In short
Podcast Notes: Football Daily - MNC: Dowman’s Delight, Man Utd’s Climb & Chelsea Charges
Episode Overview The episode features discussions led by Mark Chapman, with guests Chris Sutton, Rory Smith, and Russell Martin. The key topics include Arsenal's recent performance, Manchester United's midfield dynamics, predictions for the Scottish Premiership, insights from Russell Martin's management experience, and the implications of Chelsea's recent financial penalties.
Key Segments
- Max Dowman and Arsenal's Title Aspirations (Timecode: 2:30)
- Max Dowman's Milestone: At 16 years old, Dowman became the youngest goal scorer in Premier League history, contributing to Arsenal's victory over Everton, which lifts them nine points clear at the top of the table.
- Impact on Team Morale: The excitement and euphoria around Dowman's performance are seen as pivotal for the team's mentality in a title race.
- Mikel Arteta's Management:
- Discussion on the bravery of Arteta to field a young player in a high-stakes match.
- Insights on how young players, like Dowman, can perform without psychological burdens, allowing them to play freely.
- Manchester United’s Progress under Michael Carrick (Timecode: 16:26)
- Midfield Balance: The midfield featuring Casemiro, Bruno Fernandes, and Kobe Maynou is highlighted for its balance and effectiveness.
- Bruno Fernandes: His resurgence in form due to being played in a more natural position is discussed, emphasizing his impact on the team's performance.
- Casemiro's Future: Varied opinions on whether Casemiro remains essential for the club moving forward, considering both his experience and physical limitations.
- Scottish Premiership Predictions (Timecode: 24:20)
- Current Standings: The close title race involving Hearts, Celtic, and Rangers is analyzed.
- Insights from Russell Martin: His experiences in management lead to discussions on pressure dynamics among clubs and predicting outcomes for the season.
- Russell Martin’s Reflections on Management (Timecode: 34:40)
- Transition from Player to Manager: Martin discusses the learning curve of management, citing challenges faced during his tenure at Southampton and how he approaches potential new opportunities.
- Cohesion in Team Dynamics: The importance of player relationships and tactical clarity in building successful teams is emphasized.
- Chelsea’s Record Fine and Suspended Transfer Ban (Timecode: 42:45)
- Summary of Penalties: Chelsea has been fined £10 million and received a suspended transfer ban for historical breaches related to payments to unregistered agents.
- Long-term Implications: Discussion on how this reflects on Chelsea's past management and the potential for other clubs facing similar scrutiny.
Key Takeaways
- Arsenal's current form is heavily influenced by the contributions of youth, particularly Max Dowman, reflecting a broader theme of young talent making a significant impact.
- Manchester United's improved midfield dynamics under Carrick showcase the importance of tactical alignment and player confidence.
- The Scottish Premiership remains highly competitive, with the potential for any of the top teams to claim the title, emphasizing the unique pressures of Scottish football.
- Russell Martin’s candid insights into management highlight the complexities of team cohesion and the necessity of firm leadership in navigating challenges.
- Chelsea’s financial penalties raise questions about regulatory consistency in the Premier League and the impact of historical decisions on current clubs.
Upcoming Matches
- Discussion on upcoming UEFA Champions League matches, highlighting key fixtures involving Manchester City, Arsenal, Barcelona, and Liverpool.
This episode encapsulates a blend of current football events, managerial insights, and the intricacies of team dynamics within the realm of football, making it a rich listening experience for fans and analysts alike.
Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.
Chapters
Tap a time to open that second in VOLight-hearted Banter Among Friends
1:32 to 2:56
Enjoy a humorous exchange among the hosts about their dynamics.
“And when we spoke about the possibility of you coming and doing some radio, when I said, would you come on the Monday Night Club, I most definitely expected you to say no because of one person in particular.”
Max Darman's Impact on Arsenal
3:43 to 7:17
Explore Max Darman's crucial role in Arsenal's recent success.
“You may have just heard that in the news, but we'll look at Chelsea both on and off the field as well.”
Manchester United's Midfield Dynamics
7:23 to 13:00
Analyze the balance and effectiveness of Manchester United's midfield.
“he would have thought about his age in that moment because of the fact that, you know, he would have trained a lot of times with the first team.”
Midfield Dynamics: Casemiro and the New Balance
14:01 to 15:15
Explore how the midfield's configuration has evolved under Carrick, enhancing team balance.
“I'm sure it isn't, but he's made it look that way.”
Debating Casemiro's Future Role
15:15 to 17:19
A discussion on whether Casemiro should remain at Manchester United or move on.
“If you look at what he brings and the experience, but there are going to be limitations physically, out of possession a lot for sure.”
The Importance of Leadership and Experience
17:19 to 19:17
Analyzing Casemiro's potential contributions to younger players at the club.
“I think, was it 11 days before this game?”
Bruno Fernandes: A Premier League Talent
19:17 to 20:55
Evaluate Bruno Fernandes's impact and leadership qualities on the pitch.
“Definitely, I'd agree with that completely.”
Cohesion in Team Dynamics
20:55 to 23:17
Understanding the significance of team cohesion and its effects on performance.
“His changes to every starting 11 per game is under one, on average, obviously.”
Data-Driven Decisions in Coaching
23:17 to 24:49
Discussing the role of data in assessing player performance and making tactical decisions.
“And a lot of it comes down to the system as well.”
Scottish Premiership Title Race Analysis
25:51 to 28:01
A debate on the contenders for the Scottish Premiership title and team performances.
“I said, no, I'm going to stick with Hearts.”
Show all 25 chapters
Old Firm Pressure and Current Season Dynamics
28:01 to 30:06
Exploration of the pressures on Old Firm teams and their performance this season.
“Their style of play, I mean, even at the weekend against Celtic, the way the game panned out, I mean, Motherwell go to Celtic Park.”
Hearts’ Opportunity and Experience Impact
30:07 to 32:20
Discussion on Hearts' chance in the league and the importance of experience.
“But I just don't know which way it's going to go.”
Rangers’ Challenges and Managerial Pressure
32:21 to 34:29
Analysis of Rangers' current struggles and the expectations on their manager.
“but the importance of when we were in the Championship with Norwich the second time after we got relegated, because we had so many players who had done it before, we almost felt like, we'll do it.”
Celtic’s League Performance Concerns
34:30 to 36:49
Examination of Celtic's performance this season and potential flaws.
“It's OK if you're seeing games through at Ibrox against Celtic and 2-0 up and they win that.”
Reflections on Managerial Tenure
36:50 to 39:06
A former manager reflects on their experiences and lessons learned.
“literally been in there I think two weeks when I came in, new director of football, chief exec, new head of performance, new head coach, 14 new players.”
Choosing the Next Job: Criteria and Considerations
39:07 to 42:00
Discussion on the important factors in selecting future coaching positions.
“You will have, I'm guessing, quite a lot of different criteria to throw into the mix in choosing your next job.”
The Importance of Leadership in Football
42:00 to 43:00
Learn about the challenges faced by a football club after a key director's departure.
“So he was all involved, all encompassed in the football.”
Style of Play vs. Team Performance
43:00 to 44:00
Discover the impact of style of play on a team's chances of survival in the Premier League.
“But then we'll get back on the horse and we'll try and go again.”
Chelsea's £10 Million Fine: A Historical Context
44:00 to 45:00
Uncover the details behind Chelsea's record fine and its implications.
“Liam Rossini had to end up talking today about Chelsea's£10 million fine and a suspended transfer ban after admitting making payments to unregistered agents and third parties.”
Examining Chelsea's Financial Breaches
45:00 to 46:20
Learn about the historical financial breaches that led to Chelsea's recent penalties.
“impermissible approaches to academy players between 2019 and 2022.”
The Broader Implications of Chelsea's Case
46:20 to 48:20
Discuss the potential widespread issues of financial misconduct in football.
“People could ask if Chelsea have gone off lightly, but I go back to the point that it'd be unfair, wouldn't it, to punish the current...”
Liam Rossini and the Chelsea Huddle Controversy
48:20 to 49:40
Explore the absurdity of the Chelsea huddle controversy and its media coverage.
“And should the Premier League not maybe have more of a grip on that?”
Referee's Role in Team Unity Rituals
49:40 to 51:00
Examine the role of referees during team huddles and the resulting discussions.
“But what we don't want to do is antagonise or bring more noise on ourselves and we'll make the decision on where we do that on the pitch tomorrow.”
Clay Pigeon Shooting Club Invitation
56:10 to 56:26
A light-hearted invitation to join a clay pigeon shooting club.
Story of a Super Bowl Streaker
56:52 to 57:14
A narrative about a man's adventure in streaking at the Super Bowl.
“Mark Roberts is too lively for his body.”
Transcript
Automatic transcript. May contain errors.0:00Dale Johnson:This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.
0:30Dale Johnson:the highest B2B return on ad spend of major ad networks. Spend$250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn ads and get$250 credit for the next one. Just go to linkedin.com slash broadcast. That's linkedin.com slash broadcast. Terms and conditions apply. Today's episode is sponsored by Smart Travel, a podcast from NerdWallet. You know that one friend who always finds the best travel deals, picks the right credit cards, and somehow ends up in first class for the price of coach. Smart travel is like that friend, but in podcast form. Nerd Wallet's travel journalists sort out what's worth paying for, from lounge access to travel advisors to hotel loyalty programmes.
1:09Dale Johnson:Make your travel dollars work harder. Follow Smart Travel on your favourite podcast app. This is the Monday Night Club with Mark Chapman on the Football Daily Podcast.
1:26Welcome to the Monday Night Club with us this evening. Chris Sutton, Rory Smith and Russell Martin. And when we spoke about the possibility of you coming and doing some radio, when I said, would you come on the Monday Night Club, I most definitely expected you to say no because of one person in particular. But you... And I don't mean... Who would that be? Who would that be? Well, not Rory. You never know. And you said yes. So welcome. Thank you very much for coming on. I like Chris. He's a good guy. I don't know why Chappers would think we'd have a problem, Chris, but I'm very happy to be here.
2:00Chris Sutton:Yeah, that's amazing for you, Mark, to actually think that would be the case. What's wrong with me? You tell me, what is wrong with me? We don't have time. Or is that a whole new show? I think it's me, Mark. It's not. It's definitely him. The other thing was, he said to me earlier, Chris, he said, if I ask Russell any questions, he said, I don't want to come across like, and then I can't say the word that he said, I don't want to come across like an idiot. So my first response was, well, it hasn't really bothered you for the last decade. The second point being, so we've got a system, Rory, that if he is coming across like an idiot, I have to WhatsApp him.
2:42Okay, so feel free to follow the same method if you'd like to. Yeah, I mean, I like to offer Chris like a running critique of his performance in every show anyway, to be honest. if that seems wise we should probably have done that before Chappers I know yeah we should have done that a long time ago I don't know why we haven't come up with that before do you go back to Norwich days with him then he was there way before yeah I know way before you you're reminded of his legacy everywhere he's got pictures up in the wall in the stadium in the training ground I think he might even have a brick actually you're in the Hall of Fame Chris yeah you are I'm not I've played 300 times I'm not no captain for six of them but still not
3:16Chris Sutton:yeah that's amazing Well, we'll sort that out. No, I'm fine with it. I'm over it. I'm over it a long time ago. How many times did you play for Norwich? 130-odd. Oh, right. Did you captain them? No, I didn't. You have been stuffed there, haven't you? Well, he was much better than I. Oh, yeah. Right. Well, this is all lovely, isn't it, at the moment? We have a lot to get through. Manchester United's midfield. What's going on? Chelsea, we will deal with that. You may have just heard that in the news, but we'll look at Chelsea both on and off the field as well. We'll look at the title race in Scotland.
3:56We'll talk to Russell exactly about what he is up to at the moment and what his plans are going forward. And we'll keep you up to date with the football that is going on this evening. And we'll look ahead to those Champions League games that are coming up this week on Five Live. But we start with Arsenal and with Max Darman, who rescued Arsenal basically on Saturday tea time. and by the end of the weekend it'd help them go nine points clear at the top of the table. Do you think it's the kind of thing that can change a feeling around the place? I think so. Watching the celebrations at the end. I think the manner of the win as well but then the fact that such a young guy is such a brilliant story.
4:35It's just like a release. You could feel it from their players, from their fans because they have been edgy the last. And I think also the Man City result afterwards helps as well. I think there'll be a completely different feeling this week. But again, it can change the mentality again now because it is theirs to lose. I think everyone would be in agreement with that. But he's a top, top player. He's a top young talent. And the goal was brilliant. It was a brilliant way to finish the game. So I think they'll be feeling very good about themselves this week. Because, I don't know, you tell me, Chris, would it have been different if he'd have, say, brought Gabriel Jesus on and it had been rescued in that way?
5:10I mean, there would still be euphoria. But I wonder if this euphoria times 10.
5:15Chris Sutton:Yeah, but fans, as Russell said, fans love that. The Arsenal fans love that, you know, one of their own through the academy. And, you know, what was not fascinating about the whole thing, but what was nice about the whole thing is that, you know, he was thrown on the pitch on merit. It wasn't one where you often see managers give young players an opportunity to get a pat on the back and say, well, we're developing our players. We're trying to do it the right way as a club. Arsenal are in the thick of a title race. And he has the faith on a young 16-year-old to throw him on it and make a difference.
5:54Chris Sutton:So they're on merit, made the difference. And yeah, as Russell said, then the Manchester City result. I mean, it looks like it's Arsenal's title and people will remember, you know, Saturday night for what happened to Max Doman. Given the pressure, given the situation, with your managerial hat on, how impressive a decision is that from Mikel Arteta? Look, I know he's talented, but it's nil-nil in a title race and there are more experienced players there. I think it shows how secure the manager is in his position, where he sits in the club, where the team is at, where he feels the team is at. Also, it was so tense, you could feel it just watching it on the TV, that actually bringing someone on with, it's like a win-win for Max Dalman.
6:45He gets more minutes on the pitch, the game was how it was. So, see the game out, brilliant. Have a contribution like he did, which will be iconic, I'm pretty sure. Like Chris just said, it'll be one of the moments of the season for Arsenal. if they become champions. So I think the position he's in, being there, it seems so brave. But when you see him every day and you hear Arteta talk about him after and the talent he possesses, and also when the players are so young, it's the same as Rio watching him for Liverpool yesterday. When they're so young, there's no scar tissue. So he can come on and just play free, play with freedom in the position Arsenal are in.
7:16So actually, I think it's brilliant management, but probably less risk than people would associate at the time.
7:22Chris Sutton:I don't think Mark Russell, he would have thought about his age in that moment because of the fact that, you know, he would have trained a lot of times with the first team. He would have known what talent he is. Well, he's a kind of first-team squad player, isn't he, really? Yeah, it's his attributes and his mentality at that point, for sure. Yeah, absolutely. So, you know, there's nothing about age. You wouldn't have looked at him and thought, oh, he's just 60. You know, that didn't come into play in his thought process. He was simply thinking about a spark which could change the game, and that's what he did.
7:55And Joe Hart said on Match of the Day, Arteta is bringing him on because he believes he is going to change the game. He's not in this to win awards or say, I was the one to bring Max Daman on. He couldn't care less if he was 16 or 66. He was bringing him on to win the game, at which point Kelly said to him, if he was 66, he wouldn't be being brought on to win the game, which was a very fair point. just that sense of having a different story other than just the you know that kind of grind to get to the title it's now kind of there's something about you having a young player that that fills a fan base with excitement regardless and when it's someone as talented as downman that is that that is kind of magnified but the other thing i think that needs to be said is that i think arteta's handled him really really well you know they gave him that first it's almost like they confronted the hype around him in the summer and he was in a couple of matchday squads and he played a couple of games and he kind of, they got that out of the system almost and then he had, obviously there's been an injury but Arteta's taken it quite slow since then and I think it's been quite smart.
8:54Chris Sutton:What do you mean they got that out of the system? What do you mean by that? Well, I think when you've got a player, I mean, I first heard Max Downman's name and Chris and Russell, you probably would have been quicker than me but his name's been around for a couple of years. Like people have been saying that Arsenal got a kid in the system for a long time and I think the fan base were probably expecting this to be the year that he would come through and then obviously he's kind of in the, they know he's training with the first team squad and you then hear you know stories or suggestions that the players themselves are really impressed by his ability I think it creates this kind of buzz around him which you can either shrink away from a little bit and think okay we need to protect him from this entirely or you can kind of expose him to it in stages because he doesn't have to confront it at some point and I think Arsenal have handled that really smartly so that now he's he's had chance to develop physically a bit he'll have been training with the first team for about nine months now.
9:46And I think that means that when he does kind of start to get minutes in the Premier League, you end up with a player who's maybe much more ready for it than he would have been had they thrown him in straight away or if they'd waited too much longer.
10:00Chris Sutton:I don't necessarily agree with that because it's, you know, you're sort of saying, well, you know, they bludded him earlier on in games and were waiting for this moment. I suspect it was just a case that it felt like the right time. But, you know, the right time could have been three months ago had Mikel Arteta seen it that way. I don't necessarily think that, you know, they waited for this particular moment and that was part of the plan. I think, you know, from Mikel Arteta's position, he's just thinking about winning games and the best way to, you know, to win games and the biggest influence off the bench in that moment.
10:37Chris Sutton:You know, we're going to throw him on and see what he does. No, but the interesting point, I suppose, that Rory makes, is a lot of clubs will have a kid in their academy or under-18s or under-21s that there is a buzz about. It doesn't matter whether you're in the Premier League, the Scottish Premiership, Championship, maybe League One. And Michael Carrick was asked about one of the kids in the Manchester United youth team pre-match, I think, or in the build-up to the Aston Villa game. It's how the club as a whole deals with that buzz. I mean, you must have gone into virtually every club you've been at and being told on the day you arrived, oh, there's a kid in the academy?
11:17Yeah, we had it with Tyler Dibblin at Southampton, just like a recent example for us. So for the first year I was there, we were told he's nearly ready. He's physically, he's fantastic. He's an excellent player. So he trained with us pretty much every day. Sam Ammo now is at Strasbourg as well, the same. Jadon McGommer actually took to the Rangers with me. We were training. They were 16, all of them. But it is about the right time. And with Tyler, we just always felt Sam Ammo actually played some games with us early on and did really well. And then it's about the depth of the squad. It's about the players who play in their position.
11:47You can be really unlucky as a young player if you're a really exceptional talent, but there's no pathway for you because the two players they have in your position are outstanding. It all depends. So much of it is circumstantial, but like Chris said earlier, you have to be ready to take your opportunity. So the boxes they'll be looking to tick are physically, can you do it? And at 16, it's really difficult. So training with the first team from the age of 15, 16 helps a lot because you get a bit more used to the speed. Technically, tactically, Tackley will always be stuff as a young lad. You need to improve.
12:14But technically, you're there for the reason they believe you can train with the first team, so that's there. But it always comes down to the mentality and the psychology of the player, the young player. Can they deal with being in the line at a club like Arsenal? For us with Tyler, it was can he deal playing in the team that needs to win to get promoted? So we played him in the cup games because we felt the options we had for the league. But it was always with the plan of next year, Tyler's going to be one of the main people. Then people have to trust you. So I'm sure that's been the case with Max.
12:41There'll be a plan, but then to stick to plans, and it's never a straight line with young players. Either there'll be moments where it fluctuates, maybe fatigue, injuries, you know, all this stuff comes into it. But it is about taking your opportunity at that moment. And he did the other day and it was brilliant. Manchester United, a third, six points clear of sixth after they beat Aston Villa 3-1 yesterday. Casemiro got the opener. Bruno Fernandes now has 16 Premier League assists for the season. and if you throw in Kobi Maynou as well that's a balanced Manchester United midfield isn't it Chris?
13:18Chris Sutton:Yes it's balanced I don't think there's any I think we all expected when Bruno Fernandes was played in his best position that naturally you'd get the best out of him and that's what that's what has happened I mean it is the staggering you know thinking how Ruben Ambrin played him and you know as one of the two in the central midfield area. And now he's playing up one, has that insurance of Casemiro and Maynou behind him that he's influencing games as we all expected him to. I think there is a nice natural balance to this United midfield. Carrick has found amazing success in putting players in positions that they're used to and that they like and where he can get the best out of them.
14:02He's made it look quite simple. I'm sure it isn't, but he's made it look that way. Has he? Definitely, definitely. So there's more balance. As Chris said, Bruno's actually playing in a position where he can affect games now and he has more of a free role. Kobe Manu and Casemiro play much closer together now. So there's way more like a central progression with the ball. And it's something that Michael and his mid-advert team are very good at, was overloading midfield, playing, trying to hurt teams through the middle of the pitch. Kobe Manu's very progressive. Casemiro the same. Bruno roams a little bit and then can join him with a press where he's much freer to go and actually affect the opposition again.
14:37I still think sometimes the two of them get left alone a little bit. When Bruno does jump and go and press, they can get left alone out of possession. But in possession with the ball, the team looks so much more balanced. And I think Kobe Maynard, actually every week now, I see him getting more confident, playing his way back in, being a bit more progressive. He can run past players with a ball. But they're always looking now. That's the difference, I think. They're always looking. And before, there was two of them in the middle of the pitch, whoever it was, and very often just looked completely like there was the gap between the middle of the pitch for them and the rest of the team was huge.
15:04And now, just much more solid and much more fluid. So when you look at it tactically like that, was Casemiro hung out to dry a little bit? Yeah, I think so. If you look at what he brings and the experience, but there are going to be limitations physically, out of possession a lot for sure. So when he is playing, it's just one of the two. It's very difficult. Now actually, mind you, with Ahmad and Kuna as well, have five players in the middle of the pitch a lot. They roll inside and really try and overload. So by default, when you lose the ball, there's a lot more players around Casemiro than there were before.
15:36Way more. So, one, they control the ball a bit more. I think they're better with it. And now, out of possession, they have a few more bodies around it that help protect those guys for sure. What would you do, Chris, with Casemiro going forward? Because that seems to be the big debate at the moment.
15:52Chris Sutton:Yeah, I don't really get the debate, really. I think he's... I think that under Amrim, he was really exposed. I think under Carrick I think all his numbers have improved his performance level has improved under Carrick but so has the Manchester United team but I think this is a bit the sentimental guff as much as anything you know he's done okay but I do think he's had his day you know I do and if Manchester United want to really move forward you know as a club Casemiro isn't the future you know for that you know he's just absolutely not he's been a great player you know you give your right arm to have a career like him but you know he's just it comes to us all he just doesn't have the you know the legs which he once had and if Manchester United want to move to that next level and they're doing pretty well you know they're doing okay under Michael Carrick with Casemiro in the team but yeah he's not for next season I just think yeah on the pitch definitely his role will probably reduce and become smaller it should do at his age but with Manchester United for years now we've been talking about a lack of leadership lack of cultural like architects if you like strength and that so if they see huge value in him there to help the young players like Kobe Manu and guys like that the players that are going to come through so they have a lot of talented young players then maybe he's worth keeping around but then maybe he's not very happy with that role maybe he wants to go and enjoy the sun somewhere he doesn't want to be in rainy Manchester all the time the career he's had and not playing every week so there's so much that comes into it I think you make decisions as a club is he going to help us on the pitch a huge amount next year if he's not can he help us off it but who knows what the discussions have been he probably wouldn't want to be or he'd want £350 ,000 a week or something like that and just to be good in the dressing room yeah it's good money for a cheerleader I doubt they'd pay that well I won't I won't say I won't say anything sarcastic there go on Rory I was going to say I think I think the other thing that you have to factor in with Casemiro is that this season, the way it's panned out with United being out of both cups and not in Europe, is ideal for a player of his age.
18:08They're not playing that frequently. I think, was it 11 days before this game? Then they've got Bournemouth on Friday and they've got another big long break. It will be different next season when they're in the Champions League and hopefully they go further in both domestic cups. but then I do think Russell's right that it's it's one of those where you wonder if they might say to him look is there a point where the money and the game time is right because he would be a valuable person to have around the club it might be that he thinks right this is my last chance to move I need I can go to Saudi I can go to MLS I can go you know wherever it might be Italy and get a big contract or you know a big-ish contract and that is and you know enjoy the sunshine be a bit warmer kind of have another stage in my career that that makes perfect sense that's his it's prerogative but I think United would be losing something if Casemiro is allowed to walk away at the end of the season and I can see why they would want to maybe keep him around now more than they did maybe six months ago.
19:02I think Gary Neville said yesterday Russell that that he doesn't think he should be kept on and moved on but that United are going to need at least two more midfielders this summer to bring in in terms of a an enforcer type all action type and also in terms of a creative type. Definitely, I'd agree with that completely. I think they've got one of the best players in the Premier League in Bruno Fernandes. I really believe that. I think, and considering he's not played in what you would regard as a top team for the last few years. We know it's a top club, they haven't performed like a top team but his ability and his performance level and his consistency levels and he's just an outstanding player and they need more like that.
19:45For sure, at least, if you look at the midfield the way they want to play, Maybe they'll go somewhere else in terms of the manager and stuff like that. But they'll need to really compete. They need some more depth than they've got. Do you think he's got the credit he has deserved over the years, Bruno Fernandes? And when you've played against him, when your teams have played against him, how have you set up to deal with him?
20:08You hate playing against him. He's always in the ref's ear. He's screaming and shouting at everyone. But I think he's one of them you love in your team. He's a winner. He's a fighter. he'll take the ball anywhere I think that's the best bit about him you can give him the ball anywhere and he'll look after it or he'll want the ball regardless of the situation so I think he leads in a very different way to like your archetypal leader he leads by example he wants the ball he wants to make things happen I think we've just discussed their midfield day and we really didn't speak about how good he was it was about Casemiro and Kobe Maino coming back but he is an outstanding player and I'm sure he'll want to see outstanding players be brought in and around him that can feed him the ball more often The one final thing in all of this is that Michael Carrick has basically played the same team ever since taking over.
20:52There's been the odd change because of injury. There's been either Sesko in or Ahmad in. His changes to every starting 11 per game is under one, on average, obviously. And Amarim's was over two on average. I suppose you would say, would you, that he has the luxury at the moment of being able to keep a settled team because the games are not few and far between, but it's one a week. I think, yeah, it's a slightly different circumstance, but also cohesion is so important. It never felt really under Ruben. The team didn't feel like the relationships had built. There was a lot of change. There was people playing or a formation and a system that was stuck to regardless of the personnel and how much it suited the personnel.
21:37So he's playing a formation that suits the personnel much better. He's got people playing in their positions and actually giving people time to build some relationships, which only helps. If you think about Man City this year, the amount of change their team has had, new players trying to integrate them, that's definitely hurt the team in terms of cohesion and relationships and consistency. Liverpool as well. Liverpool is exactly the same. And then you look at teams like Villa who, when their strongest XI is out, they've played together a long time. But then you take out a couple of players with injury, Telemans when John McGinn doesn't play, they're not quite the same because they haven't got the depth of a Man City or a Liverpool.
22:09But cohesion is so, I think, undervalued and actually underestimated And it probably is not as easily evidenced or tangible for people outside of the club. So in the club, you get scores based on relationships and how productive certain people are playing together on next to each other, how many points you've got when certain players are playing in the team together. So all of that is at your disposal. You'd have that, would you? If you clicked right back and right centre half, every time they played... I've always asked for it, yeah, because I think it's important to understand, because your eyes and your bias can sometimes lie to you.
22:44So I think as a head coach, it's really important to have all of the data and the evidence you can possibly muster. So if you look at centre-half partnerships throughout the years and how important they've been to teams and the number six, now the two midfielders at Manchester United, how close they play together and all of this, it's so important. And actually, when I look back recently when I went to Rangers, expecting if we did a cohesion score there, it would have been really, really low because there's so many new players, a new style of play, people that haven't played together very much.
23:13And four weeks into a preseason, we got to play in a Champions League qualifier. So it's really difficult to build a level of cohesion and understanding within that. So Michael's done that. And a lot of it comes down to the system as well. He's gone, this is how we're going to play. This is what we're looking for. And as a coach, when you have clarity in what you were looking for, it's much easier than to stick with something and actually build some relationships. I find that really interesting on the cohesion thing. Can that also drive you mad the other way? So let's say you took, for argument's sake, the United cohesion here, and you took Bruno and looked at his cohesion.
23:46Bruno's a wrong example because he's obviously United's talisman. But, I don't know, you looked at a midfielder and his relationship with the other two midfielders behind him, and that's all great. But then you look further forward, and his relationship with your number one striker is nowhere near as good, but it might be better with your number two striker. You could drive yourself mad depending on where you're looking. And then it becomes like, yeah, and then it's circumstantial because maybe the number two striker comes on when the number one striker's beating up the defender's number two striker scores.
Read the full transcript
24:15He's on for 10 minutes and you're chasing the game. So I think it's never to be led by it, but to be informed enough to be able to make decisions. And also certain players, like, I would have a feeling about someone being more effective on the left side, but actually they're better on the right side than they are on the left. But they're a bit more exciting playing. We had a winger, a right-footed winger at one of my clubs where I thought on the left he looked so dangerous, on the right it was less effective. And then we looked at the data, it was way more productive on the right side. He just doesn't go past people as much because he wants to cross early.
24:43So it's interesting. So I think that to inform you, and also you need to know what you're looking for. Maybe Ruben would judge Fernandes' performance way different to Michael would. What's important to one manager is very different to another. So I think you have to be really clear on what you're measuring performance as well.
25:00Dale Johnson:From a small village on the banks of the River Nile... Everybody call me Mohamed, but, you know, short name or nickname, they call me Mo. ...to the biggest stages of world football. Goes for the corner! Mo Salah! Salah is more than just a player. He's an icon, a symbol, a king. It's 6-0! And Salah rips off his shirt! Mohamed Salah represents a dream for Egyptians, for Muslims, for Africans. More than just a football player, he gave us hope. I'm Kelly Cates. This is Sporting Giant's Mo Salah. Listen on BBC Sounds. This is the Monday Night Club with Mark Chapman. On the Football Daily Podcast.
25:47Russell Martin, Chris Sutton, Rory Smith on the Monday Night Club. Who's going to win the Scottish Premiership title, Chris? Well, I don't know. Not a clue.
25:55Chris Sutton:I said, no, I'm going to stick with Hearts. I'm going to stick with Hearts. They had their blip against Kilmarnock at the weekend. I mean, you can lose to Kilmarnock. Hearts didn't start the game particularly well. The reason I'm going to stick with Hearts is my sources are telling me Shankland's not far away, Lauren Shankland and Cammie Devlin, and they've missed Shankland, especially at the top end of the pitch. and I think everybody will beat everybody else from now until the end of the season, especially after the split. I just think that's going to happen. If you look at the goal difference with the, I mean, I think Motherwell are out of it now.
26:34Chris Sutton:Celtic beat them at the weekend and then they lost to Dundee the previous week, but the goal difference is all pretty tight. So I'm going to say, yeah, still Hearts. Let me give you the table. Hearts 63, Celtic 61, Rangers 60, Motherwell now on 53. there is virtually nothing in the goal difference either. Hearts and Rangers have the same goal difference. Celtic, three worse off. They're 24. Hearts and Rangers are 27. I genuinely don't know how you're going to answer this. How do you view it? I don't know. Whatever I say now will get sensationalised tomorrow morning in the Scottish papers. So I'm going to sit on the fence.
27:09What I would say is, I think Derek McKinnis and Hearts have had an amazing season. I think that Celtic fans and Rangers fans will consider themselves very lucky that they're still in with a title chance, considering they both feel they've had really poor seasons. One of them's all my fault, obviously. But apart from that, I generally think it's such an interesting season. I think the heart's shaking it up a little bit. It's been really good. I don't know if you agree, Chris, but I think it's good for Scottish football as a whole. When people are talking about it way more, mother well, the way that they've played and approached it differently under Jens, it's brought a bit of interest and the level of excitement about it.
27:45I don't think it's been there for a while. And yeah, people would say it's because the old firm haven't quite been at the level they've used to been at, especially Celtic over the last few years. But the emergence of Motherwell and Hearts this season, I think it's been really good for the game up there.
27:57Chris Sutton:Yeah, absolutely. Motherwell, we've spoken about many times. Their style of play, I mean, even at the weekend against Celtic, the way the game panned out, I mean, Motherwell go to Celtic Park. They edged the possession as one all, and then Celtic, it was a penalty and a red card. I do think that when Dazer Maeda would have headed the ball in. And Celtic, I mean, the remarkable thing about Celtic under Martin O 'Neill is they just keep finding a way to win Russell. And they're not playing good football at all. It's not like a Celtic team of previous seasons where they play teams off the park, dominate possession, dominate every area.
28:39Chris Sutton:it's been a real struggle for them so which is why it's fascinating and Rangers have sort of they're not a particularly good watch either but they've found a way to get over the line especially recently and even the game at the weekend against St Mirren a poor St Mirren team Rangers 1-0 up at half time and then it's a heavy weather of it and that's the story of the season which is why it will go down to the wire The easy thing for someone down south to say Russell is that the pressure has to be on Hart because they've led for so long. But that doesn't take into account that the pressure is always on the old firm, presumably.
29:17Oh, yeah, because it's so close. And then there's pressure on the old firm always. Chris knows this, no matter what the situation, no matter what the game. But I know it sounds crazy, but I do think Hart's have less pressure than the other two right now. I think maybe because of the season they've had and they've been up there for so long, people say, oh, no, the pressure's all on them. but I think they can probably play on the underdog thing from now to the end of the season. I don't know, maybe Derek's playing it the other way and no, we've been here for a long time, we deserve to be here so we need to stay here.
29:45Also, maybe there's a bit of the psychology of, well, no one expected this apart from us so we'll keep surprising everyone. And that's what I meant. The old firm both have a chance to win the league and the fans have been so frustrated and disappointed with their seasons. So it's a really interesting and unique season and I really don't know which way it's going to go. as well as I don't want to be all over the papers in the morning up there. But I just don't know which way it's going to go. I really don't because each week it sort of changes. And like Chris said, no one's really in flow. There doesn't seem to be a team that's really playing at the peak of their powers.
30:19So it's an eight-game season and it's going to be really, really exciting. I think there's a lot of twists and turns and you could easily see it going to either one of those teams. Rory, are you looking quizzical? Yeah, that's my natural resting face. Yeah, I think it's, my instinct is the same as Russell is alluding to, which is that you do think basically Harts will be under pressure because they've got less experience of being there. It's, you know, 40 years since anyone not Celtic and Rangers won the title. It's even longer for Harts. There'll be nervousness at Tynecastle. They know this is an opportunity.
30:54But then the pressure that both Celtic and Rangers operate under all of the time is probably just as oppressive in the wrong moments because both of those clubs now will think, well, we could win this because the other one's not very good. And I still don't know to what extent either of them are really thinking about, well, hearts are the favourites, especially now that the gap has closed because they regard themselves as favourites. I think, to be slightly careful, I don't want to say anything offensive to Russell about Rangers in any way, but I wonder whether that kind of applies to Rangers.
31:23I've heard it all, mate. You crack on. You're fine. I'm literally can't offend me anymore about this, so it's fine. but Rangers, I wonder whether they've not really done it. Don't take that as a challenge, Chris, by the way. By the way, I lost one league game. We didn't win in that, but we lost one. But how many of that Rangers squad have been in this position? I was going to say that. In Scotland? Martin O 'Neill and Sean Maloney have been there, won it between them so many times and Callum McGregor and the Celtic guys having had the experience of winning it, I think it could be really, really important.
31:57I think that in the Championship as well, I still think, part of me thinks Ipswich will do it because of the experience of Kieran doing it and the players that have. What, overhaul Coventry? No, I think that's a second. Or just get into it, yeah. I think Middlesbrough are fantastic and I've enjoyed watching them probably more than anyone in the Championship this year. Look at my sidetrack to the Championship away from the SBI. But no, it was unintentional. But genuinely, I think the experience, and Chris will know because he's won more than all of us put together, but the importance of when we were in the Championship with Norwich the second time after we got relegated, because we had so many players who had done it before, we almost felt like, we'll do it.
32:31We know what it takes. When it comes, the other teams, they'll start feeling it a bit more. And we've been there, we've done it, we know what it takes. And I think if you have that in your building, which Celtic do in an abundance, maybe it gives you a little bit of edge. Maybe it does. Maybe, Chris, there's actually less pressure on Martin O 'Neill in all of this.
32:47Chris Sutton:Well, I think that's the biggest point. Celtic fans, their direction of anger, that will not be in Martin O 'Neill's. Whatever happens. They won't be pointing to Martin O 'Neill as the reason. And from Hearts, I think Hearts are really difficult to measure because I know it's so easy to just say, well, they haven't been there for 40 years, whatever it is. So the pressure's off. I don't necessarily think it is amongst the Hearts fan base. You see the manager, Derek McInnes, in recent weeks, he seems to be getting a bit uptight. So I think that maybe he's feeling the pressure a little bit. But I still think that Hearts, all season, they've found a way to win games.
33:41Chris Sutton:They're not a beautiful football team. Derek McInnes' teams have never been essentially beautiful, but they are well-structured. he knows what he's doing Derek McInnes does in the way that he sets his team up he knows the Scottish League inside out Danny Roll at Rangers I think he's had too much to say for himself in recent times I think the defeat against Celtic in the Cup was I know you're shaking your head I'm just telling you Danny Roll opened his mouth and was telling Celtic how they should have played in Europe and this is coming from a guy whose record in Europe was pretty down And I think Rangers fans, actually, that's sort of ramped up the pressure on Danny Roll, because I think Rangers fans are thinking, why don't you just keep your mouth shut, Danny?
34:26Chris Sutton:Why are you getting involved in telling Martin O 'Neill how he should play? And it's OK. It's OK if you're seeing games through at Ibrox against Celtic and 2-0 up and they win that. It's OK if you knock Celtic out of the cup. But he didn't. And in many respects, people are thinking, well, Danny Roll's eye has been taken off the ball. So, you know, the pressure sort of ranked up on Rangers as well now. Is there a risk that if Celtic do win it, it kind of papers over some fairly glaring cracks? Yeah, I mean, if Celtic win the league this season, they'd have done it without a centre forward. Think about that.
35:03Chris Sutton:You know, I think Celtic have used five different centre forwards. And, I mean, in recent times, Martin O 'Neill's making a substitution at half time, changing, you know, changing that position. I mean, that's pretty incredible in itself. if you look at the number of goals, I think Celtic were 112 goals last season, something like that. I don't know if they've got this, 58, whatever it is, this season. Numbers-wise, they are massively down to what they were last season. And it's staggering. And there will be, I think, a thought process if Celtic do get over the line this season. I mean, I think they'll be laughing at the opposition, really, because it's been a poor Celtic side, in truth.
35:49How do you reflect on your time there, now, sitting here? I don't regret anything. I think I've learned a lot. I'll definitely be better for it. I love Glasgow as a city. I love living there. The people face-to-face were fantastic. And I think it was character building. It was really, do you know what? it was really difficult for the people around me. So family, friends, genuinely, like when my kids came up, they couldn't come to the game because of the level of abuse I was receiving at that point, and it was quite early on. But like when you look back at it, you learn from everything, right? So there's stuff that you would do differently.
36:36There's stuff that you would insist on maybe doing the same and maybe even going even more, being even stronger with that. but I think it's probably, there was so much change. So I walked into the club at a time of new owners, literally been in there I think two weeks when I came in, new director of football, chief exec, new head of performance, new head coach, 14 new players. So I think I, and I tried to stress a lot that it probably would take some time. So that's my fault because I was in a place where historically and traditionally you don't really have time. So I don't like, I don't feel bitter about it at all.
37:14Do you feel hurt? I'd have loved the time to have built something and I felt that was what the club needed was a bit of that. But the owners decided differently and they made a decision. And also, I was frustrated. I think the biggest thing I am from that is probably frustration. There was so many small things that we could have probably done a little bit better and just taken more... I should have been a bit more rigid with formation and certain principles, really. And I sort of tried to bend and flex to fit the newness of the group. And we had so many young players that we brought into the club.
37:54And it's not excuses. We should have done a better job than we did. And we should have won more games. But we felt like we were going to get somewhere with it. But we had so many young players that had just come in. And Chris will tell you, it's such a unique environment playing for Rangers or Celtic. The level of expectation. So take people like Manny Fernandes from Peterborough, going from Peterborough in League One to Rangers and playing in front of that crowd all of a sudden. It's a completely different experience. And he's flying now. Yeah, and he's been brilliant. And Kevin Fell, Dan Purdy, and myself, and we sat down and we wanted to sign.
38:26We saw the match boots, but we also knew he might not play in the first couple of months. It maybe takes some time to get to that point. Mike, him all the same. Outrageous talent, amazing kid. We signed him because he really wanted to be part of that and experience something big. and then you get on the pitch the first few games because we just spoke about Max Downman at Spurs. He was the guy that'd come off the bench, maybe make something happen, and then he was coming to Rangers and now you need to be the guy that makes something happen. And for us, I'm trying to work out the best way to do that in that team.
38:53And it's no surprise to me that he's gone on and done brilliantly. So yeah, there's loads of frustration for me as a coach and a manager and a leader, but ultimately it's always your fault, the manager. So it's my fault. It's my fault I didn't do well enough and you learn from it and I'll be better for it for sure. How crucial is your choice of next job? You will have, I'm guessing, quite a lot of different criteria to throw into the mix in choosing your next job. I think so, yeah. I've turned a few things down since I left Rangers. And partly because I have to... Football's so quick to move on.
39:30So your stock can go from so high to so low so quickly. So I think for me, and also probably I'm pretty much a yes or a no straight away for a club owner or a director of football because of the way I play. Or I want the team to play. So some will go, it doesn't fit us. We don't want that. And then the ones that maybe do, you really need to check if they really want it. Does that make sense if you really want this? Because it might not be instant, but if you give us a little bit of time, the audience suggests we might do okay. So I think for me, yeah, it has to be. and also I went to MK Dons because of Pete the Gem and gave me the opportunity he was an incredible guy and was brave to appoint me I left to go to Swansea when I was so happy at MK because Swansea is one of the clubs I thought do we get an opportunity to go somewhere that is like aligned with us in terms of their ideal football and how they've been successful the way they got to the Premier League playing a certain way and then left Swansea when I was so happy there with the staff the players what we were building but for Jason Wilcox because he believed so much he was the director of football at Southampton who's now at Manchester United.
40:31He believes so much in a certain way. And when we spoke about football, I was like, OK, this is the guy I want to work with and now I'll go again. And then when he left to go to Manchester United, it changed a lot for me at Southampton. So the next one has to be about the people, I think, and what they really want and if we really see the same things and agree on what's important for their football club. And not just on the pitch, how they want the people to behave off the pitch, how they want it to feel. The way you want to play, I'm not... However you want to play is how you want to play, right?
41:00Do you think when you've seen what has happened to say Amarim's a prime example, and I'm only going to do it this way, I'm only going to do it this way, do you think you see that and become more flexible in your approach? Maybe you'll tell me there are flexibilities within your system. Yeah, so I think Ruben was wed to a formation, not particularly away, because I looked at the team and it looked very different a lot. So I've played lots of different formations. I'm not wed to a formation at all. I think that fits the players that you're in the building with. At MK, we played a three at the back because it fitted the players we had.
41:33At Swansea, the same the first year. Then we changed to a four because we recruited differently. At Southampton, they insisted on playing a 4-3-3. It was fine, but then to win the playoffs, we went to a back five. In the Premier League, we probably changed a bit too much, trying to be adaptable. But no, I think there's certain principles and concepts. Do you wish you'd left after you'd got promoted? Well, you look at it in hindsight, but I think, again, so we had a director of football in Jason that was fantastic and watched training every day. So if there was a question, he understood the process.
42:03We'd show him the team meetings. So he was all involved, all encompassed in the football. And then also he felt the culture, how he treated people. He was massive on that, behaviours, because he'd been at Man City for a long time in the academy and built certain things that were really important. So then when he left, I tried to stress to the club, we had this guy that you deemed really important as the director of football. He's now gone and we're going into the Premier League weaker without him. So we haven't replaced him. And when I was at the club, they hadn't replaced that role. So that was a frustration of mine.
42:32And then we got off on a new contract to say, look, if we go down, we're going to be, you know, we've got you, but we want to have the best, but you need to play some young players, but we need to try and stay up. So I felt like we did that. We played Mateusz Fernández, Tyler Diblin, some really talented young players, Taylor Harwood-Bellis. We signed Aaron Ramsdale, who's only available for a few games because he broke his finger and all that stuff. So my frustration then was like, well, I feel like we're doing okay. And actually we will pick up more points. And there's been a couple of games that are tough, But if we're going to say we're going to carry on doing it this way in the Premier League because it's going to be good for us, then there's certain games we will get beat and it might be quite heavy.
43:05But then we'll get back on the horse and we'll try and go again. We didn't pick up enough points. It was frustrating. But the narrative around it became in the building. The players were amazing. The staff were fantastic. They wanted to stay on path because they believed in it a lot. But the narrative became all about we're going down because of the style of play. Any other team in that position. So if you look at the teams right now that are in that position, the teams that when we were in the league, no one ever talks about style of play. They just go to the club, can't compete because they've just come up.
43:30The players aren't quite good enough. But with us, it was all about style of play because maybe they see sometimes the guys take a chance in the edge of the box early on in the season and make a mistake. But if you sit back and defend and try and fight and win that way and counter-attack, it's completely acceptable. So my job at that point was to try and protect the players as much as possible. Then I'm the one that gets sacked, which is fine because we didn't quite find a way. But I was frustrated with that. More hurt than I was at Rangers. Rangers was a bit more hurt. I didn't really have time to do anything.
43:58But with the Southampton one, I was hurt for quite a while. Liam Rossini had to end up talking today about Chelsea's£10 million fine and a suspended transfer ban after admitting making payments to unregistered agents and third parties. It's the largest fine ever handed out by the Premier League. BBC Sports Football Issues correspondent Dale Johnson is with us. And there is a sort of highlight, Liam Rossini, having to talk about it, is because these are historical. And actually, this is nothing to do with the current ownership or the current managerial regime.
44:29Dale Johnson:That's exactly it. And if it hadn't been a change of ownership to Blueco, we probably would never have found out that anything had been happened. And this was one of the things that was said in the ruling today that the new owners have been so open that there were a certain level of breaches whereby, if they'd launched an investigation, they would never have been able to uncover exactly what had gone on. So what's happened is that there's been two offences. On top of the one you mentioned, they also got found guilty of breaches in terms of making approaches, impermissible approaches to academy players between 2019 and 2022.
45:04Dale Johnson:They've got a nine-month ban for signing the academy players for that. But this is really the important one, the fact that they made£47.5 million worth of payments to those unlicensed agents over an eight-year period. And half of that was on a series of players who really were very important to them, like Eden Hazard, David Luiz, Ramirez, and Nemanja Matic. They played like multiple hundred games for them and helped Chelsea win trophies. But let's look at the Eden Hazard example. He was signed in 2012. Then from 2013 to 2016, Chelsea paid around£6.5 million to a company which was associated with the agents of the player.
45:45Dale Johnson:So you've got to ask, are Chelsea getting off really lightly whereby they're only getting a£10 million fine and they're only getting a suspended transfer ban when you've got one of the best players in the world or the most coveted players in the world in 2012. Then you find out that Chelsea are paying like£6.5 million over seven payments to this person. It's a difficult one, Rory, isn't it? because they've been... I'm not going to ask Russell about this. We've already asked Russell about it. Like Russell could take a break in, which is why I'm coming to you. Thanks. Yeah. People could ask if Chelsea have gone off lightly, but I go back to the point that it'd be unfair, wouldn't it, to punish the current...
46:31Would it be unfair to punish the current regime who highlighted it? I have a lot of sympathy for the Premier League here, actually. Well, yes and no on all of those things, Shackles. Right, OK. Yes, they self-reported, which is good. It's commendable sort of openness from Bluto. But no, because as Dale said, these signings made a material difference to Chelsea's performance for several years. I mean, Hazard, Ramirez, David Luiz, Willian, these are some of the biggest players in Chelsea's recent history. Who were also wanted by other clubs at the time. Willian, they famously took from Spurs, didn't they, at the last minute?
47:11And Hazard, do you remember the tweet? The Eden Hazard tweet? I'll tell you tomorrow or something, wasn't it? I'm signing for the Champions of Europe. It was one of the great early Twitter moments. And no one was quite sure. I'm not even sure his account was verified, and no one was sure if it was him or not. But lots of other teams were in for Hazard. I think Manchester United were. I suspect Tottenham word is whenever Chelsea sign a player. It tends to be sort of out of Tottenham's hands. That then impacts what Chelsea achieve. It affects how attractive the asset is that Bluto then buys. My instinct is that the fine is, I know it's the biggest in Premier League history, but it's pretty paltry, to be honest, for the scale of the offences.
47:51In terms of sympathy for the Premier League, yes, because you're having to unpick very complicated financial machinations of a now sanctioned individual. So, you know, it's a really complicated bit of sort of financial forensic work, I guess. But at the same time, I mean, if this is the bit that Chelsea have self-reported, and again, credit to Bluto and to the club for doing that, what other stuff is going on there, not just at Chelsea, but elsewhere? Like, who else is doing what? And should the Premier League not maybe have more of a grip on that? And I do wonder if there's a little bit of a missed opportunity in terms of kind of the sanction that if you don't play...
48:32This whole thing, and it's the same with PSR and SCR and City and all that other stuff, none of this really means anything if people aren't playing by the same rules. It's quite a worrying sign more broadly. Is there a sense that the Premier League draw a line under this then, Dale? Or are they looking elsewhere at things? And I suppose that maybe, having said, you know, it's got nothing to do with the current ownership, there may be owners of other clubs up and down the league who might say, well, hang on a minute, we've been punished for things that have gone on under previous, owners as well.
49:03Dale Johnson:I think as far as it's concerned it's a closed book now in terms of the two cases but I think Rory makes a really good point I mean if we're going to think that it's really just Chelsea that have been engaging in this type of payments to make sure they get star players I mean I'd be very surprised if there wasn't other clubs that do that type of thing because at the end of the day these clubs want to get these players ahead of everybody else and they clearly find a way to make sure that they choose their club. Dale thank you very much Dale Johnson with us BBC Sports Football Issues correspondent such is the nature of what managers have to talk about then nowadays Liam Rossini had to talk about that then had to talk about huddles I think in terms of the huddle I think it's been blown out of proportion to be honest this is small it's a small small thing amongst many many serious things that we need to address such as the massive game against PSG tomorrow in terms of the huddle the lads have always wanted to show unity and togetherness.
50:00Dale Johnson:I think they'll continue to do that. But what we don't want to do is antagonise or bring more noise on ourselves and we'll make the decision on where we do that on the pitch tomorrow. This is one of the weirdest things I can remember. I can't think of a story as ridiculous as this, to be honest. I keep a kind of semi-list of moments where I think football has got beyond itself with stupidity and on that list is, do you remember the bit where Gary Linick cancelled match of the day? But there's just bits where you sort of think, hang on, I can't really believe this thing is happening because it makes no sense and this is a really good nice pure example of it the whole thing is completely absurd I don't understand what Chelsea were trying to do I don't really understand why Paul Tierney stayed in the huddle could he not have engineered his way out of it I don't get the thing about respecting the ball I feel a bit like there's some deeper meaning to it that I'm too stupid to understand I'm with you Rory I think Paul Tierney should just get out of the way and then it's just not even, would anyone be speaking about it?
51:01If he'd, like, it was the maddest, when I was watching it and I saw Cole Palmer hug him, I thought, he's definitely going to get out now and he just stayed there. It was like, what is going on? But yeah, I just don't see it as a problem. If you were the opposition, because I know they first said they did it away in Napoli, didn't they? When they won. Then it seemed to become a thing when they were at Villa Park. That was the one that I remember, and they did it out of time on the centre circle. It's just the location that seems to have become a thing. Would you be bothered if you were the opposition?
51:38It depends. Also, it depends on the context of the teams. If you're a team that's really in a good place, I don't think it bothers you too much. If you're not, maybe it gets used by the manager as something to antagonise and use against the opposition. But I don't know. You've seen it in rugby for years. is I'm always interested in the response to the hacker. And I was going to start getting interested in the team's responses to Chelsea's huddle over the hook, but it seems the referees responded before any teams can. It's become an issue. So I think it's just... I'm with Liam, really. It's not really a massive thing.
52:12But it's been turned into it because, yeah, there'll be memes for years of Paul Tierney just standing in the middle of their huddle, won't they? I suppose there's a point where, like, if you're caught in a really weird situation, you do kind of freeze, don't you? You kind of like, I don't know what's happening here. Why are all these people doing there? He must have been warned about it pre-match to be in there, to say, this is what Chelsea do. Can we make sure that this? I don't know. Otherwise, I don't know why that's become a... It would be interesting to see if he'd been warned about it or to do something about it to try and make them move.
52:42I don't know.
52:43Chris Sutton:Yeah, I thought it was really, really weird, the whole thing. I mean, we used to do a huddle at Celtic. Where? Well, on the pitch, Mark. Yes, I know. Yes, I know. but what in your own half in the penalty area in the sense yeah just in her own half um and uh and it was just something which we did uh in truth as a player i i can't actually remember what anybody ever said in the huddle i wasn't i i wasn't i wasn't sort of focusing on it i i find the whole thing just truly remarkable i i don't i think liam rosinia i like him a lot i think he's a he's a really smart bloke uh i do but i think he then when he gets involved in sort of having to explain things like this and talking about uh you know the the players respecting the ball and uh and you know that the that brings unity and leadership and that's that's all important i don't i don't really understand you know it's it's sort of i wondered whether he was on the keynote speaking course i was on when you hear stuff like that it's just it's it's absolute nonsense it you know it really is i think huddles are are for show that that's that's what they are and if you're a player you know show it by by a recovery run show it by you know bailing your team out with a with a brilliant block or a brilliant bit of skill i don't i don't understand what it what it's really sort of uh all for the referee getting involved in that well he you know he he loves it and he does but i don't i don't necessarily blame him and when you you know you think about Liam Rossini, he was really angry, wasn't he, about Arsenal?
54:21Chris Sutton:In their warming up in their own half. Yeah, in their half. In their half. Why is he getting involved in stuff like that? If I was him, I would have just swatted that off, batted that off and said, you know, I'm not really that fussed. It just, it's not a great look for him. Do you think, Rory, from whatever reason why they decided to do it at the start, and maybe they won't care about this really, it has actually gone the other way and made it a bit of a laughingstock. I think people, do you know what happens? I just think people are really baffled by the entire thing. The one bit where I think the senior might be being slightly disingenuous is that I'm guessing the players didn't do it spontaneously.
55:06It sounds like it's a thing that he wants them to do, and he wants them to do it around the ball. No, he said it was their decision to do it, and he would go along with what the leaders of the group wanted. Well, I mean, yeah, I'm not sure. I suppose that means it's on the players, but I'm not sure it's a great look if you're swarming the referee. I mean, I don't think it was intimidating. Did they swarm the referee, though?
55:33Chris Sutton:He was just a Burke standing there, wasn't he? I mean, you know, what was he doing as well? but if you're going to respect everything, I mean, are they going to do it around a corner flag next time? Respect the corner flag, respect the goal. I mean, you can respect a lot of things, can't you? Well, yeah. No, I just, I think it's, surely at some point, someone's going to have, it is mad that someone's going to have to legislate for this now. No, they're not. Come on. They will. They'll have to be like, rule seven, subsection D, you're not allowed to huddle around any of the match officials. That's the natural outcome of it.
56:08Okay, I'll end it there. Chris runs a sort of former Norwich clay pigeon shooting club with him and Rule Fox. So maybe after tonight... I'm in. Yeah, you're in? Yeah, come in. Come along. There you go. Lovely to see you. Thank you very much, Russell. Thank you, Rory. Thank you, Chris. Well behaved, Christopher. Excellent. That's it for this episode. Next on the Football Daily Feed will be reaction to all the teams in Tuesday night's Champions League, including Manchester City against Real Madrid.
56:41Dale Johnson:I'm Rich Hall, and this is Sports Strangest Crimes presents Confessions of a Super Bowl Streaker. When people ask me what I do, I say to them, well, by day or by night. The story of one man's mission to conquer the holy grail of streaking the Super Bowl. Mark Roberts is too lively for his body. He's just like the entertainer. Mark pushes the boundaries of what is socially acceptable. No chance, Texas. It's really strict, but then the more I thought about it, the more I thought, hang on. What are you about? Sports Strangers Crimes presents Confessions of a Super Bowl Streaker. Listen on BBC Sounds.
57:23Dale Johnson:The best B2B marketing gets wasted on the wrong people. So when you want to reach the right professionals, use LinkedIn ads. LinkedIn has grown to a network of over 1 billion professionals, including 130 million decision makers. And that's where it stands apart from other ad buys. You can target your buyers by job title, industry, company role, seniority, skills, company revenue, so you can stop wasting budget on the wrong audience. It's why LinkedIn Ads generates the highest B2B return on ad spend of major ad networks. Spend$250 on your first campaign on LinkedIn Ads and get$250 credit for the next one.
57:58Dale Johnson:Just go to linkedin.com slash broadcast. That's linkedin.com slash broadcast. Terms and conditions apply. It's time your hard-earned money works harder for you. With the Wealthfront Cash Account, your uninvested cash can earn up to 3.95 % APY. That's a 0.65 % boost over an already high rate for three months, just for being a new client. Plus, free instant withdrawals to eligible accounts. Start today at Wealthfront.com. 3.3 % base APY via Program Banks as of January 30, 2026. It is representative variable, requires no minimum, and is earned on funds swept to Program Banks. boost up to$150 ,000.
58:30Dale Johnson:Cash account offered by Wealthfront Brokerage LLC member FINRA SIPC, not a bank.
From the publisher
Chris Sutton, Rory Smith and Russell Martin join Mark Chapman to discuss Arsenal edging closer to the Premier League title with a two-goal win over Everton as Max Dowman became the league's youngest ever goal scorer. They discuss Manchester United's improvements under Michael Carrick, Bruno Fernandes' excellent form and Casemiro's impact on the squad. Russell Martin reflects on his time in management with Southampton and Rangers, and predicts who will win the Scottish Premiership title. Plus, BBC Sport’s Football Issues correspondent Dale Johnson discusses Chelsea's record fine and suspended transfer ban.
Timecodes: 2:30 Max Dowman 16:26 Manchester United 24:20 Scottish Premiership 34:40 Russell Martin 42:45 Chelsea
5 Live UEFA Champions League commentaries this week: Tuesday 17th March - 8pm - Manchester City v Real Madrid - 5 Live Tuesday 17th March - 8pm - Arsenal v Bayer Leverkusen - 5 Sports Extra Wednesday 18th March - 5:30pm - Barcelona v Newcastle United - 5 Live Wednesday 18th March - 8pm - Liverpool v Galatasaray - 5 Live




