications for Tonda Eckert.
“He didn't have much of a profile because he'd never been at the coalface before.”
Discussion on England's Challenges and Consequences
14:02 to 15:06
Explore the challenges faced by England and the potential consequences for players.
“We have to wait if there are consequences for him.”
Analyzing the Commission's Report
15:07 to 16:02
Examine the implications of a recent commission's report on junior employees.
“It's not really that clear what actually happened.”
Germany's National Team Selections
16:02 to 18:00
Delve into the dynamics of Germany's national team selections, focusing on Neuer.
“Yeah, good answer to a bit of a hospital pass of a question, Raf.”
Neuer's Comeback and Controversy
18:01 to 19:26
Discuss Neuer's return to the national team and the controversies surrounding it.
“There's also the substance of the decision, of course, because Baumann hasn't had the best second half of the season.”
Evaluating Neuer's Value to Germany
19:27 to 21:54
Consider the value Neuer brings to the German national team despite concerns.
“And he was asked about this by a journalist.”
Show all 23 chapters
Germany's Goalkeeping Future
21:55 to 24:26
Discuss the future of goalkeeping in Germany and the potential successors to Neuer.
“heavy on leaders, on experience, on winners.”
Neymar's Inclusion in Brazil's Squad
26:30 to 28:00
Discuss the implications of Neymar's selection and Ancelotti's decision-making.
“Obviously, the headline is that Neymar is in.”
Analyzing Brazil's World Cup Challenges
28:00 to 29:25
Discusses the pressures faced by Brazil's national team and player dynamics.
“from all of the reporting, seems to have been huge.”
Neymar's Evolving Role in the Team
29:25 to 30:56
Explores Neymar's shift from star player to a different role in the World Cup squad.
“So it doesn't necessarily feel like they needed or Co Ancelotti needed to do this.”
Injury Concerns and Performance Issues
30:56 to 33:22
Examines Neymar's injury history and current fitness for the World Cup.
“where he was the captain and the key of the World Cup before.”
The João Pedro Reveal Video Controversy
33:22 to 34:00
Discusses the emotional impact of the squad reveal video on João Pedro.
“Do we need to put one of those asterisks on this or like a content warning?”
The Impact of Squad Announcements
34:00 to 36:51
Analyzes the implications of how squads are announced and player reactions.
“So it was a little bit like the NFL draft where you've got camera crews in all of the family's houses and they're doing a watch along.”
Esfau Elfersberg's Historic Promotion
36:51 to 42:00
Highlights Esfau Elfersberg's promotion to the Bundesliga and its significance.
“aside from a town of just 13 ,000 people.”
Promotion Challenges in German Football
42:00 to 44:27
Discussion about the promotion of smaller clubs in the Bundesliga.
“that it's going really, really easy to the stadium and back.”
Anticipation of Bundesliga Matches
44:27 to 45:44
Lars shares his excitement for the upcoming Bundesliga season and reflects on the club's journey.
“but maybe for Germans, the inventors of modern fairy tales, not quite as romantic enough.”
Debate on Club Identity and Modern Football
45:44 to 47:26
Exploration of what makes an ideal football club amid modern pressures and expectations.
“That's Lars Jerkel from the Elf Friends Blesen Fans Group.”
Tension in Serie A's Champions League Race
47:26 to 50:30
Analysis of the competitive landscape in Serie A ahead of the final matches.
“And even though Milan are in the best position, they also have the worst goal difference.”
Consequences of Missing Champions League
50:30 to 52:16
Discussion on the implications for clubs like Juventus and Milan if they fail to qualify for the Champions League.
“If Milan don't make it to the Champions League, is that really bad?”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30Julien Laurens:Make your travel dollars work harder.
0:32James Horncastle:Follow Smart Travel on your favorite podcast app. You clocked out just as hunger clocked in. Why not answer the call and make a pit stop on your drive home? Go big or go home at 7-Eleven with their boneless wings, tossed in hot honey sauce with a spot-on sweet and spicy combo. It's available at 7-Eleven and just$5 with seven rewards. Visit your local Chicago 7-Eleven and satisfy that craving today. Valid through 62326. While supplies last, participating stores see up for full terms.
1:13Welcome to the EuroLeagues. Coming up, World Cup squad announcements as Manuel Neuer comes out of international retirement and Neymar is picked for Brazil. We'll also speak to a supporter of FC... Oh, Raf Honikstein, I knew I was going to get that wrong. Can you help me, please? S. Vau Elversberg? Elversberg. Once more, with feeling? Elversberg. Elversberg.
1:38James Horncastle:With feeling. S. Vau Elversberg. So we're going to speak to one of their fans. It's a town of just 13 ,000 people. The club have been promoted to the Bundesliga for the first time in their history. Raf is with us. The Athletics James Horncastle is with us. Hello. Hi, Crossy. Some great stories that we're going to get into. I'm really looking forward to talking about the World Cup squads. When are Italy announcing theirs? Crossing! Every time I'm on. I mean, I'm clearly here to talk about... The reducer. Carlo Ancelotti's decision to bring in Neymar. That's what I'm following. I'm the Ancelotti whisperer for the next six weeks.
2:18James Horncastle:So there we go. Lovely. ESPN's Julianne Laurent is going to join us very, very shortly. as well. We're going to start tonight with a continental view on spying. So just bear with us here because I think we've probably done enough on the Southampton Middlesbrough spy gate. That said, some startling revelations. If you go over to the BBC Sport website, there are loads of great pieces about it, about what's been happening at Southampton and the written reasons for them being expelled from the playoffs. However, one of the phrases that keeps coming up time and time again is, oh, this happens all the time in Europe.
2:59So I have been very, very keen to ask you all, Raph, does it? Well, it happens often enough for Oliwana, the RB Leipzig coach, only a month ago saying, yeah, of course we had drones, we had people in the bushes, we do all sorts of stuff, and nobody bat an eyelid at that revelation. So it is true. And I had to think back and do a bit of research. But we had some cases where Werder Bremen had a drone flying over Tesco Hoffenheim's training session when Jule Nagelsmann was there in 2019, I think. The scout who did it was fined, but not by the FA, just by the police, because it's not allowed to fly a drone without the permit.
3:47very german 500 euros fine but nagelsmann laughed it off completely said uh we we don't care we got nothing to hide and uh there was a similar case i think uh a few years ago when cologne spied on hamburg at a training ground in dubai and then somebody else said yeah We had to chase people. We chase people all the time from when they are, you know, on our last training session. So it seems to be part of the game. And of course, Edin Terzic, the new Atletic Bilbao manager, is on the record in saying that when he was an opposition scout, he would dress up as a steward to sneak into the closed session from Real Madrid at Dortmund the day before the game and watch their training.
4:37but I guess on Champions League nights when you have that training session in the opposition ground everyone knows that they're being watched anyway so yeah I think there is some merit in saying or some truth in saying that at least in German speaking countries there's a more relaxed attitude towards spying maybe it's because of the Cold War history James?
5:02James Horncastle:Well one of the funny stories of the last couple of years was Ivan Juric, who was a Southampton coach. Oh, of course, yeah. Easy to forget that, to be honest with you, but yes. Anyway, so when he was in charge of Torino, he sent a collaborator of his, I think it was Michele Orecchio, to go and watch Roma's training sessions at Trigoria, the last training session, what they call the Refinitura. and he was spotted by one of Jose Mourinho's assistants and so this was raised, the collaborator I think was moved, was basically told to be on your way and then the following year when Roma were due to play Torino again the guy was found in the same bushes.
5:58James Horncastle:different coach did osi was in charge of rome at that time it's like since there's someone in the bushes there lo and behold it was the same guy i mean i i have to say that the the drone that the drones is lazy isn't it really i mean we're talking about some of the lengths that people go to i think the drone's quite high tech uh crossy I think it's being in the bushes in sort of camouflage clothing. That is very sort of low tech. But I appreciate that. ESPN's Julien Leron has now joined us. Hello, Jules.
6:31Julien Laurens:Hello, guys. Sorry about that. No, it's fine. I know you're having technical trouble and not spying on the commentator's view to see what they're getting up to for their native. That's right, isn't it? Not this week. No, yeah, that's right. Every other week, though. Every other week. Now, you've arrived at the perfect time here because you won't have heard. Raph and James have just told us a few stories of things that have happened on the continent. I would quite like to turn the conversation to when journalists get involved in spying missions. Now, I don't know what Raph and James have been up to in the past, but I think we could describe you as prolific.
7:06Julien Laurens:I was the best. I was literally the best. I won't lie. As a young journalist, it was not really spying for the opposition per se, directly, you could say. Although maybe, you know, when France were playing, Germany or Italy, somebody in their camp where I was reading either L 'Equipe, because I was not on my own, obviously, but L 'Equipe or Le Parisien on the day of the game, because we used to spy the last training before the game. So the day before the game, the one behind closed door, especially in the big tournaments, even before the World Cup final, even before, you know, semi-final or something of huge game in qualifiers and things like that.
7:45Julien Laurens:and we've done all sorts. I mean, I'm not sure if I can tell all the secrets of that, but we hid in toilets for a long time to stay in the ground to be able to watch, just to find out the team and then to be able to report on who was going to play for France. You know, it was like that. And I think that at the heart of it was more the competition between L 'Equipe newspaper and Le Parisien newspaper. Right. And who would get that info first, more than anything else, really. But he got, under Dominic, he got huge, huge, it took huge proportions to the point that I remember very well I think I've told this story before but my mother-in-law you know god bless her soul in Cardiff reading the Guardian that these French journalists were spying on the training of their own team and that Raymond Dominic was not happy and called us traitors to the to the nation you know and she said like I hope this is not Julian you know and my wife Katie was like no no no don't worry but it was It was me.
8:41Julien Laurens:Traitor to the nation. But Jules, Jules, I mean, to find out Dominic's lineup, all he needed was the astrology. Leos, you know, not too many Leos. Scorpio, you can have more than two in your team. I think the famous quote that I remember, just for anybody listening who's like, I mean, I think most people will probably remember Raymond Dominic's bizarre spell in charge of France. But for those that don't, he loved his astrology. And I think that one of the quotes, Jules, about team selection was, I would never trust a Leo at the back. Something along those lines from memory. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And not too many Leos in your squad either.
9:20Julien Laurens:And when he took over with the French national team, he had six and he said he got rid of four and only kept two, including Thierry. I mean, it was hard to get rid of Thierry at the time anyway. But yeah, he really believes, but when I say believes strongly in it, it's not just his passion, but he thinks everything can be read into the cards and that all that kind of stuff has an impact on whatever your job is. I'm just imagining, James, Thomas Tuchel when he phoned up Harry Maguire being like, I've got one word for you, Harry, Libra, you're out. I'm so sorry.
9:55James Horncastle:Yeah, I mean, managers do make strange decisions based on whims, all kinds of things. But it is remarkable, particularly at major tournaments, the lengths that teams go to to actually protect themselves from the likes of Julien Leroy.
10:17James Horncastle:Julien's pretty fans.
10:19Julien Laurens:I've got the best story. I need to tell you this best story. Talking about protecting, very quickly, Euros 2008, and this is the peak of the war between Dominic and the French media, not just us at Le Parisien at the time, but every media. So when we went to Switzerland, he protected the pitch where they were training so well. They had fences everywhere and covers everywhere, and you could not see anything. You couldn't even access the roads because the police would close the road. And in Switzerland, police is a serious thing. but one day it was only open for the first 15 minutes we could see that there was this kind of farm kind of high up on a hill where you probably with good binoculars could be able to wash down on the pitch right and the day before that it was that euros was disaster for us we got knocked out in the group phase there was tension it was pre-2010 I know but anyway the last day before the training behind before the last day of the before the last game before we went home we said let's go for it so training was at 10 30 we the day before we went we went to see this those farmers and we said listen we explained they found it hilarious and i said to them listen i'll come at 6 a.m i bring pain au chocolat croissant i bring you literally breakfast in bed if you just let me go in the attic and from there i can probably see the training and they went yeah no problem we did that the most the best thing was there was a little like kind of railway behind the pitch where you had this small train every half an hour like just going past the pitch right and we decided to really annoy Dominic and do a like literally a live a live chat on the on the training session that was supposed to be close from everywhere you know in the whole city and we included 10 35 the little train passes by Franck Ribéry and Raymond Dominic and we could see Dominic and the people from the French Federation and the team looking around where are there because they were aware of the live description of the training behind your story was the best oh it's good um one thing i did want to pick up on raf is around tonda record though so like i said the actual story story if you like and the sanctions i think we've kind of covered that and this is the euroleagues after all however the commission's written reasons that have come out are really really explosive actually around what happened at southampton and one of the things that has been revealed as part of it is the commission talking about how central a role Tonda Eckert played in the operation but specifically about treatment of interns so the commission found a effectively a top-down system of pressuring these young people it was described by the commission as being deplorable and the reason I just think it's worth bringing up because it's linked to everything else around this story Tonda Eckert's obviously a young German coach.
13:09What was his profile before this? What is his profile now? He didn't have much of a profile because he'd never been at the coalface before. He'd been an analyst. You can read up on his various positions, but never in a head coaching job. And of course, he was the assistant coach who was then promoted and Southampton turned the season around as a result and then he got he got the job full-time but he because he was not a household name I guess the story wasn't quite as big if this happened to a you know a proper experienced German coach in the Premier League or in a championship I think would have been a much bigger story in Germany but nobody really knows who Tonda Eckert is and his profile now I think he will recover from this.
14:04I think England might be difficult. We have to wait if there are consequences for him. The FA might still charge him, etc. But I think somebody who's clearly talented, who's clearly young and made a mistake, possibly because he wasn't fully aware of the strength of the rules here in opposition or in contrast with what we said earlier in Germany, where it's sort of laughed off, I think he will recover and I think he'll get another chance somewhere. Do you think that extra bit of information from the commission's report might sort of shift the dial on that, that the commission has found that he was...
14:44Because it's almost that about... That news, that commission report almost takes it away from spying to kind of treatment of junior employees, doesn't it? So I'm just kind of wondering whether that sort of thing might... yeah, might shift the dial or not, I guess is what I'm asking. I know it's a difficult question to ask, Raph, but it's just kind of because it's news that we've only got in the last hour. Yeah, I mean, I don't know. I mean, from what you read out, I think we have to read between the lines. It's not really that clear what actually happened. It clearly doesn't sound very complimentary and doesn't reflect well on him.
15:16But I think before we actually know what's going on and, you know, I mean, football is a sort of business where people are literally doing anything to get in and as an intern you are probably willing to take risks that you wouldn't in other jobs because you want to be involved in football and I guess the same is true when it comes to wages in certain positions where you know people perhaps earn less than they would be in a normal job because clubs are sort of exploiting that a little bit I've come across that a few times so I'm not sure that's necessarily something that's unique in the situation but of course we'll have to look at a bit more detail, I think, before anyone can pass real judgment on it.
16:02Yeah, good answer to a bit of a hospital pass of a question, Raf. So thank you for that. I'm used to it, Steve. Hey, hey, that's not necessary. In Italian, you'd say ballone sanguinoso,
16:16James Horncastle:which is literally a bloody ball, by which you mean in passing that, that ball is going to hurt someone. Oh, wow.
16:27Julien Laurens:It kind of works. We say in pass en bois, like a wooden pass, because it's, you know, that bad. Yeah, I mean, it was that bad. It was both of those things. Right, we're going to stay in Germany. Let's talk about national team selections. There's some really good stories knocking around. We'll start with Germany, which is just about taken over, with Manuel Neuer at 40, coming out of international retirement and being named in Julian Nagelsmann's squad for the World Cup. Quote from him, Everyone knows the aura and quality that Manu has, what he brings to a team. We're planning with him as our number one, Raph.
17:00Wow. So he's gone from completely out of it to number one, just like that. Well, you wouldn't bring him in as a third keeper. So I think that was always going to be either number one or nothing. But of course, for Moms, he would repeat the same mantra saying, I have retired, this is over, we don't have to talk about this. Nagelsmann was saying the same. Nagelsmann was also telling Bauman, Oliver Bauman, that he is definitely the number one. And of course, Bauman is not best pleased. He's still going as a number two. But I think we can, again, read a lot between the lines in a statement that Hoffenheim released saying, of course, the national coach can pick whoever he wants, but anyone can have their own view on the style and the matter of communication.
17:52So they are obviously not happy. And I think they're probably speaking on behalf of their keeper saying this could have been handled more delicately. There's also the substance of the decision, of course, because Baumann hasn't had the best second half of the season. I think it's fair to say. Neuer has had a very good second half of the season. He renewed his contract. He feels still fresh. He still feels that he can contribute. he's not the same Neuer that he was 10 or 20 years ago but he is still a very good keeper and perhaps still the best Germany keeper and Nagelsmann who is not averse to changing his mind and doing U-turns as we saw when he brought back Toni Kroos two years ago before the Euros has decided that all the noise and the annoyance if you will and the sort of slight unease that has greeted this decision is worth it because Neuer in goal is still more valuable to him than Bauman.
18:53And Bauman has to live with that. There's one more interesting snippet to that, or maybe two. One is, of course, Manuel Neuer picked up an injury in the last game for Bayern and should recover in time, but has been injury prone this season. He's been missing quite a few games. So, Bauman might still be the number one at some point. And I'm sure that point has been made to him by Nagelsmann. But also, in a very bizarre twist, Nagelsmann was wearing a pair of socks today at the press conference. What a cent. That had been given to him by Baumann as a farewell gift when he left Hoffenheim to Leipzig a few years ago.
19:36And he was asked about this by a journalist. And he basically said, yeah, it's true. I haven't really thought about it, but yeah, those were the socks. And there were socks with candy sticks. There were socks with candy sticks on them. So quite distinctive. Very strange. Very strange. Sorry, here we are. It's a German story.
19:56Julien Laurens:It's got so much German in this story.
19:58James Horncastle:Is it? Also, that's great journalism. Well, is it? I mean, it's slightly weird. Yeah, it's so weird. I mean, it feels like, and I'm not suggesting this is the case, but it almost feels like a planty question. Yeah, yeah. Maybe. But if it was, I mean, I'm not sure what the purpose of it was. I mean, yes, I'm wearing the socks that Oliver Baumann gave to me a few years ago as a sign of what? Of goodwill or that we have still a great relationship because I'm wearing his socks? I mean, I think the story would have been more German if the only thing he'd worn was socks. But that was definitely not the case.
20:37Are you absolutely sure he didn't like walk on stage and just go, guys, I'm wearing Bauman tonight.
20:43James Horncastle:Does sound like a great scent. I'm wearing Bauman. It does scent.
20:48Julien Laurens:Raph, what happens if during the tournament, let's say Neuer starts and then, I don't know, something changes during the tournament. Could he kick? Could he become a problem? Or do you think that even if, I don't know, something changes and Bauman is the number one, then it starts and Neuer makes a mistake in the game? I don't know. Something happens and he's not playing anymore. Could it be an issue or you don't think there's this kind of cloud that could potentially be over the national team? I mean, I don't think, to be honest, it's going to have that much impact on Germany's fortunes. I think a Neuer who is not quite at his best anymore is still a better keeper than Oliver Baumann.
21:30That's my personal opinion. Neuer is occasionally injury prone and occasionally error prone. these days we saw that but you kind of put up with it the way Bain have put up with it because you think okay even if he gives away a goal as he did against Real Madrid in the quarterfinals he still then makes two or three saves that no other keeper makes so in the grand scheme of things there's still a net positive and of course you know this is a team that isn't necessarily heavy on leaders, on experience, on winners. So to have one guy who won the World Cup left in 2014 in this team, the last survivor, I think, is also of some benefit for Nagelsmann when it comes to the leadership and the experience inside of the dressing room.
22:22It's funny, Raph, because Germany and probably Italy come into the same bracket here. No, no, no, they don't come in the same world cup.
22:31Julien Laurens:So when we talk about this world cup, that's not what I was going to do. I promise you, James. They won something more recently than Germany.
22:42James Horncastle:Yeah, the Euros, we don't care. What I was going to say is when I think of those two nations, my first thought is always great goalkeepers, especially with Germany now, when you think like Schumacher, Meyer, Ilkner. Obviously, for me, Kopka is the first one I think of because of Euro 96, but then you've got Kahn and blah, blah, blah. We could go on all night. Is it a bit of a damning indictment that that's the best option now is a 40-year-old Manuel Neuer? Him being better than Bauman is one thing. His actual level for this major tournament is another question. Why don't they have somebody young who is up and coming and pushing the envelope?
23:23They have. The problem is that the guy who's pushing Neuer is the Bayern second keeper, Jonas Ubeck. And it's very hard, even though a lot of people said he's actually the best keeper in the Bundesliga right now, it's very hard for Nagelsmann to pick him ahead of regular starters. I mean, Ubeck has played more this season, but I think he's only had six or seven starts. So he is there in another curious twist as a fourth goalkeeper, but he's not part of the squad. So he's the 27th man. He's not part of the FIFA list. Oh, yeah. Actually, I think he's quite smart because with keepers, you can still nominate them after the tournament has started if there's an injury.
Read the full transcript
24:05So rather than flying somebody out from Germany, would then join late on if something happens to Neuer. The guy is already there and he's clearly willing to just come along, even if his chances of playing are quite low, as an understudy. but he is actually the keeper I think who will inherit Neuer's gloves in the post-World Cup world
24:26James Horncastle:should he buy Nagelsmann some socks I'm not sure if it really enhances or reduces his chances the jury's still out after the Bauman sock are those socks in sandals as well because that's very German no no he was wearing trainers but it's worth looking at them I mean, they are very distinctive. I'm not sure I would wear them ever, but, you know.
24:53Julien Laurens:Nagelsmann has a dress. I remember when he was the Bayern coach. We used to wear Leipzig. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Thomas, where did you get those gloves? They're great. Oh, Phil Foden gave them to me just before I picked the squad. Harry Maguire didn't give him socks. No, he didn't. And now we know that's an exclusive.
25:24James Horncastle:If your best finance people are doing expense reports, chasing receipts, or spending time on month-end close, it's time to get Brex AF, a gentic finance that eliminates that work before it starts. Learn more at brex.com slash AF.
25:46All the cricket you love. Check for LBW. Ouch! Lives on BBC Sounds. Smash straight back down the ground, this girl. Hear ball-by-ball coverage of the biggest competitions
25:58James Horncastle:on the domestic and international circuits. It's a fourth cricket and it's the huge one. Jeez. Settle down, Tuffer. Sorry, man. Cricket on Five Live Sport. Oh, I've lived every ball of this. Listen on BBC Sounds.
26:22You're listening to the EuroLeagues on 5 Live ESPN. Julien Laurent, The Athletics, James Horncastle, Rafa Honigstein, all with us. Let's talk Brazil, Carlo Ancelotti's squad. Obviously, the headline is that Neymar is in. No João Pedro, no Richarlison. We were talking about this, James, a lot around Neymar. Did you expect him to be in it? Because I think, weirdly, I'm not sure I did. I think I've been taken by surprise that he's coming from the cold. Maybe I shouldn't be.
26:51James Horncastle:I was taken by surprise because, you know, Carlo Ancelotti hasn't picked him up until now. And, yeah, Neymar has not played for his country since October 2023. I think he's only played four times since the last World Cup. so even though I kind of back Carlo to be the one person who can make this work because he is very good I think one of his superpowers is his ability to create a group out of superstars and get everybody on the same page I think that's what made him such a great Real Madrid coach that those personalities that we've seen clash this year under Xabi Alonso and Arbeloa didn't clash under Carlo Ancelotti.
27:44But on the one hand, I feel really bad for João Pedro,
27:48James Horncastle:who Chelsea named player of the year 15 minutes or so after it was announced that he would not be going to. But it just goes to show that the pressure that was placed on Carlo Ancelotti to make this call, from all of the reporting, seems to have been huge. Legends who have won World Cups for Brazil telling him to do it. Senior players in his squad telling him to do it. And, you know, I mean, Carlo Ancelotti is used to working for some very high-powered individuals, you know, be it Silvio Berlusconi, be it Roman Abramovich. But the Brazilian public might be the most demanding of all. And so, yeah, let's see how he copes with this.
28:45Because I think the one thing you could say about Brazil is, OK, you know, maybe they don't have a young up and coming player now, particularly with what happened to Esteval, that you
29:00James Horncastle:could look to and say that kid is going to be the best player in the world in the way that Ronaldinho looked like that player or Ronaldo looked like that player. But if you look at the recent conversations we've had about who's going to win the Ballon d 'Or, well, Real Madrid decided not to go to the Ballon d 'Or ceremony when Vinicius Junior didn't win it a couple of years ago. And Rafinha was in the Ballon d 'Or conversation as recently as this time last year. So it doesn't necessarily feel like they needed or Co Ancelotti needed to do this. Jules, I wonder if I could sort of throw your question back at you that you asked Raf about Neuer around Neymar.
29:42Could he become a problem?
29:44Julien Laurens:Yeah, I think so. I think it's a very delicate balance that you'll have to find. And Carlo, as Horny just said, is very good at that. But what I find fascinating is even if Carlo is very good at it, before confirming to Neymar on the phone, they had a long phone call to say that he was part of the squad and go to the World Cup. He had very clear rules to set and said to Neymar, listen, this is how it's going to happen. This is what's going to happen. If you don't want to be part of this, no problem. You say, no, I don't call you up later that day. It was on Monday night when he announced it. But you won't start.
30:22Julien Laurens:So that's pretty clear. So Neymar is aware that his position right now is not of a starter in this team, but more as an impact sub at some point. and I'm not sure he's got the fitness anyway to play 90 minutes in a World Cup in that heat at that time, let alone further down the tournament, that not too much social media. What we expect from you is that kind of experience, older brother, big brother kind of approach to, let's say, like a Ryan or those kind of young players. We mentioned Estevão earlier. And so it's a very different role for Neymar than the last World Cup, where he was the captain and the key of the World Cup before.
31:00Julien Laurens:and he was so desperate to go that I guess he's satisfied by that role. But what happens if two weeks in, he's thinking like, I don't just want to bring the water to the guys and do a bit of few drills of training and that's it. I want to play more. I wonder if inevitably for somebody like him, who used to be one of the best in the world and now he's really, let's be honest here, the shadow of himself because I'm not even sure that outside of that pressure that James nicely summed up, I don't really think he deserves to be there on the recent performances that he had and his behavior and attitude on and off the field.
31:37Julien Laurens:You know, he had this incident with Robinho Jr. He had a spot with a Santos fan with a lot of like, you know, swear words and this and that. So I think Carlo said, OK, everybody wants him there. I'll take him. I'll set the rules. But really, on a pure football basis, I'm not sure he deserves to be there. All name are that he is, really.
31:58James Horncastle:And also, Crossy, remember the circumstances in which Chelsea signed João Pedro last year? It was in that bizarre kind of window for the Club World Cup. And he came in and took over that Club World Cup. Where was that Club World Cup played? It was played in the heat of the summer in the US. And he made a fantastic impact as Chelsea went on to win that. That's why we all call Chelsea world champions every three days. so you know I'm not sure Neymar can deliver that and this is a player I mean we've just gone from talking about Manuel Neuer's sort of injury troubles this year this is a this is a player that it's hard to get on the pitch and just by dint of the way he plays he invites tackles that I I remember because Italy didn't qualify for the last World Cup, I did cover Brazil and Argentina for the Athletic.
32:58James Horncastle:And I remember his ankle got kicked so badly that he was a doubt, I think, from maybe the second group stage games up until that quarterfinal against Croatia. And if our listeners haven't seen it, go and Google what his ankle looked like. I mean, I find it incredible that four years later, he's going to play in a World Cup, given the state of his ankle, four years ago. Should people definitely Google that? Are you sure of that, James? Yeah, yeah. Do we need to put one of those asterisks on this or like a content warning? No, it's just a very swollen ankle. Okay, fine. We can do that. Can you walk us through, James, the Joao Pedro video?
33:48because I'm not necessarily a fan of the modern concept of the reveal video for major tournament squads. And if ever there was an advert for not doing it, then it's this.
34:00James Horncastle:Yeah. So it was a little bit like the NFL draft where you've got camera crews in all of the family's houses and they're doing a watch along. And there is a Jao Pedro watch along with his friends and family. and you just hear Carlo Ancelotti's voice in the background on the TV saying Vinicius Junior, Rafinha, Neymar Junior and it's then when it sinks in that João Pedro's name isn't going to be called and you just see people getting up from the table, walking around, a few choice words being said, but devastating. And again, we've all seen that, that video has gone around the world. So, yeah, it's...
34:55James Horncastle:And I think Neymar was obviously one of João Pedro's idols as well. So kind of bittersweet. I'm sure he would have loved to have played with him at a major tournament and instead Neymar's taken his place. I feel like just give him a ring beforehand. Just be like, listen, I know you're planning to do like a live... Maybe don't.
35:14Julien Laurens:Don't publish it. Don't put it anywhere. Once it's done, yeah, don't just, don't put it out. And also, it's alphabetical order often. And I don't know why they, no, I know why they all do it. All the national team head coaches pretty much do it. But when you're a player and you just wait, you know at some point the letters are getting closer to your name. And if your name is not mentioned, there's no second chance. You know, if he was not in order, you would go, okay, maybe I'm the last one of the forward names. And there's still a bit of hope. But if you draw Pedro and you were not called either at the J or at the P.
35:47Julien Laurens:And then after that, he's gone beyond. You know, this is just not for you. I prefer a... Quick question. I mean, isn't Carlo Ancelotti the sort of manager that we think would tell his player? Well, that's exactly the point, yeah. I'm surprised. And let him down gently. What about Tucho, do you mean? No, I mean, you know, he might still need Jao Pedro in three months' time. surely he must have sold it to him, explained it to him properly and so on.
36:16James Horncastle:I mean, perhaps he did and João Pedro didn't tell his friends and family. I don't know, we don't know. I like a more low-key one. I was at the Iceland squad announcement for the Euros in 2016 and Lars Lagerbeck did what I would describe as a GCSE-level PowerPoint to announce the squad. and they went all the way through to the end and the last name was Eidegger Johnson and it was sort of met with a sort of almost like a roar from the Icelandic journalists. So I think low-key is better. That's the way to go. We're going to talk about Esfau Elfersberg now, aside from a town of just 13 ,000 people.
36:5613 ,000? Goodness. They've been promoted to the Bundesliga, first time in their history. They just finished second in the Zwei Bundesliga. They've got one step further than they did last season when they lost the promotion relegation playoff to Heidenheim. Lars Jerkel is from the Elf Friends Blesen fan group and has joined us on the EuroLeagues Live. Lars, good evening. Good evening. Congratulations on your promotion. Just tell us what it means to you to have Elfsberg in the Bundesliga. It's unbelievable. You know, it's such a small town playing in Forst League some years ago, crawling rapidly, and it's really something you need to believe in some month, maybe, if really Bundesliga is played in Elversburg.
37:41What is the secret to this then? And we'll talk a bit about money that goes in and all that kind of thing. That's always part of the story. But what is the kind of special thing about this club and this town that's allowed it to achieve this? I think it's a complete package. It's a clear plan. It's continuity. It's an incredible team spirit. So I think it's really unbelievable as, for example, Eversberg lost so many good players last year and everyone was expecting to play maybe at the end of the table and now at the end we make a promotion, which is quite unbelievable. And I think it's only possible due to real good structures, really good work of management and team and really good team spirit.
38:29Tell us about the manager then. Yeah, the manager was Nils Olobog. So he was the architect of everything. He built up the whole structure, took players no one knew before, making them to really, really good players. So, for example, we have Mohamed Damar, Mazzan Aslani or Abdul Nalib. We all lost them to Bundesliga clubs. And nevertheless, they all did the same as before. Everyone worked for a team. And also the head coach Horst Steffen left to Bremen at the beginning of the season. and nevertheless said also San Nils-Oleboek himself went to Dortmund some month ago. The team was still fighting, still bringing the best on the field and I think at the end it's well deserved to get promoted to the first league.
39:30Julien Laurens:Do you expect now maybe to keep your best players and more importantly how do you see next season? Is it a case of it would be a miracle to stay up? Do you think that maybe the team can actually manage to have a second season in the Bundesliga and try to establish itself in the top flight, which is obviously very difficult? And do you feel like there's almost, it's a dream, so there's no pressure. You're going to enjoy playing Bayern even if you lose 5-0 or Dortmund or you want a bit of that pressure and going for it? I think every game in Bundesliga is an add-on for everyone, for the spectators, the fans, the team, and it's like a cup game.
40:11I compare it like a cup game. So we are the small ones. They are the big ones. But this is part of the story of football. This is why we love this sport, because it's possible to compete against Borussia Dortmund or Bayern Munich. And imagine, for example, the changing rooms in Eversberg are all shipping containers, to be honest. This is it. This is what we want. Yeah, and we are just building the stadium. We just have, at the moment, 10 ,000 spectators. After the rebuilding now in one year, it's 15 ,000. But this is something Borussia Dortmund or Bayern München have to handle because you know Westfalenstadion or you know the Allianz Arena and it's a change.
40:58And this is our chance, in my opinion, to fight against them, to show them how hard football can be and to play with the possibilities we have as a small club. I feel like that begs the question then, Lars. Aside from the shipping containers, what aspect of travelling to Elfsberg, as in the stadium, at the moment is going to be the most alien and difficult for teams like Bayern Munich? The first part of being difficult is that we don't have the train station but we have an exit on the highway that's that's a big advantage but to be honest everyone is always laughing about how we do it and I'm really going to football stadiums since 30 40 years and it's quite quite fantastic handled so we've park and ride we have buses so you don't have so many spectators that it's going really, really easy to the stadium and back.
42:05So sometimes if I go on an away game in a big stadium, for example, two weeks ago in Dusseldorf, we had nearly one hour, one and a half hour to leave the parking spot. And this time from Elversburg, I'm at home and sit in my kitchen with my kids, for example. Raph, this sounds like an amazing fairy tale. Please don't spoil it.
42:30I mean, we wouldn't be Germans if we'd find something that we don't like about a small team getting promotion. There is a sort of a purist, snobbish attitude towards small clubs because there is, you know, amongst the traditionalists, a sense that they shouldn't really be in the Bundesliga that we should have, you know, the proper clubs like Kaiserslautern and Hertha. And there's sort of a danger that the Bundesliga is becoming too small. We had Heidenheim there. Now we have Elvesberg. Not Elvesberg. They're not elves, Crossy. I'm trying here, man. I think you're channeling Lord of the Rings. Elvesberg.
43:12Literally kind of the difference, but go on. And because we don't have a history of smaller clubs sort of going through the leagues with the help of a local businessman who pumps money into it um and the few times it happened it happened very inorganically there is almost a sense that this is not a fairytale but actually just kind of modern football the way we don't like it you know like a guy just giving money and through the money they're going up but we have to explain something especially in the British context. I mean, the money that's been invested by Frank Holzer, who's the senior person there, a former football player who has been supporting the club for three decades, is minuscule in comparison to what we're thinking about when we think of Hoffenheim or Leipzig or any British equivalent.
44:05I mean, I looked at their numbers. In the last five years, which covered their ascent from the fourth league all the way to Bundesliga, they have spent 4.7 million euros on transfers. 4.7 million euros. And in net terms, they've spent minus seven. So they've made more money than they spent in those five years. So this is still, I think, a fairy tale, but maybe for Germans, the inventors of modern fairy tales, not quite as romantic enough. Lars, what are you most looking forward to about seeing your team in the Bundesliga then? I'm really looking forward to be honest to each single game because like I mentioned it's net on and I think it's really fantastic what our trainer Vincent Wagner said on the press conference as we were promoted he said luckily in the season 27-28 we are in second league so next year we save the second league and that's really really the true and that's the mindset in Elvasberg and that's what us brings forward that's what us brought to the point we are now because if you told someone three years ago where we are now it would be crazy they once say it's unbelievable and it's unbelievable Lars thank you so much for joining us I'm sure we'll speak again when you sort of demolish Raph's Bayern Munich 5-0.
45:40And they have a lock-in in the shipping container. I look forward to that. Thanks, Lars. Great stuff. That's Lars Jerkel from the Elf Friends Blesen Fans Group. Raph, what's the perfect German football club then? Because you don't like these little stories. You don't like the clubs with the big money. Like, what do you want? I mean, it's a really good question. you know even Bayern Munich fans have had a banner for 20 years saying we are against modern football brilliant so I don't know I think it's it's it's an adherence to some bygone golden era that of course never really never really existed but it's interesting cross seekers I mean they
46:23James Horncastle:have this debate in in Italy as well there are lots of Italian raffas raffaelles who are making the same point that when a Benevento gets promoted or a Frozionna gets promoted instead of a Sampdoria, for example, you have people like Napoli's owner, Arellia De Laurentiis, sort of pulling his hair out saying, for the overall TV product, if we are to get sort of international audiences in, they don't want that romantic plucky little story. They want to see the bigger clubs, as many big clubs as possible in the competition, which makes it all the more enjoyable when one of those teams knocks Napoli out of the Coppa Italia, which is what happened last year.
47:13Well, this is a perfect link because we're going to finish with the Champions League race in Serie A ahead of the final day. Two points separate third from sixth. Obviously, it's third and fourth that get in in Italy this season. So Milan are third on 70. Roma also have 70. Como 68. Juventus 68. And even though Milan are in the best position, they also have the worst goal difference. Is it head-to-head first in Serie A though, James? It is, isn't it? Yes, I thought so.
47:41James Horncastle:Bizarrely, it is crossy, yes. So, I mean, actually, the first question I'll ask you then, because it links into what we're talking about, is Como. So how are Como being viewed within that context? Are they a plucky anything? Are they not? Would your average neutral Italian football fan think, oh, great if they get in the Champions League or not? People think they're a great story in Italy because of what they stand for. They've got a young coach in Cesc Fabregas, who we've spoken about many times on this show, whose ideas are seen as very modern, vanguard and should be followed by other people in the league rather than playing sort of retrograde, 3-5-2, low block, boring football.
48:27James Horncastle:So in that sense, Como are being championed. They are not like the team that has just come up into the Bundesliga because they have spent considerably more than the 4 million. Rafa mentioned, they have had the highest net spend the last couple of years since they got back into the top flight. But they've spent that well. Cesc has implemented it very well. And their game this weekend against Cremonese, I mean, they could relegate Jamie Vardy's Cremonese. And then they've got to hope that results go their way elsewhere. Because, you know, whilst Roma have never been in the Champions League under the Friedkin group, the Friedkin group who also own Everton, and they've spent an awful lot of money on Roma, the big focus over the last week or 10 days has really been on Milan and Juventus you know who wants the crisis club that and more and that has been Milan last week Crossy because it was very much there was a big protest they wanted the chief executive of Milan out they wanted the sporting director out as well but then Milan beat Genoa at the weekend and the big surprise was that Juventus lost at home to Fiorentina.
49:48James Horncastle:Fiorentina who've been in relegation trouble for most of this season but are now safe didn't really have anything to play for they rock up a couple of ex-Juventus players scored and now this has thrown Juventus's entire structure into to doubt, which is their chief executive, Damien Comoli, or Damien Comoli, as people in the UK know him. And the structure that he spent the last year putting in place, which has been a new sporting director, new technical director, and the coach, Luciano Spalletti, who they took the option to extend his contract a couple of weeks ago. But now it feels like everything is thrown into doubt because Juventus might not qualify for the Champions League for the first time in 15 years.
50:32Julien Laurens:And who would lose the most? Who would lose the most? Great question, Jules. Perfect question. You know, where is the crisis at? If Milan don't make it to the Champions League, is that really bad? What about Juve? If Roma don't make it when they are in that position, is it okay because it's Gasparini's first season, for example, and things like that? Or who has the most to lose?
50:53James Horncastle:So you're absolutely right, Jules, in what you're alluding to with Roma and Gasparini in that I think the ownership there, whilst they have been gasping to qualify for Champions League over the last seven or eight years. Because all the money you think that they spent on Jose Mourinho and then on hiring Jose Mourinho, all the money they spent on Daniel De Rossi, they need it. But it's almost normalized not being in the Champions League. So they would be ahead of schedule under Gasparini if they got there. Milan have shown, by failing to qualify last year, that they can still navigate the transfer market in such a way that they can, I wouldn't say be non-top-four proof, but they've shown that they can find a way to balance the books without it.
51:38James Horncastle:Juventus is the one that they have a shareholder who keeps plunging lots of money in, you know, the Agnelli family. But after, what, six years now since they won their last title, and remember Juventus won the league nine years in a row, for them to miss out on the Champions League and have to press the reset button again, I think that would be inconvenient, to say the least, for their owner, John Elkamp. I have to say congratulations to you, James, because whilst the rest of us have been beautifully lit throughout this show, it's just got darker and darker behind you. Now you effectively look like a deleted scene from the Blair Witch Project at this point, but you've done well with it.
52:27What a great Euroleagues, everybody. Big thank you to Rafa Honigstein, The Athletics' James Horncastle and ESPN's Julien Leron. The final Euroleagues of this club football season is next Thursday and it will be live from Budapest ahead of the Champions League final, which is, of course, live on 5 Live on Saturday, Arsenal versus Paris Saint-Germain. So we'll be here on 5 Live from 7pm with that and that'll be the next edition of the Euroleagues. Next up on the Football Daily will be the commentator's view.
53:035 Live Sports BBC Women's Football Weekly The latest news, insights and analysis from across the women's game Dame Serena Vigman Welcome to the moment Are we including Dame in your title now? You know how much an honour that is And this remarkable team And this remarkable women They want to play in a way that they can show their skills so that's what we're trying to do Win the World Cup. It's a dream. Listen. With the BBC Sounds app.
From the publisher
Steve Crossman is joined by Rafa Honegstein, Julien Laurens and, James Horncastle. The panel give a continental view on ‘spygate’ and how Southampton’s actions have been viewed around the rest of Europe. It’s something that occurs regularly in Europe, but has anything to this scale ever occurred before?
Manuel Neuer has come out of international retirement to be named in Julian Nagelsmann’s Germany squad for the World Cup. Is this shocking given how insistent both Neuer & Nagelsmann were that this wouldn’t happen? Hoffenheim’s Oliver Baumann has been backed as Germany’s new number one when Neuer retired after the 2024 Euros, and some fans want him to keep his place. Elsewhere, Neymar will return to the Brazil squad after it looked like he may have been set to miss the tournament.
Elversberg will be one of the smallest teams to have ever played in Germany’s top division, having been promoted to the Bundesliga for the first time in their history, having finished the season in second in 2. Bundesliga. The club has bounced back having just missed out on promotion the season before, then losing the manager of six years Horst Steffen to Werder Bremen. The panel are joined by Lars Joeckel from ELV Friends Bliesen fan group to reflect on a historic season.
And it’s the final weekend of the Serie A season with several clubs chasing Champions League football. Cesc Fabergas’ Como are one of the main talking points of the season. And are there issues brewing at AC Milan and Juventus.
TIME CODES 00:00 Intro 01:20 Continental view on spying 02:00 Spying in Germany 03:50 Spying in Italy 05:50 Journalists spying 12:00 The profile of Tonda Eckert 15:30 Manuel Neuer’s Germany return 18:50 Julian Nagelsmann’s socks 19:50 A potential goalkeeper headache for Germany? 21:00 German goalkeepers 25:00 Neymar is back for Brazil 28:10 Could the pressure become a problem? 32:20 Joao Pedro left out 35:20 SV Elversberg reach the Bundesliga 41:00 Rafa trying not to spoil the fairytale 43:20 Looking forward to the Bundesliga 44:30 What club does Rafa actually like? 45:50 Champions League race in Serie A 48:00 Issues at AC Milan & Juventus
5Live commentaries this week: Sat 15:00 Dunfermline v Celtic - Scottish Cup Final (Sports Extra) Sun 16:00 Spurs v Everton Sun 16:00 West Ham v Leeds (Sports Extra) Sun 16:00 Crystal Palace v Arsenal (Sports Extra 2) Sun 16:00 Brighton v Manchester United (Sports Extra 3)




