MNC: What next for West Ham and Tottenham?

25 May 2026 · 58 min · 27 chapters

Ask about this episode

Ask anything about it. ChatGPT or Claude reads this page and answers with the times it was said.

Connect VO and ask about every podcast you hear, including the moments you saved. Add to ChatGPT · Add to Claude

In short

Relegation fallout and next steps for West Ham and Tottenham, with debate over club structure, recruitment, stadium atmosphere, and football finance.

Guests (backgrounds)

Joe Hart (former England/Manchester City goalkeeper; played for top Premier League clubs including Spurs); Andros Townsend (former England/Wales winger; played in the Premier League and internationally); Rory Smith (football journalist, The Athletic); plus football finance expert Rob Wilson (specialist in club finances).

Key claims

  • West Ham’s relegation is framed as systemic: unclear ownership strategy, recruitment “executive-led” without a sporting-director structure, and spending without a coherent plan.
  • Tottenham’s 17th-place finish is attributed to bad decision-making (manager appointments), injury patterns, and questions about medical/training quality; club statements are seen as blame-shifting.
  • Rob Wilson: West Ham’s revenue doesn’t cover costs because transfer fees, wages, and transfer liabilities exceed income; relegation cuts revenue sharply and makes relegation clauses crucial.

Notable examples

  • West Ham’s Premier League “gift” of 14 years, Declan Rice sold for £105m, and Mateus Fernandes expected to be sold for profit.
  • Tottenham: Thomas Frank appointment failure; James Maddison’s comments on injuries; talk of Romero’s emotional red card incidents.
  • Finance: West Ham reported loss of £104m; £200m+ transfer liabilities; need £150–£180m transfer income to “keep heads above water.”

Written by AI. May contain mistakes. Listen to the episode to check what was said.

Chapters

Tap a time to open that second in VO

Reactions to Emotional Matches

1:38 to 3:08

Discussion on the emotional experiences at the Etihad and the impact of performances.

“You were at the Etihad, weren't you, Joe, yesterday?”

West Ham's Relegation Overview

3:08 to 4:30

Analysis of West Ham's relegation and comparison with Tottenham's situation.

“and we'll talk about Guardiola and Manchester City as well.”

Nuno Espirito Santo's Challenges

4:30 to 6:00

Evaluation of Nuno Espirito Santo's tenure and its effect on West Ham.

“And I think that probably has kind of obscured a little bit just how significant it is that West Ham have gone, how long they've been in the Premier League, the size of club that they are, the kind of imprint they leave.”

Financial Insights on West Ham

6:00 to 7:40

Review of West Ham's financial standing and the implications of their spending.

“But for it to happen how it did, obviously that Arsenal game, a lot relied on that.”

Ownership and Future of West Ham

7:40 to 9:20

Discussion on West Ham's ownership issues and their impact on club strategy.

“they have a manager to come in and not have to change everything.”

West Ham's Club Culture and Atmosphere

9:20 to 11:20

Exploration of the emotional culture within West Ham and its effects on performance.

“Chris free tonight and I know Chris's whole stance is that West Ham fans didn't appreciate David Moyes enough.”

Atmosphere at West Ham's London Stadium

14:05 to 18:09

Exploration of the impact of stadium atmosphere on team performance and fan experience.

West Ham's Club Identity Crisis

18:10 to 23:07

Discussion on West Ham's lack of identity and its implications for club performance and culture.

“and West Ham lost most of them because if Man City or Arsenal or Chelsea or whatever go to Upton Park, chances are they win.”

Financial Challenges Ahead for West Ham

23:08 to 28:00

Analysis of West Ham's financial situation and the implications of relegation.

Transfer Implications for Mateus Fernandes

28:00 to 28:24

Exploration of the financial impacts of Mateus Fernandes' transfer to Southampton.

“So I think Mateus Fernandes signed for£38 million from Southampton.”
Show all 27 chapters

Relegation Clauses in Contracts

28:24 to 28:48

Discussion on the significance of relegation clauses in player contracts and their implications.

Monday Night Club Introduction

30:32 to 31:07

Introduction of the panel discussing West Ham and Tottenham's current status.

“So here's the first ball of this series.”

Club Statements from West Ham and Spurs

31:07 to 31:45

Analysis of the recent statements issued by West Ham and Tottenham regarding transparency.

“West Ham issued a statement today saying that they will be honest and transparent with the fans going forward.”

Accountability in Football Management

31:45 to 33:36

Debate over accountability and blame within Tottenham's management and their performance.

“As part of that process, we discovered some uncomfortable truths.”

Injuries and Mismanagement at Spurs

33:36 to 34:45

Discussion on the recurring injury issues at Tottenham and the role of management.

“Well, a non-exec chairman means that he's the chairman but doesn't actually make any of the decisions.”

Quality of Medical Staff in Football

34:45 to 36:34

Examining the effectiveness and expertise of medical staff at football clubs, particularly Spurs.

“There's clearly an issue, I think James Madison said something about this yesterday, but there is clearly an issue in terms of injuries.”

Budget Allocation for Medical Departments

36:34 to 39:40

Exploration of the budget challenges faced by medical departments in football clubs.

“Because the only way I judge it, like I say, I stayed out of it.”

Player Attitude vs. Talent in Team Selection

39:40 to 42:00

Discussion on the importance of player character and attitude in team selection over pure talent.

“You see all these theories and sometimes that's rubbish.”

Tottenham's Managerial Dilemma

42:00 to 43:50

Discussion about Tottenham's long-term plans and managerial control issues.

Player Attitude vs. Talent

43:50 to 46:40

Exploration of the importance of player attitude and team culture.

“When the lifespan of a manager is one and a half to two years, you can't give full control to that manager now.”

Reflections on Joe Hart and Regrets

46:40 to 50:00

Joe reflects on Pep Guardiola's comments about Joe Hart and their professional history.

“And the hardest thing for me to watch when he has played for Tottenham in big moments, he's not been able to control his emotions.”

Career Reflections and Closure

50:00 to 54:20

Joe shares insights on how he found closure after his departure from Manchester City.

“And that's my only real experience with him.”

The Impact of Key Player Departures

54:20 to 56:01

Discussion on the emotional and practical impacts of key players leaving clubs.

“For the players in the squad, how difficult is it when somebody with so much impact at whatever the level may be moves on, Andros?”

Reflecting on Managerial Changes

56:01 to 57:35

Explore the emotional impact of managerial changes in football.

“You were at Celtic when Poster Coglu left, Joe.”

Shifting Dynamics in Premier League

57:36 to 58:46

Discuss the potential changes in the Premier League landscape.

“Guardiola has obviously reshaped City, the Premier League, English football.”

Anticipating the New Football Season

58:47 to 59:52

Look ahead to the upcoming football season and key team changes.

“I honestly, but I really want to hone in on yesterday, how special it was.”

Upcoming European Finals

59:53 to 1:00:06

Preview two major European finals featuring English clubs.

“Thanks to Joe, Andros and Rory, two European finals to bring you over the coming days.”
Hear the part that matters, and keep it.Open this episode in VO. Double tap your headphones to save a moment as you listen.
Get VO free

Transcript

Automatic transcript. May contain errors.

0:00This BBC podcast is supported by ads outside the UK.

0:30travel dollars work harder. Follow Smart Travel on your favorite podcast app.

1:00Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks. Guava and passion fruit flavors with mango pineapple flavored pearls. Yeah, that feels like summer before you even taste it. Funny how one small stop becomes the best part of the day. Start your summer rhythm with Starbucks. Try the new Tropical Butterfly Refresher from Starbucks.

1:25This is the Monday Night Club with Mark Chapman. on the Football Daily Podcast. Welcome to the Monday Night Club. Joe Hart, Andros Townsend, Rory Smith with us this evening. MNC at bbc.co.uk if you want to get in touch. You were at the Etihad, weren't you, Joe, yesterday? I was, yeah. Yeah, I was evening everyone. Were you in tears? I wasn't, no. But it was an emotional day. It was emotional. It was nice, you know. It was nice to be in a stadium where everyone was happy. Villa were happy. City fans were happy. New stand opened, obviously Pep going, John going, Bernardo going. Like I say, Villa were in great spirits.

2:07They couldn't believe that they managed to pull that performance out. It was funny talking to a few of their lads after saying sports science is a load of rubbish. But no, it was just a magical day, magical day. And the right send-off for some pretty special people. Do you think then that will change Villa's perspective next season and they'll look to go on the lash a bit more often and have sort of five-hour playing journeys and not as much sleep. There'll be a few people that will be not wanting that to happen because there's a lot of jobs off the back of that being the opposite. But no, they just got through.

2:40I could tell, actually, I spoke to Bernardo and John. John particularly, he said the more the game got closer, the less he actually wanted to be out there and focus in because he was that emotionally rattled from the outpour of love and support and attention they've got over recent weeks that it was difficult to perform and Villa fair play to them. It was a pretty standoffish game but Ollie Watkins really stepped up obviously going into a big summer. We'll talk more about the goodbyes from the Premier League a little bit later on and we'll talk about Guardiola and Manchester City as well. Over the last few weeks Andros has joined the Monday Night Club from Thailand from London last week when we were in the same time zone so that was lovely and this week you are?

3:24I'm in sunny LA. this week. You're in LA? It's 11am so yeah Honestly. One life Andros one life lad, live it Are you looking for a club? What are you doing? I holiday with the family before the World Cup starts so again a few weeks resting Very nice. So Thailand you were 7 or 8 hours ahead then last week we were in the same time zone and today you're 7 or 8 hours behind. Thailand was 2am and then today is 11am so there's got to be a chance that we can get Andros to do this show from the international dateline so he can kind of hop in back and across and do it on different days funded by the BBC?

4:05maybe not funded by the BBC I could probably say definitely not funded by the BBC but the idea of getting you in a whole load of different time zones over the course of a season is quite a good challenge but would also have the sustainability police on my back so let's move on let's start let's start the tonight by talking about uh west ham they'll be in the championship next season and that will be the third time that they've gone down to uh the second tier we'll we'll talk nuno spirito santo in a moment we'll talk the squad in a moment i'm just going to come to you rory actually just from a media point of view as well really to start with which is because there was so much attention on spurs and whether they would go down do you think we have not ignored but underestimated the size of West Ham in going down?

4:59Yeah I think the idea that Spurs who are the ninth richest club on the planet could get relegated overshadowed the fact that West Ham who if you look at quite a lot of different kind of financial metrics are also a club that should not be getting relegated I think it's probably overshadowed it You can only have one main story, and the main story around that third relegation place was, will it be Tottenham? And I think that probably has kind of obscured a little bit just how significant it is that West Ham have gone, how long they've been in the Premier League, the size of club that they are, the kind of imprint they leave.

5:31But also, and maybe there's people at West Ham who'd be quite grateful for this, grateful that Tottenham have stolen focus a little bit. What an absolute kind of monument of incompetence it's been that West Ham are in the Championship. Is that how you would describe it, Joe? A monument of incompetence? I wouldn't use that word in no. That certainly wouldn't be in my vocab. But I get what Rory's saying. And the Tottenham story was gripping everyone, wasn't it? And West Ham seemed like when Nuno came in, everything seemed fine for a little bit. They were producing a few performances, getting some big results.

6:03But for it to happen how it did, obviously that Arsenal game, a lot relied on that. and Spurs kind of scraping through. And I think the Deserby appointment was huge, you know, because Tottenham were making mistake after mistake and then they really backed themselves and backed him to come in and do a job, of which he has, it seems. And West Ham have just slipped out the back door. It's a disaster. It's an absolute disaster to go out of the Premier League, especially with the squad that they had and obviously the stadium that they've in. And, you know, a couple of years ago, winning the European trophy, it's a real problem.

6:38there'll be a lot of finger pointing as there always is when when teams go down and a lot of west ham fans themselves will have different individuals that that they will want to blame and fans of other clubs come back and then throw accusations at west ham fans for for wanting more than or not being happy with what they what they had but the first person to discuss andros i would suggest is Nuno Espirito Santo because you sort of forget again how much of this season he's actually been in charge for there was an assumption oh he's going to come in and save them well he's been in charge for over 30 games I mean he's done the majority of the season some of this has to be on his shoulders of course a lot of it has to be on his shoulders the players shoulders but I think for West Ham it's sort of been a slow decline and I look at clubs like your Brightons, your Bournemouths, your Brentfords, they have a clear structure, a clear plan from the top.

7:38If a manager leaves or if a manager gets sacked, they have a manager to come in and not have to change everything. Where I look at like your Everton's and your West Ham's, it's like there's no real plan at the top. We go from David Moyes to Lopetegui to Potter, back to Nuno. It's like we're going from different styles and we're keeping the same sort of players. we're contacting the same agents to bring the players in there's no real person making the decisions they've spent the money you can't say they haven't spent money to improve the side but it's just like there's no real they're just spending money they're just doing things with no real plan and that's why we've seen Everton drop into the championship not because of a manager not because of the players some of some of their financial statistics are I mean backs up Andross's point, Rory, but it also highlights the size of West Ham, which is why I started with that, really.

8:34They brought in£238 million in revenues last season, which was ninth in the Premier League, the 20th in Europe, okay, 20th highest in Europe. Their wages were£172 million, again, the ninth highest in the Premier League. They've spent over the past five years£654 million pounds on players with a net spend of 317 million pounds again the ninth highest in the premier league those figures would suggest they and bearing in mind they don't pay a great deal of rent do they um you know so those figures would suggest they should be doing a lot better than they have been doing the thing with west ham and i say this this is not a chris sutton thing we Chris free tonight and I know Chris's whole stance is that West Ham fans didn't appreciate David Moyes enough.

9:28So kind of that's their original sin and everything, everything that's followed, they deserve. That's kind of Chris's logic on it. I don't agree with that. West Ham's problem is the ownership and the ownership's problem is they have have never demonstrated the slightest kind of hint that they know what they're doing. They seem not to have noticed that the league has changed around them. The Premier League now, basically, there are occasional teams who are a little bit chaotic, who kind of do mad things. Nottingham Forest aren't the most reliable. And, you know, it looks like Man United have made a sensible appointment in Carrick.

9:57But they've done, you know, a few kind of weird things in the last few years. West Ham have had this incredible gift of being in the Premier League for 14 years. Basically, one or two years where they've been kind of good to watch and they've had a push up towards sixth or seventh or obviously the conference they'd win. But basically, they finished mid-table. They've never really looked like they're trying that hard. they've never had a kind of coherent plan like like Bournemouth or Brentford or Brighton as the three teams that we tend to look at they've never shown the ambition of Sunderland or Aston Villa they've never shown the kind of wherewithal or the nows of Crystal Palace they've just sort of sat there they've earned over a billion pounds in television revenue and they have fritted it all away on a succession of ridiculous signings they sold Declan Rice for 105 million pounds what do they do with that money that's transformational money that is money that you can reinvest into your squad and kick on.

10:49West Ham blew it. What have they done with the television money they've got? How many players have they signed that have been sold on for a profit? It's not very many. Mateus Fernandes will go this summer probably for a profit. I think they paid 38 million quid for him. But not a vast amount of players have gone into West Ham and then been kind of kicked on and been sold on again and that money piled back into the squad. As Andros said, it's run like a medieval court where whoever's got the ear of the king gets to kind of determine policy. There's no strategy, there's no plan. And I don't take any real pleasure in this, but they've gone down because that kind of ineptitude gets punished in the Premier League now.

11:28You can't run your club like that. It's not how it works anymore. I think around the David Moyes situation, I think at the time he won them the Conference League, he steadied the ship. I think it was right for the West Ham fans to, okay, thank you, David Moyes, but we're a massive club. We want to go to the next level now. but I think the problem is that summer they get in Lopetegui who again I thought maybe a sensible appointment because it's a bridge between David Moyes and a Graham Potter for example it's in the middle so you can slowly progress but that summer when you want to go more progressive you sign Fulkeruk you sign Aramwamba Saka you sign some of your okay very good player you sign Max Killman these are not really players who are going to take you from David Moyes style of play to a progressive style of play which West Ham wanted to be so I think that was probably the breakdown after David Moyes that they didn't really back up what they wanted to do in the transfer market when you were there Joe and you were there 2018-19 weren't you so yeah when there was still the same ownership there so what what kind of club did you find do you think West Ham is because the other stat that i didn't give i didn't give in all the financial stuff they have the second highest attendances in the country with an average this season of over 60 000 so only manchester united have more now i appreciate that that's also partly down to ground size and if you know certain other clubs have bigger grounds then they may be above that but they get an average of over 60 000 and And they have gone down.

13:05So what kind of, you know, you've played across Europe. You've been at City. You've been at Spurs. When you look at how a club is run, how did you find it? It was very emotional. It was a very emotional club. A lot of frustration. The thing that I found that a lot of it revolved around, if I'm going to say that you play every Saturday, a lot of it revolved around the result on Saturday. If you won and you did all right, everything was fine. Everyone was good. if you lost and played badly, all hell broke loose. Fingers were getting pointed. Things got very aggressive and very upset. Now, look, to an average football fan, I think that's understandable because that's how football fans will work.

13:45Be quite emotional, love their team, up and down with the good results. Everything's fine. When it's not, everyone's a little bit more cranky. But what I've been around and went football when I've been in proper teams and businesses that are run well, like it's just it's a solid structure that we're talking about that win lose or draw it will keep moving forward and everyone knows exactly what's being asked of them everyone knows their positions where they need to step up there's accountability if things do start going wrong and I found at West Ham like I say it was very very much we were working towards the Saturday and seeing how we played fingers crossed and then work it out for the rest of the week and that's just not really what I've seen when I've been successful and been part of successful clubs that's not how it's been run.

14:28Joe, I'm going to ask you a very uncomfortable question because a lot's been made about the stadium and the atmosphere it creates and I will never blame the Everton fans for the David Moyes situation but okay the situation is not ideal, you're far from the pitch, it doesn't create a great atmosphere but I feel like the fans could have done more to make it better, to make it more hostile I've been there with Everton I've been there with Palace, I've been there with Luton and the one thing you say before the game is okay, if we start well, if we start fast, the fans will turn on the players so I think I feel like I don't know you was there for a whole season do you feel like they could have done more to create a positive atmosphere in that stadium well you know how it works Andros and you know Upton Park is now being remembered as this place that you could never go and win of course you could win you go there and you play well in the first 10 minutes at Upton Park same thing would happen and they'd feel it even more trust me they'd feel it even more because it is super aggressive and a West Ham fan will feel like they have every right whether you whether you think this is the right thing or not that when it's not going well they'll tell you and they'll vent and they'll be frustrated and they'll put pressure so i think yeah no doubt about it if you if you had a good first 10 minutes at the at the london stadium things would start to get a little bit eerie but i'm i'm not i'm not getting lost in the nostalgia mate you you know and i know that we could go to opton park and you could smash west ham and you could turn the place upside down with a good performance or winning your 50 50s for example and winning a few headers it turned just as aggressive there as it did at the London Stadium.

15:55But as someone who has sat in both grounds, admittedly from a work perspective, not from a fan perspective, do you know what, Andros? I'm not sure. I'm not sure fans could do anything in that place. And I would throw in a slightly different perspective in that I've done other sports in that stadium. I mean I was you know I was there for the Olympics but I've also done rugby league games in that stadium it is terrible it is terrible for atmosphere whatever I mean it was great for Super Saturday obviously but but but rugby league and and I have I I think when you go there I just think I feel really sorry for West Ham fans because I just think they're lost I just think they're absolutely lost in this um cavernous soulless bowl that I I look at it and I can't work out how from how it's constructed and how it's designed I'm no expert in stadium design but I can't work out how you create a an atmosphere there because you're so far away and there's nothing, it doesn't feel, you know, you look at the new Tottenham Grand, even where you were yesterday Joe, with the new top tier at the Etihad that's going to be the Guardiola stand, even just the way they've got the, what's it called, the camber is it camber, Rory, help me Oh, no, it's not called the camber your camber's on a road, what's it called?

17:30That's really annoying, yeah, the steep, you mean the steep anyhow, the steep bit, I'm sure steepness, yeah, I'm going to say that sometimes just keep it simple then, you just don't even have You don't have that at the London Stadium. And the ground isn't why you go down, but it can rip the heart out of a fan and the soul out of a fan. And I do feel for them there. I'd never thought, Joe's totally right. I've probably been guilty of the Upton Park revisionism, which would very much stand at odds with West Ham's home record while they played there. There is this idea that it was this kind of, this unconquerable bear pit.

18:09But I used to go to a lot of games at West Ham for work. and West Ham lost most of them because if Man City or Arsenal or Chelsea or whatever go to Upton Park, chances are they win. I think what the problem is with the London Stadium is that it represents what's happened to West Ham more broadly, which is, like Chapa says, the soul's been ripped out of the club. It feels like they feel like they are tourists in their own ground. There are also a lot of actual tourists there who are there to watch Premier League football, which is fair enough, because it's a massive global product and people want to go and see it.

18:40that then affects the atmosphere but the principal thing is that on the pitch you've got a club that has no identity that has no kind of other reason for being than staging football matches to to have access to the tv money in the premier league which keeps them in the premier keeps them one of the richest clubs in the world and kind of keeps them going west ham i don't think at any point certainly since moyes have given the impression that they want to be anything other than a premier league team they're not they've not kind of tried to reinvent themselves as like a springboard club or as a data club or whatever it might be they're just kind of there like andrew says they kind of sign whoever's around it's based on relationships there's no real kind of there's no strategy about recruitment if you look at their squad it's a really weird patch but i actually don't know apart from bowen and matthews fernandez is there anyone else in that squad that anyone's gonna want to buy in the summer even at wolves there's two or three you think you can see people kind of plucking a couple of players from there but with west ham given the money they've spent i'm not sure who gets i'm not sure how many premier league clubs are thinking do you know what west ham have gone down we'll take we'll take that one out of out of there i'm not sure that happens a lot this summer i think the problem with with the stadium is and you you mentioned the figures chappers is in the up in upton park getting the upton park revenue they would not have been able to be the big side that they are now spending the money with the wage structure that they have unless they move to a bigger stadium i think the problem is not the stadiums the problem is the how they've spent them the extra money they have from the revenue of the stadium which has been their biggest problem yeah and actually they've they've made a loss of over 140 over 104 million in their latest accounts to the 31st of may 2025 which bearing in mind all the other figures we gave earlier might seem slight surprising let's let's bring football finance expert rob wilson into this discussion just on west ham's finances what it might mean for them in the championship and thank you very much to everybody including paul in leeds the word i was looking for was rake rake of a stand okay i was about to say that yeah rob thank you very much for joining us pleasure mark as usual um they've recorded a loss of over 104 million in their latest accounts they brought in though as i said 238 million in revenues the rent is an extortionate on the ground.

21:02So how on earth have they lost so much money? Because you would have thought everything should be quite favourable for them, shouldn't it? I think that's where sport, football perhaps, has got this bad reputation. Because it is such a high revenue generating business, the natural assumption is, well, if you're generating that much money, everything's going to be rosy. the reality is for West Ham your statistics the fact you gave at the top of the show were spot on but being ninth in the revenue generating league doesn't make you a huge amount bigger than somebody that's 10th 11th or 12th and I was listening to Andros and Joe speaking there they used to one of them used the term it's a massive club it is a big club and I think it's almost fallen into that trap of not having any sort of as the guys have said structure or identity so So a lot of their recruitment is executive led.

21:57It doesn't follow this sort of sporting director model that we would typically see at Brentford or Brighton or Bournemouth who are also knocking around in that particular group. And I think the reality is they've just spent an extortionate amount on transfer fees and player wages. And those bills have kind of added up and they exceed what they've generated in terms of revenue. The one thing you didn't say, actually, in your fact check at the start, Mark, is they owe over£200 million of transfer liabilities. That's fees they've still got to pay. And, of course, they're going to be relegated. So there's£100 million worth of revenue that they're not going to earn next year.

22:36All right, they've got a£45 million parachute payment, but that's not going to be sufficient to really pay the debts as they fall due, so to speak, and cover the players' wages that they've currently got on the books. Which, and also you would expect, and this is just anecdotally, you know, you look at Leicester this season, you know, you watch Leicester on the telly in the Championship, the King Power was most definitely not full. It would be surprising, wouldn't it, if West Ham were getting 60 ,000 for, and I apologise in advance for picking a club at random, but Lincoln at home. all the data tells us if they start strong next year they will be able to keep a strong level of support in that stadium whether they get to 60 ,000 or not I think is up for debate of course it is but those fans are pretty passionate it's well connected with the community the big danger for West Ham now is they have an awful start to the season their August and September really doesn't go to plan and that's when you'll see a very very sharp decline in those matchday attendances which when you're playing in the championship with the amount of revenue that's on offer through things like solidarity payments you know you're going from essentially 120 million in the premier league down to 12 million in the championship it makes that matchday revenue so much more important when it's uh when you compare it to the wages that are going out and if they if they don't start well they're going to get into some very very hot water very quickly does the the championship next season goes to squad cost yes yeah and and that therefore is uh your your the cost of your squad is and that's wages and transfer fees has to be a percentage of your revenue and it can't exceed a percentage of that and that is what is it in the championship 70 is it it's about 70 okay so on the one hand for west ham the positive is that they're likely to have more revenue than anybody else in the championship so that should allow them to have quite an expensive squad but also their squad cost ratio at the moment i think is probably over 70 because they've been trying to stay in the premier league so they've kind of got cost cutting to do but but they could still be an add at an advantage this so they should be at an advantage based on their revenue profile absolutely the big challenge or the big unknown if you like is what relegation clauses the executive team are built into those player contracts and i think i've said to you before you really need to be putting in a 90 relegation clause for a player wage when you drop into the championship we hear a lot about sorry sorry andros's eyes nearly fell out of his head at that point so as a man as a man who we discussed last week has been at that end of the table an awful lot uh he looked very very shocked anyhow so 90 drop back to you rob sorry do you know what andros's reaction is exactly why why it doesn't happen so if you're if you're trying to to run an organization within its means you have to cut by 90 but what we also know is the agents are going to be fishing around to make sure they get the best deals for their clients that's absolutely how it should be but you've also then got that bit of jeopardy that where we know that the more you spend on transfers and wages, the more likely you are to be promoted.

25:52And in West Ham's case, the£45 million parachute payment actually makes them three times more likely to be promoted than any of the other teams in the division. So all things being equal, they should have relegation clauses baked into the contracts. The SCR, the squad cost ratio, should be favourable. And then they've got this little bit of extra revenue through the parachute payments to help out. But I suspect that their transfer exit door is going to be pretty busy this summer. They probably need to generate somewhere in the region of£150 to£180 million worth of transfer revenue just to keep the heads above water.

26:28Joe's eyes nearly burst out of his head at that one. Go on. How are they going to manage that one? You guys have talked about him, haven't you? I think Mateus Fernandes is probably worth somewhere between 50 and 60 million you know if we listen to what we're hearing in the press Manchester United will be all over him uh we've got Jean-Claire to be to Debo uh who had that fallout didn't he with Nuno a couple of weeks ago you know he will generate some transfer value uh Somerville will generate some value Konstantinos probably as well the two goalkeepers they've got will generate something that the key then is this goes back to the lack of sporting director the key then is how do the executive team really make that squad competitive in the championship if you rip the heart and soul out of the playing squad also going back to your very first point and then we'll move on Rob but it's fascinating if you still have a transfer liability on a player and then sell them do you then are you then paying the rest of the transfer liability as a as a lump sum on what you've brought in.

27:34How does that work? So it depends entirely on how the deal has been structured. So it can happen either way. So either you can retain that transfer liability on your balance sheet effectively. And as the terms of that transfer liability are seen, you would then be paying that money back. Or indeed, if that player is to transfer out of the club, you would use some of that lump sum to pay down that transfer liability. So I think Mateus Fernandes signed for£38 million from Southampton. There'll be a transfer liability attached to him. If they generate, let's say,£50 million, they've got a£12 million SCR, or PSR rather in old terms, profit on their books.

28:17But then they will have to recover that transfer liability with Southampton for sure. OK, Rob, thank you very much for coming on. Appreciate it. Rob Wilson, football finance expert. A joke in a side, did you always have a relegation clause in your contract and Ross yes more often it was around 25 percent 30 percent but the Luton one I had was was 50 percent wage drop so that's probably as a player I don't think anyone's signing a contract more than 50 percent relegation clause and then would you would you in like would your agent be if you had two or three teams kind of looking at you two or three options would one of the kind of potential deal makers deal breakers for those teams be how much is the is the relegation drop not really because especially i never sign a club thinking we're going to get relegated i think clubs have to put it in there in their contract just in case 25 is not going to make me sign for stoke over crystal palace for example and lute and i didn't have a choice 50 was i didn't have any other option so i signed the 50

29:26Hi, Uncle Lazer here. America's built on fast cars, fast food, and even faster women. Moto Casino's built in America. You know what they're fast at? Fast cash, rise, redemption. You see, only Moto is U.S. owned and operated. Moto. It's American-made. That's who we are, and that's who we care about. Play for free at moto.us. Moto Casino's the social casino. Avoid were prohibited. No purchase necessary. Visit Moto.us for more details. Must be 21 plus. Moto Casino. America's social casino. Ask yourself, what are your best people spending their time on right now? Expense reports? Receipt chasing? Month-end close that takes weeks?

30:06You become what you spend on, and that's not what you're building toward. Brex is the intelligent finance platform that eliminates that work before it starts. AI agents that handle the manual stuff automatically. so your team can spend their time on what actually compounds. It's time to get Brex AF. Learn more at brex.com slash AF.

30:31Five life sports. So here's the first ball of this series. All the cricket unit arms. Check for LBW. Ouch. Lives on BBC Sounds. Smash straight back down the ground, this girl. Hear ball-by-ball coverage of the biggest competitions on the domestic and international circuits. It's a fourth cricket and it's the huge one. Jeez. Settle down, Tuffer. Sorry, mate. Cricket on Five Live Sport. Oh, I've living every ball of this. Listen on BBC Sounds.

31:03This is the Monday Night Club with Mark Chapman. On the Football Daily Podcast.

31:12West Ham issued a statement today saying that they will be honest and transparent with the fans going forward. Spurs have also issued a statement. I'll read the paragraph from that after they finished 17th for a second successive season. Here's part of the club's statement. Last September, we recognised that something seismic had to change at Spurs. The Lewis family stepped in and authorised a full reset. That decision wasn't taken lightly and it came later than it should have. But what has been put in motion is real and it marks a genuine break from what had come before. As part of that process, we discovered some uncomfortable truths.

31:49The qualities that make Spurs distinct, our football, our ambition, the connection between the team and its supporters have been allowed to fade. Football success had not been driving our decisions. We did not have the right expertise in key roles. Is that accepting blame or is that passing blame to others? I've read it several times and I can't quite work it out, Rory. my instinct is it's it's trying to kind of suggest that the changes that were made at the start of the season so when Daniel Levy left and they kind of appointed a new kind of executive sets of executives to replace him that that was that that the kind of not having sporting success as the priority was associated with the with the old guard rather than the new that was how I read it but it's I mean yeah I agree it may well be I wonder if it's one of those public statements you get a lot now where it's sort of it's designed to look like it's accepting blame but really it's offering excuses that seems to be how it's done generally I think the hardest thing about that statement who said that yeah a club statement but who though that's the hardest thing I think for a Tottenham fan right now at least I say at least because it's harsh, very harsh to say it.

33:11When Daniel was at the top, he loved the club and he took it. He took it on the chin. There was some accountability for what was going on. Sorry, it's Peter Charrington, the non-exec chairman. Rory, what does non-exec chairman mean? How does that work? Does that mean he's saying, I am the one who is representing Tottenham. Everything I've done right now has not been spot on and I realise it and I realise I'm going to be working on it or is he just speaking on behalf of people who... Well, a non-exec chairman means that he's the chairman but doesn't actually make any of the decisions. That's the exec bit.

33:43So how are you supposed to get behind a statement with someone talking about such huge, it's a huge statement to make, right? Huge statement. And if someone, if the Khaldun made that statement or Sir Jim Rackbid made that statement, that's them saying it, representing their two clubs and saying, that's on me almost. I'm going to sort it out. That is just someone reading something on behalf of someone who we don't know who they are, but I'm also saying that I'm the Tottenham Hotspur. But I'm not convinced that the reason that Spurs have finished 17th two years in a row is because they've not had sporting priorities.

Read the full transcript

34:19I think a lot of what they've done is just, is they've made bad choices. And whether that's kind of the manager that they've appointed, and I thought Thomas Frank would do really well at Spurs and he didn't, that turned out to be the wrong decision. I don't think that was a lack of ambition or because they were thinking about whether they could get Bad Bunny to perform at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium this summer. I think it was because they thought Thomas Frank was the best bet, and it turned out he wasn't. Tudor, I think they got bad advice. There's clearly an issue, I think James Madison said something about this yesterday, but there is clearly an issue in terms of injuries.

34:53Madison said that you get some injuries in the course of a season, such as his ACL, that are kind of the price of doing business. It happens in football, it's a shame. no one is to blame for the fact that NACL goes. But there have been an awful lot of injuries at Spurs where you think, hang on, there seems to be a pattern here. Something is maybe not... Not just this season. Can I add to that? I left Spurs in 2015 and that was the case 11 years ago as well, Rory. The medical department hasn't been good enough for the last decade and a half. So what do you mean? What makes them not good enough?

35:28Quality of care? Is it kind of expertise? Number of staff? Is it... Everything you just mentioned. Everything you just mentioned. I don't know if Joe, you were there more recent than me. Anything you want to add? See, that was the one place that I avoided. I'm not saying like, I have no knowledge of any medical staff at any team because that was the last place that I wanted to be. I was very, very lucky throughout my career. I never had longer than two weeks. I've found that everywhere I've been, people moan. There's very few places that I've been at, very few football clubs where I've had everyone in the dressing room.

36:02saying that these are the best things and if I'm injured I'm going to go to I've always found that people have looked seeked outside help so tough one but I get I get the murmurs and obviously if James Madison's saying it whilst he's still being represented and don't forget he's just been rehabbed by Tottenham Hotspur work closely I've seen relationships when people have been coming back from from long ACL injuries or any sort of injuries where you can see that friendships start to develop but if he's saying that the quality and that's a big statement and what I would say is you know we don't have the spurs medical department to talk to about their processes which would be interesting in itself but what i would also say is it is not a discussion that has just happened now i mean we've had discussions about this on many on over previous seasons as well yes so i was going to say andros like you're a very healthy fit guy and i've been through many injuries, I'm sure.

36:59What makes a good medical room for you? Because the only way I judge it, like I say, I stayed out of it. I just judged it on if they were good guys because I just kept myself out of it. But what makes a quality room where you think, if I've done my hamstring, I'm going to be all right. They say six to eight weeks, I'll be back in six to eight weeks. Knowledge, protocols. I think, like you said, many players go outside for second opinions. and when the second opinion from the expert is completely different to what your medical department is saying time and time again on a consistent basis, then that raises questions about the quality you have at your own club.

37:38This is completely tangential and is not relevant to Spurs, but is that great that people don't get second opinions? Because, I mean, what's the quality control on that? But that's just, I think, sorry, I think that I've noticed that with like footballs, you kind of hear what you want to hear and especially when you're vulnerable. you know when you're injured you're vulnerable like I say I was lucky I didn't really I didn't really suffer any bad injuries or anything like that but you are so vulnerable and you just want certainty at the end of the day because I don't know about you but even when I felt a tweak immediately my start my head's like right okay so if I don't play this game and I missed it the next three games and that's my career over and that's probably my career done I don't have to move the whole family and that's just a thought process so you are incredibly vulnerable as a player and That's not looking for any sympathy.

38:20So you want certainty. You want confidence in how you're being treated. And the medical staffs have grown and grown and grown. And they're not always united. You know, you find that some people will roll their eyes when one person gives an opinion. It just creates a little divide in the medical room. And that's certainty sometimes that you're working one-on-one if you go outside of your medical room. But then you're trying to get better. You're trying to get fit to come back. But then they take offense in the medical room at your club. and then things just don't go well and then it can really spiral.

38:50I think, I don't know what your situation was at City, et cetera, Joe, but from the clubs, I've had many conversations with medical staff in and outside of football and it's not their fault, the budget. They're not allocated a budget to build a first-class medical department. You're signing players for 50, 60, 70 odd million pounds and then you're not giving the budget to the people tasked with taking care of those players. so then you're spending all that money Dominic Solanke for example Spurs spent 60 odd million on him he spent most of the season injured because you're not spending the money the budget some of the budget on the medical team to be able to facilitate someone like Dominic Solanke and I think that's the biggest problem everywhere I've been it's been the biggest problem that the clubs are not giving budgets to the medical departments to equal with the value of the player they're signing Luck must play a part though Andros as well mustn't it I mean, I take your point, but, you know, and Madison's point was actually, you know, it can be a coincidence, it can be unlucky, me doing my ACL, Kulaseski getting a horrendous knock off Mark Gaye.

39:58You see all these theories and sometimes that's rubbish. We have been a bit unlucky. I think they have been unlucky in certain cases but the number of injuries they've had for several years is speaking to people at Spurs the club have wondered about training intensity whether it's too high or whether it's been too high at certain points and then too low and whether that change brings danger. There have been unlucky injuries that are the price of doing business but there have been lots that would make you think that at least is due a review I would say It's the muscle injuries, the reoccurring muscle injuries which which which are the bigger problems rather than the the unlucky acl ones the the responses to the to the statement are in the main saying seem to be going along similar lines which is we've heard all of we've heard all of this before um some of the execs that are in place they are not not necessarily trusting the the spurs fans which have come in under the new regime as well.

41:01And they want to see De Zerbe left to get on with the recruitment. As somebody said somewhere, I've lost the, oh, here you go. He is a footballing expert. Leave the signings to him. Gordon Ramsay's investors don't buy his ingredients for him. They trust his expertise. i mean do you think because of just by the fact that he saved them joe that he will have the all wielding power oh you'd like to he held the cards when he signed put it that way he held he had tottenham buy them he really did if they were going to take him on they really had to take him on but i don't know if that's how he works that that's what he wants is that is he the best manager when he's got that responsibility because a lot of coaches, modern day coaches, don't necessarily, they haven't been brought up in that world where they literally put their feet up Monday to Thursday and then take care of business Friday, Saturday and do all the investments and the wheeling and the dealing.

42:06So I'd imagined he came in swinging saying, I want to do it my way and he'll have that control, but you've still got to have a relationship with the sporting director, you've still got to have a relationship with the board and it's still got to be what's the what's your two-year plan five-year plan ten-year plan you've still got to have those conversations and like I say I don't know he'll obviously know of course he does because he's been employed by the club but what do Tottenham want what do they want that they want to all of a sudden go back to being a standard top four team they've got so much to cover that's two seasons in a row 17 two seasons in a row nearly going out the Premier League they've got a lot of you know they've got a lot of making up to do this is a this is maybe a slightly loaded question andros but would you move players on based on talent or based on attitude attitude i think first and foremost now there's got to be no no bad character energy that's one thing that has to go and that's that's a rule at one of like brightson and brentford these guys is no i don't want to say the word yeah we know we know the yeah we know we know the word yeah yeah but that but that's that's a culture thing isn't it and that has to be the minimum because you let that grow you let especially like senior players with big voices you let them sort of infect other players and it becomes a horrible i've been in many many horrible dress rooms and you need to cut it at the source if there is one or two who um doesn't have doesn't have the right attitude you have to get rid of them before they infect the whole group just in terms of the um the kind of control for the zerbi chappers obviously joan langer is is there and is is a is a sporting director as recently as i'm going to say the end of february maybe maybe the start of march so it does predate deservey and it may have changed since then tottenham wanted to appoint another one in addition to langer so i would suggest that the chances of deservey they may have changed their minds completely and they might do a complete about turn but my guess is that spurs are more likely to start next season with two sporting directors than an all-powerful manager.

44:11Rory, I don't think you can. When the lifespan of a manager is one and a half to two years, you can't give full control to that manager now. But I would say it has to be somebody that Deserby trusts and works together with Deserby, especially with Deserby's character, there's going to be a recipe for disaster again. I think it's sort of a false debate that we have over should managers have complete control. I think the job now is too big for them to... I'm glad Chris isn't on. Well, the managers had a lot to do when I was playing as well. But the job is too big for them to be doing that as well.

44:45Those deals are too complicated and there's too many staff. You know, the organisations are massive. I think it's very unlikely that there's many clubs out there where the manager's not part of those conversations, whether that's Arteta and... So it's kind of semantics here, though, isn't it? It's how much the manager's voice is the loudest in the room. And actually, so far, the three trophy-winning managers in the Premier League this season are maybe three of the most powerful managers within the Premier League, i.e. they carry a lot of weight in their club. Guardiola, Arteta and Emery. There is a structure around them that does a lot of that stuff for them, but the centrepiece of the structure is the manager.

45:35Yeah, that seems to be the way that those clubs are run.

45:41Bikar, I was just having a cup of tea then. I thought something might come in. But Bikar, the difference is that, you know, if you go back Andros a few years to when Spurs signed Jed Spence, and Antonio Conte made it very clear that he did not want Jed Spence, which has ultimately proved actually whoever signed him got it got it right not Antonio Conte but the example is there goes back to the loudest voice in the room that's why I would throw that in I had many years at Palace Roy Hodgson where he had absolutely no say in who came in it was all Dougie Freeman and then when the player turned up more often than not the player didn't play because the manager didn't okay it so it's just never going to work when you're signing players without even notifying the manager or giving him a big say in who does join or who doesn't join.

46:34So it's just never going to work. Would you move Romero on, Joe? I think he'll move himself on. Right. I think it's been really difficult. And the hardest thing for me to watch when he has played for Tottenham in big moments, he's not been able to control his emotions. I think I was at Old Trafford I remember Tottenham starting well and then he kind of just lost the ball in a moment where he probably felt like he shouldn't he dribbled a little bit but he's a bit of a maverick centre-half that's how he rolls sometimes he's going to take chances and then because he lost that ball just this switch went in his head and he just nailed someone over the top of the ball and it was an instant red card 15-20 minutes into the game it's such an important game for Tottenham and I just thought wow I couldn't imagine that guy leading me.

47:28There's no doubt he's a brilliant player and you can't take the emotion out of him because that is what makes him the player that he is. He wouldn't have got to the level that he is. He wouldn't be a World Cup winner without that emotion. But to put that at the forefront of it and to let that be, let him do his thing, I think is a real difficult one for Tottenham Hotspur. And I just watched them as they were starting to unravel. I never thought that Tottenham players were chucking it in. They weren't not playing, but everyone seemed to just be doing their own thing. It became such an individual team.

48:00No doubt a lot of them are talented and no doubt if you plunked a lot of them in a different team, a successful team that was going well, they'd shine. That's why they're at Tottenham. It's a big stadium. It's a big club. But I just watched every single one of the players unravel emotionally, physically, mentally. Some people going under, some people, like I say, like Romero just losing all that kind of tension in his chest as soon as he lost the ball, smashing someone and getting sent off. And that's the hardest thing. Just didn't feel like anyone was in control of what was going on and every single player's worst characteristic would come out.

48:35Joe, when we talk about Pep Guardiola, let me ask you about what he said to Sky last week because I'm really interested in your response. He said, Guardiola, I want to confess that I have regrets. When you take a lot of decisions, a lot of decisions, you make mistakes. There is one regret that I have deep inside for many years, and it's that I didn't give a chance to Joe Hart to be with me to prove himself how good a keeper he was. When you hear that, how does that make you feel? Well, it doesn't make me feel anything right now because obviously a lot of people have sent me that and I've heard it a lot of times.

49:09but how I felt when I did hear that he said that, I was surprised how I felt because I was actually quite emotional to myself because it was very nice for him to say it and I think he is genuine in what he said because he didn't need to say it. It wasn't a specific question. How did you feel about the Joe Hart situation? But that was 10 years ago. 10 years ago, we shook hands. 10 years ago, we had a difference of opinion. he ultimately won in the difference of opinion and went on to absolutely smash his career and do brilliant things at Manchester City and we got on but do you know what it made me feel?

49:46It made me feel like I was right to believe in myself I was right to say that I think I deserve the chance and that was the only thing that I really took from it like I say I get on with Pep, always have I got on with him even when he looked me in the eye and told me that I was going to have to leave because he didn't think I was good enough to play the way that he played or he didn't have enough time to help me or give me a chance in his team but he told me to my face and we shook hands and like I say we agreed to disagree and we got on from that moment on but it was still I think from a from a personal point of view in terms of what I thought of myself as a goalkeeper and the kind of how I got a little bit lost on loans and things like that for the next couple of years it was it was nice to hear that.

50:26Does it almost give you closure hearing that Joe or is it the opposite do you feel like man like he could have taken my game to the next level what we could achieve together how do you feel off the back of that do you know what mate I got closure at the time because I didn't leave I didn't leave his office I didn't leave any conversation until we had closure it was from the moment that he walked through and you know I've it's it's interesting because I've gone through this many times and you know because it's an interesting part of my career of course it is because it involves one of the greats of the game.

51:00And that's my only real experience with him. Unfortunately, it was a negative one. But I got closure real quick. I do that in life, you know, whether it's with him or whether it's with another conversation that I need to have on a daily basis. Did it fire you up, though? Did it fire you up going forward? Or was it actual closure, park it, right, I'm just going to go with my career? Or did it? Because, you know, there are certain things that have been said to me over the years that I still use to fire myself up. Do you know what? I looked at, obviously, you do a bit of reflection when, you know, obviously, Andros, you're still playing.

51:33But personally, I've had a fair bit of reflection in the two years out. And I've always, always worked that I wanted to prove people right. I'm not bothered about proving people wrong. There's way too many naysayers, especially in the game that we're in, or, you know, the professional level of football, that you're never going to be able to please everyone. And that's apparent, you know. I was a good enough goalkeeper for some people, many people not good enough for others. That's absolutely fine. But I've always had a core group of people and I've developed along the way in terms of family, friends, colleagues, of people that do believe in me, one of them being myself.

52:10So I've always wanted to prove those people right. So the fact that he didn't feel like he had enough time to work me into his system and he felt like he had to look elsewhere, so be it. That's what he needed to do to do him. I couldn't change that. That was clear. I tried my best to, but like I say, he was ultimately going to hold the power. I wanted to play for England. That was my aspiration. I didn't want Pep Guardiola to tell me that I was a good player. I wanted to play for Man City in England. And that was pretty clear that I couldn't play for Manchester City. So to play for England, I had to go and look elsewhere.

52:42It strikes me it would take an enormous amount of strength of character to continue to think like that, as you say, in the years afterwards, when you're on loan and you're looking at City becoming this all-conquering force. to not look at that as a kind of as a hinge point at which things can change for you and not not just strikes me as being genuinely amazing not to have any resentment about that but that might be because i'm a very bitter person yeah but as well as well as that though rory and and this is not him this is not his narrative you know he's not coming and claim that he changed manchester city i didn't i wasn't part of man city when they were in relegation scraps or in the championship like we achieved some pretty cool things i've got some unbelievable memories, did some unbelievable things at Manchester City.

53:27So what did I miss out on? I missed out on being a Champions League winner. Would I have been in that team? Who knows? Would I, you know, Edison, incredible goalkeeper, absolutely six Premier Leagues in eight seasons. Would I have done that again? Who knows? Maybe I wouldn't. But all I know that when I had my opportunities and when I had my chance to play for them, I left it all out on the line. I've got unbelievable relationship with Manchester City as a football club with their fans. I absolutely adore them i grew up i went from a boy to a man my family started when i was at manchester city these are all the things that mean everything to me and you know what i also got to do i also got to go and travel into uh seriat played a year in i played there i went on loan to to the likes of west ham all right it didn't go very well but i still experienced it i'm still in the conversation about what's going on west ham and then to top it all off i got three years at celtic which i would never have got and I wouldn't change that for anything if we uh which kind of moves on a little bit with with you mentioning Celtic I'm interested in both of your opinions here really as as the former players it feels like we've had quite a momentous weekend of people who are really important to clubs saying goodbye and and that could be on various different levels someone like Guardiola who has given this unprecedented amount of success to Manchester City to someone like Seamus Coleman who has been a stalwart of an Everton dressing room for 15 years and and is a you know an icon of a football club an icon to the fans of a football club and you can obviously then there's Salah and there's Robertson and Stones and Bernardo Silva you've got Ira Ola and after everything that he's done in such a sport short space of time at Bournemouth and Glasner Kieran Trippier, who means so much to Newcastle fans because he was the first signing of the new era.

55:20For the players in the squad, how difficult is it when somebody with so much impact at whatever the level may be moves on, Andros? It can be so difficult because you spend all day, every day with these guys and you almost get attached to them. And when it's somebody, for example, like a Seamus Coleman, who everything goes through Seamus Coleman. He is everything about Everton Football Club. And all of a sudden, this player is leaving the club and you're not going to see him anymore and his professionalism and his leadership levels are not there. It can leave a huge hole in the dressing room. So, yeah, it's extremely tough whether it's a manager, a player or an experienced figure.

56:00It can be difficult for a dressing room to keep the standards and recover from that. You were at Celtic when Poster Coglu left, Joe. Yeah. And that feeling of someone who... Because he did have a massive impact on set. I mean, it's an obvious thing to say, but he did. Yeah, I was absolutely gutted. I've not had that feeling much. I'll be honest when it comes to managers. You know, in terms of I've always got on with pretty much all my coaches on a professional level. But I felt that what he was doing was unbelievable to be a part of. But look, he went on to do bigger and better things. But, you know, in answer to your question, it depends who they bring in because that's the only time that you feel the hole.

56:42I've noticed it so many times and I noticed it from a young age in my career I was like oh my goodness me these guys that I spend so much time with they're so important football just keeps going and going and going if you get caught up in it like that too emotional you almost become a robot with it because you can't afford to get too attached to people and then it's who comes in next I was absolutely delighted when it's when we found out that Brendan Rodgers was coming in because I knew he knew exactly what he was doing I knew how much he loved the football club I knew how important he was at the football club so from that that moment on you shake hands like I say wish Andrew the best who's coming in who's coming to replace them how are we going to work on it like I just I just never call it cutthroat cold I don't know what you want to call it but I was never too emotionally attached to anything.

57:26It did strike me yesterday that that it did feel like it like you were watching it in an era end more broadly though that you know Salah's one of the most recognizable players the Premier League's had for the last 10 years Guardiola has obviously reshaped City, the Premier League, English football. He has been, I think, probably the defining character of the last 10 years of the Premier League. And I can't remember another day like that, other than maybe when Ferdison stepped down at Man United, when it felt like something was shifting, something was changing. That's the only real comparison I can think of.

57:57And I remember being at Huddersfield when Wenger left. But by that stage, it was sort of four years too late and Arsenal were trying to finish fourth. It felt significant, but it didn't feel like, OK, next season is going to be a bit weird. Whereas sitting here now, it does feel as though next season, the Premier League, will look like a very different place without Salah and Guardiola in particular. But even people like Bernardo, it will be weird that he will not be part of Man City anymore. I agree it will be weird, but honestly, it will be until it won't. And then, you know, someone will come in and then there'll be a new headline.

58:29There'll be a new, you know, some people will have broken or someone will be in trouble or someone will have done unbelievable work. We've got a World Cup. It'll be, by the time the World Cup starts, it will already be forgotten. City will already have their next coach in charge. Liverpool will already be linked with whoever's going to play on the right. And away we go. But I think, and I know I'm ruthless when I say that. No, you're right though. I honestly, but I really want to hone in on yesterday, how special it was. You know, you talk about it was, everyone accepted that it was the right time.

58:59You know, there was just, it was just a time to celebrate and enjoy and appreciate each other. And it was, it was a really great feeling in the stadium. It was, it was, yeah, it was, it was absolutely iconic to unveil the stand and all those sorts of things. It just felt right. And like I say, there'll be, there'll be something happening. We've got Champions League final. That will, everything will just get kiboshed. Someone will take over from it and then we'll, we'll go again. I just want to pick up on that because next season I'm already now I'm looking I'm excited about the next season you've got I don't know if these guys have been confirmed but you've got Javi Lonzo's Chelsea you've got Maresca potentially in at Man City you've got Arsenal now with a title behind them now and the weight lifted off their shoulders you've got Man United again starting with a new well Carrick taking the job on a permanent basis this is shaping up to be an amazing year next year and yeah it's sad that the end of the of the last year but the new era is just around the corner like Joe says.

59:55Thanks to Joe, Andros and Rory, two European finals to bring you over the coming days. On Wednesday, the Conference League final, Palace against Raya Vallecano, then the Champions League final on Saturday with Arsenal against Paris Saint-Germain.

1:00:22Are we including Dame in your title now? You know how much an honour that is. And this remarkable team! And this remarkable women! We want to play in a way that they can show their skills, so that's what we're trying to do. Win the World Cup. It's a dream. Listen. With the BBC Sounds app. Spring has sprung and big savings are in full bloom at Menards. Visit Menards Garden Centre for everything you need to get your garden growing. Choose from hundreds of beautiful, colorful flowers, lush trees and shrubs, and everything in between. Menards Garden Center is back in bloom. Stop in today to get your garden on.

1:01:05Check out fresh deals happening now at Menards. Save big money at Menards. 30 years after two civilian airplanes were shot down, why is the U.S. government now bringing charges against the former Cuban president, Raul Castro. I'm Asma Khaled, and I host the Global Story podcast from the BBC. Cuba's government is calling this all a political maneuver, but the Cuban exile community in Miami calls it justice, 30 years in the making. Is the U.S. setting the stage for a military intervention? For more, check out the Global Story on BBC.com or wherever you get your podcasts.

From the publisher

Mark Chapman, Andros Townsend, Joe Hart and Rory Smith look at the fallout from West Ham’s relegation in the Premier League, and ask what is behind the club’s struggles. Football finance expert Rob Wilson discusses the potential financial impact on the club. The panel also looks at what comes next for Tottenham after successive 17th-placed finishes in the Premier League.

05:30 – West Ham’s lack of a strategy 13:00 – The atmosphere at the London Stadium 19:00 – The financial impact of relegation 28:40 – Where next for Tottenham after staying up? 46:00 – Joe Hart gives his reaction to Pep Guardiola’s comments about regretting not giving Hart a chance to prove himself.

COMMENTARIES This week on 5 Live/BBC Sounds:

Wednesday: Crystal Palace v Rayo Vallecano (Conference League final) 8pm Saturday: Scotland v Curacao (Friendly) 1pm Saturday: Arsenal v PSG (Champions League final) 5pm Sunday: Brighton v Manchester City (Women’s FA Cup final) 3pm

More from Football Daily

All 336 episodes
MNC: What next for West Ham and Tottenham?Football Daily · 58 min
Listen in VO